CorpusRecord 88388

Regular Board Meeting - December 18, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SCCPSSCommunications
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Chatham County, GA
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,274 words · about 119 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good afternoon afternoon afternoon uh welcome to the December 18th 2024 regular meeting of the board of public education for the city of Savannah and the county of chadam uh we will start uh by if everyone would stand and we'll pledge uh s Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all I'll accept a motion to approve the agenda I make a motion to approve the agenda as posted or modified I second uh any amendments no nope thank you good all right all in favor thank you uh no amendments okay announcements you guys have an amendment do you have an amendment to the motion to the I said as as posted

002and amended is that ACC I don't have any amendments before me you don't have any amendments okay okay all right all right announcements okay um oh everyone a few people will be excited about this uh our first announcement is is Winter break starts Monday uh through January 3rd all district facilities are closed January 23rd through January 3rd uh staff planning day is January 6 students return to school on January 7th finance committee meeting January 8th at 9 am here uh January 8th is also the economic uh luncheon at the that's the Chamber of economic luncheon at Savannah Convention Center and um remembrances we only have one this year um uh emene Middleton who was a school counselor date of passing 24 if we would stand for a moment of silence may I please uh may

003I please add to that uh remembrance list uh Mr Clifton Jones uh he served as District 5 Alderman and who was there for 16 years and he passed away at 92 years old on yesterday I would like to remember him as well all right thank you all right okay and now we'll hear from our superintendent I am excited to bring to you the superintendance report this month that begins with our November student of the month I'm excited to bring you all a November superintendent a December superintendent report that includes a November student of the month our student of the month for November is a senior at Johnson High School he is an exemplary student whose commitment to scholarship and service is apparent to anyone who has had the pleasure of meeting him as an intern

004National blackette diploma program candidate he has been engaged in rigorous academic Pursuits and is always seeking more challenges this is not only evident in his GPA which places him at the current Salud tutorium rank but in outstanding IB scores on exams he already took as a junior at Johnson he is a peer mediator a captain at of Johnson Esports s a member of the soccer team and a member of Savannah lion dance team his nominator wrote Our student of the month arrived in this country shortly after entering high school as a ninth grader at Johnson High School his teachers noticed right away that even though he wasn't he was still learning English he was excelling in his classes it was recommended that he enroll in the IB Program where he has continued to grow as

005a thinker a problem solver and an English speaker since joining the IB cohort he has become a leader not just academically but also socially his growth and movement to the top to one of the top positions in the class demonstrates that with effort and genuine desire to succeed anything is possible his dedication to service and Community Partnerships extends Beyond school he is also very active in his church and in his Vietnamese community amassing over 250 hours of community service just over the last two years he participates in historic Georgia cleanups and tby Beach cleanups he volunteers at Second Harvest of the coastal Empire and Host Game Nights at his church this student is a finalist for the national Quest Bridge match scholarship which is a 100% for foure scholarship to MIT Stanford Caltech or Cornell

006what a menu to pick from he also exploring Georgia Tech and the University of Georgia to explore all engineering possibilities available to him to allow him to pursue his passion in tech for psychology please please help me to congratulate the superintendent super student of the month for for November 2024 then Unwin [Applause] then congratulations congratulations thank you congratulations wonderful job exciting to recognize this student I would also like for his parents to stand if they are with us today and staff representing Johnson uh High School that are here to [Applause] support will be taking home taking home several gifts from our sponsors including Members First Credit Credit Union advertising Specialties Specialties Georgia Southern University gstream and More in addition theen and the students in his IB language and literature class will receive copies of his

007favorite book blink the power of thinking without thinking that's a great book by the way by Malcolm Gladwell donated by our sponsor e shaver book seller again congratulations to theen to his family and the suce Johnson family and special thanks to his nominator Amanda Finelli and the principal Jam Brown I continue uh with good news for this month and many reasons to applaud uh I'll start off by sharing that 58 School level teachers of the year were recognized by the superintendent and board of education at a reception on December the 4th and the five finalists for the Savannah chadam County Public School System 2026 District teacher of the year were honored and announced and I'd like to congratulate them now Jameson T Meadows uh from Godly station K8 School Christy lines of May Howard Elementary

008School Jennifer Hughes of Southwest Elementary School khita jindin at tyby Island Maritime Academy and Brooklyn Howard of Windsor Forest High School and please let's give those individuals round the finalists were determined by scores from Community readers of each teachers essay application which is based on the state teacher of the year application the finalist will now move on in competition to become the district teacher of the year for the 2526 school year the district teacher of the year will be announced in March and that will be an exciting time for us I would also like to congratulate our first ever math leader schools uh for the state of Georgia recognizing the fundamental importance of mathematics and in students education and future careers the Georgia Department of Education is recognizing schools with exceptional achievement or growth in

009mathematics as math leaders for the state the following sccpss schools were selected for this honor Charles Ellis monor Academy Coastal Middle School Garrison School for the Arts Georgetown K8 Island High School oglethorp charter Rice Creek K8 Savannah Classical Academy Schuman Elementary and Woodville Tomkins Technical and career high school and I believe we have representation from those schools [Applause] how you doing man good to see youy how are you conratulations again we would like to congratulate and um celebrate the work that is happening in math across our district um and I think these leaders and representatives from the schools certainly demonstrate that thank you for all that you do um I will move on now to share with you that the local the LEL milin Family Foundation has announced the 2425 cohort of art effect ambassadors

010this is a prestigious Visual Arts education Fellowship for educators working directly with students in grades 6 through 12 among those selected is Savannah Arts Academy visual arts teacher Rosemary Dodson this year's art effect Ambassador will participate in a series of professional develop development sessions learning from other high level practitioners in collegial peer Learning Community um thank you and congratulations to miss Dodson we are excited to have you represent us to continue your growth and professional development in the area of Arts congratulations on the outstanding light sell literacy accomplishments at Savannah Early College High School named a lightell reading Achievement Award winner your commitment to literacy is is an inspiring example showing that hard work curiosity and passion for learning truly pays off thank you for creating an environment where the power of reading and a

011love of learning is contagious we cannot wait to see where your students reading Journey will take them and even more alads for the Early College Holden hanel from Savannah early college has been awarded the prestigious 2024 Demir sailing scholarship besides school and sailing Holden was the vice chairman of the chattam County Youth commission and actively participates in community service volunteering with organizations such as old Savannah City Mission and parent University congratulations Holden we are very proud of you as we have some good news with our student athlet leetes we also have some good news to share about our student athletes new hamad's ran trole the record setting senior quarterback for the Phoenix for the Phoenix has been named the winner of the 44th Michael fasio it's hard to say Memorial outstanding football player award as

012the top high school football player in Savannah it is the second year in a row that tro has been recognized with his honor congratulations to ran and the entire Phoenix family what an accomplishment congratulations yes congratulations also to the lady Panthers cross country team from Savannah Arts Academy the girls team brought home the gold at the state championship last month this is their second state championship in school history the team held off Columbus by a score of 34- 37 to win this prestigious title Please give a round of applause to coach Steve rotti and the Savannah Arts women's cross country team if any of them are here we'd love for you to stand as well Leon [Applause] nice El Howard Grant McKay Bennett Ava Morgan Irv Julia Grabowski Ava Thomas and Leila balance and I

013would like to have them come up yes please come up as they are coming up I would also like to share that this is not only their second um Champion coach congratulations it's not only their second championship in school history it's their second championship in three years they've been on the state Podium for at least four years in a row how many [Applause] [Music] coat you have a great holiday and I'd like to go back to ran TR the record setting senior quarterback for the Phoenix uh for the Phoenix if he is here I'd love for him to stand and come up and shake hands as well he here he is not here okay great also let's give it up for the Savannah Arts women's volleyball team this was the first appearance in the state

014finals for the lady Panthers volleyball team let's give them a round of applause girls work very hard and it's a season that they can look back on with a full sense of Pride please join me in congratulating coach Lauren Lord and the assistant coach Caroline Drummond and the women from the Savannah Arts volleyball team Ellie Alia please come up Lily coffee Torin Higgin Botham Baya jaqua Baya Manley Natalie leato Sam leato Maggie Allen Lula toison Annie Tores Espino and Emma Lawson Snider there any [Applause] students conratulations great jobr thank you congratulations congratulations we have a lot to celebrate in our district and I continue to have a full sense of pride in all the great things that are happening um and some of that is happening with our professional Senate so with this uh I

015will turn it over to our representation from that group and have them do their report out for this month thank you our meeting was held on November 20th superintendent Watts shared lesson plan information with the cabinet and elevated HVAC concerns to the maintenance department Dr Watts emphasized that every employee deserves to come to a work environment that is conducive that we continue to work as a district to examine and improve culture in retention and that the Senate should feel empowered to help problem solve As Leaders at the school level while elevating things the district level as needed uh we also wanted to give special thanks to miss Tama Tribble executive director of Engagement and Outreach for coming out to speak with the Senate she advocated that communication with parents and community members should be differentiated

016much in the same way that teaching is differentiated in the classroom in order to build relationships she also shared family community resources and was available for question and answers after the meeting we then moved on where we did um the initial planning session for the 2025 26 school calendar it was initiated by Mr Kurt hediger uh at the meeting we reviewed examples of calendars from several sources including cob County Savannah Classical Academy Humble County in Texas and oglethorp Charter School some highlights from this these calendars included a full week of pre planning on the Savannah classical calendar and present in several calendars a fall break breakout groups were conducted to facilitate discussion in design calendar templates these templates were collected by Mr hediger at the end of the meeting to gather feedback for the new

017calendar design a menta meter survey was also conducted to gather feedback regarding certain elements of the calendar design special thanks to Mr David Fano Chief data and information officer for putting this together one additional consideration is a strategic waver Mr hediger explained how sccps is a strategic waiver system school system we are currently not using the waiver for our regular 1080 day calendar which meant that we had flexibility to wave days off from hurricanes this year because of this many Sen members were in favor of continuing a 180 day calendar to hold that flexibility of the waiver availability for emergencies in closing our next professional Senate meeting is scheduled for Thursday January 23rd from 4:15 to 5:45 at Jenkins High School thank you right board board policy Mr Ediger thank you sir moving along in

018your agenda item 6.01 in board matters we do have some policies for the board to review you'll note that policy idch this is dual enrollment uh this is no changes to policy there are all regulations here uh edits that have been provided for the board's review so we uh subject to the board's final review on this uh and any feedback received we'll consider this this one completed the onus on moving this one forward is driven by State Board of Education rule changes that have happened this year to further provide Clarity on dual enrollment and also to account for uh accelerated High School diplomas you'll see that these changes have been redlined in your regulation administrative regulation Dr bringman yeah I know this is in the regulation but I'll I'll beat the drum as always do

019and I know it's in regulation I um this would be the second page under grade credit conversion um I still oppose the letter grade of an a becoming a 95 at the midpoint conversion I can't find anything from gdau or state law that says that we have to make um that a 95 I find it interesting still that um we use the midpoint for a b c but when we get to the grade of D we use the high point um so we aren't even consistent in our own scale um I know this is a regulation so I can't change it and I don't know how many other board members are upset with how we treat dual enrollment grading um I know this affects many students that are high performers and actually sways them from

020not taking dual enrollment because it will actually lessen their GPA and will keep them out of their top 10 in their class um so I would really like the district to look at changing this right regulation or I will just bring it forward as a policy change and actually create policy that overrides this regulation because I am tired of um of somebody getting an a in a college course and only getting a 95 um a 95 for most of our high schools doesn't get you in the top 10 um so we are making students that are getting college credit not in their top 10 and some of our state schools don't accept anybody outside of the top five or top three um so we are hamstringing our own high performers with this regulation uh Miss

021Kowski then Dr Hoskins Brown and then Miss Hall yes to Dr bringman um just reviewing the response from Mr hediger which I appreciate but I concur that um it it is a discouragement for some of our students to be able to take the dual enroll I think there's a lot of value in dual enrollment so I would en also encourage our team to see and I understand the the Ripple effects it but it seems like there has to be a way to not penalize High performing students in particular um or any of our students for that matter um and and looking at you know a 10-point spread is big and it makes an impact so I would encourage us to continue to look creatively at a different way to be able to make that conversion

022Dr Hoskins Brown thank you um I would support a policy recommendation changing this scoring um I've had issues with this scoring from transfer credit and I think that's where maybe this range came from I'm not certain if anybody can verify that but I've argued that same issue with students bringing in transfer credit and not getting you know the the you know the actual numerical amount that they have or or something that is um more beneficial to their transcript and in one reason that this should differ for dual credit is because the level of rigor at any college level class should exceed any transfer credit from another equivalent high school so I don't see that the regulations need to be aligned because you're not comparing Apples to Apples so I look forward to seeing that revision

023for policy Miss Hall um Mr Bri Dr Bri I don't think there's any reason for us to have to you know kick this can down the road so I suggest that we do bring it up for a policy revision all right you can regulate I do want to offer just some clarification that dual enrollment students do receive the bonus points so they do essentially receive those Five Points which would result in which results in them getting a 100 but but if they take our AP course and make a 100 they still get the five points and they get 105 so a lot of our students and granted some of the higher schools want them to take AP instead of dual enrollment and that's where they sit down with their academic adviser and they go okay

024you're you're aspiring for a Georgia Tech you should actually take all AP because they actually weit that higher than dual enrollment and most of your dual enrollment isn't even going to be accepted at Georgia Tech um some of the AP isn't as well but those students are trying to get the points to get the 105 not 100 they don't want the 95 plus the five and I I fully get what you're saying Dr Butler they want 100 and then the five to get the 105 um I mean the top three when my daughter graduated were all above 100 GPA when they graduated and I I will boast but but that's why she took not a single one of them took any dual enrollment because they all were playing the game of I need to make

