CorpusRecord 87706

Board of Education Meeting: December 10, 2024 (Spanish Captions)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PSD On Demand
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Larimer County, CO
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,448 words · about 142 min
Collected
2026-06-15

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right we're going to go ahead and get started thank you so thank you for joining us the uh joining the Board of Education this evening please M mute your cell phone as we begin this meeting today is Tuesday December 10th 2024 and this meeting is now called to order at 6:30 p.m. um would you all please stand in and join me in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance thank you all right would any board members like to make changes to the agenda okay seeing none we will move on to our 4.0 recognitions and reports um so we just want to recog uh like to invite all of those who are being recognized tonight to stay for a group photo at the end of the very last recognition so uh we'll go through

002uh several of them and then we'll do a group photo at the end if we could thanks and then we have so thank you tonight we are excited to celebrate excellence in The District in the areas of Education Sports and Humanity leading the celebration is our executive director of communications John cope welcome John good evening president Draper superintendent Kingsley and board directors we welcome everyone in our audience including those watching online tonight we'll have three recognitions and I'm excited to introduce our first of the night which is Zack Elementary School for earning their second National Blue Ribbon award I'd like to invite Angel herck to the podium it looks like a lot but we have two minutes that's will be quick hi um my name is Angel herck The Proud principal of Zach Elementary and

003these are some of our teachers and students and what we recognized was you know we had the governor come visit we've had a lot of celebrations but our students have not had a chance to speak yet um so we give them that opportunity the question that I ask our crew is to say your name first and then what is one thing you're proud of or you love about Zach or yourself my name is l my name is Lucas I'm 5 years old I I'm in Zach cuz I have the best teacher ever she taught me to learn and write great thank you my name is parisha I'm I because they're loving teachers okay we do not this is all from the hip so we'll see my name is Dylan I am 8 years old and

004I like Zach because it inspires us to be creative and it inspires us to use our imagination and it also inspires us to show RAR which means being responsible organized attend and respectful good Joby my name is Remy and what I love about Zach is it's a very welcoming place um no matter what you no matter who you are you'll always be welcome [Applause] [Music] my name is Eduardo I love Z because it's the best school I have ever had hi my name is in seeking Cadence and I'm fifth grade and one thing I like about zck is the community because they motivate and motivation is the key to learning Ken I'm Laura actor and I'm English language teacher and I just love that diversity is celebrated at Zach and all of the kids learn

005from where they're at my name is Julie gr and I'm a first grade teacher at Zach and what I love most is the community and parental support we receive every day thank you all so much for this recognition next I'd like to congratulate Tim nith Middle High School's track and cross country teams for their state championships I'd like to invite Jesse moral [Applause] toi all right thank you so much for having us here here tonight we're excited to celebrate um some really incredible accomplishments athletically um here at our school um Emily Dunn our athletic and I were just remember when we were here about three and a half years ago we got to present uh to the board um about the naming of the school and the mascot and the colors and that really did

006kind of kick off our journey um and over that time span we've had a lot of growth a lot of just incredible achievement um hard work from our students and staff um and some really great things that have happened happen and it's really incredible but this is a unique accomplishment um that I want to start with recognizing Emily dun so she's over here on the end she's our athletic director um yes give her a round of applause Emily has done an amazing job of really building an Athletics program from scratch by hiring incredible coaches and really being focused on a character-based program where we strive to win which we got we we we're winning some and this is an example um but without making that the purpose and really purpose of the program is about

007supporting students with building work ethic um competing with character building sportsmanship um and just kind of um creating some Transcendent experiences that you'll take through your life that are going to help you with whatever you do um Beyond sports but um part of how she's done that is by hiring incredible coaches and our coach um Matt miltenberg he is our track coach and our Cross Country Coach he's also a counselor at our school and was a part of our implementation team really was instrumental in helping us create a vision for the school um and really think about what what we what all about at outh in terms of our character our culture um and the learning that happens within our school so we're really lucky um to have Matt as um as our head track

008coach and head Cross Country Coach um and he has done an amazing job he's just like the perfect coach to kind of build a program um that's that's character based on the way that we've envisioned so um so he is now going to take over and recognize all these incredible student athletes for their accomplishments in this past spring and fall Matt mber thank you um yeah our vision at uh 10 for building our cross country teams has been to to build a tradition that is competitive and inclusive um with an emphasis on um character and a team first mentality and and that team first mentality has led to some great team results so last spring our girl track was the 2A Colorado state champions they scored 131 points one point shy of doubling um Second

009Place Heritage Christian 66 points um and that was led with five event championships so five state championships um led by individual championships in the 300 hurdles by Addy getts and repeat state champion in the 800 meters Natalie wasburn and then the true story was our dominance in the relays um with our girls combining uh we had Natalie wasburn Izzy shimble fennick asley Stone and Jensen d'angeles winning the state championship our second in the 4X 800 met and then Emily vulker Hannah Bitner Alex mcnight and Lily ice burer teaming up to win both the 4x100 met and the 4x200 meter relays as well um this fall we moved up in Cross Country to the 4A division um and uh yeah as news spread about these These Girls and the great environment that they make uh for

010a team our team almost tripled in size um and uh starting in mid-september they they went on a run um with and did not lose again until the November state championships where they um won taking first place over second place Battle Mountain High School um Izzy shl fenic earned her third All State first team honors um after winning the conference and Regional crowns as well um she finished third at the state meet Addie Garretts turned in another top 10 finish finishing ninth and earning second Team all state honors um and then all five of our scorers including Louisa stri Natalie wasburn and Rachel Dietrich earned All State honorable mention honors um and gray Jordan and Jensen d'angeles um completed our Championship Squad all seven of those ladies plus em baky um earned All Conference first

011team honors for eight All Conference first team honors on that team um it's been a magical ride with these young ladies and we're just super excited to see um them compete again this spring thanks so much for recognizing them our final recognition of the evening will be Drake Jenkins for his heroic efforts and recognition from Denver Health paramedic division for assisting a woman who is trapped under her car at this time Emily Dunn will explain a little more about Drake J all well let me introduce you to Drake Jenkins Drake is uh is standing right next to me he is a junior at Tim school um and is just an allaround great young man um has just an excellent student um he's a star baseball player um for our our again upand cominging baseball program

012and just a really great example of character um always doing the right thing modeling the way um he's been a great leader at our school just by the way that he acts and conducts himself um but this fall he did something um really remarkable um and we got an email from man named will Dunn with the Denver Health a Denver Health paramedic who wanted us to know about this heroic action that Drake took um I don't think he would have ever told anybody other than I think he told his parents what happened but um but he's just a humble guy who who probably wouldn't have shared the story otherwise but um but here it is so Drake was on his way to DIA earlier this fall he was actually driving himself there he was meeting

013his parents in California for a um a nonprofit event for a cancer charity um which is pretty awesome so he was out there doing good things um giving his time um in a volunteer way already um when he got there he's driving into the par the parking area at DIA um when he noticed that there was a woman in trouble um the woman had pulled too far past the ticket dispenser and so she put her car in Reverse to back up to reach it um she was still too far away to pull a ticket so she opened her car door to reach it and then her foot came off the brake and her car moved moved started going in reverse um she actually fell out of the vehicle and under the in under the vehicle

014and she had some significant injuries as a result of that Drake was right behind her um he got out of his car um realized what was happening and intervened he was able to get into the woman's car get it to stop and then rendered assistance to her until Dia Emergency Services got there his quick actions most certainly prevented further injury and likely saved her life um this quote from will Dunn um the paramedic he said I'm not sure he realized then or if he realizes now that he placed himself in Peril to do what he did he risked his own safety to come to the aid of a stranger um will dun is also nominating Drake for a civilian life- saving Award with the city of Denver um and we were just so impressed and

015amazed to hear the story um and it lines up with who he's been at our school that this is something that Drake would do so we appreciate um the board allowing us to recognize Drake in this way um in a public inform formal way um and we are just very proud that that he's with us and that he's a cub Dr thank [Applause] you PSD congratulates all of those who are honored here tonight and this concludes our recognitions I want to invite everyone recognized and our board directors and superintendent to join us down for a group photo please elementary kids over here with me we'll be right out front sit down track great job I bet you're always saying excuse me I've to move my trophy sorry tropy we good aesome congratulations everybody wel done

016[Applause] you sure you don't want to stay you can do job I'll go home in theair 30 years okay next time well before we head into our next one of superintendent report I just want to take a point of privilege to say just how impressive that was um you know when we talk about what PSD is doing and the great work that they are doing notice that everything that we just talked about was about character it was about what people are doing for each other what people are doing for strangers and that is what is P PSD is all about and that is what makes us so unique and just these kids so so very impressive and I just want to say thank you it's really an honor to be here and now we have

017a superintendent report that was a really nice segue so thank you president Draper um good evening everybody it's great to be with all of you tonight I agree with President Draper that was incredibly inspiring and I'm sure that you know my heart is swollen as a result of just being associated with good human beings like that uh I want to acknowledge uh on behalf of director havelda who is not well tonight and he's participating virtually that he's obviously physically not here but I wanted to let you know that he is participating online and he asked me to make sure that you knew that and we're all I know appreciative of his commitment to continuing to move our governance forward uh as uh which is becoming I don't know if it's tradition just yet but maybe

018uh uh a habit of starting our superintendent my super intendent remarks with a quick win celebration I'd love to have everybody pay attention to our screens around the room to talk about one of our recent graduates um being a first generation College goer as a result of some incredible Financial philanthropy in our community my name is Ramon baras I graduated year 2024 from P High School I knew for sure I was I wanted to go to college I just didn't know which one just yet one I toward CSU and you know living here in Fort Collins CSU was a Clear Choice cuz I didn't want to be too far away from my family I knew I wanted to go to college but financially I was scared to apply for college cuz I wasn't sure if

019we me and my family could afford it scholarship I got through the PSD Foundation really helped me achieve my goal of going to college and getting into a School of Business I've always been more of a business person you know I wanted to get more into it I wanted to know the laws behind it the rules what it's like to own a business and I heard the College of Business here at CSU was actually really really good I want to give a big thank you to the PSD foundation for giving me the opportunity the confidence to come to college because not everybody can and I know this is such a privilege to be here today on this campus so I want to thank the PSD foundation for giving me that opportunity here today this feels

020like a brag Tuesday but we have so many incredible things that are going on I want to congratulate Ramon and not just going to college but just being an incredible student for PSD for quite some time he's got an Incredible family I met all of them at a scholarship event at pter high school and I couldn't be more proud to be associated with families like his as well as the PSD Foundation I am so grateful this district is so grateful uh for the PSD foundation's support specifically to how many students they help colle as a result of their philanthropic efforts they are about to celebrate their 25th anniversary and if you are listening or here in person or online I want you to know that today is happens to be Colorado gives day so if

021you are interested in benefiting students like Ramone uh through PD Foundation you can go to Colorado gives.org right now and look up uh the PSD foundation and have the opportunity if possible to provide a financial contribution to extend those particular opportunities to other students moving forward um we have another school uh in our mix that had another celebration recently a little bit Bittersweet but I'm going to ask staff to pull up a couple slides here uh Wellington Middle High School recently participated in the High School uh football state championship a little over a weeko um they had an incredible season unfortunately it didn't end the way that they likeed they ended up losing that game 4236 on a suspicious call uh I would say uh but the celebration here is not just in the players

022and their character but I would tell you the entire town of Wellington and all of the businesses and parents um and extended resources the parade that they had down to the stadium and on the way back the how that town has come together to Rally not just around football but around our students around our school district has been nothing short of just amazing I'm in absolute awe of what's going on if you think about I think this is their third year of playing football since we've reopened Wellington High School so the future is super bright uh up there and a lot of students will continue to be in the mix moving forward so while it was a bittersweet ending um like Tim nith Middle High School who is also at the same level of existence

023and already a state championship uh we have another group of students to celebrate up in Wellington uh in the very near future and I couldn't be more proud to be their superintendent um over the last two weeks I had a chance to visit seven of our schools I won't talk about all of them but just there's a lot of great things that are happening not just to focus on character as president Draper talked about although I see that a lot in a very significant systemic way uh but how we're tending to our core academic business has been really really amazing to see as well just yesterday I had an opportunity to visit every sing classroom at baty Elementary School uh with their principal kale Whitaker the co- teaching model is super strong I was really

024impressed with the art instruction that was happening at batty yesterday it's one of a unique model where and I don't know if you had an experience like I did where every student created the same piece of artwork based upon a model of the teacher uh the teacher there is really specific around teaching a skill and allowing the students to express what that looks like to them in any different modality that they want so the type of art that the students were creating at batty was very specific to their personal interests and passions and I left there quite inspired uh last week I had an incredible tour where I went to just about every classroom with two fifth grade students at olander elementary school and how these two fifth grade students talked about about the level

025of inclusivity and why inclusivity matters how they tend to character why all of their clubs and participation and engagement matters not just during instruction but throughout the course of the school day uh there's a lot of really really great things that were happening and those students gave me one of the best tours that I've probably had in my 27y year career uh and then yesterday I also had an opportunity to go to tlli elementary school and I met with one of our first year school psychologists his name is Zayn and he was matched and paired uh with their local school counselor Sarah who was equally as incredible and the energy in these people's eyes around what they can do to enhance the well-being of their students was really really impressive Zayn went on a tour

026to try to identify what students need and want in order to help regulate themselves like what types of activities help them feel calm and they actually created two rooms across the school one's called the cave and the other one is the jungle and the cave is where it's kind of dark it's a quiet time it allows people to calm themselves for a few minutes and get back into instruction and the jungle is for students like me who sometimes can't sit still and need to work out some of their energy but seeing all of the different activities that those two people were working together to make sure their students had access all throughout the course of the day to high levels of instruction but also being aware of their feelings being aware of how their body

027expresses their feelings and being able to put words to those things I thought was really really impressive there's a there's a lot of great things that are happening across the district um as we think about the things that we're here tonight to talk about uh I want to start off and pivot here a little bit by thanking our voters U one of the great parts of tonight is we are going to talk and outline the various summer projects to our facilities that we're going to be able to tackle this summer as a result of this Community Helping support 4 a um and we couldn't be more proud a promise made has to be a promise kept um and tonight we are going to continue to outline what that work is moving forward we're not waiting

028for a year we're going to execute on many of those projects now two schools will get air conditioning units for the very first time in their existence and so I look forward to hearing a great presentation there we'll also hear uh some work about our various committee structures three specifically our M Levy oversight committee uh we'll talk about a comprehensive planning committee to talk about some of the various challenges that not just deal with declining enrollment in our facilities but also boundaries and wanting to make sure that like last year some for many of us felt like an event we want to normalize that work so we're looking at that every single year not to traumatize people and make it more emotional but to normalize that we need to Grapple with hard things in a

029consistent way and educate our community consistently on the things that we're thinking about so I really appreciate the board asking for that committee to be jump started um and we'll also talk about cak uh a committee that has been talked about uh at length in this boardroom and I look forward to a robust conversation on that the last thing that I will share is you know while 4A is going to be absolutely transformational for this District specific to our Capital investments in our facilities I do think it's important as the superintendent to signal that our financial challenges that we're experiencing as a district are not solved um there are a multitude of things that are very real uh we found out today that as the October count recently got cleaned up our district is 44

