CorpusRecord 94424

Milford Special Board of Education 12/10/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / ICRC-TV
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Seward County, NE
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,603 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I'd like to call the December 10th special meeting to order um please call the role Mr acman Mrs will yes Mrs Powers yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes Mrs Chesnut yes please join me in the pledge of allegiance toag of the United States of can I get a motion to approve the agenda so mov second any changes not really much to change here call the RO please Mrs will yes Mrs Powers yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes chessnut yes um the before we get into the first item which is public participation U Mr spiser did you want us uh open with some comments I did thank you so much um so uh president Chessa members of the board everyone that's here everyone that's watching on TV uh just wanted to um just say

002this is a work session amongst the board uh treasur Akerman and myself and then potentially other administrators uh answering questions giving feedback so it's not like a traditional board meeting um so it wouldn't necessarily be a back and forth between those in the audience and board members um Etc however we still have uh our public participation portions of the agenda just like we would at a regular board meeting so just wanted to make sure that we had Clarity on that before we started thank you uh and with that uh Mr acman do we have uh green sheets that were turned in we do okay let's see here first we have Morris good evening just want to emphasize one thing to the board the administration anybody who's watching and that is we've got to get our

003voice has heard um we're going to hear them tonight talking about what they have heard what they believe but it's important um for us as a community to get together uh at the last board meeting I challenged many people uh to come out um and try to make sure that this board knows what the community wants um we can't continue on this path of voting down levies when we don't know why we're voting down levies so from from a board standpoint everyone knows I'm part of yes for Milford um we're not pushing the board to go ahead with a levy we want to understand what this community wants so I'm reaching out to everyone in the community you know where I live you know my name you know my number contact us and let's figure

004out this together thanks I was just wondering about if there were any discussions can you state your can you I'm sorry Bobby duchan okay thank you um I was just wondering if there were any discussions about parking for next year and expanding the parking at the high school considering the No Buses for the high school as well as any discussions about crossing guards for the elementary schools since the there's no busing in the two mile radius that was it yes yes and yes I mean we're going to look and work with the high school team obviously we've got construction that's still going on uh the junior high school the current Junior High School will still be um it'll it probably be in that process of demolition we have to Abate it first we're also allowing

005the fire and police departments to work inside of there and do some trainings first parking will be tight but we're going to do our best to make sure that we can maximize that space for parking regardless we're planning to do that anyway do we have a third we do not okay that brings us to um discussion do you have anybody who would like to start yes we um we treasure acur and myself we have some uh some slides some things we'd like to um to share out thank you Madame President members of the board uh and thank you everyone for showing up today uh what I'd like to do is give us a little recap of calendar year 2024 and how we've gotten to the point where we are right now so if we go

006backwards actually into November of 23 the first submission of the fiveyear forecast occurred and with that forecast five years down the road we were looking at a negative 13.5 million fund balance because of that you instructed the administration to reduce expenditures by approximately $4.5 Million by doing that you helped eliminate some pressure off the general fund by eliminating pressure off the general fund when we submitted the second fiveyear forecast in May what we did is showed that we had increased our five-year forecast five years down the road to approximately $2.5 million that's great the unfortunate part is is we have a 90day cash Reserve policy that we must follow so therefore decisions still had to be made on what we were going to do you then came together and decided in August that you were

007going to put a earned income tax on the ballot a 1% earned income tax now if that earned income tax passes the district would see a generous portion of Revenue coming our way if it doesn't pass serious decisions have to be made so what you see in front of you right now are some of the serious decisions which you made in October you saw an increase in payto playay fees you saw Transportation reduce the state minimum and of course the grade banded sister schools now the grade banded sister schools is a uh obviously a controversial issue but what it was going to do is put prek through one in malberry and patteron grades two and three in Boyd in selt and grades four and five in Mccormick and metav view we also going to eliminate

008full day kindergarten and take it to half sessions now what you're seeing right here is an actual overview of our expenditures 72% is Personnel cost which is salaries and benefits 19% is purchase services and 9% is supplies and other uses what's important to note about this are two things one we are in the people business so don't be overwhelmed by 72% but the 19% half of that is transportation all right so this brings us to the May 5year forecast that was submitted and this is where decisions were made and I know it's very hard to see the numbers up there but in red in red if you look five years down right right in there so it's in Gold yeah I'm sorry I did say red so down from the red in the gold you'll

009see that if we had passed the Earned Income Tax we'd be looking at 498 million and unfortunately if it does doesn't pass $2.5 million now what's what's awesome about the fact that you made cuts in January what you don't see where is I apologize for that what you don't see is by making those reductions in expenditures in January you actually helped the fiveyear forecast in the first three years of submission which means we can push things out a little further before we actually have to worry and hit the panic button so if you look at the next slide that's really what it shows you and that red is kind of the panic section so with no cuts by year fiscal year 27 we have issues and by making all the cuts we can push it

010out to now there's a lot of questions asked about a performance audit now a performance audit is a financial audit where the auditor State comes into your district and they review expenditures and make recommendations as to where you should cut cost what's good and bad about this is they obviously are here to help us but it's timec consuming it takes up to 10 months and it can cost anywhere between 50 and $90,000 now this is also something that I do and what happens is I do it and then I turn around give the results to the auditor State they look at those results come back to the board of education and tell them what they think the results and make their recommendations so and what if you do that the cost is zero because you're

011already salaried through us well that's true okay that is true um what is important to note though is because again because of the reductions that were made in January because we want to be fiscally responsible because we're going to continually look at reducing expenditures we have put oursel in a nice position for the next three years we then can take our time to do what needs to be done does anyone have any questions on the recap how do they decide what things to review during the performance a they will come in and ask the Board of Education what you would like to see reviewed if whether it be Transportation whether it be Athletics whether it be curriculum whether it be Administration would you make recommendations as to what you would think would be the best

012things for an auditor to look at I would yes okay if we were to say like today we want to do a performance audit could we get them in here like this month to start that uh probably not December but by the end of January and then how long does it take approximately 10 months we wouldn't know so if they came January we still wouldn't have their report until October correct but you're saying you could do something similar to what they would do well regardless I will do something similar so we can have similar data correct whether we have the formal correct I've been through this in the past and that's exactly how it happened they came in they 10 months it took about 10 months yes no but you would be quicker than 10

013months I hope so hopefully yeah it doesn't make sense to me to spend $90,000 or 80,000 or whatever to have them repeat exactly what those going to do for fre 10 months and get it done in 10 months I think that's a big barrier but I do appreciate your um that I know you you did this uh in Lain similar because they had issues when you were there they were in worse position than we are here um so they were actually given a performance audit because they were all when I entered Lain they were already sitting in fiscal caution um so you know there wasn't anywhere to go open up we're not in that position here I do need I'm sorry excuse me I was just going to say we do need to make strides

014forward because you always have to worry about years four and five and you need to worry about overspending I think that from what we've heard we'll Pro we probably need to do it with the state even though it costs money I think just from a public perception and just to Garder more confidence that what we've heard at the you know the listening sessions and what we've heard elsewhere are is it needs to be a third party or state audit in order to curtail the you know distrust in the information that we provide and put out okay I I was excuse me I'm just under the impression that the general population believes the cost us nothing and I think that when they find out that it's going to cost us 80 or 90,000 it's going to

015be typically speaking audits throughout the year and we have Financial audits which they audit our financial statements we have Medicaid audits OD audits us uh sge and sturge which is our retirement our pension systems audit us it probably cost us in the neighborhood of $125,000 a year currently currently already already would this audit remove any other audits that we do that we pay no be on top of this is on top of it so are you saying the audit just reviews our records like they don't make they review our expenditures they don't say you shouldn't have done this you should have they're just they're just checking is it all it's the same people legal it's just a different division they come in and make recommendations on what expenditures you've made in the past two years

