CorpusRecord 93025

BOE Regular recurrent meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Zoom User
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Caswell County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,258 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001thank you uh approval of the agenda Mr L is there a second Miss Smith any discussion if not all in favor raise your hand post motion's carried thank you announcements miss you have yes sir um Mr bdan is here to recognize um bus drivers thank you Miss GW members of board um our November and October and November board uh drivers of the month are not able to be here for uh prior conflicts uh for the month of October it was Thomas long for the secondary and um Jer uh Jerome Stanfield uh for elementary he he drives for South Elementary and our November drivers are Joanne Williams for elementary she is at Oakwood and U Leslie Crow who is a teacher at Dill like to congratulate them all right thank you Mr any more announc all

002right public comments m Kim have anything than sir all right thank you very much all right we move into reports uh the first one is Bluebird and Blossom fuels team propane bus presentation Mr again thank you again I'd like to introduce uh Kirk Burns he's with Bluebird and Michaela um they're going to start off presentation and we've also got a representative from blossoms uh who does the uh um the actual propane and any questions for him and what they need to say I'm just going to turn it over to thank you good morning how's everybody doing all right stand up the whole time so we understand there's some interested propane buses here in Caswell County so uh we were we're very grateful for the opportunity to come in just kind of talk to you a

003little bit about propane itself some IND industry data we have here in North Carolina talk real briefly about the product and then just show you some total call savings from going from a diesel bus to a propane but so um as I'm going through this please if you have any questions uh you please uh feel free just to ask me as I'm going through the presentation I'm a big guy wait just a minut Mr T would you DM that the lights in the back where we can see a little bit better you want me to slide over to the side so you see this are you okay looking at this okay okay yeah that's that's much better yeah just a little bit of Industry data um about propane in general so there are more than

00422,000 propan power school buses in North America and of the 25 major school districts in in the United States 25 19 of them are operating uh running propane buses so when you look at the information like from Chicago Angeles Houston Miami uh propane's an actual great alternative fuel source for school districts now that are looking to go environmentally friendly on their products and also to save them some money over the lifetime of of of the bus in North Carolina alone we've we've got 14 counties now that are running propa power school buses um Charlotte meca is our largest county uh in the state they're running close to 130 propane powered school buses now um we're also the dealer for South Carolina and in South Carolina they're running close to 400 propane powered school buses U

005two 230 of those are are the bluebird uh buses so why are the counties really going from diesel product um over to the propane side there's really two primary reasons one is there's substantial cost savings with respect to fuel cost maintenance downtime and maintenance cost related to a propane product versus a diesel product um and as important is it promotes cleaner environment for the children for the drivers for the community um I did put the website down at the bottom here and I'll encourage you when you get a chance to to access the Ral clean tech website and I'll give you I think I've fored copy of the presentation so you all get a copy of it but please look at some of these school districts here like at Bradford area that's in Pennsylvania Indian

006River um which is down in the Miami area Newport News up in Virginia all of them have switched over or transitioned over to ProPay pirate school buses and they've got some great case studies is testimonials from the customers on why they're going from from diesel product over to prop propane itself for those that don't know there's a lot of questions about whether propane is going to be around and is it just kind of like a a little bit of an interim solution to clean alternative fuels uh versus compressed natural gas or an EV product um for those that don't know propane is really a byproduct of any kind of petroleum based U manufacturing process that we have going on in the United States so for diesel gasoline compressed natural gas all those industries of byproduct

007that is propane the United States produces so much propane that we actually export 60% of our propane to other countries um so it's a significant um resource that's available to us um in the United States so therefore um it promotes energy independence with respect to us being able to use domestically produced fuel source and at the same time provide a product that's clean for the environment and healthy for the children the one unique thing about propane uh the cost of propane propane since is produced domestically um it's not really um it's not um allowed to fluctuate in the market like a lot of the diesel prices gasoline prices so anything any of the macroeconomic factors that come into play that drives the cost of gasoline or diesel fuel up um propane is not impacted by

008that because it's a domestically produced fuel if you look at historical pricing data over a 20-year period for the cost of propane it it fluctuates maybe anywhere from five to eight cents per gallon over a period of time so in terms of budgeting when you're looking at your maintenance cost and budgeting for fuel cost um it's a much more friendly um fuel source to be able to consistently be able to plan and you're not going to exceed your budget when you when you forecast how much propan you're going to be using for propane is on the state contract and right now the gallon of propane uh on the current contract is runs anyone anywhere from a140 to $145 per gallon um I think they're in the process of redoing the state contract if I'm not

009Mist correctly um so they're redoing that as we speak um the one thing that I do want to share with you I know there's a lot of information on this slide here and the things that I want to the one thing I want to point out here is that the propane product right now already meets the emissions requirements for 2027 and all the way out to 2031 so all these changes that are for the diesel product that are that are going to take place in 2027 where they're going to have to add additional components to the buses um and the complexity of the diesel product moving forward is just going to increase well the propane product right now already meets all those emissions requirements uh for for the EPA so we're we're decades ahead of

010the the the technology side of things so here are some examples of some Propane fuel stations that you would that you could put in place and these are pretty large operations here um here's a small setup here I think this is probably how size take is it you think that's probably 500 gallon tank 500 gallon tank so the one good thing about a propane opportunity is that you can start out purchasing one propane bus um then go to five then go to 10 make your way up to you know 75 100 school buses the the Propane fuel stations are scalable so essentially you don't have to replace anything the only thing you really need to do is just replace the fuel tanks that additional capacity for your for your operation the good thing about the

011uh the propane fueling stations as well is that they're portable right so if you want to put a location um at your main School bus garage put a fueling station there you want to put one offside at a school district or at a satellite location um they're very they're very portable and they're scalable so it makes it pretty uh pretty flexible for the for the end user the one thing we always get a question about on the buses is that you know when you think about propane everybody immediately thinks about explosion how unsafe the buses are um and the reality is the school bus um fuel tank that's on the bluebird powered uh propane powered school bus is 20 times stronger than the diesel fuel tank that you currently run on your diesel bus there's

