CorpusRecord 85729

Board of Education Meeting 12/9/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / School District of New Berlin
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Waukesha County, WI
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,251 words · about 24 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001ladies and gentlemen it is now 6:15 p.m. and we uh and a quorum of members is present so the meeting of the Board of Education of the school district of New Berlin is called to order please call the role Sor Miss Crosby here Mr Helmer here miss conik here miss schul here Mr Sidle here miss Spindler here Mr zalinski here I would entertain a motion to recess to Clos session I move to adjourn into Clos session pursuant to section 19851 c andf of the Wisconsin statutes to consider a the approval of closed session minutes of nove November 25th B the employment performance and compensation matters pertaining to staff and C discuss the superintendent contract renewal second I have a motion by Miss Crosby and a second by Mr cidel please call the role Miss Crosby

002yes Mr cidal yes Mr Helmer yes Miss conik yes Miss Schulz yes Miss Spindler yes Mr salinski we're moving into closed session and we'll return to open session around 7 o'clock what e for e e for it is cold in here e e should I wait for Joe you think okay we won't make people wait any longer then all right we're going to start um it is now 7:24 and we are returning from close session into Open session in recognition of the serious and important nature of our efforts here we will join in the pledge of allegiance to the flag for all those who are able please rise stes and now for those who wish to prepare for the meeting we will have a moment of silence this is a public meeting of the Board

003of Education prior to this meeting notice was given to the public last Friday by providing the agenda to the city library the agenda was also posted on the district website a copy of the agenda was forwarded to the Journal Sentinel the Walkershaw Freeman and the Walkershaw now all of which have filed requests for all Public Notices we'll begin with privilege of the floor uh meetings with the board are conducted for the purpose of carrying on the business of the schools and therefore are not public meetings but meetings held in public this portion of the meeting is an opportunity for you to come and voice your concerns to the board so please do not be offended when we quietly listen we may even take notes we do not immediately respond to your questions and comments this

004is a time for you to talk and us to listen thank you for coming to voice your comments and concerns when I call your name please step up to the microphone address the chair and state your name whether or not you are a resident and whether or not you are a resident in the school district each presentation is to be restricted to a maximum of 3 minutes privil of the floor will be limited to 1 half hour presentations are not to be designed for purposes of engaging others in a debate in this forum discussion of certified classified or professional Personnel or of individual Board of Education members shall not be considered an appropriate topic for this forum and the speaker will be ruled out of order we have one this evening uh Meg Gardner Gardner

005all right good evening board it is a pleasure to be here tonight and address all of you my name is Meg Gardner I am a resident of New Berlin and I'm a member of the New Berlin United Athletics Foundation or nbuf I want to take a moment to introduce myself because I may have only met some of you in passing uh or Ron I believe we met uh briefly a few times years ago through my late Father Ted Weiss saki a few weeks ago Joe proposed to the board that the task force initiative should move forward via Capital campaign based on the work we completed completed through the majority of this year the task force is an agenda item tonight so I thought it would be prudent for you to have an idea of who

006you are entrusting this project to currently there are four parents who are the core of the nbuf Jason bretzman and John nut from the east side of the city and Dale Hartong and myself from the west side two Ike and two West this is on purpose as I've gotten to know my counterparts through this initiative I've noticed a number of unique characteristics that we all share all four of us have recent student athlete graduates football track and field soccer and softball we are intimately aware of the frustration of or longing for better outdoor facilities in all of those programs coupled with that we all have younger student athletes in mostly the same Sports these shared characteristics mean we have a history with the various programs and facilities and how they work at each high school

007we also clearly understand the recent past discussions and constraints but we still have kids coming up which keeps us involved and passionate about working toward much needed improvements at both Eisenhower and at West having both of these perspectives I believe is key and it's really unique that all four of us share that I will also add that we all have day jobs we've never done anything like this before but our motivation is high we are committed and passionate about making these improvements happen and we all truly care about our New Berlin schools and our new berin community don't get me wrong we know our own younger student athletes likely may not benefit from our actions but we want others coming up through our elementary schools to be able to we want to move forward bettering

008our community as a whole and give the students of New Berlin access to equal or perhaps better facilities than our neighboring communities I understand discussions about improving the after facilities at both Ike and West have taken place in the past but have never really reached this point I simply wanted the board to know that there are passionate driven motivated people in place who are committed to this effort and want to work hard to finally get it done thank you thank you I don't have anything this evening for president's message or announcements so we can move on to the administrative team report I'll defer my items to the Open Session items and we do have a video update from Claire your Eisenhower student representative evening all I hope everyone is doing well with the second quarter

