001e e e okay all right good afternoon everyone welcome to the January 7th work session our first work session of the year we have a short but very broad agenda today talking about our ational technology um the project update what we're going to look at the the most I guess popular topic is on mobile phones we're look at all of technology and how the district uses technology in the district so uh Dr Wilson Norman I'll turn it over to you for any introductions and to get us started thank you very much and happy New Year everyone happy year happy New Year today we are excited to introduce an important initiative that focuses on Revis and refining our District's approach to cell phones and personal devices as well as a long-term educational technology strategies today we're
002going to delve deeply into cell phones and how they are utilized within the classroom this project represents a collaborative effort across multiple departments including policy technology and academics our shared goal is to Foster meaningful conversations across the district that provide data and insights to inform effective and Equitable policies that we will engage a wide range of stakeholders including School leaders teachers families and students to gather a diverse perspective today we will start with our school board and thinking through multiple aspects of the usage of cell phones in classrooms we are partnering with RTI the Research Triangle Institute and I have with us Mike Martin who has been our partner in helping us work through um our development and conducting our focus groups Mike Martin and his team have supported us previously in work our strategic
003plan so they're very familiar with our district their expertise will be invaluable in helping us design data driven and an inclusive process and so at this time I'm going to turn it over to Mike Martin to get us started in today's activities great good morning everyone work at afternoon um so I am going to um kind of go through about 15 minutes of sort of framing our conversation to give you all a sense of uh and I think um Dr Robinson shared in a policy meeting earlier at the end of last year um the direction that we're going and so we really want to use this time to kind of talk through the essential challenges in thinking about a cell phone policy and really get your input in thinking about what information you need to
004make really to deliberate and make a good choice about the policy that would um come into effect in the 25 26 school year so it's really about thinking about Gathering the right information so I think one of the things that we hope to walk away from with today is a sense of the information that you will need because this is admittedly a a challenging topic there's a lot of emotion connected to it they're a big part of all of our lives uh cell phones I mean um and so we just really want to use this time to get the information from you all so for the about the first 15 minutes I'm just going to go through some framing material so as I do that I would ask you guys to sort of gather questions
005gather ideas take notes as you go through and then the large portion of the work session will be a work session where we are going to pose some some core questions to yall about um what information you'll need to make it really to feel like you can make a good um common decision about a policy across the district um so that's kind of the agenda and I'll go through it in a minute here the actual agenda but I just um want to start out by just framing kind of the reason that we're revisiting our approach to technology so the the first part of it is is about really about you know through the pandemic every school district including Wake County had this very major move to online learning which which meant buying a lot of
006devices it meant basically becoming one to one no matter where this the uh District was um and so one of the streams of work and we're going to talk about this less today but it will be part of this work is thinking about our approach to technology that is District provision to technology the second part and the part that we're going to spend the most time talking about today are cell phones and personal devices and what policies that we we uh might want to adopt what adaptations to current policies we might want to take as a board um one of the things I will say is that as we think about all of this stuff the core um the core thing we're driving at is student learning and well-being and both of those things are
007tied together um in in as we think about technology the use of technology so I want us to keep that in mind as we go through the process just in terms of our timeline the major things that we're driving towards on the cell phone side would be a revised policy that is in place for the 25 26 school year um so that is what we're going to spend the line share of our time talking about and getting your input on today the second part of it the school issued instructional technology because that has uh it requires a lot of purchasing and time what we want to do with that is think about implementing for the 26 27 school year because right now when we think about refurbishing things like that for the 25.6 year of
008school that's taking place right now so a reasonable timeline for that is to have a revised approach and for the board to inform that revised approach in preparation for the 26 27 school year so those are our two major objectives we're going to spend the time today talking about cell phones in part because the timeline is quicker um in terms of when we want to uh implement this and it's immediately important to students families and Educators we know there's a lot of feelings around this and there's a lot of implications and it's complex so we really want to spend our time on that today so our aims really today are to gather board input to develop a clear and effective cell phone personal device policy that supports student learning and well-being we're going to um
009talk about timeline at the very end when we close out the work session um and then secondly and part of this will be gathering information but as we return to you in March and April we want to basically make sure that we have a a good analysis of other policies cell phone policies um to help you with your deliberation so that is a as we do this work together that's a secondary goal we're not going to do that as much today because we really want to make sure there's alignment between what you need as as a policymaking body and information that we provide so I'm just going to go through a a quick 10-minute framing um and I want to do this in part because I want to give us some common things to refer
010back to as we engage in this conversation um so the first thing I'm going to do is I'm going to talk through what i what we've identified as eight kind of understandings about cell phones um and these are these are in the PowerPoint in part because we want to ask the question do we collectively agree to things so I'm going to present the understandings and then we're going to spend some time actually in small groups discussing and getting feedback so we're going to ask you you know what do we need to adjust what do we need to add it's totally fine if there's something that you as a board member actually disagree with or argue with um but we think it'll be helpful to align the work of Staff in in helping gather data um
011to present the understandings and have you guys discuss them and we're going to have you record um uh on a on a couple sheets of paper that we'll be able to um kind of return to you in our process in in March and in April um and it will help inform what we do to get you guys the right research and information um so just one of the things one of the ways I wanted to sort of frame this and is to just think about it across uh the sort of state district school and classroom level right we know that like what happens day today in the classroom is going to be the thing that matters but I just wanted to give you a quick sort of overview of our understanding of what the landscape
