001e e e this is vice chairwoman Robin Harvey I will be presiding on behalf of chair Jane Lor this evening I call to order the meeting of the Board of Education of Baltimore County for Tuesday January 28 2025 this evening's Board of Education meeting is being broadcast through the BCPS online live meeting broadcast and on BCPS TV Comcast xinity channel 73 and Verizon Vios Channel 34 in order to efficiently conduct this meeting all voting items this evening will be done by roll call vote May I have a motion to go into close session as permitted by the open meetings act as found in annotated code of Maryland General Provisions article 3-35 B1 and B7 to discuss the appointments employment assignments promotion discipline demotion compensation removal resignation or performance evaluation of appointees employees or officials over
002whom it has jurisdiction or any other Personnel matters that affects one or more specific individuals and to consult with councel to obtain Le legal advice so moved from pong is is there a second second CH K thank you may I have a roll call vote Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen Miss frong yes Miss Booker dwire yes Miss chika Kulu yes moski yes Dr seavo yes Mr mcmillion yes Miss Pumphrey yes Miss Harvey yes Miss Lor thank you motion carries e e e hello good evening everyone H good evening thank you I appreciate that hello this is vice chair Robin Harvey presiding on behalf of chair Jane lter I now call to order the meeting for the Board of Education of Baltimore County for Tuesday January 28th 2025 I invite you all to
003recite the pledge of allegiance to the flag to be led by Scout Troop 8634 out of triny Lutheran in Baltimore count in rers toown Baltimore County oh I'm sorry we will then have a moment of silence and recognition of those who have served education in Baltimore County thank you I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you tonight's Board of Education meeting is being broadcast through the BCPS online live meeting broadcast and on BCPS TV Comcast Infinity Channel 773 and Verizon files Channel 34 in order to efficiently conduct this meeting all voting items this evening will be done by a roll call vote the first item on the agenda is the
004consideration of the January 28th agenda Dr Rogers are there any additions or changes to tonight's agenda I am unaware of any additions or changes to this evening's agenda thank you hearing none the agenda stands as presented earlier this evening the board met in closed session pursuant to the open meetings act for the following reasons to discuss the appointment employment assignment promotion discipline demotion compensation removal resignation or performance evaluation of appointees employees or officials over whom it has jurisdiction or any other Personnel matter that affects one or more individuals and to consult with counsel to obtain legal advice the closed session summary and the Open Session information summary can be found on board docs under this board meeting agenda date the next item on the agenda genda is Personnel matters and for that I call on
005Mr Mcall good evening Vice chair Harvey superintendent Dr Rogers members of the board like the board's consent for the following Personnel matters we have retirements resignations and certificated appointments is there any discussion do I have a motion to approve the Personnel matters as presented in exhibits D1 through D3 so mooves teski thank you Mr stesy do I have a second second pumfrey thank you Miss Pumphrey any discussion may I have a roll call vote Please Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen yes Miss Fong yes Miss Booker DWI yes Miss chulu yes Miss deleski yes Dr seavoy yes Mr mcmillion yes Miss Pumphrey yes Miss Harvey yes motion carries thank you thank you lost the next item on the agenda is Administrative appointments and for that I call on Dr Rogers thank you Madame
006Vice chair Harvey members of the board I pleased to present the following positions for your approval this evening assistant principal Harford High School assistant manager Technology support office of Information Technology operations senior operation supervisor Department of food and nutrition services senior supervisor Construction office of facilities construction and Improvement and Senior supervisor planning office of facilities construction and Improvement do I have a motion to approve the personnal matters as presented in exhibit E1 so moved Fong thank you Miss frong do I have a second second CH kooo thank you Miss CH kooo any discussion may I have a roll call vote Please Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen yes Miss Fong yes Miss Booker DWI yes Miss uh chica kou yes mrki yes Dr seavoy yes Mr McMillian yes Miss Pumphrey yes Miss Harvey
007yes thank you motion carries Dr Rogers thank you our first appointment this evening and please please stand to be recognized is Julian cover Julian is attending and is being appointed as the senior operations supervisor in the department of food and nutrition with 22 years of experience Julian's prior experiences include general manager at Sparro Incorporated chemel Center multi-unit general manager in District safety leader at NYU dining director of operations at forom University dining resident district manager at American University dining and FSE training general manager at Wawa incorporators congratulations and welcome to BCPS our next appointment is dbor folini please stand dbor is attending with her husband Scott minetti please stand or wave and is being appointed as the assistant manager Technology support in the office of Information Technology operations with 14 years of experience with Baltimore
008County Public Schools prior experiences include PC technician and it support technician in the office of Technology support services and Lead it technician on-site support in the off office of Information Technology operations prior to that uh experiences include IT specialist translator at gnm and Associates and help desk technician Technology support technician and public technology assistant with the Baltimore County Public Library congratulations our next appointment this evening is Timothy Gordon Timothy is attending with principal Robert uh coer at Harford high school we thank you we want to recognize and thank you for your work Timothy is being appointed as the assistant principal at Harford high school with 18 years of experience prior experiences include social studies teacher resident principal and principal with Baltimore city schools and executive director office of Grants Administration and compliance with the Maryland
009State Department of Education congratulations and welcome to BCPS our next appointment is George NS George is attending with his girlfriend Emily Brown and George is being attended as the senior supervisor planning in the office of facilities construction and improvement with a year of experience with Baltimore County Public Schools George's prior experiences include senior project engineer in the office of facilities construction and Improvement prior to that George served as electric design engineer at Henry Adams LLC manager at Baltimore Gas and Electric and Senior manager at sergeant and Lundy [Applause] congratulations our final appointment this evening is Jim kogl Please Stand Jim is attending with his wife Joanne and is being appointed as the senior supervisor Construction in the office of facilities construction and improvement with a year of experience with Baltimore County Public Schools Jim's uh
010BCPS experience includes senior project manager in the office of facilities construction and Improvement prior to that Jim served as an intern architect at Richard pezenik PC project manager at Thomas Associates project architect at Burton barent and Smith project manager at Turner Construction company and Aviation Constructors on-site construction supervisor senior construction manager and a senior project manager at uh J kokolakis Contracting Hsu Builders and Hees construction and Engineering Services [Applause] congratulations uh thank you superintendent Rogers and thank you to everyone who was appointed today congratulations and thank you for your service to our BCPS students and families our next item on the agenda is public comment this is one of the opportunities the board provides to hear the views and receive the advice of our community members it if not selected to address the board members
011of the public May submit their comments to the board members via email at Boe at bcps.org the Baltimore County Police Department's Homeland Security unit and office of school safety has recommended Safety and Security protocol protocols which are posted in the boardroom and AA ailable in board docs and on the board's participation by the public website while we encourage public input on policy programs and practices within the purview of this board and this school system this is not the opportunity uh or the proper form to address specific students or employee matters or to comment on matters that do not relate to the public Ed to public education in Baltimore County inappropriate personal remarks or other Behavior such as Lang language that promotes violence against a BCPS employee or that disrupts or interferes with the conduct of
012this meeting are out of order and will not be tolerated persons who otherwise disrupt or disturb this meeting will not be allowed to continue their remarks and will be escorted from the meeting please observe the three minute clock which we will let you know when which will let you know when your time is up the microphone will be turned off at the end of your time or prior to that time at the discretion of the board chair our first category is school system Affiliated and our first speaker is Megan Stewart siking Vice chair Harvey Dr Rogers members of the board good evening to all of you I have been involved with special education in the BCPS system for 15 years and for six of those years I was chair of the special education citizens advisory
013committee I have spent countless hours at these board meetings and I'm returning tonight to talk about something we've all probably heard hundreds of times the importance of fully funding special education in our budget of course you are used to everyone asking for funding and everyone explaining why their area is important and deserving there are a lot of competing goods for you to weigh but as we as we know as well special education literally touches every area of this system's life gened teachers related service providers psychologists social workers administrators climate Transportation legal and so on special education also touches every area of progress reporting Community satisfaction and assessment of student achievement you cannot Short change special education without short changing every student every teacher and every aspect of our system every person and every resource is
014stretched too thin and the fabric of our services is threadbear the growing holes cannot be covered recent prioritization of certain special education goals has supported forward progress the addition of IEP facilitators last year was a long time recommendation of secac and the superintendent showed her commitment to special ed through this immediate funding in her first budget additionally funding special Educators aligned to full day prek allowed our youngest Learners to have the opportunity to receive critical early services within their home school still crucial crucial are the following needs funding for increased positions for teachers Paras AAS to ensure appropriate Service delivery for our students funding for special Educators as we continue to expand full day prek funding for related service providers for necessary PT OT and speech for our students funding for non-public placements to ensure
015support for students whose needs are complex and are best met beyond the BCPS Schoolhouse setting we understand with proposed budget changes at the state level funding will be tight however at this point it is a moral imperative as well as a practical necessity to fully fund special education and ensure adequate resources are available for students and families receiving special ed services the success of the whole system depends on it thank you thank you our next speaker is Leslie Weber Miss Weber I I'll move to the next speaker and we'll come back to miss Weber we can get her sound on our next speaker is Nicholas Richardson good evening everyone Dr Rogers Madam Vice chair board I'm Nicholas Richardson and I am along with Anthony Freeman two of the members of our current cak uh special
016education Advisory Board Council uh we're here to once again mention how important special education funding is inside of the County uh as it was previously mentioned we know that the budget is tight we have com competing priorities we already are aware of all of the strains that not only County the County government is under but our state government now is is under as well but with that state government being stretch tight and families not being able to receive certain services that they were accustomed to receiving in the past due to uh budget cuts having special education funded inside of our B Baltimore County Public Schools is imperative um we are both are parents of children that have special education needs however we're here to speak on behalf of all children because our children aren't the
017only children that are suffering due to lack of funding where does this funding go uh this funding goes towards not only the training of individuals inside of the classrooms not only your parent Educators but and your general Educators but this training also and funding for training for your for your specials your gym teachers your art teachers who also have to deal with children that are on uh in the special education realm that training needs to be extended to those individuals as well and funding needs to go to support that those the training of those individuals services and information information services and supporting Technologies inside of the classroom if you have not had the opportunity to sit and spend uh a day or so with a child inside a special education please do that because you
018will then see how how the money that is spent in the special education area is so vital to these children not only uh today but moving forward what this funding could possibly do is create a system for Data Tracking which parents has have said and shown is a necessity inside of developing goals towards IEPs parents are unaware of how their child is being moved forward towards those goals something outside of just the observation could definitely be used for the funding inside of special education for the Baltimore County uh school system so I I'll I'll yield the remainder of my time back to the board thank you thank you thank you our next speaker is Miss Leslie Weber Miss Weber I think we're still having some technical difficulties with the sound virtually I'll move on to
019the next group and if we can get Miss weer back we will uh our next category is that of our unions and our next speaker is Lloyd Allen good evening chair Harvey Dr Rogers and members of the board thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight I'm Lloyd Allen member of tabo's board of director bringing remarks on behalf of tabco President Cindy Sexton Dr Rogers we know the budget was a struggle and we thank you for honoring the agreements around compensation of course we look to the county executive and the County Council to move forward with the budget board members we Face a time of uncertainty on many levels we don't know what will happen in Annapolis with our legislators around the blueprint and the state budget tabco is planning to take a busload of
020members to speak with legislators on February 24th we know they need to hear from all of us we don't know what will come down from the federal level on many different fronts we are likely to face many more challenges in the upcoming days weeks and months we will have to work together through through these challenges but in the meantime what we do know and what I'm asking you to focus on tonight as you have your work session on this budget is a laser focus on what is best for our students each dollar must be spent so that it helps our students we are beginning to see gains academically and we need to continue and to increase them of course what that will take are the Educators in the classrooms the boots on the ground the
021support and Human Resources our students need please ask yourselves is each dollar is each position in this budget one that is either working with or for our students to help them and while we focus on the academic outcomes we know our students need much more are the positions we have adequate to meet the needs of our students please focus on this as you work through this budget we know that we need the business side to be staffed as well and we're not negating the importance of that but we are asking that you look at every position and if that person is being used for the Improvement of our students and or our Educators we know that most of our conditionally certified Educators can become great licensed Educators if they have the support they need please
022be sure we keep these supports in place we cannot overstate how much our students need them and our school system needs them we are facing uncertainty on so many levels our students are looking to us not only for their academic instruction but perhaps more importantly reassurances let's not let them down as always tabco stands at the ready to do the work together with with you thank you thank [Applause] you Miss Weber teams can you hear me now yes we can miss Weber please proceed okay thank you good evening I'm lesle Weber president of the PTA Council of Baltimore County PTA Council recognizes the challenging fiscal landcape landscape facing our school system due to state and federal funding de increases into the increasing needs of our students and families we're pleased that the budget has been
