001good afternoon everyone Welcome to our special call meeting on this evening U at this time I believe we have all our board members present let the record reflect that all our board members a presid at this time we have new business proposed 2526 open enrollment School list is Sarah English will come good afternoon good afternoon again so I am with you today to discuss two items the first is the proposed open enrollment list for the 2526 school year toig out and you do have this in front of you okay the other um item I have for um board action today is discussing options for seats at non-open enrollment schools you have this in front of you as well so we are proposing two options for you today the first option is our current pit County
002schools reassignment policy which is policy 4150 section C2 and you have a copy of the full 4150 in front of you so that process um is our reassignment for non-open enrollment schools the parent or Guardian completes the reassignment form for the upcoming school year must be completed between March 1st and June 1st prior to the year of enrollment I do not have this copy thank you sure I'm sorry and then after June 1st reassignment is considered only in the event of extenuating circumstances once a parent makes a request the requests are reviewed by the superintendent or designate the principle of the school to which the student is assigned based on their attendance Zone and the principle of the school the student desired to attend approval or denial is a notification is sent to the applicant
003if denied the applicant May request a hearing on the reassignment request and a panel of the board will heal hear the appeal the panel panel's recommendation is submitted to the full board for final determination and the board renders a decision and notice of that decision the appeal decision is given to the applicant so that's our current reassignment process okay the other option is one we've discussed prior and we've gotten principal feedback on this senior staff has talked about this um option two would be a lottery selection for non-open enrollment schools and there is a provision of 4150 for a lottery process at section c1a and what I'm proposing as this procedure is as follows under that um that the lottery registration period would open March 1st at 8:00 a.m. and close on March 15th at
0045:00 P p.m. this is not a first come first serve application process we're proposing that five Lottery seats become available at each non-open enrollment school for fairness sake I like you I like you more and more um student must meet all lottery seat criteria and that's linked there on the digital but you have a copy of that we'll talk through that in just a minute in order to be considered for eligibility and I'm going to emphasize a random Lottery process conducted for those parent or those students who meet criteria would be conducted no later than March 31st the parent are gardening and the parent or Guardian must accept the lottery seat assignment by no later than 3 days school days after notification applicants not awarded through lottery selection so that if they do not get
005selected through the random process they'll be placed on a waiting list students must continue to meet eligibility criteria or may risk losing their Lottery seat if a lottery seat becomes available during the school year the the same random lottery selection process will be used for applicants on the waiting list parent or Guardian must accept the lottery seat in these cases within 5 school days if not accepted by the applicant the the random lottery selection will be used to select and offer the seat to another student on the waiting list and then there will be no appeal process for the lottery selection decision okay and we gave um longer if it was during the school year to allow for adjustment than during the lottery period okay and then you can see the criteria that we've outlined
006for um being eligible for lottery seat is being in good academic standing for the prior current or current school year through March 1st and good attendance standing with less than eight unexcused absences in excellent Behavior standing for the prior school year and that's outlined there no disciplinary offences that are rated as level four or five through March 1 and no more than three disciplinary offenses rated at level one two or three the the family can provide transportation to and from School of Choice each day and then applicant must attest understanding that students in grades 10 through 12 who are awarded a lottery seat will be ineligible for athletic participation for a period of 365 days okay if they get the if they're 10th 11th or 12th grader and then um other extenuating circumstances exist exist
007that are outlined in policy 4150 so students who can provide a valid reason for school choice request related to curriculum offered at school of choice but not offered at their the school um assigned to their attendance area or a documented hardship okay what questions do you have um I have two so can any student put their name on the lottery list between March 1st and 15th or only if there's an extenuating circumstance or is the extenuating circumstance only they have to meet those um eligibility criteria so all of these for all the time okay so they have to have that okay and then how do you determine during the school year if a lottery seat becomes available is that is that just if the a student that that got a seat because of the lottery
008left and not if that one of those B students left okay oh okay good question okay where ask a question how'd you come up with five we we talked that was with principal conversation Dr ler and I discussed that we did five because that's just the we tried to be fair so that every school is not on the Open Enrollment list we wanted it to be a small number so it's manageable for school staff in general how did the principles feel about yes sir so if I'll start with that five that five could potentially be adjusted because it if you look at the non-open enrollment schools some of them may have more seats available in a certain grade level so fifth through third grade is is full at a certain School excuse me fifth through
