CorpusRecord 93823

2025-01-21 Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WakeCountySchools
Date
2025-01-21
Location
Wake County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,756 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e all right everyone we are going to play Beat the weather so I'm going to try to keep everything going tightly we're going to try to uh hit all this crucial information today um I'd ask for your cooperation as we move forward if we finish with the work session early we can go ahead and jump on some priority items for Clos session and then potentially get out of here before any bad weather so without any further delay I'm going to turn it over to Dr Wilson Norman and her team uh we have drew cook and Dr Kendrick King and um we're going to hear the curriculum procurement process update today we want to share with you a process that we put in place that you'll see as we walk through our presentation that the state

002has put together a 10-year plan for the update of standards and what we've tried to do is create a process of how we would review procure or develop curriculum to support these standards and I'm going to turn it over to Mr cook and Dr kendri Kean who will provide the details of this presentation thank you Dr Norman and we'll try to be concise but also do the topic Justice I think we can strike that balance so um as Dr Wilson Norman referenced really the purpose of our time together this afternoon and the time that we have is threefold um number one we want to outline the steps the purpose uh and also the rationale behind our District's curriculum procurement process to share with you today um number two we also want to highlight um planned

003engagement of essential partners that includes Educators students and families throughout the review and procurement cycle uh and number three we also want to share insights and lessons learned from our District's own experiences in the past with curriculum development and procurement um we also will share a little bit here about strategic alignment um specifically in regards to our district strategic aims uh we want to ensure of course that all students receive Equitable access um to high quality resources that cater to their diverse learning needs uh we'll also uh reference some applicable Wake County Public School System policies uh for reference here 3100 and 3200 uh which require among other things the development of a diverse and representative selection committee um and that's in addition to the full-time District team that's now in place uh that's housed

004in academics and has been in place now for the last 5 or 6 years in alignment to uh policy 3100 and then as always uh we will continue with this effort to use the current Statewide instructional standards to serve as the foundation for all the work that we do that includes both district and schools uh and also uh ensure an alignment with state and local policy that our parents Guardians and families have the right at any time to review and inspect instructional materials use in our classrooms and we'll talk a little bit about the front-end focus and effort to ensure uh those folks are involved in the process even before the curriculum and resources are procured uh in the future uh I think you you may recall our reference to the learning model uh going

005back about a year ago or so now in addition to the Strategic plan and applicable board policy we do intend for our curriculum work to connect and align with that learning model uh which essentially outlines our District's expectations for uh how we do business uh from a teaching and learning standpoint it's our goal and expectation um to establish learning environments where every single student is seen known challenged and engaged um and by the way not just in some classrooms or most classrooms or In Pockets uh but systemically and I think we all know and recognize we certainly do that we've got work to do in that regard and the same is true when we're talking about curriculum resources um and implementation across our schools in terms of some insights and Lessons Learned uh in addition

006to considering available research and also best practices nationally uh it's also important and I think uh somewhat common sensical that we do draw lessons from past curriculum and procurement efforts in our district uh which can provide of course valuable insights key takeaways uh and at times in the past some hard lessons learn um these experiences have and will guide us in refining and also enhancing the curriculum procurement and development process moving forward uh here on this slide uh to be more specific as we've reflected on and also formally evaluated you may recall those board members that were present about two years ago we shared some formal evaluations that were done by our data research and accountability office on previous curriculum implementation and procurement Cycles um we're using that information and that data to develop the

007framework that you see in front of you today and just to highlight a few of those uh insights and parameters that we're working within uh we do want to ensure that we're focused on increasing communication upfront uh and Tim with a long Runway um I can tell you that going back 6 Seven 8 years ago there were efforts to engage community members and families early on in the procurement process uh quite frankly practically speaking they were not always well attended and I think we probably can uh make sure that in the future Dr King will share a little bit more about that in just a few minutes to make sure families and parents are aware that these opportunities are available uh and that we provide multiple opportunities and communicate them clearly and systemically uh and

008make sure that folks have a kind of a front-end heads up and an opportunity to give feedback and input and that includes teachers families students as well we also want to make sure we're focusing on long-term uh budgetary planning both for upfront costs that we often focus a lot of our time and attention on in terms of developing or procuring a curriculum resource or books but also two three five years down the road in terms of what the projected cost might be to sustain and continue imp mation of those same resources and so that's a part of our planning also extended planning time um I think we know and recognize it's important to ensure we've got adequate time for Preparation and for training uh and in some cases that might even mean training and uh

009sharing information well in advance of any curriculum resources or materials Landing in the hands of a teacher so they've got time to kind of work through them learn access before they are actually expected to implement those fully in classrooms every single day um and that's part of that longer Runway that we're talking about vendor engagement building long-term relationships and Partnerships uh with our curriculum vendors and uh private Partners uh also an adjustment period um allowing time for students and for staff to adapt to new curriculum resources recognizing that in some cases uh it may be a new digital resource or new material that requires some adaptation and modification um to be able to make sure that it's fully being utilized to its potential and then also technology integration I think the board knows and understands