023closely analyzed to reveal cost savings and that no staff layoffs are planned I'd like to offer some comments on some important proposed Investments offering compensation enhancements for all BCPS staff BCPS needs to recruit and retain top quality staff and staff members need to feel supported and not stressed and overworked maintaining reduced class sizes in grades 3 through five we're happy that the proposed budget aims to preserve current Class Staffing allocations because learning and relationships improve in smaller classrooms expanding special special education Staffing and increasing multilingual Learners resources investments in special education are critical as are investments in multilingual Learners resources due to the rapidly changing makeup of our community and school system and the increasing needs of our students enhancing Career and Technical education programs we feel that enhanced CTE programs will impude improve student
024outcomes preparing students for college and careers expanding full day prek classes prek access is important because research shows that it helps ensure that all children are ready to learn and find success in kindergarten and Beyond I'd like to add some comments regarding current events potentially affecting undocumented students and families in BCPS in a recent statement free state PTA reaffirmed its unwavering commitment to the well-being and rights of every child in Maryland and Beyond Freestate PTA does not support any action that results in the separation of children from their families such measures run counter to our mission to make every child's potential reality be by engaging and Empowering Families and communities to Advocate advocate for all children free state PTA stands United in the belief that separation is not only harmful to Children's emotional and physical
025well-being but also violates their basic human rights freest State PTA will continue to Advocate tirelessly for policy that that protect and uplift every child regardless of their background or circumstances we encourage all members to join us in this effort by speaking out supporting impacted families and working to create communities where all children can Thrive I urge everyone to read two national PTA position statements the first is rights and services for undocumented children and the second is separation of undocumented Children and Families I'd be happy to share this information with anyone who needs it both statements um both position statements begin with the statement that the national PTA believes that all children residing in the US regardless of their immigration status have the right of access to a quality public education adequate food and shelter and
026basic health care services thank you thank you our next category is nonprofit Community groups and our first speaker is Marietta English good evening excuse me good evening Vice chair elector I'm sorry chair elector she's not here would you write your comments before you get here chair Harvey superintendent Rogers and members of the board I'm pleased to be here in support of the FY 26 operating budget my name is Marana English chair of the Baltimore County NAACP education committee I am here today on behalf of the NAACP Baltimore County Branch to support Dr Dr Rogers FY 26 operating budget we're asking that this school board fully fund this budget that provides needed resources to our 110 students and 20,000 staff members we support this budget that provides funding for Community Schools early childhood education expansion my
027field special education my second field esol College and Career readiness and CTE programs when you consider the recent BCPS academic gains on state assessments where B Baltimore County public schools had more fstar rated schools than any other local jurisdiction in the state of Maryland it is critical that we fund our school system and keep this momentum going this is not a time for us to go backwards we must keep moving forward while this budget has has an increase it is necessary to maintain the growth of our students our quality teachers and maintain our buildings the naap has been a longtime partner with Baltimore County Public Schools providing academic support membership mentoring sh mentorship and administering creative arts programs through our highly SE effective academic cultural technological scientific Olympics thank you for your continued support and
028your partnership in order to continue these recent academic gains we must fully fund this budget understanding that education is the key to all of our success our children deserve the best they deserve the resources this budget provides that gives our children the tools they need to be successful in school in closing we congratulate superintendent Rogers and the school board for the incredible work you are doing and hope that this budget is supported by the school board and sent to the county executive County Council for their deliberation and approval as well thank you Dr Rogers and Schoolboard members please fully fund this budget thank you thank you our next speaker is Virginia Jones good evening thank you superintendent Rogers the um board members for the work that you're doing for our children family and Community my
029name is Virginia Jones I'm representing the woodlands of Deer Park Community Association in randalstown I'm here in strong support of superintendent Rogers budgets that reflect the community the commitment of Baltimore County public schools to provide high quality Ed education for all children and provide the necessary resources to be successful during challenging economical times we must find a way to support this budget that funds full day prek which is the foundation of our education system funds Community Schools literature and math and special education this is a time to keep moving forward especially when we are finally seeing the fruit of our labors under the leadership of Dr Rogers and this school board please fully fund this budget for our children family and Community please support this critically important budget there is no greater investment we can
030make than in our children this budget although very difficult in a tight budget season is the right thing to do and ensure that we keep moving Baltimore County Public School forward not go backwards I thank each of you for your time your service and Leadership thank you so much thank you our next speaker is Leslie Margolis okay thank you our next speaker is Donald Campbell moving on our next speaker is latata lowings hello Mr Campbell will'll call you in a moment thank you okay thank you okay good evening Dr Rogers good evening board Vice Harvey board members and children family and communities so I'm going to say as Lyn Longs the president of Baltimore County chapter Continental societies we are proud Partners we are 48 women strong throughout the United States actually we have the
031largest chapter throughout the United States and we are excited to continue support the Baltimore County Schools I know we have little but we put our money together and we try to support the teachers and we try to support the children in every area as much as we can from coat drives to food to anything that the schools call and ask us so I am asking even though our budget is not like your budget cuz we come out of our pockets I am asking that this budget for Dr Rogers FY well actually it's not for her it's for the school FY 26 operating budget that the school board will be delivering this evening send a message that the communities need this funding our children are suffering we need they need a hope they need uh INSP
032ation they need the funding to move forward to be successful as you are all around the room we had education we had support so whatever we need to do to move this budget forward just think about it we just had five School five star rating that's good Kudos right okay so it's moving so I say on behalf of the Continental Society Baltimore County chapter we're going to continue to do our small portion and we want you to continue to think about all the smiles uh of the kids coming to school with coats and happy just we have to move this forward it takes a village to raise children all hands on deck everybody hands on just just think about it I look at my school picture when I was many years ago and I was
033excited to be in school I want the children of today to be excited to come to school and have the things that they need so whatever we need to do we need to make sure that we take all of that in consideration and think about the smiles of the children that they be accountings one day they be in your shoes one day president anything so I say thank you thank you Dr Rogers please get this funding pass our children our commitment Our concern on behalf of Baltimore County Continental Society thank you thank you our our next speaker will be Donald Campbell Mr Campbell jeames what's going on Mr Campbell we can hear you okay then good evening superintendent Rogers chair Lightner Vice chair Harvey and the board members my name is Kell Campbell I'm the
034president of the Chadwick homeowners Improvement Association and also the vice president of the greater Fairbrook Community Coalition we inom about 1500 homes in our Coalition under about six um HOAs I'm here this evening in strong support of the superintendent Dr M and Rogers 26 budget as a community leader this budget will ensure that our children our grandchildren and our community will receive the necessary resources and support it needs to ensure that all students receive a high quality education regardless of their zip code or their station in life during these very challenging Economic Times we must find a way to unite and support this budget that funds Community Schools for day prek math science reading and funds our critically important special education programs this is not a time to stall pause or slow down our morale
035or ruary responsibility in providing our students with a first class education especially we are finally seeing our state test scores moving in the right direction after many years of De claim we must support superintendent rogers's budget that will continue the academic process made in the last two years and continue to close the achievement gaps that we all want to see eliminated I want to thank the school board and Dr Rogers for turning this school system around and placing our feet on Solid Ground we have a chance this year's budget process to literally put our money where our mouth is to let this budget reflects our shared values and commitment to education that we all agree education is the very foundation and backbone of our communities I ask that the board support Dr V's budget and
036send it to the county executive and the County Council thank you our next group of speakers will be individual citizens or students and our first speaker is Ralph jaffy I'm not ready yet please can can you hear me can you hear me okay yes sir all right I'm ready uh I want to thank Brenda Stiffler and Tracy Gover for their professionalism that they have extended to me it's greatly appreciated I also want you to know that I'm not not here to ask you for money this program I'm talking about the tut Tor team education program is designed to save lives and by the way uh there have been many many people have called Brenda and Tracy to say that they want this program implemented and the last 20 phone calls have said they want Dr
037Rogers to meet with jaffy and this program isn't going to cost the taxpayers one penny and I would also like to now uh mention some of the projects that we've been involved in and my teaching experiences which started back in 1969 I mentioned previously I pioneered a new teaching device called activism in the classroom 11 minut 11 months later was signed into law by Nixon documented in 1970 Edition Dan 1970 Edition re digest I mention these things to you not to brag but to to to prove to you I know what I'm talking about I know what good teaching is all about I have the evidence to prove it and I sent you uh what I call my credibility papers which shows and discuss mentions all the projects and all the notable personalities involved in
038these projects people like John Unitus National Football Hall Fame we didn't ask him for his AOG we asked him for his help Brooks Robinson National Hall of Fame Lenny Moore national football hall of Hall of Fame bran Bradley uh the executive editor of the Washington Post a movie was made called all the president men which started Jason um Ben Bradley's uh with his uh person who played him was uh Jason robarts who got an Academy Award and we didn't ask Mr Bradley for his autograph we asked them to help us so this is what these programs are are designed to do when I was in Parkville Senior High School we had two pieces of legislation introduced one was a seeing ey dogs bill which would help people who are blind to use their dogs in
039public facilities that was a B on non- returnable bottles we also established what's called people for Community Action a drug counseling center for students who had all kinds of different problems with drugs it receiv received over $150,000 in government grants so was that the bill so so um I know what I'm talking about and remember there have been at least over 120 people have called you it's one thing to ignore me but these are people that you're also going to take this pram thank you Mr jaffy may I ask you a question please yes I'm trying to understand I appreciate your persistent advocacy for your program uh and and I want to understand where where the road block is where can I see you where right here who am I talking to this is vice
040chair Harvey go ahead what's your question please my question is I want to understand where your road the roadblock is to your program have you is it the case that youve submitted an application and you haven't gotten a response the the app the the problem is they've told me I've been told that we won't even consider your program until you go through their training program and I said to them the following I orig I said I wasn't going to do that but I I'm I'm a flexible reasonable guy so here's what I said you commit to the program I'll take the Tormentor or whatever you want to call it uh programs reason why I'm so so annoyed about this I've been mentoring people all my adult life I think I know as much about Tutor
041mentoring as anybody and I'm going to go through this program they told me they won't even consider this until I go through their program okay thank you for that feedback this process usually starts with an application so I'm going to ask Dr Rogers to make sure that you get one before you leave today so that they can uh fully vet your program include the information that you provided based on your application and also you let them know about all the phone calls people said they want Dr Rogers to meet with me these are these are all these are people that are willing to take the time in trouble to tell you this I I appreciate that we'll take take that into consideration but Dr Rogers can you make sure that Mr jaffy gets an application
042prior to his is leaving today thank you sir for your comments by the way I did send you I I filled it out that application I do believe in fact I gave you an outline I gave you an outline about this and for for three or four months they couldn't even find it and this was given to you about November of 2023 I gave you the outline thank you thank you sir thank you for your question our next uh speaker is shenita keev please let me know if I've mispronounced your name kie Miss kie please come up thank you hi um good evening everyone my name is shenita ke and I'm the mother of three children ages 20 12 and 5 I'm speaking tonight in favor of the superintendent's budget for special education being fully
043funded each of my children receives or has received special education services through BCPS via 504 plan or IEPs sorry I'm a little nervous these Services have been an integral support and resource in my children's education not just academically but also socially and behaviorally as as a parent I would like to share my experience with special education within BCPS my oldest child started receiving Services via 504 plan when he started middle school middle school was a very difficult time for my son in his 504 plan transition to an IEP my 12-year-old daughter currently has a 504 plan which was implemented when she started Middle School both my son and daughter began experiencing mental health issues in middle school I also have a 5-year-old daughter who is neurod Divergent and has had an IEP since starting prek
044most parents would be overwhelmed worried fearful and concerned and I was all of these but having received special education services through the BCPS school system myself as a child I was able to request the necessary services for each of my children as well as receive as well as advocate for their needs despite the challenges my children face or have faced having the accommodations of a 504 IEP has provided them with valuable support and resources my son is currently a student at CCBC and has a GPA a 4.0 as well as being on the dean list for the fall of 2024 he receives continued accommodation in college because he had an IEP my 12-year-old daughter received Straight A's her sixth grade year made the principal list each quarter for sixth grade and had her artwork selected
045to be in Baltimore County Public School Superintendent Gallery currently in seventh grade she is an AB honoral student my 5-year-old kindergartner received student of the month in October 2024 and scored above average on her ycat assessment without the resources and system that special education provides my children would have been impacted in an adverse way special education has helped and continues to help them tremendously throughout their academic Journey I've learned something new with each child as I've navigated through BCPS in special education I as well as many other parents and families are already operating at full capacity and trying to navigate through the school system and special education to ensure that our children are being supported and having their needs met can be daunting and over overwhelming this is why is imperative for special education to