012is around cell phones when we think at the state district school and classroom level so first at the state level um you know one of the sort of reliable um sources the education Commission of the states they've done some research and basically there are some states that have taken steps to issue cell phone policies Louisiana Virginia they issued those policies But ultimately a lot of those policies are notionally directional but they really are up to the districts to make the choice of note as well in the last legislative session North Carolina there was a uh Senate bill that was out that did not make it out of session in 2425 it may come back um but that was really legislation to study cell phone policies right um so it's possible that that would be uh
013a part of our um our sort of deliberation at the district level um typical cell phone policies are really like focused I would say at a very simple level at saying by and large cell phones should not be out during instruction that's typically what district level policies are targeting and typically they have exceptions so we'll talk about that a little bit but you know and there's some variability in terms of restrictiveness and flexibility and we have a little Continuum that will help you guys think about this as you go into your small groups at the school level um um there's variabilities of approaches and we've done some preliminary work in just looking across weight County at posted policies and there's definitely variability I I think we're at the place where we want to sort of
014verify whether the posted policies are the policies in action right because obviously with something like this it may be somewhat iterative um but there's variabilities and approaches but commonly you know there's a sense that during instruction you don't the cell phone out um but there's variability some folks have you know red yellow green um some really encourage students not to bring their cell phones to school um but there's some level of variability that said most folks understand that during instruction unless there's a reasonable instructional reason they're stored away um and then finally obviously the classroom level like and I think this is one thing for us to sort of collectively think about is you know we want to make an implementable policy that supports learning in the classroom and as we get into the understanding
015one of the things that we'll talk about is we want to make sure as we develop a policy that it that it is that it keeps learning and well-being at the center um and isn't first and foremost about policing cell phones and creating the enforcement of it can become a challenge so we want to kind of collectively think about that so with that I'm going to head into the the sort of eight understandings that we've laid out and again as I present these take notes because when we get into conversations we're going to want you guys to be thinking about you know are do I agree with these is there a Nuance that is not here in this um because I think if we can sort of narrow in on a common set of beliefs
016um and a common set of understandings that will help us to design a policy that we feel good about and achieves our aims for students so I'm just going to talk through these um and then um and then we'll sort of head into the um the sort of smaller work groups and then the overall conversation so the understandings that as we've laid them out the first one um is that at a fundamental level focused attention is essential for Effective learning so if we divide attention which can definitely happen with cell phones and personal devices that can present a significant challenge to Student Success so that is one of the essential I think core things that's driving a lot of districts and driving a lot of school schools within Wake County to think about how they
017restrict the use of cell phones the second part is that and this I think is really really important as we do this work because you are are such a big District we're talking about 100 what is it 180 schools 99 9 yeah so it's a it's a ton of schools it's a ton of classrooms andin other schools schools are are doing this work right now they're doing it in ways that are somewhat common but there's also variability and I think that most districts have taken these steps to revise their cell phone policies in the pursuit of consistency and in the pursuit of improving student learning so I think the understanding too is that schools are actively addressing this and there are some commonalities right but there are definitely differences and we don't we haven't done
018the full analysis of all the posted policies but there definitely is variation in terms of how people are impl impen this and of course very big differences when it comes to like High School versus Elementary School those represent differences the third thing is that cell phones and personal devices should generally remain out of sight and unused during instructional time except in specific appr approved circumstances in our sort of survey of the of the of current schools that that seems to be the case and most policies that we've reviewed thus far seem to allow for an instructional exception that is very much connected to understanding number four which is that any policy will count for appropriate exceptions and you know those are quite variable but can be things like obviously instructional needs medical needs specific learning
019accommodations and principal approved situations while maintaining overall consist so these two things understanding three and four are complicated right so as we do this work and as we get into March and April and are actually looking at language and policy I expect the sort of thinking about how we achieve number three and allow for number four um is going to be a central part of our conversations and of course we'll look at many examples of other folks who have done this and what they have learned about it the second set of uh understandings is and I won't say too much about this one but that cellones and personal device policies will vary by great level um so I think as we think about the policy we imagine that it will take different forms at different
020grade levels for obvious reasons um understanding six is basically that enforcing policies can be challenging and as as we think about this I think for us because of how many schools and how many different implementations there are I think as we set policy we want to make sure that it is as prescriptive as you all need it to be right there's going to be a central conversation about how much is centralized right and towards the end I'm going to talk just a little bit about some of the specifics decisionmaking but um we want to make sure that we create something wherein enforcement does become its own problem which I think is definitely a a possibility right um so as we think about the degree to which you know we want to devolve power to the
021local levels decision- making to the local local level I think that will be really important because what we don't want to do is create um you know a channel for a lot of um disciplinary actions at the same time we know this is important for learning right uh understanding number seven is that and this one I think is is super super important is that the policy itself cannot be complete solution and I think one of the things that you know I think we want to talk about as we do this work is what sort of training and support families and counselors and teachers get to address student needs in terms of mental health because I think as we think about policy I think a lot about you know instructional time and where when they can