016now is that just for the general fund or is it for all of our they will do whatever you want they don't do state and federal grants but it's typically the general fund which your fiveyear forast is your general fund money everything else is usually reimbursable you just need to have cash on hand in order to make the expenditures am I hearing one of the options is do the work and you do the initial uh Discovery and report and have somebody from the audit group review it and kind of they would they would just give it a check mark or something they do their own and then simultaneously I do one okay I give them our results and I would speak to Mr spiser about this ahead of time and give them the results they

017from there to make a decision I mean if we're going to pay them $90,000 they're pretty much going to take crit redit so but that's okay yeah I do think it's something we need to think about because I agree with Michael we've heard over and over we need to have an external audit um $90,000 is a lot of money though right now especially with the financial sit situation we're in so I think there's pros and cons to both and it's definitely I mean we definitely need to have an audit either way in inter or external but I think we need to really think about is that $90 worth it or is it worth it to have the community see that external audit I'm wondering if we missed a bre Black Friday deal on this um

018okay what you guys want to move to the next slide to see what else I we'd don't have to make a decision on that right now any other questions on the I have one more question when you had this audit in L lachan did you agree with the recommendations or uh or their findings I guess your findings were the same as their finding believe it or not they took all of our recommendations oh so they threw in one or two but um the one or two was now this is an unfortunate situation because it's a it's a uh economically disadvantaged District um so they did not have enough gate receipts to cover Athletics so they couldn't afford pay to play or they wouldn't have any kids playing at all so there was a large sum

019of money transferred out the general fund each year over $300,000 and their recommendation was to stop that and then the board of course had to make a decision well if you stop that our kids just going to leave and go somewhere else because it is extracurriculars and of course you're there for a reason and and they only had a few Athletics and didn't have a lot of other arts or other uh band was was dwindling so so they'll come back with recommendations and then as a board and we would work with the administration to to prioritize or take or reject or sure act on they will have a post atic conference um it is not public but they will have a post AIT conference with Board of Education and the superintendent make their recommendations and

020then from there you make your recommendations and then report them to the public and then the report is eventually the public now the report is public so if we were to do an external audit and wait and it could take up to 12 months that would obviously limit our ability to get on the ballot anytime soon um are you saying saying that with the cuts that we made um in January that that would be okay with the cuts that you made in January and proposed cuts that we have on the table right now with again to be fiscally responsible we have to continually think about this so This District stays what we want it to be yes I think we would be okay I think we definitely have to do the audit you know for

021sure but I don't know about I I see the pros and cons on each internal and external but I think if we I was for uh I was up for a May retry because I was you know desperate to avoid some of these painful Cuts but if we can you know pull back on that because we've got more time than we thought then I don't see the urgency for May correct so so we talked about grade banded Schools transportation cuts and changes in pay pay to play so we talked about the extreme of all those but am I hearing that we could perhaps do just transportation and pay to playay and hold off on sister schools for uh another year without speaking for Mr spiser I believe you can that's an that could be an

022option excuse me thank you Mr sper choking me up uh I I do have some slides I like to cover I think it'll cover some of this that you know after treasure acrian and I have had a chance to have some conversation about this and the potential um you know what could be next Beyond you know the need for a levy at some point um so with that um yes we we have had some Community uh input we do have on the calendar uh eight Community listening sessions we've been able to hold two of them and we have two more this week uh Beyond um just tonight so we'll be doing that but wanted to give you um the community some insights some feedback uh about the 1% income tax and why potentially it failed

023you know one of the uh most obvious things I think that we've heard quite a bit from everyone is the just economic conditions and concerns overall inflation is High the cost of of everything is high uh and and just you know the economy in general was is just not great uh but what we did hear um I think one example um from one Community member is you know someone that lives in the city of Milford so they have a 1% income tax they also work in another community that had a 1.7% income tax there is no reciprocity with that community and and uh the city of Milford and then therefore they would also then have the uh the school earned income tax that'd be 3.7% so there are some examples of that out there and

024we did hear those um we did hear that there's some misinformation uh about budgets uh you know the facilities and and funding and how those things happened um you know again a majority of our voters one of the most important things that I think that we've learned is that there are about 36,000 registered voters in the Milford schools community and our parents represent 22% of that electorate our parents alone cannot get us across the finish line and so it is the greater School community that we really need to listen to and I think I heard Morris say that in the beginning of this meeting and I've heard it before from others is that this is a community effort this is our Comm Community uh and the schools are the Hub of the community and so

025we need to listen um and we're going to continue to have these listening sessions uh along the way uh again and I think there were some communication challenges it it's a it's a an earned income tax is complex uh it takes some some time to understand uh we had some um even some folks that would not be affected by the earn income tax still thinking that it would uh so I think there's some things there um that we have to take a look at but we definitely heard one thing people love their their neighborhood schools they love them and it's not just about convenience it really is about the staff the teachers uh our principes uh and there are some of them here tonight our principes are here there's some some teachers that are here

026as well it's really them you know they build that Community uh and it's really them and and we've heard that we've we've heard that for for several several years that our parents and students love they love their schools they love their teachers um and so you know that was um that was out there so also just a better a desire to really understand uh what grade band in schools and what that would mean so with that said having a conversation multiple conversations with treasure arrian I would like to propose a couple things to you tonight for for your consumption um and one would be that I I think I just heard uh Treasurer arriman say is we need some time I mean he needs some time as the new Treasurer uh to dig in um

027to look and have a fiscal review of everything uh we've had two uh treasurers interims uh since since January and so this would give uh him an opportunity to dig in with his staff uh to see what is there um and then be able to then make you know potential future uh you know recommendations for C Etc uh I think that you know some of the things that we could do going into it some of our veteran staff members could now uh potentially take advantage of Str strs is the state teachers retirement system reducing retirement by one year so um we'll potentially have some of that doesn't mean we're not going to replace them but it could it could be um through attrition that we're able to find Fiscal uh efficiencies and continue to be

028fiscally responsible John can you explain that a little bit more and how we weren't expecting that how that's something they moved through the legislature that we weren't really expecting so the um the scrs board um had been talking about it it's been kind of Whispers especially if you're a veteran teacher staff member who's been close to that 33 um and in in November they made that decision um so they did decide to move it to 33 uh it has been at 35 years for quite some time um and so they reduced it to 34 I think that was last year year before maybe and this November they changed it to 33 so it does um you know while there are great advantages of having a veteran teacher teachers that have been around for 30 plus

029years you know that you know there has been some criticism I think about oh this teacher makes so much money well they've been doing it for 30 some years that's why um they're they're expensive right uh but we're in the people business that's what we do um so there's the potential savings there if you're able to hire someone that is not 33 years versus someone that is 012 34 five Etc uh or if we're able to through attrition to not replace that position right have we had some signal that they may take advantage of that already I know of one for sure I know of two she so maybe three more um I think yeah think people are again this this happened early November I think people are trying to weigh their options um and

030what's best for them and and potentially their families uh and so I think you know the other thing is you know I have a a slide to talk to you about um all day kindergarten uh increasing that tuition uh if we're able to to keep our neighborhood schools uh it will not be a 100% coverage of that but it does uh help the overall all balance sheet uh and then our busing savings you know we've talked about you know just going to State minimums 2 mile from the end of your driveway to the student drop off there there's a savings of$ 500 to a million dollars versus um if we were to go to the state you know minimum Transportation with our Bandit schools that would be $200 to $500,000 saving there there's still a