009third grade going backwards kindergarten through third grade may be full but there may be a lot of seats in third that's what I was right or you go to a middle school one principal said I can't take anybody in sixth or eth but I do have seats in seventh um and then one high school says I just I don't have seats or I I there's nowhere that I could put them right um in general the principles um had a lot of questions about the lottery system I'll tell you that they did have a lot of questions um in terms of it not overwhelming them because they know their their schools are already full um so we did try to work through a process at the request of the board and the chair to um ease
010their concerns or their questions hence the two options well my followup is if you give me the uh option of hey my sixth and seventh grades packed but yet the eighth grade my numbers are down can I just have that open lottery for the eighth grade that would help as a principal that would really help me a lot just you know as well as just having the whole school absolutely and so there were some schools that said we we we we'll open to it but we're going to start we're going to have to start closed because we're full everywhere um so that hence option one that Miss English has here that you follow your current policy as a board with the reassignment um with what you currently have and then we add in this that
011layer of the reassignment policy or the option to with the lottery selection forment SCH um so just kind of looking through the the two policies it seems like the is am I right in saying the big difference would be there's a lot more more specific criteria listed so it's more clarity it's no longer first come first serve and no more appeals would would you say those are the big differences between the two the two options yes I was I was hesitating on the first come first serve because that's not really the case with our current reassignment policy why why is it listed in two just for further Clarity just for clarity okay um so then my my second question is how often do people ask for an appeal is that a common thing we probably
012have less than 10 a year would you say m Ranken is that very time consuming is that like a burden on I'm going to defer to miss miss Ranken helps me with that process it's not timec consuming but it the burden really falls on the panel of the board okay okay oh that's us okay new got it all right okay those are my questions the the 365 days of being eligible for athletic is that AC athletic policy interesting for pit County Schools state of North Carolina state of North Carolina okay so they they can transfer in ninth grade but then if they transfer again during high school after once they start nth grade they transfer again during High School unless it's a Bonafide address change um they have to sit out for 365 days D
013the thought process behind that is baffling to me because those are crucial athletic years for people we don't want to transfer for athletics correct but but at the same time in a lottery you're doing it for a certain reason and whether it's Athletics or academics You're penalizing athletic side of it and that's when they when that's not a criteria to get into the lottery right that's just so we're in it we're in adhering to the the North Carolina policy so any other questions well I just have just to follow up and make sure I'm correct for example at the high school there there are open opportunities it just a matter of when those kids go to pck Community College correct third and fourth period in that particular school you're referring to yes did you have
014question I have a question and it's more for our our board to have conversation about too um but I'm wondering so the extenuating circumstances so students must be able to provide a valid reason related to curriculum to say why they want to go to that school and I was wondering especially Ben Andor you've shared about Conley specifically um what are you hearing from your constituents and and community members that Conley has that are other high schools that are open enrollment have seats don't have I think if there's a program there that's really um really wanted we need to also consider how we can expand that so that more students are able to access it too regardless of Lottery that's only five students so if there's something there that students are really wanting I would really
015I want to hear that so that we can consider how we can make sure it's accessible in other places as well um so so hearing from y'all and what you've been hearing from your community too because I haven't heard I haven't heard heard those main thing is what' you say Dr English barness that's the main thing that I hear sure I'm sure Mr for is too I I've had for example parents at a couple of the other high schools that did not offer agricultural education for example want their kids to be involved in agricultural education and that was one of the things and I'm sure that there are other that's just something specific that I'm thinking about a specific parent specifics yeah absolutely so thinking about how we can also expand agriculture education to some
016of our other high schools as well too honors AP certain courses C are there certain courses offered there yeah I mean they've mentioned you know each year it may change sure but okay that's what they've mentioned that's helpful for me I'm just interested in how you know I mean fairness absolutely being able to go to all the schools but fairness is you know if that's not offered at other schools then we need to figure out how to make sure that it's offered to more than just these SP Lottery kids too um at least in in our big conversation I think that's going to be an important thing too I know in times past we've had where a teacher would um oby a you know share with another school and yet that child doesn't learn that
