CorpusRecord 84994

2/11/2025 Regular Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MPSD Board of Education
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Manitowoc County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,885 words · about 94 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e that's not encing all right thank you all for coming I'm going to call this regular monthly meeting of man Public School District Board of Education order and I would ask you all to join us thank you Al to of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation God indivisible liy andice thank you now I would ask that we take a rooll please Christopher able here Matthew fips here Shaw here Matthew scalding here Harry tra here Tony buat here all right um we have everybody here and so we will move on to the next part of the agenda which is public input switch to my reading glasses while I try to say your names correctly thank you for your patience with that all right the first request

002I have is from Jennifer hegner Jennifer it right thank you Jenifer hner 62 31st Street manag thank you for the opportunity I would first like to express my sincere gratitude to Mr Lee tennis for his dedication and leadership as an interim superintendent through his tenure Mr tennis has diligently kept staff families the community and the board well informed about the ongoing developments within the mayat TR Public School District taking on a new role at the start of the school year is already a formidable task and assuming additional responsibilities M mid year presents even greater challenges Mr tennis if you have not already been acknowledged for your hard work and commitment to the manat par Public School District please know that your efforts are deeply appreciated even if they sometimes go unnoticed but that mind I

003want to shift our Focus to a concern that was raised during a recent board meeting regarding the discussion of a new Middle School social studies curriculum the term Dei was mentioned a phrase that has been widely discussed and at times misunderstood let's begin with diversity diversity in a curriculum would mean providing students with the opportunity to learn about cultures beyond their own isn't that something we would want for all students in an increasingly interconnected world our students need to be prepared to collaborate with individuals from different backgrounds not all students will spend their careers in manag Mark some will work internationally and we want uh and we have a responsibility to equip them with a broader understanding of the world Beyond career preparation learning about diverse cultures Fosters understanding rather than fear of the are

004different from us wouldn't greater awareness and empathy make their society lessive and more Unified inclusion ensures that all voices are represented in history not just those of the dominant or Victorious groups for too long history has been been presented from a single perspective but as the saying goes no matter how flat you make a pancake it always has two sides shouldn't students be exposed to multiple perspectives so they can form their own informed judgments isn't that the very Foundation of critical thinking uh if we continue to whitew watch History how will students learn from the past and strive to create a better future in addition it isn't difficult for students to seek out other sources to find the missing pieces of History so why not include those perspectives in the curriculum from the start providing

005a more complete and accurate account of History doesn't take away from what is already taught it simply ensures that students have access to the full story equity and culum means providing students with a balanced perspective minimizing bias and ensuring that all students regardless of which middle school they attend have access to the same materials and learning experiences it also means that students should see themselves reflected in the curriculum reinforcing a sense of belonging and relevance in their education as we evaluate this or any other curriculum we should be asking ourselves does it present a present a blatant bias toward one perspective is it engaging for both students and teachers does it teach students to think critically and analyze sources for bias does it promote collaboration and discussion and more importantly does prepare students for the

006future in closing I urge all of us to be intentional and nonpolitical in our discussions education is already a comp complex challenge without the destruction of politize politize sorry terminology rather than focusing on divisive rhetoric let us engage in meaningful conversations about how we can best serve our students through a curriculum that is thought full balance and forward thinking thank you for your time and consideration thank you okay next we have Anne holson thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening my name is Anne hson 4054 goodwi R candidate from public school board I would like to take a moment to share the Mission Vision and value statements of two different organizations from their website as of February 10th 2025 organization a The Institute of nuclear power operations the mission at The Institute of

007nuclear power operations in PO is to promote the highest levels of safety and reliability to promote excellence in the operation of commercial nuclear power plants core values at info are the the foundation of all that we do professional and personal trusting relationships we develop Mutual mutually beneficial relationships at info in the nuclear industry with other stakeholders that support improv teamwork and collaboration through these relationships we improve morality retain talent and increase Effectiveness impeccable Integrity we hold ourselves and others to the highest needs of Integrity to Foster an open and positive work environment and ethical and informed decision making by being honest and dependable we gain respect and Trust influential people we create positive outcomes by the way we interact with others unwavering standards we pursue the highest standards and are Resolute in how we adhere

008to the standards we establish continuous learning we exemplify ongoing learning and strive to maximize our personal capabilities we advance organizational and Industry proficiency and P performance through teaching and learning organization manat Public School District Mission the public school district mpsd commits to educate engage and inspire all Learners to thrive in a global Community Vision inspiring education empowering Community unleashing potential poor values relationship compassion collaboration dedication Integrity inspiration I ask you to think about some similarities about some differences there are bound to be everchanging challenges faced by this board that none of us can predict what if each member took a collaborative approach with respect to statutes policies and all mpsd stakeholders imagine the mpsd vision mission and values vibrantly alive during each agenda item discussion and this in these meetings so that each student can

009achieve their own unique potential these are proven ingredients for a recipe for collaborative success I respectfully request that each board member address each agenda item with the mpsd Mission Vision and cor values and life thank you for your time and consideration next we have [Music] Mar AR post 825 Lon Street that's what I'm going to talk about Crossroads of transition and I use the word of because that's a multiplyer term for fifth grade and fourth grade that means we've done this multiple times it's a multiplication problem and you can't change the past but you can change the future once again the district finds itself in major transition mode this is past practice for the community a majority of community members are immune to what the district is doing they don't care because they feel that

010their voice will never be heard there is an Ever expansive silent majority that believe all the decisions have been made do you know the history of this community and all its people where they've been and what has transpired just in terms of employment not just mpsd staff the 80s brought the house down of living w and in some cases it became nonexistent there was massive layoffs closures relocation families broke apart it was an awful time and there was no handouts for anybody you did what you could do and you have to realize that there were a lot of people in man talk going for jobs 300 at a time for six positions and you would go and maybe you were lucky enough to get an interview usually you didn't and you had to go to

011Appleton Green Bay manw wherever you can find it there was I I did that right there were too many unemployed and not enough jobs life would never be the same for some laborers and families not enough steady living wage work man to living wage wouldn't be forever change and so would then I'm just giving you a glimpse of some of these things that affected the school district the '90s River viiew County Special I closed with no real direction that was inclusion and not everyone was on board of that so you guys can all look this up it would become Riverview Kindergarten Center eventually and the preschool was moved from the McKinley building and eventually that would be taken all to not everyone was on B with that I went to schools I was HED for

012a kindergarten I went to schools that were not in the Kindergarten Center yet but we were going to be in there and that was kind of hard people were not happy about that the changes that played a role in how the schools got to be whatever they are today I only gave you a glimpse one must know the past and its people and how these things affect the community once again you ask for input the the people have questions will they be answered truthfully the people are skeptical they see the same policies that had no resolv failing academics failing buildings constant staff turnover they feel that there has been no accountability or transparency they have given you have taken most of them have limited resources they need honesty coupled with Integrity true honesty you want

013to take their money again but what did or will they get they've given them before what's the promised payout how was previous money spent they feel their involvement isn't needed there are some these are some of the opinions and comments that I've received from community members when I go I I live here and I am out and people I ask people what they think and they say well who cares about it we gave money we don't have real resources to pay for more but they want more a lot of us don't even have food to eat I mean people that I'm not necessarily me but people that my husband and I know that I rece the community needs to know that it's imperative for them to be informed and engaged a positive Community role model

014for this students so that they may also strive to become that way through their education a positive successful Community Pro procedure stay on top of the community pulse so many people don't care about what's happening out there and every time I was with a student I always told them you only know you stay safe make good choices be kind Mo where you planted don't be a where read the undertoe I every time I come into this place I read the room what kind of people are here to listen tonight that one time I was here there were students and people were not acting as good Role Models you need to be good Role Models always always professional I'm always professional and I hope that's what I portray thank you for letting me talk thank you

015next we have Claire step hgen as I said when I spoke before this board the first time years ago put me the third graders I find Del I'm a little we with so bear that in mind um there are a few definitions of the purpose of public schools in America and this is one that I found Public Schools are more than physical structures they are the manifestation of our Civic values and ideals the ideal that education is so important for individuals and for society that a free education must be available to all and I emphasize all in these very very dangerous times the manok public school district and all public school districts must be a Beacon of Hope and safety for every student every student no Aster no question mark no parentheses no what every

016student no matter what period thank you thank you next we have Sarah Linberg Sarah weberg uh 2919 jmr Ro and KO speaking on as president of the man Education Association um I just want you to consider when you uh get to new business Item B the report from the curriculum instruction and curriculum and instruction committee uh number two the adjustment of the last day of school for elementary I'm hoping you can consider mainly doing it for the whole school district so as a staff we can have professional development we can help elementary teachers if we be en wring their rooms for the summer as they possibly take on another curriculum or we can better ourselves and prepare for the school year because there's a lot of changes happening and we would like to be able

017to work together thank you thank you and green m previously it was suggested that curriculum does not matter in the success of a district while and that teachers are the sole responsibility of ensuring the district is successful and while teachers are without a doubt an important aspect of our district success and it's necessary to take steps to hire and maintain quality teachers the curriculum is just as important you can have skilled teaches but if the curriculum does not possess the quality it needs for students to be successful the AL can produced will not be the one desired it is the same for when those two variables are switched curriculum is will provide students with the skills and Foundation of knowledge needed to succeed in their adult lives it sets trackable learning objectives to measure student

018achievement this measurement allows their learning experience to be tailored to meet their needs the framework for accountability is propped up critical thinking and problem selling skills are encouraged and developed to make informed decisions creativity and Innovation are fostered career development is supported a love of learning is developed these aspects are all complemented with quality curriculum if you believe teachers are the only factor in Student Success does that insinuate they only serve to care about that during the first year of SFA when reading scores finally began to increase I say certainly not the same quality Educators teaching the were here the year before it was implemented when a failing curriculum could not produce sufficient results I agree with the previously stated sentiment that switching from a successful curriculum to a different one would be unfair to

