001e e e order the December 9th 2024 board meeting and we'll move on for an approval of the agenda I move the Board of Education to approve the agenda for the December 9th 2024 board meeting I second buyers yes kadue Blackwood yes Castello yes Franklin yes Gordon Ross Yes Jones yes Kimble yes the motion passes 70 okay we'll move on to the report of the superintendent of schools Dr Swift thank you madam president and members and all who are joined here in person and those who are joining us remote it's my great honor to give an update on uh the Lawrence Public Schools I appreciate the work of our students and teachers school and District teams um our parents and community members as we narrow in on the wrap up of this fall semester if
002you can just believe how quickly uh that has gone uh this fall I just really appreciate that as we're out in schools we still see classrooms fully focused uh teachers are teaching their hearts out and students are learning so uh nine more days of that and we will wish wish everyone a wonderful winter break I'm very grateful to all the staff School families and community members who've joined in conversations uh this fall uh we've been with many many groups and it has been wonderful to hear directly from the experiences of our students um and then over uh many many meetings to start to really hear patterns patterns within the groups and then patterns that extend across the groups so we've learned a lot from listening to school experiences and to the priorities of our folks
003and we look forward uh to sharing all of that back with the community in January now it's not too late uh to jump right onto the front page of the website or uh to use the link in your school newsletter but we'd love for folks to jump into that a written survey if you've not yet done so it's right there on the front page of the website um I just want to give a thank a a thank you and a shout out to our adaptive PE teachers who did such a great job um I'm just going to jump ahead did such a great job in um hosting an inclusive Sports night earlier last week for families of students with disabilities and they do that in cooperation with our Lawrence special education advisory committee um we
004were really delighted last week to see Liberty Memorial Central Middle School uh organizing a um their first student showcase it was last Wednesday evening uh Josh is here and other members were really proud of that effort uh really to see our students share their project-based learning projects with their families and with the Community I I'm sorry the schedule uh issues prevented me from being there personally but I heard great reports about it um wanted to share uh the American Red Cross presented free state senior Lucas Fern with its life-saving award earlier in the fall Lucas successfully performed the heick maneuver to assist Firebird educator Jacob L Lewis who was choking we're so grateful for Mr Lewis's safety and Lucas's quick actions which he learned while serving as a lifeguard uh we have uh amazing Arts
005awards for Lawrence High School students Lola Brown and Adele Erikson earned national awards in the young Arts competition for photography and painting respectfully here is some of their work they each will receive $250 as well as mentorship opportunities and a lifetime of creative professional development as part of an intergenerational community of artists um adding to that uh more Lawrence High School the 28th Annual um High School Visual Arts competition received 640 entries this year and I just want to point out that only 100 of the entries were accepted into the jured exhibition in Kansas and of the hundred that were accepted in the state 21 of them were Lawrence High School students so uh we very proudly uh ruled that day uh in 2D Lola Brown play second and ren J third in three 3D
006r y won first place on her ceramic sculpture and Jaden Moore placed third for their jewelry congratulations to these students and their teachers Emily Marco lados Angela Perkins and Todd poti uh on from a student to staff recognitions Mike Jones as you all know director of Lawrence High bands he was just named the northeast Kansas music Educators Association outstanding band director he also is that professional organization's nominee for the state outstanding music educator award uh on last Friday morning it was my great honor to join uh the team over at New York monu and Elementary as they recognized Jory Roberts Administrative Assistant uh with the fall Class Act award every student at New York was lined up out in the hallway and uh some rules had been concocted so that Jory was the last to
007arrive and what a beautiful surprise for her um her colleagues describe her is hardworking helpful and joyful they say she loves and cares for them and is the happy heart at the center of their school our thanks to Jory Roberts to our lead Partner trity Credit Union for presenting her with a $500 check we're so uh grateful to our farm to school Partners as winter weather arrives we really thank our partners for providing delicious fruits vegetables and protein to our kitchens and cafeterias during the fall growing season look at this data from uh this season all of our Farm and Ranch Partners South Baldwin Farms jerak family produce Juniper Hill Farms table view farm and two Trails Ranch are within 50 miles of Lawrence ensuring Fresh Products nutrition and wellness director Julie Henry provides a
008by the numbers look here that you can see on this slide some of our farm to school purchases over the fall uh we're really excited uh to sh sh uh our cell phone expectations this evening I want to honor and give credit uh to the board of education for your courage in moving forward uh with the policy and I just want to take a moment to assure uh the community that our uh teachers and students have been in conversation uh our principles have actually been working along with our directors and our full team to make sure that our expectations are congruent uh with the board's policy so we're really delighted to be able to bring together all those dots and communication will go out this evening uh pending uh the board's vote um I just
009want to thank you for the opportunity to share this superintendent report and thank you for the opportunity to serve in the Lawrence Public Schools I was going to hit on next steps I can do that during the item or now you can hold them okay go ahead oh me did you say for me to go ahead oh wait you P them okay very good excellent we want to wish everybody a wonderful winter break it's not for nine more days so just saying thank you Dr swi thank you so uh I also have on my um uh we're moving on to the report of the president uh of the board and I wanted to also extend to everyone uh My Hope and wish that you have a relaxing uh winter break and to say thank you
010for the work that you're doing to wrap up this semester both to students staff Educators and families I know you're you are coming along with us on that so thank you to everyone um the uh rest of my uh president report is an invitation for um officer Bishop to join us here um at the board uh she has brought with her um well I'll let I'll let you share a little bit so I've asked her to come and explain um introduce us to Rosie yeah yeah yeah if you would she has some B oh do this you can work with her a little wow okay well we're not very exciting but um I'm officer Bishop I'm a school resource officer one of six in our community and I'm uh work primarily at West Middle School
011the Lawrence to Poli department has um instituted a therapy dog and her name is Rosie and so she um has been coming to school for about three months um and the kids absolutely love her Miss Jones had the opportunity um I spoke um to her college class the other day and we were speaking about some of the interactions that I've had with students um with being in the school for two years prior to her and now having her I can see a marked difference in engagement and connection C with students um and I know that Dr Swift met her on our community conversations night and was a big fan so she's here with me this evening if uh after the meeting if you'd like any pets or anything like that we might ask you to
012have her come on the days we have tough things to talk about to keep us all in line so I appreciate your work and the um that you've taken on this new Endeavor in your career uh and really thank you for doing it bringing it to the kids sure she's a great dog yeah okay um we will now uh move on to public comment we have a couple public comments that are specific to the cell phone policy so we typically hold those um uh qu those until we get to the that agenda item so if um just so you know I I have them we're looking forward to hearing your comments before we vote so we'll hear from you so that it can inform our um disc decision and then I think we might have
013one other do we have another um is there anyone online or is uh Mandy here and nobody on okay so if we hear from Mandy we we might be able to make some space for that um to move the meeting along um even though we are going to hold the public comment uh I think it's it might be um appropriate to read the public comment policy now if that's okay and we'll just hold uh just in case Mandy shows up do you mind the USD 497 Board of Education welcomes public comments and thanks you for taking the time to talk to us about our policies and procedures we set aside this time during our regular meetings to hear from the public patrons who wish to participate in public comment must fill out the public comment
014registration form so that District staff or the board can follow up with you as necessary this is your time to share your opinions however public comment is not the appropriate form for making complaints about specific staff or students if your comments relate to complaints concerning students or staff such complaints must be addressed to District staff as provided under board policies KNN or GAE the board president or presiding officer of the meeting May direct that a public comment request be redirected to staff to comply with board policy and or to protect the privacy of individual staff or students if you need assistance in sharing a complaint or concern with District staff please let the board Clerk or other District staff know topics discussed in public comment shall be gered to the business of the board comments
015are acts that are threatening to staff the board or others and attendance including the use of language or behavior that is disruptive of the board meeting will not be permitted during public comment in addition because students may be in attendance or watching online members of the public will refrain from using foul or obscene language the district assumes no responsibility and or liability for the information shared during public comment the views expressed are solely those of the speakers and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Lawrence Public Schools the board president or presiding officer will invite comments comment on top not included on the meeting agenda at the beginning of each meeting comments relating to agenda items are welcome after the board has had the opportunity to discuss the topic please limit your comments to
016three minutes thank you gr so we will uh move on now to board commentary I'm goingon to start with uh Carol is joining us remotely um uh Carol do you have comment tonight or do you want me to move on um this is Carol I don't have too much to say because my throat is really sore but I well I um I'm here thank you thank you we appreciate that you're here um I'll start at the end there we go yolinda uh good evening um since our last meeting I did have the opportunity to attend uh the KLC local elect officials uh Fellowship down in witchar uh it was uh very uh enlightening uh I attended some of the program before during leadership Lawrence but to get to be a part of this and to
017be a part of other elected officials in different parts of Kansas was very enlightening to notice that know that we are not the only School District that is going through the issues that we're going through and stuff and so gave us a list of um more people we can talk to when we're having those those common issues um it was nice to hear how some of the other districts are doing things to help their retention rate one of the districts took one of their older schools and um turned it into a daycare center for their District staff so I thought that was a pretty cool idea um they kind of the teachers was the ones they got together and brought that to the board to do so I thought that was pretty cool as well
