CorpusRecord 93825

2025-01-07 Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / WakeCountySchools
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Wake County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,823 words · about 77 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001better e that's e spe there all right good evening everyone today is Tuesday January 7th 2025 and we are calling this regular meeting of the Wake County Board of Education to order at 5:36 I to welcome those of you that are watching at home and I want to uh welcome all of you who have joined us in person happy 2025 and happy New Year to you all uh the way County Board of Education meetings are for the purpose of conducting the official business of the Board of Education the public is cordially invited to attend the meetings to observe the board as it conducts its business persons who willfully interrupt disrupt or cause disturbances being during a meeting may be directed to leave by the presiding officer and disruptions by any person or persons of a

002public meeting will be subject to action in accordance with General statute 143 31817 so we do have a quorum today um a quorum today you know Quorum is the majority however we only have eight members here as you know we have a vacant seat for uh District 2 but we'll be discussing that later in the meeting so with a full Quorum I'd like to invite all of you that are able to please stand as we recite the pledge of allegiance of Al to of the United States of America indice all right thank you so turning to our official meeting agenda the first item on the agenda is consideration and adoption hopefully of the agenda I'll entertain a motion at this time some mov we have a motion from Mr Swanson to adopt the tonight's meeting

003agenda and we have a second from Miss mfy all in favor of approval of the meeting agenda please signify by saying I I any opposed all right the meeting agenda has been approved so the first item on our agenda sorry if I'm grinning a little bit is a special recognition item tonight about the naming of the Courtyard at Horton Creek Elementary School so if we could I would like to call upon is it our chief of schools is it our area superintendent Cedric I'm looking at you sir all right I'm calling up uh the Northwest area superintendent intendent Mr Cedric Williams for this special information item tonight thank you board chair uh board members superintendent Taylor um it is my honor my privilege to come to you today we have um in attendance our retiree

004Dr Sandy Chambers who retired recently from Horton Creek Elementary School um before coming to Horton Creek she was is also at BR Creek Elementary School as principal there as well she served us well here in the Wake County Public School System the PT uh PTA there at Horton Creek Elementary School um approached the assistant principal there and said we would like to honor our founding principal here at Horton Creek by naming our garden and her name um Dr ch and they said what do we do to make that happen then we said well there is a process um they did go ahead and get many names um from community members there who wanted to see this happen as well so today I'm here asking you if you would go ahead and consider um making sure

005that they can put this plaque in that courtyard in honor of the Dr Sandy Chambers so that is my question to you board if you would consider that um this evening thank you Mr Williams so um we do have an the next item on the agenda is the action item concerning this request um is if everyone is satisfied with the information item or I don't know if you have any additional speakers or anyone else presenting tonight uh we can either move to the action item or we can hear from anybody who's assembled well she said I don't have to speak tonight do I um and I said you do not if you do not want to but if you would like to come and just say a few words I would definitely welcome that if

006you would board chair thank you I will leave it up to your discretion since I put on the spot she's coming up sure you better buy some flowers for that garden now indeed um well it is an honor to be considered for this honor um the PTA and the community at Horton Creek and the staff and students and the whole Community there um believed in me when I opened that school and they trusted me and valued me for the ideals and the vision that we all came up with together and um it was just it I mean pta's here miss Morton here from the school Miss small here she was the founding assistant principal of the school my family's here um and it would be such an honor for you to consider naming the courtyard

007after me we um had such a good time there but I have retired in June and I don't know if I'm coming back to work or not but anyway I would love for you to consider it chair Hagerty I would you Chambers to make a motion to approve this Courtyard naming after the amazing incredible and every positive adjective I can think of Dr Sandy Chambers so we do have a motion sorry sorry I would like to second because fun fact um Dr Chambers and I went to do junior high together in dur Public Schools yes way yes and unfortunately we haven't worked together much because you know she's not um been one of the principals or administrators in in District 5 but um that that doesn't matter I'm eagerly um ready to second that motion

008and excited for you and so proud of you and yes please come back all right then if that's acceptable all right then we do have a motion from Miss mafy and a second from Miss Edmonds so the motion is on the table for discussion Miss mfy I'm I mean I'm obviously going to vote for this because anyone who has met Sandy Chambers knows her dedication to the profession of educating students it was my first vote on the board was approving the assignment plan for Horton Creek Elementary School and I got to see how she and Miss small help build that school create that school to a a very you know it's just an incredible place and I'm at a loss for words because if you watch her work you are at a loss for words

009and I think the fact that so many of her staff members and mentees are here um is just a testament to the impact that she's had on this District in so many different ways and I know one of the first things that she talks about is her family and her very public wedding on The Today Show or Good Morning America my I'm sorry and her children and I know that that is a huge sacrifice to be the family of a principal um and so I just want to thank you guys for supporting your your partner your mom throughout this um because I know she puts her whole heart into that and at the same time she has space to put her whole heart into all of you I don't know how you do it but

010I know you have Boundless Energy and so I am just so excited for this thank you thank you thank you Miss mafy is there anyone else who would like to speak and it is it is a a an incredible honor for us to take the take the action to name this Garden in honor of Horton Creek's founding principal you know the the lines for our districts change over time and you know I know that Horton Creek was originally one of Miss mfy schools with the lines changing it became a district seven school but I could not add anything to what Miss mafy has said other than just your legacy at the school is amazing parents still talk about Miss Chambers they they they have high hopes for the future right and everything's positive you left

011the ship in good condition but everyone loves you and misses you so much and so I'm happy to vote for this and I believe everyone else on the board is as well so thank you all right we'll take the vote all in favor of the naming of the Courtyard at Horton's Creek Elementary after you know after uh is it former principal Sandy Chambers all in favor say I I any opposed all right thank you very much thank you thank you thank you thank you and Mr w do you know the address for those flowers and Bulbs I I will make sure we'll get two dozen sir thank you all right thank you I I hope you all just um appreciate you know we we have wonderful stories here in the districts and it's great when

012we can be joined by family and friends and staff just to celebrate some of the wonderful people that we do have working for us so we thank you all for coming out tonight um we will move now into the public comment portion of our meeting public comment speakers if you are new pay attention if you've been here before you probably have heard all this but please bear with me um we're going to hear tonight first from speakers who are students in our Public Schools then we will hear from speakers commenting on items on the night's agenda they'll be heard before speakers on other topics all other speakers will be heard in order of their sign up only the person speaking at the podium will be allowed to stand all other attendees that are not speaking

013are to remain seated concerns related to Personnel matters or student Personnel issues or student matters may be addressed through several other policies that are available to you and if you are here seeking uh a resolution of a situation about that please stay after and meet with staff while you're here we can put you in touch with the correct staff person to address that matter in the interest of maintaining civilian deorum speakers are encouraged to address their comments to the Board of Education those of us up here at the table and must refrain from personal attacks and insults director at the board individual board members staff and most importantly members of the public it takes a lot of Bravery to get up here before everyone and speak so please be respectful um if you have materials

014that you would like to share uh please give those to our board attorney Mr Malone sitting at the end of the table before or after you speak while you are speaking you should remain at the podium um during public comment you may speak for up to 3 minutes the microphones are adjustable and the way it works if you haven't done this before your time begins once you begin speaking once you begin speaking the green light will begin and that's the start of your time now as you go you have three minutes when you see a yellow light and you hear an audible tone that's your warning that you have 30 seconds left uh sometimes if you're not if you have your notes over the light it may surprise you don't be rattled that's just telling

015you you've got 30 30 seconds left when you hear the next tone and see a red light that is the signal that your time is up that's when we will call another speaker up to the table so please when your time is up please step away and allow the next speaker to come up and speak and again speakers are asked to respect the time limit and speak for no more than three minutes to allow everyone their opportunity to speak and to not disrupt the meeting all right so for tonight's uh public comment period we have several students joining us I'm going to start with Arana Armstrong who will be followed by Brandon Estes good evening Ariana good evening my name is Ariana Armstrong and I'm a senior at night high school and a member of

016the post centers Youth Empowerment teen and Teen Health advisory Council before I begin I'd like to thank the members of the wick County Board of Education and Wick County public school system for giving me the opportunity to voice my opinions in front of them tonight I'm here to advocate for the adoption of passive permission or optout policy when administrating the youth risk behavior survey yrbs I know that in previous meetings you have been and tonight you will be informed of the statistical advantages of implementing this policy however I'd like to take the time to provide you with the perspective of someone who has been negatively impacted by the implementation of the opt-in policy and has seen the shift in conversations surrounding surveys like like the ybs as a result in the past my school has