010even going back to our last meeting with this group uh we're in the process of a comprehensive technology evaluation when it comes to how Technologies used in our classrooms um so it'll be important for us to ensure that this work is parallel and in alignment with what we find in terms of the proper balance between technology integration and the very best of inperson instruction so with that bit of back in context I'm going to turn it over to Dr kendri Kean uh to share with you some of the more detailed and specific aspects of this curriculum framework Dr K thank you so much Dr Mr K excuse me you didn't um get the correct slide I've been called here we are so thank you Mr cook as um school board members and Dr Taylor for

011having me today um in addition to reflecting on our past experiences we researched several School districts across our country um districts such as Los Angeles Unified School District Fairfax County Public Schools and Dallas Independent Schools they offered valuable insights um for us to enhance our process by providing adaptable our unique needs our superintendent teacher advisory Council provided direct feedback for us you know they represent a broad spectrum of our Educators and the feedback that we gain help us learn that our teachers need curricula that support different student needs and learning styles we also know that they want because they told us ongoing training support and resources to effectively use that curriculum flexible materials that they can customize better communication and a long-term strategic plan to keep the curriculum sustainable and adaptable so let's MO move

012to a more detailed review of how we plan to approach the curriculum review and procurement process our process will begin when our state board of education releases new or revised standards once these standards are adopted our District's curriculum committee that's when we spring into action the first step is to review the curriculum that we have our existing materials um against the new standards we want to review to see if our resources have any gaps with what is now updated requirements based on that review our committee then moves into a development phase here is where we focus on new or revising materials that will fill those gaps that we found finally if the review and development phases indicate a new procurement is needed that is when we will go into that process this step involves colting

013and acquiring the necessary resources that meet our rigorous criteria for quality and Alignment so the systematic approach from adoption to implementation ensures that our teaching and materials are not only compliant with State Standards but also effective in support of our teachers and students in the educational Excellence that we expect our efforts um enhance the curriculum procurement process were guided in order we wanted to enhance it by three main goals first we wanted to increase partner engagement we want actively involved essential Partners be sure that we enhance our communication that is clear and that is consistent and that is timely at every stage and then to out align with our longrange planning so that we are in support of our strategic plan so doing this will improve our decision making our efficiency and of course inclusivity

014that ensures sustainability that we have state standard alignment and that we're meeting our diverse District needs the process follows six phases to ensure strategic thoral and collaborative approach phase zero focuses on strategic planning and budget assessment this is where we gather data we explore curriculum options and then we we set and align our educational goals with the resources phase one involves identifying instructional prorities and engaging our Educators students and parents we also assess the effectiveness of the curriculum current curriculum phase two we research and evaluate those curriculum options make sure that they meet the goals that were setting and the standards phase three is where we select the best curriculum and secure approval through a collaborative decision-making process phase four involves the initial implementation ensuring that educators are properly trained and lastly phase five is

015about ongoing implementation our review are we making progress is it effective and getting um feedback so that we can continuously make adjustments as needed for that long-term sustainability the North Carolina Department of Instruction time installation timeline outlines when standards are revised for a specific content area and that's when they are adopted during the installation year our district begins the process of reviewing procured procuring curriculum so what I like to do is just explain using science as the example the installation year for science was the 2324 school year last school year in Phase zero which took place during quarter 1 of last school year the district's academic team issued a request for proposal evaluated the submissions and they shared them across the Departments they also get um identified educator reviewers and then the process was paused

016so that we could realign we will start the process with phase one during quarter three of this school year in this phase we will announce a kickoff invite curriculum committee members to participate we will align the goals and criteria for curriculum selection distribute and analyze essential partner surveys to gather input re-evaluate the RFP submissions for any gaps and issue a follow of RFP if that is what's needed then we will prioritize resources and estimate the procurement cost phase two will take place in quarter 4 of this school year here's where we will select vendors host Road shows to gather feedback finalize our selection secure quotes and seek your approval for the chosen curriculum phase three occurs during the summer this is we will finalize the implementation and conduct training as well as planning sessions for

017teachers to be able to prepare get their questions answered to determine what the roll out of their classrooms could look like phase four we will Monitor and adjust the plan based on initial feedback from the training and planning um so that we can continue to fill in the training gaps now five phase five would occur Quarter Two of next school year where we will implement the curriculum in classrooms track its impact and established feedback loops this will allow us to gather insights for continual Improvement as well as make adjustments as needed so let's review our enhancements and entral partner engagement we focused on three key additions to the process curriculum and committee expansion we want to add five to seven members from each of our nine District areas so that we make sure we have