012a link here on this slide and you'll have this I encourage you to go to the link um they've done some testing on the fuel tanks where they've had some you know I call them gun enthusiasts that have tried to penetrate a fuel tank to try to blow it up with it completely full and it just shows you how strong that the fuel tanks are in the Integrity of the tanks themselves so when you think about propane um it's not one of those it's not like a ticking Time Bomb where essentially you know if a vehicle hits the propane bus it's automatically going to explode we've got over 22,000 propane powered school buses running in North America and we've had zero related incidents related to propane explosions fires or anything like that the system in

013itself is designed with multiple cut off features so in the event that there is an incident and there's a break in the continuity of the propane liquid liquid propane injection system itself the shut off valves automatically uh enable and it disables the whole system so you're not going to have propane um leaking everywhere and you're not going to have the potential for any kind of fire hazard or anything like that so I would encourage you to take a look at that video it kind of kind of underscores just how strong the tanks are uh and on our Bluebird vision bus as well the fuel tanks are positioned in between their frame rails the same location where your diesel fuel tanks located and we put still reinforcements just like we do on our diesel product and

014our gasoline products we put still reinforcements on the side of the frame rails and on the rear of the frame rails so there's any kind of side impact damage it drives that Force underneath the bus rather than into the directly head on into the the side of the bus um I'm going to go through this just for time um I did some total cost analysis for you um and this is just hypothetically speaking let's say that you were to replace uh 10 of your diesel buses uh in the county with propane power school buses um your total cost savings over a 20year period for that bus is a little over a three4 of a million dollars now that cost savings is just related to fuel cost and your preventive maintenance servicing cost it doesn't include

015any other components or any other kind of Maintenance Dam time or anything like that that is just your total fuel cost savings and your total cost savings on your engine oil your engine filters your coolants and all what we call top off fluid levels those type of things so it's significant dollars and obviously as you add additional buses that call savings is going to increment exponentially increase over over a period of time the important thing to remember North Carolina and youall are well aware of this uh North Carolina keeps their buses for 20 years right um or 250,000 mies which is a really really long time um Most states don't keep their buses as long as North Carolina does um so we offer a 5y year 100,000 mile warranty on all of our buses um

016so for five years we take care of everything ourself U but for that remaining 15 years while you on the bus all the operating costs all the repair costs all the maintenance costs falls back onto the county right so when you think about total cost savings for the county when you think about Fuel and just um your your preventive maintenance cost it's significant cost savings with just 10 buses and so you take a county like Charlotte M that runs 140 or South Carolina that runs you know close to 400 propane Pate school buses the money they're saving every year just on fuel and maintenance costs is in the millions of dollars U I know Caswell countyy is not as large as those counties but again as you increase your Fleet and add propane and replace

017your older diesel products with a propane product you're going to see some significant cost saves this gives you an idea um on the additional cost per bus on a diesel bus compared to a propane the one thing about a propane bus is it doesn't it doesn't have all the emissions related components on it like a diesel bus the transportation director he can tell you right out of the shoot how complex the emissions related components are on the diesel buses how costly they are to repair and this just kind of gives you a snapshot of some of the components over that 15year period that you're going to have to cover the cost for the repair of what kind of money you're talking to over a 20-y year period that you know for 10 buses and these

018are conservative numbers here um that we put together that's $342,000 that you could save above and beyond your fuel savings and your preved maintenance cost savings as well so but anyhow when you get time I encourage you to kind of look into the the details on that so so why propan just to sum it up um it's uh obviously it's uh in terms of your total call savings over the life of the bus significant dollars but most importantly um it's an environmental family friendly product um that's healthy for the community it's a great alternative fuel Choice electric buses are great compress natural gas buses are great we sell all those types of platforms ourselves but we definitely try to steer customers into go into the propane route because it's a little bit more of a

019user friendly fuel source alternative fuel and still meets the emissions requirements and the safety requirements that are set out by the EPA in Clips here from Thompson um I mean from Bloss mon I'm sorry we deal with a couple of uh Auto gas suppliers but um they they will come in and essentially set the the system up your fuel station up uh at no upfront cost for you so it's kind of like a turnkey operation they do all the permitting they provide the equipment they'll set it up in any location for you so essentially it makes it makes an easy transition when you got a company like blossman that's kind of partner with with a school bus uh vendors to kind of sell products so this is the last slide here the propane bus is

020the only bus really from day one that you're going to start saving money uh if you start running a propane bus um and again you know we're all stewards of taxpayer money is obviously we you know we all pay taxes we want to be smart about our money and we want a good quality product that's not going to cost us an arm and leg to run over 20e period and we think the propane product um is is a great solution for that so any questions for me by chance on propane what's the initial cost of a blossom propane bus uh standard size bus the blue the 72 passenger the additional cost is $14,988 but the state of North Carolina covers that cost now okay y yeah so in terms of the county itself um it

021won't be any cost to the county to to go propy okay and they've been covering that cost now for five years maybe six years ever since we've been selling buses which is which is a great great incentive for the counties to kind of switch over okay Mr V I just had a question I know you said that with propane it's $140 per gallon how many miles per gallon does a diesel bus get and how many miles per gallon does a propane a great question um on average a diesel bus gets anywhere from 7 and a half miles a gallon to 8 miles a gallon and the propane bus gets six miles to go the cost of the fuel um so on a tank on the 72 passenger you'll actually have 100 gallon fuel tank in

022there so you'll be able to go 425 miles on a full tank of fuel thank you how many uh school systems in North Carolina is using propane thing uh there's 14 currently using uh propane and the counties are in the Pro the states in the process of purchasing additional buses right now and we're adding six additional counties so we'll be up to 20 counties all together running propane power school buses all right Joe mechanic training yes so what will our mechanics have to go through to be able to work on these buses up to initial War period that's another great question um after the warranty period um we'll have the Rous clean tech guys come in and do some on-site training for your for your mechanics um the the unique thing about the propane bus

023it's a Ford engine it's a it's a V8 um Ford engine platform a lot of the mechanics are very familiar with with automobile engines that's essentially what it is but the Rous clean tech and the bluebird training program we'll get your guys set up to do that was there there's no cost for you guys to do that okay anybody else thank you sir thank you very much for your time we appreciate it congratulations to the board members thank thank you thank you Mr bdon is there a timeline uh for the board do you need to make them aware of anything based on this presentation for the next board meeting or I was notified by DP that the uh the purchase we we are up for one bus replacement this year one bus one bus and

