001indivisible and uh tonight's meeting is a reschedule from uh last week meeting which was the first meeting of January unfortunately uh last week the board did not have a quorum and we had to reschedule for uh this week today uh the board will also have a scheduled meeting our second meeting of the month uh regularly scheduled for next Wednesday that is the plan uh the board is also we have a posted meeting for tomorrow as well uh just in the event it's needed which is the budget hearing um the board there will likely be a quum of the board at the budget hearing uh so there is a posted agend for for tomorrow as well um all right moving forward with tonight uh we have review and revision of tonight's agenda are there any changes
002modifications to tonight's agenda by any board member all right moving on we have consent any committee reports tonight to move off consent and into the agenda seeing and hearing none uh we'll move into summary of non-public actions from December 18th 2024 Mr plans motion to approve the December 4th 2024 meeting minutes Mr Shoemaker second of that motion and that motion passed 0 U moving right along this evening we have presentation and recognitions and I'll turn it over to the superintendent yep uh so we have suzan uh can Woodcock here from uh Campbell High School she's one of our new art teachers um she's going to present um this really kind of unique opportunity it's it's it's a purchase slash donation for our Ceramics um program up at the high school it's a I well I'll
003let her explain invite her up to talk about it I was read over it looks really great yeah yeah welcome thank you thank you very much um so we do have this lovely opportunity um from The Courier Museum I used to work there and um I knew that they had U they used to have a really nice ceramic program um and they had a um their own actual little art school they ended up selling and all of that equipment has been in storage for years when I started working at Campbell High School and uh I saw that we have two wheels and I could see the interest growing uh especially with our new ceramic educator Amanda kill um there's just been a lot of Buzz so I reached out to one of my colleagues and
004asked if um they might be willing to negotiate with us um so that we could potentially purchase maybe um and essentially it came down to them saying that um they would give us nine uh wheels and an extruder and a slab roller and um other equipment the only thing that they were asking was um a little under market price uh for their pug mill which is um it's this device that allows us to recycle clay in the past um I don't believe that Campbell recycled clay and it is an expense that we can save on if we can recycle it's also a great practice for the students to learn how to take care of the materials um and it's just another way for students to get involved uh in the maintenance of their studio so
005um the asking price was $2500 for uh the Pug mail but the rest they would donate which I think is a a really wonderful opportunity and it comes at a time when we had made some curricular um proposals and uh if this were approved we would love to move Ceramics and 3D type artwork into what was the wood shop it's kind of sitting there with all this amazing equipment and um High ceilings and all this electricity where we could do very safe I promise things um but right now it's a bit more limiting so if we were able to expand and um utilize that space we would be able to then build Ceramics into this more three-dimensional space that maybe would have a lot of interest for different kinds of students who really would love
006to build something maybe more than draw so yeah so we're coming here to the board uh because it's kind of a a one two thing here um we would have to move a little bit of uh transfer of money around a little bit um to pay for the $2,500 it would come out of supply and Equipment lines where we we have a little extra spending right now um so that's not too much of an asking this is a great opportunity so we think it's worth it um but the the value of everything that would be donated far exceeds um you know $5,000 so we would need your permission to kind of move forward with this an approval uh to kind of go forward with this so we want to be sensitive with the fact that
007that we're we're buying something that we didn't necessarily have in this budget per se but trying to keep it an opportunity um interesting enough we had originally in the budget I think it was two pottery wheels um in our proposed budg next year that we actually took out as part of this which is a nice nice way that we were able to get these kind of free and not put put them in next year's budget so um this equipment you know just uh as a frame of reference the school I was at uh before this is essentially what they had in their art room so this would kind of get us um up to speed I'm not an artist but I actually recognize what all these things are and have like good for you used
008them we'll put that in quotes as in being in the class while observing and doing other things and being put to work so um I think this would be great for for um our our department I can see our kids really getting into it I know um at my previous school when we invested um in 3D art and Ceramics and this type of stuff sculpture the program exploded um with interest from students so I think this would be would be wise to do is um is it truly a package deal is it the kind of thing like we have to buy the pugmill to get all the free donated equipment um I did not ask that but I have a feeling that's not right okay in terms of like I'm assuming this is a bigger
009piece a bigger a bigger unit I'm assuming it's powered by electricity some sort some of it is some of this is like the extruder you're do it by hand like it's this giant thing right and you put the clay in and you just go crank and you come down with and like that's what it is and the slab roller is a demonstrate that again and you do that the slab stand out here but it takes some muscle this is what I'm saying like I didn't know this until being in our class seen it and like the slab roller is by hand you crank crank crank and you put it through multiple times you go through it now the kilms use electricity obviously um but I'm assuming we have KS right now that these would essentially
010replace yes um and then the pug mill I don't how much does that use I point is do we need to run 220 to power these do we is there electrical also other supplies other equipment other cost considerations to be able to power this equipment run this equipment that we're not thinking about quite yet I think there are some marginal ones yes I think when we putting it into that uh wood shop room which is what we're intended to be we have the power like big Power set up in that room already um obviously if you're turning a switch on that's not currently on there is some cost associated with it um if the board is interested I can get some more numbers of that I could ask my previous school I'm just curious like
011you yeah I think it's a great question um Amanda and I did go down when we were dreaming and we and uh it looks like the electricity is running um in a very smart way so that they could when the wood shop was there that they could move um the Machinery into different parts of the room so you know I don't I don't know um what else might need to be maneuvered but I it looks like there's a really smart setup there that would allow us to move this in quite easily are the wheels also electric yes they they're electric no kick wheels and it has the ventilation and the exhaust which is a big part that's already there so yeah and a spacing capacity like for where this equipment is going to be located
