CorpusRecord 92259

February 4, 2025 at 4:30 PM - Monthly Committee of the Whole Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Duluth Public Schools
Date
2025-02-05
Location
St. Louis County, MN
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,142 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good afternoon and welcome to the duth public schools February Committee of the whole meeting we'll start our meeting out with our rooll call member banks here chair eater present member laugher Kemp here member loal here I am here member Sadowski here member Williams here superintendent Magus present assistant superintendent bonds Deputy clerk Simone zunich uh executive assistant Shannon Brown student R Taylor and student rep great and so while uh we've done our roll call we'll turn the rest the meeting over to assistant superintendent Bond thank you chair eer um today we have uh two presentations uh a primary presentation and then of course our executive director s zunich has a a a budget update as well so our first presentation will be given by Todd Macwan he is our coordinator for Mental Health social emotional behavioral

002learning mtss so he has a very long title um so this is under the category of support reporting every student and I'm going to turn it over to Todd who's going to introduce Our Guest is that right all right uh so my name is Todd mcau I'm the mtss SCB uh coordinator for the duo School District so I was working with uh Jacob lant and Cali uh D over the last three years under uh the aware Grant um and then once Jake and Cali had uh left for other positions I now kind of both of those positions uh currently um still under the aware Grant which will run for another uh the rest of this school year and then next year and then I'll int let you introduce yourself yeah uh I'm John Herman a

003school psychologist in the district of D Public Schools I've served multiple School sites across the district but uh this year I've taken on a Content lead position as an additional assignment I'm working with Todd on implementation of positive behavior invention supports throughout the district so for today um what we'd like to do is just a brief overview of PBIS and what mtss um are and what that means for the district and then what we we'll spend most of our time is just diving into outcomes so as I said we were funded through the aware grant for the last three years we're in the fourth year of of this uh cycle of the aware Grant and we'd like to to just you know inform you on all the things that we have have accomplished um so

004go ahead so for this school year our action uh and our action card and and our goal setting is just to focus on the implementation of uh PBIS at a tier one level moving into tier uh two uh which is more specific supports for students um and then continuing to flush out our mtss process um and what behavioral um support students have in each of our buildings um the action items that we focused on are attendance um making sure that social emotional learning is uh achievable and attainable across the district um and then assuring that PB is implemented with Fidelity um at each of our buildings um so what is an an overview of p and just by a show of hands how many of you I'm sorry have heard of PB or know what

005PBS is do we need to spend a lot of time on that do you have any questions about PBIS specifically so we won't spend a lot of time on PBIS then and just the introduction um but what I do want to emphasize is that PBIS excuse me is not a curriculum or one day thing that we we do it's not sit and get um it's not a prescription for our schools it's being responsive and culturally responsive to what each School needs this is the first time for me and and this is probably a a bold statement but where we have a good temperature of what each of our schools has done through a positive POS behavioral and intervention uh lens as well as through that PBIS lens and we'll get to that data here in

006a little bit but that took a lot of work you know for us to do the climate survey through a district lens to have 13 of our schools uh PBIS certified um at a tier one level um and then to be monitoring that implementation continually um over the course of the year so we're super proud of what we've done um and we'll we'll start to get into to what that looks like member dere rer oh sorry just want to make sure so one of the the biggest accomplishments that we've done is in PB there's something called the tier one Fidelity inventory um that will measure our the state of our teams and how responsive we are to the needs of each school um in the start of 2023 not only did the school district the

007deloo School District take that tier one um Fidelity inventory but we overlapped it with a culturally responsive Field Guide which is what you're seeing here so now we are looking at the the Fidelity of implementation of each of our teams our PBIS teams and our mtss teams in each building but we're also making sure that those interventions and and what we're populating those Frameworks with are are culturally responsive and representative for for the community that we're trying to develop those programs um what's super cool about that super cool is that the Minnesota PBIS is actually interested in what we're doing so we're one of the first districts in the state to do that so we're in a sense leading the way and people want to come and and look at how this is being implemented

008and the results that we're getting member laer Kemp I just um don't want to interrupt your your um presentation but on the first page you talk about uh uh Fidelity at building levels and then you've used that phrase a lot and just I I think it might be helpful for common language for everybody here to kind of understand when you talk about we're implementing at Fidelity just kind of what you mean by that go for so a tiered framework for PBIS has certain features um for in order to be considered implemented correctly or fully and on the TFI the T inventory it lists what those metrics are and then to the level of quality that they're being implemented um both and it does break down specifically to individual sections when implementation teaming data of use

009um and we monitor that at least three times if if not two times a year member ranks thank you so you're on page five and so I always ask questions about Equity can can you explain data for Equity what does that look like um can you talk a little bit about that so for Equity data we often look at whether there is disparities in implementation and where those may be and also outcomes so when we look at data we look at you know valued outcome measures whether that's academics behaviors suspension rates School climate we look at those metrics and then we determine whether there's any disparities in people's experiences or outcomes and then we design an action step towards Improvement um in those areas the other thing is how we interpret the data um so

010we are in our third year of completing What's called the climate survey um where we're looking at the quality of the experience for families staff and for students this will be the first year that we've been able to break that down as far as is race gender um what are our other components race gender um School you you could break it down by grade levels um there's a lot there's a lot of demographic data that could be broken down um that are on the survey so when we're able to have those conversations about Equity we have that real-time data and what that looks like he can jump in just to superintend on that on that not um just thinking of other ways that PBIS uses data for Equity because I think it's very important uh