025the highest grade I can in my dual enrollment class I mean in my AP class and get those Five Points um our kids are and we've had somebody from Savannah Arts I can't remember their name they are awesome uh when they come and speak to us and and they have had to make that hard decision of am I going to take dual enrollment or am I going to take AP because I'm trying to get all of the credit and unfortunately that individual transferred in uh dual enrollment credit that then was straight to a 95 and affected their GP PA so I'm just trying to you know uh in Dr and Mr Moss's let's aim for you know high performance let's not dissuade somebody or a family from choosing dual enrollment because their child is after

026their freshman you're told hey you're in the running because once that child knows they're in the running a lot of them get very very hungry um and they just immediately say I can't do dual enrollment because I need 100 and I need the Five Points uh Mr katchmar 100% agree this is an issue we need to resolve I would love to know what other school systems do because I see the flip side you go to college and you get a 90 right or you get a you barely get an A we're giving you a 95 so there has to be an equitable way to figure out it in in our schools now if you get a 91 in AP you're getting Five Points still if you get a 91 in honors you're getting three points

027but we can't do that in college so what you're basically saying is you took a dual enrollment class you get 10 points we're going to give you 100 plus we're going to give you the five bonus so there has to be a fair way like how do you what we're really saying is if you take dual enrollment we're giving you Five Points we're going to treat it like AP and we're going to give you up to nine points for taking a college class correct so we just we need to figure out what's fair because I got I got a in like fly fishing in college and you can't take that you can't take it here but you know there's there's different levels of college classes the point is the point is there's different levels of

028rigor even in college classes versus AP classes here I'd love to have a survey of what what other districts do what's a fair way to address this because you get you get number grades for AP and IB you don't in college that's the problem continue thank you all well noted and we have taken that into account of course the changes on that were driven by the State Board of Education rule so we have those uh modifications that have been reviewed by the board the other part just to add to it I appreciate the um reference Dr bringman made to the other policy which is Iha which is grading systems so to do this review is a comprehensive review and we will continue to work together to find the solution and take feedback from the board

029on policy language moving ahead on your agenda we have item 6.02 this is a 4-year review policy jce which is student complaints and grievances part of the onus to go through this particular policy segment and make some updates as you're all fully aware uh recently through the Georgia assembly in recent years we've come up with new uh laws and requirements on the parents Bill of Rights for example the board has stipulated policy in that area as required by the general assembly it has some crossover in the areas of jce when we looked at complaints and G grievances uh so there was a need to first of all look at it from that lens uh we did get specific requirements for language modifications from our board attorney from in in-house councel uh that we have worked

030into this policy and some of that is uh in the area of Title 9 that you'll see and then any other cross uh components on objectionable media for example are also included uh here in this particular area so these are being uh presented to the board now as a 4year review and of course uh the changes that we're making in here all fall to the regulation side so preser to feedback from the board today will cons uh consider this reviewed under board policy four-year review requirements comments okay moving on your next agenda item 6.03 this is policy igb and this is a four-year review student support team uh this particular policy component will be coming back to the board for a second read and adoption during the January board meeting primarily changes in here were

031to be more clear in describe the multi-tiered system of supports that ssts would use in a situation where their requirements for support of students uh in their evaluation um for the needs uh for them to ensure that they are academically successful uh are included that was not previously stated in policy the other part as we looked at it and again this was legal council recommended was that we're very explicitly state in this policy that none of this would have any impact on a request or referral for Ev valuation or eligibility determinations under Ida well we feel that is known uh because there is some crossover in this particular policy that could assume that we wanted to be very clear that that is not something that would be uh related to this particular policy this is

032a first reader policy I GB Mr Johnson um real quick I and it's not it's about this but it's not um just remember we know all the acronyms but the public that's here and the public that's watching on YouTube they don't always know what the acronyms are so like SST student support system idea individual disabilities Education Act we I I if we could just remember that people don't the general public they do not live in educational acronym jargon uh Mr kabowski um this is I'm not quite sure the last sentence of the um next to last paragraph parents Guardians are invited to participate in the meetings and given the opportunity to provide input concerning their child um glad that's in there certainly but the way that it's phrased seems like it's is there a way

033to say parents and Guardians are encouraged or a little bit more in a um way that we're just not saying oh by the way parents you can be there too I don't know if that's me I think the invite the invite is about a formal communication that's made so we wanted that invite to be that they are inv actually invited certainly they're encouraged as well but I think that's why the word choice for invited so that they would um it just seemed like kind of you know I think you know what I'm saying I don't know if there's a way to adjust that or not and maybe not but that's my comment okay we'll certainly take the um language interpretation of that and just the the feeling of the choice of words into consideration we

034come back for a second reader uh do want to stipulate stti or uh particularly call out um in the stipulation about the acronyms yes we do have those spelled out in the in the updated language with multi-tiered system of supports mtss and student support teams but we'll look at the uh language in its entirety and we'll also look at the gsba policy code section to make sure that any titles that have acronyms that they're spelled out as well so thank you Mr Johnson for that final review for the board this is policy ifg today this is a 4-year review on internet acceptable use uh you'll see some uh cleanup language in this particular uh area of the board policy this will be coming back for a second reader this is the first read uh for

035the board's review the onus really in this particular area for change was in our area where we talk about social media and guidelines for social media we have a expanded that to also include website uh the district has made great strides moving forward to get to a clear platform of how we provide District website and school-based websites for use as a communication tool as an item of Technology uh where we saw in this area as an opportunity to be clear that that is the platform of the school district and that any websites that are created outside of that platform are prohibited unless there is a review by our District's Communications office what we have found is that some schools you'll have creative staff or individuals who are are trying to uh to be engaging and

036that is great we want that but they're creating websites that are not part of the district platform and some of them are doing it under personal accounts and that creates a liability challenge uh for the school district and a possible cyber security challenge for us as well as we go forward so this gives us a little bit more leverage when we are talking to individuals to ensure that they're following the prescribed platform that is approved by the school district so this is a first read we'll bring it back for a second adoption in January M Kowski um so I appreciate the the rationale behind this um and I guess would have a question about where we are in the transition of our school-based websites to the new platform that we have for the district District

037because I think we see schools creating their own websites because their websites are not meeting their needs so as we I'd like to get an update on the transition and as we make that transition we are working with individual School sites to make sure that that new platform does in fact meet their needs so that they can communicate in the way in which they need to yeah and the idea on this was not to restrict a school's ability to engage creatively with its family base but was to try and get to a point where um we've we've had challenges with this before for for example a Google website is created and it looks great but an employee has done that under their own personal email and then they leave the district and we have to

038find a way to be able to pull that site down and have some controls for it so yes we will provide an update for the board on our roll out of final site is the platform for the school district as you all know the new District website uh has been online for almost a year now we've gotten really great feedback and schools are being rolled P out individually but there's a training component tied to that and part of it also comes into is ADA compliance so when schools are representing the school district with their own individual websites some of them may not be ADA Compliant and that creates another challenge for us as well so we'll provide you an update on that particular component but you'll note that in the policy that's why we said

039that it is prohibited but if someone seeks to create a site they would need to work with District Communications for approvals so there are we realize there may be a situation where something does make sense but we want to make sure we have certain controls to limit liabilities cyber security challenges and ADA compliance issues as well Dr Dr Howard Hall yes for regulation when I look at training and awareness we might want to include school board members because we do also have training required training for the school board where it says training and awareness it has student staff and parents so do you think we should include school board members as well um I we'll we'll cover that a little more with the legal team I think but my initial respon reaction to that is

040the board does have its own policy section in in policy section B where your training requirements are very much uh stipulated so it would be to the board and I think that would be the area where you might want to add language to tie to your engagement through uh websites Etc that you're using to either represent the district but of course as your own elected bodies your own individuals that are operating as a school board member uh you have your own sites which are outside of the purview of the school district anyway and that's okay the board does have policy uh in its uh code section B that does talk about you how you manage yourselves on social media as well so may be an area there that that might fit as it regards to

041training uh but remember your training is also derived primarily from the Georgia School Board Association so anything in addition to that would be a local decision okay uh Dr Hoskins Brown yeah I kind of like uh Dr Howard Hall's suggestion because the board training that you're talking about is training that we do on how to execute our duties as a board but there's competencies that we're supposed to have as individuals and I think that would speak to what this policy is talking about everyone else has individual accountability we have individual and unit accountability we we'll we'll uh certainly look at that and I I think part of it is just where that line of delineation is on the policy that is is governing employees and students versus our elected officials but we are employees okay

042anyone else continue okay your next agenda item is item 6.05 and this is the board's 2025 calendar of board meetings this is an action item for the board of public education to adopt its meetings you'll notice in the calendar rundown the meetings hold two evening meetings one in March and one in September there is also the addition and inclusion here here of the uh action items for uh the board to include their calendar rundown wherein the budgetary meetings would also be included the budgetary meetings and the budget calendar has been previously reviewed through the finance committee so these dates have also been included in your calendar rundown uh for the adoption so it is again for the board's review and subject to official adoption here at this meeting uh Dr Hoskins Brown thank you I

043appreciate these dates um and I'm only challenged by one of them uh January 15th is uh later than we have met in the past I understand we met the third week last year but I actually have a conflict and I understand that there's some other activities being proposed for the 15th as well so is there is there a pressing reason that the meeting can't be on the 8th anyone have a problem janary 8 instead of the 15th uh Miss Hall I had um asked Mr heter about that since that'll be our swearing in and I think you said that uh it was so close to the return of children back to school am I right yes ma'am and that has been the Cadence of the the board's uh meeting schedule typically what the board would

044do at this meeting is announce the January meeting and then in January adopt the full schedule of meetings well we've last year we got ahead of that it seemed to work well so we're bringing that to the board again the Full Slate of meetings but we we're going on a two- week break with a holiday break and when we come back on January 6 that's only two days to prepare uh for the board meeting on the 8th so that is why the 15th was proposed well if Dr Hoskins Brown cannot be here though and she's one of the persons being sworn in then I would defer to um a calendar that would accommodate her thank you very much that was my question that was what I was trying to ask if the swearing in is

045on that date then that's a challenge um for me if the meeting is not the swearing in date I could participate virtually but I'm understanding that those things have been coupled and that's why I'm asking yes so thank you for that clarification it is the has been historically on the fouryear cycles for the the board when the um election Cycles are complete when we do the oath of office uh for this particular time frame that has always been held right before the informal session that's just a practice it's not a requirement so if it meets better for the board's schedules to do the oath of office ceremony on January 8th um we can certainly make that happen uh Dr bringman I mean I'm with Dr Hoskins Brown on this and my my reps from one

046two three and five right one two three and five that's the opposite no one two three and yeah seven one two three and seven um get the short end of the deal because we roll out the red carpet and pop in circumstance when we reelect a president I know I know I know but it could be something it doesn't need we we had it at Jenkins last time I thought it went well uh we have all these beautiful facilities um it seems odd to swear in some people at a board meeting right before and now go and then other people we have a thing at night and we invite other individuals and it just seems like there's a weird dichotomy there I'm probably butchering words but I'm not trying to do that on your stad

047but it it we could decouple it and actually change what we've done for years because it has always felt weird to me that the other we always have to get up in front of the everybody and the paper and they get to quote us and the news gets to videotape us we all have to bring remarks and we're all trying to you don't have to go against Tanya who's wrote a poem every time it's the election of the board president that makes your he's just one vote so why aren't y'all given the same so I would love to see it decoupled from just a standard board meeting and actually have some ceremony that I could get some finger foods at U Woodville or Savannah High could bring some food we could have a band perform

048I'm open I I would I hadn't thought about the celebration my conflict is that I submitted a paper for a conference and I have to go to the conference and submit the paper and it is that week and that was done and committed far before this schedule was put together um I hadn't even thought about the inequity but you're right we it it is definitely prominent I I just have a challenge with the 15 that's so do we want to move that do we want to move that meeting to January 8th um so so the board calendar uh Mr board president is for the official meeting of the board recommendation on the 15th if it is the will of the board to have an oath of office ceremony on January the 8th we will figure

049that out so you're not voting on The Oath of Office ceremony you're only voting on your calendar of meetings calar meeting office another time we have it at Jenkins that's in your District we get some pett is there some reason that we can't have the meeting on the 8th I think Mr hediger is not saying it's really difficult to prepare and they're coming back for two days later I that's not fair to get the agenda done will be impossible like I I'm empathetic let's have an oath of office ceremony on the 8th have the meeting on the 15th or the following week like what's so pressing that we have to do it in on the 15th right heck let's skip January and just do February I got billable hour to catch up on I'm trying

050to accommodate appreciate so um the the motion on the floor that the the item being submitted for Action is the calendar as printed that has the meeting on January 15 the oath of office is not on this calendar so I would submit that this it doesn't sound like we need to modify this for the purpose of meeting if I could be connected virtually and you know David and Sean can hash it out in the parking lot about how we're going to have a o office or how you want it done I'll vote Yes on whatever he decides how's that yeah M Hall Dr Watts is there uh would giving you to the 22nd of January for our January meeting would that give you um some time to take care of business items uh we are

051prepared to deliver a board meeting on the 15th I mean we've known about it so we've already put some in place but we haven't even done a genda review that's tomorrow um but I think we're poised I got 15 we are 100% poised for the 15th that does give us time to finalize and get the packets out the week of January 6th so the board has items in advance if we were to meet on the 8th then we need to get agenda items out Friday or next week so so what about board the 22nd of January for our board meeting no no no guys I think we just so I would say we just leave it at the 15th Dr Hoskins Brown can join us virtually because we also need to do other board business