012there's no issues or concerns no I mean I'm basing this off of what I saw the setup was in my previous school and I I think it's definitely reasonable you can kind of bring the pottery wheels in and out you know as you use them you can store them and then bring them out spread them out in the space when you're using them put them kind of back in the closet or corner or whatever you're going to do the extruder like hangs off a wall you know so it's just like right there slab roller is a good size machine but we can fit it in that Workshop space yes is there is there still woodworking equipment in that room there is equipment and there's equipment that the robotics uh program is using obviously um so
013we just got to be good you know people sharing and stuff like that like would the plan be to to move that out or get rid of it or no not get rid of it per se like we would still want the robox program to use that space in the evening but just make better use of it during the day like more efficient use of it it's a beautiful space like and it's it's set up to do some really cool things and this could be one of those spaces where we're doing this type of programming out of yes and Amanda um she works with a lot of that equipment and for installation if we were to use that space students could actually have high ceilings to create installation spaces and they have uh beautiful table
014saw beautiful um um everything I mean there's just so much equipment there that we could put to use certainly see a good educational benefit to this and I certainly will be voting if we're voting voting for it um I do see an opportunity as well for some type of after school program that there could be even a cost associated with that that may make up some of the maintenance fee for any students that on their own time want to work on additional product you know projects or whatever outside of that or even Community could use it I love but I think it's great out of Bo thinking I think it's a a nice way to expand program potentially and I really appreciate you bringing it to the board I'll make a motion to approve the
015uh pug mill purchase of $2,500 as well as the acceptance of the donated equipment from the curry Museum a second is that the right motion yes all right motion by myself second by Mr for additional discussion all those in favor please say I I I opposed abstained 5 Z all right thank you you thank you have a wonderful night all right next up uh we have Danny and Nick from CHS joining us this evening for our student representative report what's going on at Campbell and the district Lots so the winter sports are going good wrestling has a try meet today at Campbell boys basketball is 7-1 after a recent win against summersworth girls basketball is 2 and5 after a win earlier this week against summersworth boys hockey has a game today against Kingswood at 7
016and their 01 and three and track meet has a meet today and tomorrow at UNH um some of the past activities that happened right before break was how student council went on our annual Christmas caroling to the 55 plus Community um we also um during our big assembly we had the Winter concert as as well as the staff breakfast that morning um and this is all during our annual tree liing assembly uh some current events going on at the school is we have the math meet at Hollis Brookline uh January 15th there's a double header for girls varsity and boys varsity basketball at 5 and 6:30 uh winter track senior night is on the 17th and acceptance cougar paws are getting put around the school or not around the school on the counseling Den for
017like plans after college so if you're going to like or if you get an acceptance to a college or if you're going like cosmetology school or trades you put it on there and it kind of just is like a big collage for everyone to see like what everyone's plans in the future are so it's pretty cool um some future activities we have is like January is kind of like our cool down month and then February is when we start back up again we do a lot of stuff for Valentine's Day we do strawberry um chocolate dipping and we'll get give them to students during our advisory and then we also sell carnations and then we'll do a drink cart for the teachers and then at the end of the February before February break we have
018winter carnival all [Music] week and then just recently like academics and stuff we had um a cougar is it a h huddle to talk about like us achievements that students have been making like um my brother he got player of the year for or Gator player of the year so they shouted him out they shouted out boys soccer boys football for all that stuff and one of the main points he was talking about was using our KAG or cougar academic growth to like just to utilize it more as a resource to improve your grades cuz semester 2 is coming up so he just really reinforced that to try and kids to use that so that when semester 2 comes there's no surprises with grades like oh I'm not eligible for this not eligible for that
019so he just talked a lot about that we have no school Martin Luther King Day the last day of quarter 2 in semester 1 is on the 24th and many teachers are signing big projects for the end of for the end of semester and that's kind of what that kind of ties back into the CAG thing like because it's the end of the year and teachers are giving so much work he just wanted to talk about that and have kids know that like by the end if you're not caught up then there's no surprises cuz it's the end of the year or it's the end of the semester so that's really it any questions anything else to highlight with the district um yeah I mean it's it's been a nice kind of getting back from
020from the winter break uh we've been a couple weeks back I feel like it was very quiet next last week and we've hit B gear this week uh in terms of the kids returning and everything like that I don't want to step on Sarah toes we had two nice PD days uh right before break and and uh some positive things out of that um you know I can't remember when we last met if we had mentioned um the winter plays at both the middle school and the high school but those were wonderful to see um those Productions uh as they went and everything and um yeah I think the schools are in good shape because they happy and and doing their thing so love it all right thank you for the report tonight appreciate it
021no problem all right shifting gears into Community comment this is the first of two Community comments in tonight's agenda I will open it up to the public for for comment all right nothing this evening and uh again we'll close the community comment and we'll have another one a little bit later tonight uh moving into correspondence all right I believe we left off on our last meeting was the 17th is that correct 18th 18th thank you um so we had an email from Mr Shoemaker on the 18th circulating a summary of the fic Sur survey we had email on the 18th circul in draft public and non-public minutes from December 18th we had an email from the superintendent on December 19th circulating updated draft warrant article language for us to review on December 20th Ron o
