001are you testing okay everybody good just want to make sure all right thank you so much for the thumbs up the time is 7:04 let's call this meeting to order if you do not mind please standing for the Pledge of Allegiance thank you if we could have our five principles of the cruiser by Mr morbitzer and thank you for moving the flags our Cruiser professional Learning Community has grown so much over the last several months and I I want to point out that most of the credit for that growth goes to our teachers they've been fantastic to work with these are the five principles of our Cruiser PLC I invite everybody to say them with me we here's what we do we focus on learning we collaborate we take responsibility we ask what are the
002results we decide what to do next thank you thank you Mr Treasurer if we could have roll call please Mr K Mrs D here Mr here M gray here M here thank you all pres and accountant for Mr Vice President if you could go for our belief statement and board Norms please believe all Cruisers are are valuable we will unconditionally serve support and Inspire therefore every Cruiser will maximize their unique purpose potential and power to produce the results they want as leaders of the district we will always strive to support the mission and vision of the district be prepared informed and ready for meetings respect one another as elected representatives of the community be open-minded and recognize one another's strength value of diverse perspective and mutual commitment to the mission and vision of the district
003allow members to complete their thoughts and statements before other comment allow members to be heard and listen to all perspectives with an open mind stay focused on the task at hand and respectfully redirect each other when needed maintain confidentiality and communicate per board policies ensure trust and transparency in all dealings after a vote is cast leave meetings United as one voice no matter the outcome thank you so much Mr Vice President we could move to our agenda approval if I could have a motion please move second I have Miss graay first Mr Bower second I have a couple um um wanted to uh make a motion to add the safety committee meeting under board item F board items and make that one please I I have a second are we allowed to add yes I
004I verified with uh legal counsel um and if I could make a statement um I know that Miss Walsh you must you sent me several emails um which was right on Monday um when I was in the middle of meeting so I did not see them before the time frame to actually change the agenda as requested so they were not ignored just for the record but there were several that came in on Monday um so again I confirmed with legal counsel we could make the motion to add because of the way it was noticed so it was reviewed prior to so we're not violating open meetings act so again my motion is to add the board uh the ad safety committee meeting update to F board items one do I have a second Mr treasur
005do you have all that did I go too fast nope I'm good okay just want to make sure we're Fally all right am my second was Miss gray um could you clarify I'm sorry could you clarify were you saying S as in Sierra no I said uh board items F so fank board items yes Frank our Fox Trot if we want to use the phonetic spelling or alphabet so it'll be Fox Trot one um so it would shift everything down thank you yep and Miss gray was the second on that Mr kersner okay so if we could have roll call for that motion Please Mr Treasurer Mr Krishner hi Mrs dber hi Mr B hi M gr hi M hi thank you motion passes um and then I had one more um item that would
006like to make a motion to move on the superintendent's agenda item get to my apologies uh so superintendent agenda G item number it's the department reports nine if we could move that after is it n or 10 no oh is in board dos I think we move he's moving things as we do it yeah yeah so move that up please right after public participation if we could or we could just add it um E1 and just Shi that down I'll second so move G10 to E1 please that's a first li second liby correct right thank you if we could have roll call Mr Treasurer yes Mr kersner Mrs I Mr B hi Miss gray hi m i all right motion passes thank you everyone I don't know if anyone else has any other comments um
007pertaining to the agenda for this evening before we move to approve the mod now changed agenda with those two items any other comments from colleagues all right if we could have roll call Mr Treasurer Please Mr K M D hi Mr hi M gr hi m i right we have an agenda so we are now on to public participation do we have any public participation forms okay so I will move on to uh E1 which is now just the can we confirm that none came in late I know that you checked right before the meeting started is there anyone that has a public participation form that did not get turned in to any any of the our administrators this evening we just want to make sure we give an opportunity okay all right thank you
008guys so much and thank you for being here right so therefore I will save you the time in reading our public participation statement and move to recognitions um E1 which is now just the board update from the superintendent um on those items the board report thank you so there's a a couple items in the department update from the superintendent the one that I think U the reason we're moving this early is to talk about uh school safety and the work we're doing about that I'm going to ask Mr smatters are you going to do it from here do you want to go to the mic okay he's going to go to the podium um and bring us up to speed on what's going on good evening I just want to uh take a minute to
009kind of talk about what's going on and I'm sure you guys have some questions and I'm going to leave some time for you to ask questions for me but I want to share with you about what's going on at the high school um there seems to be uh lately a couple of large fights where it's more than just it wasn't a one-on-one fight it's a group of kids versus a group of kids and there seem to be a couple of them but I want to start off with that the start the school year the high school staff and the high school administrative staff did an outstanding job setting the culture and expectations we went through the fall had a great football season and pep rallies uh great student attendance at the football games and it
010just seemed like we were going and heading in a really good direction I want you to know that the number of fights this semester is down down significantly from this time last year and including the year before so I just went back to the last two years so in 2022 we had 124 students involved in a fight and that's just first semester so first semester 2022 124 students first were 124 students were involved in a fight 2022 correct 22 than is that at the high school yes I'm only talking about the high school okay thank you um in 23 we had 126 students involved in a fight I'm going to explain this in a minute and this year as of to date which we only have a couple days left it's 988 students involved in
011a fight so I'm going to break that down a little bit it's not always a oneon-one fight sometimes it's a fight between one person and another and then their friend or friends jump in and they're all involved in that singular fight that so we had 98 students involved in a fight but we've only had 32 incidents of fights within and so I'm gonna that's for 2024 correct this is current right now yeah thank first semester so I also want to share with you kind of how that lays out a little bit we had 32 incidents of fights 98 students were involved in it 87 of them 87 of the 98 were put up for expulsion of the 87 35 were expelled 22 were expelled and held in in parts of it held in advance which
012of probation 30 of them were not expelled and 11 were not even recommended for expulsion of those 32 fight incidents in the 8 998 student involved in it 33 uh charges were filed with the police of the 33 nine were of assault and 24 for disorderly conduct so that's kind of how it plays out um the kids this year have been doing a really good job this last incident yesterday that seems to kind of grab a nerve the videos that were out are uh juveniles without their consent um it's also within our school and it looks worse than what it was all our current staff broke that fight up within seconds it was in a cafeteria with 500 kids in it everybody was safe nobody got hurt we were able to separate the kids call
013the parents and and move on with the day and we were able to settle the kids down in the cafeteria quickly and serve everybody lunch and everybody got fed that day it it was to be honest with you the staff there did an excellent job it was me personally who turned to officer Boo and said we might need a couple more police officers to help I I didn't know where it was going at the beginning but I'm awfully proud of how it did and and everybody that responded we didn't actually need but they came and helped us and supported us anyway but the fight was taken care of quick swiftly with the staff that was already there uh kids do fight and we are trying our best to help kids make good choices and good
014decisions in everything that we do all our support systems our processes the way we do things the way we interact our relationships with our kids is about helping them make good choices and decisions and staying focused in that school and on track to graduate the overall thing we're mostly concerned is what are they going to do with their high school diploma and we've had a lot of discussions about that so I'm not just talking about the minute by minute that they're in their class while they're learning growing being successful and achieving it's what are they going to do with it what kind of people are they becoming what what kind of citizens will they be when they leave how what kind of production will they make in the workforce and follow their dream that's what
015we're worried about so along the way we are continually addressing overwhelming amounts of kids with social emotional needs food insecurities housing insecurities as well as anger and Trauma coming from the home on top of that us with the programs that we have because we have Outsiders agencies helping us with that and more willing to do more to help us but on top of that is the social media and the quick access that they have to each other where bullying harassment uh name calling calling people out and people are getting Brave on social media that create problems that come into the school and we try our best once we know about it to deal with it mediate it uh but we're not able to get all of it and a lot of times they don't tell
016us about it so um I just want to open that up and let you know kind of the doing a good job over there and I'm really proud of them I'm proud of the staff uh we did adjust some things that were happening over there to kind of tighten the ship down we we uh put a lot of structures in place in the lunchroom which may heard about but the kids come in they sit down uh they get comfortable and then we start dismissing by table so we can in an orderly fashion make sure everybody gets lunch without ditching lines and uh making sure everybody gets fed we're we're being pretty strict about in the hallways and and having hall passes and and having permission to be anywhere in the school and making sure they're
017in their assigned area but mostly making sure they're in their classes learning you can't learn if you're not in class so having a sense of urgency and a priority to be in class the entire time and not miss a minute of instruction is important any questions well I'd like to say maybe few things to to add to what to Mr Smither said um first I want to say as obvious as this is I think it needs to be said the last thing that any of us want is violence in our schools we want our kids to feel safe we want our staff to feel safe we know that if it's an unsafe environment or doesn't feel like a safe environment learning is not a priority it goes way down the list so you know if
018if there's any thought that we don't want safe schools um that that couldn't be further from the truth Additionally you know there's there's some thought that we're trying to hide things or cover things up I think we're probably one of the most transparent districts when there's something that goes on now we can't give specific details about events but we send things home to families and and notify which I feel like in sometimes it almost adds to this because people think that it grow port's the only place this is going on I'm I'm telling you and and again there there are fights to go on in probably every High School across the Across America that's not right we don't want that but this is not isolated we're working really hard to reduce those even with this
019blip that that more than a blip it was a large increase for a short period of time it still show knows that the the occurrences of fighting and violence is reducing we're making progress we know that kids come to principls and guidance counselors and teachers because they want to mediate they want to talk they want to try to avoid things uh the other thing is um I think sometimes people misunderstand when we say that that we have zero tolerance um for violence in school and and and what that means can we guarantee that there's not going to be fights in school I think everybody knows the answer to that the high school is almost a quarter of a million square feet we have 2,000 kids and hundred and some teachers if something if if if
020a fight is going to happen we can't be everywhere all the time and intervene everything now I think we've made a lot of progress and having kids make better choices to calm down to not do things to tell people to get help um but there's no way we can guarantee that there's not going to ever be a fight or a bad incident but when we say with zero tolerance we take a very Firm Stance that we do not want violence in our schools and Mr Smothers gave you some of the statistics um and you know some were suspensions some were with expulsion recommendations and some were with legal consequences that's when it gets down to the details of what happened to the situation um how how did it happen how long was it going on
021was it planned or did other people jump in did they stop what adults got on the scene um you know was it one side there's all sorts of things that take into consideration for a level of it's not a fight is a fight is a fight if if it's a situation where there's a scuffle and they immediately stop and break it up and the first time offenders that's different than people running and jumping in and refusing to stop when adults are on the scene and that's why we have different levels of response to that the other thing um you know I tell you we take firm stances against this we also don't just we're not just trying to throw kids out of school we want to make sure that better choices are being made sometimes
022in cases um there are things held in a bance to get uh students to get assistance with anger management or counseling or or different things like that to give them another chance that if it doesn't continue that they get a reduction of days but when when we talked about something being held in abeyance that probation that Mr SM has mentioned if you violate the abeyance then the expulsion goes back into effect uh so it's it's we're trying to balance we want we want the schools to be safe we want everybody to be there to be able to focus on learning and have support we're take severe consequences when bad decisions are made but we're also not trying to throw kids out and say that you know you don't have any chance or any shot here
023as well so it's a it's a fine line to do that one other thing there was some of the things where there's no um expulsion recommended there are different sets of rules uh for students with IEPs as well that sometimes comes into play there has to be manifestation hearing so it's it's not as simple that a fight equals this there are different degrees of different things there are different circumstances but but again I I want to go back and say it's of no benefit for any of us anywhere in the district whether it's a kid employee administrator whatever to have violence in our schools we don't want that and we are doing our best to try to reduce and hopefully at some point eliminate those but you know it's it's not um it's not lip
024service I would I would argue that we probably have one of the most developed Safety and Security plans of any District in in central Ohio what we try to do to keep our kids and staff safe so I this was a little bit of a ramble and a rant but I just wanted to share some of those things to to paint a little bit more of the picture thank you thank you well said any questions I have a comment one thing that came out at our osba training I attended a class um regarding self policies and went and acted at the different School districts they showed very dramatic decreases in violence when the whether they did a bell to Bell or whe they completely took the phones away it had a dramatic effect because as
025they were talking about they they were saying the social media the interactions thing going things going on in the classroom Etc were leading evidently to the violence so I think a phone policy is uh is I know it's something we're working on but I think that could have a dramatic impact also um I think I think we should start with the basics and we're doing a poor job of of of our dress code policy there's there's like no enforcement it doesn't look like it dress food code policy when you go to the school Etc so I think I think that's something we need to focus on and also uh at the elementary level I I um I hear of kids in the elementary level cussing at teachers flipping teachers off and being disrespectful and I
026think we need to on the classroom level really start to teach that respect because as we said there's some students that just aren't responding to adults and uh I think the earlier we addressed that the better thank you any other questions or comments I guess I would have a question for Mr ker where would you uh get the information on the on the uniform piece or the out of compliance well when I visited the school and when you see the videos you see a whole lot of real short tops you saw a lot of hats and hoodies up and when I visited the classroom when I I'll give you an example um I I do scholarships for um for Bo State and we visited a classroom and when I went in uh half the class
027and this was during test standardized testing and there was a substitute in the room so let me put it that way but the hoodies were up about half the class was asleep a gentleman in the back of the room big big kid kind of did the cowboy thing turned around put his back to me and did and and started talking to a couple girls in the back and you know I said hey I'm speaking up here I I expect your attention and the girl started getting nervous and poiny and the young man got up and he started coming at me and I was a little nervous and then he actually grabbed a chair and sat at my feet and looked up at me and it occurred to me that these kids were very shocked and
028didn't exactly know how to react when someone took a command present and said hey give me your attention and so and even with that I there were still kids that really took a lot of prompting just to give their heads up and and so the hoodies are the hoodies are there I see the hoodies all over and just not just hoodies but toboggans and I think kids should have and I know we have a locker shortage of probably whatever it is three or 400 or 600 whatever but I I really would like to see the kids have a place to put their wonderwear so they don't have to have Hood hoods on but also I don't think they should have caps on that they can pull over their face and and that kind of thing
029so um my observations are that and then calls from parents I know that actually have had their grandchildren telling me that this type of um communication is going on in their classrooms if I can go back to one of the things you said earlier the uh osba um about the cell phone policy do you have that you yeah and I fig I would love to see I would love I've got a lot of notes on that and also um policy committee meeting so I figured at another date I put it out there but it was kind of late that we would hopefully do a kind of osba overview and share all that that's very significant to do that any additional questions or comments I just want to say I thank you to our our law
030enforcement in the back who are there at the school and our administrators and our teachers for their hard work um for working through I just want to make sure we publicly um recognize them um for what they've been doing in the buildings um I do have a son at the high school so I have more insight of kind of what's been happening and um I do appreciate the hard work and how they're really trying to make sure where there's things that may be out of the control that may be coming in from the neighborhood into the school on their hard work so I wanted to publicly say that thank you and I'd like to recognize Matt Matt he's one of our safety security yes they do an awesome job thank you sir yes and I
031meant security when I said law enforcement that doesn't include security I was not U missing security just for good thank you I oh sorry Libby okay um so with the issues that we're having I guess I just would like to understand what law enfor is suggesting for us to do if if there's something in addition to what we are currently doing and our current policy is is there something that we need to be reaching out to our community our families that we're just not doing is I mean you guys see it every day is there something out there that we should be looking into well to be honest with you I talk with them all the time we have monthly meetings with our our First Responders and they and we do come up with we
