CorpusRecord 88386

Regular Board Meeting - February 5, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SCCPSSCommunications
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Chatham County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,915 words · about 89 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good afternoon good afternoon welcome to the regular meeting oh I'm sorry the February 5th 2025 regular uh board meeting of the board of public educ education for the city of Savannah and County of chadam um um I will first ask that uh we have sent the notice out and it has been sent it sent sent out God sent it uh reset reset and this is education uh okay sorry all re yes all requirements of the public meetings act have been met thank you um we will start with our opening exercise if we'd all stand for the national anthem and our national anthem today will be sung by uh Mary Woodard Thompson our teacher at Savannah Arts Academy [Music] what [Music] Pro [Music] through the of [Music] [Applause] I pledge aliance to the

002flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you [Applause] now I'll have a motion to approve the agenda yes Mr Mar said upon the recommendation of the superintendent and the board approved this agenda item uh as presented and or amend it thank you uh second second all in favor thank you perfect announcements I also move that we make an amendment to the agenda and that we add item 6.06 the proclamation Career Technical and agriculture Education ctae Month move all in favor thank you very much okay now announcements uh we have an audit committee meeting uh tomorrow morning uh August August February 6 at 8 A.M my gosh at 8 am I want to get this year

003over [Laughter] with uh and uh tomorrow uh we also have a HB 58581 hearing number one uh here at 1100 a.m. here in the Whitney building uh we have hearing number two at 6:00 p.m. tomorrow here in the Whitney building and we have hearing number three on February 10th here in the Whitney building at 6: PM February 11th uh the star student and teacher awards banquet at the Scottish wri uh off uh chadam Center Drive uh from 11:30 until February 12th we have Georgia day at the Savannah Civic Center from 9:00 am to 1 pm February 13th fun night out uh sccpss night at the ghost pirates game at M Market Arena uh 700 p.m February 19th uh we have a finance committee meeting that should not be at Whitney whitne stting at Whitney oh

004we are starting at Whitney okay sorry the finance committee meeting will be here at Whitney at 900 a.m. followed by our board retreat which will be atland Island from 11 a.m. uh until 400 p.m. okay that's that it good uh we would like to oh I'm sorry and we would like to add addition to the audit committee would like to announce the addition of Mr Bryce Everett as a new Committee Member start tomorrow okay remembrances um James Butler Jr um from Jenkins High School date of passing 15 2025 uh science teacher uh Katherine readen from Windsor Forest High School school counselor on 2025 and Horus Scandrick from Butler Elementary health and PE uh datea passing 126 2025 if we could all please stand for a moment of silence and now from some good news from

005our superintendent excited today to recognize our January student of the month for the month of January this particular student is a senior at Savannah Arts Academy the student is a member of triim society which is the music Honor Society he's also a member of The National Society of High School Scholars Beta Club and Spanish Honor Society he has demonstrated significant progress in math by consistently achieving a higher progression of grades on assignment and tests showing a deeper understanding of mathematical Concepts and moving from basic comprehension to applying Advanced problem solving techniques his nominator told us this student has a fantastic work ethic and excellent study habits including regular practice and seeking help when needed which has attributed to his overall success in addition he is dually enrolled in college classes for a second year this

006particular uh nominator continued by saying he's an extraordinary young man who has never allowed challenges to hinder his achievements in fact that is his superpower I have witnessed him take command of his education by confidently advocating for himself and pursuing Advanced learning opportunities he enthusiastically Embraces every chance to improve himself and deepen his understanding of the world around him with a positive attitude and a Fearless approach to hard work this particular student continually exemplifies resilience and determination in addition to his academic Su success this scholar actively takes part in School sports and community service he participates in Varsity track and cross country as well as studying Mar social Arts our Honore volunteers at the Oakland Island Wildlife Center helping with activities and events and has entertained residents at area assisted living facilities by playing the

007piano and singing when asked what motivates him to succeed our scholar responded I just want to constantly improve myself in all areas so that I can succeed in all of my future endeavors I want to show people that even when you have a disability you can do great things and succeed please help me congratulate the superintendent student of the month for January 2025 David raw David if you make conratulations thank you thank youat congratulations thank you thank you keep up the good work thank you congrats thanks thank you again join me and congratulate David and I ask that his parents please remain standing because we want to applaud you as well thank you for all you do to provide a student to us that is prepared and excited about school every day um and we

008are excited to have you uh here to recognize this celebration with us David will continue his pursuit of a college degree by taking classes in the areas of Science music and business he is going to be taking home several gifts from our sponsors today and including Members First Credit Union advertising Specialties Georgia Southern University Gulfstream and More in addition David and his and his English language arts class will receive copies of his favorite book donated by our sponsor e shaver book seller David asked to give his book to the English class he most enjoyed at Savannah Arts Academy as he finished high school English last year and has been dually enrolled in English classes in college now so again we would like to congratulate David certainly his family his parents and his Savannah Arts Academy

009family so if Miss blue who is in the audience would please stand and also his nominator um is in the audience thank you so much and David we wish you the very best congratulations in your future endeavors [Applause] January was a very long month uh with lots of different things to include a winter storm uh that we got to experience for the first time uh and that was certainly exciting but I have many other uh reasons for our excitement today I'm excited to bring you my good news report a huge thank you to Greg Parker of Parker's kitchen for his donation to The educate chadam Foundation of $100,000 do a true representation of together we can um and we certainly celebrate that partnership and um the funds for for this will be contributed or the

010funds that uh made up the $100,000 were contributed by local citizens when they purchase gas on the first Wednesday of every month at Parker so go get your gas on Wednesdays 1 cent of every gallon goes to fueling the community and helping schools these contributions along with the proceeds from his annual golf tournament provide the generous donation to the foundation it is tough to put in the words the commitment of Greg partner and his company to public education we are immensely grateful congratulations to all students who participated in the chadam County Spelling be we saw 40 outstanding spellers from across the The District in grades 3 through 8 show off their literacy skills and high levels of comprehension it was a battle to the very end as three final spellers were knotted up for several

011rounds Kila latrae from New Hampstead K8 Patrick Bang from Garrison School for the Arts and Nan Ahmed uh from Godly station eventually it came down to a spell off between n naine and Kela with Kela claiming the final top spot we wish her the best of luck as she moves on to the next level of competition thanks to the chadam association of Educators and the Savannah State University uh partners for their continued support of the spelling be the students at Woodville Tomkins Technical and career high school were excited to host a group of professional CPAs to collaborate on a rising professionals program to prepare students for careers in accounting seems like we might have a pipeline strategy here in place uh with with interest in accounting the group is building a comprehensive plan that combines

012mentorship networking opportunities and skill building activities to help students transition from academic learning to the professional world the CPA there shared Insight on industry expectations career paths and the importance of practical experience while also expressing excitement about working with our amazing Woodville Tomkins students to support their future success in accounting thank you to Our Community Partners for their investment in our Scholars thank you to the luty 43 foundation for presenting their safe driving Summit at Windsor Forest High School last month students participated in interactive breakout sessions led by First Responders Law Enforcement Officers trauma and Rehab Care Professionals and representatives from the trucking industry giving their unique perspectives on road safety by exposing our young drivers to these life-saving lessons and encouraging them to use the 43 key seconds safe driving initiative to ensure they

013are ready to drive we are in encouraging them to make good decisions to stay safe one more way sccpss is showing its commitment to the safety of our students a shout out to Jaa KH and her instructor Mr Pac Norris for their outstanding work on a flag cart for the dance team at the school of liberal studies at Savannah high jaia is a student in Mr Norris's welding two class and completed the independent Project based learning challenge during the first semester according to Mr Norris jaia has a desire to study nursing After High School but she has never turned down an opportunity to be engaged be involved and work hard to complete any project big or small even welding he said what a pleasure it is to have her in our program thank you to

014Mr Norris for sharing his outstanding student experience you can read about all of these stories and many more on our website please share them with your friends and colleagues and I will now turn it over for a rep report from professional Senate all right our January meeting was held virtually since we had the snow week uh the Senate reviewed three calendar templates created following our initial planning session last November a survey was also conducted to gather feedback regarding certain elements of the calendar design considerations included start and end of term dates options for a potential fall break and potential for staff planning and e-learning days centered around holidays such as Veterans Day and St Patrick's Day at the close of the meeting senate members submitted feedback on the templates and potential adjustments two recommendations from

015the Senate included the following clearly separate staff planning days and staff training days on the school calendar by incorporating distinct staff training days into the calendar we can ensure that teachers have protected time to focus on planning and preparing for their classes also uh to provide additional districtwide framework of the in-person e-learning days that are planned on the SEC PSS calendar this will help with overlapping commitments such as e-learning instructional time required trainings and plc's planning time and parent conferences senate members were asked for their interest in forming a subcommittee on school safety 15 members have volunteered to join this group over the next month we are collect information from schools to determine current thoughts on safety and any potential needs for improvement the School Safety Committee will review the findings and provide updates and

016recommendations at our next Senate meeting and our next Senate meeting will be held on Thursday February 20th from 4:15 to 5:15 at Jenkins High School thank you Mr haiger as we move the agenda we do have your board of education matters a number of items for the board to consider here a few policy reads for you item 6.01 is board policy BBA this is board officers this comes under the four-year review process you'll notice that the primary changes here are to align language in this policy to mirror recent changes to the board policy bbaa which uh stated the process for election of uh board members now what this does is it primarily mirrors the language of the identification of the board officers so these are the only changes for this policy this is a first

017reader we come back for second read in March thank you uh yes Dr Hoskins BR thank you so I see the change in the language is that um is the clarification that the superintendent can designate staff to serve in the secretary roles um how does that align with um the sentence it says other officers or agents may be appointed from time to time at the board's discretion so does that mean that the superintendent identifies someone and then the board has to am I on the wrong one okay all right because everybody's looking at me funny I just got to make sure that I was in the right place so the point I'm trying to get to is there's a line that says the board makes the appointment which we usually do in September and then

