001welcome to isd709 and to the community that's here Community that's watching this is a hearing so this isn't a typical regular you know formal Schoolboard meeting it is a hearing and it is the duth public schools it's isd709 it is 619 it is December 19th 17th I was just going with those nines and again we just want to welcome CFO business manager Simone zunich to present and we will turn it over to business manager zunich thank you and good evening I think Patty's going to cast for us we'll just give her a second here while we're working on the casting I'll I'll start with my what would be the ending praise and say Simone has been working extremely executive director zunich has been working extremely hard on this and uh has worked very hard on
002the audit many near sleepless nights and um extremely extremely grateful for all your hard work thank you superintendent okay I see we we have our my document cast and I want to say good evening to everyone uh welcome to the um Deluth Public Schools Independent School District 709 the 2024 payable 2025 property tax hearing this is for the school budget year of July 1 of 2024 through June 30th of 25 uh this hearing document was prepared by superintendent Magus um Simone zunich and Michael hoisel from uh Barrett and Company so the first thing we're going to talk about is the requirements of the truth and Taxation hearing um tonight we'll be showing you our proposed changes our specific purposes for changes and um our current current year budget and our distribution of our Revenue by
003Revenue source and how we're spending by program area and then we will open to any public comments and questions and we are following Minnesota statute 27565 tonight and I also would like to say if there's anyone from the community or listening if you do have a question about your property tax statement please email me and I will work with you directly and the county to get any answers for you excuse me I'm got a little tickle in my throat here can I can I interrupt just with that and say that um you know so thank you for reminding how our community can help understand the um property tax and I just want to share that I've watched mayor reinert's um video of how he explains the property statements and the property tax and um I
004think ours will be the same you look at that but I just think that that was a great way for getting the message out for the community so we'll show this too on our on our site thank you I appreciate that okay so the school district levy and School District funds um our taxes are Le taxes okay I'm all right taxes are levied in the fall of 2024 that's what I will be asking you tonight for adoption and are payable in and collected in 2025 and then we will see that Revenue in the 2526 school year so it's a three-year cycle our school district funds are based off of our general fund Levy which is based on student enrollment Our Community Education fund Levy is based on the population of the district and it also
005includes Community Education Revenue youth services and after school Revenue our early childhood family education Levy is based on number of children under the five years under five years of age in the district and our next is our debt service fund Levy and that is based on our annual debt retirement schedules and the annual Levy is what is needed to pay the principal and interest payments of bonded debt uh now that 5% represents um the fact that we actually Levy for 105% and that is because if our property taxes are not fully collected uh we basically need um a little savings account there to make our payments and our debt service fund may be composed of voter approved bonds as well as non voter approved approved bonds such as abatement bonds alternative facility bonds Capital Equipment
006notes Capital facilities bonds and long-term facilities maintenance bonds so okay um next is how will your payable 25 school taxes be spent um their general fund which provides funding for district regular and special education instructional programs including but not limited to support services Transportation instructional athletic and operational Equipment Technology and building maintenance that will make up roughly 38.2% Our Community Education fund is funding for our community at programs and early childhood family education and School Readiness is 1.7% and of course our debt service fund is our Levy for repayment of principal and interest on District debt which will make up 6.20% for a total of 100% okay so the school district levy is actually going down this year uh by 2.86% uh that comes to 1,323 441.87 and as we go through I'll kind of
007explain how we got there okay so the current school year budget that'll be the next piece we're going to discuss um this is our our budget our revenue and expenses that was adopted last June 30th um I'll I won't go by each fund but to the far right the total revenues was $174,600 uh $691,000 and our expenses are $179 sorry milliion 3923 4 so we are we submitted our budget at being overspent by 4,749 we have a couple of slides here pie charts for you to review um how for visual people um our Revenue by Source our state aid is 60.84 per our federal aid is 7.48% and 75.2 n% of our revenue is tied to our general fund okay and now page 11 we'll look at our expenditures and um 76% of our general