024it is an EC bus which I think is going propane the EC is especially um would be smart to do because when you're using that the lift that child is sitting back there where the fans are right um I believe she said by the end of December we would have to make our final decision on what style bus we wanted to do and I have told then to make that decision if we're going to switch to the program so one question about they said no upfront cost with the fuing station so you come in and set the tank set the pump station and everything and as long as the County agrees to buy fuel from Blossom is that kind of the way it works yes we work on a contract the only upfront cost would

025be with the the electrical side of getting that and Stu like thatr located the ground or whatever but other that no upfront cost at all and we also provide training twice a year people so if we continue going propane buses and we decide to add more filling stations y'all are willing to do that yes okay anyone else okay I'm sorry M I just want to thank Mr B for his bus that was in the in parate it was very cute make that was Da right yes pictures for your sometime today during the meeting Jeff's got the pictures and he can show them thank you thank you okay okay next is uh be Title One budget update MERS you all should have a copy of the budget update that I provided to miss kimry this is

026provided to you based on a request from Miss G so what I did was I indicated the total allocation and the amount spent so far this year Miss Gwenn has asked me moving forward if I could provide this along with Miss Underwoods let me ask you a question sure once we passed uh by Diller and no the numbers are are low it is is it because they have not decided what they're going to do or how they going to spend that money well they all have a preliminary budget plan that they have um in terms of spending Bley ansy and D Middle School are a bit different because they have hired Personnel okay so what we have done is we have deded deducted the total cost for their instructional coaches Okay so we've set that

027money aside for the year um North elementaries is slightly higher because they started having tutors earlier than the other other elementary schools so we have actually deducted November's payroll costs from their Title One budget okay one last question we had a good amount of money for carryover to this year yes sir will we have that for next year or will we expend most of those funds um the purpose of the funds for us to expend those funds um we've actually been flagged by DPI for having such a large carryover that's not the intention of the funding um so that's not our intention to have the carryover amount that we had this year um but we will have some carryover we won't have um a total amount spending and actually um Miss GW and I worked

028together when we had the initial allocations and we did not allocate the carryover funding um to the schools but the initial allocation was all allocated to the schools directly appreciate any question Miss Beaver okay board members I would like to say that Miss beavers does a really good job of um monitoring what the schools are spending and um the title one budget she she does this work each and every day and works very hard at it so we certainly appreciate all of her hard work absolutely and I'll be glad to answer any questions I have the breakdown by school that Miss Quinn has um but those get into individual line items um and so I will provide you guys with if this is what you would like to see I'll provide this with quarterly update

029as well that' be great thank you Miss bavers sure I'm the next presentation right you're okay I apologize my little one and I do have an update to the contracted Services I apologize there was an error on the actual contract that I wrote so I wanted to make a revision for you all today before reviewed can you pass one I'm sorry I gave you to thank you so much so I wanted to um come back um to you all with the coaching proposal that was shared by Miss Quinn um during the November board meeting um based on feedback from Miss Quinn she asked for additional information in regards to um the gentleman who would actually provide the contracted service who is Marty ersin so um along with your packet you should see his um resume

030that I attached She also asked me to provide information in regards to the current districts in North Carolina that are utilizing his Services um and so that is on page two of the updated coaching proposal and you will see that he is currently working um with a few other school districts primarily um he has a um renewal contract yearly with Guilford County Schools he's also working with Stokes County in yakin county and he has a contract pending currently with Randolph County you can see from his resume um that Mr uran um has been a classroom teacher an instructional coach he has worked for ncdpi he has been an adun Professor um at UNCG and Evon I have a question sure um go ahead the results from the different counties that he has been in uh

031have you all looked at that what was the before and after I'll use giord County so what uh what kind of improvement did they see using this person sure he has shared those with me verbally but I have not asked him for those in writing I would be glad to provide that um to you all um I will say that he provides year or annually he provides the foundations of Math training um with Gilford County schools and he actually extended the opportunity for the D teachers to attend that at no cost this year since he has already contracted with Gilford County schools and they were in agreement so we do have um teachers from Dillard who are currently taking the professional development um class and so I know that that is all ongoing but I

032do not have the exact numbers in terms of his turnaround and working an knowing um because this this will be like two um meetings per month sure correct and so I would like to see what kind of data is used what kind of turnar around data sure and the purpose of the two meetings per month is I I've asked Mr ersin to have um two sessions per month and really that's directed by um our conversation and collaboration um in terms of support so one of the meetings would be a halfday planning session where he would actually um look ahead and plan with the teachers um using our Eureka Math um implementation and the other would be where he is actually with the teacher coaching co- teing um on the ground in the classrooms on the

033on that day so that's why I asked for two sessions per month and you'll see that the coaching proposal has decreased by $1,000 because I did reduce it by one session um after our conversation at the last board meeting for those to begin in January what this is there's only two schools right yes sir and the reason I chose these two schools specifically and um miss miss when and I had conversation about coaching with the lack of instructional coaches at the elementary level um I my support can be spread a bit thin in terms of how I can help teachers we have a lot of beginning teachers who need a tremendous amount of support and so these two teachers specifically are the teachers that are kind of Singletons in terms that they they are only

034the ones um producing the math data at those two schools so in hopes of trying to kind of Branch out um with some coaching and some support um knowing that I can't do all of it um this was my um starting place in terms of seeing if I can get someone in to coach teachers and provide them with the support that they need um to be successful and again started with these two because they are the two that teach that that subject on their own and they're responsible for the scores solely okay he was talking about including some of the um beginning teachers from Dillard well anything that he's going over focus more on Middle School than more than Elementary or how would he break that up if you have Dillard middle and high and

035Elementary de so um The Dillard proposal um Mr urin would support both schools but his coaching would be separate um Miss Williams will speak more on that um during the Diller proposal today but um he would actually be coaching them based on the training that they're receiving right now through the foundations of math um my coaching would be more hands on so I would want him to physically sit down and plan with teachers plan lessons um give them strategies and res resources using our eure math resources and go in and co- te and and observe them and Coach them in the classroom um so although we're using the same contracted or proposing to use the same contracted service provider the coaching will look a bit different at the elementary school in the middle school thank