011when we're looking at disparities a lot of times we try to make sure that there is um commonality between schools as far as what is a consequence for instance if if if a consequence is given at one Middle School it should be very similar at another Middle School um same with the elementaries also um sometimes when we're looking at different types of Behavior some behavior is considered more subjective as far as what the consequence will be out like disrespect for instance the the range of what could be considered disrespect is is pretty uh uh vague in some ways and so we try and make and we try and make sure that that uh there aren't instances of bias and things like that that that creep in when it comes to defining something as being disrespectful

012or uh doing out a consequence for that so those are different ways that I've I've seen um data used for Equity purpose just just a few um and then sometimes um also looking at what are the antecedants what happened before you know maybe somebody did get mad and slam the door and swear at the teacher but what happened prior to that and it was there was their means for for uh a better relationship outcome than than what what happened so so really taking a look at root causes of of Behavioral situations and and going deeper with uh what are the outcomes and then also what are the if there are consequences especially negative consequences like suspension or things like that how are we making sure that we are uh monitoring that for fairness based on

013uh gender based on race based on socioeconomic difference based on special education it's very very important and I I think I mean I not to get on a soap box over over this but I think right now we're in a time where where the word Equity is being challenged nationally and I want to say uh as we've said in our our newsletters that Equity is is a key component of what we do here in in duth public schools advancing Equity will continue to be part of our strategic road map and when we work on things like behavior and positive behavior interventions uh and supports we we have to have Equity at the as a Cornerstone to that work and the one other thing piece would add is that okay I talk is also just looking

014at teaming structures within the building you know who has voice like how are those voices Amplified um what's the makeup of our teaming structures you know as far as um from an equity lens and and really making sure that we're inclusive um in how decisions are made not just why they're made so just a couple things off of superintendent's last remark about um the use of equity and how that's always going to to be a part of it well duth isn't going to stand alone there because really PBIS one did did is in the for Minnesota is in the Forefront of PBIS Denfeld I think was one of the first schools in the state to implement it it was well into like 2011 2012 somewhere or even maybe it was 2008 and then we took

015a little break when we combined Central and Denfeld for that year of renovation and then we had a hard time kind of getting it back in there and then I can remember um principal tusk's comment last spring that he was so proud one of the things he was so um sure that we were moving in the right direction is that every school in duth public schools was a PB school which then leads me and then in the nation there's pbas is in 49 states across the country and it is you know a big part of most primary and secondary educations which really leads me to this kind of thing that I I was just kind of looking at because I know duth is recognized as a leader in PBIS and then I went to the

016Department of Education and they have this news release in August of 2024 and they list all these wonderful schools and Del's not on there and then it even goes to you know goes the Metro but then it also says like it's it's broken down into Northern schools and then say three districts recognized for sustaining exemplary district and like we're we're like a leader so was that a mistake U would you want us to be listed there yeah because the application is open until April and we can fill it up out and be an Exemplar District based on our numbers right now well that would be a good a good maybe I don't know I I just I was kind of surprised because they list they list so many schools and we could be exemplary or

017I just want to be listed as somebody that uh supports PBIS or I can comment on that if that's okay because historically um as a district we've had different schools kind of yes Grassroots implementing and then it's just been in the recent few years have we as a district decided to be a districtwide PBIS district and every school has had some cohort level of training at different periods um and some of them has sustained it since then um I I think the issue is there isn't no one really knows about filling out the examplar applications and recognizing your school um for doing the hard work that they're doing um but I just talked to Todd about that because we looked at our data this year and it's like well we meet that Mark for the

018district and a lot of schools make the mark for the school and we could fill those out continuously and be on that list and and and that your your spot on and I apologize for just because I do remember Denfeld and Lincoln Park I mean some of our early onboarding schools um you know were listed probably a couple years ago other presentations we've had on PB I think we've been there but I get it and I get that there there is there's a good side to being on this list and there's also some concern about you know we don't want other buildings that aren't quite there yet to feel yeah you know that somebody yeah I want everyone to be a first place W ribbon winner that's my that's my downfall is everybody gets an

019award when they're on my speech team but I I think the other side to that to is just the continual invitation for Minnesota PB to come and work with us you know and I think that there's an open invitation where they see the value and what we're doing um specifically regarding how we're using the climate survey that we have those samples from each of our schools um that those are driving equity and driving intervention um and and then taking that that opportunity to apply for the that Exemplar status but I'll call on superintendent maggus and then I just want to remind the board there's a several other slides and I know they're going to go deep into some of the things that you are asking questions about so um I'll turn to John and if

020we could allow a couple more slides and then we're taking questions thanks super magaz um and when I when we give praise it's not to say that we've finished our work it's that we're we're on the right Journey we're on the right path um so by by having all of our schools be positive behavior intervention and support schools we have now a common Universal system for Behavior where we're looking at it much more deeply and we're we're uh really thinking about it from a uh a multi-tiered systems of support model so that's why it's listed as as a Minnesota MTS Minnesota uh tiered model for for implementation so it's now MN TM SS which the acronyms get I think it's it's uh interesting but we actually just received an email an hour ago uh from

021the state asking us to consider presenting at the summer Institute about our mtss um implementation and the structures that we have because they're they're seeing us as still having work to do but also that we are doing doing the right work and we're putting structures in place that are that are going to pay off we've started the journey and we have the uh imple implements we need to make that Journey successful and so I want to say thank you to to the team and we will consider that possibility for presenting but again there's more work to be done and more slides to cover yeah uh so yeah so why we do the work uh and one two of the the components of a PBIS and mtss model or that we are research informed and data

