CorpusRecord 95027

School Board Meeting - 02/19/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LitchfieldTV
Date
2025-02-20
Location
Hillsborough County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,266 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-12

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001um and I happen to train in this program so um the cost is actually pretty um minimal comparatively to other programs and the creators of efly actually generously have created a lot of things that they provide to um Educators for free and the manual is $75 per manual and then there's some other um materials related to that that I plan to talk with um the GMS team to see what those needs are but I priced out kind of a higher end cost of what it would be um and it's just under $5,000 at the high end and I have to I happen to have extra funds from what was um well thank you um budgeted for um the math program that wasn't used so it wouldn't be any extra cost and then again I would

002be doing the training myself so we wouldn't have to hire Trainers for PD I've already talked to Mr Mitchell and some of um the other members at GMS about starting a plan for professional development training um it's everybody's very excited about it it was voted unanimously by the Review Committee to move forward and I'm asking for approval tonight so that I can get going on getting things implemented so that we have a nice training and roll out happening and things aren't just here you go do it in August won't do that to you I promise okay thank you for the update is she looking for a motion that to approve and uh and for funding I'll make that motion Mr Shaker pay motion is there a second second second by Miss Ames additional discussion where

003where do we pull the money from this sounds like there's I still have money in my textbook line um so it was left over from the math program that was budgeted for and we didn't happen to need everything that was budgeted so I still have funds in that line okay all right all those in favor please signify by saying I I I opposed abstained that carries 5 thank you very much welcome all right so the next thing um we thought we would bring it's uh been a bit since we've talked about some data and um kindergarten through 8th grade just finished um if you are you put it yeah give me one sec um I lost so kindergarten through 8th grade just finished the I ready diagnostic they take it in the fall in the

004winter and in the spring and 9th 10th and 11th graders did the PSAT back in October um so I'll just wait for a minute before I start talking about the ground very slowly okay so um what you're looking at here is first there's the table that shows what's graphically represented um the first slide is for math I ready um if you're looking at the graph the top bar is the um fall diagnostic data and the Bottom bar for each grade level is the district and it goes from um dark green is your um Mid to above grade level then light green is early on grade level yellow is one grade level below then the darker red is two grade levels below and the lighter red is three grade levels or more below is that clear

005to everyone so um as you can see from fall to winter there's been a lot of growth um which is great to see and it's not just in pockets it's in each gray bubble we've had um some really good growth um especially like there's been nice growth when we're looking at students that are performing at or above grade level we also see reductions in students that are performing in those red categories so those two or more grade levels below those grade levels those um um percentages are diminishing which is nice to see um and there is a strong growth in that early Ong grade level performance which shows that those students that are in those um one grade level and above are kind of sliding into that early on so the instruction and some of

006the in interventions that are being put in place are showing some impacts um we do see quite a bit of yellow and then when we're looking at the light green category in Winter we want to see more in the mid because winter we're in the mid year so when we're early on grade level and one grade level below we want to focus on those students and intervene and kind of help push them towards that mid to above grade level Proficiency in the spring which if you're looking at it like you if you really Target and Zone in we can push those through so that's math any questions on math is there a way to get uh like cohort data for I ready scores I have it I did go through I went on a rabbit

007hole for a little bit and I was like okay I've got to get something together for tonight I mean this this is great I just am like look in looking at this I'm just curious I would be really cu ious to see like another bar that just shows cohort data yep I did cohort data not in this way cuz if you this graph is there's a lot to look at here so when you add more it gets very like when I add spring to it it's going to get very there's going to be three per grade level so I have it represented in a different way for I track a fall cohort and then a winter cohort cuz I wanted to see the where we're usually at and how those kids are performing through so

008I do have that I just didn't together so I can share it with you um if you want cuz you can join in on my rabbit hole I was like going through all the day I'm like Oho look what's happening um because there's a lot um of nuances within that kind of tracking as well now Dr sailor we're hoping in Spring that we have even more green right like that absolutely the goal is to get even more green especially when we're looking at the dark green we want them in that dark green and then red to get really low we want the red to get really low that's why when you're looking at the grass and you see that red shrinking across like that is really awesome to see like grade two team is here

009hello like look at that red it's amazing yeah right so um that was that's very encouraging to see any other questions on [Music] math all right so when we're looking at reading um it's kind of the same um kind of it's kind of the same picture right we have we do see a bit more green um in reading but again we're seeing that increase in students performing at or above grade level um across when we go from fall to winter um strong growth in primary grades in which indicates that solid foundations are being built which is only going to intensify um when we Implement U fly which I'm very excited to see what these look like next year um and then we still see quite a bit of yellow um but again that's part Ted

010intervention and support looking at where those skills are and getting those kids closer to grade bubble will be so just to use grade two as an example because they're here right here so like in reading right here just to help like it's really awesome that if you look at the the dark green bar for grade two not only like and maybe it's not exactly this but not only did they maintain the kids that were there not only did they catch all kids that were already on early but they caught some of those yellow kids all the way up to dark green already that's like very very impressive to move those kids up throughout the course of a year and a couple months like that like we should be applauding you know they're here right here

011but just applauding the work that they're doing to as the year goes on get these kids um to the grade level they need to be and am I right Dr Taylor that like it would make sense that they're going to start lower on that cuz they're just starting the grade in the fall they going to start especially to you also have to think about the tool right like they're learning the tool they're on a computer they're Littles and they're like you know and they're trying to listen to sounds and all that kind of stuff and differentiate between that so there's a lot of different things happening but um there are they are making really good growth you know attributed to all the amazing things that are happening yeah and we would in Fall for all

012the kids to be on grade level at that point cuz they're just starting to grade right like that should be a growth that happens over time right yeah and you also typically will see a lot of growth in the younger years because they all of a sudden it clicks for them and you guys know when you see it click it's amazing and you're like yes but it happens different times for different students um so we just keep going and keep targeting looking at the data seeing where they are and moving them and growing them from there it's all good thanks all right so um the next couple of slides are for the PSAT um some I want to point out a couple of things so first the ninth graders take the PSAT 89 and then

013the 10th and 11th graders take the PSAT the PSAT 89 is a little less complex than the PSAT the PSAT is really aligned with the sat in terms of question complexity vocabulary all of that kind of stuff so it really kind of ramps up and also to the um Benchmark cut scores rise with every single grade so even though grades 10 and 11 take the same PSAT test those cut scores are different so we need to take that into account when we're looking at these um scores and we can see so for math um we can see that grade nine stayed Above So this graph shows the percent of students that met the Benchmark and in ninth grade we are um outperforming the state in 10th Grade we're also outperforming the state and then we