018we don't mess with this again for the whole year and then there's a line that says the superintendent can appoint someone so my question is does the board have to follow up with something to ratify the superintendent's appointment because it seems like if we didn't put it here the superintendent would just be able to do it and we wouldn't have to deal with it but by putting it in the policy it looks like you got these two things have to work together yeah so the um the recommendation on that line again under which exactly mirrors bbaa uh came from attorney holiday and what we were trying to do was overcome any confusion on the board secretary role which previously the language included the board secretary which is a position that is hired and goes through

019the hiring process uh on a recommendation by the superintendent and that but if the the law the state the title code stipulates that the the superintendent actually acts as a secretary of the board there's also some extension of that of talking about treasurer of the board and Andor design um so so that line is just a flexibility component to provide some clarity on the role of the secretary uh as as is um through the process through the recommendation of the superintendent um now if that creates some confusion in this particular area as opposed to where it where it came from under the election of officers I I mean I could see we could easily delete that out of there um so as not to create any confusion um I just thought about it because in

020January we still do that with the current structure we announce and appoint um the secretary that in in that position is one that we have populated at this time so um if it's not confusing for anyone else at this time I guess I will just wait till it comes back for the second time for other board members to consider um whether it's an issue for me it just created language that had different actions that occur at different times that I didn't know if they were necessary I understand we're trying to align with the law um and we're also trying to align with current practice current practice is that the superintendent does do that right right um and something that might help as well in that line about the board May appoint other agents as it

021sees fit a good example is your legislative delegate so the board appoints that annually in that January meeting meeting as well so while that's not necessar an necessarily an officer of the board it is another role that the board designates um in this process so you see that language there has a little flexibility on how the board would manage that um but but the key component is the officers are President a vice president and a vice president proem um as opposed to how we had previously written in the um hired position of a board secretary I got nothing else okay all right so again this is a first reader um we'll certainly take that uh consideration and get back and uh con convene with with staff and legal on that on the on the way

022forward and of course as you stated if any board members have thoughts on that please advise and we'll bring it back for a second reader in March your next agenda item is 6.02 this is board policy jgc medication now the board will remember that we had previously brought this policy back uh for some updates which were based on some changes uh in state code uh circulating the um the way we administered medication and that the board had gone through the process of reviewing and approving that uh in the process though recently uh staff has been going through uh procedural reviews internally uh particularly about how they audit medic medication how the nursing staff audits medication uh and after some discussion it was determined that it should be included and memorialized in the administrative regulation side

023of this policy so that's a primary change that you see here in that language also you'll note the reference to albuterol was also added at recommendation of our school uh nursing team so those are the only changes this is an administrative regulation and a mid period review moving on on your agenda 6.03 this is a policy gbg arrangement of substitutes this comes to you under the four-year policy review process this is a first reader will come back in March for second review and adoption uh the primary changes that you see here are really how we manage scenarios where the options for filling substitutes in our district if we're not able to fulfill that uh through the means that we are utilizing you're all familiar that we use ESS as our substitute provider uh if they're

024not able to 100% fill those roles of need then there would be flexibility for the superintendent that the board would authorize to utilize other means and some of those means are listed uh within that policy language as well so those are the primary changes here first reader would come back in March for second read adoption M Kowski I don't know that this is a policy question more if they have to um if School administration needs to implement an alternative plan particularly that involves reassignment of existing staff and that that adds to their workload is that staff compensated for that additional workload that they are taking on if they're taking on the role of a substitute in addition to their normal roles and if not it should be so it's my understanding and and maybe I

025can have some staff jump in at the middle and high school levels I believe there is compensation if a teacher uses his or her planning time to cover another teacher's class um the discrepancy is whether that's happening at the elementary level or not well maybe I can get is there any additional information Miss Panton that you want to add to that um yes at the um middle and high schools um they are on extended day um agreements if someone is out I can't I would need to look more into the elementary um some of this language was just more in that where we're adding this is adding this additional language supports and authorizes School administrators to create a an implement a contingency plan um in the event a substitute isn't available because sometimes we just

026can't plan for emergency situation so this is really just the board and policy supporting these implementations of a contingency plan right and I understand but I just and again I know it's it's more part of the the practice and the implementation side my question but in addressing the policy it just because I I know that does happen if you know a teacher is late then the teacher next door who happens to have a planning period says hey can you cover this class and that impacts the teacher so that teacher needs to be compensated or other you know some it doesn't need to just be oh you're available come cover this class so I don't know if our teacher of the year has something you'd like to share I can provide some additional clarifications so those

027are scenarios where uh there are some normal uh coverage responsibilities for a brief period of time but if a teacher is uh providing uh coverage for the entire period or entire block then there is an opportunity for supplemental pay and then there is a category where if a teacher is uh serving in a long-term capacity then they would be on an extended day agreement uh and that pay uh is different so there you've got three kind of scenarios temporary which is within the normal responsibilities uh that a teacher may take on in terms of coverage uh for a colleague for a team for a brief period of time then you have an entire block or period uh where a teacher May provide coverage that's supplemental and then you have for an entire semester uh if

028a position was vacant and a teacher took on that additional course that would be an extended day agreement yes please um so after covid the first the first you know year or two um it was especially difficult to find coverage and I know it was a priority anytime we needed to cover classes during our planning period you know here is the paperwork you know you get you fill it out you get paid um that has not happened as much recently I don't know if that's because it's still available and maybe just not as you know readily communicated or if that's something that's been kind of rolled back but to have it it be a high priority um maybe in the writing of the policy I think is is what we're talking about yeah or or

029regulation that accompanies a policy or something to to formalize that practice so that it's clearly known and communicated Dr Howard Hall yes in some cases you have self-contained classrooms such as Elementary where you have teachers with a full-time parer and sometimes those full-time Paras have an act substituting if that teacher is out if anyone can't be located or placed so there maybe needs to be something in policy regarding paying that paror if we do have Paras who are substitute teaching in the place of that teacher who is out does that that does occur thank you okay this is a first reader of course we'll bring back uh second read adoption in the March board meeting the next agenda item for the board's consideration is a topic that everyone is interested in the Academic School year

030calendar of course uh we've been ahead of the cycle with our calendars over the last several years um so the the com the uh community at large our staff and parents really enjoy that uh we did go through this particular process a little differently and trying to look at some alternate options that possibly we could consider and ultimately we landed on a version that is now in front of the board so today we do have the recommendation of the adoption of the 2526 academic calendar and again the district has developed this calendar to meet the needs of our students our staff and families and to align with State assessment timelines the academic calendar as proposed does contain 180 instructional days and considers input from the superintendent's professional Senate this was made up of course of

031our teacher leaders and support staff additional feedback was received from school principls and District staff and a parent survey was also administered calendar development process considers a certain components that are unique to our market and our area that create a certain level of compression when you look at those 180 days and some of those influential factors include the timing of the first day of school timing for the state assessments uh staff planning days that should be included on the calendar as well remote learning days St Patrick's Day is a big one for US federal holidays including Veterans Day Thanksgiving break for one week winter break for two weeks and any election days also will provide an influence on the calendar this calendar that's being recommended includes 180 instructional days 10 staff PL planning days five

032pre-planning days two post-planning days days it also includes the Strategic use of remote learning days including one that you'll see on election day in November of uh the next school year this includes an extended October fall break there is a 4-day weekend for school students and staff and of course there is one week in Thanksgiving two weeks for winter break there's a onewe spring break included and this accounts also the calendar for St Patrick's Day major breaks are certainly scheduled at the conclusion of winter assessments and in advance of spring assessments the draft calendar is now presented for the board's review and adoption District administration seeks to use this framework of the calendar for the development of the 2526 and 2627 academic calendars of course you'd be approving the 2526 calendar but we're seeking to

033use the next two years the 2627 and 2728 academic calendars on this framework thus be it resolved that upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the academic calendar for school year 2526 and sorry to my correction here and that the board also authorized a superintendent to develop the 2627 calendars and the 2728 academic calendars that would get us an additional two years ahead which we would bring back using this framework at a subsequent board meeting okay moved by uh moved by Dr ringman seconded by Miss Hall uh discussion Dr ringman uh thank you for bringing this forward and also thank you for um trying to continue the process of um not belaboring this every single year and kind of making a carbon copy and just placing it on the calendar I would

034like uh either the dist District staff or um if the superintendent would like to um weigh in some of her thoughts I know this is her first calendar cycle because we already had a calendar developed for your first year um you're reimagining of what you're um calling remote learning days and then I know we've already had some conversations with District staff around that um dimpled Chad of a day for teachers that's the last day of the school year and how you might be seeing that as um a day that could be flexible depending on um certain criteria and flexibility of workspace so the first thing I'd like to do is just acknowledge the difficulty and the development of a calendar uh there are a lot of competing priorities pressures preferences um and I'm not going

035to say anything as impossible but it is very difficult to get everyone's desire into a calendar so I appreciate all the parents and the teachers and the board and others who have weighed in on this um process um and I ask that you give Grace in places that you don't necessarily get all the desires that you may want um as it relates to the remote learning days I am acutely aware of the challenges and the opportunities that uh remote learning uh brings I think what complicates it even further is when you also have a season of hurricanes and snow uh which then add on to prescribed remote learning days additional makeup days where we use the remote learning framework as um a makeup day um and I understand fully the challenges that that places on

036parents uh who may be trying to be atome teachers or uh supervise their children um and in the current way that we do it I also uh understand the challenges that it presents to our teachers who may be trying to remotely make themselves available to students while also tending to other District or classroom obligations um we need to reimagine and I'm not going to be able to provide a lot of detail about what that looks like um but I would like to open that opportunity up um and better Define what that day is I think when I transitioned into the district it was referred to as an e-learning day which to me carried a heavy connotation that kids were using computers at home and they were engaged with some at a with a teacher at

037some level and I think over the last year I have found that not to be the consistent methodology um so I have asked the team we've already had some internal dialogue about what a reimagining could look like um but I am not at a place where I would say I would like to do away with remote learning um it is a way of the world my own two children are in college now and they have remote classes that I pay full tuition for um they they do not in many cases have access to a teacher face to face um or even by diand right they're expected to be able to do some level of independent work on their own um and so I think as we prepare our students for Choice field lives we have