022driven um and when we use those two skills or those two tools um we can increase social uh and self-awareness and decision-making improved academic outcomes um increased student engagement fewer special education referrals and then hopefully fewer disciplinary C which we'll we'll show you here in a little bit um but we're we're capturing that information and using that data to make informed decisions and how we respond to some of the issues that we have in our schools uh you can go forward um one of the the pieces and the components that the Min Minnesota Department of Education is pushing out right now is a comprehensive School mental health system which includes PB and mtss that it's not only these two tools that we have in our toolbx but we have a Continuum of of services um

023and responsive interventions you can keep going we can go through this so positive behavioral uh interventions and supports is one of them and you can keep going again we'll fast forward a little bit but we want to be thinking at it from this 50,000 foot lens too right it's not just about boots on the ground um but how all of these systems are working together um and that means that through those models through those tiered systems we focus on Mental Health referral Pathways um we ensure that there's Co collocated on-site therapy providers as well as District certified mental health that we have a crisis response protocol um that we're using assessments like uh the shape assessment um there's what is other assessment that we use do you know any um I I apolog there's another

024assessment that we would also use to just look at how our systems are are running in each as a in a district and then in the school um that we are monitoring our our data and that we ensure that evidence-based interventions are being used in each of our schools actually can we go back to slide eight here's why I want to make sure that we don't um miss the opportunity to really reinforce what PBS really stands for and it's really about how we Foster positive learning environments in our schools and yes it means looking at data and yes it means how we address discipline discipline in uh schools but it it is really focused on what are the things that we are doing in all of our classrooms in the hallways to reinforce positive skills

025and supports for students so we I can you just spend just a a moment on that piece um of the PBIS framework yeah do you want to go so as far as the tiered model goes a lot of what we're talking about is the core pieces of PBIS in the classroom um whether that's established expectations clear routines reinforcement for desired Behavior outcomes or behaviors we're teaching within the school system um but there's also the need for more targeted support more individualized support um a lot of what our work this year has been has been mainly establishing that core foundation so that schoolwide practice of follow you know having consistent expectations teaching reinforcing those outcomes um with the students um and the staff and the families that are all part of it so um do that

026answer the question it does and and you want to maybe share one of the acronyms in the schools whether it's um yeah pause probably where board members may have seen those signs in the hallways and it's outcome of uh our PBS work and make sure kids know what the expectations are as they're walking down a hall or how they're interacting with each other and so you want to share one if you have one in mind not put on spot no but the other uh just the other component too is not just to um be working at it from a teaming structure but that we're actually going into the buildings and measuring um where we're doing interviews with students where we're interviewing staff that we're looking at Fidelity from that lens where there is a high

027level of buyin and understanding of what we're trying to accomplish through those app acronyms you know sometimes it it gets we get lost in the weeds a little bit on you know it's just it's just you know giving kids rewards for Behavior but it's really about teaching appropriate behavior about teaching you know the skills that are required to self-regulate or to enter into Community um and then making sure that we're catching kids when they're doing something good which is super important thank you yeah the intentional teaching of those expectations corre thank you I'll stop now so you can go ahead I'm sorry thank you um you can go ahead a little bit uh you can go one more um so we'll we'll get into just what are the the outcomes um and slides um so

028for for the Delo School District we have been charting and and you know that we've been uh keep track of our out our osss data so our Autos school suspension rates um so in 2021 22 we had the highest suspension rates that we've had in in multiple years at 2,194 which is also the first year that we started to implement pis and mtss um from that that District lens um since then we've steadily seen our OSS data reduce um to 1,272 in the 2022 23 school year 892 in the 2324 school year and current L uh so year to date for the 2425 school year we're at 436 so we've seen steady reduction over the last few years not only in our suspension rates but how we're starting to manage uh the acquisition of skills

029required to maintain right a presence in school um and you can go forward uh go ahead yep sorry I did make it yep okay um so so on the TFI there is a overall implementation score and for the past few years you can see how we've been monitoring the scores across the district um 70% is the go to Fidelity according to the to the recommendations of the PS um assessment but as you can see we've had ups and downs but we've come more stable in the past spring and fall this year um to full implementation across the district the one Nuance that I just want to point out about this slide is that in the fall of 2023 was the first year that we implemented the culturally responsive Field Guide when we were looking at

030our PB implementation so it's the first time that we assess culture with implementation of of uh the PBIS tiered Fidelity inventory so that is is the result of why we took a step back um and then once again we've been able to maintain over the last year go ahead yep go ahead uh well the percentage tells you how many of the scores on the TFI were at 100% or partial or zero so it comes to an average score of 70% or higher then that's fully implemented or if it's below it's it's below Fidelity or it's not implemented fully hopefully that answers yeah these are schools yep all all schools in the district took the survey and filled out this assessment so this is an average across the district M Sadowski can you um kind of

031expand on what you mean um by assessing culture or whatever you said about um in the fall of 23 and that was when you started to implement some sort of cultural piece could you explain that a little bit more us what that entailed so one of the pieces and I can share these with you you know uh if you'd like to take a look at them but one of the the uh components of ppis is that tiered Fidelity inventory and then we have the culturally responsive Field Guide um so the culturally responsive Field Guide will ask specific questions at each of those tiered uh areas about culture and if we're being culturally responsive in each of our buildings and there's a a wide range of of things that it looks like but it makes our

032teams talk about culture um and whether or not we are being culturally responsive great thank you yeah you're welcome and I would be happy to share that with anybody if you're interested share the surve share the uh the actual uh TFI so we were able to take the TFI and then the culturally responsive Field Guide put them into one document um and then we we were able to create that as a district yeah the field guide offers um a different interpretation on and some of the examples that it it has you describe as far as what your tears in PBS look like so as for an example give you one example when they talk about listening expectations in the survey um how responsive is it to other languages other cultures that you may have in