022blenis emailed to the school board and Facilities Improvement committee outlining specific data he believed that the fic needed to be able to make recommendations to the school board um regarding GMS and there was a response from Denise mchu um suggesting that um parties should discuss educational and social impacts before deep diving into room utilization on December 20th um Julie darling emailed the board uh regarding the CHS lacrosse Rings uh provided a copy of the Eastern Propane contract and sending a copy of the lssa um negotiated agreement to the budget committee and there were responses from Mr cutter Mr plansky and then miss darling uh responded as well on December 30th Dan DT emailed the uh facility Improvement committee so I'm just going to call it fic going forward um regarding meeting dates for the next
0236 months uh the school board was copied on that on December 31st and anamara emailed the board circulating the payroll 403b manifest on January 3rd and anamara emailed the board circulating the accounts payable manifest on January 3rd and anamara emailed circulating the list of manifests um that we would be reviewing for the January 8th meeting meeting on January 3rd Renee Burgess emailed to the board circulating a draft of the January 8th 2025 agenda on January 3rd Mr oennis emailed the school board and the budget committee providing in advance his comments that he planned to speak to at the January 9th budget committee meeting regarding School Board warrant articles and there was a response from Mr Sun and then a response from Mr oennis on January 5th Mr oennis emailed to the school board and fic
024committee reiterating his request for information regarding moving the seventh and eighth graders to Campbell high school there were responses from Mr cutter Mr oennis the superintendent and Dan DT on those correspondance on January 6th Heidi Ames that's me emailed the board circulating draft survey language uh for the superintendent review and there was response from Christina Harrison and then Mr cutter had just responded today too so I'm going to add that in there um on January 6th Mr cutter emailed the board circulating open house invitation at the police for the Police Department open house um regarding um their request for a new police station on January 6th Mr cutter emailed the board advising that the board that there may be a scheduling conflict um there was at least a scheduling conflict for two members and might
025be a scheduling conflict for the 3 and was looking to confirm attendance on January 7th Connie Jackson a Community member emailed the board requesting a copy of the proposed 2526 budget as well as the most recent audited annual financial report and that was provided ided by Mr cutter on January 7th um the superintendent emailed the board advising uh regarding a Power School uh confidential a breach of data from um Power School updating us on that situation on January 7th Mr cutter emailed to the board advising that there was a need to reschedule the January 8th uh meeting because of anticipated absences um and we had the option of having the meetings on January 15th and January 2 2 and there were responses from the superintendent myself Miss Harrison Miss Burgess and Mr plansky on January
02610th Ronald blenis emailed the fic committee or fic and School Board attaching draft uh meeting minutes for their December 17th ficc meeting and there was a response from Dan dwit on January 15th an andara emailed the board in closing the 403b Manifest and on January 15th ronal lenis emailed the school board attaching uh draft meeting minutes for for the January 7th 2025 fic meeting and that's a month of Correspondence almost a month very much as always yeah no problem all right um okay now we're moving into General business and we'll turn it over to the superintendent for warant article discussion yeah so um you got a bunch of links in front of you right there and I have one handout I'll give you in a few minutes as well once we get into this that
027I didn't finalize till today so I apologize for not thaning to it but Jan if you're watching I'll get it up to you as well um so this is just uh for points of our discussion kind of how we get to our tax rate and we'll go through it quickly um and then this is a document that kind of pinkish column here that as we have discussions um we can update so you can see how it affects various um aspects of the tax rate as we we kind of go on um so if you look at that top box it's just the general fund um again like that pin column is the one we'll manipulate we have conversation proposed budget and then kind of the default budget if you keep scrolling to your right for
028just our purposes here I I um made this bigger so we could see but you'll see previous years um as well if you go down to the next little section uh that's where we started talking about Revenue uh we have been talking here a little bit in budget committees at different things about Revenue our localized Revenue this comes to little tuition uh that we get from from different situations earnings on interest Food Service sales um this is all kind of in line with what we expected and as normal from previous years and everything like that if you look at the history goes up a little bit down a little bit but no wild swings because this is pretty Dependable on what we can predict this next thing is state revenue which I want to spend
029uh a moment with uh because people have questions about State education Aid there's been a lot of news about how um not as much State education is being funded by the state with their formula the formulator is is a formula is a percentage of a percentage that they reimburse uh districts with uh so I'm going to show you a couple of um highlight this row right here just numbers we're budgeting for um $80,000 um for state aid regulated to special ed next year that is a very conservative budget because we're concerned um that that the that the state may be in a similar situation where they are this year uh whether they not be able to fund uh fully fund special education so we rather be on the conservative side than on the aggressive side
030in terms of of um State funding or state reimbursement on that with these Special Ed things this is what many School District dists are doing this year if you can see in the FY 24 year um the district got about $127,000 back for their state aid um don't quote me on the exact percent but it's close to 98% of what you were supposed to get from the state you got that year in terms of special ed spending um this year right now we did not get that 98% it was um approximately 67% uh but that's a rough reate of using those percentage formulas to to do it where we got about 98,000 which is about 30,00 ,000 less than than what the previous year's formula would have indicated that we would have gotten I'm sorry
031what how much did we get reimbursed for it's about 67% so it's right what was the dollar amount uh approximately 30,000 left it's right here uh on the okay thing you can see it right there um and this is shared with with you guys you can come check it out too um and then so we took an even more conservative approach this year in terms of special ed spending there' be a lot of discussion about this at the state level um you know confident that they'll hopefully address it you know in a way that that's beneficial to all um that's helpful but in terms of budgeting our philosophy is to be you know more on the conservative side than than not when talking about these things um so that that's the state aid I know
