CorpusRecord 93437

12-17-24 JCPS Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / JCPS Media
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Jackson County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,525 words · about 76 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening everybody Welcome to tonight's regularly scheduled board member uh board member board meeting for December um and now uh we'll have the Pledge of Allegiance Jesse keny and perfect a pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the repu forance one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all you see to be light [Music] St [Music] oh [Music] thank you Jesse and thank you smug M High School choir um do I have a motion to approve tonight's agenda I make a motion that we approve tonight's agenda I second that motion all in favor all right first on the agenda tonight is smok Mountain High School principal Joey Robinson with some special recognitions chairman member of the boards Dr SS and all of our guests I'd

002like to welcome everybody to smoking Mountain High School first I'd like to thank a couple of people doing the pledge of allegiance was one of our fabulous students Jesse Kennedy we' like to thank him for coming out we also have our amazing um Advanced show choir who did the national anthem and is also going to sing another song here in a minute under direction of Katie who has done a fabulous job in her position I would like to thank some special people real quick first and foremost Renee Miller who is not here she's probably actually outside working that's what she usually does as she works she is a true ambassador to Smoky Mountain High School and all of our students and I don't know where we'd be without her the decorations the the food for

003everybody that's that's all Miss Miller so I want to make sure she gets that credit also want to thank the IT department for setting everything up here make sure that it's ready to work today they put a lot of work in here a lot of hours I want to thank thank them and finally and not least I would like to thank my amazing admin team Mr Davies and uh miss eny my assistant principls for all of their hard work and preparation for today all right so we're going to start off with a quick song a Christmas song from our show choire ch [Music] of the univers America all [Music] principal use your teacher voice oh I can't that's not a problem here there go okay good evening I bet Dave's assistant principal um the thing

004I want to talk about today for Smoky Mountain High School is a focus and we are so excited that this is coming to our campus in January is our uh Roc program that is going to get started um we've started to get students already signed up and we are so excited forward to uh to come to campus and the opportunities that's going to present for our students um and we actually have one of our former students Skyler Tamaro who's going to come who is actually involved in her r program at college and wants to talk about the benefits of the RC program SC hello everyone um as Mr Davey said I'm Skyler Tamaro and um I graduated last year um I now attend North Carolina State University and I'm a part of army RC on

005honestly I had no idea what I wanted to do and I didn't even know like that NC offered an TC program until like I did my own research but has genuinely been the best decision I've made in my University experience in high school I was involved in show choir theater and swim now as I return here I realize that doesn't really fit into the typical Soldier stereotype but you know honestly I don't identify with it at all but throughout High School I was fortunate enough to hold leadership positions in various activities and that's exactly what RC is to prepare me for the program focuses on developing Cadets not just to join the military but to become officers within it on top of college curriculum there are courses covering military tactics and Leadership skills these classes

006give us a chance to lead and manage small teams which helps us develop our own strategic thinking skills over the next four years I'll be learning the ins and outs of what it means to become an army officer which is very very exciting and while that might seem like a really long time there are many times where I feel like like I know less than my peers even though I'm gaining so much valuable knowledge so when I learned that Smoky Mountain is going to offer a jrtc I feel incredibly excited for all the students who will have the chance to get a head start on their military knowledge plus there's a chance to have about 80% of your um College tuition paid for for all four years through scholarships for jrtc students while Cadets who

007join ROTC and college can only have a 3 to twoe scholarship depending on how many years they have left jrtc is a fantastic opportunity for them to grow and prepare for whatever path they choose in the future whether it be College the military or both so I want to thank you for providing this opportunity to Smoky Mountain High School students and I want to thank you for having me thank you good good evening I'm assistant principal Cindy Ensley and I have the pleasure to introduce our wonderful dedicated peer group connection leaders or PGC leaders Cecilia Ruth Marcus Kim Bryson and Stacy Mackey thank you Miss sley so I am the PGC peer group connections coordinator here at Smoky Mountain High School we received a grant a two-year Grant to Implement uh PGC at the high

008school we just started that this fall um and so sorry I'm trying to move around here so miss Marcus and Miss Bryson they are our advisers for PGC and those are our teachers they have taught the class we have 31 leaders of Juniors and seniors and they go out and do outreaches with our freshmen once a week so I'm going to let them speak a little bit more um we have Parker Hughes Ava Krauss and Tatum Griffin hi there um uh I'm Parker so um starting out with PGC was a really interesting process it's something that you don't usually see in you know high school at least we haven't seen before uh it was an interview process so we had to go you know with our facilitators here and we talked to them and they

009interviewed Us in uh group sessions and we sort of talked about you know skill set we ran some scenarios and then they got back to us uh last year if we were going to be in there class and um what PGC has meant to me is I want to be a teacher in the future and so it's been a leadership opportunity for me in the classroom and out of the classroom I got to see these kids I got to you know help them grow and it's just been all around great for me hi I'm Ava and I talk about how PGC has affected me so PGC to me is representing my school and being a leader for my community it allows me to guide and connect with the younger students in ways that I was

010never offered as a freshman in high school I hope that they take away from this semester that it is okay to not know everything at the beginning but to grow from how PGC mentors have guided them so far I have enjoyed helping them find their classes and helping them figure out their schedules because seeing how they learned from my assistance allows me to know that I did something right I take away from my experience that I can be a leader and I hope that in the future those same freshman that I guided will follow in our footsteps hi my name's Tatum uh PGC has positively impacted not only the students but the school as a whole um over the course of the semester I have witnessed the growth of each of my students that I've

011been blessed to share this PGC with um you know traditionally in home rooms you have clicks of certain groups of people and they never mesh together but through our outreaches during this semester I've seen no clicks whatsoever and it's really heartwarming to see students come together and not put someone out just because they're different my students are amazing they um truly have meshed together and it's just been great to see that they love each other and talk to each other um I'd like to make a comment before y'all leave um I had the privilege about three weeks ago I think speaking to this class at Smoky Mountain High School and um they had questions prepared and I was so impressed with the questions I've for the last three years I've spoken to leadership classes at

012Western Carolina University and I can honestly say that the questions these students had were much deeper more insightful and um I was just so thrilled that these students are having this opportunity here at Smoky Mountain High School and I want to thank these teachers and Mrs Mackey for doing such an outstanding job next on our agenda uh Dr SS with special recognitions so I want to give a huge shout out to the peer group um connections um also because that was the brainchild I believe of Stacey Mackey last year and started having that conversation sh so it's really important to see the involvement of our students with their younger peers so I'm excited about that but also I'm excited to recognize people right now which are our adults who have done some marvelous things so

013every year the state of North Carolina provides information about student performance and teacher growth exhibiting progress I'm delighted to recognize these outstanding Educators tonight from Blue Ridge early college and Smoky Mountain High School others will be recognized as they host board meetings at their schools and we did this on a little bit of delay because the state doesn't release the data until late October or early November so teachers receive an EVO growth score and that is a fancy um acronym evos means education value added assessment system those are designations that are given to every teacher which are did not meet met or exceeded growth a number is ass signed that can be positive or negative and anything below a negative -2.0 does not meet between the parameters of negative -2.0 and positive 2.0 meets and

014anything above a positive 2.0 seeds this year in Jackson County Public Schools we had 17 teachers who exceeded growth and I shared that number with you last month but tonight I want them to stand on the stage and be recognized for this because this is um a big deal and doesn't go unnoticed so as I call the names I would like these folks to come forward and they're going to want to run but I'm going to ask them all to come forward as I call their name and stand together so that we can collectively get a picture all right first is from Blue Ridge Early College CTE teacher Nicholas presler it's kind of like a test Mr presler to see which Avenue to travel to get up here great job congratulations all right and then

015Smoky Mountain High School had the largest number of teacher of teachers who exceeded growth so we'll start with Miss Katie Ray Katie Katie is a math teacher extraordinaire shenica do you want individuals of each one or Collective group shop okay the next teacher is Mr Mark stippler another math teacher I'm a math girl hooray next is Miss Daphne Hughes biology all the Sciences it's deep next is Miss Kayla today and Kayla is a HOSA teacher Health occupation Sciences so come on down Kayla everybody wants to be in your class don't they do wants to be in your class it's always full thank you next is Miss Melissa hegler CTE teacher Miss Cory says best cookies ever Melissa she would say that they are created by her students because that's who she is foods and apparel