032we tackle issues and come up with Solutions and one of them about in this particular area I think we're doing a really good job of collaborating with each other but really as a parent and community outreach yeah and that's what I was wondering what parent and community outreach should we be doing that we're not doing right that I feel like a lot of this is coming from the neighborhoods coming into the school beforehand so what is it that we're missing what is it that we can stop before it walks through our doors well we keep having a lot of these parent meetings and you know to be honest with you it's it's a pleasure to meet people it's just unfortunate the way we're meeting but we end up having great conversations and they see it's
033a partnership but uh oftentimes they ask for help in what to do and and in in certain directions and saying that we know it but we can get people that do know it and we can get together and start talking about that maybe have some like paren Community assemblies and uh fairs or something like that that's what we're talking about and Miss gr we could definitely bring that to the parent advisory committee that we have too I know that came up during our conversation as well and then um Columbus has like their family engagement coordinators and figuring out what what that looks like at that's hoping maybe reach out to another dist that may have it and then there's some other programs too I know um with some of the things that I've seen I've
034just been trying to reach out and I think I sent you the little bit that I received I reached out to miss Moody with United Way and shared with you some of the stuff that I was kind of asking her about so I think that's maybe the one of the main things we could probably work on for parent advisory when we take it back to the committee to you know in addition to what administration is doing maybe our um I'm sorry I'll use the word command presence because I don't have a better term for it um but I'm wondering if there's a way whether it's some security people uh whether it's certain AIDs that we hire if there's not a way uh for these classrooms to be visited More Often by people because we have
035teachers that the students will take advantage of and substitutes that the teachers will take advantage of and that aren't managing the classroom probably to their fullest um so I'm wondering if there's a way to get a higher level of Engagement there and also how how we're measuring how we're doing with the teachers knowing their kids and the teachers communicating down to the families I think those are two areas I I know nothing honestly about the um the communication between teachers and parents and how how consistent that is or good it is good that is but I do know um I I believe we could we would benefit from more consistent visits to the classroom by people that um can address behavioral issues where some teachers may not be doing as good a job as they
036should be thank you um real quick I have a question you had mentioned um that some of the kids are offered um counseling and anger management classes are we in um how many kids are going through those um opportunities and then are we tracking any reoccurrences after they've taken those Mr Scott do you want to come up and well I yeah come on up if you want to but I'll say that we we are keeping the data on that the reoccurrences I'm not sure about and maybe Miss Scot can talk to you about that I I wrote that down I think that's a good point but we are keeping track of the people that were meeting with and the amount of it absolutely um part of one part of the the the process in working
037with the parents and building that relationship is that we do have the conversation to offer counseling um and to recommend anger management supports mediations those sorts of things and that is um something that I have personally recommended um and had that be um sorry a recommended condition um for abeyance or as a part of the expulsion because I consistantly tell our kids and our families our job is to help build resilient children that are able to develop um strong problem solving skills and it is very hard at their age without their brains being fully developed to be able to do that and that's why you know as part of the process and the relationship building we're asking them please come and talk to us and the snitching culture is Alive and Well in teenagers and
038so we are combating that with our conversations and trying to show that we are trusted adults we can have the confidential conversations and allow the adults to take on some of that weight and help them navigate through the process and so it's really important to us that along with the corrective action that we are doing things to build the foundation of resiliency for the students that really need that thank you so my questions I've had a lot of parents called me you know and one thing was how many security guards do we have in the building in the high school at the high school yes uh we have five there we share one with um the cruiser Cel and there is an additional one we don't count for the high school well sometimes we bring
039them but there's one at the clinic one at the clinic yeah the primary health one p is that our our security person or is that Primary Health person it's ours and Primary Health reimburses us okay um so said that no one was hurt but I'm hearing from a lot of parents that their students are very hurt they're afraid to go to school um because of bullying and harassment and I heard that we are helping the students who are getting in the fight and that's great what are we doing for these students who are afraid to go to school um who are being bullied not in fights but other the other piece of the puzzle well we it's the same type of services for those students too and we take an active approach to try to
040find those kids uh our teachers are paying attention we are asking uh students questions sometimes they don't want to let us know but we know something's going on so we can send them we can uh they can have private conversations with one of our social workers we have Concord we have our school counselors and we're going to help them how many counselors do we have at the high school five five school counselors two social workers and one person from Concord okay great oh and you said there were some structures now in the could you explain that a little bit because I I hav't heard about that and how that's telling um so in the lunchroom the kids are assigned to the cafeteria for lunch that's their assigned area they need to be there within the
041time of the bell rings when they arrive to the cafeteria they sit down and they get to choose where they sit there's not assigned seating they sit with their friends however they can only sit eight to a table we're not allowing kids to gather around the table larger than what the table can hold for safety reasons we're trying to make sure everybody's comfortable and safe so what we've also done is they come in find the table and friends that they want to sit with they sit with them and everybody sits down and settles in then we start dismissing tables and what we have done have colorcoded the tables so we'll say all purple tables you're dismissed and we rotate when we dismiss but we're also expecting everybody to uh take care of the area so
042we're always looking under the table under the chairs and on top of the tables for trash that needs thrown away we also push around the trash cans help kids remind kids to throw away the trash and keep the aisles clear of clutter and trash and in an orderly way they go get their lunch come back sit sit back down and stay seated there's no roaming around the cafeteria there's no sitting off on the walls there's no gathering in the corner it's they have to be the table spending time with each other relaxing and getting ready to finish out the rest of the day strong U Mr SMS talked specifically about lunch but there are procedures all day uh where kids can go after every class change we do Hall sweeps we check restrooms uh kids
043have to have passes if they're going to be in the hallway uh people have assigned areas to do when it's in the lunch period all the adults have been given assignments and tasks and and what to do and what their process is and where to go so just from a structural standpoint we're making sure that we're getting coverage all over we're doing a practice over and over to try to get the hallways clear kids need to be in their class or in the lunchroom get a controlled environment in the lunchroom it's just not a free-for-all so those are just a few examples of some of the structural things that are going on and there is a structured movement of PL of restroom visits we have the custodians touching Bas in the restrooms to make sure
044they're clean and stocked throughout the day so there's more adults and we also have a a rule that if you're an adult and you're walking you're not passing the bathroom without stepping in so there's constant supervision of adults within the restrooms with the complaints we've had a recent one where a kid was bullied and and somebody tried to take his phone um is it a possibility is this something we're looking at as far as maybe doing restroom monitoring making sure only two kids are going in at a time going the right restrooms have a hall pass that kind of thing is that is that something you can see as a reality so we have a system it's called smart pass it's electronic Hall Pass and uh to be honest with you we're only allowing one
045student at a time time out of a classroom and it needs to be for an emergency purpose we can see if a kid's asked to go to the bathroom every period on the smart pass uh but we are trying our best to monitor the restrooms at all times during the lunches we have two staff members at the lunch restrooms during lunch the entire time sorry we only allow five boys at a time and five girls at a time and one has to come out before another one can come in and we are constantly inside their checking so if we have an incident where you've got a couple kids bullying another kid that would possibly be Lun that would probably be lunchtime as far as you would think no uh but that is a the restrooms
046in lunchroom is a high incident area but because it's um it could happen anywhere I'm not quite tracking with the one kid at a time obviously we obviously are having more than two kids in a restroom at a time right well it's one kid out of a class there's on average 36 classes appear perod okay there are also restrooms at midpoints and in the ELA parts of every wing so if there's a student that has a pass to be out they should be going to the restroom closest to where their class is right on the same floor where their class is so it shouldn't you know if one kid's out from multiple classrooms I students should be walking from this Wing over here you meet a buddy you know in a different floor in a
047different Wing over there are we perfect on that of course not but that's procedural things we're trying to to get to to limit that so basically if a if a student has a restroom pass in their in room whatever if they're in a different Wing or on a different floor even with the pass they're out of signed area because they're not where they're supposed to be a pass isn't a free-for all to go wherever you want to go what's the mechanism for enforcing that how do you know how do I if I was a teacher how do I know if a kid's outside their Z let's say in the wrong restroom well we have adults walk in the halls and we check the passes or check the system and if we have a kid on
048the second floor in RAR from upper Pride okay going to the restroom we got a problem and so the classroom teacher wouldn't necessarily know until somebody else right found the student out of bar and then there's a reporting system for that thank you and during I will say this during movement student movement and class changes we do have staff stationed at the restroom during class changes at every restroom the number of days a maximum number of days of expulsion what is that well it depends on the situation and if it's extreme like weapons it could be a a full calendar year uh up to um 80 Days um typically students don't get expelled for the whole year okay and then how many days is suspension 10 10 the max is 10 Max okay so a
049suspension by definition is anything uh one to 10 days anything longer than 10 days is is an exposure okay and is there is there an ability to have requirements to complete anger management or some type of counseling for them to be able to return back to school absolutely and we do it all the time and Mrs Scott just talked about that it's we're trying to work with the families we're trying to help them learn from their mistake correct action make better choices and decisions and some of it is getting some of those help and so we come up with safety plans return to school plan and some of those plans invol anger management or conflict resolution um uh decision makings um or just go meet with somebody and the the maximum on the expulsion that's
050a state guideline is that correct right and I'm aware that there is a Senate bill in the house where they're trying to extend that and it's gone pretty far so hopefully that will continue um so I want to know about athletes so if we have extracurriculars if these students are expelled or they're involved in like we've seen a lot of three onone pipes right um I saw a kid with a hoodie in the tobog and pulled over his face so they wouldn't see who it is those kind of situations if we find out they're athletes what happens then or in extracurriculars um and their expell do they get kicked off the team are they suspended from that healer for a year how do we deal with that well if anyone is suspended or expelled they're
051they're not participating in extracurricular activities so they're they're not on the team they're not participating in games I will say it depends on certain situations but I think what you're getting at there's no favoritism we're they students and and what we're we're focus on them being students and making good choices the extracurriculars are extra so if they're on the football team team basketball team volleyball team and they want to fight and be violent in our school that's a part of the consequence one one thing I want to clarify because it sounded I I know what you were saying you said if students are suspended or expelled they're not on the teams if a student is expelled they're no longer student in the school and can't participate excuse me if a student is suspended they obviously
052can't participate when they're suspended but that doesn't automatically mean they're off the team right but there are there's an athletic code of conduct as well so that could lead to loss of playing time or could lead to removal of a team and and this isn't just talking about fighting this this could talk about any violations that cause suspensions when a student is a suspension and an expulsion are a legal action that's taking a student's right away to come to school and there's a due process and there's a hearing for each of those and and when I said an expulsion by definition is anything longer than 10 I I should share that you can suspend up to 10 days if it's going to be anything more than that an expulsion recommendation that is a second hearing
053with the hearing officer so it's it's another part of the due process and then a determination is made if there's going to be an expulsion for any additional days up to the more severe consequences right and what is that timeline for the hearings uh for the expulsion hearings we'd like to have those before the suspensions are up and the due process hearing is the media so if we're talking to a kid the due process is that we're going to hear their side of the story gather the facts get the evidence Look at video and actually get their statements and other statements and then we make a determination of suspension or not okay thank you what you haven't talked about in school suspension could you speak to that um what we have it how does it
054work so it's a it's another tier level of suspension or a level of corrective action so we go from talking to the kid conferencing with the kid or their parents to lunch detention to in school half days in school all day multiple in school retention to school so if you have a multiple in school suspension at the high school where do you go multiple in school a multiple day in school suspension what well you know there is Progressive discipline but it depends on the situation it really does uh there's so many variables that go into this and it they could get an in school for out of assigned area in school for you know disrespect or insubordination and you know if if n school is going to work and it will correct the action and
055the kid will get back to what they need to making good decisions then at work we're not looking to add and progress if we don't need to Mr kerser were you asking physically where do they got right yeah is there is there a particular like the in school room oh yeah we have a classroom you have one classroom side for in school system yes okay and we have a in school monitor okay thank you sorry I misunderstood anything else go um is that at the middle schools too that they do that scho classroom court and all that yeah thank you thank you thank you sir borrow this uh since this item is up the other couple things it's later in the packet the human capital items I'm just going to touch base on these and
056know you can read them um wrap back and and I think Mark has talked about this before that's when we get if someone would have some type of an offense that we get feedback uh on on licensed and and they added non-licensed employees this year that enrollment was extended till the end of January I think it was originally the end of December and then uh this is just a being beginning of being developed but here's our current uh confirmed recruiting locations that we have going on and then teaching and learning um and again I I don't want to read this to you uh but it's basically give an overview of some of the things we're doing uh with our CK work that's our new uh curriculum uh for for language arts and show some of
057the things that um we're doing to implement that and working with the different buildings and and PD schedule trying to be quick any questions for me okay if not uh then that ends item G10 which would put us back to a recogn resolution so um Dr Miranda we have her here tonight and thank you for your patience you know you understand School business said it was very important that we talked about those things but we wanted to recognize Dr anthonette Miranda for her service she's our region 6 Ohio departmental Department of Education and Workforce um member who is has I guess exceeded her term limit and so she is been a great partner with goport Madison schools uh for quite some time also she serves as our a contact for student teaching at OSU so
058we wanted to take this time and personally just thank you for your support showing up coming talking to the board speaking um with some board members speaking to families and students coming to some of our programs so we do have a resolution and there's some other things that we're going to get to use of that is why we had you here tonight so I'll turn it over to superintendent grou thank you president D berer um the superintendent recommends recognizing Dr anet Miranda for sustaining Service as a state of Ohio Board of Education member and dedication to the students of grpt Madison with the following resolution whereas Dr anet Miranda is a professor and director of the school of psychology program at theate University and holds the Casto professorship in interprofessional education and whereas Dr antoinet
059Miranda has spent well over 35 years in education both k12 and postsecondary she has worked as a school psychologist and urban suburban and scho districts in New York City Ohio and Kentucky and whereas during her tenure at Ohio State University Dr anet Miranda has consistently worked with school districts in a variety of capacities including providing professional development and college courses on site she has had a lifelong passion for making schools work for school AED children especially those most V vulnerable and whereas Dr antoinet Miranda was elected to the State Board of Education in November 2016 and was reelected in November of 2020 now therefore be it resolved that the goport Madison school's Board of Education recognizes and commends Dr anet Miranda for her outstanding service as the State Ohio Board of Education member and dedication
060to the students of grp Madison schools long e okay I'm I'm actually really excited about this next presentation um this is something that is wonderful for our teachers and our kids and obviously our families as well um and and it's it's I think a somewhat Cutting Edge way to be able to provide different opportunities for our kids and and I'm not I'm not doing any explanation the great explanation of discussing what it is uh but uh it's called Magic Ai and Carol do you want to introduce it a little bit and introduce our curriculum coordinators absolutely um Shannon uh Beaker and Liza humph are our curriculum coordinators and they brought to my attention and introduced me to Magic School Ai and the first time that I saw it I was just absolutely Blown Away um
