CorpusRecord 93819

2025-02-18 Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WakeCountySchools
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Wake County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,837 words · about 55 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e all right everyone welcome today is Tuesday February 18th and we're going to call to order our uh Board of Education work session for the Wake County Public School System um we have uh short agenda today but we have some closed session items that I would like to get to if we conclude our work session early uh the first item on our agenda for this afternoon is a review of the wcpss Board of Education federal legislative priorities so as you know we had some discussion about this yesterday sorry discussion about this two weeks ago um and we had asked everyone to look at it send in any thoughts or proposed edits I know that it's hard to evaluate a document like this in the current environment because it seems like there's new information coming out

002of Washington every day or sometimes several times a day um but feedback that I've gotten back was that everyone thinks the programs that we list here seem to all be very high priorities and you we had asked for anyone proposing changes to bring those changes to us by last Friday so they could be shared with all of the board members we did not receive any specific amendments or you suggested changes so we have the original document that we talked about before here in front of you so um you know I'll ask again what people think of the document understanding that it is brief it it it does it is focused on what we think are our most pressing issues uh funding you know funding from the Department of Education student mental health and well-being um

003infrastructure funding for our schools and then our school lunch program Sor right thank you Vice chair Swanson for for driving a bit all a complete list of these items and the language is contained within assembly um I could talk at Great length and detail about all of these items and I'm sure you all could too but I don't want to talk past the sale if we're all in agreement does anyone have any specific comments or feedback on anything within the agenda all right so originally we had this item planned to come to action tonight at our original board meeting when we were planning for this meeting because it was going to be reviewed again in work session we did take it off the action agenda because we don't like to have something on work session

004and then come to the board on the same day but if everyone is good with the with the document that we have now what I'll do is when we get to the board meeting I'll entertain a motion to to amend our agenda so that we can have immediate consideration of the federal legislative priorities sound like a plan yes all right I see thumbs up and nods around great thank you well then with that what we'll do is we will turn to our next item which is board governance and engagement uh superintendent board attorney will share information on the roles of the board and superintendent their engagement of BOE members with staff and discuss policy recommendations all right and this led by our superintendent Dr Taylor uh thank you Mr chair I will give uh Jim

005an opportunity to pull up uh uh the presentation I hope it just clicker works that it does uh so as we know uh Brandy Bridges was supposed to come and do a presentation with the board withing our U uh December Bo retreat but he was not able to be there so uh I will take an opportunity to share some thoughts uh on uh board relations and engagement with the superintendent as well as staff uh but we do recognize that at uh later in the year uh this summer when we have another Retreat uh we hope that Rand is able to come back and continue conversations about uh the relations that we have as a board um I just think this is a great time for us to have this conversation and and really level set

006in terms of what the expectations are that we have for uh each other as board members and also as a superintendent uh and ultimately how we continue to create better Communications uh and how we engage with each other uh as members of the leadership for Wake County Public School uh and so ultimately what the board expects you to to accomplish and that means to me I can tell you the first thing for me is is obviously a great honor uh to be selected to lead this district and and nothing is going to be more for uh than to be able to work with the board and make sure that we work towards the same goals um and and the board has recognized the great work that has been done by this district and we want

007to continue to make sure uh that our focus is on what we need to do to to improve and I know as a board it is about academic growth for all students uh a lot of people may uh look at some of the initiatives that we have as a board but the one thing that I recognize is every single person on this board is really about uh all students achieving and and and excelling uh there is uh the idea of quality support for staff uh you all have made uh clear to everybody in this community that the only way we get better as a district is based on the staff that we have so we appreciate that uh you all have certainly said to me that we want to have better systems of management as

008a school district meaning that uh uh we want to make sure that systems are in place that help us to be productive uh and ultimately that we have a a lasting set of principles and processes that have evolved that evolve as we evolve as a district and so I think you guys have been clear about uh what those accomplishments should be um but I also recognize that there are realities that we all deal with uh in today and things are not always as we would want them to be uh when we talk about preparing all students be competitive and successful that is a difficult thing and the board recognizes that and it is not uh as easy as many people think um I know that the board has this idea of going Beyond incremental Improvement

009uh you guys don't want to see a snow or S snails pace in terms of how students improve uh and but we know uh that is the hard work of what we have to do how we make substantial Improvement and do that quickly uh you you obviously have heard conversations about uh how we do this in terms of diversity uh for all students we know that's something that is certainly um uh what we have to address as a school district now are a little different uh I think the biggest thing for us is is definitely dealing with financial barriers that can slow the work and and I think as a board you all have expressed to everyone that this is um a financial time that we've got to be a little more uh intentional about

010how we look at everything that we do uh and certainly you guys deal with all of the local factors that are here uh I think the biggest introduction to me was Student Assignment uh and how parents certainly give their thoughts about that uh uh so those are to me uh the things that uh will always be uh the challenges that we have as a board uh uh also for me it's about how we communicate uh how we communicate not only as a superintendent with the board but how the board members communicate with each other uh and with the staff uh one of the things I've recognized is that uh your expectation of how you want to communicate can change over time uh and so when I came onto the board uh you all many of

011you were relatively new as well uh experienced board members already had uh thoughts and ideas about how they would communicate uh I think that uh Mr Hagerty uh and um Mrs beafy can certainly give you your their thoughts and ideas about what it means to be a regular board member versus being the the vice chair and then becoming the chair and so that does change the nature of how communication takes place and so I want to make sure uh that as we move forward uh if there are changes in how uh you communicating with the superintendent and staff that we have a chance to talk about that uh but I think the big piece for board is also about how you communicate with each other and um and that is something that I know is

012going to be important to each and every board member you want to make sure that uh you have each other's respect uh and that people have your respect as well um uh for board and for the superintendent it is about us being visible and valuable uh I know as a board you want all your statement stakeholders to know that you're uh visible to them uh and that you're performing the work that they sent you here to perform uh you do that through your BAC meetings uh the committee meetings that you have and the board meetings that you have uh and so that visibility allows the public to evaluate us and to evaluate our Effectiveness and so they use that to determine if we're doing the work and I also know you want to be valuable