016right is that correct uh next is someone who couldn't be with us tonight I don't think is that correct Mr Robinson um Mr Craig Michael Roy is another one of our CTE teachers but let's give him a round of applause and then lastly but not least is Miss Martha Smith another one of our HOSA teachers so once you set the precedent for exceeding growth it is now an expectation that you will exceed growth every year many of them have already done so no [Music] congratulations please and give them another round of applause that's great next we're going to recognize some schools so annually the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction provides certificates to schools for their performance our state superintendent Katherine Truitt writes greetings from the Department of Public Instruction we are pleased to offer

017our congratulations to you and your entire district for your school's performance during the 2324 school year we are presenting awards for achieving an exceeding expected academic growth under North Carolina's accountability system whether for academic growth or graduation rate these certificates showcase the dedication to academic achievement in your school system of both your students and your Educators share please join me in sharing the appreciation and congratulations from the entire Department of Public Instruction and the State Board of Education with everyone in your District so first up for academic growth is Blue Ridge School Miss Cowan if you can come on down it's a long walk isn't it next is Jackson County early college come on down Miss granning you receed two certificates one for academic growth and the other for graduation rate next is Jackson Community

018School come on down Miss winet again for academic growth next is Scott Creek School for academic growth I think Miss Bryson is out of town the next one is Smoky Mountain Elementary and Mr Kerr couldn't be with us this evening because he and his school are hosting the county commissioner meeting at his school this evening but give them a round Applause of Applause that is for academic growth and then finally academic growth award for Smoky Mountain High School Mr Robinson and that's all my recognitions all right do I have a motion to approve tonight's Open Session minutes I'm sorry the Open Session minutes from the regular meeting on November 19th make a motion that we approve the Open Session minutes from our November meeting I second that motion all in favor now it's time for

019information Dr s with the superintendent report good evening again chair and board members we are excited to have our last board meeting of the 2024 calendar year here at Smoky Mountain High School thank you Mr Robinson Mr Davies and Miss Insley and all of the staff for accommodating us for the meeting November excuse me this is a big week for high school students and all of our high school principls out there shaking their heads um as uh we prepared and began with exams yesterday it's important for our students to do their very best to show how much they have learned during the first semester also November and the first few weeks of December have been busy with Athletics Christmas band and coral concerts theater Productions family nights and many other events this past week we

020hosted a jro TC night for interested students and families from Smoky Mountain High School and Jackson County early college it was an outstanding turnout with about 30 students family and community members in attendance as of today as of a few hours ago Miss um Paige juski let me know that there are already 21 students registered for the spring semester for JROTC and more are likely to be enrolled as schedule changes are allowed during the first 10 days of any semester last week we also introduced our instructors who are Lieutenant Colonel William Carter who cannot be with us this evening but Sergeant First Class Jason trimco who is in attendance this evening and I'm going to ask Mr trim not Mr Sergeant trimco to stand so everybody give him a wave and welcome him Sergeant trimco

021has been on and off the campus for the last two weeks preparing and moving equipment and I can't go on without saying a big shout out to um Jake Buchanan and Joe kinland for making the move very smooth they have a lot of stuff in JROTC so it took um a community effort to get it all over here but we're ready the infant toddler class at Scots Creek continues to be a huge success and a blessing to our families and employees however we are still seeking an additional teacher assistant for the class anyone who is interested can reach out to miss Cassie Rogers Laura deals or apply online as we look forward to several new building projects a team is going to visit two middle schools in January this team consists of JCPS leadership building

022administrators a board member from the Board of Education and county commissioner and our County Manager we will visit a school constructed by The Hired architect which is Pinnacle architect and another school with excellent academics JCPS will also be hosting two Middle School Parent Community Information forums the first will take place on January 13th in the burough building at SEC and the second on January 14th at Smoky Mountain Elementary I think that there's going to be a QR code coming up behind me in just a moment if anyone is interested oh that was fast very good great timing the purpose of these Community engagement forums is to gather input around the new Middle School food child care and translation services will be provided at both events to have an accurate count of attendees and meals needed

023please register with a QR code that has also been shared via reman to our families and on social media I want to recognize the wonderful School nutrition staff and the many many many many many volunteers who made our Thanksgiving luncheon on November 21st a success we served approximately 5,000 meals on a single day and it was a sight to behold Laura cab and her team along with district office staff principes assistant principls and community members ensured that everyone was fed a delicious meal while having the opportunity to Fellowship sincerest of gratitude to all who supported and I'm going to just stop and say not only did our um our staff from the central office but the staffs in the school these board members sitting here many of them also went and served it was just

024a really special day and a special moment for our families and then finally what we're looking for forward to lastly there will be no school for students from December 23rd through January 3rd students return on Monday January 6 to begin the second semester and we're all looking forward to a much needed break with respect thank you Dr s and now Jackson Community School discussion yes so the next thing that we're going to be talking about is Jackson Community school and I want to give a little bit of context about um what that conversation looks like board members you have a hard copy of this in case you wanted to write notes I'll L it under your um folder so over the last um several months we've been looking at um the en enrollment and what

025Jackson Community School um either needs or we need to do to address um that campus because we have an obligation to serve students and I say that first and foremost we want to serve students that's what our business is about and so we also have a fiscal responsibility that we're looking at and and and talking collectively about what to do moving forward with um making those students a success making the staff successful and most of them are here I went and met with them and invited them to come here I think that you want to see and hear that they are here for the conversation so you have asked me some numbers I've shared some numbers with you and now I want to talk about that out loud collectively with this group so on the

026first slide it really defines um what is alternative education and the state has very specific legislation and parameters around what um an alternative education program is and so you'll see that displayed up here is this is their exact words of What alternative Ed should look like in any school district and some of the things that I just wanted to highlight there are that Our obligation our goal is to serve students in that second paragraph um at any level serving students suspended or expelled serving students whose learning styles are better served in an alternative program so the community school is an alternative model that doesn't have one um one set student that they're looking for it is trying to find what we need to serve the students that we have and there's no cookie cutter model

027for that um also alternative education should provide individualized programs outside of what a standard classroom looks like thus the word alternative so we do those four bullets we provide the primary instruction for students that are at risk and that's the the states vocabulary at risk um we enroll students for a designated period of time um we offer uh course credit or grade level promotion Credit in core academic areas and we assist the student in meeting requirements for graduation the goal of any high school program no matter what it is is for that student to graduate that's our goal for JCC JCS Blue Ridge early college and Smoky Mountain High School so we should always keep the goal in mind is that we want our students to graduate and be successful on the next slide is

028just a little bit of what I mentioned before we're here to talk not to make a decision tonight but to talk about the direction and what we should do to make Jackson County Jackson Community School a success the enrollment at Jackson Community School is the lowest it has ever been we are currently operating the campus with less than 50 students and we pulled that number yesterday that the number is 48 so that number has declined over time and we as collectively as a curriculum team and a leadership team are trying to figure out why or what we can do to address that you all as a board have also asked questions about enrollment and how much it cost to operate the campus um on a on a monthly basis and on a yearly basis so

029I believe and those are my words I believe that our board has three options that they really need to review the first option would be that Jackson Community Schools stays just as is as it is in the location that it is in the same format that it is the next option would be to relocate Jackson Community School to the campus of Smoky Mountain High School for the high school piece of that and for Smoky Mountain Elementary for the Middle School piece of that and I'm going to pause for those who are not familiar with this the campus serves students from grades uh six through 12 but we have had fifth grade students there before currently we have four middle school students at Jackson Community School and we have 44 high school students four uh the

030four middle school students are um collectively in one it's four classroom spaces but it's all connected so that they can do some alternative ad in there and they have plenty of space but right now our enrollment for Middle School is four students and then the third option I see is remaining on fight with a revitalization of strategies for an alternative school model and when I say that revitalization I'm thinking of of something that's going to want Stu make students want to come to school what is it that we can do to entice students to come there so that we can support them and be a success with them I'm on pause and ask the board if they want me to keep going or do you have a question now um I do have a question

