001this e good evening Welcome to our board meeting this evening for December 19 2024 Thursday we're here at 8:10 west Markham Street um first we going just call the meeting to order and we're going to go ahead and get started with celebrations all right um good evening everyone good evening uh before we get into our traditional um celebrations for the month of December we do want to take uh just a moment to um recognize um a couple of individuals and a couple of schools who are here this this evening um earlier this year actually last summer um we started a push to emphasize uh customer servic across our district um we brought all of our secretaries and Frontline staff um together uh during the summer for uh some training um and some very fun training
002uh with some um what do you call them um scenarios where people were role playing um vignettes and all those different things um the last few weeks we have had some Shoppers actually calling and visiting schools um to kind of see how our customer service training has been paying off in some of our schools and so today we are going to recognize um two individuals in two schools who are being recognized for outstanding customer service going well beyond uh the Call of Duty to provide assistance um to our secret shoppers and so we want to first start by recognizing Miss Christy Hawthorne you come on up and I'm going to I'm going to come down and present you your certificate as soon as I finish calling them all out calling them all out so we
003want to recognize Christy hawthor for meville middle school and we have a separate recognition for mabvi middle school and so we're going to ask Miss Jeter the principal to come up and then we also want to recognize and I hope I pronounced the first name right Danica Danica Miss Danica Carolina from Little Rock Southwest and then we're going to ask uh principal Maxi to come up as well and if you are the board member who represents those schools if you can come back to I'm not but can I come can I get in a picture you can always that's all right everybody look up here maybe I'm not they're not doing it today all right if you haven't been able to attend our incredible performances by lrsd students this week you see some of them
004featured um on the screen you truly miss a treat uh for the past two weeks students from elementary through High School provided inspirational presentations through song dance instruments um and the creative arts and we are so very proud of our students and all of the Talent um that they displayed um we have one last performance tomorrow uh 11:30 to 12:30 we'll be featuring man Magnet Middle um and plasy Heights Middle Schools dance team and the band of choir from farest Heights if you miss all of these performances you can catch them on our Facebook um page and I think our YouTube channel um they have all been amazing so please make sure that you uh check them out so thank you to all of our students and schools for participating and we want to give
005a special shout out to Dr routon um and Dr Marcus Johnson uh who helped to coordinate this event we also partner as we do every year with KARK and Fox 16 um for our toy and gift drive we appreciate all of our employees and community members who so generously donated to this effort these items will no doubt make a season quite a bit brighter for some of the children who may not otherwise receive toys and for what I hear we did an amazing job with our toy drive collection this year so thank you to all who contributed also as part of our partnership with KK and Fox 16 two lrc families were selected to enjoy a shopping spree uh one from our Child Nutrition department uh picture here and another one of our parents and
006both wanted to send messages to let us know that they are grateful for this opportunity especially during the holiday season all right this SL really needs no introduction um the parf Patriots have done it again for the third time in a row pars football team has claimed the state championship title they beat Farmington with a final score of 61-21 so congrats Patriots your LS2 family is so very proud of you uh also last week Jefferson Elementary celebrated the opening of the men Reed Opitz Outdoor Classroom with a heartfelt ribbon cutting ceremony this special um the special space honors the memory of me Reed Opitz a beloved student who passed away in January 20123 the Outdoor Classroom will serve as a hub for physical education shaded recess school events and Innovative Outdoor Learning experiences ensuring her
007Legacy will live on through joy and education the East program at Roberts Elementary is celebrating a big achievement one of their students Ro uh Ryan Ahmed has been selected as an ambassador on the East Conference leadership team for this year uh join us in congratulating Ryan on his hard work and wishing him the best on this incredible Learning Adventure uh Watson Elementary's gifted and talented program received an 8,000 reps repsen fund Grant to launch the Drone Legends program students will explore drone Tech stem learning and teamwork huge thanks to Charlotte cook buar for helping the students imagine their Futures through stem education so congratulations again to the GT students at Watson our eighth grade Career Development students dove into the health services Career Cluster by practicing Real World skills like taking blood pressure temperature and
008oxygen levels with Vital sign kits this engaging activity offers a glimpse into the healthcare field and an opportunity for these students to explore impactful careers in the field of medicine waiting for your all right Jasmine B and Zion McDaniel uh from Little Rock Southwest High School along with Little Rock Central's Bailey Carol proudly represented the Little Rock School District at the Jag national student leadership conference in Washington DC huge thanks to their Jag specialist Dr Mary Jacobs and Mr Dean Dre Smith for making these life-changing experiences possible for our students students at Little Rock Central High School had the incredible opportunity to interview Miss Elizabeth eford a member of the historic Little Rock N For an upcoming podcast the students said they were inspired by Miss egford and honored to have the opportunity to speak
009with a living legend all right Little Rock Central's Cadet Grady Rogers has been selected to receive the prestigious 2025 Air Force JROTC Flight Academy scholarship this highly competitive scholarship is awarded to only three students in Arkansas and covers an 8-week program valued at $27,000 during which Grady will work toward earning his private Pilots license way to go Grady part of the high school experience is helping our students visualize what they can become you may very well be looking at the next group of nuclear s scientists Hall West School of innovation students had an exclusive tour at the nuclear one plant in Russellville last week and from what I understand this field trip took uh well over a year uh to coordinate and plan just because of all of the the security uh clearances so students
010participated in simulations and learned how nuclear power is used in Arkansas we are grateful that our students had this amazing opportunity right great conversations with students from each of our high schools um I had the opportunity to engage with them all last week um about cell phones which we will be spending some additional time talking about as we look to update and revise our policy around cell phone use but I can tell you our students provided valuable insight and actually managed to change my way of thinking about a few things so I really uh enjoyed those conversations with our high school students this past week Little Rock School District Community Schools um along with Brady we're honored at UAMS Community partner celebration M dermit Stevens Washington and Brady elementary schools were recognized for their work
011in the green schoolyards initiative promoting physical activity and improving School experiences so congratulations to those schools a few more to go shout out to the creative and hardworking teams from Forest Park Elementary palaski Heights middle school and Terry Elementary for earning a top spot uh for earning a spot in the top 25 finalist of the 202 2425 youth youth entrepreneurship showcase competition these future entrepreneurs are putting their innovative ideas to test and we could not be more prouder of all of them so earlier this year we uh announced and debut the first our first cohort of uh high school students that will be graduating with their High School diplomas and their LPN I believe we had a handful of students in our first year about six or seven um we are now ready to announce
012the next 20 who will begin the program uh in this upcoming school well for next school year 20 students from several high schools in our area have been accepted into the LPN program offered through Metropolitan Career Technical Center and Baptist Health College this marks an incredible opportunity for these students to embark on a promising career pathway in healthcare and and last but certainly not least 800 lrsd students receed new winter coats thanks to energy Arkansas and firef firefighter local 34 operation War provided coats this year to students at Carver Western Hills and roine since 2015 nearly 6,000 lrc students have received new coats through this partnership we are grateful uh to our firefighter partners and to our friends at energy for their ongoing support and that concludes our celebrations for the month of December all
013right thank you so much Dr Wright so we'll move on to public comment thank you thank you okay so if I mispronounce your name please correct me Miss Morgan Miss Morgan oh you know what Miss Morgan give me just a sec no no no you can come upstair there I just want to make sure that we have this preface so the guidelines for public comment just to ensure that we're on the same page this is a place in the agenda when we hear from the public parents stakeholders and Friends of lrsd we allow three minutes for public comment our responsibility is to listen to your comment we do not respond or have discussion thank you go right ahead here okay can I begin yes ma'am okay can you is this on can you hear me
014okay all right so uh good evening um board members and I guess Welcome to our two new board members I'm very glad to have you here with us um I want to begin by sharing the importance of having a community within your school so currently at Carver because we only have approximately 232 stud students I know every one of my students names I know their families I know the trauma that some of them have endured I know their favorite books I know what sports they play and I know their interest that's going to be very difficult to do with an increased enrollment with the needs of our current students so I'm going to begin right now let me Begin by sharing the following data with you according let me Begin by saying this how can
015the board make decisions to merge close and create new schools without a blueprint a contractor cannot build a house based off of an idea they have to have plans like a vision statements that breaks down the plans imagine how much attention to detail is needed to implement and create a school that has students that has a variety of needs values and personalities what fundamental beliefs have been shared with those being affected by these changes that's not attached to a price tag what values have been shared with stakeholders what measurable outcomes have been shared with the community at what point were the goals for the car the current Carver Booker merger evaluated and shared with staff families and stakeholders prior to November the 12th at what point has the current team been measured to see how
016we are aligning to the original vision of Carver steam what fruit has been produced at Carver the reimagine MLK the autism program and Promise Academy why was the engagement of parents staff stakeholders and students and afterthought instead of of a collaborative effort when we are facing enrollment issues it's hard for me to believe that no one expressed that idea prior to bringing this concept of a plan to the board this type of mismanagement would have never occurred in certain zones within this school district the inside of the minds of the parents that currently have students at Brady Carver Washington self-contained classrooms throughout this District Alternative Learning environments also known as Al and any school that is going to inherit influx of students matters I don't know a single person that doesn't like for their opinion
017to be valued thank you thank you thanks for being time with you Miss Morgan I appreciate that okay um Dr Whitfield to the members of the board my name is Dr Anika T Whitfield I'm a proud product of the Little Rock School District but today I'm really sad and I'm appropriately wearing black I'm wearing black because I'm mourning and grieving the loss of more schools in the Little Rock School District we were there Grassroots Arkansas was there saying don't close Franklin Elementary school don't close Wilson but some of well one of you were on board and said we need to do that children psychologically emotionally physically were harmed and traumatized by that Educators were psychologically physically and emotionally harmed by that what Mr White or Dr W told us last last night was that the
018plans that he's presented he feels are the only plans but I'm asking you to look at the budget talk with Mr Bailey find out what other ways we can work our budget so that we keep all of our schools open for all of our students it's not ever okay when only some kids are doing well when we look in our school buildings there are discrepancies over and over and over again I encourage each of you but especially you Dr Wright I'd love for you to come to my child school which is MLK and sit in some of those classrooms and see how difficult it is for teachers to work with students that have so many needs but not enough resources and when we close schools down we close down even more resources we have excellent
019leaders we have excellent Educators in our schools but nobody does well when they don't have all of the ingredients they need in order to make a successful whatever it is a successful day a successful opportunity to teach and to learn and so that is what I'm asking you look at the budget the superintendent is giving you an option but I'm asking you to look and see if there are any other options before you say yes and you all have the decision he said to make tonight so please think about your children think about your grandchildren think about what it is to close to two more schools down in the Little Rock School District and what other opportunities we're opening and availing ourselves to the community to say that the Little Rock School District can't handle
020what we have that is an indictment on us it's a very bad indictment so I'm asking you pleading with you please do not close any more schools in our district thank you okay Mr Walker what I had on my heart to say they already stated for me okay all right thank you and Mr Ross in uh in 1954 a few nights after the Supreme Court desegregated all the schools in the nation the L Rock School District Board of Directors promised in a notion that they were going to provide an education for all children uh the white business class dominated school boards over the next years the next decades avoided that promise always using the right words rarely ever having the right actions many in this room fought that betrayal and after the states failed takeover
021we finally got a democratically elected School Board you guys that was willing to make good on that 1954 promise we find ourselves you find yourselves tonight in a rough position Dr Wright is asking you to make two very hard decisions to close and repurpose two of our schools um I'm going to ask you to vote for all five of them and I think there are some facts that we just have to keep saying to ourselves over and over again the state Republican party the Arkansas Department of Education has been attacking public schools in little rocks for a decade um they have opened more charter schools in this County than they have any place else in the state we are bleed Bing students next year the learns act will be fully in effect we will be
022bleeding students um this has led to a decade long loss of students in Revenue the third fact is we currently have 13 schools in our district that are under enrolled which means they cost us more to operate than the state funding we received these schools are all over our city but it's key to remember that in the last decade uh on the Eastern side of our city we've seen in the census data children leaving the eastern part of our city for the middle part of our city and the southern part of our city we have too many schools in the eastern part of the city please also do not forget the fifth fact that 81% of the Little Rock School District is non-white any decision we make for any school in any Zone any section
