001e e e all right all righty okay thank you for joining the Board of Education this evening please mute your cell phone as we begin this meeting and today is Tuesday January 28th 2025 and this meeting is now called to order at 6:33 p.m. for for those attending this meeting in person live captions are available on the TV in the boardroom and in the lobby to access the live captions in a language other than English on your own device please scan the QR code on the screen or on the table near the entrance and select the language of your choice the live stream of this meeting is also available in English and Spanish on YouTube for links to these live streams please visit the Board of Education page of the PSD website or the PSD
002TV on demand on YouTube would any board members like to make changes to the agenda okay all right seeing none we'll move on to action items um 3.1 resolution and supportive Career and Technical Education Month can I get a motion thank you I move the board approve a resolution in support of Career and Technical Education Month can I get a second Kevin thank you all right and Brian welcome yes hey welcome good evening everybody it's great to be in community with all of you tonight uh joining us this evening to speak to Career and Technical Education Month is Kelsey Berger our Career and Technical education coordinator uh welcome Kelsey I also believe that you are going to be joined by a couple of students Isabelle monz Salma Flores uh as well as Jeremy Miller one
003of our CT DC Automotive teachers as well as Nicole West a Career Technical Center medical assistant teacher that's a that's a mouthful so welcome to all of you we're so glad to celebrate all of you in the work that you're leading tonight excellent good evening members of the board superintendent Kingsley and PSD cabinet thank you for inviting us to speak tonight in celebration of Career and Technical Education Month as a proud PSD graduate I want to share just a second about my own Journey while leaving PSD very well educated by incredible teachers and counselors I did feel like I didn't really have a sense of direction upon graduation so looking back I realized now how much today's CTE offerings could have impacted me as a PSD PSD graduate now I have the privilege of overseeing
00415 diverse CTE Pathways that provide PSD students with the direction I once needed from agriculture to engineering culinary arts to computer science and Beyond these programs Empower students at every single one of our secondary sites to explore their interests develop industry aligned skills and prepare for Meaningful careers whether they choose the work Workforce trade school military community college or university the impact of CTE is undeniable students involved in these programs are more engaged in school feel a stronger sense of connection and graduate on time at higher rates beyond the classroom CTE Fosters economic Mobility for families and strengthens our community by preparing a prepared and skilled and capable Workforce this year I'm thrilled to highlight our two new Pathways at the career tech center right over here on pter high school's campus automotive technology and
005medical assisting these programs launch with overwhelming interest and already have weight lists showing the strong demand for Hands-On career connected learning tonight I'm joined by Jeremy Miller and Kyler Savage Jo from the automotive pathway and Nicole West Isabelle monz and Salma Flores from the medical assistant pathway who will share firsthand the power of these programs thank you for your continued support of CTE together we're helping our students be Future Ready hi um when Kelsey said 60 to 90 seconds a few weeks ago I kind of panic because I can talk a lot so um but a good thing came out of this because I've spent the last few weeks like truly reflecting on what it is that I love the most about these opportunities for our kids um at any point of any day you
006can pop into my shop my classroom and you can see something that I think is truly remarkable and it's that we have kids from every High School in this district from all walks of life we've got at risk of graduating to 4.0 um but they're sitting together and they're working together and they're developing technical literacy and they're supporting each other in this pursuit of graduating with options um in a society where I just I feel like I'm surrounded by division and action that's driven by division I walk into my classroom every day and and it just puts a smile on my face and encourages me to see them working together and supporting each other and finding out that they have this thing in common because they've opened up their hearts to each other and I
007mean it's just I can't I can't tell you how much I love this opportunity um and and with that I just I have to say that like I I go and I I'm friends with all the other teachers and I pop into their classrooms I talk to the kids and I see the same stuff in all the other classrooms and both my kids were uh let's see Cruz Preston and then one at fossil one at Rocky I've been in this long time I was born and raised in for Collins um I believe these are these these Common Grounds for these kids to connect in it's not only an investment in their future It's a Wonderful investment in the future but I think it's an invaluable investment in their sense of mental health and belonging right
008now in this world too so thank you for that and this is my my student Kyler hi as Mr Miller said I'm Kyler Savage Jo I am a junior at Fort Collins High School and I spent my last semester at the Career Tech Center doing the automotive program um I just want to thank everyone here for letting me come up here and speak tonight um I took the class because I thought it sounded really interesting I thought it would be a great opportunity for me to learn more about Automotive I've grown up around cars and I've grown up around automotive and I already knew a little bit but I wanted to further develop my knowledge so I could prepare myself and be Future Ready um and I thought overall this class was just it was
009so much much fun I really enjoyed it so much I thought everybody in there was so nice it was like you said the diversity was incredible and like everybody was just bonding over one common interest which is I think just a wonderful thing and I just enjoyed the environment like I said it was just a lot of fun the teachers Mr Miller was incredible I loved listening to all the stories he told about having worked as a mechanic and all the different experiences I got to learn and hear from him and um I just I also really enjoyed the content that we went over I thought it was challenging but it was doable it it really pushed us to figure stuff out and be able to think critically um not only in the classroom learning
010and but also out in the shop and then I think that another thing is that was really neat to be able to do is I'm going to be able to take the ASC breaks certification test here in a couple of weeks and I think that is really awesome because I will be able to go out and get a job and be able to apply for certain things um I am currently going to apply for an internship this Summer that and I think having that ASC certification is really going to help me get into that and be able to have just an edge against those who maybe didn't take this class um I'm also planning on going to college for motor Motorsport engineering when I figured that it would be a great start starting point here
011to take this class and I thought it was just a wonderful time overall and it will definitely help me in my future thank you um my name is Nicole West and I teach the medical assistant pathway um I'm not sure what you know about medical assisting so not everyone knows that particular role so medical assisting is a versatile profession profession it they provide administrative clinical and laboratory support to Physicians uh office managers licensed practitioners such as nurses uh nurse practitioners and physician assistants um as well as being essential to the care of patients there are an important they play an important role for the efficient and effective care in a variety of Health Care settings our program just launched our first cohort of students um with 18 students from six different schools um our program
012is unique in offering two certificate programs one after the first semester called the medical office administrative assistant and the second after a three- semester course um the actual medical assistant um that is completed three semesters um at PSD and then a front- Range Community College clinical experience um as they Advance through our program they hone their not only their healthc care literacy but their business literacy as well um in our first semester we're exploring um medicine the language of medicine medical terminology and medical office administration and they're completing a Capstone and in a matter of a mere three weeks they have already built a literal and figurative place for exploration growth and collaboration and inclusion um for their service project they have chosen to provide essential supplies to a local humanitarian organization um and they
013did that on their own I'm just the secretary in the room at the completion of the semester they will earn their medical office administrative assistance certificate this initial certification provides students with tangible evidence of their Advanced skill set in communication professionalism collaboration and Healthcare and business literacy um for their continuing um if they're continuing on to complete their medical assistance certificate these options will only become more plentiful assemble search this evening that I produced a list of 45 open medical assistant positions and I didn't even search medical administrative office assistant um they could make a really big difference in our local community in less than a year um for those pursuing additional education their experience will enrich their prospects and improve their favorability as applicants uh to any number of healthcare programs s nursing uh
014physician physician assistant um the epitome of graduating with options uh the program offers a place for students with diverse backgrounds but shared interests uh to commune with a shared purpose improving individual U mental health and belonging I often tell them in their cohort uh group that they will continue as they continue on their paths that this will be a group that they continue to reach out to for encouragement consultation and commiseration as they head into the challenges in their healthcare career thank you so much hi I'm an I'm Isabelle I go to Rocky Mountain High School um um one of the reasons why I joined the CTC program is because I wanted to know more about medical assisting and to know what path I wanted to go into and um before I joined I wasn't
015sure what I wanted to do so um I feel like the medical assisting program um was able to show me what I wanted to do and I just feel like this program uh was able to let me communicate and um talk to people that connect on the same level as me and like understand um the same passion I have for it and um the biggest I enjoy about this class is that um we get to learn about medical terminology and get to um learn about new uh Health uh just learn about new things that I wasn't really um sure about but um I also feel like this class got um was able to like meet new people and just to uh see that side and I also feel like I also got to um have
016the idea to join a internship at the pbh um Medical hospital and I am able to know that I wanted to pursue um the NICU so yeah I'm really excited for that um and I also feel like this is gives me an opportunity to um also find out what I wanted to go to college and um and yeah thank you [Applause] hello everyone my name is Salma Flores I am a senior at pter high school um I learned about this class because my counselor uh Mr Flores at pter high school he um uh actually told me about this class and I had no idea I have like this pressure of knowing what I want to be as a senior and it's a lot of pressure you know so I decided to tell him about my
017plan plans and he told me right away to join this uh medical assistant class and what this has brought me um has brought me a lot of personal experiences because we have guest speakers so they come in and talk to us about their personal experience and they just keep it they like they're so honest about how they joined it how their process was and I like that because it shows that it's not going to be easy work it is going to be hard work but I am willing to do that hard work um uh what we do in class is we do community building we I could honestly tell you guys everybody's name in that class because of how close we've gotten in the last three weeks uh my future plans um I want to
018be in the medical field I'm not sure what though so don't ask me but I do want to be in the medical field um um I think this class has brought me so many opportunities because I feel like it's making me realize that I do want to be the field um it has brought me just a lot of knowledge about medical stuff and like medical ter terminology and yeah thank you so much for having [Applause] me I just want to say thank you so much and also if we could stick around U we do a photo at the end of the second resolution if that's okay um but yeah just thank you so much and it it's just am amazing to me um the words that yall kept using together um the words together um
019you're supporting each other um giving that sense of mental health and belonging um it's fun you're bonding over a common interest and you're willing to do the hard work and have Community Building like that um and it just it brings such joy to me personally and I think to everybody in this room as I look around and see some nodding there um this is why we do the hard work that we do and I just want to say thank you so much for being willing to share that joy and um the best of luck to you all does anybody have any anyone else have anything else to say I'll go I just love the passion and I had a good day but actually this makes my day thank you anyone else all right yeah go
