001hello orial Nation we are live build sure can see this too he's had a couple taking a quick break all right you can see that now hey guys I'm back all right good to see Jacob awesome we're just Steve will be right back too I'm g go grab Maria and be right for [Music] right is that where you're I live between Slinger and West Ben but yeah there so it's 41 minutes it's pretty good okay that's we didn't Dr go too far not actually the the board meeting I was supposed to go was Monroe tonight so traded Monroe guys that live in Madison took that one yeah' be happy to all right how are you yes we're going to get started and we all jump in as we go long here we're live we're good
002to go we are live yep all right we are back in Open Session uh to go on to you Dr Matt and talk through your superintend report all right so we're fortunate to have a member of the school of perceptions here today Bill Foster is going to be sharing uh some the survey data that we released to our community uh prior to the break or the holiday break that is and he's going to walk through a summary of that with yall and be here to be able to answer questions so Bill it's all well thanks for having me back again yeah welcome back by the way um and I love your facilities by the way last time I was here wasn't this pretty my job tonight to take you through the results of your community
003survey you want to be the clicker I will be the clicker unless you want to do it I mean I can go right down just see here I'm gonna move Jacob up Jacob can you see the survey yeah okay okay great um so the report is organized really in three primary section the background information is actually the stuff that was in the survey so as a board member if you scratch your head month from now and say what did that survey actually say that information is included in the report that's important that creates context for the responses we're going to look at the demographic information and slice and dice and make sense of the results so start with a school perceptions commercial the fact that we've done this before we've been around for almost 25
004years and we've done over a thousand projects like this one for the the sake of both strategic planning and referendum preparation so your survey went out just before the holidays we had a deadline of December 20th we had 865 respondents actually we're getting a few surveys still trickling in but uh which raises a question is that good um so we look back in 2022 we had 643 in 2016 we had 595 with North vac so uh for whatever reason the holidays didn't scare people off they took the survey which was great which gave us a response rate of 21% which is better than average and from a statistical standpoint we're at plus plus or minus just under 3.5% so keep that in mind um when I look at this slide if I had good good
005Vision I would uh look at the make sure that our seniors are well represented which they are um so they're um up over I think it was like about 33% and then the second grouping was really our parents in that 35 to 44 there you go so that's kind of a breakdown that younger folks don't tend to take surveys but they also tend to tend not to vote so we want to make sure our seniors are well represented which they are okay um and that one that slide didn't show up whatever reason yeah um we get is this a apple thing or is this I don't know I if it's I don't know it's conversion from it's just a PDF from your upload so okay yeah um let me uh let me see if there
006are the other ones good or let check we got a couple that are going that's not work n let me try to find is that the PDF or is that the PowerPoint uh it's the PDF that was shared so yeah I can go into my email and try to check it out hold on did and I do have it on a jump drive too if you don't find it that might work just as well got it right now I can probably go right with it let's go that way yeah that works hopefully oh that's going to be on this [Music] one USB [Music] file usually they have something there not that SME AIO be let a file directory of some sort yeah usually it pops up like a scan settings folder document try this same
007thing do this to send it to my other stuff we'll get here or I could plug M I'll work that sorry everybody problem okay let's try this again this generally kind of slow I plug mine into yeah let's just see if I I just sent my email back and maybe it'll just try to go over the top of works here because it's just a slower clever touch that we have in the district but there we go here we go I can try this make sure got everything yeah Jacob I'm I don't know if I'll be able to like share this just because you might just have to listen a little bit but that's okay it Y no problem um try to make this a little bigger too can there you go there we go okay
008we're business all right so age okay so we're at 26% for our seniors and 27% for our parents which is good there we go all right is your primary residents in the district we had 76% of our sample that said yes 23% that said no % that didn't know exactly where they live which is always kind of funny um but uh which raises the question who are these 23% of these folks that are taking our survey that don't live here there's really three groups one is uh staff so there's some staff that work here that drive in each day um there's some parents that are choosing to open roll into the district maybe from a neighboring District um or Andor somebody that owns a nice home on the lake um in all three cases but
009they don't live there as is our primary all three cases they can't vote so we removed non-residents from the funding support question they took the survey but I can't help us or they can't hurt us depending on which side of you're on so that's why we asked that question we did representation from all five municipalities about um over half was the village of North fondaco friendship was 22% we had just a few folks out in lamartine lamartine and Dorado um we had 19% of our sample were staff and 41% were in parents that's going to become important in just a second I'll explain why and we had one question on overall satisfaction this is a question we use on just about every Community survey we do on a scale of 010 How likely would you
010be to recommend the district to a friend or family member North vondy scored a 7.59 on that compar comparison looking out at similar school districts was a 7.18 our software goes out says okay you landed in the 69th percentile so much better than average and that's really important because this overall satisfaction highly correlates with referendum's support if you're down here and you've got a be in your Bonnet you're not happy about something that's going on very likely you're the same people that did not support a referendum who won't support one so this is important and good news for the district good job by the board so again the information that was in the survey itself is in the report there's some background information on the fact that in November you passed a facilities referendum or
011a capital referendum and voters rejected an operational referendum so we asked how you voted here we broke it into three mutually exclusive subgroups um the dark blue is Staff the light blue are parents and the we call them the Purple People the non-parent non-staff um group um and as you can see the staff supported the last referendum net net the um a plurality of the parents supported the last referendum but the non-parent non-staff that was really the group that pulled you down 37% voted yes 48% voted no 8% preferred not to say but you maybe you can guess that maybe they they went no as well and then there were some parents that didn't vote last time um which is interesting 23% right 23% that's a chunk and then if you voted know what were
