001Mr board president members of the board Dr senson and La Hoya ISD Community watching at home and in the crowd um it's a pleasure to be with you this evening um and to share an Upstate an update um in this Milestone of our year one system of Great Schools work um I'm and I am incredibly pleasured uh it's my pleasure to be joined by my incredible colleagues um who we will um hand the Baton off at various points um in the presentation before we get started I wanted to take a moment to Anchor into our district vision statement that we just reopt it at our last board meeting educational Excellence is what we say we guarantee for every La Hoya La Hoya ISD student and family next let's take a moment to Anchor onto our
002new District missing state statement also adopted at our last board meeting this represents our promise to our students and Community it's a commitment for how we will Empower students toward agency and lifelong success this year La Hoya ISD joined the system of Great Schools Network we will participate in the program over the next four years our commitment is part of our strategic efforts to elevate Excellence for all students across the districts 25 school districts enrolling over 85,000 students across the state of Texas participate in the SGS Network the network of schools are united by a common commitment to ensure that every student has access to a high quality best fit schools SGS is about quality seats in quality schools for every student in our district as we think back to our vision statement and our
003mission statement are we guaranteeing quality seats across our system of schools are we living up to our vision mission in North Star as a district the quality seats analysis is a critical step in the annual School planning process it's not a oneandone data report a qsa will be generated each year that we're a part of the SGS Network so that we can continuously learn about our district as a system of schools and informed decision-making it brings together key data points that represent as Dr senson said the current state of the school district and it will inform strategic moves ahead at the district level the qsa illuminates most the most important Trends shaping our work works and helps identify opportunities to ensure every La Hoya ISD student is in a high quality best fit school again
004it helps answer the question are we guaranteeing quality seats across our system of schools are we providing Ed educational opportunities our families want need and deserve are we living up to our vision mission and Northstar as a district with the quality seats analysis we start the strategic planning process by seeing where we're at in our current system so um the quality seats analysis um data was collected across a number of sources it includes um our taper reports it includes our um accountability ratings from 2022 2023 2024 are verifi excuse me our verified accountability ratings um it includes a look and Analysis of the types of classroom assignments we give our students in grades K through 12 in math in reading and it includes walkthroughs of our campuses and classrooms in reading and math at all
005grade levels at 15 of our campuses and observations of how our professional learning communities operate quality seats analysis is essential for our annual School planning process by establishing it establishes a single source of Truth on our current performance it enables us to strategically group schools and will help us take actions tailored to the individual needs of each campus as we move through the data I as to think about the insights that could drive actions both at the District level and at a campus level it's important not only to consider which campuses require strategic inter may require strategic intervention but what are the bright spots in our data that inform that that might inform replication efforts in other parts of our district as is as has been shared with the school board and Community La Hoya
006ISD is a solid B District according to current tea verified account accountability ratings while there's much to celebrate there I want to emphasize that the qsa provides a deeper lens than annual accountability data um than annual accountability data and uncovers some truths that will question how that solid be should be viewed we have to acknowledge where we are to move forward to where our students and families want and deserve our system of school schools to go some of the overarching takeaways um from the qsa I would like to share up front so the data indicated While most La Hoya ISD students currently attend campuses with a verified A or B rating there's a concerning number of campuses have that have experienced a decline in accountability ratings over the last two years District Trends show a
007steady decline in enrollment across the system over the last 10 years and an a at a spike in attendance absentee rates across our grade levels in recent years the data indicated duplicative programming at high schools and how it contributes to desperate academic outcomes and stress to our District budget the data indicated provided evidence that the quality of instruction generally across our school district needs to improve at all grade levels and then finally on average the data showed La Hoy ISD schools are utilizing 61% of their physical space capacity across all campuses so with that I'm going to um turn the presentation over to um Dr little who will talk about academic data thank you good evening board and superintendent so you're going to see data in here before that in this presentation that is new
008but we're going to start with some data that is more familiar but we want to represent it in a different way to help draw insights out related to this quality schools analysis work good all right so we're going to start with some star data again data that we shared but this is a different representation you're going to see Elementary on this slide then we'll look at middle and high school a couple things just to orient us to the slide format this like yellow dotted line going across the middle of the slide is the Texas state average for last year specifically uh across Texas as we look at elementary schools so this is all grades allar test how many students were at meets or above and that was 46% we've then stacked our schools from lowest
009performing to highest performing on this chart so you can see that variation across La Hoya ISC Elementary campuses we've got about nine elementary schools that actually outperform that state number of 46% uh but that leaves more than half of our elementary schools that are under that line the big takeaway that we've got to start to Grapple with is what is happening at our highest achieving schools that we can then think about replicating duplicating or scaling across the district to make sure there are quality seats for every student at every school middle school chart here set up very similarly we see less variation at the middle school level than we saw at the elementary level but again really wanting to Grapple with what are the takeaways from our uh higher achieving schools here that we can
010then start to build a system around to ensure that exists at every school uh in the district and then for high schools actually see something pretty jarring here if we look at the two highest bars here over 80% those are our two specialty schools Thelma and Jimmy Carter but then we also have to recognize that that means our comprehensive high schools are are having a very different experience and so this really starts the call to action for us which we will unpack uh throughout much of the rest of this presentation to really understand what do we need to start asking of ourselves what do we need to start grappling with as a system a district and a community to ensure that just because you're at a comprehensive high school isn't relegating you to half the