031savings but it's not it's almost double if we're able to um do it with our current um setup with neighborhood schools uh and so with that what I would ask for you to consider is looking at our current Kinder kindergarten all day kindergarten uh total Appropriations for the 2425 school year $1.7 million to run that that's about 8,056 cost per student our current fee is 3600 I would propose $5,000 for all day kindergarten tuition that's an increase of $1,400 that is an uh additional Revenue that could be generated by doing so is $400,000 with the current number we're using the current kindergarten numbers also note that there are no scholarships so we we do have scholarships uh out there right now that we give to some of our our families there would be no no

032Scholarships in this and that's how you can get to the $400,000 um now in the in the area uh if you go to St Andrews St Elizabeth an seatan if you're a parishioner it's 5850 if you're a non-p parisher at 7200 same thing with St Columban uh Miami Valley 7500 and these numbers are directly from their their websites and so as you can see the average is about 7,000 so we're still below that we are still we would still be able to offer all day kindergarten and as we know our students do best when they are in all day kindergarten so there's uh any questions that you'd like to ask about all day do we have any Community Partners that might be able to help with the scholarships yes I I think uh treasur acrian

033made a comment yesterday I I'll let him do it um I don't want to steal any Thunder no you're at all I I I think that yes to answer your question I think we can find Community Partners um and I'm not picking on the foundation please don't I won't um I think with between the foundation and creating something there and and you know we also have pay to play I think there's somebody out there that might be able to help us or an organization that might be able to help that um so it's it's you know I did State a few minutes that's all about reducing expenditures and I only say that because we don't make anything and we don't sell anything we have to control our expenditures but these are areas where we can

034help oursel and these organizations are there to help us so and the scholarships aren't necessarily just for financial need right there are they is it also students who just desperately need full day to be ready for first grade they're they're mostly Financial oh it is awarded yes yeah they're typically are and potentially at risk students that are at risk or you know have a lot of trauma Etc and and really need to be in all day my big question on this I'm sorry I'm gonna speak for the foundation we have always approached seniors who were graduating that we could give the scholarships so they could go on or in a trade school situation they could pursue their their trade uh to another level um but we've never ever given any thought at all to providing

035funds for the lower grades and so it's something that I'd be willing to bring to our next board meeting because I think it's it's doable you'd have two votes right here uh Paul um is at the podium I think he's got a few words for us about kindergarten so I think what's important is um and treasur acrian can talk a little bit about this is we would collect 5,000 on top of our state share correct yes okay so the district would bring in somewhere around 7 7,300 $10 is per student so when you see the cost of 8,000 I think you can get an idea that we're shrinking the difference between what our costs are and um you know with the tuition and on top of the state share so and I think going back

036I think Dr frell was instrumental in bringing about um the all day kindergarten model and I think it's important if families still don't know this in the area the state does not fund all day kindergarten um so it is a if you choose to have it you can use some of your federal funds and others which you know treasure acrian can talk about what we get and what we don't get so we've had sort of this model where you've had choice and it's worked for us we have um roughly 211 students this year uh in full day and we have 110 in half day and you're not in half day just because you can't afford it there are families that still choose and like having half day uh the difference in full day and half

037day is you have uh some more intense time for actual education enrichment you have more time for socialization and you do are you are exposed to PE physical education art and music you know if you are in our halfday program uh it is pretty heavy on the academic side it's pretty quick you know typically you do your your uh Ela and you're really great reading or language arts really great reading you may have stations or purpose will play for about 15 minutes not every day then you have your math investigations and in some places your stations have your science and your social studies or it's woven into the the ELA learning I was just going to add that some children are in half day because they didn't make the lottery for full day I I

038had two granddaughters and one made it and one did not and um that is typically true but we do offer when we have spaces you can go to another building you just are not provided Transportation uh one of the things that we would have to work out should you reinstitute all day kindergarten and move to a different model is if we did not fill a classroom at 24 so metav view is a great example you have two full days and you have two half day sections I hope I'm right Nicole great so we typically cap out uh at 24 students if we are needing to run 20 in each room and we have no one left in the lottery there might be potential for us to have eight Scholarships in that building everything in this

039model is going to be dependent on how many students enroll in kindergarten so I just I you know and I think um research is pretty clear I I I believe you know as one of the academic core ademic folks in the district that we should continue the model that we have now uh but I think we also have to acknowledge the research that if you're in half day and or full day typically by the end of third grade you see everything level out but we do want to be able to continue I think we've really worked hard to live in the world of choice and I think you know should we be able to extend out and Shrink our losses a little bit but again it's really going to depend on how many kids enroll

040to and that's the X Factor with kindergarten so I just wanted to share those facts with you and for scholarships we are currently this year at $120,000 that's typically four five per building John is is yeah okay are we using any federal funds for all day kindergarten at this point I don't believe so okay um my other question and I think it's a big question is a timing issue um because I know we had a lot of parents planning to move out of the district because we said that if this failed we were going to take away all day kindergarten if we would decide like tonight that we're going to move forward with all day kindergarten um what what does that do for like enroll like for timing what does that do for enrollment for

041kindergarten for all day kindergarten look Paul can't wait to get up there but we're ready we're ready to go we we have been living in both worlds U we just have because you know if the board decides to put something on in May and it passes and we're back to normal then we're ready to go so um my team the principles we've been living in in Two Worlds uh and so I'm gonna let Paul go because he jumped up I I just our our timeline is January we typically have our kickoff meeting where we talk with parents about the difference between all day and half day what other services we offer if you do choose half day how we partner with local agencies that may transport or not transport but that's all done in January

042and we did a really good job of building out that system with our elementary principles last year that we really would need to take about an hour revamp the presentation um if you did vote to increase tuition we would be ready to go uh to maybe maybe a week or two later just so get the date out but it wouldn't push we're currently enrolling for preschool priority I believe and then we're we're in our timelines like we're not outside of any timelines I just think if families are pursuing a private school or looking at a open enrolling in another District that does have all day K I think I believe inside of our normal timelines we haven't gone G too far to lose them yet but I think the message has to be really clear

043what we're offering and what we're not offering because I think for our principles and our teachers and our families that's key at this time is what is the clear message that we're saying for next year what we're doing do you have any projection on like what the kindergarten sizes will be or is that something you won't know until January with the kickoff they are down this year that because of the change of enrollment where we move the start date from uh August 1 to September September September 30th so we moved it backwards from September 30th September Baby by the way all the way to August 1st so we are a little lower I do believe this year and so um we would expect to capture maybe this and a little more because we have those

044kids that were stuck in between and if they didn't go to a district that didn't move their timeline they're out there waiting for us so I I think we'd be somewhere in this time frame I think we have 10 full day 10 full day teachers yeah and we we anticipated 30 to 50 students difference from that date change so when we worked with our Elementary staff to to come up with that to move it looking with at our emis data with Lisa hair 30 to 50 kids is what we projected would would fall back each from the current uh at that time for the the later date we've also talked about and and we have to research a little bit the law is around the idea if you have um if you have two half

045days that are really low like for example Patterson and Cy Belo can you merge them in one of the buildings so you can be efficient and condense one of those but we really haven't worked through that is another route as Jeff would say and uh what that does but Jenny works really hard to find efficiencies in the prek area because it is pre- Tok because in kindergarten it's not uncommon for us to have to maybe have a section one year but not have it the next year and she works really hard to balance that out I think one of the things we saw this year with half day was some smaller sections and we thought moving forward can we merge them and and transport and how would that look and would there be a savings

046I have heard from families um that all day option is a really important option um and I think it makes sense to update the fee it still is uh in line less than anything anything locally um and my of my four kids my oldest who graduated last year was here before we did all day canart so it wasn't an option for him um but I really do think the benefit for for those students who want it makes sense and I know this is something that like we don't talk about but if you have a family with two working parents all day kindergarten is sometimes the only option because you're also looking at it as child care as well and so I think that is also really important in addition to all the growth and everything