052is like as far as officers and and committees and those types of things and I don't think we want to keep pushing those off until later in January but but let's hear the voice of someone who's being sworn in I thought it was interesting that my swearing in was being put together and nobody asked what any of the people being sworn in preferred we obviously have somebody who wants to be sworn in in a particular way we have somebody else who wants to be sworn in a particular way so why don't we send that to that committee and just focus on our board business and decide that at another time it's it's no more proper to change the swearing in because one person says they want it one way than it is to ignore someone

053saying they want it the other way so let's just let those folks work on it and select our calendar so so can we select the calendar today and figure out the rest and figure out the rest kind thank you okay so do do I have a motion can I just ask one quick question Sor this is a different date so the SE this month I know our meeting is late in December because of gsba is that also the reason that it's late in the calendar um for next year because normally we would meet we would last week which would give a week between Thanksgiving and Christmas but it was bumped because of gsba so do is that the reason that it's like this for this year that wasn't a so next year's calendar Thanksgiving week

054falls in the last week of November which is exactly what happened to us this year so again in that Cadence of having a week out where there's a Break um then we what we've tried to do in the calendars is have a week between the board meetings again so staff can prepare and get agenda items to you gsba then is the second week of December historically so this one accounts for that that's why you do see in this calendar the same exact thing but the real the onus of it is because of Thanksgiving being the last week in nove November okay thank I want to clarify I don't to my knowledge we don't have a swearing in committee but I want to just make sure Dr Hoskins Brown understood you want um us to poll

055board members to figure out out how they best want that event to meet their needs hold the people who are being in let them be you set a committee that's I'm making them kind of an unofficial Committee of individuals own saring yes uh but no we're not an official don't say committee attorney holiday says don't say call the question cohort okay we is there a motion yes there's been a motion was there a second thank you it's been moved in second we've had lots of discussion uh Sean has called called a motion all in favor of the calendar well you call it that ain't right okay okay so let's go back so let's let's get it right okay so we have a motion someone to second the motion any more discussion call the question the

056vote is it not I called the question to cut off debit he's now getting the vote so yeah let's just vote be long me yeah the vote is to call the question call the question is not automatic it that's what that's what I was saying okay so let let's vote to call the question okay all okay now all in favor of the calendar thank you Mr board President we have one more item under your board matters this is item 6.06 and then presenting a memorandum of understanding with the chadam County Commission and the board of public education uh this is in support of all of our goals across the school district in the way that it is derived through Partnerships it supports student achievement through student well-being it also supports staff in the work that

057they do and the see this through this particular uh memorandum of understanding and supportive of Staff wherein the supplements are being provided as a funding resource from another partner agency uh which is also supportive of priority goal Four County has identified Services provided by Savannah chattam County Public Schools to be integral to the implementation and maintenance of the chattam county blueprint and that aligns with goals of the school system Savannah chadam County Public Schools the mediation Center of coastal Empire and shadam Savannah Counter Narcotics Team have joined to provide the positive peer influencer program which is designed to help local teens and youth in our high schools and middle schools make healthy choices and to educate them to the dangers of opioids including fentanyl now in its second year the PPI program serves students in

058seven local high schools and nine middle schools and just this school year is training 140 high school students to Mentor middle school students and encourage healthy decisions the PPI influencers are trained to allow students to be influenced in constructive ways in the arrangement of this partnership with support from the mediation Center and chadam County Narcotics chadam County Narcotics as an agency of the County uh has identified Monies to support the PPI coordinators within our schools the County agrees to reimburse the district up to 40,000 a year to pay for 40 employees who act as coordinators for the positive peer influencers program which essentially provides a $1,000 supplement for staff who are assigned to these duties the initial term of the agreement will cover the program from August 1st 2024 the beginning of our school year

059through July 31st 2025 with renewal options for no more than four successive one-year terms to conclude no later than Jun une 30th 2028 as specified in the agreement Savannah chadam Public Schools will gross up meaning we will add additional Monies to this payment of $350 to each supplement to offset employee payroll deductions subject to any modifications that may occur over the specified term the board authorizes a superintendent to execute renewals annually as detailed and subject to the conditions of this enclosed agreement the memorandum of understanding has been reviewed by the superintendent assistant board attorney as well has provided legal guidance and is now presented for the board's review and action thus be it resolved upon recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the memorandum of understanding with the county to support staff coordination of

060the positive peer influencers program and doesn't authorize the superintendent to execute the agreement fully and future renewals within the term of the established agreement okay so we moved and seconded uh any discussion Dr bringman yeah I would just love again and I probably always thank the district uh Mr Ray and his staff I'm guessing that anytime we can when we give a stien or have a chance to give a stien to a staff member uh we make sure to gross up um from our side to make sure that after taxes that individual actually sees as close to the dollar amount that they sign sign up for cuz um there's a lot of people that had sign up for this and then wait a second it's only $650 I thought it was a, so thank you

061for doing that on and I'm sure Mr Jackson as well finding the money in your couch um for doing that because we've done that every time the governor given stiens we've made sure to try our best to find the funds to make sure that it's the actual dollar amount um because that means something I think as as a staff member when you see that you're like hey they said they give me $1,000 and I see that line item on my payroll or when the governor says $2,500 we make sure that they actually are impacted $2,500 not however much minus a bunch of taxes that go back to the state um so thank you for just doing that without us having to go hey wait a second let's make sure they actually get a full thousand

062okay uh Miss Kowski um I just want to thank the county the uh counter ntic team and the mediation Center for this partnership this is like I know we just heard a lot of words but when we think about what this means for our students it's so important this is truly an upstream approach to try and address something that is so critically important that we get ahead of in every way we can um so this is all about positive support this is about mentorship this is about students being positive role models for other students and I'm I'm so grateful that we have these organizations that are supporting these efforts HS in our schools so that we can try and not have to go after the fact getting students out of trouble but keep them from

063getting into trouble in the first place so thank you to each of those partners for making this happen yeah Dr Howard Hall I'm not sure who remembers this but I remember my freshman year at Tomkins High School probably 1975 we were enrolled in a class called Trends and we were trained as high school students that actually go over to Scott Junior High School to speak with students and Mentor them regarding nicotine during that time cigarette smoking so it's it's it's good to see it coming back at another level and it was a very good program back then and it's just great to see that we're continuing on with this but it's nothing new Under the Sun we did this 40 years ago when I was a a 14 year oldone else can I mention something

064um Ron R can I mention something um because I know how our employees will hear and I want to make sure it's clear when we say we're grossing up we're trying to get to the Thousand depend on people's tax situation and may be a little bit less somebody may be more than a thousand somebody may be a little less than a thousand I want to make sure that's clear clearly articulated thank you thank you all right anyone else I did want to add as well director Sarat from chadam County Narcotics had planned to be here but he had a family matter he had to attend to but he did want me to express on his behalf um how he is continuing to be um encouraged by the great work that the school district is doing

065and the willingness for us to work with other Community Partners and address subjects such as this you'll note that the chattam narcotics has been instrumental in creating not only just the work that they do to keep our community safe but taking it a next step and really being Educators as well to inform the community of the dangers of opioids and the dangers of fentanyl that are moving about our communities and he realized very quickly that it's one thing for him as a a a grown man to stand in front of Youth today and talk about this but if we can Empower our youth to be our own best asset in helping other children make positive healthy decisions at a critical age in those Middle grades then we are far exceeding anything that he could do

066as a community partner to stand in front of them and this came about because of him and his dedication to our work in this partnership to find those monies and take it to the county and the county very quickly said this aligns exactly with health and wellness of the county overall and we overwhelmingly support you so on his behalf he did want me to express how appreciative he is of the board of public education and the public school system thank you all right anyone else there being no more discussion all in favor thank you very much board President we do have one item to add to the agenda um item 7.42 workers compensation settlement sbwc number 2023-24 547 and 2023-24 n97 so I make a motion to update the agenda and add this item to

067the consent agenda okay uh and before we get to the consent agenda oh we have to add that first oh I'm sorry okay oh it's that's sorry uh Dr H dra a second second anyone oh Mr Smith okay um all in favor okay all right before we do the consent agenda we did have someone that wanted to speak on the consent agenda uh Tony Riley oh there he is Mr riy you have three minutes minute and a half of it today Mr President good afternoon my name is Tony Riley citizen of Savannah of the second district and I just came to briefly uh address the item I think is 7.8 MC 2206 East BL construction Management Consultant uh I think the last time I came to this group I question whether or not this project

068or this contract was bided and I cannot find out where it was bided and so uh I'm very concerned whether or not this money is being really spent uh is it profitable to the school board and taxpayers to pay for this project when it's in my opinion and my research is not getting the results as a matter of fact um seems to me that this project if this contract is renewed today it's going to net3 million $60,000 that's quite a lot more than a lot of the local minority contractors have made under the East SPS program so considering the fact that um the board has already started working on SPL EAS 5 I think we need to try to correct uh some of the um shortcomings as far as local uh contractors and vendors um

069profiting from East Blas and that is all I have today thank you very much thank you very much all right any other discussion all right I'm sorry all right um all in favor of the consent agenda a motion a motion to accept the consent agenda I thought we already did that uh Miss Keli second Mr Johnson any okay any other discussion thank you now yes I know all in favor all right thank you very much what I'm sorry uh any opposed abstaining Mr Cas thank you for a all right thank you good afternoon we have a few agenda items uh before us I'm going to try not to read them and try to summarize them um they have been shared with board members and published on the website on board docs the first is an

070extension for the Leia language Essentials for teachers of reading and spelling third editions letters for administrators so Source purchase the office of instructional excellence and office of strategy Innovation and performance are requesting approval to purchase additional performing professional learning materials for language Essentials for teachers and reading of reading and spelling Third Edition letters SE 3E and letters for administrators from Leia as a so Source staff is recommending the award of Leia as a sold source for science of reading training for K5 teachers administrators and District leaders for the 2025 2425 school year and the 25 26 school year for for a total of $518,000 letters for administrators materials for a total cost of 58,60 I'll move by Mr Johnson seconded by okay were yes uh by Mr catmore discussion uh Dr Hoskins Brown yes thank

071you um I'm sorry I meant to ask that this be moved because it's connected to the item behind yes it is um and we apologize it should have been bondle and we could have done it as one agenda it oh okay um I just going to try to run through them both my concern is the use of fund balance so I was trying to figure out in the monthly financials we have 11 million in purchase services and professional development the adopted budget which is more than what we have in the adopted budget which is 8.4 million Why Can't This come out of general fund Professional Services where where we have 11 million why does this need to come out of fund balance so I'm looking at I don't want to answer that question if we

072have money in Professional Services in the general fund it is probably budgeted for something else so let me look into that and I will get back to you okay and and that's why I that large a number we have it there for something else okay that's why I asked the question because when we look at the financials further on on page one the general fund item two has purchase Professional Services and it has an original budgeted amount of 10,759 and then we added another 1.2 93 million to it which takes it to 11 but then if you look at our budget book only 8 million is in that line and I'm getting really protective of general fund now cuz I know what we're about to do with general fund so I'm just wondering do we

073need P this from general fund now um or should we wait until later when we need something else from general fund yeah so can let me check on the what was budgeted for the I'm sorry I'm saying fund balance yeah I'm saying F I'm meaning fund balance okay all other than that I don't have a problem with the action I'm only concerned about the line item yeah don't not it any other questions all right sorry all in favor okay thank you okay the next item 8.02 is the actual I'm sorry no I didn't vote on it because I asked a question he said he G get back call the vote so I'm not going to vote on it without the information okay sotion okay with his back to do that sorry I'm not the conversation

074is that an understanding was that we would vote on it with him coming back that is a budget amendment if we do that which would be fine but that's not what he said so I didn't vote for it okay and I'm you know and and I'm not jumping up and down about it I'm just clarifying okay okay the next item is 8.02 yes Mr catmar hang on so I I think you have to call no and extensions but I think the takeaway is you're going to go look at it if there's unallocated money we'll do another budget amendment to take it out of that line and put it back in fund balance I think that's the unofficial takeaway from this discussion yeah so the votes just need to show that were you an no I

075was a yes but he didn't call no or exstension okay okay okay all right yes and the second item 8.02 is actual the actual budget amendment that we should have included in the first item um thus be it resolved upon the rec recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the one-time use of fund balance and so Source purchase of an additional let letters Edition and letters for administrator straters materials for a total cost of 58,183 $60 okay and as noted I will get add additional information on what's currently budgeted in the ger fund um as part of that 10 million plus number okay moved by Mr Johnson seconded by Dr ringman discussion is this the same thing yes it's the same thing yes okay but yes go ahead thank you but so did you

076say that this is in that original 10 million that's in um okay I would do research and find out what's part of the $10 million budget this is not part of that okay I'm sure of that but I have to find out what else is in the general fund that's part of that $10 million that makes up the current budget that's spread it among probably a few departments and school sites okay and if you find that there was money available in that line would you be making a recommendation to take this from that line or are you going to keep it taken out of fund balance we can bring back a recommendation to take it from that line if it's available okay thank you Dr bringman can I ask that um when we are presented

077with uh the different resources I can't remember what we were going to call them in finance all of your little pods that we were moving forward like this is part of this and this like that we actually know the recurring cost of letters training what are they what were we calling them all the little return on investment Pockets that we have like this the inventory yes the inventory items yes just have it as a recurr like cuz I know we're I know we're playing catchup on getting all this implemented but what is the recurring cost for letters each year right yes I just really quickly wanted to say thank you on behalf of the district teachers for the additional professional training on letters yes ma'am you're welcome nice okay um any other discussion all in