031about the four students in Middle School yes ma'am um I would like us to ask each principal in our K8 schools if they know of other middle school students who they feel would benefit from an alternative setting and I know that there's a process that they go through to get there but just to kind of have a picture a snapshot the principls know their school and they know those people and they know the parents and the teachers and I would like us to ask formally ask each one if they know of students that they feel middle school students would benefit from a separate setting and we do that they have meetings every six weeks and every principal is part of that and they bring forth a name and that's the first part of that supporting

032successful transitions team is not names that we as District leaders have chosen but names that the principles bring to us so you have a list of those names yes and do you know how many are on that list I do not know off the top of my head right now well that would be helpful information yeah if we just have four at the school I'd like to know what those principles are suggesting might students might benefit so miss wisnet shared that she will be getting two more um from another school in Middle School okay thank you thank you Miss wh all right if we will go to the next slide and I've made a note G of that you I appreciate that Dr s thank you um basically a recap we're really focused on the

033figuring out what makes our kids successful at Jackson Community School and there are people in this room who have seen some huge successes and there are people in this room who look and say what else can we do to make that student a success because Jackson Community School is truly a community school there are a lot of resources there that are not offered at our other settings our board also does have an obligation to consider the cost and financial benefit of operating a school with less than 50 students so for your knowledge I wanted you to have this almost 12 months we can't give you the December number um because it will be not complete until the end of this this week and so you will see our average daily membership of students at Jackson

034Community School over the last um School month since January of 2024 so they are declining now remember we graduated in May so we had a graduating class and then we started back and had a partial month in August and then rolled into September so those are our numbers um as of nov member but as I said when we pulled the numbers this week there are 48 students currently enrolled right now and that does count the middle school students okay thanks you're welcome the next slide is something I asked Mr Hol to pull for me and that is a multi-year enrollment I wanted you to see over time in the last decade the number of students who um have attended and been part of Jackson Community School so you'll see 10 years ago 102 it was

035at its highest in the year of 2018 um and then 2019 comes along and we all know what happened between 19 and 20 and there's um the impact of covid but we haven't rebounded um at all and so the number that you see right there the 52404 uh 2024 was the last day of school this past May and then how do you get to Jackson Community School how are students um traveling a path to get there I thought this was important for you to know for middle school students there are two ways to get there and that is that either their IEP team is placing them there if they're an exceptional children's student or a superintendent's placement so some of you are going to ask what's a superintendent placement sometimes there are students who um

036have severe needs or they are involved with law enfor ment and there is a reason that they need to be placed in an alternative setting and so those students middle school students don't choose to go to Jackson Community School they are either there because the I AP team placed them or the superintendent myself placed them high school students are different they can choose to attend there and there are many who do choose to attend Jackson Community School they can be placed there again by me as a superintendent or they can be placed there by the supporting successful transitions team that meets every six weeks I wanted you to know who's on that team that team consists of counselor school counselors um principles the director of mental health Megan Cruz is part of that assistant superintendent

037Angie Dills Deputy superintendent Jake Buchanan I neglected to put on the hard copy but I did add it to this our student Support Services director Janet Roberts is part of that and often the school social workers so it's about half and half district leadership but the rest of the people that comprise that team or people in the schools with our students so finally is a list of Staffing as I said we um have the campus with about 48 students this is public knowledge there's nothing secret on here um there are currently at Jackson Community School 17 full-time staff members and three part-time staff members um so I won't go through and read all of that but there are a few of them that are shared positions right now for example um Mr Brown our PE

038teacher teaches first period here at Smoky high and then he is over at Jackson Community School for the remainder of the day um the same is a shared position with art and that's Miss Autumn white and she is um here at Fairview for part of the day but I think she begins her day at Jackson Community it's a pretty even split and then you'll see some other folks on there Mr Harden teaches here and at Jackson Community School and is one of our CTE teachers others you'll see on that list Miss Phillips she is um a school psychologist so Jackson Community is really just her landing spot so she goes to lots of other schools but she has an office space there the next page is a page um that is going to give you

039a real glimpse of our our finances for Jackson Community School but you as a board asked me to pull these numbers for the entire School District so that is what I've done so I'm going to turn and take a moment to explain a little bit um to our to the folks in the audience but also so you can understand this chart the first row FTE means full-time employees so you can see across all nine schools the number of full-time employees each school has the second row is part-time employees the next row is is the annual salary so this is the salary and benefits for every employee the annual salary so you will see that row across that gives the annual salary of all of our schools for all of our employees that include both part-time

040and full-time the next line that says annual oper operations anual operations this is the amount of money it takes to to open and maintain a building on a an annual basis and so some of you are sitting there thinking what goes into operations power water sewer phone custodial supplies Workshop substitutes um and other costs associated with that the easiest way I can explain that is to say everything but salary so the operating cost is everything except salaries and then you'll see the line total that is combined the next line is the total students served and I want you to look across that because I want to draw your attention to Jackson Community School number so earlier I shared with you that the number that we ended the school year last year at Jackson Community was

04158 that's how many students were enrolled on the final day of school the number you see here is 88 and you're asking what what's that 30 discrepancy that is because in the course of last year this is all 2324 data in the course of last year Jackson Community School served 88 kids in some period of time because you have to remember that ultimately some kids are trying to go back to their home school so some students may be there for a semester or a order some students are here they move and go to another County some students are here and unfortunately they drop out and that's the case in every High School not just Jackson Community because if you'll look to the far right at that number 937 we do not have 937 students at

042Smoky Mountain High School last year never never got that high but that's how many students they touched over a course of the year that may have transitioned in and out so what you see as you're traveling to that bottom um row and you look and see how much money Jackson County Public Schools spends per pupil per student annually and I'll just draw your attention to those going across the bottom in Jackson County Public Schools um an average that we report to the state of North Carolina is about $13,500 ,000 is what we spend on average for every student but this breaks it down by how much we spend on every student and every school I'm going to pause and ask if you have questions board so the last slide then are just things that we

043need to be discussing up here and so that are things that I believe and I think that we as a board and as a leadership team and as a school district need to think about I believe we need to have alternate Education in Jackson County Public Schools I believe there should be one in every school system so that's the first thing that I believe I also believe that regardless of what this board decides over the next couple of months because we're here for information tonight not to make a decision but whatever this board decides I also believe that our middle school students should go and be placed um in a model at Smoky Mountain Elementary School and I want to tell you why I believe that because at Jackson Community School it is truly geared

044more toward high school students and I feel like our Middle School kiddos are really missing out on some impacts that they could have if they continue to be in a really small setting not with their peers um I have had conversations with miss wisnet all before this has been out that we're having this um public conversation because I I owed it to miss wisnet to have a conversation I've had a conversation with Mr Robinson I've had a conversation with Mr Kerr and they are all more than willing to share thoughts at some point if you want to know their thoughts again Mr Kerr's not here because his school is hosting the county commissioner meeting but he too agrees that our middle school students should have that opportunity now the way it would look for those

045students because they're an alternative model would be vastly different than the way it looks at the high school level so I just wanted to to put that out there um and eventually when we get our new Middle School built that's where the program will be housed uh relocation for the high school Jackson Community uh school program will require a lot of Shifting of multiple classrooms to accommodate appropriate space um I think if this board decides to do that and relocate the school that uh it is going to be very important that when Mr Robinson is working hard to figure out where to put uh the classrooms that they are together if that's the direction I want Jackson Community School to still have an identity we will keep their school code and it will be important

046for them as staff that they are able to work together and not be disjointed in this building and that building and that building so that's a consideration um that Mr Robinson and I have already talked about and and it's going to be tight I'm gonna be honest because now we have two RTC classrooms and we have sec classrooms and we have other spaces used for um many new things the dance program has a a a classroom so it's going to be tricky I would say um but doable because that's what Mr Robinson says we can we can figure it out and we can make it work if that's what the board decides um one of the things I I think that is important to say out loud if you recall when alternative aded programs really