020ahead br just uh briefly Kelsey and Jeremy and Nicole I want to just I I can't thank you enough for embodying what our strategic plan in word means in action your ability to embody both Tech not both technical literacy belonging Community classrooms while also understanding what graduation with options really means in PSD on a daily basis is really inspiring not just to us here but to your students and the people that you serve in our schools every every single day so I just want to say thank you for your leadership um I also want to say Kyler I'm sorry for not introducing you earlier uh but I was inspired both by you as well as Salma and Isabelle um you know I had an old Mentor give me advice that to never ever accept second
021place when first place is still available and your hustle and your grit and your dedication to get yourself ahead all three of you by chasing certific ations chasing Excellence while also connecting with Community it's not going out by yourself but doing it together I think is really what makes this District amazing and you're a big part of that so congratulations to all of you okay Jill can you call the vote Jim bookish hi Kristen Draper hi Connor Duffy hi Kevin havelda hi Scott shanower hi Jessica Zamora hi motion passes 60 [Applause] all right moving on to 3.2 resolution and support of National School counseling week can I get a motion please all right Kevin go ahead oh Conor go for it I move the board approve a resolution in support of National School counseling week
022February 3rd through 7th 2025 can I get a second all right just thank you all right and then Brian we have special guests for this as well we sure do joining us this evening to speak to National School counseling week is Beth green our counselor coordinator welcome Beth I believe she's also joined by Maryann Spence uh school counselor at Bower Elementary School welcome thank you Board of Education superintendent Kingsley and cabinet for your support in honoring our school counselors during national school counselors week the theme for this year is school counselors helping students Thrive National School counseling week highlights the tremendous impact our school counselors can have at all levels and helping students have Equitable access to achieve School Success our PSD school counselors actively engage in helping students examine their abilities their strengths and
023their interests they work in partnership with families to meet the needs of all of our students focus on positive ways to enhance students academic post-secondary options and their social emotional development and they work with teachers and other Educators to provide an educational system where students can realize their potential and set healthy realistic and optimistic aspirations for themselves feel connected and truly have a sense of belonging I'm honored to work alongside our school counselors and PSD and truly believe that each of them embodies the theme of helping students Thrive from the time they enter our buildings in elementary school to when they leave to take their next step after high school and I'm honored to have with me one of our elementary counselors and one of my lead counselors Maryann Spence to speak further about the
024importance of School [Applause] counseling hello everyone I appreciate you all taking the time to acknowledge the work and impact school counselors have on our students and school communities being a lead counselor this year I've had the opportunity to listen to counselors across the elementary middle and high school share about all the wonderful things they are doing to encourage personal social and academic growth with their students their dedication and pride to their school communities leaves me in awe I have been a counselor for 10 years this is my fourth year in PSD at Bower Elementary elementary counselors meet students when they enter kindergarten we help them adjust to new a new environment work with different people and learn new skills over the course of six years we watched them grow into fifth graders who are more
025settled in their personalities and we see glimmers of who these little people will be when they are grown up and out on their own one fifth grader that I have worked with since she was in second grade said having a counselor helps give me someone to talk to because my mom works a lot and I don't have a lot of people to talk to when I'm feeling frustrated going to your office helps me calm down and feel better you also help me think of ways to problem solve all school counselors come alongside their students teachers and families and help students adjust to new spaces learn how to cope when big feelings come to honor them just as they are because they are wonderful just as they are we meet students where they are and help
026teach them skills we let them know that they are seen and cared for that they are capable and that it is okay to ask for help we live in the comfort of knowing we are planting seeds of skills and knowledge that they will harness and continue to use throughout their lives I know that my colleagues in middle school and high school care for and support these students as I did in elementary school and that these students will be ready to flourish in adulthood with Comprehensive datadriven datadriven School counseling programs we can ensure that students are regulated feel seen are included know their goals and engage with their education to be prepared for the next steps in life when they graduate high school thank you for your recognition and continued support of this important [Applause] work
027again I just want to say thank you so much um first of all love the shirt it is a good day to talk about feelings every day is a good day um and what you do is so difficult and you do it with Grace every day at all of our mental health professionals here um and it's only gotten harder and I'm sorry for that um and I just want you to know that we are here to support you for that we are here to um lift you up and celebrate you you because what you do matters um you know it it was as you said the helping students Thrive that this is what you do you know end of sentence you help students Thrive and without you that wouldn't happen so thank you does anybody
028else want to say something Jim oh that was just a thumbs up thumbs okay all right so okay yeah absolutely impossible for me not to say something so uh Beth and Mary it's Maryann right on behalf of all the school counselors I want to thank you for your leadership my observation of the work that you do when I go and visit all of our schools is that you're not only holding space for students and your colleagues but you're also teaching them skills to have a healthy productive not just childhood but life I see so many of our students that are so cognizant of their emotions their body's reaction to their emotions they can put words to those feelings they can express themselves in productive and healthy ways and it's because of your Collective leadership and
029commitment to teach them those skills which I think is going to pay dividends for decades and lifetimes to come as well as their future fam so thank you very much for your leadership for it Brian said he couldn't hold his tongue well um on a personal note my sister uh is a social worker and mental health professional in a school in Kentucky as a former teacher I worked closely with our mental health professionals in our schools for um kids that were that had pretty rough environments growing up so I I know firsthand the glue that you offer to our schools um and thank you for being here and in in addition to the resolution the recognition that you so richly deserve tonight I just want to make sure that you don't hesitate to ask what
030we can do for you especially in the the months to come and in the weeks to come and if things are are getting even harder for you to do your jobs um please don't hesitate to ask uh leadership cabinet team the board what we can do to make your lives just that much easier I think that's a that's an appropriate request thank you all right Jill can you call the vote Jim brokish hi Kristen Draper hi Kevin havalda hi sorry Connor Duffy hi Scott shanower hi Jessica Zamora I motion passes 60 and if we could go ahead and take a picture that would be [Applause] great hello hello thank you app sneak up sorry than all right thank you all so much for coming truly appreciate it so we're g to move on now to
031um 4.0 superintendent report so superintendent Kingsley will now make remarks to the board of education and to the community welcome thank you uh Happy Tuesday everybody it's great to be here with all of you and I want to start off my remarks by telling you a little bit about Adam brunes Adam brunes is one of psd's many incredible school resource officers and officer brunes is commitment to serving our students and our schools each and every day is an incredible example of the robust Community Partnerships that we are fortunate to have as being a part of this incredible District we know together that we're committed to ensuring that all of our schools are safe spaces for every single one of our students and our SRO program is just one facet of this commitment so I'd like
032to invite both the community and all of our attendees who are here in person to watch a special video highlighting the magic of Officer brunches my name is Officer Adam brunes I am a school resource officer here at F Rich high school for the last 3 years I was in business and marketing back in New York City and then September 11th hit and really changed my life uh realized that I needed to do more impactful work and so I first became a firefighter with this fale fire department on Long Island um absolutely love that and then I decided to cross over and become a police officer as school resource officers um we do wear many hats um we're an informal counselor kids come to me in my office to to talk about stuff that's going
033on in their lives I've spoken in many classes and taught in government classes and freshman classes just their appreciation of me being there the thank you cards that I get afterwards and to me that means I'm actually doing impactful work really makes me want to do my job every day and show up um and just be here for the kids every day the two places that kids should feel the most safe are at home and at school um unfortunately I can't control what goes on in their homes um but I can definitely control what goes on here at school uh so giving them a safe place to come to learn to have fun with their classmates uh is something that I take pride in and that I uh I really feel that's important I do
034run a first responder Hockey League hockey is my favorite sport and I think there's no other sport like hockey as far as teamwork and just a camaraderie that that the teams build with each other last year we played the PSD hockey club team of course the kids won because they were way too fast for us and they were awesome but it was a great time uh we raised a lot of money for the PSD Hockey Club and um just again building that relationship with the kids ultimately though I am a police officer so I am here ultimately for the safety of the school and the students um unfortunately we hear about school violence almost every day and I feel that me being here I'm willing to to not go home safe as long as the
035kids go home safe every day uh that is my mission every [Music] day aren't those videos cool yeah officer brunes is cool too I want to thank all of our school resource officers I want to thank officer Meg who's here too as well representing another one of our Fort Collins Police Services Partners uh and Advocates it's really clear that together we're committed to ensuring the safety of every single one of our students every day and they don't only lead with passion and commitment but I think they also collectively in partnership with us lead with a great deal of empathy I think it's important to note that there is so much emotion in various questions and Curiosities that are circling not just our local community but our national Community right now as we hold space for
036each other we continue to double down on our commitment to educating every child every day and making sure that they feel safe so I want to thank all of our school resource officers for their Collective and continued partnership uh members of the board and members of the community we have a great and highly productive meeting scheduled for tonight and one of the great conversations that we'll have is about continuing to explore ongoing bell times I think this might be chapter three uh in this continued effort to talk about that which I think is a really good thing to have continued conversation around opportunities what does it take to get there what are the trade-offs there are no easy conversations that are coming your way tonight but I do believe uh in my heart of hearts
037that there educative in nature and will allow us to Grapple with hard things with real information that will also inform the community of some of our Collective thoughts and you'll hear from our chief finance officer a little bit later talking about that so I'm excited for having to have a productive meeting with you and I want to say thank you for giving me space to have my remarks shared this evening absolutely thank you all right and now we'll move on to the community comment section of the board meeting the board desire desires to hear the viewpoints of all stakeholders including students employees parents Guardians and community members public comment is designed to address issues not personalities or Personnel matters please keep your concerns and comments focused upon the district and appropriate for a K12 audience
038please note that the board does not generally respond to remarks made during Community comments a lack of response should not be construed to mean that we agree or disagree with what was said or the description or interpretation of events as presented by any speaker further even if some remarks may be factually inaccurate we generally choose not to respond to correct the record here because formal board meting are not the time or place for back and forth dialogue as we begin this community comment session let us model for our entire Community how to listen and how to interact respectfully even with those with whom we disagree for we all have the students best interests at heart so this opportunity for public comment is for members of the community who registered to speak by the designated deadline