033your school so when doing the field guide they found well all the signage and all the explanation is monolingual in English so but we have other languages in the district we have other language in the school so Translating that and then providing it another level of access for others to understand um was one way the field guy helped in that regard can we go back to no is that okay now can we go back to page 11 a quick question for you what and if you don't have this information you could email it or whatever what is the overall or actual uh out of school percentage what's the overall is it 3% or do you know what that number is so I don't have those number I don't have it broken down that far but

034we could find out okay yeah all right I think for the board and the public too you'll note that there's no uh year for 2021 and that was uh during covid and then the year afterwards there was that's when we saw throughout the country and and here as well a huge spike in behavioral issues as students returned to school if you want to stay you want to talk about the climate survey real quick can I ask a question quick yes um chair DK eer sorry just one question on um can yeah that slide right here so I see that you've got the survey period Elementary secondary staff families and those percentages could you are those percentages talking about the tiered Fidelity inventory or what are those percentages U so this is the school climate survey

035um this is the survey that we've been sending out to staff families and students for the past few years um it's basically questions are perceptions of what their experience has been like in school um whether it's related to how they interact with each other how staff interact with them or how you know safe they feel in the school there's some safety questions there as well um but this is just really the overview overall score um from those climate surveys um and then there's actually a norm comparison which when they did when they created this survey they actually had a large sample of other schools and districts um that took the survey and this is kind of where their average is and so you're able to compare like where does Bluth public sit with other schools

036that have taken the survey so if so for example in the fall 2024 period fames said that they were 83.8% and you compare that to the norm is being above good and Below like good or like what is the what are the parameters yeah so the average of oh sorry the average um score out of thousands of other schools that took the survey from families um was a 79.2% you know approval basically so the they indicated a positive mark on on the survey averaged out to 79% families in duth in the fall and that year was 83% thank you so much so the way that we're using this information is to help Drive the school Improvement plans for each site so that goals are written based on what this the staff student and families are

037experiencing in each of our schools and as he um you click on to the next slide so remember we used to talk about this thing about uh desired daily experiences right of our students just W and how students feel about their school experience um how families feel about their experiences with our school so their desired daily experiences the survey is what we use as a way of gauging that and this is our ongoing metric to find out if families are feeling better about um certain aspects of the school's climate and it's called the um the climate survey is that battery so we're using as a as a way of saying are things improving do students feel like they are connected uh to the school in a more meanful do they feel like they belong they

038feel like they are seeing you know so there's a lot of questions on this assessment and we use that assessment again to uh have a Baseline and make annual improvements so it's all about that continuous Improvement of the learning environment Y correct and the way that we're using them right now um is as we get better we're going from bookends from start of the year end of the year but also then comparing between fall and fall spring and spring um and then establishing what those baselines are and and then what action steps we want to to establish so the the last uh section here in just in regards to how we're looking at data so the district has taken the initiative to implement um something called Ed climber which is our data warehouse where we're

039tracking um information so we just did a edim an educ climber Champions training where somebody in the building now can coach with the staff up on that um and using that data warehouse so that our our uh information is more current you know what I mean more dat or more um readily available and we can start to create these snapshots of of where our district at is at one of the things that we're working on right now is just this data calibration um because what we're finding is that all of all data isn't equal and that there's a lot of errors in what that looks like um this is just an example of what we're doing to to flush out that data calibration so as of 162 uh 25 we had 3,093 U Majors which

040were identified in Edge climber when we pulled that information so if you would uh keep going so we are able to identify like what our major behaviors are um we know that there disruptions or disorderly conducts we know that there are attendance issues and then we also know that there are elect electronic device issues um so these are three areas then that our PBIS and our mtss systems can Target so that there's reduction with within those numbers um and then if you just want to keep going that's a great example of why we why we uh have been focused on our attendance campaign so we're using data to make decisions on why we are again incentivizing student attendance and trying to make sure schools are um having discussions with students and families and finding out

041what the challenges are it's why we move forward with efforts to um improve our transportation options with students it's because of data that exists that says we have an issue with a student attendance and these are some of the things that we implemented as strategies to improve things so I'm I'm only emphasizing that because we need to make sure that um we're show ad demonstrating to the board and the community that we are using data in an informed way to make our decisions right and we also know that this data is inaccurate right because we see holes in that because we have so many competing systems right now on how we're Gathering data that it it's starting it influences how that data is represented and in that example although in Edge climber we were able

042to pull out 3,900 you know U Majors that had been entered we know that about 600 of them were cell phone violations that were being pulled over Ina accurately right so if you look at our discipline calibration just in regards to our majors and minors we know that a cellphone violation is not a major but it was being represented in our our data set as that so we have things that we need to flush out that are are human eror in what that data warehouse does um and making sure that that information before we push it out is accurate did you have something you want to say okay the other piece that we want to to focus on is what are our Behavior responses you know one of the things that we're talking with principles

043about right now is that notifying the parent is a completely appropriate right response but we would rather be focusing on that restorative intervention in regards to what's being taught like how do we repair if there is damage first um and then making sure that that that sequence is organized around learning not just punitive or you know getting kids into to to trouble right um so you can keep going um and this is just another example of how we use our our data we can now look at what time Trends are we know that most of our incidents are happening over the Lunch Period um what's happening over the Lunch Period right unstructured time so we're just once again using this information to drive how we're being responsive uh through our our mtss and PBIS lens