061and I think the best way is to show you some of the things that it does and immediately when I saw it I'm like we've got to get this for our teachers and what it can do for them what it can do in their planning and what it can do for our kids um just a simple thing they can take any document drop it in and it immediately can translate it to any language that we ask it to um you know and I know there's a lot of reservations about Ai and education if we're not embracing it we're behind and so the nice thing about magic school AI is it's it's a closed AI platform if you will there is a student side of it we're focused right now on the teacher side of it
062um the in the the document that's in the board docs there's a couple links that I encourage you to go to kind of look at the FAQs look at the different things that it has but there's so many tools and I'm actually going to have Shannon and Liza show you some of the things in real time that we have trained our teachers to use that they're using daily and then we are going to constantly give them updates with the new tools that magic AI um that that it offers so I which one's up Liza's first hi good evening so we were really excited to introduce these tools to our teachers it's something that Shannon and I have been going to for a couple of years because it's just so useful and such a timesaver so
063we've been like rolling out specific um tools to the teachers during our professional development days that we've been having and we also have been giving time to our teachers during CT time so we've been doing small groups like most recently I went over to Middle School Central and worked with the um El team there and I showed them there's a student feedback tool where you can actually use the Ohio State rubric from the state test drop that in as an attachment and then you just set your parameters you can put the prompt in drop your student um work in there the sample and then it will give you feedback both positives and negatives and then if you put you can keep drilling down and then the actions if you say grade with the rubric then
064it will actually grade each section of the rubric like the state would grade that so it's such a time saer I received several emails back from the staff saying like you know they explained to the students how they would be grading their final um essay but it was just good to get some feedback like on the spot as they were doing it so Shaya and I just wanted to kind of to show you live just some of the tools that we've been highlighting this year and if you look on um what we have projected here the there's so many tools and I'll just kind of scroll down these are all the tools offered I mean you can see there's presentation generators there's multiple choice quizzes there's worksheets there's report card comments there's emails that you
065can respond you can drop an email in and then you can say who your audience is what what kind of things you want to say and it will promt um one I really want to show though um that is fairly new me get back up here it's called lesson hook so we all know that especially when we're talking about standards sometimes it's very difficult to get students excited like you say hey we're going to do some State Standards they're not usually like really excited over that so this is kind of like a way to like secretly get the standards going without them knowing what you're doing so this is how easy this is so you see there's two prompts on this venu so we have a grade level so I'm going to choose since I
066just worked with middle school I'm going to choose seventh grade and then I'm going to put in I could put in a topic I could put in a standard I could put in a text I'm going to actually put in one of their standards so I'm going to do RL 7.1 which is for those of you who don't have the standards memorized right off the top of your head that is a text evidence and that's the one that we see starting in our third grade test so by seventh grade this is something our students are very familiar with I don't have to put Ohio it'll know I used this enough times it kind of recognizes me so what this does is if I was going to be a teacher and start my standard on text
067evidence and I thought okay how can I hook my kids and not just say here's our I can statements here are some activities I can do and you can see like some that they pulled up here are the mystery character clue hunt which is the scavenger hunt because when you're using Clues you're using text evidence you're not saying that but that's embedded in this activity you can see there's one called character Hot Seat where you choose students to be characters and they have to take on some of these details again there's your text evidence then we have like a character comparison chart well because this is so advanced in what you're doing I was like okay well let's try this we know that the outsiders is a novel that seventh graders use I mean probably
068some of you remember reading The Outsiders I remember reading The Outsiders so if I like this U mystery character clue hunt I'm going to type right in this bottom section where it says it's right next to the button actions so what I'm doing is I'm prompting it to be more specific so I'm going to say uh create the mystery character clue hunt activity with the book The Outsiders and notice I don't even have to say who's the author anything about that book and then I come over here to this little carrot and click and it's like okay here's your objective okay here yeah I'll go back up it thinks for quite some time can we use this for life well that's what we've said if it ever disappears because we use it so much I
069mean it's just good to get like some ideas that would take us you know days to do but here you can see here's this mystery um clue hunt for The Outsiders they've got materials clue cards I need envelopes to hide the clues I need large chart paper and here's your preparation and they've put they've singled out the characters for Pony Boy here's one of his direct quotes for Johnny here's one of his direct quotes So you're secretly hooking the students on RL 7.1 the text evidence and they don't even know they think they're playing a game to do it so now to extend from that I'm going to back out and Shannon's going to show you the lesson plan generator and how you can build a lesson so Liza stole a little bit of my
070thunder with that last one but I'm still going to go ahead and go through this um one of the great things um and Carol kind of mentioned this earlier when she was introducing it but um all of the tools continue to evolve and um so there was originally a lesson plan tool you can see that in the second row there um but one of the great things they've actually come out with recently is that you can customize any of the tools specifically to you so um Liza talked a little bit about how you prompted well I have taken some of the work out of this I'm going to pretend I'm a third grade math teacher for uh example tonight um and what I've done is I went ahead and programmed into the tool certain prompts
071that I wanted to consider so um already programmed in here is an I can statement I asked it to provide suggestions for how I can Target my English Learners how can I do differentiated questioning for my gifted students but also those that are um struggling on IEPs or 504s or have other needs um so that's already programmed in here all I have to do then is Type in one of our standards so this one um if we don't know that one that's U multiplying and dividing within 100 for our third grade students and I don't need to include any additional criteria unless I want to it's already tied to Ohio learning standards and we generate now lesson planning if you've never done this as a teacher can take a considerable amount of time and it's
072the most important thing that you do and literally within seconds we have an entire lesson planned out for you now magic school does um caution its users uh with what they call the 8020 rule so 80% of what's there is something that you're going to want to use the other 20% you're using your professional judgment so you want to look for bias you want to look for um things that might be incorrect AI right now can't do math problems specific kind this particular kind in uh particular so you have to use your professional judgment but you can see here we've got assessment we've got key points um if you didn't use the hook tool maybe how to open with your students and it just goes through you can see down here at the bottom those
073um the prompts that I put in for differentiated questioning suggestions for English learning and so on so that's all there and just like Liza showed you you can continue to prompt that and it'll narrow it down if you want um additional information on how do I Implement one of these activities um we could say sorry I have to go back up to look because it's different every time did I miss it um I was looking for my hands on there it is at the bottom okay so I could just say um create word problems for the word let's see so just create word problems for our number line jump station and rather than having to go out and hunt for those word problems myself again within seconds we have all of those available for the
074teacher to use within their classroom um and be able to implement right away so um that was all we wanted to show you just like a just a teeny tiny portion of what we're um giving to our teachers to help them make their jobs easier um and and to be more efficient in what they're doing just a couple things number one you said these are obviously tied to our standards and and so if you just look at those problems developed or the lesson plan the time it would take a teacher to either cut and paste that from somewhere or write those things out and put the plan in place and again if 80% of it's great and 20% of it you scratch from that no harm or you might refine what what terms you use
075to to do it but that also creates these activities and lesson plans and things to do that we know are aligned with the standard to the level that the standard should be taught if it's a third grade math it's going to be at a performance level that a third grader should be able to do seventh grade ELA whatever so we know that the work being identified and the planes being identified are to the appropriate levels and definitely addressing the standards th this this would have been such a gift to a new teacher coming in to be able to do things like that and I know you want to be done and I don't know I might turn this to to Carol but okay when we first saw this when she showed this at cabinet she
076was doing some different it was like a creative tab or a fun thing you had you had people doing wraps about US history and I mean there's all sorts of crazy stuff you can do that's that's really kind of fun and exciting yeah we did a a rap battle um I believe it was between George Washington and Abraham Lincoln um it's not called rap battle okay that matching was it AUD there's also the S maybe that's what it was song generator all right well this was a we'll do a song about Mr SMS is that okay details in the song he loves safety he loves coffee he is mad at the Buckeyes and we will play that to Journey so it doesn't play it to the music but you you'll get the idea now the
077more information I give it obviously it would play um let's turn up this was not a setup at all they didn't know I was going to ask this they're they're doing this on the fly right now Mr sma's Safety Journey just a small town teacher living in his classroom safety on his mind coffee in his view Buckey make him frown but he doesn't care he's got passion burning and he'll always be there Don't Stop Believing in safety's Golden Light Mr smatters keeps on teaching holding cofo so tight Don't Stop Believing his passion burning bright safety is his mission and he'll win this fight some Will Mock his coffee some will laugh his way but he stands for safety every single day Ohio State can't shake him he's got principles to share a teacher with a
078mission showing students that he cares Bridge safety rules coffee's cool cool Mr Smathers knows the truth his lessons shine like proof Don't Stop Believing in safety's Golden Light Mr smatters keeps on teaching holding coffee oh so tight Don't Stop Believing his passion burning bright safety is his mission and he'll win this [Laughter] fight I will say she's more energetic now I think that's an update um and so you know and we tried a different things the one rap battle you could put two different characters in and you know they it'll come up with which one was more influential um to history and but again if you try to enter something that they it because it is a an educator platform it won't allow you to do something inappropriate and it'll give you a message of
079this is probably not an appropriate topic please select another so I know I think when you think of AI Educators have been nervous about it it is something we need to embrace um we still are trying to figure out the students side and how we want to go about that but this is such an amazing tool for teachers and principales administrator aters I mean you can create a newsletter you can create an email you put your information in and it generates it real quick and just to clarify now we did an Ela in a in a math with content areas and grade levels that this anything so one of the the PD that we did in October one of the examples we gave was create a physical education um physical education lesson using a hula
080hoop and something else and it generated a lesson so it's it's something that we're constantly updating our teachers with the new tools you know we have a PD coming up on January 6th and we're showing them the new tools that have have come out since October um but it's amazing for our teachers and when I went to Adam and said we need to get it he knew we needed to get it so we made fun of him too just to kind of add on to that um some of the tools there's one that is chatting with a historical character or you could do a book character so just trying to extend it into other areas if you're a science teacher and you want them to chat with um a scientist that's no longer living they
081can go in and they can ask questions and the tool has already set those parameters and it knows about that character and so it responds as if they are that person um likewise with history you could pick a historical figure it does have some limitations it's not up to date as of today so you know I think it may be like five years back so if it's a newer person you may not be able to use that but certainly um some of some of the older folks in history we can do that kind of a cool tool so I know you mentioned a little bit about it but I wouldn't quite sure if it I caught it right so if say you've got third grade and you've got students that are a little bit above
082third grade in your class and you got students that are behind yeah does it adjust it can you tell it to adjust it based off of that so that you're teaching the same subject but you're teaching them at different levels it does and so that was one of the things that I included in my promp when I made my lesson um I kind of just kind of leaned over it um but the the differentiated questioning you could also ask for an extension activity for your students who are finishing uh the lesson quickly and it would give you ideas for what they could do to extend their learning um whether that's still within the same grade level or it might connect up to the next grade level um and likewise you could ask it to help
083you scaffold for students who are lower performing and it'll give you some guidance as to how you might break that down for those particular students um likewise it might give you some additional strategies like using visual aids or um other manipulatives that would help the student to understand the concept and that would be included in that materials list like if there's the scaffolding for the yes and if it doesn't you could ask it specifically that's how you can prompt it then um you know there were no materials included create the materials or list the materials needed for this particular activity and if you notice at the bottom of the screen like even when Carol did the song it has some prompting for you so if you're not sure it's like right here in this area
084okay I see it so you can see even though she was doing a song this one asked what are some engaging activities to teach safety principles it knows like what however you drill down it keeps making it more finite so it'll prompt you to think of things that maybe you might not have please make sure you send me that though we we will download that yeah you can create a free account so if you're interested in getting on and playing around with it those links again are on your uh slideshow do we think that this is going to help us Recruit new teachers as well just with having this software in our district I think it's something that we definitely talk about when we we go out because this is this is huge the amount
085of time this saves teachers and not just time but as as we played with it and we have many years I'm not gonna talk about our age but many years of education or being teachers and the creative ideas I'm like oh my God I wouldn't have thought that about that you know just the ideas that it gives the teachers they may not use the lesson to the fullest but it gives them a spark of what may maybe the route they could go you know the other piece we talked about gifted we brought gifted back into all of our buildings sometimes that's challenging to figure out that that lesson and how can I extend it for those students now you enter it and it gives you a lesson so that we're not just having gifted students
086do more work no that's that's not how we serve gifted students we do a different differentiated assignment not just more and so sometimes that that's difficult so that was part of our training that we did in October was we made certain okay and our lesson now how could you change that lesson for your gifted students so to to give them that idea those ideas it's pretty amazing the one thing that from reading some of our student applications you know they're wanting to way the way that teaching is done they want it differently and they like when I last year when I did talk to the students in the elementary level they were like I loved when was during Co because we did activities it was more one onone or when they had the um we
087had the security breach and they couldn't use their Chromebooks they love that one-onone and this I feel like will give that opportunity to be more creative with their classes and think about what you just said so in one of the prompts we could have created an assignment and said create an assignment does not involve technology oh that's a good and so the more you enter and the more you help drill it down you know there's there's infinite possibilities I'm sorry if you told the AI to create a plan that didn't involve technology wouldn't it just shut off immediately maybe you want to see you want a you want a a worksheet or you want a lesson plan and it does save the results over on the left side where you see where it says output
088history that's over in that toolbar so anything that youve created it automatically saves it and you can go find it again so everything that you create stays in one spot your your account do we have it to where we also share like where if we create something and say that particular building wants to say this third grade teacher got this amazing plan and was like oh this would be great to just kind of shares their way to kind of make it available in the platform for others within our do can share it that way is it public just within our district or is it public within the entire universe I think we we watch I think you could do both you could do within our district yes so I just put in this is the
089same standard 3083 so it's a math standard create a lesson that does not use technology and requires the students to move around the classroom and I was thinking what do we know that with the percentage of other districts in Franklin County since that's our competition that's using this tool so we're talking about like Mr B VP B question I don't know all the the local districts who are using it they brought it to us and um as soon as I saw it I'm like yeah we're um a multiplication relay race math movement stations and then you could you know what about a student maybe I have a student that is in a wheelchair how could I differentiate that assignment and so I will say I do not like presentations where it's been on the fly
090but I think it was important for you to kind of see this on the Fly because that's how easy it is to use no it was great we I appreciate it personally thank you I also think magic AI is a much better name than the original name of Skynet so Carol this seems program that you you were talking about W everything to be cohesive across the district and that's going to help with this um yeah and I think one of the things too is it helps teachers really understand that grade level content you know sometimes teachers look at that standard they you especially new teachers they look at the standard they think they know the level that they should be asking but maybe they're just not right quite there well this it automatically based on