011results that students are getting at one of our specialty schools how do we just make that the norm and the promise across the board Chief Gomez p is going to come up and really unpack some some more High School data for us uh and then I'll be back to look at some classroom specific data thank you good evening again so as we're looking at what we were doing with our quality seats analysis and looking at the data at the different levels so we want to continue looking at our high schools and looking specifically at our AP and our act data so how is it that we have at some schools some of the systems of support and structures that we can replicate at the other schools that we have and so looking at our uh
012AP data and so on average when you look at this graph it'll show you that nearly 11% of the high school students are passing at least one of those AP exams so we're putting a big emphasis at all of our schools at the or some of most of the schools in the participation rates but even though in some of those participation rates as they are high we are still looking at our students not not uh not earning the scores that they need to in order for them to be earning that college credit so you want to look at these that participation does not necessarily correlate to those High numbers as earning those college credits so we have some of the schools that are and um and so we need to look at the replication at
013the schools that are earning those High participation rates act when we look at those act um scores also and as def find for Quality seats analysis and passing so we're looking at participation again being high participation rates but we are not getting our students ready for that postsecondary education that we are promising our families and our communities to be happening in our classrooms as we continue to improve instruction in our classrooms and working towards uh those highquality instructional materials at each in each of one of those each one of those classrooms so we are going to build those systems of support that all of our comprehensive high schools and our specialty schools need in order for them to be successful on the a act exam so when we are looking at act and uh AP
014exams so that also correlates to our ccmr data and our graduation rates so looking back graduation rates we are graduating our students but are we graduating our students to be college career and Military ready so when we look at that in our act and our P exams we are not delivering on that um when we look at specifically our our College ready uh CER numbers that we're earning for our ccmr our TSI exam is also an a college entrance exam right that our students are taking and are not being successful so students are experiencing higher uh success rates at our at our specialty schools Jimmy Carter and Thelma uh Selena Early College high school and so what are the systems and supports that they have in place that we can be replicating at all of
015our other schools in order for all of our all of our students regardless of what uh of where what space they're occupying and in which one of our high schools they're all being successful in earning those college credits passing act and being uh able to pass TSI so that when they leave us they are not having to take those remedial classes uh at the University level and so we want to ensure because right now across the district when we look at the class of 2024 we only had about 20% of our 12th graders that were meeting both the TSI math and Ela uh criteria in order for the students not to be taking those remedial classes in at the University level so STC every school year our dual enrollment program is big in in our
016district and so STC they always do every year success metrics um analysis of how our schools are are doing with the dual enrollment and so when you look at the different colors here it's just like a traffic sign so red is stop green is uh they're moving forward and yellow is you know kind of go slow type of thing and so you look at those numbers and when when you look at those numbers and you look at where do we have all the greens which is where we want all of our different spaces that are offering dual enrollment we want them to be in the greens and so right now when we look at last year's data Jimmy Carter Early College High School is a one campus that has greens across all of those success
017metrics and we want to be able to look at what is Jimmy Carter doing with their systems of support that we can offer to all of our students in all of our spaces so that they can be successful because that's what we want we want our students to be academically ready and be ready for that postsecondary the biggest thing here that you want to look at also is we all know about academic probation right when we're taking college courses and we're failing too many courses and rep Place students on academic probation so if you look at that particular success metric there we only have again one campus where the percentage of students on academic probation is low so what are we doing in all of our classrooms and our math classrooms Ela social studies in
018order for us to be a for our school students to be successful in those classes so that they are not earning those failing rates in their dual enrollment classes and so what are we doing we want to establish those systems and supports at all of our spaces that we have dual enrollment so in order for students to be successful in their academic work whether it's on Star act AP exams our dual enrollment class we need our students in the classroom right um if they're not sitting in our classrooms then they're not going to be doing uh the learning that they need to in order for that success so when we look at attendance rate for last school year this was these were our attendance numbers for last school year and you can see the bars
019uh highest being at our elementary level with 93.8% for the uh for last school year and so we have every uh every week we are sending our schools their attendance percentages so that they're measuring those and then we've also put in place some of the some of the support structures that they need to be doing if you have two absences you call home you have three absences what are the things that we're doing in order for our attendance rates to be uh higher than where we at so uh but along with attendance rate come our chronic absenteeism and so when we're looking at Chronic absenteeism is the percentage of our students that are not sitting in their classes at least 90% of the time and so in any given time so if we look at
020last school year which is the 23 24 school year right we had uh the students were afforded if they wanted to be in class at least 90% of the time they could only be absent 17 times anything about uh above 17 days then the student is considered chronic absent or that he is a chronic absentee student so what are we doing in in for these cases so that our students are sitting in the classroom at the high school level it changes a little bit more because if they're not sitting in a particular course at least 90% of the time then they're not going to earn that credit for that course which in turn is not going to allow them to graduate from high school because they're not earning all of their credits and so when
021you look at this and you're going to see some maps later on on how the classes on how the schools are performing so you want to look at if you see a campus like Flores Elementary where they have 29% % of their students that have missed more than 90% or more than 10% right so they're chronically absent compared to where we have Clinton Elementary where they're doing a a better job of keeping their kids in class and so we want to look at what is Clinton Elementary what is an scandone elementary with that have a low percentage of chronic absenteeism so that we can then take those structures those supports those strategies that they're doing and taking them to schools like um Flores and um Benavides Elementary when they have where they have that chronic