018a diverse and Equitable representation from 3K to 12 across our schools vendor presid presentations where we have formal sessions that allow vendors to present their materials we can they're going to answer questions and help the committee evaluate the options that they show using rubrics and a ranking system our road show reviews we want to give the options that we are having road shows across the district we at least want three in each of our nine so that would be 27 road shows to make sure that everyone is getting access to what we have give feedback and allow us to have an informed final decision so this again ensures that we have inclusive transparent and a collaborative curriculum procurement process our enhanced curriculum review and procurement process it invites our essential Partners to be active participants

019on this journey not just Spectators this is not about handing over a final product or simply outlining how we got there instead they're Partners they're involved at every stage from planning and needs assessment to decision making implementation and continuous review being part of this journey is like driving a vehicle together each partner plays a critical role whether it's in the driver's seat or maybe you are operating the GPS or saying where the bathroom breakes need to be we all all are there to ensure that we get to the destination together and that is a curriculum that meets the diverse needs of our schools and our communities Dr wilon but as we think about our enhanced curriculum and procurement review process that we hope that you see that we want to involve uh more and more

020Educators in the process from the beginning that we also want to increase in essential partner engagement so families uh community members across the district so that jointly we can come to a decision and then having additional opportunities with the road shows for people to actually see the materials once um the teachers are able to make some final selections before we actually make the purchase and then this is very important a huge piece of this process that the state has outlined when each curriculum area would be updated that we want to build a 10year budget because when you think about procuring materials for a district this large then we have to know exactly what it will cost and what we're able to do and so in the year of science do we start with Elementary and

021then year two do we then take care of middle year three high school and so building that 10-year budget so that we um as standards come up come up we actually know what we're able to provide and do so that everyone's expectation is clear based upon our budget and so we wanted to make sure that we had a consistent process no matter what the content area so if it is Ela if it is science if it is mathematics that we're all using the same process so that all of our teachers and educators are involved and so at this point we'll take any questions all right questions for Dr Wilson Norman or her staff all right I thought I was going to be able to jump in but so uh we'll go Dr Ring Miss Coffield

022Miss Edmonds and were there any others if not then that'll come back to me Miss rice and then I'll come back to me uh thank you um for the explanation just a quick question um you you had mentioned that uh parents um people in the community have um ability to participate at the road show stage of it uh any I wasn't clear whether they could be involved before the road show at part of you can you know giving feedback about before the decision is made about that quick the road show will actually happen before the decision is made teachers will begin to um look at and narrow down their choices and then we'll go on the we will begin to go on the road show and everyone will be able to give feedback okay that

023will help us in making the final decision perfect thank I also want to bring attention to we will have surveys in phase one so very on early early on before we um even start looking at curriculum options what are the thoughts or the needs that our current curriculum's offering and what maybe even suggestions that our teachers have heard about um that they also want us to look into okay thank you thank you Miss carfield um I just wanted to ask about the the committee like um what is that made up of and how do they because you said there was um three for every Road Show um and then 5 to seven for each district so how do how do they gather who's on the committee we will lean on our area superintendence we do

024have a district um content team um that's the team that supports me um and Dr Wilson Norman and Mr cook with our curriculum instruction and assessment team we also have other District leaders but that's just a a piece we're the service group right um but we will lean on our area superintendents to work with their principles we will have a list of criteria that need from those teams so that they can recruit in their schools to get representation and then n we'll have a n a process to narrow down to we get to those five or seven per area Okay so it it sounds like the teachers are going to be part of the process pretty much every step of the way correct yes okay thank you thank you clarify if five s will be

025the new makeup or is that's going to be added to an existing number that's already there I want to make sure we new makeup right now there that's the new makeup so this will be the process moving forward now we're right in assments um about dpi's timeline I might have missed this if you said it so they just did the social studies curriculum revision or whatever in 2021 they'll do it again in 2728 I have I think they will and I think with social studies we go um this is their timeline some Fe feedback that we would want to have for the Department of Public Instruction are twofold one 5 to 7 is what the state War policy says okay but some of these standards like mathematics and Ela for district back to back that

026happened several years ago that's a very costly um expense for a district especially one of this size to purchase Ela and then shortly there after have to turn around and do math and so this is some feedback that we'd like to share that and thinking about the practicality of it okay um is is something we need to provide but this is their timeline and sometimes miss edmans that the the revisions can be relatively minor okay or they can be significantly impactful that requires a large scale um upgrades and revisions and so sometimes we don't really know what that might be until that installation of those standards actually occurs so e Vision you don't necessarily have you don't even look to buy new correct it may just be tweaking around the edge is as opposed to