078favor I understand okay and abstaining one okay the next item 8.03 ET Georgia Power Grant on March 22nd 20 22 the Georgia Power Foundation awarded um SEC PSS a three-year Grant to support equity and education initiatives for the third year of the grant $727,500 has been awarded the funding will be utilized to establish a K12 stem steam triack at good elementary mercil middle and Groves High School and enhanced Early Childhood learning at Henderson e forming and go to elementary schools support the learning empowering advancing parents Elite program and address barriers hindering post-secondary education and Career Success to F facilitate these initiatives the chief strategic and performance officer request an increase of $727,500 in the budgeted revenues and expenditures for fund 584 thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the

079fy2 budgeted expenditures revenues and expenditures by $727,500 and is shown as shown in the above table to align the local budget with the ET Georgia Power Grant allocation as approved by Georgia Power move by Mr Johnson seconded by Dr oskins Brown um any discussion good all right all in favor I think I got it right that time yes the next item 8.04 budget amendment Leia letters training supplements these training supplements coincide with the professional development that's given by letters from the first two agenda items to support staff initiative staff recommends the using of fund balance to cover the cost of letters training supplements for science of reading training for K5 Educators administrators and District leaders during the fy2 2425 and fy2 26 school years at a total cost of 1,685 um use to fund balance

080for FY 25 in amount of $567,000 thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the use of general fund fund balance for letters teacher supplements for a total cost of 567,000 for FY 25 and a sign fund balance of 6 61,500 for FY 26 moved in second uh discussion yes Dr Hoskins Brown you I I do have the same but looking at this so what we're doing is we're promising fund balance of $61 next year as well ass signing yes ma'am but you only have you're having us take so that means that the total coming from fund balance is the 516 this 565 and the 601 516 and 567 this year and then committing 601 next year that's correct but if you look at these transactionally on the pages

081it just looks like a million it's actually more than a million and a half that's that's not real clear um if anything it would have you'd have another table on here it would say fund 100 general fund FY 25 then you'd have the 567 then you'd have another table that says fund 100 general fund fiscal year 26 with the 601 in it's kind of buried in here okay I'll see what you're saying yes yes the we normally put the table in for the current year um and that's been to practice with other uh previous board agenda items we did the same thing I believe for the textbooks we had the current year amount in the table but we listed the out years and the wording to the bottom but we can make that going forward

082we can do that I'm just very very nervous because of the amount of dependency that we're going to have on the general fund for the construction project sorry Lord fun balance for fund balance I'm very nervous we have such a great dependency on fund balance for the projects that we're about to approve for eastl that we're we're yes dipping into it now and I don't have a strong reason why we're in it like we it doesn't feel like we have fully exploited yes ma'am but say I feel comfortable comfortable in using fund balance now um looking at Pro C to finish that year we feel very comfortable with where we are with fund balance and fund balance in the future okay Miss Kowski not to beat this but just for clarification we're only being asked

083right now to approve the fund balance this transfer for year one so year two you're providing what that dollar amount will be but we're not being asked to so that could be shown as a line item in the budget that has the funding source other than fund balance for the year two this is just providing the information that Dr bringman was asking for what's the continuing cost of the that is true corre it is quite possible that we could find another funding source for year two or use it or use savings from FY 26 operations to pay the other portion and now have to use fund balance assigning it just gives us that option the same thing that we're going to do with East PL it gives us an option to be to use yes

084ma'am no this is vot this the way this is written it says we're voting on both of them now all right anyone else yes I'm sorry I'm back it based on this this is saying this is not adding the 518 and the 567 from the two previous actions this last Senate says to support this initiative staff recommends using fund balance to cover the cost of letters training supplements which I strongly support dear teachers so please please know that for science of reading training for K 12 teachers administrators and District leaders during the FY 2425 and FY 2526 school years at a total cost of 11685 this is voting to commit both of them next year's and this year's right now this that's what yeah that's what this says so it's okay so it's yeah it's

085not 567 it's 567 out of this year but1 million I think our was to say that to um assign it for next year we're assigning it for next year the total cost of supplements for the two years is going to be 1,685 we want to use $567,000 out of fund balance for fy2 and to assign year but not to take action until we expl other funding sources right we don't we will come back to the board with another action to take fund balance if we need to next year but I agree the way it reads it reads as if we're taking action on both so we just need to clarify the language but our intent is not what is reflected in the language okay well does say assigned yes that's assigned correct but one one

086year is assigned and one year we're going to actually execute on we're actually we're going to leverage the funding for this year to to pay the stti but next year we're just assigning it as a funding option should another option not become understand I think the way it reads and the intent is different I that's what I'm saying okay thank you that clear as mud everyone okay all right uh all in favor okay thank you mm good afternoon the financials that you had in your packet for this month covers us through October 31st of this school year um in our general fund in fund 100 um year to date our local property taxes are currently at 80 excuse me 28 28% of our budget Which is higher than what we received the same time last

087year this time last year we were at 25% our total general fund actual revenues um year-to date we're at 29.75% of our budget compared to 27.75 per last year 2% ahead of last year um our general fund expenses our actual expenses for teachers are at 21% of our budget and I our other support salaries are at 24.8 which is both of them are where we would expected to be and that's between 20 and 33% at this time of the year our total general fund actual expenditures are at 22.8 2% of our budget um which is reasonable for this time of the year um other cash and investment our cash balances are stable especially for this time of the year before receiving our second installment of our property tax revenues historically prior years balances were critically

088low this is the sixth fiscal year of which we have not had to ask chadam County tax assessor office to pay us our money early or had to um to ask to borrow funds so our cash and advest Ms we are in um pretty good shape at this point um additionally our general fund balance that you see in your packet has not been adjusted the numbers that you see in there are through last June 30th we are completing our fiscal year FY 24 budget this week so next month when you see the numbers they should be updated have any questions on on our finances Dr ban I just want to say thank you because I remember uh six years ago one of the first meetings that Dr Howard Hall and I had I think it

089was probably in December they're like hey so you're going to get um sworn in and then we're going to have to have you vote on a tax anticipation notice and I was like well let me do some Googling um so it is it is very nice that it hasn't happened since um that we have become that better at being fiscally responsible and understanding and anticipating things so thank you for cuz that was that was not a fun first meeting um I don't know how you felt Dr Howard Hall but I was like so we have to take out money and pay interest so we can pay every okay so um thank you let's keep that good work going right continue good afternoon afternoon the first thing we're going to take a look at is the

090E3 Capital plan you've uh you've seen this a number of times now uh and we've gone through this in detail previously so I won't necessarily however just to remind everyone that everything in green is cost and everything in blue is proceeds so we have on the bottom line there uh at the uh right hand side you see the zero that says that all of our anticipated and actual costs equal all of our anticipated and actual proceeds for E3 so this report tells you that E3 is on budget uh similarly with E4 of course we're into the year 2024 halfway through you see the pro ctions that we have in cost for the remaining projects in E4 and also our proceeds uh again we're balancing it off so E4 is on budget but as you know

091uh eastl is a very Dynamic program uh projects change in scope from what they were initially uh projects that we have some projects that were previous previously additions became new schools other projects along the way uh schools are closing so we take those dollars and we move them over so that we can improve and do enhancements to other projects as we go through this you'll see there's a number of projects that we are able to do more and need to do more in them so we have to make sure that we have the funding for it but again this report is important for you to see that you are on budget in East blast 4 uh just a uh a chart again to show kind of the overall dollar volume that we have in Construction

092and design and planning uh and then I'll just kind of walk through the projects Windsor Forest High um project is uh under construction on schedule it will be ready to move in for the start of August school and then of course we'll have to take the old building down build in the new parking lot and so by the end of the of 2 that project is expected to be 100% complete Bloomingdale in a similar situation as far as under construction again on schedule for August AUST start of school in 25 you know the students and staff are over at New Hampstead K8 so we're going to start making the plans for how we're going to transition and bring them back to the new school uh as we get into the new year over at De

093we're busy with the athletic fields and the in the Fieldhouse um the field the fields themselves are um finishing up S is getting put in there uh and they'll be ready for baseball in um in the uh start of January and uh the other Athletic Facility is also going to be ready uh come July of 25 JG Smith uh just starting that project uh at the Montgomery swing site we are just started the demolition work there JG Smith is gone in design right now and of course you know we're going to be replacing the cafeteria and so that project is uh is on schedule also Henderson for me under renovation um this project is again moving along well and is uh ready will'll be ready for students to come back uh one of the first

094schools that we actually took everybody out of the school and so now we're able to completely renovate it uh remove all of the flooring ceilings everything and now they're busy putting it back together again so that the student students can come back and start again in uh in August of 25 Georgetown we are in the process of selecting the CMR uh the rfps have been received they in evaluation now and uh we expect to have that ready for board approval in February uh meanwhile there's been design work started on both Largo tobet which is going to be the swing school for Georgetown we have to do some little Med uh Renovations uh make sure that we take care of an issue there some drainage issues that we've had so that work is going to get

095ready to get that building ready for Georgetown and then uh we will be anticipating relocating Georgetown to Largo toet and get started with their renov inovation work one thing that we're going to do on this project that initially wasn't going to be done but again uh we do realize and understand that this does have an elementary siiz gymnasium it is a K8 so we need to put a larger gymnasium in and what that's going to require is removing that existing gymnasium and building out uh a much larger structure so that again is additional scope in this project and so but again it's an improvement that we certainly need to make so this project is uh is often designed and when we get our CMR on board uh we can start doing more planning as far

096as the construction is concerned uh uh we have a question from Miss Hall please yes could you go back to the Georgetown screen once a CMR is determined is that when a partnership can be developed with a local mwbe organization yes yes when uh when one is selected we will be able to determine who they have partnered with their W who they're using with their wnb so Mr hinger let me ask is there a budget amount that determines whether or not a a CMR has a partnership or is it basically if there is a CMR it's not the cost of the project it's whether a CMR is present or not yeah correct it's it's not the cost of the project um and as you know we do some projects hard bit general contractor yes we

097do some CMR it really depends upon what the project is what the scope of the project is and as to whether or not we use a CMR or if we use a uh GC when we do use a CMR it's an RFP process uhhuh and one of the uh criteria the scoring criteria is wbe and how are they going to handle that aspect what program are they going to present that allows them to maximize their points in that particular area that RFP and then of course we look at Partnerships we look at mentoring ships that's the type of program that they put together so they usually present that to us in their RFB and we then know of course what those Partnerships are going to be okay so it is intentional that that happens as

098part of that RFP corre it's not you know up to someone remembering to do it it's actually part of the process that automatically takes place yes okay thank you Dr bringman yeah and uh this will probably be more on an academic side of the house do we have plans already to start meeting with families out at Georgetown about this uh move is that um there is no firm date yet set up but when we get into the new year we definitely will be uh making those plans just as as up definitely yeah cuz this is coming quick if we are on these I understand that these aren't hard fast yet but as soon as they've set let's make sure that we're doing early and often thank you yes continue okay and uh there's a number

099of projects in here that uh are still going through some renovation as far as schedules are concerned Hubert Middle School this is going to be a renovation project one thing that we're carefully looking at right now is that back area the play area there's a large uh tennis court that hasn't been used in many years the configuration of the field in order to maximize what we need to do in that project Islands uh we're working ourselves through design uh there will be an addition of a team room uh for visitors a visitors uh Locker or or bathroom area team room for the home side and uh and definitely expanding on the bleachers not only the bleachers at the home side and making a larger Press Box uh but also on the visitors side in order

100to bring this uh particular complex up to 3,000 seats and this again just shows some of the uh projects that we've completed in 2024 everything from 100 million uh in a uh de complex uh to million dollars and it's just all projects that we continue working on H faac uh we continue to work through right now colol and Garrison islands is uh coming up soon Savannah High we're working through different phases of HVAC over there and the roofing projects G uh will be bidding early next year Johnson High School the replacement of that roof is also uh going to be taking place in 25 number of high school Fields playgrounds of course the one thing that we're very happy to say is that the track at new hampson high school is 100% complete and uh

101so it it was a very long project uh but as you know we had a lot of soils correction that we had to do and that certainly uh expanded that project out quick question just out of curiosity um I heard you say that we're looking at 3,000 seats in the uh Islands complex M um just out of curiosity do we normally have have we ever seen on a regular basis 3,000 participants in our sporting events that I would have to refer to someone who if you are going to host playoff games that's the requirement by the State that's the reason for doing that thank you anyone else okay no questions okay thank you good want to make sure give the correct agenda item you're on 9.03 metal DET metal detectors yep that's what I'm about

102to read That's wanted to make sure this is in response to B Atty 3.12 metal detectors uh annual contract second renewal the division of campus police requests approval to purchase 75 open gate metal detectors under bid 23-12 from Point Security Incorporated with a cost of the equipment and installation totaling a process imately 1,335 64 the funding source would be the general fund thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the purchase of 75 open gate metal detectors from Point Security Incorporated in the amount of 1,335 64 moved by Mr Johnson second and by dror um ringman okay uh discussion right all in favor item 9.04 school security equipment fund 100 on September the 4th 2024 the board approved a budget amendment for a $2,780 316 safety Grant from the

103Georgia Department of Education the grant enabled the district to create 27 new school safety officer positions and reallocate budgeted funds for existing SSO positions to the grant thereby freeing up $1.5 million in the current budget the campus police department has proposed utilizing these available funds to purchase additional weapons detectors for all schools and to support security at special events to facilitate facilitate this initiative the Chief Financial Officer requests approval of a budget transfer in the amount of $1.5 million as summarized Below in the chart thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the fy2 budget budgeted transfer of 1.5 million as shown in the above table to align the local budget move by Mr Johnson seconded by Dr bringman discussion Dr bringman it it pains me that it costs