012the main reasons um number one was the tax impact was too large um second was did not feel the district needed additional funding um and by the way they could this doesn't add up to 100% you could pick them all if you wanted to but um about a third of the respondents were not clear the money would be spent in tax increases from other entities such as my you know my uh the city tax went up or something like that and then 18% said I will never ever ever support this type of referendum there's only one ever in there but get the point um and then we broke that down into the two groups we took staff out because there's only like two staff or something like that um really the same same data with
013the one anomaly or exception is parents were less clear on how the money would be spent Maybe they're more interested maybe they want more detail so then we get to the budget challenges this is kind of that the problems didn't go away um we came back and we developed a plan or to uh um for a a a different amount of money we did explain that we have made some cuts and if people or if taxpayers do not support anything we'll have to make more Cuts what should we do um these are all residents um and there's really not a a lot of difference here delay up updates the technology 36% delay updates the classroom materials at 34% um there's nothing here north of 50% so people are generally convinced you've looked under Mo most
014rocks um but there's not a lot you can do but we wanted to explain to people that there would be some consequences to not supporting a referendum this gives the board maybe some data but not a lot to work on and we also broke that down um by group if additional Cuts were needed this jumps around a little bit um the ones that pop out really our staff reducing transportation and uh delaying updates in classroom materials um this is actually sorted by the non-parent non-staff their number one is reduce Athletics and extracurricular activities but I think even if you did that you eliminated them completely you would save $50,000 a year or something like that you're not going to close a million dollar budget deficit by doing just that um so you can kind of
015see the data break broke down by subgroups so then we we needed a permission slip um so this is would you support the district pursuing another operational referendum and we did we got a majority at 50% of the folks who said okay try it again um 28% said no and 22% were undecided and the breakdown of that again staff was more highly supported parents were well on board the Purple People the non-parent non-staff were kind of split um they're the most important though because they represent the majority of your voters so most folks um don't work in the district nor have kids in the district so the the purple's pretty important so then we proposed a new plan explain what we would do how the money would be spent and then the next slide is
016what the corresponding tax impact would be for that plan and U 2.5 million going to 2.7 then 2.9 then 3.2 so the term I believe went from five years to four years and then the corresponding uh uh projected property tax mill rate was was shared and then the the change over the previous year so then the most important question in the survey would you support such a plan again we broke it into these three subgroups the staff um came in at 79% support with 21% saying no parents were at 63% yes with 15 15% no here I'd point out the one thing that's a little bit of a anomaly is that we're at 22% undecided so when we do a survey we're normally at 10% or less so for some reason parents still are missing
017some information on exactly what what you're going to do how you're going to spend the money we saw that earlier in the report earlier in this in in the data and now the most important group is the non-parent non-staff the purple people again the representing the majority of the voters they landed at 35% yes 40% no with 15% undecided so to kind of help you analyze that we made some assumptions so we assume that about 80% of your community fall into that non-parent non group and about 20% have kids in the district so we base that on the 2020 census there's some data out there it might not be perfect but it's a pretty good assumption with that assumption we created a weighted average analysis so basically we took the 20% the parents they said
018we're they're supported at 63% but 80% of the community fell into that 35% support so if the election were held today we would predict that you'd probably end up at about 41% maybe a bit better because you're going to pick up some undecided but you're not quite to that 50% so we asked ourselves the rhetorical question what did we learn by doing the survey well we learned a majority or 50% of respondents support the district pursuing another operational referendum however the plan tested the proposed plan um was below 50% at just under 40 40.6 41% um again if that were held today it probably would not pass it's probably you go back a slight y that confuses me because we were asking for more money and for more years we only lost by 80 votes
019so I mean it was 50.5 to 49.5 so this makes it worse yeah which I'm confused by yeah I think one one Dynamic that happens is after it fails um you know what do people do they talk about why it lost so some people that maybe didn't vote didn't know before are less likely to support or need more information before they're going to jump in the one thing that will help this is the undecided because we didn't count any undecided um into into this calculation but it it's not um it is what it is statistically and like other things with those undecided what does that what does it pan out to be usually I mean yeah it's a great question so we have a research director that went back five years ago we used to
020break about um better than a third of the undecided break yes and no and then each year um we've lost some so in in this last uh cycle we're down under 10% of our undecided breaking towards yes so we used to say it was the way that nice people would say no they didn't want to say no on the survey so they'd say I'm undecided but when it came to voting um but still someone would break so it's we're losing more year-over-year and I think people are just getting well they're getting less supportive for whatever reason um but uh hey could could I ask a clarifying question too just kind of to piggy back on uh Rick's question so in your analysis are you're when you say that we're at like 41% that's assuming everyone
021that can vote will vote right um yes and so when we looked at even the the last vote you know like you don't have a perfect turnout so maybe that's where some of the the fallof comes into play right that's a good point so the highest turnout is always the presidential every four years that's going to be your highest turnout and a you know an April referendum is going to be relatively low however um you gota you know the people who do turn out they're the ones who really care either really for it or really against it so it is a different sampling um but we have learned over the years more than 20 years of doing this the data is fairly predictive we're about 94% predictive on on matching up the data with the