03041 fewer students than we had a year ago and if you were to take 441 students today and put them in one school it would be the six largest Elementary School in PSD so that's real we're also grapa with the future speculation current speculation about the future of potential losses of federal funding that we're uncertain about that is really difficult to make sure that we're planning thoughtfully and appropriately to serve especially our most marginalized students which is where the predominance of those dollars go I would also say as we've recently all as a community and as a state learned from our governor with his proposed budget uh that he uh part of his proposal was to eliminate per pupil averaging in his budgetary process for K12 the impact locally to PSD is almost a million

031dollars but it's important to know across the state that's a191 million reduction to K12 education on the heels of our legislator celebr ating that education was fully funded I have a hard time accepting that truth we also know that the lack of housing affordability in our community continues to present a challenge as we do get new dollars we have to think of creative ways to ensure the majority of those dollars go to supporting salary for our staff to be able to afford to live in our community which we're not there yet we need to be honest about that but as we think about Distributing more Monies to compensation and salary in many instances that doesn't allow us to put more money in our classrooms for students and we shouldn't be put in a scenario as

032a school system where it's not a both and it's an either or today and that's not acceptable I share that with you because just dealing with one of those issues we can manage that but dealing with the multitude of all of those challenges in the aggregate makes it really messy hard to understand and Incredibly complicated for us as as a governance team I'm hopeful and optimistic though that we will figure these things out by doing this work together and I look forward to having a thoughtful meeting with all of you in the community tonight so thank you for allowing me to have some remarks thank you superintendent Kingsley and now we're going to head on to the community comment portion so uh welcome to the community comment section of the board meeting the board desires

033to hear the viewpoints of all stakeholders including students employees uh parents Guardians and community members public comment is designed to address issues not personalities or Personnel matters please keep your concerns and comments focused upon the district and appropriate for a K12 audience please note that the board does not generally respond to remarks made during Community comments our lack of response should not be construed to mean that we agree or disagree with what was said or with the description or interpretation of events as presented by any speaker further even if some remarks may be factually inaccurate we generally choose not to respond or correct the record here because formal board meetings are not the time or place for back and forth dialogue as we begin this community comment session let us model for our entire Community

034how to listen and how to interact act respectfully even with those with whom we disagree for we all have the students best interests at heart so this opportunity for public comment is for members of the community who register to speak by the designated deadline those people will be called on to make remarks in the order that they signed up and each speaker will be allowed three minutes to address the board so first up we have Stephanie Watson Lewis welcome thank you president thank you superintendent and thank you board I'm sorry sorry for my horse Voice tonight um I'm here to address some issues that my child has experienced this year and last year um being a part of PSD we are um a family that is a part of Liberty common and um my son

035has received some what I think most people like to call bullying but I would call racial harassment um and we're just trying to navigate around systems to try and figure out how to best support other families that are going through this unfortunately since I've come forward a zillion other families have too and I'm starting to realize that it's not just um a liberty common issue but it's a PSD issue and I'm here tonight to just go over the fact that PSD has 16 open OCR complaints and I'm really just wanting to hear what the plans are moving forward in supporting these families that are experiencing discrimination I know um superintendent and I have met before privately to discuss our family matter and he's come out into the community to wrap around the people to talk

036about and to hear them talk about their experiences but um unfortunately I'm hearing from the community that nothing is being done so I'm concerned moving forward and I'm asking what is PSD doing to protect children um that are being discriminated against um I would like to say that you know just at my own School Liberty Commons I've gotten four phone calls from families in the last month where their kids been called the nword um their kids been um told that they're slaves or their parents are slaves or that they're poop because they're black I mean this is just very um concerning and there's no other way to put it and when I think about everything that's happening and I look at all the people that are responding to me online it's not just about race

037it's about my child's not getting the proper services or I feel like I'm being pushed out of a school because my child has a disability so I'm really asking the board and you superintendent unfortunately I'm putting everybody on the spot but I'm really asking what are we doing for our community to really rectify the Discrimination that we're seeing and it's huge I mean we have to say something see something right yeah I'm sorry but you're going to have to wrap up but it's it's not working it's it's not working so what are we going to do thank you thank you and next up we have Anna leetta welcome good evening in 2017 I attended an orientation for becoming a foster parent in lur County I still vividly remember the group being asked to list stereotypical

038behaviors we might anticipate from kids who are in foster care the list sounded a lot like this scared angry sad trust issues big behaviors fight flight freeze responses anxiety the facilitator picked up where we left off and said exactly because these kids have experienced trauma and this is appropriate and normal behavior for someone who has experienced trauma if they did not have a trauma response to their trauma then something would not be right I will be forever grateful for the amount of time and energy larer County required of us as prospective foster parents to learn about trauma and Trauma and for practices prior to certification as well as the extensive resources we have received each year since to further our understanding it has literally changed the lens through which I see the world and how

039I respond to the world around me three weeks ago tonight I watched apparent of one of zala's victims peacefully hold signs outside of this building on an evening that Community comments were omitted from the agenda most of the people who attended the meeting that evening were already in the building by the time she arrived and only a handful of people walked past her on their way into the meeting with the meeting well underway this parent wrote a handful of comments in sidewalk chalk near the entrance of this building as a last Stitch chance that evening to evoke thoughts around decisions that had recently been made in PSD then she left the premises a week later she received an official notice that she's no longer allowed on any PSD property other than pickup or drop off

040scheduled meetings or public events so long as they are isolated to her daughter's school over the past year and a half I have watched this grieving parent ad ate boldly at Board of Education meetings for appropriate checks and balances that will benefit all of our children in this District in light of the tragedy her own child endured I have seen her fight for better protocols around around busing only to see policies that could have been proactively strengthened weakened to protect the district I've seen her advocate for more transparency and accountability to no avail these families are stuck in real-time trauma as they've yet to receive closure by seeing effective policies and safeguards put in place to further prevent child abuse and PSD When I See This parent I see a parent who's experienced both trauma

041and secondary trauma as a result of the events that have occurred in the school district I believe with my whole heart that things could have been so different if these families had had their concerns heard to begin with since then there have been so many missed opportunities to help these families start to heal by addressing concerns but instead of acknowledging and connecting with their legitimate fears these families are stuck in their Raw traumas stripped of any Grace to respond with em emotions appropriate in light of their trauma without being seen as problematic I'm asking the district and Board of Education to please consider seeing these families through a trauma lens and take into account the traumas and unaddressed fears that have fueled subsequent behaviors and to please resend the trespass order and instead replace it

042with a onetime warning thank you thank you next up we have Leah Casper welcome members of the board thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I'm here to address an issue that has been ignored sidelined and swept under the rug from the negotiations table for far too long Fair pay for PA professionals since 2017 I have served PSD as a Paris substitute ILS perah and effective needs perah in this time I have experienced the full emotional and physical demands of the role I have been kicked I been hit I have been bitten I have been defecated on I have been verbally abused by students that cannot control their own behavior this we sign up for seeing and growing seeing the growth and success of the students I serve Remains the most rewarding part of

043my job Paris like me work directly with students more than anyone else in PSD we provide one-on-one attention adopt General curriculum and meet our students unique needs this requires a specialized skill set including interpersonal and adaptive skills that are essential for the success of the most vulnerable student populations despite this par professionals hold some of the lowest paid positions in the district working full-time hours over 40 hours a week although only being paid for 37 and a half I often can't afford the groceries or basic necessities that I need to provide my family even while working another job I also survive off of food stamps Medicaid and lowincome housing while bonuses for leadership and administration are nearly twice the annual pay for par professionals I am not alone in this struggle 700 is Staff surveys

044indicated a significant need for improved pair support pairs across the district face similar challenges colleagues have shared with me that many of us are underpaid and our hours aren't enough to support our students effectively we often use our own time to adapt assignments organize classrooms and create an environment conductive to learning despite these challenges we do this job because we care about our students and love to see them grow and succeed it's long overdue for Paras in this District to receive an equitable wage and benefits package we are the backbone of PSD working tirelessly with the most vulnerable students tonight I urge you not to just listen with concern or empathy or with Misty Eyes but to act to act for immediate and emergency pay increase with Equitable benefits for par professionals this will improve

045our work environment which is also our students work environment I'm s have to wrap up may your hearts and ears be open to the words of my colleagues tonight and may the board's care transform into action I know together that we can create a better and more equitable future for pair of professionals and PSD thank you thank you next up we have Tori papis welcome hi I'm Tor papis and I have a first grader at batty Elementary B's HVAC upgrade is on tonight's agenda we welcome and appreciate whatever can make our building more conducive to learning and teaching and we also welcome and appreciate uh open thorough and transparent communication around this project aside from getting AC this summer there's a lot of really exciting things happening at batty we had a packed event last

046week that highlighted the various specials that we offer I had a lot of fun being led by my son through all the different programs there was Independence and personal choice alongside structured and guided experiential learning it was impressive to see how he navigated the crowds and stations so comfortably and confidently an area that he struggles with typically uh even in the art room his least favorite subject uh he was really excitedly explaining all the different watercolor techniques and I guess miss carnahan's doing something right um I believe that batty has played a role in his progress and his confidence has grown because he has a learning environment where he knows he belongs I believe he feels valued at batty and that's why he's thriving the teachers also feel supported at our school according to their

047tlcc survey responses which far exceed District averages batty teachers agree that our school is a safe place to work and for students to learn when teachers and students feel supported valued and safe they show up this is evident through Batty's 94% % attendance rate another impressive number is that we are currently enrolled at 256 students it's 9% higher than what PSD projected for this school year finally our current performance plan is 86.3 with academic growth at 97.5% again well above District averages batty is serious about developing sustainable systems that reflect listen and work I see this being prioritized during our PTO and school accountability committee meetings the energy is really exciting batty is rocking all of these accomplishments as an underfunded small school I can only imagine what we could accomplish with more adequate funding

0484 a can help especially by keeping small school support to fund truly small schools clearly Define what a small school is and then distribute that funding equitably between those schools I personally can't wait to watch my batty Big Horn become a Bev's Bruin it's going to be awesome [Applause] thanks thank you next up uh Aaron green welcome thank you for the opportunity to provide public comments tonight I reject the idea that what once public comments are allowed that then you can then restrict or mute my first amendment rights it takes far more Integrity to protect speech that is critical contains content you disagree with or find offensive diversity and inclusion can only be ideals of the district if you accept that those ideals mean you have to include opinions and viewpoints that are different than

049your own to reject that and to teach our children that it's appropriate for the government to restrict expression of ideas is concerning careful of the lessons that you teach our children my comment tonight focus on the district special education advisory committee or cak I want to make it clear that my comments are mine alone and I'm not here to represent that group as a whole the district pretends that it values it values stakeholder input when it actually only values the perception of that and cak is a great example if you've ever heard that cak decided you are being intentionally misled some examples cak decided not to have public attendance or public comments at meetings that's not true we discussed it two parents advocated for it there is not any sentiment there was not any sentiment

050expressed to the contrary but cak is not empowered to make decisions it only advises the director if you had heard that cak chooses some of their topics now that's not true a non-transparent survey was distributed the director is choosing topics and we're going are we going to talk about Transportation safety accommodations for extracurricular activities after the o finding the abysmal declining graduation rates for is students equity for is students in boundary or School consolidations are all topics that are not likely to be addressed when a secret survey only provides confirmation bias to the director if you heard cak decided not to include representation from other District boards into our meetings I have heard this but it was never brought up in a seak meeting again we have many voices and many recommendations but our Charter

051dictates that only the director to decide to resent to represent it any other way is misleading and avoids accountability internal meetings are different than stakeholder inputs spots on cak dedicated to parents are routinely filled with staff members who are also parents but in discussions with staff members uh they confided that they're unable to participate as parents that they are that there are consequences that they have to keep their District hats on while making suggestions in that group if you want to have an internal is committee you should do that but don't pretend that seak is stakeholder driven finally I would Advocate uh that the state seak allows public attendance and public comments as does CDE Don't Believe The Narrative that we run are seak based off the state model why would you want to hear

052not want to hear these concerns locally when the alternative is to have these comments addressed at state level meetings PSD reputation is growing your values are being exposed at the state level is there is that really the alternative that you're pushing for with this model allow public comments at cak meetings thank you thank you and next up we have Danny Lawrence welcome I heard a board member once say they felt public comment was sacran and that is defined as regarded as too important or value to be interfered with and I couldn't help but notice when I registered for comments tonight the new subjective mute button language recently PSD issued an order to a zanella victim's mother that she is no longer allowed on District property which prevents her from making public comments because PSD will

053remain the one last standing District that doesn't allow for telephonic telephonic phone uh public comments I feel it's abrupt it shows little regard for people that are already hurting due to District actions and I ask how would you like Sabrina to express her concerns for the safety of other children when the district employe so many of the same people who allowed her daughter to be beaten on a school bus and failed to appropriately report the crime after watching video of her daughter walking down a school bus aisle toward a standing bus driver facing her while zanella kicked her in behind her knees sending her to the floor and throwing a heavy backpack on top of her with a both with a bus driver smiling how did you want Sabrina to respond to that because contrary

054to the district's response this isn't a one employee crime you can't ignore real emotion and expect positive outcomes so was the sidewalk chalk uh the right response I don't know I'm not going to judge how someone who has been mistreated and disregarded while being egged on by your staff expresses their grief and anger and I don't think you should either as a parent I am struggling to politely express my outrage at the outrageous being ignored muted restricted isn't treating public coma as sacent and is being felt intentionally as targeted disrespect here are a few things at the moment that I find outrageous lack of followup on the transportation report that was made last spring are the cameras installed because I'm hearing they're not and how is that video retention going you were supposed to update

055Us by now agendized meeting materials that are not being allowed to be spoken in public comments which feels like a violation of the intent of the revised Statute that it was written for parents with IEPs unable to get needed documents due to encryption a district that is failing the dyslexia community so blatantly committees that operate like your schools with no oversight or district-wide policy and districts that approve Charters and then Advocate their oversight of the racism that occurs in them trespassing Crime Victims that Express their outrage and for clarity when an employees name is listed on an agendized meeting materials is it or is it not allowed to be spoken in public comment because your policy doesn't address it and the district did not answer this question directly in the October 23rd Email exchange with

056Miss herck in the core request that resulted from the Post-it note that was exchanged by all of you during the meeting it appears that you too were confused about it and for that reason and one of Grace and understanding I am asking respectively respectfully Mr Kingsley that Sabrina's speaking privileges be reinstated at least in this limited space before you notice more people infringing on their first amendment rights please offer some clarity on your newfound policies thank you thank you next up we have Lacy Nixon welcome hi my name is Lacy Nixon and I was a pair professional at Levens and recently moved to Rocky to be a PA 2 in the effective needs program I love being a PA it is so rewarding I get to help students be successful in many different ways but

057today I'm here to speak about the Urgent issue that affects not just me but many of my colleagues across the district this this should and cannot wait until negotiations as it is a critical need that should be addressed immediately you have the power to make this change because the students are the ones that are suffering right now PA professionals are not fairly compensated for the vital role that play directly supporting the most vulnerable students not enough income leads the challenges retaining quality staff pars are unable to live where they work and pars holding more multiple jobs which are all unsustainable and negatively impact students and staff in so many ways pay professionals are vital members of this our schools we work tirelessly every day to support students help our teachers and more we spend the

058most time directly supporting students in our integrative Services Program but despite all we do the truth is parents cannot live off the pay pay because it's below the living AG needed in for colins I still live with my grandpa because I would not be able to to live independently on my own income alone I've also moved positions that so I can move from a p run rate to a slightly higher P to rate just to meet my basic needs this was not something I wanted to do my school to due to my school Community or students but had no other option when I had to make more money we are passionate about our jobs but the reality is the rages are simply not sustainable as of today there are over 23 unfilled pair positions in