091the standard it's going to give you some foundational skill sets also but it's going to give that great level content for that consistency that we need yeah and is this replacing any other programs because I know you thought have all these programs we got to narrow that Focus not yet necessarily we are actually and funny you say that on January 6 at our PD we are doing a resource audit of all of our teachers what are the resources that we're using you know maybe there's something out there you know I learned about this just a couple months ago is there something else out there that can really be beneficial and maybe could eliminate some other things we don't want to eliminate it if it's being used and it's a good resource so we want to
092make certain we get a good audit of what's being used well that sounds very Miss F I also wanted to um just mention when we were trying to get all of the schools on board together we talked about sharing it within the platform um but something that Liza and I are attempting to do is to create a drive of resour for the teachers so that if they do come up with a really fantastic idea they can drop that directly into a folder and share that across the buildings as well so as we try to get that alignment between the schools um this is obviously some really creative ideas that it can come up with let's share this out with all of the teachers well that's nice and then the hard question for Adam what is
093the cost of this is this a software license for student or is it for the district it's for the district they gave us a pro-rated and I believe for the rest of this year started in October was just over 19,000 for this year so we signed a two-year contract next year it was I want to say for next year because it would be the full year I believe it was 28 maybe 29 right around there okay so we wanted when we wanted to try it out but we also wanted to to get it for two years before they jacked that price up because I think it could go up eventually so we're locked into that that price for next year based on our contract and you said you're G to set us up so we
094can play around with it a little bit you probably can with your your go Cruiser account with your Cruiser email you probably can oh so anyone who a go Cruiser access can ACC oh Mr Mr Our IT director says that is not so sorry you can't but with but on the on the main site separate from our account that we have for the school if you just go to magic school anyone can set up a magic school account and you have the pro version for 30 days so you can play around with all of the tools and kind of narrow things down and then after the 30 days it goes back to some limited tools but it's still fantastic even with the free version I did we one question in regards to special education and
095how this works when we have gifted and then those that may be on the IEP and may need additional time are there prompts and things and it and what is that okay I just thought I asked and see what there was any input from Dr yeah just like we we talked about with the um where we could prompt it to to write some some questions for gifted students you may say could you do level questions for struggling students that could get them to this point you know could you break it down by the foundational skills and it'll promp it'll send everything so there's like a student that's on a 504 IEP you can kind of put in with those uh those those things to work with them on in that prompt and then it could
096kind of help that teacher that maybe KN in this instance kind of guide room through that lesson that's awesome so it's not just your gen everybody can everyone can have it thank you you're welcome can we go back we did not we had the resolution and I I did not want to interrupt the um amazing presentation and our our our folks that came in but we did not get a uh vote on the resolution so um if we could have a first and a second for the approval of the resolution second point of clarification what what are we we're going back to the resolution for Dr inette Miranda we did not actually vote on it we got excited we took our pictures and then we got all excited about magic school AI but I didn't
097want to interrupt the momentum of the presentation but did not want to Forfeit approve uh getting this action item out the way before or we move forward thank you you're very welcome do we have a first we do so the first was Miss gray is that correct yes and miss that Mr B a second correct yes all right if we could have roll call please Mrs W hi Mr Gray hi hi M hi hi all right motion passes all right back to you I think we we on we added it would be our safety meeting would be first if there's an update from the safety meeting so I know I see Miss com I don't know if that' be Mr SMS Miss just to talk about what happened at the last safety meeting or who
098will be doing that thank you good evening again uh we had a wonderful uh District safety committee meeting and we spoke about threat assessments and what that looks like from an administrative standpoint the investigations the follow through with the threat assessments how much time it takes who all is involved the threat assessment teams at each of the buildings and the threat assessment team within the district and also our threat assessment protocol system that we use and if you want to come up uh Jamie Scott is the one that presented the threat assessment at our district Safety Committee she did an outstanding job I wish more people could have heard it we probably should have recorded it it was outstanding we had great discussions afterwards and um I just thought we might have to do it
099again and offer it again to see if more people come in it was that worthwhile and important and excellent so you want to speak to it thank you yeah so one thing to know about me I am a crime Junkie um I love listening podcast to have about an hour drive each way um so this presentation I did a lot of research on um some specific um school um violent um incidents that have happened in the past and listen to a lot of cases and things because it was important for me with this presentation it was originally designed for administrators and I wanted them to be able to see how important it is to not only pay attention to each step um and look at the the the body of evidence but also to involve
100your team and house goo 123 um in the state of Ohio is the one that prompted uh threat assessments and risk assessments for students and it also showcased how schools should approach the threat assessment in the past um a lot of threat assessments were conducted by the administrator and the people who were directly involved in a particular incident that led to the threat assessment but with the new protocols that were developed with the Secret Service in different um threat assessment agencies it really prompts the teams to bring in other adults that would be considered trusted adults with that student because we want to to make sure that we get a full picture of that student and everything that has impacted their lives and um open it up to the team and when we talked about
101the team members I've had bus drivers on my threat assessment teams I've had custodians and Food Service workers because they tend to have great relationships with kids because they're not the ones in charge of them in the classroom right and um and responsible for for grades and and things so it's really important plus we have a um community volunteers and coaches and things like that so um I really wanted to stress with our team that it's important to make sure that it is a team approach to this so that we have a really good picture of the student um and then also I was so thrilled that even with the weight of the information that I presented all of our administrative Team all the things that were missteps from the schools in my case study
102our team was spot on before I even got to where the other schools had had taken some some deviations From the Path so um we have great teams and I'm very thankful for that but it was a great opportunity to be able to get in front of them and say these are things that happen and and in the busyness of the day like take the time to get the team together involve your teachers invol your your staff um to make sure that we are gathering all the information that's available to us and and making the appropriate recommendations um and getting those safety measures in place um Lippy do you have something you want to add um I just thought it was really interesting when you did that because it was it actually took a real
103life situation and went through all of the different areas that what each person knew was going on but didn't share together and then when you bring it together it was like oh wow we missed it here we missed it there missed it and it was it was really good to see and and I agree that to have so many different people involved not just have administrators involved because they're not communicating with these students like a bus driver is or cook or you know it was it was a good presentation I appreciated it right and I just want to say that um she didn't mention it but we're looking at threat assessments threats of harm to other people but also self harm but if you think about this and unfortunate we have a lot of incidents
104in our country where we've had some incidents and then when they happen everybody starts to take a step back and wonder what happened then they start to connect the dots and they're like hey why didn't somebody say something why uh why didn't we recognize this why didn't we do anything we're connecting the dots now and it it's we're mandated to do this we're mandated to do these threat assessments and uh de beond school it's working out so now kind of like what you said we're not waiting for something bad to happen we're starting to recognize and then we're starting to intervene and provide help and support so um like I said it was a great presentation I wish more people could have been there and maybe we'll have to do that again maybe in a
105couple months and then after this is there like a way to kind of trend it and then look at better ways on dealing with other issues or looking at Staffing is that the okay so that's kind of like the long term you collect it analyze it collectively across each building and then determine additional steps kind of what we were talking about earlier staff or right okay yes um anything else Mr group you were there anything else no I think it was sufficiently covered it was it was a really good activity right okay thank you thank you all um we are on still on our board items the next item is our selection of board members a student advisory application our selection of those members so um according to the resolution it is uh for middle
106school and Elementary it's one um person per grade level per building and then High School is two students per grade for the high school just so I would like to make a motion to have it where it's um two per grade level at elementary and four per grade level per building at um middle school and school okay gra we had extremely large group that was applied and just think that we need to honor that I'll second you say again second it would be two per grade per building for elementary and four per grade per building for Middle School and High School per grade per building so four per grade for middle and high and then two per grade for elementary got it okay okay that's a motion by liby first yep and it was second
107by Mr Bower Mr treasur yes Elementary is fourth and fifth according to the resolution Middle School is all grades and high school is all grades and for a context we've discussed M um of several other meetings that we grandfathered um students in from the previous year um I was just making sure I gave you that information too again that students that were part of student advisory last year were grandfathered in they would just have to opt out if they did not want to can you turn I think can you turn your mic on sir no problem um so we're creating 36 slots for the elementary is that right is that too much or is that manageable am might wrong on no yeah she said that's right and then she I guess she's saying that can
108you explain why you wanted to add Mor G Miss gray for Mr kersner please no yeah I got the idea I just didn't know as far as a group size if that's becoming if you think that's good and manageable superintend gr um is it too much I just there was like aund applicant so for each Elementary it would be 12 right two per grade so be K one two three no only four it's only fourth andth we're not doing yeah otherwise that'd be a real big I I just did two for grade at nine schools correct Am I Wrong uh six Elementary six so scre 24 24 Elementary that's what I was hesit I was doing the ma in my head to make sure it was correct and we only have three middle schools so
109we updated those to four for grade so then we should be solid and then we just added four adding two more per slot for the high school EXC okay thank you no problem uh so we've got that is there any additional questions on this motion you think that's acceptable or is that too many no I I think that's very manageable um and it's a group where everybody can have a voice but it's also if a few kids are absent or can't come for another reason you know it's still going to be a nice size group okay thank you okay any additional questions or comments from the board before we go to roll call please all right if we could have roll call Mr treasur one question so exactly what is this vote on just that
110we're going to increase the number correct this is on the motion that Miss gray made to increase thank you um two per grade for the elementary and four four slots per grade for middle school and high school and Mr Bower has seconded that motion okay right if we could have roll call now Mr Treasurer Please Mr chrish Mrs dber hi Mr B hi Mr great I I motion passes all right now we're back to review of selection of members um I think there's a couple emails that I did not get to and I think Miss Walsh she had asked about criteria and last year we did not um make it about criteria we just reviewed the applications and where based off of students responses gave them the opportunity to sit at the table we also
111wanted to mix it up because we didn't want the same students um who were always um involved we wanted to give students who may not have the opportunity um to participate in a group of some sort for instance there were a couple who mentioned how they're in verts um they got involved it will like the opportunity I've read that on several uh couple applications per building um but I think that was your question so we did not identify criteria last year we did a discussion about students and um went from there so what I would recommend we won't name names for today we will use the line number of the Excel spread sheeet that's um that you have access to so we're not naming names so we're on the Excel spr sheet for new students
112the cell row starts at cell Row three so um just want to say that my criteria was how many per grade that's what I want I'm so sorry so and when we have the sixth grade there's like 10 returning sixth graders but now we're going to limit that to two or is that per grade per school for elementary oh that's midd school right four per grade per school and originally it was plus carryovers because there are going to be absences and every student's not going to be there in last year I covered um me and Seth kind of floated between the two and with the amount that we approved with last year's resolution we didn't have a lot of students sometimes it was only three or four five um there was one time we had
113everybody so um having the extra students will allow to have a decent group present for meetings and discussions if so then that means we will the grandfather in is that but we're still going to accept the new amount that we just voted on um a few minutes ago if that's clear so how do we make this elction I mean I have the ones that I last year we took the recommend we talked about our numbers and then um the the chairs kind of LED that but there wasn't a um a solid like voting method I went back and reviewed so it was more of a conversation and then you know you recommended who you recommended for elementary and we discussed those same thing for the other chairs but we did not do a a rubric
114and rent run anybody through anything like that we did not do that last year I would like to hear your recommendations for elementary and then if anyone else has any additional comments okay so for elementary just give the cell line like we start at three okay okay and can you pause for one second I want to make sure that um all colleagues have their ex the Excel file that was sent to you because that is what she'll be reading off of so you know which student she's speaking of um by the cell Row versus the name of the student or any other identifiable information so do you all have that pulled up it would have come from Miss ains in November I think it's the 22nd or 23rd to be specific are you ready Mr
115if you have the Excel file pulled up I'm just going to pretty much B to the the members who were there last time to whatever they out know if you were trying to get your file yeah we didn't want to move ahead of you it is open but I honestly think that um you guys will be fine at making that choice who were on the were on the chairs last time I will bow to your judgment yeah and last year we we all discussed I just wanted to make sure we were consistent so I'm sorry I was trying to the spreadsheet I didn't hear the discussion I couldn't I didn't have my closed caption in front of me and I would like to add though just John I hope you can hear me um I
116would like to see all the students who are on student council be part of student advisory if that's possible if they apply to be if they ask to be I think um that would be a good thing that's my only want right Miss gr okay um line four line five 15 16 17 I feel so this is like so weird 18 24 26 46 that's it I don't know how that many that came out because some of there was not to um for grade for building for some I think there was a couple okay can you count how many I think Mr power actually so I have if you want to follow along here I can just recap so four five seven 9 11 15 16 17 18 26 27 30 33 36 43 44
117and 46 Miss 28 okay 19 and that also included some that were returned okay and actually out of most of yours I was right on par like I looked at my lines when you speaking and was able to align with that as well I just would like to say that reading all of their applications it was a joy and my heart goes out to so many of them that have really poured out their hearts into their comments um it was difficult to make that decision on which ones but it was uh I tried to to look at all different um thought process processes that they were using and and things that stuck out that one person would say this and one person would say that so that way we have we able to have a
118discussion where there's different viewpoints so that's how I kind was there room to add one yeah only had 57 is that I think that's middle school isn't it yeah that's middle school so that was just Elementary okay yeah yeah that was just Elementary okay you can go you go all right so my middle school let me pull it up here real quick h all right sorry 72 trying to navigate it one these two oh hold on 75 and 76 okay I have 92 and that was it for me for Middle yours yep and I have uh 93 I'm just gonna go backwards okay 91 69 at 62 56 which is already there and then Kathy you what number was yours that you no it was I remember the name it was 57 I think Kathy
119if you double check that is that right7 is it 57 57 okay all right okay okay yep just so we can triple check please thank you6 599 yes ma'am we can do high school and again just if you're just now tuning in we're not saying our students are numbers but to protect identity we're just naming the line of the where the student is on the Excel spreadsheet um so that that we're not uh violating their privacy so I just want to make sure I say that again all right start y okay number 109 is where we should start for high school okay yeah yeah mine is yeah um okay 11 18 Sor okay 134 there was a lot of good ones in the high scoore this this one was hard 139 y um 187 all
120right that was my list okay yeah so then I have I'm going to go backwards I had 189 we already have 180 uh 161 156 13 okay I had one more um 133 at like technically two more but may be 115 and 14 114 so 17 18 186 187 189 161 156 133 115 and 114 yes' that's correct all right thank you so I also wanted to uh give a a special thank you I know she's not here tonight but Miss Lori Atkins our secretary did a great job first time working this trying to get it in I actually really appreciate the Excel format and working with Miss Scot's office to get that for us versus the paper ones like we were able to make notes and things so just wanted to publicly thank her
121for her hard work hopefully she sleep but if she's not if she hears it just want to make sure let her know that the board appreciates her and then the next item we are on to our music program so I'll turn it over to Super Mr superintendent sure so um we added music program to the agenda last month and then um I did not have answers to some of the questions and so Mr kers and I exchanged some emails and he shared um some different things like some reports that he found from other places and some of those that included surveys I did ask um uh Carol morbitzer to pull participation numbers by area by grade level um what I was really looking for tonight is to really kind of see what we're looking for