009well underway students are working hard to find success in the classroom in their clubs and on the sports field as well Eisen our classrooms are full of learning and fun Spanish 5 students have begun their new unit about identity AP by biology students are set to begin a lab on cell communication in the upcoming days in the applied retail operations management classroom students have been volunteering their time during their study halls to work in the limes Den Cafe to provide a wonderful area for students to study grab a snack or grab a drink our clubs have had no short of a wonderful year so far during the holiday season I now wants to give back any way that we can so we are hosting many events in doing so this Friday Eisenhower National Honor Society

010is working with the American Red Cross to host a blood drive it is a great chance to help out those in need this season additionally National Honor Society is hosting a winter accessories and canned food drive until this Friday Middle School student union organized the holiday wish list drive that will be running until December 16th items bought off of the given wish list will be donated directly to the Ronald McDonald House most Charities of Eastern Wisconsin sdnb hosted Toys for Tots toy drive last week Eisenhower Deca had their annual fatherdaughter dance last Friday it was a successful event full of dancing pictures and more winter sports have recently begun their Seasons Varsity boy swim had a meet had an Invitational a brown deer on Saturday and varsity cheer had a competition at Indian Trail High

011School this upcoming Friday boys and girls basketball face off with new berin West at Eisenhower for a double header good luck to both the girls and boys B basketball teams and be sure to go out there and cheer before I conclude I want to wish all of the school board and all that attended this meeting a very merry Christmas and happy holidays thank you next on the agenda is the consent agenda which includes notice and the approval of the minutes of the board meeting of November 25th are there any items that should be pulled out for separate consideration do I have a motion for the consent agenda motion to approve second I have a motion by Mr cidel and second by Mr Helmer to approve the consent agenda as presented any discussion and hearing none

012all those in favor raise your right hand motion passes on to the regular agenda first up on that is the Outdoor facility Task Force update I would like to introduce task force chairperson David to provide an update since the formal presentation at a previous meeting regarding our outdoor facilities task force progress thanks Joe um tonight we're just going to do a real quick recap uh this is just a followup to the last presentation late last month uh you had a few questions that we wanted to answer and kind of uh give you some ideas to uh where we think we should be going as far as next steps go um as a reminder this was kind of uh I'm not going to go through the process of what the task force did over the last

013several months but these were the task force recommendations uh that were uh that they had well we because I was the chair compiled um and then brought forward to uh superintendent Garza uh and again uh you know reiterating some of the things that Meg just talked about um you know the sdmb uh the task force uh would like the district to in conjunction with um that group uh launch a capital campaign um with a focus on Multi purpose Stadium improvements uh as well as baseball softball playing surfaces uh Capital campaign uh it's very important to that small group and and to us as well uh that um we address facilities at at both campuses uh rather than uh utilizing shared facilities um again the survey we talked a little bit about this last time the

014survey results yielded uh you know a fair amount of optimism about what could be fundraised um but they uh we didn't really feel like the task force was in a position to make a recommendation as to exactly how much should be fundraised at that time and as we talked about we should be continue to work with this uh this group the nbuf um because they are very passionate and these are the type of people that we would need to um make uh any campaign a success uh in turn superintendent Garza um brought forward to you uh his recommendations which were to accept the task force recommendations and to continue to work with the nbuf um as well as providing resources uh skills skills time financial support uh to any type of campaign that um uh

015we would launch uh with board approval at some point um and then uh as a reminder um currently in our longrange facility plan we do have about approximately $2 million uh allotted for uh replacement of the tracks at uh each school um so that's already kind of uh baked into the project as far is um taking that number off the top um and I'll get to numbers in a second so you can see that more clearly um but we also uh the the task force was very um had mentioned several times that the dollar amount that we were talking about fundraising was very very high um so if there was any more support that the school board or School District could uh um contribute or or commit toward the project uh it would it would

016it would make for a more successful campaign we did we did briefly talk about considering hiring a consultant to lead the campaign I know we had a lot of questions about that and I will get to that as well uh couple slides from now these are I'm going to show you some estimated costs that some of you may have seen uh I think some of the task force members may have seen this already um these were provided by point of Beginnings which was the company or the consultant that we have been talking with um but I I do want to caution you and remind you that these are um 20122 2023 so um they're they're not 100% accurate at this time because of you know it's been almost two years since well it'll be almost