019staff staff has spent hours of their time and funding has been allocated to professional development in regard to learning a new curriculum which the ones who have spoken at board mes have publicly stated their support now you want to strip that away from them and the students and parents noex success for all provides a necessary structure of cooperation and consistency across schools the success for all Foundation has even worked to significantly reduce the costs of their program for this upcoming school year while maintaining its necessary components in order to keep the kids while aligning with the district's financial goals instead of attacking a curriculum that has made Monumental progress compared to previous years we should be bolstering it to advance Student Success as the saying goes if it's not broken don't fix it we don't

020have a for sure answer as to whether a different curriculum will work or be a waste of funding these are the types of instances when I witness that board means I Ponder whether board members are focused on educating children or maintaining Poli I power I will leave you with these two questions one if the hon my when Dei infused curriculum was chosen instead of SFA would it be questioned the same amount by the board members questioning SFA two if a successful curriculum being considered for change was implemented during the time of the current board majority rather than the previous would it still be considered for change by the ones currently doing so thank you thank you that exhaust a submitted request for public input see if we have any other requests out there going once

021going twice okay then we will close public input next up we do have something fairly unique um we have we will be hearing a petition to alter the school district boundaries I believe Glenn kaan is here to speak to the petition yep thanks even we are asking be to Encompass our soon new home which is actually measured it off of Google Maps is 1,00 Ft from the southern border the current line this request is to help make sure our son's flourishing he's flourishing in the school like he has been he has a diagnosed with CER syndrome which look and he makes him look for stability in his life with him being in the man school just for his whole life he has developed a so to speak bond with kids in his class which is

022really no small feet as he tends to gravitate to adults versus kids this request comes with the best or son's development and with the hopes not to regress into any of the bad behaviors he developed when the schools were shut down during Co but with the great teachers of man School District they have worked through all that and he has 100% turned around and overcome everything and when he has fears the school the teachers he has now help them and work through it they understand them and there is plenty of needs in this man school district and great teachers in the special needs program so we request that you grant this change in school district for the Border Great Le thank you thank you sir wel speak no okay I'm just finding out the process

023because it's kind of a unique thing to do okay and so the petitioner gets a chance to speak the form is not open to anyone else on the matter and then the matter is considered by the board we going to provide any information on this or sure um so how this essentially works is the process yeah thank you um if somebody petitions to change the boundaries of a district it must be mutually agreed on by the boards of Education of both districts um in this case there is the petition includes five properties uh on the essentially the border of ours in the valers area school district um we found out about this petition through the valers area school District they'll be meeting it has to be taken care of in so many days they'll be

024meeting on February 24th um we consulted with valders uh because this would be a situation where our district would essentially be annexing piece of their school district uh we wanted to make sure that this was a collaborative process through that process um the valers area school district uh will be recommending to their board to deny the request U they have some concerns over um giving up the property not only for its tax value but also uh because there are some other students in this in these homes that attend their school district um my recommendation that I have given to the board um is strictly based off a simple rationale of uh my recommendation to the board is also for our district to deny the request um the reasoning behind that are is really three reasons

025um first of all uh this petition would impact more families than just the petitioners second redrawing district boundaries is a much larger conversation uh that should be more collaborative than just saying that we believe we should take the land of another District um mpsd and thirdly mpsd works hard to maintain a positive and collaborative relationship with our neighboring School District um just to give you an example uh in in in sort of the tenor here um I would ask you to consider if the shoe were on the other foot and if a district who was looking to essentially Annex a piece of property um would just you know vote to do that without consultation and collaboration um it only takes one entity to deny the request for it to not be approved uh and therefore

026I didn't want to uh damage the relationship between the valders area school district and the manat of the school district uh not that I don't have empathy and compassion for the request I I mean with all my heart I want every kid who wants to come to manat to come to manat but as you know uh last month the district also um set some caps on um you know our open enrollment uh for students with IEPs and we have to follow the letter of the law on that um because if we didn't we would be essentially opening it up for um potentially many other students um so does anybody have any questions I don't know I just I I think just to you know change change the Border uh for one child is is probably

027not the right do you do you have any questions for the I just yeah the question I have yeah the question I have is there any other way to resolve uh a situation that involves one child without without without changing the borders I know we said caps yeah um so legally what would occur if a a student uh and Katie can help me with this if I'm wrong but I think I remember what she told uh if a student were uh to uh do an open enrollment request by law we would review the IEP and and and look at it that way um but in the end whatever level that is we would have to follow what the board imposed gaps are uh and am I correct on that and if we were to but

028if well if we were to make an exception then it opens up um to a ton of litigation and then it really makes knowled we've made based setam that wased by the board any any other questions for the superintendent yes sir so did did the student just move into this area or or how it sounds like they've been attending the district for several years recently family just recently relocated he been going here since he's 3K he's in the fifth grade right now which sixth gr so 8 years he's been going to this District we're renting a property in the district right now and we own property that's in valor's discrict so we wanted we're remodeling that house with my parents and we eventually want to move into that home but we want our son to

029be part of manage walk district is why we're proposing the volary line because of the open enrollment with the I situation so my question is is I I completely understand the district says no and it's more than one family my concern is if we've been providing a program a successful program for the young man is there any way because he's been in the program that we could somehow amend the cap as a board I I'm just saying that as a as a parent of a student with need with disabilities it's hard to change programs and and this seems to be an occasion where maybe we could sit down with the elders and go oh you know we got work this out for the student for the good of the student you this question I don't

030I don't know the answer to that I would I would have to check with DPI um because that is it's required that our board pass this seat allocation in January so I would have to I would have to check with someone from DPI to see if there can be an amendment or a special exception and what that would entail and I can I can do that Mr F I want to talk off of Mr Hansen's comment first so Mr Hansen what you're kind of trying to articulate I believe in what I'm trying to articulate is we have an appropriate education that's been met by them already for over eight years so that relationship is staying so I think that's what I'm I'm 100% on with you with that because we have existing relationship for over

0318 years that's where I would be coming from my question to the superintendent is of those five homes how many of those homes have uh age appropriate children in a district um according to the only one that I know for sure uh because I have an email here dated today uh that there is a neighbor with three schoolage children that attend the valers area school district one home is what you're as of today one other home that is what I know for sure okay thank you yeah um I know one of the concerns was uh opening yourself up to like Katie said opening yourself up to litigation if we were to make an exception is there any way to mitigate that by saying it's an exception because of somebody who does work for our school

032district because I I do know that she's a bus driver here now not working for the school district but I mean she's been a friend of ours for a long time she she knew my grandbaby before she passed away uh and I I I have a heart for that family so is there any way that that exception could be you know I mean something done in our policies or whatever to where that would protect us from any type of a litigation and that's my question and I I don't know and I know you guys aren't legal but can we look into that maybe before we make a decision there there are typically not those exceptions unfortunately what what the district can do is create determinations about who gets on a waiting list um in the

033event that you know like so we have space available in our high school programs so let's say we have more applicants through open enrollment than we do space availability in our three High School seats that we have available what we can do in those circumstances is we can provide priority to people who have siblings people who have been long-term residents of manitto and have recently relocated so we can set priorities as to who gets to fill those seats there are just not exceptions once we make our space determinations there really are no exceptions to that rule um which is I'm drafted an email to a consultant at DPI right now um I I know what they're going to tell us because had this conversation with a number of families because they're absolutely heartbreaking conversations um

034they really they're they they really are and there's nothing worse than having to be the messenger and delivering some of those messages question Mr CH you said it takes a mutual agreement between both districts valers has already said no they they're scheduled to take it up at their meeting to say no and if one District says no it's not there is an appeals process for the petitioners so do we table this and we wait to see what bers does um so one of the things I think in term in in terms of the timeline just so you're aware I Believe by the end of February this issue has to be resolved if they meet on the 24th I believe this this board is planning to meet on the 25th for a special meeting to review

035uh survey results uh therefore yes I mean you could table this said no so you will know on the 25th what they're uh what they are doing they're receiving a recommendation to deny just like we received a recommendation to deny corre as well so I think we're in the discussion portion now yeah so I get a motion we can really discuss like okay I make a motion to accept to move the boundaries for uh that particular family um to accommodate the needs of the student because of the existing conditions okay so we have a motion have a second we have a motion to move the boundaries and a second that's open for I know where you're headed so if there's any discussion before we go where Mr Shaw has headed so yeah my discussion would

036be that um we've already heard testimony from the parents that the child's needs uh so a free and appropriate education is what the statute says we already are achieving an appropriate education from testimony from the parents so if it takes two districts to say no or only one I should say only one in my views of understanding the betterment of that family not being partisan whatsoever I'm looking out for that family and I would say let's try to help that family because of the long-standing relationship with that family I would be voting to help them have the district boundaries moved because of this exception yes sir with the second to second that and and agree with that because like you said it takes one to deny so I'm going to lead that up to bers

037I would hope that we could work something out and we could maybe I don't know maybe this other family wants to come and atalk I don't know but if it only takes one to deny it's not going to be me yeah here go Katie would that would that change the situation with DPI and the C that we yes if they if we adjusted our district boundaries and they were part of the npsd then they would not need to apply for open enrollment okay so then the camp does we already have sorry we already have that space available because they're in our district right now they would be residents then hey hang on what if we just did it anyway what GP accepted the open enrollment yeah what would the GPI do they would tell us

038that we have to accept every student with disabilities that open anals to our district how many of those are we get um 50 a year approximately and how many do we we that we have to okay um we don't we when you make your space determination so this year again for next year we said that we would be able to accept three students at the high school age that have mild disabilities faed on our projected workload formula that we created is there anything in there like for circumstances like this or it's been in the district for years and years only that in a in a space that would be available that they would get priority so if there was space available at our Middle School level for next year um based on what and supports

039he has in thiss and because we have a long-standing relationship with them and they've been in our district and you know um mom is you know an affiliate employee then we would be able to push them to the top of the acceptance list if we had space that so how do they not get in there if they if they're doing that because we voted two weeks ago that we don't have space available the only space we have available is in our high school based on numbers and our work PRS no they they have moved they're relocating to valers so they are here right now but they it will be an opener moment when may relocate out of our community no longer be residents I understand that but I guess what I'm getting at is that