013uh to your constituents uh are you able to provide the change that the stakeholders um expect you to bring uh the difficult thing for a board is that you are nine different members elected by nine different districts and that could be potentially nine different sets of expectations that they have for you uh but at the same time you still got to be able to articulate um uh to your constituents that you are there to represent uh specific concerns that they have uh but also those concerns as an entire School Board uh and that is where the work I know gets difficult for you um this work also calls that there calls for what we uh view as trust and collaboration uh for me this is one of the most difficult things for a board uh

014it is the fact that um uh you have to trust that every board member has the right intentions regardless of what personal feelings may be or things that you may hear at a board meeting uh but it is about uh how you trust each other and know that the superintendent the staff and yourselves uh you're doing this work because it is the right thing to do and that's where it takes a lot of trust uh among board members uh but I think the more important thing is the collaboration piece that we can have trust for each other but if this work is actually going to get done uh there has to be a tremendous amount of collaboration and so um I learned a long time ago that when there's the board uh the first thing

015that you need to do is learn how to count and when we think about this board what is the magic number see that's it if you can't count to five then no matter what you feel your influence may be uh the work is not going to get done and so that is the thing that I will always remind the board of is that uh you're going to come here for specific reasons uh but at the end of the day it is about how you reach that magic number in move legislation and uh and policies for uh so that's something that I know each of you consider as a board M sometimes you may lose sight of that and forget about it uh but at the end of the day it is about how you collaborate

016to make sure uh uh that you can reach that magic number now we would love for the number to be 90 all the time uh but I do understand that's not always going to happen and so a big part of what we have to do um when it comes to person personal development um uh that is where I know it's it's uh every board member has to determine uh how they engage in the work to develop themselves uh and so that means knowing and understanding uh the Committees that you serve on is there's something that you need to do um um to enhance your skills and abilities to be able to lead this work uh so it is about uh that personal development that you got to engage in uh but it's also to me

017about the Collective development and growth that you have as a board and so we're going to always work collectively to to identify what the goals are for the district uh I know that our strategic plan has been a big part of that and and you guys engage deeply in that work uh but again it's also about um uh working with the staff to develop goals uh and that is why the professional staff are hired for this job you you hire staff because they do have the ability I remember uh Miss MF hope she doesn't mind be saying this uh but we were talking one day in the meeting and she said you know you know I'm a board member uh but I don't have a professional degree on my wall as an administrator to do

018this work and that's why we hire you guys and so that's something that I always remember that uh you hire staff for the expertise that they have uh so we have to make sure that they continue to grow themselves to be able to do that work uh but also as board members you're going to have individual interests and talents and we want to be able to to use those talents to make us better at the work that we do as a district uh but also make you guys better at the work that you do as board members um and so uh that is where uh we will have the appropriate kind of board involvement in the work that we do and so uh talking with Mr hery I know that he said well doc you

019know if I'm going to be the person that's over facilities and I really want to be able to to to learn the things that are going to help me be better at this work as a board member so that is part of the development and the growth uh that every board member has to think about uh I also want you to think about uh those professional hours that you have to get in terms of professional development and I know Mr Gordon you are about to get your first 12 right yes but it doesn't end there I want you to know that um what I've seen over the years is that when you go to the School Board Association meetings you will see board members uh that have the different statuses in terms of the professional

020development and hours that they've gotten as a board member and so as relatively new board members it's going to take you time to begin to build that type of uh professional development hours uh but that should really be the goal of a board how do we uh really engag in the professional development as board members that can show to our public uh we do more than just show up to a board meeting that we take the time to develop and grow ourselves uh professionally uh as board members and that's going to be super important um um I'll talk briefly about uh what is the the special U relationship between the board chair uh and the superintendent and and um we only have two uh a past chair in here which is uh M behalf in

021our current chair uh one of the things that will always develop is that relationship with the board chair because he is the leader of the board uh he is the spokesman for the board and so that means that you're going to spend uh an awful amount a lot of time with the chair uh what we've been able to do is to actually develop a relationship with as the cheer and the vice cheer that we meet uh on that weekly basis to address those things that we know are important to the district uh one of the things I do like about that now now Mr Swanson you may tell me differently but I do think it gives you an opportunity to know and understand uh what a lot of that position is going to be like

022the board selects you as the chair I think everything that I've seen in terms of what I know that the board selects a person as Vice chair that they hope will serve in that position at some point uh so it does give you I think uh a close look of of what that position is like and so I always try to remind board members that uh that is a relationship that the chair and the superintendent will always have uh but in the same time it's it's also about not neglecting other board members because you have to make sure that um uh you meet their needs as well so um uh that is something that I know uh as a superintendent of many years I'm Tred to to make sure I develop that relationship with a

023board cheer but that's going to change every so often uh and so anybody who's new to the chairmanship uh um maybe Mr hagy will share this at the end but uh sometimes it can be U uh much more than what you thought it was uh but I would tell you guys that um um the chair absolutely needs the support of everybody on this Bove because it is one of the most difficult jobs uh trying to uh manage and work with eight other individuals uh that at the end of the day uh the only people you're beholding to uh are the people that sent you here uh and and so remember that uh that is part of what he has to be able to do as the board chers and manage all of that uh I

024also know that that uh there are some things that we have to be careful not to do uh this is not just for the superintendent but there everybody here it's about how we criticize the past and so coming in as a new superintendent one of the easiest things I can always say is well this wasn't inflation that wasn't inflation blah blah blah uh that's not my role as superintendent to talk about what wasn't done in the past it is about knowing how we move a district forward uh and doing the work that's necessary now I also give that advice to board members as well uh that your role is not to criticize what has happened in the past it is to really look where we are as a district now what resources uh and processes

025that we have to put in place uh to make sure we can move the district forward um I also have to remember not to neglect Communications with everybody at the board so when we talk about that special relationship with the chair and the vice chair we're going to have that Conant communication uh but I also have to make sure uh that I still have that connection with everybody here uh one of the great things that I think we've been able to do is is reach out to board members and say how is it that you want to be able to meet with the superintendent and some say look I want to meet on a consistent basis and some say look I'll check in with you every nine weeks and I'll call you when I need