104so much but I can't put a price tag on our student safety I'm glad that our district does everything that it currently does and continues to do to keep our faculty staff and students safe and visitors safe um and this is just our new Norm um I'm sure if I asked Chief some questions he'd talk for 30 minutes so I won't um but he always he's got he's got a wish list he's got a wish list a mile long but um I am thankful that we have such a dedicated staff um and that we are continually looking again it's nice to have a grant to pay for some things to free up money for other stuff but um always still need more bodies to fill positions um so thank you again yes Mr Johnson um

105to that effect also uh when we first got notified when we first started purchasing weap weapons detectors um I did ask uh Chief about it and he did let explain the difference so I'm glad that we're getting we weapons detectors and not just metal detectors because they are two different things um so I would like to and I also am very thankful that we got this grant so we can free up money so we can protect not only our students and staff but also o visitors to special events that we have like the football games where we're building with these uh complexes and the basketball games and the baseball games and the cross cross country just every anything and everything that we do as a district this is just one more level of protection that

106we're doing not just for our students and staff but for the community as a whole oh I'm sorry yeah I know energy okay we need we need some chocolate Okay um all in favor the next item is 9.05 uh the awarding of bid 24-25-4 small construction services for projects under $100,000 the purchasing department receive a total of six bids um and actually staff wants to award the contract to all six vendors um in order with a primary up to the last bidder in ranking the primary goes to sdg Construction Services United ground maintenance services uh Buu Mandu Builder Club LLC Baker Roofing LLC CNB Construction LLC and Southern Atlantic mechanical the funding source would be used from fund 308 thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the award

107of bid 25-14 small construction services for projects under $100,000 annual contract to S DG construction United grounds maintenance services incorporated Buu Mandu service Builders Club LLC Baker rofin LLC CNB Construction LLC at an estimated cost of $1 million so move okay moved by Mr Smith seconded by Mr Johnson uh Miss Miss Hall um again I'm asking purchasing to let us know where these businesses are Loc located oh yes if staff would do that that helps us in our promotion of our use of local businesses so it would be very helpful to know where United ground it's not included in loc incling doc where is it here is it all there next page over next page over okay R okay um again I'm going to say that we need staff to support us in what we're

108trying to maximize yes ma'am indeed uh Mr Smith I would like to say um I am very very happy to see uh that we have some minority businesses Community businesses local businesses that's going to be uh working on this project I believe that one of the uh the the one that was primary sdg is that Scott Development Group they're they're here and I would like to say congratulations to them as well as say I'm very very grateful that we're doing what we are doing and keeping the dollars in our community thank [Applause] you the next item 9.06 oh we didn't vote okay okay not yet guys all in favor Miss Hall oh oh oh Miss Hall is a no okay no she's the no all opposed okay the next item is 9.06 and respon to

109response to bid c256 ctae modifications at the Davis Edwards Harris education complex the purchasing department received bids from four biders in response to the bid staff recommends that this bid be awarded to the lowest responsive and responsible bidder which was determined to be suit Corporation at a total cost of 2,626 722 this is a an eastl project thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the award of bid C 25-06 ctae modification at the de educational complex to seit Construction Corporation I'm sorry in the amount of 2,667 22 moved and seconded by uh Dr Howard Hall any discussion she can't move no I said I'm sorry moved by Mr Johnson seconded by Dr Howard Hall any discussion all right all in favor wonderful thank you the next item 9.07 is

110just a budget transfer to transfer funds from un unallocated to the construction um account to play for to pay for the additional ctae modifications at the Davis Edwards Harris education complex in the amount of 26267 122 thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the budget transfer as noted moved by Dr Howard Hall second November Johnson any discussion all right all in favor okay thank you item 9.08 is a contract extension for the multimedia classroom presentation systems the division of of office of technology and Business Systems and operations capital projects staff are requesting an increase of $ 2,150,000 to the previously board approved amount of $1,300,000 to cover additional purchases and services thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the contract extension of

111RFP 21-28 multimedia classroom presentation systems annual contract to the firm of net planner systems Incorporated at an estimated increased cost of $ 2,150,000 I'm mov by Mr Johnson seconded by Mr Smith um discussion all in favor okay thank you item 9.09 is similar to a previous item we're awarding the annual contract for on Call civil structural mechanical electrical Plumbing environmental engineering and surveyance services the purchasing department received proposals from 12 vendors thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the award of RFQ c25 -03 on call civil structural mechanical electrical Plumbing environmental engineering and surveying Services annual contract to chadam engineering company incorporated out of Savannah Georgia that is dely I believe that's what it is weeks and gagano Incorporated out of Savannah Georgia ECS Southwest LLC out of

112Savannah Georgia EMC Engineering Services Incorporated out of saan Georgia Goodwin Mills kwood LLC Al of Savannah Hy gab B and D young Incorporated Al of Savannah method Engineering Group L LC Al Savannah mfet and nickel Incorporated Al Savannah mssa P BK DBA Leafs Engineers out of Sugar Hill Georgia p Funding Company Alis savan and Thomasson Hutton engineering company Alis Savanah for a total estimated cost of $3 million move moved by Miss Hall seconded by Mr Smith any discussion how wonderful Mr Jackson we found so many firms in Savannah who will contribute to our East floss to support The Local Economic engine that is so wonderful thank you yes ma all right all in favor okay um all opposed abstain okay all right the next item 9.10 this is in response to RFQ c25 d04 on

113call Design Professional Services annual contract the purchasing department received proposals from 15 vendors for this RFQ thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the award of RFQ c254 on call Design Professional Services annual contract to Bernard Architects Alice Savannah mandrella architect PC Al Savannah CW and Associates Incorporated Alice Savannah Goodwin Mills kwood LLC Alice Savannah Green Line architecture Incorporated Alis Savannah Hy gay and Bell D young International Alis Savannah ls3p Associates LTD Alice Alice Savannah Pond and Company Alice Savannah Raymond engineering out of Savannah and SS OE Incorporated also out of Savannah for a total estimated cost of $2 million is there a motion motion by Dr Howard Hall second by Dr Hoskins Brown any discussion I do have one question Mr Jackson when you're reading those and

114maybe I missed it I'm not sure we go by what is printed in the resolution correct because I thought there were a couple firms that may have been skipped inadvertently but we go by what's posted yes ma' in the resolution okay all right any other discussion all in favor all opposed extensions motion carries okay the next [Music] item 9.1 tus well corative contract for Fleet Management equipment and software Sova Solutions on November the 4th 2020 the board approved an agreement with Sova sovia Solutions LLC a subsidiary of cal cal amp via the sourcewell corporative contract the initial contract was a 2-year period staff recommend recommends ratification of the automatic renewals total in $ 53,9 184 for the period March 1st 2023 through February 20 8th of 2025 and approval of the final renewal period at

115a cost of 256,257,258,259,262,274,277,284,530,531,282,283,296,301,318,319,529,532,306,270,271,272,305,315,33432 thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the ratification of automatic renewals of the sourcewell Cooperative contract Fleet Management equipment and software with sovia Solutions LLC a subsidiary of cow amp with a total cost with of automatic renewals of $53,900 and be further resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the final renewal of the sourcewell corporative contract for Fleek management equipment and software with sonovia Solutions LLC a subsidiary of Cal amp at a total cost of $26,995 thank been seconded um Dr bringman yeah we didn't get to the transportation update this morning but when that is Revisited I'm sure some of the on time numbers are coming from this software could we also have just uh like a I hate surveys but

116we need a survey or I would love to know how well the app is working for parents if if when they log in they're actually able to see the bus if it's giving them good useful updates um I know I get frustrated at least two or three times a week at the cat app because the the bus my son rides on just magically disappears and then reappears and we usually have gotten a text by then that he's on the bus and then like oh there it is on the app yeah where's that bus spin so would love to know if this app is working better than whatever cat is using thank you okay Miss Hall I'm very pleased to announce that many times parents let me know that that here comes the bus app is

117working very well and is very helpful in terms of um uh making sure that they're children are safe in getting to school on time and to me this is a perfect example of a business that we do not have the capacity locally to manage so going out to California or wherever this company is to get this kind of um transformative app is wonderful so if you haven't had a chance to use the hair com to the bus app do know that it is working well from everything that I've heard um Dr bringman thank you for the reminder that we did have to skip that Transportation update and I'd flip through it quickly but I thought I remembered seeing something in our transportation that we were going to be doing some solicitations For assistance with our

118transportation so um I'm I'm certainly supportive of continuing the to renew the app but I'm wondering why we are doing it as you know out to February of 26 particularly if we are re-evaluating our transportation system we're talking about adding a potential another app with a parent carpool like things could change where we might find there's this isn't able to meet all our needs and I don't think we want to end up having our parents have to download five different apps so I would certainly support you know the renewal but I'm just wondering why we have to go ahead and include an automatic renewal when we are in the process of evaluating our transportation systems and it may not meet our needs long term I think we've done enough preliminary inform research on the app

119that is being referred to in the presentation it does not have the same functionality right here comes the bus I I understand that but what we're so if we go that route we now have two different apps where so there may be a source out there that could be one app that does both things so I don't want to limit us to a renew an automatic renewal of this app if there may be another one that better suits our needs particularly as we continue to evolve our transportation discussions so do we do we have to do all these renewals now or can we take it in smaller bites so my recommendation would be to move forward with this just because of the time it takes to implement the app fully make sure we have the

120integration set up uh but if that is not the will of the board we can definitely go back and explore for that last um renewal uh what other options are available out on the market are there any savings in us moving quicker now or waiting any any any money lost that we can potentially have I unfortunately couldn't tell you unless I've reviewed other options that were out there to tell you what the cost difference was I guess to ask the question a little bit differently can we can we do a renewal through you know February of 2025 um can we just break it up into smaller you know February 2025 and maybe break up this this the last renewal into a smaller one that doesn't obligate us obligate us for the next year and a

121half two years but I'm thinking the main thing maybe the solicitation process even if we look for another app that could be a 3 to six months process so we would be in a few months without having an application out there I mean I'll support it but I just um I I don't like the idea of us getting locked into something that may not be best suiting our needs is there any language in the contract I'm asking um that would allow us to get out of the lease earlier or not the least the the contract we can check I'm quite sure there is but we can check build something into contracts that allow us to with adequate communication we can exit well could we modify this to proove us through through February 28th 2025 and

122and do some research because then the next time chunk after that is March 2025 until the entire following year um yeah I think we'll have to go back and negotiate with yeah as ition I'm just about the solicitation process itself that would take a few months um to narrow down vendors um and do some maybe site visits get vendors to come in that's going to take a while itself so February is right around the corner right February 2025 is but February 2026 a little further out that's okay you get my point you get your point anyone else all right all in favor all right here we go um the next item 9. 12 is a change order for w farest High School um J down construction this change order increases the guaranteed maximum price of

123the gymnasium by $3.8 million staff recommends now that board approved the GMP change order number 25 for the winon Forest High School repl replacement and to and the superintendent supports this recommendation thus be resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the GMP change order number 25 to J down Construction Company Incorporated in the amount of $3.8 million to add the modifications and additions to the existing gy gymnasium and increase the GMP to 82 m474 273 for the construction of the w w of Forest High School replacement school I'll move by Dr bringman uh second by Mr Johnson discussion Mr Johnson I don't know if this will make it more any more efficient and or what not for future reference um since we since the next agenda item is if this one

124passes is the moving of the funds is there a way to combine the two um that way there's less things that the board has to vote on yes and some a little more time you know more efficient with with the time with the board correct so noted all right any other discussion all right all in favor okay I'm sorry I'm sry I I'm so sorry AB stain thank you all we're almost there uh next item 9.13 as mentioned that this is just a budget transfer itself transfering $3.8 million from unallocated to the construction account for w Forest High School thus being resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent that the board approve the budget transfer as noted okay move by Dr Howard Hall seconded by Mr Johnson any discussion all in favor okay uh abstain

125there you go all right so uh president Moss if it is the will of the board we will uh go back to the presentation and complete that from earlier to today that's right yeah we still got present oh that's right yeah continue what now what we can we can okay uh we're going to take a five minute break sorry here you go guys you have five minutes I should have brought my e e e uh Miss Davidson before you start I actually we do have someone that sign sign up to speak on this agenda item uh so we have Miss Briana Paxton Miss Faxon you have three minutes thank you thank you good afternoon uh my name is Brianna Paxton I'm a district 2 Resident pres and parent to a kind kindergartner Grace at Savannah

126Classical Academy we chose Savannah Classical Academy because of the consistent upward trends of educational Excellence it's diverse student body and it's the closest school to our house my daughter sorry my daughter and I biked school every day up Atlantic Avenue I strongly urge you to approve the superintendent's recommendation for $4.2 million to necessary repairs to Savannah Classical Academy this investment is critical to ensuring the safety comfort and success of our students and staff these improvements fit further fit under the priorities listed in your 2026 strategic plan and I want to particularly point out the stewardship priority this building the historic location of St Pas Catholic school for African-Americans educated the likes of Floyd Adams Jr and Clarence Thomas and from my understanding it then closed in 196 9 due to the chaotic nature of desegregation

127of our education system to me Savannah is a city that hasn't fully recovered from white flight but Savannah classical is a actually providing a successful diverse environment in a historic location where we can tell that story I urge you to maintain and improve this location and the continued Excellence of the academy thank you thank you very much thank you m Davidson you are welcome all right I will uh lend to the superintendent to now further uh continue through our presentation yes so our last Mike uh one of our final proposals for discussion today amongst uh the board is um our Charter School participation in East blast um we have invited our charter schools to participate by submitting uh proposals for their needs uh within their schools that may be covered um in the East Bloss