122what what do we need to do to prepare and make the best use of our time do I need to bring music people in have them talk about their recruiting strategy do I need to have um just to kind of get a clear picture what we need to do and put a time frame in a focus sure for what what the what our goal goal is so we can be appropriately ready to provide everything the board would like for that so maybe you can start us with that my my interest is one one specific thing that has come to my attention is that we have uh eliminated Stage Band which is kind of near dear to my heart um because we didn't have participation of 20 people and I know from Stage Band you don't
123need 20 people or Stage Band you could have a great eight or 12 person Stage Band and Stage band's awesome and uh it it appeals to kids that may not be able to or care about marching band or concert band they may play a trap set or piano Etc so it opens up music to additional kids would love to see the Stage Band reinstated I don't want to say reinstated but I want I would love to know that for our next school year Stage Band is definitely on the agenda and we don't have some you know some high number that we have to hit in order to make the state band a state band um outside of that I'm just I just I mean I noticed after some of the incidents of the football game
124when I showed up and you know some of my friends were band members and I'm like where's the band and there was 50 people and so so um you know and it used to be hundreds so my whole thing is there's a couple of things one is music helps with education you know what what are we doing for me coming up music was a crit was an important part of Groveport all the way through I I had a first grade teacher she played s her guitar she Incorporated music and education we had choir at early grade levels um and encouragement for band in the middle schools and a big big band we we called it the best Dam band in the land at the time and our jazz band got paid to perform at hotels
125and stuff the music was really really cool and vibrant and uh I think Libby got similar experiences I just want to see it grown back what do we need to do where do we need to farm what are we what are we doing well what do we need to do better let's get a couple hundred people back in our band that we got a we got a 1700 or whatever it is high school um 10% participation is not a lcky goal uh we've got I've seen schools that have 50% of their High School in the band you know small schools that literally new Newton is like a 300 three 400 person in high school with 200 people in the band so um we've fallen off and I just I'm just curious what we can do
126to grow it because I think it it engages our students and we can tie it into education I don't have any specific goals beyond that just you know learning what we're doing well where it can go how we can make it better and just have a board discussion get that a question real quick just as a brand new band parent this this whole world is new to me Stage Band is that jazz band ask question yeah stage band jazz band yeah Jaz yeah okay but it doesn't have to be a stage band is a Stage Band you can you can play you can do any type of music you want but it's yeah an ensemble you know 15 12 so it could be an orchestra as well so we wouldn't even have to limit ourselves
127to Jazz but it could be I don't know what we have going Orchestra Orchestra in choir used to be huge here uh and I I don't know that we I don't even know if we run an orchestra yeah the orchestra I mean when they we built the high school that was the plan um we had brought in a band director that was going to teach the strings okay so that we could have but then found out that wasn't the interest good I'm sorry so I said we had when we built the new high school that was the plan we built the pit so that they could have the orchestra pit right um for the music program that was going to be one of the U pathway programs um and from my understanding when they um
128at the time that was students were very interested in that um the theater the um the music program choir programs uh all the Performing Arts and then the high school then was finished they surveyed the students and there wasn't the interest there that there was yeah we have and I and I don't know what what happened for sure um but I do know that once Co hit it really made it difficult for band because how do you teach instruments right virtually yeah there was Co there was a lot of issues that have to be so I know our numbers dropped considerably at that point but they were dropping prior to that too I I do have a couple things I guess just to put some parameters upon the ask if we're with us having the
129discussion um as we're looking at band and we're talking about the band isn't what it where it was um can we also find out in survey is it a matter of not having the means to get an instrument and do we have the resources on Partnerships where a parent may not be able to afford the instrument we can then get the instrument or get something discounted I know there's like the monthly plan and what's already set up through the um the one instrument shop I don't know if I think it's still lay music down on the main street but what if they can is there that something else for us to look at so I mean I we're surveying students and made parents hey if you want did you want your child in the band
130and if so was it a barrier of and also getting them to in front practice if it's after school is there ways for them to get home like what are the barriers um that may also not just why are they not there there may be reasons so may be prompt that way and then um the music selection music changes and um a lot of times students may not be having interest because the music does not connect with them so uh if that is the case if the music was different would you consider the band and if so what type of genre or song suggestions or something like that to get a get a feel for maybe why are missing and then if we're going to look at band then the same thing with choirs um
131because our choir are we um challenging ourselves even around certain times like have specialty choirs for special things so you know women's history months in March can we have a all girls choir that focuses on going out and you know what I mean I don't know just things like that and and um Coral music that is for this is just a suggestion but but maybe those are some of the things that would then help us understand like where we are because students are not involved for a reason and they'll tell you if we ask them and and then I think there may be barriers I think for the um instrument piece too in transportation and I gave a I gave that band not bad band examples but band wasn't music is the focus the whole
132the whole PR so yeah so hopefully that is that help Mr group superintendent group like given those parameters like kind of understanding where we are with our student population and why for both band and choir and then Mr you looking into how to bring Stage Band and maybe some special it's certainly helpful I think we could come in with a presentation to talk about what do we offer K12 with the different levels and then get some of the directors to come in and talk about um what could be helpful from recruiting are some of these cost things what what are things we could do you know there's there's sometimes uh scheduling situations that that limit that so that that gives me uh an idea and then after we take through a presentation I think an
133interactive conversation with the music educators and the board would be great and I guess another thing to look at and this this has a monstrous effect is it's not in our control but um you know the boosters programs have a lot to do with the success of the programs and uh I I would anticipate that they have uh they have probably fallen off as well and I we can encourage we can't control but we can certainly look at encouraging and engaging and see and and and make them part of the process as well as the students to find out um you know the band parents Etc what their feedback is and what they think we need to improve and that could be a part of that engagement fece we were talking about earlier in general
134how do we get our parents involved from not just from a discipline standpoint but even in our schools that are higher grades in the so that could be added to that too yeah I think a survey would be a great idea for the parents so we know what they're looking for in the younger grades um instead of you know we don't want to make assumptions let's find out what they want and John you said uh the stage ban was cancelled when was that last year this year I I heard I think it was this year I heard um from one of one of the directors was pointing out that that was something that happened when when I ran into one of the band directors somewhere and we were just casually talking about it and and
135they mentioned the state band that would be that would be an area where we could make things better bring that back so um and honestly I couldn't I I couldn't tell you the name I think it was a middle school band director but I I got the indication that that happened very recently I don't know the specifics thank you who who makes that decision to cancel programs like that like the if it was canceled this year who would have made that decision I'm just curious she said it was all Paul's fault just kidding well I can't I can't answer it um and we're not going to answer all this I could answer all this but I think it might be nice to have the band directors come here we have outstanding band directors okay all
136well all our music programs uh but there's a couple of things one we definitely have an outreach program and some outside programs that help us with instruments uh and so if there's a family that needs an instrument we can make sure they get it the other thing is uh reaching down to the fifth grade and start doing uh like instrument investigations there there is so much talent here that uh students don't even know they have it yet yeah but if you go to a talent show you'll see our kids are talented it's amazing you see what they can do but I'll say this we have uh over 2ou about 2,000 students in the high school and we have one band director most schools that size have a band director and an assistant band director however
137with the numbers in our band you kind of balance it out so if you have one person providing music instruction uh for the whole school and they're teaching six periods a day sometimes you have to make a decision how do you maximize that one person and do they do a class with nine or are they going to do another class that can take 30 kids so Stage Band is a smaller class and we have one person and we'd rather than work with more kids than a few so yes that's kind of how that ended up going to the side but moving forward and we get the numbers up and the need is there then we can start looking at an assistant band director and then now you have a second person that can help with
138that and I'm not saying that I'm making any of those decisions and we're adding staff I'm just saying you look at the numbers the need and the desire and matching what our community kids and families want that's what we're going to go with right now with the numbers that we have in our band it doesn't require or uh show a need for a assistant band director at the high school yet it would be awesome if we could do that uh and I think we got some really good people that can fill a position like that but it also depends on Recruitment and retainment from the middle schools and how we are outreach program for our fifth grade and we have some really good Middle School directors that are doing that both in band and choir
139and to be hon honest with you the band has increased each year over the last three years and so has our choir um and we have like our pet band is playing at our uh basketball games I didn't know if you guys knew that at our basketball games they are outstanding they'll get that place rocking and they do that on their own but they're doing it for credit uh and we have a one of the band directors helping with that uh looking at specialty bands like Stage Band and jazz band and some other ones or um our our honors and advanced core Coral groups are we'd love to do all of that yes said something when you're doing it make sure we include theater so just when we're theater involved in that just make sure
140we include that I don't know if you heard her and and I will say I've seen it throughout my career I know there's several studies but the music programs the art programs uh all these programs and the kids involved and invested in these programs it does help them academically it helps with their attendance it helps with everything the more we can get kids connected in school the more invested they are the more they feel like they belong the more they feel like they're part of something and uh that's what we're trying to do yeah so you know going back to my reference today yeah we definitely had a band director an assistant band director and the assistant band director in my case was the Stage Band uh music theory uh there were quite a lot
141of other music courses um that that assistant would teach not not not marching band but like I said music theory Stage Band other other courses like that so ensembles that kind of thing all right thank you are there any additional questions or comments on this topic from the our colleagues for superintendent thank you okay moving on to our transportation discussion so I think that was a request um Miss Walsh wanted to discuss Transportation so we'll turn it over to you well yeah we want to have a discussion about um the possibility of bringing um transportation in house that would look like um savings n yards maybe we should have a committee that would look into that I know that contract is it seems like we reactive instead of pro proactive that contract is coming to
142where we're going to have to make a decision on um if we extend the contract if we end the contract um so I think we need to look at those G ask my other board members what they think about the subject computer problem right now I actually just wanted to hear more what your thoughts were um for me before yielding any additional comments but if that's all you have to offer then that's fine I I personally think it would be great um we don't have a lot of data or information um I in my head looking at I think there's um there's a pretty big spread between um the cost and the overall cost um I know firsthand transitioning from private Services back to in-house is a is a lift and it's got to be
143done extremely well um and one idea I have is uh you know engaging the owner and seeing if there's any interest in um highly in him to make help with the transition anything along those lines but I think we ought to form a a committee and not on a long term but a short term work with the treasurer understand things uh not rushing anything we've got a February date coming up very quickly and then you know this will always be on the table you there's now now or a year from now whatever but I know many many many years ago we we looked at at this and now we've aligned ourselves with finally with the type of staff that would allow us to bring this in and it would be good for us to to
144be able to speak as a board and understand um potential cost savings potential risks opportunities uh and all that kind of thing so um I certainly don't have answers but I would I would love to work with work with theard somebody or for us to work together and kind of get answers um to what we see as risk cost analysis and where we want to go but I think I think the most important thing is the way to make it work is cooperatively if if there's some win-win big wi uh to make work and to do a transition over time I think uh we and see if it makes sense okay any additional comments you guys yep weart thank you all right we moving does the I'm sorry does the board have a thought on
145the idea of forment and transport transportation committe for short time to um I don't have any comment on that right now so I just wanted to hear you guys brought it up I wanted to make sure we heard but I have my questions I've already given to Administration on that so but I don't have it I don't personally have any additional comment at this time but I was interested definitely to hear what my colleagues had to say so thank you so much for sharing appreciate it okay anybody other thoughts on this I already put it out to the board I don't have this time now I think that's disappointing that we're going to be once again reactive instead of proactive and I am disappointed respect your right to have an opinion put an opinion out
146yet just thinking exactly it wasn't clear on what they asked was so they need for you to say that the row we're going one way or another we just said at this time we didn't have a comment so uh putting words in someone's mouth is not appropriate all right on to item five um approve the resolution to join the vouchers hurt Ohio lawsuit so I'll read that my mouse is not working on a second all right if I have a motion I think person I'll read the resolution read so moved right I first Mr bow and second M what is the motion could you read the motion please well it's to approve the resolution to doing the hurt Ohio and I'm going to read the resolution so we've got the two the first and the
147second now I'm going to read the resolution good yeah okay so I I do have a kind I was G to read the resolution and then we can have discussion if that's okay right where's the state is adopted Universal voucher system and whereas Ed chice vouchers are funded by the state from designated appropriation line items 200 550 200- 604 200- 612 and payment to private schools diminishes the amount of funding and levels of educational opportunities in school districts and ESC and whereas the dedu DED the deduction of school voucher funds from funds available to authentic public education further reduces the funding available to support the additional needs of minority pupils pupils in poverty and pupils with disabilities and whereas the deduction of school voucher funds from the Appropriations that fund authentic public education increases Reliance
148on local tax revenue to maintain School operations in violation of the Ohio Constitution and clear directives of the Ohio Supreme Court section one now therefore the Board of Education finds and determines that the universal voucher program is harmful to the districts its pupils taxpayers voters and staff section two the Board of Education authorizes and directs the school districts join Joiner of the Ohio Coalition for Equity adequacy of school funding Coalition and directs the district Treasurer to pay Coalition dues is set forth in section three Coalition dues Coalition dues excuse me for the school year are the sum of $2 per District pupil enrollment listed on most recent report card due shall be allocated by the Coalition as follow 50 Cent per pupil shall be initially allocated to the payment of the of Coalition operating expenses
149and two a150 per pupil shall be allocated to support the coalition's effort to change the constitution constitutionality of the Ed Choice Voucher Program educational DS dues a total of $2 per pupil are payable among passage of this resolution after a regular meeting of the grpt Madison School District Board of Education on motion and then there's the date and all of that um so I will then yield to you Miss W you had a comment um what organ what type of organization would the money be going to is it a 501c3 what what is it so my understanding V heard is a 501 they also were at osba but we're going to get you the true designation if it's a 503 or some other designation so just stand by but they also came and presented and
150provided materials as well and I can try to find that um board meeting where those materials are located if you would like to look at those if you give me a few minutes okay thank you so my understanding is that vure HT hurts Ohio what you're calling it that's just kind of like a catch name an advertising name it's the Ohio uh Coalition for equity and adequacy of school funding it's not a 5013 it's a business and this uh lawsuit is fully funded we're having conversations here about students taxpayers not being able to maybe provide ban instruments for their children and us having problems and um so now you want to spend how much would that be um for this uh for our district the total cost for our district it's it's two bucks per
151student we have 6400 kids ,800 um and I also uh I've been told that the um project is fully funded um they do not need money um so I'm not sure why we would I can see putting forward a statement that we support their effort I don't see any logic in throwing money at them when they're already fully funded for their lawsuit I disagree I think that it's important that we um participate in this um for a few reasons mainly though I think it's important that we advocate for um public taxpayer dollars to go towards Public Schools um you know one of the issues and I know we got to hear from both sides um one of the main issues is you know $349 million going towards um private schools with this private schools can
152change their tuition rates on the fly if they want to and they can also pick and choose the students that attend so I think it's important that we um you know personally I feel that it's important that we We join this lawsuit and the other districts um around us um that is going up against us so um and to be clear um our Surplus has gone in the little time I've been here from 30 million to 50 million so your anyone sitting here telling me how vouchers are hurting Ohio I would say huh not and secondly these are not vouchers these are um what's the term we um what's the term that's being used they're not vouchers you're getting if you go to college and this college sponsors you it is a schar scholarship they