038to begin to provide those opportunities for them so that they have a Readiness to engage in reality that they will be walking into um in the near future as virtual learning and virtual work are now a part of how life is lived um in in in um the world today so I'm not at a place where I would say we want to get rid of those days I want to leverage those days but I want to leverage them um in a reimagined way and we haven't defined that yet um I also am aware of the um debate around makeup days um and that has been a point of interesting contention um as we've navigated hurricanes and uh most recently a winter storm um this is one of those issues that's very difficult to navigate because

039while we have designated makeup days on our calendar which typically are listed as the week of Thanksgiving and the week of spring break many families and many teachers plan vacations during those weeks and so when we talk about wanting to then flip those days and use them as makeup days we run into conflicts with staff maybe not being fully available because they've planned a cruise or to go visit a family member somewhere else and we're also uh competing with families that may have planned trips and we look at very low attendance on those days um the same with half days anytime we have tried to do a half day our attendance drops significantly in the district um so the challenge with up days is where do you place them on the calendar that doesn't conflict

040with someone's already pre-planned vacation where we can have High attendance from students and enough supervision uh from staff and then how do you weigh in the fact that there wor state of emergencies and we do have a waiver so I don't know that I have a very strong answer for that know that that is a place where I'm still grappling but I do believe as we move forward there will have to be quarterly uh a threshold that we look at and if we miss a certain amount of days within that quarter period or within whatever the designated time period is we do have to look at making up days um this has been a choppy year and I'm not sure the influence that that will have on our student learning um but I am as

041concerned as others uh have been uh around that topic so uh I think the public can expect some additional Clarity around when we and how we decide which days get made up and when they get made up I think is the other piece and I think the other question is how they get made up because there are lots of ways you don't have to have a full makeup day on a designated day that we've already set off you could add minutes to a school day you could add a half day Saturday you could add like there different ways to get at how you make up time um was that the wonderful and I was going to ask you about makeup days and you got there too oh the the last day of school for teachers

042so yes the last day of school for teachers uh we have looked at this as recent I believe as yesterday uh Mr hediger was in my office and we were trying we and we'll continue to try to figure this out to the best level possible um what I would like to offer to teachers is um we could look at how we could flexibly use that day I think members of my team know that um I don't necessarily believe that people have to show up in a place to work and to learn that work and learning can occur from many places including your home um and so if teachers are all finished and they finished all their activities that they need to close out school um I could see that that last day being a opportunity

043for teachers to plan from home and provide evidence of that planning from home so that they did not necessarily have to show back up at a school building on the 26 so um looking at that day again the same way we think about student remote learning how can we leverage the reality that uh people don't have to show up in a specific location to do their jobs I have gotten much work done in the middle of a Panera Bread in fact that is where I tend to be most productive um not in the office so uh just wanting you all to know that we are looking should this calendar be passed we're looking at how we can offer our teachers some flexibility around the use of that day to work but maybe not to show

044up in a traditional manner for work thank you so much it may help too for future consideration that the days of Memorial Day where Memorial Day falls is what creates the conundrum in this particular calendar in 2027 Memorial Day is on May 31st and in 2028 Memorial days is on May 29th so we have more days in the calendar and I feel uh without going through and specking out all the days uh but knowing that there are more days in May for those years there's a strong possibility that this wouldn't be an issue in the next future calendars Miss Hall um Dr Watts I'm very pleased with your broad expanse of thought in terms of our teachers and how learning happens and um the reason I approve of this particular calendar is because I think

045it pays a lot of attention to the Integrity of our instructional delivery the more um most of our students are in front of their teachers the better to me and to me this calendar provid Ides that opportunity best for them thank you Dr T Tanya Howard Hall yes I would you could you just talk a little about us being a Swiss School District although this calendar is based on 1008 day instructional time we do have the flexibility to not make up those days if you can just explain yeah so the board of public education has entered into a contract with the Georgia Department of Education to be a a waiver District so we call it a strategic waiver school system I.E Swiss in the acronym one of the things that was built in there was

046the waiver for the requirements of the school year calendar school year school day so the current statutory requirements on school year school day in Georgia is 180 days we've all been very familiar with that but we do have a waiver built in now it doesn't mean that just because that waiver is in the contract that it automatically is going to be used one of the things that we wrote actually in our policies as well one of the few districts in the state that has a policy on the use of waivers one of the things we wrote in that policy was if there are any major components that are within the contract that the district seeks to use that has broad scoping impact and the calendar is one of them the academic calendar the Board of

047Education would vote in a meeting to approve that so if we wanted to use a waiver in this process it would be written into the calendar we'd also have it in the agenda item to say that the board also approves that use of a waiver for less than 180 days now I will say that in the general surveys that we've done initially talking with the professional Senate many of them felt that 180 days was important there was some openness to saying well maybe less than would be okay but there wasn't an overwhelming push to say we should have less than 180 days our School principles our building leaders also said the same 180 days was important so these are some things things that in the consideration of the calendar when we went through this whole

048process and created a couple versions We Used 180 days the other part that is really important in this whole discussion is having that waiver built in and if you do have storm disruptions and weather events that create outages and it could be anything as far as we have to evacuate and you have no access to um technology or the ability to be able to log in and do remote work then the consideration of using a waiver is very helpful in that and as the superintendent said that's a grappling point because we have always and consistently said we're also going to name certain days on the calendar that are currently existing where there is no school where we could make up a day presumably but that has been met with resistance over the years when you

049start saying we're going to actually Levy the makeup day in Thanksgiving so depending on the circumstances it's all different having that waiver in the toolkit to be able to use if the circumstances warrant the the need for it is a real benefit for us but if you build a calendar that's already behind say 178 176 days and then you have storm outages you're already really kind of losing a lot of instructional time Dr Howard Hall I'm sorry oh uh Miss galski um thank you Dr Wat for some of your comments particularly about remote learning because that's something I know we've all talked about I mean I think it makes sense and I was glad to hear you say that the makeup days may not necessarily be in the classroom because it seems like that could

050be a remote learning opportunity as well um on the the May 26 got lots of comments and feedback and appreciate um the team providing all of the survey results because that was that was great to see I know that some of our teachers will do continuing a during the summer where they go to a conference or something like that is there a possibility that that could count towards that day um so that would be great okay so I definitely support not necessarily requiring them to come into the classroom building on that day um I agree with um M Graham about the specifying the planning versus professional development days if there's a way to be able to do that working on that right now fantastic and then um when are grades typically due at the end

051of the year because I have heard that they are due like a full week ahead of when we have our last day of school is that correct yes that's correct so the grades are generally due before the last day of school so my question is what happens that last week of school because that just seems and in high school it's a whole another level because you get graduation that coincides and so that last week of high school is just a bust all the way around um which maybe that's okay I don't know but to have grades due a week before school is out you're missing five educational days so I'm not necessarily saying that that's a nut we're going to crack with this calendar but I think it's something we need to think about because

052to you know as a parent sending your kid to school to go watch movies for the last week of class it's like we're that's like a I mean that's a we and and and I do want to clarify when you say the last day of school the last prior to teachers last day so their grades are being uh finalized during that last week so there is an opportunity in many cases for students who may not be currently passing um to complete remaining assignments uh so there is there is an opportunity uh and there should be during that last week of school uh opportunities for students to complete those tasks that may be an exception with our seniors but but generally speaking many of the assignments are complete during that time but the finalizing of grades

053in power school does not happen until that last teacher work right and and I get that but it still just seems to me that we're not really getting a full 180 days when we don't have those that last week I I think some of what you're saying is could be accurate I see it more as a window we say there's a designated endpoint for grades but teachers are still accepting grades teachers are still updating grades it also gives us time to assess whether all grades are in before the teacher actually goes home um so we need a little bit of Grace to do some of that but I really think ultimately what fixes that is just the culture in which the teacher has in his or her classroom that learning is going to continue until

054the last day and we're not going to watch movies right and so I appreciate that and so I I appreciate in the resolution that we want to use this as a framework for the next two years and I know Dr brayan's going Whoop I'm a little bit hesitant to do that and I'm also hesitant to push that to next month why do we need to adopt the following two-year calendar because the resolution says we're going to come back at the subsequent board meeting and adopt those next to your calendars I don't see I mean I think it's great to have it done earlier than we did this year but these are some of the things that I would like to better understand when we're looking at our calendar and the other thing which which I've

055already shared with the superintendent is we have may like May 26 is always like our limit point and I would rather see our teachers not have to come back into the classroom build into the school building in the month of July even if that means we go into early June which I know is like a total thing and Dr bring is about to jump out of his chair but that's just my two sents that um I don't know that we need to rush into using this as a framework for two more years keep in mind too that the state assessment window plays a big role in this as well so and that's helpful and to have that information in the context of this calendar would be helpful yes so so would you like to to

056[Music] amend potentially but I think contined discussion is warranted okay all right um Miss Hall then Dr ringman um just very quickly I have found out that several schools that um uh I keep an eye on have project-based learning going on and some of the best learning some of the best times are held by the children at the end of the school year so um in terms of spreading best practices those schools who don't have those kind of activities the principles need to uh get with each other the teacher Senate needs to get with each other but we have some wonderful programs going on for kids that last week of school that that really stamps what the superintendent was saying about the culture of the classroom and how you utilize those days because they are

057still instructional days notwithstanding the timeline to get grades in we will also add that in our feedback with the professional Senate superintendent received some comments from teacher leaders as well that said please don't end the school year after Memorial Day or push it into June because then you really start to lose the focus of the students graduations are done the grades are clearly in the state why graduations have to be that weak why do graduations have to be then like if the school year gets put like why are we we're setting that own parameter for ourselves that we have to always have graduations the third week of May well the other influential factor for us and determining that schedule is the availability of the Arena so that's what's Driven that and that was that was

058the Legacy from the Civic Center but is that true still like these are these are just questions that I have that I want to better understand particularly if you're asking me to take action for the next three academic years so Dr I fully agreee on the fundamental like what's happening those last weeks we could go deeper and be like what's happened in the last month they're done with gmass that's how the state grades us that's what gets in the paper on the reading level and this level and that level and that's done at the end of April first day of May y I don't understand why the state does it that way but I'm I'm definitely Dr bringman is not asking that we start the school year in in whatever because in a perfect world