023of the city is going to affect non-white children we've been a non-white district since 1977 six thing is that the Little Rock School District is not in financial distress that's great news but if we don't address the loss of Revenue and the loss of students we're going to have financial problems in the very near future and then finally please don't forget that we have had a population of about 19,000 children for the last decade we currently have somewhere between 23 and 24,000 seats in the Little Rock School District we cannot sustain paying for spaces that do not have children in them if we're going to help the children we've been forsaking we have to free up money to spend on the neediest kids in our district this board Dr Wright have shown repeatedly that you
024will not forsake any kids in our city you all and Dr Wright have been focused like a laser on the kids the Little Rock School District has traditionally forsaken African-American Latino and special needs kids great things are happening in the Little Rock School District and while this move hurts us all this temporary step back will allow us to invest more money in these kids and help them with services and the very resources that the last speaker spoke of as you all work to develop an amazing marketing strategy in the coming year that will explain to all of this city how great we are I think we're going to see growth but we got to take a step back right now so please vote for these motions thank you okay we're going to move forward to
025the district committee reports okay certified hello ma'am sorry I missed everyone last month um good evening to the board and good evening especially to you two because it's my first time meeting you all Mr Rose and Mr Bali um I am bringing forth the November and December report um November's report is it's it's really short but when we met in November um one of the topics of discussion was the multi-year contract um it did come to us as a proposal it was not an action item um and the PPC um has actually decided to try to work a little bit more with um Administration and drafting that language of the multi-year contract um the there was disapproval of the language in The Proposal um The Way It Was Written it it takes more rights away
026from the teachers and we know that they're getting cut more and more as we know also um the PPC did mention that we had no involvement in coming up with the proposal draft for the multi-year contract so hopefully after the first of the year we can revisit that with the um Administration to come to some language that we can all agree upon and so that was for November for December that was probably one of our shortest meetings um of the year and they did approve um because I was not at the December meeting but the 2526 calendar was approved by the certified PPC so we were excited exced about that there has been a couple of concerns about the stiens and we um thank you all for approving those stiens they are retroactive back to
027July 1 and I think that there just was some miscommunication um staff assume that the back pay would occur this year and I think that it's important to note that maybe um payroll should probably send something out districtwide because that retr pay we will not get that until our last paycheck in so um and I hope with with that that people really kind of continue to do their um to do their duties because after all they've worked it for months but won't get the money until the back end so that was on the stiens um one really good glow is um the committee has been working on the board policies and um we had our second meeting last Friday and I am proud to say that we have finished section 3.0 licensed Personnel policy committee
028we completed section 3.1 the licensed Personnel salary schedule and we completed section 3.2 the licensed Personnel um evaluations and then after the break we took off today it's the holidays and so we took off today and we'll reconvene after the break and we will pick up with Section 3.3 which is evaluation of licensed Personnel by Rel relatives and so um that really concludes my report but um as I get ready to dismiss I do want to um just publicly say thank you to Miss Norma Johnson Miss Vicky Hatter Miss Anna strong and Miss sha Burgess they helped me yesterday with the eighth grade mock interviews at Mary and G Lacy um despite a situation we made it work yesterday and we had a grand time that's one of my favorite unit and I just really
029want to say thank you and I look forward to seeing you all next semester for the second set of kids to come and visit with us are there any questions of me how did you let me Miss yesterday got to come in April now I need you need you and so and you too Miss Wesley but miss Wesley brought up a good point she said can I join Zoom we might set that up like that though just because you know absolutely to be flexx we're moving in that yeah so many people do that now yeah so many people yeah abolutely so that may be a component that we can add for the next time going to be a part of it but that's fine I'll be there in April thank you just remind all right
030I'm on my way back to the game we're playing the Bears tonight thank you all happy holid same to you all right okay classified PPC classified PPC no okay all right no Pras round t Okay so we're going to entertain the motion for what agenda for the consent agenda I have a question before we go to the vote why did we move the establishment of the foundation to consent agenda uh usually when we discuss items in the work session and there aren't any um outstanding issues or questions or concerns that come up we typically all of that in the consent agenda just for uh a blanket approval all right I move that the lrsd board approved the consent agenda items as follows 5.2 Personnel changes 5.3 purchasing reports 5.4 October and November board minutes 5.5
031Community Service Learning applications 5.6 donation of property 5.7 proposed 2526 student calendar and 5.8 establish lishment of the lrsd foundation second it's been moved and properly second all in favor any opposed the motion carries [Music] okay okay schools and academics optimizing lrsd 2.0 Madam president I would like to move that we address these recommendations serat which means paragraph at a time they have been um if you'll reference yes if you'll reference your document I'm referencing it right now look if you're blue you're blue ah the blue yeah the blue I'm Sor that's okay no problem problem yep okay thank you so optimizing lrsd 2.0 recommendations okay we have any discussion on this one Dr WR any discussion no okay so it's been presented I know a number of times however obviously if you have a
032question um I'm sorry director Adams go ahead and then director hat her since we have to discussed this um m m Wesley and and I I'm ready to make a motion on the to get us started and then uh if we get a second I'll be I'd like to speak to my motion so I would move that to the lrsd board approve the recommendation number one as presented second it's been moved and properly second questions so I would like to speak to that motion if I if I may sure um you know one of the most difficult things to me to me that we have to do as a board member is when we have to face you know closing or changing any school it's it's just a terrible thing to have to to put
033a community through and yet I think that with the challenges that we've been discussing the last few months I think that it's a complicated situation where the keeping a school open is not the only consider ation there are other considerations and and in this case there's a consideration for us to be you know fiscally responsible to be able to provide the things we need for students and to stay out of distress and I think it's also we have the responsibility to to be as flexible and Innovative as possible to meet the needs that we have and I really want to commend the administration um for their work on both on all these proposals because I I think that all of them uh respect the complexities that we're dealing with and the challenges but also try
034to find some positives to come out of the difficult situations that we're in and I think that's true for this first one I think that although it's certainly distressing for the families who will be impacted I think in the long run I think families will be better served and we'll have another um we'll have a creative way to use the Carver School building which would is going to serve families and and help our district and help us to to do better and I think when we get to the second one I think we'll also see that we're going to continue to use the buildings to serve families and um in a way that meets some of the needs that we are not meeting so so I hope that we will find a way to approve
035the first recommendation you like to add okay um for me it's it's it's really not a you know an argument of closing um a school but it's more to the heart of it which is a plan like we don't have um a strong plan on what we will offer at the schools I get that you know we want to consolidate but if we recall when we did Booker to Carver it wasn't a good consolidation because they uh still didn't get the help no matter how much advocacy went forth on that um and although Carver is staying in place in Lea number and name and the grant money that's going to Washington um it it feels a bit um disingenuous um knowing that Carver staff was told that they would have to reapply for their jobs
036Washington doesn't so it seems like we're moving and doing away with caror keeping the Lea keeping the money keeping the name and moving it into a existing building um especially since a transition team wasn't put together until last week um and that a clear plan forward have not been given to the board or the community um and it's easy this have been a interesting time for me as far as that saying where they say when it's other people's children you will do and vote however with other people's children and I had to ask myself would I allow uh my daughter to go through this and not know where and what to expect and the answer is no I wouldn't I I I I I would not um in good conscious uh be able to even
037answer question I can't even answer questions from parents that I'm getting about what to expect at the school um what staff members are going like what programming is going um and those are just common questions that parents would answer and for us to move these children um uh it it just it's to to me it is uh disingenuous and for for for that I'm I I am a no vote on this because of lack of planning lack of transparency and and then we are doing things to um the community especially when we know that families are moving into um the East End and Carver is is is is is a non- Zone school so everybody bring their children there so it's not a issue of um people not uh coming um and then even with
038Washington you have the same issue right where um folks want to always say we have the S district and the pedway district but the reality is um as far as from from a benevolence standpoint yes they will give and they will invest but as far as their families and their children they are not sending their children to Washington um so I I I just think um for for that um for this one is going to be a no vote for me because I just don't want and gamble um and and sell something to appearance that like we haven't even fleshed out all the way other questions just sir I told the superintendent I told the superintendent earlier this week that I would uh not be able to vote Yes on this until the transition plan
039for the teachers was in place um have to agree with Miss Hatter that that that that transition committee was put together awfully late and of course they they haven't reached their conclusions yet so um I will also put in here that uh because my wife is one of the displaced teachers if the rest of the board decides that I shouldn't vote on this at all I will go along with that we appreciate that any other questions I have a comment so I'm sort of a out of the box type individual and sometimes I think that maybe our help should come from another level for instance I was thinking that maybe the kids that birthdays were late maybe the state would give us a waiver and allow us to receive some of those kids or if
040they would even just invest in a 3 to four year old program so sometimes I don't think we reach far enough now I don't know if that's possible but I was a December kid and I had to wait a whole year so I think sometime in August is to cut off where can we just accept the kids up through September I don't see anything wrong with that some say they are what immature well 3 to four year olds immature as well it's a learning process so I'm sort of that person that thinks that sometimes you need to work outside the box so my answer would be no as well other questions I would just like to make a comment if this does go through um cuz I'm if it does go through um my thought
041would be for everyone to have to reapply and not just throw away um the folks that um uh Carver and to um have a plan to hand over to our um parents and and and so that they are not gambling uh with with with their um child's education and to I would say and and closing is right if we're truly just moving bodies moving children into a existing School building taking away the Washington Lea number then just say that and then just say that um whatever the scope of work to meet the satisfaction of the grant then that will be done but um I think a clear plan would would would help um with this decision and migration for those who choose to go just want to ask for clarification on the hiring piece um
042from the superintendent if I could we have not uh finalized uh that process yet we have started um discussion and I share the draft of what our initial thoughts were uh with the board we actually met um with uh Chris heler today to kind of ironing out some things and so I feel like we have a a better um plan uh we'll be discussing that in our cabinet meeting tomorrow and I'll be sharing um what that draft will look like with the board probably over the break may I ask a clarifying question on that yes ma'am the piece that was shared that you referenced was shared with the board are you talking and I'm just referencing from our conversation are you speaking of that that idea of a drop but that has that has changed
043after our meeting with uh Chris haer today so yes okay and that's why it was just it was just a draft just some initial thoughts okay I didn't realize that was a draft I just thought that that would okay it doesn't matter if it's changed my last and then my um last one of that followup is will it at will it adhere to the labor laws and the overall due process because what I heard um that you said have changed would would I had concerns that it would not um adhere to those things but that's why I was saying I will hold off on any other comment um comments when we talked yeah whatever when we finalize um what that plan would look like and we bring it uh to the board it will be
044aligned to to state law local laws and everything we're not going to bring anything that that that conflicts with with lws okay any other questions okay so let's look at the recommendation so it's been moved um for the um that the lrsd board approved this recommendation recommendation one the relocation and consolidation of Carver steam Magnet Elementary School with Washington Elementary to create Carver Washington steam Magnet Elementary School all in favor say I I can we do a roll call absolutely Miss HS should do the roll call yeah Miss Hudson should do the roll call she's the clerk sounds good I'm going to go no no yes yes yes Mr yes Mr yes first four or four the last five yes is on that side which is interesting way of seas motion pass okay so I'm
045sorry M Valerie give me those numbers I got five yes V five yes votes and four no votes the motion carries okay all right so we'll move forward the chair will entertain a motion or do we have discussion on recommendation two discussion a recommendation two questions discussion I'll make a I move that um I'd like to go ahead and make a motion if that's okay and then I can speak it for a absolutely okay yes okay I move that the lrsd board approve recommendation to as presented second it's been moved and second questions comments I'd just like to um to speak to this as well and I said this last night at mcdermit when we were uh meeting with some of the families who would be impacted by this and that is that this is