022actual outcome so it's pretty darn good um but it is it is going to be a different group um that voted in the spring versus the uh the fall so your your point is the percentages should be pretty good uh but the raw numbers might be different I'd say that's true okay thank you um so what I guess what do we do um you know you could go for it and say we just don't do the numbers but I I I I I I'm pretty confident that numbers are good I think you do have some work to do on educating and communicating um that's that's a anomaly based on your data and you might have you know a good chance of moving some of those people into supporting once they understand the real need and
023how the money would be spent um but that being said um this is really a how much is it going to cost me question and as that cost goes down support will likely go up um only once in our lives have we seen support go up as the cost went up um which is very strange but generally this is very very true and uh really I guess the first question is should we do anything in April I would say yes I think you should um I think there's some confusion out there um but do you go out with the plan as tested I would say probably not I think you uh I think people want to know we've sharpened our pencils we've looked under every Rock and we've come up with a you know we're
024going to have to make some Cuts or something um you know it's not going to be perfect but we we're asking for the voters to consider this a a slightly smaller referendum and if we don't have data to say the tax point is this or that we didn't ask that question in the survey but it's going to be a little bit lower than what was tested in the survey um there are a couple you know I think one one thing you can modulate or change and mik can talk about this as a term and you did go from five to four um the is just dollar amount and then where where you asked for it well uh last time with the cap our survey was just over 20 I think 21 or 22 and you
025advise if we got down below 20 that it might work better or would work better and so we went with 18 roughly million is there some number in here that might if you want to scroll up to the so what we're really talking up yeah where you want me go up to go up to the plan um it's really and by the way I've never taken a class in Psychology I'm an engineer by training so don't listen to me but um we're really talking about psychological thresholds so in the case of the capital project um 19 sounds better than 22 um that's one psychological threshold the other is um the total amount you know here you're really at 2.5 up to 3.2 and then the other psychological threshold is probably the tax increase and one
026thing we've learned over the years is if it goes over a buck which represents $100 per 100,000 that's kind of a a Tipping Point as well so you really only have one year where it's it's more than that but that could be a a point where people tipped and went from from yes to no questions on that um one about your experience with a second you know coming back right away with another one is it tended to work um I don't each place is if you if you go back and ask for the exact same thing my experiences it doesn't work um now what we propose is not what you ask for right um but it's it's it's hard and I think what it is is I think what happens is after it fails you
027know the articles in the paper maybe quote people that didn't supported versus those that did so you get a little bit of a negative story going on that you have to combat um so it's not easy Mike do you have a experience on I would agree that asking the same thing or very similar thing is not overall successful unless there was some unique event that caused you know that maybe shows it in a different light um and then the other big thing is you are going from a November you have a larger turnout and they typically tend to be more successful to an April where you'll probably see 50 60 maybe even a 70% drop in the voter turnout depending on what else you might have local on the ballot um so the the group
028that's going to determine success or not uh is is smaller and understanding who that is um we have just to piggy back up what Tim or Bill said this um a greater we're seeing a need for greater level of communication effort more diverse communication effort uh for districts you know there are some districts and Bill czs where you can kind of ask almost anything andri go you get thumbs up and there's other districts who who struggle over some very basic things so um so that you know maybe more targeted more in depth more frequent uh communication effort um I would I would imagine be a big part of an an April effort if that's what you choose to do any other questions for Bill I guess I'm not sure it's the best answer or there
029is an answer um it's obvious Communications an issue for us so how much now that we've lost the first one how how specific do you get about the consequences of not passing the second one you get back because you're negative or yeah there's a line um and some people say well you're threatening us we don't like to be threatened we're really going to react negatively to that but there are consequences there's not a rich uncle that we can call to make it all good um so there really are cuts that are going to need to be made um well that's what scares me is when you looked at where they ranked the things they they want least cut yeah are the things that are going to be most cut right and I don't think they
030understand that and it's you don't want them to understand it after the vote I mean I I don't know how to walk that line yeah and I I think you have to it's really delicate and I've seen districts go as far as approving the cuts that will be made if the referendum fails they really we're not kidding Cuts you know these are really all going to happen and we we've approved them as a board prior to the ref I've seen that I don't think you're in that situation I think I think you got a pretty good district and I I in pretty high levels of satisfaction but you do need to clearly communicate the need what you've done what you've cut and what you're proposing and how it's different um and strike that balance without
031going over the edge of we're not going to have a football team next year you know or something like that and I think the other thing that's important for people um is to understand this isn't unique to you you're not the only one doing this it's it's everywhere we have a map all the districts ask operating questions and there's very few that are not colored colored in and it gets smaller every year so you know explaining that and then the other thing you're going to have kind of going on at the same time you're communicating your referendum is um the state budget's going to be discussed so in February the governor's budget is going to come out and say I plan on giving all the school districts all this money well people may you know
032not understand that's just First Step June is a long way June July hopefully not August is a long ways off what's really going to happen what's the district going to experience and if you do get dollars beyond what you're using for your assumptions what are you going to do and we've had those some of those conversations about and districts the L re re limit see they went to 11,000 District's passed operating referendums the majority of them didn't use their full Authority because they got more money from the state than they anticipated so there's going to be a lot of things going on um simultaneously is your your effort and you won't have answers on the state budget until few months after the election I have seen districts in that situation and say if if the