008fund is uh our expenditures are tied to our general fund by 76% our food service is 3% Community Ed fund is 5% our debt is 15% and our internal service and our gifts and bequests those are our fundraisers our little Student Activity accounts page 12 here we have it broken down by object code the object code in our seven 17 digit series um eup fars code identifies the service or commodity of the expenditures so we have it broken down for you by salaries and benefits the utilities supplies equipment debt service is not part of fund one and our gifts and requests and then we also have a v um lovely pie chart at that has it broken down for you page 14 now we have it broken down for you by program and this kind
009of uh encompasses all the as aspects of our District Operations including instructional admin and various support activities so we're looking at it how we spend the money and buy the programs as well and then page 15 is another pie chart for those that uh I like my pie looking at a pie charts too I think it's easier to understand okay now we're on page 16 uh on May 14th we had a capital projects Levy um referendum it did not pass we gave you our some information there uh yes votes and no votes the yes votes was at 47.84 per and our no votes were at 52.6 we gave you an excuse me another reminder as well of our referendum we asked for on November 7th for Bond refunding and capital projects Levy the bond refunding
010um we it saved the District of roughly 2.6 million annually that passed um again the capital projects Levy did not pass there were yes votes of 49.5% and no votes of 50.5 and then we added this one more time we did this for you last year as well just some his historical information on the November 6 2018 operating Levy referendum okay yes let's talk about student enrollment now um first of all I'd like to say from 13 14 school year all the way to the left and all the way to the right to the 2324 we are slowly trending back up again as you can see in 1314 our adjusted pupil units that's the bottom line uh was 9,122 kind of dipped down a little bit and kept going down and then back in 1920
011went back up to 901 went back down again and we're slowly coming back up again so I'm very um hopeful and enthusiastic about that okay page 21 this is showing you how our tax base is here in duth the composite um 46.4 one% um is our residential homesteads 24.9% is our commercial industrial and the other big one is our residential non-homestead which our our rentals is 24 a little over 24% page 22 uh we're going to look now look at how our state aid and local levies determined good stuff yeah so um The Authority for school levies um a school district levy may be either set by state formula or voter approved so on page 24 we have our general fund gross Lev comparison I won't go through each line but I will point out
012line number 11 our long-term facilities Levy uh we're taking a negative adjustment there of 1,561 and um that also uh corresponds to line 410 on the actual Levy these are always Levy adjustments that we're seeing two years later we I've talked to the Department of Education and we will recoup These funds in two years line number 12 oh CAD que go yeah line number 12 we took another large adjustment of 476,000 building lease Levy I wanted to um explain that one as well that is when we had the lease at uhg and because of the crossover from July to September we had to take the adjustment for that and then there's a small abatement Levy of $78,000 okay on page 25 we now have our Community Education Levy um again these are always adjustments what
013you see in red our basic Community Ed Levy um usually that's a formula change went down $37,000 our adults with disabilities Levy went down $9,000 the one that's more difficult to look at is the school Age Care Levy and when I talk to the Department of Education I I Levy for this every year I make sure it goes in there but we did not have any expenses in there in the 2223 school year because it's always two years behind um when I talked to the Departments they simply could not find any hires for these afternoon programs we had some hires last year um but not we did not go all the way up to that 990,000 so we'll continue to Levy for it but we will have to take adjustments if we don't fully expend
014that money uh home visit Levy went down $24 and a baits of $5,185 okay now we're on page 26 um this is our debt service and this is how we restructured our debt so the first line of voter approved Debt Service Le Levy um so we had a payment in n in 2024 for our debt they when we restructured and passed this question we restructured it so there would not have to be a payment this year in 2025 this spring but we will be making a payment in year three and so that is why we have um the adjustment of a million n right there but we also don't have to make a payment in the spring for our debt and um debt excess we had um some adjustments in 23 24 in 2425 but
015it actually is to the good of 516 129 an abatement um adjustments of 119,000 okay so all of our funds together now on page 27 all told our gross Levy which was matching on the slides that we saw in the beginning is 1 million3 and um you know we our our property tax debt to our uh residents is going down 2.86% so I mean I'm happy about that as well that um they won't be seeing any increased taxes on the school side this year so our debt um our percentage for our Levy is went down 2.86% so we won't be asking any we'll actually see an adjustment for all of our residents to go down and I'll be showing that in a couple slides here um this one is really VIs visual it shows you
