CorpusRecord 94577

Shelton School Board Dec. 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MasonWebTV
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Buffalo County, NE
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,869 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001hello everybody it's 6 o'clock let's go ahead and get started if we could stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all have all the board members had a chance to look at the agenda there's no changes I'm aware of a motion to approve this evening's agenda a second all in favor I I okay we have an agenda superintendent report Mr Jesse thank you board president wander other board directors student Representatives staff family members and community members uh I'll start off uh today I was at Evergreen Elementary it was a really nice visit I was in a number of classrooms um uh really touching to have a

002number of our students uh especially some our students who reive multilingual Services uh reading to me they were doing word games uh working off their units uh a number of them were going through their uh book baggies explaining why they lik their books some of them are super proud uh that they were in chapter books so it was really nice um just a mix of genre uh non-fiction I learned a lot about some specifically wolves today uh we had a young young man just able to express uh a lot of detail about how interested he is in wolves so that was nice um really nice setting um special uh recognition to miss aosta who's the third grade teacher there uh she just really invited me in and she was really trying to show me all

003the things that she had been working on with her students and being in a dual language classroom she had definitely working really hard to get kids into literacy and um definitely building their skills so um good on her for sure uh and I just other real quick note uh special thank you to maintenance we had a little bit of an uh issue with the HVAC in the Performing Arts Center at shs and they were working to resolve that issue so um thanks for working overtime and getting that because we had a performance there over the weekend so I think it was starting to get cold and so it was nice to at least get that resolved um in an emergency manner so thank you so much for the maintenance team for the Shelton School District

004so with that that'll conclude my comments thank you all right and now we have a presentation from the cedar high school students good evening president wander and the members of the board thank you for this amazing opportunity to for us to share our project with you I believe what Cedar does is very important and really helps the way that I learn and uh it helps the way I engage with others and I think it's really going to help my future and I'm very glad that we have a school like Cedar in our school district without further Ado let me introduce who I have with me here Elena white and Ryan Simmons and I'm Anderson Porter uh the three of us participated uh in plant bio during the first trimester and a quadrat poster project as

005you'll learn shortly a quadrat is different from a quadrant all the 10th graders are required to take this class so we began this research project by in the spring of the 2023 and 2024 school year we constructed a 1 M by 1 meter quadrat which is different from a quadrant um a quadrant is just a [Music] square just a square meter stick used for like biology study or ecology um we an made an analysis of the plants that grow in our study area which the pictures here are on top of our Hill that we use to study the native and non-native plants 28 students continued this work for the goal of learning the clear-cut regulations it is a cedar goal to continue monitoring and studying this area for our campus so the process of the

006quadrat that we used was um to find an area that has organisms and all types of plants around them and uh to create a square with four meter sticks uh and to toss the quadrat and randomly uh to identify these plants and other organisms we used an app called I naturalist after identifying the plants the plant count and how many was how many plants were inside of the the quadrat uh we also track the percentage of plants like overall uh and so I naturalist helps uh find coordinates to where it is so we know exactly where it was on the hill and uh it also helps identify each plant so uh we understand what we're learning about and that's very important so we know the difference between a uh native plant non-native plant invasive non

007invasive Etc um and the last step is to uh repeat step three through six so and this happens 20 times so you just toss it the quadrat and keep going with a group of four so after analyzing our data with the eight groups they reported all having grassp being their number one in all of their quadrats 16.6 of those quadrats all had grass and 12.4 of those quadrats all had Scotch broom after analyzing each group data 12 plants were found native and 13 plants were non-native to our Hill uh some of the next steps we'll be taking is uh collecting data data of the percentages of how much plants grow throughout uh the winter and into spring um so then we can see how the growth is throughout the different seasons and some of the

008things we will be doing differently is uh making sure each group has 20 points of data uh for each of their quadrats and uh cutting the hill into like quadrants to make sure that we don't have repeats of the data so then we have more accurate data throughout uh all of the quadrant quadrats we do and then uh the last thing we'll be doing differently is uh assigning different roles to each people to each person into the groups uh I would also like to mention we started off with a driving question which is like the main idea of the whole project and our driving question was uh can we learn from what can we learn from uh sampling plants within a one square meter and right after we were presented the driveing question uh we

009met with our group which was eight people and we uh signed our group contracts which is like the agreements that we all abide to and and if we don't agree with those we will try to resolve it any questions I was just curious what some of the native plants you discovered are um let's see it's okay if you can't read it off the ground the other question anything surprised you in your study um I think that one thing that really surprised me in our study was just how many different types of plants are on that Hill and how that hill was once just completely clearcut there was nothing to it it was all dirt and after some time all of these different plants grew there and I just I just think it was really interesting

010how something could just go from nothing to something pretty big and really important to our school also there was a lot of scotch BR I would also uh like to point out the fact that uh being able to like just see what's in the quadrat really like helps us get like uh a perspective of like in retrospect like how many small things are in an area and I kind of like related it to like the difference between like world history and like Washington history because you get more specific data great job thanks [Applause] okay next up is community comment as part of the regular school board meeting the board welcomes community members to make public comment in order in person and or by phone as conditions allow please see the full script with call-in instructions

011and guidelines for Community comments displayed on the screen above first up will be Laura Lyn Rogers good evening chair wheer and board I'm lauran Rogers soon to be from 1208 Hemlock Lewiston Idaho I was hoping for a public request a public records request that I did not yet receive but this being the last meeting of the year I thought I would speak to it without my prr I will just say that I am under the impression that certain members of the board do not give any credit to the open comments from the community however I want you to realize if you look back a year or so on public comments three members of our community pointed out the shortfall you are experiencing would happen with concrete numbers to support it one of the parents only