018we had a couple of mayors that was there as well City Council Members Lawrence kind of dominated the the lead the fellowship I think it was what six of us there from Lawrence so uh it was pretty nice and then also attend a negotiations meeting on last week so thank you for going and sharing with us what you learned and the good ideas that maybe we can Implement here so uh an Castell um so we have some policies up for second read tonight policy jda AA student misuse of medications this would allow the discipline of any student found to be self- administering their own medicine at a dosage or rate exceeding product label instructions Distributing over the counter or prescription meds to other students or possessing another student over the counter or prescription meds policy
019JG fgb supervision of medications this has been amended to remove duplicative language in student self- Administration now found in jgf BGA that policy is also up for student or for second raid student self- administration of medication lays out policy around this topic including student eligibility authorization required employee immunity waiver of liability as well as additional requirements for students prone to specified emergencies um and it also notes that Controlled Substances may not be self- administered um earlier today I was able to tour the uh College and Career Center is a part of my role on the schools Foundation I am the board liaison for that school um it was great to learn more about all the different programs that are housed there and I was able to watch uh some students learning how to dice a
020potato and they were all way better than I am at it so I think I should come in for onion day as well um and I was very sorry to have missed the Southwest band concert uh last Thursday but due to a delayed flight and Southwest taking 35 minutes to get my baggage out I was not able to get back in time so and that's all I have thank you all right uh so um just wanted to share a few things actually going back to kind of the middle of November since I hadn't had a chance to share about them um the facilities and operations and policy committee meetings in November that I attended I think were reported on uh during the last board meeting um on November 13th I had the uh lovely opportunity
021to attend the chamber government relations lunch where Dr Swift reported on uh work of our district and I really appreciate her um sharing with the community um all of the great things that um that she had to share about what we are doing in Lawrence Public Schools uh that next day was Ruby Bridges walk to school day and I want to thank Ashley Smith at Quail Run Elementary for the invitation to come and um be a uh an observer of the parade that they did of their students they had all of their students make posters and do a walk in honor of rubri bridges and it was delightful and thank you to Mrs Smith and the quail staff for organizing such an inspiring event the kids posters were outstanding um kasb convention was that weekend
022as well um and I wanted to give a shout out to the usd497 team steam robotics team which participated in the district Showcase in Witchita on November 15th I spent some time talking with students on the robotics team and they uh uh did an outstanding job of representing uh their work in our district and our students and staff um thank you to the community members that uh spoke with me at the West Middle School Community conversation on November 19th um I too participated I was one of the six Lawrence folks that were able to participate in the leadership Center um fellowship program along with Yolanda we had um just really excellent deep conversations and some really good learning that I hope to um use use as we do our work at the board table so
023uh appreciated that opportunity and then I wanted to give um a couple of quick kind of legislative policy updates so uh interim committee meet interim Committees of the legislature have been meeting um in the last couple of months right now the big ones that impact um K12 are the legislature has decided to do its own budget crafting process so there are multiple meetings of the legislative budget committee happening this month um the education uh budget for the Department of Education and the recommendations for K12 funding will be on the agenda on um Friday so they are meeting from 9:00 am to 5:00 P pm on Friday um and it is streamed online so you can watch it on YouTube the education stuff is supposed to happen in the morning between I think 9:45 and noon
024um so if you're interested in observing in observing that conversation um and then uh also there was a meeting of the uh uh uh joint financial institutions pensions committee um they got i i attended that meeting in person they got a dayong update on um Capers and had uh some discussions about making recommendations to legislature on Capers everyone agrees that they need to make improvements to Capers 3 it seemed from the conversation but there's not much agreement about how to do that because of the price tag um Capers 3 is the version of the retirement program that anybody coming into the profession after about 2015 um is under and it's underperforming expectations um and and hampering recruitment efforts and retention efforts for younger teachers so that's a a conversation to to continue watching um also
025leadership elections are happening and committee assignments are happening leadership elections happened last week uh for both the House and Senate um there are going to be changes in in leadership in both Chambers um uh new um new um Majority Leader uh in the in the Senate um Senate vice president um some other changes committee assignments are beginning to come out uh the um House of Representatives has announced all of the committee assignments and chairs for the Republicans um we will have a new house chair of uh the house committee on education that will be representative Susan Estus um there is a new chair for the house K12 education budget committee that's representative Jason getts um we're still waiting on Senate committee assignments for all the Senate committees for both parties and also the um the
026Democrats haven't made their committee assignments to the house committees yet either so there's still some uh committee assignments to be made that will be watching and then the State Board of Education meets tomorrow and Wednesday and it is anticipated that the board they heard the report on the cell phone Task Force um last month it is anticipated that they will adopt their guidance at the meeting uh this week so thank you that's that's all I have that's probably enough um I just have a couple things Thursday the 5th um I went and helped in uh Dr Barker's room at Billy Mills um with the classroom assignment which was a lot of fun uh and then um negotiations later that evening with Yolanda and then a couple items on consent uh there's an item on there
027for the disposal of outdated uniforms um that we have on there and then we have two items for um it one is for wireless access points we we're uh um e- rate supported to to purchase those with a um Financial um contribution from the District of just over U $102,000 and then renewal of network security software to help against um internet uh threats malware and filtering uh internet traffic for a cost of $193,000 thank you uh I just want to uh recognize that it's really helpful to hear the reports from the committee so from negotiations from policy and from facilities it's um we've fallen into this and to hear the legislative report is helpful and it's a nice pattern so thank you all very much okay well move on to the approval of consent agenda
028I move the Board of Education approve the items listed on the consent agenda second kadu Blackwood yes Costello yes Franklin yes Gordon Ross Yes Jones yes Kimble yes buyers yes the motion passes 70 uh we're going to take a moment to recognize a retirement the board would like to thank Ronda R for her five years of service and offer sincere appreciation for um everything that uh she did for the district and for students and staff okay we'll move on to uh approval of board policy jcaa which is the cell phone and electric device policy this is the second read so we will vote this evening should the board choose to um and we have Dr Swift with us today and uh extend appreciation to Dr irvan and uh JC robertonson and Christine uh Kristen Ryan
029for their assistance with this is it right oh it's not show oh no that's super oh I'm sorry my bad thank you thank you so much was there very good thank you Madame President members of the board and of the community uh since our last meeting on November 25th we've done a great deal of work to fine-tune the guidance of implementation in the schools and we've worked uh with a number of groups had good um spirited conversations with students um and really are bringing tonight a set of guidance and our communication will go out uh of course uh pending the board's vote but we'll go out this evening with uh the expectations as well as um all of the guidance and really of full chapter on uh the rationale or why behind this change so
030the change is really very simply stated uh that as of January 6th the Lawrence Public Schools will Implement cell phone free instruction and the goal of this change is really about one thing and that is lifting up the teaching and learning that occur every day in our classrooms and lifting that up by diminishing and removing as many distractions as possible and in this day and age the number one distraction is that of the cell phone so the expectations are really very simple uh at the elementary level uh students will not have cell phones uh out at school at all if their parents are sending one uh for safety or other reasons that will remain in the backpack and not uh in the classroom so uh then at Middle School really students use of cell phones
031uh will not occur uh during the school day there is one caveat at middle school that allows our principales to work with their teams and on occasion uh if students are demonstrating their personal responsibility and ability to manage their devices and keeping them put away during the school day on occasion perhaps a lunch uh where they would celebrate um um being able to use their phones but throughout the school day uh at middle school for the most part not having cell phones out and then at the high school we really are following a developmental a progressive uh approach because we know that our ability to manage the phone while it's on us is a life skill and so at high school the use of cell phones and personal devices uh is prohibited during class time
032um however high school students if they're able uh to manage their device would have uh that Latitude to check in on passing period or at lunch and you know when folks ask the most number one most commonly asked question what are the consequences if students aren't able to meet the expectation and you know we really are going to spend the open weeks of 2025 learning as a system together because this is a significant behavioral and cultural shift and we all recognize that however we've talked about it quite a lot and at the end of the day a student's ability to manage their device uh is a privilege that if a student is unable to learn to be able to do that and all of our supports uh and interventions really are not working um then
033that would end up as a forfeiture of the ability to manage one's own device and we hope that that doesn't happen because we really feel like if we're preparing students to go to college and for the real world uh it's much better if they learn to manage them so uh that's an overview uh our next steps are clear we will be on a full course press uh all of my team and all of our principal and all of our administrators in the district to support our principles we've been in close contact with them many of them facilitated staff meetings over this past week where all of the information was delivered uh but these next nine days we will be on a full court press to share the information to participate in ongoing education around the
034why because if we all remember how important it is and members have placed a book at your table that's one of the books uh that we'll use uh for our education efforts during January February and March it's called the anxious generation the we rewiring of childhood uh because of Technology we will be looking at that book we will be looking at screening the movie screenagers um Free State High School has already reached out to host their January parent meeting as a screening of the movie screenagers so that they can introduce that information to their community in fact we've had Outreach from all parts of town to host either a a book talk or book club on with the book or uh or a screening of the movie so we'll be doing a full court press