017given students the opportunity to fill out a survey just like the ybs where we are questioned on things like our mental health substance use and the Intercourse we engage in and are asked to anonymously respond one day I noticed that the seat of one of my friends was vacant and when a few presumed sick days turned into weeks of absences inquiries on her whereabouts took place she later told us that she had attempted to take her own life and was at home recovering the story of my classmate is just one of many within Wake County there are thousands of children whose voices are not being heard and problems are not being considered in the results of surveys like the ybs because they are part of a disproportionately underrepresented Community Way county is the largest county

018in North Carolina but has the lowest overall ybs response rate the ybs is meant to gauge the needs of Youth today and help form strategies in the community and improve school programs but if we don't know there's a problem how can we address it if more accurate data had been collected from surveys like the ybs the data can show schools and support systems that students need more resources and support and my friend may have received the support she needed sooner I hope that when you take your vote and think of this survey you will remember my words and think of all the students like my classmates and I you will be helping by making this small change thank you thank you our next speaker is Brandon Estes will be followed by phix Belo all right

019uh good evening everyone my name is Brandon asz and I'm a junior at Bren High School um now I'm here to talk about something that is that people love seeing in their inboxes surveys so um over the past few years I've noticed that my peers do generally care about tackling mental health issues um like anxiety depression and self-confidence but here's the catch we don't have the data to fully understand these challenges like fixing a car without knowing what's under the hood we need the youth risk behavior survey data in order to identify patterns and move forward since the pandemic things have only gotten worse for my age demographic with worse with my peers mental health taking a hit that's why I'm here advocating for uh the adoption of the youth youth risk behavior policy um

020first it would offer an accurate snapshot of student well-being weight count is unique and Statewide data just doesn't cut it with our own data without our own data is just like trying to solve a jigsaw piece or jigsaw puzzle without without half the pieces Miss Missing second this data helps organizations that are addressing issues just like this the post Center for health education is an excellent example of a group that with the proper data and its resource ources can effectively help address these issues third let's talk about grants imagine competing against Charlotte meinberg funding without local data it's like showing up to a job interview without a resume Wake County is already at a disadvantage and in today's landscape every bit of funing funding counts here is the reality Wake County is the only oversample

021District in North Carolina using an opt-in policy other districts like Charlotte Durham and forsi use apparent and for Passive cons consent model and they've all received weighted data meanwhile wake is left with nothing it's like my buddy who showed up the friends giving without a dish it was awkward disappointing and a waste of time and resources when I walked the hall AB Bren I see firstand firsthand how mental health um struggles affect my peers not just personally but academically healthy students perform better and the ybs data is no exception to that and can help schools craft meaningful solutions to address and improve academic outcomes for parents this data opens the door to important conversations about how their CH child or children are feeling and for schools it provides a road map to fulfill the Strategic

022plan and Equity Frameworks you have already set out to complete towards or work towards at the end of the day this isn't just about surveys or statistics it's about giving students a voice and empowering us to advocate for ourselves and building a healthier and more supportive School Community thank you thank you our next speaker hold on one second is uh Phoenix Bilo who will be followed by Rana Graham good evening board members and happy New Year um I know I've discussed this before but I want to talk to you guys a bit more about phones um I know that there are problems uh but everything has its flaws drugs cause problems but the drug problem within our schools continues guns cause problems and that still continues but good things can cause problems too our busing

023system is flawed our lunch programs are flawed our School computers and iPads are flawed but we're not going to ban buses and lunch lines and Technology instead we look for a solution to the specific problem there's no question that phones cause problems but the root of those problems is deeper and removing phones would only result in a new outlet for those issues phones can disrupt class and cause distractions why because students don't care or most often students don't understand and don't get adequate help if they didn't have a phone they'd F something else I'm pretty sure we all remember the fidget spinner craze um students use phones to harass classmates why because we as a society have failed to teach children that bullying is wrong and bullying came long before phones with no phone students

024would still find a way to bully and harass their peers phones create drama why because people see something and are compelled to say something if there was an intruder in the school people would find a way to gossip and embellish it even without a phone but what would the good what about the good that comes from phones students can can and do use phones for academic reasons I have apps on my phone that help me understand Math and Science because I know I struggle in those areas students can and do use phones to prevent bullying or to get help for it we use the say something app to report any concerns within our schools students can use phones to contact loved ones if necessary I'd never want to create drama but if my life happened

025to be in danger I would absolutely tell my mom my sister and my girlfriend that I love them every rose has its thorn but sometimes things are worth a little prick in the finger phones do much good for everyone not just students and the cons of phones greatly outweigh the cons of being phoneless and if phones were banned wouldn't that apply to the teachers and staff too School staff leads by example they followed the dress code they don't Vape they treat everyone with kindness and doing all of that sets an example for students it wouldn't be fair to take student phones while staff can still brandish theirs about I already feel hugely unsafe at school on a regular day and my phone is something that provides me with safety it's a tool for survival I

026don't know if I could even handle a regular day without my phone not to mention a day with additional danger and I know I'm not alone in that there are options and numerous solutions for the phone related issues and those options don't have to be the removal or Banning of phones because I assure you that will just cause more harm thank you our next speaker is Ranna who will be followed by Kevin good evening good evening my name is rhanna Graham and I'm currently a senior at wake young women's Leadership Academy and I have had the privilege of serving as a member of the post centers Wake County Youth Empowerment team for over 2 years I'd like to begin by extending my gratitude due to the Wake County Board of Education and the Wake County

027Public School System for their ongoing commitment to Student Success I stand before you today to advocate for change to the current policy regarding the youth risk behavior survey or ybs specifically I am urging the board to adopt a passive permission or opt out policy for administrating the survey under the current active permission or opt-in policy the process for collecting data is faced with a number of challenges students are asked to bring home permission forms for their parents to and return however this process often fails to for various reasons students may forget the forms May m m may be misplaced or they may feel uncomfortable asking their parents to complete them as a result many students are excluded from participating in the survey leading to a significant loss of data this data is not just a

028collection of numbers it is a vital tool that helps guide policy decisions and health initiatives that directly impact our community at the post Center I have personally used the data collected in the in the yrbs to make policy proposals and ways to advocate for issues in my community all these things depend on data collected and when the data is limited or includes so few policies and programs fail to Target or reach students who need help when we take a look at the data produced from the North Carolina 2023 youth risk behavior survey we can see that students feelings of depressions have had a downward trend for the first time in a decade in 2021 feelings of depression reached a high of 41% and then decreased to to 39% in 2024 this is data that is

029key to the adoption of mental health policies in North Carolina and has proved beneficial and has proved beneficial in the past with the adoption of shlt 003 or school-based mental health policy this is data we need to see from Wake County and why we need to adapt passive permission in conclusion I urge the Wake County County Board of Education to consider the benefits of an opt out policy for the Youth risk behavior survey this change will lead to more accurate and representative data allowing for better informed decisions that benefit the health and well-being of students in Wake County thank you for your consideration thank you Miss Graham our next speaker will be Kevin agong who'll be followed by Anish patkar um good evening and thank you for the opportunity to speak before you today my

030name is Kevin aine and I'm currently a sophomore at milberg Magnet High School I I here today to advocate for the Wake County School Board to adopt a passive parent consent policy for the Youth risk behavior surveillance survey also known as ybs the ybs is a every other year nationally conducted survey administered to middle and high school students it provides crucial it provides a crucial platform for students to anonymously share their experiences and offer insights into their overall well-being by participating students are able to provide a clear understanding of how they are fairing highlighting any needs and challenges like every other state this information is vital to North Carolina as it helps identifies areas of students lives that need attention while also evaluating the effectiveness of existing programs and initiatives in schools and other institutions

031for the last several administrations Wake County has been an oversampled District but had too little participation under the 60% for weighted data due to opt-in permission also known as active permission policy because weight County district has not been able to obtain the standard requirement for participation the CDC does not provide the county with weighted dat unlike surrounding areas like Charlotte mberg durm Winston Salem fory and chadam the data withheld from our district is important for several key reasons offers an accurate snapshot of student well-being in weake County Highlights Area for program development for institutions like the post Center informs incomes of Grant applications as those who do meet the 60% are more capable of competing for Grants and also serves many other purposes a major problem that withholds all of this data is active permission

032policy which requires students to obtain consent forms have their parents decide whether to opt into the survey and then return the forms to their teachers this process has many fults that can lead to the form not ever being accounted for causing the this lack of participation as a result the data collected may be biased and students in our County are deprived from the opportunity to share the perspectives in my life alone I personally witness kids who struggle with substance substance abuse and vaping and mental health issues and valuing themselves and and realizing their selfworth in and outside of school all topics addressed in the yrbs the solution proposed today lies in moving away from active permission parent informed from away from active permission to parent informed passive permission excuse me under the passive consent information