044and you can keep going if you want and then we're we're in the the final stretch so one of the things uh just before we end we just want to continually push um that we are are focus on District cohorts and coaches for coordinators that we getting into buildings uh helping staff develop um through the aware Grant we continue to focus on uh appropriate uh staff development um whether there's there's a whole range of staff development that we're doing um but making sure that staff have the right skills in the toolbox um that we are uh exploring uh a billing uh so that will be a new thing that's funded through the aware Grant or that we're exploring through the aware Grant and at a state level um is how are we billing for special

045education Social Work Services um and that we're continuing to focus on those those unstructured times so buses lunches outside making sure that um all staff have access to to high quality training so anything else sir any questions I feel like we went over a little bit uh as far as um but questions or comments yeah um I have lots of questions well a couple questions and I might maybe I'm supposed to know the answer to these so I apologize if I am um and it might be a question for you but as far as OSS um how and by whom is that determined is that a school handbook thing is it a district policy thing is it a Case by casee basis how is OSS determined and by whom out of school suspensions we have

046a scho a student handbook that um so it's for each school no the student handbook um oh student handbook sorry student handbook um is used by our School principles who ultimately make the decisions on whether suspension is Meed out or not so um OSS if OSS is deemed necessary it's a black and white thing like this determines you get out of school suspension the handbook gives guidelines and ultimately the principal and the team upon doing their investigation or the nature of the incident will make a decision if a an out school suspension is warranted and May and the level or the number of days a suspension is needed okay so suspense and and offense may lead to a one- day suspension two day suspension or five day suspension depending on the severity uh based on

047the administrator's judgment and uh fact finding okay thank you and then um can you explain a little bit or give an example of what a restorative intervention looks like sure I think like the the primary example is between students you know that there is a restorative interaction that's facilitated by an adult typically that will look like a harm repair Circle or like where we bring those conflictual children into that same space and we're able to take on like perspectives um we're able to make those amends and then we're able to acquire and teach new skills on how to prevent that from escalating further the next time that's a very novice you know what I mean way to um to look at that but one of the things that we've done uh is to train I

048think we've trained like almost 200 Duo School staff on what restorative circles are um and then how to do those harm repair circles so that is peer-to-peer what if it's student teacher is is that a different um would you respond differently I I would say no you know I think that that the the Integrity of the interaction is really what matters um but also making sure that there is an opportunity and both people are ready to enter into into that repair um so that we're not re traumatizing or you know what I mean stress or whatever that may be um but I I do think that that's an interesting question and I think we continue to flush that out as far as our skill set and how we're developing um the capacity you know of

049our staff yeah does that answer your question perfect and the I want to go back to the OSS just for one second but that also like one of the things that we're focusing on is what are the our our uh excuse me our alternatives to suspension right so it's not just a one-size fits-all right there's a lot of nuance in there um and what we want to do is continue to to find research on what best practice is so that we have an an arsenal of other things that we can do uh besides just getting kids out of school right um basis Sor that was kind of the basis of that question so I'm glad to you say that and one of the things that we're exploring our seal curriculum you know what I mean

050we're exploring restorative practices like there's a lot of things but the the focus will always be on community right how do we keep kids in community because that's where they learn best right um disconnection strategies only lead to further disconnection um so we we are limited by how creative we can be right um and I think that the more that we focus on connection um as the mechanism to prevention um the better that we're going to be and set ourselves up for the future member laa Kemp and then member Mikel thank you uh thank you Todd and uh Tim um this is you you mentioned Todd that um this is a lot of work and it's takes a lot of time and I I I know from this kind of started when I got on

051the board when we started moving towards this and and so having just numerous presentations over the the years um I just really I'm grateful for for all of the time and commitment that people like you and and and our staff have had uh to making this happen because these kinds of uh changes don't happen overnight they take they take time so I appreciate that um can you share with people a little bit more about the kind of training that happens with our staff and um to to to become that PBS uh School that might be helpful for people just briefly so as far as cohort training um the regional trainers um within Minnesota usually provide a training for a group of leaders in the school um and that includes principals lead teachers support staff and

052they usually talk about the core components of PBIS as a schoolwide practice so the would be like what are your expectations how do you reinforce those how do you acknowledge them uh how do you teach them and do you have a consistent structure across multiple settings multiple environments within a school and really it comes to the team's generation of their ideas with in their school um to what that looks like whether it's the designed around Roar whe design around sore or the 3bs you know be respectful be responsible be ready I think that's another one and that's their basis for how they Implement and then they onboard new staff and then they train other staff in the building that may not have access to formal training I know that some do have like a two-page

053here's what you need to know um when other staff are in the building um and there's other strategies of course that they pick that allow other people to access it a lot of artifacts that they collect as far as what they work on from teams um because they meet regularly every year so and I I would add we're at this point as a district too where we're focused on tier one implementation across the board but we also know that it's it's not a one-sized fits-all problem right like homec homecraft has different problems than denfield right there's all of those nuances that we're really trying to take into account um to make sure that the program that's implemented in that building is representative of the students and the families that are having that experience you know

054in that building as far as setting the the Baseline you know as a district like I have a list of things that we've accomplished um PB resource Hub you know what I mean that all like information is being shared between building um there's been Second Step um in regards to having social emotional learning you know like what goes into having curriculum what does it mean to to go into the classroom and teach these skills um we've updated our code of conduct our family and student handbook um we've purchased curriculum for our high school um we've added collocated therapists you know and increased our so that we have Fondulac and culturally representative you know Mental Health Services in our buildings um we've developed a Community Partnership protocol we've developed gender inclusion uh policy and resource Hub