059you should should end school right before gmass and that should be your final cuz that should be we have learned for 180 days preparing for that state test but the state cuts out 20 plus learning days because they tell us we got to do it then why I don't know maybe somebody smarter in the room knows that but I mean fundamentally those months what I mean those those those weeks we're doing learning but we know that there's going to be learning loss over the summer preparing for the so yeah so I will defer to the resident expert teacher in the room yes M Graham I just wanted to jump in real quick AP testing runs through May 15 which gives us one week after that to wrap up for the year so just just as

060far as if we're talking about testing and I knew AP was on a different yes it at least is closer to the end yes yeah so it's important to keep that yes so I guess I would ask if we could amend the motion um to just remove the and beit further resolved statement in the resolution so that we're not tied to coming back and adopting another two years second am okay it's been moved and seconded uh any other discussion okay um yes I just like the teachers across the district to brainstorm what are some wonderful things we could be doing with our kids after the academic year is pretty much set up I know that there are many third fourth fifth graders in my district who have never been to the Massie center it's not

061planned if the teacher doesn't think of it's not something that's mandated so half of our kids get these field trip experiences the other half haven't been anywhere so there are so many things that could be done outside of the classroom that will help our students if we can get it all um Dr Watts you know is some sort of uh synchronized way but don't we have limitations on field trips during the last week of school I believe we do but we need we need we need to change that's something we could we could fix yeah those are self-imposed obstacles yeah okay Dr Hoskins Brown thank you um this is a lively discussion on the calendar it always is um I would like when we look at these other calendars that look at the other years

062that we bring in all the information that we know affects our decision and Contracting is one of them and if we don't want to deal with the the temporal limitations of Contracting and the calendar of other organizations then we need to consider what other factors we're willing to wave and that is do we want to be outside at one of our athletic complexes maybe not some people think that's awesome some people are like no I don't want to outdoor um graduation so if we don't want to be constricted to the Contracting policies of the institutions that can host our graduations and we don't want to incur the additional cost of setting up and breaking down or covering an outdoor venue all the things that we don't have to deal with by having three a days

063four days back to back then we need to be prepared to talk about that um because that's part of what has shoehorned us into the schedule that we have is saving the money on decorating having them compress in one facility that's completely adaa accessible and that is weather resistant and doesn't fall within the instructional time we have lots of other flexibilities if we want to wave those criteria um and if we don't then we can make decisions knowing that we are choosing one uh over the other any more discussion on the amendment okay all in favor of the amendment okay all right now uh now okay so the recommendation as revised will be thus be it resolved upon the rec recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the proposed academic calendar for school year

0642025 2026 there you go okay clarification question yes on the the nuances that we talked about as far as um the flexibility of the 26th and the potential to designate specific are those things that can be clarified or modified after the official adoption or do we need to include some language around that in the motion right so so the board is not voting on the um the management decision on work calendar for example so how we manage and implement the use of Staff planning days that would be a function of the superintendent Administration the board is voting on the dates of these calendars as proposed so for all the reasons that have been previously stated the calendar has plotted the way that it is we do have one day to get the 10 staff planning

065days on this calendar without putting it somewhere else that would lose an instructional day that day Falls the day after Memorial Day because Memorial Day in this particular year in 2026 Falls sooner than it normally would in the 27 year and the 28 year so it's where we find ourselves but the superintendent has stated that we are open administratively and we've had internal discussions about how we would manage that to allow teachers to use a remote work option on that last staff planning day okay I just want to make sure that in taking this official action we don't inadvertently limit any ability to have some flexibility around that day so we're okay all right uh call a question all in favor oh I we got a second I second yeah yeah yeah here we go

066all in favor uh Mr Smith I'm in favor yes Smith yes all right thank you very much and turning the agenda to the board president for Proclamation item 6.05 National School counseling week Dr ringman thank you it is my honor uh National School counseling week Proclamation whereas school counselors are employed in our schools to help students reach their full potential and whereas school counselors are actively committed to helping students explore their abilities strengths interest and talents as these traits relate to Career awareness and development and whereas school counselors help families focus on ways to further the academic career and social emotional development of their children and whereas school counselors work with teachers and other Educators to help students explore their potential and set realistic goals for themselves and whereas school counselors seek to identify and

067utilize Community Resources that can enhance and compl comprehensive School counseling programs and help students become productive members of society and whereas comprehensive School counseling programs are considered an integral part of the educational process that enables all students to achieve success in school therefore we do Proclaim February 3rd through 7th 2025 as National School counseling week in witness thereof we officially the Seal of the Savannah chadam County Board of public education to this Proclamation on this fifth day of February 2025 signed Mr Roger Moss board president Dr Denise Watts superintendent I'll accept a motion moved and seconded all in favor and we I know that we have some school counselors here today so you please come [Applause] I got two copies so I'll let you fight who gets to app thank you for advocating thank you

068you do to Advocate [Applause] app who has and we have a another Proclamation happy Career and Technical Education Month whereas February 1st through 28th 2025 has been designated Career Technical agricultural Education ctae Month by the Association for Career and Technical education and whereas ctae offers students the opportunity to gain the academic Technical and employability skills necessary for true career Readiness and whereas students in ctae programs participate in authentic meaningful experiences that improve the quality of their education and increase their engagement and Achieve achievement and whereas ctae provides students with career exploration and opportunities early in their educational experience which enables them to make informed and beneficial decisions about their academic coursework and pursue establish programs of study and career Pathways whereas leaders from business and industry Nationwide report increasing challenges related to addressing the skills

069Gap and connecting qualified professionals with careers in critical and growing ctae related fields such as advancing manufacturing cyber security energy Health Care Information Technology transportation and whereas ctae prepare students for these and other fulfilling careers by offering integrated programs of study that link secondary and postsecondary education and lead to the attainment of Industry recognized credentials and whereas ctae programs ensure that employers have access to a qualified and thriving Workforce ensuring our nation is a strong and competitive economy therefore we do now Proclaim February 1st through 2 8 2025 as ctae month in witness thereof we officially affix the Seal of the Savannah chadam County Board of Education to this Proclamation on the fifth day of February 2025 and I just like to add this ctae pretty much dispels the myth that we do not provide

070fulfilling careers for our students in other words in the words of the old trades a lot of times I here in the community we used to have shop we used to have home Mech and and we you all aren't offering trades we offer fulfilling careers and ctae actually dispels that myth we offer the four EAS and we talk about this often enrollment to post their education um employment a lucrative in some cases employment for those who become wers and work in other fields enlist in military as well as entrepreneurship so we know that we are very proud of our ctae program um Dr Angie Lewis is our Guru and I most certainly hope that she is cross trining a lot of employers and staff because she has a wealth of information and knowledge so thank

071you very much for everything that you're doing for our ctae program okay secretary motion mov in seconded all in favor please come forward Dr Lewis w [Applause] [Music] [Applause] will come back up to get their certificates LP number two thank you so much all right I'll have I entertain a motion to approve our consent agenda been moved moved and seconded uh any discussion no all all in favor thank you yes okay good afternoon agenda item 8.01 budget transfer for academic Supplement Plan in support of the district gos to provide competitive compensation promote equity and support retention and recruitment initiatives a budget transfer is requested to implement supplemental academic pay for the extra time and work contributions of teacher staff leaders who serve in one of the nine lead positions that exist at each school this

072supplement accounts for nearly 800 individuals not related to Athletics these academic supplements apply to specific priority academic roles that provide work duties Beyond regular job related responsibilities including positions such as grade chairs department heads esol coordinators RTI and testing coordinators social media website newspaper yearbook and ban and coral directors the academic supplement Road's administrative guide book outlines additional duties eligible for supplements staff now request a transfer of funds to create supplement budgets for each respective School site the summary of the proposed budget transfer is as follows thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the requested budget transfer in the amount of [Music] you my question is about how these positions were identified I mean I I understand the nature of the academic support that's in these I could

073also imagine someone who is supervising quizbowl or something else that is a really academically driven competition or robotics could also um be seen as being aligned with an academic supplement so I guess there's two questions are these the exclusive roles in the supplement and how did we decide the roles that would apply um there are some additional roads uh this process actually started before the pandemic it got kind of delayed during the pandemic but I'm going to ask the academic team they worked within the last 12 months to identify some additional roles that we did not start out with when we started this process so Mr Butler can take it from here yeah I think uh you captured it uh well so this is work that has started uh a few years ago uh and

074so this is really the culmination and the implementation of the academic uh supplemental plan uh so there was a working group uh that identified those key uh academic roles and responsibilities in schools uh and so uh our team this year was really tasked with uh refining uh that plan for implementation however our continual work uh includes looking at additional uh positions uh that have been been developed over the last few years uh and even this year uh as part of our uh academic Supplement Plan for sy25 26 uh there are some additional positions uh that are not included in this academic Supplement Plan that were already uh receiving supplements uh but part of our work is reviewing uh the current landscape uh and uh additional responsibilities that we know our site based staff have to

075ensure that we're considering that uh in our uh ongoing academic supplements thank you that's really helpful I mean I I did not think it was arbitrary but it's good to know what the method was and if somebody asked this is somewhat identified democratically by this working group um and many of our site based staff have inquired about some of the positions that they have so uh we we've been taking that feedback and we'll continue to do so awesome thank you m Kowski and then Dr um so similar line is Dr Hoskins Brown I remember years ago when we were working on this strategic plan this conversation came up quite a bit so I'm glad to see this come forward um I would ask and it not necessarily right now and I appreciate the clarification Mr

076Butler if clubs are also included in these supplements our teachers who are leading clubs particular they after school do you know off hand if they're included so they're not currently included in this particular version okay uh it is something that we're going to take a look at but I think it's also important to note that uh we are mindful of the many responsibilities uh and so we we have a uh a guideline that we use that serves as that indicator that says based on all of the duties and responsibilities and the time commitment um this is what would be considered uh a position uh where we would provide a supplement but we'll be again reviewing that in our current landscape to see what those additional roles and responses but as it currently stands those extracurricular