047that happens with all day kindergarten one thing I do think is that if we bring all day kindergarten back I think the Board needs to make a decision on this quickly because I would like to stick with our January timeline because I think it's really important for parents to know what is going to to be happening for their children in the next school year yeah this is something too that can be you know reverse right we can reduce the cost just like we can raise it so it's one of the things that can you know although it's not good to raise the cost it's something that should a levy pass next time around we can we can lower it or if we find other cost saving someplace else so it's definitely a good good place

048to save some money I mean I will say that you know we will'll need to put a a asserted effort on the scholarship piece right because just because what you just said right I mean two family two two two uh adult working household you know 35 of them would be in pretty rough shape if uh there's no scholarships for their kids to be able to go to kindergarten all day so um but we can tackle that in committee and try to find some Partners to to work on with that yeah roughly 20% of our families are on free and reduced so it is an equity piece that's important to us I mean um so we're we're right there with you and I'm I'm sure over the years if if there were some Partners I think

049the district but we're always willing to say shake new trees and overturn you know new avenues but it is we have been very generous as a district I think in in order to meet that Equity piece uh and and to acknowledge that our community is 20% free and reduced well and I think it's important to point out that the all day kindergarten is um a benefit to the students and the families but it's also a benefit to the teachers you know I see a first grade teacher back there that I I'm sure wishes everybody was in all day kindergarten they're just prepared they're more they're ready to learn to read right and I think that's one of our struggles I think it's about a 24% difference in our uh screener our Universal screener just seeing

050where kids are in that fall and spring and when winter right now we see about a 24% difference uh between those who are in all day and those who are in half day and then we see even a greater level of achievement for our students who uh were in preschool who came to us either through our preschool or a a private partner what about uh like a $5,100 proposed fee and keeping some quantity of scholarships say that again like if instead of this says $5,000 what if it was $5,100 and there was was still some partial scholarships or um something like that because 5100 is still cheaper than any of the options yes of local um of the of the local qu days I don't know how much how much would that be 100 21

051students yeah 200 plus times $100 something it would raise you about uh it would raise you from 295 400 to 500 so about 21,000 quick math on the Google Sphere Excel Google sheet yeah it's just something I mean it's still the kindergarten is still cheaper and if you're a working family and you get half day then you're you're also using Kinder bus you know one of the local daycare providers would probably fill in that the rest of that time and that cost will be easily $5,000 for 5100 yeah that's good we we have the potential to use title dollars as well so we could keep it at the five but use our title monies U Federal those federal funds to do that as well okay and Mr arri would know best of what a hundred

052th000 would do longterm you know to the fiveyear forecast I you know what would that 100,000 what would it buy us 10 days would it buy us 5 days would it buy us a month I mean every penny matters I don't want to I do think from an education perspective I'm not the money guy Equity is really important when you look at the community as a totality we don't want to keep anybody at of all day K because they can't afford it and sometimes circumstances are not defined by the child child so that's truly important to that that piece for us I agree 100% on that I do think it's important to look at how we're using our title funding because I don't want to take it away from anything that's really important uh right

053now that we're getting a lot of benefit from but also I mean Studies have showed that the sooner you get kids in there and reading um the more successful they're going to be and the less they're going to have interventions later using title funding for this or not y so ultimately you know going to all day kindergarten really comes back to uh keeping our community schools and so I you know with that I think that it's important for us to remember that you know we aspire to be a destination District not only for our families and for our students but also for our staff um and that just a reminder that our staff really is I said it earlier that's it's the heart of our district it's what we do um and we cannot really

054aspire to be that destination District if we're going to let go of 30 plus staff members uh and transitioning The District in that way um and so if if treasure acrian you know says that we can buy some additional time and some potential continue uh efficiencies and fiscal responsibility you know I think that um if we can keep 30 staff members then I'm clearly going to suggest to you that it is my duty to say that we should put sister grade Bandit schools off to the side it's still an option in the future if it gets to that um and just know that um you know we're we're we as a as a group the board included are doing what we can to to maintain the quality education that we have right now um and

055keep that Excellence um and um so that would be my my suggestion for this piece right now I do have one more suggestion and that's pay to play um can I say one thing real quick about grade band schools I think it's important to point out that it would just be a deferral while we're waiting for this information you know because we have bought some time so it's another year and just thinking about the logistics after the levy failed I thought how are we you know people are going to be looking for jobs and packing up their rooms and then hopefully would pass and then okay never mind the move is off but and some people would have already accepted other jobs and everything so I think it it's smart to wait till we have

056more information I will say too um Morris had spoken and said um that he wanted the community to contact us and we have received so many emails and texts and conversations and phone calls and almost all of them are about the neighborhood schools um it's very clear that the community is extremely passionate about the neighborhood schools um and all of these emails were urging us to find any way that we could to keep them um or at least reconsider them so I do want to acknowledge that we do hear you and we do read your emails and we do hear what you're saying about the neighborhood schools um and to piggy back on that the the second part of the conversation or the emails was often let us go again let us try again it

057was very passionate families and teachers and community members who wanted to try again so whe when this comes back up that's what we're going to be leaning into um I think uh only a quarter of the families are are have students and so we need that quarter every every bit of that quarter talking to a quarter of their neighbors and the other quarter of the neighbors down the street because um I think the awareness when Mr sper showed what people missed it was awareness oh my gosh I didn't know this was happening so the um the message from families of please let us try to pass this again um we're going to need everybody to kind of Link arms and and find six friends to to do that too well and I wanted to point

058out too after the levy after the E failed and as they said we got calls we got emails please put it on in put on get a little get a little closer so the people at home can hear you oh thank you okay um after the failed we got these messages as they said regularly and a lot of them wanted us to put the issue back on the ballot in May and I called the Board of Elections to find out what would it cost us to do that and I was told they don't have the they didn't have the number for 2024 but using last year's figure it would cost us $103,000 to put it on the ballot and if somebody else had an issue then we could share the cost if they didn't we

059would be paying that full cost and it's like that's unacceptable I mean how can we do that we're telling people we don't have money but we're going to spend $100,000 at least to put it back on the and try again so I just want to make sure that everybody out there knows that because I had no idea it was that much I was shocked okay um our final uh item that I'd like to discuss a little bit here is um pay to play um I think the The Proposal we can get into the details here and I'm actually going to have uh Josh Kaufman come up um the spreadsheet master uh and help help explain some of this to you but in the end what we're proposing is uh doubling our current pay to play

060which is significantly less than the current proposal and I think maybe back up and just say that you know we heard the board uh loud and clear that you would like to also see a different approach a tiered approach something um that would not be quite as drastic knowing that um a drastic increase in pay-to-play fees uh will certainly limit the number of folks that could participate but and also potentially uh decimating programs uh in general uh and it also becomes economics right uh whether or not you can feeli a team or not what's the right amount um so the short answer is 200 at the high school becomes 400 100 becomes 200 at the junior high there would be no um no cap and it would be for every season and then um I'm

061going to let Josh speak specifically about some of the the plays the musicals and um clubs Etc and then also a proposal of an activity fee of $25 or $50 uh and I'll let Josh talk a little bit about that and then he passed out the same sheet that's up on the screen just a little bit easier for the board to read and for those of you at home and those that are here this this slideshow will be available on our website so it will be available to you as well Josh take take it away yeah thank you so uh Mr Spicer asked us to working with Mr zubkin Mr trout we were all kind of able to get in the room and and pour together uh into these numbers that you'll see um and

062wanted to look at a couple different impact points uh as it relates to pay to play and before we kind of get into the minutia I want to be really clear I want to Echo a few things that Paul said our Core Business is education that is the nuts and bolts of what we do um however the Arts the Athletics the the extracurriculars they they give the color to our district right they they are our front facing they are the front porch to our district community in a lot of ways so certainly you know our Core Business is is the academic piece but these are important part of what we do and also you know to Mr Spicer's point and Paul mentioned it also you when we start talking about some of these numbers we