040like they're currently going to the district now but we have to make our projections for next school year so it's based on all of our projected case load assignments for next school year so they're not they're not considered currently in the count for next school year Mr sha voted as a board to close the enrollments for one for Staffing reasons right we we open our orders back up again we increase students in our cap classes that's going to cost an increase in staff we have to consider that it's going to cost probably could be as a full teacher or perhaps a pair professional um depending on the handicapp and condition which I understand and I and I being a former services I get that but we cap our enrollments U by doing that was a

041purpose by every District in the state to save those enrollments from adding greater fiscal responsibility to people flip-flopping districts an IEP is an IEP it's a document that can be followed at IEP can be followed by many many school districts competent teachers I get that but we be voted at as a staff or a board rather to cap our enrollments and and we're getting a feeling that valers isn't going to well then then I still maybe stick to my motion that we table and see what valers does are you moving that right now yes I'll second because I anticipated that's going early on so okay motions to table there's motion on the table we're in the middle of discussion you cut me off well no you I did give you a chance to speak to

042the motion we have a motion to Table in a second which now we just vote on the motion to table which is not a debatable motion so if table that would mean we would revisit this after valers makes a determination all the table right so all those in favor of the table signify by saying I and opposed say nay hearing none this will be tabled and we will take it up within the deadline but after valers has looked at the do we have a meeting after yeah make sure that thank you thank you all thank you we have also line of communication with Bowers that we can talk to uh and and as well as the board too and get some sort of uh we would talk superintendant would talk so I guess the board

043would might have to initiate myself all right okay thank you all next we have the consent agenda is there anything that anyone would like removed from the consent agenda okay see seeing none I I will say I would like to have removed from the consent agenda uh revised policy uh 5771 search and seizure that is my request is that under February policy yeah yeah okay that's under policies that's under e policies brought for for consideration you're pulling all of them right well I I'm pulling that one from e if you if you'd like me to pull them all I just thought do that sorry yeah no anybody have any other policies they like both anything else okay so you have the rest of the consent agenda I would look for a motion to approve the

044consent agenda yeah thank you do we have a second second two seconds three okay all those in favor say I I oppose that is approved then we will take up policy 5771 search and seizure I did ask for this to be considered separately and the reason I asked for it to be considered separately is just like last year when I did not support our search and seizure policy I believe it is too broad and it presumes things that would not normally be considered reasonable cause so while I understand and we all have examples that we have seen of times where we have to act that preemptively I believe this is too broad and like last year will not support it okay we don't have any recommendations no I would notations to change I'm just saying

045that I'm going to be voting against it so it hadn't be pulled for that so somebody wants the motion to approve it obviously I can't I'm voting against it absur approve thank you second and a second any other discussion you'd like to have about why you don't want to prove it I I believe the way that it's written is too broad and it doesn't provide what I believe at times is reasonable cause for for for example if you just want a simple example out of all of it it is the fact that we can bring dogs through a parking lot without any reason to have the dogs there and if the dogs mark on a car we can bring the kids out and have them unlock the vehicle and the cost there is the dog

046Mark the vehicle but there is no cause for the dog to be wandering through the parking lot in the first place except that they're high school kids cars in their own school property yeah adults adults that would not be considered reasonable cause that's because they're yeah I yeah because I see their car is their property I would disagree just I did it for 10 years and there are situations in a high school with kids that I am I was so happy to be able to go to the SLO and say please search this young man or this young woman because they might have something on them so I think schools are essentially different because there's so many students and for safety it's not it's not the same as the real world got 1500 kids in

047a building and I I have to make sure those kids are safe and uh when we search it was a discussion between the police officer in the building and ourselves and um it worked and it was good for kids so I would not support that at all the change there's no proposed change yeah I I'm G to senent with bi said it's just uh when it come into safety on a school property it's it's it's like an airport I mean it so when it comes to searching we have to consider the safety of the rest of the students um and you know it's always under the supervision of an officer there as well um I I I absolutely agree that the policy is wide for that purpose um and and I definitely will vote to

048keep our schools safe no matter what and it yeah it it's different it is different with a school and that's why I agree just to speak to your comment I would encourage you to park on night Street or to Vis sorry I had to that long walk to my house oh that's where people Park so that's that's public that's the role so sorry I had to say that uh call question all those in favor signifi by saying I opposed may just like last year that's why I stayed out of the Weeds last year all right all right moving on from the consent agenda we have our student Representatives report so I just have some updates on good things happening at linked because they deserve to be celebrated so um our dance team made it to

049State and took home some a trophy with their fifth place finish in D2 pal which was very exciting and uh one of the dancers Caitlyn jansy made the All State team which means she uh danced a solo and the judges said she was better than a lot of other people so it's good for her um uh boys basketball senior Brandon steinbecker made his th000 point um at the game last Friday and it was also senior night for all of them so it was a very fun celebration celebrating his accomplishment and all the other seniors um FBA competed at regionals recently and roughly 20 members qualified for state in a lot of different categories I could list them all but there's a million it's impressive how many different areas um the musical uh had their performances

050last weekend and put on a very very great show they did the Percy Jackson musical and then um our Winter Dance at Lincoln was rescheduled for March 14th for anyone who didn't know or see that um we had attendance and DJ issues so hopefully that'll be resolved from State um and then my last thing is not an update but we do we didn't meet with the school board committee last month because of finals week but we do have a meeting this month and it's next Tuesday and right now it's just Biff signed up so um as a committee we were talking today and we're just hoping to um have one or two more people come just so we can have conversations with everyone it's great I love that you're there but you know we want

051to talk to everybody um they are at 9:39 that's what time our win period starts and and always if there's an open spot when it comes I'll sign up for but I like to leave it you know I I sign up for three and then I wait to see if you have an open spot on call and we're meeting in the library now not the conference room for anyone that comes oh if I had known that we we four of us show up do you have to have a if four of us show up we probably have enough to do a bad key notice for one of committee so that and that's why we do the sign up so that if we can see we need a bad keep we do it that's what yeah

052we TR it's not to say to make and that's why I made it three so up to three can be there Beyond three we'll talk so much the students would never get a chance yeah so we have a meeting every month still so I think three is fine for from any of the months so yeah but that's my just last thing if you would so yeah that's all I got and it won't be snowing that B I hope not you'd like to see the dam team winning dance team senior night this Friday they're playing or they're dancing Friday night at halftime of the game so if you'd like to come and watch that they'll be do that Ellie is that next Tuesday uh the meeting yeah it's next Tuesday at 9:30 oh yeah like 9:30

0539 um it's just the weird time our bell times so I think it's in the it should say it says the time in the sign up that CHR it does and if anybody needs the sign up the sign up uh whatever you call that thing from from Sign Up Genius the link I can send you the link I finally thought the word so just let me know I'll send you the L again thank you now we have superintendent report yes thank you um and good evening to everyone um to begin my superintendent report this evening I actually have a couple of guests here that i' would like to share with you I have Mrs Bey the principal at Wilson and some of her students uh who I've asked to come to give a brief update

054to the board about their buddy system at Wilson Jun Wilson Middle School so Mr Speedy it's all yours actually I'm going to inv CHR up and she's gonna share with her kids awesome um I'd rather to Spotlight be on rather than me so wel introduce first all right so I'm Miss Chris I'm special education teacher at Wilson Middle School and I brought along some students here who are participants in our peer mentor buddies group um we just started this group this year so it's brand new we're all learning together um this is a small peer mentor support group that Fosters relationships between students receiving special education services and general education students um the purpose of this group is really to help um encourage language play social skills and relationship building um it also encourages leadership

055roles while creating trusting relationships between each other um we're really hoping that by creating these new friendships this can lead to more inclusive opportunities both in and outside of the classroom um so we brought along you want to ince yourself um I'm Owen and I join buddy group because I knew some of the buddies from elementary and wanted another chance to interact with them I'm Jaya and I don't have the opportunity to interact with others and help them and by gaining leadership skills and by leaving leading activities that we do I'm trip and um I like joking around with others going to BU food yeah yeah so a lot of them say that they just really enjoy the fun activities we get to do together um it gives them kind of a break in their

056day to just have fun and laugh together and do things that we all like do nice thank you very much uh this uh this group was also recently uh discussed at our special education parents night uh and the parents uh gave R reviews uh of the program and wanted to know how we were going to get it into other schools so really a kudos to uh staff and students at Wilson uh for the Buddy group um just a couple things for my report I'll be brief obviously you have it in writing so I have uh highlighted the February is the Career and Technical Education Month um it would be remissed if I didn't uh boast about our school district in offering over 40 CTE courses in family consumer Science Tech education and business education as

057well as that all of our students participate in academic and career planning as part of their uh curriculum in addition we have the strongest school to work program in the area with over 300 students at the high school involved in school-based learning including 170 youth Apprentice uh so uh kudos to our school the work team our counselors uh and all of our teachers who help our kids get ready for what's next because that's our mission referendum planning uh you saw that we've scheduled staff meetings uh at each School uh it's very important vitally important that we share all of the factual information uh with our staff uh around um our ask of the public uh for their permission to borrow $25 million um in addition to those meetings uh we're working on scheduling meetings with

058um PTO uh advisory groups uh service organizations in the community and we have also uh landed on um scheduling Community Information sessions so I want to share those um February 20th at 6: PM which will be plugging out after this meeting uh we will be at the Washington Middle School auditorium uh for presentation and Q&A session on March 5th we'll do a 6 PM virtual meeting via Google we'll send that out and put it on our website uh so that really anyone can join uh not have to come in person if they would choose not to on March 12th at 6: p.m. we will do a meeting at Lincoln high schools Auditorium uh at 6 p.m. and on March 19th uh at 6 p.m. uh we will be at Wilson Auditorium uh for the same

059um lastly I do want to plug also uh that the Tuesday February 25th special board meeting uh will be uh for the purpose of sharing our districtwide staff survey results with the board uh representative from school perceptions will be here along with Mr KN uh to discuss those with you and have a dialogue around uh where our uh results came in this year um in addition to that um you know the goal would be that you'll have some of that information ahead of time so you can take a peek at it before the meeting that's at 6 yeah yep 6:00 um on the 25th yeah um lastly u a big thanks to Mrs Bey uh at Wilson uh officer rockowitz and our district safety coordinator normana help TR Tri I can never get that right