027a wholesale renovation that's all right thank you m r um I just want to say for me it's the level of Excellence that your team always brings to this table um when presenting something you take whether it's creating these with the standards that are at the state level but you've taken it the extra mile and broken it down and what it needs to look like for us as a district and you make it very actionable steps and I think and the way that you break it down in Concept in process and width and in depth um it just needs to be elevated and commended the level of expertise that you bring to the table with sharing what steps has to happen and then bringing it to the board so that we can make real decisions

028or just be knowledgeable of sharing the impact of these decisions that we might have to fix or change so that the work that you're trying to do works and so I just wanted to just highlight and say thank you for always coming to the table always coming to the table with actionable items and steps that we can actually follow and do and understand to make our student achievement process better thank you so much thank you um a little bit of feedback that I wanted to offer as well I really appreciate all of the efforts to bring in uh more partner engagement but I want to you know bring in the contrary the counter position too which is that while that engagement is good we have to make sure that we don't over rely upon that

029when we have the road shows again not to name the devil but where we've had trouble in the district before we've had a vendor maybe come in with putting a lot of money into promotion and flashy salesmanship and less on customer support right and so you know you don't want folks that are coming in as Layman to be wowed by a lot of bells and whistles if the staff has vetted it and maybe has concerns and I just want to raise that up that this needs to be a balanced approach um and then the second thing that what I'm actually the most interested in is that rubric that you're using for evaluation and I don't know if this is a factor or not and I don't want to you know get too too far down

030in the process but to me as we make decisions about the district it's Direction its academics performance and its budget I think a priority in selecting curriculum should be could we take an educator from anywhere in the country and drop them into Wake County and would they know how to teach the curriculum the standards might be different from state to state but the basic process the basic teaching principles of the curriculum are they Universal enough or standard enough that we don't have to invest too much more in professional what I'll call Redevelopment you know whether it's an Ela teacher a math teacher or a science teacher if they come to Wake County we need to make sure that new teachers that teachers we've recruited or train for other areas can come in without having to

031go through an extensive retraining process um I think that'll help us in our professional development costs and our efforts we have more resources for development in other areas and it also helps with parent and family collaboration if they understand the teaching techniques that are used as well I know it can't always be the same way it was when we were kids growing up and and what our parents did but I think there is a benefit to having some level of commonality as as as we go forward so those are just the two bits of feedback that I had thank you all right Dr Wilson Norman anything else or Dr Taylor did you have a final thought yeah yeah I did um I just wanted to add that um we know the biggest issue with curriculum

032implementation is who may or may not agree and so when we talked about this process the idea was that we wanted to make sure that people were engaged at the right time knowing that there are going to be those that disagree but we know that when people disagree and they haven't had a chance to voice an opinion that's when it creates problem uh I appreciate the last comment that you made in terms of um making sure it's not people that are bandwaggon and listen to bells and whistles uh that is where the professionalism of this group and the committee comes in most and so we want to make sure that they know and understand that uh that it's not about uh Someone putting up a a pretty presentation we've seen that happen before uh but

033ultimately uh this helps us select the career culum that most people will agree to um uh when it's time to implement even if they want something different uh and and very specifically making sure that allign from a budget perspective uh curriculum is very expensive no matter how large or small the district and we know that as a board in in a in a in a district we' made a commitment to have more Fidelity when it comes to a budget and I think this is where this process would lead us so just wanted to share that so but great job all right thank you all right continuing on uh the next item we have is the review of our U Board of Education legislative priorities on our legislative agenda and so all of you in assembly

034will try to pull this up should have access to a draft document I apologize we weren't able to get it formatted and uh you know pretty in time for you but you'll at least have most of the base Concepts and there are a couple typos in here so please bear with me um what I'd like to do is go through the whole document explain the presentation and the formatting I'd like to get through all of it and then come back for feedback on specific items so first if you remember a board retreat the advice that we'd received from our government relations team was that while we really covered many bases and a lot of situations with last year's agenda that the recommendation was that something that was simpler and more direct that really up that

035really highlighted our highest priorities would be more effective so what we tried to do was take everyone's feedback at The Retreat and narrow things down to about three or four issues which we couldn't do because there were many more priority items so we came up with three categories and then tried to take priority items and put them under there the three categories were funding of public education a category we we called local flexibility over operational issues and then fair and transparent access to school performance and I'll go through each of the items I want to jump ahead a bit and say one thing that we had mentioned but didn't discuss too much at The Retreat had been the idea of a federal agenda and so some members have come to us Mr Hershey and some

036others with items that we thought could be included on federal agenda um we support this and want to move ahead with it we don't want to put it on your calendar today my goal is if we can talk about the state agenda first get it to a position where we're ready to bring a product to our February 4 board meeting then we can get that out in advance of our state Bill drafting deadlines that'll be on the timeline that was recommended recommended To Us by our government relations team and then also on the February 4th work session we can talk about our federal agenda and then try to bring the federal agenda to our board meeting for a vote on the second February meeting so that's that's the timeline that I'm putting out for your