039those people will be called on to make remarks in the order that they signed up and each speaker will be allowed three minutes to address the board and first up I have Katie no welcome good evening thank you thank you pter School District Board of Education for allowing me to speak today my name is Katie nelk and I have two children at olander elementary our family recently moved back to Fort Collins from Utah our son Otto has Type 1 diabetes and celiac disease our daughter Mari had a severe eye injury that still requires Continued Care in Utah we had a close relationship with the school nurse ensuring our children's needs were met however we quickly learned that olander like all PSD schools does not have a full-time nurse despite the warm welcome and dedicated staff
040at olander our experiencing has been challenging due to this lack of resources my concerns are not with the teacher staff or Administration but with the district's policies and resource limitations for example a reasonable accommodation for type 1 diabetics is remote monitoring of blood sugar levels initially our request for this was denied but after months of persistence and highlighting Ada law violations the district finally provided this critical accommodation for Otto Otto is not alone he is one of three type 1 diabetics in his class PSD has nearly 30,000 students but only 18 School nurses and one health services coordinator resulting in a 1 to 1,700 nurse to student ratio these nurses split their time across multiple schools making continuity of care impossible some schools have health technicians but they are not as extensively trained as licensed
041School nurses at olander budget constraints have limited us to a 30% Health Tech position for the 2425 school year I stand before you today to address the urgent need for better care and better student to school nurse ratios School nurses play a critical role in provide in supporting student health safety and academic achievement as student healthc care needs become increasingly complex we must adopt a comprehensive Staffing approach that considers each school's unique needs I understand the budget constraints and the many many needs within the district and I urge the board to prioritize funding for full-time School nurses in every school our children's health and safety depend on it let's work together to ensure that every student receives the care they need to survive and thrive thank you for your time and consideration thank you next
042up we have Julie wiel welcome good evening Schoolboard directors and superintendent Kingsley my name is Julie wsel and I'm the proud parent of a Fort Collins High School Junior and a seventh grader at Lasher middle school last year I wrote you a letter regarding the busing and school start time puzzle and I'm hopeful that there are more options as you revisit adjusting start times tonight we're on the same page with these key points no one wants to see no one wants to take busing away from a student who needs it to access their education hiring and maintaining bus drivers is a national problem the science medical professionals continue to prioritize sleep for our youth we know what happens when students don't get enough sleep behavior issues inability to focus increased anxiety increased depression and lower
043test scores and we know that just because school starts early concerts and games and after school jobs haven't shifted to earlier times our middle schoolers have long days there have been 500 more tardies in the first 14 weeks of school at ler this academic year than last year I'd be curious about the data from all our middle schools on tardies comparing this fall semester to previous fall semesters what I want to add to the conversation tonight is what I've observed as a volunteer crossing guard from 7 to 7:30 a.m. every Monday and Wednesday morning at the prospect in Stover crosswalk when I arrive at school at 7:00 a.m. there have been weeks when the stars are still out the classrooms are a glow with teachers already in meetings large coffees in hand there are students
044huddled at the front door taking pictures of the Moon waiting to be led inside our neighbor has been at school since 6:40 a.m. for jazz band his mom says he really enjoys it but is considering not trying out next year due to the time at the crosswalk there is a button to press to activate a red light and a walk symbol there are also flashing yellow lights indicating to drivers that this is a school zone these flashing yellow lights do little to slow down Prospect traffic there are drivers not paying attention and drivers who are sleepy and drivers racing to get their kids to school I've contacted the for counts police twice about this concern and a wait a response in the meantime I think that drivers are not expecting students to be walking to
045school at dawn there are dozens of students who bike and walk and use this crosswalk one sixth grader typically bikes all the way from the mall sometimes they have earbuds in and sometimes their hands are full of books and instruments and many times they're in a hurry to make it to school before the Bell I've had to hold individuals back from Crossing to ensure cars were stopping and I shouted at cars who didn't stop for the red light I know we can't control a lot of pieces in this puzzle but we can look at a later start time so that visibility and alert Ness are improved I urge you to look at options that could help getting to school just a little bit safer I grateful to you for your long hours and late nights
046devoted to our children and our district as you reassess schools start times and busing optimization please use student wellness and safety as your compass thank you thank you and last up we have Anna leetta welcome through it good evening I may have missed the last meeting in person but I was watching live at home when you said dyslexia thank you I have appreciated periodic updates from the district over the past couple of months since it was determined that the dialogue around dyslexia would be shifting as of this year I know that a Bo a board of education update is happening soon and that various levels of professional development around dyslexia are underway to provide trainings across the district and inform various stakeholders of new consistent messaging more air quotes on one hand I find myself
047truly grateful for any movement even just the basic idea that the message is spreading more broadly that teachers and admin can St dyslexia and learn about its characteristics and on the other hand I find myself cautious ly reserved on behalf of our misunderstood yet incredibly dyslexic incredibly capable dyslexic kids this time last year almost exactly a year ago in fact the district enacted a series of 2 by tws to update board members and dissuade them from any alarm or concerns that may arise from the things I was saying in the back of my mind I can't help but wonder what the actual major Catalyst was for the 180 and narrative that I'm hearing now deep down a part of me fears that it has been born out of necessity more than from a true vision
048for our dyslexic Learners and I wonder did it have anything to do with the systemic complaint filed with the office of civil rights over the summer in regard to discrimination against students with dyslexia does it have anything to do with the State Board of Education being open and moving a little faster on changes around dyslexia than the cde's initial recommendation to hold off a few more years does it have to do with the funding model changing to increase State funding for kids identified with special education needs my fear is that much of this could fall flat for our kids if the district is by any stretch begrudgingly making these changes in order to cover bases check boxes meet bare minimums and ultimately tweak the consistent messaging based on these motives regardless of how we've gotten
049to this point I thankful that we're saying it and I am asking you tonight both the Board of Education and the district to please take this shift very seriously please take the time to learn about what is at stake and set it up for success please make it count this has the potential of serving a significant number of kids who are below grade level proficiency and yet still not eligible for special education this is both a gened and special education issue we need Rob robust and proactive policies in place around mtss and special education we need the silos to be dissolved if done right I believe with all my heart that this will be one of those shifts that will benefit our entire district and that we will only regret not having done it sooner
050thank you thank you for saying it heard you hold you to it thank you all right thank you to all our community commenters today uh next up we have a board topics and committee reports this agenda item is an opportunity for board members to provide an an update um there we go on committee work or speak to board topics do any board members have anything they wish to report Kevin go ahead like to give a proud summary of the first of our uh engagement sessions with our community that we hosted um myself Jim and Kristen attended Johnson uh Elementary and we had a really good showing and for those that don't know what I'm referring to we are now hosting some Community engagement sessions at various schools um before I forget the next one is
051coming up Thursday February 20th that'll be hosted at both dun Elementary and Cru Elementary for folks that want to join um I think we had around 34 to 30 seven individuals at our opening session a large composite of those were Johnson folks which was nice to get to meet them um be on some of the the conversations we had last year um true to form as I mentioned there one of the purposes of having those Community engagements is not just to have the conversation there but to continue the conversation to amplify some issues that were raised and to continue the discussion so I want to honor those and validate some of the the these are I took scattered notes I'm sure Jim and Kristen took better um I was trying to describe as best I
052could but in no particular order some of the the clusters of comments that came up were surrounding the mevy override um how the district intends to use those dollars how they're appropriated how they'll be accounted for um we we heard still some messaging from um last year that our community is still recovering and repairing from some of the trauma that was that they went through with school consolidation closure so I want to again um honor that and validate that um those feelings and that we're not that far away from those discussions and it was a difficult time for our community and difficult conversations that we had so we're still learning um a lot of um great ideas surrounding marketing too of how we're going to sell our district how we're going to talk about our
053district and not just from a top level John but also at this at the more organic level what are the conversations we're having with our neighbors with our friends about selling our neighborhood schools um we also uh uh took some issues on like enrollment data and some parents expressed some concern over um District not policies but practices perhaps is a better way phrase it of sharing enrollment data with not just Charter Schools but with other neighborhood schools around school choice and so that was an interesting conversation um a lot of conversations around surrounding safe routes and prioritizing um you know what makes this community great our community great is how navigable it is through uh biking and walking and we want to preserve that and maintain that and be thought around that um there's also
054some discussion around Equity enrollment um which was was good information the other thing I want to do too I want to thank Kelly Lyall col Roden for being there covering that um and also doing a better job than I just did probably summarizing and synthesizing some of the things that were uh expressed but again I think it's it's a it's a it's an invitation to our community to continue to be a part of the conversation what I learned is that um some of the the questions that arose we've been answering in this room with our public discussion on very on a lot of topics so it was again another invitation for them to either watch online come to our board meetings reach out to board directors reach out to leadership um it's not it's not
055that we have these conversations in isolation then we forget about them so I think that's an ongoing invitation some interesting solutions that are not mine that came up organically from the room um in pertaining to marketing is to have maybe a feeder fair so having a Rocky Mountain feeder Fair where all the Rocky Mountain feeders will come and and showcase their their schools at a sort of an open night which had a really good feel to it um one that was interesting um well this will be subject for more conversation Dave but um in in the athletics department there's some tough conversations around accessibility to sporting events and extracurricular events and that you know not everyone has the ability to drive to and from these events and so one thought was to make maybe make
056coaches drive and ask them to pick up a CDL um I mean that's when I was growing up all my soccer coaches had their driver's license and they were driving us to and throw in Western Kentucky Backwoods for soccer games um another interesting point butd I think is more for your Camp which we can follow up on um another solution was what are we doing districtwide policy wide to have more uh uh thought towards Energy savings as a district do we have policies that require teachers to shut down computers and shut down lights at the end of every day um and you know I'm sure there are but I think that was a that was an interesting solution interesting discussion that came out from a teacher that had been other districts um so again want
057to promote the next one February 20th if you can't make that the one after will be Thursday April 17th and that one will be at Rice Elementary in Beth key um and again I want to keep inviting our community to keep showing up keep talking about the issues that are important to you and so that we can further those discussions here and um and have some more thoughtful conversations thanks thank you Jim did you have just the thank you for that summary have and I think that was great I would only add um it was exciting for me not just to have Community comment where it's all one-sided but to actually have a conversation with parents I just thought that was awesome I agree with that it was really nice to be able to have