153are scholarships that are being SCH that are being issu but additionally here's the r okay we're overcrowded our high school so now we want to force everyone in the district back to our high school that makes total sense secondly we've acknowledge we're not we're not where we need to be my son I thank goodness the the gifted program at sadelia was honest with me and said we got nothing for you Mr kersner and Jared we're going to you he's two and three grade levels ahead in every grade we got nothing for him but to have him in the high school when he's 11 or 12 years old you need to go somewhere else unfortunately for me that meant a ton of money out of my pocket and at one point I couldn't afford it my
154parents helped but so to for someone to come in here and say oh this is just benefiting the rich this old superintendent is the rich guy we're giving the money to and he doesn't give a crap about the poor kids that's my opinion um so I think it's really bold of us I don't think we're representing the taxpayers in any way that are moving out of this District that are struggling that don't want to have their kids at the high school to say we're going to Shackle you there and I actually think it's it's totally counterintuitive they're going to want out more if you make them so I think this is just totally a bad move but beyond that it's financially ignorant the project is funded this person and this group needs no more money
155to carry on with the lawsuit so all we're doing is taking from the taxpayer and giving to the rich so I think it's totally opposite of what you think it is that's all I have to say thank you I would just say that I you know I am for school choice um you know parents ultimately have the you know the right to to determine what school their their child should go to what I what I would advocate for though is that the funding of these should be a Level Playing Field and it's not currently and so that's where I have a big um issue with these vouches or you call scholarships is that it's not an even playing field um and we have um public funds going to private and charter schools and I can
156tell you as a parent what's not an what's not an even playing field is spending three or four thousand in taxes and then another three and four to get my kid in school that can accommodate his giftedness or uh the education level and my and I'm a cruiser I wanted my kids to be Cruisers but I also wanted them to be prepared for college and Gro Port wasn't then and in many cases isn't now prepared to provide for all the kids that are here and a lot of them don't have the money um and uh that's just that's just a reality it's not anti-school but the truth is what do you do you know if you if you need that very specific education it's hard to get and it's expensive um so I just think
157we're tying the hands of of parents when we need to be offering them a lot of a lot more options and this was opened up this whole program was opened up based on um failures of schools schools that were in academic dire need and yes it's probably expanded a little bit from that but at the same time all this money is taxpayer money we're not taking money from anybody but ourselves we're all paying for this so um again uh we obviously respectfully disagree and I appreciate your input and my understanding of how what was presented to us is that we pay out to for these vouchers more than what comes into our district for that student is that correct we we pay out well the tax dollars the tax dollars more as deducted than what
158we would receive for that student but that's what was presented to US during that meeting that is correct because it could be based off your home value so if you're only paying 3,000 and taxes but then the voucher or scholarship could be valued more so therefore what you're putting in in those tax dollars you're actually taking more so that that's what comes to that right another not and then the other issue that I have is that they they can select their students we don't select our students if it was you'd end up having the best students every school would be picking the best students and so um when it's taxpayers dollars I just feel like it's we should be educating all students and if they're taking taxpayer dollars they should be educating all students there
159should know picking and choosing who they want to be in their um uh schools and then the other thing is um they don't follow the same guidelines that we are required to follow and so we're our taxpayer dollars are going to something that that wer we're required to do some things and they're not required to do that certain types of testing certain types of curriculum things like that it's like if it was an even playing field that would be one thing but it's not an even playing field it's not in the selection process it's not in the dollars and it's not in the education that's that's a broad that's a broad brush I mean you're you're taking every school option including specific schools for autism that take kids that very difficult kids specific schools for
160people with handicaps and you're just painting them all with one brush and you've got a lot of these schools like Madison Christian that have fallen over themselves to meet state standards and to they spent years getting approved by the state and to make sure that they're meeting the state standards yes uh is there a criteria to get in of course the final point I promise is this this is the same guy who found or his organization determined that schools are unconstitutionally funded yay and we have done what with it it ex exactly what will happen even if he wins the state's going to look and go yeah so what it's unconstitutional just like funding is and all we've done is spend our money and that they don't even need uh and well that's all we've
161done we've spent money that they don't need they're already fully funded we're just giving away tax tax dollars and in the end even if some judge says this is unconstitutional I seriously doubt that our current current legislators are going to worry about it they also said our Boe our our Board of Education was unconstitutional and off they went so so far being constitutional isn't the measure that our current legislators uh really care about so again a win is a win is a win for this organization and this gentleman's Pockets thank you just so everybody's clear this money will be going to a business okay to fund their initiative it's not going to a 501c secondly this is going against our scholarship programs Ohio has five of them they have an Autism scholarship the Cleveland scholarship
162the John Peterman special needs scholarship you know the John Peterman needs the schools who take those students they pick their students too you know and yeah some schools don't we don't even have enough schools to take the kids who want to go to different schools um we have students who we cannot provide the services for and they should be able to go whatever the gentleman who came said oh it's for rich people it's for the middle class it's helping the middle class 135,000 for a family of four that's not a rich family that's a middle class and I have a problem with our school district wanting to hurt our families in our district and our taxpayers did we do a survey did you do a pull of our taxpayers in our district to see if
163they want their tax dollar to go to this initiative to go to this company that's business I I don't think we did that and we'll be paying actually more into this company's pocket than school districts like Beckley and then we have conversations earlier today saying we don't have the funds for certain students can't even have an instrument but you want to throw 12,000 plus dollars at this business it's a bad decision 9:30 okay well yes 93 can we move it on well you had plenty of time to talk Mr so I'm all you can turn your mic off then thank you um so uh I do appreciate all the comments I definitely wanted to make my statement I definitely concur with with Miss great uh stated in Mr Bower and no it's not a brush
164for all so I am definitely an advocate for school choice I've used every bit of that I've had uh children in private public and Charter and I will say Madison Christian does not accept all um my son as well but that's the point so um they they do pick and choose and if you're on an IEP slightly they will deny it so even if it's hold on one second I'm not I'm not saying what you said I'm just giving my experience thank you um even with the John Peterson scholarship I've been a recipient of said John Peterson scholarship it does not cover all of the tuition so if you go to a marburn Academy or a spectrum normally those tuitions the tuition for K3 education is about 28 to $30,000 if you are a student
165with an IEP which most about maybe at least from what I saw um it's common to be other health impaired um and they only give you about ,000 or maybe $9,999 then the remainder of that bill goes back to that pairing there's also uh sometimes a psychological evaluation that's not covered by said voucher which is another $1,500 there's also um the enrollment fee or their matriculation fee which is like another 350 and then if it's your first year there's another fee on top of the difference of the tuition so yes those programs are there but they are not fully there to help parents uh all students they only help certain students who are able to maybe meet up the make up the difference so whether I'm able to obtain a loan possibly get financial aid
166for a portion of the remainder it still may not cover the remainder of the tuition or obtain a second drop job also because their hours are not always in sync with maybe your school district um and where you go busing can be off so then the parent is trying to pay for before and after care so I I definitely believe in school choice school choice is not the issue the issue is that vouter be fair across the board and that all students have the same opportunities I would you know I think any parent Who as a child with a disability if they wanted a Christian education them having an IEP should not be the reason why they can't attend so we take everyone why can't everyone take everyone via a lottery system if that's the
167case 's a lot of stipulations um when it comes to other schools if they will or will not take the student based off of special education needs unless it's a specialty school like a Bridgeway Spectrum or marburn Academy and I've done my research there's also um I I'm verifying and I did verify verbally but I'm working on getting pulling up the business search but um it is a nonprofit and it is fully funded by the school districts um I did also ask for the financials from the organization and then I also called and talked to the opposing side for vouchers just to hear both sides in addition to what was presented to our school the other thing that really hit me hard is looking at how we from a federal level school districts are not
168funded appropriately under idea we're only about 11% um funded federally so then guess what that idea piece is being pulled from our local tax dollars if school districts were funded appropriately federally um that would then trickle down to the state we would be able to do more but that's where those additional things come on to our taxpayers um in addition to things like buildings and such which that is on the taxpayer that is you know our responsibility but the other portion is school districts for years have never been fully funded especially through idea we all know with covid that has all changed and that also we've seen an increase with students with disabilities and yet our our federal legislators have not fully funded that by itself then we have the full I guess the make
169us whole formula State form formula and there's no um end in mind on that yet either but we can push the voucher program but we can't figure how to fully fund Public Schools so I have a problem with that hence where I am with the vouchers and then there's also a book I would just challenge my col colleages to read if you would like to um if you really want to be open to it unless you've made up your mind it's called the private teers how billionaires created a cultural war in sold School vouchers and that'll be something a good read I read that in another book that coincides but I wanted to point that out as a parent not as a board member tonight but as a parent that's looked at every option I
170love the fact that our state of school choice I do not want to remove school choice I don't think that's what any of my colleagues are saying what we're saying is if we take them they should take them if we have to support them all have to support them because our Educators do why shouldn't the others and if we are held to these state standards and we're required to do these things they should be required to do the exact same and then it's our job as elected to go back to our federal legislators and state legislators and say hey what's up with uh fun fully funding idea we know a lot more children are having more disabilities and issues that would help us in the states so we're not moving money around robbing Peter to
171pay Paul and then we don't have a parent we have a parent who would love their child who could go to this amazing school like marburn but can't make up the difference of the 28,000 versus the 99,999 that they gave them so if after that I think everyone has made their comments if we can move to roll call Mr treasury please respond to that for sure some of that's just not factual and we have to realize that right now in the Senate are several bills that have been proposed for transparency reporting for private schools they're making those kind of changes in the Senate but they doing it in our district paying tax dollars that we could be using for our students and and telling our students who have already gone out sorry you're gonna have
172to come back because we're we're working on no one has we can't even provide the services that you need it's just wrong no one has said that though that's what you're saying that is that is not what I say what the outcome will be for a lot of people who don't get vouchers that is not that is not what the voucher lawsuit is about ma'am and if you would if you guys were at the osba conference there was also both sides there representing and presenting that as well so no one's saying that we're trying to it's not to get rid of school choice it is not it is to make it a play play uh Fair playing field for all schools in school choice whether you're public private our Charter it is not to remove
173anyone's right everyone has that right that's what's great about this country we three of us on this board have served for this very reason but what I'm saying is if my child with a disability wishes to attend this school and you tell me you can't and then or you have the right which this has actually happened in my family from said private school you took the money for years and years and years and now oh you're not really cutting it so we're kicking you out and then they have to go back on their fifth grade year to a whole school a school system that they were not a part of because for whatever reason it's not meeting their requirement that's that there's some emotional piece and some other things that are happening with that student
174that is not being considered but you had no problem taking that money for four to five years and make you start in prek so we can't it's it's it's not that and I will just state for me my reason for work for voting are supporting or or my stance on vouchers heard is to make school choice fair and that everyone has Fair funding that is what I'm speaking to okay that's everybody won't have Fair funding I I understand the goal and I think it's honorable I'm not sure that this this lawsuit gets you there and what you're talking about doesn't get me there either so joh P so you know the John Peterman scholarship John Peterman has Peterson is that John Peterson has been infused with 200 million since 2023 so I think the analogy
175you're giving is probably a little outdated I think I think that's become more affordable for more people I do appreciate what you're saying is not actually and the person who actually started is actually the endowment they're actually the same people that started the marburn academy to be clear so I'm very very knowledgeable on what I'm speaking of because I can speak to one of the teachers that started the school so we can go on and on and on but we can go to Ron Mr treasury please thank you hold on that's right Mr ker no Mrs dber hi Mr bar hi M gray hi and Miss W no motion passes now we're on to discuss the date and time for the organizational meeting for 2025 um we had some dates already for some other items
176and I think I received an email or two if I'm not mistaken from um Miss Walsh that some dates have changed so if we could just kind of rehash out our January dates please so we need to get a date and time for our organizational meeting for 2025 any suggestions um yeah we had a state change was for the you had set a date I think for the first Monday was it Monday for boardmy for boardmy yes that's correct and yeah um was one of the one of the dates that we were looking at I think was jary what was that yeah I can't do that the first two Mondays I'm not going to be able to can we talk about dates that folks can do so I know that um you inform me that
177is there dates that uh we are normally the second Wednesday so the second Wednesday in January will be January 8th is that not an option for an organizational meeting for 2025 I think we're talking about two different things I think Kathy you're talking about the training right wardmans ship yes I'm speaking of our organizational meeting for 2025 that's organizational meeting Wednesdays um and Thursdays are two evenings that I um have classes so I was hoping maybe we could move it to Tuesdays we had done Tuesdays once before maybe move it back to Tuesday I don't recall Tuesdays we were every re since I've been here it's been Wednesdays Tuesdays yes it is is and I it's the same conversation we had a year ago but I've seen the first I know the first Wednesdays caus
178maybe some preparation issues is that right I remember that right no first Wednesday this year though was New Year's Day so I'm just trying to no I'm not talking about I'm not talking about for that I'm sorry yeah in general I just want to stay focused on doing our organization 18 did we do the well me I got to step in here first I have I have a tax budget that has to be submitted by the 15th of January so it needs to be anything before that 14th would be really quick to turn around the next so for me I need to be before that so but is is there a law that we have to meet and elect our officials by a certain date so we need to know yeah I do remember that
179I find it so Kathy you're out for all Wednesdays and Thursdays for the 20125 sorry U my classes are on Wednesdays and Thursdays yes all Wednesdays and Thursdays every day every week uh there'll probably be a week here and there within the area that there won't be classes like two week pauses but I um yeah those are Wednesdays and Thursdays classes and I may be able to do the six um I definitely can't do the 13 14 15 and and the six will be way too fast for me to turn around since the holidays or January 1 close down year end so according to our policy we have to the board has to meet within the first 15 days of January yes so could we do yeah six I can't do I can't turn around
180I can't turn around the sixth I couldn't do because I'd be too fast I can't turn around the year end by the sixth so maybe you can't do wednes or Thursday about Friday Friday the 10th Jesus that's ad ad yeah Friday that's that's I mean what about the 13th Monday I I'll be at the Cleveland Clinic on the 13th 14th and 15 you're 1 so question is the organizational meeting going to be followed by regular meeting it typically is the typically is that would be the point yeah so if we can't do 13 14 15 so we have to do either the eth nth or 10th Kathy can you do the E 10th I can do the 10th you do the E I can't the 10th so I can do six seven 10th six and
181seventh be really tight can we do the 13th no she can't do 13 14 15 out of the 6th seventh and 10th I can do I should be able to do six or the 10th again the six bad turn around the six is too tight too tight yeah just year end we get year January first like that' be way too tight plus we get the board out ahead of time so the 10th that's Friday but I hate doing it just be like organizational meeting then have the regular meting on a different day yeah no not if we're doing a Friday I I I that's that's especially if we're gonna have our staff stay on a Friday I think that's a that's a hard ask okay but then we need still have a board meeting and
182then still turn around I mean but then we're exactly we still have to have that to meet his absolutely so the the as far as the entire board goes the prefer the date preference is to keep it it it would work at least for Wednesdays work best for same here Wednesday so question if we have the regular meeting on the eth to accommodate everyone uh the second and fourth Thursdays yeah the second and thir first fourth Thursdays are endless 14 hour days for me starting super early with the food Panter so if we do the eth can we then move our regular meetings to the third Wednesday can we do Kathy can't do Wednesdays at all Tuesday Kathy's not able to do Wednesdays at all I get that I'm just trying to figure a compromise