033state does come through and exceeds our estimates we will commit to under leving that amount um just to eliminate that is a concern and that I think that's fair and reasonable yeah and we've talked about that too in our messaging and our communication when in the fall as well and maybe continuing that messaging of up to 1.9 million up to two million to kind of stress that that's the most we would ask in that year y but it's just permission gives you the authority to L it down doesn't re require you to um most districts use typically use the full amount I don't want but um but because of some things happening in state budget years we have seen some districts react to that and with the understanding that it's likely if you're successful with
034this effort if you choose to move forward you're going to be back in four years so building up that credibility with the community important this is not a one andone type of a thing this is a forever thing even districts have asked recurring questions ultimately come back again a lot of them yeah I think it's important like when I think of our district we had we had one passing operational referendum in 2022 but that was with a capital referendum and this community has only done cap that was the first time ever that we had language around operational referendum and now this is a standalone like there's no Capital referendum so I think we've got to somehow double down on how we communicate what that goes for because I still think there's confusion on because you're
035not you're not going to see it I and I I have no data to support that either but when I drove in I drove past you know a beautiful fitness center that I looked in I oh that's really looks nice then I drove over here I was like this building is and it's all done right so I think in people's mind is well we we supported you we supported you and you've got beautiful buildings now quit asking us for money and I don't know if that's true but I could imagine and where they don't understand that how this money would is being used differently than that money and I think yeah as part of your communication campaign you need to explain that um I think we have to look at communication different this time like
036I know we done the meetings and go places and have six people come visit you know what I mean like I think but I think it need people want to be met where they're at they don't want to have to be inconvenience to come to our you know what I mean so I think we've got to figure out how we meet every parent every non-parent every staff member where they're at and give them what answers they're looking for and give them space to ask questions too right so that it can be answered so I don't know another part of that districts will do is is they'll Identify some maybe some key people within the community to make sure they're educated on what's being asked because they'll have conversation with other people that you might not
037encounter in your your effort so um yeah that that is one of our plans already to you know organize not only key people within the community but also you know pival parents who can share that message too in that way and staff members too for that to make sure they they understand the need why you're asking why that amount and what is going to be used for so they can then pass that information on you know they don't necessarily need to be cheerleaders for the school district but just being well informed so that when they're communicating they're communicating accurately any other questions from bill is helpful appreciate it thank you for coming in making time to do that I know you're very very busy right now so appreciate you and uh everything that we obtained
038from the school perceptions I'm just so glad we did this uh too I think it's really important that we hear voice you know as well we didn't do this before our our last one so I think we got a little better understanding of where people are at and that helps us I think also create and design that message and how we get out as well so and make decisions on what the resolution looks like too so stepping into that area into the financial Mike you want to take a a little bit of this and talk where we're at it's all night yeah yeah definitely a Schoolboard convention so um so yeah so some of the things I was going to touch on I I've already shared um uh during Phil's presentation and um you know
039and I know that we had had conversations uh in terms of how can you make this look a little different um I know the district had gone through a process to to make some reductions and some things and um you know to kind of put itself in a position to not ask for as much in November um and we talked about the amounts we talked about the number of years you know um shortening a year um you know probably I wouldn't consider going for less than two years um but when you are short you you're right back into the referendum process which if that's what you need to do to be successful that's what you do um but it's just s sets you up for that next step and then maybe if you can build
040awareness build some comfort level with the voters maybe that next time then you can go back to maybe a four-year um something like that the numbers are dramatically lower now though yeah and that's why I don't want to touch on that too in terms of the tax rate right now the dollars you're asking for are the same as my understanding as what was surveyed you're still considering less L you be asking for Less so so on the survey was like 11 something and we're down oh we're down to 8.6 from the survey was so what [Music] amounts maybe I this is what I was working so you're asking for 1.9 first year okay I'm sorry yeah so those are down we just on the survey we put what we asked for last time okay with
041exception of removing this current year so yeah so so based on what you're asking for now the tax impacts are much less um which I think is a big step um now like compar well he took that's down but on 100,000 he had over 100 we're at for the whole four years I'm at $39 on $100,000 house for the whole four years of $39 yeah and and so that that's a big step and I I think if you you're comfortable with that because if you're asking for that for four years that's what you have to live with for four years again we touched on the fact that the state comes in with more more money than you anticipate then you are um you know make it adjustments which I think is really an important part
042of this building trust with each other um the other thing that you have to understand is that when you project a tax rate like that how people look at that tax rate in the fourth year and if it's $863 cents and they do the math today what are you using for your house value it's a $100,000 house today they're using $100,000 that house will not be $100,000 in four years that's so much not so much it might not have as big of an impact on this vote but the next referendum because they might think well I would thought it was going to be this and it turned out to be this because their home went up so there needs to be some effort to and we've seen this through the capital referendum and you've had