022be used but as we all know there's a big question about the impact of cell phone social media on student mental health and well-being and obviously this gets challenging because that is also the perview of parents and fam right um but we do know we want to be able to support um through the policy instruction and and well-being but also recognize that there needs to be continued support and the last one and I just put it down because in part because this is such because it changes so quickly because a lot of other districts are doing this and will learn things from it we imagine this policy will need to be return to and update we do not think that this is a thing that is fixed in place um and would be you know
023sort of in place for you know 10 years right it just that just does not seem feasible given the rate of change about how and when technology is used the advancement of research and what we will learn about this work um so those are our basic understandings and we're going to ask you guys to to to spend some time talking about them I have three more slides and then we're going to kind of jump into um small group discussion and then larger group questions in discussion so the the one sort of I think um kind of um conceptual thing is to think about and this may be helpful as we get into discussions about this and as we think about the decisions the actual language of the policy later this spring we think there's sort
024of kind of a more restrictive manifestation of this and a more flexible manifestation of this um and just to give you guys some sense of what on the more restrictive side that might mean not at school at all right there's some places where it's like the the message is don't bring it to school right or off and stored away or on the person in stored away but as we all know like you can have yourself phone on and if it buzzes in your pocket part of your brain's there right um so the difference between often stored away and on person stored away and then there's also a lot of districts chadam county is one example that is piloting this that have these sort of pouches um they're doing it as a pilot so that's a
025thing to consider as well obviously with the pouches there is definitely fiscal considerations right um but there's also and even in our first conversations we met with the super attended student advisory and you know there's definitely cases right now in way County School to school where kid can have it in the backpack right or some teachers in the same building will required to get put on the door um so there's that sort of difference in the middle it might mean you know allowing it and this is for middle in high school during lunch during passing periods allowed on campus or allowed at approved Times by teachers administrators and on the very more flexible end would really be set classroom to classroom so that's just sort of a conceptual Continuum for us to think about and
026then finally and these are these last two slides are not questions that we are going to answer today um but they are things for us to think about and that is just you know who who will make the decision right so that's a fundamental thing that I think you all are taking on right now is are we we will have a mandated District by policy house specific will it be it will allow some flexibility but what flexibilities these are the things that we will talk about over the course of the coming months um and then schools have that decision about what flexibility they offer you know at one of the examples in preparing for this that we talked about is like you know music class cell phone is a great thing to tune an instrument
027right and so how do you think about you know those kind of variabilities with with also recognizing the potential challenges that can come with cell phones and so there's the question of who and I think that's one of the main things we're going to r with here then there's the how like how and where personal cell phones and personal devices are stored and kept backpacks silent or in the off position in pouches and lockers or in designated storage in the classroom and then there sort of when where and why and when and where I think kind of uh run together um but you know for when it's sort of during transitions at lunch before after school potentially not on campus at all where I mean you can use them on the entire campus classroom when
028given permission only in Halls in lunchrooms not in bathrooms um outside of the building or not on campus at all you know so there's this sort of fundamental question as well and then I think the last part of this and I think this is really really important is that you know we have done like just looking at some Pew research there's an awful lot of support for cell phones like the majority of respondents in the Pew survey say they don't want cell phones in the classroom day-to-day when you ask that question about should you have cell phones on campus the support becomes much less right so a lot more parents are like and this is totally understandable I want to be able to contact my kid for Just For Peace of Mind reasons also for
029practical reasons pick up that kind of thing so at least that and that's a very recent survey I think it's October of 2024 so there's Americans in this survey support them not being out in the classroom but by and large do not support like the idea that I'm just not going to be able to contact my kid um and obviously that's complicated but to this last question like when cell phones can be used you know I think we need to think about ideas of contacting families in case of emergency um you know you could imagine for a more uh flexible policy for any reason um you know for instructional purposes or sort of predetermined Health needs so these are the sort of things that we believe we're going to have to wrestle with over time
030so I really appreciate everybody sort of giving us some time to kind of just frame it to have a set of things that we can refer to as we move into the group so what we are going to do for the next 45 minutes is we're going to actually break into three groups and I'll I'll tell you what the groups are and we're going to have staff go with each of you and we're going to ask you guys to use the the deck that was presented and we're going to ask you to really respond to three key questions um and basically since this is the only item so we have 45 minutes we'll give you about um 12 to 15 minutes per question but then we want to allow for a solid 20 or 30
031minutes for share outs of what you guys are thinking about your needs any questions that you have and then we'll close out just with a sense of our process um in terms of gathering feedback and again just to remind you like we want you guys to help us think about what you need to feel like you can make a good decision about this that's part of what today's purpose is and I'll talk a little bit about the process that we and staff will use to gather feedback moving into the spring um so the three questions that we we would love you guys to think about and Mary Claire who's with me here is going to has um sheets that we'll use to record um your thinking um so the first question is like sort of