012wants to help the district her kids are in one has chosen private school for his children yet still cares enough to come and share his verifiable concerns one has no connection other than wanting to keep you all informed all of them take their time to research and speak to you because they just want to improve Shelton school district for Community kids this is just one example there's been many examples of caring caring and verifiable uh comments I have heard at uh during my time here thank you very much I believe it's Kyle Christmas most people get that all right uh thank you this is my first time at a school board meeting so thanks all of you um my name is Kyle Christmas I am a parent a volunteer and a member the treasurer of

013the ptso of Evergreen school district and I would like to at least say a few words about the uh email we got sort of out of the blue about the cedar High School being moved onto the Evergreen campus um that email shocked all of us uh that we spoke to because no one had heard anything about it prior to this um because we're so involved in the school uh the school there I brought it up to other parents and to teachers there and no one had any idea that that was something even being talked about or being something that was brought up so um that was one thing another thing is I didn't even know that Cedar high school was a thing which as we all know if people are left in the dark their

014imaginations run wild so I looked it up and uh very serendipitous that cedar high school was here to talk about something that was actually really cool to see and learn about so um just just something we didn't know and a lack of communication around what was what was happening the email also didn't provide any sort of information around Logistics safety information anything like that so um we just wanted to make sure that if something like this happens and impacts you know this community and the people involved more information is shared and the input of those who will be impacted is included and I mean I don't imagine you could hold off on this decision until more community members get a say in things but that would be nice if that could happen or because the

015the locations they're being put in are Portables could they be you know moved to somewhere better fitting of that so that is uh that's that's have to say so thank you all thank you Marilyn Aaron good evening um I'm here tonight to address several significant concerns about the lack of transparency and communication from our superintendent time and time again we see conversations that go in circles where answers are vague incomplete or entirely avoided this approach undermines trust not only between the superintendent and the board but also between the district leadership and our community first I'd like to address the superintendent's recent claim at the last board meeting about reducing six district office positions this statement is misleading two of those positions the k38 athletic director and the special services secretary are not actually district office

016positions while they may be physically housed in the district office they are funded by sources outside the district office office budget K througha athletic director is funded through the levy and the special services secretary is funded by restricted special education funding including these roles in the count of the district office reductions is inaccurate and creates a false Narrative of significant sacrifices being made at the administrative level while we're on this topic since superintendent began at the Shelton School District he has added at the district office level the bilingual coordinator director of student wellness HR Manager and data manager to name a few these additions contradict The Narrative of sacrifice and austerity at the administrative level meanwhile the majority of the burden of budget cuts has fallen disproportionately on certain staff this inequity raises serious questions

017about fairness and the prioritization of resources in our district true leadership is built on trust which relies on honesty openness and clear communication a leader must ensure the board member staff and the public have access to the information needed to understand decisions and their rationale without this Foundation skepticism and frustration are inevitable I urge the administration to provide a more accurate transparent portrayal of Staffing and budget needs and changes as trust cannot Thrive when decisions and their impacts are presented misleadingly yes other districts across the state and country are struggling with budget deficits but this is our district our community there are kids instead of focusing elsewhere we need to focus on what we can do right here to move forward and ensure success for our children it's about what's best for them not excuses

018or comparisons to others you see I grew up here my mother was a substitute teacher this has been my home I graduated from Shelton High School my father was a driver's ed teacher at Shelton High School my grandfather drove logging truck for Simpson my kids go here I live here and unlike the superintendent I spend my hard-earned money in this community I buy groceries shop at local businesses attend local events I pay my taxes here I have profound roots in this community and I talk to people a lot of them I've built trust with them because I care deeply about this community and our kids trust is something you earn that starts with clear communication honesty and transparency it means ensuring that staff aren't being pitted against one another because of incomplete or inconsistent information

019right now there are gaps in communication and a lack of clarity are fostering blame and Division and that is unacceptable the lack of clear concise and transparent communication has created a toxic divide between the representatives of Staff this divisiveness is counterproductive and it is the responsibility of leadership to ensure everyone has accurate information and to Foster Unity not conflict I got three more paragraphs so I guess I'll email you unless somebody wants to give me their time Dean [Applause] J Dean I'll give my time to Marilyn uh just who is that really quick L Lisa Bern Lisa Bernett okay thank you um okay the board also has a responsibility to lead with accountability blind trust in the superintendent words does a disservice to our whole Community you were elected by your community to ask hard

020questions demand straightforward answers and listen to the concerns of the public you were elected to represent ignoring those voices only deepens The Divide and erodes confidence in this board and the district's leadership we need a superintendent and a board who prioritize transparency accountability and collaboration it's time to rebuild trust and move forward together for the sake of our students staff and schools it's time to stop ignoring the concerns of your community and start leading with integrity and accountability here is my personal recommendation Mr Jesse you could forfeit your 6% raise that you convinced the board to give you in June and maybe maybe that would be one step forward in gaining trust back from your staff you have an essential role here you were elected by the community and you need to put those needs