032people have questions about that uh vocational a Child Nutrition that that is in line with what we do uh these kind of federal grants there's not a lot that changes in regards to these grants and how much funding we get with them they're pretty consistent um so so there they are um the next kind of set of lines here that I kind of want to talk about is again related to kind of Revenue and credits and this is where when we get to the tax rate and the tax rate's higher and we'll get to it in the bottom here is I won't say is the problem but it's the problem like when we talk about like um a significant increase in terms of the tax rate um a raw budget is probably in line with
033what you've done in other years you know um in terms of just like raw increases that you do you're honoring your contractual agreements that that were passing last year in the budget process your Lea and your lssa collected bargaining agreements um but the big difference here is the amount of money um that can be used to offset taxes and what we're projecting out for that so you know best practice um you know you try to spend you know 99% of what you've asked for in a budget like if you're doing your budgeting correctly you're going to spend the money you ask for like that's how the system should work obviously we can't um we shouldn't um go over that budgeted amount you know so we always try to to stay under it um so this
034$200,000 is is uh is an estimate of what we could return in taxes um this is close to you know we spend 99% of our budget this is what it would kind of come back to is about $200,000 this is the amount we want to long-term get to best practice if we've presented a responsible budget um through the budgeting process and that's approved by the voters then we should be spending what we say we're spending the money on and there should be minimal amount that we're returning the taxpayers at the end of the day we know that's not always how things work things change that's life that's reality um last year for this District was a good kind of indicator of that um you had the land that you return back to the tax payers
035payers that you're obligated to do that was a half million dollar right there approximately $497,000 we do not have in Revenue like there is nothing we can do about that so taxes went down last year because we were returning that a large amount of money and it's almost hits us twice like we can't return that amount we got nothing to make up for it that's just a one time kind of return in revenue on the district the fund balance uh used for war articles is kind of a wash on that um our final budget that we would put in the system um you know at the end of all this into the next fiscal year accounts for those increases that are approved through through the warrant article process if we have $300,000 worth of warant
036Articles um approved that money not only does that money come over in the budget the money to pay for it comes over from the previous year's budget so kind of think of that as a wash regardless of how much you approve or don't approve on that the other big number there is how much you you sent back last uh June to reduce um in taxes I was present at that meeting when you guys had a discussion great discussion I think you made some responsible decisions and and a number of things there um but it probably was a number that that was higher than maybe what you initially desired you know when the when the budget was being prepared in the fall and stuff like that you can kind of see the history here of that
037particular number and this is the one I'm talking about to reduce taxes um back in FY 23 it was about that 285,000 which is probably ultimately kind of where you want to be is at $200 range um FY 24 you're close to 442 um and then this year uh this past year was 640 that return it with taxpayers that's great you can return that to um your taxpayers and you should do that when you can but at the same time it can cause these kind of swings in your tax rate from year to year if you're not consistent in that amount that that you kind of get back so what stinks for us as the new bees on the Block is that our uh revenues and credits are significantly down from where you were year
038ago which will show you what that does to our tax rate here momentarily um Revenue conct to the Food Service Revenue to this is some math some accounting stuff here to subtract out to get to our tax rate we do some subtraction stuff here um and then uh some other stuff related to taxes here so this would be the total amount of money we would need to raise when you're factoring in uh number of components including the grants and and everything like that um that would be kind of associated we subtract uh various things such as food service res their fund stuff and everything like that um and then this is the next big thing with our local kind of State education grant again if you look at this line and you look at history
039right here you will see that the amount of money uh the town of Richfield is is receiving from the state for state a here is decreasing um year to year or over over time you're not necessarily year to year um so the town has had this Grant from the state called a hold harmless Grant um based on an aacy formula um that if based on your valuation of the of what your town was if it was like within a uh in your free and reduced lunch population all this stuff if you're within if weren't within 104% they made up the difference of whatever um it is but that Grant is being phased out and essentially every two years the town from educational standpoint we're going to lose about $380,000 worth of revenue from the state
040because of this grant being phased out now that could change um this is a revaluation you year for the town so that will change some of the formula um in regards to how that is calculated that could hurt that could help uh we'll see how that valuation um kind of plays out it is connected to free and reduced uh numbers that is a connected data that we have I mean we did the food presentation months ago and I know we kind of said it a little in just but not really like hey if you need free and do reduce lunch we need you to apply for the program you know so we get that reimbursement and this is another example of why it's important that people follow up on that you know um because those
041are the numbers that these formulas are based on if we have people who are in tough situations and would benefit that program I know it can be challenging to admit that I know it it can be it's hard it is confidential the only person who knows is the food service director who knows the specifics we get the raw percentage number when we have to put it in for data purposes and stuff like that but we don't know the only person who knows in the district is the food service director on who those families are so I'm not saying that to be difficult or whatever but if you are in that situation we have mechanisms to help and it helps everybody so if we if we can continue to to chase down people who need that
042support that benefits all of us so you're going to lose some of um that funding to that that hold harness our swept um our swept went down as well for the town here um when you're factoring those two things together it's another loss of about $500,000 in Revenue that you had compared to last year the swep is going to fluctuate year to year you can see this from your own town here uh back in fy20 3 you're at 1.4 you went up to 1.9 is for a couple years there came back down to 1.8 that number is is normally a little bit up down up down up down depending on various things there so um and what's going on in your town and stuff like that so that's what you're losing another big chunk of