046be 100% funded and supported throughout BCPS so that continued support is provided not only to families and students but to Educators as well thank you thank you our next speaker is Simone buers please correct me if I've mispronounced your name Vice chair Harvey superintendent Rogers and the board I'm Simmon bird and I apologize Miss B that's okay and this is my son Tyler bur he is a 10th grader at New Town High School in a self-proclaimed Biblia file and CES Pilan and I want to share with you the success that can come when you fully fund a budget and you appropriately staff and have special related service providers from prek 3 to 10th grade Tyler went from Franklin Elementary in a general education classroom with uh pull out special ed support that model did not
047work for him and he was fast tracking for school to prison pipeline because he ended up with this issues he hadn't had before and he was partially mute during those early years and now um I have a handout for the board you can see new town is highlighting his word of the day where he's using technology which I think is also included in Dr Rogers budget um and they have put a wall because he goes around the school educating other people and advocating and that doesn't happen when we fuss over whether you have full-time positions and can fund them that doesn't happen when you don't have enough uh Speech therapists occupational therapists like myself or physical therapist related service providers it's really important to extend that Village some of our village is here with us
048supporting us one of his previous principles and special education chairpersons continue to stay in touch with us to see where they work in the early years is still impacting him now um it's hard enough for parents to accept their child's ch challenges and that they may need special education services it would be abysmal for families who can't speak up loud enough for themselves not to fully fund this budget I look at this budget and I thank you Dr Rogers I look at it as the minimum it's not the ceiling it's what your data showed you need presently but it's not qualitative in what really needs to happen in the school so I look at that budget as this is where you start and I know money is tight but we need to think beyond that
049and see where these students can go so they can be contributing citizens Tyler is committed to coming back to this board and sharing with you when he opens his own personal business and takes over the world I have no doubt he'll do it um and I will send you videos of him from early on till now where he spoke for his fifth grade commencement and was chosen to be the speaker a child who didn't used to talk so I just implore you not to Short change the students and not to burn out the staff what you've already done is wonderful and I expect you to be excellent thank you for your time thank you and thank you [Applause] Tyler our next speaker speaker is Clifford Collins good evening Dr Rogers C can you hear me
050Mr Collins yes can you hear me yes we can sir okay uh good evening Dr Rogers chair ller Vice chair Harvey the members of the board my name is Clifford Collins a longtime resident of the randles Sound Community and the former employee of the Baltimore County Public Schools I wish to inform you of my support of Dr Rogers fiscal year 2026 operating budget for the Baltimore County Public Schools you must maintain your commitment to help ensure a secure and vibrant future for Baltimore County by continuing to invest in the preparation of our students for the challenges and opportunities they will experience in the future I also believe this budget will provide the resources necessary to sustain and enhance our recent academic Gams after careful review this budget is reasonable and supports critical areas of our
051school system including Community Schools early childhood education special education and programs for multilingual Learners and C CTE the Baltimore County Schools is asking for a full funding of this B balanced budget this budget is for and about children teachers and the Baltimore County communities I would be it would be unwise for the fund for not to fund this fiscal year 26 operating budget especially after reviewing the achievements in the Maryland State Department of Education report card Baltimore County saw increases in our academic ratings BCPS had the greatest number of five-star schools in the state of Maryland 66 BCPS schools earned a four or five star rating with 38 schools increasing their overall star rating a significant improvement over the previous year given the structural deficit it's even it's even more urgent and critical that local
052school systems fully fund their fiscal year 26 budgets BCPS is finally moving in the right direction after years of academic decline now is not the time to decrease funding for our school system now is the time to fully fund our board system above maintenance of effort and continue the academic gains all of us have seen the past two years thank you superintendent Rogers and the school board for overseeing this remarkable academic turnaround and let's keep moving BCPS forward and again become number one academically in the state of Maryland Dr Rogers and the Baltimore County Board of Education I applaud your tireless work and Leadership please pass this budget I thank you for this opportunity to speak to you this evening thank you our next speaker is Kenneth Brown good evening superintendent Rogers Vice chair Harvey
053and other board members my name is Kenny Brown and I'm here today in support of Dr Rogers operating budget for the fiscal year 2026 I speak as a father of three daughters who graduated from Baltimore County Public Schools as a former chair of the Northwest advisory Council many many years ago and former president of bford Elementary PTA again many moons ago those experiences helped shape and Propel my belief that education is an invaluable asset to our people family and our communities now why do I support this budget we all know that a school system can have the most most motivated students who are so eager to learn it can have the most exceptional and engaged teachers and a system can have the most responsive Forward Thinking leadership but if the system is not funded with
054enough money allocated to the right priorities you're going to stagnant you're not going to move forward I believe this budget hits all the right priorities and initiatives to address students needs and help them Excel for the future the budget supports what I as well as a lot of stakeholders and Community folks see as critical areas for our schools system hiring and retaining quality teachers supporting Community Schools giving our children the best start with early childhood education and helping them succeed with special education this budget invests in our students future by providing essential resources needed to sustain recent academic gains the State Board of Education report card on local schools saw BC BCPS make crucial gains in our academics I was pleased to learn that 66 of our schools earn a fourstar or five-star rating that's
055a significant improvement over the previous year those state test results tell us that Dr Rogers her team and our committed teachers and staff are doing something right I'm hopeful that we can keep up the momentum and do even greater things for our children BCPS is a critical is at a critical inflection point we can choose to move forward move backwards or stand still let's not settle one final Point timing is everything as we know the state has a $3 billion structural deficit with the federal budget situation in play there is a Big R question mark regarding the potential impact on public schools that makes funding the BCPS budget even more urgent again let's do the right thing and fully fund this school budget thank you Dr Rogers for your vision and your stewardship and thank
056you Schoolboard for your time and listening I wish everyone a good evening thank you all right thank you next we will have public comment on board policies the first board policy is policy 3113 transfers and supplements and uh our first speaker is BOS Fon Dr Fon I'm going to ask you to remain seated to provide your public comment on the additional policies please thank you thank you good evening to all I'm sorry about my voice I have a little bit COPD um the first policy is 3113 correct yes okay so the policy 3113 basically says that the superintendent is responsible for managing the budget and the second item that the super intendent will ask the board for permission to transfer money from one category to other so here is what I think right and I
057don't know as much as you do but as a citizen taxpayer looking at the policy it's really too brief the superintendent is the secretary and the treasurer all right so my question is why do we have have to say in the policy that the superintendent is responsible for managing the budget of course Dr Rogers is the treasurer and she is the superintendent too and the secretary the second item is about transfer I understand the Board needs to have surveillance and input and approval of transfer but but the policy does not really say anything about the value of the transfer you know whether it is urgent emergent semi urgent um to me it is kind of like open and too brief and after all as I said for the first thought the superintendent is the manager
058of the budget actually the superintendent is the executive that holds the power once you give the money so you know I thought basically this item uh the first one seems to me you know why you put it in I I I don't get it you know and the second one is just too vague and those are my comments about this policy thank you the next policy is policy 3121 funds management and classification of expenditures please proceed policy 3121 is also brief and it says the superintendent must have receipts and comply with the county code States statutes and federal law so basically the policy says that the superintendent what happened apologies okay um the superintendent needs to have receipts okay well I mean you chose the superintendent giving her $3 billion and more and she is
059the secretary and she is the treasurer why do we ask her for receipts I mean do we expect that superintendent will spend money and not really have receipts everybody will have receipts and if you specify in this policy um that she should have receipts then I think it needs to be explained a little bit more you know what kind of receipt it is it is by email is that acceptable is it by paper is it by hand with a w I I don't know I mean to me this is a policy that seems to be of no value and I I really don't get it and um in my remaining time um you know I am not really an accountant but nonetheless I read which is my downfall so there is something called generally accepted
060account ing uh rules or policies uh I mean to me a policy like this should have more information about how the administration needs to behave in relation to expenditures and this policy doesn't really mention even the word audit now I know you have audits from inside and I know you have audits from outside the state basically audits the school system in a way but I sincerely as a taxpayer that have been taxed almost to death in my 50 years of being baltimorean you need to have a truly independent outside auditor that when they give you an audit it would not really be wishy-washy like it has phrases that negates whatever responsibility they have for instance the report that you will have tonight when I read it in one area shows the responsibility another area it's
061kind of like a disclaimer to me that's a a wiggle that if something went wrong with their audit you know they can wiggle out of that responsibility an audit to me as a taxpayer is to make sure that there is efficiency there is no waste that every dollar is going in the right place and I'm okay with 7 Seconds thank you our next policy is policy 3123 financial reporting please proceed and this policy is interesting like the two previous ones it says superintendent shall prepare financial reports monthly and annually and then another item must comply with the laws I know I raised this issue before and the board elected not to take or answer my my point again you chose the superintendent you know you did your vetting and judgment Etc why do you have
062to say must comply with the law I I don't get it and uh Madame chair Vice chair to chair today you answered the other person asked questions I really want my questions to you today and in the future you answer me in writing because I need to know you know why do you have to say that the superintendent must comply with the law it's it's Common Sense really I mean you know can can the super inten and not comply with the law I guess anyone in Among Us can but obvious viously it's illegal if you mention it it stating the obvious you know why do we put it in it's more ink more paper more for us people who are looking for research who are trying to read things in appropriate and reasonable time and
063trying to figure out what does this policy add to the quality of the school system of course the superintendent must prepare report and they must be accurate informative and share them must comply with the law I don't get it why you have to State the obvious so we will move to policy 3125 please restart the clock thank you policy 3125 is a bit of a trouble for me all right so I imagine myself as a principal and here all of a sudden as a principal I'm responsible for an activity that is generating funds that I'm responsible for managing the account and then this policy states that the activity of that school must contribute to the moral values of the students that's one and it also States and it must not conflict with instructional time so
064basically if you remove all the the wording of it those are the two points so here is my question to you please answer me which moral values we are talking about which religion moral values we are talking about so as you know I have been baltimorean for 50 years and when I first came the school system had much more moral values teaching over the past 10 15 years it's less and less and less and I guess it's Nationwide so I like moral values but it worries me you know are you going to impose one moral value over others I think that needs to be clarified and you know moral values are um you know there are Indian moral values there are Muslim moral values Jewish Christian there is Carl Max moral values um there are
065all kinds of moral values if you search it on brittanica.com or on on Google um I I don't get it and last point about this is as a principal the biggest responsibility of principle is to be a leader and you know safety and the quality of Education why do we have to give principles the charge of taking care of accounts that for maybe a football or basketball or something like that you know they have enough responsibilities you know you need to do education you don't need to do things U that is not really education it takes you away from making this school system great again and I I uh thank you I just want to make one clarification and miss py you correct me if I'm wrong and and understanding the policy uh the policy
066speaks to the educational experience or morale of students so I just wanted to clarify that we're not imposing morality uh on the students as a condition of using School activity funds it should contribute to a positive morale for the student body so I just wanted to make that clarification is that correct Miss Pumphrey that is correct thank you thank you Dr much I really wish the phraseology you would change to make it clear cuz when I read it it meant something different understand thank you so much our next speaker for uh policy 3125 school activity funds is Nichelle Hicks minute I just need to give a little preface um so this is my first time signing up and when I did the form I did not do it correctly however the uh the issues that
067are being presented regarding um kind of align with this policy but more so with Transportation so I do apologize please proceed okay go ahead good evening my name is Raymond Jones Jr and I'm a student at Parkville high school and the Secretary of our NAACP chapter I'm here today to address imp I'm here today to address the implications of the proposed budget and policies regarding a current concern of students related to policy 3125 and others the lack of communication between students families and transportation services needs to be addressed last week we conducted a survey at our school to understand how bus delays affect students commutes out of the responses 50% were from magnet students like me who depend on bus transportation to get to school alarmingly 89% of all participants reported experiencing bus lades without
068prior notice of these 19% their said their buses are typically 5 to 10 minutes late 15% reported 10 to 15 minutes and 39% said they've waited over 20 minutes multiple times a week we also asked if bus delays caus students to miss school 43% of participants said yes this is this is a concerning statistic as it highlights how Transportation issues are affecting daily attendance additionally we explored communication with bus with transportation services while while 42% of students have contacted the BCPS bus transportation help line 45% reported waiting over 15 minutes for assistance alarmingly 57% didn't even know the helpl line existed what's even more worrying is how budget cuts May worse in these issues reduced funding for transportation could lead to fewer buses longer routes and increased delays making reliable communication even more critical at