035this is a community in Endeavor it it it rises and falls on on our classrooms but it is a school and a community Endeavor to support this cultural shift uh members we will be out in schools this week uh to collect before data we'll be walking classrooms and schools and Counting the number of phones we see we won't announce our presence because we want to get the real data um and then January February and March will continue to take those data polls just to see that we're making positive progress and we're achieving that goal of a distraction and cell phone free uh instructional environment I was recently talking uh to a colleague in another part of the country uh they implemented districtwide uh in August and I was inspired by his on the ground words
036and they were they were this um that this move is a game Cher for teachers who are committed to teaching and for students in their learning academic growth and their social emotional development as well so I can't wait uh to continue to update you as we're here at this board table on our progress uh we know that big hard things like this uh are worth the effort but we also know it will take quite a lot of effort on everyone's part uh to get from here to there so with that trustees or members I thank you and uh I believe that covers our part of it although I've got members of the team handy if you have questions okay uh before we um before I open up for questions I just wanted to clarify a
037couple points that came up last U meeting and one of them was that this is the the beginning of this uh process there'll be a um a review from the policy committee to see how the implementation is going and whether or not we need to refine uh the the policy in terms of the way it's written now and then the other the other piece I heard in terms of the evolution is that we're beginning to look at the utilization of screen times at the elementary level could you just speak to that real briefly before I open it up to questions yes forgive me I intended to hit on Elementary um what we're really hearing from from our teachers in the classroom uh from our principals and uh it actually is the number one request among
038the hundreds of parents uh that we've heard from on the tour and that is a a focus on the reduction of screen time uh at the elementary level so uh uh director Roberson uh is engaging the principes already have an action plan I'll uh copy you all on that um to really engage in a thoughtful conversation with our teacher Leaders with our parents with our principles and our goal is by fourth quarter to bring forward some recommendations we do want to use uh the power of technology to help students with skill building uh outside of school hours if that's helpful but we also want to ensure uh that we're not rewiring uh as our research tells us we have to be very careful with young students around the amount of screen time so I can't
039wait to see the recommendations that come out of this study of the amount of screen time at elementary thank you okay I'm gonna open it up for um questions and would you would um I'm going to start with Carol Carol do you have qu uh questions that you would like to pose now um you can also interject whenever but I just don't want to forget you there well um I don't have so much a question but I would just like to thank Mr David Reber from free state free state and Zachary Casey for bringing this to our attention back in June this is something that um has been coming up time and time again and I'm so glad that the um it was teacher initiated I appreciate that thanks Carol uh board members that have
040questions gr others okay I'll start with you um so I just want to Dr Swift first I just want to thank you and your team for the work that you did B uh after last time to to take the feedback that you got and to to rework both the guidance and the and the and the policy I like the the progression through the through the grades um so I'm I'm I I like the policy as it stands I like that um I like the mindset going into it that it's we're going to we're going to go into it and then we're going to review it as we go and and and and and it's not a it's it's not a it's not set Stone but it's it's we're going to we're going to work on
041a on a cultural shift using this as a as a guide which I like um the other thing that I would ask um if if you're if you're willing to take a feedback um on something else that you said while um and this would be for JC as as as as well when you're looking at elementary screen time when you're working on that proposal if that were to include a reduction of devices at the elementary level would it be possible to explore taking those taking the funding from those devices and turning them around to replace iPads with iMacs at the high school if if ultimately that was the direction that we went I would love to see how that were H how that would play out thank you so much so not really where we're
042going but I saw an opportunity to bring it up so thank you uh I'm also highly interested in that so appreciate the investigation and that we've definitely um heard from students that there might be benefit in uh reviewing that decision the board made um which had fiscal implications but um might have had uh negative educational ones as well so appreciate that you'll be looking at that thank you other questions sure um can I get one clarification I know there was an exception as far as um medical reasons for cell phone can I get a more clarification on is there a form that they need to fill out is there I know it's if it's written in their IEP but for the ones that don't have an IEP but they do have the continuous glucose monitoring
043devices that they need to have on and stuff like that is there a medical form that needs to be filled out for the parents thank you so much it would be the same one that's in place for all of their accommodations and by that I mean just making sure that that uh case person uh and the and the teacher uh is aware the administrator is aware and making sure that we have that noted in power school but we'll follow the same process whether that's a 504 an IEP or just simply an accommodation generally uh that we make um but um it it will be a process of conversation and um I think uh Kevin harell has helped us to understand if that is not already an accommodation um in an IEP or a 504 then
044we'll need to have that conversation but for medical reasons there would be no question that would be taken care of thanks Alanda Bob did you have a question um actually just more of a a statement I'd like this to thank the staff uh for the work you've done I think at our last board meeting when we addressed this there was definitely some incongruity between policy and and our procedures and I I like um I us I like the sausage making of this I think people look at it and say well you wrote a policy and they don't match this process is where we get them to match and come up with a policy that fits so I really think that uh we're headed in the right direction I I I think everyone needs to understand
045that this is not the end it's simply the beginning on the road this to me is a major systems change uh which takes a lot of work I think parents need need to understand uh that their responsibilities will change as well um that you no longer can pick up your phone and call your student or your child and expect they're going to answer that phone the likelihood is not is they won't be um so I I just want to thank everyone and I hope families can deal with that I think teachers will have some learning to do for some of us are some of them because the reality is this is a part of your classrooms of which you do the management of there will be no additional staff managing classrooms around cell phones it's
046basically a part of the teaching environment that you control uh any other questions before I move to public comment um not so much a question just uh I appreciate uh Bob's kind of pointing out that this is this is the process um you know we uh we really we actually really began looking at this as a policy committee we started talking about this and either at our April or May meeting so we were very early on in this year talking about how we were going to have to address this we had we had it on our agenda in June by July we had a draft um going but that was a working draft and we asked our staff uh to take that and get feedback and help us figure out what the best way to
047do this work would be with the goal of this cell phone free instructional time and I um I feel good that that process has resulted in us taking that feedback um adjusting our guidance adjusting our policy doing the work that as a board we are um we need to do with our district leadership so thank you to everyone for um you know kind of coming together and making this a reality um I think it's very timely for our district to be adopting this tonight uh it's uh state board is getting ready to adopt guidance for districts across the state tomorrow we obviously saw that this was a need and we're working on this um on a timeline that is allowing us to adopt our policy and begin this work um now rather than waiting months
048more after that guidance has come out and really our our policy aligns with uh that guidance in in many many ways um I do want to address you know one of the things that's in the State Board guidance that'll get written about this week is that they are recommending um storage of phones um not on the students's person we consider that um in our discussions and I appreciate our district administration's guidance um in terms of how we can make this work in our district in a way that meets multiple concerns and needs of different um of different groups um while at the same time achieving the goal that we all share around um improving the learning environment for our students improving the teaching environment for our staff so um that's uh what I wanted to
049share and I uh look forward to hearing the comments and and the remainder of the board discussion thank you ready to hear public comment um uh one Shannon just said something that reminded me of of one other comment we did there is um through this process whenever you're doing this type of participatory um policymaking you learned things that you weren't that came up as part of the conversation like for example we maybe needed to look at the elementary screen time as well uh the other thing that has emerged is this discussion around apps that are not um that we need for curriculum that cannot be put on the iPad and there's discussions around exceptions for cell phone use in those cases um I would ask the district to look closely at when those requests are
050made and to see um what's the barrier to it being implemented on our device uh is it the is it the device itself do we need a different device um is that app something that is um is so expensive that it's difficult to have as part of the curriculum and then to to challenge the district to look at if there is a curriculum that is not going to be available to every student because not every student has a particular device um what are adjustments that we need to make there but I think in most cases what we're going to find is that um there is a workaround for teachers to continue to do the Innovation that they're doing with technology and not have to um water down their their curriculum while still supporting every student
051that has um the same access to uh an electronic device to be successful in their um academic experiences so I I would like us to um begin to look at where are those requests for exceptions why are those requests and how can we accommodate those Educators and getting those tools available to every student because I know that's what they want when I'm talking with them um similar to gr's discussion around laptops that's also been true around some applications so um I know the district's already looking at that and I appreciate the work that you all are doing on that um um I'd like to call um make time for folks that have come to to speak um gr read the the public um comment so um when you come up to the podium there'll be
052a like a three minute timer and I'll raise my hand if if we're getting close to that so uh Jennifer Wilson welcome I'm glad you're here thanks and if you can't get everything in in three minutes we'll definitely please uh stop us afterwards or send us an email or something if it doesn't get on in I just want to start out by saying I I do have a head trimmer so if you see me kind of do this just stabilizing myself thank you for sharing that with us okay so mine is completely commentary okay um thank you for allowing me to speak tonight regarding an issue that is pretty important for me I had a lot to say but honestly cell phones are going to be banned that's the way it is so at this