183I know I was as well I was just trying to figure out dates from everyone first so and what are the dates for the food pantry for you I'm sorry what dates are days of the week it's always the second and fourth Thursday of the month okay and Mr colier needs to meet with us about the things to meet his deadline so and that we have to do that before the 15th but still give him time to turn around when he needs to turn around so if we could do the eth Le n or the best she can't do or and the sixth and seventh for you is year in so that's why correct agenda by Frid what if we did the organizational meeting on one day and then that way we'll be setting the
184dates and everything and then the first meeting have it on the 14th if you have to because 14 14 that' be a quick turn around but I'd to get sub by the next day yeah that's why we were trying to stay away from the 14 at least then if we have the organizational meeting I can be a part of that for setting the schedule if I have to miss a meeting you know it is what it is I understand that I'm willing to miss a meeting if I have to for the good of the board you know to have the meetings on the day we're supposed to have them but I would like to be part of the organizational meeting so we can set the schedule because I do want to have a a vote
185on that all that organizational items is that a possibility so you're pushing hard for the seventh is that what I'm hearing no the 14th she said 14th no I'm saying he kind of needs it to be on a day for him so the 14th but if we could set the organizational meeting for the seventh then I can be a part of that and then on the 14th you have the regular meeting the organizational meeting will ask what an hour maybe it's very short if that right it's very short and then the 14th you know right there's couple it on so I move we schedu the organization meeting for it's not a vote it's not just a discussion it's okay if it is then normally we just play but if it it's not I think it's
186necessarily an action item but we can so we could do the seventh organizational meeting 8 regular board meeting 14 or 14 would be organizational 14th would be throw another wrench into the thing we're going to another Bond Levy in may we have have two meetings in January with the first and the second Bond passage because it has to be done by now we can always include that with the organization meeting and a regular meeting or something but just to throw that just make sure thank you for putting that out so we all know that too so if we do the organization meeting on the seventh along with a couple little items no you have regular meeting organization meeting but again the organization meeting shouldn't take long because there's there's only the President and Vice President
187o because nobody's new the other dates so then we would close close that session one agenda item coule and that would be on the eth seven seven and then on the and then on 14th or something or that be two meetings we have in January so I can I can probably I can swing one Tuesday I don't know if I can swing two Tuesdays with in the 14th same but I could do we have to have up to four the 15th tax right okay so she won't be here so we can do 13th or 14 now we may come back early enough on Wednesday but wed so if we on 13th that would be better so then it gives me a question I mean if I'm not going to be there on the 14th you
188guys can have it on the 13th and give time you know because I'm not going to be there I'm not going to be there I could probably be there on a call like I've done in the past um because it'll be in the evening and I'm sure all the evaluation stuff won't be done during the evening so if we had organization on the 7th and then the regular meeting on the 13th that's fine with me all right now I've had discussions of six o'clock rather than seven is that possible yes I I guess my only concern was with p if well not for the organization but going for when we look at meetings as a whole I her parents you know the time that we have is good by the time they get home at
189least the parents that have reached out to me get kids situated seven is is better for them than to be here versus trying to rush and be here by six if they're getting off at 5 so but before organizational we can do six or or earlier because there's not much so so Mondays and Wednesday if we're doing Monday I can do six did my close caption come okay Cy I saw your face I did it come across okay yeah I see captions some you're saying six o'clock right no you made a face when I was saying the parents that reached out to me um talked about seven versus six I didn't make a face you it looked like it I just wanted to make sure you could hear me that's all I was asking so
190this for this motion I want is January 7th this is organization meeting January 7th 6m yes okay and we can vote can vote on so I'm sorry I so Tuesdays if we could do seven on Tuesday I I can do six on Mondays and Wednesdays but Tuesday I have to pick up my kids get them back to my house January 7 7 that okay does that work organ Monday the 13th for the regular meeting at six at six and I will talk to the county auditor about if we can do because organization meting would have another board meeting right after that to do the first passage I'll make sure that given them only six days from the seventh to 13th is quick enough for them to turn around so I will let you guys know
191before the before set the next meeting I had I I had to move something is it possible we could at least do 6:30 on the 13th and not 6 y thank you what about Saturday no I'm sorry I will not do that to our Administration and I won't do it with my family all right for for this for this motion it's January 7th at 7M y January 7th at 7M organizational and then and then January 13th regular board meeting at 6:30 p.m. got which will be the halfway point 6 okay all right I make that motion motion second call Mr treas Mr Kisner hi Mrs hi Mr hi Mr I miss I motion passes I don't know how much time we would like to add on to this but there's the U the Mr s
192was so kind to present to us a month or so ago about the request from the board um about updated AV Equipment and provided us access to the documentation and the consultant so just wanted to make sure it didn't get lost or no one thought it was forgotten about just wanted there they're waiting on us to kind of provide next steps is there something else that's needed or if you all would like to table it that's fine I just wanted to make sure this did not get lost as a request of the board I'm sorry before we move on to this topic did we need to appoint a chair I was just reading thing do we have appoint a chairperson for the meeting or do we do that at the organiz yeah previously we've just
193had the previous current president overse okay all right thank you I'm sorry interrupt so this is just a followup on what was presented for additional questions or any next steps for Mr s um to move forward about the new equipment here in our boardroom I do have additional information I can share sure about where I'm at in the process um I I am working on getting a scope of work from uh Mark that um board member kersner connected me to U I have scheduled after the first of the year to have another sound company exte come out and assess the situation and get me a quote I have also contacted two transcription companies and had a demo of one I was hoping to demo that tonight but I couldn't get to work not a good
194sign um it kept giving me an error that I didn't give credentials to the Google meet there's no place to add credentials to the Google meet I opened a support ticket and they were like what do you mean so um on on that note the pricing for and that was just a demo how the transcription Services work accurate good um that's not for live transcription their pricing for live transcription is depending on the application anywhere from 650 to $16 per minute so at our board meeting lanks at 650 you're looking at a minimum of about $2,300 per meeting for rev's transcription live transcription Services um I don't have yet have scheduled what I'm in contact with um digital Nirvana and getting a demo schedule with them for their product for transcription so that's the update
195I have for you as far as I but I have I will in January have three quotes for the sound system and hopefully at least have had two of the transcription Services demoed and maybe one of those other two companies will have a different transcription solution n the the one transcription service that you demoed uh you talked about live transcription pricing is there a different model yeah so there the product is is like a bot that you join the meet and it listens records the meet and then transcribes but it's not uh a live close caption transcription so then I can go into my dashboard and look at look at the transcription of the meeting but that doesn't that isn't the live transcription or CL captioning isn't included in that product and there's three tiers
196of that product the free business and Enterprise but then the AI transcription or live transcription is a separate product itself which had the price that I how did the demo was it the demo the live version of the the the demo was was actually just the notetaker transcription did it work well it worked well for the for the sales rep that was demoing it to me but I couldn't get it to work or as of yet have not gotten it to work I have a support ticket open with comp and it could be that our like everything you said came out perfectly um it could be with an improved audio system that we see a great Improvement on our poose cop as well the one we're using now it could be a great Improvement just
197by having a better functioning audio system I think Google's always improving and also the the the louder or the more gain on the feed into the system and the louder more clearly the person speaking speaks has a lot of impact on thank you there any additional questions for um Mr sore any additional things that the board wanted to add for direction on this topic okay thank you our last item is the membership and the legal assistance fund is that you Mr Mr superintendent or Mr call that you yeah I can do that is recommend that the go M Mass school's Board of Education join the Ohio school boards Association or osba legal assistance fund at the cost of 250 bucks so second liby and John that's cor any comments or questions from the board okay
198we have roll call Mr Treasurer Mr K hi Mr hi hi M Grant hi M Walsh I motion passes okay on to the superintendent's agenda um we have the business service update we have this listed as a separate update so Dave have you come up and do that okay I will try and be very brief basically the update is in regards to playgrounds just sort of updating you on where we're at with that and what we've got accomplished the good news is is right now we haven't had any further vandalism everything's going very well um we are still checking from the maintenance department and operations checking regularly um as recently as today but also some of the things that um I've been briefing the board on over the past couple months the playground uh replacement
199items are scheduled to arrive by the start arriving by the end of this month I think the first one's coming on the 30th P will start installing them as they arrive so I realized there was a little bit of a long lead time with those items but they are starting to arrive this month so that will all be taken care of as they come in um as far as cameras go EPs and our outstanding technology department have um partnered to install cameras on our playgrounds I know our technology department is working on helping to pull the cable to keep the cost down and make it manageable um we're adding a total of 15 cameras at a total of 15 cameras to the elementary schools and you'll we're adding three at Asbury two at Groveport three
200at sadelia two at dunow one at Madison and four in at Glend Denning and that's based on um when Nate worked with EPS they created models on actually what the cameras would see in trying to provide coverage to our playgrounds in some of our more difficult areas so that will also start happening I actually had a meeting with EPS yesterday and they will be uh on site over Christmas break to start doing their part of that camera installation uh as far as playground inspections go I'll go down through this and on the next slide I can show you an example of what we're using but the daily playgrounds inspections are completed by the head custodian deficiencies are entered into a comment box that District Maintenance can see and that way they can address it immediately
201um the buildings with out playgrounds also are now having exterior inspections so basically the middle schools and the high schools on the spreadsheet I'm about to show you they have a tab on there also so they're required to at least check the exterior of their buildings for vandalism lights out broken glass windows things of that nature and then we're still having the annual playground inspections are done by the district's maintenance department and then if you can go to the next one Nate okay the daily playground inspections this is a Google um sheet that I created and shared with all of the head custodians all of the building principles and all of the maintenance department so this is a live document that gets updated daily and Nate can you click on daily inspections please you should
202have it now okay so this is the spreadsheet that's created not there'll be a new one created monthly you can see the dates across the top basically I have over on the left side the building name and what they need to be inspecting on a daily basis then they can come in and basically just give a quick drop down whether it's satisfactory or unsatisfactory the ends are not inspected so weekends or if they happen to be out sick or something for that day when you scroll down a little bit the direction I gave was if if you have to mark unsatisfactory you have to put a comment in on what the problem is so the maintenance department can see so that's what they've started doing down here this was done at the very beginning we
203had a heodan meeting the other day and I showed them how to insert a note so it's not running all the way across the screen basically when they insert the note it leaves a little flag in the box and then the maintenance department just clicks on that flag and they can read it and then they know to address it but if um you can see across the bottom there's different tap for every school and um so they can put in the comments the building principles can see this like I mentioned so if there's any issues or if things aren't getting inspected it's just another set of eyes to make sure we're following through and keeping an eye on our playgrounds and make them sure that they're where they should be any questions about this before
204I go on to the next one yes down at the bottom where we have comments they can put anything they want to down there any other questions on this no this looks great I think this would be great for to train you'll be able to train so thank for that and then on the other um this the monthly inspection as I believe the form I showed you before it's in public school Works um it's the same one that they'll still do on a monthly basis and keep on file and then the other one is done by our District maintenance department which is our annual ones which is also kept in public school works so those two really aren't new I was just trying to show the whole process any questions thank you sorry um I
205noticed we've got our the three Peterman whatever ated buses well we whatever part of the settlement the buses were in the doors were open when it was pouring rain and they're in an unsecured area um by at the end of the football field so I just I didn't know if there was a plan to get them secured or if they were still there or what yeah I wasn't aware that they were unsecured I'll look into that first thing tomorrow yeah and then there's one of our own buses I think parked in the same area on the grass yeah that one is uh to be exposed okay thank you any other questions are they I'm sorry are they going to be taken to a secure area the buses they will be I mean right now that
206the parking's tight over at as far as the Peterman buses the blue and white ones um we can probably get them over at 4500 location which is right now parking was tight with just opening the facility we were trying to get everything up and running smoothly over there before worried about those okay yeah I know a lot of people are having their tanks drilled and and things vandalized so that would be great all right thank you thank you Dave Mr Thomas ladies and gentlemen of the board Administration my report stands is submitted a couple comments that I'd like to make uh we're going to have our our Christmas party tomorrow 9:30 welcome Venus Bailey one of our drivers is the caterer she does a really good job they're all excited um House Bill 279 that's
207uh where the state legislators are trying to access the rainy day fund for to um provide more funding for transportation one of the things on Teresa's wish list is to get the external cameras on the side of the bus so you can catch cat passing motorists hopefully uh we can uh access those monies and get those they're about $ thousand dollar a bus and they're certainly worth worthwhile as far as the three Peterman buses and the band bus and the other bus there is no room at the end at 4500 you you bought another bus last month there's 80 parking places and 79 buses so that that's the problem over there that's why uh those buses are are stored over there at at the um at 4,400 and then we still need a resolution on
208the band bus uh the band bus is Sitting In Limbo it's available I know the band parents would like to have it I got feedback on it but we need to know who's going to own the bus who's going to insure the bus and how that's done and uh and right now the band bus is over at 4500 if you'll recall that's the one that we it it couldn't the floor couldn't be repaired so we went ahead and made it a good bus for the band instruments but we'd really like to have a resolution on that the fresh fruit comment uh com AR has been implemented uh Avi you should go over and see instead of having vending machines for the drivers all day they may now have fresh food available and it's in a
209kiosk basis so even though it's it's under video surveillance uh they the driver still have to pay for it but it's a lot more options and it's nice for them uh if some of them spend a lot of time during the day the other big thing is we're implementing our safety and training calendar so your three obis because we're staffed up your obis your onboard instructors do not have to drive in almost every school district in the country your trainers are a driver and it's hard to train if you're a driver so we not only have traines we have Trainor and they are doing inservice training they're using your wonderful video system you have the seon video system it's really easy to clip videos and instead of just reacting to incidents on the bus for
210when there's uh bad behavior they are using the video systems proactively to monitor the drivers their safe driving habits how they handle behavior management and all that other uh wonderful things that school bus drivers have to do every day I think that covers what I'd like to say are there any questions Merry Christmas thank you J um our next item superintendent recommends local Board of Education approve the minutes for the November 6 2024 regular board meeting second I miss gray first Mr bow second any comments from the board yeah I uh I sent some things that I saw that were not quite right and uh I don't know if those got changed I couldn't send them until I emailed them email Friday I think maybe maybe not I don't know I would have done it
211sooner but I didn't I didn't have access to my computer because of the change so I was having trouble getting on thanks Nate for fixing that and getting me all up and running you want to uh share the changes or do you have anything to send to us now okay share those um so on the page one item B we had a discussion about going into executive session and we actually uh moved U the whole discussion is missing meeting stopped and then we came back can you forward your email to the board could you repeat that please that what you're reading can you forward the email that you sent to the board please I don't think I can actually I can try I think I sent that from my home email from my okay I
212was just trying to follow okay sorry about that thank you so voting I know in the content yeah I guess cath if you have those we can always come back and UNM to make any changes if you want to get that to the board that's an option as well I didn't have updated until I got here so I just assume they've been changed okay if we could just have roll call as a and if there is if there's anyone that ever has a change that we couldn't get to or wasn't able to share to discuss we can always uh put a motion on the floor to amend that me those minutes if we could have roll call Mr CH Please Mr K no Mrs d i Mr Hig nope motion passes superintendent recommends goport Madison
213local School Board of Education approve the minutes of November 13 2024 parent advisory meeting second any uh questions from anyone yeah I didn't notice that um there was a recommendation for an officer in a second but the vote was not recorded also it would be great to knowe I that I don't know if the matters but I I didn't participate in any voting that was not not there for that purpose so I OB stain from any voting yeah that motion actually passed uh I was at that meeting and then there's one other thing oh and that would have been moved up action number 243 was to amend 242 so actually 242 was amended um uh to have one parent officer and I think actually it was like at least one but whatever I think it