016what in 2020 the levy was was at40 million and then in 25 it's now up to 449 so you can see how we've trended up and the next uh items are what are the main variables that may cause property tax increases and decreases one of course are changes in Market values changes in class rates in history market value exclusions there's a a newly adjusted pay 25 credit amount um voter approved referendums State adjustments a new programs authorized or mandated by legislature so overall the property taxes the valuations went up in duth so overall basically we have to ours everything will come down but if you bought a house this last spring and that house really was you know exceeded anything that was more than the average you will have to pay an increased property tax
017but for the most part everybody's is going down on the school side page 30 the changes in market value the market values are final and are not a subject for the upcoming budget hearings they were discussed at the local County board of review and County Board of Equalization hearings held earlier this year the final taxable M uh Market values may reflect a reduction Under The Limited value law if this property is a qualifying Homestead the final taxable Market values may exclude improvements which you have made to your properties um Barrett and I talked about this we we gave you a copy on page 31 the new statute regarding market value exclusions I won't read this word for word right now but you can read it so we wanted just to provide that for you and
018for our public page 32 is just another tax base history for people to see how things have changed and then on page 33 so if on your property tax statement you had no increase to your property tax value um if you look under residential Homestead and where look find the number please for the 285,000 according to the Department of Revenue data that is the average price of a home in duth so if you go all the way to the right if you had no increase to your property value your percent will go down 10.67% in the amount you pay we wanted to give you a range here and if you go to the next page if your property went up six and a half% so for the same value home of 285,000 to the far
019right your tax statment went down for the school at 4.20% so we just wanted to show the range for you so the last page 35 is our resolution whereas pursuant to Minnesota statute the school board of Independent School District 709 is authorized to make the following proposed tax levies for general purposes and you you will also find this resolution in your packet your board packet for tonight okay comments and questions so if we went to page six I think it is I think it's page six it's about the district's lease Levy decreasing is that on page six is that um actually it's a little bit more further down here where I'll find it for for you so the lease Levy did get adjusted because of the uhg lease um when we entered that into our
020our summer Levy we have to enter the value for the whole school year but we left in September and we had made the payment in July so they made that adjustment because we were not there the full year but we levied for the whole year is that the adjustment 476 911 okay yes PID 20 24 okay okay that's correct and then um just lots of good things like on on page 27 and 29 I think or just the you know so we have to remember this and this data we should have in our brochures when we go out door knocking for our next Levy or referendum that you know in actuality in this coming year property taxes schools portion has gone down by 2.86% and if the city is claiming theirs also stayed level so
021we would assume that if if your property taxes go up it's the county that is correct okay yes we all just kind of play a shell game between all of those three entities when we're wanting to share with our public but thank you for sharing that too other questions member ller Kemp yeah and then member eer I uh appreciated the information uh on the enrollments uh changes and um um this is always gets a little complicated in terms of particular the public understanding it but um uh the difference between ADM and adjusted pupil units um which method of student count is the funding source for this formula just to clarify it for the public thank you on page 20 where we saw our student enrollment that bottom line where it says adjusted pupil units that
022is how our BAS our basic formula is composed of that number times our basic formula allowance so that 89988 times our basic formula that does get confusing you know the ADM versus the adjusted pupil unit thank you and on page three just a question um Early Childhood family education children under 5 years of age in the in the district is that in the district that are going to our schools or is that people who live in our district that might not even have children in school excuse me that would be people in our district uh we're working on a census right now um with early our early childhood department and Gathering data from the county as well um we've had to pay for a file you know it costs like $15 we've we've paid for