046not an easy decision for any of us and our responsibility as board members is to ensure that we are providing an amazing education to our students and that we are keeping our budget solvent and that means that hard decisions have to be made sometimes and um we've all we've all done our work to be at the table and try to see if there are other places we can find 9 million um after we found 13 or 14 million I think it was last year and I think these are you know we tried everything we could to not get to this point so um that is kind of the reasoning behind my motion my vote director Bali second yes I just want to add that uh you know this with this being my very first official
047board beating uh I can't agree to sit back and just watch schools closing uh again and again and I believe phrase nothing about us without us and so when we make decisions for a whole city for entire all these communities we have to make an honest and intentional effort to engage with the community here concerns and try to work on ways to make corrective action plan so that we can actually listen and redirect our interests if needed to make sure that we're working for all the people as a elected board well I'm an appointed board member so I can't say that right now but uh I I can't agree with that because I know how when schools close that tears apart intentional communities and when we're working to build intentional communities we have to look
048at the interest of all the people that are affected by that directly impacted by that whether that be students teachers but also parents uh in the community as well as people who uh are not directly involved with the schools because their property taxes do go to pay for those schools too and so uh having more schools in the communities actually makes those School those communities safer and so I just want to go on record to say that that the the way I'm vote tonight reflects my um my personal beliefs and I understand that tough decisions have to be made but uh sometimes we have to come up with tough Solutions and not tough excuses okay uh director hat then director um I just want to say that I don't believe that we exhausted all of
049our possibilities in cutting because we didn't get multiple options we got these as options um if you guys remember just not that long ago even when um um our last superintendent Mike poor was here we had a list of options to do to choose from to create the hybrid I like we and we had more um options to help us uh create the best uh decisions and even in when we and what I'm speaking about because he was here through multiple of closures I'm talking about the options for Hall we have five options and one of them was a slow closure which is where we're at now right um and then uh we had uh to make it a all ninth grade academy my point in saying that is uh Administration went above and beyond
050to make sure that we had all the options even the ones that wasn't the most popular um options and to say that we have seriously looked at the budget as a board that's disingenuous it's not we have not I think um that is well well documented um we don't have budget discussions we don't allocate budget like we don't we just say okay and yes um so for me the my vote will be a no vote just because I'm not convinced that like we looked at all of the options especially since um we're going to keep our buildings open um or repurpose those buildings um and then I haven't seen what would be the cost savings from having Personnel in the Building compared to having um our children in the building and then where and what
051other areas could we possibly cut yes sir the cut that's they're going to make the difference between having people in the building and not having people in the building is the salaries of the people that's it utilities are going to be the same it's going to cost the same it's just going to be the salaries that are cut and that's why I'm voting against these three measures because I don't think the plan is complete you can tell me what's going to happen to the teachers where they're going to go and what jobs are going to be in and if you tell me well this these 33 are gone not going to keep them and these 20 we going to put back in these schools I won't have any choice but to accept that because I
052I perhaps unlike Miss Hatter I I trust that these numbers have been sifted through and this is what we have to do but I want the whole plan in place before I vote for it so I'm going to vote against okay other questions yes sir direct yes I'd like to speak in favor of the motion and and just share just a couple things one is that I think that the plan to have a to put a variety of the services that our families need under one PL roof student registration and other services for child care and have it in a place that's centrally located as oppos where it is now and where there's PL of parking and easy access I think it's actually going to really um improve the experience for families who are dealing
053with the district to give them a place to come and register and get information about our early childhood and other programs and and I'm excited about that and I also just want to express appreciation to um two of the families who came to our community meeting last night at mcdermit they stuck around and spoke with me afterwards both of them are going to be impacted by the change we just voted on and the change that we're going to vote on now if it's approved none of them um were angry none of them were were uh accusing us of being irresponsible all of them were expressing respect for the challenges that we were facing and and knew that it was going to be that we were facing some really hard situations and they were giving um
054they were expressing some trust that we were trying to work in a good faith way which Ty believe that we are other comments or questions other comment just a clarification for me it's not a trust issue it's a due it's a due diligence issue so it this the statement was made that um the numbers was crunched the number wasn't the board did not do that as that is one of our duties and we didn't do that and so I'm speaking from that standpoint and looking at all options and so just to be clear for those who want to um repeat what I say it is a due diligence issue it's not a trust issue I I apologize I didn't mean to characterize your decision mean it's it's no no no I mean that's why you
055know yes ma director okay strong I oh go ahead go ahead direct C with um really a broken heart I'm voting for it I um have been around a long time y'all know and uh in this district and I started where integration started at Central loved it but I had to leave there I was there years changes happen people the longer you're there uh they changed the zones where the folks who went to Dumar all of a sudden couldn't go to Dumar they had to go somewhere else they changed the folks who were going to uh Booker send them to Henderson I was there uh then there was another change and they came through through and said we have a bigger better idea and they call magnet schools and so we had to reconfigure that
056and then we had all the magnet schools then the magnet schools changed and they decided that we're going to do something different and they did had to go again uh when this is not popular I understand and I if I would I would have right I would have loved to have been in the same spot for the years that I did work in this District but I see it now I was mad then feelings was hurting and all of that one time I got moved I just bought a house but the the the thing is I am more involved with maintaining public education people because I really think public education is going to go the way in the world if we don't do something and see the Articles and the things that you see uh
057and uh from from the various sides of the issue public education is dying and we keep fighting amongst ourselves we got to come up with something I couldn't crunch the numbers I'm not a business person I'm not an accountant we saw it we had the list I read it some things and then it changed I said well look but things change we have excellent people who have gotten us grants we're trying to save the district people public education is what we're trying to do okay I the salary increases I loved it I made $8,200 the first year I was here I don't even know how I ate okay but that's just how things go you're not going to always like it but to me it's not about Evelyn Callaway it's about the kids I don't
058I don't blame Carin for not wanting uh uh I I don't blame folks for not wanting to move I was at J fair for a long time but they closed that too they they they they sold David old die Clos that too Roman they tried to close it then I had a fit and they really it turned into something really positive but the fact is in the last 10 years is how many people have we lost and then you got the Larn act Larn Zach is not waiting for us they're going to just go ahead it's a locomotive that's out of hand and that is law I don't agree with most of it but that's law and I would rather save this situ and I understand you're where you're coming from but we have to
059be not I'm not saying you're selfish because I was selfish I felt I was really just messed up every time I had to move but that's how it happened but then my whole point and I stayed in the classro the whole time I was here it was about the kids if it's about the kids kids sincerely about the kids and that's who I'm voting for the parents I don't agree with the uh uh with everybody and and don't agree with me because I'm talking I'm just telling you sincerely what's on my heart but I don't care for and I've been an educator all my life and a continuous learner since then I do not like the charter school system I've observed it I've seen it I I do not want public education to go away
060and I'm just voting and the reason why I am voting like I voted I don't want to see it go away and another 10 years I probably won't even be alive but my grandkids will be I want them to be able to go to some school char school if if they come to me and they can't read well they can't read here too but I mean you know me some of them but let's say and they get to the place where Charter Schools can kick kids out we can't we kick them out they almost have to be able to go to jail I mean that's true so that's my opinion thank you and I wanted to just say that's the reason why I spoke that absolutely do it D yes um I just wanted to
061read a bit from an email that Mr Bailey and an email exchange that Mr Bailey and I had Mr Bailey if I get any of this wrong or anything's changed please uh correct me um but I had asked him as part of my kind of just background work on all of all of this what um the projected cost impact of the merging of Carver Washington and the closing of Brady would be given that they will both remain open for other needs and his response that was that um we would save about 1.3 million milon from each building and closing so a total of $2.6 million toward the $9 million we need to reach from the buildings from the the salary and benefits going away and that the building C cost to operate since we're moving
062other things into that that are already budgeted that's really kind of the in general the total savings so um I just wanted to say that I did ask about that I think that is an important did I get that right did I get that okay you want to come up here m sorry if I messed that up thank you we appreciate you Mr y'all can call on anytime I'm back there thanks so what what's that no I'm not good evening again so you you pretty much captured but those was the minimum savings so that's minimum typically going to look at so most Elementary we closed in the past we about a $650,000 saving give or take uh typically we're going to have those schools for two years anyway because they go on the list for
063charter schools so we'll maintain some level of utility usage there but uh for the most part these we looking at about 1.3 on each one of those as minimum so as you look at Staffing across the district so I know we we've talked about this for a long time so I've been here since 2009 we've been cutting for long time since we had to do the dag wind down and everything else so that that's typically what you're going to be looking at so I I did send another email I don't know if y'all want me to embellish any of that now but I've worked for seven superintendents uh none of them like closing schools so I mean this probably one of the hardest thing any superintendent and probably know for Dr wght cuz I know
064it it pains them so uh when you get to this point you exhausted pretty much most of your efforts out there so when we looking at data we talked about this during September doing a budget presentation of that we've had the kind of you know hope for that we were going to bring a lot of students back but we have to live with the reality what we have now so going to be a 19,000 or 20,000 uh student School District that's what we're going to be we won't ever I won't say doesn't look like we're going to be a 26,000 School District again at this point so uh but we have to live with the reality Where We Are so it's going to be some difficult decisions so as we uh went into this fiscal
065year with a $8.4 million deficit uh that's significant uh and you'll see the chart and you've seen it in the past but I have the the chart in this presentation so you'll see that decline of fund balance going down there we're at a point right now we're on the district in py County outside of Jacksonville North py with they knew that hadn't been in fisical distress over those those years that we had that wind down so it's because we had an opportunity to see these the data points there and make decisions with a scal and not having to take a out and just start whacking at things so when proposals come for you that they've been discussed with many people I'm typically a part of that as well so and just the facts when we
066looking at here so we've lost I sent another report but K12 in the last 5 years we lost 1,00 students K12 of those students 14 1464 were elementary students we hadn't closed at many elementary schools the average elementary schools probably about 280 300 maybe they're nowhere near 350 so that equates to even more so those 380 7 additional students and and this year we're down 387 from October 1st of last year to October 1st of this year that's going to equate to another 6.5 million Foundation decrease on next year so we're looking at $8.4 million deficit this year another 6 and a half next year it'll be offset a little bit by declining enrollment that's only for one year so where we are right now we can't take another major decline otherwise we'll make that
067other list we'll join the other districts that's been in fisical distress I don't see us making it so once you see that Point you're going to see where your fund balance is so low you're struggling to make payroll you're struggling to do these other things that you have to do we have 50 $60 million typically annually and grants that we get most of those grants on a reimbursable basis you have have enough funds to float those till you get that 30-day you know reimbursement may be longer than that cuz they're talking about a government shutdown too and things like that so if you're in a situation where you're like that and it becomes dire I mean it's it's important that we we make the hard decisions so no decisions going forward here I know we
068we uh I have four kids you're going to look out for what's best for your your students and the kids and I mean I have family members and everybody that works so when we're making decisions not just we're looking at bottom line dollars we know it's going to affect families we know it's going to affect students that's why we here otherwise we don't need to be in this business so hard decision but we have some facts here we have the data there and we we showing the decline there so uh whatever way the board votes on here we still going to have some more tough decisions this is just kind of the beginning of it this doesn't get us to the to the finish line so uh we have some beautiful things going on in
069the district with new buildings and enhancements going there but we also and SS but we also have some tough decision to make but any questions you might have you have anything you had something yeah um so with our right as we know that the um enrollment will will continue to decline you know we knew that a few years ago cuz we did a a projection about 4 years ago pre projecting out uh and now we are looking at a nice siiz um investment within early childhood and we know that you know outside of the government funded seats um for those seats that are in our district that do not meet those requirements of government assistance um the the the uh District take on that burden of cost so knowing that um and that's what maybe