036you because that's one thing I always get that you know when you sometime combine one person to both they kind of tend to coach on one and the other does not really get what they need sure and you'll see on his resume that he's actually worked across m multiple grade level spans so he's had the ability to coach um at the elementary the middle and then he taught at the high school level as well so um he has some some experience there that would give him the ability to have that range okay Miss back up to this point what uh additional help has these teachers been given because it's already December and it won't start until January and that's a half a year so what has been happening sure so I've been in the PLC

037meetings I meet with with the plc's um pretty consistently I'm not as at North as frequently um it is a bit more smooth at North in terms of their functioning plc's um but the other schools I have been there much more frequently to support the teachers I'm at Stony Creek every Monday um South every Tuesday um and at the other schools in in between there so I'm meeting with teachers planning with them I'm actually observing them providing them with coaching feedback doing walkthroughs um I've provided them with resources I provided them with planning sessions um I provided them with quite a bit of support but I know that they deserve more support and um it's just not right now it's not possible for me to provide everyone with the differentiated support that they need so

038I'm really just hoping that this would be something that could be helpful to them so that they can get the support that they need and the state also provides us with Margaret schaer who has been working with Miss bavers particularly for K2 correct she is a K2 yes she is an El which is an early literacy specialist so she she provides support for K2 teachers in the area of literacy but she does not provide math coaching or support so that falls on me anyone else um my information since I'm new at this is this contract um presented or written by Marty Ken it was not it was written by by me okay yes ma'am okay anyone else chair I'll make a motion okay I make a motion to accept the contract for elementary this one

039for elementary M Smith seconds any discussion if not all in favor the motion please raise your hand post motion carries 70 thank you thank you thank you m thank you okay now we are at contractor Services a law you do that yes board members um you all had this contract uh in the previous at the previous board meeting for um support services from Miss long for guidance at Bley yansy High School um you asked for some additional information we just wanted to make sure that we included everything in the contract that you had asked for but remember that she's been um she was used last year to help at the high school and particularly with infinite campus um and the heavy lift that that's going to take in terms of scheduling she would be an

040asset at the high school to help those two counselors with with those scheduling needs um with the transition between power school and Infinite Campus so we're just asking that you all go ahead and approve that contract from as long to work with those counselors at the high school please just one question about the compensation uh is there a scheduled amount well not to exceed X but what would a weekly or monthly schedule be four minutes long like it say so much per day how many days a week would it be well I think that would be determined by the need and the principle and the relationship that she will be having with the principal and the counselors okay and that's going to depend on need all right anyone else hearing none is there a motion

041to accept the cont contct black makes the motion there second M uh Knight in discussion if not all in favor raise your hand post just a gentle reminder for everybody uh when we vote we raise our hands a no raise means a yes vote from you uh and when you want to be recognized please raise your hand all right and uh I'm worried about that last motion right there okay all right's all right next item is consent agenda I'm sorry thec not here not here no number two is not here okay all right new business uh first item is consent agenda you have two items P listing for transportation as well as the transfer request for next school year is there a motion to D for the consent agender Mr L is there second Miss

042Smith in a discussion if not all in favor raise your hand POS motion carried 70 thank you uh next item is number two NL math coaching position all right okay board members we have principal Williams here with us this morning um to talk about the contracted services with Marty ersan good morning Miss Williams so I'm not a history teacher but I'll just explain a little bit of the history of uh how Marty got to the district um somebody gave me his name and I reached out to him early for Diller specifically and um he and I kind of went back and forth about the supports that would be needed and as you know and we all say it all the time that math is different from how we learned it um I can do sixth

043grade math it would be difficult for me to teach sixth grade math and I have four degrees um just because that is not my my area of expertise so Marty sat down with me and he did a walk through through the building and he pointed out some things some easy fixes for our teachers and he said you know what sharid I really believe that they would benefit going to this foundations of M math class and what that class does is it takes teachers and it teaches them how to break down the math to a middle school level and so we have several of our teachers going through that class the idea was that we would get them through that class which teaches them the math itself and then he would come in to provide coaching

044support so that you um inspect what you expect right we expect teachers to follow these new models what they've learned and so he would come in to provide that support and kind of stand alongside them as needed to guide them you know you have a coach on the ball field you have a coach in the classroom somebody to kind of walk alongside you with that math we have an excellent instructional coach her background is not in math and specifically our math scores say that we need somebody who understands the content and how to get that content across to the students and Marty is that person so our proposal has similarly um face-to-face observations not so much necessarily the planning piece because we've got that covered with our instructional coach so he would actually be spending

045more time going into classes working right alongside those teachers giving immediate feedback to the teachers and working with them during our planning time so there'd be no need for us to pay subs because we be working with them during their planning time as well um you can see and I'm is everybody looking at this document okay awesome so you can see that overall the change was in the negative Direction um for Dillard um from 2022 to 2024 we're looking at going backwards um and what we need to do is really give them a and push them in the right direction so that's why we are asking for these services are ah are they going to work with all your Math teachers or just targeted to aou our Math teachers your ma fantastic anyone else M

046begy um the coach we already have would she be able to interact with some of this to maybe she has actually been going to the class with the teachers so she has already started to support in that area she actually there were manipulatives and things that she said hey our teachers really need and we went ahead and ordered those things to kind of get them um that jump start that they need to using those things so we've already been she's already been in that training and she will also be prepared to support okay anyone else another question if not what is your pleas I make a motion second second um motion by Miss Blackwood second by Mr Li is the the discussion if not all in favor of the contract please raise your hand oppos

047motion scar 70 thank you thank you m Williams uh item number three uh contract for Angela yes board members if you all remember um I also brought this to your attention um at the last board meeting but there were some um some adjustments that needed to be made I'm not sure if you all have the new um the new contract but I will just make you aware of what um was discussed we would like to um contract Miss Martin's services for from now uh January the 13 through March 13 not through the end of the year um and the reason being is because we want to um monitor her Serv services and get some feedback from the teachers right now UNCG U Miss Ramos is serving 14 of our 32 beginning teachers that would leave