023a file to get accurate num so um we can truly hopefully predict how many um school age kids we will be getting so again District means these are kids that are enrolled in our district well they potentially could be there are residents yes correct just to clarify that is from the Census of um this last census whenever that was done yeah I'm sorry that the the the the information you're getting from the county it's the census data that is correct thank you and then um just another Point sort of an educational point where School Board who I always like to make sure we continue to educate um unlike the county and the city school boards don't set their own Levy that's done by the Minnesota Department of Education that is correct there's a small amount
024of information I enter every August into the Department of Education and um I put in transportation information all of our leases and the actual costs that we had to pay for our leases any new leases um and um OPB data which is from our Actuarial so there's like five or six different things we have to enter but that is all set by the Department of Education we cannot set our Levy as opposed to a city so we can't set our Levy as opposed to a city and then we also have um a basic formula that's given to us um set by the state and then any additional monies that we seek out we have to go out to the voters and the public and seek that money which is unique to school districts and looks
025different than it does for other um municipalities and counties correct very true thank you thank you um member Mike cell and then member zidow thank you for all your hard work on this I know that it's a busy time of year um when it comes to all this information needing to be published for the um public um I'm looking at page 12 in our expenditures by code and just noting where there's um big jumps from previous years and so seeing that our salaries and benefits are up by nearly $10 million compared to last year and are you able to comment on like what are some of the things that go went into that increase sure well last year we had um Esser funds as well but uh mostly we have um contract settlements and then
026you know people move up on their uh lane or step uh but mostly due to contract settlements great thank you um obviously making sure that we you know have um good paying jobs for our staff our talented staff is important um and so seeing that reflected there and then also looking and seeing that um supplies and our equipment those have both gone down um by significant uh $4 million or $3 million and I was wondering if you can comment on that um also due to Esser we had Esser spending last year and this year it went away so we had to adjust and go back to what we were spending on supplies and equipment sure four years ago um my last question is then um we the public did um vote Yes on one of
027our um requests um for additional Levy where is that um two point whatever million dollars reflected within the budget then so that's a really good question thank you for asking so before it was in our general fund and we made our debt payment out of our G general fund but by refunding it and we were able to pass that question it now moved to fund seven to our debt service so now we are able to Levy for that P the principle and the interest and that was that page where I explained we did have a payment in 2024 in the spring it was structured so there won't be a payment now in the spring of 25 but we will go back to being able to make a payment in 26 thank you so much thank
028you memb Sadowski and then member banks I have a couple questions um first I'm looking on page 16 where it talks about our May 14th 20124 capital projects Levy but um it was also referred to as a tech Levy do you want to speak to um the difference there sure um those those names are commonly interchanged so we can call it a tech Levy or a capital Levy it's that simple yeah I thought I remembered that thank you for clarifying and then could you go back to page 25 for the school Age Care Levy I want to make sure I'm understanding that piece correctly um so we Levy for that every year up to $90,000 but they look at our expenses two years back and two years ago they were not able to um code
029anything to that after school care they simply could not find people to to work the jobs it's it's um anywhere from an hour and a half to two and a half hours a day and it's at the end of the day so our PA professionals or our support staff work during the day and it's not easy to find someone that can come in those afternoons and and honestly last year we had expenditures of a little over $24,000 so I'm going to see another we're going to see another uh adjustment at our next Levy next year and then um but they're working diligently to try and find um you know people to work in the program so what I'm hearing is our Levy is kind of based on what we've spent 100% from two years ago
030okay and that's why we'll see a lot of ltfm adjust adust Ms because if the project wasn't finished or they were even unable to start it but yet we put it on our 10-year plan for our Levy and they weren't able to do anything they essentially take the money away but we can always make up for it um we can try and get it done that same year but again it'll be two years before we even see the money again thank you um can we go to page 14 please Shir just a quick question related to the um special education instruction can you um give us some kind of prognosis as to uh whether or not this is going to increase or go down or um I'm just curious as to it's a it's these