017way they they need be face to face with the teacher I mean that's what has been mentioned um so have a question thank you thank you Sarah um you've done outstanding putting this together at the board requested so today we have before us two options to choose from correct no just this okay now I'm confusing sorry I'm sorry I'm sorry as a point of clarifica can I clarify one thing under option one you're not I don't believe you are planning to alter your policy so this is this is what is in policy right now so you you would retain reassignment I think what it really is is that you would be adding five a lottery really under your existing policy with some criteria so ex sort of more of an administrative procedure that's really what
018you would be right okay we need to call that something else then because that's very confusing misleading instead of option one option two because they think they have options yeah or like add or like this is our policy this is like you said an amendment to this policy or something besides an option yeah in c1a there is um what it says is that the superintendent will designate a procedure for the lottery so that's where that that's where it's written into policy right now so just to clarify with attorney Hodson option one is for the board today yes option two is for the board today so either we want option one to stay with the reassignment policy as it is you're going to choose okay that's I was confused okay okay so based on all of
019our principal input um and conversation um to limit confusion on for parents what we are recommending to the board is option one but we wanted to give you both options um to make action on can I can I clarify something I need to speak it out to make sure I'm on the same page um so option one between uh May March 1st and June 1st parents can apply for assignment to any school reassignment to school and then they can also appeal it for our open enrollment schools if they don't get in and would be then be in front of one of a panel of us they appeal and they don't get in right so reassignment is for those schools that are not on the Open Enrollment list um and then it Go the superintendent design
020review those requests and if denied the parent has an appeal that comes to the panel that comes to us so then we could say yes you can go to that school determine our determination so there's so the our policy does offer the opportunity for seats yes in our open enrollment schools yes already it would just be through our discretion versus five random students okay thank you that's and your recommendation to the board is option one yes can I ask a question about about that just why I'm sorry I we have two more questions yes so can I ask so you all wrote up these other options based just kind of on our conversations um repl so why if you're recommending one you want less detail because it looks like option two is offering more clarity
021about process to parents but you are recommending one why to reduce confusion so there is a lot of confusion with so right now we have open enrollment and reassignment and just with those two choices my office processes a lot of conversations phone calls and Fields a lot of questions about what the difference is between open enrollment and our reassignment policy okay so if we added Lottery that adds one more layer of so that's going to give you guys more okay right am I'm so confused I'm sorry I'm just really confused so option one is our current policy yes yeah so we're so you're recommending our current policy I thought the whole point of this discussion was to talk about I thought this was going to be like an amendment to this policy not an additional
022policy so uh if just so our last meeting um May I yes please at our last meeting um and as we do we we presented our open enrollment to the board right um and in the effort of allowing other schools to possibly be possibly be open enrollment uh at the board's direction we talked about lottery so we were asked to go forth and create a lottery system so that other schools could give a way for students to be a part now under your current as a board your current system you're already doing option one the thing that we drew out for the board is that we don't typically utilize option one uh a lot so we were adding that as a layer to open enrollment so that there are schools in the district they know
023that if I if I can't go an open enrollment I could at least apply under these circumstances so that I could go to this particular School regardless of the capacity right that's what you're normally doing your second option is what you as the board chair directed us to do was to create a list of lotter receipts where would add to this in the sense of those non-open enrollment schools we could open up a few seats for parents to choose so your option one is what you're Norm what you're doing right now so you you would decide whether or not you continue with what you're doing now with an emphasis on those non-open enrollment schools we would encourage them to apply through reassignment which is the current policy the second option would be this would remain
024but then you'd add on your lottery schools um and parents could apply for a space at at a certain school it could be five depending on after this conversation we could talk to principles and say you've got you've got 17 seats in fourth grade all right so those are the two things what Miss English is saying when we talked the principles they were saying parents are confused about Open Enrollment they already reassignment and then you add a third layer of the lottery so I think that's the recommendation in terms of narrowing down confusion parents would still in this option adding reassignment letting them know it's available they still would be able to do it or or Lottery system all the schools and depends on the seats that they have open so that helps I don't