059our district does that not concern you it should concern all of us because it means the students those positions are supporting are not having their needs met and the IP Services minutes are likely not being fulfilled the only way they're being met is through other staff members is doing more than one job every day to meet the responsibilities and requirements of more than one person's position this often falls on other pars or is Teachers I'm here tonight asking for your action and attention we need Fair compensation for the work we do pairs are essential and without us many students would not receive the level support to be S succeed I urge you to recognize the value we bring to the classroom and act swiftly to address this issue people say that where the district spends

060the money reflects the values and priorities please show parents like me that we the work we do is valued our students deserve the best and that starts of supporting the dedicated paay of professionals who work with them every day thank you thank you next up we have Kate green welcome in accordance with policy GP 313 my comments tonight are made on behalf of Sabrina herck to start out I would like to talk about a public comment that that happened back on November 5th I want to be very clear that your staff can write letters supporting your new HR Director until their hands fall off and it will never mean a thing to me for one very simple reason words of support shut down the investigation that should have kept 11 children safe from a child

061predator it didn't even take letters upon letters and snide and a snide public comment that totally wasn't intended to cause the victims more pain it took only four words he's a good guy which actually ties in quite nicely with my main point for the evening for the sake of accurate meeting minutes I'll be clear my main point is that I object to this District silencing their critics with trespass orders 11 disabled children got beaten for an entire school year and the response parents of the victims having to track you down only to get canned answers deflecting blame onto the state legislature form letters from someone now named in a lawsuit for knowingly hired hiring a child abuser form letters directing parents to take their victimized children to either cak or another mental health CL Clinic

062that shares a board member with this board a member of this cabinet telling District committees that he doesn't think such a massive failure in his own Department wor its policy change and then that cab Cabinet member leaving of his own accord eight months later a thirdparty audit that you still haven't released to the public a year and a half later and another audit that even cherry-picked for positivity revealed issues in this District that would get an animal research facility shut down security upgrades that guarantees Anella version 2.0 will have less evidence to support a conviction not more and finally staff turning up in Mass to applaud the decision to promote a person who by all publicly released accounts had a hand in the abuse happening and now you've trespassed a parent of one of the

063victims for quote unquote harassing staff all because she thinks that a promotion deserves public discussion not more of the priv privately emailed letters and gray rocking that she's been subjected to for the past year and a half it took an entire school year for this District to find somebody with the tiny shred of a moral compass required to properly investigate the blatant child abuse but when it sidewalk chalk that you when it but when it sidewalk chalk that you felt harassed in employee who wasn't even present to see it 3 days that's all it took for you to sign a trespass order your priorities are clear looking good is what matters to you somewhere along the way you forgot that looking that step one of looking good is doing good so rather than listening to

064families who have been harmed by your bad policies you prioritize telling them mother how to grieve the harm that you caused her family a little advice for you rules exist to promote decorum of morality not the tissue paper facade this board hides behind so if you are going to tell the people that you'll mute them for disrespect start by doing something worth respecting thank [Applause] you thank you next up we have suda tic welcome hi everybody my name is swuk I'm 17 years old and a junior at Rocky Mountain High School today I'm here to discuss the need for scoliosis screenings in Middle Schools scoliosis is the sideways curvature of the spine the most common type is adolescent idiopathic the cause is unknown but it develops around the ages 10 to 12 it affects around

0653% of the population and if left untreated can affect cardiovascular function caus chronic pain and more not all cases of scoliosis get severe enough to need treatment but when they do the most common options include bracing a cast that pushes on the Torso to realign the spine and surgery metal metal screws bars and wires inserted into the spine to correct the curvature internally typically bracing is most effective when the patient is growing and surgery is offered to those with more severe curves and little to no growth left bracing is the least invasive least risky and least expensive option but surgery becomes necessary when the curve becomes too severe the only way to stop it from progressing that far is to catch it and start bracing early in the game that is why scoliosis screenings are

066necessary the screenings themselves are a quick test where the patient will touch their toes in any sideways curvature or spinal rotation can be seen by the person performing the test it takes maybe 30 seconds and requires no special equipment in 2004 the US preventative service task for task force stopped mandating these screenings in schools because they were diagnosing so many kids with moderate scoliosis the type that's treated with bracing at the time there was little clinical proof that bracing works so they felt the screenings were a waste of of resources well now 20 years later there is plenty of proof that bracing works and I'm an example of this in the seventh grade I was diagnosed with scoliosis by my pediatrician and in the in eth grade I began bracing by that point my curve

067my curvature was severe but my parents wanted to try bracing as a last resort my treatment worked and I'm now out of surgical range unfortunately not all pediatricians perform this screening and not all students receive regular regular checkups because of this I believe it's important to provide these screenings for PSD students I hope you will be willing to work with me to achieve this goal thank you for your time thank you next up we have Jen Casey welcome good evening my name is Jen Casey I'm a parah at Boltz during my time as a par professional at PSD I've had the privilege of working alongside many talented individuals over the years I've consistently heard a concern raised within the par professional Community the daily lack of respect we experience it feels as though there's a

068hierarchy in our schools with par professionals often treated at the bottom of the hierarchy such treatment is detrimental to morale and is in general disheartening those of us who choose to become par professionals do so because like a lot of Staff here at school we are passionate about serving our students we are committed to their success whether we are pursuing careers in education developing our professional skills or providing essential support to children with special needs we come from diverse backgrounds parents students community members and we are all deeply invested in the success of our students and the Fort Collins Community as a whole in addition to the need for dignity and respect one of the major challenges within the paraprofessional Community is retention too often paraprofessionals are seen as easily replaceable many staff members assume

069that building strong working relationships with par professionals is not worth the effort because at the first opportunity apparel will move on while mutual respect and kindness are important the issue of retention is more complex it's no secret that lower wages and the high cost of benefits often push people to leave the par professional role we all understand the district's budget constraints but what's often overlooked is the cost of employee turnover replacing paraprofessionals comes with both direct and indirect costs not to mention the impact on our students who lose the stability of having familiar trusted adults in their lives students are far more likely to thrive when they have the same adult guiding them year after year stability and staffing has a direct effect on the quality of Education our students receive if time permits let

070me briefly share a glimpse into my typical day to ensure I'm prepared for the day and can give my students my best I arrive between 6:30 and 6:45 a.m. unfortunately my badge doesn't allow ow me to enter the building until 7: a.m. so I'm often left standing outside waiting for someone to let me in ironically students are often already in the building before my badge will let me in this becomes even more troubling when you consider that across the district many par professionals have 24-hour access to their school buildings in summary I'd like to propose starting a culture of teamwork collaboration and mutual respect between all staff members this culture must begin at the top and be nurtured at all levels of the organization by fostering such a culture we can better serve the needs

071of our students and the entire Community a simple but powerful step in this direction could be granted could be granting par professionals extended access to school buildings this would improve morale and serve as a clear demonstration of how the district values its par professionals thank you thank you next up we have Caitlyn Guzman welcome hello good afternoon members of the board my name is Caitlin Guzman and I am a par professional at bolts middle school and I work in our center-based autism program I would like to start off on who I am and my key role in pter school district at the age of 16 I decided I wanted to become an educator as a sophomore in high school I helped my little brother while he was in kindergarten this striked my interest in becoming

072an elementary school teacher my high school in the neighboring District had a program called the future educator program I was one of the six kids in the whole District who were chosen to be a part of this program in my second year I decided to leave the neighbor neighboring district and come to pter as I felt like there was more opportunity for me to grow as I continued to attend college part-time work here at pter full-time I have unfortunately needed to get a second job I currently make 2063 an hour I would like to start off with some positives the reason I stay in education is the relationships I have been able to form as well as the fortunate as well as being fortunate enough to have an amazing supervisor and being able to work

073with Early Childhood up to Middle School in the three years I have been in education although my older kids show love differently there is a they are the reason I show up and I am I'm super lucky to have a team who is more like family I get paid 20 63 an hour to get hit more than 20 times a day I get called all kinds of names by students because I prompted them to follow a direction this school year alone I've gotten a minor sprin on my right arm hid so badly in the back of my head that I was sore for four to 5 days a sensory room door that weighed more than a 100 lb was literally broken off the hinges from a student I believe we should be getting Hazard pay

074as par Professionals in the center Center based autism program we are performing hazardous duties my cooworker last month was covered in a student's blood I get I have been spit on consistently by a student who thinks it's funny enough to who thinks it's funny to do so as well as any bodily fluid possible with not enough time to prepare for those situations as well as physical heartshape was which has been stated above before the school board meeting I have recounted how many par professional openings we've we had in the last month 11:20 we had 20 23 per professional openings today 1210 we have a total of 28 openings in our school district let that number sink in let's put it this way 28 classrooms are without Paras no help with redirection no help with elopment

075no help with behavior management one less body in the classroom but this ties back to a lot of people with for pay the reason why I became a par was because because this is the first step in educ in education for me the sense of being able to make a difference in a community as I grew up in California and a lowincome community with some amazing teachers who never gave up on me I now have a voice and I will use it we need better pay now thank you thank you to all of those who came tonight to speak really appreciate it we are now going to move on to board topics and committee reports uh this agenda item is an opportunity for board members to provide an update on committee work or speak to

076board topics do any board members have anything they would like to report no okay um I will just let everybody know that um starting in January we'll be having monthly Community engagement sessions uh with the board so I'll be looking for that we will be setting dates um within the next few weeks um and we will be doing those on a monthly basis so Kristen can I jump in you sure can Kevin I'm sorry that was the one that was one of the things I wanted to oh I'm sorry I didn't even see your hand rais there Kevin you're all right and I'm for whatever reason I'm not uh is not working I didn't see it yeah no you're fine um again I wanted to thank Chief of Staff Lauren hooton for arranging me to

077participate today as long as as well as as PSD staff um I'm sorry I'm not physically there I'm as you can hear I'm sounding and feeling pretty rough today and didn't want to share my germs with our community but still wanted to be there because we've got some really important conversations and really important and exciting things ahead of us on our agenda um first one I wanted to announce is that superintendent Kingsley and I have been invited to attend a podcast called selling Fort Collins uh we will be recording uh a week from last this past Monday so 12 16 and this is with Greg Raider who's an incredible uh realtor in town but also is doing a deep dive into all four Collins and so sen Kingsley has already appeared on this podcast um

078so you can access that via VIA Spotify YouTube If you Google selling for Collins it'll it'll pop up so I wanted to just make that quick announcement we'll be talking about um some exciting things uh down the road for pstd this year um and next and then also I did want to jump in on the opportunity thank you uh president Draper to mention I'll be working with the other directors as well as our community and staff to try to launch um I understand there was there were engagement sessions prior to the pandemic where you uh our community can meet with uh PSD directors um my vision is for this to be very informal No Agenda but having a set time where community members can engage directly with board directors either in twos threes uh or

079as many as as are available um we're working on what day of the week would make the most sense for everybody right now it's sort of in the incubator stage but we're thinking it makes sense to host these at uh schools and then have different schools host uh once a month that way we can also showcase some of the great things that are going on within our schools but a lot of our our Comm are going to already be there right they they'll already be in schools so it'll be easier for them um I'm going to work up a budget preliminary budget so we can offer some food uh one thought was to have pies with the directors um so we'll see what our pizza budget may be and if people are sick of pizza

080then we'll we'll look at other options but the point point is get our community directly in front of our directors and to talk all things PSD um that way we can open that dialogue uh again in another Avenue um we can uh talk about things that may appear on our agenda or that we may want to put on our agenda direct from Community back so it's just another another Avenue other than Community comment where our folks can express their opinions and and what they want to see happen what we're doing well what we can what we can change so I appreciate you announcing that um we'll put some a lot of thought into that and if our community has any thoughts about best to structure that logistically if they got ideas for child care if

081they've got ideas for food and and venues I'm all yours so please email email me at kavela psdschools.org that's all I've got thank you of course thank you anyone else okay I will move on to the consent agenda would any board member like to pull an item from consent okay uh Kevin is that hand up for consent or is that left over there we go thank you just wanted to make sure so seeing none can I get a motion sure I move the board approve and adopt the recommended actions for the items on the consent agenda can I get a second thank you Jess and then Jill can you call the vote Jim bookish hi Christen Draper hi Connor Duffy hi Kevin havelda hi Carolyn Reed hi Scott shanower hi Jess Kora I motion passes

08270 thank you all right we'll move on to 9.0 action items uh 9.1 monitoring policy review El 2.3 Financial conditions and activities can I get a motion Jess you got it oh looks like Connor has it I move that the board determined that the superintendent has reasonably interpreted Board of Education policy el2 .3 in his internal monitoring report dated 12124 and that the evidence presented supports the superintendent's conclusion stated in the internal monitoring report can I get a second all right thanks Jim all right um and are there any questions regarding this okay all right so Jill can we call the vote Jim broish hi Kristen Draper hi Connor Duffy hi Kevin havala hi Carolyn Reed hi Scott shanower hi Jessica Zamora hi motion passes 70 thank you all right moving on to informational reports

083and discussion items 10.1 District annual budget process priorities and update and I believe we have a guest for this yes we do providing an update tonight on the district annual budget process is our budget director Brian gustaffson Brian welcome all right thank you thank you for having me good to see you all again um unbelievably we're wrapping up semester 1 and a calendar year and halfway through our current fiscal year I'm going to take just a few moments talk about where we are in our current budget process as well as uh for this year but as well as our planning and start of the budget process for next year um of course I'll I'll be piggybacking on some of the comments that superintendent Kingsley made earlier and then you'll hear some of those uh those

084same um items come up as we get into some of the challenges and some of the things that we see on the horizon for fiscal year 26 so as we think think about building the budget uh we must consider and and keep U grounded in the alignment to the Strategic plan priorities of literacy mental health and belonging and graduating with options Additionally the priorities of evaluating enrollment Trends addressing safety and focusing on competitive compensation and benefits Okay carry over currently from the current fiscal year into the next as budget priorities right so these things will be focused on and will be addressed as we go through the budget planning for fiscal year 26 on top of that and especially in in light of the new debt-free Mill Levy okay we we want to make sure

085that we highlight additional budgetary of ensuring high quality ucation options for our students and families here a continued stewardship of taxpayer dollars and Community assets like our facilities a equipment um locations Etc and then of course maintenance and Improvement of learning environments to facilitate quality in ruction okay so all of these priorities are are at the Forefront as we get started into this budget process he so let's talk about the process a little bit and I won't have a lot of numbers uh for you just some really high level initial information that was already addressed a little bit earlier hey the process really starts for the next fiscal year in November of of this fall where the governor rolls out his budget request with the state of Colorado okay and in that budget request for

086K12 education we see a total program increase of about $299 per pupil per pupil funding hey that is built basically on a rate of inflation assumed to be 2 and a half% as a point of perspective this year's rate of inflation that funded or or built the formula was based at 5.2% okay so a pretty significant decrease in that per pupil um increase of$ 299 hey now I know the question that will be coming is what does that mean for PSD how much more money and the answer is I don't know and and here's the why uh really as as you know as we talked about a lot in the fall we've got the two big factors the per pupil rate and the number of pupils hey we still have a lot of of uh