047came into fruition and it's been a long time one of the the positives about it is a student who was struggling in school could go to an alternative model and only need 22 credits to graduate and so that was one of the the um one thing that would entice students to want to go there because we were under the 28 credit model we Jackson County Public Schools long before I got here we required 28 credits now if you'll remember the legislation that happened this year allows any high school student who has the requirements that are needed could graduate with 22 credits so that's very different than what what was the enticement of of going to an alternative model before because a lot of times students just wanted to take what they needed to take and

048graduate and get out but now any high school student through lots of parameters and protocols um Can graduate with 22 credits and so that piece is missing from what would en entice parents and families and students to want to go there and then finally just some thoughts no matter what decision is made I think that the that we are missing the boat in some in some ways in some areas and that we need to figure out what's going to make our students successful um at the community school and then you know looking forward whatever we decide whatever you decide as a board but whatever conversation we continue to have there are parents out there that want to talk with us there are families out there there are students out there there are staff members out

049there I think we have to hear the voice of all those people so those are all the points and things that you had asked me for um data so at this point this will be conversation for you all as a board yeah a quick question about the successful transition team that meets that's just for the high school not for Middle School age kids the middle school students names are presented by principles on that so we are following their data their progression and so when I when when I say that those kiddos at the very end if there's a student that is not an IP team decision and and Jake usually come and say okay we have this sixth grade student that we' followed him we have tried everything for her that she needs um and

050we are at a loss in our regular setting we think that this student needs to go there so that falls under your superintendent correct so outside of the 22 credit model going away for just alternative setting do we have any idea why we feel there's been a decline at JCS is it referrals is it do we have any idea where that's coming from I you know I I would say a couple of things and I don't know if Angie or um Jake wants to share any of that but this is what I honestly believe um I think that students know when they leave the campus of smokey High typically they're going to also not have opportunity for several things our alternative school students do not play sports there are not the uh numerous offerings for

051electives that you're going to get um they do have a CTE that's Mr Harden's um construction class or woodworking class they do have Jag which is not a class offered here at Smoky hit offered at Blue Ridge so there's far fewer offerings when they get there than when they're here another reason is we often get students from other districts I don't want to call one school name out because some all districts do not have an alternative model and so often we get students who want to transfer here if they are in an alternative model they should come and be placed for our DPI follow through but they don't have we don't have the offerings that they may have had in Charlotte Mech or somewhere and so they know that if they come mid semester they're

052going to lose all that work that they've done for the first half of the semester so it's really tricky on trying to figure out where to go with a student who has been taking welding or or a HOSA class who has done something often is a placement from a superintendent from other districts and now we can't accommodate that elective schedule I think that's one of our our our biggest things is we have such small offerings and that's like the Chicken and the Egg I have to be honest we have a small number of offerings because we have a small population when we had a larger population we had more offerings for example there used to be a um um nutrition and Foods class culinary arts over at Jackson Community School and that's not the case

053anymore the numbers were dwindling so if the AL alternative school was moved to Smokey would those students have access to more CTE classes because they're here that is correct what we would do would be like a dual enrollment for them so that they could be enrolled here and um here for Smoky high for some classes they could be offered into JROTC um but they would still be uh primarily assigned as Jackson Community School students but they would have access just like a lot of our jcec students come over and participate in band they are dual enrolled because they are allowed to come over and take a band class and will be allowed for JROTC classes so they would have offerings that they don't have on the on their current campus I think one of the

054points for an alternative school that was mentioned here at the very beginning for students who I was looking for the wording um need to be in a separate setting and I I know that there is disagreement on this not everybody agrees with this but as a longtime educator I believe that there needs to be a separate setting for those students who cannot function in the traditional class room not just for their sake but for the sake of the teacher so that that teacher can teach and so that the other students in that class setting can learn and if we don't have a separate setting then that defeats the purpose of having an alternative school and I think we have to really look closely at you know it I I mean IDE really it sounds great

055for them to be able to go in these classes but why were they taken out of the traditional classroom in the first place are there issues that that child is student is dealing with that prevents them from being successful and then maybe occupies the teacher's time from being able to teach those other students who have the right to learn as well and so I think it's got to be looked that so carefully and separate setting means separate or it's not separate I mean it's just you know we I don't want to play word games are we going to have a separate setting for a alternative school or not you mean like keeping it at the the other location well or if it was move to a another building is it separate look try to put

056it where it's separated and and and you know that I guess is something that Mr Robinson would have to um address because ultimately too all the students like are at different levels so some of them might not ever come out of that separate setting but given the opportunity some of them want to move back to a place where they're in they're outer an alternative school that's always been the case right we've always had that opportunity oh she couldn't just what I said just now yes um no I was just saying that some people some of the students need that like separate setting for the whole time and so if we had that separate part at Smokey they could stay in that separate setting and not ever come out of the three class rooms but then

057you're also going to have students who are willing to progress out of separate setting and back into the corporate and that'll be I think that would be more facilitated if they had an opportunity to go to those other classes um other CTE classes and you know of course it have to be approved but I think that it would cost them to like have a goal to reach um sometimes when you don't see things you don't feel like you can reach it and being where they are now it's it's almost like well I'm stuck here and I don't have like I can't see something else but coming here will give them the opportunity to see if I can transition back into Smoky Mountain High or if I can transition out of alternative I could start playing

058sports again I can start doing other things again so I I can see where you do need a separate setting for an alternative school but like when I was in high school our alternative school was in our high school and we had to learn how to have sensitivity and respect for those students as well so I think it's like good for them but I think it's good for our high school students to learn that there are people who need alternative education you know well and I think that you made an excellent point um Kim and I think that there there's always been that ability to move back to to the traditional classroom setting when they showed that they were willing to comply with the School Code of Conduct come to school you know just the

059basic requirements of every other student that's always been the case I think we have to remember that every student at Jackson Community School is not a behavior problem because there are students who are placed there or choose to go there because they have experienced trauma in their life and they um appreciate uh uh having the more individualized in in uh attention because they're they they're a little Collective group and so I don't I don't want it to come across that every student is there because they've been placed there because they've done something because that's absolutely not the case and that that brings up another question I had um about the third option about remaining on site changing the model you also continue to offer a more traditional path for the students who want to take

060that traditional path but need an alternative setting that's a good point yeah we do owe it like no matter what we decide we owe it to those students to Rebrand What alternative school is like Rebrand it and and give it a fresh a fresh look because for everybody involved even the other students who in the um County that they need to know that just like what you said we're not dealing with just kids who are bad behavior um there's kids who are going through serious trauma and I've expressed that even here on the board that I grew up in that so I didn't have alternative school to go to but when you come out of a lot of trauma I needed a lot of hand on to get me through high school so and I

061didn't want to be looked at any differently and but I do think we we owe it to those students to Rebrand what that looks like they need to feel like they're their own club like they're their own stuff and it's good stuff you know I think there was a time when the alternative school was viewed that way don't you think Dr Ard there was a pride of place and accomplishment in many of those students I talked to some of the students um this week and they were telling me they'd like to be called the Hub again I don't know where that came from but they were jillard can explain that we're the they said we're the Hub we want to be called the Hub so okay I I really do have something to say about

062all of this um the grant that we original that we originally wrote was designed by Dr Dale Carpenter from Western Allan painter who was a school psychologist and me and what we did um was we sat together at a table with a lot of others and said okay let's dream like we have no Financial constraints let's just dream about what we could do to make kids want to come to school and so we designed it to be for kids not behavior problems although there were some but for any child who had become disengaged with the regular instructional process and you would not believe the numbers of problems like they just weren't interested in going to school so they didn't so a lot of it was just truy so how are we going to bring those

063people back in and make it exciting so we changed the whole instructional program handson handson handson and I don't know how you all feel about it but just as a student I remember all the science experiments and all the little field trips and I could not I could not even tell you what was on 56 page 56 of the environmental science book sorry um but we had such great success and we we still required 28 credits to graduated we did that for quite some time until SC Simmons um changed it to accommodate some of his athletes Etc and that was several years after we opened but our enrollment kept growing and growing but not because um well what do we do about discipline I'll just tell you a little story I told the kids we