060I I struggle with that one sorry nman um who are offering uh uh Community Information uh meeting on school violence uh this will take place on February 12th at 5:00 p.m. in the Wilson Auditorium and uh they will be focusing on the warning signs of school violence and they'll have the our uh of course anyone in the community is invited to attend uh because uh school safety uh is always on our mind and a top priority uh and helping educate our public on that is V that's all I have and people have questions any questions all right we'll go to the director's report you have that before you so any questions for the directors the directors are saying that yes sir can we just get a a summary of the report a summary of the

061director report yeah I could start sure um we had our look here sorry um we had our uh special education monthly special education um parents advisory committee meeting uh that's always held the first Monday of the month um we saw excitingly an increase in um in participation after that group has started to share a newsl um with all students um and families students with disabilities so that went out to approximately 900 families and we had a response rate of about 400 people so we felt pretty good about that we hosted our first um parent engagement event here last week Wednesday we had about 11 participants great conversation um had a a group of staff leaders support that training um Chad Breer and Julie seon and Marissa oh I'm going to not say her last name

062right by our Behavior specialist at Monro who um with under the leadership of Vette seminar um just did an outstanding job engaging with that group of families and that was very positively received um and we had jul Sam fipo came in um on our last uh staff development day and he is um a superintendent from Fall Creek Wisconsin B crickets if you want to check him out there's lots of resources about him but he's a culture changer so he met with our building leaders and um it's a great morning of learning and um and inspiration for our building leaders thank you some additional items um that were Shar was shared by the office of ccul instruction we shared out about some optional Ela curriculum um that people are looking into um are Act 20 update

063really looking at the excitement that we have our we have finally hit that point where last this last Friday all of our prps personal reading plans went home to parents we had about 550 plans that went out um and we're hoping to hear back from parents they have an opportunity to fill out a little bit of information to share about their student um as well as any questions that they have um and then we hope to get those all signed in back to school um the elementary principal team is working hard on professional um learning this year around math and we are diving into we do our own um PLC meeting our professional learning community meeting once a month where we look at data that we have collected and talk about um effective um teaching

064practices in the area of math and we also did some of that same conversation around writing past month um and 100 Day plans we had all of our principles write 100 day action plans in August for the start of the school year and we are meeting to discuss um how that that first 100 day action plan went we'll be sharing goals and looking at how we might want to modify goals or change goals um to again to the end of the year thank you next could you talk about the PRP plan a little bit in the 10 we intervention like how that's going to roll out and what's your plan with that um so every student that has a PRP is in an intervention that intervention could be with the classroom teacher it could be

065with the reading teacher um and we have those goals are set based on the student needs students in kindergarten are focusing on letter naming and our students that are in the first grade through third grade are focusing in on um basically how how quickly they can read words would be the best way to put that can I ask is it will be in groups or will be individual both very it will be very rare that a child would be individually working with a person because many of our students have similar goals we group them according to similar goals small groups like under 10 or under five or um I would say probably our kids are in groups more like three to five thank you you said what else did you say after that um where

066was I at pretty much small groups and then doing the 10 we program yeah so sorry 10 week every 10 it is um a requirement of act 20 that after 10 weeks of intervention and progress monitoring that we go back and re-evaluate where the student is at and whether or not the PRP would continue which I'm guessing in many cases it will is there what is there an assessment um Y what assessment will you be using so we are using the um am web plus screener that's the state requirement we'll use that three times a year the next testing window for that is in April so it's at the end of the 10 weeks then we have another twoe testing window for that um we have additional diagnostic assessments that we have and based on

067what the kids intervention was um or the area of need was we will do some of that diagnostic assessment again but we won't have to do the full battery of Assessments every single time because it was pretty extensive the first time what materials will we be using in those interventions um we are using sips sipps um is the intervention that we're using from collaborative classroom that's for our most our students that have the most intense needs um and we are using uly and hegr as the main resources for other students we do have additional assess additional interventions that can be used by a reading teachers based on student needs but those are the main ones else about that I don't think so is it pretty heavy on the ad recording side of it for extra

068load on you guys at all no the teer the weekly progress monitoring is really we we've got a pretty simple system for it I mean I think that assessing the students for that progress monitoring at the end of the week um might take a two minutes per student to actually do the monitoring and it might take a minute to put it into Infinite Campus so maybe 15 or 20 minutes max for that once a week is there going to be meetings at all between staff to try to cooperatively try to figure out Solutions or data how they're working together how how things are being implemented that it's communicated at all levels when all of the students when we were done when reading teachers were done with their assessments same met with classroom teachers um to

069help them with guidance on what interventions might be best and what progress monitoring might be best now that we're up and running um it's the expectation that we would review those at the 10 week Mark but I would anticipate that if teachers recognize that a student's not doing well that the conversation would Happ been sooner between staff or student and teacher and between reading teacher and classroom teacher and then the parents get that notification of the 10we mark but more individual uh eyes not uh I'm asking will the will the read teachers and the classroom teachers collaborate on strategies or anything like that yes absolutely during professional development or yes grade level meetings okay that's I on an individual student basis yes okay that's thank you that's all I have okay thank you so I

070provided you with some information regarding the why staff report and the DPI y staff report is a report where we submit to DPI all of our teaching teachers in their teaching assignment so if they're teaching social studies or math or whatever and DPI takes that information and matches it up with their license certification when there's a mismatch it pops it out as an error so we have about as I was just looking 650 employees that are that that are required to have a license we ended up uh having about 70 errors the first round and what I mean by that is is that they provide us with this report I think it's about mint the latter part of December so of course we you know reasons the reasons that this happen is some some people

071just the license expired last June forgot all about it so they have to go in and and apply other person maybe the assignment doesn't match up um they're teaching uh four sections of math and one social studies they don't the social studies serve uh another one is there their assignment doesn't match up because of grade level they're certified six but they're teaching 678 another one that popped out a few times this year was there's this thing called a lifetime license it's not truly a lifetime license it's a fiveyear license and some you know you call up and say hey your license is expired I have a lifetime license I got news for change so so they expire every 5 years they call that a tax yeah you um so the good news is we went

072after this and uh we're down to about three employees now that I expect the bank uh resolve their situation this month February we did have two people who did not renew last J July they one resigned in September one resigned in October other got so you can't bre me about that those bottom line is I tell you what and all my years Nate I put this in here this is this is this has been a good outcome a really good outcome so compl please response of our employees to get take care of business Mr no okay I'm sorry you can forget about me but that's okay uh first part is theie for the a um the next finance and Facilities meeting we will present the B uh the audit at there so there'll be a

073pres a presentation of the audit at the next meeting next weekly I believe it is uh business office working through some software issues uh reporting Wisconsin retirement was there it was software issue with all districts not uh antis schooling no employe or employee data was affected by it however um there was an ER of $93,000 that was paid to Wisconsin retirement uh but it was all taken out so the money was uh taken out correctly uh workers cop experience is problematic um we're working on that they've added the staff person to monitor it however we have uh it's an average of three years and it's prior three years and there's one year in there that was extremely high about two or three years ago and so we got to run that mod out so in

074essence a good example our mod is 1.8 uh average District when we're talking school districts is one 80% above the average and we're trying to address that issue and get people back to work as soon as possible um business office working Rec update Sal schedule we were meeting um a few times and uh the uh we're we're going to come back with some proposals about salary increases right now the um CPI that they're using State the CPI U is at 2.95% so that's what we're looking at any questions thank thank you sir thank you okay so we move now on to new business and we start with a report out from Mr Hansen for the personnel and policy committee a very short meeting um you went over the the um policies for tonight I'll just

075make one comment we did change one policy that was about the social media for the school district and it was the unanimous vote that um we have Facebook accounts Instagram whatever account we have we will not allow comments on anything that is posted there um we all know through Facebook and those kind of things what can happen when people start posting things so if somebody doesn't like it they can take it and do whatever on their personal page but the Public School District page shouldn't have some of these comments and language that we see on other social media accounts so um that's was the only change that it was a good discussion and it was unanimous it was good to hear the or have the Boe on that committee agreed because it's there's really not

076a place for that kind of language in our history so yeah we kind of agreed that we have a social media more it's more informational it's it's a bolon board for us to be able to get out that information not to have these conversations they want to have those conversations they can have them on their own Pages we kept our meeting short so Carrie could have his yeah well we had it we so now so yeah that's okay okay so now we will move to that meeting the report from Mr TR did we have we had a half an hour yeah we had a half an hour and and fairly big fairly big issues but we did have a I thought a pretty thorough discussion of the discontinuation of success Ro all for the third

077year and the I want to I want to say that there's a recommendation from the curriculum committee um which which which uh was supported by a 3:1 3:1 in favor vote that we do discontinue uh successful all for the third year for the reasons that are pretty clearly stated in this document here this this that number one it it it cost us 3.4 $3.4 million for two years number two that we don't have any Esser funds left number three that doesn't doesn't line up appropriately with the ACT 20 act 20 uh requirements and um that faculty reading faculty are already in the process of considering other curricula that will that will come in at a price of a around 8 800,000 for 6 years so it just seemed to me and to other people who

078voted in the 3:1 majority that we just can't we just can't continue to afford this we don't have the money to pay for it and um that we recommend that we uh cease for uh cease beginning next year having success for all now the thing is is that they that we have really gained a lot by success for all there's no question about that and a lot of the things that are left left over even when it leaves are the coordination the cooperation the the the making things uniform uh the the the collection of data and having really methodology now to really to really deal with with with with the reading the reading the reading problem uh in a really constructive in a constructive way uh regardless of what curriculum we what curriculum is adapted

079for for for going forward so I I I because it's recommended by the committee I present it as a motion I'll second the motion oh so we're going to the vote on this right I mean we're skipping over right now right no no no there discussion now now it's discussion yeah oh I didn't think we were getting that I thought there was just a minutes we were talking about here or or whatever is this actually the motion okay he's he's on number one success for oh okay all right gotta yeah actually 101 10 B1 okay yeah 10 B1 I would like my take me I can feel it or you can feel it okay you do you made the motion so okay so we have motion and a second to end the contract with success