063are talking about Equity pieces and as we fight for our kids and creating these opportunities for kids um one thing that I believe this Community is not about is programming that is only available to our wealthiest students so it's finding that kind of sweet spot where um we recoup some of the expenses that are associated with these but we still make them accessible so uh as we looked at different scenarios uh you'll see kind of the breakdown uh of and you've got um in front of you uh a little bit different than what's up here you have also the year-to DAT this year numbers those numbers are incomplete because uh as you look at third sport uh type things you know currently those are free in in the current model uh those numbers have not

064been loaded in those teams have not made selections the winter programs in the Arts have not been loaded in yet those rosters were just set within the last couple days so those numbers are kind of up till yesterday uh but these numbers are last year settled in the book so we looked at if we would just not honor any waivers any hardship waivers any free and reduced waivers what the impact to that would be uh so last year that would have generated an additional $1,445 uh then we looked at what if we remove the tiered system the 20000 free um in the Arts we removed that uh after last year to make more customized fees if you recall we really kind of tried to narrow in and hone in on the cost uh to run

065some of those programs uh but in eliminating that last year um last year the Arts were under that tiered system uh if we took away the tiers and we did no waivers that would generate an additional uh almost $770,000 last year and then we looked at what if we had no tiers no waivers and we doubled the fees and as you see there that's that $400,000 number uh we also had some discussions about um we do have a number of activities where uh there's no pay-to-play fee associated with it however the district pays an adviser to run that uh to compensate for their time outside the classroom after school uh student council that coordinates homecoming there's a lot of hours involved in that we pay an advisor to do that um we don't don't charge

066the students to be involved in student council we don't charge students to be in National Honor Society or Key Club or a lot of those organizations so as you see here in the last two columns we also modeled what it would look like if we assessed a $25 per year activity fee so the first time a student hits an activity that's not a payto playay activity first time a kids in National Honor Society or student counsil whatever that is they would receive a $225 or $50 activity fee that would essentially grant them participation in all activities throughout the year that are not pay to play so it's not $25 or $50 per activity it's it's that first one that triggers it um so as you see that modeling there um in the highest case scenario

067it would generate an additional uh if we want the $50 fee $433,000 uh last year is what it would have generated this year um if the numbers were settled today it would be close to 300,000 but again we've not added in of the winter activities and all the spring activities so that would go up pretty significantly as well so um but I want to thank Mr zukka Mr trout um and Mr Spicer for all and Mr acman everybody was in the room Paul was in the room uh to help us kind of come up with these numbers um what questions can I answer for you Josh can you give us an example of the activity fee the first time it might hit in the fall and then what would happen you know in the spring

068if if I hit it again like just as an example so people understand you're talking the the single the 25 25 or the 50 if the board decides to do that yeah so a student uh join student council and they help with homecoming they're going to receive that $25 fee and then come uh October they get tapped for National Honor Society is that what you're so they would then they've already paid their fee they just move into National Honor Society now if they didn't do student counsel or didn't do a in National Honor Society was their first activity the $25 fee would be attached to that um that is I you know to be frank with you that's a daunting um it's a daunting amount of work we have about 742 students at the high

069school that are not involved in um an athletic activity or um a fine arts activity um that is a lot of bookkeeping um that's a lot so I think one of the things the board has that would come out of my office and as I you know um I had a lovely parent at a band concert last week and she said are you the only Fine Arts administrator here this evening and I said ma'am I'm the only Fine Arts staff member um so that is that is a daunting amount of work but if that's the board's desire we'll make it happen um but I do think there's a cost benefit analysis you know that the Board needs to weigh there um yeah um not to sound awful as we are all talking about Equity but

070I also want to balance that with fiscal responsibility and I think the idea of adding this onetime fee for the activities is smart um would it make sense to raise it just a bit more than $25 because I had been doing a lot of research on like what other schools pay to play is and they're all a lot higher than ours and um like I'm not trying to make these activities exclusive but I do want to be very fiscally responsible if we are taking a step back and taking some things off of the table and as you said it's a ing amount of work so I don't want that $25 fee that then has to be worked into um a working plan for somebody to figure out um to not be worth it yeah I

071understand what you're you're saying I think that's a very valid point um I think that you know certainly those are just two different snares 25 and 50 it could be 30 it could be you know and you can kind of look at the the difference of the variance in between I will say that outside of you know we've added significantly to the pay to-play programming on the Arts and extracurricular side since I've been in this role um when I stepped into this role the only activities that were pay to play was band um so we've added drama we had a choir Esports robotics unified cheer several of them a lot of the activities that we run out of the junior high and high school that do not have payto playay attached to them not all

072of them but the majority of them I would say phoned one of two buckets they are either academic extracurriculars so I think of National Honor Society I think of Spanish club or German club or those types of things that are really more academic in nature or they service organizations Key Club student council National Honor Society so I think we also want to be very careful that there's a you know it's supply and demand we don't know we don't really know what participation will look like until we put a number in place right so we've got 150 students involved in student council at the high school this year um at $25 at $50 I don't suspect that number is going to be the same um what that number is going to go down to I don't

073know um and you know we try to project and find that sweet spot because at the end of the day we also need enough students in student council to run homecoming um in some of those things and I think that you know those are things to consider um you know we are in looking at doubling the activity fees for across the board um that's pretty significant um and I'm not going to you know sugarcoat for some of the our programs that that amount will cause some of our programs to shutter I think that that's that's the reality um and and ideally at some point we can get those back or we can lean into some booster groups you know we've been working really closely with our booster groups and said you know kind of pump

074the breakes on buying stuff um we really want to see funds leverage to help our kids moving forward and create opportunities um you know I know for the band booster fee we've talked a lot about that being $500 for next year um I think we're going to make really substantial progress on getting that down um to try to keep it affordable and keep our kids involved because these these programs are important to our community I believe that is there a way to have a Student Activity fee for just all students that's exactly what I'm sitting here thinking that's what I did in college I I don't know that you can assess that to students that are not involved in activities I think that they have to now you could apply universally and say you know

075my son pays a no matter he's in seventh grade no matter if he's on the basketball team or if he's in Builder club or Key Club the fee is the same and it's across the board you know I think that that's an option but again I think that that number based on some of the things that we've looked at I think that that number needs to be at a point where it's so high that I think things like Key Club or student council or National Honor Society they they really start kind of falling apart yeah and I have a problem with that because I mean student council you're you run for it and you're elected and then it's like but now you're charged and Honor Society National Honor Society you earn that and it's an

076invitation you know so I'm just really conflicted I and I Echo that I I feel that same kind of internal conflict where um you know recognizing the financial situation that we're in it's very real yes but also feeling like we want students and families to be in a position of needing to buy accolades and that doesn't feel great we are there are we are paying for staff to cover it though so I mean the activity fee is going to staff time right so we're not just like activity fee general fund I mean it's it's covering staff time because none of those exist if there's not a staff who's willing to so if we charge an activity fee for every student and that would give them a right that would cover them for anything that they

077wanted to participate in but I think Josh is saying that's kind of hard to I I think that if you if you had a lower amount if it was a lower amount I think we could but I I I want to caution I don't I don't suspect that we can charge that just universally to every child no I think they have to participate to be charged a fee correct um yeah um and remind me the doubling it would be everything it would everything 200 to 400 it say High School two Athletics 200 to 400 400 season every season No Cap no family cap No Cap yep in athletics it would be um yes 200 to 400 100 to 200 for junior high in the Arts um they would um and I can provide this to