021first this District needs leadership that prioritizes collaboration fairness and honesty it's time to rebuild trust work together and focus on what's best for our students and schools thank you [Applause] D so do you guys see a a common theme here uh first we'll talk about WTH Jesse having a yawn attack while we're trying to have conversations and we'll talk about Matt not even looking at people for the first 58 seconds when they get up here and have a conversation there's a lot that happens with nonverbal communication and we when we see a superintendent just nodding and smiling I mean what is that is that a bobblehead at the Mariners game I don't get it uh concerns about the state of our District's financial management and to urge you to take a more proactive and direct

022role this is addressed to the board uh in addressing these issues as representative of our community your responsibility is to ask the hard questions and to seek clarifying answers and hold your leadership accountable to the highest standards of transparency do we do that each and every day or not I don't think we do otherwise we wouldn't have this many people here Wyatt question for you how long did you spend in the classroom most admins have to go through and spend certain amount of time in a classroom to qualify to get their admin degree my wife got her admin degree and Jesse fired her uh how many uh Consultants did you bring in wyth and are they your drinking buddies you've got a consultant you got two Consultants here now you can say that they're paid

023with a different Grant but they come out of this year's budget and then you're paid back could that money's be be saved for a couple teachers or a couple pair of Educators uh we sent a we sent a district employee to the east coast how much did that cost us how much did that take out of the budget uh we have District employees wives being hired uh update on the charging station I'd heard that uh it became public so now they're trying to quash it and or not do it I wonder what that is I wonder if there's any truth to that uh we had to borrow money just to make payroll are you serious do you guys understand why you can't make your budget and it's not the word solad and the dance that

024we had last last meeting with Wy Jesse up here it has to do with enrollment the school gets what $8 plus thousand per student and when you have enrollment that drops down to homeschooling take a look at the facts how how is how has homeschooling grown in Washington state it's exponentially growing so there goes your funding it's not your cost of your food it's it's not the cost of your power bill that you can't pay I I got 22 seconds left Matt so keep an eye on that clock so there you go have at it thanks guys Heather Kowalski my name is Heather Kowalski I work for the school district and I really didn't want to be here today talking about riffs and people possibly losing their jobs but I want to trust the address

025the teachers and the community in my position with Safety and Security I work with every building in some way some more than others but I know most of the teachers and almost all the support staff and of course at the high school and obj you all know me I've been the union president for the parent Educators and food service for four years I would hope that my hard work has built up some trust and respect from from all of you I know that you trust and respect and have love for the people you work within your buildings and in other buildings you've known many of these people for years you rely on them you've literally shared sweat Blood and Tears with them what is happening now with the Rifts coming up and they are coming

026up no matter what is tearing us apart look at all of your union leaders we've all been working as hard as we can to save as many jobs as we can and trying to figure out how many of our members how they're going to survive this year we shouldn't be pitting ourselves against each other or the district office this is the time for us all to work together and make some sacrifices for the good of everyone because not only do we lose but our students lose I see those kids get off the bus at elementary school and high five the Paras I see the littles hugging the custodians at lunch I see them chatting in the office with the office Personnel or hiding there to have a safe space we're always saying every student needs

027to find their person that person that will be their safe space that person's not always a teacher our students need all of us every single one of us can you think of anyone in your building that could disappear and none of the students would notice or Care Now imagine three or four of them just going away we need to stop pointing fingers we need to understand the realities of the situation just because your position might be safe this year it doesn't mean it will be next year and who's going to suffer when there are no more Paras helping struggling students the ones who just need that little bit of help to get to reading level that one that needs to walk to calm down with their favorite person and now that person's gone what does

028that do to them and to our community who want to punish wyth for whatever their personal reasons are are you willing to let our suffers our students with the highest needs suffer what is Les staff going to accomplish you hear a lot about bullying in schools through Facebook do you think that there will that will go away with less supervision less behavior TX fewer Mental Health Services less supervision and fewer counselors we have some of the highest needs in the state our students deal with abuse neglect drugs mental health issues and it isn't getting any better the school is their only safe place and the only place they will be taught how to regulate themselves how to treat others and how to make friends I'm Heather Smith giving my time to Heather kosi thank you

029it might be the only place they get food or that they are warm we have staff that help kids with clean clothes and help them fix their hair in the morning so they don't fill out of place who's going to be there for those kids when they're running on less than a skeleton crew so is our community going to step up please come to our buildings please fill out that volunteer packet please talk to the admin come in volunteer to supervise a lunch walk the hallways see the 90% of those students succeeding see that good share that good with our community on Shelton talks don't tear us down build up our community to what we want it to be thank you Lor Chapel good evening community and superintendent and school board members um for those

030of you who don't know me my name is Lori chapel and I am the vice co-president of the ESP I worked at the Shelton school district for 22 years I wanted to speak tonight on the budget situation and this is a trying time for all no matter where you fall on the Spectrum tonight I was told I was an advocate and I was good to speak because I was loyal to the district I'd like to restate that I'm loyal to the hardworking people of this district teachers and classified staff today we are coming together not just as individuals and our respective roles but hopefully as a United Community of Educators our sure goal is clear to Foster an environment where everyone can Thrive and to ensure that no one must face the fear of losing

031their job but also doing what is best for the kids and that is having welcoming caring staff who want always what is best and in these turbulent times across many districts and many states we are not alone facing the current budget problems when the Winds of Change seem Relentless and uncertainty looms it is easy to feel overwhelmed we find ourselves caught up in a cycle of anxiety about what the future holds today as I'm speaking to you I want to emphasize that is precisely during these times that cooperation solidarity and commitment to one another must become our greatest strength to get through this it may feel at times that our district is just made up of numbers data statistics and we're not important in the whole scheme of things but remember we are much more