080for all any discussion and I'm sure there's going to be some yes um I just wanted to start by talking like addressing some of the things that Carrie said how much we've learned from SFA and and all the good things that we have gotten from SFA we all know that it's working I mean we we all he even said it m the biggest the two first things that he said on there had to do with cost and I know that we've got a letter from a lady who the aon's with us through SFA and they' worked last month to drop the cost down to $71 per student I believe it ends up being 153k uh which is a little bit over just a little bit over uh what you were talking about before so the

081cost itself is really should be null and void to be honest with you um everybody that I've ever talked with and interacted with students coordinators teachers it's literally an emotional response almost every single time when I see them talk about the progress these students are making I have a hard time even considering walking off the edge of the cliff which is exactly what we'd be doing because you've heard them say that we've been looking into or we've been considering uh new curriculum we we so there's no decision we have no idea which direction we're going I have a hard time getting rid of something that's working in a in a manner just to save money when when they've actually stepped in to help us save money now to go something that we have no idea

082is going to work or not um and the emotional response is because this program is working these kids are learning um we have so many other places that we can cut budget and we cut money we've given them options we haven't taken any steps towards relocating district office office which we talked about we haven't taken any steps towards consolidating schools there's there's money to be saved I just think it's not within curriculum and Student Success and achievement if if somebody was to vote to get rid of this I would only ask that we change the the motion to uh exactly what it is and that's a motion to you know foro Student Success for nothing no idea where we're headed with this this is just crazy I'm done Mr and then you how much is

083it going to cost us to terminate that contract early $ what about the money equipment are you sure about that and the materials okay I've the reason I'm asking that is I've I've talked to staff that have told me otherwise so I don't know if they're misinformed uh no I have also two directors who sat through all those meetings and conversations with SFA that they couldest to that there is no fee for terminating our contract early okay so we can end the contract for goal of that last year and you're saying it would cost us Z to correct there's like no like nothing they won't charge it correct I'm just making sure yep okay he's asking what you're saying all right so the next question I had is I know we've made a sizable investment

084in this program and with that there's a lot of I guess ancillary materials that come along with it what are we going to do with all that stuff ID do you want to address that question um we hope that we would be able to we have things that are still in packages we would hope that we would be able to return some of those things um typically at the end of any curriculum um when you are no longer using it it becomes disposable there are things that we would hope that we could keep and use um the the reality is that many of the texts with SFA are really older versions of things and we had to work hard to find books because they're not in publication anymore so there are definitely resources that we

085could use in book rooms and things and there are resources that we would dispose of very much like the last curriculum you know you have the things and you invest in them and then the new curriculum has has resources that go with it also depending on the amount of that's we could also consider trying to sell them to other districts that may need of them as well as long as they're in good enough shape yes sir I didn't want to miss something oh I thought there was somebody going before me but oh I'm sorry I for go go first did we have gains yeah we did do other reading programs other districts in the state of Wisconsin have gains yeah and some are better than ours and it was programs that didn't cost as much

086money we when this whole process started the reading curriculum committee of teachers picked out a program that was $800,000 this was 1.4 million to buy so we lost 600,000 buying this program over the $800,000 program that most of the schools not just in Wisconsin but in the country use you look at F SFA and I researched it again today and the numbers are the same there's 200 21 roughly 21,000 schools not districts but schools in in the country SFA is used in a thousand that's 0.004 percentage of the schools that use this program used to be more but most schools have moved away from it there were Wisconsin schools that used it in the early 2000s they moved away from it of those thousand schools that still use SFA across the country only half use

087the whole program that's 0.002% of the schools in the nation and that's because the K2 program is pretty good with phonics but there are other programs that do phonics pretty well also if you read the data and you read the test results there aren't any test results anywhere that I could find that blow the other programs away the phonics is good as good as other programs but one of the downfalls if you read is the kids who start excelling and reading better are held back their scores do not increase as much as other reading programs because the program wasn't designed for kids like that the program was designed for a c certain type of student and that whatever is needed in Reading to get them to Excel and read and increase at faster rates it's

088not part of SFA and that's something I've heard from teachers and parents that there are kids that should be in reading groups much higher but they can't that they it's not allowed to do so are we holding kids back on the other end that aren't learning to read we can save some money on materials we got that we can save $1.54 million just in salaries that are used for SFA that weren't there before 1.5 million we need to send a message to taxpayers we're asking them for money to fix our schools in a referendum we need to send a message that we're looking at everything to start cutting cost are we going to take all of those people currently doing SFA and get rid of them right away there's probably other places we can use

089them but we could still s save probably half a million in salaries at least half a million dollars this was never brought up by the past superintendent when SFA was talked about he talked about the program and I remember sitting here and all of a sudden we had to vote on coaches why wasn't that in the planning stage why wasn't that part of what was we were being told about this program the program has some good qualities but the program is expensive has cost us a lot of money in this district and it's no better than a program that is used by other districts around us so why are we spending that extra I'm not taking money out of curriculum and making it worse I'm being wiser with the cost of buying something if I

090don't need something as expensive as SFA to get better results why am I buying that but I can be buying a reading program that's just as effective and save the taxpayers of this District some money 40% increase over the last two years for some people in school district P taxes and it's not going to get a lot Rosier unless we start looking at stuff like this this has to change and there are programs out there just as effective maybe more effective that will not cost us this amount of money the other thing that we have to remember SFA is not certified in the state of Wisconsin it's not a certified program in this state and if you go online and you start looking at States and how they rank educationally we go somewhere from 10th

091up in every organization that rates educational effect Effectiveness so I think the state of Wisconsin has a pretty good grasp on what is effective and what it isn't effective and they're telling us this isn't a program that we should be using so I'm all in favor of looking for the next program the only thing I would wish that would happen in this process is somehow we find a way for the Educators to get the time they need to dig into this when my lovely wife was teaching into rivers and they switched to a new reading program The District said in service days this is what you're doing nothing else you're going to work with the people that help train you to get this program off and running and that's what we're going to have to

092consider in this but as far as keeping the program this has run as course it is not as effective as other programs and we can save money without affecting the quality of our reading programs thank you yes sir thank you Mr Hansen for your your comments um I want to start off by saying that that's kind of how this curriculum was structured there's a lot of front loading so it did cost a lot of money to do the training so that the the staff and the the teachers and the whole schools were on board and understanding and that's why it took so many resources to do that um so that's kind of why we had such a high price T in the beginning and I think it's kind of uh interesting to me how we

093all knew about Lucy ckins not working and we kept that program just keep on rolling even though we knew it wasn't working correctly because it was getting away from phonics but now that we uh subscribed to this uh curriculum and yes it was very expensive on on the on the front side from all the training to prepare the staff and teachers and the whole schools for a complete change and and one thing I wanted to make sure that didn't happen or I was trying to not make it happen is that I know the culture of the school when you have a change it affects everything so much and then the staff gets so fatigued from the change it's it's it's like a burnout like what are we going to do this year let's let's reinvent

094the wheel let's grab a new ship and let's let's see if it sails and it seems to me now that we're going to be voting on right now in a couple minutes we're going to vote on dumping a curriculum without replacing it and that just seems to me that we would remove something before we have a better or more effective way to do it so that seems backwards to me um and then I want to move into the the testimony from the parents that say hey my child is loving this it's making them engaged it's really turning over a new Leaf for them and uh why would you get rid of this why would you get rid of this so that that's on on the parent side that I've gotten comments about this is working

095don't don't don't change this and then from a staff perspective like I said about the burnout and the turnover like it just wears a person out when you you get on board about doing something and you buy in and then all of a sudden it comes from the top saying we need to change change how we're doing things again because it's going to be too much money when there was an operational referendum that was passed and now this isn't just about money this is about investing in your staff for the professional development so that they're on board and understanding continually especially if there is a turnover so I I understand about saving money I I really do I'm quite try to be fiscally conservative about things but when I see the payoff going to our

096direct staff and the results to our direct students it's just you know uh the comment about neighborhood schools and about an extra million dollars for each neighborhood school well I would say I'm going to put my Merit on i' rather give that money and have it most effectively used for the students and the staff directly so that's where I think the money's going but I understand um so the the program was very heavy in the beginning that's what I want to say and we're on the third year so we'd be canceling the third year that would be like the cheapest year I think that we should only fulfill the contract and then it would give us time to regroup reorganize get understanding with the ACT 20 requirements that the state was behind in already about

097reading proficiency why didn't we have this from the state three years ago I didn't they have a road map for everyone no no you just keep with Lucy ckins we'll figure it out in 2025 and then we'll mandate it down your throat one last thing not maybe the last but the SFA was giving us a Cooperative accountability and I said that in the committee meeting we were able to have each School working independently but then ultimately being held accountable with each other with the exact data points and where things were coming from we understood that we we were on top of it about having children needed incentives or extra time or or having the reading blocks the way they were it was a good thing and now there was still mistakes but it was a

098good thing so to to end a program on the third year when we've had such gains seems silly to me the the staff fatigue the parents uh wanting to do this students enjoying it it just doesn't seem smart for me to just end it on the on the premature in the second year when we have all the materials and essentially the biggest cost is going to be investing more money into our staff for more of trading so thank you okay thank you is this I got a question okay uh what does the investment in SFA look like if we can if we kept it that last year versus going into a new curriculum do we know that with the new figures that we got are you talking about the total for the curriculum or all

099of it last year what's year the year that we're talking are you referring to the lower price given the email that you received yeah so I'm referring to I guess the total cost and of SFA like for just the curriculum piece and whatever else we needed to execute year three as opposed to one of the Alternatives that you guys are good question um what I would say first of all uh about the uh what seemed to me as a a attempted to appear as a discounted rate uh that SFA offered for the third year knowing that we were having budgetary issues which I greatly appreciate it however our team didn't consider that option because it wasn't a discount it was a reduction in Services which included essentially getting rid of some of the very best

100Arts of SFA which is having coaches here on site helping our staff um that's a that's an amazing part of the system which we we benefited from um but you know the idea that I would you know go to the car dealership and look at buying a new car and you know finding one that I really like for 30 grand that has all the things that I want and then but I tell them I can't afford 30 grand I need I can only afford for 20 grand well you know what what will happen then is that I won't get all the things that I wanted the bells and listens and so that that really wasn't something we wanted to consider because the reduction in the services that would be provided in terms of professional development