033is provided to parents and Guardians and consent is assumed unless they explicitly choose to opt out this approach would significantly increase participation while keeping parents informed and empowering them to make the decision to withdraw their children if they wish while I'm here today advocating for students to take the survey and share their experiences perspectives on the wellbeing I recognize that I cannot fully represent the experiences of over a 100,000 students in the way the W the youth risk behavior survey can the survey offers invaluable insight to device diverse challenges and concerns faced by students by encouraging participation we can ensure that these voices are heard thank you thank you our next speaker Anish patar and then we will turn to our non-student agenda good evening Anish good evening so my name is Anish and I

034am also a senior in high school but as someone who has attended a public school who currently attends a private school now I feel like I wanted to offer a perspective that from both a private and public school perspective about um a youth Behavior opt-in survey opt out survey as everyone else here I'm also in support of the opt out use risk behavior survey as we have seen before mental health issues are at a alltime high since the 21st century sexual issues plague many of my friends who are in public schools drugs that people take due to withdraw and so many more issues which aren't able to be seen and heard by the broad school system in Wake County many of my friends and peers who attend these Public Schools lament the P the lack

035of help and counseling they can receive for these issues but to be fair how could these people know my private school durm academy is one that has just um added or adopted an opt out survey in the past few years and I wanted to give some insight to how this has given our school a lot of opportunities to use this data with the data used from these surveys and other private schools in our area our school has identified nicotine as a large issue depression linked to school work and relationships and alcoholism that results from peer pressure with this data our school has been able to take action has spent singular days tackling each of these problems in the next year our school did better on each one of these single metrics so clearly being able

036to Simply hear these problems from from a community that historic hasn't seen them can show tangible results in my school when I feel like the case of the use of an optout policy to give more voice to the kids in Wake County would see the same problem being relieved in Wake County as well I've already seen the work of the youth risk survey in helping identify problems at the post Center which has presented to the North Carolina Department of Instruction and the data was immensely valuable in revealing Trends about sexual and mental health I know Wake County would benefit highly from getting an additional voice and it would be immensely helpful in bringing the problems facing my community to an end thank you thank you that concludes our student speakers agenda for tonight and so

037next we'll move to our uh on agenda speakers we have three speakers right now speaking to issues on tonight's agenda uh or allegedly so our first speaker is John bog will'll be followed by Michaela hanik good evening good evening how are you Happy New Year happy New Year and all that good stuff good evening board thank you for your time looking at the budget numbers you have a minimum $2.5 million deficit this does not include new Schools maintenance compensation or benefits one suggestion is to voluntarily request an audit when is the last time DPI Andor each County was audited I believe Dave bolc would do well to start an audit once in office on your website you mention a watershed moment graduation rate Rose 1.4% where are the numbers the total number of students and

038graduates for each year since uh we are paying 50% of our taxes into your budget we expect some fantastic results with students who are well educated and can perform at or above grade level congrats on your 91.4% graduation rate but but without the numbers there could be lower numbers of grads or students or hundreds or thousands not graduating so it would be helpful if we had more information on that when they do graduate students need to be ready for society College trade school or the Arts meta Microsoft door Dash CNN Walmart Zoom Toyota caterpillar Ford Nissan Molen Kors John Deere Lowe's McDonald's Tractor Supply Company Harley-Davidson Polaris Indian Motorcycle American Airlines UNCC Chapel Hill University of Florida MIT Idaho Board of Education have all closed their Dei programs they all need to this is a

039quote from the businesses focus on their business which is what we need to do here one by one we will bring sanity back to Corporate America they don't give a squat if their new employees are purple or green or think they are an eggplant they are all switching to a merit-based system imagine that it's time to focus on education in Wake County in addition you might find some missing dollars for your budget merit-based not numbers based I walked over 30 miles in school districts 356 and 8 I went door too and to people on the street 9 n out of 10 did not know about the poor grades the budget issues 2.2 billion budget in just Wake County TI title n passage which allows boys and girls bathrooms or lockers pornographic books in libraries in

040fact I was shouted at as being a liar even when I showed the information most of which was from the Wake County Public School System website yes the parents have spoken the election is over but the parents were not informed we will take this time to prepare for the next election in two years District 5 and six won by 21,000 oh thank you very much our next speaker is Michaela honik hanik who be follow who will be followed by Thomas Ray good evening good evening uh thank you all for giving me the opportunity to speak to you again my name is Michaela honik and I'm the tobacco prevention control coordinator for weake County and a member of the school health advisory Council I'd like to reiterate the importance the opt-in versus opt out consent for

041the use tobacco survey yts as well as the ybs or youth RIS Behavior survey the current opt out approach for these surveys ensures lower participation rates thereby making it difficult to determine to the extent which tobacco products such as Vapes and nicotine pouches are being used by our students putting all of our youth at risk collecting localized data will allow us to make the best decision for our students specific needs rather than relying on Statewide data that does not accurately reflect our County these surveys provide critical insights into the behaviors attitudes and Trends surrounding tobacco use among students in both County and the state our County's meaningful contribution of anonymous data will be able to help local and state departments and elected officials better support their communities additionally having more data will allow us to

042better understand how the money from the proposed plans for the jewel settlement will help us create a healthier student body as a reminder parents are still able to opt out their children from taking the survey and there are no repercussions for doing so there will be clear communication to families about the nature of the surveys what it aims to accomplish and how to opt out their child participation or non-participation will not affect the student's education an opt out policy for the yts and yrbs would increase participation provide more accurate data and enhance our ability to make informed decisions on how to best protect the health and well-being of our students this is about giving every student a voice and ensuring that our prevention efforts are as effective as possible thank you for your time thank

043you all right our final speaker on for on agenda items tonight will be Thomas Ray so full disclosure I wrote I thought that um I would be after the meeting so I'm going to still read it the way it is so good evening chair Hagerty superintendent Taylor and school board members um my name is Thomas Ray as a former Wake County Public School uh High School mathematics teacher in person at fway for eight years and then online with score for a few after that uh as the assoc associate executive director of the post Center for health education as a Wake County 4 Youth Development stem specialist using geographic information systems to empower youth with data and Technology to address community issues as a member of the community Equity leadership team as a father of four

044adult children and grandfather of three I want to in advance express my sincere gratitude for this bold move to update the permission policy for the Youth risk behavior surveillance in the youth tobacco survey I will not repeat the statistics that you have uh have already been so eloquently presented by the youth voices uh that you've heard in November again in December and then already this evening um I will not reiterate the excellent use cases for local data that have been shared over the last several months including from the Wake County sha uh school health advisory Council earlier in the year or last year I just want to say thank you thank you for your desire to hear the voices of young people of the voices of the young people of Wake County as they face

045unique challenges and provide unique perspectives your vote tonight ensures that you as school board members and the staff and Leadership of Wake County Public Schools will be informed to make datadriven decisions about the programs and priorities that affect our youth you will have the information you need over time to demonstrate accountability for the funding that you're responsible to Steward from tax dollars to Jewel settlements you will be able to track the impact of efforts and make adjustments as needed based on weighted local data our County Commissioners will have the data they need as they seek to make Wake County passionate proactive active and purposeful especially in the areas of lifelong learning inclusive Prosperity safer community community health and wellbeing the post Center for health education wake for Youth Development and other youth serving organizations that

046are focused on building the community infrastructure to support the resilience and well-being of our youth will have a realistic snapshot of how our Wake County young youth are Fairing and uh where to invest our best thinking and efforts to optimize outcomes with our Limited resour sources further organizations like the post Center others along with you Wake County government and many other nonprofits will have the local level data they need to compete for the resources that will benefit our students and families and communities I know you know all of this but I want to clearly state for our community and for Wake County Community uh the benefits and importance of this policy change and I'm once again grateful and optimistic for your vote tonight thank you thank you so that concludes our on agenda speak speakers

047we only have a couple off agenda speakers and with the board's uh discretion we'll push on all right thank you so the first speaker off agenda we have is Joseph Deon will'll be followed by Margaret Belo good while celebrating the record high graduation rate of 9 1% Dr Taylor rightly noted that we still have a long way to go especially for students of of color and lowincome families Dr Taylor reported that 64% of Wake County students achieved an overall score of grade level proficient glp or better on state standard tests but that means that 36% were not proficient this begs the question how we can go from 36% not being proficient on average through all grades to all of a sudden 91% uh graduating un unless you're just passing people along or allowing for doovers

048or simple makeup exercises furthermore 71% uh scored glp for high school English 2 but only 50% scored higher as college or career ready CCR for math level three 68% were glp while only 46% scored CCR the scores for math level one were dramatically worse uh so I infer that a large number of poorly performing students do not proceed on to level three but my main question is why are students considered proficient and why are they graduating if they are not either college or career ready graduation rate is the wrong metric to set goals on I I've seen this problem before when I worked in R&D one of the Dow 30 Industrials management would set various goals and then low and midlevel managers would pad their numbers in ways that were really not addressing the underlying