058a conversation that was great anything else okay yeah go for it my comment here is not in the spirit of competitiveness but I do want to acknowledge that I have Community engagement session envy and you're all having the fun so I'm starting my own uh and we're I'm going to have a superintendent Community engagement session next Thursday at Boltz Middle School from 5:30 to 6:30 so if you are listening whether you're an employee a parent a student um I'm hoping to have more numbers than we're at those sessions that you all attend it and maybe we can have a competitive Spirit to see uh how we can get more and more more people out but I am really really interested in engaging the community thoughtfully the same way that you are um and it's just
059another extension of listening engaging and getting to the root of some of the core challenges and opportunities that our system is grappling with so I want to thank you all as board members for modeling that practice I think it's really really great for us as a governance team and I hope that you don't mind that I get my get some skin in the game just remember the number to beat is all right moving on to the consent agenda uh would any board member like to pull anything from consent okay seeing none can I get a motion I can go I move the board to approve and adopt the recommended actions for the items on the consent agenda can I get a second thank you Jess all right and Jill will you call the vote Jim
060brokish hi Kristen Draper hi Connor Duffy hi Kevin havelda hi Scott shanower hi Jessica Zamora hi motion passes 60 okay moving on to action items 8.1 internal monitoring report El 2.0 can I get a motion Jim did sure I'll go I move the board determine that the superintendent has reasonably interpreted the Board of Education policy El 2.0 in his internal monitoring report dated January 28th 202 5 and that the evidence presented supports the superintendent's conclusions stated in the internal monitoring report can I get a second all right thank you Jess all right and is there any discussion on this item seeing none Joel can you call the vote Jim brokish hi Kristen draver hi Conor Duffy hi Kevin havalda hi Scott shanower hi Jess Zamora hi motion passes 60 fantastic moving right along um go
061on to uh 9.0 informational reports and discussion items and 9.1 will up get an update on ongoing study of bell schedules so Brian we have some special guests for this one yes we do thank you uh tonight we look forward to hearing an update on the ongoing study of bell schedules from our chief finance officer Dave Montoya Dave welcome thank you um yes and so tonight I am uh providing an update on the the ongoing study of bell schedules um I think many of us know that made some significant changes this year we're going to walk through what those changes were and why we did those and then we're going to talk a little bit about some of the data analysis and ongoing efforts that we've been doing to explore what happens if we were
062to move bell times um specifically talking about start times for schools moving to a later date or a later time so so we're going to go ahead and get into the uh just kind of the the why we are here and uh you know I I remember us talking back in covid um in fact I remember us having an emergency negotiation session around this this challenge that we were having and it really came down to bus driver shortage and and it was very significant for us that year um and what it caused us to do because we had such a shortage of drivers we were just not able to move the kids that we needed what it caused us to do was to start exploring cost savings um and and ways to actually reduce the
063number of bus routes that we were running on the road um this was really an effort to one be able to hire enough drivers because we weren't there wasn't enough drivers in the pool at that time is also looking at some cost savings trying to get some efficiencies but really what caused this was covid and that's what really started us to look at this in in a significant way um so when when the district started exploring this last year um one of the things that was noticed right off the bat was that we did not have standardized Bell grade levels or standardized bell times by grade level and so what that meant was we had multiple differing times and end times so you can see in the notes Here we had 14 differing morning start
064times and 19 differing end times um ultimately what what this bundled into was that it was a two-tiered routing system that was less efficient and so there was a lot of discussion last year around you know what what options are there um so to start addressing that the district actually engaged with a firm called first Consulting and we looked at some of their data last year multiple times as we started talking about bell times um but that that work really started back in August of 23 so so we've been at this for a little bit and uh first Consulting is a nationally recognized School District that um that is a transportation specific consulting firm so um so they're very accustomed to helping optimize bell bell times and routes Bell routes um they're also um very
065knowledgeable in just all aspects of Transportation so it's very helpful to bring bring that and um that coupled with the expertise that we have on staff as well I don't want to overshadow the fact that we have very talented routing staff on on staff and being able to work with Consulting we were able to do some work around this um what what first Consulting came back with as we as we hired them and selected them was and and this wasn't a surprise to us at the time that there there is a more efficient route if you can run three tiers in a single route so what that means is you have a start time you're picking up kids drop those kids off you have another start time pick those kids up you drop them off
066and then you have another start time pick those kids and drop them off so that would be the morning and that would be like a three tiered tiered system um keep in mind our previous system was that two-tiered system so so moving to a three- tiered system basically means you're able to move more kids with fewer buses it's it's just altero right um so so what we're really looking is for more efficiency in in uh in these schedules and and how the uh the bell times work as well as trying to align the bell times so that they made sense in a three- tiered system so that was kind of the work that we started last year um so where we ended up uh Landing last year was uh we did move to a three-
067tiered system from that Old two-tiered system with multiple start times that um that were all over the place and uh what we landed on what we currently have um and we heard a little bit about this tonight is uh we have all of our middle schools on what we call our first here that's our earliest time um that's 7:30 in the morning um we have all of our high schools in our third tier that's the later tier of busing and then we have the elementary schools in the middle because they're the largest group and so they make up that middle tier but then we also are able to kind of spread that that Elementary over to the other tiers to get everything to balance out and and so that's why uh first Consulting had uh
068Ted recommended this three- tier routing structure and and that's exactly what we ended up with um this August of 24 so as the school year started um implementation required rerouting of all students under this new three- tiered model and uh that was when I came into this position I remember one of the first tasks was going over and talking to the routers and the bus folks and they were really nervous about this it was a big Endeavor for them to take on um so so we did do it um and we did it with some some haste um it wasn't without some some things that needed to be smoothed over but I would say overall it was a very good implementation giving the amount of work that we needed to do in a short period
069of time um and and so that was really the work we did this August and it actually started in July and then finished in August um but uh but the idea was that that was our new routes for this year and so we actually implemented this three- tiered schedule last year um positives that were noted um and observations from this so so positives uh we talked about this from the budget side too um not only from the operational side last year but uh the three- tiered system allowed us to reduce 10 routes or another 10 or reduced 10 routes and so what that means is we went from about 123 routes down to 113 routes um it created operational and financial efficiencies uh we talked in the budget last year about being able to save
070$1.1 million that was part of the reductions that we put forward to actually balance bring the Bal the budget into balance um this this year and so that was that was a big part of that um and it also reduced the number of drivers needed and again that was part of the the reason why we're doing this and so so the first time uh for the first time when we started the year since 2020 when this all started in Co we actually had proper number of drivers either on staff or in a class getting ready to graduate that match the number of routes so so this was a big win for us in transportation um leaving some of that challenges that we had in Co where we just did not have enough drivers and just
071so you know what's happening when we don't have enough drivers what happens is the people that are the central people that are keeping things going like our managers and supervisors and Driver trainers they all have to get on a bus and and that's that's a real challenge for them so we were really excited when we started the year to say wow you all might not need to be on a bus all day because what that meant is they were driving the bus in the day then they were working at night to do their their normal job and this wasn't just sporadic this was ongoing and so we were we were excited about that fact and uh and and I do want to say that we are still experiencing driver shortages so we started of the
072year as I described we've lost drivers um we also have a number of drivers that are constantly being out sick and so it's a big pool of drivers we're we're trying to manage all of that um all the time but uh but we are still experiencing a driver shortage and in fact I just checked with our staff this morning and uh we're short about six drivers right now um so what that means is we have six management and supervisor staff that are filling in to make that work um the good news is they told me we have six people in the class it's it's going to be graduating and they high hopes that they're all going to graduate so so again we're feeling good here but that's coming on the heels of feeling really bad
073with significant shortfalls before that so just just recognize that um also part of why we did this is um what was happening with not only managers and supervisors getting on buses but with these significant shortages um of Staff what was happening is our drivers were working enormous amounts of overtime and that costs money because it doesn't pay out at the normal rate it pays out at time and a half so so that was a big drain on the budget that we knew was a function of not having enough drivers as well as the last part of this bullet point is charter buses um many of you may have noticed that during Co after covid and even not so much this year but last year we were even running charter buses uh for athletics uh different
074activities because we didn't have enough drivers and buses to get get that that working so the idea was to try to contain all that and move to a better system um we still have some overtime because we have shortages um but it's greatly reduced and we're continuing to track that but it is reduced um the other thing is we're not chartering near as many buses which is great I mean there's a handful of times where we're talking about it might make sense typically probably given the distance of the trip or something like that uh but but really we were able to contain some of these challenges by by moving to this system and and reducing tin routes and and again I I don't I just want to talk I'm talking from the budget sense here
075right like there's 10 routes each route was about $110 $110,000 per route um so other positives that we noticed during this this change was that um no school moved more than 25 minutes either earlier or later than the previous schedule um it increased the number of Triple Triple should say runs in there both morning and afternoon and what a run is is what I was just describing you pick up kids middle school kids in the morning drop them off pick up elementary school kids you drop them off you pick up the high school kids and you drop them off so that would be like a three tiered or a three three run system and then a route would be that whole bus that's running those those runs um just for for your information because I
076think it helps from the budget sense um and this this numbers increased a little bit from last year uh but each route is currently approximately costing us about $115,000 per route and what we're looking at there primarily is is mileage um meaning how much gas is that going to gas or diesel is that bus going to use as well as um you know all the other pieces that are involved in that as well as like labor and and Driver time really as what's in there so so that's a that's kind of a a reference for us it's the positives that we noticed uh moving to the system um and we heard this tonight for sure uh there's some negatives and and I know that that's why we're continuing this exploration is um we know we
077knew this last year um that middle school starting at 7:30 may be viewed is too early um so that was a slide that we had um it was something that we I think we knew going into it but we were still going into it for efficiencies um and so so that negative is still there um elementary school starting at 905 could be viewed as too late and then this was an interesting one the savings achieved were not as significant as was hoped and I think we had some lofty ideals originally when we got first Consulting on can we really get an efficient schedule and can we get like closer to a $1.5 million savings maybe even more what we found once we got in and started working with the data and this is a very