017two years since we got these numbers so um let me just point out what we're looking at here uh on the very far left is the projects and those projects include Eisenhower Stadium turf and track and by track I want to reiterate that's just not the track that goes around it's all the ancillary pieces of track as well so the the shot put the discus the throws the jumps and all those pieces as well so when I say track it's not just um just the the running track um West Stadium same thing Turf and track Eisenhower baseball softball infields only uh or Eisenhower baseball softball full Fields there is very uh vast cost difference between those two uh similar for West baseball and softball infields only and full Fields lights at four ball diamonds which

018was something that we asked uh point of Beginnings to add in there because we talked about this very early on that um adding lights to those fields would increase uh the amount of usage that we could you know use those and and maximize the usage of those fields um in that second column um that total at the bottom is when you look at just the infield um so it's the two stadiums the tracks but also baseball softball INF Fields only so you um adding that $2 million for lighting you get a subtotal of a just over $10 million the district has already committed $2 million in tracks so we're looking at about 8.14 million to do all of those facilities the third column that's just adding uh instead of just infield only that is the

019the full the full field at the full Diamond baseball and softball at both schools as you can see like I mentioned there is quite quite a a cost difference between those two um on the very far right you do there are some notes in there um uh we talked about the grand stands a little bit uh being a I wouldn't say a point of contention but it is a it's a added cost that not everyone on the task force was uh in favor of pursuing um similarly I just I just put West also does not include Grand stands although that wasn't part of the conversation throughout the task force process um that that piece about the amended soils um that's uh just something we haven't cost it out yet because that wasn't part of the

020conversation so we don't really have a total necessarily for that um but uh what would happen uh if we went that infield rout uh just the turf infield route um we would need to do some work in the Outfield um and that would require some amended soils to improve the drainage and and fix some of the problems that we have at both at both sites especially when it comes to baseball we don't have that same issue necessarily with softball but the baseball fields uh both have some some drainage issues in the Outfield and amend so I would would help fix that so there is a little bit of a cost for that or I wouldn't say little bit I I won't even guess as to how much but there is a cost associated with amended

021soils um I did put a note there uh you know if you removed or deferred uh the cost for the lighting that would obviously be $2 million less and I'll show you what that looks like and then finally I did mention again um we have accounted for $2 million when it comes to the tracks so what does that all kind of look like I know this I think uh Matt you asked this question how does this kind of look what is it what's the breakdown um I'm going to walk through that a little bit um just to give you an idea of what what total dollars amount needed would need to be fundraised or possibly needed to be fundraised this is the stadiums tracks and infields only um again that's the lesser of the two

022numbers still over $10 million again I want to remind you 2023 early 2023 too um take out the 2 million allotted for tracks you're at just over eight uh someone on the board last time uh mentioned a possible fundraising match of of a million dollar maybe it was $2 million I can't remember exactly what was said but uh this would just give again give you an idea if the if the district brought another million dollars to the table uh the the total cost would would you obviously be reduced by a million dollars and we're looking at around seven um if you took the lighting out of the project again now we're looking at maybe F just over $5 million similarly uh with the full Fields uh that 13 uh just over 13 and a quarter

023um the 2 million that we've already allotted if there was a fundraising match of some sort um you're down to 10.3 and again this is just if you were to remove the lighting I'm not advocating for removing the lighting that's not a decision that we've really talked about yet but it's just a um as far as trying to get that fundraising dollar um down um that would be a way to to do that um as far any questions I shouldn't have well let me get through and then I'll ask for questions I'm sorry um I know I buzzed through that a little fast uh as far as the next steps go um we are actually meeting with the nbuf again uh this week on Wednesday um at that time we are actually bringing in uh

024because they had several of the same questions that you had regarding what a consultant could or would do um so we're actually bringing a um a fundraising consultant into that meeting and he's going to share information about uh what a feasibility study actually is what a wealth screening actually is the process for those two steps steps and then how um someone uh either some type of consultant could um manage a capital campaign as far as the school board's next steps um you know there's still the question of whether or not we want to move forward with this and I know I know there were some questions about the cost and that so that's why we brought that to you um there is the question about how much total funding um could the district commit to