070about $2 to $4 million maybe maybe2 to three not quite that much so you can have like what Miss had is talking about so ABC I think we have like 1,285 seats that are paid some 1254 okay she so 1254 that's part and you have maybe another 250 or so students that's attending that's not so if you're paying for a teacher out of those funds I mean you may have a class of just say that's on ABC and three that's not so it's not that much difference on there so the esa funding was actually meant for that when it was called nsla I think when I think it might have matter uh I think BB was in the either senate or house at that time when that was passed but that's a big portion that
071we actually used toward it early childhood now the task force has I think recommendation on a sliding scale on those but yeah and and they've been talking about that ever since when Mike was here um so um my question is giving the fact that because those funds it does take away from the K12 students right and so regardless of how we move money around and to say what category it comes out the bottom line is that it takes away from our K our K12 students which is what we're in business to do we're not a child care center we're not early um childhood like that so um knowing that um and and these conversations have been in play for a while um about the sliding scale of course everybody know about vouchers or those who
072uh need vouchers know know how how to apply for those things um and it's great to have um the public school system to cover that for those who do not qualify for um government assistance but my question is how much do we give and take away from our K12 students to expand our Early Childhood for um persons that um do not qualify for the state funded pres um seats um at the cost of our K12 because at some point we're going to have to have this hard conversation um but I'm I'm bringing it up because you know i' I'm because looking down the road it is definitely something that we may have to look at and maybe only offer Early Childhood to the ones that are covered by the state I'm I I just put
073that out there so that's all superintendent can you to that and and um I've had quite a few conversations with Esther um who directs our early childhood to kind of better understand this funding mechanism and where we are right now and and I'm going to get her to clarify but the number of voucher seats we have versus those who don't qualify who are currently in early childood from my understanding is not taking anything away from K12 because the number of um voucher funded Early Childhood seats that we have now pays for the salaries of all of the staff that we have it's only if we took more families who don't qualify that it would right now it's covering everything and so that's why there's a plan to do the sliding Fe scale if we open
074up more seats and So currently right now um it's not taking anything away from uh the K12 budget and that's that's my understanding based upon the way that Esther explained it to me so is there a way for what's the hold up on on uh having a sliding fee schedule not for families that are able to pay something instead of instead of us um because at the end of the day we are going to outside of salary and fringe benefits there is still a cost for having that child in inside the facility educating so what is stopping um implementing the uh fee scale so Nothing is Stopping it there's a we're actively planning now to introduce um a sliding P scale for these other uh seats and classes that we're planning to open up so
075that's actually in the works now okay is is there a projected date for that so I don't want to misspeak but I believe from our last conversation this upcoming year the plan is to notify um families who don't qualify to give them a year to prepare for the sliding fee scale so it will be introduced um in the upcoming school year but it won't be applied until the school year afterwards that's my understanding based upon the last conversation that I had with Esther okay and then it it will be market rate will it be comparable it should be I'm just saying we shouldn't subsidize it if if we don't have to that's all I'm saying yeah I don't know the particulars but when we when we get to that point we will definitely bring um
076that so that can be clarified and I don't know an if you you may know a little more than we I mean I will just say um D madam chairman I'll call M president I'll call for the question okay uh we've been um it's on the uh floor of the question I have a second second okay it's been uh moved and proberly second a question all in favor ma'am president I'd like I need to say something this has to do with this vote okay so it's the question has been called so we have to vote on it first Mr Kaz tell them I'm sorry it has to be a 2/3 vote and that means we have to call the rooll it does require two3 vote on the question right to you're voting to end debate
077so right two do that so so what I'm asking is for the question right so we're voting on the question you're you're yeah you're calling you're you're ending debate so that then you will take the the vote on the underlying motion so this is a the first motion on on calling for the question yes and that requires a 2third vote successful if that is successful debate will end and then you will go immediately to vote so we're in the middle of voting on the question yeah is that correct am I not yes you're so we're taking the vote on the question okay is that correct to to end debate yes to end debate that'll be that will require a two3 to be successful exactly so all in favor on the question the r call the
078roll I'm sorry I'm Sor that's fine that's fine we I don't think that we need to call the RO V we can count by the the way we've always counted so if we have uh all in favor say I I you have the count on the eyes this is for the question yes ma'am for the question for eyes can I have hands on the eyes 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 all in favor seven opposed two the motion carries so we will go directly to the motion okay okay so the motion is it's been recommended that we the lrsd Board of Education approve recommendation two the closure of Brady Elementary School yes maam Direct no director Rose no director Johnson no director Hatter no director Wesley yes director Callaway yes director Adams yes director
079Mason yes you forgot me director strong yes motion car motion Carri five yes five yeses motion carries okay we'll move forward all right so we'll move to recommendation three uh chair will entertain a motion or is there discussion oh um yes ma'am okay I don't have a do you want to do do does someone want to do the motion or I have questions um Madam president I would uh move that we Rec uh the recommen recommendation number three reimagining D as dber business leadership and Entrepreneurship Magnus school second it's been moved and properly second questions yeah yes ma'am um this is one this is a school we haven't talked about and we haven't held meetings on um so is it changing the I know if we have the Grant and everything so is it changing
080the Lea number to wipe it clean the start over or is it can can you help me um uh help help me recall cuz I don't Rec call us ever talking about this there is no change to the Lea number um the only uh the only thing behind this recommendation is that dumbar um is one of our um extremely under enrolled middle schools but we are not making a recommendation to close it we are moving forward full steam ahead with the implementation of uh the magn grant that we receive to uh with the leadership and Entrepreneurship Focus so that's all this is yes sir do I'm sorry do I where you finish you I just had a quick followup hone so so the current enrollment at dumbar is like 300 and something right corre so
081it's severely under enrolled yes and the operation cost is millions to operate that build building uh so what and where are we um are the district looking to come to the board to talk about the feasibility of the um school or um because at some point um outside of receiving grant money it then have to become viable with with students we know we it's a registered historic building but I would like at some point in the future near future to um see some type of a plan uh of of of of the future of of the operation right of that building especially with only 300 kids in that building when it holds about 900 Mr Rose does this still include moving the um AP program I'm sorry could you use your mic please I'm sorry
082I'm Sor does this still include moving AP program to man the AP program to man the the uh the uh GT program no okay it was at one point all of our middle schools have a GT program yes but you the first time I saw this it said we were going to move the GT program from Dunbar to man that group no yeah or was it bringing GT back to Dumar because years ago it used to be at Dumar I don't know let me back you're not aware of it that's my yeah I Surrender okay he's not aware of it any other questions or concern any other questions I think you have another question I have I have a comment more Miss Hatter um when I was on the board before back in my day
083um closing schools that had a strong historic culture produced um we had a 50-man March one night when uh one of the fraternities marched in did sharp turns to sit down it was it was intimidating well that was we did close those schools but closing D Bar will be a lot harder I think as far as the community goes mhm you wouldn't be able to there's there's no recommendation discussion about closing I'm talk I was just speaking to her I knew no recommendation I just want to be clear to everybody okay yes please there's no recommendation to close dunar okay any other questions or comments okay so it has been uh moved and properly second for recommendation three to be approved to uh reimagine dunar it's dunar business leadership and Entrepreneurship Magnet Middle School all
084in favor I all opposed any you we didn't call for a role but I had a question if we're changing the name do we need to do a new Lea number or no no okay okay I'm Sorry Miss Val you said something okay I'm sorry all in favor please raise your hand the uh everyone everyone is uh saying yes it's opposed I can't see that from you uh you can't see that I'm sorry yes ma'am uh let me ask any opposed okay so one up one more time let's do all in favor and let let's do this let's go let's just do the roll let's just do the roll okay so Mr Botley yes Mr R Mr Rose yes M yes m yes M strong yes M Wesley yes yes Mr Adams yes M yes
085from this perspective it's okay that's okay we'll do whatever you need to board clerk you're able to do that yeah we'll get some buttons next it's no problem no we didn't like them okay so we'll move forward to recommendation for I move approval of superintendent's recommendation four second been moved and properly second to approve increased early childhood education C and lrsd based on demand availability of space in ECE centers and other lrsd buildings can I speak to that just to just comments questions yes sir um capturing uh a bunch of high school juniors doesn't improve our situation a whole lot toward population uh four-year-olds cost money and we're bleeding money but captured four-year-old population has a greater chance of staying with the schools the district as they go forward and so I'm of the opinion
086we should never turn away a four-year-old we should always find a place for them if somebody comes says I wanton to put my kid in school you find Place director strong um I just want to speak a little bit to this on the work that we did in the early childhood task force we have not yet had a chance to bring that plan before the board it will come as part of the Strategic plan I believe in January I'm looking at Dr Wright um January is in 2025 um uh but that strategic uh that that task force brought of 10 really amazing Educators Community Partners and uh Miss estra Jones who I cannot say enough wonderful things about um and myself and we met 10 times I believe over the course of a few months
087we met a couple times a month and really built a very comprehensive plan that I I am personally very proud of and I hope that you all will approve this is one one piece of that and the the very big our big hary audacious goal as they say is to offer at some point in time in the future Universal prek-3 and prek4 um through a combination of the current state ABC funded slots that we already have those 1254 slots Mr Bailey referred to um the we don't right now to my understanding use um the child care uh Development Fund vouchers in our prek 3 and prek4 but we do have the opportunity yet right but we have the opportunity to do that um and that is a slightly more burdensome uh type of funding for
088the parents but it is a way it pays a lot of money when when we have great high quality early childhood education like we do in every Early Childhood Center here in the Little Rock School District um and additionally using that sliding scale fee which would have a sliding scale for families above the cut off for those ABC funds and then um have a parent pay program for those parents who are above that and we did do uh had 900 responses to the surve we did during um during that uh task force that 2third of families said they would be maybe or were willing to about about evenly divided were maybe or or likely willing or were willing to pay for Early Childhood especially if they could have a seat in the school where they
089knew their kid was going to go to kindergarten um and so all that being said I think this is an extremely popular idea I think that we are um it is a way to get kids in and show them the quality of our district from day one and also a way to improve our kindergarten Readiness um and so that we are able to have uh kids who are ready to learn on day one of kindergarten when those test scores start counting and so um all that being said I'm extremely in favor of this and one last point I did want to make was that are the esa dollars that Mr Bailey referred to um those are funds from the state to improve outcomes and those are only available to be spent on certain evidence-based strategies
090like early childhood education and a couple other things I think after school and summer programs Maybe um that we can use those for so there are really limited availability limited options for using those funds so we get them and we have to use them on things that improve outcomes and early charge is one of them so um I really am very excited about the comprehensive plan y'all have put together in this space Dr right thank you so much for your work on that and estrogen thank you yes sir thank you Mr Wesley I just wanted to comment I think that every recommendation we have here in this one in particular addresses the two major concerns we have for district one is we have to improve academic outcomes for students all our students across the board
091and the second is we have to adjust to the reality of having a smaller district and and what does that mean and and how can we do that in a way that minimizes the harm and increases takes advantage of the opportunities that might be there too as we reimagine and rethink about how we do education and I think that both of those concerns are addressed in a really positive way in recommendation number four because I think it helps academic outcomes for kids get high quality special uh you know prek education and it also helps us uh gives us a better chance of stabilizing our enrollment and so um all these things I think connect to those but this one in particular thank you thank you any other comments uh Miss Hatter yes um I just
092want to uh be um I know how how I'm going to vote on this I do have some um hesitation in expanding um the child care outside of what is governmentally paid for because whether it's the uh vur or the ABC Grant it's all Government funding um and it's all income base um my my concern is not there especially um uh a person that then then I totally support early childhood uh been in the space created uh help create spaces like this my concern is the budget and the um have expanding to have um seats that are not already covered and then not um seeing a plan so I like to read and see plans um and so my no vote is not um uh um representation of not being for Early Childhood cuz I
093am definitely for Early Childhood I am looking at the cost um especially with our declining enrollment and we know that um K12 that's the business that we're in and from talking to other Seasons um board board members and other District leadership um a lot of them were talking about the focus on K uh k12 and um making sure that that early childhood um dollar are not taken away from no from that K12 space um so uh that is um that is um the reason for me uh saying no to this it is because I want to see a plan and I want to make sure that we are not um having to pay for seats that are not already covered U by um government uh government subsidies okay one other yes ma'am oh you're m