037consideration of proposing so so here we took this first item funding of public education and we're talking about uh funding of salaries for teachers and classroom classroom support staff that are competitive with other states and other professions that's something we really haven't talked a lot about you know we'll talk about how North Carolina rates and teacher pay but we've seen in working to staff the vacancies that we've had in the district the last few years we're not so much losing teachers to other districts as we are losing them to other professions and so if you look you and again you you can look online on your own copy the document I don't want to read all of it through you but that's some of the suggested languages and some of the points that we wanted

038to make that we thought might resonate with legislators talking about a meaningful public investment in education that is competitive with States in our region and with the other economic markets that Wake County competes with um it recognizes that not only do we lose teachers to other teaching districts but to better paying private sector jobs and that can be really difficult in for example career in technical education who's going to come in and teach someone how to weld or be an electrician when they can make three times the salary actually engaged in that profession um we talked about modernizing the special education funding formula and really I think if there's you know any item that has strong consensus among our board I think we all see that amending that fund that funding formula and amending the

039funding caps is absolutely essential when you look at the portion of Wake County students that receive some sort of special education services it exceeds that 133% and ideally we would differentiate by the kinds of services we need to provide whether it's ECS or you know other types of student needs um you know you all have I think been very clear that and this is where we have a little bit of a typo the first sentence is duplicated so um strike the first one and then pick up the same sentence again um the importance of our students you know being you know having the nourishment and the the the health the food security to be able to learn and we've seen that with Rising food costs Rising labor costs inflation you know the federal reimbursement rates

040just do not match up and we really are in a spiral and so you know calling on our legislators to supplement funding for the student meal programs this is something Wake County wouldn't do alone and we debated this because you know you remember the government relation team said there's other state coalitions working on this so did this need to be something that we wanted to put dedicate space in our agenda but based on everyone's feelings on this we thought it was important to include it as an item even acknowledging that other organizations will be working on this as well and you'll see Dr Taylor included this important fact uh North Carolina can close the remaining gap for no cost breakfast in grades K5 where the foundation for futuring learning has developed for approximately $140 million

041that's Statewide so when you talk about meaningful Investments that the legislature could make this isn't even just you know helping us out with the reimbursement program this is full funding of no cost breakfast in those early grades um and then the last funding need is one that we talked about which is the school funding formula being based on actual School enrollment you know it only makes sense especially if we're moving to a system where funds will follow students when they leave public school what happens when they return to public school you know rather than funding on an average amount at the beginning of the year you know you're you're taking a snapshot of a system in constant motion and being able to fund schools based on actual enrollment just makes more sense to everybody that

042that we've spoken to so um those are the fund those are the funding school funding related items we'll move next um to what we talked about in terms of local operational issues yeah so here we talked about our operational issues that are essentially local issues but they're controlled by state law so once again we have to we we have to make the plea for modification of school calendars even if it's as modest as aligning with the state community colleges and then being able to make calendar adjustments based on weather and and emergency related situations we shouldn't have to go back to the legislature and get a bill passed if we get too much snow this week you know and we shouldn't have to have Saturday school you know these are these These are basic simple

043asks that based on the conditions on the ground in Wake County or any County that we should have that the county should have that discretion now K3 class size is something we've talked about um here we're not talking about eliminating the class size requirements but just giving the counties counties like Wake County a broader ability to wave those K3 class size requirements so we can more cost effectively utilize the facilities and classroom space we have we know in many cases we'd like to get class size down as best we can to a manageable level but having class siiz requirements that even shift from grade to grade 16 students 17 students 18 students you know you end up having to hire more teachers than you may need in a school at a particular grade you have

044empty classroom space within the schools that can be better utilized when those schools fill up we have to cap the schools and then deal with issues like reassignment which we know parents don't like we end up moving families further and further away from their neighborhoods when we have the capacity within the school buildings to teach those students and we can do that teaching more coste effectively per student if we had the ability to um Grant those waivers and so you look at some of the scenarios that we discussed wavers for for non- low performing elementary schools could provide that relief um to the district while having minimal impact on academic achievement um you know additional opportunities oh sorry so there should be a second paragraph there um after the K3 class siiz requirements the ability

045for Wake County voters to have the opportunity to vote on additional funding options for school capital and operation through local Revenue collection um you know there are Provisions in state law for school districts to have like a temporary sales tax and here this is something we've heard from legislators well if HVAC problems are so bad why aren't you asking us for help why aren't you asking us for a bill well let's call them on it and let's say if you really want to help give us the ability that we can get caught up with the backlog in our facility needs that we can address these life cycle improvements that have either been put on hold or or haven't we haven't been able to keep up with because we haven't been able to sta those positions