078you offline if you'd like but because we went to specified yep a non-tiered system for marching band it would go from 200 to 400 Winter Garden Winter drum line $125 to $250 um choir would go from $100 to $200 um drama uh this year we charge $75 for a straight play that would go to 150 for a musical 125 would go to 250 Esports would go to um from 75 to 150 per season we charge 75 per season BattleBots would go from 150 to 300 unified cheer would go from 100 to 200 so um I think that those are you know significant numbers I also think that you know whether it's our booster groups or outside groups I think what Mr akman mentioned is really significant that um there I I believe there are people

079in this community that want to help um and I believe that there are people in the broader community that um you I'm just going to put this out into the air because there there are people in the greater Cincinnati community that can leverage their dollars to make life changing change for our students um private schools do it all the time they endow programs right so they create endowments that perpetually fund programs um I love him I hope that he's okay I I heard he HT his knee last night Joe burrow just spent $2.8 million on a Batmobile and that $2.8 million would fund pay to play for the Arts in perpetuity in Milford so if we can start thinking that way and if there are people out there in the community $3 million ows the

080Arts in perpetuity I'm sure Joe Burrow's watching this right now you know what Mike Michael I am taking that chance I am taking that chance every time every time uh so I I think uh the recommendation that I would make to you would be the the second to the last one which would be the note uh excuse me doubles it everything's doubled no tears no waivers and a $25 activity fee going forward that's what I would recommend to you um I think it's the best we can do at this time what do our waivers cover like what what qualifies you for a waiver uh free and reduced lunch typically or a hardship of some sort yeah and that's this so that's that bottom line last year was $112,000 yeah so there's you know uh Aon

081zepkas in the in the audience here Josh and then Mark trout I've talked all three of them their booster groups are waiting to help and Joe Barrow is as well so we we we will have opportunities for for those um that that would need it but there this also becomes fundraising for for these students becomes more important uh it comes to the front now and so they're going to have to to step up their game if you will um just like other districts and students have and um so that would be my recommendation at this point I um I I think this recommendation was significantly more palatable than going fully loaded I was really nervous when I heard basketball turns into $1,00 a season like that just means we would we would crush JV freshman

082team teams I don't know who Who as a freshman would would be um able to pay that much for multiple students so I think the 400 or four possibly 425 I suppose um feels much more palatable hopefully it will not be as impactful on families um to be limiting and frankly 400 is still cheaper than you'd pay for a season of sports anywhere you know um so so if we're looking at your proposed number here the 6945 40 plus the potential savings from busing which is 500,000 to 1 million is that correct correct okay so we're looking [Music] at bringing in 1.2 to $2.2 million of savings with our Cuts just to clarify though the new Revenue Mrs Mason is this $433 okay okay yeah that's the $50 activity fee I thought justed yes you're

083correct 46 416 Plus in last year's numbers right Doug how soon would you be able to get you know how you had your graph that showed it needing we needed uh help in by 27 no it was 26 and 28 could you get an updated one for like if we modify these I I'll be able to give you some update ated graphs um within a couple months so I've got things that I'm already putting in place so great something you'll see on Thursday if you want to come to the finance meeting 7:30 A.M 7:30 in a.m the the last thing that I would like to just put a pin in you these numbers were based on the kids that participated last year right so you know that revenue is going to be determined by the

084number of kids that particip please remember this is revenue and we we talking about expenditures now this just reduces expenditures a different way so Mr sper was that your last slide oh there we go that's it question I have a question uh I know there were a long list of cuts that you presented in um I think September and what I was wondering if those some of those cuts if we know are off the table I know you and I and I think I've heard everybody say it separately that we wouldn't be voting to eliminate Fine Arts so I would love it if we could take things we know like that off that list for just the morale of the teachers involved absolutely yeah so I think going forward working with uh treasure acrian what

085we'll do is um depending on where you go with with the recommendations we'll we'll work together to continue to find efficiencies and then begin a new list and then beyond that list would then also be potentially items from his own performance audit financial performance audit plus the performance audit by the state and then from our perspective we will remove that item for sure because I again I'll say it again no no art music in the elementary we're keeping it it's never going away as long as I'm your superintendent and you don't vote for it um so yeah we can do that um I just have a couple questions because I've been taking notes I just want to make sure that all the information I have is correct um and this is a question for Doug

086so basically when you looked at our fiveyear forecast that was just presented the November the yes okay the November um you said that the cuts that we made in January plus these potential cuts of busing and um increasing payto playay MH would allow us to maybe not go on the ballot like in May or November because it would give us time to reconsider all of these things things all of your options correct um and then um this is this is actually just a question that I have um so if we hold off on going to the ballot um what kind of factors should we be monitoring over the next few months to determine the right timing for the levy well I will be giving you once a month and updated 5year forecast based on the

087current fiscal year so it basically shows our cash flow that will be able to tell us everything we need to know and honestly the way the system works submitting two forecasts a year is is very beneficial um May probably more so than November November you're just getting the year started you have an idea what's happening but by may you have a better snapshot and then um if we do delay cut cutting neighborhood schools um or holding another Levy this year are there any risks to that besides just having the higher cash balance is there any risk to continuing with the neighborhood schools uh no no no like because we're talking about delaying The Cutting of neighborhood schools and we're also talking about delaying putting a levy on the ballot are there like any other risks

088that we need to be thinking about there's a few things that I think we need to do um most of them are related to our infrastructure and things that we're you know where we're making payments um I know we're not here to discuss those things right now but um it has been brought up in the listening sessions um and we need to take pressure off the general fund that's we're utilizing some of those funds to pay for the uh the various buildings so restructuring the debt restructuring the debt okay yes um we didn't talk very much about Transportation can you pull up the transportation slide uh the slide that at the bottom one of your first slides uh yeah busing savings wait that that one the so the bottom bullet there so we have an

089option that we're still talking about so um transportation so if we don't do the sister school so we keep Community Schools we're looking at that first bullet Savings of State minimums of half a million to a million dollars correct so um we haven't really discussed what that looks like are we in are we at like where are people feeling and and can I say that half of that is high school and half is State and minimums and Elementary because we have that option right we could say only cut High School you you could do that and um but that would change that number y uh and we would have to go back to them um so it our our bill if you will is based on the number of routes and so that's what would

090determine whether it's closer to the million or closer to the 500 um I'm going to look and then the the other piece I wanted to bring up so when we were at osba uh Capital conference we talked to Peterman and we asked Mr Peterman I don't know what his name is his name is not Mr Peterman but maybe his dad was Mr Peterman Mike settle there you go Mike settle okay we asked Mr Peterman um what would happen like so if we cut busing for next school year to potentially save half a million to a million dollars and we have a November ballot and it passes what does it look like to bring it back like can we bring it back the next day um and one of the things he said that I had

091not considered was it depends on how we tell them to pause so there is um if we have hoped that it would come back in November we cut it in August we could pay a retainer essentially because uh Staffing bus drivers is not easy right so if we say we don't need any bus drivers it's he said it would probably take until maybe the next year to bring it back um just because of Staffing and then he has the buses and they have a lot of infrastructure they have to maintain so even if the savings was half a million to a million there is also that added factor of do we tell Peterman to hold on and if that's the case he thought that it might be possible to pass in November and bring busing

092back in January did I hear did that make sense yeah it makes sense I don't I mean I think if we cut it it's just cut and then we figure it out when things come back versus is having a retainer on the books I agree yeah what were your thoughts on the just high school if you just do high school the scenario that they ran would only save us maybe $200,000 it's not enough are there Vans or any type of support for families that are within two miles that just like the the walk isn't safe and the kids can't get like do we have any option for it would be private yeah okay um I have a few practical questions about the blessing and I know that uh we've been talking with Peterman so hopefully