101to the staff um really is a Cornerstone of what makes this successful anyway so getting rid of that to us was was a non-starter uh that part of it okay so assuming that the staff figured it out two years into it and we're able to continue that same track that they were on how much would it cost are you saying without having the coaching yeah like if we just compared that paired back option they provided do you have that figure in front of you you looking that is that in board that thing that you're looking at there yes where's that um it's on the agenda for today1 Success contract the bottom got it and I guess I guess while you're looking that up you know I know there's a lot of talk about cost investment

102which I could appreciate you know however I I think some of these numbers are a little bit misleading because I mean were these all brand new positions that we created just for SFA yes they were so these none of these people were here we hired an extra 15 or 20 people above and beyond what we had yes we actually most of the people that are in those positions are some of our highest paid teachers in the district because they are people with experience those positions our two like two of our two of those positions are literally our two highest paid teachers so it's very expensive that piece of it right but yeah one of the things let me if I could just add on real quick and again just I totally appreciate the conversation on

103cost we have to be cognizant of that but I would like to remind everyone here that you know we spent a long time years and years teaching curriculum that wasn't viable right and we saw it wasn't working so that cost millions and millions of dollars so what I'm going to suggest uh again just giving a different point of view here uh and I'm C open to seeing how this process plays out and you know determining what's best for the district but maybe it's possible we just had the wrong structure for a long time you know because I I think you know maybe it's possible the staff that we had just didn't have the right tools uh the right training you know to be successful right so I would just like to encourage everyone here to

104keep that in mind as we go through this process and not be so quick to close the door on a program that's proven to be successful in our district produced the best results we've had since 2015 in single year growth in Reading proficiency and also math amazingly right in in almost 10 years right so part of that I believe is that there are some unique challenges that manw has with our demographic right and if you guys recall when we vetted SFA there was lengthy discussion on that right and one of the things that really appealed to me was you know looking at populations with high English language Learners economically disadvantaged uh families SFA has a track record of working really well in those communities so my point again just as we go through this process

105let's be open-minded to the possibility that maybe for years and years when we spent millions of dollars teaching curriculum that wasn't getting the job done we finally got one that showed us some really promising results in one year our staff did a great job learning a new curriculum and now we're potentially asking them to hey let's learn another one now right that's a big lift and I just want to make sure that we're all keeping that in mind so did you get the answer to your question no please I I don't I don't have number for you like right off the top of my head well I think we need to know that number if we're going to vote on this well I I think that we've given a lot we've given a lot of

106information and I feel like the last thing that we sent out like if you want me to get a number I'll just need a little time to put like an actual number to it but the one point I want to make that continues to not be part of the discussion that I think is one of the biggest things for me is that we are purchasing a very expensive product and we are looking at having to it's a 90 minute reading program and next year and for the rest of this year we are taking out 30 minutes of that 90 minutes to add in things that don't exist so that our students can because this stuff with X20 and the science of reading and you the prps that all of these kids are on we have

107to now bring in additional curriculum so we're taking out of this thing that we're buying and we're saying this is the product that we have we are removing time from that product and next year we'll have to do even more of that and so to continue with something and paying this price that we're paying and then having to supplement of that 90 minutes which means taking out part of it so what part do you take out do we decide that as a whole school district or is that school by school so I just think that what's hard about this is it's it's it's a multi-layered issue there's the financial piece um there's the burden on the teachers to have to learn a new curriculum but no matter what they're going to have to learn some

108new stuff because we now have a program that has holes that we have to fill we we recently heard a number that our kindergarten students um are 75% proficient at the same time I have 76% of our kindergarteners have a personal reading plan so that's contradictory data and those are all of the things that make this complicated so I just think there's a lot more to it than even just the budget um the complication of a product that we can't use whole product we have to modify the product that we're paying a lot of money for so I just think there's there's a lot to this at the end of the day it costs more to do SFA for sure there's no doubt about it I think it's important to remember too that we're when

109SFA is sharing the internal data it's compare its internal its internal curriculum data so when we look at it compared to as web which is our mandatory screener we look at it compared to fast fridge and we look at it to compared to forward exam there's much more modest growth when we're looking at it compared to our state and nationally normed assessments so we have to be careful about just relying on that internal curriculum data and make sure that we're taking a full picture of when those numbers are shared to Heidi's point to vot kindergarteners internally SFA saw growth for 76% of students but when we're looking at our state screener we're not we don't have that we don't have that number we have 57% of our students grades K through three have to have

110a personal ized reading plan so when we have to compare toward on those Norms we're having very different more much more modest growth than when we're just looking at the SOP and Mr Shaw yeah thank you very patient um no problem thanks to thanks to Mr null I had a opportunity to spend six months at Washington Middle School last year than did sound all sincerity a tremendous opportunity but um I think that I I have to share a conversation that I had with two of the national Reps for half hour to 40 minutes the national reps that had Wisconsin as your territory from SFA and that conversation was extremely detailed and these two these two wonderful women shared with me they said we're surprised we're here because SFA does not do well in states where

111your n or your state test is based on common course standards Wisconsin's state um test is based on common core standards SFA does well in States and they really show gains Kansas Ohio wherever they were North Dakota that states are not aligned with common for standards so we talked about that a little bit and I talked about the these these percentages that I kept seeing all over the Billboards we've raised our scores 12% 15% 14% she said you need to be very careful with that she said they are Level tests yes when SFA tests they test at a level if a student does not do well on that level test they get a chance to correct it the scores that go into Infinite Campus that all these old we went up 10 15 20% were

112all based on corrected scores I'm an advocate of that as a teaching tool I think it's a tremendous teaching tool and I wrote a memo to Mr fil and asked him to be to be honest when reporting these scores saying that there's two scores here the beginning score and the corrected score I think the public needs to hear that the beginning score of the program is different than the recorded score that is collected for data I asked him to report those two scores it did not happen again his choice but I also think that that we need to State we're we're a district that wants kids to come to us but we're a district that doesn't have a state recognized reading program we say give us give come back to manat we have a superintendent

113that's sending out many many Flyers come back what can we do to attract you yet we don't have a a reading program that is on a state vouer a state list of accepted reading programs that's that's kind of ironic to me come to us we're strong academically but we don't have a state recognized reading program I I find that a little weird the other thing that the other thing that bothers me about this is when we take a look at uh this whole SFA I remember Mr file writing a letter to the state asking them it was it was pretty a pleading letter asking them to please reconsider their position on SF will you will you allow Mana to get the resources we need do the funding get get some money back on our resources

114for the K4 program and the state said no we will not reconsider and the letter was well done we all read it the the whole Community read it the state then said no again we will not sanction SFA that's a powerful tool it's a state organization master's degree phds in curriculum and instruction they regulate what is applicable for success and we're sitting here saying nope we're not going to listen to you I have difficulty with that thank you sir Mr the quick real quick please I would you suggest that we would have kept the third year contract if act 20 wouldn't be mandated and all that stuff no I I I feel I feel like probably yeah because it wouldn't it wouldn't have come up as like this it's there's too many variables that are

115making it unviable to continue down that road is what and I I I understand what and how you articulated I think was very respectful and very honest there's just too much going on right now with that mandate from act 20 and if we didn't have that act 20 I think we could have adjusted it a little bit I yes and I think ultimately I don't like that we would be spending the money on something that we're not you be able to utilize the way it's supposed to be used it seems wasteful that's on that side of it but I'm saying okay you answered my question hang on I I've been really patient okay and I I'm going to reiterate some of things that some of you have said but I want to start by saying

116two things personal experience first of all you would not believe how many people I have spoken to in the last week on the phone and in person as I go about my H Jinks in town where they say so you guys are getting rid of SFA next Tuesday and I say not really because until we have something that replaces SFA SFA is what we're doing in that way I would Echo absolutely Mr bip's concerns that you normally have a curricul before you don't have a curriculum so that you don't have a ho and honestly for me that is a concern it is a concern I expressed last Tuesday for some very strong reasons one of those reasons is because I listen I get I completely get the economies of this thing I really do but

117I also completely get the helping kids to read and if we're going to talk about efficacy having dedicated focused people in the buildings that are looking at the performance of all the kids and putting kids together in groups that put them in the classic teacher expression the zone of proximal development that's what makes it successful that doesn't mean that it's perfect I am the last person that you will find that will say 90 minutes on reading is a good idea uh I taught third grade for a decade and a half I can tell you third graders would string me up if they had to read for 90 minutes a day you know I would honestly be afraid to ask them to do that so there are ways that you vary that and there ways you

118fix it but there are things we can fix 90 minutes of the junior highs is clearly affecting both our mandatory and our optional electives that's a concern too the the these are honestly what I am about all this is nervous when you talk about materials I'm very concerned about materials because when we switched over to SFA I will tell you nobody was more heartbroken than I was to see the dumpsters going to schools where teachers left a 20-year collection of books that aligned with the to topics the interests the ideas the subjects and the approachability for their grade level in their classroom I left over 600 truly great books for all different kinds of interest that third graders pursue in my room when we switched over so much of it went in a dumpster that

119it just truly nauseates because it hadn't been approved by that program they don't need to be approved by programs they need to be approved by teachers and that's the truth all the materials we now have for SFA if we're not going to use them we have a moral responsibility to get them to somebody who will but we also ought to be checking with our facilitators and our administrators and saying hey what of this stuff can work I will not support any program that doesn't use that model of somebody who is coordinating the approach to reading across the building somebody who is working constantly to match kids and to make sure that kids are moving forward all the time could it be the reading teachers it sure could could it be our title teachers it sure

120could but I'm telling you with 550 prps right now I think they got plenty on their plate so all I'm saying is I'm really good SFA facilitators I really really good and I don't care what they cost when they're that good you spend the money on people like that and I've seen that in more than one school so and those people are now worried because they're saying what am I going to do now what I want them to do is what they're doing now they don't have to do it with SFA but for heaven's sakes let's make sure they're doing what they do best which is make sure kids get the best possible instruction for reading matching kids to teachers matching kids to interest matching kids to level okay so so it it is ultimately