069the same time we understand that funding is allocated to many essential areas such as improving classroom resources supporting teachers and enhancing school programs these Investments are vital for Student Success and we appreciate the efforts to prioritize these needs however transportation is just as crucial without proviable transportation students struggle to access these opportunities which undermine the effectiveness of these Investments to address this students suggested suggested adding a chat feature to the busar app to provide real real time updates on bus statuses they also express interest in having direct access to the app which is currently restricted to only parents thank you for your time and attention to this important issue I hope we can work together to ensure Transportation remains a priority allowing all students to benefit from the resources and opportunities available to them should
070you have any questions comments or concerns please feel free to reach out to me or my fellow youth leaders of Parkville high school and of NAACP chapter thank you thank you the next item on the agenda is action taken and closed session and for that I call on Mr Burns the board took no action requiring confirmation thank you the next I the next item on the agenda is new business report on board policies this is the first reader for these policies and for that I call on Miss Pumphrey thank you members of the board the policy re Review Committee asks that the board accept this report of the committee's recommendation of proposed changes to the following board policies board policy 3113 transfers and supplements board policy 3121 funds management and classification of expenditures board policy
0713123 financial reporting and board policy 3125 School activity funds these policies are presented to you on tonight's agenda as exhibits H1 through H4 thank you committee chair Pumphrey board members are there any separation requests hearing none may I have a motion to accept the recommendation of the board's policy Review Committee for board policies 3113 3123 and 3125 so movees toleski thank you Miss teski no second is needed since the recommendation comes from the committee is there any discussion hearing none may I have a roll call vote Please Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen yes Miss frong yes Miss Boer DWI yes Miss CH Kulu yes Miss tuski yes Dr seavoy yes Mr McMillian yes Miss Pumphrey yes Miss Harvey yes thank you motion carries thank you the next item on the agenda is
072the work session on the proposed FY 2026 operating budget request and for that I call on Dr Rogers good evening and thank you Vice chair harvy members of the board I am pleased to uh provide a brief update um and walk uh you and the public through some items related to our fiscal year 2026 proposed budget uh before I do that I do want to acknowledge the student that just spoke with us um as it is always uh a very very positive thing for us to see our student Advocates uh coming forward to the board and just uh reassure the young man that we indeed have an increase in transportation in our proposed budget not a decrease of Transportation so with that if we can uh post a slide presentation thank you first thing we
073want to do is make sure that we ground ourselves and our community in the fiscal year 2026 operating budget making sure that we review which components um are included and which components uh we spend the majority of our efforts on as part of the operating budget um there are several funds listed on this slide that are part of the total operating budget but we really focus for the operating budget season on those uh uh funds that include our day-to-day expenses all of the salaries and benefits for our staff our operations as well as the upkeep of our uh facilities you will note the uh figures for the fiscal year 25 adjusted budget um compared to the fiscal year 26 proposed budget and the difference the difference is $126 million over um the adjusted budget um
074which is a 65% change from the general fund um we will also note and review again that as a result of the savings that we made we were able to reduce our request to the um County Special Revenue fund includes uh grant funding uh there is a uh change there and then on the bottom of the slide you note the other funds that are a uh part of this the internal service fund which the Board of Education reports on in fin cial statements the capital projects fund which we have a local and a state capital budget and a very detail process um that we follow from the uh spring throughout the year to bring those uh recommendations forward uh you will note and we will uh look at in the other slide that there is
075a significant increase in the capital projects fund um The Debt Service fund um as well as the rise fund uh which includes both uh workers compensation as well as uh food and nutrition services uh making up the overall operating budget for the school system this next slide speaks to uh briefly our capital budget um as I've mentioned uh the board of education has a robust uh process to um make recommendations regarding capital projects uh what's important for everyone to know is on every even year you'll see a large increase in terms of our request uh the even years are typically the years where there are uh referendums that are posted and the even years also include uh fiveyear projection of our uh projects uh to come um on this slide in uh particular we have
076uh some changes upcoming in our school system it is unprecedented uh in Baltimore County Public Schools history since the Inception of buildings where we have um built three high schools uh in quick secession and so uh listed just to bring to everyone's uh uh attention are the projected cost of uh the high school Delaney high school talson high school and lown high school um in particular we also have two elementary schools uh that are on Deck as our uh upcoming sets of projects it was important uh to bring this slide forward to the community not only to remind everyone of the work um that has uh taken place regarding the capital budget but also as there was uh some questions about whether or not the Board of Education and the school system uh was going
077to be moving forward with such a robust capital projects fund uh given the uh the fiscal situation that we find ourselves in uh with the state as well as uh Federal funding and so I wanted to make sure that our community uh was reminded of the steps uh that we have taken the 15-year my iass report which details uh all of the facility improvements that we need as a system as a school system we have the third oldest set of buildings and so it is part of our responsibility to relieve overcrowding but also to ensure that our students um receive the best facilities possible that we continue to move forward with this budget and just raise it to uh all board members attention and the community that I know uh has advocated for years for
078these facilities that this was uh indeed a topic of conversation that was raised most recently this next slide speaks specifically to the process that we have undergone as a school Community to ensure that this operating budget really reflects the needs and the uh feedback and input of our stakeholders uh we have spent the vast majority of the Year engaging with offices schools leaders and stakeholders about priorities about the current state of our schools and what the growing needs are uh we started uh talking about it early in the fall uh the blueprint funding challenges that we were hearing whispers about we came and brought forward to the board of education and in all of our community meetings to uh the challenges that were being uh projected with the state budget as well as the growing
079needs of our students and listed on the slide are the variety of opportunities that our uh community members had to participate actively in this budget and so I understand that everyone is not able their schedule does not allow them to uh watch all of our meetings or attend all of our meetings it's important to know on our website budget 101 is updated it has information dating back to fiscal year um 17 if I remember or 18 and um you can also find uh many videos and quick multimedia presentations where you have a variety of stakeholders speaking to their experiences what they feel the uh needs are of the school system and speaking to the work that they're doing on behalf of BCPS students since we knew it was going to be a challenging uh fiscal
080year we had the hints at the state level there are some specific practices that we employed as a school system to make sure that we were being fiscally responsible I bring uh back to everyone's attention we engaged again in zerob based budgeting where every division uh when they made a proposal and a request that request had to be uh had to include a rationale as well as the numbers that supported the request budgeting to actual expenditures um and Rising costs that we had uh documentation of we employed a central office hiring freeze for the majority of the school year with a small exception uh process that was limited to critical positions uh we did employ a director of uh grants and special projects as well as supercharging the efforts of the Education Foundation um to
081maximize opportunities for grant funding and philanthropy efforts reduced redundancies really taking a close look at um a closer look at all of our divisions and departments to identify those opportunities uh that we had uh to make reductions that were not going to negatively impact our students and increased our efficiencies in terms of our processes and our products as a result of these efforts um last year we were able to save 104 uh million do this year uh because we did all of that work uh last year and uh our school system is rather lean uh there was uh intentionality around and that resulted in an additional $26 Million worth of uh reductions so um about the same week where I delivered the uh proposed budget to the Board of Education uh the state proposed budget
082uh was shared um the following week last week our uh Team received an updated fiscal note uh that allowed the budget team to calculate the potential impact on Baltimore County public schools in particular um this slide depicts uh the specific areas that would impact uh Baltimore County Public Schools specifically in the uh revised proposed state aid formula um as well as other state revenue primarily non-public placement for our students receiving special education services we see reductions in both of those areas for a total of um almost 10.5 million and then uh there is a requirement an additional uh percentage uh for uh contributions to the state retirement and pension and that's an additional $9.4 million for a total impact additional uh unanticipated of approximately $20 million and so we have spent some time in the
083uh review of the budget and the presentation of the budget going through the different external data points and the progress that Baltimore County Public Schools uh has made over this last year and a half I think it is very important for us to be able to answer the question why our 111,000 students are worth the investment in their future what is the return on investment for our taxpayers um for our 800,000 plus taxpayers who reside in Baltimore County Public Schools we can see for the first time it has been um confirmed by our division our department of research assessment and accountability at least since 2012 um all of our data is moving in the right direction at the same time um you see here we've noted chronic absenteeism measures of academic progress in reading and
084math Elementary literacy uh mcap State assessment performance in mathematics and literacy our Maryland star ratings and teacher retention um uh we have heard it said that um while there are gains in Baltimore County public schools there are small gains um and I would implore our community to um implement the same standard uh that we have when we think about winning other areas that are perhaps not as critical as educating our future and identifying that a win is a win that it is time for us to publicly applaud uh not only our students but our staff members that are working tirelessly on behalf of our students to make these gains uh for the first time in um going on 13 years as confirmed and the team is still doing research we are able to show that
085we are not moving backwards or we don't have conflicting data uh points in terms of our school and that is worthy of our applaud but more importantly our students are worthy of the continued investment in the steps that we have taken the investment that the county has made this board of education has made in their future that is turning their trajectory around um another uh significant portion of our budget is the people um we know that our leaders and our teachers have a tremendous impact on our uh student outcomes teacher retention is an area that all of our stakeholders across the board family members uh uh students um uh Community Partners our lawmakers our actual teachers our staff has said Recruitment and Retention is the most important thing and so it is important that we
086share the data on where we are with teure Recruitment and Retention last year I presented to the board that many staff members that were eligible for retirement chose not to move forward with retirement and that institution institutional knowledge is critically important it uh in our schools and for our newer novice teachers uh we were able to identify the national Trend data that is out from the United States Department of Education National Center for educational statistics and our uh data shared from the Maryland State Board of Education on teacher retention and compare that to our teacher retention year to date and you will see that we are outpacing not only the national retention numbers in a time of national teacher shortage but we are also outpacing the state of Maryland we want to move to staff
087allocations and uh last week I had the opportunity with uh a large team including Human Resources Partners including uh curriculum and instruction Partners um also our division of school Partners to meet with our principles um all throughout the day to uh move forward with the assignment of Staffing allocations so they could begin building their master schedule for the upcoming year year um in that all allocation meeting we debuted a new tool um I do want to thank um uh three areas that came together who built this over several months the uh Department of research assessment accountability um division of Information Technology as well as human resources uh that worked over the last several years so that we could remove um any issues that we had in our system with making sure that we were properly
088allocating resources to our school uh we have a new tool um it is fueled by powerbi where there is an algorithm that is programmed um we have formulas for how we allocate staff and we provided uh direct information to all of our principles as well as um sample and technical assistance so everyone could see what numbers were used um to allocate Staffing the numbers that we had last year compared to the numbers projected for this upcoming year and where there was variability um you'll note in addition to enrollment the category of Administrators as well as teacher and support professionals and non-teaching support staff uh was all provided to our leaders so that they had the best information um so that they could make the decisions that needed to be made as as well as explain
089clearly to their school communities if there were changes what the changes were based on um that there was open Clarity uh when we shared the or when I shared the uh proposed budget uh I talked about uh protecting and preserving our staffing allocation formulas and I want to spend a little more time making sure that we have a clear understanding of what Staffing allocation formulas are um in the blue chart you will see how we allocate so in other words the formula that drives the numbers that uh shows up on the allocation um chart that every School receives is based on the chart that you see so for every 22 kindergarten students that are projected to be enrolled in your school you're going to receive one teacher um it's important to remind everyone enrollment is
090the Baseline Staffing allocation that's where we start every one no matter what school has allocation based on enrollment then we layer on top of that for special programs and then we layer on top of that for student needs student needs meaning our multilingual Learners our students receiving special education services and our students living uh experiencing poverty and so many times we have received feedback um that the Staffing allocations cannot be correct the information cannot be true because some of the lived experiences of teachers inside of a classroom is something different last year we tried to um explain uh this in one way and this year we're taking um another approach because it is critically important and I shared directly with principles especially as we Face uh the state potential cuts and uncertainty at the federal
091level it is important that every Community understands the difference between an allocation in class sizes and so the formula that I just showed you is the algorithm no matter who you are what side of the county how large your school is how small your school is based on your enrollment and the grade level of the student you're going to receive a certain number of teachers so for this simple example let's pretend uh this dream school only has 105 students because they have 105 students the computer allocates five teachers to that school now what the class size looks like is 100% dependent on the decisions that are made in the schoolhouse the decisions that the leadership team makes with the uh analysis of student data student needs and communication with the community will determine the class