214states that there was under action 243 second by Miss okay we have a roll call please is a roll call with those the it there's the amendment there so what are you saying what change are you what motion are you making to change I'm sorry can you repeat that I'm not following what change are you speaking of to have the record the vote that was taken on action which one was it the motion it doesn't even have the action on there actually it should it was action it would have been Action Four I don't know why this is missing but there was a motion by Ashley Zimmer to nominate herself as president a parent officer for the committee second by cassandre Lewis there was a vote taken it passed I think it was two to
215eight I'm not sure the exact total vote but that vote passed and but that's not recorded here okay that's on page two there no numbers but that would been page two okay y we'll just add motion as passes under the any that where she motion to nominate herself and that vote we just need to add motion passes so that will be with that change then this was okay okay so the vote is for the parent advisory meeting um minutes for November with the change to add that the motion passes uh for the self-nomination of the parent officer and that's action three it doesn't have a number's no okay so just missmer motion passes to nominate yes please everybody okay with that yes we gotoll call Mr treasure Please Mr chst hi Miss hi M hi
216Mrs Gray hi and Miss hi motion passes superintendent recommends Gort Madison school's Board of Education approve the GM Lea memorandum of understanding Mr this uhou was to clarify some evaluation procedures with Jia any questions or comments from the board yes did we F did we fall behind on evaluations or what is the what is the reasoning behind the memorandum please Carol would you mind coming up this is to clarify the language on what happens if we were to miss a timeline um not necessarily that anything has happened but in the past the contract if if it had if you violate a timeline basically the valuation ended so what that does in the system is that puts that teacher on a full evaluation the very next year which we kind of looked at if maybe we
217miss a timeline by a day in March that would have put that teacher on a full evaluation next year year after they had already been on a full one this year and we didn't want to do that so continue with the evaluation if it happens to be lower than the um previous rating we'll take the higher of the two ratings is what we came to agreement on any additional questions or comments from the board okay we can have rooll call please Mr kersner all Mrs dber hi Mr bow hi gray hi and Miss W i motion passes superintendent recommends yourport Madison Schools Board of Education approve the following certificated Personnel items as outlined on the certified board agenda attachment second Miss gr first Mr second any questions or comments from the board okay if we
218have a call then Mr treasure please yes Mr hner hi Mr D hi Mr bow hi M gray hi M hi motion passes superintendent recommends goport Madison school's Board of Education approve the following non-certificated personal items as outlined on the classified board agenda attachment second I miss gray first Mr B for a second any questions or comments from the board it looks like we had a lot of res naations from the educational AIDS so have those are we having trouble in that department are we going to be able to fill those Mr dce or Mr hman which one of you want to address that as you can see we have had some resignations for many different reasons we've had some movement also but um we seem to be able to find many of our residents
219are actually stepping up and and applying to these positions so thank you anyone else right Mr roll call Mr Treasurer please hi Mrs hi hi hi M motion passes I thought we'd skip item seven tonight it's a joke joke superintendent recommends that the goport Madison school's Board of Education approve payment Al for the transportation reimbursement the Ohio law allows for public school districts to determine the impracticality of transporting resident students attending schools not located within the district after consideration of a number of factors upon that determination the school district is permitted to offer payment L of transportation to the parent/guardian trans ation department has completed studies and residents in the affected areas may be offered payment for the 20 I Chang to 2024 25 2024 2025 not to change that the initial list of families
220being offered payment low transportation is attached as executive content since it lists students names soov second Miss gray first Mr Bower second any questions or comments from the board yeah I just again you know not a fan of this I see Harley's on there I noticed from some other documents that Crystal Ray which is also a peral high school and we are transporting to them and they're downtown they're farther away I it's just confusing to me doesn't make any sense um so each each one is based on the the criteria that's listed there Teresa Richie our transportation director and uh the person who oversees us from the high Department of Education we were trying to get in before will be coming to the January meeting to talk about the process we use and um I
221guess I don't know what else to say on that part thank you all right any additional questions or comments at this time Mr treasure we got a roll call please Mr kersner no Mrs daer I Mr Boward i m gr I miss W no motion passes superintendent recommends the goport Madison school's Board of Education approve the bowling field trip to bound Ohio second hi Miss gr first Mr B second any questions I apologize I'm forgetting which is which one is in a couple days and one already taking place I think this might be the one that's already taking place this one looks like it's December 21st so maybe the basketball all right and that's because of the distance any questions or comments from the board roll call please Mr Treasurer please Mrs Walsh hi Mrs
222GRE hi hi hi M hi motion passes superintendent recommends the goport Madison school's Board of Education approve the basketball team's trip trip as outlined in the attachment so move second I have John and Mr bow you have any additional comments Mr superintendent not unless there are questions are there any questions or comments from the board okay we can move to roll call then Mr treasur Mr K I hi M hi motion passes former item 10 weed moved up in the agenda the final one uh item 11 approve special education contract uh superintendent recommends the grp Madison school's Board of Education approve the special education contract with emerus amerus for assignment confirmation of Colin mcel the occupational therapist so move second all right got John and Mr bow any questions or additional comments from me comment
223I would add uh we had I think there was a new print out of this at your table tonight this is one that's actually an auto renewal uh but we we updated the name to make sure it's up to date M Angel you do you want to is there anything else we need to say about this contract so with the second contract that you see listed if you go to section 2.2 so this contract it indicates that it automatically renews unless we terminate that so that's a little bit different than typical contracts um but that's what indicates 2.2 under renewal so the agreement shall automatically Renew at the end of the term for successive oneyear terms unless either party provides written notice of at least 30 days prior to the end of the term that's
224what that contract St so it's been in place I think since 2023 was the original date I had them update the date just to see that it's it's a new person not necessarily a new contract um and then the um staff listed on page 19 were old so I had them um update page 19 so do you have like that on a reminder that we need to review this contract we need it every year yeah and I'm I'm in touch with the company frequently so um they they reach out pretty yes so we don't need it we W so it's basically the company name changed it looks like it did it was um Maxim before and now it's so and and then this Colin mcy is a addition to this he's like an addendum so
225that's a separate contract he is actually replacing one of our virtual occupational therapists because we agreed to try to replace the virtual staff that we have with iners so that will be an iners but he's an attachment to this correct right yeah that's the first thing that's the first thing well I'm glad thisa here the other one confused me a lot other question is it is it typical I know there was a time when uh contract with boards govern to Auto is that an issue thank right we got both call Mr treasure if there's no additional questions or comments Mrs Walsh hi M gray hi Mr B hi hi Mr hi motion passes and we're on to the treasures agenda okay right um first motion is treasur recommends that the gr Master schools boards education
226accept the cast donation amount of 15,000 Middle School North for the purpose of sponsoring the washingon DC so second this is a very generous donation yes very nice gray and we got a roll call then Mr treasure List's questions from the board I have a comment is I would like to thank them for donating this to our district families yeah and I would like to thank them as well um IUD is actually one of the recipients so I will have to obstain my vote but cannot thank this family enough for their generous donation um to middle school north for this trip yep thank you very much twice for I'll make sure you obain okay Mrs Walsh hi Mr gr hi Mr M i Mr I I motion cashes uh another donation uh treasur recommends that
227the gr mass and Schools board education accept a cash donation amount of $250 the girl from high school John second any questions or comments from the board a big thank you for helping her thank you thank you Mrs Walsh hi M Mrs Gray hi Mr bow hi Mrs I and Mr motion passes all on to my treasur reports Link in real quick okay all right you make make that big I have I have um real quick though going through November um typical month again um our our state Foundation came in just a little bit less um but more than in September everything else stayed about the same $4 million in Revenue um and our expenses about 7.7 so again negative 3.7 for the month but again these again we get our big big uh tax
228Li in AUST in March the rest of the months you know we're negative but my numbers are still looking good for my fiveyear forecast I did last November and I'm still still liking when the numbers are coming in outu so no problem on cash flow Revenue chart again just shows uh most of our money came in obviously State Foundation 3.5 million of it and we have a little bit of other stuff expenses again 76% of our expenses are personel Insurance retirement like normal um and then changes from prior year actually not too many very very similar from November last year um we had a settlement that's what we got the more on the other revenues $289,000 difference from last year and then increase in salary benefits is kind of the other big changes from prior
229year we just had less Capital Le this November than we did last November that's good but again all the numbers are looking good and I'm happy with them s update um we have spent all the funds um so we are good to go wither we got we got everything down by 1231 yes like shout out to my office especially Tanya Boyd it worked great with with Sarah Bricker Eckler and everything but yeah the last check we had to beg them we're like can you send us an invoice because the work's done and we a check so by 1231 we'll be done a awes oh sorry the last last amount of money the check we actually had to like say hey send us invo work is done it's like send us so we get this done
230by 12:31 so they finally did that and then we'll cut the we cut the check and then we are all done we spent all the Ester money like we use S Alle as make sure pring wages and everything we've been using her from the whole Esser even before I got here but just to make sure all make sure we were legal so that's why I said a big shout out to her um she work on every payment to make sure we were legal paying wages and and everything so oh you're good um and then bot discussion I kind of said it earlier we need two we have two meetings in January because we have to have that if we're going to do that by February 4th but I already talked about that so that's all
231I so do we need to do that I mean I think the voters said their piece at the last election and how much money does it cost for us to put something on I don't have much but since there's gonna be a lot of state issues on in May it's not going to cost as much it's not like a special election where you pay a lot a normal election can can you repeat that Kathy I didn't hear you she would know how much it cost for a special to have this election like sometimes there's a special election so you got to upfront a lot of calls so since there's going to be a lot on it's going to be a normal normal election okay all right any additional comments on this or questions from the
232board okay on the cons uh comments announcements and other business so I have a couple things um I just want to give a huge shout out to Glen Danny for Their donation to um drport Madison human needs they um the kids over there um With Their donation they did $2,487 which directly impacts um kids and families in our school district um and because of that and and several other donations um Austin Snider um who's the kicker for um Ohio State um he did a toy Drive um and was able to collect enough toys um that filled up a U-Haul um which was incredible um we were able to with human needs um 174 kids were adopted and we had 113 um kids receive um gifts as well so just wanted to say thank you so
233much to Glend Denning the students over there and Austin Snider for for the running the toy drive um and then in addition to that um the Groveport Madison High School gotta give them a shout out um the swim team um did their swimathon they had 18 swimmers um do the swimathon they reached their donation goals all the kids did um and just again I know I've said it before but the coaches over there are doing an awesome job with the kids and um really proud of where they're headed so I just wanted to say I was not able to go to the osba conference because that's during my busiest time of this year at work and um but I did get online and downloaded some of the documents and I would like for us to
234consider there was one that had to do with OS um a board membership um just a handbook for new board members and I think that would be a great tool for our board to adopt something like that that just goes through all the criteria what responsibilities are um just things that roll forward phone numbers contact information those types of things and I think it will be great for um the board to have yeah I would I would Echo that I set in a meeting um with Toledo um city school boards and um their superintendent and they had developed their own as well and had some great input about committees um that I'd like to discuss in an upcoming meeting when we can do a little osba recap I'm sure we all took away some cool
235things from that uh couple things I'll share one is there's all the holiday concerts and things going on and and um if you have a bad day and or you just want a reason to put a smile in your face go to some of those concerts or go to a sport event just see our kids doing the good thing that they're doing um it was I it's really good and it and it uh warms my heart the other thing I'll tell you um PA and I didn't go to obba and we actually moved the meeting to allow us to go to the safety conference in safety conferences you sell the new technology and and different things and artificial intelligence but um this is honestly my single biggest takeaway and I've tried to say it as
236many times with as many people as possible uh one of the sessions we sat in and it was an overview going over a school attack in Nashville but as obvious as it seems you want to protect kids you got to have doors you know there's all the different safety planes and things like that people don't get shot behind closed and lock doors now that that's not 100% but it's like 99% you know and the other thing is it slows victims down and it and it removes it a lot of times they pull and tug and they'll go on to the next thing and slow down to gives responders some time to get there and react but it just it really hit me as we're listening to this is a ton of bricks doors are a
237very simple solution an obvious solution that we we need to have our kids find I'd like to share a couple things from the conference it was great and it was good to get into that I will say uh being at the conference there was a lot of sessions that reinforce that we're doing great things in this school district we have a lot to be proud of I will say at the vendor part of it we had a vault was there and they knew about us and they knew our implementation uh they even knew Jamie and I when we walked by but what a couple of things with the sessions was the communication and collaboration with the local First Responders that's a priority for us and that was a in the sessions a a must that
238schools School District should take away the other one is that I'm real proud of especially with our football games they spend a lot of time talking about securing extracurricular events also the um the our safety alarms and uh having some designation and different differentiation between our alarms so if a everybody's used to hearing the fire alarm and the fire alarm goes off and that means hey it's evacuation because there might be a farm a fire however they talked about the importance of having some designation between alarms and if we have to evacuate for a safety reason or if there's a safety incident that there's a different sound and it's a blue it's it's a blue light and when they explained that it made perfect sense and so Jamie and I were talking about what that
239might look like in our district and then the other piece and this is the last one I won't talk too much about this but it's it's pretty big um you see how I'm wearing my ID and within the ID all the staff have IDs we can connect to this ID a 911 alerter system for all of our staff and what happens is you it depends on how we do it but to make it basic is you have to push this button four times once you push it four times at alerts 911 it's GPS located in the building they have maps of our building and it would even go down to even the classroom so if I'm in room 211 and I hit my button it knows I'm alerting in room 211 at the high school
240so um we're looking at working with navigate 360 uh Dave's been talking with them about getting a quote and and possibly implementing those in our school district in an opportunity there possibility and you probably heard this is uh verse of an alarm you can have alarm in a voice which tends to get people's attention and clarify I think better anything yeah that's correct they and they did say that that's right thank you and I'd like to um give a shout out to the dunlo PTA for um securing coach for our students that a was awesome and I would like to see us have a discussion on the agenda for not January because I probably won't be at that meeting but um getting lockers at the high school or maybe even getting new lock some lockers
241so I know we don't have enough but we did at the facilities meeting jamy came up with a good plan on adding classrooms maybe we could add lockers to that area I think those children those students need to have a place to put their winter gear I I think it it's important I think for us to expect all our students to carry around their coats all winter long and backpacks in our boots it's kind of disrespectful to them and I think if we can do something about it we should do everything in our power to do that and at least talk about it and look at it thanks that's it okay merry Christmas everybody I just wanted to um take a moment just to thank all of our administrators who are here for an awesome
242year I know some of you all came um midy year um thank you for being a part of the team jumping right in adapting and being flexible and finding ways to do what you do best and thank all of our teachers all of our staff custodians volunteers and then also wanted to special thanks to the goport PTO they did an amazing Polar Express event on Friday and I had the pleasure of going and serving and um they even had ways to give donations of students who couldn't go to the Santa shop which their Santa shop was lit I have to say that um it was fire um the kids loved it and had it open and that they were able to raise money for students who may not and we were able to give so
243I wanted to thank all of our PTO and ptas for that matter and all the things that they were doing around the holiday season as we transitioned um being the last day and wishing all of our staff um in the buildings A happy and a much needed break um enjoy it and um remember to be present in the present so be that present meaning disconnect and actually show up for your family um with that if I could have a motion for adjournment second all right that John and Mr Bower if we could have roll call please Mrs hi hi hi hi M all right motion passes the time is 10:46 this meeting is ajour