055you know I could go on and on but like that is the work you know and I think that that is what I get excited about um but I also know that we're still trucking you know and we're still moveing in the in that direction and that takes time and people um so yeah I'm I'm proud of what we've accomplished but there's still a ton to do and I I know that we're getting um as far as time so member mikeil and then representative Dean yeah thank you so much for being here tonight um I know I get to see PBS in action at Oran East for my sons and um as student and where I'm on the PTA and we do a lot of support for their programs there and so they do they're

056doing such good work and I just want to um raise them up for that um I have three questions so um one the aware grant that you've mentioned a few times um how long does that last what does exactly does it fund and what happens when that Grant is over so right now the aware Grant will run through run through this year and then next year so in the is that 25 26 will be our last school year where the aware Grant if funds positions So currently it funds two positions two full-time positions uh which are mine as the coordinator and then an interventionist who is able to work within the schools um to to develop those mtss coordinators which were referendum funded to make sure that they're supported in their in their work within

057that I mean are you looking for kind of dollars or I'm just wondering when the grant Runs Out are we done with CJ it'll be 25 so that's the trip is that we're good through 25 26 school year but we're trying to leave breadcrumbs in a foundation that will last much much for longer than that um we're trying to create districtwide hubs you know I mean access points um where where schools can contribute good ideas and continue to feed you know what I mean off of each other um as well as those teaming structures of meeting bi-weekly with mtss coordinators so there's that interconnected framework right of support that is in the school district not continually coming from outside of it so and I'll jump in the answer is um P will continue even if

058the funding um is not through uh the grant because it is again it's one of our foundational supports for how we enhance the learning environment in our schools we know we we're going to have to make budgetary decisions uh about those um you know positions and the need uh for them but that's why we are really spending a lot of the uh Grant now to build capacity of our staff so they can continue the work but that doesn't mean that we won't have to find some additional uh resources to continue that coordination of efforts okay thank you um last question then so um you say that we're an example for the state people come and see the work that we're doing here um we know that on page eight the why we do the work

059about the um research that has shown how it's improving social and self-awareness decision-making capacity improving academic outcomes increased student engagement etc etc fewer disciplinary actions so in the data in the presentation that you have here for us tonight today we're seeing um a dramatic decrease in our out of school suspensions which is incredible and if that has you know something to do with PBIS that's like applauding that um we're seeing that our survey data is showing increased um approval uh satisfaction sure but I'm not necessarily seeing other outcomes that the research supported is that just because we haven't yet gotten our data system like up and running in order to capture some of those things or is it out there I I think some of it is uh this is my first time presenting uh

060so just knowing what you want to know more about you know and if those are the data points that you want to be interested in we can dig further in that I think the other side is that we're just scratching the surface on edge of climber like what that does to organize our information um so I think that we can start to dig a little bit deeper um and this was meant to be more of a int introduction and peripheral of of the things that we're doing and what we're seeing so far um but we can always dig deeper and I appreciate that question yeah of course thank you so much representative Dean okay so I'm sorry if I'm misinterpreting anything you've said but it sounds like the climate surveys that get sent out do

061they in like to what extent do they inform the work that you're doing with that well as an outcome tool they inform people's views on how things are being done so if things are safe in a school for example and everyone agrees with that in the fall but maybe less so in the spring the question is okay why is that when we start to problem solve and we try and come up with Solutions look at other data sources and then set up an action to see if we can improve it the following year uh or throughout the year okay and I would say too there's several categories you know that we look at and each of those categories could be a Target area that we would use to inform what we're going to do to

062to be responsive to that so if a student is saying um I don't like if 50% of the students at Denfeld say they don't like being at school we would want to explore that even further and I guess I just brought that up because I feel like at least at East where I go people don't put a lot in to answering those surveys and I'm sure that that's something you've had a hard time with in the past but like I can honestly say for me personally I don't remember one response I've ever put on one of those surveys and I care about stuff like this but I at least at East I don't see those being and I know those obviously aren't sure I I was curious because I was wondering how much that's really

063in informing you because they I don't know that they would necessarily I don't think that students responses would give the best reflection of their one thing I can say to that because as far as like survey data goes we want to get a good sample we want to get a large sample and I know certain schools have fluctuated in terms of how much participation they've had um so it's both a yeah there's an appro approval here there there's a lower score here um but we're talking maybe 20 that participated in the survey so it may not be may not be reflective um some some of those things I did note on the the table though um so you could see how many people participated in the survey but that is not broken down you know

064by East by Denfeld but you know it if you break it down by school you do see a lot of difference um and it could certainly do that drill down if you want East to to share with you because I've looked at East along with the rest of the schools but I think you bring up an excellent point though too in regards to what are we doing to help students have better access you know I mean to have a voice and if you're interested or you have friends that are interested and want to give us feedback on how to get a better sample and more people involved we would be more than willing to listen to that and I think that that kind of thing is really important like so I run student Forum at

065East where we I ask them questions and I compile reports for this and I think that those kinds of in-person discussions are always so much better than any online survey we get we get so many Google forms in our emails and none of them get a lot of attention so one of the things too that we've been focusing on is potentially switching up the format that we're using so rather than just a one through five you know whatever that is but there's actually a feedback survey so we sit and listen you know what I mean and we're a there's rins um whether or not we have focus groups there's a ton of different ways you know I mean I think that we could we could gather and capture information um and I think that having