092sizes so in one school we provide five five um teachers and they divide all 105 students into five equal sections the class sizes what the teachers are posting on Facebook what they are experiencing what when you go into a building you see when you walk into a classroom in that instance is five equal classes of 21 students each you can have another school that chooses to pull nine students out of the 105 out for a special class section whether that is additional reinforcement based on additional needs or it is a class um that is there for acceleration of students in that school you will have one teacher who experiences nine students in their class and the other four teachers with 24 students in their class the allocation has not changed and in the last example
093if you have a school that pulls 14 students out and they want to provide more than one section so that students can fit in the class maybe one in the morning one in the afternoon they're not all locked into one section and then they divide the remaining 91 students into the three equal sections you're going to have two classroom teachers who experience seven students in each class and then 91 doesn't um divide uh by three equally two teachers with 30 students and one teacher with 31 students and so this is uh not only our work but the shared responsibility of the principles to ensure that all communities have a clear understanding of Staffing allocation but how Master schedules are developed and how um courses and sections are prioritized and what the impact is on class
094size the other question uh that we have heard is around uh this uh increase this increased request to our County government what makes for such a large request uh if everything stayed the same um just for inflation we would have to account for an increase unfortunately for us everything is not staying the same or fortunately depending on how you look at it um we see that our students are improving we see that um and we saw it this evening that people are choosing to come to Baltimore County public schools throughout the school year and definitely in the summer we see that teachers and staff members are choosing to stay in Baltimore County public schools and we certainly know that because we were dealing with a uh decade plus of academic decline that there's still a
095lot more work for us to do um a large portion of our request is our Union agreements we have a three-year compensation package for 20,000 employees funding year two of those agreements um is about $56 million because we had Esser carryover for quarter one we were able to fund additional funds uh for the extended school day and the $4 add-on carryover for substitutes and temporary employees that carryover has to be covered that is almost $6 million uh we have heard many Advocates um not only speak this evening but throughout the year about um the needs of our students receiving special education services last year this board um partnering with the county executive and the County Council made significant investments in special education um and to continue that work as well as ensuring that we are
096budgeting to our actuals because there is not that flex and that additional uh tens of millions of dollars available um during the school year we have to budget for the needs of our students 23 million for special education our employee benefits total a little more than $14 million and as I I have shared um on numerous occasions and had the occasion to meet uh uh with uh the uh Baltimore Gas and Electric uh this week our Rising costs uh total almost $10 million and so this is more than $100 million um even though we're requesting $100 million but when you add up uh these numbers as well as the numbers uh additional numbers in the uh budget and you subtract from that the savings that we're bringing to the table that is how we get
097to the 100 millon ion dollar request that we're making to our County funding partners and so with that I turn it over to you Vice chair Harvey so we can open it up for questions thank you Dr Rogers do any members have questions Miss frong um good evening Dr Rogers so thank you for the additional information um in addition to the budget that you provided us so I think um I guess I'm asking a question for clarification just for myself as well as for um information purposes um I think at times that when people look at the budget one of the things they want to focus on is um Central Administration and saying that there is a lot of money there can you speak to how the money that's spent at Central and their duties
098do impact what happens in the Schoolhouse and how it helps with our academic achievement absolutely thank you um that was some uh feedback and some input that we had received from our stakeholders in the past uh that Baltimore County public schools had a very large Central offices and so as a part of the work that we did um last year with those hundred million Ser uh savings uh we were able to engage in a reorganization that really put resources uh closer to schools in um almost every area you're going to find those significant efficiencies uh specifically for our Specialists and other positions we have a requirement for the percentage of time that's spent directly in schools um our Central offices if you're looking at the instructional part of central offices uh they are in schools
099they are providing that training they are um engaging in Fidelity of implementation walkthroughs they're sitting in on um leadership team meetings they're sitting in on planning meetings uh with staff members and then if you take it to our operations uh team members in central office um that is how we effectively and efficiently keep operating the third oldest set of uh buildings because we have people working around the clock to troubleshoot and respond immediately medely to issues as they uh come up so to the extent possible we're able to ensure that all of our students are in school um it is not possible to run a school system with 111,000 plus students um in 176 facilities without having the central office infrastructure um to uh Monitor and engage on a day-to-day basis to uh take take
100care of the needs so that our school staff can focus directly on the school Community um starting with their students and of course adding um the staff members that are in the building uh but we are a lean Central offices um last year the uh organizational chart that was unanimously approved by the board realigned our uh divisions and offices uh to uh make sure that they were uh moving directly with our school system priorities and um that is where we are as a school system we have been able to show uh what work our central office is doing there is accountability uh for all members across our team and we also engage in a uh regular meetings where we're reviewing our student data progress and identifying um action steps uh for support of our schools
101directly Miss Pumphrey thank you I'm referring back to your um discussion about excuse me Staffing allocations and class sizes um and I want to mention that um my question is more for the public because I believe I already know the answer um so my question is a couple a couple questions here um for class sizes are some of the classes such as AP courses limited by how small the class can be in order to to um make this adjustment work in other words are they limited to having a not having a class of eight for example so this upcoming year one of the things one of the best practices that we're going to have to implement with other school systems is having a minimum number now there are exceptions to that certainly a regional um
102special education program um different levels of our ELD courses for multilingual Learners our um seniors who are in program completers necessary for high school graduation we would never Implement um a practice that would put their graduation status uh in danger and so there are uh exceptions like that or there are some lure requirements so for example for a nursing program the state says that an RN can only supervise a maximum of eight students and so if you only have one nurse that dictates the size of the class but in other in es um the request um the the expectation for all of our schools is that we're not running classes that are smaller than 15 and there are multiple best practices and ways that we can ensure particularly for our high school students that they
103still have multiple opportunities throughout their careers to sign up for those classes and I assume that it's probably more difficult for schools with magnet programs to sort of make that adjustment because they probably need some classes that are smaller based on um the magga program itself is that correct not necessarily um what we found when we've examined uh the specific sections and the courses are in some instances we've offered five and six sections of the same course the same level very small numbers and so um those teachers most you know our teachers are certified in a content and um you know not a specific magnet program and so if you have a uh teacher that is teaching an illiteracy magnet and they're certified in English language art um instead of offering six sections of six
104for 36 students over two days a day and b day you could offer two reasonable sections of 18 and that teacher is now available um to teach four other sections of literacy which is their area of certification okay one last question um for um administrators that may have some difficulty in their allocations and you know seem to have ridiculous class sizes um is assistance provided to them to help them work this out to make it more reasonable absolutely uh first we have um a uh specialist Miss ganelli who she is our master schedule um Guru and our specialist and she is available to help all schools create their master schedule um not only the technical piece but she goes through the thinking with them and what options have that exist um there is uh certainly
105a process where schools can request extra Staffing but um I was very forthright in meeting with all of our principles directly last week in that we will not be allocating any additional Staffing before the month of May um for obvious reasons and so uh we want them to uh partner with colleagues we want them to call on the division of schools uh div division of curriculum instruction for us to problem solve together um Master scheduling is is something I actually like to do and so I I have uh stepped in um where we help our partners to work through it because sometimes it's just something that you've never done at the school level because for a long time um you know finances weren't an issue for us as a school system so this is not
106only a shift in terms of a technical shift but it also is an Adaptive challenge of of how you wrap your mind around this and how it can be done and we have all of those supports uh available for them thank you you're welcome is there any further discussion or questions uh Miss tier I'm Sorry Miss Booker dwire thank you Vice chair Harvey and so when I look at page 85 of our budget book um which is the board of education budget and when I look at our fy4 budget and when I look at FY 24 to fy2 um when the rest of the school system took a a hit a decrease in the budget we actually got an increase in our budget and so then when I look at fy2 to FY 26 we
107do get a decrease in our budget and I'm just wondering as a board is there anything else we could sacrifice so that it could go toward the school system is there any other cuts that we could take to our board of education budget um I know that it is what we're at 1.7 million it would just be pennies but um considering that FY 24 to fy2 we actually got an increase um is there anything else that could be cut from our budget um to show good faith with the the school system uh I don't call on people right share Mr McMillian has a question well she asked the question what we could cut uh one minute Mr M I want to make sure that I'm acknowledging people in in order uh Miss deleski requested to
108comment prior to thank you um I just have two questions um just on behalf of the of the public so thank you for the update this is all very helpful information I really love the um the point you made with central office that a percentage of their time is spent directly in the classroom for those that are curious what is that percentage I believe I know it's more than 60% I think it's 70 80% for specialist 60% for coordinators 80% for Specialists and 60% for coordinators okay I couldn't hear her say that one more time Dr 50 to 70% for the division of school 50 to 70% for the division of schools and that's very impressive and then just um the other question on behalf of the public for those that have asked in terms
109of central office can you speak to um the salary changes or increases for central office staff for the FY 26 sure so the salary increases are not unique to um central office staff um I would just call everyone's attention into the additional I think it's $56 million uh worth of increased compensation that touches all 20,000 employees it is um the year two compensation increases that were agreed to as a part of the three-year um negotiated agreement for every single Union thank you you're welcome thank you Mr McMillian yes I was just going to answer you know Miss Booker made a comment about what we could cut as a budget or on the board of education budget I think we could start looking at you know the travel to the conventions the national conventions and the
110flights and hotels and all all that kind of stuff I don't think personally well you can smack me if you want to but personally I don't think that we need to to spend that kind of money going across the country and doing that kind of stuff that's my opinion and I think I have a right to my opinion thank you can I respond thank you Mr MC ion um and and we have taken that into account and there are significant reductions particularly uh in this time of fiscal crisis across the system we looked at things where um we have requirements uh for example certain programs there are required trainings annually and so we you know we kept those minimal things in there but we made significant uh reductions in that area that was one of
111the uh areas so thank you for raising that Mr Young thank you Miss Harvey Dr Rogers you may have answered my question with what you gave Miss frong but in the presentation you gave us um last board meeting you mentioned as part of the cost savings um I'll say approximately 120 FTE Cuts so when you said earlier you know a win is a win are we cutting positions that are um necessary that have helped us to improve the system and and supporting um the schools I appreciate that question absolutely not um that's why it's taken us so long to engage in this thoughtful intentional process uh where we have month after month um identified um areas for consideration the budget team has done uh Yan's job of providing us with three years worth of ual
112expenditures uh my normal process was to take that information directly to our principles they would first engage with each other then we would have a full group conversation and then bring it back to Central and we followed the same exact process with central office um working with people who were closest to the work uh to ensure that all of the steps that we taking in the right direction that we don't um that we're not so overzealous uh that we uh have some unintended consequences which is one of the reasons why um you know the difference in savings is moving from 100 uh plus million doll to $26 million thank you thank you Miss dominowski so just to since you brought the capital funds if you go back to 23 we requested 200 million then 250
113and then last year we asked for 160 um I know we have several high schools that need are in the process of renovation build but what made you confident to ask for the 550 million now as opposed to the previous years when we asked for a lot less so I would call your attention to um the actual capital budget process so it it wasn't me confident asking I think uh the board has prioritized the order of capital projects and identified uh What uh you guys as a board would like the school system to advocate for at the state and county level um I will also note that one of the things that happens every even year is usually the five-year projects and the referendum um that come with that um this year there was a
114referendum that our voters in Baltimore County voted for uh which I believe was over $300 million um for school facilities every even year if you take a look FY 2020 uh fy22 the proposed ask was over $400 million and we didn't have any high schools um that we were building that was about 591 per increase uh from the year before in FY 24 the ask was over $300 million that was over 114% increase um FY 26 the request is over $500 million for um over a 240% CH uh change and uh the driving Factor are the three high schools um that uh we are building um and we have two elementary schools and um we have used built to learn funds that supplemented some of those asss after that legislation was passed in 2021 uh
115that do not exist at this point and so I would um submit that the priorities that have been set forth unanimously by this board of education in terms of the needs in the communities um particularly having three high schools at uh the uh brand new uh bills um have driven the cost up and the IAC um has also shared with us since um 2012 costs of school building have more than doubled and so this is the cost that we know now for these major projects uh by the time we start building and look at materials Etc um it it's not unlikely that there are going to be increased costs in incurred and so um I would share that there has been staunch um advocacy from uh communities um from members of this uh Board of