094okay I'm sorry um I'm going to vote for this I am totally against us paying for anything other than public schools now um now charter schools are supposed to be Public Schools where we know they're really not and uh that uh being an early childhood child development person I feel that as a taxpayer I want my money to go into the public school system had I been a senator whatever i' have voted against it in A legislature but only thing I feel that we need to look at is how this is going to affect us in little r School District how it affects Lisa Academy or those other places has nothing to do with us nothing or the private uh uh daycare centers or whatever this is Little Rock School District public school education and
095for that that's the only reason why we need to look at uh uh that we that's not our business charter schools or private schools if you can afford them pay it I do I resent having to pay for Charter Schools or private schools personally come as a taxpayer okay so it's been moved and properly second that we approve recommendation for increase early childhood education ceas in lrsd based on demand availability space and ECE centers and other lrsd buildings do we need a roll call Miss Valerie Mr yes director Ro yes director Johnson yes director Hatter oh you said no well come back to me director the way word it yes director Wesley yes director Callaway yes director Adams yes director Mason yes director Hatter if you divide the cost over 12 years if they stay
096it's good yeah I I get that but I'm just saying we are not evaluated on that um yes thank you the motion carries thank you Mr okay so we're going to move to uh recommendation five permission for lrsd to actively explore the addition of Elementary bilingual programs to District program offerings I'll entertain a motion I move that we approve recommendation five of superintendent second so we moved in properly second any questions I have one I know I keep having go ahead um I would just like to note that a few years ago this board voted to close Baseline yeah and I am thrilled that we are at a place where we are reopening Baseline in a way that serves its community and serves the kids who are um in that Community with people who are
097um speaking their language literally and I am thrilled about this I'm thrilled there's going to be some Early Childhood there as well as some K2 um I'm very excited so I'm a strong yes thank you thank you any other questions comments it's been moved in probably a second that we I'm sorry did I see something I'm sorry Mr B I'm so sorry sorry yeah I don't like where I'm sitting um you can see now I just wanted to add I I think that this is a a good opportunity uh to embrace cultural exchange also uh the academic benefits and the cultur and social growth benefits as well uh and it's also good for teachers uh to continue their education and think of themselves as policy makers as well too so uh I'm I'm definitely all
098for that and I know uh my zone in particular will definitely uh appreciate this and I but I just also want to add to I know a lot of people think that when we talk about bilingual programs we're talking about the latinx and Hispanic Community uh there are uh many students who uh which English is a second language and is not Spanish and so those are opportunities as well to explore bilingual programs that are outside of Spanish the Spanish language so I just want to just be on record to say that any other comments or questions make sure I see everybody I'm sorry okay so we'll move forward to uh it's been um moved and properly second it's been too many of them it's been moved and properly second the recommendation five be approved for
099permission for lrsd to actively explore the addition of Elementary bilingual programs to District program offerings all in favor hi I think we have it all and any opposed the motion carries unanimous vote okay so we'll move forward are we out of those five and operations all right Mr Bailey thank you good afternoon again good evening good evening good evening time I guess it is so I have I have two uh items here I'm going to call Mr Parker higs up as well so uh back in 2022 October we issued RFP for uh net metering facil uh along with doing that investment grade audit after that we actually awarded to RP uh to Integrity group uh since that time we hadn't had an update formally to you all we've been meeting with them over the last
100year but wanted to bring them before you and I have attached update there as well but I have Mr Parker Hicks here from uh the integrity and he's going to give you a brief update kind of where we are right now and uh maybe for see where we may be in the next year or two that's right all right thanks coy uh thank you board first I just want to say uh this this month we went through the enrollment application process for my 4-year-old uh to start PR so I look looking forward to the time where I can come present to you not just as someone working for the district but as a parent of a child in the district um yeah so um October about 14 months ago we approved the project we immediately
101got started with the utility study process with interg Arkansas uh that took 11 months we had kind of anticipated nine based on our experience with Intergy uh again all over the state it varies depending on what utility you're in but that took 11 months for us to get them to finish their study on what kind of upgrades they would have to do to their system in order to handle uh the solar array system so uh that was finished in September uh they gave us a fee of $1.4 million that was well above what we budgeted we went ahead and paid it at that time uh Because by the end of September was the requirement uh to make that payment uh to ensure that we are um kep we we get grandfather status of net metering
102Legacy status for net metering so essentially that means as the project was based on the savings that you get from the utility is the exact same rate that what you pay them for anyone doing a solar project today is not going to get that rate so uh yours and many other projects were we're we critically aimed towards that September 30th deadline so we did meet that we've got that status um when we looked at the 1.4 they came up with we identified some errors in their study uh so they looked at it again about a month later or so they decided you're right that's only a million dollar uh we're still waiting to get our $400,000 back but we do expect to get that uh but this is still pretty far above what we budgeted
103uh it's it's 50% higher than any interconnection fee we've paid on any project uh up to that time we have other projects that are having the same impacts to them uh so the way that we are dealing with that uh yeah the way that we are dealing with that is you may or may not recall uh again the agreement is that the school district buys power at a set rate um and that rate would change depending on the amount of tax credits uh that the project receives so 40% 50% 60% and the savings the guarantee of performance was based on the 40% rate so uh what we are doing is we are going to raise the 50% and the 60% rate uh we feel as a company fairly confident that we can achieve the 50%
104rate um and so if we can do that at the higher rate then we can still recoup enough of the costs to cover this uh interconnection fee by doing that we are not going above the rate that was that 40% level the savings that are guaranteed and based on that will remain um and you know unfortunately due to continued utility rate increases the savings will likely go up just just last month interg asked for another 4% rate increase so construction started as soon as we got uh through September uh we have done site work clearing the land driving piles that are going to hold it the the panels are actually there on site and secured um at this point we're in a long waiting game for electric equipment which has 12 month 10mth lead times
105that's both for our equipment and also for the utilities equipment so the our equipment we believe you know we could get everything in probably by October next year the utility says their timeline is November December uh so we believe it'll be November December of next year when we can actually turn this array on and the school can start realizing those savings um yes so that's that's the the gist of the review are there any specific questions I know any questions question board members yes question the the is this a supply chain issue with the panels well it's not the panels so we have the panels it's it's the Transformers it's the switch gear um it's been an issue since covid and with data centers and solar arrays and everything that industry has remained uh pretty
106difficult to to get equipment so um yeah again even the fastest that we now we couldn't order equipment until we had the final approval this past September we can't get equipment for for 10 months right is is it coming from uh over the Pacific Ocean um most of it is yeah fair question the uh so so no most of it is is domestic even the the array the panels that we have are domestic as well uh I think the supply chain has issues in that the manufacturers are less than what the the demand is and so they can only even running I'm sure double shifts and all that they can only produce the reason why I asked that are we going to be tffs having yeah yeah uh no we should be protected from tariffs
107and and that's actually a great point that I do want to hit on too because the administration change at the federal level um we have ordered all the equipment um we have made payments we have also been able to um submit the project under current tax credit rules so even if federal tax credits start to change and reduce we will still be under 2024 policy so you'll be protected from that thank you any other questions yes sir is there any point in on this million dooll deal is there any point in pressing it and going to the Public Service Commission we don't need to be shy about it if there is where if if you think it might happen I I'd say it would be very difficult um um it is tough to say I
108I mean there's certainly a lot of discrepancy you know we work with other Utilities in the state the costs are up and down we have projects it's the exact same size that are in the 600 $700,000 range right for an interconnection um you know I don't know that it's been done yet but I I it's certainly a pathway um and we we can you know if the school wants to go that direction we can provide um support and documentation one nth wants to go that way any other questions or concerns questions thank you thanks for the update absolutely 7.2 ready to move forward moving right along all right financial report I'm going to jump around a little bit on here but I'm I'm going to hit the meat of the summary real quick here and
109you all stop me if you have any questions but routine here just a summary kind of where you can find the pages of the report attached here but based on where we are right now and this no I got we've been talking about a lot of reduction we got to have some happy points and some presentations here so one of the happy points here is that property taxes cuz they're they're split up based on uh uh two Hales so we have July 1st through December 31st it's the property tax collection is and that's account uh 1110 and then we have from January 1st uh through June 30th which you'll see Zero there but based on the Year date collection this is actually the end of November we collected $19 million $821,000 that was over what
110we actually had had budgeted so about $ 102% so that Revenue projection is good so hopefully the second half of the year come in just as good and you can see kind of the balances here and some of those will start chewing up a little bit more as we get get through the fiscal year interest on investment is still doing good so we're almost I mean based on what we budget we're 87% toward our actual amount there that's because of the interest rates are still you know up four plus per on any deposits we have out there and the deposits mainly for our Capital Improvement funds that we have that $100 million come in so and that goes right back into our Capital Improvement so the things that uh Park here talking about the inflationary
111cost of things everything is costing much more than what it did four years ago so we'll take all that so right now the Revenue looks good I typically don't list state revenue on here CU it's prescribed and it stays the same uh only other thing that typically changes uh is uh property tax collection if we get any additional grants and uh Miss Young I think provided you all with a pretty comprehensive uh report on grants so and that's still going well so things as far as salary that we look on this report this similar to last month as well it's displaying that we actually have 9.6 million available in that a available balance you look over there uh once all those uh actual person there we put in there all the different stiens and everything
112when in there about $1.5 million that's available and that uh includes any vacances we have out there so and things that we're looking at here and highlight that the main part is classified overtime we looking at ways that we can trim that back make sure we're monitoring that uh we have certain areas that we're really looking at has new reports uh develop as well so you'll see things like architect and other Professional Services typically that's all to do with our Capital Improvement things so we actually issue POS out there but all those POs won't be paid in this fiscal year so similar to the high school out in west lck or West Pinnacle View I guess we can call it that Pinnacle View High School uh we encumbered that whole amount but most of that
113encom are roll over so there's going to be another need in the near future next couple of years to get some more uh Capital Improvement funds to continue these projects uh you'll have projects coming before you probably over the next month or two uh uh for Park VI auditor and renovation and we also have the Baseline cuz all those will be over a million dollars I think we have one more I'm forgetting one but it'll be before you to check it out so we look at all these things to try to Monitor and some of these uh when we're talking about in Commerce so I'm not sure if you're familiar with Commerce but soon as you you issue a PO and in Commerce basically reserves budget there and you have a lot of open in
114comerce not necessarily all going to be liquidated but these are accounts that we actually looking at that maybe over budgetting we have to move uh from a different category so Supply Center for instance I just picked that one on here the 66150 where they buying paper from our Supply Center they might have put all their budget in the 66100 so it's a a matter of just moving budget from that that location so and this is comprehensive of all departments in schools all right so fund balance look much better than what it did last month on operating the fund balance because we had got an influx of that uh fall payment there so you know was fairly low I you saying I was saying more than cuz it got real low so when you you're having
115all those payrolls and everything else going out you have so many capital Improvement funds so it it'll reduce that but our Capital Improvement fund balance is been pretty healthy but the operating fund balance was fairly low but it's 65 million there won't stay there so don't don't don't engrave that in anything don't start spending we spending it it's already decreased now cuz it's December so but Capital Improvement fund balance these eyes of November 71 million uh Federal fund balance uh is positive so you know that's on a reimbursable basis and our Child Nutrition balance has come up a little bit it's down from what it carried pretty much 5 million last year but uh that balance pretty much has to be a two-month operating which is still higher than that so she's still doing a
116lot of renovation and ordering a lot of equipment and different things around there so if you visit some of our uh cafeteria and kitchen you'll see so it's looking good so we still have a long way to go but as we jump in here and this is something I did not forget it director Adams uh he got on me last time now thank you very much sir amazing so let me reduce it if you can uh maybe a little bit go up a little bit but the orange I wish that this was our general operating that we look at the orange but it's not the the purple bluish is actually our general operating funds our funds one and two the orange uh represents our Capital Improvement fund balance and you can kind of see how