053point I'm just going to tell you that I had the privilege of observing kids in a middle school with the permission of a principal and what I saw basically was I saw kids on the iPads 247 they didn't put them down they were playing games on them that has since been addressed um I did see two teachers on their phones I saw one kid on their phone that checked their phone for the time the um passing in between classes in the hallway I believe is about 3 minutes to get to your next class I didn't see a kid pull out a phone I walked behind them they thought I was a substitute teacher they had no idea who my kid was who I was they thought I was a teacher they didn't pull out their
054phones they were trying to get to their next class so I'm old school I believe in books I believe in lockers I believe in winter coats being used and having a place for those winter coats which we don't have lockers um I worry about with the screen time as we're starting to notice with the younger kids the learning retention are these kids actually learning and I'm also worrying about them always being on the iPads they're not writing physically writing cursive is gone um my my son my student his writing is a ferocious they don't practice writing enough and I don't see a lot of the teachers and this is in high school I observed in my daughter's High School all three of my children have gone to the Lawrence Public Schools I don't see a
055lot of the teachers going out reading books to the kids hey what do you think of that what do you what's your favorite part I don't see that engagement that we need with kids and I think that the technology is taking that away from kids enjoying what they're learning and having an opinion you know you can ask the the kids to write down their opinions but they're gonna they're going to write down what the teachers want to hear and sometimes it's okay to say I don't like this book I couldn't stand Homer or Odyssey all of that I couldn't stand it so I told my teachers that and they worked with me but I don't think we have that in anymore and I really think that's important I think it's just something we should think
056about Middle School does that mean I'm one minute it's you I apologize so I'm over yes yeah I appreciate you're coming up and taking time with yeah we appreciate you're coming in um and uh observing your school thank you appreciate that um uh Justin um yeah if I could just piggyback on that I think um everything I just heard I'm on board with and I think there are more and more papers coming out scientific papers that show that the way that the nervous system engages with screens is very different than the way that nervous systems engage with paper and pencil that being said I do want to say thank you to the school board and for superintendent Swift for navigating through this um it's probably not as far as I would go but I really
057do understand the pros and cons of all this it's a very complicated issue but I do hope that the school board uh remains amendable to reconsidering these policies going forward and one other thing I think that is also worth considering is there's going to be a lot of data coming from different School departments across the country that are using Yonder bags they're using all different ways of actually maybe even keeping the phones off the kids for certain parts of the day off of their physical body and so I think you know keeping an eye ey on those results is going to be something that the school board should consider because there's going to be a lot of experiments going on probably in the next six months to a year that are worth keeping an eye
058on thanks I appreciate it thank you for your work on this issue okay uh I'm gonna ask now if there's a motion I'd be glad to make the motion if if we are ready mhm okay um except that I apparently uh left the meeting uh give just one moment please and I will be back there there we go okay now I've got it I move the Board of Education adopt board policy jcaa cell phones and electronic devices following second reading I second Costello yes Franklin yes Gordon Ross Yes Jones yes Kimble yes buyers yes kuo Blackwood yes the motion passes 70 okay thank you board members Kelly yeah I just wanted to I didn't have any questions but I didn't want to have a comment so um I wanted to thank Dr Swift and all
059of the admin who worked um tirelessly on this I know it was not easy and there was a lot of last minute scrambling and changes um I I think I said it at the last meeting um I'm a proponent of you know an even stronger ban but based off of you know leaving this to The Experts those who are on with the feet on the ground who are doing the work um and understand it better than I do um I was willing to support this version of the policy also knowing that um we are going to continue to look at this and that's really one of the things that I really appreciate I feel like um that hasn't always been the case in the past with different things that the the school board has looked
060at or approved um and so I'm excited to show the community this opportunity where we are open to feedback and we are monitoring and it's not a set it and forget it it's a we're going to see how this goes and see what adjustments need to be made on the go forward and then take that action and not just kind of let things fizzle out appreciate that um I particularly appreciate that coming from you as you are on the policy committee and now we will all hold you to keeping us honest that we will review this policy and look at you know do we need cell phones in middle school for example all right thank you okay so we're gonna um take a uh five minute break um and come back at e e e
061going to call the meeting back to um we will move on now to item 4.1 uh the approval of the uh contract with proximity learning I'll ask Christen Ryan and Leah wisdom are the administrators responsible for the report thank you madam president I'll uh go ahead and then the team will be available if you all should have questions please take that down uh we are talking this evening about a proximity Tool uh the board you have the uh documents on uh the agenda the board has been briefed on this I want to be clear that our use of this is simply as a tool to support uh particular group of students and their Spanish instruction over at West Middle School where we have uh struggled through this fall to maintain highly certificated Staffing in the
062class classroom we have been fortunate in that situation to have two uh very committed uh substitutes who are in relationship with the students but it's important to us uh to have a highly qualified teacher so the proximity tool allows us to um bring that teacher virtually uh to the classroom and to continue with our substitutes who have the relationship on the ground to continue the work in the classroom I want to be clear here uh that I believe we believe deeply in the value of World Language that is why we're taking this unusual step to ensure that our students get to finish their spring semester uh we believe um here in this University Town of Lawrence that uh every student should be proficient in a second language and we believe in that so strongly that
063we're bringing to you tonight a tool that is a step beyond what we would normally ask for or normally do um I also believe deeply as I know you do in the value the transformative value and power of a passionate teacher of World Language um I was one of those and there's nothing better than having that highly qualified deeply committed amazingly passionate teacher of World Language it transforms students lives so I want to be C members of the board this tool this evening is about doing the right thing for a group of students a full case load of students for this spring semester but it in no way is demonstrative of any uh lesser commitment to having the very best teacher in front of our students so you will notice that the motion reads up
064to $35,000 and that is the cost if we were to continue through uh the end of the school year um however we will continue to vigorously recruit I'm looking over at the team they're out every week uh trying to find great passionate teachers we will continue to recruit and we hope uh that we'll only have to do this for a short period of time and uh we'll keep you posted and updated I appreciate the support of this team uh I will follow up uh with a conversation with our Spanish teacher team in the district because I feel so strongly uh about our efforts to continue to offer quality language and also want to solve this problem in this moment so um we have our team on hand if there are questions uh but this is
065a commonly used tool across the country when you run into that situation where you your qualified teacher is not readily available thank you uh board members are there questions pertaining to this item is this something that we looked at also um for the German when we was that one of the conversations there yes yes thank you member Castello we've looked at it a few times um and really uh are also looking if we're going to be in this position on occasion perhaps leveraging through Lawrence virtual School uh an approach from within our own team uh that would be similar to proximity but it would be our own folks so a number of ways to go at this and of course our our top and first priority is always to have that fully certificated teacher uh
066right there in the classroom thank you thank you um so I appreciate that um rather than um walking away from a commitment to provide language instruction we are trying to problem solve a way to continue providing it I think that's really really important um I I will add that and I believe it was at the last month's state board meeting uh they presented some of this data on teacher vacancies and one of the areas that they mentioned in their list um in addition to the ones that we hear about a lot which are the um middle and high school science and special education uh language teachers was was one of the areas where they identified a Statewide challenge in recruiting um CER certificated instructors so I just wanted to share that context this is not
067a struggle that is Just Happening Here in our community it is happening um else all over our state um you know it's the teacher shortage is very real and um there are certain areas that are definitely hit harder um so thank you for trying to problem solve this in a way that will will continue provide um high quality opportunities for our students I also appreciate the dialogue that you'll be having with the uh the Spanish teachers themselves and other uh World language teachers so that we can see um learn from them what are some ways we might problem solve I'm sure HR has been working on that as well and um appreciate all of your efforts to continue to prioritize getting a teacher into the classroom thank you okay is there a motion oh wait
068y you got something okay maybe my brain just works differently than everybody else's um because I got different ideas that's going through my head now I know how we looking for qualified teachers and things like that and this is something that we are really lacking for our students you know so have we reached out to families you know you know how we trying to do community engagement to get the ball rolling have we reached out to families to see I know we need certified qualified teachers that teach but some of the languages that we're trying to teach some of these families are proficient in it so I know there's might be a red tape and Hoops we got to jump over and things like that but to get the community more involved in helping us
069teach their children could we maybe explore that Avenue or see if maybe we can get a family member that is proficient in German to come and hold an after school course with the to come with the kids or something like that just to see I mean to see how many students are really interested in learning German you know so that's just how my brain works I do apologize absolutely and Miss Ryan actually was recently with a group of Spanish speakers uh and shared back with me exactly what you're saying is really that Outreach to them I don't know if you want to Mr try and give a response or um but there are require ments for the classroom teaching but certainly to do enrichment or after school um yeah yes thank you for bringing that