032what key information do you need to guide your deliberation action on cell phone personal device policies for 2526 um so I I think that's really sort of thinking through what will help you make the most decisions that could be what you need to know about current implementation within way County Schools it could mean what you need to know about analogous siiz districts CMS whomever um and and what how what action they're taking um secondly I I think it's really really important because I do think this is a very emotional um infused topic as you review the understandings that I previewed what do you agree with what do you argue with and what needs to be added on and elaborated so as you guys think in your groups you know if there's a part of this
033that you want to make sure you capture um and that you would argue with or edit in some kind of way we want that feedback to sort of sense where you are as a policymaking body and then the last thing is I think this you know more than anything you all are elected representative so we really want to know as you think about your role as being representative of of families within the district what what input you're hearing from parents and Educators that needs to be addressed by the policy um what needs to be addressed by schools um that sort of issue of of centralization right how specific do we want want to be based on the conversations you're having and I think slide 12 and 13 which is the who what one wear will
034be really helpful around that so those are our three specific questions um that we're going to break out into groups and we'll have myself and other staff um go with you in in groups to have those discussions we'll take about I'll try to keep us on track so we'll take 12 to 15 minutes per discussion you guys get your ideas down and then we'll have Pro we should have a probably a solid 20 minutes to share out to you know so that you can share out as a group so you can all hear where you are collectively ask any questions and then I'll close out with timeline okay all right so I think we're ready to move to our groups um so group one is going to be Stacy uh Miss Coffield chair hegerty Miss
035rice and then you guys are going to be right down here um group two will be uh Drew and and Shashi with Miss Edmonds Mr Hershey and Mr Swanson and group three with Dr Robinson uh will be Dr Taylor M mafy and Dr so Mary CLA is going to come around with the the handouts and we're going to spend about about 12 minutes per question I'll keep us on track make sure you're recording this this will all be very valuable as we uh think about how we do this in grp two yeah all right we come down this way group two is right here right here taking yes no you can sit right here yeah always my down there yes sir sor you right next to so we getting shushed or we getting gu good
036question all right so uh what um what key information first I need to know what teachers want so I need to know what teachers want or their in phrase it and I need to know what the other districts that have taken action what their results are what North Carolina have changes they've made if any some of these from the end last year school year results basically what their of outcomes have been what simil size districts have done what neighboring what's wor Pros cons especially unanticipated they I've got some feedback so really all I hear is from information started I think they really help the last one and talked about the security having a cell phone provides that's in when going to the bathroom I think that's helpful um but I also have my mindset that
037I trying trying to monitor that and police that sounds like a nightmare not only that but the bathro that's where that's where accidents can happen and so I'm looking and I've gotten feedback too I had this as my discussion topic at my AC in December but that's not enough I mean that's a very small amount of people even within my own District let alone um I was going to say the last thing is and I've gotten feedback from some principles but I think it would be helpful for principles that have implemented different things to say whether they've had any issues with enforcement or this one conc spoken few my principles as I go through and figure out what they're doing and some of my principles are already doing a a modest I don't want to
038say B but there's some procedures in place um when do they have the calculator things that you stor every little student yes the pouch is B but the pouch is there every student has a number on their desk that is their assigned um space for their their C and at Green hope there is no it stays there because that's also A disruption I'm teaching about trying to reenter the conversation um car High has a very similar thing they use the couches that you put in your binders for pencils and taped somehow is connect to the chairs therefore stud take technology away West Cary Middle School they have a no cell phones at all um and so I would love to hear from those teachers those principles rather at whether it's a work session talk about
039lessons gr face um I think you're going to get a broad range of discussion from all the teachers um when I taught I knew techology children but the ask you about only that was not supposed to be majority of our teach more because that is also I am definitely someone not peace because for transportation we don't have our where we want so I would not want a kid to Beed for trying to fure out home have issues diab that data I don't want those but on the flip side I don't want every student to say they have a medical need a there has to be somewhere lunch lunch perfect place to unwind but I also think as adults adults have to mod that behavior I can tell you br hat their policy is Bell to
040Bell no sell so they don't take it out even I guess kid we and go to either way that's a little extreme but she said they've not had any issues the first they're not necessarily treated like right the words students can have the s that's pretty the leadership academy think it's based on different parts of dist more relx I don't want to say relax but I think depending on certain parts of our district she expect folks are going to show up and be a little bit different situ show uple months ago about the data and whatnot and so I think folks out in Western Wake should be sou I still want to be able to have control and access my students specifically Target the teachers five years but you also do get the input of
041the T-shirt I just want to make sure don't think we should have go to the common I think of an all out what what are some examples nationally regionally but also within the district maybe approaches and balanced approaches that sign effective andfor I would be curious as how many schols are actually already just doing you mean similar to Bron well like most of the middle schools think principles would have data from their teachers that I think it would be very our children um I think we could lose market share if we were to do a full out no cell phone no sell but they also I'm not in favor some char are um to see what some of their plans are and how they're what you heard to is I'm curious how well you know
042how parents are also following those policies right it's wonderful that the teacher has the whole situation so how well are teachers our parents following support for for whatever respected you know teachers sign but maybe stting that information into them saying this is an agreement not just for your child but for you being your child as well um it doesn't make any sense for us to have a policy if parents are not going that was something think all but one of the components of that policy is involing counsel social I think recognizes resarch about addess itself social trying to incorporate proactive measures on FR that have actually I don't heard as any I can't I don't know District have done that I think nationally school and districts [Music] absolutely first well and that was part of