117it trended down we got really low on the orange you see all the way down to June and then uh we actually did the next sell in July so we spended almost down before we had to get additional money you can kind of see how the it abs and flow on the other line our fund balances on our operating fund balance uh you can see July it's moderate then you get a jump in November December area and then it starts going back down and April when you get those escro payments from your mortgage company come in for your taxes it goes back up a little bit and then we start spending it right back down so uh no rated really I mean this kind of historical piece that you can see over the last two
118years so we watch this I mean we're watching it closely so especially when our fund balance you can see October can you see October there it's very small very small I'm going roll down there and scroll over you don't want itge so that that wees your CFO when your fund balances get to that point along with my Director of Finance cuz she's watching the daily as well as far as you know the the expenses going out so I'm happy to see the influx in November Mr Bailey I just wanted to make one if it's okay with the chair yes okay I'm sorry um on this graph I love this graph um I um really like it um and I just wanted to know I think it really beautifully kind of describes the challenges we as
119a board have when we are building a lovely new high school that we have we have Capital Improvement dollars for but our operational balance is low I think it's a really great visual to help us explain that so I um really appreciate it I think it helps understand like the orange dollars can't be spent on operational things they can't they can be used on repairs but yeah but not like not they can't be used to pay salar for yeah Educators things I talk about when we're looking at repairs we've had a pretty tough time so far this year with chillers and different things like that so uh for instance pinac viiew Middle School we have some chillers going out there so that's going to probably be close to a million dollar price tag so me
120limping them along we've been uh had some communication with neighbors out there and they're louder than usual and that's because they're starting to fail so uh we met last week and getting designed and they'll get out for bid but you have things like that occur so I most of our buildings I mean they're a little bit older but most of our buildings average age about 70 years old so you have a lot of those infrastructure pieces that are going to start to fail over the next few years we've been addressing as much as possible you have those electrical upgrades the schools built 70 years ago didn't have all the Chromebooks all the servers all the everything else out there that we have we've gone to LED lights so that takes down the the resources needed
121for electrical need out there so it's fully LED for the district so that's a saving we'll be seeing as well so uh but you'll see some more charts on this uh next year too we're doing if you want to see any more we can try to add some more here uh one thing I do want to highlight one other thing so I think I've showed I covered this typically doing uh our uh budget presentation but I keep a lot of spreadsheets to kind of see hisorical kind of where we been and gone and where we may be heading and this is one that kind of shows assess values here uh based on uh current assessment look like we may have about a 3.04% growth next year for assess VAR that'll be a little more income
122and revenue here but we also have some things I know we've had some questions a couple questions come in on how Foundation funding is actually calculated uh so and it we'll scroll down to the bottom and this is typically always highlighted so this year's Foundation funded amount for all schools uh is up to $7,777 if you doesn't have if you don't if it's a school district or a school doesn't have a tax base you get 100% of that if you have a tax base it's offet so basically the foundation funding guarantees you to get 98% of your first 25 Mills and how that's calculated I'll kind of show you this and how we actually get to that point so our total assess value right now is $4.7 billion so we would take that 4.7 billion
123and multiply it times U 025 let me make sure on here let me make sure I'm getting to the right one uh 025 which is 25 Ms and get 98% of that then we we add what's called miscellaneous so that gets us this amount H 115,000 that's how much 25 Mills at 98% collection would act reduce if we took our $7,777 times our 3/4 ADM and ADM stand for the average daily membership that's all your students has enroll at that time they take the first three quarters and average together and they actually come up with this is K12 on no PRK so last year and this four your previous year so last year our three qu average was 19785 84 so you take that times is $77 $771 and it comes up to 153 um
124million uh you subtract those both and that's what's the difference in actually how you actually get your foundation amount that they actually the state is going to give you so this is amount and equates to the same thing here so our state Foundation funds that we're getting from the state this year is $ 38,4 79,2 uh I did I'm always looking forward so based on just saying we're down 387 K12 if if we actually realize that through the four 3/4s and that 34 average actually goes down in 19,0 3988 uh .84 that's where you see this reduction from 38 let me actually do the math real quick to make sure so that's where you see the 6 and5 million that I quoted you earlier that we may be looking at a reduction that's not going
125to be a full 62 million because they have what's called decline enrollment which is kind of about a third of that may be reduced so you may look at to say $4 million reduction next year but the year after if we don't have any growth that's going to be a realized four 65 million so the things we talking about I mean they're real these numbers real they don't there's no magic to them anything so it's the data that we actually pull so but that's basically how you get your foundation calculation it's not an easy calculation if you don't know it but that's that's kind of so you have some districts if you get growth like here if we had 9% or close to 10% growth I think the county was close to 9 Maybe even
12610% growth they get $0 as far as Foundation amount because their actual tax base pays that full amount so uh and if you look over the years here you can kind of see and I've always done percentages here so I'll go back to 2000 yeah the reason why I asked you that question that that that formula how long has that formula been in place uh I before my time I've been here 15 years so it's I mean I mean we I I'm just I'm just saying we should get all our money that's what I'm saying from the state really well they made it to kind of make the plan feel maybe equal therefore cuz if you have a a district that's has a richer assessment versus one that may be declining so that I mean
127that's what only thing I can't tell you any more than that they they're trying to make it equal that's what the state is trying to do but if you see here penalizing us from State Fund yeah so as our assess value has grown over the years so at one time 57% came from our local revenue and now we're we're up to 70 well 75 and maybe 79 next year and that's based on when you have that growth in assess value it goes down on that part so so that's a little Cliff Notes on you for that so I know some of you all had question feel free to reach out to me anytime but that's kind of my summary of those and when I've talked about enrollment these are the enrollment Trends so we look
128at enrollment all across the board so I'm looking at we're looking at uhoh you can't see that game going to stay I can't either but I mean we're looking at roing across several years here I mean you can see where prek was in those years we were up to 1,700 students at one time 1765 so and things we talked about in the past before of course Mr Rose were board member way before I got here I think but we talked about uh getting kids on read reading level by third grade and prek helps do that so my kids have four kids uh 22 all the way down to four and all of them went prek here in Little Rock so and I have two more that starting now have gone through so I got at
129Rockefeller I mean it's amazing you can tell a big difference I mean a big difference when they're in there so versus a daycare and we started them in a two year old program we actually paid Little Rock cuz two-y old program is not free so we paid talking out a daycare and it's a big difference on what you're learning in our district versus what they're getting in a high quality daycare and it's it's no it's no different it's no it's big difference you can't compare them so and that's my personal testimony so but that's pretty much it so we're looking at these and when I talked about uh us losing those students you can see where the largest loss has been uh prek is down you know 244 over that from that big part but
130I mean we had a major drop in 2020 during the pandemic but 1,400 elementary students were down 544 middle and middle used to be the leading leader of uh being you know down as far as the losses and actually High School is up this year as compared to uh fy19 over the 5e period so we've actually gain more high school so questions comments yes do could could we possibly get a readonly version of this spreadsheet that you just drop on a Google drive somewhere I I don't want to mess with it but it so often and I just never quite feel like I can keep up on here is there a way we could just maybe when you update it every month or whenever you update that if you wouldn't could you would you be
131able to do that yeah I may give youall a condensed version just with the ones I hit I have a lot you don't have to give us all your work and tabs down there but you may not need me if I give you all that so you got to keep now any other questions comments um Mr B for the uh upcoming school year the budget uh that you typically start working on that in is it April May or when is that when do you typically we start working on that we never sto working on budget really just honestly so I mean the presentation is a piece so like I said any actions You all take uh when we approve stiens when we do all that that's part of the the budget process so what you
132all typically see is a pictorial view of what actions has been already taken yesterday uh yesterday so yes yesterday so if we voted to bring everybody every District employee back that was a budget thing there so at that point we're just working on actually trying to fill the gaps as far as funding pieces so you have I I don't know if you've looked at the audit report so we have a ton of different funding sources that come through each one of those persons have to be uh coded to a funding source so lot most people are operating but that's typically what we're doing but I guess whenever you all want to kind of sit down so Revenue projection will probably be ready uh as far as taxes probably we can see May because the collections
133the last collection the big collection going to be April May and you want to make sure you make that Revenue projection we were pretty kind of aggressive more than than years past on the revenue projection for local taxes cuz we had we needed to be otherwise we've probably been looking at a $10 million deficit so we went in we still have vacy we still looking at a lot of personnel so we have a lot things that we discussed at cabinet and things to be discussed as well as far as you know changing some some operations so so the point of me asking that is um because typically we uh we just approve what you bring up and so my and in and its you know actuals versus programs and what we spent and went out
134get that but as far as a working budget session um to where uh we are looking at the schools the school budgets like other boards do across the country and they are very active in the um budget uh process and so um you know I'm I'm going to save you cuz you've been hearing me say this for almost 5 years now but we need a budget session we had one and 21 and then that was the last one we we had so we um as a board this is one of the major things we do because when when whenever there's an audit or um something happens regardless if it's budget or anything else they're they are coming to the board that's the whole point of having the board to where it takes the heat off
135of the staff and it place it on a board and so that's why we have a board right to oversee these different things and so at some point we do need to just have our start um rekindle since it's been 20 since 21 so start restart having budget sessions where we're looking at budgets looking at the budgets um at one point you gave us not only um the testing scores and things like that of our schools and we were looking at that which is part of the learns Act actually we're supposed to be looking at all this stuff and um but also looking at campus budgets and um projections and really having a more um involved involved for those who who want to to have that so at some point it would be nice to
136have that sounds great sounds great that be totally up you all call I think the spring would probably be the the time before you actually once you issue contracts I mean we're we're pretty much set and we're filling positions at that point if we need them so I mean you're looking at enrollment numbers too so I mean you know when we're thinking about meetings um and we're talking about agenda meetings versus other meetings that we need to have to make sure that we are communicating that information I think that'd be great so we can definitely I think we should definitely explore that uh the chair what you need a you have a question half instruction half question it may be just because I'm new or it could be that I'm thickheaded I need a list
137of all those abbreviations in knows oh we will I I need to send you a budget book so I have some narrative too okay so we have a lot so we typically do all that so also we typically would bring Mr Trump in from Stevens to go over BN financing and all that so that is I figured out I forgot I need to send both of you off so I figured out some of them but some of them were just completely alien I couldn't imagine if I us one just say I don't know yeah when I say Esa enhanced student achievement fund so it used to be called nsla so we'll use a national school lunch meeting the chair will entertain a motion all right thank you I moved at L Ro School District Board
138of Education approved the November 2024 financial report as presented second it's been moved and properly second that the lrd Board of Education approved the November 2024 financial report as presented all in favor say I I I any opposed the carries unanimous thank you so much all right so we're moving on to strategic communication and Community engagement the vision mission and core values superintendent all right so um we don't necessarily have to we can't really spend a lot of discussion time on this because the um staff surfery just closed Tuesday and so in your folders I gave you a copy of how the um vote turned out um on this little sheet here but in our January agenda meeting we are going to uh dedicate time to having a uh discussion about uh the vision and
139the mission statements already know even though we've got feedback from our staff we need to uh shorten that mission um uh significantly to keep the essence of the message but I did want to at least give you um the results of that particular survey um but we will have dedicated time um in January to kind of um discuss it and I think I I think I know I communicated um to the board last week about the whole process and how we even got here um but of course the board being the governing board um if you wanted to go a different direction in terms of how we um approach this um of course that's the purview of the board but at least wanted to give you um the survey results and then you can have
140time to review it and and think about it and then uh in January we'll have some robust discussions about it any questions or comments uh pending that discussion and other information all right we'll move on thank you so much for that information to nine policy personnel and legal uh Roi and final report from Kasa that Miss Hatter qua quesa I'm sorry I just cannot believe case the head would you like to present on that sure um so um this is this this is something I wanted to um follow up on as far as their um return on on investment with quesa and um and then like the steps forward with the district and so like they were able to bring in um a substantial amount of um dollars back into the district in the form