026you and so one of the things uh that I will always look to board members for is has that changed for you I recognized that when I came in in October most of you had been here for 6 months and I was the third superintendent and you probably went through several iterations of how you communicated uh so I do want us to be able to level set and say that now that I've been here x amount of time uh this is what I'd like to see in terms of how we communicate uh so you guys will have time to think about that and Miss Gordon uh whatever you may decide and we'll give you eight months and you may be completely different about it DOC I want to see you only at the board meeting

027yes um uh I also um have to be careful that the board is not surprised about anything and I can tell you that uh as superintendent uh that River changes all the time that uh you can send things constantly to the board that you believe they want to know about and the board doesn't care and then everything that well you know the board's not going to care about that and then I get nine phone calls you know I get one from Chris first he look man they blowing up my phone man what's going on I said what are you talking about and so it is about uh not making um um surprises for the board uh from the superintendent and from Administration so the one thing that I will always ask board members is that

028if priorities have changed in terms of the things you want to be updated on then you got to let me and administration know so we can think one thing as I something um I also Vis the board and myself about how we deal with change and one of those things is knowing and understanding that we have to be intent um have to have intention about decisions that we make uh and that we not change things too fast I also recognize that we don't want to be super fluent in terms of how things happen in well uh but that was one of the things that I promised you all when I came here that if we're going to indeed U be a part of the long game uh then some things that need to be changed

029in this District uh uh part of that is changing the mindsets and changing the culture of the school district and the community uh and so we want to make sure that we're intentful uh intentional about how we do those things uh and so these are the things that I have to be careful about um and so this is something that I know uh a lot of people will look at aboard in terms of how they make decisions and whether or not the board is unanimous in those decisions that they make uh and so one of the things we want to do is Administration is always make sure uh that uh we give you information uh that can help you make good decisions uh and that is the most important thing that we can do one

030of the things that I promise you all as a superintendent is that I will not give you information to make the decision for you to make the decision that I want you to make uh that is unfair to Avo it is about me as a superintendent giving you information uh so you can make uh informed decisions uh I always look at the kind of conversations that take place uh at this board table with me and with Administration and I do want people to make sure that they don't ask nonthreatening questions to the board uh because at the end of the day who do we all work for we work for the board and so we want to make sure that there's a good uh way that we can communicate with the board that we give

031you information but you can make informed decisions uh and that we always keep the work focused on students so I recognize that boards are not going to always be unanimous um we recognize that but part of our work is also making sure that when we give you information is information based on the professional judgment that you asked us to make and that put you in a in a in a greater position uh to be unanimous uh or closer to the decision that you make as a board again they may me you know 81 72 some sometimes time 54 we know that's going to happen uh but I always ask the board to think about uh when you look back at your votes uh do you believe you have a tendency not to be agreeing on

032anything uh and that gives us a chance to to step back in level set we see if there's something that we can do different uh to better do that um uh one of the things um uh um when we think about I may missed this SL yeah that's right uh but I also like to think about uh the operating principles that you all have as a board um uh and the roles that we all play so we're all part of the leadership team U that is the first thing I want us to recognize um and that there has to be uh again that communication that cooperation that support for everybody um I won't uh lecture the board again about judgment and Trust uh but that's all going to be part of those operating principles that

033we have as a board um I'll talk more than a minute about how we deal with uh uh staff complaints our citizen complaints uh and I'll talk more about uh the board meetings uh uh for those things that are going to be part of the operating principles that we have um um as an organization I want to um mic I want to talk uh just a little briefly about what a learning organization is and that's what I want us to continue to be as a School District uh how many people how many board members are familiar with uh what it means to be a learning organization uh you may or may not be familiar with uh all of the tenants of it uh but I I I'll just share briefly uh what this is uh

034so a learning organization is an entity that falters a culture of continuous learning and knowledge uh and and and knowledge and creation at all levels it is an organizational Paradigm that recognizes the importance of adapting to change acquiring new knowledge and leveraging insights to improve performance and Achieve strategic objectives and so uh Peter S if you familiar with him he wrote a book called The Fifth Discipline uh back in the 90s and I still refer to this book when I think about a learning organization and he describes these as uh organizations where people continually expand expand their capacity to create the results they truly desire where new and expansive patterns of thinking are nurtured where Collective aspirations is set free in where people are continually learning how to learn together and so that is uh

035what a learning organization is that is what we want to be as a school district that is what we want to be as a board how do we adapt to change how do we do those things to better inform ourselves uh as a board and so when we think about uh the characteristics of a learning organization and I won't uh go through all of these things on the chart but um if you look at the top uh in that highlighted section that talks about uh really what a learning organization is and you can look at the different um categories where you can bring that out and so when you think about the board that's Community leaders and advocates for schools you think about parents parents as members of the school Community uh so you can

036go across the list but if you look down at the bottom and this is comparing um us if we were not a learning organization and the worst that we would be is that the school would be hearing officers almost like parole officers we know that's not what you are as a uh there's distrust uh you perform as Bureau Chiefs if you're the superintendent principls are like the wards and teachers are like the guard the guards and so uh that is the difference between the top where you are a learning organization versus one that's very rigid uh and functions under the Old Guard uh of the 20th century and so as a board as a school district we want everybody to know that we will always be a learning organization and we are going to adapt

037to whatever changes that may come before us uh I can certainly say that uh adapting to change is what we have to deal with right now and and we're going to continue to do that um so again you can look at uh from a board perspective when you are a learning board which is on the um on the right that you continue to be outward focused on the work that you do uh that you have values and your Purpose Driven um you create responsive systems you're not about managing people um so all those things that are going to make us a learning organization versus a board that is on the left uh that is inward focused and micro vantages those are the things that we don't want to be uh as an organization uh so