022absenteeism those percentages are higher we look at our middle schools and so it's the same um explanation on our bar graph so we have uh chronic absenteeism 33% of our students at the Savala Middle School are chronically absent which means they were not in class at least 90% of the time and so that has a reflection on our star data right and so how are we getting them to that meets we want to have them in the classroom sitting learning so that they can be successful academically and then you're going to look now our high schools and so when we look at our high schools and we looked at how they were doing on Star how they were doing on act how we were doing on our AP scores and then you look at Chronic
023absenteeism and you look at at schools like palmu high school where 53.9% of their students are chronically absent they're not sitting in their classrooms learning and so how can we get them in class so that they have a higher ACT score so that they can pass their AP exam so that they're successful on TSI and those are the systems and supports that we want to look at what is stma Salen is doing to have the kids in the classroom so that they can uh we can replicate those supports whether it's the counseling uh our social workers our treny facilitators all of the different resour ources that we have at our campuses so that we can help them and build those systems and get better at what we're doing discipline so middle schools in La ho
024ISD have the highest percentage of students involved in discipline incidents and so when you go back to Chronic absenteeism the middle schools generally across the board are anywhere between 20 30% chronically absent right and so we looked at how are they doing there why isn't that they're not coming to school but when you look at these discipline and incident reports the incident reports are because of violations to the student code of conduct that they're not necessarily um when we looked at them fighting or or you know drugs or anything like that it's violations to the student code of conduct like uh insubordination dress code those are the kinds of things but we have the system where every referral is put into Skyward and we're able to pull out the reports and specifically what are those
025incidents specific to every campus and which ones are the ones that they have the most and so we can then Target that campus for if it's in subordination then we need to start looking at do we need to do group therapy or our social workers different things and so um we have those things and we can track them I had a couple questions um if you don't mind no go ahead and proceed um one of my questions was um when you're comparing Jimmy Carter theras SZ versus the Comprehensive High Schools um you were mentioning that we want to see what's going to be what what is Jimmy Carter and themma doing different to see how we could kind of replicate that in the other three high schools when do you think we'll be hearing that
026sort of presentation to see um that data so we're doing those analysis right now and hopefully we'll be able to not hopefully but we will bring um some a presentation to you on November the 20th on some of the analysis that we did so that you can have a little bit more insight on some of the supports and structures that they have and then how can we align those okay perfect and then second question was for The Chronic absentee uh that we see in uh the different schools at different levels do we do anything about reaching out to those families parents do we keep track of that do we see you know the reasons why these kids aren't coming in and do we have that data as well so we have a tiered system of
027support that we do and so um we call it our tracking form and so so it's in our in our handbook and so it's like after two absences a teacher calls and so the teacher has a call log on where they're communicating with the parent and tier two is okay now I'm having a conference with the parent and the student on what it is and then we start building those supports with counseling with our social workers with our Behavior specialists at the elementary and so there are different levels of support that we're offering our campuses and there are in some cases that you know after we call the parent in tier one we jump straight to okay we need to uh refer to counseling services depending on the situation why they are um why they
028are being absent and so we we have that in place yes okay thank you and I would also add U Miss Chavez that one of the things that the team is actually starting to do is going out and meeting with the high school teams um and so the cabinet along with the executive directors have actually begun to do the shoulder to shoulder work of meeting with the administrative teams the counselors um all of the assistant principles the principal and all of the supports to walk them through kind of what we're calling the workshop model of the wise the what next the how do you do this the how are you monitoring the how are you tracking because sometimes helping people put those systems and structures in place takes some coaching if this is not work
029that our campuses have done before um this feels new um this feels a bit like we're monitoring a lot and we are because when you have a 50 some per chronic absenteeism rate it requires central office to do some intervening and so we're stepping in and so um the team has gone out to do some visits especially with our high schools first um our executive directors have also done some campus visits but we're going to continue to do that shoulder-to-shoulder work because we want to support first before we go directly to accountability um but it's kind of a both and perfect great thank you Dr sson kind of along the same lines around um um attendance do we have a uniform tracking system for attendance one and then two my other question is um do
030already do we already have in place policies and procedures um that need to be followed on a daily basis right is that also uniformed so we do we do have an attendance SL treny manual that uh we updated this school year because it was kind of a little bit different we had one for treny and one for attendance and so we they go hand inand so we combine that and so that attendance manual has already gone out to the campuses to where it outlines what are the steps that we need to be taking at what time we need to be taking who's doing the taking and all of those stuff we've also included in there in that manual we have um a section that is designated just for our the campuses should be establishing a
031campus attendance committee and so they need to what is the data that they need to be bringing into that committee meeting so that they can review and then what are the actions that they need to be taking at the campus level so that they can be working on improving their attendance and so it's it's outlined for them with the forms everything that they need of course Skyward is where we take our attendance and so we have our our different times Ada for elementary is at 9:30 and then at 10:30 is for our secondary schools and so at that time attendance clerks have certain things that they need to be doing if the kids are not there um there are some schools that start before calling the parents hey so and so is not here and