049problems a more meaningful goal here would be to get 91% to score college or career ready on state standard test as long as NCP ncdpi doesn't water them down don't complain about teaching to the test because we have to have an objective measure of what students have learned and where we need to improve the formula to improve math proficiency is simple you have to work more exercises there's no other way you don't need to spend $5 million on new math software uh thank you and good evening thank you our next speaker for our off agenda speakers tonight is Margaret Bido who will be followed by Becky L Hobs is Becky here tonight if Becky is not here then following Margaret will go to Christopher English all right welcome Margaret hello uh thank you for the

050opportunity to speak again tonight um uh my comments tonight are related to the upcoming conversations regarding updating the district cell phone policy um while I understand the desire to minimize distractions and create a Better Learning environment I believe an outright ban could have serious unintended consequences particularly when it comes to student safety and accountability school security cameras while valuable are not a complete solution students know how to avoid them and cameras don't record audio that missing context can be crucial in understanding incidents cell phones on the other hand have captured pivotal moments that cameras missed for example the cell phone footage of George Floyd's murder in 2020 showed the world in undeniable truth leading to accountability and a global conversation about racial Injustice in 2015 a student named Ahmed Muhammad was wrongfully arrested for bringing

051a homemade clock to school which was highlighted by documentation of students after the fact and exposed deep-seated biases while we've also seen incidents uh like something that happened in South Carolina where a resource officer violently threw a student in 2015 um or students capturing racially motivated bullying in California in 2021 these videos weren't just documentation they were proof that sparked change without cell phones these injustices might have gone unnoticed a blanket ban would take away an important tool for accountability leaving students more vulnerable additionally this policy risks creating a gray area for necessary Electronics many students rely on electronic devices for 504 and IEP accommodations as well as augmented communication tools to fully participate in their education a cell phone ban could inadvertently harm some of our most vulnerable students instead of a blanket ban

052I urge the board to consider an approach that empowers teachers let them guide and manage phone use in their classrooms based on their unique Dynamic and needs teachers are already balancing many responsibilities they know best when and how to set boundaries for their students in closing I'd just like to ask the board to Prior prioritize safety equity and fairness cell phones when used responsibly are not just distractions their tools for empowerment accountability and inclusion thank you thank you uh last call for Becky Lu hops if not we'll turn to Christopher English followed by Johnson Olive good evening all right so I gotta just first say the thing with the survey that they were all talking about I'm behind that and I'm also behind the cell phone thing that was also mentioned so you guys should

053listen to them uh but getting to the issue that brought me here today is again the 2020 uh 2025 2026 enrollment plan as it has significant negative ramifications uh for my community in Apex uh last time when I was standing here uh I really tried to argue against the approval of the 2026 uh or 2025 26 enrollment plan because I saw uh a few issues with the the data being presented uh for example uh I have a graph here I will email it all out later along with a long diet tribe that uh I typed up earlier today uh basically here is is what was presented to you for the enrollment at Bolan Road and Pleasant Plains uh there is a a difference between the uh capacities uh for uh the next year and the

054year after uh then if you listen to the audio during the working session miss mafy asked Susan pman about the PPE enrollment if it was to switch to a traditional calendar and she came back with other numbers uh that you know if you look to the 2027 calendar the difference between the two schools disappears even though the schools have the exact same capacity uh 924 students meaning that the traditional enrollment should also be similar she did not give a number for that in any of the data she presented so issues there's a huge issue there and I would also argue that after you guys approved the uh the plan you also approved an amendment for Bolan Road and that was to switch Bolan road which has a lower capacity than PPE to a traditional calendar

055rather than being on a yearround calendar meaning that PPE should also be allowed to be on a traditional calendar especially since the neighborhood at large has been arguing for a traditional calendar uh furthermore yearound calendar schools are are becoming a decreasing Trend across the country yearound schools also have poorer po poorer yearend performance when compared to uh traditional schools and I'll send a link in my email to reference that in conclusion I don't think we should continue with yearr round schools thank you Mr English thank you all right um our final speaker for tonight is Johnson Olive good evening Mr ol good evening members of the board first I want to thank the current students for speaking out tonight keep it up be bold don't be silenced you're very well heard um my name is

056johnon Olive I'm a Wake County resident uh and Native where I went to K through2 School graduating from Athens Drive go Jags um I'm also a Raleigh resident and homeowner um two months ago my husband Ryan hosel brought up a concerning problem student lunch debt and then we decided to start a GoFundMe because we figured that was the easiest way to start getting the word out um we feel very strongly about this issue that the most of the general public is unaware of he was unable to attend tonight because he works in the emergency departments um he emailed everyone on the school board as well as a Council to get as much information and Direction but the responses were minimal and that is why I'm here this evening uh one city council member did respond

057to us and she was unaware of this going on um I would like to thank is it Hager Hager I'd like to thank you uh for your most resp uh receptive response as well as is there I think there was a Mr Strickland Mr Strickland is on staff and works on these another another person who gave a very well receptive response um the third member who I'm not naming provided a brief show of appreciation followed by a very long misinformed and assumptive rant about my husband's children not attending public school and being in private school uh to respond to that member the children's mother teaches the at the private school that they attend and the logistics of transportation and child care benefit them best at the school tuition is PA by us out of pocket

058with no vouchers so to go back to what I was talking about so far in 5 weeks um we have received 114 donations totaling $3,370 over 80% of the donations have come from people who do not have children but pay taxes we are continuing to receive donations our donors want to give more and would like Direction on how to do so I am here tonight to open a discussion on how to make the largest impact with these funds with that said I appreciate you taking the time to hear some of the questions that I have because it's been a little unclear so far um we don't know what the current uh lunch debt amount is um with very limited information uh we have heard donate to donate uh to the angel fund or have to

059go to schools individually on and pay the entire amount on that specific day so I know that I'm running out of time here for every student to succeed proper and consistent nutrition is critical if a child can't pay for lunch they're most likely facing insecurity at home these students already have unnecessary struggles allowing this to compound be compounded Mr Olive that is your time sorry that's quite all right and you can always follow up with us online for additional comments what what's the best way to do that um email and then I get I think M Chief Lisa Luton here is our chief of communications and she can assist you too all right so that concludes our public comment period um at this point we'll turn over to our board comments uh starting with superintendent

060Dr Robert Taylor thank you Mr chair uh and first of all I'd like to say good evening and happy New Year to everyone I can tell you that uh a superintendent I'm certainly excited excited about what the 2025 school year will mean for us as the district and I do hope that our community is is excited as well about the potentials that we have for this school year uh I just have a few brief announcements and updates for you tonight uh first January is National mentoring month an annual campaign that highlights the importance of mentorship and celebrates all those who give their time and talents to support our young people research has confirmed that the mentor mentee relationship has a positive impact on everyone involved mentec improve academic social and economic prospects while mentors build

061leadership management skills uh as they impart their wisdom and experience in our school district we are extremely fortunate to have thousands of parents and other caring community members who regularly volunteer to help our students grow uh but there's always room for more uh everyone in education knows the truth of the old saying that it takes a village to raise a child so we are always looking to increase our engagement with trusted community members to those who are already serving as mentors I thank you and I ask that you continue to provide that support for our students to those who are interested in sharing their knowledge and counsel with our students I encourage you to contact your child's principal or visit uh wcpss.net volunteer here to learn uh how you can get involved we certainly encourage

062and hope you um work with us as mentors next I'd like to congratulate this year's finalist for the Wake County school library media coordinator of the year uh the finalists are Ashley Clark of Scott Scott Ridge Elementary Kristen Ziller of Pine Hollow Middle and Chris Howell of East Wake itch and design Magnet High School all of our media coordinators play an important role in making sure the materials available are up to dat relevant and support enhanced academic achievement each of these finalists has demonstrated exceptional dedication and innovation in managing the school library promoting literacy integrating technology into learning and creating an engaging space for students to access important uh information and resources the winner will be announced at the celebration of teaching Excellence on March 26th my congratulations and thanks to all of these finalists

063uh in closing I'd like to extend an invitation to our 2025 state of the schools event uh which will be held on Monday February 6th uh February 26th at 6: pm at Southeast Raleigh magnet Magnet High School this will be an opportunity for our community to gather and learn more about our many successes as well as how we intend to build on those uh we do indeed have much to celebrate even as we acknowledge the ongoing work that will be necessary to reach the goal set forth in our strategic plan I can tell you as superintendent I'm always open to hearing responses about the work that we need to do to improve um we know that as a public school there are resources that we need to continue to do this work uh but we

064are certainly proud as the district in terms of where we are with student achievement uh one of the goals that I would do is to certainly make sure we work with our community to know and understand the difference between uh proficiency growth and all of those things things go into identifying when students are career in college ready and how that um parlays into what we call a graduation rate uh I encourage people to understand that a graduation rate is about the minimum preparation that a student has and they have met those requirements but we have so many more students that exceed what are the minimum requirements and so it's certainly our responsibility as a community uh to know and understand what that means and our task as Administration is to make sure we make that