066students have a voice is incredibly important so I appreciate that you bring it up I I I know that there another question but on this this point related to student in input really appreciate the the question and I think this just exemplifies why student leadership is so important and I'm so grateful for both of you to be here tonight and um I also wanted to say that we we have intention as I've mentioned uh to the board before about creating an opportunity for a u superintendent uh advisory Council student advisory Council so that we have multiple voices and and uh because it's hard to be the one and only voice right like you said the the discussions is where things things matter and that could be potentially an opportunity for a forum or opportunity for

067us to ask deeper questions to because you're right sometimes a survey it's just like check check check and we want to make sure that we're truly hearing you not just saying we listened yeah and that's very insightful and and he beat me to it and so um I'll just add that your spot on and we do uh realize that sometimes when we get data their responses from our students and families that we see differences across uh the community on who responds and who doesn't and sometimes we believe it might be some there might be survey fatigue out there and then when it comes to students we we're trying to get re uh become real strategic and when we give out the surveys and how we give them or if it's done during a there's no

068more home rooms but if it's done during a class period or if it's done during when so we're getting we're trying to get uh become really strategic on when schools or uh give those surveys but so thank you for that information because we we do see a difference in responses so let me go to I believe it's member lold and then member lamp and so um representative Dean thank you you actually took that I you know I I also say you know are we getting strong returns in and not just our student surveys but in in staff and in families and I'm not you don't even have to respond we know the struggle we just shared why that happens it happens with students it happens in all areas um could it be you know but

069it is so important I know that we there's better ways especially I mean if you try to focus on on students there are some we have some captured audiences they do go to school most days you know I've spent you know the last seven years on the board and we've had many evening uh Gatherings where we're asking for Community input we've had surveys where we look and we don't you know we we have three or four that attend Community Service uh events that we have for their feedback so it it is frustrating and we hope that people will watch this because one of the things I think sometimes our community thinks especially when they see that there's behavioral um issues not just in duth but across our our country this is the um way that

070we want to address student Behavior it's not punitive it is focused on positive behavior supports teaching them um and if our our public doesn't quite get that because I think I've heard many times why don't we just suspend them why are they even in school can't we just can't you know and as an former educator and and a parent I want to say you know that that isn't that isn't going to teach them the skills they need to teach and alternatives to suspension I see it at denfield almost every day that I'm there and um it really is an Avenue of success and it's a way to you know alleviate when you send them home you know that's not a great place for them to spend that time so um I applaud the district for

071using resource to to do to do not only PBIS but alternative to suspension programs and on a real concentration but what's lagging is that's the perceptions um that we happen and and when we do have disruption um in our school buildings with with our students you know um some some will say well yeah we just need to to to kick them out or to suspend them and that isn't that isn't educating students every day all day every student so um I've kind of Taken a little leap there but um edge of climber I hear it we hear it when we're in our student or in our teacher um Quality steering committee um it sounds like a great um program or application I don't know but I think we're still working out some kinks in in

072loading that up or how teachers access it um so I'll give you you know keep working on that it seems like it's going to work um and then I just wondered if if teachers if new teachers that are at the colleges in their education programming are introduced to the concepts of PBIS and mtss are they it would help us I think that we're getting better at it um one of the thing I am also an Adjunct professor at the College of saints Glasco um but one of the things that we are I'm seeing more of is that these conversations are happening at the college level you know and I think that that's encouraging but I think that's for us for us like where we're starting to plan out our professional development days that in August

073we're front-loading these conversations you know it's out of the gate um it's not in February March April you know that we make our gains early um and I think that as we work better with anarie and and how we start to plan out those professional development days I think that you're absolutely right in in how that looks um and just exposing um more people to that language and and that way of thinking member Lara Kemp yeah to two things one is um how uh it's been mentioned a little bit about how families do the surveys and I know one year um they Ed kind of school conferences to do surveys and and I was happen to be tabling uh I I can't remember it why we were tbling at a few schools and it seemed

074like that was one way that seemed to be successful um is is that kind of continuing one of the ways that you you're reaching families yeah there's a a variety of different opportunities a lot of schools use whether it's a family night um conference night um whether it's you utilizing a Sur a raffle or something to get people to participate more um but that that is a that is one of the good strategies that tends to get a good sample and one of and one of the problems with that is that the sampling happens very close together because conferences for elementary are like in the middle of October and then again in the middle of February where we want to make sure that there's enough time that goes by that we can demonstrate growth um

075so those are things that we're working out right now yeah because the survey it's given 45 days beginning of the year and 45 days at the end of the year according to the manual so you have enough time between samples um for any action steps you may want to take um but not everything in the schedule aligns with that survey so got to be creative sometimes okay thank you John and just the the last piece of it was um uh the professional development and you mentioned I I think in in the presentation that you do a lot of onboarding so that's onboarding with our new staff through professional development how about our substitute teachers and our staff like that there's work to be done you know I I think that there's holes uh across the

076board and I I think that um the more that we're aware of it the more that we can plan for what that looks like in the future um but there there definitely are holes and we need to acknowledge them yeah durability and sustainability is kind of The Next Step because now we're we're implementing but for new staff to come in for Subs that come in we're going to need to strategize a little more it's a process thank you member Derek eer um this chair Dereck eer chair right um yes dang it um you will respect my authorit just kidding um so this is more of a comment but on Friday I was at pedmont elementary they had an assembly and they they're sort of like PBIS is work respect belong and they give little certificates

077and everything and all the kids were coming into the gym and my parents are just sitting there and there's just kind of an awe because everybody's in line it's loud principal holds up the zero all the kids quiet they sit down they're respectful they cheer for one another and my parents like how does this is how does this happen and I was like well that's PBIS that's tier one supports that's expectations that's everybody understands that we're ruin in this community this is how we act and this is how we respond and they were still rambunctious and fun and all the things but it was pretty incredible to just see when you have those strong tier ones and the PBIS how um incredible it can make those experiences for kids and teachers and everybody so yeah