087uh navigation to do to get that established number of pupils dialed into where we can really make a good estimate and there's some other variables I'm going to address that that make a a projection of what dollars we'd be looking at uh possible additionally and then this was mentioned earlier in that budget request there's the elimination of pupil count averaging and this is not only in the current School Finance formula but in the new one that goes into effect next year and and that's that's going to be a really interesting Dynamic I think as we um get into the legislative sessions starting up in January on top of that an extension of that new formula implementation from 6 years to 7 uh will be something that it's hard to know the impacts of uh but

088we'll have to monitor and see what does that really mean what what does that extended Runway really do um to to start this new this new school Finance formula he so on top of those those items in the governor's budget request for the the total program increase uh that request also included addressing categorical programs remember those are things like transportation funding special education funding uh a assuming a 2.5% inflation increase in those funding streams as well so we we've seen basically the real high level what we have not seen yet are any what we would call runs okay any really significant detailed runs we we've seen some um guesstimates on what this might mean U but really we typically see in late December or as we get into January CDE produce some more detailed information

089that puts some numbers behind this this information and and really what they're waiting on is that final certification of this year's October count and then plugging it into the formula as a new basis on which it the formula should uh operate okay so with that in mind what are we doing as far as our process where are we in in our efforts to get started here and really um I want you to think about a four-lane process we've got multiple processes actually already started and going at one time and one of them being the student based budgeting process and we've talked about student-based budgeting or SBB a lot in the past and this process is is already underway and I'm I'm going to show you a couple visuals to remind is kind of where we're

090at there but that's already going as far as wrapping up this year but even some thoughts getting ready for next year additionally and in kind of a different Lane is our departmental process for budgeting this is where our academic and our operational departments are starting to do work in analyzing their current budgets their current Staffing their current goals and then thinking about next year and and how their budgets might look or need to look uh with some of the the goals that they have on top of that we're engaging in some budget review processes okay utilizing some of the Comm Community or the Committees and community members in the district to engage in reviews of our budget and processes including the budget advisory committee which I'll talk about and the district accountability committee as well

091as the budget design team and then of course there's another Lane that's of course the Board of Education okay reviewing and providing input on budget priorities and as well as uh going through the process of of feedback analyzing budget presentations budgets throughout the year and ultimately providing adoption uh for a budget at the end of June so we'll look at that first Lane that SBB Lane and this is a a slide we used back in October just a a quick refresher here on that SBB cycle and we're right at the top of that that circular cycle the box at the top that says December 2024 fy2 trups he right now we're in the process of collecting the current Year's October count information and as you heard earlier we're just getting final numbers even as as

092early as this afternoon um to really dial in and plug into our formula to know how we must adjust funding at the schools for this year based on their enrollments so we're in that process right now and we hope to have those true UPS the adjustments to school budgets done next week so fingers crossed we can uh have that accomplished and and we're finalized with our data there then we'll jump right into uh looking at next year when we get into to January and we receive some enrollment projections by the end of January on what enrollments will look like at our schools for fiscal year 26 and I know our data team is working feverishly behind the scenes to not only wrap up this year but think about those projections moving forward because I know

093that that's that's really a huge part of the equation that we have to know so we can start putting a number to that question of what does it mean mean for PSD he in February then with those numbers we'll roll out allocations for next year by Valentine's Day February 14th he we'll get a Little Valentine to each principal that'll say okay here's your allocation and then then they will have two weeks to start to build their comp plan or their their plan for how they they will build their Staffing their operational spending throughout their building they'll work with their stakeholders to do that and provide a comp plan by the end of February he then those will be reviewed in early March and hope hopefully all wrapped up probably by about mid-march with approvals and

094really at that point then the budgets are allocated to the schools and then Staffing can can be filled in principales can work on their Staffing plans around those budgets on the screen is just a little different way to look at that cycle so we have a graphic here we at the top left we've got those two large components enrollment projections and the school Finance formula right now we have a okay idea of that school Finance formula and we're still waiting for those enrollment projections to really start this flow for next year's student based budgeting U allocations those two items together will lead to of course dollars as I mentioned that flow to the schools the schools will work with their accountability committees their stakeholders to build their local priorities and then build Those comp plans

095that I discussed I think uh you also important to note is that as this process takes shape that the schools will be analyze analyzing how they wrap up this year right because they're going to also be planning on what are their needs that that are ongoing this year to get into next year's budget what sort of reserves are they able to carry over to help uh with with implementing whether it be uh remaining programs onetime programs Etc as they get into next year hey going to that lane two that I talked about where are we at was starting in on departmental budgeting and this is already commenced as well here this fall our departments are now taking some time to to get with each other and analyze their Staffing and they're going through their Staffing

096rosters they're going through and rebuild building or reaffirming their organizational charts and so they're submitting those and also considering what are their objectives for deploying their budget within their Department right how does how does that budget benefit the school district and and and educating students here so departments are currently working on those and we're collecting those and we'll then also have our departments start diving into their financial data here after the the start of the new calendar year a analyzing their spend looking at their budgets from the past considering their needs and upcoming priorities for the future and really trying to take a look at you know how could those things change maybe in a perfect world but also in the realistic uh kind of environment that we Face ourselves with in in Colorado school

097Finance okay as departments compile this information we're engaging our budget advisory committee a little bit differently than we have in the past and I'll talk a little bit more about that group but this group will then have some eyes on on this stuff and and again I'm going to talk a little bit about about that group right now okay the the budget advisory committee is a group of folks it's smaller group than some of our other committees that's uh made up of internal and external stakeholders he the charge of this this crew is to uh review some of this District fiscal information um but this group just met for the first time last last Friday and I want to share with you really the focus that uh we came away with out of that meeting

098he the BAC has identified a focus on building shared understanding of the budget process to ensure transparent alignment with strategic objectives while keeping the budgetary focus on what's best for students okay so this group will add another set of eyes on our budget processes coming out of departments and potentially schools he looking at those objectives looking at expenditures looking at budgets a surfacing questions maybe wonderings asking for additional information if possible or maybe even helping to highlight areas of need and consider redundancies and inefficiencies okay so this is a small group adding another layer to to Really build that shared understanding and and honestly personally I came away from that meeting Friday energized about that with this this group of folks I a pretty common understanding of of wanting to do this together uh was

099was um really really refreshing and and exciting for what we can do in the future and so that budget advisory committee is one of a number of um groups that will be providing input on the budget throughout this process I already mentioned departments are going to be providing input the BAC providing input and the district accountability committee has already provided some input on the budget process and what needs of the district uh should consider okay so these groups together all will be generating some information maybe it's recommendations maybe it's some thoughts additional questions and that will be forwarded onto our budget design team that's a little bit larger group an internal group that will then uh consider budget recommendations possibly and that they can forward on to our cabinet to the negotiation cycle to the

100Board of Education so we've got some flow going here got some different Avenues to to take a look at things provide some insight on um that District budget design team is made up of license classified administrative staff and typically gets engaged about this time of the year we're going to start them probably a little bit later so that these other processes can get some stuff rolling for this group to start to evaluate and listen to and take a look at uh as we get to the end of January AR into February so you've already had a little bit of insight into what are some of the challenges that lie ahead we've talked many many many times about enrollment Trends here hey earlier you heard this year down 441 students from from the year prior hey

101and that's that's significant obviously in that that big equation he we're awaiting what are the new projections like based on you know kind of start this year as a new normal where do we end up uh looking at for next year and then 3 to four years beyond that so anxiously um you know awaiting seeing some of that information talked a little bit about the implementation of a new school Finance formula what does that extended implementation of going from six years to seven years mean uh and what does this elimination of averaging me now as mentioned earlier really what it means and I'll editorialize a little bit is a budget stabilization factor in a different uh really in a different name hey we'll hear a lot in this legislative session that there's no budget stabilization

102Factor well elimination of averaging regardless of which formula we're talking about does free up resources to the state of Colorado from 190 million to maybe 200 million or more dollars so it's just I I again a n talization but it's a same mechanism different name kind of thing now I do also think that uh the legislative session will look a little differently when it comes to uh the discussions of the governor's budget requests this year last the last couple years what we've seen is the governor rolls out a request we have a lot of talk a lot of things happen for five four or five months and then it's kind of always settled back pretty close to that request guess and and certainly it's just a guess right now my guess is this might be

103a little different I I think these are topics that are going to generate significant conversation and um and maybe have a lot of other opinions and constituents weigh in heavily on when it comes to things like especially that averaging there are large districts there are many districts that would be impacted significantly By changes in that mechanism of the formula for us that might mean aill million dollar for other districts it might be tens of millions of dollars so uh that that is going to be really um interesting to to not only watch and listen to but see how it impacts the process and how long it's going to take for us to have some answers here on top of everything else we have the challenges of really fewer Statewide resources for ongoing programs and example

104is the healthy meals for all program an extremely popular one that's relatively new providing healthy meals to all the all the kids in schools and what the state of Colorado has found it's so popular that it's been tremendously expensive and now we have to find dollars to fund it that's just one example a even other pressures that can be exerted on the state budget things like Corrections um think Transportation law enforcement Whenever there are other pushes and pressures on the state budget K12 is impacted because just like our budget there's a finite amount and and the more demands there are the more it gets spread out other other parts of the budget have to make sacrifices so we'll uh we'll have to monitor those as well it's it's going to be a busy busy I

105think winter when it comes to the state of Colorado budget uh this is not not an easy slide to read certainly this timeline but it's in your packets for you to review a draft timeline of the budget process uh really if I were to summarize it I would excuse me address uh the things we've already hit on that student based budget true up based on the October count ongoing now we will revise our District budget in January uh for approval by the board at the end of January and and there will be some significant revisions this year we're adding an extremely large uh local Revenue source which is incredible and we're going to build a new fund that will be in the budget to house that debt-free Mill Levy and in doing so there will

106be changes to the general fund and so all of that will be in a revised budget in January for you all to review uh and and uh on top of that we'll also have finalized October count impacts on our Revenue so that will be reflected as well and I already talked about the SBB cycle for next year that'll be out to schools by February 14th and we await multi-year projections for district enrollment a little later in the winter and spring so that we can continue to to do our modeling to the best detail that we can all right with that open up for some questions thank you so much Brian that was great and I know that it means uh you know having to make some changes in January but I I feel like once

107again it's um we have to send our appreciation to the voters for giving us this problem of having to make changes in in January it's a really good problem to have so we're we're thrilled with that so once again to the voters just a huge thank you this is going to make um everything that much easier um I also just want to highlight the fact that you know we are still talking about unfortunately um we are not funded to where we need to be um and you know looking at close to a million dollars in cuts um next year with possibility of this um renamed or reallocated BS Factor whatever you want to call it um with a lack of averaging um you that is something that we need to be aware of and be

108concerned with and I think the our voters need to be aware of that as well that um this is something that as a school district and school districts throughout Colorado have to deal with um that these things are fluctuating and uh we are at the mercy of um the the governor and the the governor and the and the legislative and the fact that we have our taxes are are finite are are the money that we're working with is finite so I just wanted to you know just reiterate all of that we we do have an interesting um circumstance in front of us a good challenge in how to deploy a new local Revenue stream yes a significant one make significant impacts on the district but also deal with the potential of a state revenue stream

109they may not generate any new Revenue potentially and so uh with a low inflation rate driving the per pupil rate depending what our enrollment Trends are we're going to have to balance those two things it's going to be interesting absolutely so thank you so much for your work on this thank you anyone have any questions yeah Scott go ahead yeah thank you for the presentation um can you give me the justification that the the governor has for getting rid of averaging like what's the argument for that I know the sense in the room is it's a negative I think it is a negative for us for sure I just don't understand what the positive is uh the only the only Insight I have is listening to um uh one of the members of the state

110budget and planning U group that that basically um said we have to find a way to to um WR right rightsize things more quickly uh as far as the the the K12 budget and not not funding um students that are no longer in classrooms to address other demands on the state budget and and that's me paraphrasing um from a presentation I heard a number of weeks ago other questions Jim did you have something just I was Wonder do you know follow on to Scott's question do you know if other states do this kind of averaging I thought I read something that maybe they didn't do you know it is all over the place okay um and and I have an interesting uh article that that maybe we can forward and and it it can get

111to you all from Moody's uh who does credit ratings on especially school credit and bond issues and and it's really interesting in that IT addresses the same issues that we experience here it's almost like reading about pter school district but it's a nationwide approach and it's um variable School Finance formulas that all some have averaging some don't and and it's all over the place um challenges with declining enrollments challenges with cost of living uh and it's it's like check check check check check that that state after state after state is wrestling with and funding schools other questions go ahead Scott um another question uh the 441 that the decrease in enrollment how close like we're talking about we'll do be doing projections in this budget for 2526 how close was that number to the projection

112for 2425 really preliminarily and I need to see it plugged into the average but I think as far as the number of students projected to be in our schools we came in about 65 higher than the projection some somewhere right in there so that's pretty pretty dang close other questions okay well thank you so much really appreciate it thank you all yeah okay we will move on to 10.2 summer 2025 mil Levy projects update which is very exciting yeah sure is uh thank you for uh the transition here so tonight we look forward to hearing an update on the summer 202 five mil levies projects from our CFO Dave Montoya Dave welcome thank you and uh yes this is a very exciting topic to be talking about um I uh tonight we're going to start

113talking uh one of the things that we were talking in in the cabinet about is that there's going to be a lot coming at you as a board in the next couple months uh especially as we gear up for any projects that we think we can accomplish 2025 um as well as projects that we're going to start really diving into in preparation for 2026 so um so really this is there's no action tonight um what we wanted to do is just kind of give you an idea what might be coming at you um there will be plenty of opportunity to ask questions about these things as they develop over the next couple months um so first thing is just uh kind of grounding us into why we're having this conversation um we've talked about it

114a lot tonight um we want to thank our local voters uh the $49 million override uh that is the debt free malvy override um will be a drastic change to how we're doing business in in the district so um we're really excited about that and when we think about that mevy override we we're really focusing on a number of things recruitment retention School maintenance classroom resources and neighborhood schools so tonight I'm going to focus more on the school maintenance side and some of the things that may be coming at you in short order in the next couple months um as we dive into these projects I I need to I need to qualify a couple things um one is we are we are going at these projects with all intention of trying to get as

115many of them done this summer as we can I also want to ground Us in the reality that we're going to have some things that may be at odds at us being able to accomplish that this summer um things like lead times are real and so we're going to need to look at equipment um the other thing that really is the the only barrier that we're seeing right now is the permitting phase and getting through permits at the state level and we're going to try to get in early but as I think many of you are aware there were a number of Elections that passed uh in across the state and so we expect that those state permits are going to start to populate quickly and and so we may have to reorganize our our

116timing on some of these based on those two things but but really what we did is and uh in kind of thinking about having some Swift action this year this this summer is a little unique and the fact that we needed to wait until we knew what the results of the election were before we could really go forward with some serious detail planning and start spending some money on this what that did is it created a very short window on things that we can get accomplished this summer because of all these things that I've been talking about um so we weren't just sitting idly by waiting for the election we actually started looking at this earlier than the election uh to prepare for that and uh and we did identify a number of projects that

117we felt that could be accomplishable in this short window this first year um understanding that we had wait until November to get an answer and we've got a very short wind Runway up to Summer of 25 um to get be able to do this um and again why we're here tonight is there's going to be potentially a lot of things coming at you in your board packets um you may see contracts for design you may see contracts for contractors um we wanted to kind of give you a heads up about that so that we don't get bogged down on that because we will need to keep moving if we're going to if we're going to stay on these timelines um so just kind of a little brief background and the slide's a little busy I