078data intensive effort right once we started working with the data we we realized that those Savings of 1.5 probably were not achievable and that's where we landed with the 1.1 as we move forward for this year uh but those those negatives I think are still still pertinent and and top of line for many of us okay so that's kind of just like how did we start this why did we start this what did we do last year um so now we're going to move into this continued EXP exploration because the board was interested in continuing to explore bell times and looking if there would be more efficiencies more opportunity maybe to negate some of those negatives we talked about with a 7:30 start time for middle school so so that's really what we were tasked
079with doing and so what we did is uh I went back to our routing staff and we we had a real significant conversation around do we need first Consulting to help us with this again and the the common will of all of us and me included was they were very helpful it would be helpful to have them come in again so we did we did ask them hey can you help us out with this the great news about that was they just helped us with all our routes in August like on a detailed level not just the data level like they did prior to that so so they came armed with more information about what pter school district is and what our current system is um so we we we had first Consulting come in
080and start exploring options uh the way we went about this is we use psd's bus planner software it's actually pretty fascinating to see um if you can I didn't bring graphic with me but you can see the outlay of when a bus starts when all the buses are on the road and when they come back and and you can see it helps you manage the data better and so what what first Consulting really came up with is is a TW model option to consider and so these are Explorations and we're going to get to a table where we explore all these options but really what it distill down to is two model options were considered um one was the three- tiered option that explores changes to the earliest and latest start times in the current
081model so that was one option that we were looking at or one approach and then the second one was coming back to the second tier um option and explore what would that look like under earliest uh exploring earliest and late start times um in the 23 24 model as well um so sorry so what we what we did here was we don't have the data from the two-tier model I'm reading my note again here um and and what we ended up using was the old two-tier data because that was a really reliable data source because we had that old tier two tier 2 model before so it helped us kind of to do that um exploration better because we had already explored that prior um so so what we let's get into the details here
082and then I we're going to pull a table up I think that's going to bring this all together for us and then that's where we're going to spend most of our time is on the table in the next slide after that U but the best uh the bus planner Bell time analyzer uh we started using that to to shift start time so moving them forward or to a later time um and then we used the route Optimizer to repackage runs it's a computer algorithm that does that and and it does it based on schedules and so what we programmed in there was option one let's explore both the three and two-tiered model so in option one um what we looked at was moving the start times to 8 8:30 and 905 okay and we explored
083that both in a well in a three- tiered model there and then we explored different option would be moving to a tier two two tiered model um with start times of 8 and 9:05 um so one of the challenges with this and and we'll see it in the table is that in options one and two we were really trying not to move the length of the school day and and because when we start moving the back end of the school day you start bumping into challenges with activities and Athletics and all of that so so that that that was something that we were conscious of as we went through these options um moving into option two um and we're going to see we're going to see why that matters on the table it really makes
084sense I think so option two um because we didn't NE I mean we came back with some data and first Consulting came back with that and we looked at it and said wow okay that's adding a lot of routes so what could we do could we maybe look at moving it up 15 minutes and I know 15 minutes doesn't feel like a lot but we explored that option as well so so we explored a 7:45 825 and 9:05 start time um in a three- tiered model and then a 745 and a 905 start time in a two-tiered model the last thing that we explored was and in this example we actually did move the end times up and we're going to see how that impacts this it's interesting um but but option three um really
085was having the start time at 8 8:45 9:35 and then what we were trying what we did is we had to to model that in a three- tiered system and then we did the eight and the 935 in a two-tiered system um but what we did on this and we're going to see it now is we had to to move the bus return times up of which creates a lot of challenges so so that was a lot I I like tables and I like data so let's walk through the the table I think this actually pulls it all together and then we're going to we're going to kind of look back at some of the implications of this evaluation um but we might want to bounce back and forth between the table and the next
086slide that's going to come after this so so the first line on this table is our current three- tiered system so this is kind of our base that we're going to reference to um again uh it reflects our current school start time uh 7:35 and then that High School 9:05 uh the bus return times right now on this are 5:30 and 6: p.m. okay the operating time and this is this is an important concept here the the operating time is the amount of time that is in I'm going to try not to draw with my hands but I can't help it sometimes um it's it's the length of time between those intervals so think about the school start time it's the 7:30 to 9:05 so so there's an operating time that's in there and as
087that time gets wider we can disperse kids across that distribution more but as we squeeze that time in what we do is we start to Bunch kids up and that's what causes the differentiation between a three and a two-tiered model um so in this first base and then again this is our base for reference um we're coming back to the 113 routes that we have um that that cost there's no differential and cost because that's what we where we're at now and then of of course going over to the tier so you see the three- tiered and then there's the two-tiered option modeled in both option and all the options the two-tiered at the end is na on both because we're not on a two-tiered system so this is our base okay now getting into
088the option one so the option one was that one where we're increasing the start time the beginning and then you'll see the bus return time doesn't change a lot okay um so what we've done is we have an 8 to 9:05 or the 8:00 start time and then the 9:05 for the high schools um so that has been increased um the bus return time would be 530 to 6 and as you can see what we did is we didn't move that 90 five time and squeezed the other two tiers in and so by reducing that operating time or that that length of which we're trying to squeeze kids in um and as we compressed it what it did is it required us to add routes to be able to accommodate them and so in this
089first example on a three- tiered system and this got pretty expensive pretty quickly um what it was yielding was that you would need to have another 28 routes or buses to run that system um that equates to and I did the math for us but the 115,000 at the bottom per route um that equates to about an increase in cost of about $3.2 million um we also modeled the two-tiered system uh just to see what that that would yield um and it's interesting how these played out because it's it's all simulations that are being done in there but um what we found in the two-tiered system was that we and was that we actually only needed 21 routes in that situation still a lot um that's $2.4 million in that in that scenario can I
090ask a quick clarifying question I stop your mojo but um just so I have a frame of understanding when you're talking three tier two tier for each of these routes in the start times are you also going one step further and saying you're standardizing that start time per grade yeah I or is this or is a three tiered mean three tier start time per Elementary embedded no no no so what we're trying to do is standardized to the grade level so that's what I thought so so like like in our current system right now the first here is that middle school and then that third tier is the high school and then the elementaries kind of fall in the middle but some of the elementary spill over to balance it out if that makes sense
091so these sorry in these proposals just to be clear that standardized start time mean because the reason I asked because last time we had this conversation I remember it presenting a challenge because there's so many more middle or excuse me elementary schools than middle schools and high schools and so to standardize means more routes more drivers um so your this this model what we're talking about here would standardize start times based on the grade level even with the teer the level of tearing that you're doing all all it's doing is taking our current tiers and and increasing their start time so like the 7:30 time is now 8 um that's an example they just all shifted 30 minutes forward okay I think so so I'm GNA try to I I appreciate the question because I
092think when this conversation chapter 2 last year the aspiration was to have very distinct start and end times for all three levels of schools this was Elementary start and end time this is middle school starting end time high school starting end time not necessarily in that order of tears but that was the vision what I believe Dave is presenting here and I invite you to correct me if my interpretation is wrong for option one is we still have a very distinct start and end time for middle schools and high schools but in this three- tiered model our elementary schools are still spread across all three tiers in essence what option one does is take the current model and shift it back in time 30 minutes and yes correct is that is that accurate yes okay
093thank you sorry sorry if I was going in a different direction there but no great okay um so so that's a that that's the option one there is that we were were exploring both that three- tiered and then two-tiered and uh and in this case uh again what we're what we're compressing is that operating time and and that's actually something interesting to focus on because the more you compress that the more run or the more buses you need to be running in there because you're squeezing more kids in a shorter period of time um option two uh it kind of takes the Middle Road between our current system and option one um so in this case you'll see that the start time there is 7:45 as opposed to the 7:30 15 minutes earlier than the
094eight that was modeled above um nothing else has changed we did not change the return times again we're trying not to change the impact the other side of the schedule um and in this case what it what it does it allows us to stretch out a little bit more because now we're stretching a bit um and so we have an 80 minute operating time in these scenarios and that reduced it still we still need more buses um but it does reduce the number of buses and routes by by looking at something like an option two so in the three tiered system sticking with that um we still have a you know a nine bus increase inre or nine route increase that's approximately a million dollars um in the two-tiered system you have approximately 18 more
095buses needed and about $2.1 million um that would be the cost of that now option three is where we yep may I add one piece of context I apologize so as I was explaining based on the question that you asked director havelda in partnership with what Dave was presenting I think one of the things I want to restate or maybe say differently is option one there moves back tier one and tier two 30 minutes but it maintains the high school start time at 9:05 which is what creates the compression of the operating time from 95 minutes to 65 minutes in option two the start and end times of the first two tier shift back in the day 15 minutes while still maintaining the third current tiered start time at 9:05 which is our high schools
096which opens up the operating time it still creates compression from our current system system but creates a little bit of wiggle room based upon what you saw in option one I misspoke by saying everybody moved back 30 minutes I think why I wanted to restate that is an option one and option two our high school start times would stay the same sorry about that Dave this kind of goes back to another related issue is that what's the virtue of only having so I'm looking at Option One for instance we've got on a three-tier system we have uh roughly 141 which is an increase uh a significant increase from the current for a three- tier to run it's roughly 3.2 but yet for a two-tier it reduces the amount of buses understand and that is that
097what yields the savings so the virtue of doing less tiers means less drivers less buses less routes yeah the two-tiered option on this one was a little perplexing to me too because it actually went the opposite way that you would expect right um I think there was I'd have to go back and dig into the actual data analysis but I think there was some interesting d Dynamics is the as we were running the the route analysis where it actually redid it um I think there was some Savings in there that we had but uh but yeah both of the scenarios were still fairly excessive to what we're doing currently and it's flip for option two which is what's confusing to me because it it seems like you're reducing the tiers is more expensive there and