014see that there's a dip in 11th grade which there's some factors that we need to consider in this kind of disparity and um really thinking about assessment culture and mindset too because as an 11th grader and you guys have probably a test we've seen this test and we're like oh my God what does it have to do with me right now um and there's always a swing when we get to the SAT because things now are like oh this is the SAT like we need to and this is only one snapshot of one particular cohort if we could see you know like this is an example where I would like to see the cohort Trends so yeah that's what I was going to ask is like can we look at this for the last five

015years or years I've also pull I I have a folder with that data too and I started going down that R pole but and then can we see SAT scores yep I have those too when did they take the PSAT that is in October October okay yep so again we're talking it's start of the year yeah we're getting back into the swing of things now we have this test it's a PSAT I don't know you know so there's a lot of factors but it also brings up some good conversation too like really look in and dig deeper into the data points and and see what those skills are where are the students having a difficult time and what's happening instructionally etc etc like these just these data points again they're one snapshot and that goes

016with I already it goes with all of the assessments right like we've talked about earlier a holistic approach to looking at um data for students not just considering one right assessment when did they take the SAT oh oh the SAT is coming the window opens in April April yeah so like I I'll forget right I forget after these meetings but like can you at some point can we revisit this with the cohort data and so the Juniors will take the PSA the sat in the spring correct so we'll have two a data point from the beginning of the year and then and I will say without having all the data in front of us this is the trend that I've seen since I've got to Campell each year the PSAT is relatively low and then

017the could do better nth they improve the next year they improve that last year was our best performance on the for our current seniors they outperform the state in every section which was I think a first since here so right I'm not super surprised by these but again as AR said conversations for I had a loan today already um around you know stru practice in the classroom curriculum that sort of thing uh it just gives us some really great data to look at start yep so if you look at I mean a same kind of um Trend going for um reading um or evidence-based reading and writing we see um ninth grade um remained pretty solid which shows a it's actually a good transition of skills from middle school to high school and then we

018kind of Di down but not by a lot um in 10th Grade and then 11th grade and again it goes back to the conversation we just had about it gives us a conversation piece to talk about what teachers look in and see what's happening and then think of that assessment um mindset and culture so uh really getting into the key takeaways um all of this data continues to go back to the three Focus areas that I set forth at the beginning of the year which is the targeted interventions datadriven instruction and enhancing our um curriculum vertical alignment which we are well into the throws of which is has been amazing and um the um learning outcomes task force and the curriculum Review Committee all of these things are going to take shape and start to

019really drive us and move us into a really we're we're on a good we're on a good train right yeah so any questions or comments or it's great to see data yes I'm with you I want to see year-over-year Trends right kind of that curious about the 11th grade thing like right this is not a criticism this is just an observation like in my previous school we did not have the ninth and 10th creators take the PSATs right it was only the juniors in preparation for their sat so there wasn't a ton of wild swing because it was the first time they were doing the pat right um and I wonder I I was just thinking out loud here as I saw this you know Sarah do Taylor presented this uh to our group you

020know earlier this week and stuff um if there's a little burnout from taking the PSAT when they because it doesn't count yet for them and that's why you see that huge the only problem with that though is 21% of the rest of the state is not as burnt out as Lichfield that's what I'm saying like at B they don't take it until they're a junior like they don't take the PSAT I see what you're saying I see now that's a total that I that's why I was asking what the trend is is this normal for Campbell that's what I'm curious yeah um so I guess when you're looking at cohort stuff it' be it'd be really good to know are they taking three years or are they taking one year I won't speak for Miss

021Nelson I'll speak for Miss Nelson we've had this conversation many times if we wanted to stop 10th graders from taking it we' more than happy to do that as well so well and there are some um districts that they're taking it 8 n so who's the who's that decision with schools us you know mhm we have to have I think it's a philosophy you know like B philosophy was the PSAT was strictly a uh uh you know the Prep Prep you for the sat right there would be when I say it was exclusively Juniors it's a little bit of a fib there are some sophomores bu requests that would take it because we were giving a testing date that day right and it was convenient and they could they could do it um but it

022was a required thing solely for the grade 11 students and it was advertised as this is your preparation for taking the sat in March so take it seriously right um there are different districts that do it just like Campbell a lot of districts do it like like Campbell does right where they have nine 10 and 11 take the PSAT um it's a good use of the day because then the seniors are doing they're they're senior like um college application stuff and other things as well um but there's just different philosophies on that approach so that's why I think looking at that cohort data could be really interesting well and I also think too um and I think I've talked about it before is changing the assessment culture um and mindset and purpose because if we

023don't set a meaningful purpose then it's not going to be meaningful right so um there are useful ways there are use useful things to this data and to taking this assessment um that are multifaceted so we just need to bring that to the Forefront so that it's not like all right we have to do this thing because it's this thing that we're being told that we have to do and this will probably be like a shame on me moment but Danny and Nick any of your teachers counselors ever really talk to about your scores on your PSS your SATs like talk about them after take them yeah like other than hey here's where your scores were it's it's more personal like you see how you do on it and if you have if you like

024want a better grade you go study for it yes yeah but there's ways that we can make that differ correct something give you like pencils and ice cream Sund it works pesta mints remember those aspect of it but also just talking about why we do it what it is exactly there has to be why what you're doing in your actual classes and that sort of thing as where you know we we fall short a little bit with time making those connections good update anything else no any questions for Dr Taylor thank you again yeah thank you all right jumping ahead we have the public minutes from January 5th I'll make a motion to approve them thank you Mr Shoemaker we have a second by Mr plansky additional discussion on the minutes all right all those

025in favor please say I opposed abstained those carry 500 now we're on to new business and we have sorry I just want to clarify those are February 5 minutes oh that's right yeah we just BL me off sorry I we called them but that's the intention February 5th 2025 yes I mistake is the link correct yes yeah we just labeled it incorrectly I apologize no that's fine I just making sure it's clear for everyone y February 5 thank you uh new business we have facility Improvement committee updates we are moving so quickly not progress discussion oh that's next sorry so we have board appointments expectations and continued objectives you want to get things kicked off here well I I think you know just looking at the fic it's a board committee correct we're about to

026have a new board like that's the time of season we are um places that I've been this is a good opportunity to like review your committees and how you want them to kind of continue to move forward um I think specifically with the fic um I'm just going to stick in the Schoolboard realm because that's my area is working with you as the Schoolboard um we have two people running for two seats and you know uh one of the candidates is currently the um uh Community chair as part of the fic right if he's elected to the school board um then he can't be the community in my opinion can't be the community chair anymore he could take over you know you could step down as a school board representative as the chair and he

027could do that um but you would probably I would recommend me to appoint a new uh Community chairperson or have that committee appoint a new community chairperson so I thought it would be smart to use this as an opportunity to kind of um go over your expectations for for that committee uh one of the other things is we are making we're going the next agenda item is making progress towards uh recommendation regards to Griffin um but as we've seen from the on-site Insight reports there's a lot to do with facilities for the district so as you know the conversation shifts from like all right this is the direction we're going from Griffin do we want to expand this commit it's called facilities it's not called the Griffin committee right do you want to expand this