128referendum uh we were guided in this process by uh several legal aspects you can see those listed there on the left side of the page um and we also considered many other factors as we uh prioritized uh Charter School submissions along with our own District needs um regarding the use of East Blas funding so you can see those considerations there on the right um You will see in front of you over the next series of slides each charter school that participated in the proposal submission um and their uh specific proposals and the dollar amounts that align to those uh the ones in green are the ones that I am recommending to the board board based on both legal guidance and based on the other criteria that was shared earlier um the green items are the

129ones that um come to a total of $7.5 million um and those are the specific aspects that I am advancing uh to the board for consideration so I will pause there for discussion discussion anyone okay and I will pitch it back over to Miss Davidson to complete this presentation all right thank you so uh we have previously highlighted the safety security and Technology proposals so if there is no questions I'll I'll proceed on through those uh as our other facility actions we have highlighted there is a going to be a potential sale of property this building the uh and other facilities that are in or sites owned within the district to the decision to sell these properties is based on several factors the suboptimal condition occupancy and utilization the revenue that could be generated a

130cost benefit analysis the reduction of ongoing maintenance costs and to support the Strategic reinvestment any discussion needed there all right I'm going to continue so our criteria for PR prioritization of the projects and funding strategy as Dr Watts highlighted earlier we utilize data data data so our facility condition the utilization enrollment also other factors like the budget and and uh the availability of funds other facility considerations facility preferences versus Necessities stakeholder engagement and academic programming all went into our consideration Matrix as a quick reminder our initial project list exceeded our funding estimate so our initial project list almost got to a billion dollar so after review we were able to uh bring that down to what is now a balanced um project list our East Bloss 5 Revenue projections we do project that we are

131going to bring in $75 million and that is what um the uh project listing you will see includes as well as funding from um fund balance so we have included a fund balance analysis I will lend to Mr Jackson to quickly go over these items as we look at the fund balance projections for um FY 25 as we get into the year we're projecting to end up with a fund balance of about $235 million after the Auditors have finished their statements for f FY 24 um currently we have um assigned or designated fund balance of 9.5 for texbooks um some previous board agent approved items from FY 24 some outstanding purchase orders and budget transfers that have not been completed yet um the we adopted the budget to use $8.2 million of fund balance in

132fy2 and there on today's agenda there's an assignment of $1.6 million as of today that brings down our un signed fund balance to about 210 million um which is still way above the 3 month average um and going pretty close getting to the 4month maximum or Target that we have looked at in the past go to the next Slide the proposal is to take $60 million out of the to assigned fund balance of $60 million that we will have currently or have after the fy2 24 audit which will bring our um available on sign fund balance down to $150 million but keep in mind this is not like your like typical transfer we would do with fund balance where we would take it out of the general fund and put in the capital projects that

133that $6 million will stay in the general fund until we have a need for it in the future so so it may be four or 5 years from now so in planning what we were looking at is if we if we assign $60 million of fund balance for future use by the time we get to it we have replaced the $6 million from fund balance that we're going to add every year from savings um so that was our our strategy and that's the plan that we were going to have moving forward but in doing that that puts us a little below of the target of three our 3 months Target by 4.8 mlion but based upon the actual operations and expenditures to date you see up top we expected we budgeted to use $8.2 million

134from F balance we really don't see that happening we really don't see where we're going to have to use $8.2 million of the current fund balance for fy2 we think at this point we're we're coming along pretty good and so we're probably in the in the positive and not in the r of Us in 8.2 so that puts us in a better situation to meeting that 3 month Target any question Miss Hall um Dr Watts I thought that we were assigning the $60 million so that we would not have to wait until January of 2026 to begin using East blot funds for our projects that that 60 million was going to give us um Advanced funds to go on and begin um our you know our our process once um E5 would pass so we

135have included in the resolution bonding language and that that opportunity will allow us to start projects earlier the bond the the bonding not not the fund Bal 60 million is to make sure that if anything regarding 208 Bull Street goes over um or with the Savannah Annex things that specifically cover administrative staff that we are not to be using East blo dollars for that is what that 208 that's what that uh 60 million dollar is for so that we are not using easto dollars to fund things that we're not supposed to fund okay so so bonding is is not a more cost costly route than using the fund balance it's not more costly but I'm not the expert so let me defer to people who can answer your questions about bonding what keep in mind

136the resolution yeah because we'd have to pay interest yeah that's what they do yeah yeah yeah keep in mind you have to pay interest but at current rates um what the financial advisers have kind of pointed out in some presentations if we borrow money and put it in the bank the rate of interest we collect will be more than the rate of interest we have to pay out in some of the original projections and and starting those projects earlier could be less expensive because of yes unless everything get cheaper wouldn't that be lovely yeah but to m h to your point I mean we the $60 million could be an option but we just want to make sure we have all the options available that we need okay um we have fun bance for a

137reason um I I prefer to bond or I I don't want to spend that fund balance quickly allegedly tariffs are coming there might be ice storms there might be hurricanes um we have fund balance for a reason so let's be very conservative and using that all that's my first comment my my question on this is for E5 for budgeting purposes you're projecting the use of over five years a total of $60 million over five years yes so and it's going to be some portion of some lesser amount every year depending on programs depending on East Bloss cover projects versus academic projects so we're not spending it all in one year so we're not going to drop below the three months correct in any one year um and given anticipated collections we'll probably still be above

138that every year correct correct okay yes Dr Hoskins Brown thank you um appreciate the presentation and I don't have to restate with my concerns have been about the use of fund balance I um Mr catchar stated it very very clearly uh my question is that when we first started talking about the long range ftil facilities plan I asked and and we were talking about using fund balance for it I asked okay what are we going to be what are all the things that we're going to be using um fund balance for and so we we've dipped in it twice uh today we've obligated another dip into it for next year for 600 um, we have the which is not very much compared to this but then we have this amount is there anything else that

139we are going to fund balance for or can I feel comforted that we're not going to be touching this for a while um I'm not going to make any promises but I would try my best to make sure we don't dip into it anymore um at the end of December which is kind of the first half of the year we're going to really start looking at operations so some of the other if there's some big ticket items we're going to look at savings from operations and not use fund balance going for it to help help that count up okay and one of my personal uh professional goals this year is to not have to leverage fund balance to balance the budg budget so there's another body of work that is happening to also be more

140efficient in the use of our general funds um I'm I'm not I don't feel 100% confident saying that we won't ever have to go back to this because if I remember almost a year ago to date the governor did a bonus to all staff and we had to go into this to make that happen um so there are just unforeseen things that we can't necessarily anticipate I think key takeaway here is that 60 million um is not going to be used all at one time it could be three years before we ever have to touch this so if we needed to do something different we have the flexibility to do it thank you I am I I fully understand that the presence of external factors could influence that I just want to make sure that

141we're create we're controlling for all internal factors and I don't want us to be for lack of a better word lazy or or you know just not energized about managing other small pots because we have this large saving account somewhere if this happens today we know the limitations that we're working in so we have to uh govern ourselves accordingly as it relates to anything additional we want to do okay thank you m Kowski where are we looking for funding for the increases in costs where's Mr Ray that's probably Mr Ray question um for the um healthc care pre that's is going to be ratcheting up because that's going to be a significant expense is that anticipated to come from fund balance I am going to try my best to balance our budget without having to

142go into the fund balance including those increased costs absolutely okay we try our best not to use any ongoing operational cost to go any from fund balance we know it's going to keep keep going up every year am I remembering correctly that those those increases have kind of gotten pushed off and able to so that we can plan for them but we still have to plan for them and then it will be a continual so there's that kind of initial almost that fiscal cliff that we're going to end up on because of those increased cost right from the state yes and that's that's part of um the juggle with uh the military and state revenue so we're just going to have to kind of wait and see what happens on the state see how much

143they're going to fund then we have to make decisions on with our local milit rate because we want to be able to sustain any changes not only one year but each year after that but I want to make sure I understand the question you're asking about a cliff well to me that infers that a decision has already been made that is now at some point going to I'm just talking about the The increased costs that we know are coming right and maybe that's not the right and I'm going to try to incorporate that within our existing general fund budget process all right so we will continue next will be timeline and next steps so we are nearing the end so assuming that everything is is passed today we will move forward with Public Announcement and

144an awareness launch so our plan is January 6 through January 15th we will work with our potential Partners like the chamber and City representatives to help organize an official announcement um and get that message out and then January 21st through February 15th would be continued engagement and additional awareness events in our schools and our partner locations so hosting events in schools City Halls community centers and other municipality and chamber partners and then February 1st through February 20th would be partnership and Community mobilization opportunities this is where we want to work closely with our cities we have uh many different cities within our County and so we want to engage the city and Civic groups to encourage participation from our local businesses and our neighborhood associations and then February 21st through March 10th is going to

145be our final awareness push in anticipation of that March 18th voting date we would distribute information updates and voting reminders across the city and the district so now if it is uh approved I will move forward with the uh resolution yes Miss hang on um M Hall I don't hear any mention of Television uh podcast anything that's going to be recurring as opposed to events that are in person that that is a great question so we can Market our um our great programs and what's going on at the school but we would lend to our partners to Market um those television events they have to spend the money as a district we are prohibited from spending those funds so we but we could uh make a request to our partners and highlight the benefit of

146television or podcast opportunities so we that would fit into the partnership and community group mobilization time frame uh talking February 1st to the 20th before that could get started I think we've started and uh having conversations about a particular partner that could help us go through this process but to be clear we can't Market no I we can't we can't do any of those things so um those things aren't highlighted on this slide we are staying within the confines of what we can do we can do okay but I think they're inferred and embedded within that all right continue all right so I will move forward with the resolution so this is on uh strategic priority for efficient effective and Equitable resource stewardship uh Administration presents a board resolution for the continuation of the education

147special purpose local option sales tax this will be the fifth time a resolution has been presented for the consideration and would provide for the continuation of the existing 1% or 1 cent sales tax for East boss 5 this resolution provides that chadam County Board of Education impose Levy and collect sales and use tax for educational purposes within the chadam County School District conditioned upon approval by the majority of the qualified voters residing in chadam county and voting in the election thereon to be held on March 18th 2025 the eastl 5 resolution has been developed with the guidance from the board attorney and has been legally reviewed and is enclosed in your packets thus be it resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent and the board approve the enclosed East Bloss 5 resolution been moved and

148seconded uh discussion Dr bringman as I stated in the informal I'll restate to some degree um this has been um a lot of work with board members with the superintendent with District members um we have tried to reach out um through the superintendent to create stronger um relationships across our district um and we are showing a good fourth effort to include all areas of our County um I think that the presentation this morning and uh just finished up really shows and proves that I believe the last four East Bloss did that as well um I was thinking during uh executive for a little bit about what schools were like in chadam County when I was in school the 80s and the 90s and trying to remember was anything built new um and and I and

149I don't think anything was built new um the late 90s Yes actually I had to I had to have a presentation um and speaking for one of our principal former principles 1970 was um Largo Tibet Elementary and then the next school was East Broad um which was 1989 okay so 19 years yeah so um every school I attended Butler Gould um Bartlett now stem and Beach uh many of those have been rebuilt um and all of them have been renovated at least once if not two or three times um so I'm I'm proud to sit here as a board member being able to support a resolution that makes schools better for our students um I can't remember going into any of my buildings and being excited about the building that I was in um truly

150I I really can't um because they were they were older buildings was I excited about some of the classes I took yes um was I excited about not excited about some of them just like y'all probably yes um but there is something to be said for when you walk into a a new building as a student and the pride that it grows um I'm proud of what beach High looks like now you know it it brings me a sense of Pride um and I'm glad that that members before me did a great job at making that happen um I'm super excited that my name is on the same wall as my daughter's name at Jenkins High School as being part of the board that finished that I didn't promise it I I helped finish it

151get it to the Finish Line um so as I stated earlier not everything in here is perfect and not the way that if I got to wave my magic wand it would be um but I know it will work for our community um so I will uh fully support the the superintendent's recommendation Miss Hall I just very quickly want to say that what our efforts mean it's more than just these buildings it's our commitment to public education and I think that's something that's sorely needed across our country now to know that we have districts and board members who are very interested in keeping our public education as excellent as it can be it through buildings programs technology but just that we have great spirit and great vision for public education in this country going forward

152even though it may come under a future attack Mr Johnson um well let's see the first time I we I talked about East Bloss we got um new Hampsted K8 on the East floss referendum that was what E3 and now we're here at E5 and like Dr bringman said it's not if my magic wand was to go it doesn't have everything on it that I want however it has the most we can get for all of our kids whether they are out on the islands all the way to West chadam County to almost to the border and everywhere in between that's from traditional public schools to our Public Charter School schools and from the little babies to the 18-year-old about to graduate high school so yes it's it's a lot it's a lot of money

153but we I fully 100% support the recommendation from the superintendent um I am very glad to see that after as most of y'all can attend to every single month for the past eight and a half years I've been up here trying to get a high school out in Pooler and we only have one on these floss so it might be my last vote but it's going to be my most proudest [Applause] vote Howard Hall to answer David with Dr Bran's question as a student no but as a teacher yes I was with the first teacher at Georgetown Elementary when that school was built probably 30 years ago and I'm very proud of that in the 70s when I was in high School Windsor Forest High School was the elite school that was the best built

154school it was the modern school and that is why it last because it was in front of everybody else so I'm very proud of the work that has gone into this plan and looking forward to be around for a few years to see the beautiful schools that we will continue to build for the community thank you Mr catmar thank you I'm I'm going to Echo comments from my fellow board members um on two issues one East Blast has been um Community changing for Savannah chadam um I'm I don't really like taxes generally I understand you need them uh to function as a civil society uh I like roads and airports and bridges and all that stuff um and we pay taxes um what I like about East plast is some percentage up to 40% maybe