064have no rules unless we have to make them and every Monday morning we had a school meeting where we brought all the problems to the table and the kids would say well we have somebody's smoking in the bathroom okay so what do we do about that and I said well you guys tell me what you want to do they said well let us give us a week so they came back to me in a week and they had designed this beautiful architecturally drawn place where they could smoke and it was outside the fence in the back and they were far enough away from the road to so nobody would see them smok and they were far enough from trees and greeneries fire so I congratulated them and I said you know you you guys have

065done a beautiful job on this let me just take it and look at it so the next Monday morning meeting I said to them you know I don't have good news for you but the land outside of the fence also belongs to Jackson County Public Schools and you could hear this Collective oh and um so finally this wonderful High School senior beautiful girl said after about a minute it was seemed like an eternity she said you know what guys we're acting like babies we just need to suck it up they never smoked again so we made it a point for them to handle their own behavioral problems to discuss why those rules are in place that kind of thing um and every Monday morning um after the at the end of the meeting I said

066I want every person in this room to to remember how much you are loved today you were not placed here you were chosen to come here and um so a few years later one of the real Rascals said to me oh Dr ly he said um I said are you still having your Monday morning meetings he said well we have them sometimes but there's just no love in the room and little stories like that were so meaningful because that's how we controlled Behavior it wasn't through um suspension I in the the years that I had Alternative Learning which is I guess about maybe eight or nine and all um I only suspended one student and that was really to give me time to think it was a severe occasion um did we have well one

067student had brought weapons to school one student lived in the garbage dump down from the school with his dad who was an alcoholic and they had no electricity and he was getting to ready getting ready to leave but he had to leave at midnight because his dad didn't have a driver's license they didn't have a car so um there were just some real um stories there um one little girl had to sleep outside in the cold because her mother had married a pedophile uh second marriage and she came constantly with headlights to school so yes we had all the tragedies but today the majority of those students will tell you how much the Hub meant to them um and we have the kids some of our kids are paralegals some of them uh head chefs

068and um so I consider it very very successful but when Dr SS and I talked about it I said well could you change the the standard course of study does not address methodology it only tells you what subject matter do you need to know how you present it or how the kids learn it is up to the school system and I don't know that we could find a teacher who would be willing to go far enough away from traditional instruction to really accommodate I mean it takes a lot of work to accommodate those kinds of kids and keep them excited about coming to school so that's what I have to say about it I I I question the financial expenditure but now um I really think that if we could get somebody to get in

069there and change instruction and you know a lot of the people I hired were not certified teachers um but they were teachers of the year they were Carpenters they were uh like preacher Blandon who did the the greenhouse for us and and one of my kids said you know if I go off the beaten path here don't don't get another uh mental health person let just let me go out to the greenhouse and talk to preacher Blandon so I mean and they just we had the community garden where everybody in the community came I mean it was just a thriving place to be and that's what we bring we need to bring it back to that is the only thing that will increase enrollment um thank you I don't know who you are but thank

070you thank you thank you um but um it stopped when they started sending all the kids from the school system who had been suspended to the hub and they had to stay in a room be quiet all day and then leave and go home well that's when it became really a behavioral uh adjustment place and and I I was very much against that but I had nothing to say about it at that time so I think if we could find the right people even people in the community there is a line item in the budget for other professional assignment it doesn't call for it doesn't need certification and if we get the people in our community who are excellent at what they do um artists and um we had somebody who's left now but who

071we we got a beautiful Kil and those kids loved Pottery um but we just need in the regular classroom and I told the teachers when when we do your evaluation let's see a product and I gave um the science teacher a suggestion um let the kids write the textbook and if they're interested in something dealing with science and it just happens to be in the standard course of study let them um research that on the computer and and write a chapter on it with all the illustrations and everything because that's how you learn that's where the motivation is and so the kids actually made their own science textbooks that covered almost the entire course of study and they aced it so um and then when we studied American history we took them to Yorktown Jamestown

072Williamsburg Philadelphia Washington DC and they came back and they the people said well they'll ner past the end of course tests like that well let's see so we gave them the end of course test and Bo they aced it because for two weeks they had lived it smelled it tasted it dressed it um and so they said well no they must have cheated they I don't know where they got a copy of the test so I said well what do you want to do well we'll put them in the boardroom and put a lot of Proctors in there and give them a different uh test uh and so I said well fine go ahead and guess what they aced it again so I'm just telling you that the standard course of study does not dictate

073methodology and how you present the material to the kids and there are very exciting ways to do that and it will make kids want to come to Alternative if we can't do that then we might as well forget and go on and go to another school or whatever sounds good are there other questions or thoughts I think we need to address the financial issue on the financial page um you know I who has ever driving this would you go back to the financial page thank you so I know one of the options was to stay there and just try to revamp it but the cost of um keeping up the place and how much we're spending per student um I think needs to be discussed does anybody think that's too much well we do have

074just for your knowledge kind of what started this conversation back in the summer in August um was because they currently need an hbac system which is at a price tag of $450,000 to replace so that's really the impetus of what started this conversation back in August so we are holding tight because we need a 400 $450,000 worth of work to um repair slash replace the HVAC so that is going to be a cost that's a cost a needed cost well I know for those of you who are out there and parents and the public who is like why are you even thinking about this from this board member I would like to say I would I would like to be a good Steward of the money that we are spending and I don't look at

075this and feel like a good Steward of the money that we're spending to keep up that building I I think the kids are worth it but I don't think it's being a good store and um just like if one of my own children asked me for a Mercedes Benz right now I might have the money to get it for them but I don't think I would be being a good Steward of my money and I want to be a good Steward of the tax dollars that come in and we are spending an astronomical amount over what we're spending at the other schools per student and like I said this isn't about value I think the children are worth it but I think if we could do better we should try to do better I will

076say I think this is something that I asked to see um but really I mean I feel like it just shows I mean it does take a little more to to get some students to a certain point in education than it does others I've got four kids and I can promise you one of them learns a whole lot quicker than the other one does you know and so I really it just kind of showed a couple things to me one something that was obvious it cost more per student to operate a smaller school and you see that across the board and then to you know some kids it takes a little bit more investment to get them to the point they need to be at so I don't to me this is not a determining

077factor in whether or not we relocate that school so I will say I've had a couple of questions from various people in the community who know this is coming um parents who have children at other schools are saying why do you spend and they don't know these well now they know these numbers they're public then they're not a secret anyway if my kid goes to fair viiew is it really fair that my kid is only getting $110,000 per people and they don't that the people I've had conversations with don't necessarily know the exact number but the question is about equity and fairness and I think you're right it cost more for some students to get to that level of success we need but I also agree with you it is almost four times some of

078the other numbers and that is something as a taxpayer we have to consider if all of that was in salary I would be like okay but like it's we we could take the number from the building relocate the school I'm just saying and then put that same amount of money back into the kids but maybe not in the building we're putting it more into what the education they're getting so these alternative class that Dr Dillard is talking about we could really boy up because we would have the money for the classroom money for the teacher money for supplies to do those alternative things um field trips and stuff like that but but just to put it into the building well and one thing I think you have to look at look at the operating costs

079is pretty Equitable within a few hundred ,000 you know except for Smoky Mountain High School which is so much bigger building and has much more facilities like this lovely you know Auditorium we're in and two gyms and Smoky Mountain needs all those things so the the differential is really in the salaries and that's because number of personnel so when the you break that down by number of students it's not really fair to look and say you're spending 37,000 per student that doesn't translate into a different or a better education for those students because it's personnel and we have to have we have to have a principal we have to have assistant principal we have to have teachers and there's just less students in those settings and I think chairman um Jameson made a good point

080that some it's going to cost more to take to meet the needs of some of these students because a smaller setting with more one-on-one attention is what is going to make those students be able to succeed and it's worth it but can we can we do that and I'm just I'm not I'm just saying can that be feasible in another school because I do look that operating expenses because I mean k Valley is almost as much as Smoky Mountain High School um you know so there are some other high ones and so can some of that operating money that we're currently using at Jackson Community School if we didn't have to spend that amount of money could we still serve them in an alternate setting at a different location I think so to help eliminate