032we are built upon the dedication and talent of the staff that makes up the SSD each individual brings unique skills perspectives and experiences that contribute to our Collective success so how do we ensure that our Workforce remains intact first and foremost we must Embrace open communication we need to foster a culture where there's transparency where the correct information is being shared so that rumors and unfounded truth do not deter us from the goal of keeping our staff a place where concerns are raised and heard without fear of Retribution when we really listen to one another we can identify challenges and work collaborating to find Solutions how do we find these Solutions and make sure that we are not not pitted against one another but working together as teachers and classifi find themselves in competition for

033limited resources teachers are clear in the message that they sent in rejecting theou they didn't want to lose pay they believed it would re affect the retirement and several other items I won't go into that they have shared there are also opinions of it's not my job to save other jobs along with the district created this mess and we shouldn't have to fix it on the other hand the classified who not got do not get paid with their wor stand on the side of advocating the importance of their roles I'm Kim Howard I'd like to seed my time back to Lori okay okay the classified who do not get paid were there were standing on the side of advocating the importance of their roles in providing a functional School environment the loss of classified staff

034would impact the whole district and most certainly devastatingly ffect those who would lose their jobs we try and teach our students to have empathy and compassion for one another and I'm asking the same we need to try and put ourselves in one another's shoes to to truly understand we need to stand together teachers we need your help to minimize the reduction this year as we all try to navigate this we must remember that tension can lead to division yet I believe that in times like this we need to band together and Advocate and highlight the importance of both roles in our Educational Systems we know that cuts to either groups will have a direct impact on our students educational experiences we also know without staff so many programs and people you count on will not

035be there to help with the reduction in staff larger class sizes burnout will surely creep in we will have decreased morale it will impact all the positive work that we are doing but in the end it will affect student outcomes fewer staff less to give to our students teachers I want to make it very clear I am not against you I have always stood with you I have worked with Incredible teachers over my years here teachers that have been amazing mentors and helped me become a betterer educator I have taken a stand when people who are not in your shoes daily badmouth the job you are doing your job is not an easy one there are many factors who navigate unless someone is in your shoes they will truly never know how hard and how

036many hours you put in for your students please know that I would fight for you if your jobs were on the line but yes sadly many of your jobs will be on the line once the school year ends so I'm asking you please ask questions is this a temporary fix is it permanent what is the truth of the whole matter don't make assumptions because people's livelihood are on the line please reflect on the matter of what we have before us I also just want to let you all know that my building is extraordinary regardless of what some may think we have teachers and classified who give 100% every day our admin Works tirelessly we hired eight new teachers this year they are all amazing please come to our building and see what they do we

037have a well honed classified staff my fear though is not only for the classif staff that I represent but also for all the newly hired teachers who will also be Rift if we can't find Solutions I can't see my building without teachers or the classified staff in it it hurts my heart to see what we are trying to create at OMS will be fractured it is in human nature to find someone or something to blame bummer thank you is there anybody online okay item number six uh 6.1 will be reports from the student board Representatives we'll start off with Abigail Hurst Shelton high school next Friday is our winter Renaissance assembly during this assembly kids will be recognized for academic achievement and along with the winner of our readathon which is students versus teachers all

038winner sports are in full swing both girls and boys have basketball games going on this week tonight is boys basketball and Wednesday is another boys game both at 700 p.m. in the Mini Dome girls basketball won multiple games including the one last night against Rochester wrestling has a match this Thursday the 12th in the mini against bellermine prep at 600 p.m. and varsity is at 700 p.m. last week week we had Miss Elliot's class visit from Mountain View to participate in our teach kids how to swim program seniors have the chance to submit a baby photo to the yearbook to participate in the Guess Who section the Deadlight Deadlight deadline is closing soon today we had a college visit from Washington State University in the career center during both first and second lunch bowling is

039doing very well recently they won against black hills and their next match is this Thursday at Westside Lanes December 6 15 through 20th is our holiday spirit week Monday is red versus green Tuesday is Timber Tuesday Wednesday is where your ugly Christmas sweaters holiday themed Thursday where you dress as your favorite holiday character and Friday is Pajama Day for the night before Christmas break December 2nd we started the second trimester and we start winter break this Friday the 20th thank you Alan Ramirez from Cedar yeah so we had some pretty big news uh at Cedar we had news of moving to a new campus I will say even though we are I uh when the news was broken to the students on I think was it last Tuesday yeah last Tuesday we had a um

040we dedicated an entire advisory to discussing this uh transition with the with the classes and at least in the class that I was in we seem to have a very mature conversation about the logistics of it and how we would try to continue on to work on our projects and to really double down on that we are still going to continue working uh together with OC to work on the hill project and we're really we really do think that this is going to open up a lot of new opportunities for us especially because of the location we're hoping to work very closely together with Evergreen Elementary and especially try to help with their bilingual programs or try to teach their students more and and we have also uh not only is the hill project in

041collaboration with OC it's also in collaboration with I think it was americore yeah I think it's americor so we have quite a bit of community evolvement still and our friends of SE group has started to evolve a bit more so we will hopefully be able to contribute a lot more to the community and the community will help contribute to us too so during the these very difficult trying times of transitioning to a new school we're making sure that our students are also involved in the conversation we just recently had out a sent out a survey uh to ask students how involved they want to be in the transition of the new school and I will say I've seen a lot of students fill out that survey being very interested in speaking about the logistical sides