155or more comes from visitors um to the county so they're subsidizing um our educational uh capital and technology and transportation needs um I think what we've done well as a district is always keeping at the Forefront that um being transparent with voters who support East blast uh and being accountable to voters um has been at the Forefront of every east blast we've done so far um we uh we we disclose the projects we overd disclose spending and budgets and it's on our website it's at our cic meetings it's during regular board meetings um and we deliver on our promises and that's been a driving force for this board and superintendence in its various iterations since I've been on it so I'm very supportive of East blast um and this East blast in particular second um

156this has been a very collaborative exercise one of the we've learned a lot of ongoing lessons since East blast one I came in to this board or onto this board at the end of East blast one when we were starting to put together East Blast 2 and frankly we were getting more sophisticated as a district about how to manage construction how to manage maintenance and operations um and we've we've gone to being very data driven doing facilities condition indexes prioritizing um needs versus wants and in higher priority needs over lower priority needs Etc um and then once we have that data sitting down as a board and as a staff and in multiple Retreats talking about how do we prioritize um what we need to do and balancing out facility needs with academic programming needs

157with population growth Etc so congrat ulations to us the board and a a huge thank you to the superintendent this is her first year and she did not expect 70% of her year to be focused on facilities and maintenance and operations um but it was um but she and a lot of our new staff um and existing staff put a lot of time and effort into this and so thank you and thank you for putting up for the board's um uh inputs and crazy questions and proposals during during um Retreats um I do have um agreement as well that this does not contain everything I would have want or in the order I would have wanted um but that that's why there's nine of us up here and District staff and um nobody makes decisions

158alone and often what you get from collaborative group effort where you look at data is a really pretty good product um and that's what politics and compromise and group participation is so this is a um a very good proposal um I do have a couple of tweaks that I'm going to propose at the end of this and I will make a motion to amend the pending agenda or the pending agenda item and I want to explain why um and um after this I know what's I'm pretty sure what's going to happen I'm going to be labeled as anti-ar um and I want to explain that I am anything but um from every charter school that's currently in operation in the district uh I have supported its initial application to be a charter for two of

159our current Charter Schools I was early on the board and the recommendation from superintendent and staff was to deny the charter applications and the board at the time uh was leaning heavily towards denying it um and I and some others engaged in some heavy lobbying and ultimately we got those Charters approved the the superintendent changed his recommendation the board changed his vote there have been several instances over the years where various Charters um including several of our existing Charter Schools um were having significant struggles financially academically um operationally and um there was a lot of internal staff and board discussion about not renewing the charters about pulling the charters and I was a staunch advocate for letting the charters try to figure it out they had Growing Pains early on um and I was a

160vocal advocate for not pulling their contracts their Charter agreements and for continuing them um we've had new Charter proposals come to us um and I have been in the minority in voting to approve them and the rest of the board did not um I am not anti- Charter I Am pro accountability I Am pro transparency so I wanted to put that out there at the beginning because I know what's going to happen later because it's happened in the past when I've said anything negative about any Charter so and anybody out there who's watching who's here today who's listening I will sit down with you and have a cup of coffee and talk this through my cell number is on the district website my emails on the website contact me I'm happy to have a conversation

161so that said um we have historically been told through East Bloss that that we cannot as a public entity spend taxpayer funds on privately owned property okay um and we've what what's happened with this round of East blast is we tried to find creative ways to spend public tax dollars on privately owned property while still maintaining a residual property interest in the investment but regardless of whether we can or can't do that and I don't know the answer to that I know what our uh there are various views on that um that's not driving where I'm coming from what's driving where I'm coming from is I have a fundamental problem as a taxpayer spending public public money on privately owned property um I've got plenty of friends and clients who would love thousands hundreds of

162thousands millions of dollars on their private property and we don't own the property we don't the the school district doesn't own the property doesn't lease the property um so it's just basically giving a A gratuiti or a gift to privately owned property and I just as a policy matter I'm not comfortable with that so in past East blast we have designated funds for charter schools for technology for other expenses and I'm 100% supportive of doing that in this East blast um what I'm not comfortable doing is allocating money uh for private property for the benefit or Improvement of private property and the proposal for classical and for um Semco um both has site improvements allocations that to me cross the line if we owned the property if we leased it I would have no problem

163because ultimately the district owns the property I just I'm not comfortable spending public funds on privately owned property and I've had this discussion with people in the community and on this board and some of the comments that have been raised to me were well it's about the kids we need to support the kids the kids need you know a non-leaky roof the kids need air conditioning 100% agree right we have 55 district schools that we spend monthly cic meetings looking at the condition of their HVAC and looking at their roofs the difference is we own those buildings the taxpayers have a an asset in those buildings It's Our obligation to make sure they're safe for the kids and for staff and it's Our obligation to maintain that asset for the benefit of the citizens of

164chadam County who own that property the the argument I would make is when you when any charter school is budgeting they're making decisions about where to spend money and looking at the past presentations from several of our Charter Schools um several of our charter schools get facility grant money from the state um and in looking at their presentations to us um classical has never said to us in the last I looked at the last three presentations where what was raised were here are our challenges here are our concerns the challenges raised in the last three years of presentations were absenteeism and learning loss there was nothing about the facility there um in 2020 there was a presentation about um it had the history of classicals building it was purchased and renovated in 2014 there was

165a three-story Edition in 2016 the gym was renovated in 2018 the kitchen was built out in 2020 and then a listing of the planned facility upgrades were playground renovation lower school restroom renovation and student services renovation nowhere on that list was hey we need to fix our roof and our HVAC but now the request is hey fix our roof and our HVAC when a charter school is making budget allocations just like us when we allocate money for schools we have a certain amount of portioned for maintenance and operations um that we have to apply and so we could spend more money on higher administrator salaries on on lower class sizes by hiring more teachers on more counselors on more nurses and that's all things we want to do but we have larger class sizes and

166maybe a lesser administrator than we need and our salaries are not in the top 10% Like I'd always like them to be they're a little lower because we also have to spend money on Transportation on technology on maintenance and operations so these are adult decisions these are not you know we're not impacting kids this is we are impacting kids but it's adult decisions and the charters in particular have direct control over their budgets we don't set your budgets we don't set those so we set Public School budgets so when when there's a maintenance and operation need a contingency fund should be set aside or maybe it should be prioritized but I have a problem saying we're going to spend more money on programming on labor costs on whatever on on whatever we're spending it on

167but we want public tax dollars to subsidize are part of Le owned building that I just have a problem with that so um I'm again not anti- Charter um there are other ways we have we we have told Charters we can try to work with them uh we can use general fund money or east blast money to pay off Bond debt um and this issue comes up every time there's a new East blast and what I've said to every charter school is let's discuss a public public partnership a public private partnership but whatever you bring to us my personal view is we don't I don't want to spend public money on privately owned property but if the district owns it or has a long-term lease I am happy to spend money on a charter facility

168on a charter school the other issue I've got is the proposal is to spend public tax dollars on um classical which has the newest of newest building of all of our charters um in the in the meantime in the last 5 to 10 years um Susie King tayor has come to us and said we're having significant building issues uh our private landlord isn't willing to invest we need help with a building we need help with a facility and this board has said no taibe has come to us since its Inception and said we are renting private property um it's got significant issues it's broken up over multiple geographic regions and we're probably going to lose the lease in a few years please help us with the building and we have said no tyby came to

169us and said okay if you won't help us with a building lease us one of your existing facilities that you think is Surplus and maybe put some money into it to renovate it and we said no and if you're going to talk about a want versus a need taibe is at an existential threat for its existence because it's not going to have a building when its lease expires okay Susie King Taylor has almost gone out of existence because of its building issues so I have a another in terms of prioritization and policy perspective I have another issue another problem saying that taibe and Susie King Taylor repeatedly sorry no but we're going to fix your roof and HVAC and and put money into um facilities at at Semco and Savannah classical and I don't I

170don't have anything against those schools I've always been pro-choice uh when it comes to schools I support I support choice and and Specialty programs I've supported Charters I want there to be as many options in chadam county for families as possible I want there to be academic rigor and accountability and competition so families have choices so but I'm not able to support the sections of this um referendum that give money public money to private property so thank you for letting me vent or uh explain myself um and so I move that the proposed referendum be amended as follows on page seven of the referendum which is the first blank page and it's the actual referendum to go on the ballot um under the heading which said uh paragraph one under the heading which says 1%

171educational sales tax uh line 11 that we strike site improvements and then line 13 we strike and repairs to roof and HVAC systems and then on page eight of the total handout which is page two of the referendum under Section 3E we strike the second line Savannah classical HVAC and roof replacement and on the third line we strike site improvements so I'll I'll read you want me to say them again okay so again on page seven which is the first blank page and it's the actual referendum paragraph one under the heading 1% educational sales tax line 11 we strike site improvements so the sentence reads so one e would readed providing well I'll do this line 11 strike side improvements line 13 strike and repairs to roof and HVAC systems so section 1e will read

172as follows providing Charter School capital outlay projects to Coastal Empire Monas charter school for equipment SL buses technology and secure facilities Savannah Classical Academy technology and campus security improvements and tyby Island Maritime Academy equipment and Technology ology improvements and then on page eight under 3E we strike the entire second line Savannah Classical Academy Charter School HVAC and roof Replacements and section 3E the third line we strike s improvements so it just reads Coastal Empire monory Charter School equipment and activity school buses clarify question of your motion sure would we oh never mind I'm good so it's been moved by Mr catmar it's been seconded by uh Miss Hall um I have something to say but I want to listen everyone first Miss Kowski um I will support this motion I Mr catmar stated it very

173clearly and eloquently and I share his view um I think that I would love to continue conversations with each of our Charters to see how we can assist and I've and everyone I've spoken to about this proposal particularly for Charters I have expressed that to them personally um so I am all about let's see how we can help and partner and I do want us to have to build stronger relationships with our Charters so this is not a you know anything against Charters at all it is about the transparency and the responsibility of how we're using public funds and so for that reason I will support the amended resolution Mr Smith question uh thank you um for this review Mr Shan uh I would like to ask um the board as well as superintendent um

174Mr sha talked detailed about the history of charter schools and their request and their response our responses for those requests my question is uh if we were to uh move forward with the proposal as placed or as printed will we be um will we be carrying out this same practice uh for the years to come does that question make sense yes I think um we would approach ongoing East Bloss referendums under my leadership in the same way that we have this one we would look at data we would look at prioritization versus needs and wants um I think it is clear to everyone in here based on the proposal that I also want to partner with our Charter Schools I see their students being a part of our educational ecosystem and so they would be

175invited to participate um and prioritized accordingly using a variety of sources but I can't tell you today that um Charters would always be included because it depends on the circumstances the data the budget it depends on a lot of different factors so there's I couldn't commit to own goinging participation there will there will be ongoing invitation but not a commitment to ongoing participation right I guess my fear is I don't want to necessarily do for one and not do sure do for all but and of course I think about that in terms of even your districts at times um I think the largest allocation of dollars that we have is going to a certain uh district and a certain geographical area of our Community whereas less may be going to others and so um it

176it's an equity it's where is the need and let's try to work towards the need Dr bringman [Music] um well stated Mr catmar could never have delivered that that well and I I fully understand the logic and support the logic um but I'm going to look at it slightly different and this is literally changed in the last you know 30 minutes thinking on this um it's less than a percent of our E5 proposed budget and everything you stated about us saying no previously is correct um so maybe this is our point where we say we're doing this and moving forward we'll get better rather than let's not do this and then we'll get better um so I see this as I don't yeah a turning point an olive branch a okay um and we learned

177even in this process by soliciting them we probably could have asked for a lot more data like moving forward you're going to have to have some fcis you're going to have to have some third parties go out there and actually tell us that this building actually needs X Y and Z just like all of um like our district does for every single one of our buildings um and we've learned that we need to ask all of our schools what's their list you know for Santa um because we don't do that we don't ask hey do you want want a bunch of robotic things for your school um and so we've learned even now that we need to dig probably even deeper into um pass the principle and just start soliciting everybody and I think the

178community hopefully listening to some degree will get on fire and and and give us thoughts um because that's how we generate this huge list it starts off a lot bigger um so I see it as as a small drop in the bucket that still helps students and might help direct our team um in a different direction um it's a small push on the rudder to say hey we're doing this um how can we in future iterations um in E6 do well and do better um so that's where I'm sitting Mr Johnson um I understand where Mr casmar is coming from and Mr Kowski is coming from at the same time um I'm still supporting what the superintendent had I cannot support the amendment to take it out uh you know Savannah classical and Coastal Empire

179they asked and the superintendent said yes that the need should be on the referendum we hired her for that job we need to support the superintendent with that I don't always agree with the superintendent superintendent doesn't always agree with me um I mean there's been very few times when I have when it comes to taxes and this amount of money where I have agreed with the with the super any superintendent I've worked with and their staff and Administration I mean heck I've been here for two terms and I've voted I've only voted in favor of two budgets um and the these projects yes we only take it out a little bit but it's really like Dr Brean said it's only costing a little bit if you take it in the in the larger spectrum and

180when we have kids going into schools which we know even in our own schools where the hvac's aren't working and it's it's how how does it look when when we are willing to repair hhd yes I know it's private property however we are working through that through our legal team charter schools legal team of how to make it work so that way we are not losing the public money we are not losing public funds so we need to make sure that we take care of every single child who is in a public education School whether it's Charter or a traditional one whether it's choice or not and I mean there's some things on these lists where I I would not have agreed with and so I'm glad they they weren't on the list because I