038now I want to talk about uh uh some of our governing principles and and and what I'll say to you and I've said it time and time again and I'll continue to say this uh that the most important relationship that we have is going to be between uh the superintendent and the board uh it doesn't you know we can stress this all day long but if that's not a good relationship uh then that's going to create problems I can tell you that uh I value the relationship that I have with everybody in this room um uh I think that is one of the best things that I've had as as being the superintendent is that there's a quality relationship uh with every board member that is not something that always happens for superintendent uh you

039can be elected uh selected as superintendent uh a new board is selected 5 months later and they want the new superintendent going uh but I can tell you that um um working with everybody here I have not seen any of that uh and that is something that I appreciate and I value uh and so I do want to um at least say that to you all so that you will know uh uh how important that relationship is to me um so now I want to kind of uh uh talk about uh understanding the organizational structure the situation that we have now the one thing I don't need to do is to tell the board that uh uh your position is about creating a policy and my job is about implementing policy uh I think we

040all know that uh and so uh we can look at all the component of what that relationship should be uh and at the end of the day uh that really is the relationship that the board focuses on policy hiring a superintendent evaluating men evaluating programs uh that's a part of the organizational structure uh but as superintendent I'm responsible for the day-to-day work and that's where I think we want to make sure that we continue to level set on what that looks like uh but I also recognize that as a board uh you can get uh as deep as you want to In The Weeds as a board uh but you all also recognize that you can't leave a district uh from board meetings so we do recognize that so it is about how we uh

041work to level set on those things um when we think about uh the policies that govern the board most of those are going to be found in the governing principles in the 1,000 section and that really talks about the the board's legal status uh the policies related to rental involvement safety your place all those other things that are there uh in policy uh 1010 specifically talks about the board authority and and the duties um and so there you can find exactly what the authority uh of the board is um and and and the one thing I always want to stress is that when do you have authority it only happens when you are in a board meeting uh and that is when the board has the ability to be able to to implement whatever it

042will is uh it doesn't happen in committee meetings it doesn't happen with individual conversations with the superintendent or with staff as a board uh everything that you do uh happens uh when you are in this meeting and uh there's not uh more that we need to really say about that U but I think everybody recognizes that um and I won't go through all of these but when you look at what I call the significant 11 and that is in policy 1010 it's going to outline uh 11 specific things that are identified in your B board policy in terms of uh that Authority that you have um and it explains those duties bail those out and so this is uh the board policy uh that you've approved that you put together so obviously as a board

043uh if there's something that you want to change that you can uh but I think you all are really comfortable in terms of what that is uh when it comes to board operations uh that's also founded the 27 policy uh and so that really does talk about um uh how I should keep you guys informed um the operational function that you have uh your legal status how you elected how you uh feel unexpired terms how you deal with conflicts of interest so all those things are um those are things that I would encourage uh board members to to to revisit periodically so that we can all be aware of what those things are and so I know uh Miss Gordon that's something that's going to be interesting reading for you as a new one member

044is going through the series 1000 and 2000 and knowing uh exactly what you're supposed to be doing as a board member uh so one of the things I want to do now is is is talk a little bit more about uh engaging with staff and kind of what those expectations might be um um I recognize that um as board members you all have some really good relationships uh with uh staff members in the district uh and one of the things I've always said is that uh I want to make sure there's a a healthy opportunity for board members to be able to talk with staff uh get information from them uh and that I'm not the person that's that's standing in the way uh but with that I also recognize uh uh that uh requests

045really should come through the superintendent so there are things that may be General things that you have uh but there are if there are specific requests uh we don't want to put staff in a position to where uh they're getting requests from not different board members at different times and they're not able to do the work that they're performing um I do recognize that uh committee request um uh there may be needs that you have as a committee chairman um to fulfill your role as it relates to policy that you developing so that means you're going to be talking with Chiefs you're going to be talking with assistant superintendent saying that I need this particular information uh for my committee meeting so we can craft the policies that we have um um I always want

046to remind board members is that there's information that you're requesting uh we also want to make sure that it's not something that's going to require board members to to put a lot of time and effort in in order to create uh and so we have to be cognant about that uh if there's any new information that um that you may ask them to to uh bring together uh I can tell you that the board has uh been generally good with working with staff um uh anytime that there's a problem staff will let me know but do recognize that plenty times staff may not tell me anything uh and why might that be why might that be they recognize that they work for the board and that is if if uh chair Hagerty calls and ask

047for something uh well you know you need to call the superintendent he needs to approve that you know uh staff want to make sure that they're respectful and provide you the things that you need and they may not say anything to it so that is uh something that we'll talk about later in terms of what might dve of as as a particular policy that we have as a board uh but know and understand that as board members there are going to be times that you engage with staff uh and I know that and that's something that um uh my role as superintendent is not to try to prevent that from happening uh but making sure that it happens in a way that allows uh you to get the information that you need and that staff

048can still focus on the work that they doing uh I also want to share some information about um in terms of how you engage with the public um right now I think every one of you do a really good job of sharing information either with me or with sta uh when people send you complaints and and what I can tell you is that complaints Go In Waves uh you know there will be times that you may not get many there will be times I get 12 in one day uh but uh I really do appreciate uh how you all are quick to make sure you send that not only to me but to the appropriate staff so that we can deal with it uh and so as always that is about sending to me or

049the uh the designated staff uh I'll always um uh ask board remembers to be mindful about how you meet with people in the public uh so you're going to always have requests uh of someone to meet with you and so uh what I would always say is is if you can uh avoid meeting with staff about something that may be a staff issue uh a funding issue that they have a Personnel issue uh and and while that may be a good intent um you know uh Miss Gordon what happens if you meet with a staff member uh about a Personnel issue is and they give you their side of the story and now all of a sudden that issue could end up in front of the board as something that you have to make a

050ruling on and then you may have to recuse yourself from it so we always want to be sure that uh board members know and understand what those meetings and relationships should be like uh meeting with staff but certainly um when it comes to meeting with the public uh that's part of your duty as a boy people are going to want to meet with you they're going to want to uh share information with you uh and so everything is about giving them that right opportunity uh and then you be being able to lift that up to Administration and staff um um um that's going to be something that we want Bo Min continue to be reminded of uh when it comes to visiting schools this is something that um I know as board members I want