042of moving to a new campus thank you and it's good to hear that you guys want to be involved with that it actually in my mind kind of lends to what the the overall School actually is is that Project based learning so thanks guys and then Kaylee Allen from Choice uh this week we're holding our elections for uh class representatives um and they're going to meet with our ASB officers once per month to help plan uh school events assemblies Spirit weeks and all that and then we also next week on our Tuesday Tuesday evening we'll hold our monthly Awards assembly for students who met adequate progress and attendance and uh Behavior goals for November and then we're also still in preparation for our annual winter celebration on December 19th 5:00 to 7: p.m. which has

043open to everyone so I encourage everyone to come and yeah it's going to be a lot of fun there's games Foods snacks all that so the 19th and everybody body's invited right yes all right 19th okay 6.02 budget update with Clinton Sherman uh good evening I wanted to walk through um an update of the budget uh give some context some some things will be reiterating reiterating some slides you've already seen uh and then providing some other context and then what we're doing moving forward so as we' talked about before there are really three major factors um taking big a big buy out of school oh before I get started um in a little bit I'll introduce Jennifer pretty who is the Deputy superintendent of ESD 113 to provide some further context as we get a

044little farther down the road uh the ESD has been a great uh partner and uh sh up represent a team that helps support us with some nuts and bolts things as we move through this process so the has an a lack of non-restricted non-restricted dollars um and that has really um impacted what our fund balance normally the fund mons we've had in the past has all been restricted that isn't a healthy way to manage um the budget as we move through things um the local Levy dollars are shrinking and actually in doing some analysis um we actually receive slightly less Levy dollars than we did in 2015 um think about today's prices of things and salaries those dollars just aren't going as far as they used to [Music] um enrollment is the major factor for

045our funding and as all districts uh they took a dip during covid we've kind of plateaued through our recovery and so now that we know that we can plan accordingly and move forward this is slide I showed earlier about how we and and why we took the aort in advance we received 22 and a half% of our Revenue in July and August that doesn't make a lot of sense for us uh not how our expend has moved so we asked for that money earlier that's what happened at the last board meeting that money is coming at the end of this week uh from the Washington treasury in the 2425 budget column that is what you adopted in August and what we knew at the time and so that picture has shifted as we close the

046books into a negative fund balance so what that required us to do is kind of reforecast revenues refor cast expenses and get an understanding of where we are now and what we need to do moving forward so the updated projections that middle colum that talks about this negative $3 million fund balance that is after reforecasting revenues and and expenses and so knowing that we can't end in a negative fund balance what has to happen to end in a positive so that far right column is what we've revised is that our what our our goals are to reduce our expenditure level to end with a positive in general terms that $400,000 we we really we're looking for plus $1 that isn't really the solution to the long-term problem though I mean this is a multi-year problem

047that we're dealing with I re forecasted the revenues they're roughly the same there were some shifts around but they're roughly the same this is a chart you've seen before I just wanted to bring it back we're an $83 million District about $44 million of that is actual basic Ed and the rest is uh Grant dollars Cate orical restricted um which means that a lot of the other differences come from the levy um one thing that came up last um at the last meeting was the pro typical school funding formula and so I brought up this is an older table that was used to explain how the funding model works and so there's a lot of numbers on here so I'll give just a little bit of context um if you look at school nurses under

048the k6 elementary our k6 student population is about 2,000 students what this chart is showing you is that it takes 5,263 students to generate one school nurse and of course we provide more than one school nurse for the 2,000 students so we have about two School nurses providing services to those kids with less than half of the number of FTE and so that how that's how this um table works across the board so it takes um 7,200 students at OJ uh at um Olympic Junior High to generate one school nurse right and that's their student body is about 538 so I won't dive into it more we can talk more about it but it is just showing you that how the funding model works it doesn't generate enough Staffing FTE to do the job that

049we're required to do I think that's really the point of this I mean 72,000 students for one social worker it's right I mean that's just not how unfeasible so the next thing I want to talk about is how the dollars come in for those Staffing members so we're funded from the state $78,200 for each teacher thankfully our teachers are more educated and have more experience so they fall farther um on the salary schedule so our average salaries for our teachers is $90,000 then most teachers have some sort of supplemental contract whether it's coaching or extra days the average for that for us is $6,700 so off right off the bat we know that we're not getting enough funding for the staffing levels and now what I'm trying to show you is that we actually are

050under $20,000 $199,000 from what we get from the state to what we're paying out and again the levy dollars make up that difference so here's a slide you've seen before as well uh I added um updated some 2023 numbers in 2018 you'll see that the um Levy amount dropped in 2019 and that was we did this Levy swap I don't want to get too Lost In The Weeds which I'm prone to to do um but that reduced what the local taxpayers could contribute it kind of actually removed some local control by swapping and saying okay we're capping the levy at a150 when before that the taxpayers would support the district at $438 right so that's a $4 million drop that first year and so that's why we're only we're collecting a a little less than

051we did in 2015 because we're kind of climbing back out of that so that's where that assess valuation is growth is we're seeing right like the assess assess valuation growth has happened we've all seen that in all our tax roles but the actual Levy amount that we're collecting is a little less than 2015 which was pretty shocking when I when I dove into that as I stated earlier this is a complicated slide I want to introduce Jennifer pretty again this is data we got from the ESD to talk about how these things adjustment for inflation are impacting districts of different size and our district specifically and Jennifer has been a great collaborator um and we continue to work with us as we move forward and so I'll sit aside for a second thank you um