043of Revenue there which we can't offset in in some of the stuff that we're we're raising here and everything like that um so that brings us to what we need to raise for taxes and how that affects tax rate and everything else um we presented to the budget committee last week a very big number it was 2.45 uh we'd be able to at least bring that down here for you tonight to 2.1 um the reason is that we worked with Kim at the town this is a valuation year we did not factor in a a new evaluation figure when we did ours we were more conservative on that uh speaking with Kim and what they're doing for the town where they are budgeting this specific number the 1 b239 so on and so forth there
044she said you can use that number as well I'm confident that that's an appropriate number for budgeting purposes um so we adjusted our valuation number there which did help um with the tax rate here so it is a high tax rate and we'll talk about uh what we can talk about here right now um so we have a local tax rate of 16.25 here uh from a dollar standpoint 2.10 uh increase and here this 14.82% from last year now we're here in part of discussion is to talk about how we want to budget for this right we talked about the budget committee last week would have made sense to talk to about you guys at first but life took over sometimes is there's certain things here this is budgeting we're guessing we're doing best estimate
045what I'm about to show you I'm not advocating for but I'm showing you something that how this affects and how these things all work if you were increase the amount of money you return to offset your fund balance which has been higher in previous years it changes your tax rate so for argument sake right here instead of returning $200,000 to the taxpayers right now we're going to return a million dollars to the tax rate to the taxpayers and as you can see because we've increased the revenue it's increased the tax rate that we would be looking to do for um for raising and stuff like that because we were banking on generating more revenue for the town now you may say to yourself right this second that sounds great Brian do that right that just
046lowered that number a whole lot I cannot stress this enough this is not good practice right if we're banking on having a million dollar at the end of the year balance we're doing a poor job budgeting year to year this is not a practice you want to get into is to ensuring that you have these large dollar amounts it it puts you in tough situations you can't guarantee you're going to have that money if these unexpected costs arise you got to take care of them right you should use the mechanisms that are designed to take care of those things such as Reserve funds and capital funds and those type of things but the reality is this is one way to offset a tax rate and make it lower for for people is to generate more
047to give back at kind of the end of the year and stuff like that so I'm not here to advocate for a million dollars back at the end of the year but budget I want to go through the exercise so you understood that that is something that has a variation on that if we were to come to a more um and budget say for 400,000 which is more than I think we would want to typically do but if we're using really rough numbers is about the average of these three years over here very rough numbers you can just quickly do math it's about 400,000 there is kind of the average and say that we were going to try and have that in an end of year balance to return to the taxpayer you can see
048a down to about 1 Point uh $1.94 there so that's ways that that can kind of change so that's something that as a board we prepare the budget it's ultimately yours as a school board right what you want to do and how to do this this is why we're having this uh discussion right now I'm going to change this to $200,000 back because that's what we have now likewise I I would like to uh I don't know if defend is the right word but would like to justify some of our uh budgeting decisions as we kind of gone through and how these things affect um if you come down here to a percentage of increase from last year it looks very big 14.82% which we understand what that is but that is factoring in all
049that Revenue that we currently do not have right so if we come up here to 2025 for just one second and I removed the land right if we just assume the land was a one-off thing and pretend the land never exist the land existed but pretend it never existed for a second and I it's to delete that amount that would have changed what the tax rate rate was last year for the for what was related to education and you can see it lowered our percent increase right there of what we were talking about in terms of a budgetary standpoint to do a similar exercise so let's take the land out for a second and yes I'm trying to paint us in a better light I don't I want to be transparent about that but let's
050say we got the same exact Revenue that we had um last year in terms from the state in terms of the Grant and in terms of swep all of a sudden our tax rate has gone down even more to that $1.3 and 8.9% and when you look at the Historical increases is a lot more in line with what the town is doing so we are we are unfortunately hurt this year by the revenue that that we're not getting from the state and that one off with the land just those two adjustments right there made a radical difference in what the tax rate is right this factored in all the good things we did from a budgetary standpoint and everything like that now if we have magic W and we could change that great but that's
051not the situation we at but I want people to understand like where this is coming from this is a largely dependent on Revenue that we unfortunately don't have and we cannot change that so I'm going to pause there for a second yeah so at the budget committee meeting last week the budget committee graciously um did not vote on many of the Schoolboard articles because I had mentioned the superintendent mentioned that we didn't have a quum we we'd like the opportunity to meet as a board and all that and they understood that and agreed they're going to be doing their voting on most of the school board articles tomorrow night after the hearing to allow us to vote this evening right so just get that out of the way one of the things that I had
052mentioned again because the budget committee saw this before we as a board had the opportunity to talk about it um was the tax rate on the draft warant articles we didn't see that beforehand and it caught me off guard because again we hadn't had the conversation about revenues yet and what the budget committee saw was a $244 45 45 Cent number and I was surprised by that for the Warr article for the warrant article and the and the reason why I was surprised by that is because typically in a normal year with a million million2 increase which is typically what we see right that equates to a140 a145 type of increase so for me when we're talking about a slight you know yes it's a higher increase this year I'm still expecting a150 somewhere in
053that range so when I see a dollar 45 or $245 increase I'm like whoa something's up right without the picture of the revenue which we've talked about now since then now I understand I'm like well we have to talk about this as a board and something we have we have to have a conversation about what can we do what other levers can we pull potentially to lessen the burden to the taxpayers right and I think that's the conversation I want to open up with the board tonight specifically for this first article now I have a letter here right here that you have not seen that I'm going to pass out to you right now and just before you do that right because you're on the you're on the conversation of um I'm going to play