070up and I I do think it is that balance of meeting that state lure for during the school day but then that opportunity to provide students additional Community Support um specifically with some of our um groups in Lawrence SOS is one of them in terms of supporting our our student so yes thank you anyone else uh is there a motion I move the Board of Education to approve a contract with proximity learning in an amount not to exceed $335,000 hi second Franklin yes Gordon Ross Yes Jones yes Kimble yes buyers yes kadu Blackwood yes costell hello yes the motion passes 70 okay uh we're going to move on to the Athletics facility study and Dr englebrook is here and yeah [Music] welcome I'll go ahead and finish it you started oh okay got president Jones
071board members Dr Swift thank you very much for this opportunity it is a interesting challenging and exciting time to come to you and talk to you about this uh study that we're working on I need to begin by telling you the importance it is to realize that over the past 10 to 15 years a great deal of great work has been done in our district at each and every one of our buildings and our reports should no way reflect negatively upon that work our reports are showing that some of our facilities have worn out and we're beginning to identify those we began that entire process four years ago by looking at the things that were the most obvious roofs leaking potholes in the parking lot curbs and sidewalks that were not uh functional and we
072have been working on those and we will continue to work on those but the past year the board has asked us to begin to look at some other things we began with our Fine Arts study our Performing Arts study and it opened our eyes to a number of things that needed to be addressed it opened our eyes to things that would benefit our students and our staff not only in the co-curricular activities but during the school day in the very same way when we began the athletic study we were thinking we would be looking mostly at athletic improvements the facilities are all used for athletics but our staff came back and talked to us about how this would impact their classroom experience and their students classroom experience also we hope that you see some similarities
073between the two studies we've attempted them attempted to do them in the same way and we will continue doing this in this manner so that there are those common threads and things begin to align and are easier to pull together in this study we did conduct a visual survey a comparisons of fa and comparison of facilities with our neighboring districts I've already mentioned but all of these facilities are used both as classroom and co-curricular venues things that we need to keep in mind at all times our gymnasiums are not just a Friday night gym Friday during the day they are a classroom what we have done we have conducted site visits we've asked for staff feedback one-on-one during those site visits we've then provided that information back to the staff allowed them to give us
074feedback on it we've opened up online electronic capabilities of Staff providing us input and the last couple weeks we've held two sessions where administrators and staff members have been able to either in person or online come to us and talk to us about individual items each of those has been very very um important to this process you have a very long report this evening if we chose to go Page by page I don't think you want us to do that you also have the benefit of having the gentleman here this evening who put that report together Doug Loveland Doug put together the final draft uh the final copy of both our performing art study and is working on the final copy of this study again helping us to keep them a common theme and helping
075him to work through the process of the presentation I think you're going to find that at the end of this evening what we find out through all of Doug's information is we need to do some prioritization and we are going to be at that point where in all good dissertation studies you come to the conclusion further research and study is needed so Doug if you would like to begin I'd appreciate that thank you and thank you for allowing me to come speak with you again um I do have a hard copy for myself of the full report in case I get detailed questions from anyone in particular named Miss Kimble um that does tend to happen but I have a much briefer set of notes that I'd like to buzz through on the presentation if
076you want to interrupt me while I'm presenting it is not going to Rattle me if fear not I think you might get those questions from an too I'm I was just about to say I thought he was gonna say an cello so just speculated um so thank you for allowing me to come talk to you about this again um so I want to reiterate what Dr Engelberg said we had participants from really three different groups District staff uh my staff at ACI Bowland Architects and in this instance again we brought in a special consultant as with the Performing Art Center study I will be the first to admit that although we have some expertise there are people that are more expert in this topic than we are so I brought in a group called vssr
077design led by Vance Rea um please don't ask me to spell Vance's last name I've known him for 25 years and I can't spell it um VSR is a Specialty Sports Landscape Company um they have assisted me in the design of facilities around the region and in this instance he helped us evaluate the landscape architecture Stadium Sports specific components of those outdoor elements my team took care of the architectural elements outdoor and indoor um as with Performing Art Center study we did essentially six major things we did a site evaluation we did do an electronic staff survey that we left open open for about a week um we did a first draft report that we distributed to the same team that had access to that survey and then we did a series of forums to
078give them an opportunity to come in and give us um see some detailed feedback um I want to reiterate both when we did our in-person evaluations and when we had the staff Forum um we had great interactions with LPS staff um in the in the site review and we sort of invading their space they were courteous answered questions gave us feedback live um in the forums they came having reviewed the report which is fairly long and with detailed questions I'll be very Frank um on that final version the last page last two pages is the sort of uh give and take of those staff forms and you can see we made corrections to the report based on the feedback we got to staff they corrected some assumptions we had made they corrected our interpretation of
079what we saw in a couple of places that is incredibly valuable to make sure that we're being accurate um I I've got a sort of an asteris slide on here that I did not have last time um and that is that for a a study uh where this study ended up going um it was very difficult for us to just produce a list of costs unlike the Performing Art Center study where the result said things like we should consider um revising the uh sound system in an auditorium that's a fairly discret project could be fairly easily priced the recommendations in here as you've seen in the report and I'm going to talk you through here in the next few are a little more nebulous um line items um can be combined with other line items
080maybe for some economy of scale maybe for some successful dual use so it's a little harder for me to give you a an agenda of costs at the very end I did give you some highlevel costs that we've been seeing around the Kansas City Metropolitan Community I can identify where we got those costs from if you want to ask um just to to let you understand the order of magnitude for the sorts of things that we are describing so let's start with the middle schools um we did do two major activities we did our own field assessment of your facilities condition of things sizes of things numbers of things we also did a peer review study um for Shaunie mission for doto for Garder it was a visual survey um Google Map evaluation a little
081bit of working knowledge in those districts already or OA I got a sat down a sit down with the director of facilities Travis palangi who's a a former colleague he's an architect um he was very generous with my with his time we went through a checklist for both high school and middle school to sort of identify fairly specifically where OA is going with their facilities and there's some differences um some of those differences are district choices and some of those differences are just prioritization the peer study for the middle schools was favorable um your facilities in terms of quantity what you have what you've chosen to put in place for your middle schoolers for those teachers for those coaches is essentially equivalent to what other districts are doing um the concerns of the Middle School
082are wear and tear we're starting to see some fairly significant wear and tear at the track complex um across the board um they're of a similar age um and they're wearing to the point where we're starting to be sort of end of life and and one of those symptoms if you're walking getting a little Fitness in at one of the Middle School tools and you're walking those orange tracks and you start to see the Black coming up through that is the top what we call structured spray actually wearing all the way off and the next layer of the black mat coming through um that's just a sign that you're getting towards life end um couple of places we had some places where we identified some slope questions nothing tragic but some areas that would if
083we decided to improve those tracks we would recommend we investigate a little bit more um tennis specifically is at end of life and you're going to hear this when I talk about the high schools as well um we are getting to the point where patching is no longer anything more than a two-year repair you would like to get five to seven years out of a out of a a crack patch um we are past that on your tennis courts across the district um at the high school level their their reports are a little more alarming they've got more competitive Nuance to to sort of monitor um but speaking speaking for the middle schools we're getting to the point where the Middle School tennis courts are just sort of Beyond really successfully being patched um future
084items that did come out of those peer reviews um one OA talked a lot about being on a maintenance and repair cycle they talked a lot about how they had spent a lot of time getting organized so that they could keep track of the expiration of items and just get on the treadmill of keeping their facilities in the condition they would hope to keep them out um and there was there was a lot of of back and forth between me and Mr palangi about um their efforts to get on a cycle if you will um the other one is is that they are beginning to consider putting turf at their middle schools one multi-purpose field I think we can all close our eyes and assume that that's in the middle of a track but one
085multi-purpose field per Middle School campus to give them an all- weather surface for PE for track and field um for Community use if they decide to go back to you community use at their campuses um and and just uh having something that they can count on as long as it's not actively raining or lightninging um that's one of those things that's creeping to the north from Texas and Oklahoma and getting into Us in Kansas I know that similar communities to yours uh elero specifically when elero did its new Middle School about 15 years ago they put multi-purpose football at their middle school but um that was in service of a particular extracurricular activity so these were the findings the Middle School um I will say this indoor didn't get mentioned because the indoor facilities are
086in great shape you've got two gymnasium spaces you've got good seating capacities facilities are in good condition we did note and you'll see in the report we did note at liberan Memorial Central Middle the older of the two gyms um there's some um roofing issues that they've been addressing through Roofing um that are visible on the inside got noted by my reviewer um but generally um at the Middle School uh the indoor facilities are are are in good condition stand up well to what your peers have so let's talk about the high schools a little bit um the high schools identified two really major items um the first is it has become the norm in the Kansas City region to begin having true video both in at both indoor and outdoor venues I am not