052chair uh well Ender and board of directors um again my name is Jennifer pretty I work for esd113 and we have been um researching specifically kind of the well-being of school district finances and the revenue sources for school districts and this is a particular ly dense slide so I'll walk through it slowly but it tells a very important story about the Shelton school district and school districts across the state so Clinton referred to local Levy funds and state funding and this is to focus on local funds and that includes levies that voters approve but also the state Levy Equalization funds that the state um matches uh where districts don't have very high property values and so what this is comparing is local funds in the 17 18 school year so before the pandemic and before

053the state made changes to Levy rules and to Levy Equalization comparing that to the 2223 school year and what this shows you is at the very top when you look at all districts across the state and compare those two years districts have lost $114 per student but when you think about that you also have to remember that inflation has skyrocketed and so the inflation adjusted number for all students across the state is a loss of $400 per student that's a lot of money we all know that a bag of groceries was costing us $50 before the pandemic and now it costs us 75 or 80 or 90 right and that's happened to school districts also but the next section on this slide is the Shelton school district and you can see that in dollars Shelton

054has lost $600 per student in those Levy and state Levy Equalization funds and when you look at inflation and add that into the mix Shelton has lost $800 per student comparing those two years that's $800 that Shelton cannot devote to hiring more staff or hiring more supports for um the school district for the students or for investing in extras for students around um activities Athletics and that kind of thing Shelton is actually losing quite a bit when you compare Shelton to other school districts with 4,200 students if you follow down to the category that says 4,000 to 6,000 students really hard to read because it's a very dense slide Shelton has lost a lot more per student than other districts in that size category so the Shelton School District has some pretty significant financial challenges

055when you look at how much local Revenue um has declined but if you go to the next slide there's some more challenges that Shelton faces oh I got I got it and that's when you look at how much the state is funding compared to how much it costs to provide the service and so the First Column is for special education again a very dense slide but it's showing you how much the state is funding compared to how much is being expended and the gap between those two uh resources and Year bye you can see that the Gap is significant for the special education program The Gap is significant when you compare how much the state is providing to um fund substit teachers compared to how much the district must deploy for basic supplies it's the

056same and for transportation and so when you look at um this data on a per student basis it's about $900 per student in the 2223 year so look at how much the state is funding compared to how much the district must spend that Gap is $900 per student added together it's about $1,700 per student that Shelton can't spend to support staff and support students because of those four factors the loss of local Levy revenue and then these um expenses that are Beyond State funding do you have any questions for me I'll add one more Factor this is Shelton is not alone this is some something that all districts are experiencing and in Mason County also it is um what districts face thank you I have a couple more then I'll open up for questions just

057provide a little more context uh we're talking about this um this third column is called MX which is Material supplies and operating cost they us should be called nerks non-employee related costs um and these are costs that you just have to have to run a district and they are some some are in the millions and some aren't and that's fine that's just what the costs are one of the things I think is important about this slide is there are some things that aren't really expensive in the $85 million budget but are also required that we can't get away from and so like the audits we have an audit every year that is valuable to us it's valuable to the community but we can't cut an audit cost right and they the district has done a

058good job even before I got here moving through these mxs and trying to reduce and cut those down over time so these are ones that are hard to get away from um insurance I'm sure you've all seen your insurance rates are are sky rocking as as Florida and different things happen Nationwide there's only a handful of carriers that provide that service anyway just some more context of what this looks like just to regularly operate a district so what has happened and and we're doing now is decre decreasing some positions in the district office um we have reduced those mxs um those non-staff related costs we're limiting Subs that's a big cost to the district like we talked about earlier uh which is a tricky thing uh but also extra hours and overtime for classified positions

059those are big those become big ticket items as they acrew over a year as you can imagine um there's a a hiring freeze there are Furlow days that are being activated by the principal the administrators and the superintendent uh and we also um reviewed all the categorical funds that are restricted and seen where we could cover some qualified expenses that can create some savings um and that's where we're at now and I think that's all we have for tonight what questions do you have which I am sure there are many um so it wasn't this information available back when we approved the budget for in the positive of1 million now uh negative 2.3 so that's 3.3 million right off all this information about the increase in costes costs and the less money coming in wasn't

060available when we approve this budget yeah I think my understanding so the the the budget process is it kind of starts off in the um now really and in January and it's kind of your your best guess as you forecast things out and that that's one part of the equation the second part is when you close the books for a year our fiscal year ends in August 31st but you don't really close the books through you close the books through October and kind of november-ish and in closing that books process they identified some expenses that were way higher than they had anticipated so you're yes you're right some of these some of the things are were known um but the some things at the end of the years the Clos of the books were unknown

061well that seems like in a two-month period That's awful lot of yeah unknowns I agree uh question I have is you know we talked a lot about being underfunded by state and mandates and things like that um with the and I'm I know I'm asking you to prognosticate a little bit but with uh the state being kind of underwater and and all the freezes that are going on there what what do you predict that costing us next year as far as programmatic dollars and such yeah so this is a 105 day session legislatively so it's a it's a full bium session and there were some big ass coming from different from Wasa and wasda and wasbo and all the different groups that was totaling around $3 billion a fully fund education uh but when the