028to talk about facilities districtwide right one of the things that we we' been working on is taking the on-site Insight reports um transferring them to you know an actual plan not just those documents but uh starting with an Excel sheet and starting to map out when those things it would be great to do that with that committee who who has um you know the the feelings of the the community and stuff like that so using this opportunity to talk about the fic it is a board um board committee and it's at your leisure how you want them to proceed and stuff like that it's your directive and Direction uh so be a good time to kind of talk about some of these things before um you know before we have elections in so great thank

029you uh superintendent there was a lot of Email exchange over the past couple of weeks on this very topic so allow me to get things started is that okay so uh what was intended truly to be a uh a thoughtful email uh I guess was not received that way so uh um Miss Harrison may I put you on the spot okay when was facilities started it was it it's been years yeah right it was at least three years before the last proposal right so facilities has been a longstanding committee well before the Griffin Memorial project right and that's my point right so the facilities committee has always been intended to be a committee that's looked at our schools district collectively and put together kind of a plan for aging infrastructure um and has been comprised

030and correct me if I'm wrong keep me honest has been comprised of largely School District administration and has largely had an open Community seat for year for a long time because we lacked interest from a Community member after a long time to fill that Community member position right fast forward to late 2023 early 2024 right we had Mr oenus Right very interested in the Griffin Memorial project uh I believe you came in because you were interested in why the school changed land positions and that that's how kind of how this start great so um you were asking great questions you were heavily involved you were certainly um you know heavily involved like I said but you know really thought-provoking and challenging the status quo which the board appreciated still appreciate and really making sure that

031you know we're thinking about alternate options again heavily appreciated and we uh on January 3rd 2024 and in the minutes of that particular meeting January 3rd 2024 stated Mr cutter made a motion to have Mr oenus join the facilities Improvement committee as a Committee Member Mr plansky seconded that motion that motion passed 5 that is is in my mind an appointed position as a citizen rep to the facilities committee that is not to be interpreted as a free willed citizen rep in a non-voting capacity that is an appointed position as a voting member on the committee but I'd like to open that in my thoughts to the board on what happened on January 3rd 20124 and how you view that position so I agree with that I do want to clarify though that the rest

032of the community members that volunteered do are voting members so they do have voting rights as well okay by the by the sort of Charter that we've created when we sort of really got a lot of interest in that I do want to say um and I just want to point this out just for your future yeah you know I believe you will be elected again and you know possibly serving as chair I just wanted to say I wish this convers had happened before you sent the email because as if when you sign as chair of the litfield school board it implies that you have the consensus of the board and we hadn't discussed it we had you know the matter hadn't even come up in discussion and so I feel like moving forward I

033think best practice is to you know kind of refrain from if you want to reach out as a as yourself that's fine but to I didn't have his email from my personal email yeah but then you know the signature it does make a big difference so I you know I've I've done it too um when when I was the chair and it's just it's it's important to remember that you know you you can only speak on behalf of the board when we have consensus and when we've discussed it or when when you're representing action that's taken place so that's just a you know going forward I wish you m much success in that so I do feel like it kind of opened up a can of words but I'm glad we're having this conversation now

034my feeling is exactly what that was at the time Mr O blenis was very involved in the in the planning um and ended up you know um actually fully supporting the new the new building and the proposal that went for went forward um and you know uh I felt he was he was a voting member at that time and and in practice on the committee I believe he you know acted accordingly and I agree with you that it was an appointment by the board other thoughts uh I would agree with what you said that it was at that point it was an appointed position from the board your thoughts yeah same yeah okay so given that position right and just fast forwarding so after this January 3rd 2024 Bo board meeting then we fast forward

035to the March vote the March vote failed in 2024 as we all know then in late March at our second meeting in March the board said hey we really want to understand why this failed and what are we going to do about it and that's where this whole conversation about let's get a Grassroots Bottoms Up kind of team together and get representation across section of the community together and let's start to dig into this and understand it right right and the board representation the representative of the board changed when we reallocated our committees as well I just want to put that forward correct so we put out a survey right so who's interested you know please let us know we had 17 or so people in fact I still have the spreadsheet where I collected

036the names 17 or so people interested those people then formulated the now facilities Improvement committee many of those members are still in place point being right those individuals applied so to speak right and are now community members that filled out an application so to speak and are and are a part of the facilities committee not to be the same as an appointed member by the board to the committee well I don't know I don't know if I agree with that I mean they serve on a committee any it's a subcommittee of the school board but we didn't vote no we didn't that's the difference for me we didn't vote on the the Community member on appointing them oh right we did not I think moving forward we should if you the so I mean I

037think what we're I think what we're getting to is like there's definitely some refinement that we need to make with the fic I I agree I think that what probably should have ultimately happened is we as a board should have once the fic formed and the the interest was expressed that we had that group of people we should have formally appointed all of those people um and so we can C we can certainly do that with this you know with this next round of this next wave or I mean we could actually take action on it at any time right because we still are a sitting board so well I think the next part of the conversation is what happens in March when there's a new board and all the appointments reset so I think

038my feeling tell me what you think I I think the work we're doing would be very interrupted if we turned over the fic every time we turned over the school board um I do think you know we the the emails that are going back and forth are are raising a very interesting issue which is what happens when there's people on the fic in a Community member aspect who then become members of other Town boards m um and I do think that we need to address that you know we need to address that um I tend I I understand the long-standing practice I tend to agree with it like I can't you know we're both on the board we can't say okay well we want to be on also as community members so that way we

039both get a vote and that it would skew the process I think you know I think that the same should apply across the board the community members should truly that are voting community members should truly be just community members and not have other involvement in other things well that was another question that I had after you know after reviewing everything you know we appointed a representative from the school board and an alternate for all for all of our committees is Peter an alternate or is he a second School Board member on the board I'm not a voting member we only have one vote right so I participate in the I participate in the meeting but I do not vote right but there have been times too when we've had two opposing viewpoints coming from each

040of the board members and the role of the representative of the board is to represent what the board right what the board decides and and and you know the board's desire so yeah I mean I don't think we' voted on anything I don't think we voted on the board hasn't decided a direction right the board is looking for direction from this committee yeah I'm just just I'm just put putting you know good discussion it doesn't impact me personally but I'm just you know kind of watching from the outside at this point I mean I think the more I I personally like having the the more input I think it's useful um I think one of the things that we really fell short on in the past is just there not being enough continuous voices not

041for us a lack of trying but it just wasn't set up that way and so personally I think that that's been a real value ad no and appreciate the work the committee has done I just think we need is s jump in just listening is there any way to kind of split the difference here like for your board committees you do update that every time you have a new board so once a year you'll go through and you might have the same people as part of these committees right or you might change it up depending on the makeup of the board and stuff like that when you think of the facilities committee which is an offshoot Committee of of the board is there any way that if someone's standing hasn't changed right you're still a