087it is not Beyond sort of one location indoor and one location outdoor so for example if you've got an easily identified main competition gymnasium it may have a video board in it if you have a main track soccer football competition field it will likely have a video installation or they are in progress of installing it um shiny Mission has them in place OA has them in place Blue Valley bid them last spring and I believe is under sort of underway on that project um it's in their facility committee notes from March so um it's coming um the second is the number of available PE athletic space is both indoors and Outdoors uh starting Outdoors one of the things that I got corrected on um by the uh by the staff members who were in our
088review meetings we had looked at the facilities you had the high schools and we had counted all the areas that looked sized for football soccer and so if you close your eyes and you envision free state you've got the main Stadium Field you've got the soccer field to the north and you've got that large grass area to the east of the soccer field if you're really really looking at it you've got the grass area behind the Press Box at the stadium where they do their throw Sports in the review meeting we were corrected that staff has been directed not to use the grass field east of soccer is it's just not maintained or um ready for real PE Athletics so they asked us to correct our assessment because they're not allowed to use that field
089tempting as it looks on a map or when you're walking around the complex it is not one of the fields that they use um and so that that was a that was one of those places of in input where we went back and forth for 15 minutes making sure that we'd heard the right thing when they told us tempting as it looks they don't use it and they're they're directed not to um however what we are seeing so Outdoors we're generally seeing you as sort of one planned utilized outdoor football soccer size surface short at each of the two high school campuses um that's freshman football that's uh junior varsity soccer if you're not using the track stadium for soccer practice ice because you've got one all weather surface on your campuses specifically for soccer
090um remembering that boys soccer is up against boys football every fall there's a there's a uh practice field shortage a little bit um in the spring girl soccer is up against track and field and so track is all over the the main complex and soccer has really just got one field to practice with there's not a swing field indoors it has become common in your peer districts to have a third major indoor PE and Athletics venue that might be an oversized wrestling room um that might be a third a second auxiliary gym essentially a third gymnasium feeling space I will tell you right now um OA has has those spaces um shaie Mission has been working on those spaces and I believe just completed them they were doing some significant work at North I believe
091to complete some of that effort um Blue Valley is adding auxiliary gyms right now um including one on my son's High School um the other thing that I will say is that those are going on as storm shelters to comply with the changes in the building code I cannot add a substantial space to really any of your educational occupancies at this point without starting to address um a designed stormed Harden spaces on your schools and that's that's a building code element it's a city level element I was just just checking the building code before I said that at the mic but um changes in the recent building code are requiring us to give you storm hardened spaces and what is happening is that folks are using the auxiliary gymnasium gymnasium editions they're making them out
092of pre-cast they're making them storm hardened and it's allowing them to serve both Masters got a big space big enough for their entire high school campus that is a storm shelter as well um other concerns that were highlighted at the high school level um wrestling was a big one and this did cat just off guard and this was the second major item that we got from staff um boys and girls wrestling is the same season and for obvious reasons they're not practicing together and so what has happened is with the introduction of girls wrestling they've doubl the number of wrestling facilities that they need um they have concerns about mat damage because specifically at Lawrence High wrestling spaces get used by a lot of programs they get worried about their fairly expensive mats getting torn
093up they get worried about mat storage um but at both of your high schools girls wrestling is having to happen off- campus at a rented facility because they just don't have somewhere to do it on campus um T and T track and tennis was not positive again uh fairly similar track surfacing there's nothing wrong specifically from a design standpoint that's just getting to the end of life tennis same thing there's nothing wrong specifically however they are getting Beyond end of life and patching is again a one to twoyear solution at best um there are some Stadium conditions you've got those um landscape block stadiums at both high schools it's getting to be time to do some maintenance on those we're getting reports of pavers being dislodged of some of those retaining walls heaving just a
094little bit there's some concern that we might need to invest a little bit of Maintenance at those two stadiums in the grand stands at both campuses and at baseball and softball at both campuses um and then uh the Press Box at freest state was specifically highlighted we had already taken a look at that and had already sort of seen what was going on there similar to what we did a year and a half ago at the O um the South End building that we rewrapped we're having some deterioration at the Press Box at freest State it's of the same age generation and construction um the last one that I will say is that condition of the gymnasium spaces generally came up at the high schools and the quote that I got from one of the
095administrators was when we invite alumni back to Lawrence High they walk into the West gym and it feels exactly like it was when they were students because it is um there's not been an opportunity to do much in the way of improvement at the gymnasium attached to the Carl Knox Auditorium um the main gym at at Lawrence High fairly similar um just a general that the scoreboard is getting to be out of date there's not a lot of Technology certainly not the technology density we see in new gymnasiums um they did bring up seating capacity that's something we're going to continue to study architecturally I would say that the seating capacity at Lawrence High is okay but the reporting that we're getting and from the uh Athletics group generally is that for the cross town
096games um Lawrence High does not have enough seats and there's um potentially some solutions to that but the floor plans would say they have X number of seats I've actually got that in the report but the reporting that we got is that they actually can actually seat fewer than that a couple hundred fewer than that let's talk about the staff survey for a second um unlike the Performing Art Center study we did the staff survey at the end of the process with the Performing Art Center study we used it to gather specifics about how they use the space types of performances so that the professionals could go in and evaluate it knowing what their goals were um with Athletics we did it the other way around we went in and evaluated it it let us
097customize the survey a little bit better um let us be a little more precise in the questions that we asked um we got good responses I will say we got 25 responses the average response time was 41 minutes so Doug needs to write some shorter surveys um 19 of the 25 responses were at the high school buildings we did get at least one response from every single building but 19 of the responses were from people who self-identified at either free state or Lawrence High um so the the big high level items here um Quality and condition of scoreboard equipment came up again quantity of gymnasium spaces at the high schools came up again lack of video came up again um the big ones that I also wanted to point out um was we got a
098couple of comments about the difficult in controlling the impact outside groups have on the facilities um you do have a different rental po you have the rental policy that you have um other districts handle it differently um but the concern from the staff members was they're not staff to be able to supervise those outside groups using the venues in the evening and there's just an undercurrent of concern things aren't put back the way they would like them put back sure but I think the the other undercurrent of concern is um just an anxiety about expensive equipment being mishandled or damaged inadvertently because we're not staffed to be able to supervise them while they're there um the other one that came up was that outside of your main stadiums there's no broadcast capability so I'll tell
099you as a softball parent of many years um what that means is you've got a parent volunteer with an unlimited cell phone plan turning on their data and broadcasting the softball game hopefully with a camera so I can watch from home or work um but you don't have much in the way of it or support at those outer venues soccer baseball softball you really don't have the capability to let parents of those Sports see that remotely grandparents Etc um and then there is a little bit of a disparity between free state and Lawrence High we didn't get all the way to the bottom of it but it feels like there's been some donations at free state that have not happened at at Lawrence High and so there's some there's some technology differences between the two
100high schools in the gym and in the football stadiums um the rest of this is fairly normal uh outdoor storage tennis conditions got mentioned multiple times track conditions got multiple mentioned multiple times um overuse of facilities equipment it was very interesting I got a different tweak on that than I've gotten in other places the concern was that some of the equipment is donor funded or sponsor funded and that the having to use it really heavily just makes them anxious that they're going to wear out things that were generously donated or funded by outside groups quickly just it was it was a tweak from from your team that I had not gotten in other places so summary um there are some major items gymnasium spaces are major items there are some major items that compare poorly
101to the peer districts that we identified which was your conference opponents um to really give you a master plan on items that significant we're going to need some either some additional direction or some additional study and and the reason I would say that is if you close your eyes you envision free state and you decide to make an addition I could probably close my eyes and fairly easily identify how to do that the puzzle is very different at Lawrence High the puzzle is very different at Liberty Memorial than it would be at West MH so your buildings are unique some of your buildings are closer to an urban School setting like I would find in Kanas Missouri um some of yours are closer to a Suburban setting from a site and space standpoint like I
102would find in a Blue Valley or OA so to really give you sight by sight recommendations um even a couple of options would take some some more study um but and and the other piece is it just generates a massive list and I'm I was I I did not feel comfortable showing up here and giving you a massive list just to prove I could um but immediate concerns consistent immediate concerns track conditions tennis conditions um some grand stand issues the Press Box at free state and some grand stand issues at softball baseball and then in the sort of zero to five more nebulous time period um I think a community conversation about where you want to go with uh the high school gymnasium PE space count and I keep going to PE space because some
103of that might not look like a gym some of it may look like a different type of PE space um Athletics and PE equipment conditions it came up some of the fitness equipment is starting to age and may require some reinvestment those types of things and then AV capabilities at both high schools just to give you some order of the magnitude cost for this and I'm going to identify where these came from as I go when we talk about a fairly basic auxiliary gym addition on a high school that is a storm shelter as well Blue Valley has those going on right now Blue Valley West bid in the spring of 2024 it's under construction right now um at about $6.2 million so 8 million would be your your your total project cost your your