141of students and uh I think it was a three-year pilot that we are program that we used them for was it 3 years 2 years what was it we it was just it was multiple things we used them the first campaign was just a pilot and then last year was just was our first full campaign but it wasn't a multi-year contract okay so so we use them two a different times yeah so it's multiple okay so um and then two I wanted to like look at like um the the ab the absenteeism and how does that um uh play a role in um students uh loss of students as well as the overall student experience cuz they uh did um reach out and they sent like 86,000 texts and uh they had a very robust
142um reach out to to parents to engage them uh to see one and then right if they're staying in the district two and then if they're coming um back into the district and and um was able to bring them back so with us not um uh using uh quesa and they are open for others to um use I want to know what what is the plan forward to for student engagement and experience more so student experience fam's experience um to retain and to attract uh students and families in our district superintendent um I'm going to answer that in in in a couple of ways um so if you look inside your folders there are a couple of documents there is a reconnect and recruitment plan um but before I get to that I really wanted
143um you guys to take some time I know you just you're just seeing this um but uh I think it's important that we as a Cabinet we have been asking ourselves lots of critical questions around iron enrollment and Recruitment and how and and Trends we just want to have a a a a realistic understanding of of how the trends have been over the last couple years and so if you look at this document um it actually shows you the number every year since 2019 how many students that left our district uh for example in 2019 we had 2,43 students who left us the year before at the end of the 2018 and year of those 83 uh showed up before the October 1st uh account in the previous year and then we had 68 um
144that returned after January 1st and then if you look at the last column all the way to the end that shows you the number of new students who came to our district for the first time excluding kindergarten and so when you look at these Trends um and then this document is just broken down by grade level so I'm not going to go over that it's just this data broken down by grade level so you can see where the great level Trends are the question that we ask ourselves is that 132 or 135 students um that queso was able to retain or recruit for us and of that forgot the number 132 135 whatever it was something like that um I believe we they received $850 we paid them $850 per that 135 which equal to$
145114,000 that we paid them um that is literally half of the money correct me from R Mr Bailey that's about half of the revenue that we would have gotten from the St like we we in essence split that in half um we paid quesa yeah that 850 per student and the rest of it was ours and so when we look at the net gain from students who leave us M return and new students um um we really strongly felt that that 132 um although we we're Greatful and happy we when you look at like the overall picture and overall Trends we didn't feel like that was a a a good return on investment um now what we did do we learned quite a bit um and I know Dr Phils was supposed to join us
146via Zoom but I think we're having some tech issues we have learned quite a bit from quesa in terms of their strategy and and things that they do and it it you know reveals some glaring holes in how we don't follow up with families when they leave us how we you know don't communicate with them to find out exactly why how we don't make opportunities to re-engage with them and so we've actually taken some pieces from their script um and when you look at when you get a chance to review this um this is what we put together and we'll be going over with our attendance secretaries and our principles we moved all of our principles now Elin principles all of our principles in our district for 12 months um we also make sure that
147all of our schools now have attendance secretaries and so we now have the staff within our own District to pretty much pick up some of the strategies that they were using and we're really borrowing uh some of the tools that they use and when you get a chance to review this you will see um what we are planning to do to kind of um re-engage and reconnect with our family so as for example as soon as at the end of every quarter this plan calls for our attendance that secretaries to send to report data to the district office in terms of all students who with Drew um we will get that information at the district we will disaggregated we will send back um a report to the schools um and you'll list and see here
148what their responsibilities are at the school and we'll do that every single quarter um and then you'll see uh some of the steps that we plan to take to um reach out to parents and how we plan to do that when you have an opportunity to see that so that is the plan but I wanted to present all of that data as well so you can see how we arrive um at the decision that we arrived okay and so out of that I'm so out of that I'm taking with other oh you sneeze God bless you um so out of that I'm taking that the district is putting the onus on student Recruitment and Retention on the individual uh schools and so if they continue to lose enrollment and followup then that directly uh falls
149on the principle and the attendance secretary yes and and part of that is you know we all as a district um and I don't want to go too far down a rabbit cold but we are all responsible for Recruitment and Retention and what we want to really hone in is that you know the more we keep losing students we need our employees to understand that it impacts them um and so that we all have to share responsibility and number one making sure that we're providing the right type of customer service um you know we're putting a in place to make sure that our product that we're providing in terms of the classroom is getting better um but we also need to do a much better job of reaching out to parents to have structures and
150policies in place to know to to be able to know why people leave um and then be able to follow up with them in ways that you'll see uh described here and so yes we are trying to share the ESS and responsibility of selling our district and um the recruitment um on all on all of our staff specifically at our schools okay um I would like to see a report to be able to measure that rubric um to see if there's a return on investment for taking um uh and giving a 12-month uh contract and uh a new position to do just what we were Contracting out on so if we are saying we're taking it inhouse um and they will do all the things that um quesa was doing then that means that we
151should see a return on investment but in to in seeing that we we would need um a measure of rubric a rubric to measure that to see whether or not there is a true return on um investment and then um and then what all and and what other adjustments that might be be needed if possible questions from the board um I think director R question Miss Hatter I um I think if they got 135 kids it'd be worth I mean that's what we got from them from K so if the principes and the secretaries tenant secretaries come up with 135 students I think we're doing great um and there are other things that the principles are going to be doing in their extended contracts besides this that mean 12-month contract they're just going to be
152loaded down with stuff all the time anyway as they are now we're just going to add you know two more months to jump on them which is fine you know they get the they get the middle size fcks for it um well they are the CEO building midle I would uh if anybody in this process thinks that it would be of any value for a board member to talk to somebody I'm all for it I'll I'll talk to somebody about why they left and why they can't come back and what we need to do to change things that would make them want to come back consensus driven decision- making is a wonderful tool so if you talk to somebody and say well what's your problem and they tell you a problem and you sit there
153and you think well that's not a problem we can fix that then you gain two kids 2.2 kids so I'm available thank you director um one of the things I wanted to bring up with this is and I know Dr W you kind of referred to it but it's just our general our general overall strategic marketing plan I know we talked about this um this week but I have um received two emails this week from um some list I guess my name got bought on from a local Charter School um to try to recruit my children to that Charter School um which they are not going to uh they will not convert me don't worry um but it but it does show the level to which some of our competitors are going I mean they
154are working I tried to kind of dig in based on the information in the email and I think there's a local PR firm representing this school and it looks like there is they've bought a list of names from somewhere so I just kind of want to state that that is I know you know this but that is what our competition's doing I've got some very lovely looking emails and um very kind of you know this is the only college preparatory program etc etc and so I just want to kind of note that maybe we need to step up our game on that front and both at the district level as well as the individual building level I think particularly about our middle schools in that space because we do tend to lose a lot of
155kids and I think as we see start to see the Imp implications of learns even our older elementary kids our fifth graders I know may start to go over to middle schools to get a spot before all of the learns um spots fill up um so anyway I just think we need to be ahead thinking ahead on this that's all director B yeah um just as far as thinking ahead and I talked to you before I actually got in this seat or whatever thinking about some innovative ways to recruit and do a community engagement uh I know when we talk about principles attendance uh people they might not necessarily um have the expertise in how to engage with the community and so giving them opportunity to get some professional and personal development on building relationships
156with the community I think uh if we can find ways to offer that I think that's very valuable and I want to stress again too um going down going down the road to City Hall and talking to the people the city the mayor the mayor there there's actually supposed to be a youth council with the city of Little Rock I don't know how often they meet or when they meet but engaging with uh the mayor the city of L Rock uh the community programs and finding out some ways where we can partner with them to help uh recruit in the city and um get them involved in in the process so we don't put all of the work on um schools and administrators but we can also put the city to work to have a
157question I do have a question Dr right I know that our dropouts are students as well do we have a plan for going after our dropouts the students that drop out the students that just go away drop out is my mic not on no I'm I'm I'm thinking about how to respond because when I think about um our dropouts immediately think about the different categories or type and the first thing that actually came to my mind were um our newcomer students um and I use Southwest example as Southwest High School as an example you know the primary reason why their graduation rate is still in the 70% range is because all of the newcomer students who come um to Southwest who don't speak English um who may be 16 17 we got a couple 18
158year olds who have never even been in a public school before um and so those students enroll into our school and because we don't have the proper U programs in place to adequately serve them now um that's one kind of Dropout then I think about all of our um overage uncredited kids in our district who once you continue to get older and you Contin continue to lag behind in terms of credits that also increases the likelihood that you drop out and so I think about our ACC program that is how that Metro in basically three classrooms um that is not even adequately set up to serve all of our overage under accredited students in our district so one of the things that we are looking to do is to find a space to drastically explain
159a uh expand ACC so that we can serve more overage uncredited students and prevent them from dropping out because that's where the that's where when I think about dropouts I think about those two categories of students and I believe that that is like they probably make up the majority of dropouts that we have in our district and so our ACC program is not set up to serve the number of overage over credited students that we have and then we are looking to do a I don't want to speak prematur because we're trying to get some Al funding for this uh and so I'm going to hush but we are looking to have a a real newcomer program at our high school so that when those students come to us that we're not sticking them in
160a English one class okay they can't speak a li of English they're 18 years old around you know 13 14 year old students um and they come to school for a couple days and eventually you know so yeah okay I know a long answer but we have a plan okay any other questions director yes I one of the things and I'll be like the other directors I'm I'll be really curious to see what happens you know with this if we go down this road of you know working with principals and and attendance secretary but I think one of the potential positives that I see from that is what I saw on the quesa report that they gave us that looked at that some of the top reasons that people gave for leaving one one was
161if I remember correctly was um you know frustration with slowness of response and and you know from administration at their school and another was bullying which was not resolved and and both of those are really concerning and problematic and and if the school principal and the staff are hearing that and getting that then it cuts out in some ways the middle person that you know if Cas if somebody else is hearing it it's different than if the person who's hearing it is a person who's responsible for fixing it and U and so I think that that does give us at least an opportunity perhaps to address those concerns that for some some of the top concerns that people are are leaving to address those concerns in a more effective way very good yes I worked
162with ulr on some Why students didn't return stuff and we found that usually when somebody talked about frustration with slow responses that just meant they weren't getting the response they wanted so that's to be taken into consideration when you're thinking about that yeah yeah well I do agree that you know there's you know in the world that we you know there's in a human world that that it's not going to be possible at all times to to meet everybody's concerns and needs but we but I think that it's also possible for us to do a better job than than we're doing and and it's on us you know to to do the best job possible and um and build on the good things that are happening but but do the very best we can you
163know for the students benefit and for the district's benefit Co we move forward uh let me just say one and you know what I do agree with that but I I think sometimes with the differ locations and different schools and different principles I think resolution is somewhat different as opposed to being Universal so what one person may do to resolve the issue another person may do something to resolve the issue but it's not the same so I think if you had a universal location person group or whatever to handle your customer service I think that your outcome would be a lot better any other questions I'm sorry any other questions yes ma'am director Johnson uh comment jogged the conversation with uh some parents that was contemplating well they're moving to schools um and it's centered
164around being talked at and and being belittled when talking being um spoken to and so what I take away from that is making sure that you are meeting the person right where they're at to where you're not um speaking in a derogatory or a belittling tone or way um towards them but but then you were truly actively listening right to resolve the issue um because parents parents are different today like before they would try and work work it out now it's like you know what if it's not working then I have these other schools to shop around and and go to and so like they are they they are showing um institutions how they feel by right by movement versus um their words because some of that the soft expectations racism and classism are soft