042Community member you're still a part of it like you're not going to get you don't have to be re renewed or revoted it reappointed if there's a new board but if the Dynamics of a person has changed either they or a Community member and now part of a board whether school board or bu budget committee or board select whatever the case may be then you have to have that discussion and then reverse too if someone was you know part of one of those boards and and wanted to be engaged as a community member now in that type of situation could you also like have a discussion on appointing them then like somewhere to have that because I think if if this is a successful committee and and it hasn't always been fun but that we'll

043talk about progress being made with it and if this is going to continue in the years ahead and we look at at it being a continuous thing you're going to have these conversations of people's Dynamics changing both ways right coming on and off boards as it is so having some sort of protocol it's it's different than these committees in the term that these are exclusive to board members but like maybe you can follow similar practices when you talk about this committee on how you're going to handle those type of things can I throw a question out there how and I'm honestly thinking I should probably know the answer but how does the town do it with respect to the wreck commission that's an an appointed committee that falls under the select board they're not elected

044they're appointed I think same with plan and Zoning right Capital Improvement do those turn over they're appointed for x amount of years okay so I think maybe we need to be specific with that and then have our appointment Cycles rotate so maybe it's if there six community members two for you know every two years but so it's the same there is some overlap and people know the commitment it's not forever you're not always appointed to the same committee but I agree I don't think there should be turnover necessarily yearly because you would lose some of the momentum you have as a committee but at the same time things change and you have to take I agree with that I think that that's a good suggestion I think we do need to move to an like

045it they do need to be appointed across the board and and I think honestly in last meeting I think everybody who was there indicated that they wanted to be on the committee going forward right because there's a real feeling that we're making some progress this is great right you like the idea having something I know like conservation does at this twoe seats you you stagger it y yeah I'm just trying to make the parallel of how we do this and I'm not sure we've ever really had a lot of committees that are open to public on behalf as a school board they typically are made up of seu employees different versions never been this much interest true right which is again a good thing and again we would have gladly welcomed Community input think the

046fact that the meeting is now at 5:30 and not at 2 or 3:00 in the afternoon I more people to participate yeah I think it was more than that people are a lot more interested in what's happening and obviously facilities is a Hot Topic right now so I think that in March it's an opportunity to reset yes it's an opportunity to start fresh for all of us and all the subcommittees right and all everything that we serve and it's an opportunity to get this right right and and do it open and if we're going to stagger terms we're going to stagger terms if um and I'll let you you know who who's ever going to start in March with facilities if that's you if that's Peter whoever's going to do it we can figure out

047what the right terms is if it's one two three years whatever you want to do give people a one year out if that's what they want great but I think that's um that's probably the right direction there was a one point and again I'd have to go back and look in the agenda wasn't there I don't want to say rules but bylaws that were drafted I mean that could be a good time to review those bylaws as well to make sure that we have in there a conflict of interest policy or anything along Dan has the Dan is like the he's the bylaw Guy questions yeah do you want can we have Dan come up and answer some those sure in the fic operations document it states under memberships and organizations now it doesn't talk

048about how the board but it just says that appointments to the committee will be made by the facilities Improvement committee when a vacancy occurs and will be communicated to the school board for notice an appointed member will gain voting rights at the completion of their fifth meeting in attendance one a vacancy concerns the facilities Improvement committee will seek out volunteers for the community and will use multiple modes of communication to ensure maximize reach of message that's how it's currently stated yeah so I think we probably need to amend that to be that the facilities Improvement committee will make the recommendation and that the board will do the appointment correct that's otherwise it's not right binding and then would you need to update that with like whatever your terms are we would add the terms to

049that and then I think we do also need to address what we were just talking about whether a a member becomes a member of a board or likewise a member of a board no longer is a member of a board do we want to continue to offer them is language in thew about voity to members and yes and I could tell that in the five years that I've been on the board we have always had a select in addition to the school we've always had a selectman rep who had a voting member and a budget committee who had a voting member until I believe the winter of 23 yeah when the budget committee voted to not have their representative vote on that committee Dan yeah I mean my feeling on this you know just I'm

050I'm really proud of the work that's being done by the facilities Improvement committee I think it was a good pause on behalf of the board to say we're too close to this at this point we need to go outside and we need to get fresh perspectives from people in town um and I think as we have continued to um you know there I think we're still feeling out how this works it's kind of Grassroots because again it's our first committee that is made up of more community members or voting community members than um SAU and and board members um so I I do think the election gives us the opportunity to refresh our the bylaws as it relates to the committee as well as our policies around that um because you don't think of things

051at the time you don't know they're going to come up you know okay any other conversation on this one that's just uh so who's going to do it I guess yeah so what's the action item here so action item is updating the bylaw the action item is updating the bylaws on the facilities right the action the other action item is in terms of board appointments to the facilities is effective March at our March what is it Fifth meeting the appointment that we made effective January 3rd 24 is reset and that would have to be managed then by the facilities committee going forward right so it would be the first meeting of March or the second sorry the second meeting of managed by the facilities Committee in the sense of making making recommendations to the board

052for appointments for appointments yes so would we need at facilities to discuss updated so with the bylaws updates facilities would they do it and then bring it to the board board for approval that's what we did before think so I mean but I do think that the board has has to Ultimate say on has ultimate say but maybe the recommendations from the facilities committee on the updated bylaws bring to the board I guess I don't want to my concern is we've given a deadline on a very specific item I don't want to take any of the facilities committee time yeah yeah um coming up with bylaw changes so I'm I mean it's not my I don't think that there's massive bylaw changes I think it's literally just what are the terms mhm we're going to

053make the re you have to do at that time anyways right and then the only other piece of it this is going to impact Mr DWI anyways yeah so right then the only other piece of it is how are we handling the additions to boards versus subtractions from boards in terms of does that mean we have to set a number because we really didn't have a number y I would people on the board I would say and I would probably say you you you might want to consider setting voting as well m not opening it up to everybody so right now the voter we already do that they're like I'm a non- voting member right I mean obviously and anyone can attend these meetings they're public right they're announced they're recorded anyone can attend is

054there public comment at the meeting if someone's not on the it hasn't been only because everybody who's there is typically okay a member although the the the committee sort of found its own form I mean there's probably really 12 or 15 people that are at 85 or 90% of the meetings and there were there were many more names than that that never show either never showed or showed once or twice and and bailed so and we had it we had something in the bylaws about attendance right Dan yeah if you miss so many so many things in a row you yeah we also have C membership at 20 members 20 there's a size that's a very large community it is that's maybe why we had seven right yeah stuck that number so so so just