181want to support this and in its current state as the superintendent has it I support it because of that I'm so I'm sorry Mr C I cannot support your amendment to take it out because I feel like for those kids and those two schools need to make sure that those they have a safe and a comfortable learning environment Dr Howard Hall oops won't be long myself too am at a you know the turning point if this was not the recommendations per the superintendent I wouldn't have reservations but since it is in the superintendent's um recommendation for the resolution I just um I don't see myself voting against it because it is part of the the um resolution and has been included in the budget I know that I understand fully how everyone thinks as everyone

182knows there nobody thinks the exact same way and since this is um in the recommendation is in the budget I will be voting to not amend it thank you anyone else uh Dr H yes I um I hear the points of view that have been stated and what I'm not hearing is that it's not a removing the language doesn't remove the possibility of paying for the HVAC and the roof because there's a $200 million Bond opportunity there that $200 million in bonds can be used for anything and I think I think what I heard from Mr kar's statement was there was not that inclusion for the other charter schools to have a specific request but the line that says if in position of the tax is approved by the voters such vote shall constitute approval

183of the issuance of General obligation debt of Chad of the chatam County School District in the maximum principal amount of 200 million for the above Capital outlay purposes and for the payment of capitalized interest so am I seeing that incorrectly I'm going to ask our legal counsel doesn't that that has an un not an unobligated but it has a restricted availability of a $200 million bond is that not correct am I seeing that wrong 200 million is u a general obligation Bond and is subject to the requirements of Georgia law for the expenditure of that as a general obligation Bond as opposed to a SP project thank you you so beid FS funds be used to pay any bond debt we have no bond debt at the moment so even if we previously had a

184bond it was used for some other purpose whatever that may be this bond this SP funds can be used to pay back thank you it can also pay the 200 million that be authorized in this thank you so what I hear in that is that there's not just possibilities for Savannah clasical in that as possibilities for any lawful investment in the other charter schools and I think where what I'm I'm hearing that there is a difficulty either philosophically or legally in paying Capital Improvements for property that's not ours but there is time and $200 million of opportunity to figure that out so I don't know understand why my colleagues are seeing that as either or I I don't read it that way I read it as above that the bonds are only supposed to be

185utilized and leveraged against projects already on the list and if we're going to and maybe I'm wrong I really that legal definition means I I can't I can't even I'm not legal um I see it as if if we're going to use that 200 bond to go back to the other Charters and I would hope go back to all of our schools if we're soliciting for other projects um we're going to have to get rid of some of the other ones um but why if we're going to say yeah and we're just going to use the bond for that anyhow why wouldn't we just keep it included because we just said if we're taking out a bond and then paying it off we're paying interest on it anyhow so um uh I I don't see

186a problem with having 05% of our budget already in there um yeah Miss Holland Mr katmar very quickly I don't see this in any way Dr Watts as a pro Watts or anti-d Watts discussion thank you that that wasn't even on my mind thank you um what I am captivated with is the thought that we're using public money private property that's all and is that our prerogative to do and if there is a way to help our Charter Schools without Crossing that bright line good so I don't see it as oh I'm supporting Dr wats at all okay Mr gar yeah I mean that's exactly the point um I'm supportive of everything else in there for Charters if any Charter came to us and said give us one of your facilities because we need space

187I'd say let's make it work my issue is giving public funds to private property um to benefit private property on on the on the analysis of if we can use $200 million in bond debt repayment to pay for anything so might as well leave it in I could equally say you might as well leave it out because we can do it we can use it for anything but Charters have come to us since East plast 2 was up and said we need help with facilities and we have said every time we'll give you money for technology we'll give you money for transportation we'll we'll do some other things that are not Capital facility improvements but we're not giving you funds for Capital facility improvements and we had the ability to use Bond debt repayment funds

188in E2 E3 and I think we paid it off in E3 right at the end of e3 so and and instead of saying hey Charters we're going to talk to you about what we do with our bond money we said no we're we're going to use it just to repay down Bond debt so I have no confidence of what I'm hearing here which is hey other Charters don't worry about it we'll take care of you we'll talk about it they've heard that for four East blasts and we're not there so if we can spend that that 200 million in bond debt repayment funds on anything we want number one we got to cut existing projects because we're going to add stuff and number two if we're spending money on Charter facility Capital Improvements they're either

189all in or all out but and especially the private property issue is my main concern um sir if I could clarify the the resolution does refer to how the bond debt would be the 200 million Bond debt would be spent um it does say specifically that it is for capital outlay projects described in the notice so what we've done in the past is past uh the board will remember that what the way we have eliminated pre-existing Bond debt is to list that specifically in the referendum so previous East blast had list that we would pay Bond debt pre-existing down with East blast funds but we don't have any bond debt because we've already paid it off so this particular resolution has written does specify that the 200 million is to be used for projects that

190are listed in the notice thank you that answers that question that answers that question so um all right I am the only person that sits on this board that's ever started a charter school I'm going to tell you how Charter School finances work Charter Schools we we give Charter Schools x amount of dollars out of those dollars they pay salaries they pay everything they don't have an East Bloss and as far as the the grants those grants are not given every year it is not $100,000 a year what Charter schools do is and you know they have to come up with some way of paying their lease every month in addition to paying their staff and everything else they do not have another fund um my POS of course my position is and and let

191me get something else I I have to say this I am tired of hearing public schools and Charter Schools charter schools are public schools I'm tired of hearing I am tired of hearing district schools and Charter Schools our public charter schools are part of this District when we get our scores back from the state those charter schools are listed along with every school in chatam County I commend Dr Watts for actually reaching out to the charter schools and wanting and letting the charter schools know you are part of us I understanded the the conundrum that some of my board members and I respect that I totally respect that and by the way please understand these board members are not anti-ar so please do not go out of here saying they're anti-ar they are not we

192just have a philosophical difference and my my philosophical difference is I want this to be the beginning of a new day in chadam County where our Charter Schools when we look at East plus when we go to the voters when we go to the voters I want the voters to know charter schools are in included in this because guess what Charter School parents are taxpayers like everybody else so you know you know we're going to vote and and um no I cannot s i i I cannot support the amendment but um I I need some guidance on how how we do this vote because we had an original we have we we we there was a motion on the floor there was an original motion and then yes that had been there's a motion to

193amend in a second so you got to vote on that passes then you vote on the original and if it fails you vote on the original okay so we vote on the amendment okay okay before we vote any more any more comments Miss Kowski I just have a question going back to the bond um and understand what Mr hediger was saying about it being linked to these projects is that does it have to be linked to the east W projects the bond yes I know no I know as it written as it's written but can that and I'm looking at our attorney can that can that coupling be uncoupled I would not recommend it okay that's what I need thank you question I don't think we could issue milon that's not on the list that's

194correct than I just want that clarification thank you any other questions yeah Dr bringman yeah I just I I support the resolution as it stands um and I want to have that good faith that Olive Branch um for all of our Public Schools but some of our public schools that are deemed Charter chose to be separated chose to find their own building chose to find their own staff to use a pace system they get to decide on chose to be outside um we are trying to include them in East blast but it would be nice moving forward that if it was a relationship that was not adversarial far too often we are sued by Charter Schools none of our other schools can sue us um and that makes it difficult um so please begin to

195be less against us so that we can be with you um please like it it it just is really difficult um to know some of the things that are said about people that are said about District staff um that have created some of this problem that we're kind of dodging around and I'm just going to step in it because I want to um because I want to move forward but having to get email after email that hey another lawsuit has been filed against us and you're like really um haven't had a telephone call but that would have been nice to have been told as a board member that one of our schools had an issue with us that wanted to sit down and have a conversation with us to wanted to discuss some of the

196issues they were having rather than oh boom lawsuit um cuz I haven't had that telephone call from a charter school that said this is a problem I'm having with the district you're one of the board members of the board that is over top of all of our schools in chadam County can you sit down and help me to be an intercessor because that's what I see our role as when a parent I had a parent literally this morning problem already solved um um that's my job um but a lot of times um that has been skipped completely um and I definitely have found out about many many things without ever knowing anything was actually happening out in the community and then we get hit with a lawsuit oh and then we get hit with another

197lawsuit so let's let's try to be less adversarial let's try to be less I got you let's try to be hey last minute meeting eting boom gotcha um we ask our children to be better than that um and to be open and transparent and everybody wants us to be transparent but that really isn't the relationship that I have felt for the six years I've been on this board um so I'm sitting up here today trying to take a step forward in a relationship but I want it to be a healthy relationship not a battered board member relationship because that's how it feels when we keep getting told how we're being treated um by some of the schools that have elected to be Charters thank you got um I uh 100% agree with Dr bringman and

198it's not just that it's the misinformation that is spread through the community um and then people come back with questions you know why do you hate Charters really we got five of them here and I've supported everyone and I'm I've given I've supported East blast budgets to give them non Capital Improvements technology Transportation Etc um the other point I wanted to make on that is Charters come to us and say hey we don't like what you're doing we want something different we think we can do it better we sit down with them and evaluate their proposal and then the school district and the charter school enters into a contract it's a charter contract they sign it voluntarily we sign it voluntarily it's a negotiated document where we talk about everything under the sun related to

199that Charter's relationship with the school district what's happened is we have signed Charter contracts and then some Charter say well gosh we got that wrong or we thought of something we didn't think of before so instead of coming to a phone call or a discussion or hey we need to do this we get sued all right I mean that's one way of doing business it's not a way to Win Friends and Influence People um if you've got a particular and we we're doing what we're supposed to do Under the contract right these requests for help us with our facilities were not in the charter contracts right so now it's a hey we want East Bloss money because the charter contract we negotiated and promised to adhere to doesn't cover the other things we need and

200are thinking of now and instead of having that discussion we get sued so I don't like that process either it is what it is at the end of the day my job as a board member protect public money make sure we do what we're supposed to do as a district based on the charter contract commitments we made and that's what I will continue to do let's vote okay all right um we're voting on the amendment um all in favor of the amendment all oppose to the amendment all right sorry I know okay now we're voting on the on the resolution correct okay all in favor of the resolution yes yeah the actual res yes good wonderful I'm sorry I'm sorry there was a motion earlyer that was early that was early yeah yeah okay all

201right okay uh we're not done no long range facility plan let's keep going assignment of fund balance [Applause] okay okay item 9 now y'all going to leave yeah y going to leave us here y'all just going to leave us here you pH assignment of fund balance I believe I believe we've talked about this enough uh the proposed assignment of $60 million will reduce the general funds on assign any fund balance but maintain reserves above the 15% acquired by board policy the funds will be reallocated to the capital projects fund for designated projects staff now recommends that the school board approve the resolution to assign 6 million from the general fund fund balance to support long range facilities planned thus be resolved upon recommendation of the superintendent that the board approved the assignment of general f

202fund balance in amount of $60 million for long range facility plan projects yes I'm doing this but I'm ready to go home go ahead thank you oh was that that was the motion that was a motion okay and that was a that was a second was that a second Mr Kowski okay any discussion no we're not done yet I ain't done either oh oh oh that's why I'm sorry okay hang hang all in favor all right okay okay we have any other requests appear here before the yeah yeah we do we have one person that signed up to appear uh to appear uh that's we're done yes H um Miss Isabella Frasier thank you you have three minutes good afternoon superintendent Dr Watts and other esteemed board members thank you so much for giving me

203the time to speak this evening my name is Isabella Frasier and I'm here as a gifted dual enrolled graduating high school senior but my achievements were not earned without struggle I was born into this world at a whopping 3 lbs 3 months ahead of schedule along with a long list of negative medical conditions that I've thankfully overcome I wouldn't be standing here today if it weren't for my Village that's been supporting me since day one a combination between family friends mentors teachers and so many more and it would be an honor to see them in the crowd as I walk across the stage currently Savannah chadam County students only have 15 graduation tickets an amount that only represents a fraction of the villages that have raised us this leads to difficult choices such as whether

204to invite your teacher who first taught you had a persevere or your Mentor who taught you the positive impact you can have on your community a choice between your aunt or your mom's side or your aunt on your dad's side both of which have never ceased to cheer you on or maybe it's a choice between the friend who taught you to talk to reach for the stars or the adviser who taught you had a dream I and countless other graduating students and future graduating students did not make it to where we are today through willpower and academic strength alone it is with the love and the support of the massive Villages behind each of us therefore I believe it is important not only for students but for the Savannah chadam Community as a whole to

205be able to come out and celebrate graduating classes on their momentous achievement thus I propose that the ticket amount be increased from 15 to 30 to better ow for each and every student to be properly celebrated supported and loved as they move on to this next chapter in their lives thank you so much and happy holidays thank you very much wow what oh by the way what school academy okay okay uh um we have David request a can I get three minutes yes here we go no you get one yes yes so um if you are still here we're trying to make this the longest meeting that Michael will ever attend after his last meeting so this is a filibuster um no no kidding um wanted to say congratulations on behalf of all the board

206for years your years of service um your point of view we have not always agreed that's one of your favorite things to say um and I will always keep that um but I know that you have always been dedicated to our students um and that you will continue to be dedicated to each and every student in this District um just chatting during all of our eoss discussion um Michael voted for E3 voted for E4 and just voted for E5 and um we're all going to be happy when E5 passes but to think about the Legacy and the footprint that you have changed on this County that will serve students um for years to come and probably years after you have uh left so understand that you are leaving behind a legacy on Savannah chattam County

207public schools with the work you have done here today um if we didn't eat enough at lunch um we got to stick around and eat a cake um because nobody gets to go home until it's all gone but I would like to lead us in a round of applause for uh Michael Johns [Applause] you may kiss the [Laughter] bride move to a move to a Jour and eat cake okay [Laughter] second all in favor all in favor yes [Music] was EX [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.