118apologize for that but I just wanted to ground Us in kind of how we got to where we are at least for this first stage of the of the planning um the first one is just some background we we we partnered with mckinstry we talked a lot about this during the election um and we really started with that data set uh the facility condition assessments that they did um we took that data further and uh our facilities team actually expanded on the initial database we added other categories that McKenry did not include like Outdoor Services playgrounds Athletics um so those were some enhancements that we made to that data and then using this data as well as historical maintenance data we teamed up with the entire operations department so not just project people but also

119the people in the trades and we talked about what are the things that need to be funded first like what are the priorities and in fact I don't have it it's on my desk but there was a list that's on the website that has the fiveyear priorities as we outlined them for the election and many of these project these projects come right off of that that list so that's where that came from um as we think about how we prioritize this always Safety and Security is is a high priority for us and and this is a good time to maybe take a pause to say there's also a lot a lot of projects that aren't in this presentation that already started like last year um we started a lot of door projects for safety and

120so we're going to be continuing to finish those up this summer of 25 um what I'm really talking to you about is these new projects that we're talking about but um but Safety and Security is always going to be at the top of what we're looking at um deferred and preventative maintenance was a very important thing about the election that's what we were trying to accomplish so that was one of our priorities as well as student and staff comfort and energy and sustainability is something that we also want to be keeping track of um what we did is we used some strategies to look for uh cost and labor efficiencies by um combining similar trades um so mckinstry took a very holistic approach to how they they created their database and that's very focused on

121asset asset asset that kind of approach but as you start really diving into it and and we really started dipping our toes into that for the summer of 25 what I'm really excited about is coming back after the break and doing some really intensive planning around looking at projects that we can bundle together to get efficiencies and um and so that's one of the things that we we we tried to do is we tried to identify where is their op opportunity for us to combine some things um to actually move forward in a quicker way um we are also trying to consider our subcontractor Market um concerned about oversaturation in certain categories it's not starting to materialize yet but something we need to pay attention to um and then we also need to think about

122uh system improvements technology upgrades um whenever it's been official to do that so those were some strategies that we used um using those strategies and again there's a clear delineation between what I'm going to show you on the next couple slides and what's going to happen probably starting summer of 26 um because of the short Runway what we did is we identified projects that we thought we could get accomplished now are we going to get them all accomplished this summer probably not but we have a good opportunity to accomplish the majority of them depending on lead times and things but what we what we're going to need to be cautious of is that as we start getting documents in lead times we we get designs closer we're going to really know where these where these

123projects are going to fall our goal is to try to get as many of them done this summer as we possibly can so let's look at some of the the categories that we've identified um as far as things that we want to accomplish this summer if we can uh but in reality some of these may end up having to to move to Summer of 26 because of lead times and other things like that as we get equipment um the big the big one and and we've already kind of talked about this uh superintendent Kingsley talked about this in his in his remarks um we are looking at rooftop units eight air conditioning and boiler projects this is a big this is a big category for us in this C in this um this function and

124this is a great opportunity of what I was describing earlier around identifying where we have opportunities to do things at the same time and so one of the things that we had already planned on doing was some work with batty and their rooftop units okay not air conditioning but we knew the rooftop units were failing so once we knew the answer from 4 a we quickly pivoted and said what would it look like to actually install air conditioning in those units instead of a like for like type of replacement and so that's just one example of for both batty and oday where we've actually identified two schools that we think we could get done pretty quickly um what we're going to need to do is come back after the break and do the detail planning

125for the rest of the five and 10e plan but these are these are the ones that really filtered up to the the um understanding that we think we might be able to accomplish them now I'm also going to pause because those first two projects the air conditioning rooftop units those are extremely big projects and these are the ones that I'm alluding to that we're concerned about lead times um so we've already started talking to designers thinking about this um we are going to be looking at how we can get some electrical components but that might be the barrier for us as some of these electrical components that we might not be able to get um so we will get ready and and you've already approved a uh an amendment to the design contract for us

126to really start robustly um diving into batty and and seeing what that's going to look like um we also have some boiler Replacements in here um one of them is uh the first one on the list there Fort Collins High School is actually a boiler that went down this year and so that is a replacement of something that failed um we are also going to be looking at boiler Replacements at bolts cruise and Laurel um we've got a number of roofing projects that we're going to try to accomplish uh pror High School is another big project and that one we're going to start as much of it as we can this summer if we can get a large amount of it done we will but usually a roof of this size may have to be

127phased over a couple years and so we'll work with our designers and that's what we're going to start working on is how is this going to work how how can we phase these things in um we're also looking at roofs at uh Harris uh PCA Irish and shepardson um we also in this this grouping have identified fire alarm systems I won't read through all these schools but um we have identified a number of fire alarm systems that need to be upgraded um so you can see those schools as well as a building automation system at Fort Collins High School that's a very large project as well um and it'll couple well with the boiler replacement that we're going to be doing there at the same time um and then I I guess I want to

128call attention to that bottom thing on the slide there um all these costs are very rudimentary um they're based on historical what we think internally they may be the reality is once we get the designers on staff and really start getting into the projects we're going to need to refine those they will drift quite a bit up and down depending on what those designs look like but I just want to we wanted to put some numbers behind this but just understand those numbers will change as we go through the design process and get closer to contracts um other projects that we have uh slated uh Carpeting and Flooring projects we got a couple of those um we've got a parking lot project that um that we think we can accomplish in this short window as

129well as um potentially looking at replacing uh track and field replacement at at French field um that would be that's something that's been overdue and something that we need to do and then there's a number of playground projects that we want to accomplish if we can um across the district and again same same caveat on all these These are rudimentary costs as we go forward and bring contracts forward we will understand what those costs are better um these are just a sampling of the con of some of the projects that we're going to be doing there's also a large number of smaller things that we're going to be doing that I didn't want to go through a laundry list tonight but um these were the ones I thought were relevant and and would be of

130interest to the board um coming back to a little bit of about our process and and why we're talking tonight is this really starts with a project need whenever whenever we're thinking about doing a project there's a need and then this this is a fairly normal process here you you enter in a design phase and that's what we like for the batty one that's the the change that we did tonight we're going to go in and really start designing that that air conditioning unit in the hopes of getting that permitting started early okay so that's why we want to get going on design so we can get ahead of Permitting um once we get past the design then we enter into procurement and we go out and we select contractors to do the work um

131typically if those are over $250,000 we'll ask the board for approval not typically we were required to do that um and then and then once the board approval is done then we can enter into the actual construction phase and actually do the work um and and just recently we uh the board approved a project uh for the Futures lab up at the career uh for the advanced manufacturing and that's a good example of kind of how this process works okay um just a reminder because these things are going to be coming on your on your board agendas um we do conduct formal solicitation so formal means that we actually post it on bidet and and go through fairly lengthy process we do um conduct formal solicitations on all contracts or projects over $50,000 um the

132board will be required for any contract over 250 to approve those so we bring those to the board for approval um just giving you a heads up on one of the one of the exceptions that you're going to be seeing and and as we reviewed the projects not many exceptions but the one that we do see is that there is standardization for our building and automation system so that's something we won't go out and necessarily get solicitations on because we've histor we've chosen at a point in time that we're going to use long building Technologies as our building automation system and it's important for us to have the same system across the district so we did some work way back when where we selected them and we're just staying with long and that's just a

133heads up that sometimes those things happen but for the most part um you're going to you're going to see a a normal uh a contract request where we'll describe the procurement that we did we'll describe how we selected the vendor why we selected the vender things of that nature um so next steps there's going to be a large volume of things coming on your agenda um that's a great thing we're really excited about it and it's it's going to do some great things as we look at those some of those lists that we just visited those are things that we would not even be contemplating right now other than maybe replacing that boiler and doing a roof or something that we absolutely had to do 4A has changed how we're going to do business in

134this District so be ready there's going to be a lot coming at you probably through January through April um and uh and and again we're g to we're going to try our best to get as much of this done summer 2025 I don't want to overpromise though because there will be things that have to slip to the next year that's not meaning that we're not doing the project it just means that we had to slide it a little bit but we're we're moving full steam ahead on these um the timeline that we have is aggressive um this window between the election and the summer is a very short window we will not let that window impede us next time we're going to start planning for summer of 26 as I said January of 25 when

135we come back after break so that we have a really nice window of getting s more Runway so that we can be more more Nimble around what projects we're bringing so so the ones we brought are the ones that we think we can do um but it is aggressive we may not be able to get it to everything this summer um yeah and then I already took my other bullet point because I wanted to reinforce that multiple times tonight so that's uh that's kind of where the presentation ends I don't have a question slide but I can take any questions that you might have thank you so much Dave I think this is amazingly exciting and um the what you've laid out for us is truly aggressive and impressive and if we can get you

136know the majority of it done that'll be absolutely amazing um and I know that our staff will appreciate that whether it's air conditioning in the rooms or or doors that you know um are functioning the way they should be or um anything like that so once again to the voters I just need to say thank you so much because this is this is the reason it's happening um because you approved this and um you trusted PSD to make these uh improvements and we are hitting the ground running on this yep I do have one question for you um and that is is it possible to be looking at some of these things doing have to happen during the school year I know that you know big projects like a roofing and air conditioning unit probably

137not but um is there something that we can be looking at throughout the school year and to that end is there any possibility of using swing spaces to you know maybe do a bigger project in a building for 3 months um or something to that effect yeah so so projects during the year um we typically have shied away from those historically but um I think we've got an example up the hill that's actually taking place right now so so I I do think that that's that's something that we can explore um more more possibly I think um we we'll also be exploring any of those creative ideas I think when we come back after the break around um is there shifting that can happen or can we do projects during the school year um given

138the short runway for this Summer that was not achievable but that's exactly the next level of planning that I'm really excited about getting into because like it was like we wanted to get what we could done this year but I'm really excited about setting the stage for that detail planning on how are we going to approach those things and there's all sorts of new ways to look at this and I think that you know I've got Alex here with me we are um we're excited about maybe thinking about things differently where it makes sense excellent thank you so much are there other questions yeah Jess go ahead do we have a sense of there being any supply chain issues I mean that was a huge problem in the past has that gotten any better or

139yeah yeah when I was when I was mentioning lead times that's exactly what I'm talking about is supply chain issues and um for example the a uh the air conditioning projects require a lot of electri electrical upgrades and so we're not necessarily having a time a tough time finding the sourcing the units potentially at some of the other components that may hold us up and so again we're being creative we're talking about is there other ways to do that and and having the designers on board now um and that's good it's good that we were able to move forward with some of these things after the approval tonight because then we can actually really start diving into that and and seeing is there opportunity thanks Steve this is this is absolutely exciting uh to see

140um and I think there's going to be a lot of a lot of happy people um come to start of next year I'm thinking if if there these are the big projects um it's I've gotten feedback that there's a lot of um small projects and a lot of schools that have kind of the work tickets have have added up yeah and some of those I feel like could be potentially done during the school year um When contractors may be looking for work during the winter months interior stuff um I I think you're saying that's your next look is is those smaller projects but I'd like to get some of those low low hanging fruit things touching other schools that maybe not on this list so everybody feels like hey yeah something's happening actions being taken

141with this these new dollars I think that's a really good point to make and um I want to call attention to something that's also happening that I wasn't thinking about bringing up but I think it's really good for you to know we've convened a group of principles and staff to actually review our project proposal process because what you just described of projects out there in the system some have been around for a long time some are not documented well and so what we're talking about is with 4A there's a great opportunity to do a grand reset to say what are those projects so yes we will be looking at those but I want to establish a good process by which we bring those in and vet those before we just start cranking through them um

142but that is the important part that is another layer of importance to this work work sorry Jess did you have one Connor Dave I think first and foremost this is this is great super excited about getting a lot of this stuff um right now we have you know a plethora of projects to get through um and I'm not too worried about any of them moving up in priority or moving down as money becomes available but in the longer term one of the concerns that I have is and may maybe even near-term concern if we can't get to these projects this year what's our process on the capital carryover until the next year so if we don't allocate all the capital this year a project gets delayed we have supply chain issues what's the process for

143our carryover for that cap so so um I mean what we're still is that we would dedicate once we identify the project and we identified what the cost start typically with a contract we would establish a budget for that and then that budget would move forward into the fiscal year the next fiscal year as needed now everything in the debt free schools levy will need to stay in the debt free schools levy because it's going to be a separate fund so any carryover is going to stay in that category it just moves to the next year so so I think it's just a matter of managing it and making sure we understand how things are moving from year to year but all the carryover will stay and live within that category of of projects okay

144good and then to follow up on that if if we sanction a project so let's say we do phase one two and three at the end of phase three we have Financial investment decision the board approves it that project is sanctioned that money will carry over to whatever the execution time frame is um in the individual fiscal year when those budgets gets moved do you Envision any of the projects that are kind of like on our bench or you know kind of you know there is a need do you see those moving up or we would keep those in the same Capital allocation process um I kind of lost the last part of your questioner can you repeat that again so if we have a project this year 2025 can't get to it but we

145need to but we have a need for something else for something else do you envision a process where we say hey these are these are bench projects that we like to get to and we think we could execute is that so what you're talking about is being able to be fluid with okay this one has to move here but can we fill in some things there you got absolutely I think we can do that and that's what we want to do um and that's that detailed planning that I'm talking about when we come back after break to know which things move and fit where where they can um but yeah we that's that's part of this is that there's going to be times where okay we couldn't get to that this summer because we thought

146we did it's going to move move the next summer but we don't want to lose the opportunity to do things in that in that moment so we'll try to have the the bench so to speak um already lined up with projects ready to go and that way we can pepper them in when we need to a lot of planning that still needs to happen so everything I'm talking about this detail planning like we've got a good five and 10 year plan we've talked about that but the implementation on how we go about that is there's a lot more to that other questions okay go ahead Jess so I obviously we love all of this and I don't imagine there's a lot of folks that are listening in our meetings but they would love to hear

147the things that we're doing do we have a place that the projects that are happening or have happened where that list will live so that people can access it and just feel good about where their tax dollars are going yeah so so I would imagine just like many other bonds or movies that we've had we will stand up something on the website that we'll talk about that we'll work with Communications to to do that but we we have a history of being fairly robust around that uh because our voters do want to see what we're doing with the money and uh and they do pay attention other questions yeah go ahead so comment and just a follow up to the Dave's last statement I really appreciate that question we're going to need to communicate those

148promises made everywhere y from the deis from our social media from our website and our community engagement sessions I just think we need to continue as a governance team holding each other accountable to being in the know around the status of each of those projects pictures and celebrations and ribbons to be cut so I look forward to that uh as we close out this particular presentation and pivot to the next one I just I want to commend Dave and the operations and the finance team who have been working in Partnership for the last 6 months on some significant design work to be able as a result of a successful ballot measure we're able to hit the ground running there are a lot of districts that may have had across the state a successful measure that

149are just starting design work now um and I think your preemptive nature to get ahead of that positions our district quite well not just to engage the workforce thoughtfully but to be more respon be more responsive to our voters so I just want to say thank you and if you could please extend that gratitude on behalf of the entire governance team to the broader uh teams that you lead I would greatly appreciate that yeah I want I want to Echo that and I just want to say thank you for all the hard work that you've already put into it um please rest up because it looks like you got a lot of work ahead of you too so I hope you take the next few weeks to just sort of you know appreciate and um