104Full Bucket to do a project that is a box and a neck um very basic auxiliary gym storm Edition they've also bid some more complex weight room wrestling room type editions at one of their high schools it came in the 4.2 range so smaller total project cost lower different type of project um track resurfacing um uh various districts are doing that from time time to time including some quotes you got from McConnell um surface only about $375,000 um if we have to start talking about the asphalt condition and getting down into that asphalt base layer the the start value goes up Tennis complex six courts Blue Valley West High School bid in the spring of 2024 um bid price $640 to $700,000 so for a six Court complex you're you're getting awfully close to a
105million dollars if we're doing it a year later and we're trying to capture all those soft costs I'm trying to give you budgetary numbers and not construction numbers and then um athletic building reskinning and renovation potentially Press Box or something similar to that uh these costs are where we were on the oath when we bid it 18 months ago with a little bit of inflation and the soft costs added on and just to clarify Doug um on the Tennis complex would have we have two at the we have one at each of the high schools and we have the same size or slightly smaller at the four middle schools um you have two Courts at the middle school right each of the middle schools okay you have six at free state and eight at lawr
106high and I desperately want to look down at my cheat sheet here and make sure I got that right but I'm pretty sure I got that right you're right right um it's interesting the one of the things that did come up is the inability to host tennis regionals you can't host it on a six Court setup you really need eight at a minimum and one of the concerns was your current eight Court setup doesn't have is it broken up right to be able to use all eight Courts at the same time um because you got to walk across courts to get to the next court you can't do that while it's in competition I asked very specifically about using the city's courts because the city has a nice complex over at the Rock Chalk Rec
107Center um and the response I got was it's hard not that it you can't but that it's hard you have to reserve it 6 months in advance they literally set an alarm and wait until 6 months and 1 minute away from the event that they're hoping to schedule and they try and snatch up a reservation because it is a little challenging um so it can be done but it's not without difficulties and am I wrong in thinking that qua actually schedules the dates and locations for that a year in advance year in advance yeah okay so that is what I have I am ready for questions um start with [Music] questions okay go ahead gr um I just had a couple um thank you Doug for that that was just as informative as the uh
108Fine Art study so I appreciate the work in the time and and uh the energy and also thank staff that participated and and and gave you the the data that that you needed to work it so I've I've basically have two questions um so one is when when you were working through um specifically the comparison piece um um do so I'm going to ask you your opinion because I'm know that you'll freely give it um do you have any feedback or opinion on as as we move forward as a district um on our district policy and culture for Community use and wear and tear versus what you found in comparison districts so I'll let you answer that first and then I'll my second one I as a taxpayer in my local school district I appreciate
109the ability to go walk on a track when I need to uh get some Fitness in or that my kids have always played wreck basketball in the local Middle School it's easy it's convenience it's in my neighborhood um what I will say is all of those activities are supervised um and so I think an attitude that is open-minded towards allowing a community funded facility to be used by the community probably has to be accompanied by the ability to supervise your facilities to ensure that the folks who are borrowing them know how to operate them can operate them can make an adjustment if they need to because I I'll also tell you this the difference between fifth grade basketball and eighth grade basketball is a couple of feet on that goal and even you know not
110everybody even knows how to raise and lower the goal um and it varies from model to model and so when we think about um volleyball being mechanically operated more and more often coming down from the ceiling when we talk about adjustable height goals on even something as simple as basketball practice for fifth graders um the ability to have a staff member there who can make that adjustment for them instead of leaving them on their own makes a big difference okay Larry do you have anything I think we would be very shortsighted if we ask the community to allow was to use public funds to improve facilities and then say oh you can't use them I I do think in talking with some people one of the areas and I think Doug touched on this is
111a supervision of the facilities we need to find a way that we can have our facilities supported when a community group is using them we need to have people there that know how to adjust the goals know how to adjust the Heat know how to take care of a problem if it comes up and that they're dedicated in there uh during that entire event the other thing that we're finding difficult and I will um put together a recommendation for this uh our staff we're talking predominantly our custodial staff they work an awful lot and they get to a point in the year where time and a half on a Saturday all day long they start to look at I need a Saturday off I need a break and we need to find ways to con
112continue to work around that support them give them the time that they have off but also make it well worth their time if they're coming in some of those people are very very dedicated and will come in completely worn out because they know the community needs to use the facility and we appreciate that I I picked on my basketball volleyball friends for just a second there but I can also pick on my own sport I can pick on my soccer friends um one of the detail items inside the report is that the corner kick areas and the the gold mouth and things like that on the turf soccer fields are what he I think the consultant called it kicked out so you've got that carpet and you've got all the rubber infill on that carpet
113and what happens and it happens on pitching Mounds pitching circles and softball it happens in batters boxes it happens at the heavy use areas on football and soccer you get that rubber moved out you don't replace it what happens is you start attacking the carpet you start wearing the structure of the actual Turf and so baseball coaches and softball coaches are instructed to go out every third inning and sprinkle more rubber in those heavy use areas they're instructed to use mats when they're practicing in the Batters boxes and the catching boxes so that they're not digging out that rubber constantly and attacking the carpet um that's tough to tell a bitty soccer remind a bitty soccer coach to go do and I was a bidy soccer coach I had other things on my mind gotcha
114okay um my second question more is is probably for Larry um you know as we as we look at you know I you you mentioned it right when we started about you know at the end of this it probably will need more more time and more study but you know as we look at the Fine Art study and then as we look at this study um and as we start to talk about prioritization um you know all of this falls under capital outlay and you know we have an existing five-year Capital outlay plan um that is set now with projects um do have you thought through or or had conversations at all about as we start to prioritize this how do these things fit into the existing Capital outlay plan as it exists today as
115it exists today uh we would be reacting to emergency situations we have damage to a turf field right now we respond we react we need to be proactive and start doing just what doug told us treating that field rebuilding the rubber within that field more often throughout the year I think now we do it once or twice a year we probably need to look at the possibility of developing a method to do that every week and to check our fields in terms of the big picture our capital outlay budget cannot support the big picture when we look at uh the needs just out of the Performing Arts uh study 8.5 million it would take take us years and years to start getting down that road you could uh compare it very favorably to the roofing
116work that we've been doing we've been doing a great deal of roofing work every year and we're getting closer and closer to not having huge sections of roof that are leaking but we still have roofs that we need to take care of over the next several years and guess what's going to happen to those roofs that are 21 or are 22 years old in the next 3 years they're going to catch up and they're going to be our next problem roof going on again great deal of great work has been done in the district This Is Not Unusual when you talk to districts about infrastructure we look at the the wall itself the ceilings the floors this evening beautiful room that we're in a thermostat needed to be reset because because of building automation systems
117that are extremely old that's what we're looking at now are those things that are Behind the Walls those things that we keep covering up a little bit and we respond to in the last minute I would also say that I think there are other areas that this is brought to mind that we need to look at when we are talking about the co-curricular areas what curricular areas do we have that we know we have some problems in and we could use um a facelift or that infrastructure rebuild art classes music classes home economic classes the foods classes particularly one area that I think we have a great deal that hasn't been addressed uh in recent years is uh our CTE program that's no one's fault that's all just things finally catching up with us programs
118that were well funded taken care of funding has shifted funding has changed we're now to the point that we need to make sure that the infrastructure we have in there is correct the other thing Doug I think has alluded to and he'll tell me if he didn't but we need to do this study comprehensively if we're putting a new addition on a building for a wrestling gymnasium what else does that require let's take it all the way back to the service entries to the network needs there all of the needs that are there and not just build a building for wrestling or revamp a track he talked about the tracks and what is the subsurface like we have to look at that uh surface under the running surface prior to putting hundreds of th000 into
119the running surface and that's where people sometime don't understand why we're doing things but if we put a new track down we want to get the full life expectancy out of that track that we're paying for we don't want to be Pennywise and foolish here thank you fair yeah again I when I'm thinking about this we I know we just had a recent Co snap um and we had a lot of furnace type issues around the district when I look at this and I look at uh the performance arts study and what I'm seeing is we have a lot of issues that are not related to mishandling things but are more related to age because I was on the original board that approved a lot of the remodeling in in our buildings uh and that
120was around 2013 and we upgraded uh from boilers to heat pumps um and which was a great up upgrade the reality however is the utilization is different on a so that what you end up with is things aging and I think right now for me uh my question is we have so much that we need done and not enough Capital outlay to cover it uh I don't know that you can prioritize it with as much as we we have setting here because when you talk to me about a roof and we have 10 15 years of going through to go through a cycle by the time you finish that last one the one you started with is having problems and now you need to repair it uh so so I I guess where I'm at
121is with all the stuff we need done um you have an idea of how we get to an end because I don't I'm sitting here going going you know if our tracks tracks and our tennis courts are in poor condition they're not going to get any better in two years even if we slap a patch all that'll mean is it'll be worse so it's I'm more of the one one that would say if we need to use them then we need to fix them figure out what it's going to cost and let's get a plan to get it done I think my answer to you would be yes as we started four years ago with where are our worst problems take care of the worst first and then move forward we need to look at