055for clarification what do you want us to bring back to you proposal for revised bylaws changes okay I would think that would be we have to bring that to you before March they're not going to meet before then well no we are meeting we have a lot of work to do now would it make sense for that to be I this might make a decision does it make sense for this board to vot on that or the new board will vote on that I think well we're going to need to do well I guess we could always do that appointment we don't have to do that appointment we could do it the second meeting yeah because you don't appoint your actual committee I'm assuming I haven't been here yet for a transition that you not

056right so but and that's not that initial meeting correct you you get recommendations on what people are interested in them I'm assuming at the next meeting is when you set the appointments correct or a future meeting we we'll try to add it into I'll talk to Dan about adding it into our agenda as soon as possible but I once I give you an update you'll understand what we're working on I mean again this is sort of new in the sense that we haven't really had to appoint community members and so when we're picking our committees as board members a lot of the times it's a lot of not it not no okay you only have one your turn you know as you go through not everything obviously but you know it's it's certainly not I

057don't know that there's a lot of fighting over who gets what so I think it's okay to bring the but it's your decision I don't don't I don't want to force anything down your throats but I think it's okay to bring those updated bylaws to the new board right you know so like you wouldn't need to have this from the fic for the next school board meeting think that makes sense because if you vote on those there at that at that second March meeting you're doing appointments when you're also doing your committee appointments for the board itself so would you like an update now that's next on the agenda you good go ahead so yeah we had a very productive meeting the last meeting um we spent more time looking at the Matrix that we

058created um we had some conversation about prioritizing items the in the yellow if you remember the yellow box prioritizing items um we had a kind of round robin conversation about the top five or so saw a few Trends in that um and then people were going to be emailing in their like the remainder to to prioritize those um but in looking at so in in sort of looking at the survey results and looking at the Matrix we as a board voted to remove two of the options to recommend to the uh school board so okay we eliminated the new school option the complete new new building um and we eliminated the repairs only option um by vote of the committee so what we're left with right now is uh renovation so renovation and renovation plus

059addition we've kind of um not officially but we've kind of lumped together because ultimately the scope of a renovation could include an addition once we like if we put out an RFP we feel like or if we suggest that you put out an RFP we feel like that could be broad enough to allow for an addition if it seems to make sense within the budget and within the uh you know confines of whatever the architect or whoever we work with recommend um so that's one and then the other one that we're looking at still or still talking about is the shuffling grades you know sth and eth to the high school stuff like that um the continued interest in that is largely based around just the idea of utilization right I mean so we know

060there's we do we have discussed that there are a lot of challenges with that in the sense that we would have to touch all three schools we would impact all operations at all three schools but the sort of thing that we haven't moved past to a point of wanting to make uh you know sort of decision on that one way or the other is just the utilization component of the space at the high school right now so we have uh those are going to be the basis of our conversations for the next meeting or two and then we're going to be coming with a suggestion I watched the last meeting M um I have some comments if you comment away um I was relieved that you did eliminate eventually eliminate the repairs only um I

061think a solution that does not meet the educational needs of our students is not is cannot be an option cannot be the path forward um and I felt strongly about that you know the board and the survey results were very clear that the committee needs to balance educational impacts and money and they were pretty as if I recall correctly they were pretty evenly evenly matched it was there was not one that was a greater importance than the other the the only one that was so you had educational needs only you had balance of the two and then you had money only yeah and so if you lump educational needs and educational needs and and money CU both of them express some regard for educational needs it was from the survey results it was well beyond

062so the educational needs are important to both the school board and our voters right is what we but to the level of the respond whether they should be balanced with the financial considerations versus completely regardless of the financial consideration that that's where there was a right absolutely so repairs only to me was a a very financial situation it was not right really concerned with the educational needs of the that we that we had identified that was reflected in The Matrix yes so if you looked at the Matrix there was a lot of know this would that achieve those things y um I was very disappointed that the new build was eliminated at the same time as repairs only and not only because I was a supporter of a new Bel but it was the only

063option that um met all of the educational needs so if you look at the Matrix we can meet a large you know you have to remember you have to remember that we're talking about the balance right because the majority of people wanted a balance between the two um we we can achieve those with that like I'll be honest with you about my per my personal view is I want a solution that's going to solve the educational needs and and fix the problems right I don't I'm not married to a new build let me be clear I'm not either right I am not my support for that was largely just based off of the fact that I and is my own personal belief is that I think that once we start digging into walls in an

064old building the price tag may be the same but I what I can tell you about the the sentiment across the facilities committee pretty unanimously was that regardless of whether it's going to be more cost effective which we you know we don't know but regardless of whether a new bill will be more cost effective the perception uh is just too hard to overcome for us to make that recommendation and that was that was unanimous across the committee I disagree with that because of the survey results so the the only the only counter I will say to that right so I I personally also feel like the survey results were an important metric and I feel like we did as much as we could humanly do to Tred to get as broad of a sampling however

065we did only only have roughly 900 responses right so at the end of the day we have to you know there are people on the committee are saying well that's not an accurate sampling well maybe it is maybe it isn't but at the end of the day it's a consideration that we that we have to I understand that but the data implied two two that the the data from the survey implied that there were two options that were supported by people who responded and we cut one of them completely out that's my disappointment um again I support a renovation and addition build I think we can get there I think we can meet all of the educational impact needs that we need to meet I think we need to do that in order to receive

066building Aid because that's what we've been told we need to meet all of the requirements that we said we were going to fix in our first application or that needed to be fixed in our first application um and I think that if we're if we're worried about the cost I think we need to I think we would be doing our taxpayers a huge disservice by not taking advantage of the building Aid that we know now that we that we are going to receive so ultimately we're tasked with making a recommendation for what we think the board should put out for an RFP to do further investigation right and so our position not and this is not our official position I'm going to leave the seventh and eighth thing to the side for a second because

067I don't know if that if we come to you with that then that's a whole different thing but ultimately we're we're not we're we're not jumping to this is exactly what's going to happen we're saying this is what we think needs to be investigated now we would like the board to investigate that that's not to say that if we hire a completely different architect who comes in and does all of the studies and all the plans that they won't say okay the cost you know you're in you're potentially in line for state aid it it may make more sense to go with uh something that aligns with the state aid application versus you know I I don't know what they're going to say ultimately all we're doing is asking we we're we're giving you a

068suggestion for what to S to ask for for an hour my only caution on that point and I I totally agree with you and I appreciate that my only caution is that when you put out the RFP you're asking for a specific job to be done as we did with Kyle Barker in the first project proposal he came forward with a with a recommendation the board you know the the committee came to the board and the board approved it and that's what what went forward on the ballot we then received you know even though as you know because you were on the committee we studied all of the different options the the push back was that we hadn't vetted each one adequately the reason for that was because we put out an RFP for a