150the work that you have already done we're already gone you're you're already running rest for the no well it's been it's been fantastic um do take some deep breaths and um we will see you back here for more so thank you so much thank you everybody and thank you to the voters again yeah appreciate it absolutely all right so we will go ahead and um actually does anybody need a break before I just we have one last I want to know if we want to go through or push through or take five okay yeah let's go ahead and take five 5 minutes um so it is 8:35 p.m. we will back here at um we'll call it 8:40 e e check e e e 8:42 pm on Tuesday December 10th and we will be moving

151on with a 10.3 update on District committees yes thank you so presenting an update on our district committees this evening is Dr jod raml our director of integrated Services she's Jo are joined by Barb morang who leads our parent Outreach efforts for our integrated Services Division and uh Chief of Staff Dr Lauren hooton will be joining them as well welcome to all of you thank you so much um uh directors and president Draper and uh superintendent Kingsley thank you so much and Community thank you so much for having us tonight um and inviting us to give you updates on seak and our community outreach efforts so I wanted to talk a little bit about um our roles with seak to start with and so um my role is to attend and be a supportive member

152um I give updates to them and I take their feedback and I bring that back to my leadership team and my role is as the cak coordinator and I help to facilitate and coordinate the meetings and maintain documentation and order food so in August you all shared um your top priorities and it was based on your your conversations and also Community comment and we took that information and they fell into three categories it was membership what goes on the agenda as well as feedback loops and we took that to the September seak meeting and I'm going to go ahead and let Barb share with us um what what would the results of that yeah so um I also wanted to just jump back a minute to say the purpose of cak is as an advisory

153role so really to um provide advice and recommendations on topics um that impact special education and to improve um our special education services across the district um so like Jody said at the September 25th meeting our task was to review the feedback from the Board of Education meeting and see how we could revise the cak charter to address some of the concerns so um this feedback uh is what came out of that meeting and it's documented on um oh well the structure of the meeting first of all is um we uh explore a topic either by presentation or in this case it was the charter break into small groups and have discussion about it and then from those small groups um break into two larger groups or combine into two larger groups synthesis that information

154that was discussed in the small groups and come up with recommendations or action steps in a large group action statement and then that's what informs the um action statement that gets uh delivered to the presenter so in this case um this was a feedback from um from the membership documented on those action forms so their ideas for expanding membership um was to add par professionals from all levels add a child find representative add an athletic director that could um address Unified sports topics add a student representative and continue to find diverse representation and continue to ensure that the number of parents is greater than the number of District staff um let's see as far as the meeting struct rure they talked about um changing the location to a Midtown more central location we did that

155last month we'll probably go back and forth um and then there was some a recommendation on the documentation to continue with no public comment but to create public feedback opportunities outside of seak in terms of the agenda um the recommendations were to provide opportunities to provide for the membership to provide input on topics dedicate time for updates on action items from the previous meetings have more topics per session and balance the needs of the district for feedback and the needs of the membership and prioritize topics relevant to families and so as part of that um a survey was sent out to the membership everyone was in secret and we gathered some information we did not get a big response so sent it out again um and I've gotten a little more response so we'll be

156um reviewing those topic ideas in our January meeting um and then the feedback loop invite Board of Education members to attend cak we do have two Representatives at our uh alternating sessions um and we will be presenting an annual report during the Board of Education meeting at the end of the year another form of feedback loops um that we're incorporating it's a standing agenda item so whatever we've presented the week before and they've given recommendations on um we try always in the next two sessions to come back and say thank you for your input and this is how it's being applied in real time so an example was we went over a program evaluation there was a lot of great feedback I really appreciate it what I said to the board I mean to the

157committee with that sometimes we don't see the forest through the trees and it was really nice to see their perspectives and to see the holes and so I was able to to make some changes to that program aval and I brought that back last time so that is um been really helpful I wanted to say that we wanted to talk a little bit about our parent Outreach but I just wanted to be really known that um parents call me on the daily I meet with parents every week um parents can ask for an IEP meeting at any moment and their teams will accommodate that my the assistant directors and Barb we meet with families all the time so what we're going to talk about next is additional opportunities so not our Norm but things that

158we're doing to increase that dialogue and to increase those opportunities for communication so last month we um hosted a integrated Services Spanish night it was a pilot program and it was really organized by um Danny Zena Torres who's an ILS teacher very passionate ILS teacher at Loc Elementary and he got this all organized and it's a pilot program that was a collaboration with lce language culture and Equity we um had sessions that were in Spanish and um we hope to expand it to the whole District in the future but this was just kind of a trial uh trial Workshop we're also starting to have uh listening sessions so last year we had uh Community Forum uh nights at different schools and um parents came and they were presented information and then we had almost like

159a focus group where they had questions and answers and some of them were open-ended but the feedback we received is that parents really wanted to talk more privately about their issues and So based on that feedback we started these listening sessions parents can sign up for them um for a 30 minute individual session it would be with Barb myself and their area assistant director and it can be any topic that they choose um we're we're getting people signing up um we have date schedule for December January and February this was advertised through email in the newsletter um and on social media and we will continue to uh get the word out there also um through different times of day we realize that some parents can't come in the morning so we have midday sessions we

160have after school sessions so were trying to uh provide a variety of different times for parents to sign up for these we also had a more informal kind of meet and greet um we had one at the Future Ready Center um I believe that was last week uh we had seven parents would have loved more but we did have some parents and it was great camaraderie between each other and sharing information um and we're going to continue to have these at different times of the day throughout the school year we had a parent survey that went out within uh the newsletter that I'll talk about next but um it's still open and hoping to get more input about what topics what uh parent Workshop topics people are interested in what times a day work for

161people to attend events and activities um and just give them space to give us feedback and comments and then um we started doing a monthly newsletter in October it is going out um monthly through email to uh families of students who are supported by special education um and really the goal is to just share information and resources and provide a way for um for families to engage with us through that survey or other other ways um yeah I think that's our last slide but I wanted to open it up for for questions or feedback just know that um definitely wanting to always continuously improve and open to hearing other ideas and suggestions well thank you so much other questions looks like Jim you have one yeah thanks for running the Spanish session especially how was

162attendance at that you didn't say oh sorry it was um it was kind of low but it was um kind of a first effort I think there were probably 15 families maybe that came to that um and it was really the um Family liaison at pter had individually called every single family from pter high school um so really did a great effort in trying to get people there so yeah I'd give yourself some credit 15 didn't sound low to me yeah thank you other questions yeah go ahead Scott thank you guys for putting this together um Jody I really appreciate you taking the Bow by the horns and trying to get a fresh start in your new role um I think this is really important work we've heard feedback for several years now about uh

163the need for um more uh interaction between parents and integrated Services one thing I would suggest I know the community comment that today we we heard about public comment at seak my understanding is that that had been tried in the past you know this is a very emotional um a lot of times emotional topic for people it's their kids they're going through some really hard things so it can get emotional it can get heated my understanding is get it got kind of intimidating for some members of cak that ended up quitting after one session I I think you guys have told me about that so I understand why that might be a challenge um Jess and I uh were on the D AB committee we also didn't have public comment uh it's a group of

164like 50 50 parents it's a big group so it's hard to manage that that was one of the challenges but one thing that I I remember is we would get feedback from parents occasionally via email and they'd send it to the dab General Gmail account uh voicing their concerns uh the exec team had access to that email and would read that and discuss that um that might be a way to get feedback into the into the membership of cak I don't know how many total members you have but it might be good for you to share those emails so that there it can spur meaningful and constructive conversations you're not alone you know that kind of message can be can be uh exchanged between the cak members because I think that's one of the criticisms

165is if they're not allowed to have public comment about a certain issue how they know how do each family know that they're also having those issues and I know some of these other uh talks are ways to do that but I think this would be a good way to insert that conver into the conversation at a cak meeting without the intimidating or the emotional because we all our emotions can can run wild and so I think this would be a good way to do that in a constructive way so that's just a suggestion no I appreciate that and I just want you all know that I don't make any of the rules for seak I'm really just a support and they did discuss it we just look back through our notes and there was that

166one comment that we put on the slide that was made about public comment but I think it's worth bringing back to the group there's a few other things that are loose ends with the charter and we'll be revisiting them in January and I think that's a great suggestion thank you I would also say that on the website on this uh web page for cak it does say that if you have comments or uh suggestions to contact me on the contact for that and so that is on the website I haven't received anything but it's there other questions all right well thank you both so much for all your work that you do and for this great presentation really appreciate itk you yeah my pleasure all right so we are going to switch gears now and

167talk about a couple of other District committies uh that involve Community participation starting with the debt-free M Levy oversight committee so we'll start again with a thank you to the voters for authorizing the debt free Mill Levy so that we can create such a committee to oversee how those funds are spent uh historically in the district we have always created an oversight committee for any ballot measures that are passed and that oversight committee is essentially charged with the functions that we will talk about with this group tonight which is to primarily regularly monitor the implementation of the debt-free mil Levy the program the expenditures that are associated with that and then to help provide transparency and assurance that those funds are being used in the way that we have promised the voters that we will

168use them so this committee once it is convened will be charged with reporting out to the board at least annually uh essentially providing an update on their oversight of the expenditures associated with the debt-free M Levy and we'll have a couple of co-chairs who will be responsible for providing that update we'll talk about committee composition here in a moment um but really we're we're hoping to provide a lot of information to assist in maintaining Public's trust around how these funds are being used in the district so a couple of sources of information that this group will be given will be the expenditure information from our finance department specific to the debt-free mevy and I think this group has probably heard in the past Dave say that we'll be tracking these funds in their own fund

169within our budget so we'll be able to report out on that specifically we'll also be providing with this oversight group with the master schedule of projects to be completed using these funds so some of the work that was described earlier tonight for example would end up on that master schedule of projects that the group would take a look at as they're looking at the expenditure of funding uh we will also ask that the members of this group provide regular updates to leadership in the district so the superintendent and cabinet and that they also work with our Communications team to provide regular updates to our community as well uh as was mentioned we will stand up a web page you can look for that sometime around February of 2025 uh that will have information about how

170M funds are being expended uh one note here is that this is not a decision-mak entity so oversight committees historically are not decision-making entities their job really is not to make recommendations about specific projects to be funded through these Mill dollar but rather to oversee how those dollars are being spent and assure the voters that they are being spent in accordance with the Bal language so what you're seeing here is the list of members that we would bring into this committee so we're looking at a committee of 17 members six of those would be appoint appointed District staff members and then 11 would be selected by lottery so assist uh appointed staff members would include the chief of staff the chief finance officer the lead assistant superintendent and then one representative from each of our

171employee associations to be identified by that employee Association I do want to note this is a little bit of a change in our structure for committees for for the positive and and really ensuring that our employee associations have a voice in this process uh going forward we haven't historically had these dedicated seats so we're excited to bring that into the process this time around uh we will also have 11 members who are selected via a lottery process so that will be four principles essentially representing each of the levels in our system four parents or Guardians with students who are currently enrolled in PSD schools and then three community members who reside within District boundaries we will make an effort to ensure geographic distribution by ensuring that there isn't more than one representative from any single

172school that's filling in these particular roles uh and at any point if we have a Committee Member who decides that they are going to depart the committee will back fill that role in the committee as well we are looking for lottery selected members to serve two-year terms we recognize that when you start a committee everybody has the first two years together and that creates somewhat of a challenge with maintaining historical knowledge over time so what we've we've done in the past is ask some members to stay on an extra year to create a stagger so we create that continuation of knowledge over time uh we will ask the committee to meet at least twice a year uh if they would like to meet more frequently they certainly can do that that would be a decision

173made amongst the committee uh because this is an oversight committee that is dedicated to looking at the expenditure of public funds these are open meetings so if observers wanted to be in the room and listen into that group's work they certainly can do that uh once we convene the committee we'll post all of the leg istics to that web page uh that we'll create as well and then the co-chairs will work together to plan all of the agendas for the meetings and the specifics of the meetings as well uh and those uh co-chairs will consist of one appointed member and one Lottery selected member to be determined by the committee itself our expectation for this group is that they really maintain the best interest of the entire District as they're looking at how these funds

174are expended and not focusing too much on a single School Community we're also asking members to commit to attending those twice annual meetings and if they are missing multiple meetings within the school year then we had asked them to step off of the committee or if a member was not acting in accordance with the charter and the expectations outlined here we would ask them to step off of the committee as well which is our standard practice for district committees like this one uh as I mentioned we will also have the Communications Department stand up a web page that is dedicated to this committee and their work this is where we'll report out on plans for spending Mill dollars on a regular basis and then the communications team will work directly with the Community Committee to

175provide broader updates to the community uh if when they are necessary so we would anticipate regular uh updates going out after this committee meets uh and throughout the year that is an overview of the debt-free M Levy oversight committee I'm going to pause here and ask if there are questions or comments on this committee Kevin raised his hand all right Kevin go ahead I don't have to go first just because I raised my hand if some if others have questions um no go ahead it's up there uh I think my question will be brief um I appreciate that thorough over overview Dr huden um my question when I was looking at the composition was I wonder if you could shed some insight as to why why some of the membership or the the membership criteria

176will be a lottery system and not more intentional with its selection and um if we think back to the long-term planning steering committee um from the spring that was stood up it was an application process I recall and there was a sort of a selection criteria use so I'm wondering um it's both a question and a comment I'd like to learn more about you know the Prudence of it being a lottery system um and also uh I'm curious as to what the other board members think about maybe being a little more intentional about who we select and the reason I say that is because I think that this committee is a is like all our committees but this one in particular right now is going to be very very important um we're on this crusade

177to rebuild our trust thanks again to the voters and to our community for stepping up to the plate and uh entrusting us with the necessary funds that we're going to need to do the work that Dave and Brian and others were talking about tonight um I think giving this committee some more legitimacy um we could think about the composition I'm looking at I think it was the three members from the community um I wonder if if there's an opportunity there to be a little bit more selective in who we would choose and I don't know who that would be but I I'm thinking of someone that would have a little more financial logistical um perhaps architectural gravitas in our community that's expressed a willingness to to show up and serve um so those are my

178thoughts so I I had the question F the Lauren and and and Brian and others and that was my wondering and I'm interested in others thoughts sure so I can start just speaking to why we landed on lottery here we've uh selected committees different ways in this District we've done application processes we've done Lottery processes in the past for a committee like this that is intended to represent sort of the crosssection of Voters who support this measure we felt like Lottery is an appropriate way to go we actually also spoke with Martine carason at uh CSU about this and he indicated to us too with this committee and the one we'll talk about next that actually Lottery is a system of selection that many entities are going towards so kind of becoming more of a

179best practice in that space so that's where we've landed at this time but we're certainly open to feedback I would say if we're going in the direction of an application process looking for specific expertise it would be really important for us to clearly Define what criteria we are looking for and how we would evaluate that you other questions go ahead and Connor oh Caroline I'm just going to be the devil's advocate for the other side of that for lottery um I would think that Lottery is a more fair way to do this because everybody has an equal chance to get on the board and on the committee and I don't think that we want to put our finger on the scales when we're selecting people for this committee I think Lottery makes it transparent and

180fair thank you for that Connor did you have something uh Dr hooton can you tell me more about in the past how has it been recruiting people for these uh committees that's a great question uh director brokish we historically have often heard great enthusiasm about committees and I will get like three applications so I would say that often there is a lot of discussion of the committee and not necessarily a lot of community maybe follow through on applying to serve on the Committees and particularly serving over the course of a couple of years so that was kind of my question and not to get into the weeds you might not have thought about it but what is going to be the requirement for Quorum on this committee I think we would do probably a majority