025this project at this time or in the future and then uh again I know you still may have questions I do believe Ron you are attending the meeting on Wednesday so you'll get Ron's going to kind of get the uh idea of what the consultant could do um so we wanted to make sure that the board uh got some of that information at the same time so that so that there was an understanding of exactly what a consultant would do on this type of project um that was pretty fast so I'm uh open to questions or anything else and I'm sure Joe Pat and I can answer anything you have for us as of right now everything's kind of an all or nothing so it's all this is packed into here have you guys looked

026at doing just the football fields and the track as a capital campaign for the next say one or two years and then look at doing the softball fields and baseball fields as a separate piece yeah we have talked about a phase a phased approach um and again that kind of is dependent on some of that may be determined as far as uh if we do the feasibility study and the well screening if if the if the results are great and the the dollar amounts are are out there um there may not be a need to wait to phase the two um but that's at this point we don't know what what kind of fundraising capability this community has so are we paying for that feasibility study in wealth screening we have well at some point

027someone would have to we have not yet they're just going to present on what that would look like and yep just coming in to tell us about what that is so yeah there is no current cost to the district at all I was under the impression that we did something similar to this with the foundation before Julie was involved in it and I think that's kind of why we were told six years ago I think it was that that didn't take off because they were doing all this groundwork stuff and my concern with these is there's a lot of groundwork and then we don't actually see where the rubber hits the road for a year or two with that was anything done with that do you guys remember I don't I don't know if it

028was actually a well study or screening I believe there was a uh it was a database that they were building or something with that with alumni and other community members that's something different um alumni Nation I think is what you may be thinking about that was you're right we were trying to collect data for an alumni database and um the records that we had for our throughout our district just weren't good uh wasn't the greatest data so we weren't able to compile what we wanted to that may be what you're referring to I'm not sure but it was around the same time as uh when the foundation was getting going so it would have been all interconnected but I I think that might be what you're might you're referring to I mean in summary I

029I think think you have my support to move forward with a you know cutting this project in half to start with I don't love the idea of the consultant I just I think we're going to spend more money than we're really going to bring in from there not completely opposed to it but I don't love it off first sight but I'm definitely in support of starting some sort of capital funding and I think the board could would be willing to match some of it I don't know what the dollar amount is and what the rest of the board would agree to but than uh well at this time we weren't anticipating anything from the foundation um yeah they they would be um helping out in a in a supportive role um but I don't I

030mean at this time I think we talked about this a little bit last uh last meeting um with the amount of different projects that they are working on for them to take on the capital and I say they it's Julie uh for Julie to take on a capital campaign all those other projects would would fall off and I think that'd be a detriment to our our district especially the students and the staff that are impacted by those grants and scholarships um that's part of what this conversation is um I mean if you looked at the if you look at 10 million um if if we were to take out that lighting and then or now it's down to8 million so we're looking at a three or $4 million if the district were to move that

031to two that's about a half district and a half fundraising so um I don't think there is a precise and again that may be something that a consultant would tell us differently um that um it should be uh what a consultant will probably tell us is that there's a certain dollar amount of gifts that you need to um collect um it's like a it's a gift pyramid um and that would kind of break down how that would look but um there is no third uh element right now as far as yes that can thing yeah would the consultant um be how would that be paid for because it sounds like the foundation could benefit from that as well would that could that be something split between the two or is this coming out of community

032funding what fund is it that's something that we're still looking yet only because we didn't want to get too far ahead of ourselves that's why we're going to have Ron at the meeting with us we also don't know what the uh the the community group but they're uh you know they haven't heard this yet either so what we're meeting on Wednesday to determine is this something that we really should be investing in or not uh and then and if so uh yes we've talked internally about seeing if we could work with the foundation because they would benefit from some of it uh you know like the wealth screening um and the feasibility piece uh and then we would figure out a way like if it was you know possibly a fund to 80 uh approach

033um which again wouldn't be out of the general fund uh but that's something that we would again we didn't want to get too far ahead of ourselves on on that aspect because we're just not sure we're moving in that direction at this time a lot of times J to answer your question um a lot of times those numbers are just the the consultant fees are just added into what that total dollar amount ends up being so if it's a a $5 million ask from the fundraising and then I'm just throwing out I me another $100,000 for a consultant or two then you rate then you have to raise 5.2 million so you're you're throwing the consultant cost then into the you can unless yes and the the opposite would be again there's a way that