093we have answers but I don't know the first one is we've confirmed with OD W that it's not a radius of two miles so it's where your driveway meets the road to the student drop off point okay um and then how will family know this like obviously they're not going to go measure it themselves correct I think they could probably use Google Maps but that would not necessarily be accurate because it has to be with the versatran software and the route that the bus actually takes right and so um we would do our best to to communicate that as soon as possible right and so as soon as Peterman can get those uh families plugged in and get them routed we would we would put P that out do we have like an estimate on

094what that would be once we made the decision on the timing I will ask them to have it done yesterday that because most of it's done in the software that should should be a relatively easy process okay um keep in mind I wasn't here the last time this Milford was at State minimums one of the the challenges is if you and I are neighbors I might get transportation and you might not there there is a divider that is literally from one house to the to the next door neighbor where Transportation stops um it it's hard to Grapple with it's hard to understand why you know the bus is coming down my neighborhood you know when you're picking up my neighbor but you can't pick up me um but that's the reality of how that TW

095mile you know no transport ation Zone Works um Mr spiser mentioned about you know just doing eliminating High School transportation one of the reasons that's less of a savings in Milford than it is in some other districts is because we're still sending buses to that campus because we have the middle school that we'll still be transporting students to so there's obviously less students on those buses which means less buses so there is savings but because we're still sending rout to that campus every day to transport our 68 middle school students it's not as big of a savings as it is in some other districts and I'm assuming that since uh we're talking about cutting all busing this wouldn't affect school start times I think it could I think it could because most likely what we

096would do is currently the middle school well it's the junior high now obviously but the junior high and high school have the same start times we would most likely shift the high actually probably shift both of them potentially so that we don't have all the traffic from the high school coming in on campus at the same time the Middle School's coming in so we would we would look to shift those start times um we don't know exactly what that looks like um Middle School might move up a little bit High School might move back a little bit maybe it's just the high school moving back we don't know but we have definitely talked about if we eliminate High School transportation that we would probably shift school start times and I'm assuming that because of that

097it's also going to affect how long kids are on the bus like if they're on the bus for 10 minutes right now they could have a longer ride sure um honestly I'm not sure how to answer that question okay I don't want to guess so I think the change in times also is a matter of three tiers of busing so we got to get the first tier in and get them out out to get the second tier and then to the third tier and then some of our buses only run two tiers and some of them run all three um and state minimum busing is k through eight k through eight eight okay so they all and two mile and two mile so the the Junior High kids would get busing that is correct if

098they're more than two miles that is correct but High School is we have zero so there would be zero high school buses correct and then I know that we're required to provide busing for non-public school students as well how would this affect the non-public schools it runs the same way so if they're farther than two miles away we would provide transportation the way we do today whether they're deemed impractical whether we're putting a bus on the road um quite honestly probably the only schools that we transport that would be potentially affected would be Satan and St Marks because they're inside of our School District I don't even think St Columban probably would be affected that's the next closest private school that but no high school do we bust we would not transport any high school

099they would high school priv private high school would then be ineligible for transportation as well regardless of where they go so to summarize what I heard we talked about um the grade banded schools hold and put it on our future cut list but not for next year transportation to State minimums increase play tolay double payto playay and increase all day kindergarten fees is that what I with board members it's double also we have the activity Fe that's new yes plus 25 activity um and those Mr Treasurer th those changes in services and increase in collections would keep us solvent through next year would give us more time definitely to look uh will allow you to start an audit process corre um so we don't have to go in May correct and we gives us more

100time to talk about when we would need to go next corre but even with all these changes we need a levy right eventually we need but we're not the only District that's going to have this problem so yes have we had enough discussion there's just one more thing that I want to throw out to the people who are here and the people who are watching from home is one of the segments of the population that we targeted this year was my generation and up until days before the levy I still talk to people who went I'm not voting for it because I can't afford it you're retired you don't have to pay it they I don't know how we reach the people we need to reach we had four lisening sessions at senior centers and

101yeah Parker do you have for you guys how do we solve the problem I do think part of it is KN on parents yeah we're going to send Parker out Parker Brown around town talking to the seniors um I mean I figured since he was here you know yes but but I do think a big part of uh parents and the 25% of people who who feel the impact uh all finding you know 10 neighbors to to reach out to I think so too critical so we we've already started holding our community feedback sessions we've hosted two so far um our first one was at meow view we had about eight participants not including board members or District leaderships or or Morris over there who I don't think we need to ask for his opinion

102um and then our other one at mberry which had around 35 so I would estimate we've had around 40 participants so far our two Community meetings we have six more for the rest of the sort of a time until January an overwhelming majority have been Pro they've been uh they voted yes they've signed that they have voted yes and will vote Yes Should the district run again uh we've heard a few oppositions so far large a large piece of that is the performance audit they've been asking for the performance audit um and then I would say an overwhelming majority of the people who are there cited concerns of just not being completely informed uh which is partially on my fault but um I mean they we need more runtime uh then evaluation of what the

103district is doing uh so that's been the feedback so far the biggest piece of concern is Sister schools that's what we've been hearing at these sessions there's been a few uh vocal people who were there who are no votes um we heard them and they heard their feedback another piece is we've heard concerns of 1% earned income tax versus just a general income tax versus a property tax uh to be more Equitable as some of the things that we've been hearing uh as far as reaching more of no voters I think that relies on the community um people we we have our hands tied is what I always say as far as what we can communicate as a district our pack does uh a good job communicating a lot of the stuff out here but

104it's all based off the people knocking on doors and talking to other individuals and being more active Community as far as well we've gotten a a bit of news coverage but with a little bit more time to make that announcement uh we could have more news coverage and inform the community who's not actively our parents who I think John said 22% of the voters out there so it's reaching those other 80 something per 8% okay um I just wanted to say something else and it's something that our new treasur touched on at the beginning of uh the session but when we as a board made a decision to outline these to outline these three cuts that we talked about tonight and also that we've been talking about for well in some form over a year

105we always rely on the information that we have at the time um our new treasur has been looking through the numbers and it sounds like he's saying it makes sense to pause um and to me it's very critical that our decisions are based on accurate data and facts so I think that makes sense um but also in the past month and a half we've heard from so many people in the community and we've heard what you passionate about and we haven't had that kind of response to anything in a really long time and I think it's very very important to keep up that Community communication we need to hear what is important to the community and I think Parker's done some really great things um by communicating the information out um I think our social

106media has really shown a lot more um information on things uh the Schoolboard meeting updates um where we have the summaries I think are really great um and I think um these listening sessions have been really valuable for us especially the people who do the exit questions um that help us gather information about what is what people are really passionate about so I think it's really critical that you communicate to us but also I think that as a board maybe we can do a little bit better communicating to you as well um I think as a board it would be nice to set some benchmarks um about what we communicate to the people especially with finances um I know that we have a financial report at the beginning of each meeting but I think it

107might be helpful to talk about what we talk about to the public in that report um um and what we are doing to remain fiscally responsible and I know that's a big part of what um attracted us to hiring Doug in the first place as our Treasurer because that was a big part of his interview he wants to communicate to people in a way that's easy for people to understand so I think we can look at that again um and we just really need to show how we are being accountable to the community how we've learned from the situation and how we're committed to this Good Financial stewardship for our schools agree um and and I um also feel like a lot of the feedback we heard was I'm so confused we don't have to

108we want to know exactly what we're doing and I think part of the problem is that we don't I mean if the answers were clear or easy we would have made them already so I appreciate the patience until we set this meeting up to have this discussion because as a board we are not allowed to discuss these things if you if it's not open to the public and so um I while I hear the frustration uh and it was like wait and listen um I appreciate the fact that we have been able to really look at financial responsibility I think what I heard a lot tonight was Min minimizing disruptions to families because we know these are all big impacts um and that the conversations happen you know with the administration but really when us