043some big uh valuation increases within the community and hot spots within the district in terms of efforts is that just showing a tax rate is great you know but making sure they understand what that means or making some effort to me we're going to have a lot of explaining to do because our average assessment ratio changed so much this year we kept the mill rate the same and our taxes went up a ton which it was the question I was going to ask tonight so our mill rate stayed at 8115 but everybody's taxes went up 13 14% because our average assessment ratio and the village went up 12 12% yeah because your equalized value was up about 11 so so there if you keep the same rate and you multiply it by equalized valuation 11%
044higher you're going to generate 11% more Revenue so that's where my question is so we anticipated a certain Revenue amount now this 815 which we anticipated now that got 11% higher so where does that extra money go did our state aid decrease or are we going to have that much extra this year and in our Revenue than we anticipated no you're still you're still under your Revenue limit I think you there was a little extra Levy for fund 39 um I don't know what you need did I don't I don't have that level of detail here 400,000 it went up what's that your your aid went up went down we we went down didn't we our Aid I have to look but I mean 815 brought in a lot more Revenue right had yes it
045does so where did that where that where is that Revenue well I mean your Revenue limit went up you you got the 325 student your enrollment went up um your debt service went up a little bit um actually that was fairly well your your your debt Levy was scheduled flat but the district increased that a little bit um but your Revenue limit calculation is is independent of what the levy the mill rate is I it it generates the dollar amount then you subtract your Aid and then the levy is the balance soile yes yeah I just printed out the one page um because the district's the district's revenues fund 10 revenues from 2324 to increased just under $700,000 and expenditures increase almost the same but you still ended up with a deficit again looking at
046this model output I'm not sure if there ref final numbers about 600 $41,000 for 2425 I don't know that sounds close it's pretty close the expenses went up almost to milon yeah I I don't know I would you know I'm not sure what type of salary increases Staffing increases other expend expenses you would have so I guess the question is when we did uh when we got that 86 M that was based off equalized value that was the final equalized value or what we thought it was the 815 that would be the final equalized value and we over led a little bit in fun 39 to keep it at that 815 so that 815 previous 85 is not Aid we've been overlooking no but I mean because equalized value was so different right yeah I
047mean can't compare the 815 to the previous 815 no no there's different I mean your variables are different your levels are different your Revenue limits different your valuation is different um I think we've talked about that how we've districts have kind of moved away from looking at just the the tax rate alone and looking at overall Levy and see exactly what that's going to C how that's going to translate to the individual tax bill because of the high valuation if everybody's growing at 2% or somewhere between two and 4% then the the tax rate has more validity because some of those factors aren't as significant but when you have 11% growth in some areas growing at 18% and some growing at 5% the tax rate becomes less of a uh you shouldn't use that as
048your sole thing to determine what's happening to the the tax bills um so here your a looks like it's been fairly flat see your computer here it's projected to increase a little bit so yeah so that rate increase would have translated to a levy would have been mostly would have driven a higher Levy but obviously you had the capacity between your debt service your and your Revenue limit to Levy that amount so I I would and maybe this will this way I put this together kind of kind of illustrate my I think thing I want to make you aware of is so in 2425 this is your actual your 815 your actual rate and you had an existing non recurring operating in place 24 on a on a $200,000 home that translated and this is
049equalized value I should have put that in there um but it's close to fair market it's that translated to $1,630 for that home now if the tax rate as is kind of projected with the one .9 operating referendum and the tax rate is at 8:30 that same home if it goes up 5% the taxes are 1686 even though the tax rate is falling and then as you keep going further out you once you get to the last year of of this scenario of these assumptions in 2829 if you would ask for 2.5 m ion it that same home if it increase 5% a year is up to 243,000 and it's paying $2,097 so how do most districts Market that do they Market it at $200,000 across the border that they marketed with the 5% increase
050it depends on the type of question if you were asking for $2 million a year for five years you could you could start with the 200 you can start with the $200,000 and say this is what it's going to be and then you have to factoring things if you're like a highly na district and you're G to have a Aid loss the second year maybe the your the tax levy goes up the second year but when you have a step increase that gets a little trickier so how I would communicate it so on a on a home of $200,000 today it would be increase again this is looking at your total Levy some districts will isolate the referendum amount that's what we've done I think in the past marke we were doing total okay so
051You' say that through base year 2425 a $200,000 home would have paid $1,630 next year with the new referendum amount and assuming that home value increases 5% it would be 1.67 and then so on to reflect the fact that their home values are going up because is to get to these numbers my understanding is that you have a 5% growth assumption in there makes the rate look better but you also have to reflect if you're going to get the benefit on that end what that means to the homeowner now to the point that there's new growth within the district that can help offet that two degree but you're about a billion dollars so are you going to get $20 million of New Growth to get 2% New Growth to help kind of offset that you're
052getting some growth but that's still a big number yeah I guess I I'm trying to recall I don't recall seeing the district like I did it you I've got the same number you do for the first you know for the the actual for 24 25 but then I just kept the 200,000 for all five years which is what I've seen in all those other tools right right and I think it's probably the most common way it's been done um and it's said for two reasons again if your amount is flat that's still a valid approach um it because if you don't have that increase the the amount that that $200,000 home again if you ask for $2 million for four years and it's a $200,000 home the first year and that value goes up but
053everybody else goes up the tax rate is going to drop more because you're you're you have a rising tax BCE in a fixed dollar amount and and what they pay towards that excuse me kind of disregarding Aid is going to drop because a portion of that growth is going to be new new valuation and those and that's going to divert some of the burden from them when you have an increasing amount and your it gets a little bit more complicated because your maximum tax impact is until the fourth year now the thing that this doesn't show is that home could grow at 5% and if the rest of the district r at 10% they're going to pay less I mean but I say here in the village of North which is the majority they're all