054devil's advocate for a minute right because you're on the conversation of fund balance to reduce taxes and we have we've always had this $200,000 plug that's in my mind why do we budget why do we budget to reduce taxes to the town why is that why is that a budget item for the school everywhere I've been has done it I don't have a great answer for you um because we're we're kind of learning this too uh as we go along not in a bad way but just like we follow whatever practices we've been using to and every District I've been to has budgeted for that Revenue because I think it comes from the mindset is we cannot ask for more money right like we have a responsibility to not exceed that budget that we've asked
055for in terms of our budget so if we're doing good practice just think at your home right like if you're doing your you're managing your own budget at home right you want to make sure you set that number that you're working with a little bit above what you're actually going to to to to spend in case of whatever happens right you know your electrical bill spikes a year right you know um your hot water heater floods the basement and you have to now fix it whatever the case may be right so you have a little bit there now we have a responsibility not to do too much of that over budgeting right and find that right balance of spending the money we have asked for and being purposeful but the nice thing is when we
056go through all this there's little quirks that come up you know during the year that allows us an opportunity to save a couple dollars here a couple dollars there and I give you a really like minor minor example but these minor minor ones look up I don't know why this one that popped into my head but it did um you know our staff have contracts and within their contracts they have three personal days right there are instances in people's lives where they may need to take an additional day beyond that three personal days so a staff member will take that day as unpaid so that's money that we budgeted for right because we have to budget fully everyone's contracts and everything like that that staff member is taking that day unpaid well we're not going
057to turn around and spend that on anything else it just goes into extra money right so there's those little things over the course of a year that you kind of save on not every staff is going to take that unpaid day it's it's rare right um I think I haven't approved one today that's why it's on on top tip of my tongue but um those are the situations that as you go through a year you might save a little bit there save a little bit there um we work with vendors the same as anyone else you know they're going to give you one price when they quote you and depending on when that when you actually follow through in a purchase things can be slightly higher slightly lower and you can have to adjust from
058there we're coming off of the co like wave so some of the huge pricing that we had the kind of budget for when it came to some materials and some deliverables and stuff like that have either plateaued so we while we anticipated the bump it never arrived or not went up quite as much as we thought it was going to be so on and so forth right um and those are where those kind of small savings so most to answer your question most districts do budget with the understanding that if they've done it right there should at least be a little bit of returning back to the taxpayers and finding what that number is some people present present it as a percentage of their budget right it's 1% of whatever their budget is that's what
059the numberers they put in which represents that they spent 99% of their budget some people might be 2% it all depends on what you know your business people feel that are used to in that practice thank you y okay so I have a lever um that I'm going to pass this way that you know we've been kind of working on you'll see later in the agenda um out District tuition projections so one of the good and bad things right now in the district is you have all new people kind of in SAU positions right now so we're kind of learning up the speed on a lot of the ins and outs of the district and when we do the budget you approach it in a way of just like hey we can't rip everything up
060right away we have to be here for some time and learn how things are going on the same vein we're now here six seven months we've been looking at how things are doing and when we started this budget process in late September early October we kept the thing a lot of things pretty consistent than what they were already in the budget besides some very obvious things we we could address one of those being the reduction and pairs that that are in the budget um from vacant positions and so what you're seeing in front of you is a is a budget reduction uh proposal of about $248,000 because we've been going through all of our bills and because we've been seeing things come in and we feel that now that we have a stronger handle of
061everything we have the experience of being here a few months we might be able to make some adjustments to to to what we we proposed from a budgetary standpoint I want to pref this with two things this is a unique opportunity because you have so many new people right I don't want people to think this is going to be a habit when we get to it next year and we all have a year under our belt in these positions we're going to have a handle of how the district is operating right we're not going to be able to come in at the final hour here with a cut to help out in the situation what we propose in the budget next year will be what we believe is the right thing to do in the
062budget and I'm not saying that wasn't true in October we just are more knowledgeable now and if we have an opportunity to take advantage of the knowledge that we've gained in the past few months we should Tak an opportunity to to take advantage of the knowledge that we've gained in the last few months so that's why when you see stuff with the reduction um of Transportation I'm going to use that one the the third bullet down here um and special education you know we had a budget process it's pretty straightforward we thought we were taking uh student both ways to and from from their their destination the reality has played out that we don't and that's how it's going to be moving forward so that's something that we weren't able to make that final decision
063back in October or much more confident being able to say that now in January so that's a reduction we could have here in terms of this that's because we were learning those kids we were learning those situations and everything that they're going the first one's going to freak people out and it needs a little explanation there's a reduction of One Professional staff position here at this and you'll see that the specific position is not to be determined until we do scheduling this spring so we do have vacant staff vacant professional staff positions right now in the budget this reduction would not require anyone losing their job I cannot stress that's enough this is late we got to this really late I haven't even talked to the to the Lea yet they're going to kill me