043the the premise and reading some of the research like some of the researchers will say try to have something in the right and only during instuctional time accessibility interception are there are another piece of information that I'd like to have policy i' like to have better understanding technology to get was none whatever the problem with that was there was no cons when when isfor then it was condition might just well the parent asks for it some parents might say yeah sure my kid throughout the board so I think that's going to be legitimate metal they student at BR and is having also one thing thaty but how students are using like our English language are using their phones for translation so that they can access other classes or instruction that may not have something I
044would still like to know what's happening yeah how is that so I'd like to learn a little bous and what do we mean by is it more like what you describe I have it on to Bell it's in a pouch to translate certain simp we have to realize smart watches are a thing too so are we going to put something that's brought that up and I think too just based on the scans that we've done so far is a lot of the a lot of the Bands the more your bands are just being implemented to which may be a challenge in terms of finding to find exactly how it's going but we are speaking we have a we are lining up to speak with other districts and and their leadership to talk with their to
045see how things are going and talk about talk about these questions that we're raising so we can at least get their in um and hear how things are how things are what I'm concerned that teaching and learning teachers are becoming cell phone please versus being the Educators that supposed to supposed to be do so how do we know there going to be another bur that's being placed on educat um by saying now I'm have to whatever you can find do all this other stuff and now the cell phone please and I don't want to get cut out have to C the cell phone um you know what support can we get these a long in terms of thinking about a longterm plan and then I guess so we are um trying to helping keep us
046on time sure we are about two more minutes left for this question um are there any other thoughts or things you want to add about what just related to small even though it's not necessarily answering that question um I know some of the principles include Elementary School expect children not have a kid they are remind like their distraction no don't bring Smart Watch to school um and I know like fairx County their policy addresses smart watches and one thing that I'm not sure we're answering with these but I think that our I would like us to look at our technology policy and like fcking out policy there policy to put that over here because I I WR paper on this is a policy families are going to look for 12 minutes in youology policy that
047has like three parts whatever makes it easy for families to does yeah so the a which is the accept acceptable use policy of technology is very generic and a very broad within that there could be some specific policies like the see what DET District may I think be a great topic for us to really move around the district because what I'm concerned about is we're going to voices and we're going to neglect a lot ofes may not be so so the next question take you have not or you access to screen but those I wrote them down I think that data would look attention is essentialy in general the whole out of s during instructional time Poli account for appropriate exception the policy will likely veryy enforcement challenging policies loan is not a complete solution
048n and then policy will I got I have I a couple that I have some concerns about um that second one wcsf schools are actively addressing I don't know I've had BPL come in show distri so many schools from grade level to grade level very might have had um80 that goes to the third one cell phone Dev remained out of sight instr I believe that but what I've seen is a lot ofools half of that say that the device should out of sight future lawyers out there among the students just say I had my earbuds in I was listening to music smart stuff where they think well if the teacher doesn't see it I can still use it and so that's sort of where if I think this be a very difficult policy for us
049to really connected so if I lose my phone or don't have my phone I can still text so the distraction is still there that's what we're trying to eliminate forcement Mak computer some students do even though it's not a full BYOD right or large stud bring their own connect to Wii but again they're restricted to what they can do but they can right now everything is on the cloud not like that when we take into account the differentiation and the reality is it could be a student that is literally we have special education that has something they focus provides those in terms of access and student with ADHD cannot sit with nothing that's why I also to the understanding number eight require regular updates the evolution not just technology or like some soft music or
050something I think that's one thing but then there's also students security Fus like question number I'm not trying to punish the kid but I think they should be focused on the classroom and that's where I'd just like to see two and three those understanding think third blanket of of the class versus students about it being an educational a phone being an educational tool so for teachers they have their devices they can use it but for students they think of it as an educational tool I think there's going to have to have to think about different from elementary to Middle School to high SCH ele scholer restrictive stance than I would for most um and I'm wondering if those students know how to get through all the different types of Technology uh guards we have are
051we able to you know tighten up the security on the Wi-Fi what they have it's an Ong process obviously you know we we never going to say this absolutely show is not continuously tweaking it I think it's pretty good but again to that point CU I know there's like so different things view points on both sides of but I believe that you do need to have a district policy that creat you say every family parent student has a certain level of expectation it might vary from classroom to class and that's what there was a school that we heard that had differences in nth and 10 one teacher and then there were differences at elementary schools between K through 2 and 3 so that's that's interesting so that's interesting thank you for us for our district
052ourselves starting with something like a bill to Bell policy St put it away you always have the exception leadership policy it's like policy specific to high school and if I'm a teacher how am I navigating leadership leadership they're based on application so I'm wondering if we can put in the applications you are agreeing to this this is I I think also the principles like Mariah the leadership academy it's the same from 6 to 12 also Addus that's that number four but just at the moment I think maybe at some point but I C this is going to be to County it takes a while folks to that's something dig understand it so I think putting another layer on top of policy that we don't quite know what be a little bit more big calls more
053hard me that goes back to the first question it may be a new practical purposes you always the teacher that allows it a big number regard to those special schools the or like we have one we only have one K right right so that's that's part that we could have I do I do fall those special schools with those split that disc because you get teacher in the high school students I would still like to see that in their applications it's surprise it's clear oric Elementary secondary address all if you could come back to give updates days to kind of see what's working needs to be addressed by the start maybe process to once this policy RS out maybe mon send out a survey to really Educators what is working what's not working get that