025know I also want to sorry go ahead recognize that there's less criteria that one would have to meet to go through the reassignment process anyone could apply for that um at any point and be at our discretion whereas there's two weeks that these five students could potentially apply so this isn't actually doesn't feel as fair and in that regard because it doesn't give as much time when it's closed they can't I mean and if we're looking at curriculum the documented hardships which are also criteria then we as a board would also have more understanding of what's going on in our schools and be able to have more conversations so I I wanted that so that feels like there's more opportunity as long as we make sure that families know that they can appeal it sounds
026like that's been a that something that people don't aren't as clear about is that if we don't um get approved then we can appeal and have those conversations and come to the board it sounds like that might need to be more clearly ex um explained in that reassignment process thank you sorry I'll stop now thank you m chair so I I I won walk through this process as well so I know under the current system even though they can appeal the process going through to get the appeal is very very small is that a fair statement the process to get the appeal to to be to be successful the percentage of people who are successful and actually getting a hearing yeah think he it depends on exu it's a case by case depends on exua
027circumstance where in this case you you will have five that at least will have the opportunity and if I'm hearing correctly possibly more if those schools have opportunities in areas where they're more open right so so you at least have five and then opportunities for more if there are areas in the school that has space available yes any other question sorry okay so I'm here I I I'm just going surprising I'm surprising myself here but I'm leaning more toward this Lottery idea for several different reasons but for the first like you said there's that guarantee but also there's no appeal process I think with the appeal process you're relying on three different board members to hear your case so you know I think some of the fairness is taken out of that aspect as well
028because I mean it's just and it's going to be more if we make this more um I don't know well known I guess you could say that's going to put a lot more on us as well so I'm I'm just thinking of no offense I'm thinking what's easier for me right now too so I'm thinking like I like this idea because it has higher standards like you have to hold to these standards to stay in that school it's not only about the hardship or the the grade but we don't currently hold just reassignment students to this policy do we we it's behavior in attendance be okay so I think this sounds a lot better give these students more of a reason to really want that position yes sir all right sorry my brain works different
029also so hypothetically if we take option two yep you still can apply apply for reassignment March 1st through June 1st but you also have the ability to apply for the lottery March 1st through 15th so you have two opportunities to be selected to go to that school yes I mean to me that's I'm I'm almost agreeing with Amy cuz like you're just providing another Pathway to get into the school that you originally wouldn't have a chance uh you select number of seats yeah right and the and the principal's were not in favor in the leadership as much with option to because they thought it would be too confusing they just felt like it added another layer of confusion yes how about fairness sorry and Equity they were I mean they they understood 100% where we
030were coming from did they feel like that was going to be a benefit or they didn't if you could if we could do it by grade level about where there's space so if that that elementary school or that cas school I have space in third grade I've got space in e8th grade Dr L can I open these up for lottery absolutely can I close the others you can close the others can it be a shorter window of time yes it's shorter window of time you got till March 15th to apply and it's done can we do that can we do a Fusion then that's what we're what we're to you I think for Simplicity sake this is for we're going to do what you tell us I think for Simplicity sake option one is basically
031staying exactly as we are yeah maybe with a re-emphasis on reassignment option two adds the layer of the procedure for a lotteries yeah would our corre like if we did by grade I'm just that sounds so complex to me would our all 28 our school or however many schools um that would be eligible for this be able to give us the numbers of how many sleeps they have open in each and every grade by March 1st so that and get the information out to parents because two weeks is not long especially in March and that's right before spring break so that feels like a lot to do to make it an and make it a viable option right like in two weeks so we have two options before us option one and option two superintendent
032want to say something before we we vote you need a motion yeah can we answer my question can we answer my question that's why I said he wanted to say y'all not listening to me um so our principles had this discussion three weeks ago yes so they know what could potentially be coming based on what you all direct us to do as a staff um it is a lot season so they are going to play it safe between now in terms of how many seats that are available however as I share with you all certain principles told me I've got space in this upcoming grade but I don't hear so they can play it safe with a smaller number so I would probably revise that five Lottery seats and just change that phrase uh given
033what I'm hearing you all discuss I would I would recommend that Miss English and I talk about changing that phrase to by grade level if that's where you're where you all are thinking um but the principles will do what what they will they're asked to do um although I will say it does add another layer a third layer that Miss English and I will need to work through with language for our parents to understand so that no one's confused right in two weeks right now yes and being able to give that information out to parents because someone that wants to go to you know Eastern in first grade but there's not a seat there and there is in third grade and having get being able to accurately that information to so what we do is