065known our hope is that um My Hope Is that you attend our state of the schools address well I will talk about the successes that we have as a district as well as the growth and support that we need as a community uh and so with that Mr chair I will uh turn it back to you thank you superintendent Taylor um I want to thank everyone on the board for coming out and giving your full participation for our board retreat I thought we had many wonderful ideas some great discussion I got to dive into some issues um a little deeply than we usually do and explore some topics and get some good discussion around them um Dr Taylor Vice chair Swanson and I are working on several items as follow-ups based on your input and

066we'll be bringing some of those to to you at the work session at our next meeting so uh again thank everybody for coming in um and and really participating and um re really making the most out of the event um I also want to share I guess that we had the memorial service for a friend of mine this past weekend I've mentioned before WEA Watson who's come out to speak to us and just I've received I don't want to un I don't want to dwell unnecessarily on on on one person's passing when we have so many people who contribute so much to our community but I do do want to just share that even today I was receiving emails from people who were motivated to come out to the meetings based on weed's urgings you

067know they may not speak they may not stand up but they wanted to be here and they wanted to be present and you know either show support for what they believed in or you know show their opposition to things that they didn't agree with and and that really is the impact that one person can have and and you know through her Memorial and and planning it out she encouraged all of us to act justly to show mercy and to walk humbly according to our faith and I think that's good advice for all of us whether we're on the board or just general citizens so you know I will miss weda um but I just wanted to share that just even in her passing she's still motivating people you know even if they agreed with her

068and if they didn't agree with her she still gave them cookies that she hand baked and brought to these meetings and we will miss her um I'm going to do something a little bit different and I do want to address a couple things that were raised tonight at some meetings um in some of the comments at the meetings um I do know that Chief Luton is working with Mr Olive and I know that school lunch debt is something that many on on the board have raised as a priority and you I know we've worked to address this with our um our Angel fund but lunch de is different than you know having the funds available and I want everyone to know who may or may not be involved and Mr ol is still here I've

069been working also with our chief of staff Dr Clinton Robinson and we're trying to find a way to make this work it's not really a yes or no but how do we because working specifically with GoFundMe there are certain legal obstacles and there are certain things about Student Records in terms of the Privacy each student has about their debt to be able to share certain things we obviously know that many families would want accept this help but we just have to go through the procedure of how to do it but please know that your gesture is certainly welcomed and I think embraced by everyone up here um I know he has left but Dr English who's raised the questions about reassignment you know um I want to be clear for anyone who has questions about

070this that the concerns raised by Dr English that he shared with us again today again very civy and and and here in this public comment period as per his right were concerns that we brought two staff to miss pum and Mr cor Roa and who explained why according to their data Mr English had reached the wrong conclusions and misinterpreted the numbers that they had presented you know we don't want anyone to feel that they're not being list listened to but at the same time when there are honest disagreements you know we we have to stand by our data and the decision that we made and so I would like to invite him if he's willing to sit down for discussion with the staff to be able to again any board member who is interested if

071we have more than five of us it's a quorum so it' have to be a public meeting but anyone who is interested to review the data and just make sure that everyone understands it and if there are concerns that exist we can address those as a board but I think as you've seen in all of the documents that were shared with us during the reassignment plan and I hope that guided your votes a lot of these concerns were looked at researched and you know Miss Miss po and Mr carosa shared you know their opinion that that everything was valid moving forward and I'm I'm happy to have a meeting where he can sit down address those concerns with staff and with any of you to hear how those were resolved and if you still think

072there's an issue we can bring that up at a future meeting but but but the the this is something we have taken very seriously um the question raised about the audit I I have to you know I I really respect everyone's opinion and the First Amendment rights to come up here and speak you know speak their truth and speak their concerns and their opinions but there's just some basic information that we've repeated over and over and over again if you ask when the last time Wake County received an audit all of you on the board were present when all of the data was presented it was October 26 2023 and before that October of 2022 and before that October of 2021 and before that October of 2020 and before that October of 2019 before that

073I wasn't on this board but I will tell you that every year we have a full professional independent audit done of this District's spending and its Financial Accounting not only that we go above and beyond and we have an independent audit committee made up of members of the community that are brought in with financial expertise to ensure that there's no thumbs on the scale that everything is being done and conducted the way that it should be and beyond that the board I know is aware but the public might not be this District continues year after year to receive National recognition for its transparency and its professionalism in accounting so you can disagree with how funds are spent You can disagree with policies and program s but if you're going to state that our books are

074un audited that is verifiably false if you're going to accuse the District of mismanagement that is verifiably false and again people that do this professionally around the country provide us commendations and accolades for the job that we do so when you imply that there's something nefarious something there's mismanagement or fraud I'm going to take issue with that and I'm going to call you on that I am fine if you disagree with how funds are spent but they are being spent legally accurately and according to the law finally the questions about proficiency this is a conversation that I I think we need to have and you heard Dr Taylor talk about it because how we judge Student Success and how we judge proficiency is measured by many different measuring sticks but it's important to realize what

075these sticks are and what they mean for actual student Readiness College and Career preparedness we look for measurements we look for standardized tests so that we have some accountability and what we'll say is like a standard of measurement but these tests are one test given on one particular day in a student's academic career they do not accurately measure everything that we do in our classrooms day after day to prepare our students for college and it is a reasonable question to ask why can these test scores show numbers that you might find unacceptable regarding proficiency and then yet you turn around and you see High graduation rates but it's important to look beyond that that not only do we have High graduation rates we have high levels of acceptance in the finest colleges and universities around

076the country the Wake County Public School students are not just getting accepted and admitting to our military acmy to our universities State and private outof State institutions recruit Wake County heavily for their students but then what those students go on to do successfully and these are difficult metrics to track but this is something that the North Carolina Department of Public Instruction has been working on to track students postgraduate ation from high school to see what they are doing in terms of do they go to college do they go to the military do they go into work and then do they have success in those fields and again they're only beginning to capture and collect that data but so far we County students are at the top of that list so I'm not as you know

077as Dr Taylor has said we can do better we must do better we have an obligation to every student that every student should do better and every student should have that success but let's have the conversation and let's have a whole conversation about all the factors that measure Student Success and while individual test scores do need to write do need to rise remember again that is one factor of many factors that determine Student Success and we can be judged on those test scores but we should be judged on more than just those test scores and so with that I will conclude my comments and I will turn it over to Vice chair Swanson thank you so much chair hegerty and uh Happy New Year to everyone and I hope everyone had a very well rested

078winter break whether you celebrate Christ Christmas Hanukkah or Quanza hopefully you and your family had a safe and restful Break um thank you chair herty for laying all that out I also want to thank you for uh bringing back the budget committee because it seems as if we need to have a little bit of 101s and you kick the year off offer not only a financial 101 but some academic 101 as well so thank you um and I also my remarks going to be very brief I also want to thank Miss Honeycut for joining District 99's BAC meeting last month um and the Apex High School Community for hosting us um as we talked about our very robust CTE program that is also very award-winning and has very high rates of of completion so we

079are doing great things and I look forward those great things that will continue and and uh the year ahead of us of the great work that we will do and um I would be remiss if I didn't say that uh January is also na um national school board members uh appreciation month and so to the 115 uh school districts in North Carolina and across the the state and Country I think they're all feeling the same thing that we're feeling and I often joke and saying that we're a part of a b613 for those who don't reference Scandal I'm still a big Scandal fan um but the work that we do daily does impact communities and the work and and whatnot so I also want to thank the students who have shown up uh time after

080time to advocate for this great change and you know um as the the Community member had had said before your voice is important you all are the future the generation of now and tomorrow and do not ever allow anyone to try to silence your voice take your place you all's voices are very important I look forward to the great things not only that you all are going to do but students across when you all step into your power and no longer accept things as it is and so thank you for advocating for yourselves and for the students who may not know that you all are advocating for them thank you so much and to um um Mr oliv I also want to thank you for taking on this initiative as well for advocating for students

081who who who may not have the needs or the funds and so I want to thank you for standing in that Gap and seeing an issue and trying to get into some good trouble to make sure that our students have what they need to be successful not just academically but as an entire person as well so thank you um and that concludes my remarks so thank you Mr chair thank you thank you Vice chair Swanson uh those who have attended the meetings might have known a little bit of musical chairs um we have reordered uh the order of the table with uh our former Vice chair uh Monika Johnson Hustler's vacancy so we will have a new member in District 2 joining us who will be seated next to Mr Hershey but in celebration of