064tomorrow they I'm even bringing it up right now but no one is going to lose their job because of this this is not what's going to happen we have open positions and if we have to shift around to do this then we will reality is as we go through the spring if anyone who's worked in schools I have worked in education for 20 years I have never seen everyone come back to to the district because life happens right you get new opportunities someone might get a new job someone might move someone may not have to work someone may have to retire whatever the case may be there is always movement in school districts even the best school districts right so we're banking on a little bit of that movement as the spring kind of unfolds
065and as we reshuffle the deck in positions is there an opportunity for us to reduce by one professional staff member in terms of this we think there might be we think there might be now on the flip side if the event we have a wonderful place everyone loves us we bring everyone back exactly in the position they are no one's life changes in any aspect right now we have a gift we have a class reduction class size trust fund that covers the cost of a teacher that if we had the situation where we didn't make any changes to anything that we're doing from a teaching standpoint right now we can access that trust fund it would empty that trust fund and we'd have to do a public hearing to do that and everything associated with
066it but we have the the mechanism to pull to cover that in the event every single person came back in exactly the position they are right now so let me just I just want sure that I'm understanding that piece of it the the the additional employee trust fund are are you saying that in that situation we would transfer the funds to the operating budget to then return that money to taxpayers no what I would say is we would cover it to cover all of our staff right so we have vacant positions right now so we would we would basically make the reduction in the budget yes and then use that money to pay for the money use that to that's only if everyone comes back though every single person came so he's HED he's hedging
067that hedging but if somebody does doesn't come back that's still a reduction in force that's what the proposal is it could be right so let's say a scenario where there is you know just changes D Dynamics right and I'll do something extreme just for argument sake this is not what I would would recommend at all right let's say kindergarten signed up and we have 50 kids signed up for kindergarten next year right now we have five five teachers for kindergarten right that that that's going to be that's going to be tough right like it's going to be hard to justify that right that's not going to be the reality we're not going to have 50 kids sign up for kindergarten or I would be shocked if that is but if that was the scenario right
068chances are we're going to have other movement other places in the district right and as we move pieces around to put this person and that person there we could have less teachers needed in kindergarten because we moved one of those people to teach here that person teach that I'm not saying this is ideal yeah this is just like a lever we can pull if we're we're at this stuff like that okay now if again everything played out exactly let's say we had a spike and kids come right like and we needed every single person every single position we have in the budget continue to need it that's where that trust fund comes into play and everyone returns and then we could access that next year now that's not a long-term solution that is a Band-Aid
069to this right now because we would be emptying that trust fund in that emergency situation we did right and there's nothing else you can do about it but I want to stress I know people are home I know people are going to freak out no one's losing their job a person is not losing their job here like no one is going to lose their job because of this if they were elected to go with it but it could impact programming could impact programming yes yes what does call it round numbers $250,000 how one for tax so I'm going to pull this back up give me a moment so this would lower I'm just going to work on the the proposed budget right now so from 200 20 200 27.3 is million brings it down to
070about 26.1 as we go down to the tax rate if you take this as it is right there you will lower it down to about 1.9 we were at that 2.1 there before it comes down to about 1.9 as this is laid out right here now you don't have to accept this at all you don't have to accept every part of it these are just different options that we have right here that could have an effect anything beyond this I think we are I I wouldn't do yeah right I do I see potential benefits in making the other reductions I'm hesitant to because it's still a projection yep it's still you know we don't know solid we have a better understanding now than before but um but reducing professional staff I I think you know
071we put forward a budget of what we need for staff and you know I think we have to stand by that and I don't like the idea of seeing if somebody decides to leave and then adjusting programming accordingly so that you know to reduce it by 20 cents yeah I just want to present what this look like right no I understand I'm just saying my that's my my my position on it so with that reduction would you I mean obviously you're you're thinking that next year you'd be able to cover that but what about in future years that's what I mean this is a Band-Aid to this year like we're doing like is there anything to do right now to help with this right and this is the thing you can do right now to
072help with this but next year we're going to be back at this table we're going to look at all of our staffing we're going to look at whatever it is we're expecting a a little the start of a CO bump which is going to last a year or two but that bump's going to carry over throughout all you know all 12 of their grades that they come through the high school and stuff like that and we'll have whatever Staffing projection we are I want to hedge myself a little bit because we're going to have the full year under our belts as as Administration here to make some different decisions right and the reality is is that you know you you got to see what you have right like we're going to do course signups we're
073going to have kids Mo sign up for kindergarten everything's going to be moved like that then we're going to see where all those kind of chips fall and we we'll have to make adjustments regardless right that's just the reality of it and let's see where those adjustments are and see there's stuff that that kind of makes sense I know from the high school perspective that's my background not only do obviously teachers don't teach exactly the same case load year to year but there are teachers who may teach other their subject area year to year right based upon the needs of what course signups and stuff like that so it's not unheard of to do these kind of adjustments from a staffing standpoint there's also the real reality that hiring is still going to be a
074challenge right in education right there are certain positions that are going to be really challenging to hire for and if someone was to leave in that position we have to deal with the the programming as it is we were very fortunate in this District in World Language that we found people like the last week before school started right like that we just found people right like there are schools that did not find people to fill those type of vacancies we have a case manager position open right now that has been posted for an eternity that we don't have an applicant for and we're not alone right like there's going to be openings where like we flat out have to change the programming cuz we don't have a person right now I wouldn't I would leave