051you to be um have Clarity and understanding of what that should look like uh I normally uh uh wouldn't ask board member to let me know when you're going to visit a school I need to know when you go you know blah blah blah and that's not what we wanted uh I know those are going to be opportunities that you take as board members uh uh to go out to a school see a program and have an opportunity to see the great things that are taking place in the school uh and so you use those as opportunities uh to become uh better informed about what takes place in the school I would always U uh remind board members just encourage board members not to have regularly scheduled meetings with principals meaning that I'm going to

052come and and this month I'm going to meet with you as a principal and and kind of go through some things uh that is the responsibility of the area superintendent that's the responsibility of the superintendent and so we want to make sure that as board members uh we're not having those kinds of conversations when we visit a school uh so that you're not setting up a situation where the board or whether uh the administration feel that they're answering to a board member uh and not the superintendent or or his designate um I can tell you that um uh those kinds of things have not been reported to me that doesn't mean that did not happen and and and I can tell you that uh as superintendent the biggest thing that has always surprised me doing

053this work for the last decade is that sometimes I could be the last person to know something you know that people go out meet with uh staff meet with Personnel uh and I'm the last one to find out I know that this is what I would say to you uh that I want you to remember about your role as a board member that uh everybody in the district know that we work for the board uh and and sometimes uh staff members are reluctant for something to get back to the superintendent because they may believe that reflects that they're not doing their job well and now I'm on the superintendent radar uh and that's not where I want people to be I want people to really uh engage in the work that they do and do

054that with Fidelity uh but I also want board members to know and understand that um visiting schools and getting a pulse of what's taking place that is a part of your responsibility um and so with that um uh there are some things that that we will bring to the policy Committee in terms of uh these items that we talked about in terms of school visitation engagement with the public and engag staff um um I want to thank um uh Miss mafy who actually shared some some uh policies with me I thought it was really good information that you shared uh in terms of some things that we may want to do to codify um some of the work uh related to board and how we visit schools um how we request information how we engage

055with the public and so I thought that was really good work uh with what you'll find is that uh boards uh uh have different policies that may or may not include these kinds of things so we think uh this is something that will probably be good uh if we were to codify that uh and so with that I I want to pause for a minute because uh R has some slides that he wants to share in terms of the role and responsibility of the board attorneys R I'll give you the chance to share your peace I'll do that first of all I only have three slides so that to tell you that um there's not a lot that I really wanted to cover but um I did think it when I talked to Dr Taylor

056it did make sense to maybe back up a little bit and talk a little bit about the relationship between the board and the board attorney and as you may know you have a policy 201610 that covers hiring the board attorney and sorry and um and it also um States that and this is I think one of the most important parts of it is that the attorney represents the school system The Entity or the board um we don't represent individual school board members um and we don't represent individual school officials um there are situations however if the board is sued um where we would in those situations represent either individual board members or individual employees in in the defense of those lawsuits but as a general rule we represent the entity and not individual board members

057U we get work um historically through either the board chair or the superintendent um or one of the superintendent designes and interestingly here in Wake if someone contacts us to do work um there's a specific list of individuals who can approve that work so if we get a call from someone that's not on the list then we will reach out to the staff member that's on the list to make sure that you know David's designated or authorized Trish to call us on the topic or you know an area superintendent authorized us to do some work so um the work that comes to us is approved by the superintendent's office or the board chair and that's historically how we we get our work um when we get requests from Individual board members we always Channel those

058back to the board chair that certainly doesn't mean that if we get a question from a board member that we don't answer those questions when they come in but if it's going to require any kind of extensive work um on our part then we um we either require the board member to socle back to the chair we would reach out to the chair to make sure that the chair's authorized us to perform that work so that's kind of how we get work from either um the the board um for for um for staff um when we do work for um for the board um we work really hard to make sure that we share those answers with the entire board not just to the individual board members so if a board member asks a question

059that's authorized by the chair to us when we respond we make sure that we copy the whole board so that everybody knows what advice we provided to a board member you know most of our advice as you know comes in close session and you know that's attorney client privileged and um Andor we will provide Our advice through some written attorney client privilege communication but that's typically how we try to communicate with the board and again this because we're trying to communicate with the entity the board as a whole um and not individual board members and um the only other thing I think I want to add on this point is that we work really hard to try to provide um non-politicized objective legal analysis um we um we do advocate for the board in areas

060in which you authorize us to advocate for you for defending a position of yours in the lawsuit but we otherwise try to provide advice that's um just good clean legal advice and that's not um not skewed one way the other by politics within your policies you have kind of authorized um us to do various things um one is in your 171 and 1720 policies we are the investigator of certain bullying harassment and discrimination claims if the claim is against the superintendent our office handles that investigation for to the policy if the claim is against a board member that our office handles those investigations the superintendent can assign other ones to us but policy you know we handle those um your 2000 series of policies has various um opportunities or situations in which the the chair

061or others will consult with us on various open meeting questions parliamentary procedure questions and other various board meeting issues so all of these are already in your policy manual um to to authorize us to perform certain actions in your um policy 2155 um you authorize the board attorney and that's Kenneth award is the one that handles this for the most part and the superintendant to negotiate real estate contracts on your behalf um in U board policy 2610 uh you authorize our office to handle um criminal Bond forfeiture matters and uh motor vehicle forfeiture matters on your behalf and then in policies uh 5030 6420 and 6430 you authorize us to review form contracts um to approve joint use agreements and various purchase contracts so within your policies you've also designated certain areas um where you've

062youve authorized our firm to provide legal services for for the board so that's kind of an overview of the relationship between you know our office and the board our office and the school system I'm happy to answer questions if there are that I might yeah well uh sorry and so um so I want to end with uh first of all saying that um you know one of the things that the most gracious was the opportunity to be able to lead this board and Lead this District uh lead this District uh and and I've enjoyed the relationship that I have with the board I think we have a really good working relationship uh I know moving forward uh this board continues to be about continuous Improvement uh and so uh as superintendent and uh and as