054feedback and continue to treat that headphones ands so really students are more in tune than what we think and phone away some students now if it's there's always exception they we have a clear consistent understanding of what what is cell pH including soes earphones watches you know saying differ between smart we got all have another got got glasses if you have a camera like your glasses BN you cannot run Campa there are other policies to address more conc with this policy that's the first thing you want to address work allow for other policies perhaps to I can't do it because my life but it is something that I'll Just sh my personal T I've been in a situation left the phone and had to go somewhere Char I can't charge creates I think is good
055for right and I think that I don't want to P someone looking at that differ between flipping a phone and just checking it and actively playing a game testing CRS you know in terms of breaking that distraction so much of what we've seen from the clinical psychologists those that study the student brain activity and especially around student media is that notification that reward action that stimulus reaction and that's what that oh someone posted that that's what's constantly dra their away more that we can do to give them more support don't have those at during that study period I think that's going to have better health benefits and give them more again with accommodations but more Focus for their learning and then when that bell rings and they're out between classes they can check get I'm
056in agreement I'm in alignment that's I want that was youg try it for this is anotal that Cheryl and I when we were at the School Board Association conference went to that workshop and I believe it cumber not children heard that's okay um it was not the thece people for a sales pitch but they were sucesses they had they really like it coming at from different people information from parents about what we were to say hey starting Monday no phon trying to get people to not take pH Administration is really do come from different levels of exposure that's how they're trying to prejudge it but let's see you know we know our own expectations but are we the exception or are we PES that would be something to I would like to make students I'm
057just thinking you have that to step up in the have do think if that's patterns are forming as they're growing so if we're showing them there's a time and a place which there is for everything in life we I think there's there's different types of technology that you use there's a magnetic you can also have the that's what they're doing in all time that's fine but in school there specifically to learn pick them up and drop them off you take them in High School having distraction only theal toess is getting distracted from getting deil the capacity social media declare process we're having the um disagreement in processes let's let me clarify one of princip advocating for a student to have currently my children to do it I'm say of govern signed a bill saying need
058to do what I am saying and the we're talking about having them specifically in contract got it so would be have a c during instruction that point that when we talk about policy we also that's little bit off but no no this was her District what is the expectation for staff because we have teachs that are on Tik Tok that are filming during the school day during class you know when the School Board Association is looking at doing a public education campaign all the advertisers are oh you got to have influence here some of the best influencers in County teers media and maybe there's maybe there's we ought to have policy are their boundaries what's would you like to see your child on somebody else's social media channel without your right and just sort of
059what those are I'm not proposing a solution want to get that on there to look at now specific to this what specific input are you par needs to be addressed so I want to make sure we get to this everyone has the chance one of the things like I hear from parents on both sides don't you dare take his phones away I hear more you know for taking them out but I might hear social interaction what 20 parents out of 160,000 students right so you always have to stop and put the numbers SCH for some people doesn't mean that's get that's different it be it could be a little different between but I immediately qualified that by saying I don't think it's s using that as an example that I think any survey needs to
060I agree in high school completely also the middle scho for this one a specific thing I he that I worry about it's going to be an interesting discussion contact my son or my daughter during an emergency my son is not and I'm not committed anyone that that creates as many security and concerns like when you had a television reporter that was conducting an interview with a student inside to ahead anybody listening or watching on the feed could then see inside the building how do we address anxiety and concern over students smile they've appar students safe in a situation like that of and that's going to be one that the experts tell us one but parents you know going from their heart are going to tell us something else and I don't know how we recile
061so we can reach out to them and see what districts they work with but I think the districts that have put I think everybody be right back nobody which is good it's fisc respons but I think taking the respons have different from mid elementary middle and and high school are all different gradu way to approach property you know is more about what situation on my different for example they can't reach out to somebody you know so I understand that having that and that's why I feel like a bell to Bell because in the when the bell rings and you're in classroom you're with the teacher so you should be safe in that class they had all the exceptions out of the classroom kind of so I kind of understand that um and then the other
062thing was you know if you take it away you don't have as much flying they're not on the device but they now they have K through6 most of the bullying stuff happens see it like you can wear a watch but you got turn all that stuff I mean they're not it's online from home they're doing taking I want to can't take away anybody's device than another adult purchases we're talking about basically put was utilized like an executive I don't know if he did executive order I think it was an executive order you can't bullying is going to take place on electronic devices on social media and has nothing to do with people all tell everybody we've seen you still don't get the samec about a phone I don't think their point was it 100% stop
063buling I would think that point was that it would have get there stop going to the bathroom taking it back wouldn't have kids going to the bathroom open toing whatever I'm this is something that I'm gonna just I don't have enough knowled your experti stuff personal experience and so seeing what has gone on in districts you know has it helped has it had no impact that should be something we should be able to start to track do incidents of bowling go up do they go down or are they unchanged and it may be kids like it was like it was ranged you know how did you have your cell phone out to C something the do even in the classroom verbally because that's where it takes place first it verbalizes Sil and that's from the