034I'd have Miss Ranken at the bottom here put non-open enrollment schools and we'd add a chart just like this with what seats are open or closed for lottery so we just add another page non-open enrollment Lottery schools list those schools by grade levels and it would say open or closed so that's if we choose option yes yes yes do we need to vote on both options and option two is actually option one and two so either one alone or one and two together right I move we adop option two second then moving second that we adopt option there any questions but are we adopting it with the amendment that it only be for grades with open seats yes yes that's the amendment that's the amendment I'll accept that as a friendly Amendment friendly but if
035I don't want it to be okay I I I'll accept it even as an unfriendly Amendment but by Robert's Rules I will a friendly amendment is right yes that's what I would like all in favor option two with the amendment got it was we get a second I thought we second he did discuss discussion I just want I just want Clarity um because I hear you wrong but if we select option two the lottery with those stipulation that Dr ler just shared with the you set this up so that we the parents they can be seen right that's what we're voting on I just want to know makees sure that thank you yes I have one quick question okay if I'm using my district as an example if F middle has a lottery open for
036grade six my kid get selected I select the seat I want to go there am I now entitled to go through fille Central because I went to no no come come my freshman year at high school I either have to reapply or go to where I'm okay a great question any other question all in favor option two with a friendly I can't count that's seven4 any against option two pass with the amendment do we vote on option we don't even have the vote on op well I hope we have made the right decision today I hope it don't put unnecessary work and stress on you uh we want to make it the best we can for all students in the school so thank you very much do we need to open on do we need
037to vote on the Open Enrollment list or was that included in that that was included that was included okay thank you good morning good afternoon um my name is Tom Feller I'm the director of continuous Improvement and I'm here to share some information about restart uh we do need a board Act action on on one piece so uh just a quick uh refresher uh we have five schools in pic count schools that uh operate under restart you'll see them up there on the list fauland Northwest South Greenville Griffon and EPS uh schools operating under the restart model have some flexibilities not afforded to other schools basically if we think of it as um they have Charter School flexibility there are several that they can use um all five of ours primarily focus on one and
038that's bug flexibility uh that's used to provide extra salary supplements to staff and then there uh several of them also use it to purchase like extra positions um or to you know for for additional supplies and materials for the schools there are some other common flexibilities used outside pit County Schools like calendar flexibility but none of our schools are currently doing that uh every five years schools are required to be reauthorized by the state um the process C of that um well actually that's the next slide so I'll just say the purpose of this is to ensure that the flexibilities are resulting in improved metrics um at the school level uh what the state is looking for is that you know the there's continued growth um and as long as that is happening uh we
039can we can continue to operate under restart this year two schools um are eligible and required to submit that application that's Faulkland and element fauland and Northwest the process involved each each of the schools uh submitting an annual self report uh where they did some reflection they shared some specific metrics and data they looked at their student performance grades um they identified areas of progress and growth um that they've been focused on the district also needed to submit a a self self um report where they reflected on the work we were doing with the schools um and you have copies of all three of those reports in uh in assembly right uh at once they submitted uh the reports they were reviewed by me um also by HR and curriculum and then ultimately Dr Lasser
040all of us had to sign off on them they were submitted then to the state um they reviewed them and provided feedback we've just gotten some of that feedback and we'll be going through it with the with the schools just some of the um recommendations that they made at this point um the two schools are like I said are fauland so um in terms of Metro reported to the state the one that they're um landing on is that they met or exceeded expectations um in terms of student performance um and they're not going to submit any additional data as part of the process that's one option they have uh the second one is Northwest they also met and exceeded expectations they are selecting to submit some additional metrics based off of their individual goals again
041all of those individual goals are included in the in the reports that you have uh so at this point we are recommending uh that the board approv both faulin and Northwest continued authorization to work um under the restart model um like I said you've got all three of those and um what will happen is once you guys um vote assuming that you vote to approve their their process then Dr Lasser will go ahead and submit that to the state um that's the very last step we're holding that um until we have a decision from you so that's where we're at do we hear most to uh approve this request motion to approve I second it any discussion all in favor of approving the request successfully approved thank you thank you thank you anything else to
042come in for us today motion to adjourn motion to adjourn move second any discussion on that no sir all in favor right all our in favor let's go home