032so we've been meeting a lot with our attendance clerks because they are that Frontline on taking that data and that uniform system on Skyward and making sure that we're doing that correctly and that we're all on the same page when it comes to all of the uh the I guess the the data part of of the attendance yes and so again I would um two things one we are doing an onramp of support first for our campuses and so we feel really strongly that since we are leaning in and we're really taking this first semester to do some shoulder-to-shoulder and handholding and building up capacity um around this first semester because this is also the first time that the district has looked at it through a chronic absenteeism lens um if you look at the
033two slides and you hold them up you know next to each other you look at an attendance rate and for a long time the district has looked at the lens through oh okay well our attendance rate is 93% and so we felt comfortable right well now we're talking about the lens of chronic absenteeism and that's a very different lens now we're talking about percentage of kids who are not here at least 10% of the time they're not here and if they're missing class when we need to know who's missing where are they and what do we need to do to get them here and that's a kid by Kid by Kid byid intervention system that schools have to put into place and then you have to design interventions based upon which each individual child needs
034which requires a system of support and so we're taking time this first semester to work with campuses to develop those systems of support um Miss Gomez Petes along with Dr Little's team are working shoulder-to-shoulder with our schools to do that um and the multiple people on campuses designed to do that as we then do that support along with accountability um this first semester and throughout this year as we then also start to hold campuses very accountable for the outcomes they have the closest proximity to kids and so they're the ones that have to do this work yeah and along those lines and so developing those systems of supports for our campus as they are needing things or they are wanting to data points or just different reports and so our data and a data Department
035uh through Dr Little's office and M Melinda Flores office and so if we're looking at okay how do we see uh kids that have been absent three times can we just click buttons instead of having to run Skyward reports and so they've set up those reports through Tableau and so it's made it really easy not just to look at what are who are the kids that have been absent three times and we get a list really fast but then we look at within that same report are they economically disadvantaged are they at risk are they uh homeless what is military connected so that now we can be super specific on okay if they are homeless and we need to make sure that we're looking at our mckin vento and then what are the systems of
036supports that we have for that for that population what are the systems of support So as we're going through the process on how do we get better at this and they're needing things and so we're working on our ends on how do we make it easier for the campus as well to be able to get those supports and provide those supports to our students as fast as they can got it and then um on the term of like discipline and discipline um along same lines of my question is there kind of like policies out there that kind of that outline what would in term cause a student to be suspended or um in school suspens in school suspension or the different disciplinary actions that are available so we have our student code of conduct that
037is aligned to our task B recommendations and so we took what was in place in the district and then at the beginning of the school year we aligned it to tasby recommendations for student code Codes of conducts and that came up for board approval at back in August I think it was right and so that was adopted and so we have at every campus a campus Behavior coordinator which is an assistant principal that we meet with them through our through Department uh through student services and so we meet with them once a month and we talk about what are the discipline codes making sure that we're coding them correctly what are the uh the systems of support that we have we have PBIS which is a framework and talks about positive behavior intervention systems and
038so it talks about safe schools uh respect and so those kinds of things so that in the in the classroom we can be doing some of those lessons with our students and so we have that CBC that helps us with discipline what we are working on right now is Our Hope placements and so the students that we're sending to to the alternative campuses and and making sure that as we are transitioning kids to that placement we are offering those systems uh to the campus but to the families and to to our students on how are they going to be successful but we've developed those we have the the um the cbcs that we meet with and then we talk about okay this month you had so many referrals and they were all about this okay
039what are we doing to ensure that we are talking to students about respect because most of your referrals were on in subordination right and so those kinds of things and reminding them that we have PBIS we also do character strong which is a really good system that talks to students about how they need to respect each other and they respect themselves and stuff like that so thank you thank you any other questions question about had a question about the AP testing uh do we have a list of all the AP classes or courses that we have um because you know there's a rank of which ones are harder which ones are easier and then I don't know what's the opportunity of the students um to how many uh we have available for them so every
040campus whenever they're doing their course uh requests uh through their master schedule so students at the at when when they're selecting in the spring what school what courses they're going to take for the following School year and so we list them in there the courses that they have available it varies from campus to campus depending on what those course requests are or also if you have a course that is a dual enrollment course and it we have an AP course then we are not going to offer both we're going to offer either the dual enrollment or the AP class but the St we do have lists by Campus of all the different AP courses that that they can take yes thank you any other questions for our presenters you may proceed thank you Dr little
041all right thank you so we pulled a lot of data analysis which is what we walked through so far but part of our quality schools analysis was also going into schools and into classrooms so we were in 15 schools over 60 classrooms and I want to share with you a little bit about what we learned and saw through those classroom visits uh the first and this is a huge Testament to our teachers and the work of our campus leaders this year uh when we question whether teachers were using the right materials in the classroom like we just adopted a new math curriculum if we're in there watching you teach math are you using those materials or if we're in the reading classroom are you using the right materials and what this slide uh really shouts
042is yes they are so nearly 97% of the time when we were in a math classroom we saw people using Eureka or Carnegie or whatever the adoption was uh for that course at the high school level and that is incredible knowing that we're asking people to do new things this year on the reading side even though it's not a new Adoption we still saw really high rates of of implementation and usage near 90% what we also looked at though is beyond just using the materials what is the quality of instruction that's being provided uh this slide does a few things the red blue and gray show different levels so that's elementary middle and high school we've got math classrooms on the left and reading classrooms on the right and then at the bottom we're looking