048Miss Martin um having the opportunity to serve the other 18 um teachers who need support our beginning teachers who need support I also decided to repackage um her support by allowing her to provide some professional development and support to instructional coaches um on a good coaching model for our district so when we experience the gradual release from Miss Martin that our instructional coaches will be able to take the Reigns and support our mentors and our BTS actually Human Resources the Department is supposed to also meet with BTS I mean with mentors in a PLC monthly that is required by ncdpi now um so Angela Martin can also help to support our mentors in that way as well so as I was thinking about this and repackaging um how she would support our VTS I think

049building capacity with um with our instructional coaches and with our mentors once she leaves the district they will be able to sustain that support Mr begy D M would she be with um Elementary or would she be with it depends on where where those teachers are because you know my thing is um what I've been hearing is when we have someone that splits like that like I was asking her it's kind of like if they doing Elementary some of the Middle School especially feel like that they're getting Elementary stuff and they and they feel like that middle school is getting set back because of they go to stuff and it's they're not learning what they need to learn so I would really we can make sure sure so remember that um what I just said

050that Miss Ramos supports 14 of our teachers because that's all that UNCG would allow her to do so the other teachers who need support um Miss Martin would be able to give them that individualized support that they need and also like I said working with instructional coaches at the secondary level to make sure that all of our BTS are getting the support that they need Joe to dat it says through April not may I mean not March we can change that change I will make sure I made a note of it as well Mr lard because you are right we did say March 13th everybody understand that on the contract okay uh Mr Co I just got a question as far as beginning teachers go so when I think of beginning teachers I think of

051a first year teacher what is considered a beginning teacher you're one3 1 so how many of these 32 beginning teachers have been here here for 3 years like how many that's you know that is a good question I get those numbers for you I don't have those off the top of my head right now I just didn't really understand that I was sure like 16 of them in the third year when we it there what's the year okay so you have I think 16 I just didn't understand that so okay I got you all right you you done Miss okay Miss Black um Miss quen will she also be giving some um feedback to long-term Subs as well could that be something because we do have right many long-term Subs I know we're trying to

052uh change that but uh at Dill we have those long-term Subs which would be nice for someone to go in and just have some conversations and do some things if that could be included okay I made a note of that okay all right and I also have the breakdown for you all um in terms of beginning teachers at Bartley yansy they're eight at Dillard five at Oakwood eight north8 South four and Stony Creek one so that's 34 okay any more questions okay Miss begy so these teachers will still be their Mentor teachers even though we got all this extra yes yes but understand that mentors are also teaching mentors are in the classroom yes they are in the classroom so any support that they are providing for BTS has to be during planning hope hoping

053that they have the same planning and then if they don't they either have to support after school before school or when they have the time to do so because I know we had one that us Mentor two people one teacher and that's why that's why I and that's not uncommon Miss beggarly there you know sometimes Mentor support two or Free People yes ma'am because mentors there's also a criteria for mentors so everyone cannot serve as a mentor there's a criteria for that do we still provide like a little extra it used to be yes ma'am we do provide um they do all right they used yes ma'am used should sign up for them you oh okay anybody else all right uh I make M blacker makes the motion Miss beg second any discussion if not

054all in favor the motion please raise your hand POS motion 70 thank Youk all right um number four SE sa solution mrti good morning good morning Mr request one out about possible comment two three quotes ands for the seats at six um the way the seating hussy is the manufacturer of the bleachers six center and the gyms that we have new and old gym as well as v um I reached out to husy the manufacturer to for inspection parts to see if they're still available and the inspections they contacted their dealer who safety seating Solutions they're from North Carolina and South Carolina they are the dealer of North Carolina and South Carolina they are the ones that came in inspected and also wrote quotes for the bleachers so in order to reach out for a

055second and third party somebody would have to come back and um respect them which we would have to pay plus they'd have to go back through the dealer to get the parts right so so um that's where we're at with on we're just replacing Parts when not purchasing new bleachers if we buy new bleachers we could go out and send it out and request bids for two or three different compies that makes yeah that's Reon we only have one now with the this price we have right here what will it actually do how long will it last us B what they told you well the bers were installed around 1980 nothing really has uh been done to them system so that's where we're at today okay um a few things with the handrails or machines

056um has been done and some duct tape and some black tape has been wrapped around a whole lot of things um this is to fix and repair with the manufacturer recommended Parts as well as the rails with safety and hand rails to provide if something would happen it would be on the manufacturer recommendations it wouldn't be with our recommendations or our people involved with it we're looking at almost a thousand people that's send them bleachers at the Civic Center and um everything you see with the state for its inspections all bleachers require three inspections they requireed six months just a periodic visual inspection at the end of the year you're supposed to go out and inspect the bleachers to make sure there's nothing been tore up throughout the year and then you're supposed to have

057the manufacturer or a dealer of the manufacturer come in every two years and do a full inspection of the bleachers okay and I'm not sure at what point in time the school system may have had this done done over the years but okay um they are husty bleachers and I'm going through the manufacturer recommendations okay is beg I saw your hand yes sir um I know you talked about Diller and B so will that be a separate quote yes deer and by will be a separate quote and they will be um kind of like this school of itself thank you thank you not a problem but I knew that far as the gyms go um we put it in with Newber and Davis when we looking at Lottery funds and stuff to fix the gem

058so I'm just trying to get a separate quote see what I can get other than far as new now in the Civic Center based upon if prove did they give you a time frame is when they could do it no sir they have not um I would have to call back and coordinate that with them as well as scheduling um with the building being uh rent okay now with the situation now the bleaches are in push back okay and I think U maybe January and February we may have some open times in there before April starts all the dance programs so maybe we can get some stuff kind of scheduled before then okay the spring starts any other questions now we had talked about approved the funding that you would recommend for doing this and

059Brooke was talking about how we I would recommend us take this out of capital Outlet fund balance that way we're not tying up the line item for the Civic Center contractor repairs if we don't use that money it goes right back into the PO but if we have to have it if he has to replace the hbac unit we're almost High Mr petit's hands if we bagle the budget that we have now got you everybody understand that part of it okay I make the I make the motion to go ahead and approve and take it out of our cap out L fund balance B back with seconds any discussion on that if not all in favor raise your hand pose Mo thank you Mr thank you everyone give a call yes sir I will thank