046so this last category was difficult to name but the best we could come up with was fair and transparent access to school performance and really this is about accountability um here if you look at school performance and how Wake County schools are judged and evaluated by the legislature how they have to compete against other how we compete against other states other school districts and Charter and private options you know what we're asking for are some basic basic rules and tenants of fairness uh the first statement really is just a a principle but it's one you know I think we all need to stand behind funding for public schools needs to be prioritized and met before public funds are provided to private schools now we know that the state not only passed but greatly expanded the

047public school voucher program for private schools as I know there's a debate on this issue even among members of the board I don't think we expect that they'll go back and repeal those vouchers this year so if that's the case is there a way that we can improve that program and get some common sense reforms to it and one thing that just makes sense is that if anyone receiving public dollars had to provide the same student achievement and budget accountability information to the public it would protect families and consumers one thing that I've heard since I've been on the board is I've seen families that have gone to private schools then those children have applied for college and then they were shocked to find out that the colleges didn't accept their transcripts because the private

048school they attended was not accredited and parents often often times don't look for those types of issues you know before you commit to a private school if you are receiving a substantial investment from the state you really ought to know how well it performs that leads to the same degree that the public schools perform and if these dollars are available let's make everyone just like consumer product labels tell us how they're doing you that the student should take a end of grade test and we can compare apples to apples they should provide the same you know public budgets of how money is spent how teachers are compensated and then consumers can make the best choice for their families using fair and objective information the same principle is true with our grading and evaluation system you

049know Wake County North Carolina followed a movement of other states that went to school rating systems it was sort of a national movement but where we haven't kept up is that many of those other States after a few years the grading and evaluation system went back evaluated them and adjusted them whereas we sort of kept the same system in place so the ratios of performance to growth by the states that we held up and championed as models look nothing like the ratios that we use in North Carolina today now personally you know our previous superintendent of Public Instruction looked and made recommendations that these school performance grades don't adequately tell us how prepared students are for life after graduation and you really need a much more comprehensive system for evaluating school performance and the Readiness

050of students you know those efforts were not completed in her tenure I don't know if those efforts will continue but something like that would be better than the current system that we have so those are the three categories and those are the systems um the subcategories under those again I went through you know all the notes from our our our Retreat tried to see how many people had spoken up either if it was like one person thought one issue was the most important or someone mentioned many issues I tried to capture all of it evaluate it and put put them in there the last bit at the bottom is sort of a catch all because there are issues that we just don't have room to include but if they're included on the school board's Association

051legislative agenda or there more specific things about School meals that could be at school meals for all Coalition it's a general endorsement of that work as well so if these items are items that you support if there are items that you think should not be on here if there's you know again we do want to keep it as as concise as we can so if there's an item we want to add we might want to think about an item we would need to remove but we can fine-tune this we can get it formatted and we can bring it to you for your discussion and consideration at the next board meeting all right we'll turn it over for discussion I'll start with Miss Edmond thanks um so the I understand the Senate that talks about funding

052for public schools prior needs to be prioritized before funding of private schools or what however it's worded under the um second thank you so but I think it needs to be repeated in that top section about school funding okay I don't care how you do it but I think it needs to be in both places um I mean a simple like as stated above you know to reiterate in that lower section and just for context um Dr Taylor thank you for the 140 million number about the school meals um so that we can um reference or have that in scale for the 24 25 school year the legislature with hb10 allocated $616 million for voucher for that one school year that is not cumulative that is 66 more than 616 million doll for private school

053vouchers for one school year and it's going up in subsequent years compared to that 140 million that would pay for K5 breakfast thank you Mr Hershey so a lot of this is great so great job getting this together um I got a little lost when you were talking about the way County voters should be given the opportunity to vote on additional opportunities did you say the legisl legislature was saying why don't you bring this to us or who who said that so and I did get a little muddled there let me let me explain so school funding you know comes through the legislature counties can provide it some district and the legislature has in the past set up methods for local governments local counties to have additional Revenue for schools usually through a sales tax

054of some sort so that's out there as an option that we could consider more recently in discussions and debates about um hvac's and you know uh heating systems there was a lot of discontent when schools had to shut down early because the school environment wasn't appropriate for for kids we had some legislators that came back and said this is a problem it's unaccept able and no one's talked to me about it you know so if this really was such a big issue why aren't why doesn't way County bring this to the legislature and we know that typically Capital costs Capital expenses are funded locally as opposed to being funded by the state so usually we go to the county for those issues we go for the state for these other issues so traditionally we wouldn't