116Education and um uh it's it's what is required to meet the needs of the students and this is not um misaligned with the capital budget process that happens every even year in Baltimore County Public Schools just a quick follow up on that you said in 22 you the ask was over 400 million but the um approved was 83 million so that's kind of alarming if we're asking for 540 now well I wouldn't be able to speak to that I I can share what the asss were and the asss are always comprised of the five years worth of projects um that the school system has projected and then the state and local um government will make a determination based on the funding that they have available to allocate to us um for you know for building
117new facilities okay thank you for that uh can we moving on to Title One funds um last year the budget was around $9 million and this year in 25 it's gone down to 57 can we explain to the public why that's gone down and how we are still able to meet the needs of our students in this area yes tital One funds are federally um um uh you know Federal special Revenue uh Grant funds um we received that allocation um uh directly um the state of Maryland overall because we did engage in some uh robust conversations with msde um when we learned of our allegation allocation they shared with us that they received their allocation from the federal level and there was a reduction in the state overall and so there was a trickle down
118effect um because Title One is uh formula based um you know the the team was able to look at the student data and um uh share you know here are the resources that we had we uh did um we shared this last year as a part of our process in Equitable resource allocation we did um create uh procedures where all of the allocation all of those um teachers were assigned directly to our students to meet the needs of our students in our um school buildings and uh reduce some of the uh funding that in the past we had used you know for other um items and uh things of that nature that we really invested heavily in the people that were reducing uh class sizes and things of that nature um that that is one
119area that we are watching closely to find out what is ultimately allocated to the school system for the upcoming year um not all it in previous years I want to say was was 24 we did add 15 million from the general budget is that something we're going to have to think about if we don't get the funding that we need if we were not facing what I just shared with you for the proposed state um uh budget as well as uncertainty around the federal funds I think we would have been better positioned to suggest that I think um you know a our uh our position right now has to be um taking a close look at what is potentially happening and uh really spending a lot of time uh focus and energy advocating at the
120state level so some of these Cuts don't come forward um you know I I have shared that last week I was in Annapolis advocating on behalf of team BCPS tomorrow I will be testifying in front of the uh education subcommittee and meeting with other um uh committee leads I'll be back on Thursday and for the next several weeks as well as members of team BCPS our teachers our administrators our education support professionals um to Advocate um so that we don't have this reduction in funding I think we would be in a better position if we know that uh the amount of funding that we're going to receive from our County uh Partners as well as um that we're not going to receive additional cuts from our state budget to um you know look at supplementing
121in that way right now uh given the Bleak Financial Outlook it doesn't look like that that would be something that we could um reasonably do um $15 million you know we share the uh uh for one teacher is about $105,000 um dollars and so for $15 million um that is a commensurate number of uh teachers and and we have heard loud and clear um that you know we want to prioritize our teachers and keep them in those classrooms working hard on behalf of our students so certainly I will have my fingers crossed if we have funds are absolutely uh willing to you know take a look at that but right now it doesn't seem that that's the case for us or any other school system in the uh state of Maryland thank you Miss dominas
122I'm G to ask you to hold your question to allow other board members to ask questions right I are we at three minutes no because it stops when the person stop right where are we 130 1:30 proceed Miss ask uh with the career in college readiness is taking a 50% cut this year how will this affect programs like Avid ecap Early College access programs and advanced placement so um can you point me to which career and college readiness I know which page you're referring to it's in your budget cut it by 50% this year so I would uh request which page we're speaking of so I can respond to whether or not um these are blueprint uh F I haven't written down the funds are it's 1.27 million is it for this year and 2025
123it's 2.63 million General it's general fund seems like the team is looking for that page uh so we can move forward while they look because it can be blue Miss Dominos do you have an additional question while her team is looking for the documentation of your yeah but you're probably going have to keep looking for documentation if you don't know because the rest of my questions are pretty like that as well well I don't think we should presume that I think you should ask your question and we'll find out okay so the executive director of literacy and Humanities Department 95 did this replace the teaching and learning Department 95 of the previous years in 25 and 24 23 so if you'll recall last year we brought forward a um new organization chart to the Board
124of Education where we realigned in curriculum and instruction our executive directors to be aligned with the academic priorities and so that there that was indeed a change that was uh approved unanimously understand but the uh the former 95 the teaching and learning had a budget of over $100 million and now the literacy in humanities has a $500,000 what is the what caused a drastic change in budgets so last year uh when we went through the budget process we were able to reduce um significantly funding that we spent in contractual Services we were able to maximize um grants uh we were also able to reduce positions we had the uh reduction in um some of the uh resource features that were converted to our uh specialist in um curriculum and instruction and those Specialists provide direct
125supports to our schools uh we could I mean we we would have to look into that but that was a part of uh last year's uh budgets and you will note that there have been no uh negative impacts on literacy in instead we've seen quite the opposite in terms of our literacy outcomes for our students and the literacy literacy team um has uh implemented last year all of their Fidelity visits to the schools with the uh vendors and have provided um I think at least three reports to the Board of Education about their work okay thank you for that um also it's page 144 for the College and Career Readiness it's 1.2 million from the general fund and last year we were receiving uh 2.6 so how will that affect advanced placement Avid and early
126college early acceptance EAP ecap well I can tell you there there are going to be no cuts to those uh programs so so I can share that with you uh the book that I have has a different um page I don't know if uh Mr sarus you have found that yeah it's very difficult for us to deter yeah where $2 million uh well you have to go back cuz you guys don't put the um that that way so I had to go back to the last year's book to find it so we'll follow up in um what we'll do is we'll follow up in writing and post that yeah there's no apparent variance of of $2 million on that page so we'll do that research miss dominowski you compared it to the last book operating
127budget from last year from because that's the only place you can find it okay thank you um uh the online learning what is the reason for the increase are we admitting more students to our online learing program it's uh gone up about 80% this bud bug um so remember last year we combined all of the separate online programs that we had um into one office uh for efficiency so I I think what you're speaking to and we can confirm is um you seeing all of the groups come together we used to have um remind me all the different letters of the different online programs e-learning and blp there were two different mechanisms so e-learning was um students could register through e-learning to do it was all for high school students was model I'm Sorry Miss
128Dado can you please step up so everyone can hear you thank you so previously there were two separate programs the virtual learning program which was our online program that started following covid which what initially was kindergarten through 12th grade and then e-learning was a high school um with a few Middle School courses programs that had been in existence for a very long time the two programs merged together so this is really the combining of those two programs so last year they were probably listed as two different budget items um VP and the online learning program because that happened after July 1 okay thank you um I probably Mr SOS needs to come back the CFO why the increase of 60% in budget did we have a change or adding in FTE it's going went from
129about 350,000 to 600,000 yes I think um on one of the pages in the budget because we wanted to note this uh there was a budget neutral reorganization from uh inhuman Resources with uh the division of finances and I think it was for risk management where staff members moved over along and uh the budget team is all shaking their heads and the chief HR where the budget the people and the salaries moved over under the CFO yes okay risk management move Madam chair can I have a point of order to ask that dominowski your time has Mr Burns has noted that your time is up Miss hen do you have a question do you have still you have a point of order I do just so that the rest of the board members can follow
130along if there are questions specifically about the budget if the person speaking can reference the page number so that the rest of the board can follow along as well thank you thank you Miss Hinn please proceed thank you Madame Vice chair um my question has to do with the general fund balance and I'm on page 33 of the proposed budget um the forecasted fy2 beginning general fund balance is 128. 6 million um my first question is is the what is the forecast amount of the um ending fund balance for fy2 along with what is expected to be available um for expenditures for FY 226 and if Dr Rogers if you could speak to that there is a fiscal note indicating that BCPS increased its use of fund balance beginning in 2023 due to requirements from
131blueprint um so if there's anything you could um elaborate on in terms of our use of the general fund balance versus what is available for expenditures versus what is reappropriated thank you so thank you I I think I will have uh Mr tant Liff and Mr sarus come to speak to the numbers but you are absolutely correct the um starting in FY 23 um the uh fund balance uh was being used it was part of um uh you'll see here transferred to 25 million transferred to Baltimore County government to support some of the uh capital projects and um as I proposed in the budget some of the actual expenditures were annually um not only in Baltimore County but across the state to the tune of more than a billion dollars where uh the special education
132cost um exceed the budgeted amounts um that is and uh Mr sarus went to actually check and I believe he told me he could see for at least um 10 years where that has been the case that is uh the case for us this and you and you would know that as well that is going to be um part of our expenditures uh this year as well as um other items to uh maintain operations but uh these uh team members can share details on the uh fund balance thank you and that was the second part of my question um in that same chart on 33 the expenditures exceed revenues by um what's 1.9 million in revenues to close to two billion in expenditures so good evening gentlemen if you could comment on those two numbers
133as well I'd appreciate it thank you uh sure so one thing is the use of fund balance you can't uh see in there because Revenue uh versus expense it's not uh new Revenue it just uh reduces our expenditures uh so right now we're still working on this year's projections uh if we need to do a supplemental as we if you recall we did need to do last year um we're expecting our year-end fund balance will probably be in the general ballpark of what you see there but you know it's a pretty Dynamic situation so um you know later in the year as we get towards the bat and the supplement we'd have a more exact figure for our uh yearend projection but because so much got squeezed out of the budget as we've been discussing
134our um end ofe variance uh has pretty much gone away right now so as Dr um you know during the presentation when we uh looked at the amount that we cut last year the amount we have cut in the 26 budget um there's just not a lot of money dropping to positive variants which we we saw a lot of especially postco when people were at home a lot of purchase orders didn't get used and we were generating a lot of positive errand we just don't have that flexibility uh like we have had in the past so things are very compressed and tight and that's why uh Dr Rogers talked about budgeting to our expenditures because we just don't have the flex that we've had in the past so we are not looking at having a
135positive starting fund balance for FY 26 no we'll we'll have a we'll have a positive starting fund balance for sure do we have an idea of that number or ballpark I I'm it's cited here I don't if you look at the bottom of page 30 and I don't know if we've talked about that where we have prior year fund balance that is not the actual fund balance that is the portion of which we have rolled over to NE we plan to use for next year so I think that that fig figure of 18 million and the smaller figure in the chart you cited of 40 million illustrates the fact that that the balance itself is increasing as well as our ability to use it and we coordinate with Baltimore County government on this very closely
136because that fund balance is the taxpayer's money so we don't want it to be too big because that's money that's sitting on the sidelines that's not going going to direct education expenses so it is uh it's important to maximize that when it's available but we don't want to uh allow it to accumulate we want to put it back into the budget and that and that's what we're doing here and I think uh as Mr tantleff indicates we we're only really halfway through the instructional year we've got expenditures in our accounting system through through December so we'll have a better idea what that number is going to be as we get towards uh the county government's final adoption and believe me they will be uh assuring them themselves that that we maximize the use of that
137fund balance it just will not be as big as it has been and that can be a good thing or a bad thing depending on how you look at it and is it preferential to use that does it affect the calc calculation ofe does it really not matter because it's all the same appr appropriation pot in terms of County only uh money appropriated from the county counts towards maintenance of effort so fund balance is not in that calculation because it's already been appropriated we're not counting you could think of it that way but it's just new County revenue that goes into maintenance of uh effort calculations in other words what they would give above Moe is number that we're focused on that Dr Rogers was talking about with a100 million that we'd be asking in
138additional Revenue whatever portion of the fund balance we've budgeted has has reduced the amount we're asking from Baltimore County government and there's a footnote and this is my last question on this thread um Madam Vice chair and that is that other sources um excludes reappropriated fund balance of for fy2 49.6 million so potentially that could increase our general fund balance that's available for FY 26 should the county approve that that's just that's just trying to explain the mechanics of the chart because you asked about the the fund balance piece it doesn't go um it isn't new Revenue but it that expense still happened so it it's just it's really just trying to tell how much was budgeted for fund balance in those years correct so that was returned more or less to the county so
139could it be it tends to be tuition interest earnings things like that isn't that correct the other sources um in this case though it's just try that footnote is just identifying how much was used out of uh fund balance and one thing also of note is you know our fund balance usage has been increasing as things have gotten Tighter and Tighter and our usage of fund balance you can see in the budget drops from almost 50 million to 18 million next year because we don't have all of that flexibility anymore and that's another factor that makes the budget tight this year one of numerous factors okay which still includes the phasing out of the uh covid related grants sure which had supported a lot of compensation and an additional instruction and the like right and
140a large portion of that that fund balance had been unspent salaries and wages so as we see improvement with um recruiting and retention and filling those vacancies I would expect to see a declining fund balance as well as well as use of the fund balance to meet our BL blueprint requirements is that well the less State money we get and the yeah will be pressured to use maximize the use of that and we'll be working with County government on this starting yesterday we have not seen her okay thank you thank you Miss hen are there other questions from board members Miss Cho hi thank you for your presentation Dr Rogers just had two quick questions so for the Career Technical education funding just in my personal experience we were kind of like encouraged to take