122that in a number of areas uh Doug and I know of a organization that's getting ready to do uh just over $12 million of roofs this summer if I brought that type of proposal to you I would ask you up front to ask me some tough questions if we do $12 million worth of roof work this summer and hit a large percentage of our roofs with new roofs what's going to happen in 22 23 years from now we're going to to be right in the same position we need to put all of these things again the worst things first are prioritization but then put them on an ongoing rotation uh when we put this entire package together it may need to be more than five years some of the things once we get them in
123place roofs with a proper care we can get 20 to 25 years maybe even a little bit more out of them but we need to take care of those roofs nobody sees roofs so out of mind out of out of sight out of mind but we need to put that ongoing maintenance um consideration in questions um okay I'm not going to require you to pull out your uh written report I hope um I just um in looking through the written report I just wanted to get some uh clarification from you because you did mention um the peer groups or the peer districts that you looked at shaie Mission OA was a deep dive doto Gardner um when I had looked through the report and I might have missed it I didn't see Blue Valley but
124you mentioned Blue Valley so I I was just curious did you kind of look at Blue Valley in the same depth that you looked at shaie Mission for example Blue Valley Parent I'm a Blue Valley West parent I can't miss the construction and uh I have a freshman in college who last year was a senior at Blue Valley High School I couldn't miss the construction then either okay um I know them fairly well because I've been involved okay so you had that context to kind of inform okay um I was just I was just wondering if there was something about blue valley that caused you to deemphasize looking at at their facilities a conference opponent we we really identified the the venues that your students are playing iname for basketball soccer football as that peer
125group that is that is completely understandable and makes a whole lot of sense um we'll say this Blue Valley publishes everything from their finance committee so they are a nice spot for Architects to go get some data as they publish it okay um you mentioned uh the challenges that our staff have identified with uh girls and boys wrestling um I know that wrestling for girls has the interest in that Sport and participation has skyrocketed probably over the LA even just the last six or seven years um what are what are what have our peer districts done to address the competition and practice needs um that you saw they're kind of all in the same spot um the challenge with wrestling is that it is in the same time frame as basketball and so all of
126your indoor venues are full um as a as a high school ecosystem um so all the districts are struggling there's some split practice times that I I think I see on school websites um which used to be the response to uh swimming and Diving um you know my friends practice swimming and Diving at 6: a.m. um and so there's there's some split venue ideas um I will say Lawrence High does struggle more than free state free state has a designated wrestling area Lawrence High uses the mezzanine on the west gym um and other sports are in and out of there it's not really something they can put some doors on to protect their mats so lawai is struggling a little bit more than free state regardless of the gendering of the sports is this where
127the third gym conversation really becomes important it's where the third activity space conversation I'm I'm going to be really careful not to call this a gym because the solution might not be a gym the solution might be a a multisport dance wrestling aerobics Fitness complex that is well suited to be wrestling for at least one gender or wrestling for both genders um coupled with some lockering space coupled with adequate storage coupled with some of those other things that's why I'm I'm not trying to be KY the solution might not be might not walk in and look like a gym to my grandfather mhm that makes a lot of sense and then you also have the instructional component um for and the instructional component did come up there is a difficulty getting through the instructional day
128with enough spaces to teach the different courses that we would all lump in our head as PE um in the facilities that you have at the high schools right now there's just it's it's it's tough um Lawrence High has the added complication that to get to the West gym or to the auditorium you have to go outside so gr actually asked the third question I had which was kind of this this prioritizing and can we do how much if any of this can we really do in um Capital outlay versus needing to do some other kind of planning um so the last thing I wanted to say is a comment not a question which is that from what you have presented and what we've heard with the facilities uh the Fine Arts facilities study and
129the the many conversations we've had in facilities committee over the years about about things like the state of our roofs and our our parking lots and that sort of thing um uh I would um make the request to Administration and board leadership that we begin the process of of working through a master planning um type process to try to come up with a a bigger um a plan and a scope to address the needs that we have um I think is critical because some of some of this is so tied to curriculum yes like for example what we're talking about um as it relates to physical education as it relates to um our Arts uh programming um and then wanting to have good athletic space for our athletic um our athletes um so I I
130can see why you're asking that and I think it's important given um the competing priorities that are not part of these two reports right I would I would say that um I think our team can help determining how many pencils it might be but if you've got three or four different pencil jars I can't tell you how many pencils you want to put in each of those jars that's where we would need assistance uh you had mentioned uh some require government changing around storm hardening structures how would that affect this um what has happened is is the city has adopted the 2018 International building code it's the first building code that specifically put in place that it is a requirement for an educational occupancy of over 50 people to have uh a designed compliant storm
131shelter okay so the city of Lawrence specifically um and and if you want to follow up uh dr's going to have a screenshot of this uh later this evening um from my email but the city um specifically wrote in some caveats when they adopted that building code which they can do as the local jurisdiction but in essence um if you're adding less than I think the number was 10% of the floor space of a building so I've got a 200t building and I'm adding 20 more square fet or less they'll only make you shelter the occupants of that new space if you start to exceed that they're going to ask you to consider the occupancy of that entire building and Sheltering it in this newly designed newly engineered shelter um people will use the term
132FEMA shelter because FEMA has been one of the major sources of funding for this for years and years it's part of their post disaster mitigation funding um I don't like hoping for a tornado but the International Code Council and its wisdom has put this into the basic buing code it is no longer something that um districts can uh um try to avoid for economics it is it is the worst building we're legally allowed to build do we have any storm hardened facilities now I don't know that I know that answer yes we do uh some of our classrooms particularly at the uh elementary schools are have been prepared for storms uh we have a at uh fno we have a room in the center of the building that is prepared for storms but in our
133in our high schools and Junior and um middle schools do we high schools I do not believe we have any our junior high schools as I think through them I believe the answer would be no I think you I could be wrong I want to say we did we did class some classrooms in some where we added classrooms and I'm I know that where we added classrooms at the elementaries yes we did do storm Harden spaces and I remember we had a conversation in our secondary Bond planning about this very requirement because they it wasn't in the building code but it was coming um and uh there was a solution and and the city acknowledged I think the city acknowledged in their addendum to the building code that um they in essence if you've designed
134some things to be storm hardened then there's a conversation to be had okay um whether it's the full engineered solution that a new facility would have to comply with there's a there's a standard out there um I think if you've got explicitly designed things it it used to be we would do a space with some storm shutters and and make sure the walls are out of masonry um I worked for a firm that was part of evaluating Joplin after that tornado not all of those spaces do as well as we hope they did when I was taught to go sit in the hallway and put my head between my knees makes sense I have a question um kind of in relation to that so Lawrence High is lots and lots of Windows um so do
135they have storm shutters or when since that's a relatively new build there most of those windows do not have storm shutters and to be honest with you I am not aware standing here of any windows at that facility that has storm shutters but those wouldn't be the storm shelters in the event of a tornado no I'm just saying in general while it looks very pretty it's not necessarily practical like I know when I toured it with leadership Lawrence they were talking about like in active shooter situations you're supposed to block and all of the the those rooms down that hallway I'll have glass to the hallway as well as to the outside so that becomes a safety risk as well um and so I was just curious about that so we did talk about that
136extensively in the design work at Lawrence High and there are um aspects of the use of that building that make it safe for students um but the the classrooms wouldn't be where the students are supposed to go in the that's what I'm saying is that there are spaces in that building that are designated for students to go in the case of a storm emergency and they're not it's not the classrooms right yeah so uh I just one clarifying question um and it's a I think it's a very easy answer but I just want to name it uh the um Elementary education uh students also are active we've had conversation about um their physical education spaces about um playground equipment that they utilize for physical education that's not included in here because you've done that analysis
137as it relates to playgrounds recently and you know the state of the gyms because of the most um recent I just wanted if you wouldn't mind clarifying that in a larger Master Study we would look further into the um elementary schools and and a total picture of their uh facilities around activities and and arts and as well yeah yes thank you sure okay okay are there additional questions or discussion um I'll give space Carol do you have questions that you wanna no not at this time thank you uh thank you very much for your report and we will uh move now to the next agenda item which is a motion for an executive session I move the Board of Education recess to Executive session for the purpose of discussing Personnel matters pursuant to the non-elected
138Personnel exception under coma with Dr Janice K Swift interim superintendent invited to be president and with the board to return to open session in this room at thank you with no action to follow I second Gordon Ross Yes Jones yes Kimble yes buyers yes wood yes Costello yes Franklin yes the motion passes e e e from the executive session with no action to follow we're going to extend and I'm going to ask for our expert Shannon K Kimble to help us I move the Board of Education us to Executive session for the purpose of discussing Personnel matters pursuant to the non-elected Personnel exception under coma with Dr Janice kswift inim superintendent invited to be present and with the board to return to open session in this room at um 905 uh 9:05 p.m with no
139action to follow second I'm GNA just Kelly Jones yes gr yes Bob yes Shannon yes and yes Yolanda yes the motion passes e e e um executive session with no action to follow um is there any uh new business I believe we're all wrapped up Madam president and members is there a motion to adjourn move that we adjourn second all in favor I anyone opposed oh your tongue hey hey [Laughter]