055go to the state for money for air conditioning but if there's a political will there and there's interest there yeah here's a way that we could go to the state for authorization that won't cost any state dollar would allow us to act locally to address these needs so it would be something State Legislative Partners could do that could help us locally address some of these issues and Mr advis Swanson was talking specifically here the idea of bringing up something to address a specific need that would have a Sunset date as well that you're not putting it out there the legislature includes that in the legislation so it's not one of these things about well this is only temporary and then it just keeps going forever quick two very quick questions does the general assembly have

056to approve the grading and evaluating section or is that we make that ask of the um thei actually the general is saying that they will make the determination of what um the school performance grades look like right uh the um the addition of U performance versus achievement uh they make that determination so right now it's a 80/20 split before it was 50/50 between achievement and performance right so as the chair said everybody recognizes the imbalance many states have already moved away from it uh but we remain and so this is something that's self-imposed by every state okay State can let make the bar as low or as high as they want it to be we tend to make it high but in this case we all know this is not indicative of true scoop um

057last thing as an ad and AJ great timing sir I emailed them um there's a couple of items from HR that relate to licensing that we kind of brought up last year during the short session but that um I mean do you want AJ to say them real quick what everything be yeah I think you could just B General and advocating for some lure flexibility I think might be a good way to to phrase and advocate for it I know one of the specific challenges we often have are experienced teachers from other states especially at the K5 level lots of years of success still have to come down and need additional testing requirements and that can be a barrier to lure but I think just overall you know looking at some licens or flexibility to

058be a good advocacy Point okay so I I I'd feel better if we could flesh that out a little more but like the idea of having Pro provisional certification that someone could come in and then maybe you know fill a position while still looking to meet North Carolina criteria something like that if you if that's something that you can work with us on to draft we'll throw it to the board I don't want to put it in without other comment but if people like that then we can introduce some language for the next not yet the the the February 4 meeting Dr Yeah question regarding that is there a reciprocity type of arrangement that between states very rarely is there true reciprocity where somebody can just take a license and get a new one in

059a new state without having to be some additional testing it's easier sometimes at the secondary level very challenging at the El level and so that's what I was going to suggest that we perhaps look at some language around reciprocity is much different than than it was 30 years ago so I think back then we probably had a reciprocity with about 20 States I don't even know if it's close to any of that now so we'll massage that lamage and and bring it back um and the other thing I just want to mention and just and you can move on but I I do like what you talked about in the the K3 class siiz waiver um just the fact that you you made it into kind of concrete yeah the reasons why and what were

060the impact like realistically in in our schools you know to have a wa for for that for that reason and and then the impact on financial especially with having to go through a you know physical cliff and all that that that that does make a great impact on our ability to uh you know sustain uh our educational you know goals thank you I appreciate that um Miss coffin um I just have a question in reference to the same paragraph are we asking for the ability to wave the classroom size requirements so I think it's we have the ability to wave them now under certain conditions conditions right but it's broadening those conditions for fiscal issues fiscal management issues and you know if the legislators were willing to consider that we could work with them to

061determine what those guard rails would be but it wouldn't be eliminated them it would just be you know creating the conditions that could grant us more flexibility so um I mean the feedback that that I receive is that they actually like the teachers and the families the the smaller class sizes and we specifically say in here the waivers for low performing elementary schools but I would feel like they am I reading it wrong not performing all says waivers for non oh I'm sorry non- low performing okay okay one of the things that I had noted was that I was hoping that we could put in some kind of wording for an allowance for extra people where we need it extra Tas or teacher coaches something to explain that in some of the low performing schools

062where we need it we would have the availability to add in more than they would normally aot us I don't know exactly what the wording would be but just to ask for yeah if you have more low performing confus I'll try to explain it a different way if we have low performing schools it would be more beneficial to have in some of those situations more right like the restart flexible spending and having the availability to either have the money to do that and spend the way we need or to have the state provide us with more of an allowance per student for those extra bodies I'll let Dr respond yeah so so what I was going to say is that I think a lot of that is going to be captured under the the adequate

063funding uh and so with with restart schools we already have the flexibility that we would want um um if we talk with the G about adequate funding meaning they give us more money uh then we do have the opportunity to direct those resources in the right place and so uh when there's not enough uh then you have to meet those base formula needs and you can't expand beyond that so we do have that now um if we my suggestion would be if you begin to get into those weeds there going to be a whole bunch of places where you would would want to identify similar types of things so I would capture it all under adequate funding is where I would do so do you believe that just saying adequate funding is actually explaining why

064and how it could well what I'm saying is that if um if we begin to identify specific pieces of where we would need a additional funding that there are going to be a lot of earings I think that uh special education is one that we see as a big rock but if we talk about uh needing to add more Tas need needing to add uh coaches things of that nature so we have funding now that allow us to um to hire coaches and and put them in the places where we need uh but um we want to be careful about identifying too many singular areas just identify those big rocks but increase funding in more flexibility allows us to put it where we need it so do we have that flexibility in all of our