081some of those expenses hway Valley's got students so if we move those students and move the faculty and staff the only cost savings is going to be the operating is that correct or am I reading this wrong and the $450,000 that we're going have to spend on H fact and then other problems because well was that is that factored into this operating expense no and I will say that I shared with the staff that if you as a board decide to relocate every staff member has a job they may not come all together in a group because we may look at uh um or we haven't had a math teacher for a really long time at at Jackson Community school now we got one that's coming in January but we haven't had a math teacher

082but those students have have been getting Edgenuity math which is not ideal to learn virtually but all of the staff if you choose to relocate Jackson Community School all of the staff still have a role they just might not be part of Jackson Community School they might be at Scott Creer Smokey high or faw or somewhere so that money won't be a savings which it shouldn't be we want those people we need those people and we need to spend the money on on the kids I'm assuming this money is capital money that would only be able to be spent on facilities anyway um not necessarily because that money is allocated to us most mostly from our local budget for operating costs that's part of what I go and ask the County Commissioners for every year

083I'm looking at see right yes so she's shaking her head yeah I definitely am not saying I'm not trying to save by looking at the numbers I'm trying to reallocate funds to something other than how old is the building know it's one of our it was built in the 30s through the Jake remember what is it the year the building was built mid that's what I thought too okay so when we started talking about this months ago and then have been talking in the last few weeks I recommended suggested that this not be an action item because we need time to think and process and gather data and information and then my recommendation for you all was a board as a board is to have opportunity to listen um over the next month and see

084see what people want to say to you because they want to have a voice and then not make a decision um even at the next meeting but until February but I will say this that leaves the staff in a pickle because the not knowing is hard and I had that conversation about not knowing so tonight is for information only and I wanted to share the information you asked for but I I think it's important too for you all to hear what our community has to say and what our students and families and staff have to say so if there's other information you want me to gather before the January meeting you just have to ask and I'll get it and I know we've talked about space and we know that space would be tight if

085they were to relocate I guess my concern is you know we didn't have space for the Catamount school because we were bringing in um you know classes and Jr OTC so are we truly going to have or be able to come up with an alternate setting and Joey I'm not saying that you wouldn't do this or do your best to do it but are we truly going to have a separate setting where those that space can collectively be that's my question too thank you Abigail so if you think about uh Jack Community School in the format it is now those classes wouldn't translate exactly like that over so we have an Edgenuity Lab at J Lab at Jackson Community School we have one here we would just combine there's no sense in having two different

086uity Labs on a on a campus um if you think about uh um the Jag program that's one of the spaces we want to continue that so we're going to have to find space for a Jag program that teacher could be in an office space but then go into classrooms to teach that so like a shared classroom space so there it's going to be tight you're right but it's going to be it's something that that Mr Robinson said I can figure it out I can do it if that's what the board decides we'll make it happen could we kind of have somewhat of an answer that could we go walk through and see before we make an action I could ask Mr Robinson as I look at him right now that before the next board

087meeting or maybe even maybe that first week back in January if you could kind of walk your space and kind of get a tentative plan and something to offer to this board even before the next board meeting so you would have information is that fair okay and I would like to um as Dr SS mentioned it's going to be critical for us to hear from the community if you as a a parent teacher student please reach out to me it's on the on on the web page my contact information yes make informed decisions we need to be informed and you're the ones that will inform us so please do that yep reach out all of our all of our emails are out there blow my email up if you got an option for you know

088that we're not considering up here blow that email up I might have a you I'm going read it okay I'm just joking I read all my emails okay and if you can't find their emails cor is really good if you email core you can always direct all the emails are there other questions for tonight I've got some to-do things that you've asked me to do and I will take care of that no and I would encourage you if you are reaching out to one board member if you'll reach out to all of us to provide us that information oh that's good we do try to forward each other emails if we see that others have not been included but we do all want to make sure that we have the same information so make sure

089that you're reaching out to all of us thank you Abigail thank you AB all right next on the agenda are capital project updates from Jake oh yeah I got Mr chairman Dr SS and members of the board um I do have just a little bit of a capital projects update for you this evening um just as a reminder not all of our capital projects are as exciting as some of the ones we were able to share at the last meeting with playgrounds and new signs and and things like that some of them are not quite as glamorous but for those that need them they are um extremely important um we've had quite a bit of roof maintenance uh over the last 30 days and some HVAC repairs and we are scheduled to replace the ceiling

090in the Blue Ridge um High School building uh that got the new roof so hopefully that'll be completed over Christmas break and when the kids come back we also had to replace some sprinkler heads here at the the new gym in the auditorium it's these you can see these little white things right here I think especially that one right over top of Lin had to get replaced so it wouldn't spray her on the head um uh some fencing at the prek classroom at uh at CAE Valley U maglocks on the prek classrooms at colway Valley um but I will say that uh funds for our larger projects as we talked about when we were back at Scots Creek um are winding down and dwindling down and so we really are more in focused on repairs

091and maintenance than we are larger capital projects just because that's the time of year and the funding that we that we have um but I'd be happy to answer any questions as the board has about any capital projects past present or future thank you all right thank you all very much thank you Jake up next is Christy Walker with the unaudited financial summary good evening Dr SS Mr chairman members of the board in your packets you have a December un audited financial statement um you have comparison data for last year is there any questions regarding this information okay thank you uh now uh we are at the public comment section thank you cor do we have any on up yes Mr chair um first I'd like to read the instructions for public comments we do

092have um one written public comment that was submitted and we have four speakers that will be with us this evening each month during part of the regularly scheduled board meeting time is set aside for citizens to address the board through public comment each speaker will receive three minutes to present comments however the public comment session will not exceed 30 minutes total except by a majority vote of the board a signup sheet will be available 30 minutes before the meeting begins for any individual or group to indicate their desire to address the board during the public comment period we will recognize the speakers in the order in which they signed in substitute speakers will not be permitted and speakers may not donate any portion of their time to another speaker if a speaker is unable to

093present all of his or her information within the specified time limit the speaker May provide the board with the additional information in written form if an unusually large number of people request to speak a majority of the board may decide to reduce the time for each individual or to require the designation of a spokesperson for each group of persons supporting or opposing the same positions at any time the board May establish additional procedures to ensure that public comment sessions proceed in an efficient and orderly manner written public comments may be sent in advance of the board meeting and will be shared with the board during the meeting all written public comments must be received by 4m. the day prior to the board meeting to be included public comments are designed sign for the school board

094to listen the board will not engage in dialogue or answer questions and complaints about individual employees or students are prohibited our first public comment come came in on Sunday December 15th at 6:40 a.m. and I read dear JCPS board members we are the parents of a special needs kindergartener and we're made aware on Friday 126 of a policy change being brought to the board on Tuesday 12:17 we strongly object to a policy that eliminates ABA service for students in Jackson County ABA therapy is an evidence-based practice and is the gold standard for helping children with autism spectrum disorder determination of the need for ABA support in school should be made on a case-by casee basis and by a CH by a child's IEP team excuse me blanket policies such as this hurt the most vulnerable

095in our community and send a clear message to families and children with disabilities that they do not matter our child has benefited from Individual AB individualized ABA support at school at no cost to the district our insurance company pays for this service it has enabled him to participate in the general education classroom and to be successful by removing this service it would be harder for him to learn to make friends to integrate and to be a productive and contributing member of this community not not only will these things be harder he will regress he will lose skills that have taken him longer to learn than other children his age what happens then how will the district address this deficit smaller districts like ours have fewer resources to meet these specific needs when compared to larger

096districts in our state the benefits of ABA support are innumerable and are not only for a disabled child everyone benefits from the availability of this support other children in the classroom benefit the teachers that are already overburdened with larger class sizes benefit and other school staff benefit for example the child is not as disruptive in class the teacher does not have to spend extra time away from other students and can do their jobs more effectively the other children are learning how to interact and make friends with someone who is different they feel more comfortable asking questions and getting those questions answered they feel more safe and secure and most notably they are learning how to treat other humans with differences with dignity and respect the most important lesson of all lastly why is Aba singled