054going to stay the same right and they're all going to grow at the same not not because it's all because our assessment was just done say two or three years ago so the only thing that's going to change is that average assessment ratio that changes for everybody the same right but but everybody within the village assessment might not go up the same percentage so I think you sure once you're in the village isn't the average assessment ratio the same for everybody in the village the averages right but that doesn't mean that if if a certain part of the village those homes increase in value more than another part so their assessment in terms of how the village would would assign we had this conversation after done even within the village you had some districts whose
055assess values went up 12% and some people who went out 30% within the districts within the different municipalities but I think it was even within the village I thought some because it's like I looked at everybody's tax bills and that average assessment the same for the whole village you can go and print the report out for every year but the average assessment is the average assessment of their fair market value or equal value but if their equalized value if their their value goes up more than somebody else they can have the same assessment ratio but it means that they still could be assigned a bigger portion of the tax they sold the because we get our assessments all done at the same time but does everybody go up the same percentage and assess value not
056assessment ratio but in terms of assessed value so if you have a $100,000 house on this end of the village and $100,000 house and they both go up they're both $10 but the assessments don't the assessment doesn't change unless the village doesn't move assessment right and they're not going to do one for they just S one two or three years ago right well I mean yeah in general right if if if they don't change the assessed values then the assessment you're correct but if they would change some larger municipalities they'll assess a portion of this right you know and that's and that's the typee of thing where your assess value do message translate I guess the important thing is here you have to you have to kind of make sure you're setting reasonable expectations of
057what what that tax rate means to a home today over the fouryear period of time so so you've seen it then we instead of talking about the whole tax impact you just take what the referendum amount is both ways now you could get the same result if you just looked at the just the referendum amount you're still going to have the higher highest Levy amount in that last year and over that fouryear period of time that person's home is going to change no ours will be in the first year because we're going from 800,000 operational 1.9 so it'll be 1.1 million the first year and after that it's 300,000 additional right but the highest the highest dollar amount you're can be asking paying out if you just if you're sub segregating and say this year
058for 26 we're increasing the tax by 1.1 million MH and next year we're only increasing on by 300,000 right that that the largest increase is the first year right but the year-over-year increase but the largest dollar amount You' be asking for will be in the well won't because just look at this I'm lying here but so that it goes from 1.9 to 200 to 2 million so the second year it's only going to go up 100,000 and another 100,000 so so you're only in that say is only 100,000 right right the last year you're going to say it's 300,000 right so your largest dollar amount is the first year when it's 1.1 your L your largest increase year-over years in year one the largest dollar amount total dollar amount you're ask a given year right
059and this this this this is doing that that but you can see that in the fourth year that that Homeowner of a $200,000 home of today that's going to be their biggest bill in the fourth year it's going to be their biggest total bill total bill increase from previous year will be the minimum amount okay so would it be so I'm still I'm still lost on the 5% annual growth because if it's I get I get the why like I get why we do it but if it's if we're showing an example of 200,000 isn't that the example we're showing across I mean money I get property values go up I 100% understand that but we're just showing a number of 200,000 that as it that if I have $200,000 today I'm gonna have $200,000
060a year from now I'm have $200,000 from my value is going to go up I get that side but the ask is still $200,000 the the 200 ,000 is the value of the home I I we I've never seen that oh yeah okay yeah but you're starting to see it because other districts are running into the same problem where that's not what you told me it was going to be four years later and then we have to go back to him and ask and then I guess I'm just seeing that from that side right now I'm just throwing that out the thing is when we go back four years from now is going to go back you know pick a number two or two or 300,000 a year we're not going to be looking for
061Millions a year right I I don't think you anticipated going when you went for 800 having to go up 1.1 in one year either I don't know if that was part of the discussion but isn't that just adding another assumption we goofed up when we did that because assume 800,000 we weren't giv any inclination at that 800,000 to continue well I think that's one thing to remind people is that you know it's it is a 1.1 million increase it's not a $1.9 million increase but so what you're seeing is the districts can ask anything they don't have to put the same level of effort but if you have as as bill was explaining people who who aren't sure the tax impact's too high how are you going to use the money you have to in
062my mind give them maybe a fuller picture of what this means over time and what it means going forward Beyond this because you're in November of 28 you're going to be in this scenario you're going to be back to renew an operating question unless something drastic changes for the 29 30 School so I think it needs to be a more indepth conversation do you have to do exactly this or do you have to make sure in your point to say when you're talking to people now keep in mind that these your your home value is going to go up so when you look at these tax rates it's going to be applied potentially to a higher value home we don't know where your home values are going to go but if your home value goes
063up it's going to mean something different different so it might not be necessarily sharing this chart or this level of detail but at least in you know setting the stage and letting them know that that you just can't take your current value if your value goes up it's going to mean something different in year two it's going to mean something different in year three it's going to mean something different in year four because you're your value values will go up and you're using that in the model to R now if you're using 0% growth in the model you're be getting different tax rates then I wouldn't be so concerned about it but you can't kind of use it one area and maybe not well no but but I know you're kidding but U but these