065schools right now no no and so that's part of the idea that when you think about restart there's a tremendous amount of flexibility but you have to be in academic trouble to use uh restart and so it's like uh it's a double-edged sword you don't necessarily want that and so we don't have that flexibility um there have been a lot of restrictions placed on a number of categories teacher assistance is an example to where uh in in the past um uh districts would make the the choice of transferring money in or out to create more teaching positions but now that's restricted to where you can't do that so so that's why I'm asking if we had that specific terminology language or ask of having the restart flexibility it allows us to do all those things

066where we need and with what we need because we do have so many specific needs so what what I'm I'm hearing two things um I'm hearing on one hand that having that flexibility would be a priority and would assist our schools particularly those low performing schools but I'm also hearing that we have to be very deliberate with the language that we use I think in last year's agenda we had an agenda item about expanding what we call Charter likee flexibility to use in those situations I'll ask you know kind of look around the board for your comfort level if we wanted to go back to last year's language it would fit I think here under that operational flexibility category and if you go back and look at that if it sort of meets what you're

067talking about we could bring that to the agenda for the February 4th one does that sound yeah because unless I mean unless you have like a specific language now I'd say if we just look to what we used look at it see if it meets what you want then we could just use that one I'm just not sure if Charter like versus well so that would be like where we'd want to right redefine that yeah but if we can't like come up with a specific language now just sort of use that as a model yeah I would um and and I know what you're suggesting I think the simple language is that uh an increasing Charter or restart type flexibility whatever that word is we're talking about increase flexibility and so yeah okay thank you

068all right um other thoughts again it is a tough job because there's so many issues we could put in here and you know we wanted to give some examples we wanted to flush out the issues and so that made some of it longer than we would have liked but then in other areas we we had a lot written and we had to go back and cut it and cut it and and bring it down so um if you don't have any other specific uh comments then what I'll do is we have this is what I've captured taking that principle about the public school funding and making sure that's also includ uded in the category heading trying to put some additional context on the amount that went into like some factual factual statement about the amount

069that went into private school funding um we'll try to bring um language and I'm going to rely upon Mr Hershey to work with Dr muello about flexibility um I still have a question on that policy-wise if we have reciprocity and that makes it easier for teachers to move from state to state and we pay the lowest of most of the states is that going to end up harming us more than it helps us that's a HR not me I'll just I'll put that out there and then the last one I had was Miss cofield's language on flexibility like they have in the restart schools Miss mafy no I just want to highlight when I moved here from Washington State it took about somewhere between 6 and 8 months before I received my North Carolina um

070license um in order to be able to teach I would hope that that's something the State Board is looking at now that more and more states are going to the ntpa format um but they took my check right away um but I think that that's I'm glad that that's something that hopefully they will look at as we look at the future shortage so I appreciate that ad and okay although I'd love to add a lot more I'm going to refrain there's a lot of restraint in this process are we doing it in this format or the same format we did we're just working on so we're just working off this is a Word document but we would give it to uh Chief luton's team and they would work their magic to make it look similar

071to what we had before that's why it's in this formatting cuz oh I'm sorry for talking no go right ahead um we took quite a bit of three of us kind of word smithing it taking everyone's thoughts and flashing it out and looking at the language trying to make sure that it's not you know to Dr E point last year make sure this is not a wish list but it's a tool to for our lobbyists to really be able to do the work that we need for the district and so that was something we really took into consideration um to give a product and so yall did a good job yeah thank you all right all right so I'll take that feedback and we will work uh with staff to produce um a document for

072us for consideration at a board meeting and um juggling sorry always juggling and and um what I'll ask is Mr her Miss Coffield if you want to work with me and rest your Swanson directly we can get uh proposed amendments that capture CU I don't want to like think that I've got it and then I show it to you that's not what you wanted um you provide the language quick yes we do and you know ideally it would be great to have this by not tomorrow Wednesday but next Wednesday so we could talk about it in our leadership meeting and then make sure it could be formatted and loaded in assembly for the February 4th meeting all right okay so with that Mr Hershey well I was going to I have the close session stuff

073up but yeah I was going to ask since we're done so early if we wanted to spend 10 minutes on the federal because of everything coming and we had it off the work session my preference is knowing what we have in work session I'd rather I'm sorry with close session I'd rather stick with the plan so that we can do as much of that and get everyone home safe before anything I would like to make a motion to go into close session to considered confidential personal information under gs43 d318 one18 6 and 115 C- 319 okay so we have a motion from Mr Hershey to um move into closed session for the items stated um in the uh agenda pry seconded by by Vice CH Swanson all in favor of moving into Clos session at

074this time signy by saying I any opposed all right we'll give the the room a minute to clear and then we'll proceed with our Clos session agenda hey

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.