060you okay next one is the policy update uh for 3620 this is thing we've been talking about the homeschoolers uh and you see what's there they it's had a little history at one time they could not then they came about that they had to be enrolled at least half a day to participate in athletics in athletics and uh now they they can but you need to have a policy hand to cover all that m b I saw your hand okay you done I'm done right now I've reached out a couple homeschool people that I know and um because I wanted to ask them you know because we have students that have to maintain a certain grade to play and then you know I wanted to know how we could tell with theirs you know what

061they're doing or they're really in school and um one of the parents really she she told me to go online because she didn't want to persuade me one way or the other and to look at all the outlines have to go by but she says that we could require them to show their prior Year and that they are enrolled so I would want to make sure we had that in there somewhere that we know they're enrolled and what their past grade was or come up with something that make it fair for our students well just a few quirks about that two there two basic things that well not two three one you must have a athletic physical within the last year number two you must have an attendance uh data and the other one you

062must pass at least X number of courses the previous semester which you can ask for that how you get that data we get it by what was power school and now it's going to change the infinite cvas we have that at our disposal and uh it needs to be reminded that the next the spring Sports start in February so you're talking about the previous semester which is going to end hours going to end in January home school I don't know what schedule they on but that data needs to be that data needs to be uh made sure because you don't want somebody floating in and out because they need to have time to be notified about the spring Sports which is February I I think it's a good thing uh if done properly yes that's

063the you all want to act on this now or well I don't have a problem I don't have a problem that'll give more time because everybody won't qualify just look so I think Connie reached out to get the wording because there's only three options on the word it's this wording the wording we had or not at all so I don't know that we can make a lot of additions to it the wording is that they have to show their homeschool card um I mean this is the state policy and that's what we learned in the athletic thing in our conference is the state has moved the requirement that homeschool kids can now participate without being enrolled in classes so I think we either take the verbiage put it back as there halftime enrolled or um

064you know don't do it at all but you know I think having homeschool kids getting back involved in our inter Scholastic Sports would be huge um you know and we've got sports that right now we don't even have the numbers to play and so having you know students from home school be involved allows us to play some sports we may not be able to play I mean we couldn't have a a boys soccer team into High School this year because of numbers um it's very likely we'll not have boys JB baseball uh possible girls JB softball um you know these allow us to get some numbers back in there m I just think it's a great idea because um I think you'll end up having some kids that are homeschool come back to public school

065could be all right Mr chairman I would like to make a motion that we adopt this policy and we wave the first read we moov property second any discussion I have one I was talking to miss Gwen prior to our meeting if we approve this look like we are uh one I like two things I like to see happen any contact that we can make with the homeschoolers you know let them know what we've done also put this in the cas Mion too because February will be here before you know it and they need to be notified of that those two things I'd like to see any other discussion so so are we going to ask for requirement to see if there are INR well they have to bring their card they have to bring

066their card okay and the other thing the other things about the eligibility you you know you know how that goes okay what do you mean you know how that goes for example uh let's say I'm a homeschooler and you're my homeschool student and I say uh TR made all a they don't have to show proof they just have to show their homeschool card home school card according to the State and it's the state's rule that our athletes have to be eligible I mean we're going by what the state is saying right I think events that's going to change you have to have some kind of safest thing though is make sure to have that athletic physical too because you don't about they participated hav had the phic so I'm are you saying that a homeschool

067child just shows a card and they do not have to show that they have passed any classes and how would that be fair to those students that have to pass classes I agree but you're looking at the policy the way it's written now that that's what you're looking at so we can we add to that policy and what's the legal if we change that policy um Mr Brer to add to it what the they that I feel like if the uh regular students have to pass pass certain number of courses then hom school students should have to show that they pass courses too just a c doesn't say anything on that card that's not fair that's not posed any extra burden or anything else so it wouldn't be a problem it just would be how

068do they prove their pass it be whatever so are you saying that homeschoolers do not have to show any grades to anyone I I I'm this is saying they have to show the C from the state the card from the state that tells their homeschool kid I mean who is going to verify those grades anyway I mean if I want my son to play I'm G tell you he made an a there's no there's no grading system for a homeschool child other than passing the test at the end of the year I I have a question um Miss beavers or M Dr Jones can you all do you all know any information about homeschoolers Miss Blackwell they're they're not prepared to question I just I just would like to find information I would like to

069have more information on that what would you like I would like to find out about grades okay the grading system but just to say that anybody can say they made a a I thought that they had to have something to prove that I really did so I would like to know that information yes ma'am if you read if you look at the policy the first page page 105 that's the uh State requirements that's the State High School Athletic Association tells you about attendance by grades etc etc the home school thing that's a gray area in terms of you know how do I know you know exactly need to be fair understand Miss beg and then miss the three parents different parents that I spoke to the only thing they have to show would be at

070the end of their great that's it that's the only thing the state requires them um they do not give report cards out through some you know through there going just at the end of that quarter so that's all but the parent told me that she thought we should ask for that bring but then also don't we need to also let them know that we will not be paying for their insurance either my understanding what I read they have to provide their own insurance so we need to make sure that it's provide you know they know that on top of their okay getting their physicals they have to pay for their own insurance happens to their child I think we saw that uh Joel just found something first go to you find it okay on page

071two where it says that prior to the first practice it does state that they present the home school card um but also as well as a transcript that covers that covers it that's I was looking thank you how if they have to provide their own insance how does it fall with us when they're riding I bus to the ball game if they're not actually legal stent was you still havea Port CLA action Department Jus so they will be covered something happens to them on that bus system would be office defend purs it with the to to I thought I read I had to reread I thought they had to purchase that insurance from us stud must also present proof of catastrophic accident insurance coverage unless the student is covered under the board's catastrophic athletic policy

072but the thing that I they told us in our athletic meeting was that um about purchasing that additional insurance from us that if they don't have any of this then they have to purchase that insurance from us to be covered that we offer um so a homeschool kid would just if they don't have something on their own they would have to purchase that PO see the football is different than the other sports anybody else okay uh time frame is it's a short time frame to you know when this pass contact those homeschools if we can and then to put it in the cas me to so we're meeting the ATT of the law that what the state says and then it's up to them if they want to participate but like I said the first