109five as a board can can sit here and we haven't been able to do this since two days after the election um so uh we appreciate the the patience and it's coming but I know it's been a whole month of what does this mean for my family and that's uh heartburn inducing for a lot of people so yes so if our discussion is wrapped I'd like to motion an amendment to uh or motion to amend the agenda um is our discussion complete to move on on something like that so so I moved to amend the agenda to include taking action on resending the previously adopted resolution regarding three cuts for the 2526 school year and then uh a subsequent motion will come to include taking action on a revised resolution regarding the some of the

110cuts that we've outlined here tonight Mr Treasurer are we allowed to take action at a work session sure okay it's a public meeting just want to make sure that we we follow the procedures that uh so moved all right right so we have a motion to amend the agenda by Mr Wilson I need a second I'll second it any other discussion um I just want to say I think that this is a good idea because we have families that are waiting and need to know but we also have teachers who are waiting to see what our decision is as well and I think that that's really important to keeping our school district whole right I agree um okay call the role for amending in the agenda we amending the agenda Mrs will yes Mrs Powers

111yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes Mrs Chestnut yes so then I motion uh to resend our previously adopted resolution that called for moving to grade banded elementary schools implementing State minimum busing and moving to 100% pay to play for the 25 26 school year so moved we have so we have first and then a second Mrs Mason yes any discussion did you also say you were gonna have a second motion on what we okay so first motion to resend what we uh had had spoken I want to First fully resend and then we'll we'll motion to adopt and then if what I suggest isn't accurate you guys can suggest to uh you know we can talk about changing that okay okay so call the RO to resend the previous motion Mrs will yes Mrs

112Powers yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes Mrs Chesnut yes so then I motion to move to adopt a revised call saving plan for 2526 that includes increasing payto play um along the fourth tier that we saw which was doubled doubled no tiers no waivers and the $25 activity fee and then also increasing kindergarten tuition to 5,000 from where it is today State minimum busting as we discussed at the end with uh no high school and the two mile radius based on the state's guidelines and then I would like to include that we move on the performance audit even though it's going to cost money to the district I don't see how we get through the objection from some of our no voters and Garder The Confidence from them without doing that I'll second that

113motion any comments uh I I since we're sort of talking about the motion um I appreciate all the work that has been done by the administration and the board members to bring us to hear tonight because I know it was a lot of questions a lot of digging on our own part a lot of what about this and talking to other school districts so um I think that's our this is our function of the board um and I appreciate that the five of us have been able to come together with the administration um to hear the feedback of this is this is way too big of an impact on my family um and how might we move forward a different way any other comments I would just point out that this is um exactly how

114our committee meetings are people don't come to the committee meetings of the only guest that's been at the committee meetings in the last year was me while I was campaigning uh so no one comes but uh when people say you know it's just a 50 vote it's because we have all these discussions in our committee meetings and we can come to an agreement we don't start out agreeing a lot of times and we ask a lot of questions um so this I think is beneficial in that regard yeah and I would just like to add that this and we've talked on this that but these these items are to you know the only thing that we've been able to think of this as is like slowing the burn right so like I know we've talked

115about this a lot um but the deficit spending is not going away right this is a a slow of that so you know it's our hope that you know through throughout the next uh year here going through a performance audit and you know pointing out as Miss Mason said some specific goals and things like that that we can read out to help the education of the Comm community and educating on earned income tax if that's what we decide to move forward with which we'll have to talk about that in some following meetings um but these items are just as slow slow that down right so we'll have to continue as a community to highlight the great things that we do and and the savings that we have and then work to reverse these things because

116you know these are obviously not things that we want to see going up also with I think you brought a good point up about slowing the burn in addition to all this I think we should get the community involved um in part of this process as well we've been talking about it on and off but is I know that we have some restraints from the state with what we can do with levies is there any way we can do something similar to the cat team where we have some work sessions where the public can participate instead of just listening to us yes I think that would be a really great idea yes we can do something very similar to that I think we should talk about that in committee meeting and see how we can

117really hear um what the community has to say and also so they can see and understand some of the constraints that we're up against too with some of the like Ohio Revis code and just some of the things that we deal with so that we can work together to build our schools in the best way that we can absolutely yes I think I was going to suggest that we're going to continue with our uh six lisening sessions that are out there and then we can have further dialogue and discussion about what uh other engagement looks like Beyond uh the first couple weeks of January for those sessions so absolutely and I will just point out that we I think felt passionate about slowing down the grade band schools because that change is irreversible there's no

118coming back from that unless you know millions of dollars would just be bestowed on the district Jo which I don't think it's going to happen you you say his name three times he show you pay to play I mean pay to play we can reduce the rates when we get on an even ke busing you can bring back we've done it in the past um so I I appreciate that we are able to single that out and defer it for now yeah and that it's important to note that the state ever has to come in so if this continues to burn as to go on with the analogy that that I I started things like grade banded schools it's you know it doesn't always happen when the state comes in but there it's possible that

119it cannot be stopped by the board eventually right so I mean bringing these things up and trying to utilize them to you know save the money and get us into better financial situation is uh some of the type of actions that the state could force upon us should we get there so any other discussion um can you just summarize what we're voting on again since we had all this discussion yeah so I I singled out the pay to playay into the fourth column which was doubled uh no tear no waivers and the $25 activity fee the uh increase in kindergarten tuition to $5,000 uh the state minimum of busing as discussed um with the no High School busing and the 2 mile radius um provided by the state guidelines and then to move on the

120performance audit um uh just as soon as Doug can work through that okay any other comments okay Mr Aran call the role Mrs will yes Mrs Powers yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes Mrs Chestnut yes thank you any other discussion the last thing I would say is just you heard it from me for a lot today just to the school administration like it's a huge asterisk for me next to like no waivers no tears any of this stuff that we absolutely bring you know uh the information to the public that if they are you know on free introduce lunch or they're a low-income family or they're just you know going through a hardship that they know to bring that forward so we can try to find options for them before they look elsewhere we

121will make that commitment abely and I just want to take a moment to thank all these people who showed up tonight and there was really no interaction with the board and you but you were patient and you listened and and we appreciate it and I want to encourage anyone who has a concern or a question to please reach out to any of the board members we I promise you we will respond yeah and go to those listening sessions I went to the second one at Meadow View and it was really really really good so they're not they're not recorded just because of the style that they are um and and but you know there might be a board member there or two but that's the maximum we can have but the administration is there and

122um you know now that we've made some of these decisions conversation can even change a little bit from what the previous ones had but you know continue to show up to those that were nice can you remember what are the two this week I believe it's Patterson and boydd Patterson and Boyd patteron tomorrow night tomorrow night 6 o'cl 6 o'cl we'll be in the hopefully the media center Media Center well hopefully not because if it's too too many folks we're going to move to the cafe but there might be basketballs next door so that's what we're going to try there okay Patterson Wednesday night six o'clock Thursday night Boyd Boyd six o'clock yes and I think just one final thought just like while we just saved 30 staff members we're still going to look for

123efficiencies being fiscally responsible and there's a potential for not replacing through attrition like retirements Etc just want to make sure we got that out there right yeah any other business did we have any additional people who had turned in sheets that didn't get to speak can I ask one question really quick um yes ma'am to clarify the other cuts that we did not vote on um you know originally and now like like the Fine Arts people with all there were like a list of things are those off the table officially we no longer have a list we need to create a new list that will make it easier so that list is gone until we come up with a new list okay good that way there's no confusion for anyone yeah no list no there's

124no list at this time okay the list is Michael's uh Michael's Amendment okay uh if that's it we have our next regularly scheduled board meeting here in this room uh Thursday December 19th 6:00 uh 1099 State Route 131 Milford Ohio can I get a motion to adjourn so moved second please call the roll Mrs will yes Mrs Powers yes Mr Wilson yes Mrs Mason yes Mrs Chestnut yes thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.