082our new alignment we'll go to miss mafy who now sits on this side of the table all right thank you chair Hagerty and uh thank you for the reminder that I am uh excited to be the uh new chair of the student achievement committee um and so following Vice chair Swanson's footsteps but he won't be far he's going to be the vice chair of the committee so um and then that is where you can see a lot of conversations about academic performance in Wake County Public Schools um both our glows and grows as they call them um happy New Year I want to you know to our students that are here speaking out um thank you for sharing your voices thank you for being here on a school night [Music] um we have already pass

083approve this on first reading so tonight is the formal second reading so you won't hear a specific Vote for This policy it will be a part of our consent agenda so if because I I don't want to say it's but if the consent agenda is passed that means the policy that you're advocating for has passed been approved and is now a part of the Wake County Public School Systems policy so if you're looking for it that's when you're going to hear it it's not going to call out the policy specifically but thank you for coming and lending your voice and I just don't want you to feel like oh my gosh I missed everything because you didn't it's there it's just tucked in in the consent item so when you hear that vote that's will

084include your policy so and that's all thank you Miss mafy Miss Coffield thank you um I hope you all had a merry Christmas happy holidays and are having a good start to the New Year may we all find many blessings in 2025 it is time for reflecting and new beginnings and right before the break the board went we met for a two-day Retreat where we discussed some of the focuses that we want to have going forward for this new year I was happy that some of our school board members here joined me in a collaborative effort along with the surrounding counties to implore our legislators specifically for higher teacher pay I know there are several things that we would like to advocate for on behalf of our classrooms this is a joint ask letter ask

085that asks for our teachers to be bummed to a new starting salary of $50,000 and all teachers to receive the same increase in Pay proportionally whe county is the 15th largest in the nation but we are at 38 in teacher pay sorry it is valued uh they are valued in a very important role not only for our children but teacher shape education and how our community will look they deserve to be closer to the national average here in North Carolina one of the largest school districts while this is only one way that we could show our teachers support I hope our legislators will hear our plea and support our teachers and students at the classroom level with the supports that are needed especially with our growing Community needs and the variety of needs from our

086children and our teachers I'll still work on advocating for our other needs that for our teachers and our students but this would be a great start I hope that everybody has a that 2025 proves to be a very productive year that's all I have thank you Miss carfield Miss rice good evening everybody good evening tonight I want to say happy New Year um and tonight I have only three comments so I'm going to be quick okay all right District 4 um next BAC meeting will be on Monday February 3rd at Hunter Magnet Elementary School with a topic balance with the topic of balancing technology and focus rethinking cell phone policies in schools um I'm also so excited um to be the new chair of the community engagement uh committee following the footsteps of the former

087Miss um Vice chair Miss Johnson Hustler I really enjoyed her swearing in ceremony on Friday um and being a part of Team Hustler um and then for our eight Dimensions of Wellness tip today we're going to focus on physical wellness because I've been going through quite a bit of physical wellness um and Recovery over the holiday season so these tips will focus on our winter months I want to encourage you to do activities to promote um movement such as stretching yoga or dance and indoor spaces for students and staff brief movement breaks during the day can boost circulation and energy community members can organize group fitness classes at local community centers for engaging in Virtual workouts to stay active even when it's cold outside the second tip is hydration and nourishment winter often reduces the

088the sensation of thirst but staying hydrated is essential drink water herbal teas and warm broths I've been doing a whole lot of that lately um balance this with nutrition-rich meals including seasonal vegetables like sweet potatoes carrots kale and I have to add in Collard Greens all right um and schooling community centers can often can offer winter nutrition workshops or healthy meal initiatives to promote these habits so that you can have what a positive and productive day thanks everyone between between you and my wife trying to get me to eat those collards they're good they're good luck for New Year's though that's right kale is not the only thing out there they're collate greens and mustard greens for those of us who are cultural who offer the same nutritional values that's right thank you Miss rice

089we'll come back around Miss Edmonds are you ready thank you thank you um I actually didn't have any prepared comments but I wanted to piggyback on your comments um chair Hagerty first of all thank you so much for addressing those issues um I think 2025 needs to be a year about telling the truth and putting accurate information out so I really appreciate what you said I wanted to add that um we just had the 2024 audit presented to us on November 26th by the audit committee um Mr cobal was here and Miss B bham Patterson was here at our work session on November 26th and the last thing that I will add is that all of those are public record that's a little bit of information that I'd like to add to your comments um

090anyone in the public can access those Audits and read them in full and they're available on our website and if people need help finding them I'm sure our staff is more than happy to help you thanks thank you Miss Edmond Dr Ring um hi good evening happy New Year and um I hope that everybody had a restful uh holiday and um that you're refreshed and ready to tackle the challenges of the new year um before the winter break I had the honor of being a judge at um Northway College and Career Academy for their um polit uh government and uh AP government and political assign class and um thank you for uh the teacher Miss uh Stacy Arch and principal Hutchinson for inviting me and I was able to listen in on the students um

091ideas for their political action plan presentation it was um I'm I can tell that they did a lot of research and they knew a lot about their topic and they were ready with a lot of answers anytime I ask him the questions um but I didn't give them too much of a hard time um um and you know I I was really impressed with their um depth of their knowledge um and I was able to give them some insight into kind of real life politics uh especially at the state in local level um and I was also able to tell them kind a little bit about the real world um medical uh uh healthc care um scene um uh and and because uh one of the presentation was about um health care and advocacy to

092the center for Medicare Medicaid um so um I I you know it was kind of touched on a lot of uh things that I'm um have some opinions on so um and then uh just today we had our uh discussion at the work session in uh regarding cell phones and um last uh work session before the break we also had uh touched upon some issues with with regard to artificial intelligence and um you know we're starting the conversation now um but really the conversation should be um done in the in the home you know with uh your families and with the community um we really need to all be looking at how we use our technology and you know do we have command over the technology and harnessing its vast potential or are we going

093to be controlled by it or molded by by it um and for sure you know children are kind of at the Crosshair um and um I've been reading this book by Jonathan height the anxious generation and the opening chapter um the author asked the question to the parents you know would you allow your children to travel to Mars knowing that the effects of lower gravity and exposure to Cosmic radiation would most likely have permanent effects on them and what if your children were going to Mars without your knowledge or permission or not really understanding the full effects the the the of the um the trip uh into outer space um and so basically his point is if if we're going to be using this technology for good um we also need to understand how it's

094may have impact on our children and the rewiring of our minds and the rewiring of our CH childhood and um you know the you know his his jump in his conclusion was uh that there is also some concern about it causing an epidemic of mental illness um so I'm I'm still in the middle of reading it I'm going to be continue on reading it um and I would invite everyone listening to do your own research um do your uh readings um look at the topic and decide for yourself where you stand um the board of course will be um you know considering the policies in the upcoming months um but really I urge parents to take charge of the issue because it will impact your children far beyond the boundaries of the school um so

095you know we can only control what we what happens in the school but you as parents have control over what happens at home and what happens at you know with your children's access to and use of um cell phones and other Technologies so that's all I have to say thank you thank you Dr in and we will conclude with Mr Hershey uh I'll be super brief um as we talk about the cell phone policy I want to encourage people watching this to send us your thoughts uh and opinions on what we should do regarding that policy um you don't have to wait for a survey you can email all of us anytime and after that I am not going to stand in the way of what these students came here for I just want to

096say that when people try to Define students as a grade or a test they are so off Bas and it's clear that they do not interact with Wake County Public School students we get the privilege to do it when we are invited to uh I know uh students at milbrook high school and Dr uh Dr wings uh Dr in sorry I can't even speak Dr in uh District they emailed both of us because I'm right there on the border and um I was a part of a couple of projects and interviews and these are incredibly thoughtful people and not once did I think I wonder what their grade point average is or I wonder what they scored on a test and and we have to stop defining students as a as a piece of dat

097a piece of data they are thoughtful um amazing human beings who are so much more than that and I will leave it at that and I am I am going to be proud to support what you all came here to speak about and well done with all of your speeches and with that we conclude our board and superintendent comment phase thank you so the next item on our agenda is consideration of our consent agenda reference approve by Miss second and now motion or you know U moved for adoption by Miss mafy I heard a second from Vice chair Swanson is there any discussion or any debate if not I'll take a vote on adoption of the items on the consent agenda all in favor say I I any opposed all right all of the items

098on the consent agenda have been adopted congratulations all right so now we'll proceed to our action agenda um we have a couple items on here tonight the first of which uh again goes to our uh employees and the chief of schools area first we'll talk about long range capping recommendations and then the magnet school assistant Grant so I see Miss Rory here um we have you or Mr car Roa presenting good evening thank you for allowing us some time to bring forward the uh longrange capping recommendations for the 2024 25 school year staff presented the 2024-25 capping recommendations to the board of education at the December 3rd 2024 work session the capping recommendations would be for the remainder of this school year and into the 2526 school year staff recommends that we maintain all current