064foreshadowing or making making sure they should consider that potential because you have no idea like I said they could go up five and if everybody goes at individual home could go up less than everybody else's and their taxes will go down there's not every scenario you can communicate but you have to raise I think a level of awareness that especially with some of the home value increases that we're seeing in some areas and still um I mean are still home still disappearing as soon as they come on the market here a little bit longer but not a whole lot you know and so over this period of time it's reasonable these home values are not going to go down you're probably not going to stay flat maybe it's 3% maybe it's 1% two but just
065so you want to reduce the number of surprises in in that people have in the future and give them you know at least a basic understanding of what that rate means relative to their home value and not to sit there and say they take their home value today and use these rates this is what's going to cost me because that home value to generate those tax rates you having those home values increase so Mike if you come at a different percent like three that's going to be a smaller ask right than the five because the five is increasing more than it is the three over the time the tax rate will be higher okay yeah the ask doesn't change it's just the yeah actual rate and so maybe that's the question I was going to
066ask is would it be simpler for us to just go in and say let's assume the tax rate and the the values are zero constant because then at least they're the same like you were saying you know like we could predict five we could predict three we could predict whatever if we just don't if we use it as zero is that just a way to articulate it so that it you can at least do the math right yeah it get a little tricky when you're using the model to generate these things so because valuation also plays a role in the state aid formula so if you if you if you put zero in your valuation growth and then you have variables that increase in your model you're gonna get a lot more Aid which will
067lower your tax levy so it's it's a very it's a difficult thing to do so you just have to try to be as precise as you can in all of the assumptions or or or make people aware of of the Poss possible outcomes or what to expect don't give don't you can't speak to this with a certain level of certainty without some qualifiers you can't make this is it you can't say this is it for the next four years this isn't it yeah you know you know the chances that exactly 803 all the variables you know it could be you know 795 it could be 880 you know um what you're really using this for is the the differences between year to year but these exact tax rates you know they're going to be different
068than what you're showing but you're just trying to get a reasonable assumption what the increase is your year over your um your forecasting yeah potential forecast um you know districts do this use the model a lot for that purpose they look at the levy and say this is you know because it is active it takes into account you know state aid some of those types of things um and again I'm not I'm not saying I'm just saying you need to set out some expectations and make sure that you're being uh you're you're touching on what this means and what it doesn't mean the other thing that we've discussed is like these are these are the numbers without the state tax credit on your property tax Cor so which is for us been running between 18
069and 20% so I think it's fair to show the numbers and say when you take the state tax credit and you lower these by 18% on what the impact you as the tax is going to be we have seen districts communicate you know the the the tax credits you know I I have not seen a use a specific dollar amount for percentage and say this will reduce that impact but I would encourage people to look at the tax bill to look at their net tax um and to to make sure that they're aware that there is a a levy credit that comes to them uh to help offset these types of impacts but you haven't seen a district use what Rick is talking about in their ask or to share there no forecasting not say
070it hasn't happened but yeah but if that's more if that's like certain like there's a a percent I I don't know what the percent is but wouldn't we want to account for that if we're going to take an assumption of 5% growth when that's not certain well if so right now that tax credit's fairly constant probably growing a bit um it's so what you'd have to do is you'd you'd have to net it out of 2425 and then you'd net it out and it' be marginally better for you going forward if that if that Trend continues but all you're doing from comparison year-over-year then is dropping the base year so that the increase in the levy would still be similar it makes the dollar amount lower but the increase but you're then you're comparing it
071to a lower number as well see like you you by going up the 5% you come up with a total impact of 174 if I go if I don't go up the 5% and I include the state tax credit I'm down to $78 in that RI that 174 isn't the tax impact that's the monthly that's but the total tax impact for the whole four years the way we've been talking about them is only $78 for the whole four years but are you adjusting your base year that you're comparing it to you have you how have you handled the I've included the state tax credit on that and I like I said the difference between is I didn't increase the house value 5% right that's the difference but but I'm saying that if you take it
072out of the base the year-to-year increases will be very similar to what you're seeing here without adding another piece piece of the puzzle you know you know you can definitely make them aware that the that's there but I have not seen a lot of districts use it to that extent you had said um if it was like a consistent ask year-over-year so two million for four years do you still typically do that 5% or did you had you mentioned right okay I want I'm not saying you need to do the 5% you need you need to understand that the impact on the household if that occurs and be able to prepare and discuss that I think as part of your ref process no I understand it's it's it's the to get your question a flat
073dollar amount if um and I I had this in a spreadsheet I think I probably sent you a PDF though didn't I um you would see that without if it stayed at 1.9 for four years or 1.1 that valuation increase has less of a a factor okay because of the amount you're asking for is fixed and the overall valuation would be going higher and so it's less of an issue is a$ okay compound a little bit more by because you can see that you know the the annual impact is up $56 from in 25 26 and you've asked for 1.1 more million dollars more and then you'll see that it increases a bit and again what's H this being driven really by the tax rate because you have a bigger jump in the tax rate
074there my guess is um there's something else happening in the model and I didn't have time to think it with the model much it's making that tax rate go up sure so it's it's not as easy but if you just looked at it independently of just those dollar amounts then the 5% is less of a conversation piece if it's a flat dollar amount for every year okay and then one other question this is I know I think you've answered this before when we've talked when we when you go for operational referendum and we have it where it's staggered different amounts based on the need has there been any more research on like does is it better to be consistent across the board or is it because our whole thought was always we want to just