063a leader of the staff uh I do want you to recognize that um um we want you to ask tough questions uh that is why we are here uh and we don't have a problem with that um uh that is how we get better as a district that you take your role seriously as a board member about how you develop policy um I always want to um stress to the board uh that I know that your goal and desire is not to be in the Leeds uh I recognize that um and and the only thing that that that you can do as individual board members is to uh ask yourselves am I doing things that put me in the weeds uh ask my fellow board members you know am I overstepping my violence uh do

064I need to dial back uh I also want to say to the board that uh your role as a board member is about self monitoring uh and so there will always be this idea of um what the superintendent can do to make sure a board stays in line or what the board shair can do to make sure a board stays in line you know uh the board share uh runs a committee runs a board meeting through uh Robert's Rules of Order uh that means that everybody in the board has to be willing to adhere to Robert's Rules of Order but but if we as individual board members decide we're going to say what we want to say do what we want to say what can the chair do you what can he do to you

065I mean uh I think the last time I checked there some some legal things that can cause a board member to be removed But ultimately it is about um how we agree to work together as a board and and respect the authority of the chair and respect what Rob's rules and orders are um um I recognize that I know you all board members recognize that uh I'll also say that I know as a board you want our public to know that we want the best for our schools and for our children uh for our children and they see and understand how we function um as a group during a board meeting or a committee meeting that's generally the only time they get to see us uh and so we want people to recognize that uh

066our goal will always be to to work towards consensus uh that is why we are on the board this this is why you board members uh and and we don't want there to be uh any ambiguity or confusion about what the intent of the board is it is about uh holding me as a superintendent accountable and holding staff accountable so that we can work towards continuous Improvement and questions will get tough sometimes we recognize that uh but I hope that everybody knows and understands that his board me uh you take your job seriously uh and I think that is what I appreciate more than anything as superintendent is that uh you all don't see this as a pass through you are really committed to this work uh and I think that's important and I know

067we can continue to send that message to the board and so with that um I welcome any comments the board members may have or any questions that they might have uh Mr shair I'll to you all right thank you super Taylor so I appr appreciate the uh presentation and you know one of the things that I want to say as chair is that you know we all represent different districts but as chair I also feel like I work for all eight of you as well um and I want you to be successful and I want you to accomplish what you want to accomplish um we all want to get things done and I admire that sometimes we come up with like ways to do something new or maybe something that's a way that hasn't been

068done before and you know sometimes there's a reason why we haven't done it before and sometimes when you come to me as chair I might not know that reason and so sometimes some folks have come to me with what like seemed like a really good idea and I'm like yeah this is a great idea and then I found out after the fact well maybe I should have talked to the superintendent about it right or maybe I should have talked staff a little bit more about it and so I'm I'm going to pledge to do better myself um and I think the the the best thing that we can one of the best things we can do is you know just know and trust that we all have the best intent and that people are working

069hard to try to get things done and get changes done and then as board members when we don't see change or we see what look like the same results it gets very frustrating and you know there's there there there's going to be different things that will you know trigger different you know different individuals differently sometimes is and and I'm speaking from the board like just to the superintendent here it can be if a speaker shows what we've perceived is disrespect to board members interrupting them or dismissing them or sometimes it can be when information is presented that seems contradictory or conflicting with other information that we have and so you know when that happens board members I think can respond a number of ways but we want to respond in a way that's productive and

070that you know we're working together as a team and we're working together as a team with staff to get good things done and I think there's nothing wrong with having new ideas or you questioning why we do things a certain way and wanting to do them another way but we also need to ask the questions about why it's done a certain way or if we can proceed in a certain way um before we get too far ahead of ourselves um so with that I'll open it up to questions or comments um I couldn't tell if you were Ting your fingers or if you had a hand up I'll go with Mr hery um one thing I'd love us to do in the future I know we have a busy schedule today is kind of digging

071into the most School boards are like this and a learning organization the school board would be more like this and I'm just looking at the you know what is responding personally mean versus creating a responsive system and the responding to Community um and building community and I can guess on my own but I don't I mean that's one those are a couple areas where I would love to dig in and whether it's just me individually with somebody for some training or as a a board Swanson thank you Dr Taylor for sharing this I just had two clarifying questions for you um the first one is how do you expect us what is your expectation for us to communicate with staff is that continue to put you on emails or whatnot and then the second one

072is regarding the school business do we still you still want us to proceed through going through area superintendent chief of schools putting you on email cuz it wasn't little clear in the and so what I would say is that um you know I think you guys now contact area superintendent and if you're not doing that just simply let them know that you know I'll be visiting a school to then I think those things will continue you that's if if if you are able to do that with area superintendence there's not necessarily A need uh to let me know that that's what you that works for me because they are that designate uh and so I don't have um I think we can continue to do that what was the first question again um expectation for

073communicating with staff okay and so um uh if it's something uh specific that you know you're asking for uh then let me know as superintendent so I can be aware what it is that you're asking for um uh I will also communicate to staff is that if there's a request that's been made that is going to require you to do a certain amount of work uh then that needs to be approved by me um um again I'll tell you that everything that I've seen is that uh staff have been able to provide you things that you need but if they haven't said to me uh I'm getting requests from Dr in all the time uh I wouldn't know that and so uh so I will uh U Mr Swanson share with the board uh the

074specific expectations of what I would like to see uh and then you will automatically know as a board member if you're going above or beyond that and then that way we can level set and everybody will know what the expectation is so I'll will share that so thank you okay you want to on the close session I do I just wanted to make sure if there were any other questions I think some of this is about expectations and you know Dr Taylor has also talked about expectations and how we deal with staff but just having conversations about how we work and communicate with each other you know assuming good intent trying not to surprise folks um and you being transparent with Communications um we might not all agree but if we can work together and