097out there are plenty of outside companies who are contracted with JCPS that come into our schools and Provide support to other students example mental health support and occupational therapy why is the district prioritizing that need of students who need these supports over students who need ABA support it is not ethical to deny any child access to a support especially when that support comes at no cost to The District in summary we implore you to vot vote against the proposed policy of eliminating ABA services in our schools our child matters and this support is vital to to his continued success ESS respectfully Chris and Christa Johnson end of comment we now have four speakers the first one would be Nancy Harmon she would like to speak about Jackson Community School Miss Harmon please come up no

098it does not it's a test to see if you can run your time starts now chair board members Dr SS the school of Alternatives interchanging the word comprehensive early began as an alternative model for Jackson County Schools it finally became known as The Hub the center of the wheel because it was seen as a central safe place for students in Jackson County it developed into a training ground for administration teachers with high turnover as well as a resource for truancy and academic and behavioral failure it has now become Jackson Community School a school where students can choose to attend all are welcomed and is asset based post covid and even after 37 staff changes five programmatic changes the students and STA and staff look at this place as a place to heal and learnr currently

099our school is now a place where teachers have chosen to be employed they have chosen the children a place where multi-disciplinary teaching and project-based learning and classroom management are the foundation for brain development and helping students move through complex trauma our students have felt marginalized however they do not feel that way at the community school they know they're safe and heard and have opportunities to be themselves even if they are in having a familial crisis or Mental Health crisis the intent of this district has always been to create an alternative model that incorporates best practices for the student careful transition is a healthy start the student population in 20124 is very different than it was 20 years ago broken families abuse addiction mental Health and Human Trafficking not to mention the social media are all

100challenges that young people have to navigate interventions are a part of this challenge when those experien are the midst of concerns academics are impossible and rigor is even further Out Of Reach the faculty and staff at JCS offer every student a safe place to be students are given the opportunity to de decompensate walk out of a classroom regroup refocus in a large school this would be impossible what would help to get our numbers up I do not know but I do know that low numbers can be viewed as a positive we are doing good work good work that might move us as a district to being proactive and not reactive in which we can our mission our alale student and thank you thank you there's another next we have Jessica blankinship who would also like

101to speak about Jackson Community School Nancy would you please email that to the board I will thank you thank you I don't think okay your time time starts now good evening um sorry we started with the Hub probably when my kid was 10 um best decision that was ever made transition back to elementary school um come to the high school and he is not perfect by any means he does have behavioral issues he does have emotional issues he has mental health issues he acts out he it was a superintendent decision to move him to the Community School my son graduated in May of this year yay that is is if he would have stayed here at the hospital I don't know where he would be and that's just they took the time to get to

102know their kids one on-one he could not function in a class room in a normal setting period it didn't matter he had an IEP we started at Swain he got a 504 he got an IEP once he came here they recognized it they did anything and everything they could to make sure that he had what he needed to be successful so at 17 years old he's a high school graduate thanks to them because if it was not for them he may not be here we we don't know he would have been a Dropout but we couldn't ask for a better school integrating them back in a big building I don't think would be beneficial because you can't take somebody who can't function in a regular class and put them in the middle of a school

103and expect them to be able to function because you're putting them back in troubled children like mine you're putting him back in where it started where he had the ability and access to things that should not have been in the high school to begin with and wasn't really listened to when given the option or questions weren't asked to find out what the initial issue was but as soon as we got to the community school he was worked with he was talked to like he was somebody and it was he had his one-on-one time and he had what he needed and if I had to get a phone call I got a phone call but they worked with us it wasn't just okay you're suspended they had alternate access and Alternate resources to be able to

104allow children to have what is needed because not all kids are black and white the world is not black and white we have a lot of rainbow kids that you they'll never fit them in a square box and that's what needs to be known and seen and they make sure that happens for these kids that need it thank you and next we have Kenny parmen is it okay didn't see the r sorry he would also like to speak about Jackson Community School good evening board leadership our community that wasn't required to be here my name is Kenny Parmenter um I want to state that the My Views and ideas are my own not that of my employer I am a resident of Jackson County and that's what I'm speaking on part of I'm also a

105clinical social worker I have worked in day treatment I have worked in schools for the past six years um and before that I was working with troubled youth um so I have a plethora of experience working with kids that do not fit into the mainstream population um most of the my experience es with kids that were not in schools um and there are children that will not function in a gened population that is why alternative schools exist as I was doing my research um it was also um spoken about as a sanctuary School a place where children can go um that they feel welcomed and supported um Mr Robinson I I wish you luck if they do decide to move it here um it's going to be very difficult to create that safe space within

106the gened population right we talk about Edgenuity um being in the same classroom that's no longer a separate setting right and I look at the finances and the the money and I understand that it it costs a lot of money to run these programs and we have to find that money to continue to allow these students access to an education for those that wouldn't have otherwise been able to attend school those that would drop out were that we have a policy of no child left behind right children will be left behind if they don't have an alternative education and so we have to find a way to continue to make this functioning um and to get those numbers up I feel if we are able to revitalize or re uh reinvigorate the program they can

107they can find ways to get students into um the setting that they need right the kids are out there and some of those kids are continuing to fall through the cracks another piece that I worry about is that if we reintegrate those children um there's a number of IEPs and 504s and if you put a teacher with 30 kids and 20 of them have IEPs there's no way those those needs can be met we're going to run into lawsuits with those parents and children that are being left behind and so whether we save the money by reintegrating and and cutting administrative cost that that money is going to come in later where we have to find alternative programs that no longer exist outside those buildings so I worry that if we try to cut Corners

108now it's going to come back and hurt us later I work in Haywood County and we've seen that the academy was taken away four years later it was brought back um it I I want to see an alternative program remain in Jackson County for those students especially middle schoolers um that that need that level of support and I understand those numbers are real low right now um but if they have the most amount of chance of being successful being treated and hopefully recuperating thank you for your time can I ask one more question of the board um you can ask the question um what information do you all need to know to make that decision I'd love to do more research and support finding the evidence to show you that these programs are successful so

109please let us know what you need to know thank you and finally we have Mr Curtis Collins who would also like to speak on Jackson Community School I think Kurt walked out did y'all see Kurt walk out he had to go thank you Marcus did he leave Mr Collins he left okay then we are through thank you thank you uh thank you all for your comments they'll be very helpful as we move through this discussion about the Community School um up next we have our action agenda items uh budget amendments Christy Walker your your own deck good evening again I'm requesting approval for budget amendment number four to the 2025 budget resolution this amendment includes the state fund Federal fund other specific Revenue fund and capital outlay this uh copy of that amendment is in

110your packet are there any questions at this time that I can answer anybody have any questions for Christen do I have a motion I make a motion that we approve the budg budget amendment as presented I second that motion all in favor thank you Christie mat next Jake with final change order for the Smokey Mountain High School construction project now a long load so the board will find in their packet a request for change order from Buchanan and Suns um this is specifically for Smoky Mountain High School I will point out that this change order reflects um bsi's willingness to basically cancel out all change orders uh the cost not not the work itself um but the cost of all change orders so that uh we will be responsible for paying for the cost of

111the original um quote for the uh for the cost for specifically for Smoky Mountain High School and so the the list on the back side you should have two-page document is a breakdown of what those change orders had been along the way so I would recommend um accept in this uh Ashley has been a part of this along the way and um I'm not going to speak for but I if she would recommend um accepting this change order as well I'll just make one brief comment um when I was the county commissioner that was the decision to spend that money on on those walls to make one portal of entry in our schools was the hardest decision I voted on my whole four years because I kept thinking of those millions of dollars that could

112go into the classroom but Mr Banning convinced me that those were needed and uh I'm glad they're done well I appreciate your your voice your vote those years ago and support and I do greatly immensely beyond measure um am thankful that we are coming to the end of this project Hey Jake just for point of clarification that this says the smuggy Mountain High School Construction project but this is all of the campus wall projects right this is this particular uh portion so um the board has already voted on change orders for all the other projects um and this is the last one to complete it out yeah well I move that we accept this change order that's just oh they're still talking I'm sorry no and I guess the reason Wes was asking that question