075ask exactly for the dollar that's needed right where you could do that different ask for the similar amount and balance it over the four years right right I like asking for the amount you need per year okay because it you know you're you're basing the overall number on these you might as well ask for what you need I think I think that's a good conversation to have the other thing it does it it it leads to a the last year being of higher number and since you're G to be back and let's say your new number in this case we'll just say it's 2.7 million yeah you're going up 200,000 to Bricks Point versus if you flatten it out and you had it all at 2.2 now you're going up $500,000 that year sure so
076I like to step up for those two reasons is the flat amount a little bit easier to communicate yeah well that's what I that's why I asked the question because of the feedback we just heard and with us I know last time it was very consistent so I think the language was not reoccurring for three years $800,000 per year right where our last one we just did is this huge chunky paragraph that says year one this amount year two you know what I mean so like I'm just wondering if with with where our district is if that was where some of the confusion was if you were G to go for a flat amount um you may give you might want to give them more consideration looking at two years okay which you know I
077know is you're back you're just right back at it again but um you know to have the Surplus a couple years then they have a deficit a couple years you know you have to manage it mean that has to be the outcome yeah I worked with the district who went for an operating referendum and they said they're G to use some of their money to build the fund balance back up because they had drawn it down the end of that time they it didn't happen right it didn't happen yeah I get the discipline part I just wanted to see yeah I mean I like the step UPS I I like four years um because you know definitely border fatigue is definitely part of this um but you know if you know this Bill said it
078wasn't he felt you should go I think you definitely need to go um but you definitely have some work to do within the community to to get a successful outcome and to to to find the ways that allow you to do I mean whatever bill says I say anybody you know you don't know for sure you know the survey didn't give any clear Direction it didn't say ask for this amount for three years and we vote Yes um so that's that's the Dilemma you have as a as a group have to determine what you're comfortable with what you think the community will accept and what you think they'll understand because again the understanding of how the dollar is going to be used why they're needed I think definitely is a big part of the conversation
079and I just want to uh Jacob has uh something else he has to go to so Jacob if you need to drop off I appreciate your time today but I just want to make sure that everyone wasn't wondering why he's leaving so yeah hey thanks John thanks everyone appreciate it yep we'll do you know so I really don't want to go under four years just throws everybody in the chaos the staff doesn't know what's going to happen right no I I I think you've made some significant changes in the dollar amount um and I think if you if can come to a good way to kind of explain it and maybe touch on some of these issu I'm not saying this this is not the number one issue you're talking about why you need this
080money yeah you know what you going to do if the state budget comes in better those are the bigger talking issues but you can't make these projections sound so certain or you have to put some qualifiers around them to say you know know valuations go up more or your individual home you know um you know these these numbers could look a little different this is to give an indication of an average home that's going to happen um and mik I I think that's a good point but I don't think we need to get overly detailed because nobody's going to remember that in four years when the next referendum comes up anyway what we said back here about the possibility and without undermining today because we got a pass one no right right no understand that
081and and you're right a lot of most people won't um but I've seen it where people have come up with old informational pieces districts have put out and come back years later and said you said this and it's not this yeah and again all you can it's impossible for you to look at each homeowner property owner and say this is what's going to be exactly to the penny for the next next four years you give what you're looking to do is give a reasonable estimate and and and the factors go around that estimate and and and and do that I think most people understand that that it's not a simple thing to do um but you know they have to understand that and be comfortable because you know we are seeing you know the success
082rates of operational friends continue to fall and districts where we see continued success I think is is the communication efforts and the nature of the district there's some districts you can just pretty much almost ask anything and they're going to get yes that's just the way it is um but I think districts need to do more and and to have a ongoing continued dialogue as it relates to these things um you know starting in the next couple years what state budget comes or state budgets finalized you should have you know some communication or a write up or be prepared to answer questions and what does this mean relative the referendum that has you know you have to it has to be more of a knowing thing um so me this is just my thoughts um
083I you know I I you know your community better than I do um but I just was a little my looking at some of the assumptions we used for these rates the 5% you know makes the rate look good but if you don't communicate on the other side or or these forecast what that might mean on the other side I think you come back and bite you could could any other questions for M tonight might be back this is helpful though yeah I have to change my number I just I have met with our financial person at some point I am going to retire but with two freshman in college it's not going to be the next year or two so but uh well we appreciate you thank you again um I guess you know
084as we continue this two will still lean in and yeah get kind ation with you and as we move into those next steps some of those things might help having you there thoughts on how you might want to communicate these types of things and you want another set of eyes to look at or another Viewpoint again not that it's different than yours but just sure you know just what we're see in other districts and how we may be addressing thank you all right that's all I have for the superintendent's report this time around excellent we have uh one item of new business um and it is to consider approval of not new hire but promotion of Julian Gordon to our Bessie Allen Middle School principal um so we're looking for approval for the contract um
085which will be an 18-month contract uh for Jillian for that that role look for a motion for that approval second okay and roll call Matthew yes yeser yes G yes yep all right um next we're just going to go uh back into close session uh and look for a motion to go into close second good night everybody