077clubs and activities those sponsors they're not included in this plan okay well I'm glad to hear we're looking at it and I also appreciate the objectivity that it sounds like you're trying to create so that teachers know what's a supplement and what's not I think that's extremely helpful for our our staff I know many of our staff do simply because they love it and they love our students um but I think providing that Clarity is is really exciting the last comment I'll make is I am just so grateful to represent a district that places high value on all of these um to be able to say that we have music and band and art throughout our district even though we don't get the funding from the state to do so um it's one of the

078things that I highlight every opportunity that I get so thank you to the team for continuing to move that forward and for recognizing the extra effort that goes into um providing these great opportunities for our Scholars Dr rman I I will um continue the Kudos that uh Dr Grabowski you're a doctor now um uh ended with because uh yeah you get your board packet and you're reading through and then you get warm and fuzzy like this is one of these things that I'm just like it's it's taken a while we don't move quickly we're a big ship tiny Rudder um but it feels so good to be a part of something when you know you're moving the needle in the right direction to Value people who are going above and beyond enriching the lives of

079our students making those connections um and the vast majority of them have continued to do it for decades probably without a supplement um um this just makes it a little bit easier and gosh maybe it's I I could definitely see some of them saying now I have a supplement and I can buy another thing for this club it's not even for they' be like now I can get that thing that I've been wanting for this for this group um that's the type of staff and teachers that we have that work for us um so I'm just so pleased um both on the front of doing right by our people um but also as Dr Butler said most multiple times and it's been echoed that it's an objective process and we're continuing to look at what

080that looks like what is the threshold to add other people to this list um and not have to tell somebody well you you don't work with the right student group to get a supplement um that just that that should sound wrong um so thank you so much to the superintendent to all the staff that have worked on this um and to my fellow board members who will support this unanimously absolutely uh Mr katmar um so I just want some clarity on this and I just to be clear I fully support it um and I'm G I'm going to do what bringman tells me to do just like just like never um so in the past I've made a big fuss about um coach supplements and and athletic supplements and then supplements for teachers who volunteer

081for quiz bowl and go spend four days in Columbus with their kids and things like that and I thought we had done supplements separately from that um there's a there's a there's a pay scale or a supplement scale for coaches but we had also which we started the process we done something we did but we we never implemented it we started the process for some of the staff but we didn't we added additional staff since we the initial onset that was a presentation like I said probably year or two before the pandemic and we started because it was a um board Hot Topic item so we did start with some we increased some supplements again like we did for athletics um but we since that time we added a few more positions than we initially

082started understood but we already we periodically evaluate athletic supplements and Coach pay you know regular season uh playoff kind of thing but I thought back then we also added some supplements for nonathletic extra stuff the quiz Bowl coach the robotics club that a teacher who went to Augusta for several days I thought we were doing some supplements for them already and my question was now I'm nervous are we not but is this is this supposed to be a rollup these are all the supplements we're doing now replacing anything we've done previously or this is or is this an and this is an end this is this the this is includes this is the end there are some other supplements that are already out there we have a um a document it's about 23 Pages the

083guideline document we're talking about we would be more than happy to share that with board members um so this is in addition to those supplements that are already out there so this is an increase of the 924 th000 to go along with the other supplements that already in place but I see this as fundamentally different too these are structural positions that require regular additional effort and work over and above that's department head is different than I'm going to volunteer to be a quiz supporter they're both equally important um but we already do the quizbowl supporter I hope um that's what I want to check on yeah cuz I thought we were doing that already the Athletics out I'm sure the qu B some of the teams a let us double check on that cuz it

084was totally I mean the big the reason it was a hot topic was it's not fair for a teacher to say I'm going to go be an assistant exp sport coach and get some more money but I'm going to be a robotics coach and not get anything and so we were trying to equitise the extra effort uh because they're both important from a that anyway we we need Clarity on that we the other position other supplements the original supplements right okay so I have Miss ski Dr Howard Hall then uh Dr hon Brown just a quick request I know we've got the second phase of our compensation study that's underway so that when we get that study and kind of the compilation of everything together if we could have this information as a part of

085that report so that we can see the full package um that would be helpful that sense well I it does but I want to manage expectations and maybe Miss pant Dr Panton may have an answer I don't know if a part of their study is looking at supplement no it's not necessarily as a part of their study but that we get this information alongside okay I got it Dr Howard yes have we considered our Emergency Response Team but many times nurses are required to attend games and provide assistance as needed for supplemental and I don't I don't they're not being paid overtime to my to my understanding just um based on their salary so so I can answer this from from a uh each school has an emergency response team lead uh while they are

086currently not included in this Supplement Plan um that is a position that we are considering in our future plan uh I cannot speak to the while the nurse is on the Emergency Response Team along with several other key members um when it comes to um after school activities or a a letics we do have uh athletic trainers uh now there are some scenarios where our nurses may serve as a substitute or support in some capacity and so uh they are compensated in that way uh but the nurse is not a part of this academic Supplement Plan but an emergency response team lead uh is at each school and that is something that we're looking at in our next iteration of a supplemental plan and we do have Lisa Wilson here at making expound on that

087I'm not sure if Now's the Time but she she's the expert in that area she I see her sitting out there they are good afternoon I was stating that um Mr but is correct the nurses that work with Athletics um to assist those services are supported and um compensated for that time we have approximately I think 11 nurses that are working in that capacity now attending practices and games to support our athletes um as far as emergency response team leaders not all ER leader leaders are nurses many of them are other staff members who have a full day's work ahead of them when they walk into the building building um we are in the business as nurses of uh saving lives and providing safety and en encouraging those around us to be strong in their

088skill set that will help save lives in the event of an emergency and I can tell you that the Savannah chadam County Public School System school nurse team fully supports compensation for emergency response team leaders they are our wing men and wing women in cases where um lives could be in Jeopardy thank you for the opportunity to speak speak thank you Dr Hoskins Brown thank you um I also recall the conversation or the the energy around um supplements that Mr K katar is referring to and if I recall correctly the issue was that everyone who volunteers to do something outside the school day with young people wasn't getting a supplement some people were some people weren't I understand that this is the academic supplement um there were others like you know cheerleading coaches and that

089sort of thing we were trying to ascertain in that discussion exactly who was getting supplements and what qual what level of effort or activity qualify to supplement um so I think that's what some of these questions are are getting to and the people who are not getting a supplement are probably going to be the ones we're going to hear from um who are going to want to Advocate um for themselves so if we could have a definitive list of who gets a supplement who doesn't and what is the emerging source of criteria that we're using because I think we all have the hearts to say that eventually everybody who says I'm going to do something after school before school that adds to extracurricular enhancement we would like to um support them and that's one of

090the reasons that people don't volunteer to do extra um activities and some incentives that are offered by Third Parties by Community Partners fail because you can't get a teacher to sign on to be be the advocate because it's just one more thing for them to do uncompensated so um if we could if we could know that information next time we talk about this it will probably be helpful thank you academic supplement is great so thank you we're taking baby steps Dr bring I I would just ask maybe I think the February 19th Financial uh finance committee meeting is kind of heavy but definitely before we set our budget yes if we could have a an inventory from budget we don't I don't want names names is bad positions positions outside of the duy set forth

091in a contract because our teachers and our staff have contracts these are duties that are outside of that contract that they have taken on what are we current what positions are we currently compensating what other positions do we have we figured out in our inventory um and I would think between finance and HR we should be able to have some inventory and we can look at you know what are our objectives and how do we as a board feel that people should be compensated um so that we can you know we found money here how much more do we need to find to make it Equitable for those positions that we and the district feel move a needle enrichment um but fall outside of the contract duties of our salaried you know employees yeah HR

092and finance can definitely present that at Finance you you don't have to do as superintendent all right uh okay any other discussion uh yes I just wanted to say a quick thank you on behalf of staff for taking this so seriously and making great strides toward recognizing the extra efforts that staff are making outside of the regular school day so thank you all very much wonderful all right tell your friends um any other discussion okay uh all in favor all right thank you very much good afternoon everyone the financial statements that you were that you received in your packets this month covered us through December 31st year to date which was 50% of our fiscal year and 40% of the school year um for fund 100 our general revenues property tax collections are at 60%

093compared to 62.6% last year overall revenues were at 56.5 % of budget which is also a little bit lower than our collections last year which was at 58.5% our general fund expenditures this month I want to highlight energy expenditures we are at 43.6% of budget Which is higher than we were um the year before at 41% teachers salaries expenditures remain the same at at 37% of the budget power professional salary expenditures are lower at 31% of our budget compared to 36 and 32% from the prior year overall our total expenditures are at 39% compared to about 37% the year before um outside of that we have nothing else to report we're in um all of our other funds we're in pretty good good shape you have any questions uh Mr katchmar this is a very

094odd question but that's what you get from me sometimes has there been any discussion in your um kind of Municipal um Association groups about potential tax impacts on of tariffs of all of the um changes coming from the new Administration how that might trickle down to impact on especially on um some of the tax collections um that could be in Jeopardy if Goods start stop flowing for a while have has there have you in any of your uh Municipal organizations or trade organizations is there any discussion or forecasting on what the next year might look like or is it too early to tell it Larry I um we haven't heard anything as far as the organizations that we are um affiliated with and and it just may just be too early um there hasn't been

095any Chow out there yet I would just ask if you do get some prognostication from those groups that maybe you share it with us as we go through the budgeting process for 25 and Beyond yes thanks question uh Mr Smith question um thank you for your report thank you for your report um with the uh since Mr Sean opened this door I'm going to kind of walk in it a little bit more with the possibilities of changes to Title One funding and things of that nature uh I would like to ask a plethora of questions one being uh can you tell me how much or what amount of salaries are accommodated by Title One funding um also I would like for you to tell me if there are any uh talks about what would we

096do if there are any uh changes significant changes to that um that program y um to respond um I actually sent an email earlier to my fellow um staff members we plan to have a a response or presentation on the 19th if that's okay to bring to the board just to talk about the types of federal programs what they do the number of positions that are involved and what type of budgets that they have so we do want to kind of bring that to together in a summary to board so we can list all of them and we can have the directors talk about their programs and talk about their initiatives so we want to give you the kind of the big picture and not just peac mail it awesome can and would you also