069new build and in many people's minds and I'm afraid that if we only put out an RFP for a renovation and addition we won't do the background check to see does is this what really what makes sense before we have before we put something so I mean it's within the board's perview to structure the I'm just I just want to I wanted to comment because I'm not going to be on the board when this comes to a board vote and that that's besides the point um I just want to make sure that the facility understands you know kind of the implications of what I'm what I'm seeing as an observer of these meetings um there's still we're still dis having discussions about how little can we do without bringing the building up to code and

070and that to me is the antithesis of of why we're on this committee and why we're no no no no no no no having a project that that passes isn't better than having a project that passes but doesn't meet our needs got a lot of that's my personal opinion and I'm saying it now because I'm here that's fine but I think that what you have to understand is that this committee we we intentionally created a committee of community members with diverse opinions MH and so ultimately it is within the right of those community members if if their personal belief is that I don't agree with that but if their personal belief is that it is within their right to express that and ultimately the checks and balances are that it's a committee that has votes

071and so as you've seen if that was the General sentiment of the committee we would not have eliminated the repairs only option but that's not the general consensus of the committee right so it really is about checks and balances I agree with you on that that I don't think as a school board member that that's what's right for our community to to disregard education but yeah that's also doesn't seem to be the way that the votes on the committee are going either the other piece about um my last and this will be my last comment um the discussion about redistribution of of grade levels throughout the district um that a redistribution of grades across the district as we've discussed kind of briefly impacts every student in the district every teacher in the district every staff

072member in the district and it requires a lot more time and thought and planning on the part of the school board than yeah let's look into that and see how it's going to work like when we we never actually acted on it but when we proposed having a start time change and changing the start times at each of our schools we had we put a committee together it never met but we put a committee to together um and the plan was to study that over a year just to decide if it was feasible to change the start times at our schools changing redistributing redistribution of grades is so much more involved with that you're talking about planning programming curriculum co-curriculars bus schedules I I mean if that is a direction the Board needs to go

073in that's I would I would recommend the board decides that quickly swiftly and and and take the year to adequately study it that that's going to require committee Community input um surveying the community surveying parents and staff and and figuring out if this town even has the stomach to do that um I don't know that that can be an option if that can be a decision to recommend or not recommend on from the facilities committee I think that has to start within the district and with the school board so the school board asked us to make recommendations from from a community perspective as to what we think the community will support and what you know right so at the end of the day if the recommendation is to the school board that that's what we

074think the best option is then yes I mean the timeline would be stretched out the school board would have to do all of that investigation the superintendent did present a lot of those points to the committee the committee the committee has heard those um I anticipate that the committee will be rediscussed to the committee about this you know I had asked a question about having Kyle Barker come back um I'm going to ask again because I think that now that we're down to two options it may make sense to have to re-engage the conversation of when you looked at this what were the not talking about the cost just when you looked at this what were the Practical considerations from building perspectives because the superintendent's done an excellent job of educating us on the educational

075aspects and some of the programming aspects and the staff aspects all that stuff um so you know again we have two more meetings that that is largely going to be the topic of conversation at those meetings so Tina from my from my perspective I want to get something done that does something because if we just keep putting up a new school and I think that the folks the even the admin team that was on the meeting somebody asked a question I forget I think it was Dan does anybody think that a new school is going to pass in the next five years Dan dway I believe it was Dan correct me if I'm wrong not to a person nobody thought anything no nobody thought a new school would pass we have to do something that

076improves the situation may not be perfect but we need to do something to improve the situation um and the for me the the best solution not the best solution but a solution that will do that would be to do some repair do do all the repairs that are in the first five years at GMS right at the beginning knock them all out and then do um po some additional renovation within the building to centralize services and things like that there were part of the Matrix is to maybe pick maybe it's the top five maybe it's the top 10 depending on what we think we can spend and then um redistribute the school redistribute the kids it can be done we have enough room in all of the schools to move kids around without having an

077addition if we don't wouldn't even need to put an addition on Griffin it wouldn't be perfect I don't think it's going to be perfect as I said the other night I don't think we can the town all statements that's okay I and and to totally respect your opinion because because we've looked at it and I agree with Matt I think it would be wise to bring Kyle back tell them what we looked at you were on the board at that time Peter and and you you also voted to approve the new bill to go forward right I did I supported it and it was to give the the thing the best chance to didn't pass it we keep forgetting that it it failed miserably all right I'm I I don't need to debate this anymore

078I don't have a say um I just have one question yeah right is there any consideration and the one big thing for me in all of this is is there any consideration to the impact of the kids so thank you so yeah so I mean that was one of the biggest things about the shuffling right is that there is impact on not just operations right but there is impact on changing on changing when kids are changing schools right so that has an impact on you know ultimately we talk about change years right with curriculum transition years right so we we're impacting the transition years yeah there's there's absolutely conversation about that and I mean I think we've touched on educational impacts uh on multiple meetings now but I again I really think that we're down

079to these two options here I think that the next two meetings are going to be focused largely on what does it mean if we choose one of these options over the other because again it really comes down to the the the shuffling grades really just comes down to utilization building utilization that's 100 that's really three administrators shaking their heads right now and I understand it but I'm saying that's that's all it comes down to so again to your point it's not it's not the educational that's not an educational option like that's not what that's I'm think about our youngest students you right lit our youngest students in prek through four at the moment right notably Griffin and I'm thinking about all the construction around them and all the distractions around them for multiple years and

080what that learning environment is for them when we're when we're measuring I ready scores and all the benchmarks that we're trying to improve and what that's going to do to them that's what I'm thinking about when when are you saying that in the context of even with respect to renovation plus Edition yes yes so I think it it was it tractor I think it's within the do I I mean 100% I think it's within the board's purview to keep an RFP broad enough to allow for the the exploration of it just I think it makes sense to keep the the RFP broad enough that's the best I could say to that it's within the board's purview to do as you continue conversations please keep that mind it feels like the educational impacts of a project

081and the educational needs of students especially when the committee is ranking the education well I think Ada is important but I don't think that we need sprinklers or I think that we should have speech Services located someplace else but I don't think we need to redo the nurse's office I don't feel like those impacts on operations and education are being considered with enough weight as well we got to fill our our seats in our buildings and you know I I don't feel like they're getting a fair Shake in the conversation and just based on what I what I I heard at this past meeting my comment is to Echo you know what Andrew's question is my struggle is I'm going to be honest I did not think the redistribution would be the one of two

082remaining I didn't like that is shocking to me that that's what's coming out of the facilities Improvement committee and that gives me pause and I'm just being honest because the educational impact of that decision may not I I think outweighs the facility conversation and you guys are tasked with facilities Improvement right so and that's a to me that's a different topic than educational impact I I don't know that I you know we we took great pride in putting together people who are really familiar with facilities and construction and all of these different aspects to it and I I again I'm very proud of the work you guys are doing and please don't take this as a criticism but my the harder part is that the educational impact piece isn't necessarily um I don't know getting