098less expensive for three tier yeah I mean I mean this is this is the data modeling and and the routing the way it the way it works it's it's not just it's not always exactly as you would expect because there's a lot of detail that's going into there um but I I think what we're really trying to identify here is the what's happening is that as we compress and extend for the most part except for some example on that maybe that two-tiered system in option one um for the most part um that has a direct impact on the number of buses and routes that we need to do um so again this is exploration um we can take any of these explore them deeper go go deeper with them we can also explore other options
099too as well sorry just to be the stickler go for it got a lot of questions about this um so in those models and if you this is probably yes or no at this point do those costs include anticipated overtime for the workforce you have if their day is elongated by x amount because that's that 1.5 multiplier will add up quickly do you understand what I mean yeah I do no I I don't believe so because we're still staying within I mean we're still trying to keep our bus drivers in a 40 hour week I'm with you but I'm looking at the bus return especially in option three being six to 630 and there's I understand it sort of you have a start shift and an end shift we got let's go let's go through
100option three because that that's the last one that we that we should go through um because it is different than options one and two it's it's a different approach can I take a stab at Option One really quick though because I think I understand why three tier would be more expensive than two I got you um so when you only have 65 minutes a bus driver can't necessarily get to the third tier so you're hiring somebody extra to do that extra third Drive whereas in two tiers One driver could possibly do more of those routes because they have enough time in two tiers in that hour to do more in that scenario right I mean I I don't think I'm not I'm not saying that it makes sense I'm just saying this is what the
101data produced right um I I I don't think we would want to be actionable on that because that's yeah um option three um option three is is similar to option one in which we um increased the start times from that 7:30 to 8 and then again what's interesting here is we actually moved the the third tier system or the third tier start time up to 9:35 in this case Okay um over here um what that did and and again we explored this this doesn't mean that we want to do this um but what what this does is it allows for a bus return of you know the 6 to 6:30 time frame um and then what we're looking at is going back to our kind of our extended 95 minutes because we just basically moved
102everything forward by by that time so we just picked it up and moved it um the result of that because we're still at the 95 minutes the the result of a three- tiered system is we'd be right where we are are now okay um the two-tiered system obviously we're compressing and we just talked about some of the Dynamics with the data that how that works and so in that s system we would need to add another 18 18 bus routes to that or about $2.1 million um but why we approached it this was this way was it gave it us a flavor of how things flowed now obviously the devil's in the details on some of these um but it it gives you at least some understanding of where you might want to go um
103because you can start to see how stretching time impacts things also compressing the whole day has has cost implications versus stretching the day out has cost implications or lack of cost implications um let's go to this last slide and then and then we're going to definitely do discussion that's necessary um and and have time for for all of that um so so the option implications here are um again option one um 8 830 and 905 starts in a three-tiered model and then eight 9005 starts in a two-tiered model and and what that showed was a fairly significant increase no matter how you sliced it um regardless of that the how those played out on between the one and three and two tiers it was still a 19 to 25% increase no matter how we looked
104at that and so so that would be a challenge for us um but it's it's a data point to look at option two is kind of that Middle Road um where we move mov from 7:30 to 745 the next tier would be 825 and then the third tier would be 905 um and that's in the three tiered model and then very similar 745 and 9005 for the two-tiered model um in in this case uh they were both pretty close so I just called it 8% increase in bus drivers um they're they're very similar in that in that situation that would be kind of where we're at and then the last one this option three is again the one where we actually shift the entire day so instead of starting at 7:30 we start at 8
1058:45 and then 9:35 um and then we would be coming back um we would have to shift those start times at the the top end so that's that's that the end times of 435 and 440 um when we would actually be ending the day and picking kids up um so so in this situation here um that was that model that was because we just move the day forward there was really not an increase in the number of buses and drivers that would necessary because we're doing what we do now where the implications on this one really start to impact is what happens when you start shifting that that day later um and and especially for high school activities Athletics that could be a challenge and something that we need to explore deeper if we were
106going to want to explore any of these options further um that is a summary of the at least the work that we've done to this point um we can continue to do more iteration um on on this but uh but really before we go into questions um I thought I'd just kind of summarize at least kind of some of the conversations that that I've been thinking about as I was putting this together and and I I can't help but blend the budget into most of what I do because I live and breathe budget all the time that's where I was born right um so I just want to remind us our budget situation is still serious um we continue to decline in kids um that's going to be a strain on our budget and and
107we're going to talk more about budget all through the next couple months um we've talked a little bit about the state is dealing with a billion dollar shortfall um and we've already seen how the state is talking about changing the averaging um to basically introduce a new budget stabilization factor or a reduction for K12 again um that is most that is highly likely that that's going to happen um the last piece that and this is just a reality on where we're at it's not to say we're always going to be here um but as we were talking in the community about 4 a um it was very clear to all of us that were engaging in that that our bus fleet is in really bad shape um we talked about an average age of 15
108years for a bus and I talked a lot about to get to an average of 15 that means you have to have a really old bus in your service and you're still running it to get to an average of 15 um so why I mention this is when we're talking about adding buses right now our last order of buses that we put in two years ago we still have not received there are significant supply chain shortages in buses um we just recently couple weeks ago put out a a solicitation because of 4A um we put out a solicitation where we're asking vendors to provide us pricing on up to 17 buses to see what that would look like um at that time when we open that and start to look at that solicitation I think
109we're going to start to get a feel for what the supply issue is um we really we really challenged ourselves in transportation to think a little differently about this um one of the challenges that we had with the fleet is at one point we decided to standardize to International brand of buses that's not helping us in this supply chain issue so we re went back and rethought that and said okay yes there's challenges to having multiple types of buses but we can overcome them um so we are actually asking vendors to provide us inventory that they have and we will actually probably select as long as it's within within reason we will probably go with something that's a little higher price than low bid if they have the inventory and they can get it to
110us quickly um we'll have to make a more informed decision when we look at that we'll share that when we bring that to the board it's a large purchase you would need to be involved in the approval of that if we decided to move forward with it but why I bring this up is because when I was talking about bell times with the staff um the one that probably got the most scared was um our the our maintenance manager Dan Weaver and because he knows that he is cobbling these buses together every day and we come in and there's a bus that doesn't run I just saw one come in on a tow truck like this our bus fleet is in it needs attention the way we get out of that is by buying some
111buses and starting to move that direction but adding any bus routes at this time is going to be really really challenging not to say that we're always going to be there but that is just the current state right now so bringing kind of that lens of not only what can we do procurement wise what's going on in the budget um I think that helps us have a deeper conversation around this presentation and the data exploration that we did could take any discussion and questions thank you Dave um Scott you've got a question go forward yeah so um Dave thank you so much for exploring this this is something that I've been concerned about since we voted on it last year I think two of us were Nos and I was hopeful that it would only
112last a year and I see it in my own neighborhood it is brutal uh to I'll walk the dogs at 7:15 and there's a line of cars and really pissed off parents and kids being up that early it's it's rough um those middle school starts so um I was very excited that Julie wiel decided to come and speak tonight she was um on the district Advisory board for many years when Jessica and I were there and I think the heart of her time there was when this Middle School start time and high school start time discussion happened and there was a lot of uh presentations about the science behind um later starts I saw it with my own kids you know that those middle school and high school years are really tough to get them
113moving in the morning Kristen you've talked about that with your own kids um so I'm very much excited about the idea of possibly bumping this back if if it makes sense to everybody um you mentioned the decline of enrollment I think the early start times might be a a small factor in a kid or a parent choosing maybe to change it it would have to be a whole bunch of factors to to move out of the school but I think this is hurting a lot of families um teachers as well I just if it what did Julie say people are getting there before seven I I want to work that early you I don't know how these teachers are doing that so if they can find a different School District that doesn't have this kind
114of start time I think that would be a factor so so I'm liking I'm I know we're not voting on things but I'm liking what option three looks like my only concern would be the athletic um not just Athletics but the after school activities I know kids that are in athletic sometimes have to miss their last period so that might solve that anyhow uh and then on the beginning of the day if there's elementary school starting at 8:45 parents work schedules I I worry about that a little bit too and I know it's like between 8 and 845 that they would be starting so I do worry about those work schedules but I think we have um staff that would be there to kind of oversee kids um in different programs and stuff like that
115so I I just wanted to throw all those ideas out there uh no particular question except I'd like to see more exploration about what the impacts would be on those after school activities yeah and we would definitely need to do that exploration because that's a if that's a big part of it that we have not looked at can ask a question and get into a few points uh piggy back exactly on that one thought that I had which I've heard before is not my own idea is that there's there's some pretty compelling data to suggest that um the pre high schoolers the middle schoolers are the the category that need the most sleep as they're developing prepubescent wise and so one thought is if we're going to run into a problem with extracurriculars for high
116school by elongating the day into free why not flip the high school middle school tiers and have Middle School start the later start time and High School start at the 8:45 sort of sweet spot and the thinking there being is that not all high schoolers but a lot of high schoolers have not only extracurriculars but they have jobs they have their own transportation it's not nearly as much of a burden if they're staying in that sort of Middle Ground than it would be for say middle schoolers right um but as I'm talking this out so that's that's one question is has that been explored and starting just flipping those we did not explore it but I I think understanding how the data was moving I I think conceptually there's the opportunity to basically flip tier
117one and three right like you would flip those and and it wouldn't cause a I think we need to explore it deeper and understand how it actually works worked but theoretically that's similar to what we're doing it's just changing that tier one and three I like any I'm a proponent of that I like that at least that I'm curious so I'll leave that there um I'll say my own piece about 7:30 and it's not just because there's I'm one of those parents in the drop off line at 7:45 um here's some other things that are actually real concerns for folks that are dealing with at 7:30 I know it looks like we're getting to abandon that but I'm going to push one further and say no nothing before 8 to me is acceptable um working
118parents have to juggle figuring out how to get kids to school at that time some of the working parents work at Weber some of the working parents are teachers there they can't drop their own kids off at daycare early enough to get to their assigned post because of that that's a challenge and that's a real thing that people are having to wrestle with and principal is having to wrestle with so I don't want to speak out of turn on that but I'm using Weber as an example there um I use my own maybe TMI but for a lot of lot of times we sort of neglect students with special needs when we're having this conversation and oh it's just early yeah but what does that mean for a student that has to have medication to
