001e e e she's [Music] they're not concerned enough to stay [Music] start Speed those up next time kids yeah have to get them to school IND we can maybe anothere or one we it's up to the Denise joh you okay good morning I'm going to call our meeting to order and we'll begin with uh roll call please please St boy here Denise Chapman here thank you Amy Doran Don Kirk here Barbara Cruz here Alexander LOM Nancy rumfelt here thank you Laur um Nancy would you please lead us in the pledge oh yeah of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under indivis let's start over should we go back to indivisible forgot the indivisible start over I'll redo Nancy redo over yeah it's like where's she going
002algi to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Nancy pres yes um Don would need to State for the record why she's participating virtually okay thank you all right um first item of business Don can you um St why you're joining us virtually uh because I have because this is a meeting a special meeting it has to be somewhere else right after okay thank you okay thank you all right um first item of business will be the adoption of the agenda for today so this is would be for um oh my gosh this would be for today's date which is um December 13th and um I just need to know if there are
003any changes or additions to the agenda before we approve hearing none I will take a motion to adopt the agenda as printed so move I'll second thank you Laur Lee would you please call the role who's seconded I'm sorry oh I did you did okay thank you stu Boyd I Denise chman hi Amy Doran Don Kirk hi Barbara Cruz hi Alexander lesum Nancy rumfelt I thank you so we will begin with public participation and I'm going to ask steu if you could read for for us the um guidelines for public um comment because the board wants to hear the viewpoints of the public and also needs to conduct its business in an orderly and efficient manner it shall schedule time during its regular board meetings for brief comments and questions from the public the board
004Shall Set an unlimited time for public participation prior to the business portion of the meeting however the time for each speaker shall be limited to three minutes and each individual will only be recognized once public comments and questions at a regular meeting May deal with any topic related to the board's cont conduct of the schools speakers may offer such criticism of school operations and programs as concern them but are encouraged to exercise their speech rights responsibly the board encourages the discussion of all Personnel matters to be conducted in executive session thank you stu and is there a list yeah yes all right and just so you know um I'll start the timer there'll be a green light when we get to 30 seconds it will yell and then red at 3 minutes so Lori Goble
005good morning that's kind of a change isn't it um Lori Goble I live here in uh Thompson School District uh W 3 here in Loveland and last year um Madam president board members Dr Schaefer I stood before you and asked you very very pointedly to please reduce the mill Levy in light of the increased assessments that were before every single property owner here in the district um that didn't happen and sadly um you know everybody is there a lot of people um got a lot of seniors like such as my mom a lot of people that are are working and literally literally surviving paycheck to paycheck and I think the board right now you have something before you where you could truly make a compassionate stand I asked for this last year and I'm asking
006once again please don't change the mill Levy you could have lowered it last year in light of the increased property values and you chose not to do that uh once again that question is before you find folks here today and having this meeting on a day when most people are working their job 9 to5 to put food on the table provide for their family uh nice Christmas for for for their children and by stepping up and saying you know what in light of all this we're not going to increase any anything something I'd like to bring up to you is the fact that um there are two businesses two very large corporations here in the United States uh Tractor Supply and Harley-Davidson you say what in the world do those two companies have in common
007well they chose to scrap their Dei programs because they were not seeing the results uh Walmart has also made as a corporation has also made that same stand so my question is uh what first of all how much more did the school district receive in light of the increased assessments how much money is being spent on Dei programs and maybe we need to look at the budget and please give a break to the Fine citizens of Thompson School District thank you for your time that's public good okay all right um we will move now into discussion action items and this would be item 4.1 which is the approval of preliminary 2025 me Levy certification so um I assume it will be introduced by Todd and then okay rusty rusty okay all right oh that's right
008so welcome Rusty thank you I should have asked beforehand but do I read this memo or just talk about what I'm here to okay uh good morning uh Madam president and members of the board Dr Schaefer uh my name is Rusty Williams and I am the new um CFO interim CFO for the district and I am here to ask you to certify the mill ly rates um I believe Gordon presented these back in August and uh the actual assessed valuation went down $3 million from the preliminary numbers we received which uh led to a slight increase in the mill ly rate the uh preliminary M rate was 44.87 2 and the final rate will be 44883 so it's an increase of 011 are there any questions for Ry okay um just a minute Nancy I
009will uh take a do I just move into the motion I will take a motion to approve the preliminary 2025 meal Levy certification so move you could take a motion but then n can motion right yeah okay doesn't the motion have to be seconded before there's an amendment well because um what you're doing is um um Barb is motioning on the current I guess it doesn't matter what the order is um but if we you make the motion then it's seconded then we'll have to act on that I think discussion would follow that and I believe that's when Nancy would make per Amendment we could do that either okay I think that's yeah have a no don't we don't have a second I'll okay second okay Denise seconded it okay is there a discussion around
010this I would um I would like to amend the motion I move to amend that the mill Levy for the 2018 mlo have a temporary prop property tax credit of 2123 to maintain the total mill rate at the 2024 rate of 4 2.76 which will reduce the financial burden of a tax increase for our community okay so you made a motion for that to amend it is there a second to that motion I'll second the motion so that we have an opportunity to discuss it thank you so we'll open it up to discussion and you can begin Nancy explaining a little bit more um much much of this for me is coming from after um reading the close to a thousand comments from the post elction survey of why they voted no and I think