083as much representation in fic as it needs to particularly I know our admins are in there and advocating but I I I feel like that piece is getting lost a little bit and so I guess I would just say I have a lot of concerns if redistribution solely based on utilization of numbers is what we're looking at the educational impact and how it works to go from a three school to a two school or a seven to 12 cannot go to a two school I just would like to can I just reiterate one thing though uh you know we had a survey question that asked in determining a solution for future needs of Elementary education what should the facilities Improvement committee prioritize lowest cost options should be the top priority educational needs should be the

084top priority lowest cost options and educational needs should have equal priority 51% of respondents selected that last one yeah 15.8% of respondents selected lowest cost options should be top priority so doing the inverse of what I do all the time to to defend educational needs 66% of respondents care about the cost and 84% care about educational needs I understand but you can't you can't you can't not pay attention to the the cost I and again I'm not not I'm not advocating to not pay attention to the cost but the fic is if if we didn't have to consider cost there would be one option and one option only which would be a new build I'm not advocating for fic to not consider cost map but what I'm saying is that and the same survey that

085you're citing if you go to the last question 41% would strongly not support sending the people out a district and when it came to redistributing same thing again right I haven't presented that as the recommendation from the fic all I've said is that that's the one of the two remaining right and the reason why it's one of the two remaining is it was very easy to eliminate repairs only agreed right the the new school while surprising in some regards it was the consensus of the committee was that they don't think that that option will pass so that's why that was eliminated I think that when we sit down personally I think that when we sit down and look at the shuffling option we're we are going to re we haven't Revisited the survey results with

086respect to that yet we're going to revisit that we're going to look at the Matrix again and then we're going to have to have another conversation about the educational impacts and I I quite honestly would be very surprised if that was the recommendation of the school Bo personally I think as the person who presented to the facilities committee the idea of a redistribution right we did it from a very very limited informative standpoint right like a 12,000 thing these are some of the things you have to start to consider if you're going to even go down this road we need to have a serious discussion in fic about what that road now is because if that was ultimately the recommendation and I'm not advocating for or against I say this all the time in that

087facility committee I'm here to inform you from an educational standpoint on on these matters right that's my job as a superintendent you're likely needing to do a significant amount of research before committing to that which is going to slow down the process right now if that's ultimately the right decision for your District you need to take your time to do that type of work right but it's not as simple as and I have said this multiple times of just plopping 180 kids into the high school right and I will I will pound my fist on this for this it's not necessarily the 7 through 12 that concerns me it's the 3 through six configuration I don't I am not familiar with that instructional model a building that's 3 through six I've seen other configurations of

088different schools I'm not saying it's impossible but as someone who is an educator by trade and at heart I would want to educate myself on how that model can be successful right before advocating it to others correct because that's the math when you look at these buildings if you go down that reconfiguration we talk about 7 through 12 because that's the the move and the Campbell and there's the space to there and and there are schools that and in that model that are successful that are 7 through 12 schools and and so we know that's a model that is out there that works right I just am I just don't I literally don't know about that 3 through six model I'll talk about where my kid goes to school in one them it's a k

089through 4 prek through 4 56 78 9 through 12 right so like that's a model I'm familiar with the district I just left was a one school was a prek through 4 the other school school was prek through six they came together a 5 through eight model half the kids were there and then the other half arrived in seventh grade that's the model I was familiar with the district I left a long time ago was a K through five multiple schools filling into a middle school that was 6 through 8 9 through 12 right each district is different and you got to take time and figure out what's right for your District but my cons I just don't have a knowledge base on a 3 through six model one other quick thing for you just

090about that option too Mrs Douglas brought this point up which is you know and she's would like to see utilization but she also acknowledged the fact that that option may have been better served years ago before we didn't work to the middle school if we could have gone to a two- School model which still would have been very large schools but financially speaking right like if you're only looking at from a financial perspective the the savings would have probably been drastically better on a two- School model so it may not even really serve the purpose we just haven't finished that conversation yet yeah no and again I know we're coming in mid you guys are still working really hard and I I don't want you or anyone on the committee to take what I'm saying

091at all is critic I take no personal offense okay good I I again I know you guys are weighing out all of the options and it's not easy so I appreciate the work you're doing I just struggle a lot it it is the outcome of the last meeting with the two options that were eliminated and the two were that were left were quite surprising to observe from an Outsider perspective well hopefully one of them wasn't that surprising no one was not surprising well two were surprising the fact that redistribution is what's left and the fact that a new building is gone those were the two surprises to me but again I I trust the process and you guys are going to come I know with a wellth thought out well you know written trust the

092process proposal we trust all right this is uh beaten to death tonight all right I appreciate it um looking forward to the recommendation meeting we have to it's for students so we have to do it all right um The Time Is Now 7:57 are we okay with allowing our student representatives to go I know you just plugged in but sorry unplug excited I I know just getting warmed up for the night okay thank you for listening in enjoy your evening yeah um the time is now just about 8:00 we'll open it up for public comment you have policy first if you want to do that first in your agenda do public comment we'll do public comment first yeah policy is going to take a few minutes probably right so maybe baby Ronald B 15 review

093Circle I just want to I'm going to go back I'm not even going to address the other things because that sounds like it'll be a topic for later um the one thing I I would just wish to highlight is that what I said before on these wages I went in and looked at a specific individual I won't mention your names and pulled out the rate increases that are published that will occur over three years the existing year is $952 this is per hour 20 26 is $20.99 27 is 2235 228 is 2388 that increase in total is 23 22.3% simply on wages and that includes the steps this is for an individual that is in the step procedure and if anybody wants to debate me on that I'd be happy to but those figures come

094out of that spreadsheet that you did for me and then I did the same thing looking at this sheet which is the public rate has nothing to do with f i or anything else it's just wage rates and I did the same thing and the numbers come out exactly the same so that is the wage increase that is included with steps and there is as you know a longevity payment for anybody that's over 15 years what was the first number run the just the first hourly and then last hourly to it went from what to what thank you 2388 okay so that person is going to go over that period of time if you annualize it using rough math from $39,000 a year to to what 23 an hour yep 2388 roughly $46,000 a year

095yeah so okay so one employee but just understand that hiring people who are willing to work for $39,000 a year in 2025 that that's part of the consideration that's why we negotiated this contract like I understand when you look at it as here's the deal right at the end of the day there seems to be some discrepancy beh behind whatever math you're doing Mr and I'm not questioning whatever percentages you're calculating but whatever math you're doing and whatever the math is that we're being supplied by our Human Resources Director and the superintendent right there seems to be conflicting information somewhere and attorneys what and our attorneys and our attorneys and your attorneys with with all due respect by attorneys with all due respect right not disputing any of your math here but I'm relying upon