043at some key research based things that really are part of tier one quality instruction are we using the right research-based strategies are we considering uh what in education speak Universal Design for Learning but really have we thought about where we want to end up and are we building the lesson and the learning process to to achieve that ultimate end and then thinking about content based strategies with language as well just two big takeaways here what we generally see is math is slightly stronger than reading that makes sense given the work that we've done with new hqm and lots of professional learning in math this year certainly at the elementary levels it's almost been exclusively math uh we are changing that starting tomorrow but that has been the case uh thus far uh the other big
044takeaway here back to all the high school data is we see that our high schools are generally the least likely to be using these elements of research-based highquality instruction so again you you heard Chief Gomez pz really late out uh this story of of causing us to question gives the high school diploma that we're offering actually guaranteeing that you're prepared for whatever you're going to do next we see that in actual classroom instruction as well that we have work to do uh in the high school space beyond looking at classroom instruction we also went into teacher planning time you've heard us talk about plc's or professional learning communities as a key part of our strategy this year as teachers getting together to prepare for the lessons that they're going to deliver so we also wanted
045to understand like are you using that time in the way that research would best say is going to set you up for the most success when it comes to instruction just like what we saw with with teachers using the right materials this long bar at the top shows that they're also pacing themselves really well like they are where they need to be at that point in the school year teaching the right Concepts and skills as we go down though we see opportunity for improvement uh so we we know that we've got to do more work helping teachers know exactly what students will do to demonstrate that they learn the concepts in that lesson that's the bottom one here about Exemplar responses to demonstrate Mastery do we know exactly what we're looking for uh from our
046students learning that's a big area of growth from us as we can see in this planning data to close this part out we also wanted to understand if the designations that our campuses have we know there are many from stem to leadership to uh by Literacy By cultural you see the list here on the slide but we wanted to know if those designations were actually showing up in real experience and instruction in the classroom and as we were doing these walkthroughs what we found is that we couldn't find any evidence of differentiation so whether I was at a stem school or a media arts and communication School my experience in that lesson was the same so this is really begging the question about what designations mean currently but also as the superintendent starts to go
047out with strategic plan development and engaging the community on what we want experien to look like moving forward one that we're super clear on those experiences and two that they actually do shape the day-to-day experience that students have uh in those classrooms and in those campuses we'll turn we'll pause and see if there's questions before we sort of zoom out and take a a much bigger look at where we are as a district members of the board do we have any questions for Dr little I have a question go ahead Dr um for the previous Slide the very last drafting Exemplar response to demonstrate Mastery uh from that am I getting that teachers um can step away from the curriculum just to make sure the students understand what they're teaching or what what can you
048explain that to me a little bit more yeah I will certainly try cuz that is not the takeaway that I want our teachers to have um from from that point so it's not that you're stepping away from the curriculum or you're going to do something entirely differently if I am teaching you a lesson on how to add and subtract fractions I need to know how you're going to show me that you learn that and so this is really in the time where you're sitting with other teachers grappling with what is not only the best way but what are the multiple ways that students can show us that they really know this concept and are ready for the next thing what we often find is that if teachers skip that step they're in the classroom they
049may check with you to make sure you know it but they didn't have a systematic way to see if the whole class understood that concept and so days or weeks later you find out wait I actually have a gap in student learning that I wasn't aware of because I wasn't super clear on how to know if students mastered that Concept in the moment so evaluating rather than the teaching yeah I would actually argue that those go hand inand in many ways uh but yes it is the understanding part of what was the result of this lesson not just delivering the lesson thank you thank you Dr little do we have any further questions for Dr little before we proceed how often do we plan on performing walkthroughs can you repeat that I didn't hear you
050how often are we going to perform walkthroughs moving forward was it just this one walk through this that's a great question um one we are sort of my team is in schools all of the time providing support uh to teachers and to leaders so that's on a daily basis this part of the qsa where we sort of had a team go in specifically to look at this would likely happen on an annual or possibly twice annual basis as we're updating the quality schools analysis and as we're updating the annual School plan good question I'm up there weekly okay any other further questions before we proceed next portion all right again we want to zoom out for a second we've talked about accountability data with the board Bo in the community earlier in this year but
051again we want to take some different looks at this uh for the purpose of asking if we're providing quality seats consistently this first slide probably not super surprising on the left we see the percentage of our students that are in certain rated school so 19% of students in La Hoya ISD are currently sitting in an a-rated School 9% of students are currently sitting in a d or f rated school if we think about what that looks like in terms of number of campuses that's what we see on the right hand slide if we go a little bit deeper though we start to see something interesting we have the full spectrum of ratings at the elementary level a through F all are present in La Hoya ISD for middle schools and high schools though every single
052one of our schools at the secondary level is a or b but I would ask us to go back to all of those slides that really dug into High School data and particular and this starts to have us question like what's under the hood and what do we need to do to improve quality across the board and not just sit on the fact that we have an A orb rating but really grapple with the reality of what students are experiencing every day and what their outcomes are at the end of that Journey this just lists each of our schools by their rating you can see the actual accountability projection that we had from our our verified process uh so we see our A's and B's in the the left and the right most of our
053schools are b-rated schools in the district again that's something to to celebrate and to be proud of but we're really asking what do we need to do to make it better uh as part of our conversation tonight and then on the far right we see the schools that are rated C D or F if we take this one step further we can actually understand how is that changed over time so if we look at the last two years of accountability data which schools have improved in that 2-year time period those are the strong and steady ones on the left they either maintained or in increased over those two years all the way to those seeing significant decline or are underperforming and some of these are are uh really hard to accept numbers like you see