119be released in time for it to be effective in time for first period because I've had to struggle with that and then exploring if medicine that is a slowly release the night before is covered by Insurance thereby creating another challenge on top of everything all because of a start time that's that's a real conversation that I have in my household and having to have conversations with teachers about this and I mean that is a very difficult thing to have to navigate all because of a start time that seems I I understand why we did it I voted for it too and understand the savings that we got I'm glad we did it stand by it anything before 8 I think is is too early um especially when you're looking at other other choice schools in
120our district that are not just our PSD footprint but our Charter Schools their elementary schools are offering 8 o00 start times and I've had you know anecdotal the best but I've had conversations with with some parents asking why why aren't you considering neighborhood school why aren't you considering this too early this one starts at8 that works better for my schedule that works better for my kids schedule so these are all I know we kind of I want to add some voice to them and add some color to the reasoning why 7:30 or even before 8 is just for me not a deal breaker and I think that I'm so glad that at least there's one option that looks like a financial net neutral to me I think that's another huge compelling point for all the
121reasons you just articulated Dave is that we have to be mindful that we've got a fleet that is depreciating the second it drives off but also it's too old so we're going to need some money to purchase some new vehicles so we need to be exploring the financially prudent one as a board it which is trying to find that net neutral while still reconciling that start time so that's where I'm at and I I really like so far what I'm learning about option three yeah I I think the you know we said this before that the challenge with option three is the activities in that that day but we I think we've clearly talked about that great thank you yeah other question did you want to go add I mean I just have comments so
122well one I had the same thought around Middle School and High School switching them to alleviate the after school activities for high school we've also heard in stack a number of students having to miss that last period and having that be rough when they start at nine now so that potentially actually fixes some level of a problem for the some students at least um and the other thing is I currently have the seventh grader going to school at at 7:30 and Elementary starts at 9:05 it's a fun spread um yeah so every morning is rough and every evening is rough and it's luckily my husband works from home and I have a weird schedule that we make it work and we have a good support system but neither of our kids can take a bus
123and I want every kid similar what Julie said every kid that needs a bus I want them to have it but this is a it's really really difficult to have kids with that level of a spread in their day especially when they're having a really hard time in the morning waking up and it's really difficult to get them to go to bed at a reasonable time at night because 7:30 is too early I'm with you on anything before 8 is too early for kids so lots of other thoughts Dave thank you so much um I I also had written down can reverse high school and middle school um and and see if that would help um alleviate some of that because the middle schoolers may have after school activities but typically um don't have jobs
124that would go um you know like have a dinner shift at a restaurant or something like that um that they would need to be there by 5 which I think a lot of high schoolers would um but what I'm noticing too is that there's that 95 minute spread and that's what keeps us neutral net neutral right is that 95 minute spread so there is a possibility of doing and it's not going to make anybody happy but there's a possibility of doing a 745 to a 920 correct like we could bump at 15 I think we can explore multiple iterate yeah we can what's that put options yeah sure thing because what I'm thinking is that yeah if you go if you do that 90 minute spread and then you did a 745 what you're you
125know suggesting yeah yeah it would be a 920 right because it would be 95 minutes um so a 920 end that would still be net neutral because it's that 95 minute spread um and it would have the high schoolers end at um between 4:15 and 420 right yeah everything you said is conceptually right I think the devil's always in the details of looking the data and seeing where the routes lie because we did get some extraneous things because of that but I think everything you said makes sense so I'm just wondering if there's if there's room to play with that as well even even if it's you know 10 to 8 you know 750 109 you know uh 25 or something like like that where it's still that 95 minute window um but you know
126to to make it um cost neutral but it gives us at least another 15 or 20 minutes in the morning it still gives us that you know that afternoon could be an issue but I think also if we were to SW if if it's possible to swap um the middle school high school um that that would really that could be really beneficial thank you yeah yeah go ahead is there well do you have an idea of when we could get in update or like I mean I would like it tomorrow if that were possible but I know that's not realistic it it takes a little bit to run the data um and I think it also depends on if our Consultants available or not that just so happened they had a little bit of time
127available in January to really peel off and do this um I suspect they're getting fairly good at it at this point um so we could run some more scenarios I I think that one of the things that I I mean we've looked at this from the Transportation realm and what might be possible I think what we need to do is also start thinking about okay if we're going to explore some of these other options what are the other ramifications are and explore those deeper we need to bring it all together I think go ahead Connor um when's the drop dead you would need to know from the board to make a decision or to vote in order to tell schools so they could fold that in because one thing I'm also hearing too is that
128you know our community was was pretty upset with the disruption that we did to the bell schedule last year understandably so but if we're going to do it again it's that they the need for continuity and predictability and so as school leaders going back to planning as they're marketing their schools their neighborhood schools incoming they need to know what those start times are going to be yeah I'm I'm G Dr G do you mind jump in minute yeah I sure can so it's probably too late for next school year um one of the things that makes it too late for next school year is that we've just finished the first round of choice so a lot of people chose you know their next school for next year based on the start times that we have
129published right now and so that would cause you know people could re-enter the choice process based on a revised Bell time but they may not get the choice that they want then because the reordering now that we go into second round changes their priorities so that's probably the first implication the second implication is is um schools are starting our secondary schools are starting their configuration packets and their configuration packets are essentially their schedules for the year and so those have to be built so kids can you know do their courses we have to verify um seat time and there's quite a bit that goes into that those configuration packets are due in the next couple two three weeks somewhere around that so for next school year so if yes yep sorry Conor this was supposed
130to be quick the earlier the better probably still good but I mean I'm I'm wondering how much lead time we would need in order to do a year in advance because for the same reason yeah for that same reason we open the School of Choice window November first for then the following year so we would want to have a decision before that no to kind of follow up on that um I think last time we visited this I flipped my lid pretty well on on that same thing um it's the continuity for the community and when we keep changing this it doesn't send the right signals whatsoever to but for Dave I mean we can create scenarios and run all this stuff but speaking for myself any scenario that raises cost I won't vote for
131we don't have the money so it may sound nice to do this and run that but if it's going to increase cost no thanks um other thing on that is all during last year and running up to 4A we heard multiple times from the community that Local Schools were important and that the city has made investments in safe roots to schools and that begs the question of are we actually putting too many kids on the bus in my neighborhood I can see the school from my back porch my kids are eligible for the bus that should not happen right we need to look at moving the zone for kids who qualify for the bus or at least run a scenario on it how it moves it back and the reason for that is because we're
132investing in Local Schools if the school is nice and close to your house right and I I don't know what that is you know is it is that one mile 1.5 miles whatever we want to decide on if it's close to your house and we're investing in it to keep it open we are also saying to you you've got to utilize the additional facilities from the city for safe roots to school um a lot of parents said that last time and last but not least at least on on that very thing is I think having kids off the bus especially at that Middle School level is really good for their sense of belonging they stick around school a little bit longer they ride their bikes with their friends they walk home with their friends they
133don't hear the last bell get on the bus go home and go online and I think that's really real important to think of those things when we're thinking about these changes as well thank you Connor other yeah I I think it was about this time last year that we made the decision so I'm kind of struggling with it was appropriate to make this decision last year at this time with a commitment that we were going to look at it this year to only do this for one year and now we're saying it's too late to actually make a consideration and a change for next year so that doesn't sit well with me um two we talk about continuity and predictability I don't know that teachers can consistently feel that there's a predictability of whether or
134not their students are going to show up to their first hour class I don't know that students are consistently getting getting a continuity of Education if they're not physically there on time so I understand it being difficult to make shifts for next year I I don't know if I completely Buy in into we have no options for next year yeah I sorry uh I was just going to try to look it up do we know the date that we've did that vote I was just trying to look it up but it was definitely in the second semester so I think the feedback that you are providing is absolutely Fair it I think we can all look back and say that the decision that we made while I believe fiscally responsible and financially necessary a year
135ago was not ideal in terms of timing because as Dr guile articulated the implications on scheduling on all of the choice we went through all of that messiness last year does that mean we can't do it again no we could it's not ideal though and I would also say that we continue to 4 a has helped provide some Financial stabilization where we're not in the pressure cooker that we were a year ago but we also recognize that the financial challenges that Dave uh articulated but whether it's declining enrollment changes at our state legislature or with our governor's office changes that are being proposed on a daily basis right now from the federal government are all kind of weighing into uh all of our thinking as a governance team and as a staff around our ability
136to pull some of these things off but I think you all have provided and we certainly want to continue the feedback if you have it tonight provid add us some feedback that can lead to immediate actions of getting on the horn with our consulting company and say hey we've heard from many board members tonight that option three was palatable but we want to see what that might look like um if we flip middle schools and high schools I think president Draper articulated looking at option two but considering moving option two back 15 minutes and seeing what that might mean while also flipping middle schools and high schools I hear director Duffy saying look at all of those things but also look at the radi of what creates eligibility for transportation to see if you can
137play around with that you didn't use the term play but you know move that around to see if there's ways of maintaining Financial efficiencies while still providing close access to whether it's Walkers people who are within certain proxim so I think those are three tangible options I think the other piece of this story that I'm curious to get some feedback from you all is how to engage our families because I think one of the things that I'm just workshopping in my mind as you're ideating is the implications of moving our high schools to the first tier um would be something that would be a shift to I think we would want to know how our high school families would find that on the back back end of that if we move our middle schools and
138I'm not saying this is me being very neutral but I think a piece of this story that I think we would want to be curious and investigate with our families is our Middle School age students while I do believe at Alliance to research to have them in tier three they're not independent and able to drive on their own so in the event that their school start time was whether it's an option 2 9:20 or at the latest at 9:35 and they were not eligible for a bus or we would need to think through what are the potential implications of that and ask families I believe uh around what that impact might be to understand but maybe you know I'm curious if you agree with that or if you think differently so we can work in