121if I can just finish it it is ultimately a question of costs versus benefits if we can get the same benefits we got from SFA with another program then great the truth is regardless of how you vote today if we see three programs and we don't find any of them offer the benefits that SFA did we can vote them down and we're still going to be with it until we find something that can do what it does or better I know letter sound kindergarten needs to be fixed it can be fixed within or separate from and there are other things that need to be fixed too they can all be fixed or we can find a better program but still use all the critical things that we learn as I said last Tuesday I don't

122want to repeat myself out all the critical things we learned from SFA we can use going forward okay and I'm certainly not going to support something that doesn't do I just wanted to add on we were talking a little bit about the the discrepancy with the SFA data and some scores uh the fast bridge data that's that's nationally Norm right and I would just like to point out that looking at the data that was reported back to the board in December of 24 we saw a districtwide increase of over 9% compared to other districts across the country and the other thing I'll point out with that is that you know that includes McKinley which was negative 9 right and they weren't even using S face so I don't know how like You' probably be over

12310% is my guess if if we didn't have them in there but my point in sharing that with you guys is that it it showed growth right it's significant growth and that's nationally Norm data so if we if we just say hey we don't want to use the internal data fine and you know the forward data honestly dude these guys at DPI you know they're constantly changing their minds like who knows what they're going to do they could change it next year and we might have to change again just let you know I don't I don't even know how much I trust their data right but comparing us to other you know districts Nationwide I think is Meaningful in many ways and if if we showed you know ballpark 10% gain I I think that

124that means something right so we're on to something right here we've accomplished some good things and I think we just got to figure out how do we keep this thing moving forward and not you know just for this rush for cost savings which I agree we should look at let just not too hastily you know make a bad decision Mr SP um couple of things to comment when you're talking about trust and dpis data that's what uh Keith touched on me for was the uh the phds and the master degrees that have come up with all these things uh so that's why we trust them um although I'd like to say that those are the same people that said Lucy Caulkins was good and we all know that it's not um and then with what

125you talked on before Chris uh about wanting the facilitators when they're that good care what they cost I I I totally agree with you but then that takes away from what part of B's biggest uh um comment was before is that we're going to save $1.4 million uh with salaries uh he did say that you know we I'm sure wor half the half of them we'd be able to get them to do something else but so that would lead me to believe that the other half I'm assuming we're going to let them go or or what that is I'm not really sure but um I mean that's a cost savings portion that we were talking about before so I just wanted to make sure that yeah and and just to answer back to that I

126I recognize the fact that at the grade schools where I think these are vital that's probably about a $600,000 b so that's a third my last comment is I haven't been presented a clear plan on how we're going to get to copy SFA without paying for it I haven't been told a road map or a solution of how we're going to do that I've been told that P 20 is being mandated we have personal reading plans for students all being distributed this last week I haven't been given a clear plan how we're going to use the staff that we've invested a lot of money on that are very intelligent the probably the best in the state for reading because we've created a bunch of Highly skilled highly paid positions that are the best at teaching

127reading at our facilities and I haven't been told how we're going to utilize those people all I've been hearing about is how we're going to cut wages cut positions of people without moving forward with how we're going to utilize those great people so I can't support this at this point because it hasn't been clear to me how we're going to move forward successfully utilizing all the great things from SFA without paying for them anymore so thank you all good did you have any of the answer share spoke on yeah so there's just a couple of things and and again you know this is uh acting on the recommendation of of our team um a lot of it was hashed out around cost in act 20 and those things are are all true I do just

128want to comment of why you know in terms of the question about the cart before the horse um in our view we had to make a decision about SFA before we commit to putting the Manpower of all of our staff who again already have a lot to do uh into looking at other curriculum uh this board essentially needs to decide whether or not we are going to continue for the third year of SFA that's really what this decision is about um in terms of not having a replacement before before it's terminated um well I don't think that would be very smart you're not going to um you're not going to put something in place before you've made a decision on whether this curriculum is what we want to continue doing I think we've all talked

129about the positives and Mr fips just asked what the road map would be uh the road map would be this um we need to continue to make sure all of our schools are using the same curriculum with Fidelity no matter what curriculum that is we need to make sure all of our schools are setting student performance goals around the the results that we want uh that include curriculum measures fast Bridge measures that is nationally normed the measures that we take from our state assessment around the uh screeners that were required to use all of that data is very helpful and I would agree with Tony the forward that's going to change like the wind but if we establish our own way of measuring our students progress and success not just one way but multiple ways

130so that we can be ensured that when we have data to presentent to the board and our community that it's backed up by more than just one thing third thing is we're going to continue to collaborate as professional around the learning goals that we have for kids what we do as professionals when the kids don't learn it and what we do for the kids that already know it and helping them enrich and Advance uh those are the the very key things of SFA that we've learned from we don't need to pay SFA to do those things uh the other thing that and and is is is what I would point out we've talked about the professional development that has existed in our district as a result of SFA and that has been a positive thing

131very positive we've gotten great professional development but that professional development when we're flying folks in from all over the country comes at a very very large cost what I would tell you is right up the road at cesa7 we enter a contract with them every single year to provide services for us around professional development our contract Services work pretty simple we sign up we sign up for number of days we plan those days with them they come and they help our folks what if we were able to provide coaches in our schools that are going to come in and help all of our staff uh with the implementation of a new curriculum as well as coaching around best practic um and in terms of you know the folks who are helping us out in terms

132of our SFA folks they're phenomenal they got their jobs because they're they're the leader in our district around reading we're of course going to use them to lead reading in our district uh we would be crazy not to uh they will have a role in whatever curriculum we have I would remind you that you'll see this and and it's not all of our staff in our staff survey it indicated 48% of them are within their first two years that means we have a lot of teachers who are on some specialized licensing don't have the experience levels that some of our other teachers have uh it is a it is an absolute essential piece that we keep coaches in our district who who can support our our our brand new staff really uh in making sure

133that their tier one practices and learn helping kids learn how to read are are at their best uh we can do all that with a new curriculum and we can do all those things that SFA were really good at with a new curriculum and that's what we will do our team is dedicated and so are all of our teachers and our principles to helping our kids learn at higher levels in this district and that's evident in the scores part of it is the efficacy around believing and SFA gave us some way to believe because we got on the same page we set some goals we monitor out our progress and we achieved at higher levels in some cases we can do that with any curriculum what we really need to focus on here is a

134return on investment and at a time when we need to ask our public to help us meet the needs of our kids in terms of their facilities and other things and give input on our long-term footprint of Education in our district we also have to show them that we're going to be more fiscally responsible and in this case this is an opportunity for us to do that as well so those are the backbones of our of of of our recommendation to you this evening uh and I would say there is a road map Mr fips to make sure all those things are in place thank spot just I just want to highlight that we did have an operational referendum in the community spoke and they wanted to spend money on the correct Staffing to support

135this adjustment so that we could sustain this for the children so I mean the community already spoke that they wanted to support the cost of St St and the professional development so that they could teach kids how to read so thank you I would just like to point out unless I missed it it sounded like we don't have a a clear picture of SFA your three cost versus potentially Plan B alternative so what I was able to review today and what they sent I what what I calculated you know by eyeballing this and eyeballing that was that the total cost would still be near double of what it would cost for one year of a new curriculum at the cost of $800 and some odd, for the six years because remember it's for six years

136so you really need to divide that $800,000 out by six to get the cost of what it costs for one year of that curriculum this obviously still is above that uh correct yeah correct and that's with that's with remember a reduction in services so what we just talked about the professional development that we would in a new uh curriculum would plan to get from our cesa friends up the road for much cheaper cost than what it would cost to bring in here uh we're committed to make sure our professionals have the correct professional development to do their jobs the best they can and frankly that's why we didn't consider this this idea of a discount was because we wouldn't then get that training so what we're saying is we can get the training but it's

137going to come from a lot closer for a cheaper so it's really if I'm hearing you right it's only about $20,000 cost differential plus we get people closer for the training versus relying on remote training and then just you know the staff that's been trained to train and however you want to you know look at it and then plus all the brain damage that the staff would go through with having to learn a new curriculum so so just so you know the ca folks the only folks that would be uh that can give professional development on SFA are are from SFA no one else in Wisconsin has it they don't know how to train for it so that that necessarily isn't a fair comparison because the Green Bay folks aren't going to be coming down

138here and helping us specific with specifically with SFA they would be able to help us with tier one uh instructional practices but not actually coaching to the the Cor Lee can I ask just one question yeah is it the ACT 20 portion or what is it that makes us in such a hurry to not finish out this one last year the my answer would be it doesn't make any sense to invest in another year of something that does not follow a line with our state requirements it doesn't make any sense to me to take something that was designed to do what it's been doing in 90 minutes and then somehow now say we are only going to do 60 and expect the same results because it's designed for 90 for a reason but the bottom

139line is is if we don't have a state align curriculum What's Happening Here in that situation is SFA really just doesn't align we have to supplement for what we're what it's not doing and if we have to supplement on top of the 90 minutes we is the time for that in the day and also the somebody asked Mr phips asked a good question about these profession or these reading plans um folks we had to buy these interventions because SFA don't doesn't have them so Heidi mentioned sips and some of these other ones that we're using we had to buy those this year because SFA doesn't have interventions they have tutoring but they're not that tier three intervention that looks at the diagnostic issues of students reading and then intervene so that that's the real Crux

140for me is that we're not going to even be able to use it the way it was intended to be used and I wouldn't want to put our results at risk knowing that when I know that we can get a curriculum that other districts around here no matter which three you pick I can I can pick a neighboring District that has it and is doing well with it okay and then then the SFA pieces from it like I talked about what we would do and make sure we have in place we would continue to do we would continue to monitor the progress on each of those assessment times we would find a way to get that public to get that with the board so that they're monitoring that as well so all those things we

141can do but to me that that's what it boils down to I maybe a silly question but you know we keep talking about that 90 minutes a day and how it's going to you know go back to 60 minutes a day now because we have to supplement another half hour with the stuff well you know I I wasn't a math major but these kids are in school for more than 90 minutes day aren't they I mean isn't there there's not a half hour the rest of the day that we can't supplement our teachers who are in the audience uh would probably be happy to answer that but what I would say is this they even have a hard time finding a half an hour for science and social studies based on all the things that