064district level [Music] longevity dat I don't know this is anecdotal but um I've gotten a lot of consensus from elementary level parents that they're not think it's much easier you know I think that students are to the ones that have told me they don't they don't their kids even have one yet I mean just the elementary level so I don't think it would share at any time I don't I think our the most resistance get home that's the only access maybe not resistance might not be the right word but if it happen the most Nuance everybody I think as long as they can access it after whether we hold it off at full transportation and the other partell aspect I have one thing I I love put in place to understand quietly share what it
065is and I think just goes back again to the cell phone policy is not a compl because it really is did you I don't want us to be blind decision making creating this don't some adults proactive well we have that we have that issue now with other Poli we didn't have a cell phone to tune anything we're tun together know a l Dr Robinson I'm going to spy down so you can sit in a real chair no there you go I don't swing it down now don't make all right thank you everybody um I want to be mindful of time because I know we have um you have a full meeting but I would love to just offer a a short amount of time for um Reflections from groups around the the three questions if
066there were particular things that came out in your conversation um that you wanted to highlight as you sort of think about and make these decisions I just wanted to open it up to the group for a short reflection and then I'll close us out with just our our process and timeline um so I'll just open it up to the group for any any particular Reflections that came out of your conversations I know we got a lot of very great uh very helpful stuff down I think we're really interested since since a lot of schools are already doing things we're really really interested to hear how those they're basically pilot programs going on all over the county yep and how many schools are already doing something what are they doing what are their results I think
067that's huge yeah that was a big part I think we wanted to add students we did to understanding I think it was seven y um and that was a big part of our conversation anybody else I mean we gave a lot there's a bunch we gave a ton I just it was great and I think that the feedback was super super helpful and I'll just kind kind of to close this out I'll go through you know our sort of timeline for for what we plan to do um and in essence I think you know we're going to ask the questions to gather Stu student staff and family input on the current use of school issue devices we talked less about that today um and then we want to develop a very clear understanding of the
068instructural functions that need to be met and this is really thinking about the second part of the work about instructional devices on cell phones I think a lot of what we have planned I think what you guys provided feedback on will help us be even more detailed about this but we want to gather student staff and family feedback about the current use of cell phones and personal devices to inform our policy so I think um to what Mr Hershey said I think that's exactly right we've already done a cursery scan of middle and high schools um so we're going to do some work to verify that um but we definitely want to know actually weight County input the second thing is to use comparable cell phone and personal device policies for other districts again we've
069beginning be begun to collect some of those things I think you know Winston Salem I know has done that CMS has done that so we'll get some information about what other districts are doing um and then set up a set of considerations um that we'll use as we put the policy together and in terms of timeline I think we are right you know kind of in the staging process right now I think this feedback you all have provided is very very helpful throughout uh the next couple of months we're going to be conducting uh uh feedback sessions across the district um to sort of identify Trends and then moving into March and April and I think we we plan to probably use a combination of of policy meetings and work sessions to Think Through bringing
070this together I think we're going to um do some sensemaking with what you guys have done today I think the one big thing that I I believe we all sort of collectively agree with is that bold thing highlighted in phase two that that we expected the board to discuss and vote on a cell phone and personal device policy this spring to be operational in 25 26 that feels like a very important goal um obviously what's contained within that is we have to figure that out collectively um together um but that is the goal we are driving for which you know means that we have you know enough time but a Brisk timeline to make sure that schools are ready to align their practices with the policy um so with that I if there's any other
071questions I would turn it over to the chair so thank you I do have um yes I see as R I do have a question to um I I do want to to talk about the timeline and going back to the original one and it's just one opinion but but my opinion is that policy around Tech use does not necessarily need to be delayed until the 26 27th school year and I know that this needs to be the priority because we want to get all the feedback develop a reasonable policy and then make sure there's enough notice to parents and staff that we can be prepared for it but there are some other important issues regarding Tech that I think we may have time to address between now and that 26 27 school year specifically
072around how Tech is used in the classroom for instructional purposes ex looking at expected access do we have students using for example um applications on Chromebooks that might require two- Factor authorization but then we restrict cell phone use so then they can't authorize what we've told them to use and just avoiding those types of unanticipated uh conflicts we can get ahead of that by looking at that now I still think using technology to hand in and turn in assignments remotely we really need to look at the deadlines and I you know it's again just a personal belief but having midnight deadlines for turning in assignments does encourage students staying up later turning them in I don't want to penalize a student by giving them less time but I don't want them online longer than they
073need to be at night when we know for their heal they need to get as much sleep and as rest as they can and then looking at staff use of technology and Mobile use themselves whether it's instructional use which is perfectly appropriate but also if it's personal use during school hours and instructional time so those are just some things that are concurrent or not concurrent adjacent to these important issues but I hope we could look at them before that 26 27 thank you y I got it that makes total sense and I the 26 27 is really about provision right but I think to your point you're talking about use and guidance yes okay Miss rice uh thank you um chair herty I just have two questions uh one with your conduction of focus groups
074um I'm curious at what the samples um are going to look like of the people that you're going to use for focus groups um are we are we using um the focus groups of all parents across or bodies of people across the district um are we only uh uh sharing or putting a net with a certain group of people I I'm concerned about um what does that look like when you're saying you're choosing the focus groups I need to know a little bit more clarity about what who are you're choosing in your focus groups to see what your samples actually look like um I that was something that I would really like to know specifically um to make sure that we're hearing um the right voices across the district which is everyone's voice and a