054double digits into the 20s and 30s in some cases over a 2-year period that is obviously not meeting our our commitment to educational excellence and it's part of what we're doing every day to figure out how to best support those campuses for growth if we show this visually each of these dots represents one of our school schools again this is plotted over a 2-year period uh so we can see that we got some strong and steady schools on the top right so they were doing well and now they're doing even better uh but what's really fascinating to note is that blue box at the top left we have no dots there that means that none of our schools that were rated C or below actually improved over that 2-year period every single one that was
055a CD or F went backwards over the last 2 years obviously we want and need a very different picture moving forward and again that's part of what this is helping us to to see and then we'll inform our actions the last thing we wanted to really do is is grapple with and I will say as someone who's only here four months like one of the first things I heard coming into the district is there is a real north south divide Mile Line schools and Expressway schools are not the same and they get different results so we wanted to test that uh with this data and what the map can really show is that yes there is some grouping in the district we see in the far north we've got two D's and an f-rated school
056also in the center we've got some c-rated schools but location is not a promise to outcomes in La Hoya ISD nor should it be we also have b-rated schools on 7even meline road and just off of it we've got a and b-rated schools in the center of the district as well so as we think about achievement and as we think about these changes what this prompts us to do as we start to take action and build that strategic plan is really know what we need to do so that every school is improving in the Hoya ISD and every student has access to Quality seats and happy to take questions before we transition to the next part any questions sorry I had a question Dr little um in the previous section how we were looking at
057as you said the data of all the schools you know the STAR testing and seeing how about you know 50% or more of our schools are not meeting the state star uh uh percentage right then now we're seeing how we have a lot of A and B campuses how is that correlating is that because of how the state determines as accountability scores based on just Improvement and not necessarily actually meets and above or where does that that's exactly right when Mr duk sort of walked through the accountability system a month or so ago remember there were three parts and the district has really been benefiting from that second part which is is growth data now this last slide shows you that that's not true at every campus in the district but many of our campuses
058were showing just enough Improvement to be able to maintain those a orb ratings or in some cases the C rating but as we've tried to be consistent since August and we've been presenting this data is that when we look at Absolute achievement at meets or above none of our campuses have reached the 60% threshold and when we look at grade levels and contents it was only eighth grade math that has yet to hit that Mark so from like actual on grade level Readiness and achievement we have significant work to do in the district the accountability system has been favorable to the district thus far but that in many ways is masking the like reality of actual outcomes in La Hoya ISD perfect and then your second part of that response kind of answered my second
059question because I say well how would the score look if we weren't using the Improvement Factor we were using just the the the meats Factor um so then we would probably won't be having all those A's and B's it it wouldn't look like this uh to to be quite Frank so many more of our of our secondary campuses would look like the elementary spam where we would have CD and potentially f-rated schools I don't think we would actually have F at secondary schools but there would be much more variation uh than we're currently seeing okay thank you do we have any further questions for Dr L before we proceed no thank you for the clarification on the perception that people have that where you live affects your score so thank you for the clarification on
060that that's what I always heard that if you lived in a certain area that your schools were going to perform po but I appreciate the explanation that you shared with us thank you Dr thank you good evening we are going to transition to our findings on finance and human capital data so I'm going to start with the average total spending per student in La Hoya ISD which is $1,734 um and this is total expenditures across the district against the number of students enrolled in the district if you see the graphic however you see the difference between our Elementary uh schools and our secondary schools can reach nearly a, higher than in comparison for average spending per student finally I want to emphasize the piece on special education or St we have a total of 14.3
061students identifyed on special education which drives 8.76% of total expenditures in this area however I want to say that the average of students identifying in special education in the state is only uh 10.4 5% so this um is showing us that we are overidentifying our students and the impact that this has on our budget and now miss Miller we are going to switch gears to teacher evaluations in the Hoya ISD our leaders use the test our Texas teacher evaluation and support system this tool is used to help improve teaching practices through giving teachers continuous feedback the test rubric is based on four domains these domains are planning and lesson internalization instruction learning environment and professional practice and responsibility once the principal has done observations and feedback with the teachers they are placed in five different
062tiers the first tier is Improvement needed a teacher at this level struggles to meet the standards of highlevel teaching in their classroom it's if you look to your left you're going to see that in La Hoya ISD we do not have any teachers that are in the Improvement needed tier the next one is developing this level represents teachers who are partially proficient at giving high level instruction in La Hoya we have about five a little over 5% of our teachers in the developing tier proficient are our Rock Solid teachers these are teachers that are proficient in high quality instruction C and they are growing all students in their classroom in La Hoya you see that we have a little over 71% of our teachers in that bucket the next tier is accomplished these are our
063Rockstar teachers they are growing all students and they are showing consistent highquality teaching in their classrooms we have about 23% of our teachers and then distinguished are your unicorns these are our teachers that are our highquality rock stars who are not only growing their students but they're growing students outside of their own classroom by growing other teachers we have just about 4% of those teachers but if you look at Trends in La Hoya you're going to see that our a-rated campuses have over three times the proportion of accomplished and distinguished teachers compared to our c d and f-rated campuses we would expect that because our um um distinguished and high quality teachers are growing kids and are a rated campuses are showing that but if you look at our C and our d and f