075work together professionally and Civ you know in a civil manner we can get a lot of great stuff done so um if there no other comments we'll leave it with that and we will entertain about Mr R um for point of clarity I've heard a lot about how the board is expected to do what it's supposed to do so help help me better understand how does the board help the staff understand that a direction may be the right or the wrong direction that it's going to get the outcome that we ex are expecting as a board who have to answer to its constituents um not being necessarily all on the left side of the column but actually working on the right side of the column as well I want to hold a realistic expectation of

076this presentation of real life in real time um so I would like to know how how what are your expectations around that because while we trust and believe that everybody has the right intentions on both sides of the aisle um and if I can just stay I won't even talk about the past let's talk about the current if we look at our current data and our current state of where we are how do we get better so we won't even talk about the past that's about where we are right now how do we get better how if our job as a board is to create governing policies that move us in a positive direction for student learning with the right outcomes how do we communicate with you and as a team or bring about a

077better understanding if the only person that we're going to listen that your relationship with is the chair even if we get how do we even get to a vote of five about anything that's moving in a direction from what's being presented or whatever the case is when we don't see things happening that we need to see happen so I'm just curious um and they going be a different time or whatever to share but I I think the presentation was really great it was really good but I need a little bit more clarity on what we're what we're going to do because what I what my lenses that I just saw and what I understood is um was was understandable but it it leaves me to say I'm just being transparent since we're being here you

078talked about what do we say when we're together or when we're not I I feel like I'm talking in circles but I know what you're saying yeah because I'm I'm trying to I'm trying to be polite and so I'm trying to I'm really trying to say what do we how do how do we help us move in a different way when it's not moving in the direction that it should be going by following these governances which are important and so uh the first part of that is really about consensus that a board has about what you want to see and so those conversations do take place here uh those are the questions that you absolutely ask uh when you're at a meeting and and and the example would be uh if you're the chair of

079a particular committee uh and then as a as a committee as a chair as a board you may decide that we want you to bring data that shows us where you're tracking in this particular area uh and then you can give your feedback as individual board members doing a committee meeting or a board meeting uh about what we presented to you uh the board has to have consensus on uh what those uh goals are what the metrics you want to see to determine whether or not we're actually making um um uh progress on what we've agreed to as a board and so part of that consensus would be uh one board member may say we need need to eliminate this program all together and other board members may say well no we think this is

080a great program um and so that is a board reaching a consensus about what they believe is good or bad and so part of your job is always to ask those questions that's what you're supposed to do uh and and when these presentations come in front of board members you do have the opportunity to ask questions you do have the opportunity to say well you know now I've seen data that says something that's a little different than than what you presented uh so can you better explain that and and so um that is the role of the board to make sure uh that as a group you have the greed on what you want the outcomes to be uh and and again that can't be an individual member uh and we as Administration can have

081thin skins if you ask us tough questions and we're not uh delivering the metrics that you've asked for uh but it does really start with the consensus of board in terms of what you agree on as the metrics but you know can I build on that and then to let you follow up I think one of the things that when I came on this board I was very frustrated with is that sometimes I would come in and i' would feel like I've sat here through a committee meeting that's gone on a really long time and then we had maybe 5 to 10 minutes of questions at the end and I didn't feel like I was in a position where at best I was contributing anything and at worst that I was sort of being managed

082yeah and you know that really bothered me and you know over time I've sort of learned different ways to you know Advocate and bring up the issues that I want to see addressed and through the superintendent and Senior leadership team kind of try to raise those issues up and push some Direction but I think what I'm hearing Dr Taylor is that we'd like to hear or at least some of us would like to hear some specific suggestions of what this could look like if it's because we often times don't get an opportunity as a board to raise issues of concern unless it's already on the agenda or it's already part of a scheduled conversation and so you could have something that's a huge concern to you and to people in the county but if it

083doesn't come up on a schedule then where's the opportunity to bring it up and so if this if there was an opportunity to have I won't call it like an open meeting in work session where it's you know no agenda but a way for board members to bring specific questions or specific issues to you on a frequent basis so that we could get some measure of like feedback accountability and the ability to share these issues that might be a way to kind of lift up some of these things that you know some board members may not be seeing and then I'll asress I didn't mean to interrupt no no thank you um for sharing and then the final question that I have is in reference to visiting um schools we have I can I can

084talk about my in my district um they've been very excited to have a board member present at events um when asked to come um and just interested in even supporting what they're doing and so um based on upon the presentation that you just did um or what have you how how does that how does that reflect relationship with every student and every teacher is still one of our constituents around this table so how how do we support schools and let them know that the people that they elected are in support of them by showing up at their events or supporting them in those ways um when we are going to when we're you know doing schools I may be transitioning quickly or something and I might forget to text Dr um counsel or or something

085but I'm going to something that they're doing or whatever and showing up so um how are we proposing with that and what does that look like or are we violating some type of policy or law because we show up at schools that we are chosen to govern or represent so so first of all uh if you show up at a school at any time you're not violating the law I mean it's it's a public place and your board member you can go uh and so I want to make sure that that that I'm also clear in what that expectation is that I'll never say to a board member you can't visit a school uh you got to let me know every time that you walk into a school what it appears to me is that

086when you make a visit to a school you reach out to the area superintendent and you let them know hey I'm I'm going by the school I've had board members to say I want you to do a school visit with me to look at something particular those kinds of things happen uh um the only advice that I give to board members is that when you visit a school uh that you be uh uh mindful of what the nature of the visit is because uh you going out to see a program those what I call the benign visits uh that's not an issue I would never want you not to go out and do that uh but uh but you'll be able to use your professional judgment to know that if it's a vis is it

087Beyond something that is just general uh and that's what I want to um and it's not about me uh restricting a board member coming to a school but again you know if there's um what I don't want is a visit to where uh staff members and administration are feel as though they're being evaluated by a board member you know that's completely different than you going out engaging with the community engaging with students you know those are the things I absolutely encourage you to do because you get a feel of what it's like in a school you do have an opportunity to talk with students hear back from teachers and things of that nature but it's um knowing and understanding if that visit is going to be viewed as something that's evaluative and not just a