011and also from all the different things I heard at casby last week I think while that yes it will reduce our Revenue I also know that um many times we often outperform the budget and so we still have a lot of preliminary work to do on the budget as I'm sure Rusty knows so I think this would go a long ways towards generating some Goodwill within the community and reading those comments they're um the overwhelming theme is there is a huge trust deficit with the community and the top two reasons I saw was one they simply can't can't afford any more taxes and two the the accountability and transparency so I would prop I would like that's why I'm proposing that we maintain it at the current 4.76 rate with a temporary uh property tax
012credit on the 2018 mlo okay is there further discussion yeah um I will vote against the amendment and I'll explain why uh first of all for the last few years particularly since the pandemic uh the district has experienced declining enrollment that's expected to continue every student that we don't have uh next year that we have this year translates to a loss of about $9,000 uh I believe last year there was an excess of 100 students is that correct um in terms of a decline in enrollment um so that translates to a million dollar assuming that approximately the same number of of uh students would not attend this year um also coincidentally yesterday I had a conversation with representative Ron Weinberg um the board knows that I'm um meeting with the legislators who represent the Thompson
013School District One onone on Monday I met with representative armagast uh yesterday with representative Weinberg this afternoon I'm meeting with Senator Marchman to discuss our new legislative platform to talk about our concerns and the board is aware that the number one issue uh that we wanted to address in our legislative platform is funding and so we talked at about that at some length certainly longer than we talked about anything else and I told him how concerned we were uh how um unsatisfactory the Colorado school Finance Act is it's obsolete uh it was enacted about 30 years ago it needs to be changed he agreed with that I also shared with him the concerns that the board has as a result of the failure of the the U Mill special Mill and the bond issue and
014that what the effect of that will be on the district and at that point he he joined the conversation and he said he's very worried at the state level as well they know there will be a significant budget shortfall at the state level he said we're quite confident we're going to have to cut uh programs we're going to have to to cut funding in virtually every area every aspect of the budget um Nancy mentioned outperforming the budget um we've been able to outperform the budget because the investment um scenario has been very positive uh I did some looking last night at economic forecasts the forecast is that is that the forecast is not as rosy as it has been in the last couple of years so due to all of these factors and because my
015responsibility as a school board member is to make sure that our students have the very best opportunity they can to learn I can't support a motion that would take 6 Mill ion dollar out of the School District budget and so as I said at the beginning of my remarks I will vote against the amendment I understand the reason for the amendment I appreciate uh the time that went into presenting it but I can't support it thank you any further comment or questions make sure your mics are turned on please has either side given uh per pair like what's the actual impact on each taxpayer at the two rates from I I looked I used my home um and it's it's a difference between either a 3% increase or all like a 5.7 but it's hard
016to say that that would translate to everybody because everybody's property is going to be different whether they're in a Metro District or how much their house went up some houses might go up some might go down mine went up so it's hard to say I think for an average and I also think right now it's probably hard to say what the true impact would be because we there's so many things we still don't know like the per pupil funding and all of these things I just know that for us to be able to pass a bond in a mill Levy or any kind of Levy I think this would be instrumental in helping um in the community but I understand Stu's reasoning and I do appreciate him seconding this so we can talk about it
017thank you does Don Madam yeah mad president I also have a comment okay okay um so I just I have several things I want to say um also in explaining why the spirit of Greater transparency so um children raised in communities that divest from their schools generally have lower academic performance and lower graduation rates as well as higher poverty unemployment violence and physical disorders but High performing schools like ours that just produced our best Cass results ever raise property values and then generate wealth in our community because Great Schools increase the resale value in top rated school zones they they often sell for 49% more per sare footage than National Medan and in our more expensive areas of town that increases to 77% more it also drives the demand for property 26 to 42% of
018home buyers consider good schools important homes in good school districts sell eight days sooner on average and communities attract families and new residents and businesses when they have good schools and that act increases all of our communities access to more valuable resources and that creates overall more desirable neighborhoods it enhances the overall perception of our community it includes like a halo effect those communities are considered more stable because when you're investing in kids it talks it really talks about what your values are as a community it also lowers crime rates and that then lowers the cost we have of Public Services like police it decreases the bullying and delinquency that happens inside of school it increases attendance rates students skip fewer classes when we've invested in their education and then that all translates to a
019higher income across our community not just our employees but everybody has an increase in their income when we have good schools but notably we are the largest employer in both level and so when the district pays well it impacts the greatest number of people in our community and what they have available to spend in in our communities um and we already know that we will not be able to match the raises that will be given in neighboring districts which is already resulted in dozens of people contacting me to say they're not sure if they can stay here and that is often our most experienced and best teachers who feel that way um when we invest in our future Workforce we are creating graduates every year that are Career College and Community r they our graduates