142they have in their in their day today uh in fact they do quarters so it's a quarter of Science and then a quarter of social studies and a quarter of Science and and that's been that way in this District even before the 90-minute reading block I join something yes you mentioned this earlier Chris and I think it's important to highlight uh in the middle schools we're talking about like finding time right now and correct me for wrong but when SFA started the middle school schedule changed right and they lost out on a ton of electives and electives are what make kids want to go to school like I'm I'm going to school to go be in banded or to go learn SP like obviously the cores are important but that's what makes kids want to

143go to school and enjoy being there and they're important life skills too to like know how to be in family and consumer and know how to cook or like I said taking a Spanish class and learning different cultures and I know kids that had to choose between getting to do an extra jazz band and getting to take a Spanish class and they're already getting this time taken away from them that's making them want to go to school and and that's the enjoyable things and preparing them for the electives that are high school because a lot of times you're expected to take these most people take Spanish one and two three or middle school and they come into high school so can get up to Spanish 5 and earn uh college credit for you can earn

144up to 14 college credits for that but not if you don't take Spanish and middle school and we're already running short on time so I think that's one of my things that I think needs to be highlighted more we have Chris only mentioned it briefly is especially in these middle schoolers like they don't have the time to get all the things that they need I mean it's important to say and and but correct I just want to know are we going to be gaining that time back now too then we question yeah yeah absolutely we would be able to go back to the schedule that um so you'd be eliminating 90 minutes of reading and filling it with electives I guess kind of what I'm asking like no no it's just the way the schedule

145structur had to be structured at the middle school level so when they did that they had to take a block or two that was intended for electives and move it into the core right so what would would allow us to do based on the time is go back to those equal box of time to do the instruction so that would allow for us to have more opportunities for kids to choose electives at the middle the 90 minutes is for elementary right yeah it's 60 it's 60 at Middle School oh yeah they don't do 90 at Middle School current you with the schedule of the middle school is because reading has to be taught at the same time there had to be there there had to be a schedule manipulation that limited the amount of other

146elective opportunities because everybody was in Reading at the same time so that they could be leveled appropriately so where were you beginning the 90 minutes I guess what I'm saying they don't do it at the middle school now then the elementary school is the 90minut issue in act 20 remember is only grades K through three Yeah question is everybody ready okay one more question sorry yes sir uh so really what we're voting on is just to authorize you guys to cancel the contract and I guess is there some sort of time constraints that were under to cancel that contract or or does that really matter can the time constraint is that much like you've all been talking about the concern about what's next so the time constraint is we need time we need to know

147where you guys are at with this so that we can pursue our new curriculum and have that in place our goal is to um coming up next I believe um is that adding on that extra professional development day at the end of the year only for elementary because only Elementary um have to go through the intense training of a new curriculum and it is pretty much everybody in the school minus art music and F teacher so our like the entire school at the elementary will have to attend that training um so we need time to be able to say if this is if we're making this change people need time to make a good decision about what's next and we need time to um Reserve professional development and things so that we have people in

148the most s the most optimal um situation to do some learning at the end of the school year have time to go into the summer knowing what the new curriculum is have it in their hands and also have a professional development day for them in um August before school starts so it's just the idea that we need time so that's the that's the time is having time to make that next decision if that's where we're at so couldn't we not cancel the contract and you guys do your due then come back to us when you have four numbers um I'm just thinking that kind of forces our hand a little bit contract the thing about it is it just impacts it's such a huge Domino the amount of changes that we that we made to

149put SFA into place and then the amount of changes that because it's just so different from anything we've ever done as far as the T BLS and all of that Staffing is another big part of it right now we have um additional staff that um we need to look at and say it's Staffing time right now what positions do we have open so there are definitely Staffing implications that's part of this timeline as well questions okay so to the question which is to uh end the contract with success for all with the end of this school year all those in favor signify by saying I and opposed say no okay we have two who are the names fding thanks then we move on to you needed that last thing I have to report him is

150to Shi the final day school from Thursday June 12th to Wednesday June 11th so that we can have a staff development day um on June 12th at the elementary at the elementary schools the elementary this is all because we did the last vote so I just like to put in there that maybe says down here on this memo that uh Middle School ELA teachers also be given a PD day um so there's going to be some tossing around of different levels School teachers and uh you know I I move that we accept a suggestion made by Sarah that we just give the entire District that day so they can all work together so your your motion is for a PD day for everybody Thursday right second yeah okay so we have motion for a second

151to have it go across the district can we talk more about that yeah hang on I got a motion in a second we would need to know mathematically right if that's going to donk us up on instructional time I I hear yes sir that's why I'm looking at it all right we have 15 hour days of excess instructional time at the elementary level that's why those kids are so smart we have three days at the high school and I leave four days at the middle school if my memory serves me correctly okay A little tighter much tighter at at the secondary level than the El depending we do one day depends on how much still February depends on how much is snow understand school has three understand they did this they'd have two and of

152course who knows I'm just putting it out there that's that's the fact that's the situation we may have to move later I don't know but as of right now I say give it to everybody okay and I know the director wanted to share something I guess I would ask why we would give everybody that day when everybody doesn't need that day that's like a free day secondary right now and this is sorry this is a very passionate topic for me um our secondary staff are so fortunate every week every day sorry every day they have 90 minutes of PLC and prep time every day well that's not accurate okay I'm sorry what is it it's lock schedule so it's not every day okay how often is it Monday through Thursday middle school Monday Wednesday and

153Friday if they're on the A and then if it's the other way it's Tuesday it's 45 minutes for sure every day yes on average that's what it averages out to yes yes and so Middle School it is every day middle school has PLC and prep every day our elementary teachers have 45 minutes of prep every day that is all and we ask them to give up that prep time to do PLC work at least twice a week so at least twice a week our elementary teachers go without any prep or any PLC our elementary teachers are the ones who have Beed the burden of the of our El our El teachers our reading teachers they have Beed the burden of all of this like learning they are the ones who will bear the burden of

154an additional curriculum so giving our high school people and our Middle School people so at the middle school we will make sure that those people that PL will have the PD that they need and they will get that time but giving everybody a day off is like saying to our elementary people it doesn't really matter that you guys have to do more work we're all going to have the day off so that very frustrating I don't see it I don't see it like that to be honest with you it wasn't looking it wasn't asked for as a day off this is something that she was looking to collaborate work together with other teachers kids and our elementary teachers would be literally in a training the entire day and the people who aren't in the training

155have a day to do work with their colleagues so I don't really see why we're giving people a day to work with colleagues when other people are in a training I this you're all fired up right now yes while I would love an extra day off the high school already has half days that whole last week of school unless you have like an incomplete you have to stay and like we have stuff going like w if Wednesday was our last day of school seniors and some Juniors still got to stay for grad practice and I'm also afraid like that was the last day they wouldn't they would just like go so like I I think the point that is making in val even as someone who would very much enjoy that extra day off we

156already it's basically like a 2 and a half day week anyway two day not even two and a half so that's all those high school kids have it made yeah I'm not really concerned with the fact of giving the students the day off or anything like that this is specifically for the teachers and that's that's where we're going around I Really they got come back for regret I really don't for Teacher development more than anything else have okay so we have a motion in a second and the motion is please say the motion the motion is to make the PD day on the last Thursday in the calendar for everyone all instructors across the district okay so if I understand it right you you don't want that yesing yeah okay so all those you look

157puzzle so I don't want to take the vote if you have a question I understand the discussion I'm just wondering if if there's a way to say if if the reason for this is because of a new curriculum potentially for elementary okay yeah could that instead of just making it mandatory for everybody at at the high school and Junior High Level could it be if you're working on that new social studies curriculum or or if there's a reason to have that day off but that make more sense than just that way they get a day to work on it um with their colleagues and the band teaser can make their kids come in well and I'm no I you're right I randomly pick something I I don't part of the rationale that we're also just

158not thinking about is that our re our K3 teachers have to also engage in mandatory act 20 reading training which is pretty expensive throughout the summer so this this thought on Heidi's you know to speak for Heidi and for those teachers is that because they already have extensive training requirements throughout the summer this would be a g to have those curricular Tools in their hands so that leading up to that training they know what resource they're using they have they have a little bit of an advantage um whereas some of those other you know curriculum adaptions you're making a valid point but they're way less intensive than the science of reading instruction and literacy instruction roll on at the elementary level Mr small I totally agree and I and I think that we're not taking

159anything away from them they have a lot to prepare for but I also think that we're and you guys are teachers so surprising it's coming for me but you act like man I get ready for work I got to be work at 10 o'clock I have plenty of time to prepare for work teachers prepare for their day where they're weak in the weekend I'm fishing and they're already you know working on what they're going to do on Monday and Tuesday these people are spending a lot of time of their own uh preparing it's not giv them a day off I mean yes it is but I have full confidence in the staff that we have and the teachers and any one of them that I've met whether they even like me or not I know

160that their interests are for those students so if they take that time or if they don't take that time I just think it should be across the board that's all I got than anything else okay so the motion is to make the PD day Universal all those in favor signify by saying I I and oppos saying nay n good Lord that fails expose fire now do we have any other motion so the motion is that the final day of school be Thursday June 12th um no wait the final day of school from should be changed from Thursday June 12th to Wednesday June 11th and June 12th be used as a staff day for elementary elementary teachers right the final instructional day and I use our quotes because I've done the last day of school way

161too many times to believe it's an instructional day so it's mostly just holding on that um okay so we have the motion do we have a second are you seconding okay I have a second who made it who made the mo the motion was Mr Dr second was Mr Hansen any discussion okay all those in favor signify by saying I I opposed none we have been a suspension and silence is asent you usually get from me anyway having gone through all that um under remarks from the board president I actually I'm going to combine that with future meeting dates only to remind you all that tomorrow if the weather cooperates and all the bad stuff stays down in chaban there's an interesting uh safety security and concern presentation at Wilson which uh at 5:00 which

162I would encourage you to attend if you can Thursday of course is the event at the capital for the uh Awards of Distinction uh from uh the chamber and I hope to see many of you there and then we have the following Thursday we have facilities and finance and the following Tuesday after that a special board meeting with only two things on it okay now that I look for a motion to adjourn so move we have a second please signify take oos I got Tri

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.