088general visit thank you okay all right any other questions M Coffield um I just wanted to be clear and I think it's kind of sweat what they were referring to but um when you were talking about questions and reaching out to staff you're not talking about just questions in general you're just talking about what part that would be basically overstepping where if you wanted to get some more information on something or you wanted to learn about something yeah and so um you know you may make a request uh as a as a board member that uh I need information on on um um the letters program at a particular school and and I need to know all the information about how the students have performed uh and K through to over the last five years

089uh because I want to be able to you know to share with my constituents that this program is not doing what it needs to do and so that's something that's a request that's going to require that staff doing um um tremendous amount of work uh and but now if you have a a general question such as you know I got a call from a parent they were telling me that um you know our discipline policy doesn't allow us to do so and so can can you kind of help me to understand you know what the policy really says so asking questions for knowledge and understanding that's one thing but asking for um um information from staff members that requires them to put in a lot of time to develop that report for you uh that

090is something that would be different and so U what I would say is that if you know it's a specific kind of information that you need uh then let that come out in the committee request uh that kind of goes back to what chair hagy talked about that there's information or or questions that you want to ask you know how can we create the fors where you have the opportunity to ask that and you're not blocked in by what's on the schedule and you don't have that opportunity so that's what I want uh want to be able to to kind of help board members to understand is that if it's a general question to ask for understanding um you know staff are always there for that it's just it's like calling the board attorney and

091saying you know um can you explain to me what I you know um policy 2160 says I'm not quite sure on what that is versus you know um um I'm drafting some legislation to send to the general assembly and I want you to give me some feedback on see that's something that an individual board member you're doing and not as a board and so general questions to ask for understanding so you can better understand a program or a policy that's always fine but it it's about um I need this and it's going to require this level of work uh that's not to say that we won't provide that to you uh but we don't want to put a b um a staff member in the position to where it's going to take them two or

092three days to be able to put that together that's what I'm talking about okay so just to follow up um like for example you know I spoke with you about the AIG and how we wanted to kind of get a little bit more robust conversation going on and if that is not on the agenda or not on somebody else's specific radar at the moment how do you go about doing that without actually having the conversation with staff to know what your questions and what deeper information you may so I think that's a perfect example of that you have a question about it it is all right to ask those questions of the staff or ask those questions of the superintendent but if there's something uh Beyond um um what may have been shared with you

093by a parent that requires more research uh more digging into uh then that is something that you want to come through the board so we're talking about let's say we want to see something different with our AIG policy that's something that will come up in student achievement and I think it's fine asent achievement sh that you say to academics uh we want some information in the presentation about the AIG program because we've had these particular questions uh and this is what we would like to see in this report when you come back to the board and so um remember you know the goal is not to restrict the board members access to information uh we want you to be able to ask those questions but we also want you to be mindful that uh that

094if you're one of nine board members you know staff could get those questions all the time and and that's what we want to make sure that they can focus on the work that they were hired for um and anything else it can come through a committee and we give the board whatever it is that they ask for so um and just follow up one more time for clarity but when you tried to answer to your constituents about things that are important to them and things that you hear about repeatedly and you cannot get that on the agenda how would you have that conversation if it's not on the agenda you can't bring it up at the committee so you are actually P pigeon hole to you can't talk about it or proceed with anything that

095may be important to the people that you're speaking to that do have those expectations of you and see and that's where I I know that the consensus of the board comes in that if you've got uh constituents in your District that are asking about something um uh and you want to be able to respond to that but if if if the rest of the board does not see that as a priority uh now you have an individual member that's that's directing something and so uh again this goes back to what the chair talked about is there are concerns that individual board members have how do we get those reflected in a conversation if it's not part of an agenda and so if that you know cuz one of the things I want to know is

096that as board members if there are things that you want to see addressed but you feel you can't do that uh then it is my responsibility to make sure we can do that in a manner to where you can do it and it also falls under the consensus of what a board wants his will uh and so that's going to be the difference between being an individual member versus being a board that has consensus also where we want to be able to give you the ability to respond to your constituents because you are responsible to them uh to answer the questions that they may have and so staff always wants to be there to assist you in that manner so remember that uh if you ask for something um um the only thing I want

097to make sure is that if a staff member um feels that this requires a certain amount of work uh they may have to do that if it's something I say yes it's okay you know it's going to take you 3 hours or 4 hours but I approve for you to do that so I don't want anybody to ever believe that they can't ask for information that's not what I'm saying I don't want you to ever believe that but um but I do want everybody to be mindful that uh when staff have request we want to make sure it's not putting them in a position where it's not requiring them to do too much and um you know that is the best way I can explain that but I don't ever want you to feel that

098there's something you feel you can't if that's the case call me and let me know and I know we had really good conversations about those things that you want to see okay I'm just going to comment that sometimes that although I understand everything that you said but it does not mean that you get to put things on the table that one of nine right can even have that conversation to know that you can take it to the next step and it becomes very challenging when you sit here on a table of one of nine and you just can't have that conversation then you don't feel like you do have a valuable seat at that table to represent your constituents so it does become a challenge yeah and and I understand that and and and that

099is uh where the consensus and the trust and the collaboration comes in because if there's something that's important to you as a board member um uh it is about how you have conversations with the other eight board members that say you know you Mrs Coffield we understand this is important to you so let's determine a way that we can have this addressed in a manner that meets your needs uh or it might be a situation where the other eight board members said sorry you know we're not going to deal with that as a board uh and that is I think everybody here knows as a board member that is the challenge that you have it is about uh will everybody else agree with you and you know that that's the work of a board I

100I would say all right so with that I would like to call our U work session to a close um before we do as you know we have some items we weren't able to finish at our Safety and Security meeting that we need to deal with in closed session so at this point I'd entertain a motion so consider confidential personal information connected under gs43 D1 sorry- 318 11186 and 115 C- 319 is there a second that also include all the other reasons and all the other agenda all right then I will second okay motion from Mr Hershey second from Miss mfy all in favor of moving into closed session for the reason so stated say I I any opposed all right we'll give the room a minute to clear and then we will pick up

101our in our on the agenda on our closed session items

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.