139partnership with each other and next steps moving forward I 100% agree that we need to get that feedback one of the biggest pieces of feedback we got Beyond um 7:30 is too early is that high schoolers were saying that 4:15 is too late so that was you know that there were two big pieces and it was one was too early and the high schools all said we get out too late we can't go to work we can't do extracurriculars we miss not only our last class but sometimes half of our second and last class so yes we need to get their input on it if we can flip that so that it's you know Middle School um it's High School than Middle School we absolutely also need to find out what families think about that
140because yeah that that would indicate that most likely a sixth and seventh and eighth grader would have to get themselves to the bus stop or get themselves to school because people may already be at work you know if it's a 910 start or something um so that would that is definitely something that we would need to to talk to parents about um and I think we need to know I think that may be putting the cart before the horse we need to know if this is viable um first first off if this if the if the swap is is viable we need to know um if it's cost neutral um to do that that sort of thing um and even if we were to do the 945 to 925 um so essentially option two but
141extend it to the 95 minutes um we still need to ask that um for our high schoolers if we cannot flip that um because that that pushes them back yet another 15 minutes so I think we definitely need to that but I would I to me the first priority is find out if those are even viable um and then if they are and we decide that we like the cost neutral um you know and then it's a deciding of what to do then I think it's going going ahead and getting engagement in that yes go ahead um Just for information um I did look up that we got an information review about this on the sixth of February last year we actually didn't vote until the till March 5th so I think you're right Brian
142that you know it's painful and I I understand exactly what you're saying Tracy but I would hope that we could possibly change it for next year um given the feedback we've been getting so just want to give you that context go ahead Kevin yeah and two things on that quickly I was surprised by I'm not it makes sense exactly what you said but it was surprising the sense that I I thought what we were voting on last year and what we had told our community was that this is a one-time pain we would revisit and make it different in there com so to me it feels a bit um I I it doesn't sit well with me if we're going to say ah it's too late I mean I would I wish I would have
143known that when I was going into my vote last year so I'll just say that um the other data point that I think is worth putting into this discussion I understand we're sort of like stretching the beginning and and and pulling the end but elementary school kids get out if you're at 7:45 I'll use olander you're done at 2:20 there is probably 5% of the working adults in this community whose work day ends at 2:20 so there's a reason why a lot of kids are stuck on buses Connor I'm one of them we put our kid on the afternoon bus even though we absolutely he could he's close enough he's too little to walk home from oand or by himself he's getting there but he's too little so it's a safety challenge my wife and
144I don't have the luxury of being able to take PTO every single day to greet our kid and to pick him up not a lot of people do so it puts an incredible strain especially so we're talking about the nipping and tucking elementary school kids that's to me that's where the transportation needs to be focused because those are P I would I would bet that your data suggests that those are the primary users of our our transportation and I think what we're talking about in start time yes painful for high schoolers they have other options they're older they can use public transit they more autonomous they they have more Transportation options so I it's not that I'm less concerned with their end time but I think the pain point of an exit for an elementary
145in the beginning of an elementary is far more poignant than that of a high schooler that's that's my I mean I see my neighbors across the street driving themselves to school or and carping other kids to school I did it too so I I think that that's it's worth considering I totally agree but for the the captive audience of the kids who literally have no other options either mom and dad are taking them or they're on the bus and that's kind of it I think that should drive a lot of our decision making honor I agree and I think there's some kids that maybe not all kids especially kids with special needs they're always going to qualify for a bus um you know maybe I have free range kids but you know kindergarteners in in
146Beth key they do walk home um and they do cross the railroad tracks so and it is pretty and I will say the the local infrastructure um around Beth Key School is not the norm so they're not Crossing major roads um however I I think it's worth investigating um the other thing that I would say as far as timing on the on the change is we're not going to make everybody in the community happy on this right we we heard that last time and you know it's what decision do we make that is for the majority of the people that this is palatable for I think any change is unpalatable just because we've had so many changes but if we are going to make another one then let's really focus on you know making sure
147that this decision encompasses the as many people as we can from high school all the way down to kindergarten because I think we're going to get we're going to get a lot of emails and a lot of public comment saying you know well now my my kid can't work after school you know my kid is you know they're no longer at school crosswalk in the morning but they're leaving school late at night where it's also dark and you can see the stars type thing so I think we should just be cognizant of the fact that we're not going to please everybody on this um and we'll we'll make a decision on us yeah anything else great you I want to invite I haven heard I haven't spoken up I'm learning a lot from the par
148parents here thank you um I also like the option of uh switching the high school and the middle schools because the Athletics I know at the high school level are a uh a big issue so that's one thing uh Kristen you made a comment about the U middle schooler needing to get themselves to school but I don't know they either need to get themselves to school or they need to get themselves home right because it just slides back and forth so uh I would love for some quick analysis on option three flipping the the high school and the middle school and see where we can go thank you yeah I think so I think what we're hearing is cause neutral and let's look at um flipping those High School Middle School possibilities um and you
149know I think I would just add is let's not do change for change sake um I don't know that shifting everybody 10 or 15 minutes um for the sake of changing it because we said we would I don't know if that's the the way to go um maybe it is maybe that's what comes out is you know we we do a 745 to 925 and it saves US money I don't know um maybe the high schoolers would love it the middle schoolers would love it um but I think we need to be just very mindful as to what we're changing how we're changing it um and why so that's till next time I have one more comment though okay I think 15 minutes before 8 A.M is a very different ask than 15 minutes after
1508 a.m. 15 minutes before 8 a.m. feels I you can come to my house any day no well no I was just say it's like an hour versus 15 minutes from 8:45 to 9 not as much of a problem like not the feeling is different well I personally don't disagree I think the high schoolers would very much disagree so that's that's this is where this is where it is you know it's it's very difficult so I don't think there's an easy solution here and I'm just naming that so um anything else so I just want to recap if that's just really briefly just to make sure that we're all aligned um I I think I've heard loud and clear that we are being charged as a staff appropriately So based on the promises and assurances
151of how this was framed a year ago that we're going to continue to EXP exp efficiencies and study this um in the event that there is an opportunity to execute and a plan that you all support for next school year we're going to do everything in our power to get you the information and engage our community in a way that does that thoughtfully I would be remissed if I didn't share that I am concerned about our staff's capacity to do that that is not an excuse it is me just leaning into the realization of the multitude of challenges that we continue to Grapple with we were dealing with different challenges Alles a year ago there are nuanced this year and we will figure that out together but you have a shared commitment from our team
152to provide you updated information as soon as possible we'll contact the consulting firm this week to identify how to expedite that I don't know the band not the bandwidth I don't know how long it would take to study the implications on changing the radi of eligibility for buses I think that may be a multi-year effort that and would have more of a significant Community impact um but I am committed to looking at that because I think there may be Financial efficiencies while maybe also finding a palatable Sweet Spot in compromise that doesn't negatively impact our families as much as possible um there are trade-offs here that the implications of the looking into this effort does not uh override the implications on families as you articulated on our teachers and staff and leaders today so we're
153going to need to try to figure out that together but I think we have what we need based upon the feedback that you provided to come back in short order with this is what we learned based upon the direction around option three the fine tuning around option two um and then seeing if it's feasible to flip those two uh groupings um I want us to be clear that none of the feedback nor those options adjusted the current elementary school structures where that you will have elementary schools on all three of our tiers they just obviously would have a later start time and a later end time but I feel like that was kind of the feedback that you were all explicit about am I missing anything cost neutrality was also a priority of this group
154especially while our Fleet it remains in its current state we are going to as Dave shared continue to aggressively pursue upgrading and enhancing our Fleet and adding to it um but we know that's going to take a little bit of time but I'm really proud of the efforts the staff is taking to reimagine our historic approach um which will have um I think it'll it's a good thing that we're doing that I've I've have a thought and this might be a good compromise for you Connor because it's something that I've been very passionate about we've talked about um superintendent Kingsley about the way I want to frame this is eligibility for busing and um I think you make good points and I think I don't want to diminish those by saying that I stick my
155kid on the bus although I do because of the time crunch that we're but I do think you're right I I do I think we need to maybe re-examine this may be a longer process this may be a two-year analysis and and not this time crunch but thinking thoughtfully about who should be on our buses who should be eligible for our buses and including our schools of choice in that as well because that's something that I've been very passionate about for an equity lens is kids that would otherwise go to a lesser or go to a 100% Choice school but don't have the means of the transportation to do that what can we do can we make some determinations based on some savings that we may draw out of this so I think that's that's
156an appropriate ask I think but maybe not right now if that's I don't know if that's would that be okay Connor go ahead Conor yeah Kristen and I had spoken about this I I forget under another conversation and the the equity piece because I think that there's multiple students and families in our district who would like to explore all the choice options that we have and they can't be because they're not eligible for the BS good so I just want to say thank you I feel like this has been one of those conversations that I have been very invested in for a year and have lots of feelings about but I really really do appreciate the work I appreciate the context around timing I appreciate the work around the transportation and the fact that I
157mean one thing I wrote down was we've not actually had to cut service or have lack of service for kids like I was trying to remind myself like we did this for really good reasons right we saved money we gave Transportation some breathing room so that people could actually do their job during the day during their actual working hours we have you know more consistent bus drivers like there's a lot of good reasons why we did it it's still something I'm going to continue to be passionate about changing but I just wanted to put out there I do appreciate your work and thank you so much for the amount of effort that's gone into it and continuing to put the effort into it because I still think it's important but thanks okay anyone else all
158right in the words of a former board member ditto okay moving on to 10.0 executive session can I get a motion go ahead Kevin I move the board on our executive session for the purpose of receiving legal advice on specific questions relating to civil action Number One D or one colon 23 CV 02 546 RMR nrn as authorized by CR 246 424b individuals invited to join the board and executive session our superintendent Brian Kingsley Chief of Staff Dr Lauren hooden Chief Financial Officer Dave monya lead assistant superintendent Dr Tracy guile and general counsel Autumn Asin okay can I get a second Connor Thank you all right Joe can you call the vote Jim brokish hi Kristen Draper hi Connor Duffy hi Kevin havelda hi Scott Shan I Jessica Zamora I motion passes 60 okay we
159will now convene in a closed session this is the last agenda item before adjournment at the conclusion of the executive session we will adjourn the meeting the adjournment will be recorded let's meet in there in let's give it 10 minutes so quarter till e