020are able to work in high paying trades on day one and we have more than 50 Career and Technical education Pathways that allow them to do that our critical Fields like construction are going to lose 80% or more of their Workforce in just the next few years and so 90% of our students are graduating right now and that number has been steadily increasing we're investing in how many of our students are are graduating and they're graduating with more and higher qualifications than ever before they're getting millions in scholarships which is investing them in higher education but they're also getting certifications and college credits and internships while they're in high school and all of that invests in our local businesses right not like our staff is spending money here because they live here and they're telling
021us that they want to be able to stay here and live here and then they spend their money here which boasts the local economy economic development and it creates jobs it creates a robust economic base and it stabilizes our tax base overall but also we provide safe and free child care which is a pillar for our business Community because that allows workers to work Universal prek saves the average Colorado Family $6,000 a year and then our free breakfast and lunch saves the average family $1,250 a year we're also producing well-educated Future Leaders that are more likely to participate in Civic engagement because we have one of the highest uh community service expectations for our graduates our graduates volunteer in approximate 60,000 hours each year that is over $865,000 worth of direct investment in our community
022and then those students that have high engagement also increase their voter turnout they're engaged citizens who are educated and that means they are less relying on social safety nets saving as money over their lifespan and that reduces long-term tax burdens on all of our residents not only that though it contributes to public Revenue which funds programs for our retirees it has and all of us have an improved quality of life and we have great education and Great Schools we have higher health literacy greater Health outcomes better access to health care and healthier Lifestyles which all reduces The Strain on our Health Care system so that seniors people who are sick and are disabled community members have improved access it also has intergenerational benefits it breaks cycles of poverty and illness and unemployment and it builds
023generational wealth that supports public services that retirees rely on including our healthare and our transportation and our senior centers that's also an in our cultural V Vitality it Fosters our neighborhood cohesion there's a greater sense of community and our schools aren't only used for our classes we use them for events and churches and nonprofits healthc Care Mental Health before and after school care most importantly I think in all of this is that for every $1 we spend on public schools property values generally increased by $20 one of the greatest Investments a community can make a 20x on investment so using the numbers that we had to work with a $6.6 million decrease in Revenue would ultimately have an increase an estimated decrease of over $133 million in property value here at ler birthday and one
024other thing that just came out this morning is that we have seen the greatest District Colorado Department of Education performance in their 2024 data it's a more than 5% increase from the year before and that 5% Improvement in test scores leads to a 2.5% increase in home values in our communities so I am incredibly concerned um that as I've stated already that our Mill and bond didn't pass we know that we are facing hard challenges Stu highlighted some of those at the state L level we're expecting similar cuts from fedal programs as well and our number one commitment in our legislative platform was to talk about how we can invest in our schools and I just outlined why that is so important to every member of our community especially our retirees they are every homeowner
025is getting their greatest value from their investment in our Public Schools thank you Don live and that number I didn't even factor in you know I can but I won't um so I can't Poss Vote for This I know that it's hard I myself am paying more money just like everybody else is but I've also seen the greatest increase in my property value that we've had in my lifetime in this community so I'm creating generational wealth for my children that I did not have the opportunity to have when we were investing more in public education in our schools when I went here as a child we owe it to our kids to do better than they they did for us and we're not doing that we are not we are not investing in them the
026way that that they invested in us and that's unfortunate and I can't do that and and and you know sadly any change we make isn't even going to impact my kids this isn't a no longer a personal decision we already did not invest in my kids education my kids had less money spent literally not just adjusted for inflation than we had back in 199 when I graduated only one of my children has had two years of a fully funded education out of four kids that is unfortunate and we have a social contract and a personal benefit to every homeowner in our our community to invest in our schools that is what we are here for that is what we swore to do thank you Don Madam president may I just really really quickly make one
027final comment yes really quickly um I appreciate everything that director Kirk just said and I understand it I also know that I believe that this goes back to highlighting why there is such a true need for us to really look at how we present our budget our financials and like many others um governments we are all going to have to start taking a hard look at what we want to fund and this is just the many of these types of discussions so I will let us move on with the vote now thank you Nancy at all all right Laura Lee please um call we have oh we have to go back and do the motion we have motion okay would you restate your your motion your amendment I move to amend that the mill Levy
028for the 20 2018 MLL have a temporary property tax credit of 2123 to maintain the total mill rate at the 2024 rate of 4 2.76 which will reduce the financial burden of a tax increase for our community okay we will be voting on that motion now so Laur please call the rooll Stu Boyd no hang let me record these Denise Chapman no Don Kirk no Barbara Cruz no Nancy rumfelt yes okay the motion fails three no four to one M CU Don all right so now I need to the original motion it's been made and seconded and seconded would you repeat that well okay um let me find it I need a motion to or I yeah it was simply to approve the preliminary 2025 M Levy certification as presented all right all right so
029um Laur please call the rooll Stu Boyd I Denise Chapman I don Kirk hi Barbara Cruz hi Nancy rumfelt no motion passes 4 to one thank you all right um that is all the business we have at this point in time so I will adjourn our meeting um at this point e