097be able to tell us how many employees would be impacted by that thank you so much number of employees for each program yes sir thank you uh Dr Howard Hall I just add I can say that for a fact with title one we know that what would happen with those positions they'll become State paid employees so a lot of vacancies that we have more than likely to be filled if we have teachers who are currently funded through title one for those teachers um in the event that something really goes south and we lose tile One Fund those administrative positions they will again be offered State paid positions to basically go back in the classroom I think that's important for our community to be aware of our employees as well thank you Mr M yes also

098there's so many court cases coming up that this is going to be a rolling um information uh situation so we'll need to just stay tuned and see from dayto day um try not to panic can just see how things go okay agenda item 9.02 um startup cost and F 100 budget transfer here we're just trying to establish startup cost for the new Bloomingdale Elementary and The New wior Forest High School the budget transfer is transferring $1.2 million to various Supply and Equipment accounts for both of those schools if not mistaken we're doing 750,000 for the high school and 500,000 for the elementary school thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved a recommended budget transfer in the amount of 1,250,000 for fy2 startup CS to support the new Bloomingdale Elementary

099School and wior Forest High School as shown above moved and seconded any discussion this is just this and this might just be me the term Expendable equipment just is uh an Expendable I mean I understand that it's FFN just the Expendable side of it just sounds like he we got it just toss it here toss it there it's Expendable um I don't know if I know that's probably some bit that's probably a financial yeah it's a term I don't know if we just down to the bottom Expendable equipment can are these things rather than just we're just buying some computers that we're going to have and then we'll just throw them away um so yeah I know it's it's actually the desks and things like that but it just comes across as like it's just

100Expendable what is the other items beside FF and V so it's not the desk and the big items the major items that will last more than 5 years is really for you know calculators projectors that type of stuff yeah I small stuff nor at the bottom that says yeah Dr Hall and I'm back with Title One if it has a life expectancy of less than one year is not is not um considered as Expendable it's it's um non-expendable okay any other discussion there being none all in favor thank you item 9.03 out of four a student support and academic enrichment Grant the Georgia Department of Education has allotted suround chman County Public Schools 1, 380,000 26 for the federal tler 4A student support and academic enrichment funds for FY 25 below is the summary of

101the proposed adjustment for the grant thus we resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the budget amendment shown above in the amount of 814,000 $711 to align the Tyler 4 a student support and academic enrichment budget with the grant allocation as approved by the Georgia Department of Education moved and seconded any discussion uh I have question this is based on a Federal Grant I believe this 2 Century the title four is yes any other title pro programs are federal grants so through the department of it comes through the department Department of Education yeah just like Tittle one Title One comes through the Georgia Department of Education so we are 98 90% we're getting this as of today yes sir all right I just want the public to know that this is

102another yes question mark Federal B this is a question mark we were talking more about it on the 19th um oh I just want to know is there a specific time when it comes April 1st um when when do we expect the funds to be in place this grant is currently in place this is just an additional award so this grant is currently in place in place we have the funds already yes we have some funds already this is we some of we don't have all of the funds right we don't this grant is reimbursable so as we spend money we can ask for reimbursement this is just an additional funding for the grant Dr Hoskins Brown I'm this so we're approving extending the amount that we would incur the expenses we would incur that

103we would seek reimbursement for have we already sought reimbursement for our expenditures on this grant to date yes we do reimbursements monthly for all of our grants so we would only be 30 days in on any expenditures on any Department of Education yes ma'am originating or fil funding yes either federal or state Grant okay thank you Mr gmar um for planning purposes I know the the court the court arguments Miss Hall uh referenced earlier are Congress already voted to allocate These funds um and so the executive has to execute um what Congress already approved that's the argument anyway um yeah argument versus reality but I'm just saying that's the argument um but for next year right different Administration different control of Congress a lot of this may not be allocated for the next budget cycle

104even though it has been for this so when we plan we just need to be cognizant of this might not be a multi-year program based and we won't have the argument next year that Congress allocated the funds because they may not so we just need to sounds like you're you already know that we're trying to navigate right beep without knowing what the information is and not withholding opportunities from kids I mean what what I fear most is that we become too conservative and withhold opportunities from kids and then the money comes and then we're scrambling so it's a balance that I guess we're trying to strike between how we move forward but we're also trying to forecast and predict and plan for the unknown okay Dr Hoskins Brown thank you that's a really good point

105because we're in a continuing resolution so we don't even really have this for this year so we'll know next we will know the resolution is authorized until March 14th so we won't know before the March board meeting but we will know by the April board meeting whether or not there are any cuts to this current year for Education funds that's correct sh but as Mr kmar has mentioned I think we're going on the premise that those funds that have been allocated hopefully they will continue to support those and fund those position hopefully but we never know he sees me making faces at him as a federal employee you hopefully we'll be allocated make you smile thank you Mr Jackson M I just want to say if that come becomes true that even though These funds

106are already allocated voted on and allocated and we don't get them we we will have much more serious problems than than just just this okay um you have one more Mr MZ I'm sorry yes Dr hhal from looking at this is is this related or tied with 21st century or is that's just one of the grants I know that this just one of the grants part of title for is separate from 21st century they had to correct me on that too but 21st century is upon on the Toler 4 as well okay and I know also there a um HB 12 is it 141 12 out there um hb2 that talks about Georgia legislative talking about the grants that's a whole another um yes I can check on that I know that's in your wellhouse

107okay any other discussion all right uh all in favor thank you item 9.04 change order number one s arts academy M Knight Construction on April 13 2022 the board approved a guaranteed maximum price of $22,988 th000 to magnite Construction Company Incorporated for the Savannah Arts Academy audition and renovation project the project is now completed and all costs have been finalized the final cost is 2,991 1532 which is 89,4 98 under the GMP in accordance with the contract all cost savings under the GMP at completion or returned back to the owner therefore GMP change order number one reduces the GMP to the current contract amount of 21,990 1532 staff recommends board approval of GMP change order number one for the Savanah arts academy and the superintendent supports this recommendation thus be resolv upon the recommendation of

108the superintendent that the board approve GMP change order number one in the deductive amount of 989,50 46.98 to Mite construction company and a fineral contract amount of [Music] 21,990 uh got your motion are you moving yeah yes moved and seconded and now you have a comma yes um this is quite a windfall for us um Dr Watts thank you for clarifying this for me um and I'm wondering now thises this $989,000 what fund would it be returned to unallocated unal unallocated unallocated okay right all right reallocate and we yes well this this is quite a windfall for us very good to see I M Kowski Dr Brown thank you to mcnight for job well done and to our team for job well managed to be receiving a million dollars back from a construction project in

109the day and age is kind of unheard of so kudos to all Dr hus Brown thank you I I know when we were talking about um looking at projects that were unfinished I'm not I'm sorry that were finished but that all the funds had not been consumed that we were targeting them to do other projects so what is the plan for this money um currently it would just go back to unallocated I don't think we have a plan yet for the expenditure of these funds we I I just remember in one of Mr batra's previous presentations he said that we were moving towards identifying projects so you have many have a list that we generated and which we'll be reallocating I don't know about these specific funds okay like this specific dollar amount but there

110was there were other unallocated dollars that were discussed in a previous meeting and we do have a list of those projects and how they're going to be reallocated okay has that been shared no okay will we see that at some point yes okay thank you okay um hang on um Miss Hall in addition to MC Knight I want to also uh commend the pat matthys Construction Company who are the junior partner in this um project this is very well done okay any other discussion all right this is one my really like to vote on uh all in favor all right thank you okay item 9.05 R of qc2 24- 09 geotechnical engineering special inspection and materials testing annual contract first renewal on December the 6 2023 the board approved the award of RFQ c249 geot

111technical engineering special inspection and materials testing annual contract to the following vendors Contour engineerings LLC out of chipon Georgia ECF Southeast LLP out of Savannah Georgia Goodman Mills katewood LLC out of Savannah Georgia teron Consultants Incorporated out of Savannah retical laboratory Incorporated Alice Savannah and wsp USA environment and infrastructure Incorporated Al Savannah staff Rec recommend exercising the first renewal option with all terms and conditions remaining the same the estimated annual expenditure for the first renewal period is $1 million thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the first renewal of RFQ c249 geotechnical engineering special inspection and materials testing and anual contract to the following vendors cont engineering ests Southeast Goodman Mills kwood teron Consultants vertical laboratory and wsp USA environment and infrastructure for an estimated cost of $1 million

112and seconded any discussion right all right all in favor thank you very much it 9.06 C 2301 districtwide Furniture fixes and Equipment FF for K12 media centers annual contract second and final renewal on January the 11th 2023 the board approved the award of RFP c231 districtwide Furniture FES and equipment for K12 media centers to the farm of Masons Incorporated the award was for an initial one term of one year with two additional one-year periods the estimated expenditures for the first period were $17,616.63 n36 for for secondary schools on December 6 2023 the board approved the purchase under RFP c231 for plasy K8 media media center furniture at an estimated cost of $162,200 which included media media center Furniture under RFP c231 staff now recommends renewal of the contract with Mason Incorporated under RFP c231 for

113the final annual renewal period through feu February 17th 2025 through February 16th 2026 for an estimated total expenditure of $600,000 as detail below for those following School Largo toet swing site Montgomery swing site JG Smith Elementary and Georgetown Ka School thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the renewal of the contract with Masons Incorporated under RFP c231 districtwide Furniture fixes and equipment for K12 media centers for the first annual renewal period with estimated expenditures for the final renewal period of $600,000 and I'm sorry that should be final renewal renewal final annual renewal period was an estimated expenditures for the final renewal period of $67,000 it's been moved been seconded uh any discussion all right all in favor wonderful item 9.07 RFP c2-05 construction manager at risk CMR services for

114Georgetown K8 Renovations the purchasing department received proposals from seven offerers in response to RFP c255 construction manager at RIS services for Georgetown K renovations the initial intent of this solicitation was to establish a contract for construction manager at risk services for Georgetown K8 Renovations as outlined an RFP c25 d05 for all related documents proposals were received from Carol Daniel Construction Company Alis Savannah DBS Williams General Contractors Al Statesboro J Don construction company Al of Savannah MB con Al of Savannah M Knight construction out of Savannah samit Corporation out of Savannah and TQ Constructors incorporator Incorporated out of met staff recommends RFP c255 construction manager atrisk services for Georgetown K8 Renovations be awarded to J down Construction Company Incorporated with an initial stated cost limitation of $25 million the scope of the work for the RFP