096all of the hard work by our Administration that's been thoroughly vetted and reviewed at this point and has come to the board and the board has approved that's what I have to go on I just want to clarify the attorney piece this isn't just our math right right like we have our attorney review it and the lssa has their attorney review it and the attorneys agree these are the correct figures this isn't just our math internally here this is the agreed upon people by the attorneys who are doing this stuff my my point though is what you failed to present to the public is a 4% raise is not just 4% on what is the current rate what has to get factored in is there is built in 3% steps for year 1 through 14

097that if no raises were applied everyone would get 3% raises correct only if they only if they get not everyone gets Ste though wait a minute wait just a minute everyone gets a step if they have a qualifying year they work so many hours no if they're on top step they're not getting a step if they're what on top step they don't get a step wait just a minute I'm talking about people between years one and 14 when you get above 14 you go to longevity payments that's not not necessarily that's what it states in the contract you have to be of service to the district for an x amount of time someone could be hired at step 14 cuz they have 14 let's use teachers cuz it's an easier example cuz more likely you're

098going to have teachers who get the top step we can hire a teacher at step 14 because they have 20 years of teaching experience somewhere correct they're never likely going to hit longevity with us because they're not going to be internally in our district to hit that longevity Mark longevity payments come out if for the amount of time you've been in the district I've been in education for 20 years I've never hit longevity in any District cuz I keep changing districts it's my fourth district that's fine and and there is an option I read in the contract that you can place people on the step scale cuz we can't hire people like that's the nature of this contract my point being is there is steps in place that occur every year of an employee don't

099shake your head no it doesn't happen for every employee it has to that's what the contract says it doesn't all right this is not going anywhere productive so we're going to end this conversation is there anything else you'd like to address I'd happy you sit down with anybody and and go over there that's what the figure saying I would just like to clarify one thing about our warrant article that we put up what we have to put up for a warrant article is the increase to our budget that's what we're putting in there right this contract is going to cost the district if it is passed an additional $26,000 that is what the warrant article is it's not voting on people's raises I mean yes you're getting to that figure CU you're factoring in the

100additional cost of clarify for for the next year for the next year correct and we give estimates for years two and three because there's a ton of variables for future years people come and go everything associated with that right and we may not even hit that $26,000 that is the maximum we would hit because that's where we factor in from the negotiations of everything that it is included in that figure because our operating budget or default budget have not been voted on is all the positions that we are reducing by next year but in the negotiations we have to includ include that in that math because technically the positions haven't been cut yet so for example those races for the vacant positions that are likely not going to be in the budget next year because

101the budget's going to article something's going to happen in article one are not going to be there so that 206 represents the maximum amount of money we are adding to the budget if that contract passes period for 87 employees and it's not all salary it's the cost of the employee to the district as Miss fzone mentioned it's FICA it's retirement and their salary all match together that is part of that with the cost of the district is there anything else you'd like to address to the board tonight no I I'll just reiterate that what you published and what I stated is correct and I happy to sit down with anybody and prove to me that I'm wrong What did the what did the calculation you just do come up with it was like rough math

10239,000 no what is what is what isent increase of those two I didn't do the I did I got 17.9% no you have to do from the first one to the fifth fourth one I did the but perhaps you could also just focus on what it's like to try to hire people for $39,000 like that's an important piece that you seem to leave out of your this conversation's done it's not productive I'll just finish up I got a $100 a month increase my Social Security and I got a $169 increase in my medical because of the negotiated prescription plan so I I'm not getting the pay raise this year I'm I'm going behind I have to pay taxes I like a lot of other people like in my situation so I don't get s or

1038% increase every year and I'll stop there okay thank you very much any other public comment this evening all right at this time we're going to close public comment and go on with the rest of our agenda tonight next up we have policies yes policies the first three we're going back all right let's do it um so we have been advised to revert back to our original language um for these different um policies after by Council is this a result of new Administration yeah yes so guidances they revert back to the title 9 guidelines that were in place uh previously so so that's what we're doing okay so that's one through three number four is a new required policy um based off of um changes to state law okay I've read the policies I'm fine

104with them is everyone a chance all right I'll make a motion for first read to approve policy ACAC hyphen R uh policy ACAC policy ACN policy JJ i i c second motion by myself second by Mr Shoemaker additional discussion all those in favor for first read please say I I I opposed abstained those carry Z nothing think for second read this evening nothing for old business this evening we'll move into school board comments anything on school board comments tonight yeah um I I have something it's not directed to the board um if if it makes you feel better for us to acknowledge that it's a 20% increase over 3 years I'm willing to acknowledge that it's a 20% increase for some employees over 3 years I don't have have a problem doing that because I

105know that our pair professionals our food service workers our custodians our buildings and grounds workers and our admin assistants at our schools am I missing anybody Holly monitors lunch and recess monitors um are are Diamonds in the Rough and for the work that they do and the the value that they bring to our school district and the impact that they have on the education of our students is profound we had last year a crisis in our district um a crisis of Education because we could not hire pair professionals we could not find food techs we could not find custodians um because of the of the salaries the wages it's really not salaries it's wages it's hourly wages that we were offering to to those employees um this warrant article for the new contract will make

106a big difference for people who don't make a lot of money we're talking about maybe $4 an hour is that kind of what I heard $4 an hour over three years um for what they do and they're in my opinion and I'm going to advocate for them they're worth every penny and more I know that the salaries that we've the wages that we've negotiated are still at the low end of competitive for surrounding districts um I work in a district that pays more base salary beginning wages um by quite a bit and even they have a hard time finding people we have open positions in my district as well um the board negotiated this Contracting good faith because we know we have a need and we need good people to fill these roles and um

107I'm I I know that times are hard and they're hard for everybody but as you heard too if if these if these increases don't go through we have 87 people 50 of which live in town who will not see any increase at all um and that I can't I can't abide by that these people do important work um um we're still short staffed if you would like to take advantage of the 20% increases we can send you an application and you can can come work for us part-time because it's until you're you're in it and you see it and you you understand where it's coming from this is in my opinion the least we can do to support these people that's all I'll say about it stated yeah thank you and I'll piggyback on it

108if this contract does not not pass those 87 employees would probably very easily find pay in any surrounding district and that would our district and cost us a lot more because we' have to hire staff and temp we contract out for the open positions we have now the pair of professionals we pay four times as much for contracted providers can I respond to that no no we close public comment all right anything else for Schoolboard comments all right moving into manifest we have four items to report on manifest from February 5th 2025 we have payroll in the amount of $429,450 3B deductions and nhr for $ 36,19626 70 as well as accounts payable for $449,500 specifically under a as well as C uh I will entertain a motion to move into non public we have

109a motion by Mr Shoemaker a second by Mr plansky all those in favor please say I I I opposed abstained that carries 500 and we are moving to public now thank you very

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.