064campuses you see that there's discrepancies we have um proficient and accomplished teachers on this campus but what did we say um proficient and accomplished teachers do they grow all students in their classroom but our accountability ratings are not showing that we're growing all students on these campuses test is meant as as a tool for growth it is not a got you and these ratings are designed to guide teachers on a pathway of continuous improvement with a focus on professional development so that they can move from one tier to the next tier so we have to ensure that we're rating our teachers appropriately so that they have they are on the path to get what they need to grow in their own lesson planning in their internalization in their learning environment in their highquality instruction and
065in turn the students and the ISD campuses will also grow in their academic Journey do you have any questions members of the board do we have any questions for Miss Miller in the schools that are rated CND do we see a high turnover um no we do not see a high turnover there may be a couple that are our F campuses where we do see a higher turnover than our a andb campuses so no real correlation okay but not a huge turnover yes ma'am any other other questions how often are these uh T Test ratings um like either put out or evaluated um at the at the campuses so this is a growth process it's an observation and feedback so it starts with a pre-conference where the leader meets with the teacher talks them about
066their lesson then they go in and they do different observations and give feedback then they have their summative um observation where they go in for at least 45 minutes and then they have a postc conference after after that observation to talk about what they see but this is used to grow teachers it's not just a oneandone it's over the semesters it's over the year that the principles go in and then they should give feedback to the teachers and then have that summative which is where their rating comes from and is it happening like once a month or once every semester how often is um it depends on the leader so some leaders are in campuses more than others but we do have a calendar and we expect them to go in at least once a
067month to observe teachers and give them feedback think the process is done throughout the year but our teachers are evaluated on a yearly basis I have a question kind of on that same um topic with these um test ratings if they're being done by the principles and we're seeing a discrepancy in these ratings of having these proficient accomplished and distinguished teachers but we're not seeing the result result of this distinguished you know merits are we thinking maybe it's where the principles may not be doing the accur an accurate evaluation because potentially you know I could see how principles with their teachers they know them they're friends sometimes you get you know feelings involved how do we kind of maybe see where it's coming from do we need to get like just trying to see where
068maybe the discrepancy is coming from so we have to remember that this is data from the 23 24 school year this is where we are but where we're moving is we do have calibration training with our principles this year so they are digging into the rubric they are looking at what makes an improvement needed teacher what do we see in a classroom above a proficient teacher what do we see in the classroom of a distinguished teacher they're also doing learning walks together so walking into classrooms and then rating walking out and raing the teachers so that we're calibrating to ensure that we place our teachers in the right tier um we have professional learning Dr little um spoke about that to help with the high quality instruction in our classrooms and Leadership coaching we now
069have a leadership team and network leaders that are on campuses they're walking into classrooms with leaders they're calibrating on T tests with them so we do have things in place for the 2425 school year so these are things that we didn't have then in these are things yes because this is data from last year this is where we were in the future this is where we're going thank you and in addition uh Miss travez I would also add that we all engaged as a executive leadership team and cabinet um and uh a executive leadership team um in test training um where we all learn together and calibrated together on um principal professional development so and principal evaluation so that we as a leadership team were calibrated on how do we evaluate our principles so that
070we could coach them as they evaluate teachers so that we could all be calibrated on evaluating principles do we have any further questions for Miss Miller Miss Miller is that your team to my right your left no that's not that's little well we're all a team right I saw them leav they all got it over here yeah they all got it that's why I'm like I was watching them and I could tell that they were agreeing with what you were your responses to the board so thank you for that m g Pettis okay so it's not GNA no so we are going to transition to our enrollment data so as we are talking our equality seats analysis and the data that we are presenting so we want to look at where have we been in
071the last 10 years um we have been doing a lot of things in the last 10 years right but a lot of it has been staying the same regardless of the enrollment that we've had um so when you start looking at overall in the last 10 years we've lost about 20% of our student enrollment we've gone from um the 29,000 plus to 20 23,000 so it's a little over 55 5600 students that we've lost in the last 10 years overall in the district when we start looking at per grade level so we look at prek all the way to 12th grade and so we have some anomalies here prek is there's a growth but we did not have prek 10 years ago and so now we do so you see that big uh bar graph
072right there for prek and then you also start looking at the end and so 10th 11th and 12th historically we've had we've we have students that leave during our Middle School years and then come back during our our high school years and for several reasons when we interview students it's Athletics it's fine artarts it's the dual enrollment programs that we have and so all of our all of these kids are coming back to our school so we want to again make sure that we are providing the best education that we can for our students because they're coming back to us for those great opportunities that we have in the district and we want to make sure that we are preparing them not just for Star but for all of their post-secondary education when they leave
073us and all of those uh postsecondary exams and things like that that they need um we also look at per campus again we have that now we have Kamar Elementary that opened within the last you know 10 years so we want to see they have uh that growth of 15% but it's they opened right during this year so we looked at our secondary schools and so in our secondary schools the one high we've had only a Palm View High School that has grown 1% in the last 10 years so when you look at the district as a whole we've lost enrollment um throughout we've also we also look at interdistrict transfers and so comparing the 23 24 school year to the 2425 we've looked at how many students and to what schools they are transferring
074into and so we have JFK that has a big percentage of transfers into that uh that school again we want to look at how are the schools doing so that we can replicate so we want to look at why are students choosing to go to JFK compared to some of the other schools if they are not zoned um to JFK or to some of these other schools we do have a transfer process that we the families parents uh Guardians right they they fill out the application it goes through our office and then we look at those transfer policies procedures that we have in place to accept those transfers um there's certain criteria in order for them to stay at those schools they can stay um absences grades and things like that if not then they