113and I was confused is because Blue Ridge school is referenced in the letter and then fair viiew is referenced in the um line items so they are referencing that they did this previously so this is in line with what they've uh done in the past as far as these change orders um basically what we're doing is in lie of liquidated damages for the contracts being extended we negotiated with them in lie of liquidated damages because it took so long elaborate yeah that's what time extension Jake yeah do you mind to elaborate on that for the board and further public which part as far as the liquidated damages yeah so our con so this has been a complicated project from the very beginning and it is also been taking place during Co and so there were

114um there were so you got to remember our architect their job is to argue so that the school district pays for essentially nothing or as little as you possibly can and then the contractor's uh job is to complete the work and also try and get paid for as much as possibly feasible and so throughout the process uh Architects will point out this is something that was not done in an amount of time that we deemed that it should have been done in and general contractors will point out well there were extenuating circumstances that were outside of our control and we were unable to foresee that in the bidding process to know that when we bid this project we didn't realize that it was going to take 57 weeks to get a door in so so

115the architect will tell you tough and the contractor will say well owner you are in the middle you are the final decider of this and so what we have done is negotiate with Buchanan and Suns um with our architect saying that we should not pay for anything at BSI saying please be reasonable and us coming up with a solution that is is reasonable thank you in a in a 30 second condensed version of the last four years of my life it really has been four years that's oh my goodness and a reminder to the public that the students came to a school board that I was not on but I would have gladly wanted to be on um and asked for they did they asked for the protection and the walls so for everybody out

116there in the public who wants to know where this idea was dreamed up it was our beautiful children yeah and I will say the quality of the work that Canan and Suns has done has been excellent everybody building inspector architect there's no question about the the quality of the construction and the flow of it has been um excellent as well there's been a few little hiccups but nowhere near the worries that we had going in of how difficult it would be to get kids to follow the the really the guidelines and um and it's gone extremely well so but I do ask your approval for the um change order I make a motion that we approve the final change order for the Smoky Mountain High School construction project I second that motion all in favor

117all right Jake you're up again with policy update first readings yeah we have uh quite a few policies to review this evening um the first one is a first reading um which is policy 5150 reporting to external agencies and again this is a first reading so you don't have to make a decision on this but just a little bit of context for why your school board and remember all of these policies were written by your School Board Association and their attorneys and recommended to you have been reviewed by your attorney and recommended to you and then reviewed by the appropriate Jackson County Public Schools central office staff and recommend it to you but that first one um which is in there what you will notice is each one of those items references another board policy

118so there's really no new reporting requirement in this policy it is simply for an organizational purpose put all of the policies into one location so that school administrators teachers and central office staff have it in one location we intend with our annual trainings that we do um which some of the board members have participated in to include this one board policy into that because it collects all of the reportings and by reportings for those in the audience that don't have the document these are laws that previously existed policies that previously existed that dictate reporting to DSS if you if you feel that something dangerous is happening with a student that requires the superintendent and the HR Director to report specific behaviors of teachers to the Department of Public construction so that they can consider whether

119or not a license is revoked um for a teacher based on um disciplinary conduct that they've taken so really this comes from just being perfectly honest and actually could speak more specifically but there was a school district in North Carolina that had a central office um position that was charged with failure to report based on a DSS report and so I think your your School Board Association has recommended this policy to put these all in one place so that all of us your employ employees have one specific place to go to to say these are all the things that we're required to report so that policy is a is a first read with no need to vote on the rest of these again are recommended by your your Association and by your attorney and by

120us the one that I'll point out I know the board has looked at all of them but the one that I'll specifically point out to you because it will affect the how the board meetings function is uh policy 2302 remote participation in Schoolboard meetings yeah and I'll let Ashley address this more um but um it basically changes the requirements for participation in a remote meeting stating that if if a board member is remotely participating in a school board meeting then that does not count towards having a quorum to be able to hold that meeting and this is based on a recent court case and I'll let Ash explain more if you need more but this really it was not um the practice of the board to regularly have remote participation in school board meetings until

121covid and of course covid and the declared state of emergency and so this policy would say that we could not you could not participate in a meeting towards the Quorum um unless there was a declared state of emergency in North Carolina and so actually is there anything you would add to that or no you explained it really well does that also mean the the person who is participating remotely does not vote on action items that's correct [Music] okay and and really we don't feel as if the board has much Le legal leeway in we do understand that this impacts the function of the board um and how they would meet but we don't feel we feel like we have to recommend you to accept this policy based on the court cases and based on General

122statute any other questions about any of the other board policies that I can get Ashley to answer for you I'm the on the smoking and tobacco products I thought in the I couldn't see what it originally was but I thought vaping was I mean I'm trying to wait for it to come up I know it says liid a wording um electronic pipes and components of Vapor Products are are we clear like are is that really clear for these students when it comes to vaping I don't know I thought it there was two eight is tobacco products and then 12 is smoking and tobacco products which which one were you referring to Kim which which P policy the 5026 or the yes the 5026 5026 I'm just going to pull it up right quick so I

123just I know it's clear like I I can understand it but also could our students and parents understand that vaping is part of this like so I will say so I get your question now so I will say our code of conduct is very explicit okay um in that so um we feel the policy is sufficient but I totally get your point to make sure that students and parents know that this is a prohibited Behavior okay and so we have spent time over the years when we because we are required by law to reflect on our uh code of conduct Every Spring and we have spent quite a bit of time over the last um four or five years because when I was a principal vaping had just barely started and it rarely ever happened

124and we all know that it is it is quite possibly the the single largest threat to um uh to to child safety um in our community is access to Vapes and whether it be one over the counter or one with um you know who knows what in it but our our uh code of conduct is very explicit so that it's um that Vapes are absolutely prohibited and that there are consequences for that and that really any substance that is used to try and alter your state okay um is prohibited unless it's uh prescribed by a doctor okay yep good question any other questions and this isn't a change there's no change in this one it's just there are for So for 50 that number is26 and so the attorney notes for 5026 is that the

125recommendation is made to be to uh to be consistent with applicable laws it basically revises the definition of a tobacco product to align with the new definition that the state law has laid out okay it also includes some minor footnote changes and some verbiage changes but basically to your point about what it's being called that's to align it to what the state legal definition of a of a vape would be thank you um in the future can we get the strikeouts to like where the changes have been made the red Lin yeah they're both both in the I okay sorry that's okay I just poured over I figur I figured it out each one had both to strike out into the version okay like 30 different God there was a lot of policies this time

126lot a lot to read okay thank you need more time oh yeah I was struggling if there are no other questions about any of the policies I do ask for your approval for basically that would be two no I'm sorry one one through 15 update 15 make a motion that we approve policy updates 1 through 15 I second that motion all in favor thank you field trip Dr s yes so I am seeking your approval for um the three field trips listed the first one is Blue Ridge Early College grade 12 going to Williamsburg Virginia it is an overnight and out of state number two is Jackson Community School grades 9 through 12 going to the Alcatraz East crime museum in Pigeon Forge um and then finally number three Smoky Mountain High School grades 9

127through 12 visiting Kataba Valley Community College and that is an overnight so I seek your approval for all three field trips make a motion that we approve the three field trips I second that motion all in favor at this time we find it necessary to go into Clos session pursuant to GS form 43318 11 for the following purposes under subsection A1 to prevent the disclosure of privileged or confidential Personnel information pursuing to GS 115c 319-321 and A3 to discuss matters protected by the attorney client privilege do I have a motion to go into Clos session I make a motion that we go into close session I second that motion all in favor if you're not coming back after close session Merry Christmas to you a Merry Christmas Merry Christmas um e e e go my

128already do you know what time I went to bed last night 9:17 yeah we're not done that's my everyday bed time did you hear me Abigail I called in we're back on we're live we're live we're live I don't GA live what' you say about that person Gail I changed I said Wes is so amazing that's not okay all right no action was taken during Clos session so I am seeking your approval for the Personnel action um agenda as presented I make a motion that we approve the Personnel action agenda as presented I second that motion all in favor the next regularly scheduled business meeting of the Board of Education will be January 21st 2025 at 6 pm at Smoky Mountain Elementary School no ma'am I'm sorry I don't know that yet do I have

129a motion to adjourn I make a motion that we adjourn tonight's meeting second all in favor hi Merry Christmas so next meeting we

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.