099School caps staff also recommends that we change the Overflow school for beaverdam Elementary from night Del Elementary to Forestville Elementary staff's recommendations are based on several factors that include principal feedback a review of the base student population excuse me percentages projected growth and school capacities St staff will continue to carefully monitor the impact on overflow schools and this evening we are asking for an approval vote of those recommendations and we are scheduled to meet with all current C and overflow School principles data managers Etc tomorrow thank you thank you Mr Rory and so uh board members you do have in assembly a presentation that accompanied that so if you review the presentation uh you will see it aligns perfectly with Miss Roy's comments but uh for any questions you can see again the definitions of

100Capp schools overflow schools crowding schools crowding management uh what the enrollment cap considerations are and specifically that list of cap schools so this is one of those documents that you might want to say for future reference as it something you can come back to and refer to throughout the year all right chair Hagerty I make a motion that we adopt the um capping recommendations presented by Miss Rory we have a motion from Miss mafy and a second from Vice chair Swanson uh to adopt the 2024 2025 capping recommendations are there any questions for Miss Rory or any discussion again this is I'll just say one of the tools that we use to try to manage growth in the county and for some people capping is very unpopular and for other people they would like to

101see more capping because when we have schools that are overc capacity and we can't put more students in those schools we either have to cap them and send the new new new arriving residents further away and they wonder why they can't go to the school closest to them or when we reassign you have families that might have lived there a long long time that wonder why they have to go to a new school so you know I know there's not necessarily love of capping but it is one of the tools that we have that makes all of this possible as we continue to try to build new schools and manage our District's growth so with no other questions or no comments we'll move to an immediate vote all in favor of the 2024 25 capping

102recommendations please signify by saying I I any opposed all right thank you Miss Rory thank you all so then next we will turn is Dr Lane here if Dr Lane is not here will Mr Cora because he knows he would be the one to present if she is not found go ahead Miss Evans Mr chair are we out of order if we move to the district 2 vacancy update while we wait for Dr Lane or um we would technically have to move items on on on the agenda um I believe Mr CA is ready and available to present and it's just a race between whether he gets up to the podium or I can get the hold music on my phone ready to play well I apologize I don't have a copy of the PES

103in front of me it's quite all right um this is the item uh Magnet School assistance prog Grant Elevate project evaluation contract staff is requesting Contra contract approval for the mettis associates the contract provides for mettis associates an outside Grant evaluator to visit the five msap Elevate schools Wendel Magnet Elementary Wendel Magnet Middle Zebulon Magnet Elementary Zebulon Magnet middle and East Wake Magnet High to determine Baseline data for the 5-year ma or msap of EV valuation required by the US Department of Education while it lasts the contract provides evaluation data to ensure that wcpss is utilizing funds and working to meet performance measures as outlined in the 2023 msap application approved and funded by uh Ed and Ed again is use Department of Education funding is included in the msap Elevate Federal grant budget PRC

104398 for the period of October 23 to September of 2028 a 5-year Grant fiscal implications the contract amount is up to $430,000 over 5 years of the grant years 1 and three equal 70,000 per year years four and five equal 110,000 annually so Mr Cora with that uh background information is there anything to present or could you explain the item before the board so this is um a group that works to help uh implement the Grant and so there's a lot of work behind the scenes that goes to keeping up with the grant to make sure that we're in compliance and so we hire an additional company to support us in that process thank you Glenn could you also share if that is a requirement of the grant that it be evaluated yes it is

105thank you so in order to receive the grant funds this is a compliance requirement yes all right with that Miss rice so so it's also to be said we're continuing to be transparent and authentic around making sure we're following um guidelines around budgeting right that is a astute observation Miss Russ chair hery I make a motion we approve the uh msap Elevate project evaluation contract we have a motion from Miss mfy for uh approval of the contract in the amount requested we have a second from Vice chair Swanson all in favor of approval of the contract amount please signify by saying I I any opposed all right approval for the contract has been granted flexibility too all right thank you so now we turn to the last item on our action agenda uh the district

1062 board member vacancy all right and so I will need a minute to pull everything up but um let me ask have all board members been able to check email and receive the update uh updated information from Miss Melissa Allen okay so then for for everyone's benefit you know that we present we put forward a timeline for how we would and requirements for how we would fill the district 2 vacancy um the deadline for applications was yesterday and we received we have eight total candidates that appear to live within District 2 although one did not submit all the information set forth in the announcement one was missing letters of recommendation so so the candidates or I'm sorry the applicants for the district 2 vacancy and I apologize if I mispronounce any of these names are

107Alexandra Alcantara caroleta Daniels Christina Gordon dilon Fletcher Dr Brady Coker Cara gensor fadus Sherman and and uh Josh McGee although Mr McGee was missing the letters of recommendation that were requested so at this point if you look in assembly you should see the timeline that we had previously approved um for going forward with the vacancy for the benefit of people in the audience or people at home um our job today is to confirm an interview schedule for these seven or eight candidates um currently we had our our plan was to conduct interviews on Tuesday January 14th and so then one item to consider is whether or not you feel that we have enough time to complete all the interviews on that date and if not if we would add an interview date and if so

108when we would do that um so if an alternative date is needed or if we need to set an alternative date for any possible weather related issues we can do that tonight and then finally we're scheduled for a swearing in ceremony for the candidates selected either on January 14th or after the conclusion of any additional interviews uh that would be Tuesday February 4th Miss mafy thank you chair Hagerty um I believe as we were discussing this in December we talked about uh candidates that didn't submit a full profile and so um I would submit that we since we have eight candidates seven with a full profile that we um interview the seven folks that have fully submitted their application um and that is 5 hours and 15 minutes of interviewing if we stick to the

10945 minute interview schedule for those seven candidates and that would be similar to some past interviews we've done can I take that suggest question as a motion you may is there a second from Miss mf's motion second I have a second from Miss Edmonds is there any discussion that we would go forward with the seven candidates who submitted all of the required information um and go forward on that interview schedule that would all be on the 14th that would be my suggestion but I understand that people have different calendars and 5 hours and 15 minutes uh plus time for setting the meeting is then long meeting and lunch then let's just take the first motion on the seven okay so we'll do that first um Miss Edmond just wanted to support Miss maf's point about

110um the seven candidates uh I think we were very clear on the expectation of what was to be submitted um so I'm supporting the interview of seven okay any further comments yeah I was I had the same thing I had to um do a side bar question to ask the very same thing um considering being the last last person on the board who just went through that process um I think it's important to have everything that's asked in the pr in the backage and I think there's something special about the people who had to go through that process than you I'm just saying all right thank you all right so if there's no further discussion we'll take a vote on Miss maf's motion to interview the seven applicants that provided all of the required information

111all in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I any opposed all right so we have the list of seven candidates and so then the next question would be to uh set an interview schedule um again we have um Miss mafy had calculated the amount of time it would take if we uh proceeded as we have in the past that no break time or lunch in between okay six hours six a half okay Vice chair Swanson so Mr chair I would propose that we go through with just one day um I think if we went multiple days it would it convolute the process and we may not be able to give that applicant AFF Fair um it may not be fair to that person to try to remember various candidates so I'm going

112to recommend that we um start if that's a 11 o' or 12:00 start um I think it was similar to the past if I'm not mistaken with District 4 we started around 11 is I'm looking at Miss alen and she's um around 11:00ish I think we were scheduled to go to 6 that evening um so that would be my recommendation I can put that in a motion if need um Miss subm then Dr gr thank you um I agree with the one day um on January 14th however I do think it would be wise for us to choose an alternate date for weather I think that's wise okay um how about I'll just make a suggestion that um we go ahead and try to decide the meeting date first and then the times and then

113we can look ahead to the calendars and those of you who don't care about the meeting dates you can go ahead and check calendars for alternative dates right now just in case there is a weather issue uh Miss C oh sorry dring and then miss Coffield um yeah so um just wanted to remind everyone that uh East milbrook Middle School has a 50th Anniversary that night uh at 6:30 so I'm planning to attend so I just want to make sure that you know in setting the time that we have not only time for the interviews but then time for deliberation and vote right in order to get you there right I I think that's a reasonable request Miss Coffield that's what I was I was going to raise the same thing so that's it all

114right two reasonable requests all right then um I was trying to look back it might take a minute [Music] um chair I don't think we've ever had seven applicants yeah correct we've had six but not seven so let's see looking back it looks like that meeting was on um February 13th of 2024 and we did start at 12:00 so also thinking in you know the availability to get lunch and then to get through the whole process what is your thinking Vice chair Swanson so to honor Dr in request I wonder would a 10:00 start be doable um or even not yeah either I I'll propose n or 10 whichever yeah let's let's keep it right now just an open discussion and then we'll have the motion we sort of see what where people yeah I