115includes the renovations and modifications to the logo tobet swing site to prepare this facility to receive Georgetown K8 school after the 25 24 through 25 school year is completed construction documents for the logo Tibet School are ready for release and to keep this work on schedule the CMR needs to be to begin issuing these documents for bills toward incl subcontracts mobilizing and starting construction at the lgo tobet site as soon as possible therefore this contract award would allow the crr to incur cost and be reimbursed as part of the cost of the work in accordance with the contract preconstruction costs and crr overhead costs and expenses to being reimbursed are a maximum of $2,913 th000 including a 3.5% of the CMR fee thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board

116approve the award of RFP c255 construction manager atrisk services for Georgetown K8 renovations to J dong construction company with an initial stated cost limitation of $25 million it is further resolved to allow the CMR to commence work on the Georgetown K8 preconstruction and loggo toet renovation phase prior to the submission of the final GMP the board also approves payment of up to 2,913 th000 for preconstruction cost and CMR overhead cost and expenses including a 3.5% fee to be paid upon review and approval by the superintendent and District staff in the ordinary ordinary course of business which may include submissions and review of pay applications after work has performed and the applications are submitted by the contractor and reviewed by the design professional and District staff mve and second it any discussion Miss Hall well congratulations

117to J Dunn um I was so happy to see on the list of criteria that the LM wbe program received points worth 15% and then when they had a second initial meeting with the top two contenders um that there was a consideration of 20% for L mwbe participation however I do not see a partner a junior partner from the L mwbe community listed in this proposal I don't see Brownstone construction I don't see the poot Corporation I don't see Pat Mattis construction or any other entity representing the minority community so what has happened and what points did J dun receive for 20% participation and we don't see anything here in the contract I'm going to let someone from the design team come forward and explain the criteria that was used companies yes ma'am thank you

118um first let me just uh be sure it's clear that having a minority conern construction management partner is not a requirement of the RFP the RFP however does require that the vendors give an explanation of what their lwbe program is and how that program is going to best satisfy board policy and then it goes on to explain or to ask the each individual respondent to provide their proposed plan to describe what their good faith efforts are going to be to maximize the utilization of LW MBE and to promote capacity building so when they respond to the RFP itself they have to respond to that question they each put together their plan their program if they are going to be using a CMR partner in the management of the contract that will be put in their

119plan however other vendors come forward with plans that use trade Partnerships so the response is asking what program are you going to put forward that's going to best utilize give us best efforts and satisfy what the board policy is that's what's being scored and initially it was scored at the 15% because there were a lot of other questions that were being asked and they had to respond to when the short list was developed then there were less questions and that particular response came into 20% now let me just um also say that we have been asked before okay anybody can put anything in a plan however what's the proof and this particular contractor uh J done has done four four projects they completed with us and I only know from E2 on I don't know

120if they did an E1 project or not but they're on the fifth project with us it's a total of over $27 million of construction and they have documented proof that we presented throughout the course of E2 and in into E3 just recently E4 the results of this I won't go through them individually but in local participation they're averaging 66% and in wbe they're averaging 23% and that is one of our better producers in those areas um every one of their projects have been completed on on time and they're working on Windsor Forest right now and their schedule shows them and we certainly believe that project also is going to be completed on time so based upon their responses in the RFP and the grades that they received from the scoring team they were the high

121score and consequently they were recommended for award Mr h we're launching an E5 referendum in March I want the constituents of chadam County to support that referendum this is not a satisfactory way as far as I'm concerned to get there if J Dunn has given a list of the ways they're going to comply with our request then we need to be able to see that traditionally Dr Watts you hav't been here but when we have a CMR at risk a junior partner is named and these are the three entities that have been most um capable in terms of being a partner with our uh contractors our Prime contractors Brownstone construction Pat mathys construction and the poo Corporation J Dunn has certainly partnered with those several of those firms in the past for there to be

122no participation listed here from one of these entities or from any entity that just they gave a very good essay and narrative about what they plan to do without any written agreements with any of the people who represent our minority Community it's not satisfactory and I feel that capital projects those listed here on that selection committee our purchasing department are not carrying through with encouraging minority participation when we have these huge $25 million projects to give out to the community if I expect people to vote for our East blast in addition to the wonderful schools we built for our children that East blo is the economic tool for us to use then I expect for us to be transparent and diligent about keeping our promises to the community that we made when E4 was P

123Dr bringman I'm s I'm sorry uh Dr Hoskins Brown Dr bring I'm sorry that's all right I'm I'm just quick normally when we have something like this we have like some scoring and we have some supplementary documentation why is all of that missing we don't we know we have scoring but okay okay so wait let's let's people are getting reactive and it's it's late I'm I'm I just asked we normally have some supplementary information that tells about tells us about the process so what is it that is different about this purchas the that part as far as the additional information normally you get the scoring sheets did you not get the scoring sheets with this project no we do not have a scoring sheet we only have a resolution I've only ever gotten a scoring

124sheet for like one or two projects I do not believe that that is our normal process unless we ask the District to provide those scoring sheets I have I never had them just sent to me prior to a vote on any other construction project only when is the problem well that's not an inconsistency that's when we ask for it they provide it okay so let's let's go back further we need to go back to polies on how what I want to ask is we need to probably re-evaluate our policies if we believe that we should get those scoring sheets before we vote but the only time I have ever been a part of a conversation where scoring sheets were shared with me is when one of the board members reached out or myself that is

125the only it has not been normal District protocol for the last six years I've been on the board to get those scoring sheets with every RFP at any dollar amount on on some contracts we have and I think that the key word is inconsistency on some contracts we get them on this one we have not um I just wanted to know why we why we didn't but I mean we can get them yes we can get but nobody asked for them it was my understanding what was just explained is how it has occurred I think what's conspicuous is there's a lot of language in this resolution about scoring there's like three different paragraphs where the scoring is referred to but we don't have the scoring that's all so if you're going to if you're going

126to make a resolution that you want heavily dependent on on something like that then you just provide it that's all I would agree that this is out of our normal resolution on some of the of of explaining the RFP process um I do not want it to be our normal to have the score sent every single time because it is not my job to re-evaluate how we have District staff evaluating those it is our job to set policy and we we've been having this discussion in cic to say how do we want that to look so that when people do put in for an RFP they understand the process and we believe that the process is going on appropriately if Miss Hall does not believe that scoring is done appropriately then a third party should

127be auditing it not board members asking for scoring and saying I don't believe that score is correct or not um so that's how I see this going but I would love to to know what in this process process was done incorrectly to create the issues that we're discussing now Mr Smith oh you're okay okay Miss Hall it's my contention that the purchasing department and capital projects is negligent in promoting the spirit and the substance of what the policy is asking for prior to E4 E1 E2 E3 in most of our schools that have been built there was a primary contractor and a junior minority contractor it slipped by me that when the farest High School had no minority partner that has been a big part part of our presentation to the public that we are

128using the East Bloss funds as an economic engine in this County if we do not deliver that and if we just bypass it and I'm saying that the people on this panel who have been here long enough to remember Mr hunting you have been here and you have seen the contracts as recently as the Savannah Arts Academy with mcnight and Pat math construction so this isn't some you know Pie in the Sky you know Revelation where is the push from capital projects and the purchasing department to make sure that our minority contractors are included in these huge sums of money we're giving out to J Dunn and the other primary contractors and I don't blame J Dunn because if we're not pushing it then what you know what do they need to do come and

129say oh you haven't asked us to um keep the we're not asking for it the people who represent us on these panels are not pushing for it Miss Kowski then Mr catchon then I have a comment um so I appreciate Miss Hall's advocacy for the mwbe program um but I also heard during the staff presentation that J Dunn has demonstrated their commitment to our mwbe program through the plan that was evaluated as a part of the RP process which is how it should be um and based on the records that you stated from Jun I did not write them down but I believe you stated 66% local participation is that correct and 23% of wbe so if we have 2third of the funds remaining within our own Community I can't think of a stronger economic

130engine um and if they're achieving 23% on projects of nwb participation it may not be to the three large firms that were mentioned but to me that looks like it's going up to the smaller firms who even need to support even more and so I like to see the diversification and the building up of those smaller contractors to be able to increase and improve their capacity over time to increase the pool of contractors that we have to work with um and really build a robust ecosystem of diverse contractors across the board so while I appreciate the advocacy I do support the work that staff has put into this and it seems to me that through the process and through the identification of the plan that was mentioned that those are the criteria that we should

131be evaluating in addition to the other criteria that are very important as we are selecting a contractor thank you Mr katmar um Miss Hall I'm going to ask you a question if that's okay I'm trying to understand the concern is the concern that there isn't a junior CMR our partner identified here or is the concern that all of the proposed ways in which this contractor is going to try to meet um our lmw be goals not listed um like for example if we had received the list of all the trades lmw be trades that this contractor proposed working with would that be sufficient or is it your contention there should be a CMR partner I appreciate you question the most efficient way to see that all of the contractors that Mr Grabowski is speaking of

132usually comes under an organization so say if Pat mathus construction was the junior partner that is their whole purpose to make sure that every possible company in chadam County that can work on our projects will be involved see they they they professionalize it so that it's not you know oh here's mock Plumbing running over here and here's something over here there's an organized structure to the labor force so that as many possible companies you know represented by local women minorities are involved so that's the efficiency of it that's what I'm looking for but if they gave us a list of 25 if J Dunn gave us a list of 25 companies that they're going to be having business done with yes that that that would in a way you know that would be this in

133a way that would be it but it wouldn't be the professional way of doing it because you're talking about dealing with een meeny miny mo rather than going through a specific company that you're Contracting in good faith to make sure that it happens and since you've been on the board a little longer than me and Dr hin Brown I know that you recall that for many years that's the way our CMR projects were delivered and my contention is that it's the Lac ofical [Music] ah why do we have to go through that and to me that's not what I want to present to the public when we're going out and asking them to vote for an East blast 5 understood my um I think we've all been on the board about the same time it's