141the additional CTE certification exams even if you didn't feel as prepared as a result of that so I was wondering are there going to be stricter guidelines to ensure that we're maximizing success and student preparation and if so how is that going to be communicated on a schoolwide level to ensure it's actually being followed so um uh you bring up a great Point uh terms of the certifications that we were paying for and uh out of the mouth of the student whether you were prepared or not uh we were encouraging um students to take those and in incurring a cost for that and so um you know part of our work uh is with staff ensuring that uh so there is fun there are funds in the budget to continue to pay for certification first
142uh firstly but we want to uh maximize the percentage of students who are earning those certifications and what comes with that and so um that's part of the uh retraining that we're going to have and level setting expectations uh for our staff that we're not just taking um uh exams to take exams because they're being paid for and uh that's really uh all the exams that were provided we're still going to be paying for AP exams we're still going to be paying for uh college courses but we want to make sure that um you everyone is doing their due diligence us as the adults in terms of sharing the expectations and providing that training and um in many instances there are multiple opportunities to take these assessments and so um uh making sure that as
143staff members uh we perhaps are not saying just go ahead and take it in October and you're shaking your head so you you know uh just go ahead and take it in October and November and waiting for you to take it in the spring when we know that you have the re requisite knowledge to be successful thank you and then for my second question was about the um software licenses so for the programs that require it like the magnet programs where in like the graphics programs they need the Adobe Creative Suite and in healthcare they need the OA so are we like I think we already do this but do we have that differentiated model where we just identify students who require those specific software so we're not incurring additional expenses and then for students
144who have already left the program like for me again as example as a senior in the graphics program where it's not compulsory for me to have access to those Adobe programs am I also like terminated from that so we're minimizing that cost as well oh we certainly do not have licenses for every single student that goes to uh you know goes through our team BCPS schools I can also share um you know that our department of Information Technology they are uh they are working double time to increase efficiencies particularly knowing the infrastructure um Hardware needs that we have in this upcoming year uh they've looked at every expense not only for uh students but also staff uh perhaps licenses that and subscriptions that we've just renewed annually because we've always had them but also looking
145at the actual usage and um some subscriptions that we pay for that have other capabilities that we never Ed because long time ago we were using another um system and so I would say um absolutely maximizing efficiencies and the department of information technology has done their due diligence and examining everything thank you and then for my final question I remember sorry I remember um you previously talking about the classroom sets of just technology for lower level schools and so I was just wondering with that budget that's likely still continuing but for like the online learning program and for other additional Services we may need kind of whether the steps being taken to still support those families like this necessarily might not be a budget related question but just with the Elementary classroom sets kind of
146how are we still accommodating that absolutely part of the conversations that um I've had the opportunity to have with principles um and with our Union Partners is um uh around making sure that students who have needs they have they continue to have access to technology some schools have actually uh tried it out on their own where the devices don't go back and forth every day but they have a system whereby families can check out an advice for a year so um a student who doesn't have access to a device at home it's provided by the school as well as the hotspots that we continue to um have that um we're able to share those with families so students are not adversely impacted you're welcome thank you uh miss here Booker dwire okay this is just
147my last uh comment about the budget so I am deeply concerned um if the 20 million in cuts on top of what we're already cutting happens I'm also deeply concerned if there are additional Cuts federally um especially with the federal freeze I don't know how we can sustain the the progress we have seen in Baltimore County public schools with additional cuts um I don't know how we can right now we know that class sizes are all of our class sizes are not where we want them to be um and I just don't know how if the continued Cuts especially even with um central office positions how we just how we can sustain um the progress that we've made so I think you this budget I mean you have done a a phenomenal job I encourage
148you to look deeper at the board's side of the house I agree with Mr mcmillion you know cut us to the Bare Bones even if it means cutting all but essential positions um because we were not touched last year and we are in crisis right now and so whatever you have to do to dedicate funds and you know to the school building I encourage you to do that um and whatever we can do to Advocate with elected officials or whoever to so that we can um at least preserve that 20 million because I don't know where we're going to get it and this is where it's going to really start hitting um at the school level and that's what we it's already hitting at the school level but it's going to it's going to really
149hit hard we just we can't afford any more cuts to this budget we are already at the Bare Bones and we just we don't have anything else to cut um and so yeah that's all I have to to say about that yeah would you like sure Pro well thank you Miss Booker DWI for those uh comments we certainly Echo those sentiments which is why we're thank you uh which is why we're continuing to engage in advocacy at the state level I would would say to um all of our board members and our families who are watching um that we need their voices uh we need everyone to be Advocate uh advocating um to the state um that we need the funding that is uh available for the blueprint so we can continue to invest in
150uh members of team BCPS um I will share with you that no matter what happens we have um very POS relationships that we don't take for granted for with all of our Union partners and we're going to bring them to the table and have open and honest conversations um about you know what our uh next steps are but but really our work right now is um advocacy at the state level and I say at the state level because our County funding Partners um they have demonstrated time and time again uh their commitment to um uh high levels of funding for the school system and uh they remain uh committed to Baltimore County public schools and so um and and we'll have to wait and see you know uh the impact on a uh Federal level
151I think you raised the freeze uh notice that we received um today which right now um you know the state department is uh unpacking what that uh may or may not mean uh for schools and school systems uh across the state thank you Miss deleski thank you um I just want to propose and if I need to make a motion I will given the importance of this discussion the our moral imperative to serve students and um the importance of what we say here and the answers provided for stakeholders if any board member that has gone beyond their three minutes has additional questions I do believe it would be honorable to allow them to ask their questions and if I need to make a motion I certainly will no I disagree to call sff about College
152and Career One Moment does that require a motion I believe so okay so then I will make a motion that for any board member that has gone beyond their three minutes um this motion is to allow them to ask their additional questions so that the community and stakeholders can receive you know answers that they might wish thank you I'll second that there is a motion made by Mr deleski that board members be allowed to exceed their uh three minutes it has been seconded by Mr mcmillion is there a discussion Miss Miss hen thank you um I would offer an amendment to that motion if I may and if proper if I may please proceed um I move to amend the motion on the floor to schedule time at the meeting on febu February 11th for
153board members to bring prepare and bring questions um on the budget to hold a follow-up work session on the budget to be to be scheduled on February 11th order so that that is a separate motion Amendment it be made as a separate motion but it wouldn't amend that the last so do you offer an amendment to the motion or do you I'll withdraw my Amendment thank you is there we have a second motion yes Mr McMillian seconded the motion is there discussion Miss dominowski I just wanted to add since we no longer have a budget committee I think it would be helpful for us to have the additional time to discuss these issues because this is the only opportunity we have to discuss them Is there further discussion Miss fromong um I was just going
154to ask that that be done after the other board members have exhausted their time and again just uh requesting that board members refer to whatever page in the budget book that they're referring to when they ask their questions so board members staff and even the public can follow along thank [Music] you are you amending the amendment the motion amending I'm sorry are you amend you're amending the motion can you please repeat your [Music] Amendment my amendment is that if we give the additional time it be done after other board members have exhausted their three minutes um so that others have the opportunity to to ask their questions um and then also that any questions um from the budget please provide board uh page number so that board members the public and the staff can follow
155along with the questions is there a second second toleski is there a discussion first the first part the first part of it I thought was Germaine because it talked about the timing for the additional questions and you got to be careful amendments being too too many Clauses too complicated it moves away from Germaine so my advice with board is or or to miss frong would be maybe parse it to what's an appropriate Amendment to the folks having additional time which I think was your idea was I think I heard to Simply say that would happen after other board members had had their opportunity I would advise that's an appropriate Miss rang are you agreeable to this recommendation so yes do I need to restate please okay so my my amendment is just that um we
156allow the additional time after other board members have exhausted their um given time of three minutes is that suitable thank you is there a second second stoski Miss deleski thank you for your second is there a discussion Miss Pumphrey I actually have a question that may impact my vote on the amended motion and the motion if we have additional questions um we were given a time frame to submit in writing um a deadline will we have an opportunity to submit additional questions that would be answered and provideed and those questions and answers provided to the public outside of this form yes thank you thank you Miss pfre Miss hen I was going to ask to respond because I'd like to introduce a new motion after we vote on the motion on the floor to um
157propose a second work session which is what I Believe Miss Pumphrey was asking about so I would like to introduce a new motion after we vote on the motion on so uh let's do everything in good and decent order and handle the business of course thank you is there any further discussion Mr Young I'm sorry I want to amend the current motion such that the um board member is given an additional minute to speak is there a second okay wa this a second amendment this is amendment to the amendment we never voted on the right we didn't vot vote on the First Amendment we don't need to vote on the okay so we can amend the amendment yes with the second is you haven't going back to the primary motion yet all you're doing is
158adding that Clause that it would be in order thank you again is there a second to Mr Young's motion to limit the additional time to one minute I'll second it so we can have discussion so second from Paul one minute sounds good thank you m Rong is there a discussion um I guess quick question okay M just one quick question so is this motion just from moving forward or is it specifically just for this meeting surrounding the budget presentation or is this are establishing this is to amend the current time for speaking on the budget at this meeting to to extend it and has been amended proposed amended three times to include an additional one minute um to for board members to be allowed their additional time after they've exhausted their initial three minutes wait
159did I what was I think that's it to restrict it to one minute and then speak for only one minute so this is just specific to this board meeting it's not establishing that precedent okay thank Miss fron um I do think we should put a limit on the additional questions I don't know that one minute is long enough long enough we heard enough is there any any further discussion so we are voting on amendments Mr Burns first the first amendment we are voting on first which was the other first voting it's Mr Young's amendment was we are voting on Mr Young's amendment to limit any additional time to one minute may I have a roll call vote Mr Young yes Miss uh dominowski no Miss hen no Miss frong yes Miss Booker DWI yes Miss
160chicao Funny yes sorry Miss tuski no Dr seavoy yes Mr McMillian no Miss Pumphrey no Miss Harvey yes Miss lter just logged on Miss Lor are you present yes I'm present Miss Lector my vote is we're voting on the additional work session correct no we are voting on Mr Young's motion to extend any additional time to discuss the budget tonight to one [Music] minute yes I vote Yes I believe that vote is seven motion carries yes ma'am thank you Amendment carries we are now voting on the amendment to I got I'm sorry I was distracted by some side conversation we are voting on the amendment made by Miss frong to uh allow voting me allow board members to have their additional time after all board members have had their add initial three minutes just have
161a clarifying question if board members don't all use the three minutes can the individual have the additional minute we will confirm the board members have exhausted their time whether by time or Choice okay so if board members choose to not use their three minutes then board members that have used their three minutes can have the additional minute after all board me the motion is after all board members have used their three minutes so yes in other words we're not forcing you to talk Mr deleski may I have a roll call vote Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen yes Miss frong yes Miss Booker DWI yes Miss chk K yes Mr deleski yes Dr seavoy yes Mr McMillian yes Miss Pumphrey no Miss uh Harvey yes Miss lter yes thank you motion carries just
162to remind the board we have now approved an amendment to add an additional one minute limit additional speaking time to one minute after all board members have uh proceeded to use their three minutes to speak on the budget now we will vote on the amended motion which is to extend time to discuss the budget this evening Mr Young yes Miss dominowski yes Miss hen yes Miss frong yes Miss Booker DWI yes Miss Harvey yes Miss chica kou yes Miss deleski yes Dr seavoy No Mr mcmillion yes yes Miss pumy no Miss lter got a stop I'm sorry I I'm can you repeat the motion the motion is to extend time this evening to discuss the budget yes thank you motion carries prior to calling on board members I'd call on uh superintendent Rogers for comment
163thank you um I wanted to ask Mr sarus who has uh located uh information directly related to um College and Career Readiness to provide an update to the full board thank you thank you Dr Rogers hopefully the sum and substance of this will be clear uh I have a uh 2025 adopted budget document and that document has a lot more detail in it because it's the final document and it goes through three iterations so with that um we're able with consultation with Dr D denado and Mr tantleff um we find on page 200 the uh the current Year's adopted budget for colleg and career Readiness uh of 2.6 million approximately um and then uh it it there's further detail here which we don't have in this superintendent's proposed document that there was $1.2 million in
164transfers and uh Dr D denado indicates that those funds were transferred to the Department of research accountability and assessment for the specific purpose of testing and testing fees so then when we we go now I'm cross referencing that to page 188 of the current Year's fy2 adopted budget we see that uh the uh research accountability and assessment budget is 4.7 million cross referencing again to page 144 that Miss dominowski originally referenced you go to the top of the page you see that the department of research accountability and assessment has increased by $1 million and I think that that is the explains the primary variance uh that we talked about and we'll certainly uh get go into the detail and provide Dr Rogers with any any more detail that would tie to that difference but I