075lose that privilege uh for that transfer Dr Gary good evening so one of the last pieces of data that we took a look at is the uh building capacity and the usage of that capacity across our district you'll note on this slide that we are only utilizing 61% of the building capacity of all of our buildings out of 100% of the buildings across this entire District um and that includes our a-rated campuses this uh unfortunately this speaks to some inefficiencies and expenditures that are unnecessary with um building repairs energy costs Staffing supplies all those types of things so we have to really dig deep into this data to find out how can we better utilize our building spaces more efficiently so that we can allocate our funds to things like amazing programming and when you
076look at our a rated campuses on this slide you'll see that many of those schools are also at that 61% average or below so that means that we could actually extend the reach of our best teachers our best leaders and our best programs if we could expand the the seat offerings or find ways to utilize these spaces differently and then we also have um this slide that shows that uh our lower performing campuses are at a 58% current capacity so there's not that big of a difference between the amount of students that are attending our high performing and are low performing so this data really tells us that we as a team have to dig deeper into finding out how we can better utilize these spaces for everyone's benefit uh and I'm going to turn
077it over to Dr Mr Nella any questions for Dr Gary before yeah any questions for Miss GES is Sir Dr gir quick questions Mr President uhad one question for Dr G just what are some big picture Solutions we're looking at or considering right now for the future to um well considering the capacity issue a at this point we're just in the beginning stages um of assessing to seeing where are the patterns where are the best programs how can we better use the spaces um and that is part of actually some of the next steps that Mr Nella is going to speak to but that is one of the next tasks of this team is to take all this data that we've gathered and make some of those um ideate some of those decisions thank you
078Dr Gary I have a question was 6 don't don't take off yet um is 61% alarming to you that we utiliz buildings campus wide is that alarming to you or is that pretty average uh it's it's pretty alarming actually in our some of our uh lower performing campuses they're less than 50% capacity which means for instance we We Run The chillers or the AC for a building of say a th000 kids and there's only 500 or or a building of 800 and there's only 250 there's a lot of wasted um just even energy and that's just one small component right and so when you look at that um you know that we could be taking those dollars which are in the hundreds of thousands of just in energy and take it and put it to
079an amazing program that we could bring for our kids so yes it is is very alarming um because um we need to focus in on what's best for our kids in that respect I agree with you so can I ask you if something in the past has ever been developed or was this had you found any data that had something similar to this or was was this something that we did for the first time I I actually I could not find any evidence that we had assessed um ourselves as a district in the past in this way um decisions did not appear to be made based on this type of data thank you Dr giri any other questions thank you Joseph so as we conclude I ask us to to step back for a moment
080so we're a district that's committed to um data informed research-based practic practices the quality seats analysis I hope you hope you're able to see is a very comprehensive um holistic view of the state of our school system we had some very robust conversations um and those conversations don't stop tonight as I indicated in the first slide or in my first uh uh earlier um the qsa is something we're going to do annually um but tonight's milestone is is is only the start of our work um we will as a Cabinet we're going to begin the annual School planning process by teering campuses and we're going to develop campus by campus action plans we're going to identify aligned opportunities through state state grant opportunities such as the school action fund and the lasso grant opportunities as
081we think about school actions for individual campuses on November 20th we're going to bring forward to you a high school action plan in it it's going to Identify and discuss some and go into more detail about some of the duplication of programming that's happening at some of our campus our our high school campuses we're going to prioritize Clarity and focus in planning to address these duplications and we're going to keep student and Community needs at the center of all of our decision-making so our next steps also include starting Community conversations the executive cabinet is going to go on is going to be going on a road show with our quality seats analysis we're going to be sharing this with our community we're going to be sharing this with our teachers our principles tomorrow morning we're
082going to be sharing it with um anybody who will listen to us over the next month and a half um so again want to ground us back into what I view are the two Central questions of the quality seats analysis what does it tell us what does the analysis tell us about what we need to do to ensure we're guaranteeing a quality seat at a quality school for every student in La Hoya ISD how does it inform how we view ourselves in living up to our vision and our mission so with that I thank you very much I will take any questions should there be members of the board do we have any questions for Joseph or any or any anyone on this team no questions but I do want to say this is an
083eye opener and I appreciate the information that you all provided especially with the seed quality analysis I know this was something that we were expecting and waiting for so now that we know this we I'm hoping the community can see where it's not only problems that we had in previous situations and we all know why but also the fact that we have the problems of of our our campuses and the ratings and everything that we need to kind of focus on to make sure our kids are in the best seat quality seat that they should be thank you well said Mr Gomez any other members of the board I also kind of want to note that I think um in terms of next up it's super important that we start with those Community conversations right
084cuz I think it's important that the community is aware of what's going on and where we're at and what dire want to hold so thank you guys for kind of getting on that on that road show for that yes ma'am thank you anyone else Joseph just let me share with you how exciting this is especially when we started the conversation in the presentation this morning or this evening when Dr s Inon said we'd be the only school doing this it's exciting and so I love the idea that you'll be taking a road show so um I heard that Dr giri was going to be taking a bus full of admin we were going to be going out there but I mean who else is doing that that's that's amazing that we're going out there and
085I think the community is going to be very grateful and they're appreciative of the fact that we're going out there we're listening to them as we promis we would and full transparency has always been our modotto so we appreciate you doing that and I'm glad to see that on the near future you'll be reporting back to us some of those conversations that you've had with our stakeholders so thank you for that absolutely thank you sir