062state announced their deficit and their hiring Frees I just just me speaking I I really think one of the things I'll look at is changing that Levy cap $2.50 because it doesn't cost them any money to do it it's it's free to them to change that law and allow local taxpayers to pay more which to me is lwh hanging fruit for them to do that that Levy swap has not worked out really well for any District um just provide a little more context on that so Shelton school um District the community approved like $438 cents I think it was and then it went down to $150 so they removed that local control but then say there was a swap we're going to take it down to 250 but then we're going to give you 81

063cents as a new state school tax but but a $150 plus 81 cents is not 438 so Shelton lost money right away and and a lot of districts did so if I had a crystal ball um I would think that that's where they'll try to make the move is push it back to local taxpayers will they remove the 81 Cent state tax in no no cuz that um all right I try not to get in the weed so the 81 Cent tax that you see on your tax bill does not come to this directly the Shelton School District it goes up to the state and they do with it what they will it's supposed to be earmarked for education but I tried to track those dollars down years ago and you couldn't have a trail

064of those dollars coming in and then those dollars going out from the state okay so thank you no that's those are all great questions yeah thank you so much um that's a lot of information yeah so if if you're watching at home or following along and you want to look at that again is that available online yeah I think these are recorded and put on the Mason web TV I'm available if people have questions and want to talk about it I'm happy to do so I've been doing that for 18 years um and then yeah we can post it online I'm sure okay and then U just to follow that up I think part of the question is if we got here and we're kind of surprised by it how are we avoiding that in

065the future so what steps are we taking to make sure that we we don't get surprised again that's a great question so so before I came here I watched a bunch of the um Mason County TV web TV which is really fast awesome uh and actually the budget process that wyth introduced like in I think it was in June I watched one that he had revamped the budget process that process is the process that keeps you from this and so if we weren't in um if we didn't have a deficit now the budget process that built this budget that we're in now is pretty right on it's we need to build a fund balance back to I think the board approved a 4% fund balance we need to build it back to that and then

066we can start operating as normal but but the problem now is if we operated as normal now we would still be in a deficit and we can't maintain that deficit right uh following up as you look around the state other school districts we're not the only one sure um what paths are you seeing is this how other school districts are are climbing out of it what are you seeing in terms of solutions around the state uh well every like as superintendent Jesse has said before every school district is different so they have different Avenues to help with this problem some people have um uh kind of more robust capital projects funds that they can take a loan to help mitigate this a lot of folks are waiting till their next Levy renewal because as the

067S valuation is grown they can that that $2.50 by the community can generate more revenue and so it just it just depends on the district and so we're having to um live within what Shelton's options are yeah um as you project out and yeah with your crystal ball sure I love it how long before we can start to get on that plus side before we're cutting and we're we're back to a stable Staffing level um okay so um a handful of years because because if you took the people out all these wonderful people that spoke before me the math solution is really simple right but it's also the most harmful to your community and the most harmful to kids so that's not what you do so you make it take a little longer because that's

068the that's the right way to do it to provide an education system for students and so instead of doing it in one year and just deating everything you're doing you make it take two or three years yeah so if I can put that back if I'm hearing you correctly we are going to take a while to try to mitigate laying off and Rifts as much as humanly possible right you're going to be I think minimizing and this is conversations that um superent Jesse's been been leading like minimizing the impact in the classroom is the number one goal right right I mean your guys um the outcomes that were discussed at the last meeting you districts aren't seeing those outcomes so you you really don't want to mess with what's working in the classrooms I mean

069this it's it's one of the reasons I chose come here is because the stuff you guys are doing here is really impressive so this is definitely a hurdle I think we can move through this together and get through it um but yeah that that is the goal is to minimize the impact of the classroom thank you yeah la yeah uh thank you for your presentation I really appreciate the visuals they're helpful especially in Outreach with legislators as we're trying to you know explain our story and share with them where we need that that fun funding Gap closed I'd also like to thank the ESD for coming and presenting and and sharing your support um we were able as a group some of us to come and see your presentation at wasda also and it was

070very informative and just thank you for the support and and the visuals explaining explaining our situation of course anything else all right thank you thank you all right that moves us up to item number seven the consent agenda really had a chance to look at that I make a motion to approve the consent agenda second all right all those in favor I okay thank you discussion and action items 8.01 proposed revised policy number 6605 student safety walking biking and riding buses this will be the first reading with Robert Heron good evening Mr chairman and members of the board thank you so much for allowing me to come before you this evening Lord about the forward uh policy and procedur change for 6605 student safety walking biking and riding buses and so the the big gist

071of this change is that um the policy had not been the procedure has not been touched since 2011 so as we're trying to get through and making sure that all of our policies and procedures are being updated that they're current with wax with the recommendation of wasda this is what was happening with 6605 so there's actually not significant changes in here though as they formed a committee and went through uh everything they thought that the policy was pretty comprehensive uh to our needs but there was a lot of things that needed to be cleaned up to align with the wax so in the back you'll see the wax that are referenced some of them are not current and have been stricken and updated with things that have been revised some things like the safety advisory

072committee that's listed was something actually the district never has done in anyone's memory that currently serves right they really all those things are determined by WS p and by Wax and they are directly administered and so the safety advisory committee as reference is not valid and so that information has been updated also there's an entire safe routes uh to school plan which is a whack and and completely uh encapsulated so that has been uh listed in in as uh requested by or recommended by wasda so most of these revisions are driven by wasda recommendations and so uh I don't think there's really you know typical things that we've gone through is things technology has changed like to make sure we include vaping explicitly those things are also included uh otherwise uh you know also the