165think that's the that's the propensity of it okay so it is a transfer of testing to the appropriate office it is not a cut to students and resources correct thank you all right thank you thank you thank you are there board members that have questions regarding the budget Miss hen prior to starting your question let's do a time check to see how much time you have remaining on your three minutes Madam Vice chair I'm not starting my question I had a um request to make a motion prior to going to Dr Rogers to open up for board member questions please your please proceed thank you I move to schedule an additional work session on the FY 2026 proposed um budget for the board's next meeting on Tuesday February 11th is there a second a second
166pumy thank you is there a discussion Miss Pomfrey I would just like to mention the reason I don't know if I can I don't know if this is appropriate but the reason I voted no on the initial motion was because I felt that it would be same as my question that we could submit questions um in writing and be provided those answers and if further discussion is needed that could be done at the work session but our questions may be answered in the in the meantime Is there further discussion Miss hen um I also would appreciate the opportunity to submit further questions and would have the chance to prepare those in advance of the work session thank you I believe superintendent Rogers has already agreed to uh provide that to us are there any other
167questions or discussion regarding this motion do I have a I guess a question for clarification Miss fral so if the questions are submitted electronically and then superintendent Rogers um response which she has do we still need the work session for February 11th you like me to respond Madam Vice chair Miss hen yes I believe this dialogue is extremely helpful and that is why I'm making this motion so that we can have this dialogue and board members can hear each other's um questions and the response and input from staff and from the superintendent thank you thank you for the question Miss Pumphrey my opinion would be it would depend on the answers and what we get done here tonight um I think some additional questions that may have been brought tonight May hold over until the
168work session if needed but I think it would depend on the questions and answers that we receive is there any further discussion Miss hen only one I think the length of the work session would be determined by the um the questions we have and the responses that we receive so it could be a very brief session um to miss pumphrey's Point thank you is there any other discussion I would like to say that many board members have commented that this ask for an additional work session is contingent upon the questions that may be asked and the answers that may be received I would remind the board that the board leadership does uh engage in ag agenda setting and that that agenda setting is participatory by every board member I'm not sure that setting a work
169session uh in in the uh next board meeting that may not be required based on the responses you're giving is is uh necessary are there any other points of discussion may I have a roll call vote Please Mr Young yes Miss tamowski yes Miss hen yes Miss frong yes Miss bookwire no Miss Harvey no Miss CH Koo no Mr lki yes Dr seavoy No Mr mcmillion yes Miss Pumphrey yes Miss Lor no Miss Gover what does it count please favor is seven motion carries Is there further discussion on uh the budget this evening hearing none we'll move to the next agenda item the next item on the agenda is information information items are the financial report for the month ending in November 2024 and the report on the single audit the next item on the
170agenda is board committee updates and agenda setting we will start with board committee updates uh prior to prior to asking committee chairs uh to provide updates I do want to um provide everyone um with some information regarding our committee meetings for the next uh for the month of February we have decided to pause committee meetings for the month of February as you all have all heard all throughout today and this evening we are facing a dire situation with our budget uh even additional Cuts may be made to our budget based on uh State uh St funding and so we are giving the superintendent and her team the space in the room to dedicate as much time as they need to making sure we have a budget that supports not only our goals and our students
171and our families but the progress that we're making in Baltimore County Public Schools the looming uh state budget provides uh difficulties that make it essential that staff are dedicated to focusing on uh support supporting our students and safeguarding our progress however uh the committee work will continue when we resume the committee work committee chairs are able to extend committee meeting times as needed or uh schedule additional committee meetings as required and so I just wanted to make that clear having said that we'll move to uh committee meetings and we'll start with the audit committee Miss Booker dwire please provide report okay well we were looking forward to kicking off the new year with the audit committee but the snow had other plans so on January 7th um the central office was closed due to um
172the inclement weather and so we had to cancel the audit committee meeting and um and due to the announcement that uh Vice chair Harvey just made um our audit committee meeting for the month of February is cancelled as well so we are looking for to um our March audit committee meeting we will all be in green we'll be happy to celebrate St Patrick's Day with the audit committee March 18th we are looking forward um to that audit committee meeting thank you Miss Booker DWI uh we will'll move to Mr Young for buildings and contracts the buildings and contracts next committee meeting will be held on February 10th uh virtually at 5:00 p.m. thank you you we'll move to the curriculum committee presenting is Miss deleski thank you the curriculum committee met on January 23rd and
173we had two informative updates the first presentation was um progress made with hmh and the implementation of that and our second presentation was on the msde Maryland State Department of Education process of reviewing and approving highquality instructional materials um um and we did approve the ELA curriculum contract on that evening as well um our next meeting will be on March 20th uh 20125 and we will meet virtually thank you thank you Miss teski we'll move on to the equity committee Miss F brong turn the mic on good evening the equity committee met January 16th we received information on the Strategic plan for the Department of equity and cultural proficiency there part of their work this department works within the system to promote authentic relationships rooted in humanity and grounded in compassion and dignity our teachers
174provide instruction in a variety of modes visual auditory kinesthetic Etc with the coaching and consultations the equity Department trains Personnel adding skills to the quote unquote toolbox of BCPS Personnel so for example if teaching a concept is not working the teachers able to reach into their toolbox to speak and provide information and instruction in a manner that resonates with all students the department contributes to the system's goals and outcomes identified by Dr Rogers a previous program with the focus on a student population whose suspension rate was high and academic achievement low had success by 75% of their students having an A or B for math in the third quarter and 70% having an a orb and Ela for the third quarter as well as discipl referrals went down from 26% to 5% between quarter the
175first quarter and the fourth quarter there are those who may think only of student student population such as Black Or Hispanic Latino students when they think of equity but this important work also includes our multilingual Learners and our children with special needs disabled and special education we will resume meeting again on March 13th uh thank you we'll move on to legislative and governmental relations and for that I call on Miss Booker DWI so we had a great legislative and governmental Relations Committee meeting um we reviewed the Maryland Association of boards of education's uh legislative priorities and we also review the 2025 legislative platform of the Maryland State Board of Education uh we started discussing um the priorities the legislative potential legislative priorities of the um Baltimore County Board of Education we still have some work
176to do on those so they are not ready to bring to the full board um for recommendation just yet and we also discussed some of the pre-filed bills um and we will not have a meeting um at this um we won't have a meeting in February but if there are any bills that we need to bring to the board's attention will do that dur during the the regular um board meeting um so our next legislative committee meeting is March 12th thank you Miss Booker dwire and thank you for bringing up the point that any committee uh activities that require the board's attention can be brought to the board for discuss the full board thank you and we will move on to policy Review Committee Miss Pumphrey thank you policy Review Committee does not meet in
177January so I do not have an update because it would be the same as last month's update um our next meeting is currently scheduled for March 17th however if we decide that a an extra March meeting is needed um the website will be updated with the date thank you thank you we'll move on to agenda items proposed agenda items for the next meeting uh does anyone have proposed agenda item Mr mcmillion thank you if you if you're following along on the agenda letter J information number two report on single audit the total the entire title for that is report on single audit year ended June 30th 2024 that's a 25-page document constructed by Clifton lson and Allen on page 12 under financial statements the the yes box is checked signific ific deficiency or deficiencies identified
178under Federal WS the boxes checked significant deficiency or deficiencies identified from Pages 13 through 25 five findings are discussed on page 13 the first finding is adjusting journal entries if you open that up and look at it accounts receiv receivable was underestimated by $3.2 million adjusting entry 5.5 million adjusted entry totaling approximately $7.2 million Mr mcmillion you have an agenda item for us please yes that's what I'm getting at is to put this on I'm giving a rationale for what I want I want to see this topic on our next agenda so your agenda item is to have the report and dig deep into the uh this audit report and I if Miss if CH uh Sher Amos is available I'd like to see her here invited to discuss this and there's a lot so
179those totals amount up to $22.4 million if you total those up so I think this this topic needs to be looked at by us thank you you're welcome are there other board members that have agenda item requests Miss pumfrey am I able to make a comment without an actual agenda item is that allowed yes okay I just wanted to um thank the superintendent and her staff for the hard work on the budget and I um know that that was difficult fa considering our fiscal constraints um and I just wanted to reiterate that our questions well at least my questions as a board member are not trying to undermine any of your hard work it's more to bring transparency which I I've learned not to like that word too much because I think it's overused um
180but to the public and so that they are aware of where their tax dollars are going and I think sometimes our questions are simply to bring light to what um you know to make the public understand this is why this much money is needed um and I also appreciate other board members questions because often times they are about things that I haven't thought of and I think it brings more me more knowledge when other board members ask questions and those are answered by the superintendent and staff thank you thank you Miss pumfrey are there other board members that have agenda items Mr meski I have um comments so should I wait for absolutely okay so first of all I just want to publicly recognize and thank all of the stakeholders and employees that reached out
181via email regarding the safer together campaign um we know this will take time but um your care and concern for school climate is heard and we will continue to work with you I also want to um give a huge shout out to owing Mill's High School there's a couple different things I want to recognize first um I want to recognize uh the art teacher Mr Conway and his students for the creation of what was called this Virtual City which kind of looked like a train garden in their Lobby that was displayed around the holidays um it had a a variety of elements of meaningful and engaged learning um the students had such pride in this project there was absolutely no disrespect it was this huge train layout um and it brought such Pride to the
182school um next I want to recognize uh Miss gains who is involved with the fouls program and she has created what is called a Twice As Nice Thrift Shop which I have um walked through it is absolutely beautiful it looks like a real store um it's completely staffed by the students in the special ed fouls program giving them important uh development and functional life skills additionally at owing Mills High there's a coffee cafe and a school store also staffed by the students um all of this is just amazing and then finally as a volunteer with the student support network and there it's called The Nest we have students that come and volunteer and these these volunte these student volunteers are absolutely wonderful they help us with unpacking the deliv IES on the day that the
183food bank order arrives and then also on the days that we distribute the food to families there are seniors that are on early release that come and volunteer their time and help so I just want to recognize and thank all of the students that help us at the nest thank you thank you Miss teski are there any additional in agenda items or comments for Miss I'm so sorry Dr seavoy okay all right I was just going to say the weather's changing and so soon it's expect expect that some of you will be visiting classrooms in your district and when you go into the school usually the principal or whoever's in charge that day will show you everything they want you to see but you have to have questions after you've seen everything okay questions about
184what's going on in school what what about your infrastructure you can ask about that your PTA participation Special Air classes asked to go into a special a class and a Esau class um ask about the extracurricular activities what are the children doing after school how are they involved especially in high schools and and middle schools and what is the uh student achievement rate okay so those are some questions you can ask and if you don't know what questions to ask I have about a hundred of them at home that I can give you you don't want to burden the people but you want to have intelligent questions not just T questions for them okay I mean everybody in here is intelligent but I mean questions that make us appear you know we know a lot
185we know okay thank you so much thank you Dr SEO are there additional agenda items or comments Miss fral um I have comments and the first part of my remarks are actually not my own um but I'll go ahead into them um so it says you can go to live in France but you cannot become a Frenchman you can go to live in Germany or turkey or Japan but you cannot become a German a Turk or Japan Japanese but anyone from any corner of the Earth can come to live in America and become an American yes the torch of Lady Liberty symbolizes our freedom and represents Our Heritage the compact with our parents our grandparents and our ancestors it is that lady who gives us our great and special place in the world for it's
186the great life force of each generation of new Americans that guarantees that America's Triumph shall continue unsurpassed until the next century and beyond other countries May seek to compete with us but in one vital area as a beacon of freedom and opportunity that draws the people of the world no country on Earth comes close this I believe is one of the most important sources of America's greatness we lead the world because unique among nations we draw our people our strength from every country and every corner of the world and by doing so we continuously renew and enrich our nation while other countries cling to the stale past here in America we breathe life into dreams thanks to each New Wave each wave of new arrivals to this land of opportunity We're a nation forever young
187forever bursting with energy and new ideas and always on The Cutting Edge always leading the world to the next Frontier this quality is vital to our future as a nation and if we ever close the door to new Americans our leadership in the world would soon be lost so again these were not my words but something that I came across and they were actually said by a person who some would regard as one of our nation's greatest presidents and that person is actually Ronald Reagan so in these unpr president at times I just think it's important that we be mindful that as individuals we're deserving of humanity humanity and that our relationships be grounded in compassion and dignity thank you thank you miss fromal the last item on the agenda is announcements the board's next
188meeting will be held on Tuesday February 11th 202 2 at 6:30 p.m. I would like to uh thank board member Tiara Booker DWI for taking on the responsibility of the vice chair and chair L's absence while I take on those responsibilities I appreciate everyone's participation feedback and patience as we work out uh some difficult decisions and have some difficult discussions thank you for joining us tonight and have a great evening be safe the meeting is now adjourned who hits that yeah