073practice for spring is in February he something else okay if not is there a motion to effect to uh I'm we've already done that no more discussion all right not if all in favor uh the policy please raise your hand oppose motion scar 70 thank you very much and I think handb will have to be changed it will be have to be yeah and actually they uh the thing I think it's going to eventually happen it's going to trickle down to not element it's going to trickle down to Middle Schools too eventually because that's same thing basically but I think this FAL covers doesn't grade 6 through 12 and that's the whole thing they they are different guidelines but they still have to have the same thing all right moving right along superintendent updates yes

074board members um in your packets you have the reorganization charm for um for central office since Mr USI is now the COO so you should have that in your packets and secondly uh CTE student interest survey results you should have those as well and Dr Jones is also here to um answer any questions that you might have about that Mr battle did have um a question for Dr Jones and I just wanted to um make sure that you all have the answers so I'm passing out an additional document for you just in case you all had some of the same questions or concerns so those are the questions and answers all right Dr Jones I'll turn it over to you all right well I'll give you a moment to just digest and that page that

075has the questions and answers from the survey but initially what um occurred is upon your Quest We surveyed 9 through 11 students at the high school they had about three weeks to access the survey um via their student accounts so we could see there was about um 49 students who were surveyed and eighth grade students were surveyed last semester but of course their current ninth graders but we do plan to survey seventh and eighth graders Before Christmas bre Dr Jones it's 241 students who were surveyed and respond correct okay 49% of okay that's right of the students 911 yes okay and so I added an additional question question six just to hear we were just curious to hear what additional courses that students may want outside of one through five and you can see the

076gamut there when you see the 0.4% that basically is between one to three students who have responded so Mr B I know that you specifically have a question about masonry well not just masonry when I look at numbers you can play with numbers any way you want to there are things that kids have to take which are required we understand that they get 22 credits they can graduate they can leave at their junior year but if we offer things to kids I want to give kids what they want okay rather than say Hey you have to have ABC D then if you look at the number the questions I asked if you look on the single sheet people 2 uh 41 students were uh they respond all right you know how kids are if you

077send me an email I might respond I I may not respond but if I'm really interested I'm going to respond so that's the reason I wanted to know how many kids responded so we make decisions based upon you know what we get the other question I wanted to know was uh you got 49 % of the kids uh in 9 9 through1 were surveyed you know what what what the other kids think you know and then you look at question number six they don't really want nothing in number six you see where I'm going with this because when we talked last year about last year we said we had enough formy now we we don't and a lot of times I don't want us to offer something for kids they don't want that doesn't make

078sense there but if we can provide it just to give you an example the cosmetology for a long time when I when I was at by I bought it up it was only offered at the rockboro campus before year and year and year we didn't take no surveys but we finally got it now that has been dropped you know kids kids interest something different so that was my reason for asking this get this data as to how many kids and the thing about the eighth graders too who will become ninth graders and then the other thing that hurts us too not hurting us the kids that go to PCC in 11th and 12th grade you know that's a separate entity right there that you don't have to really worry about because they have already outlined

079what they're going to do they get their associates degree so I just wanted us to do what effec toy kids what they want you know because kids have a tendency to you know but I'm interested in that you know rather than say hey this is all we're going to offer you this year so that's that was really my questions yes sir anybody else uh Miss B and Miss Smith so so we send out an email to these kids the high school did which we know half them don't look at their emails me apparently but um how do we get it across to them how important this is any suggestions I mean I believe I counselors talking with them about careers and study paths I do know there will be a huge difference now because of

080our legislative requirements for eighth graders to have a career development plan and 10th graders to have them so it'll be a very intentional conversation about work Readiness and career Readiness because I I get a lot from parents we know why don't so I didn't know if like if maybe when before they sent this out if something go home to parents hey they will be a survey your kid needs to answer on courses that you know we will possibly try to I just didn't know if that would be a way of getting it out so parents know that we are trying just parents don't read their kids school email I mean just just my thought and sure you know we could have another survey a spring survey we can do um that survey we also survey

081doing our CTE business advisory count we sent out a survey to our additional community members and we're really excited for some of our ad Partners um so they will also complete an additional survey so we can surely do the spring but we can also administer an eighth grade one before we get out and I spoke with Mr Stokes um on away in this morning just looking at senior interests we can also do a separate survey for the seniors as well before they get out because you know sometimes that data is good to review even though we have quite a few who are in our um CCP courses and also in the associates pathway okay thank you you're welcome any other questions concerns I'm Sorry Miss I'm sorry so I got a question um M Jones

082like as far as construction goes that looked high 52% we don't offer construction at the high school now we offer woodworking so correct is this something like we don't offer pharmacy technician correct correct so these are just new things that we've suggested to the students and then we would look to try to find somebody to teach them right so these are options that they can take in the CTE pathway but how do we offer it to them if we don't have a teacher to teach it like like as far as construction because that would be great as far as even repairs at the high school it did well um I was following the board request and that was to administer and then we request exactly and and go from there but it is it's a

083course and a pathway that's available to students but yes we would so this is new this is what you just did based upon our request that's right okay I'm sorry okay I got you and as far as masonry goes if you think about it I'm not saying that a young lady wouldn't want to take masonry she very well may but 37% to me that's that's high for masonry to get that big of a response because in my mind it would probably be young men that responded the yes you know I don't know and didn't know that 50% didn't respond at all so that's good I mean it's very informative okay yes ma'am anybody else okay now you say you probably might do one in the spring too I will definitely in the spring and then

084we can work on ging more in because see children may have a different mindset in the spring more or less and say hey this is what we're going to offer next school year that's exactly Bas on what you get so okay that's good anybody else thank you m thank you all right see where we are next item is board member observation uh at a future work session I want to recommend something to you I don't really want it's been there for years to me it's not really observations uh what what are you observing uh you know things that we talk about what we've done I think if we can just change that word into uh comments or whatever uh just get rid of that word observation uh but we're going to keep it for the

085day but we're looking at for the future uh let's start on uh Miss Black side today thank you Mr B you're welcome I knew he was coming to be first um I did go by Bartley yansy High School um went through the school and cafeteria I liked what I was seeing with the students very quiet um also I was able to have some discussion um because I'm I'm really thinking about the academics part so I had conversation uh with Mr Stokes uh about evos because we talked talked about that when we went to our workshop and he was able to sort of give me a scenario of sometimes you may have your AG students and you may have students that are not AG in the classroom and you may think that your AG students where