115think that's I think that's that's very reasonable Miss rice um I do recall that one of the candidates last time did not attend which made the meeting shorter so take that in consideration if it seemed like it went a little faster and then is it possible that um there may not be and is without breaks I think you're saying Miss mcfey oh no with with like a break with a break but maybe not have a break as long a lunch break cuz if it's a six and 1 half hour meeting we'll need to eat State need to eat yeah I'm not saying we need a a European lunch Miss rice I like the two-hour life right but yeah those those are the only considerations that maybe we not take I'm going to readjust my schedule

116to make this happen but those are my suggestions okay so what I'm hearing is either a 9 or a 10:00 start Miss mafy I'm early bird um I I would wonder if we want to leave it flexible until you and and vice chair Swanson speak with Miss Allen who will have to set up uh this Arrangement and see how much time she needs in the morning but I think if the board is amable to for that flexibility she um yeah she oh yes I love you Miss alen yes sorry I wasn't trying to like look over your shoulder but I was no I I figured I knew what you were doing but um so I think in because we have seven candidates and you know they all have a varying degree of excellent qualifications um

117I would propose the 9:00 because that way we don't have to worry about Dr in sweating at like 5:30 or maybe I don't know it might take that long but we'll try to give you a buffer well yeah it's it's it's the it's the 9:00 and just to teach it like a workday 9 to 5 we're done I mean but a short a short of 30 minute break um if you think about it if we start at 9: it's a it's a regular business day Vice chair Swanson and then anyone over here I just wanted to follow up that that would not include deliberation and the vote um so I just want to make sure we had enough time to give each candidate the time and the discussion they deserve 8 o' well I tried

118yeah I tried to so the 5 hour 15 minutes is everybody gets 45 minutes I tried to bump in the half hour for lunch and then an additional hour for so maybe optimistic deliberation but who knows so my cating that so I do have another suggestion that could impact that depending on what you all think in the past and and using the time frame that Miss mfi has used that was if you remember the district for vacancy we asked each each applicant 10 questions that eight of us if we reduce that to eight questions then everyone asks a question and maybe we cut off a little bit of time and therefore could shorten the process and that's right not everyone uses that that's what I was going to remind you is it seemed to me

119that you were really only using about 30 minutes and then we were sitting around for 15 of the 45 minutes and then the other 15 minutes in between so I I think you can short shorten the interview time mhm and cut a lot of time out of the day it just my memory anyway so what do you all think about that if if we if we reduce it to eight questions understand that we will have time we won't necessarily have to build in breaks if everyone's not using that 45 minutes we have a built-in break but maybe it doesn't have to be as long we might be able to compress it a little better starting at 9: and then um we'll work with Miss Allen to schedule candidates accordingly with the goal of getting out

120of here by 5: PM yeah and Miss Coffield said we would be out potentially by like 3 3:30 so which I do not have a problem with all right so if that if if that sounds acceptable to everybody we'll put that in the form of a motion that we will have our uh special called meeting a special called meeting of the Wake County Board of Education beginning at 900 a.m. on Tuesday January 14th for the purpose of interviewing and selecting or interviewing applicants and selecting a replacement for the District Two board member so moved we have a motion for Mr Swanson second for Miss mafy all in favor of that schedule please signify by saying I I any opposed all right now the the the tricky part you know looking for an alternative date say

121there is an issue with weather or something like that um it's a little bit tricky because normally we would have had committee meetings that day we've moved committee meetings to Wednesday and then I don't know about the rest of you and your schedules the rest of that week the 15th and the 16th if um you know technically we do have the following week after that we have a board meeting on the 21st that will have a full en active agenda but we have other days that week as well um I will tell you that I will be traveling for work um on the 16th and 17th and I won't be available um but you know I know that while we'd like to have everybody it may or may not be possible so what are your

122thoughts looking at your own at your own availability for alternative dates Mr Hershey C can we cross this bridge if we need to next week because I'm looking at the weather the weather looks fine the 7 eight day forecast we could spend 35 minutes here trying to figure out another day and we may not need it at all I do hear you but I did want to give people enough notice right so it's not next week and then we're trying to find a date that might have been free today but between now and then we scheduled it um tell I tell you what I I hear your point will you humor me with just giving us five minutes all right so with just five minutes looking along can we just go through board member by

123board member and just if you can identify any conflicts or availability between now and um February the 4th um it'll give us an idea and I think Miss Allen might be providing some additional information as well concerning committee meetings and other scheduled meetings um I'll read what's been shared right now we have the special called meeting scheduled for the 14th on the 15th we have an executive an executive meeting at 11:30 Community engagement at 1 p.m. and facilities at 300 p.m. on the 16th uh we have several schools with midyear graduations we also have you know potential afternoon uh due process hearings nothing currently scheduled on the 17th uh the 20th as you know is a holiday on the 21st we've scheduled our student achievement meeting we have the board work session board meeting and

124midyear graduations for some schools midyear graduations on the 22nd and 23rd again most of those are going to be I think evening hours some May schedule some during the day um we have a morning due process hearing on the 23rd but then nothing scheduled on the 24th so potentially it looks like unless there's a midyear graduation conflict uh Wednesday the 22nd um or again I'll be out of town but Thursday the 16th may be the best days according to the school calendar but I don't know about your individual work or family calendars anyone have any dates that are out I have a lot of dates that are out but I can share what's available which puts us for me um Wednesday the 22nd still as well okay Miss Coffield do you have any um so

125you cannot do the 16th I can figure out something to make it work unless he's not avilable 16th and 17th I can do the 22nd as well okay Miss mafy what about you I hav't it's going to involve some phone calls but can make the 22nd work as well as the 24th okay thank you I appreciate that Mr Swanson uh the 22nd or 24th preferably the 24th would be better okay I can do 24th you can do the 24th as well okay what about you miss Coffield I may not be here okay okay just excuse me from my students at Wilburn Elementary for reading to you that morning I do apologize well what you can do is you can find whoever's selected for district 2 and then bring them with you for the makeup twice

126as much reading uh Mr Hershey you said you were good both days 22nd thank you I appreciate that dedication um Dr ining um I I Friday is better Friday is better okay and Miss Edmonds I can do the 22nd and the 24th but I'm wondering is the 13th Monday the 13th is that not an option the day before I don't have a preference I'm just asking the question it's it's available I think the thought was that we would only use the alternate date if we knew the 14th would not be available um I know with some of the weather that's expected they've been talking about it Friday and Saturday um with more clear weather later so any residual might be a little worse on the 13th but it is an open date okay all right

127so what we'll do is you know based on this it sounds like either the 22nd or the 24th some of us have conflicts on one day some of us conflicts on the other um might be the day for the potential um alternate day so let's just state today in the public meeting that if we cannot interview everybody on Tuesday the 14th on the 14th we will select one of those two days based on everyone's input for the 22nd 24th that way we give everybody notice and we ask that you hold that availability if it is available but we won't select it until we know we actually need it sound like a plan all right great yes any questions oh the candidate questions and so I had asked at the last meeting for folks to go

128back if you had access to look at the questions we had asked um I know we threw a new wrinkle into that tonight by talking about reducing it um from 10 to 8 um Mr Swanson did you have specific so I went back and review well had access I think we still all have access from the old Google doc yes which I think I put those comments in in February of 2024 yes so I just wanted to stand by those recommendations or suggestions for questions if folks had opportunity to look at them and give input I appreciate that Miss mafy um chair herty I am I trust you and vice chair Swanson can Swanson can condense those 10 questions into eight and um I'm okay with those changes because I think the spirit of the

129questions will continue and if everyone is happy with that then what we can do is vice chair Swanson and I will work with Dr Taylor to approve a final question list this Friday and we'll get that out to everyone so that you'll have that in advance okay all right are there any other questions related to The District 2 vacancy and then just the last thing I'll remind you as we've talked about before we want to ensure that this is an open but a fair process so I would encourage all of you to refrain from discussing the vacancy with any of the candidates that have been named if anyone has a question about it about meeting dates procedure questions please refer them to Miss Allen um who should be in a position to answer any question

130that they might have if someone has question questions about the job or duties of a board member what I've done is I've just simply explained that I can't talk to any applicants but I've provided information for some of our former board members so they could talk to them about their experience of course you do you know what you think best fills your conscience but that's really been the expectation is that to make sure that nobody has access to additional information that none of us talk to any of the applicants um that are officially being considered except through the interview process okay all right all right so are there any final questions or thoughts I think that covers everything all right if that if there are no other questions about the district 2 vacancy process what

131I'd like to do is entertain a motion for us to return to closed session some move Mr chair all right we have a motion from Vice chair Swanson and a second from Mr Hershey all in favor of returning to Clos session say I I any opposed of course not it passes we will now move back into Clos session thank you all good night e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.