181of each type of group but we have not clearly articulated that yet and then I have a question on um so one representative from paa Ace and Pace um would it be would it behoove us to have two representatives from each I know it increases the numbers but it also gives us the chance that if one can't make it um it's still all the information still gets back to the um paa a and Pace um I don't know if that's it you know it's just a thought yeah we can certainly consider doing that other questions so they simply have like a backup instead of them both attending yeah yeah I mean that's what D did triggering thought yeah I mean it's what we do as a board too we have somebody who's a stand this

182standing um person on the committee and then somebody who goes in when somebody can't attend um just as a knowing that that information needs to get back to Ace paac and and paa um would be good I I like the idea I think one of the things that I'm wrestling with in my mind is that this committee is intending at least from onset it might change based upon the will of the committee to meet only twice throughout the course of the year so I think having backups you may lose continuity um again I think the spirit of the request is good and I'm certainly open to it with staff but I think that would be one thing that I'm just kind of trying to help make sense if they're only meeting twice a year um

183making sure that those people are able to be at the table I think is really important just food for thought yeah I so maybe maybe considering doing two of each of those um so bring your total to 20 members um I don't know if that becomes too unwieldly but something to something to think about we appreciate the suggestion other questions okay thank you so we're going to transition now to the comprehensive planning committee which is also a new committee that the district will be standing up um for those who have been around around in PSD for a long time you might recall that we have historically done longrange planning committees more as a committee that does a particular project or a set of work and then is disbanded this comprehensive planning committee is intended to

184be a standing committee so one that continues to exist in the district over time kind of like the daab or the DAC that sort of thing um so this standing committee would be charged primarily with monitoring evaluating and making recommendations to District leadership specific to facility utilization boundaries the possible need for new schools if we were to enter a growth phase as a district including temporary modular placement in areas of the district where that may be necessary due to growth and then uh large scale Renovations as well the work of this committee is specifically informed by two District policies so District policy JC and El 2.3 both of those are a ailable on the PSD website for those who are curious to take a look at them but they essentially dictate that changes to boundaries

185are the responsibility of the board so that decision would lie with the board at the end um when a committee and staff bring a recommendation forward so the specific responsibilities of this group are to start by reviewing and understanding those two policies that I mentioned and then also to take a deep dive into the work that has already been done in the longrange planning space in the district so that would include looking at the facilities planning steering committee report from the spring of 2024 and the work that they did also looking at the small schools committee report from 2010 as well as the master planning committee work that was done in anticipation of the 2016 Bond and the boundary committee that was associated with the opening of new schools as well so we had asked

186this group to take a look at that historical information as they're grounding themselves and getting started we would also ask that they really spend time reviewing and understanding data that are relevant to the work that they'll be doing and I'll provide a list here of some of the data that they would start with uh and then their their first primary charge as an entity would be developing criteria specific to enrollment and building utilization that would inform possible conversations about boundary changes consolidations new school constructions modular placements that sort of thing when conditions warrant in the future so they would be charged first with coming up with those specific criteria the district would provide to this group a plethora of data you're seeing a list here of the data that we typically provide to longrange planning

187or comprehensive planning type of committees if there was additional data that this group decided that they needed we would help to support the acquisition of that data to inform their work as well we're also asking that as this group starts to do their work and starts putting together recommendations that we are very intentional about sharing that information with District leadership before we start sharing that information publicly so that we can make sure that we're communicating with all facets of our community uh kind of in a sequence as information and recommendations are being developed um as I mentioned if the community needs any additional resources we would work with them to determine what those resources are and then to provide them through the district's procurement processes as necessary uh this next bullet point subject matter experts

188and representatives from schools will also be brought in to support committee work I think is particularly important when we talk about a committee this large so what you'll see when we look at the composition of this Committee in a moment is that we're not trying to necessarily have a representative of every facet of the district's operations sit on the committee or every facet of the community that might inform this work sit on the committee permanent permanently rather we will bring folks in as subject matter experts as the committee is doing their work to help inform that work going forward so if for example we decided that we needed to talk with the county about something relevant to this work we would work with the county to bring in the appropriate subject matter experts to inform

189the committee as they're continuing to move forward from the district side you'll see for example there is not a transportation representative in this list of membership again that would be sort of the subject matter expertise that we would bring into the committee if we're at a point where we're looking at changes that could potentially impact Transportation Systems the same with school Representatives so if we are at a point where we're talking about changes that might impact a particular school it is at that point we'd bring in school leadership and other representatives of the school to speak to that school's needs as opposed to expecting those who are sitting on the committee longterm to represent anyone school's interest in this particular work again this is not a decision-making entity the the role of this group is

190really to provide recommendations to staff which would then come forward to the board so this is the list of committee members for this particular group so we will have nine appointed members on this committee one assistant superintendent a representative of facilities and operations as well as Finance we will also have representatives from integrated services and language culture and Equity again a representative from each of our employee associations that will be identified by that Association and psd's District architect as well in this case also you'll see that we have 13 members selected by lottery four principles representing essentially each of the levels uh and six parents or Guardians with student students currently enrolled in PSD schools one from each of our feeder systems and then three community members who reside within District boundaries we would make

191an effort through running this Lottery process also to ensure Geographic diversity uh across our system in all of the seats that are filled here uh we will also have a board of education liaison who will be appointed by you all to sit in on the work of this committee their goal is not necessarily to partic partipate in the discussion of the meeting but really to be an observer in the meeting much like the board liaison function uh and District Advisory Board and then they can share information back to you all as that committee continues to do its work over time so like the last committee that we discussed were also asking members here to serve two-year terms and not more than two consecutive terms we would stagger those two-year terms as well to create that

192continuity of knowledge once we seat this first group of committee members uh we are asking that this committee start out meeting by monthly and I will clarify here by monthly meaning every other month so not twice a month uh unless this group decides that they would like to meet more frequently uh the agenda for their meetings would be determined by the co-chairs which would consist of one appointed member and one Lottery selected member we will also develop a web page for this group's work so that we can regularly report out on what they are doing and the members of the committee would be listed on that website as well the communications department will provide support for communicating through that web page work um we are also asking that this committee present in a public meeting

193to the board at least twice annually unless you all ask for more frequent updates from the group and we're asking that they present at least three times this is cut off on the side at least three times annually to uh the superintendent and cabinet as well so the expectations for members of this committee are to maintain focus on the best interest of the district as a whole versus individual School community so this sort of speaks to this idea of bringing in subject matter experts where they're needed and really asking the the permanent members of this group or the seated members of this group to think about PSD as a whole in their work we're also asking that those who volunteer to be a part of this understand that it is likely that they may have

194to recommend changes at some point and that that can be challenging work uh we also are asking that this group really commit to conducting committee work within the space of committee meetings so with the group that's been seated for this purpose and that we're really intentional about when and how we're sharing out information to the community um we will also ask that folks that join this group be really intentional and reflect about any internal biases that they may be bringing into the work at well as well and really Center themselves on being advocates for all students in our system to help support the group in that space we will do an onboarding training uh prior to starting the committee work which will include orientation to the use of psd's equity framework so that we are

195all grounded in that framework um much like our other committees we do expect folks who volunteer to be a part of this to attend if they're missing multiple meetings then they would be removed from the committee and we would replace them um on that committee going forward so just next steps for both of these committees and then I'll take questions on the planning committee in particular is that we will are at this point planning on Distributing applications for both committees in PSD now which is the district's newsletter in January of 2025 and we would complete the selection process as soon as is feasible after for that so questions or feedback on the planning committee thank you so much other questions go ahead Scott thank you very much this is really important work and I'm so

196glad that we're we're getting to this now and and uh moving forward um I have two questions the first is kind of dovetailing what you were just talking about with the timeline when do you anticipate the first meeting of this committee to be I would say reasonably speaking if we put out applications in January as planned we would probably be notifying folks sometime in February meaning a meeting maybe towards the end of February beginning of March depending on scheduling all right and then this is that that makes sense to me uh this is a more specific question I saw a bullet point says this committee is not a decision-making entity in selecting or recommending specific educational programs is outside the scope of this committee what what's an example not understanding what that means sure so

197a specific educational program for example would be something like core knowledge programming um so something that is essentially defining the instructional program of the school go ahead Jim so let's see I'm actually a little worried about this committee and let me tell you why I read back through the recommendations from the long range planning committee that we had in the spring and one of them was to have exactly this committee that you're proposing and I think what that committee couldn't know at the time was that we would have a mill Levy where we would say hm uh one of the things that we sold in the M Levy was support of neighborhood schools and that basically we're not planning to close a school three to for the next three to five years okay unless there's

198some catastrophic enrollment problem or you know all those things that probably won't happen so I was at the district Advisory Board La let's see this was December 2nd and you you covered all of this to get feedback which was great and it was an interesting discussion because there was a woman in the feedback session that um she was also on the spring planning committee the spring long range planning committee and what she said to me or in a very respectful way by the way was are you actually going to use the results of this committee and I think given that we're not planning to close anything for the next three to five years I have to wonder are we making a good use of the committee members time for the next year or two doing

199this kind of work I I can see getting things going at some point and I you know I I think there's a need for that but I'm I'm nervous that we're hitting this just a little too early so I don't know you can decide or we can we as a board can decide what we want to do with that but you know maybe you form the committee and you have less frequent meetings initially or those kinds of things so there's lots of ways to solve that issue but I want to be really careful that we're not wasting our volunteers time and Jim I think that's it's a great um point to bring up and one of the things that um when I was looking at this what I'd like to see is um not a

200recommendation um yearly but when this group gets stood up have a recommendation at year two um and to make sure that that recommend that take that first year and my thought process was basically run them through PSD leadership so um that they have a a real good understanding of not just how their school works or how they think you know School Finance works but an actual real understanding of how PSD uh works and that could take about a year when PE when people go through PSD leadership training that is um about a year um to do that and I think that would be great um for a couple of reasons one to learn um but two to build that camaraderie um and have that um you know working relationship built up over the course of

201the year and then um going back to you know the specific things that you were going to bring on um the um what was it it was um sorry uh eel uh 2.3 um you know those what we've done previously that's also a long-term study I would hate to see um just that stuff being thrown at you and saying okay you're going to go study that on your own and then we're going to come back and have a conversation about what to do next I think those things having the the foundation of how PSD works and then having the um the background knowledge of what was done previously uh or why things were not done previously with would be extremely helpful and so I see starting um you know if you were to start now

202I would start there and say but we don't want to even see anything any recommendation until at least year two possibly even year three and honestly my thought process on that is about um you know we'd be looking at boundaries at that point um and seeing how boundaries are affected um because we are putting in that moratorium of um no you not not talking about school closures for 3 to 5 years um boundaries on the other hand are things that we just shifting we're not um talking about closing schools so that would be um that would be my thought process is that um it really would be a great training opportunity for those people to have that background knowledge to understand what it is we have done previously to understand why we didn't do other

203things um previously and then to kind of start from there um but then you know have them do the meetings but we don't necessarily need to have the reports about what their meeting about their meetings until um you know I would say year two that's just a thought yeah Caroline so I hear what you're saying Jim I I think you're right maybe it could be too long of a Runway but I'm not sure that it that it is because when we stood up the last committee I think what we heard is they felt really rushed and it was taking a time for them to assess and collect all the data that they felt like they needed and to agree on what the facts were and I think that some of that work can happen now

204you know before they have to start um thinking about recommendations so maybe in the beginning not meeting so often but I do think that we need a longer runway for them you know just based on our our last experience Scott yeah I'd agree with that Carolyn and I think I understand where you're coming from Jim because it is going to be a a long process but I think that's part of the reason to do this is is we saw that we had a credibility and a trust problem and I think this is one step to build that trust back is that hey we are now taking a measured slow long-term approach to this uh problem and hopefully it won't be a problem in 3 to 5 years but but I think this committee can not

205just look at um you know boundaries or consolidations or any of that sort of thing but growth like hopefully we have growth that takes a long time to figure out Carolyn you had to deal with that going back to 2016 like that's uh a big deal and and we have the fruits of that planning now with Wellington and Timnath and and we're seeing great great things from that so I think it's it's it's both issues and I think we'll we'll build our credibility back if we have this you know it'll be easier for the community to accept decisions that are really hard if they know we took our measured time to do it and Kevin has raised his hand just doesn't go ahead Kevin thank you Dr huden um I agree with a lot of

206what's been said I I um this is my comments are going to build upon those um and Jim I here's what I think I think that this was it's kind of an amazing thing of where we are right now because this was one of the firm recommendations of the long-term steering committee so here we are and we're standing this thing up and we're talking about its purpose and we're talking about its composition so um I I I like the the comment that you made I I I think I'm closer to what um president Draper has said though I I think that this is and there's a reason my thinking is this should be a little bit of a slower burn before decisions or recommendations are made in the consolidation or closure for a couple of

207reasons first as as president Draper said I think that first year is g to be really about forming and norming and establishing the why and what they're going to do um what the Criterion they're going to review when they're having these discussions in year three four five Etc um I do like the boundary update every two years I think I think that's great so if we're going to do this by year and say the first year is really purpose scope Clarity and what are we what are we actually going to accomplish in the next couple years um two could be the heavy lifting of you know a boundary a reab boundary analysis that's going to give our community the time that we that I believe they've essentially bought in that mevy override and that that

208we keep saying three to five year moratorium but we we can't do this work instantaneously and expect good results so it's going to have to be a both end and so as we're analyzing the enrollment Trends in our district we need to be putting the the framework in in ready if if the worst case scenario happens again and I think that's that's the conversation that our community was begging us to have is to slow down let scrutinize this a little bit more carefully and so I think by the time we get to year three we're going to have a really good data set of where we are as a district as far as our enrollment Trends I'm I'm discouraged to hear that we're already 441 students down I tend to be an optimist and we've

209got opportunities ahead of us to do some really important work and while we're on that subject before I get to composition because I've got a couple comments about composition um we've heard a lot of uh of um our community and schools and affected people from last time saying you know please hold us harmless and leave us alone and I want to challenge that thinking a bit or just maybe um uh revise it slightly that suggests that a school is its own universe and should be responsible for increasing its own enrollment and I think that the the you know uh blevens comes to mind they're a great school that's doing a lot of Outreach right now doing engagement right now to sort of to get their numbers back where they need to be but they can't

210do it alone um and nor can any of our schools so I want to kind of challenge the thinking that this is your problem and put it back to PSD this is our problem one of the one of the U the sessions I I attended in casby was about school turnaround and it was about the role of the local board and anticipating when turnaround conversations were coming from the state and then trying to get out in front of it being proactive when you see declining performance now again we're talking enrollment which is different than academic performance but you know I think they're ex ably linked and so I think we have a duty as a board as a governance team to start really both supporting but also scrutinizing our enrollment Trends in certain sectors and

211start thinking a little boldly about what we're going to do to address it I think just hoping the problem is going to go away on its own in three years with uh with the money from the mil ly I I I personally think it's wishful thinking I think we need to be doing more things and this committee to me is one of those things it's not just analyzing a problem it's also what are the support measures we can offer to these schools that are in need of enrollment decline right now uh financially logistically what are those things um is that appropriate for our government seem to take up but that's a conversation I think we have to be having and so just hoping the problem goes away I think is inappropriate um the second point