086your high scored show the growth but it may not be the AG students that show the growth it may be the other students so you have to take a look at all the students and looking at those numbers when you providing instruction and so um that was very informative to uh Tred to understand that information so um and then I also visited uh dill and I should have said something uh to the principal while she was here because I you know I like what I saw um that they are changing the culture of the school it's all about academics and uh she was was able to tell me that all the teachers will be doing a format uh and when we were in a workshop we heard where a school system changed things around by

087doing the format which is basically the six steps that we were taught when we were teaching and so they're going back to some Basics and she's making sure that all teachers are going to be doing that and they're going to be checking that too so some positive things that they're putting in place I thought you know was just great just to know that it's starting and also looking at the long-term Subs to make sure that they are on target as well and then she was talking about uh how they're recognizing students uh not just because of Honor Roll but because they're doing some things you know some learning spurts and teachers are just recognizing students so those were some positive things that I really saw going on at the Middle School uh had an I

088did go by Oakwood uh the one comment I would make there is that uh I know that the principal was out and so I asked who was in charge and it was great to know that right off there they were able to say who's in charge of the school so that was something that we as board members had worked oning uh I went by Stony Creek and uh that was sort of toward the end and she also was talking about academics making sure that um well that program that Miss beavers was talking about she brought that up and really stressed the need of making sure that her beginning teachers get some additional help and so I think that uh all of the principles and the school environment was about uh academics and uh making students

089be the best that they can be so I was pleased with those visits so thank you to all those that I spoke with thank you very much you're new but if you you still on Bo want to okay I well first of all I W to uh thank the community for allowing me this opportunity to serve with such a great uh group of people and thank you for your warm welcome um this morning I'm excited to be back home but in a different capacity um I look for to visi in the schools I did have a chance to attend a basketball game on Friday I enjoyed that and I look forward to other opportunities I'm grateful to hear that we are putting some um support in place to help our um students be successful academically

090as well as support our teachers who need that um support it's tough it's a tough job and they deserve you know whatever resources we can provide for them and I'm just excited for the opportunity thank you thank you very much Mr Li um first I'd say it's exciting to see all the stuff wrapped around the holiday season in the schools uh it's a lot of excitement for the kids and the staff I think all of our schools are doing something um posting pictures and and that's great um two new board members welcome to the board we're glad to have you um and then last thing I'll say is to all our amazing staff that's working so hard uh hope they have a happy holiday enjoy some rest and time with their families and this is

091a little different you know as you get older you appreciate things a little differently uh I was telling Miss McGee's son that I hired his mother as a teacher I'm G to say that again he did a great job I've H hir Miss as a teacher he's our historian that was a long that was a long time ago long for me long for me but uh just to change Gars a little bit there's a couple things I want to bring up to you one is Kathy B who is retiring in the next few days she a lady that helped us with our policies uh we could not have done it without her and I got to see her at the annual conference and I would hope that I want to make a motion to this

092board that we do something for her and let uh superintendent gwy Miss Kimber get together and whatever they decide you know since we' be gone but uh I think it'd be all together fitting and proper for us to do that so I'll make a motion to that effect uh that we do something for Cathy board for her retirement is there a second to that second Mr L in discussion if not all in favor raise your hand pose the next thing who is going to PCH Thursday is it just three is that right you going never okay you're not okay I it that Monday okay night said okay you're going I can check with her today okay please the reason I bought that up is so we can get together and and use a County let

093me know about that CU we need got you okay go start still start at 9:00 okay used to be 9 o00 getting up with the chickens all right please confirm that today so I can fix my schedule all right thank you uh dto uh I'd like to welcome it two new boy members uh this is a new Venture more or less uh whatever we do we do it for the children we do it for the staff and your role is important uh everybody not going to like every decision you make but you still have to keep that in mind you were elected to do a job and do it to the best of your ability this is my last go round it's time for the younger generation to come along uh and I'll stop with

094that right there all right M Smith welcome our two new board members um heart's still kind of heavy this morning we went a few of us attended um the balloon release for um shaale Wilson continued prayers for that family all right okay this night um um thanks for the welcome I guess like said Miss Nicole was say I guess I'm glad to be here um I hope I can live up to the expectations of the community folk that elected me and I guess my former co-workers over at Oakwood I just finished a long longterm Ser on Friday that was there the host um I guess since August um they're a good group of folk that work with they're hardworking um I guess they have a lot of faith in me and I guess they're hoping

095that I can come make some positive changes that would eventually impact all they do um I guess I was at the on Friday night also it was nice to see the basketball team from 7475 being recognized but one thing I did noce that the PA system over there was very shoty you know it was a nice recognition you know they were standing out in the middle of the floor and you couldn't hear a thing um Mr Stokes did come up to try and do Crow control and it worked while he stood there but when he left they went back at it again and I thought it was no disrespectful means that they didn't know who I was but being an adult you sitting amongst all these young folk and they did not respect the older

096people sitting around and didn't even um show respect to what was going on on the center floor okay Miss B um I got a chance November 26 to help with a parent advisory committee they have at dber Middle School to serve teachers as they went out for Thanksgiving that was very nice and um also um I had uh someone from the community to reach out to me to invite all the board members to um the holiday show December the 20th at North by the PTSA president and then I also um had a lady to invite all of us to the pajama book party at pelum December the 21st where they give out pajamas and stuff if anybody would would like to come to that also also we have a by danc Cal coming up I

097attended that last year so that's be some 19th anybody go to that it's really nice um also welcome my two new staff members we thank appreciate it and happy holidays to all our employees and thank everybody for all their hard work and then our hearts do go out we also had principal I mean that we attended the you know so let go out to both of those families and everybody else with heavy hearts for problems that we all have on all right thank you very much at this time I moved at the C County Board of public education going to close session for the purpose of considering a Personnel accident involved an officer employee of this board DC General stat 31816 and for the purpose of discuss information that is privileged confidential or not a

098public record NC General statute 143 111 and to confer with the attorney is there to any discussion if not I raise your hand all right after a short break please

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.