031are incredible expenditures but with regard to special education instruction what are the needs there well um they are increasing every year and we have uh we have to hold to a maintenance of effort so whatever we spent last year we have to spend that much or more the next year because we cannot deny anyone services and um yes the um special education instruction is very high um I read a great article today in the duth News Tribune and it is is um an issue for most districts across the state and we're all you know trying to um you know make it work um whatever isn't covered by the cross subsidy and the regular Aid the uh general fund pays for thank you for asking member laugher Kemp yeah I was I was just looking up
032where that article came from uh that I thought was MPR and I just before I commented on that I wanted to make sure I it was an excellent article and I'm glad you brought that up and your question as well um member banks um I um I I thought the article really gave a great understanding of our district even though it didn't highlight our district but what the needs are and and why we've also been lobbying so strongly uh for more funding for special education uh with our legislative agenda um but that wasn't my question my question went back to uh the chart number 13 on the page uh 13 and I just think that I I hope that this chter is really highlighted because and the the page before that um and I am
033really proud that um we 86% of our budget is Staff uh and uh staff across the district and I I just um really I think we have incredible staff in our district we've attracted staff from other districts because of um are are are are great place to work and and and um I just really appreciated uh this particular chart uh and how how it highlighted um really where our money goes um uh is in people and where people business as we all know and um uh and uh so thank you for that uh important chart you're welcome so I I hope this um provided enough um answers for you uh and for the public um there's there are a lot of components to the levy and um what we you know present to our public
034and uh we'll continue to move forward and do our best I see that superintendent Magus has his light on too but you summarized things so well so I can I can leave it there but um just the the chart that you pointed out from page 13 I think that really speaks a lot to the U the budget work that we're we're doing right now to to see we've been saying 83 to 85% but it's actually 86% of our our U expenditures are staff and or salary staff salaries and benefits and this year we took 2.6 million out of other areas largely that's why the 5 million that we have left to reduce unfortunately is going to have greater impact on on staff and so I think it's a very clear illustration of of that I
035also think many of the other points that were made related to uh the difference between cities and and counties not having to to uh go out to taxpayers to for Levy increase I think that's really vital for people to understand because when it comes to voting for a referendum or not uh there's a lot of research that says that that people will if if there's one thing that can control and say no to they're going to they're going to say no to that that one thing that they finally have control of when when the three other or two other entities uh can't uh be part of that but again as I started things I just want to say thank you uh your your insights your uh thoughtfulness your re resource uh is just um unparalleled
036and very very greatly appreciated and I think that's why masbo the the state organization appreciates having you as a presenter because of the skills you bring not just to the district but the state thank you very much and now do we have an an opportunity for any community members to come forward and ask a question isn't that part of tonight they can certainly but if they have a particular question about their own property um I we can take that by email because I'd have to look into it if there's a particular question we'll move the podium over if there are questions you come up to the podium hi um just looking at page five um I see that our total taxes are going 60% to debt and I obviously don't know much about managing a
037school budget but I was wondering if we have information on how we compare to other districts in our debt to you know um that I can easily get that um I'd have to research another District but are you talking about the area districts it it if you know something comparable sure you know locally or otherwise I definitely can get that for you um you know essentially we like to see the general fund and The Debt Service fund to be 5050 um but because of some restructuring that we've had to do we've we've taken on like with our long-term facility maintenance Bond we do have some additional so that um you know changed it to 60.2% and 38.2 ideally we always try want to strive to it should be more 5050 but I can certainly get
038you that information Julian that would be great Simone okay thank you thank you any other questions from our community thank you thank you very thank you this concludes Our Truth and [Applause] Taxation and then we'll just give three minutes or so to refigure the live stream and to um just reset for our regular school board meeting thank you for staying to for those of you that are waiting to