212I was going to make is about composition um I've been thinking a lot about compositions of these various committees since my question last time on the last the the accountability one the only one and I I I I invite cabinet into the room they're thinking this the the composition of the long-term stering Comm Committee in the in the spring was hugely inclusive of our community members um and so that that again to me gives it both the transparency and legitimacy of that Nexus between our community being part decision makers or part um problem solvers with with our staff who are doing this hard work every day and so because of that I'm encouraged to hear that there's going to be a board liaison I think it should be a rotating one personally because I think

213you're going to get a lot of different views um from different sessions um from board members but I also challenge um and this again I invite some conversation about this I'm I'm I'm somewhat concerned about having an assistant superintendent on that committee and and not an observer role and here's why for the same reason I think that it would be somewhat inappropriate for me to be a member of that committee and start thinking you know including my thinking in the matter and saying this is what I think this is what director avela thinks you know you all ought to do that carries a different weight than you know another person that the community that's not going to have to make the vote right same is it's it's similar Dynamic I think for an assistant super

214which is the the composition of those PSD staff are going to be looking at that person as somewhat their boss and so I think they're going to be taking the lead from an assistant super in lie of you know maybe getting creative with their own thinking and challenging status quos and things like that so I invite some conversation from other people on that that was just one one thing I had about composition but again I think in order to legitimize whatever recommendations are made we need to be incredibly thoughtful about who's going to serve I mean we're already well in the way and I credit the the thought that's gone into this already especially with the Staggering approach I'm I'm a huge proponent of that too um but those are my my unfiltered thoughts thank

215you Kevin anybody have any good Connor looks like you got something so Dr hoot and I I support creating this committee wholeheartedly um compensation I'm okay with uh I suggest um having at least in the first year meetings quarterly and um also for the rest of the board members I think that we should kind of uh wait um to see how many people actually sign up for this um I I I think that we may be unpleasantly surprised that the Vigor at which the community came out for uh the long range planning committee last time will not be there this time other thoughts Jess I mean since everybody's talking um so I remember when I was first on the board and when Tim nith opened at that time I can't I want to say he

216was a planner District planner but he recommended that we I mean because we had not looked at boundaries in ages and part of that I think was just that it's hard part of it was probably Co but even at that time he recommended doing it at least every 3 years and I feel like having a committee that consistently is at least checking in on it is valid I also think that we still despite stopping last year we still made some decisions this year with regard to Tim nith with regard to our transitions programs um if we don't have any committee to do that we're continually just dependent on ourselves and hoping that our community is going to follow whereas this provides some level of predictability we are consistently talking about it what we heard a

217lot last year was that it was shocking and nobody knew the problem was coming at least if we're consistently talking about it you know where our data is or if you don't it's not because we hit it right we are being more transparent by having a committee that's consistently looking at it um I also agree with uh president Draper and a lot of the other folks that have been talking about having a timeline right I appreciate the first year being establishing our the Baseline of our system establishing how our system matches our systems our community's values making sure that they do build rapport because I think that was also a challenge last year they had to hit the ground running there was no time for them to just sit and Community with the data and

218absorb it they had to start making decisions immediately which is part of the challenge so I I like the composition of the community of the committee um I don't have strong feelings at the moment about the assistant superintendent voting or not that was a new thought that I hadn't considered um I think that's mostly what I wanted to say but I appreciate the committee I think it's a good idea I think it's a good thing to do long term so thanks go ahead Jim I'm still just a little concerned but I can support thanks for your comments yeah and I I very much support this I think it's uh be great to have this um just standing committee so that we know you know and and again my thought process is that um if if

219we're more fluid about this if we are are knowing that every two years we're going to get a report about boundaries um we know that you know in an even year we might get a report about a boundary that may say we want to we're suggesting you move something um they may come back and say everything's great we actually just looked at everything and everything's great um but at at least then we know it's on the radar it's not a surprise to people um so and that's something that we even um in previous years when we look at boundaries it's been that has been a surprise that has been an emotional reaction and I'm not suggesting that we go back and forth I'm just saying that it would be nice if we had um data

220numbers the why and the suggestion and then becomes ours to wrestle with so I think something like that every couple of years would be really great did you have something Jim just does anyone from Administration want to comment on Kevin's question about the administrative superintendent and I don't know the power thing and all that kind of stuff yeah I think you know some of the feedback that we've had over time like I'm thinking back to the small schools committee that um was in 2010 and there were principal representation um on the committee but those principls maybe had their perspective of what the their school did and then maybe tried to speak for other schools and so I think the idea behind the assistant superintendent role is to have a perspective of all of those schools

221and being able to you know think through implications as well as you know the programmatic Parts as far as it being like a voting member or anything like that I don't think that that's as important as it is that you've got someone who is you know really involved in the day-to-day operations of the schools in the district which I think a principal can do a really good job of providing maybe their perspective on here's how it runs here in my local context and you need somebody who has that broader view of all of the schools and the programming and the interdependence IES with one another and so you know thinking about who would serve that role would be something to consider go ahead so I'd like to Echo what Dr Kyle just said I don't

222like like her I don't have any specific position on whether it's a voting member or not but I think having them strictly as an observer would prevent a lot of institutional Knowledge from being front and center within the work of the committee so that's you know my food for thought on that particular topic um you just if I can I say a couple just other things would that be okay yeah yeah are you sure oh Kevin wants to respond Kev did you want to respond to that yeah just briefly um I what I think I heard was Dr G's volunteer herself as tribute um a little bit no I mean that makes sense and and the reason we're we're we're having this discussion is that I haven't made up my mind on anything I just

223I that's the tension that I that I see and I think Jim and I had some pretty good conversations about us the board members not being in the room at all because we didn't want to compromise the Integrity of the the organic nature of the the recommendations that were flowing and so that that was my only concern there's a way we can thread that needle because I think uh superintendent Kingsley make a good point we want we want our best and brightest and our most talented in the room when we're having these tough conversations I just don't want it to be steered uh one way too heavily and the the other thought on that too and I think this is I'm picking up something that maybe you were alluding to director brokish Maybe you weren't

224but I and I I don't want to speak this into existence but I do like having decision points in align with what we had told our voters we would do so I think that we've got to understand what the problem is and where what what we're going to do in years one and two and then year three four and five we have to make a commitment that we're going to actually resolve the problem and I think I the reason I like this this committee being stood up is because it has the air permanence to it it's going to outlive you know the directors on this board and by what what I mean by that is that I this this this committee is a crucial Okay Kevin if it looks like you're not with us anymore

225so I apologize yep Scott did it oh he's there and you back PSD TV has taken over control I don't know oh okay all right well Kevin if you can if you can um hear us just jump on back in when you um when you can while they're trying to get them back one quick clarifying question will these meetings like the previous committee be open to the public the intention is not for them to be open to the public because it is a working committee that will be discussing information that we'd like to be sure we're sharing with the community in a measured way yeah thank you for asking that question I think you know something that I believe that we all can collectively agree on is that our community right now is craving stability

226it's craving deep transparency and in many spots it's asking for some level of healing and I think as we want to be transparent we also want to make sure that sensitive information and ideas are being circulated in those particular meetings if those got misconstrued in any way and miscommunicated in any way it could cause a lot of harm especially knowing the emotional underbelly and current that is running through uh our district today that I think we need to be incredibly sensitive and mindful of you know I think what I and to build off what many of your comments were uh this makes this work not an event but it makes it a way of work in this District moving forward and last year's long-range planning efforts you know felt more like a Sprint to our

227community than a marathon I think we heard that loud and clear and I think this is being responsive uh to that work which I'm really really grateful for if there's something that I could ask the board to be to weigh in on and to be as a collective and individually very direct and explicit with your charge to this particular committee is a couple of lessons learned from last year that I think we really have to think thoughtfully about making sure that there's no scenarios for a specific set of time because I think if we are out there and have just promised the community that we've bought three to five they have bought as a result of their voter support three to five years of stability barring any unforeseen circumstances I think creating scenarios that are

228naming particular schools in the short term and I think this was what director brokish was alluding to many of you were building off of can cause a lot of emotional distress even though the intentions might not be to act on it for three to five years so I I I really believe this Board needs to have continued dialogue prior to launching this committee that gives a very specific set of parameters on when you would even want to entertain or maybe that's to be determined right or and I don't know if that's the right way of approaching it because I think the ambiguity leaves people in a space of is it now is it next year but I think getting very clear and explicit around when scenarios would be appropriate when would Criterion be appropriately named

229because Criterion and the data is what the data is so even discussing publicly the Criterion schools will start to name and identify themselves in their respective communities will be so I think being mindful of when you would want to as a collective entertain the thought of some of those things surfacing out of this committee I would just ask to be as direct as possible with that Comfort level and I think a couple of you uh appropriately suggested a timeline of whether it's not until year two or you know so some of of you were building off of that but I didn't hear from all of you and the last piece that I would ask and it kind of builds off of this and I don't know if you feel that this is appropriate you know

230one of the things the steering committee last year did an incredible amount of work in a short period of time and that's really commendable and we're on we're better District as a result of the work that they've done but I think one of the Lessons Learned as they were working in partnership with this board and in partnership with this district is we lost control of the scope of the number of schools that were being iated about which created a ripple effect around not knowing whether it's the entire district is involved in this is it some of the district some parts and I think a lesson learned for me as the superintendent is I would like for us to think about how to incubate this change in a more thoughtful manner moving forward and I think

231we all in hindsight like I've learned from my mistakes and I think we're all learning from these circumstances to really prove have a proof of concept that any event that we have to make hard decisions in the future that we can prove to this community through a trust and a human- centered approach that we can actually do it in a way that they realize they're getting something better as a result of that change and I think our ability to do that at a scale of four six 10 schools I think is really really really difficult and I think we have in in the spirit of rebuilding trust have to think about that in a very very small scale to prove to this community that we can do this well and we can do that with

232them and not to them and that's feedback that I've heard from a multitude of of members and I think that requires this board to be very direct around how you want to see them manage scenarios and manage change and I think leaving that up to the group I think is something for us to be thinking about and talking about I'd love your thoughts on those on those things first thing Uh Kevin I believe you're back so if you'd like to um jump back in that'd be great sorry I was I was on a havela tear and I don't know where I got cut off um one of those times where you you're talking to someone on the phone and you have a great thought and then you realize that no one heard it so um

233I I don't know where I cut off so I'll try to truncate as best I can it sounds like I was talking very similar with what superintendent Kingsley was just mentioning was one I do think that we need to have this this committee as a very permanent structure and that it will Outlast any kind of you know uh candidate or board director that may be running to do certain things I think we need to be very intentional with the purpose and the timeline of decision points so in year one we're forming in storming year two its boundaries whatever it may be and year three to five because I that also mirrors the commitment we made with our community I think I've got lost again no you're there okay great sorry my screen froze um so

234I think in year three we'll have enough data to suggest this is where the enrollment trending is going in these sectors of town um I don't know how to thread the needle as far as not naming schools or not that's a different conversation but I think having the having the criteria established and then by year three four and five we're making decisions or the board is making decisions as to what to do with that whether enrollment is going up or down we're going to have a good arms wrap around it it's not a sudden thing it has that transparency that we were we were seeking um and it's it's been a long slow burn so I think to to some of the the points that Jim may have been making which maybe he didn't I

235don't want to speak for him but one thought is to we we're right back where we started three years from now Mak with no decision based on a new composition of a board and so I'd like to have the decision points be pretty firm and I think to to Brian's point we need to be very direct about what the what the what this committee is going to be doing and the work that it's going to be doing and I think that's that's a both and it's not an either or we can address the clining enrollment and support our schools where they're where they're hurting in this next two to three years with fora with other bold measures but we can't ignore that Trends may not go in our favor so we have to be ready

236for that and so my suggestion is be in year three four and five we have the hard conversations and decision points about uh consolidation closures what or not uh but we're using a very specific set of Criterion on applying it across the district uh and that so that's that's kind of what I think I think the the the work has to go on and the decision points have to be very clear uh in the timeline okay thank you Kevin yeah go ahead Scott I hate to agree with director havela but I think he makes a really good point just kidding um I uh I think that's an awesome Point actually we we want to give future boards the opportunity to finally make a decision and um not Kick the Can that's that's how we got

237into this problem is years and years of kicking the can it's easier to do that and have the community love you then to make those hard decisions but if we have this committee doing the work um where it's you know the Criterion is there and I agree we don't want people you know guessing you know who's who's on the Block if that is even an option hopefully it won't be but um I think it's really important to to put the structure in place now as our Legacy so that future boards can make this decision uh in a measured uh Smart Way um I like all I like what you said Scott I like what you said Kevin I'm still stuck a little bit though like if I come out next year and I say hey

238gang here's the here's the enrollment level that you will be considered for a future closing three years from now I just think that's um going to settle off a lot of anxiety in the uh community that is really inappropriate than I believe so for me I would much rather have that dis discussion at the three-year Point um because I think that's the time that you know if it depends upon how soon we would need to close a school there's a lot of hypotheticals here right of when would enrollment at a school get below a certain level that this committee proposes that that would um that that school should be closed right so I I I like I think um superintendent Kingsley was going after is I I don't want to do that too soon because

239I think we cause a lot of unnecessary angst too early in the system and I think that's to in my mind that's why I like the idea of if you stand up the committee now you get the year to um you know what Kevin was saying and storm and then you have that that second year to form right and then you can go ahead and that second year be looking at uh I believe we need to be looking at boundaries um for a year or two and still not be looking at school closures because we have said no year you know we are not looking at those um until at least 3 to 5 years so once having looked at those boundaries um then we're able to kind of reset for the following two years

240to say okay those boundaries what has that done now um for our enrollment numbers um where are we seeing um you know enrollment continue to drop that we cannot work with boundaries on that um and then go ahead and have that conversation do we need to do something Beyond boundaries because I think the first you know the first two years that's what we're looking at in in in my thought process yeah Conor go ahead I'm feeling like we're starting to beat a dead horse here so I I don't think we're asking for a vote tonight right so otherwise I'd call for the question that sounds question has been called so to speak so um do you have what you need I think we have feedback that we can take back and then determine some next

241steps from here okay thank you so much much um and thanks for all the hard work that's been put into forming these various committees and um just making them work we really appreciate it so Kristen I I know that was the last thing on our agenda but um being sensitive to the fact that no board member can ask the superintendent to do something without agreement from other board members I was um tonight um impressed by suda UK who came to talk to us about scoliosis screening and I know we've had other students come and talk to us about really important issues to them and I wonder um I was just looking on um the scoliosis foundation's website and I see that Colorado is one of the states that does authorize scoliosis um screening and does

242allow it by School nurses or third parties and I guess I'd like U an understanding of what we do if anything to to screen kids for scoliosis and so I just right now would just like some information about it and I wonder if this is one of those things that's lwh hanging fruit that we can put in place for you know a minimal um Financial um amount so I just wanted to see what the rest of the board felt like I think exploring that would be a great thing I was very inspired by what she shared and I have that as a action item already in my debrief tomorrow to look into what our current state I will tell you I personally benefited from those screenings myself in school and many have many friends that

243benefited from them um same as uh the young person from Rocky shared today so I think I want to look at what our current state is be able to share with this board what the opportunity is and I'll come back with you uh to you uh early on in the new year um with what I find okay yeah thanks for asking thank you all right and with that uh I now would we are now now adjourned at 9:56 p.m. on Tuesday December 10th good night I'm going to beat everyone [Music] home e e for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.