075sample of that uh and the other thing that I have a question about is um sorry I lost my thought the listening opportunity so I guess it's one and the same it's kind of the same question um and all which is uh yeah I'm more concerned about the the deployment of the districtwide survey oh that's what it was that I had the question about the survey in the past I've seen our surveys from the district and it's really a guiding answer to what we want to hear and I need to kind of know what are these surveys really going to look like in asking a question that doesn't kind of guide to what we want to hear but but is it a real survey that's going to allow people to really share with what they
076want I know that's very hard and Technical sometimes but whoever is creating the survey um I would I don't know how you do it and develop it together as a team of people or whoever who is it one person is it a group of people and then of that group of people what is your diversity look like what does your mindset look like what does your level of expertise look like so you can be able to ask inform the questions so it's not saying that people can't do the job I just need to know who's putting it together because what I've seen in the past as a district and as a parent who has to a answer these questions is very specific which doesn't really give you my thoughts but it guides you to what
077you want me to tell you as a district that you want to there and so I'm concerned about those if I can build on that and then specific specifically Mr rice is this something that you would be interested in and I'm going to look to Dr Robinson and staff as as well Dr R Norman as well but Dr Robinson for and Mr rice because of our community engagement committee would this be an appropriate topic to bring to community engagement to really do a deeper dive on how we do the surveys methods of that data collection and kind of what best practices are and then suggestions for improvement this could even be something where if we're going remotely this could be a topic we take out to the community is that anything you that's an excellent
078suggested and idea Miss I just wanted to say that um Mr Swanson raised that exact um point when in our small group was that it should go to the community engagement committee well thank you great mind and we concurred think we can handle it can't we Dr Robertson we got it all right all right see we're already taking Stacks all right other questions for uh specifically related to the agenda the time line um process anything like that M Cofield or did you just I I mean we had our input I'm not sure I guess we'll get a consensus of that how's that going to come back talk to us a little bit about kind of we have three groups three or four that have worked together to produce some thoughts on this will there be
079a report out will we be a will we be able to see what the other groups talked about yeah well I think we definitely would come back in March with that information um and then you know I think to build consensus I think you know we want to pretty quickly move to a draft policy right because that is the you know that the heart of where we're headed to so I think the imagine of for sort of sense making with the feedback that you all have given returning that in March and then I think pretty quickly beginning to think about with the feedback that we've gathered what policy look like and then have a lot of discussions about that so are you saying that you'll have a proposed policy draft in March or we'll just
080be speaking about it again in March I think what we're saying is as we look at the scheduled meetings that we'll look at in between policy and work sessions have a bring back what you talked about today in March the collection of what did the community say what did students say and then based upon that here's a policy but but in between that heard um we want to hear what we already have in place across schools we need to bring that back we want to hear what are other large districts doing we talked about North Carina but we've looked at districts Across the Nation and so we want to bring that back and so we will just begin to look at mapping out what can we bring back between each meeting to keep you a
081breast of the work that's going on March is kind of the um page in which we like to have a draft policy to make sure that schools have enough time to make whatever adjustments but we have based on your feedback today we have some things to bring back to you to help you before we get to the policy decisions so can we do this uh so I think that progression that they're talking about is absolutely what we want to be but if you're interested in what the other two groups said for this exercise I think that's something we can probably lift up pretty quickly and share with you all so at least you will know and that will keep us on the other timeline as well would would that be is kind of what you're
082asking for what the other okay final thought yeah um and when you're reaching out to the the um the public I'm just curious are you going to I think it was more along the lines of what Miss rice was saying are you going to have like specific questions or things that you're going to ask them and are you going to give them scenarios that they could answer cuz the public might not necessarily have an answer but they might have an opinion if that makes sense like if we were to say how would you feel about a bell-to-bell policy you know like if we were give them certain examples um they might be able to give us some really good feedback with that we will have questions and we have some researchers and I think they're
083looking at surveys that have been done other places in focus groups so that it can to your point not be bading but we can look at we can create whatever we want but trying to look at a baseline of um surveys that have been deployed other places and then working with our research Department to think about how can we do it internally within way and I think definitely for focus groups we will to start first with not leaving questions open in questions that are about exactly the stuff we talked about today how are cell phones affecting instruction your students lives and get that feedback and then I do think the survey I think will we will need to narrow some questions because it will get into specific things about you know like the decisions that
084we need to make about when and where so I think we'll have components of the survey will ask pretty specific questions and because you know to think about representation we also want if you're if you haven't participated in one of the focus groups and you are taking the survey we want to know what you think so there will definitely be an open-ended set of questions where you know folks would be able to respond as well okay great and you know I'd invite all of you if you come across articles you've read feedback from parents I know we've had this top come up in b meetings there's been conferences we've attended just feel free to share that information between you know among yourselves now so that everyone has access to the information we can all see
085some of those issues and we'll go into March the best prepared for it okay all right well if there no other questions we'll call this uh work session to a close um before we do or do we have a motion want to go and close session we have a couple items we could address between now and the meeting motion to go into close session to consider personal information protected under gs1 43-38 11 A6 and5 c-31 perfect good enough so we have a motion for Mr Hershey to move into close session second for Miss mafy all in favor any opposed all right we'll give the uh room a minute to clear and then we'll move into Clos session thing