134been a long time and we've had a um an evolution of our lmw be approach um we both I think came in right at the beginning of E2 and we had several discussions about what our lmw be process and policy should be and how do we grow that policy to get to the goals we wanted to get to and so in E1 and and in E2 a bit there was a lot of CMR partnering and we didn't do a lot of hard bid we didn't do a lot of variation and then if I remember correctly and somebody can look this up and tell me I'm wrong but I think when we looked at our numbers every year E1 and maybe E2 we were in the teens in terms of lmw be participation and I distinctly

135remember it was either E2 or E3 we had a presentation on what we had accomplished that year with our lmw be goals and it was in the high teens and then we looked at surrounding municipalities who were celebrating 6% and 8% and we were ecstatic we were like at 19% um and and so we said to ourselves how can we grow this pie increase increase the pool of small lmw businesses and other L mwb businesses that can participate and we talked specifically about expanding it to the subcontracts not just the main contracts um to try to grow the smaller companies the subcontractors um that we could help you know grow that pool of in chadam county and the next time we looked at lmw participation we were up at like 24 or 26 or 28%

136I think that was an E3 and we use that to go sell um not sell but go pro sorry we can't promote we can't sell to go to we to share neutral information on on no but but the point was our lmw process has evolved over the years and we've gone from the high single digits to the teens to the 20% um as a districtwide um and so um I'm G I'm circling back to make a point which is I agree with M uh Dr bringman that we hire staff to to run the scoring in the process and we need to let them do their job we shouldn't be second guessing them if we don't like the criteria being applied we need to rewrite our policy um and and there's an opportunity for people who

137feel like they were grieved in that process to appeal they can challenge um there's an appeal process Etc um I don't know if that's happened here or not um but that's certainly there's certainly an option to say we were not scored fairly or we don't think the criteria were applied correctly and again if we as a board don't like the evaluation process we can write another policy and then I hear what you're saying and those organizations you've mentioned have been long-term partners with the district on various projects um but the bigger picture is if we're if if contractors are providing opportunities um to lmw be businesses at a i' I'd rather want I want a higher percentage as opposed to there has to be these trades or uh C Mr our Junior partner and unlike

138other contractors they've got a long track record of actually delivering so I I'm going to support this resolution I don't see any reason why uh I don't see I don't I haven't heard any problems with the bid process I don't want to hold this up um and again if you think if we collectively as a board think that there's a reason to rewrite our policy to change the scoring or change the point of emphasis that's certainly a discussion to have this will be a final remark I think our policy is great I don't think there's anything wrong with our policy I don't think it's being implemented and Dr wat I'll just say to you anything you can find out I'll be happy to announce that I was absolutely wrong in error but I feel that

139the spirit of what we're trying to do is not being carried through that's our policy is great we don't need to change anything and goodness knows in time with what's happening in Washington we may you know not have anything but for the few remaining gasps of air that we have I would appreciate if you would take a keen interest in whether or not you feel our policy is being implemented by the persons representing us are the have taking us taking this seriously okay so I have a couple of questions um and I haven't been here very long um but what I have seen uh when we've awarded these um contracts is in the process none of these the CMR is not necessarily naming their L mwb whatever uh companies they're just saying this is our

140commitment to and this is our commitment and this is our plan is that correct they would in their responses name a wbe if they're going to be participating in the management portion of the contract only that's where that Junior partner comes in got it and I can only reinforce what Mr casmar said in that we did have in E2 our cmrs did have Partners they were in the management and I'll be bluntly honest there were some passrs in there and our policy right now and our process right now and getting that work down to the level of the Construction and building up smaller we've got a number of contractors that have and could come in here and say as a result of working on this particular project I now can increase my bonding capacity I

141now can go out and get better work not just on a management level which is important and it has been done but now it filters down into the construction level and J Dunn is one of our Champions yeah so our so our policy was not that we had to have an mwbe as no it does not that is not the because we can't do that because by law we'd get sued okay that's part part no that's part H hang on that's part one part two our policy is an L W MBE policy it is not just a mwb policy correct it is an LW okay so we're looking at at J Dunn and thank you for giving us the background on what J Dunn has done and by the way I don't think any of

142us should be promoting any company let's just put that out there right now but what you said was they have finished projects on time they had 60% local that's the Y they had 23% mwbe so what you're saying is when you guys were looking at and and thank you staff for what you've done because at the end of the day what taxpayers all taxpayers want to know is that we're spending their money wisely and you spend their money with people that get the do the job done right and on time and what you're saying is they did that plus they did it with 60% local and 23% mwb yep and let me add one thing okay cuz I forgot this a plus plus was this this particular CMR did heslo Williams and Jenkins three of

143those projects let go back in the board dos three of those projects they return savings under the GMP so all of that would have been good in the resolution that's right that's what you need in a good resolution Dr Dr Dr briman you call me whatever I'm fine it's 4:40 we're trying to get but I mean I said we'd have a short meeting so it's all my fault um thank you for bringing up board dos and thank you for having board dos because I've been over here digging through all of our last contracts and I'm going to say I was wrong because I'm at the Jenkins contract has all the same language for the percentages in the Jenkins contract guess what's not named in the Jenkin contract a junior contract uh guess what's named in

144the contract all the people that sat on it so the principal well at that point the Jenkins contract has Miss Harrington she's retired um but here we've got the principal so we are following our normal all the way back to that I didn't have enough time it took me a while to actually find that contract because you yeah but but we're following the norms and I mean I know everybody wants to go home but we could we could get the resident expert that's sitting over there under the reserve for media sign and he's probably got the Powerpoint in his pocket to say how much money all these companies have gotten from all of these contracts because that's why I think we have them as a contractor for us to make sure that this policy is

145done but I'll go back to my first if we don't think we're doing it right in cic let's look back at how we're making this happen and we can redesign what the policy looks like around the RFP awarding process we can't tell them exactly how to do it but I think we can build it with them if we don't think that it's meeting the needs Dr Hoskin thank you I have a deep desire for this to have been a short meeting too so I'm not I'm not going to add a lot to it I I think that one of the essential things that we're missing in what Mrs Hall is trying to convey is how people perceive how we're doing the work and how receptive they will be to our advocacy and education on East

146Blas based on how they see us transacting our business um so I still advocate for strong effective resolutions that don't require 30 minutes of discussion to demonstrate the Merit of the recommendation because that's what we've had to do we've had to talk for a half hour to get to all the things that are not here on the resolution that we're being asked to vote on all of those Salient points all of that back information would have taken care of this and really the only thing that has not been um addressed which is Mrs Hall's preference and that's hers to articulate is the presence of and an L mwbe in a more prominent management role in this and and it's her right to want to see that and then not vote for this for not seeing

147it but all these other things are not as subjective they're just missing from what we have reviewed okay any other discussion let's vote all in favor thank you I'm sorry opposed yes any extensions nope thank you very much all right we have thank [Music] you yeah oh here we go we have one person that is here to speak and it looks very exciting actually uh I like the topic the thrill the First Flight LLC uh Mr John Ratcliffe I'm pulling this off not strip I just want everybody to see t-shirt a nice about uh go to the microphone please oh okay I I I shout so much yes I'm ex military Air Force so I can't hear uh with me is Lexi I don't try to pronounce her last name she just got married and

148it's confusing so Lexi Lexi is a part of Savannah Aviation which is one of the Premier flight schools out at the Savannah Hilton Head airport and what we've done my group I got two groups that I'm representing one is black Pilots of America and the other one is one that I just started two years ago called Thrill of the First Flight LLC because when I when I would fly these kids they'd get off the airplane and all you see is a big grin and I and I took that to mean that they enjoyed it but our our presence here is uh uh to First tell you what we do we fly kids last year at the Savannah Hill airport we flew 182 kids that's a lot because most of the parents don't want them to

149fly anyway and why do we do it because it it was available to me and I try to make it available to everybody else the program will be on March 29 of this year at the Savannah Hilson airport at 34 Hangar Road which is the Savannah Aviation hanger uh the sponsors you see on the sheet Thrill of the first flight Savannah Aviation and Living Hope Church which some of you might be familiar with that's my church is that your church you tell Miss Civ I said I was here okay all right uh we got fre flight opportunities for the kids this year we're going to limit it to 50 through 12th grade because last year we were overwhelmed we haded third through 12th grade so this year is going to be a limit you're going

150to sign up the kids will sign up via event bright um I think most of you may be familiar with that as an invitation only kind of thing uh they will be able to mingle with Aviation professionals we have air traffic control Pilots flight attendance airport maintenance uh facilities main navigation maintenance all kinds of things like like that and I will have two of my simulators available for those who might be afraid to fly they can pretend uh Hot Dog chip pop juice for the kids and everybody that comes with them a real important piece you see on there highlighted in yellow youth must be accompanied by a parent or Guardian yes no dry balls okay and the last part is uh last year we weren't able to do this but this year I'm personally

151going to sponsor one individual for 16 hours of flight time to try to get them to a solo position so they can go ahead and learn how to fly they will need to seek additional funds from other sources to continue their training but we'll get them started we're going to do that here in in Savannah we're going to do it at Statesboro and in Way Cross so if anybody wants to contribute FirstLight ga.org and you can contribute and we'll give you a receipt online for your tax deductions uh I'm not asking for money but I am we can't thank you enough okay and that that's the that's the major part of our story and I I dropped all the business cards I had on the way in here somewhere all good uh but we're good

152if you go to flight uh FirstLight ga.org you can find all the information you need about us you're the best thank you so much be the best I'm proud of myself yes yes Lexi you may speak yes uh my last name is gurganus just just to say um but I would like to add that last year uh we did host the sitan aviation and it was a big hit um it was something that was a really cool exp it was it was something that was a really cool experience to all the kids out there um and most importantly it's not only an experience for the kids but it also opens up a um career in aviation so kids um children that are in the school district may not really understand um what Aviation has to

153offer so I think that's something that's very important and can definitely be an eye opener thank you very much please stick around I want to talk to [Applause] you all right by the way I I turned 80 this month oh my [Music] all right I'll accept a motion Sean's already okay has already been seconded all in favor yeah thank you guys

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.