034the the district paid for it or supported or if there was a split cost or um yeah split cost between the foundation and the district I do share Mitch's concerns about paying for a consultant so I guess I'm not full on board with that but um I understand what you're doing adding to that I think the number one thing we myself would like to see out of that is what is the cost for the consulting fee what are they guaranteeing how much are they asking for up front how much of that is paid on the back end so I mean if it's more of a they want a quarter million dollars with no guarantees and we got to pay it up front it's obviously a lot less advantageous than it comes out of the back

035end after they raiseed $5 million yeah and I and I think Ron will get a lot of those answers on Wednesday and I hope he asked similar questions to not to put the not to put the pressure on Ron but you know no note note taken uh we will ask those specific questions on Wednesday yeah yep anything else I had one more question on the lights there was maybe I'm mixing the two but we talked about lights going on the track or on the football field for the ancillary Fields there is this the lights or is these lights just for the two softball two baseball field yeah I'm sorry if I for the confusion yes the this would just be baseball softball uh lighting the lighting that we had talked about uh previously is that

036if there was some work done to the Eisenhower Grand stands um there could be lighting added to that east side of the grand stand which would then light those um those ancillary fields or practice fields yeah okay and then that is not included in anything that I showed you today one more question too I was always under I was always told that West baseball fields flood so bad that there's like standing water out there are we really do we really feel that this solution is actually going to fix that or are we putting a bandaid on that that's my bigger concern is that we'd actually solve the problem well I don't want to I don't want to speak wrongly but I know there are some drainage issues there for sure um but I do believe

037that that coupled with fixing the drainage problem um that coupled with either turfing the entire field or the amended soil um would be a solution it would it would be a solution Pat maybe you can speak more to that I don't know if I'm misspoke but I think yeah um if you're putting Turf in you're obviously going to have to have a drainage system out there that would take care of that issue um amended soils uh they would essentially be taking like I'm just going to say like a foot or foot and a half out of that soil and they would be putting in a mixed soil that drains really well um and then there would also be the drainage that would be in that so the biggest issue was West uh the west baseball

038field used to be in a flood plane and the flood plane the flood plane delineation was changed I believe two years ago and so now we don't have to worry about that anything else all right thank you thanks so we will continue to move forward with our efforts and we'll keep the board posted uh we'll likely have another update at one of the board meetings in January okay uh then we have approved the change to the 2025 2026 calendar so based on feedback that we've received from staff as part of a staff survey um and based on the fact that we have instructional minutes cooked into the calendar uh we would like to propose an additional staff inservice day or a work day on March 13 um we also have uh some uh our administrative

039team and school leadership teams are going to be uh moving forward with uh the sale Academy training and this would allow us to uh have that that meeting during that time but uh again uh the main reason is based on staff feedback do a motion um I move to um amend the 2025 20 a school calendar second I have a motion by Miss Crosby and second by Mr hmer uh to approve the amending of the 2025 2026 calendar do I have any discussion I just wanted to know is that date significant is it just halfway in between breaks or something uh we actually picked it because there was a really long period during the winter months yeah um and the timing of you know when exams are and when teach teachers could get the most

040bang for their Buck of a work day oh I have a question actually not related to that when did we move to the whole week off for Thanksgiving did we discuss that I don't remember that being the I I don't know that meeting it was the last time we spoke about a calendar last January okay is that just because we had a it's just the way that it worked out okay yeah are we planning on sticking with that schedule going forward or is it depends on how the calendars work out falls out okay yeah it's it's not always going to work out that way I don't think okay thank you anything else all right then all those in favor raise your right hand motion passes uh we don't have anything from closed session future meetings

041and dates are held here in this room on the 2D and fourth Mondays beginning at 7:00 p.m. uh next meeting is not until January 13th and then we have January 27th and February 10th uh we have other events and dates December 23rd through the 31st is winter break there is no school January 1st New Year's Day no school January 17th is the end of the quarter January 20th is MLK day then there's no school um we are going to return to close session to um finish up some things do I have a motion move to adjourn into close session pursuant to section 19.8 51 C and F of the Wisconsin statues to consider a employment performance and compensation matters pertaining to staff and be discuss the superintendent contract renewal second I have a motion by

042Miss Crosby and a second by Mr Helmer uh to move in the close session please call the role Miss Crosby yes Mr hmer yes Miss conik yes Miss Schulz yes Mr cidal yes Miss Spindler yes Mr salinski well we will move into close session and we will be adjourning from Clos session thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.