078for sure and I think that the the earlier that we were doing those things I mean like elementary schools is perfect you know for exactly what that intervention is and the other part that I go back to a lot is that the best prevention is connection right when we are in community that prevents you know I mean things in the future so I think that that is the overarching goal of all of this um how we use a climate survey why we do PBIS why we're looking at mtss um all of those things so thank you I don't see any additional lights on so I I do just want to emphasize what um member lold um was sharing is that even though you see a and others we you see a decrease in our overall

079suspension rates we do still suspend but you see definitely a decline and that's a good thing because we are really spending our efforts on you know positive behavior reinforcement teaching of strategies addressing behaviors in different ways whether it's in school suspension or alternative suspension so we want to make sure that the community and our staff I know sometimes questions too is is why are we not sus speaking those students or why can't we just get you know um you know send them home but we are really trying our very best to keep kids in school but also re to address their behaviors in different ways to teach those students uh appropriate behaviors to make sure we do remove them from those settings and put them in alternative to suspension opportunities but we still have them

080in school learning and growing because that's what we're striving to do is trying to keep our kids um with us in community with us in school so thank you for everything you're doing um gentlemen and your team much appreciated yeah thank you everybody next up chair dere eer we have one additional presentation uh I have executive director Zo and executive director uh sance uh coming to the table they're going to provide a budget update so I'll just turn it over to both of them good good evening um we both we just didn't want to inter interrupt each other um we're just going to bring tonight um an update on where we where we are at with our budget reduction timeline uh that's what um executive director Severance will be doing and uh it's going to

081be short but uh we're open to any questions uh so as we discussed I think last month uh we are moving forward with displacements and that process did happen um through last week Communications were um had with the employees that would be affected and then letters were sent out on Friday to all of those affected employees we do have a session uh tomorrow at the f for the teaching um staff that were affected just a Q&A drop in and we'll answer any questions that they can from 3 to five so if they have questions we've also reached out if they can't make that certainly call HR or the DFT president all willing to help answer the questions um there were a number that were not um teachers and so I'm working with the par professional

082Union to have conversations with their staff as well and then we did have um there's other non-certified staff that actually were laid off or given layoff notices of course these don't go into effect till the end of June so there may be some internal changes where they can also um secure other positions before that time frame comes we do have a second round based on registration for the secondaries once that closes we will have a second round potentially depending on what that gives us for results for what classes need to be on um what are going to be offered for the secondary schools and that will take place mid mid March member lold does that mean a second round of potential uh letters of of displacement yes ah okay superintendent Magus sure and just to

083point out for the public and I know we've talked about it at the board table quite a bit but the difference between displacement and layoff the displacement means that you're separated from your current position position with the the district but you're still employed by the district and layoff if if it should come to layoff that would occur uh in in the late spring early summer uh just because that that's when we would know what is our final result with our budget and and where are we with state aid and and enrollment and several other things so it's something that we we look at very closely I would also say that because people have been informed over the course of the past week that some of the things that we've talked about as far as what

084areas might be reduced that those are more public now so you might have people advocating about about for against certain things and so uh we um encourage you to have that individuals let us know if they have concerns but also if you have concerns or questions feel free to reach out at any time and we're glad to answer any questions related to some of the changes that are in effect chair Derek eer um could you just remind me again when was the when was the final notice or the due date to let for staff to let us know when their retirements the date uh is was February 1st February 1st okay and I believe the last number of folks that will be going at the end of the year so we have some that have

085already happened of course I'm not including those were 12 which is a lot less than we typically have in any given year since I've been here there are different calendar and there are different calendars that have different dates besides February 1st but the certified teachers are February 1st so administrators and others are on on a different timeline but we uh we keep keep track of all of that as well member banks and then member loo thank you so um you you say displacement uh so when folks are displaced are they eligible for unemployment insurance so the displacement just means that at the the end of this school year if they haven't secured a position then they we have to do something else with them so they're it depends and I hate to use that as

086an example or as the answer um but if they are a tenear teacher then we are obligated to find them a position or lay them off which um superintendent megas mentioned would happen in that time frame of kind of late late spring early summer if they are a um non-tenured teacher they would be likely not non-renewed do not I'm not sure if that is unemployment eligible or not but if they are laid off they absolutely would be able to go through that process they can all of the folks that wouldn't have a position for next school year would be eligible but they are paid through the summer so that is one thing too so it really is more dependent on what happens at the beginning of the school year than it is in the spring

087so so fair to say that right now we don't have any layoff they're all displaced until early early late spring or early there were four layoffs because their contracts are not in a uh they don't have displacements in their contract so there were four that were given layoff notices for the end of [Music] June oh sorry my light is still on and but the question that popped into my head as as you asked is um or comment rather is that uh we are still making sure that everybody is everybody has been informed but there are a couple of different layers that we have like we mentioned with the registration process and and some other things um so some people have asked can we have a list of all the the layoffs or or displacements and

088and can we know the bigger picture and we want to make sure that we share that information when we're when we're able to but we also want to be thoughtful about uh individuals and individual circumstances rather than have things shared publicly before um before people can be well informed and have opportunities like we have tomorrow to have questions answered we're really trying to make sure that there are those safety nets for our our staff we we we care about them and we want to make sure that we have answers for them related to some of the questions that they may have chair I don't see additional questions or light um that concludes our clegend for uh for this evening thank you we are adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.