073changes in student discipline and the policies related to that since 2011 those things are now back and in current with current District policy so that's basically the change I hope you had an opportunity to take a look and if you have any questions I'll do my best to answer them um six 605p page two I didn't receive page two of the four pages in my board package so I don't know if there was any changes to that there there there is uh changes on page two and that's in fact where the entire safe route to school plan it wasn't in my board package okay um um we will make sure we get those to you right away thank you page three paragraph three um the driver bus supervisor shall provide the parent scra it's uh

074lined out and student with a copy of the report why would you not give the parents a copy of a report if their kids are misbehaving on the bus I believe that uh that there was to be in alignment with Wasa recommendations when it comes to issues of student privacy and getting an alignment with the laws as they are in Washington now and so it's not that I don't think that that in any way that a parent is prohibited from getting that except for what's limited by Statute so I don't think that that in any part of this would a parent be prohibited from receiving well later on it'll be given uh to the parent after huh so if it's so he's answering as if it's another the victim of the of another students on

075the bus but for the question of calling so the administrator so we've handed that off to the administration and so the administrator at the school so that the student goes to will be the one that will contact the parent if there is anything that requires any level of discipline um regarding students on the bus the driver or bus supervisor shall provide the student with a copy of the report but not the parent they're just a rep they're just going to give that to the student the parent is going to get contacted and when if any discipline was happening they would automatically generate a NDA which is a notice of discipline and action that would go to the parent so that related that um and the only other thing is um I like how you took

076a lot of this possible disciplinary actions out and referred back to board policy 3241 discipline so it makes it a lot more easy to read that's the only other thing I have and I'm looking forward to page two yeah and I think that's the the student or sorry the um it's one of the problems with policies right is that student discipline is something that is reviewed and frequently addressed and is and is so inter interconnected with so many other things other policies and procedures and so it's important for us to keep that updated and the references to them versus trying to repeat them all the way through so yeah it's a though I would like to be informed if my kids misbehave it on the bus I don't know why that would be invading the

077privacy of a student I just yeah I can't answer that any other questions I read through it there's a lot of red and a lot of red in the rcws so it's obvious that they updated a bunch of laws yeah thank you for going through our policies and updating them it's a constant battle to keep up with uh with State guidance so anything else thank you okay proposed policy number 3141 non-resident students Subs first reading uh Miss Tara Richardson so good evening um just kind of some Genesis some background on this policy uh because I know it looks all red which means it's all new um we do have policies regarding student transfers um right now in our district we have one policy it's 3130 and it covers all different kinds of enrollment and all

078different kinds of transfers and so the purp purpose of bringing this to you this evening is to start the process of teasing that out and making it more in alignment with what wda recommends so the policy before you tonight is the first of a couple more that you will see um that help break out student transfers uh to enable us to track them better um part of that tracking has to do with how we claim funds from the state so we've all heard how important it is to have our student enrollment increased and so forth and the policy tonight that we're looking at is about students who live outside of our district and who want to come and go to school in our district which is a great thing um right now we have about

07950 students um that are in our records in terms of attending from outside the district who live outside the district um this does not include students who attend from District where there is no high school grade so when we think about like McClary Griffin Pioneer and so forth they are not affected by this policy by law they are allowed to attend any District that offers a grade that their home District does not so we're talking about mainly here this would be students who um whose parents work in the district for example we have lots of teachers who work for Shelton and they bring their students with them their children with them to attend school here um and we do have other um cases like this so it's not a very large population but we must

080um have this policy in place and we must be able to track that we have a release from that home District to show that we have the right to claim that money so when the auditor comes to visit um we can show that we have the policy in place and we have the documentation um from that District so uh again tonight we're just looking at nonresidents enrolled in in um that's kind of a mouthful of a term but again it's students who live outside the district and who would like to attend here um in future policies what you'll see are students who live in the district and want to attend a school other than their homeschool um as well as students who live in the district and who would like to attend elsewhere so we'll

081be coming back to transfers again um so with that are there any questions or anything clarifications I can help with um good job just can we number the pages as all absolutely because it's confusing thanks yeah thank you for the work appreciate it yeah it looked pretty self-explanatory and not a lot so thank you right thank you very much thank you that brings us up to item number nine board comments we'll start there on the end with Mr Dale yeah I just want to thank our student Representatives again and appreciate all the updates particularly Cedar high school I know that was a surprise for you guys and appreciate your feedback and willingness to be part of that next solution um also just want to say thank you to everybody who shared a comment I know

082how hard it is to get up and and share and to speak publicly and this only works if we have Community involvement so I appreciate the community being here tonight and that's it thank you to the students for your reports um you have a great attitude on Cedar changing I mean the district's put in a situation that they're just doing the best they can right with what they got you have a great attitude for the change and thank you for your report and hope to see you on the 19th thank you to the community members always for speaking out okay I I just haven't heard yet a thank you to all the uh students from the different schools who participated in the parade and the events uh over the weekend you know Christmas the Christmas

083events are always my favorite part of the year um it was it's always fun to see the band and everybody at the out there and uh everybody just be safe this holiday thank you for coming okay uh again thank you for all the community comments tonight um and we don't have a meeting later on in a month so the next time we get together will be in January uh icy roads are forecasted here the rest of the week so be careful with all the kids out there on the roadway uh Have Yourself A Merry Christmas happy holidays and we'll see you guys in January there's no exempt or executive session so I would take a motion for adjournment a motion to J the meeting second all in favor I okay and we're done

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.