165expectations is not something that we've done away with in this District you said it that's right so the the chair will entertain a motion we're moving forward to number 11 number where no board resolutions so moving forward to number 11 oh I move board going to Executive session to consider some imployment matters I'm sorry I think we have to have a uh just a point of order I think our moving to go into executive session has to fit the criteria La us at the state very specifically need a very specific motion so are we what are we doing we I'm entertaining a motion specific to Executive session number yeah number 11 yes is this for the waiver what is this for oh well it wasn't on the agenda we can move we we can move
166it till on January we um really we've talked about it already multiple times but we can move it to January okay so no uh no motion okay all right so we'll move to 12 board comments board comments can we sing around with the happy holidays um so um I do have a comment um I just really want to applaud the board I feel like we uh did some wonderful work this evening um I think that we were very focused uh for the most part I think that there were a number of things that came up that may have um lended to a number of other things that you know kind of um caused us to Veer off the course but not significantly and so I really applaud um our efforts to work collaboratively um on
167a number of occasions there have been times that um we've been met with individuals who um have watched us with popcorn and children and seeing us as entertainment and I really I find that disheartening to say the least uh and so I just really applaud us for been really boring tonight absolutely I love it I love it and so I I just applied us for doing what I believe we all came to do and that is to focus on our students and their outcomes and to ensure that they are excellent and that we do the very best that we can to ensure that that is the case um and I hope also that um you know when we are divided and that will happen sometimes in our decision making that we all understand that it
168comes from a place still of wanting excellence and wanting um the best for our children in the district other comment yes Miss callway brings this up I brought it up in the last several meetings the learns Act is going to kill us and we can't just roll over and take it federal court is the place to go with our objections to the learns act into the Ballinger Act and the superintendent needs to hear me on that just I we don't need to be afraid of lawsuits they'll cost us a little money but they won't cost us a whole lot of money and the Ballinger act we can attack as as freedom of speech and freedom of association thing uh the the vouchers are just con constitutionally illegal it's just flat out there in the Constitution
169says they can't do it and they're doing it anyway that just that just needs a judges a judge to shake his finger and I'm going to be urging my fellow board members to urge you to consider that we sue somebody other comment to um just to my um uh colleague uh Tony Rose I do agree with you this is a different DNA of the original board because I I think we probably would have did that um My Hope Is that um we do um not attack or are not um approach learns from from from a state of fear but but but but really from a a proactive way to where it benefits not only um our district but also um our families uh within within our district and and and the reality is um uh
170you know the state kind of already did what it is they want to do the Little Rock Know by saturating it with a lot of um Mom and Pop uh Charters and charter schools and and twoo you know it doesn't make sense really to be upset with the physical building of a charter school the the the issue is really with the legislature because Charter Schools I look at them like a tax credit place I mean like you can't get mad because somebody is able to um took advantage of of of of an opportunity that the legislator created and so and so the issue is really at at the legislator um level for and to the S SP really because because the SBE keep on um approving uh Charters particular particularly in Little Rock so um
171and so that's kind of right where the fight or or or the um point of um address should be is that those point of of inj um injuries like the legislature like the court system um and and the SB but yeah so it is um holiday season you guys um have a wonderful wonderful wonderful um holiday uh season no matter whatever you um celebrate in whatever way whether it's uh K Quanza or Christmas or Hanukkah or just celebrating being alive would say it again just or the sausage just being just the sausage that's right just being alive so um in that um and you guys one thing I do want to say don't ever be um and then always be your authentic self even if it irritates others be your authentic uh self cuz it's
172only one you I don't know any other way to make other comments Hallelujah other comments happy holidays thank you all so much um I will yes I do don't I okay so the chair will entertain a motion okay right CL this meeting school district for the year a second second okay been moving properly second all in favor I unanimous we will move forward to the next meeting board hearing and Dr do Mr can take a minute break sure we can take a three minute break absolutely no e e e all right ladies and gentlemen I now call the Personnel hearing to order pursuant to Arkansas code 6-7 17- 414 which allows employees to request a waiver from School District Board of Directors if the school district board director grants a waiver it will be effective
173only at that school district therefore the L Rock School District administration has advised the employees SL applicant of the disqualification and the right to request a waiver on behalf of the lrsd Administration the representative will present the affected employee in facts for board consideration the background ground check Personnel hearing is open the affected employees should appear at the meeting and he and be prepared to present their respective case and answer the board questions the circumstances that the board may consider includ but are not limited to the age at which the crime or incident was committed the circumstances surrounding the crime or incident the length of time since the crime or incident subsequent work history employment references character references other evidence demonstrated or demonstrates that the applicant does not pose a threat to the health or
174safety of school children or School Personnel the port will discuss all issues regarding the back background check appeal request in the open session board executive session is not applicable concerning any background ground check Personnel appeal hearings Mr Kaz thank you madam chair board members for uh the Administration has two parts for tonight and so I don't embarrass myself the parts we're going to start with are in the folders that are this color and then later on we're going to get to the folder that's this color um we're going to begin with uh Charlene Jackson and in your packet you're going to have every document that I'm going to uh discuss with you this evening uh the Little Rock School District administration does not oppose this waiver request the administration recommends option three uh based on
175the Decision Guide which we'll talk about and that's that's listed in the in the second page turning on that turning over you'll see Miss Jackson's request for an appeal hearing uh turning over there you'll see the December 2nd 2024 letter from the Arkansas Department of Correction uh advising us that Miss Jackson showed up on a criminal background check uh for an offense dated back in 2010 so um now fully 14 years uh for that offense to have occurred turning over you will see an order to seal uh which has been filed with the palaski County Circuit Court with respect to that underlying charge um and that goes three pages for the order uh you see the the expungement on the page after that after the entry of the order and then you see Miss Jackson's
176employment application um option three uh which is on a a page that looks like this option three is the recommendation from the school district um that Administration does not oppose a waiver of the disqualifying offense uh but Miss Jackson will need to reapply for employment possibilities due to due to irregularities or falsification of the application the expungement may make that uh just kind of thinking out loud the expungement could be confusing at that point for a defendant that figures hey I've got all this behind me um and that is the that is the administration's position the very last page in your packet is a copy of the resolution which the Department of Education will need and if the board chooses to Grant uh the waiver uh we'll need action on the resolution uh to show
177to the ad uh with that Administration rests we have nothing else with respect to Miss Jackson I Believe Miss Jackson is here and ready to present her side you doing all right how you doing I'm doing fine I see that this happening what have you been doing since again working after that you miss understand how trouble yes yes you learn your lesson onm it was a mistake I learned for it and I paid for it PID C what you like to make a statement to start out would you like to make a statement specific to your request um Miss stepanie she here to here to support me Miss Stephanie and I I didn't understand what you were saying right I was just asking if you'd like to make a statement on your behalf um on
178my behalf I it was a mistake I know it was wrong and I paid for it the I paid for it and I paid it back and if I could turn and go back there back then I'll go back and change it questions from the board questions one question uh you you working for um Miss Walker a hind right now how long you been working for I've been uh since 05 in little Ro School dist okay and I have another job I take care of kids at school care so you got two jobs yes sir 05 so that's 19 years I've been there a long time okay that's enough for me any other questions thank you thank you thank youall so much welcome M Wesley I'd like to make a motion that the the school
179board for Miss Jackson it's been moved and properly second all those in favor say I I any opposed passes unanimously I love that you brought your Christmas cheer tonight your holiday cheer thank you board members I'd like to direct your attention to the folder for Miss Carolyn noly uh as we discussed with Miss Jackson uh the administration does not oppose a waiver in this situation uh the school district recommends a uh option three as with Miss Jackson due to uh falsification in the job application process uh turning through the pages you'll see um Miss nollie's request re EST for a hearing before this board uh you'll see a December 6th 2024 letter from the Department of Education uh showing that the background check has has uh turned up an offense dating back to 1988 um
180and then miss nollie's employment application uh as I said the the school district does not object to a waiver in this case given the uh the age of the underlying offense and I would request that uh if the board were to adopt the resolution that they do it with option three in mind and with that the administration rest yes good evening hey how you doing I'm good full disclosure Miss Molly Miss Molly was in in the building with me at high school so okay Miss n oh my God despite it would you like to make a statement on your behalf I would like to say that I love doing what I do working with kids and I would like to continue work with them and put the past in the past questions that we have
181any questions huh I got to get you a r entertainment a motion entertain a motion Madam chairman I I move that option three let me look at it first um that we okay thank you uh that the recommendation of option three for um I move that the lrb board approve the resolution granting a background check waiver for Carol and nly okay option second it's been moved impr properly second for option three Carolyn no's request for a waiver of a disqualifying offense which prohibits her employment in l r school district is granted however must reapply for employment possibilities due to falsification of the application Administration may prepare the appropriate resolution for the signature of the board president subject to employment upon further review by the administration all in favor say I I any oppos passes unanimously
182that's the Little Rock Central High School wonderful wanted to know for sure Merry Christmas Merry Christmas to you Merry Christmas [Music] and board members I'd like to direct your attention to the folder for Mr Dion Hayes um as in the previous two matters uh the administration does not oppose this waiver request in a different light from the previous matters Administration would recommend option one uh because Mr Hayes did disclose uh the underlying offense as part of his application process he is uh currently working uh with L Rock School District as in the transportation department as a driver uh as you'll uh as you'll see the underlying offense dates back to 2008 um and you see various uh documents related to that and then Mr Hay's application uh that he submitted with li Rock School District
183uh I'd like to direct your attention to the criminal history section where he disclosed it um and then as before there's uh the the options and since there's there's no need to reapply if the court were to Grant a waiver we could do option one and the resolution that accompanies it and with that the administration rest thank you Mr Hayes doing well Mr Haz would you like to make a statement on your behalf uh yes ma'am I was just um in my past I was young um I made dumb decisions and I hung around the wrong crowd you know and I'm trying to um put my P behind me and continue on with my future as a employee with the L Rock School District questions from the board entertain a motion Madame President I move
184that lrsd board approve the resolution granted in the background check waiver for uh Mr Dion Hayes option one second it's been moved improperly second for to approve option one Mr Hay's request for a waiver of a disqualifying offense which prohibits his employment in the L school district is granted the administration is authorized to prepare the appropriate resolution for the signature of the board president thank you thank you V yes I'm sorry we didn't take a vote I'm sorry I'm so sorry I'm so happy that we had it I'm so sir all in favor say I I any oppose it passes unanimous all right Mr Kaz we have how many more a little BR I'm sorry no honey we got together had hurry we got board members so happy to get get a man this folder's
185a little bit different and if if the board will indulge me U as we walk through it there's been a a little change in the regulatory structure of the law around disqualifying offenses which requires renewals of resolutions on a five-year basis the remaining uh six people on the agenda are all current employees Little Rock School District they have all previously received a resolution for a waiver from The Little Rock School District some of these dating all the way back to when uh there's at least one that has commissioner ke signature on it um none of these six people have uh had a break in service with Little Rock School District theyve worked for us the entire time these are our employees and there are no issues in their work performance or in any other matter
186this is a formality they they come back to us from the Department of Education and essentially the department is is asking um is asking for a new resolution and so I'm asking the board that this evening I'm happy to March through all six uh none of those six people are here this evening the chair will entertain a motion I move see that the Larch school board approved resolutions granting and renewing the background check waivers as presented in agenda items 3.1 through 3.6 second second it's been moved and properly second um we approve the motion that the lrsd board resoling granting and renewing the background check waiver as presented an agenda item 3.1 through 3.6 all in favor say I I any opposed the motion cars M president move for ajour I entertain a motion forj
187no objection okay did we get a second to move prop second all in favor I and oppos the motion carries I recommend that for adjournment that the chair says hearing no objection we're ajour not bother to vote I sounds good we don't have to wonderful sounds [Music] great for