075a case manager open for eternity because you need that person because of the iips but if there's a different teacher area like where if we had an opening and it wasn't like that required by law type of position you know running an IP type of position we have to have a serious conversation if we're in a position where we can't hire for it right and I and I there's nothing I have in mind that's what I don't want to represent here right you know and I know people are going to walk away he's got something in his head that he wants to cut and that's not the case I generally want to see where things play out in the spring I think we have to recognize that things are going to be different because it
076always is and if the unlikelihood it isn't we have this trust fund to help us in in that situation I'm interested in other board member's thoughts as well it's a lot of information to get in 20 minutes it is sorry still proc no it's not your fault I'm just it's the cards it is it is all right so the other three let's just leave the professional staff aside the other three those are based on very you you're very confident that those are going to be savings that we as of today yes and I say that because with any things can change on a done right you know but to to go through it so so the reduction on some of the cost so with CTE Transportation these are things can schools can do we can
077ask Alvin to ensure that our kids are in the same block you know of time will they do that if they want our kids they will right you know like it is a business for them they generate Revenue off of us sending kids there I know that in in other places I've been in the in the CTE centers we've worked at there's been those arrangements we can send our kids during this block right like so can you make sure our kids are there right and they do the best to accommodate that now exceptions let me ask you a question about that though because I mean we have they have a lot of programs right and we have kids in a lot of programs is that truly something that they can accommodate based there exceptions so
078right like if there's a program and this happens that isn't say our block is the first block of the day that's where we send the bulk of our kids right now for for for Al is the first block of the day right um and there's a program that's the second block of the day right like we can make a request and that kid can self transport there's different things we can do um to ensure that we can get that that kid there right there's different steps that we can do um and usually my experience with CTE centers is they're willing to work with us um work with schools to ensure people have those opportunities and stuff like that um right now pingen is helping us with this right they have all of our kids driving
079right now so this is not um a crazy request for them like all of our kids are self transporting to Pinkerton currently so that's just a practice we would need to continue to do that was by their request if I remember correctly it was happening right when I was coming on um but I could be wrong don't quote me 100% on that but I feel like that came from them so um we just have to work with the sending schools and there are exceptions to all of this but um that's something that we can look into and I think we can pull off so now in terms of the I went over that special web we just as a situation as we've see a situation in full we don't need two-way Transportation it's oneway Transportation
080um is where that's kind of settling and that will not change with this it's that's for one student yeah I can give you a little more context on public but just so not to kind of get real too much there yes that's going to St um and then reduction of of Nur nursing Services uh for current students we had a reduction in the costs associated with that um we have a couple different students who who uh uh have nursing Services outside of what is a school nurse kind of provided they again changes in uh IPS changing in Services changing just in the contract we're getting from our provider that um we get the services from has allowed us to have a reduction in that it seems like a lot but the line itself is huge
081so it's it's uh but it makes a difference when you look at these dollar amounts and stuff like that you know I think my concern and I think I'm In The Weeds on it so I'm not going to the CTE my understanding is a lot of the times it's the part one the younger students that go in the morning and then the people who are doing the second part the part two they've already done a year and they're doing the second part of CTE in the afternoon and I don't know how necessarily they'll be accommodated but I do think a lot of the ones who are doing the part two are upper classmen who probably have their own trans station so if that is something that can be figured out for parking purposes at the
082program then I think you'll be able to handle that um you know I do have concerns about cutting a professional staff position I mean is this is this considered a reduction in force has there been formal notice is the no like I haven't done any of that yet this is today I'm giving this to you and like I said I'm going to get killed tomorrow when I walk into the office they're going to have going to have my back but that would if we did make this reduction that would have to to happen yeah right so you basically notice everybody I don't think we have to do that I can get clarity on that because we have vacant positions that are in professional staff right now so we're not we're not doing that like you
083know in in other places I've been when we've reduced by professional staff I'll just take the school I was just at we reduced professional staff because we had a retirement and we didn't need that anymore then that just naturally happen right like there was not this blanket we got to reduce everyone down for that and we've been doing that for years reducing positions as but I think they were I think they were RIS I mean I think this is the situation where you know I hate saying desperate times call for desperate measures but we're at the point where it's literally January 15th we have to vote and get warant articles out there we have to have an operating budget um so I you know again I truly appreciate that you put this list together um
084because and I hope that the public sees it the way that I do which is that you know you're taking the experience that you have and gained from when the original budget came forward to now um and using that knowledge to make additional reductions it's going to be a hard sell mhm but I think I I'm not sure we have much of a choice I don't think think we can ask taxpayers to pay $210 I don't I don't think so either I think we have to do what we can to to reduce the the tax burden to the taxpayers I think the superintendent is proposing um opportunity to do that um as uncomfortable as it is I agree right um but I do think it shows Goodwill that we're looking at all options very late
085in the game to try and reduce this budget for the best interest of the taxpayers that's that's my at least it's something creative as opposed to just cut X number of dollars off the off the revenue yeah my concern remains and I know we're being conservative with Revenue forecasting for next year but if this is how much our Revenue has been cut from last year to this year or what we're expecting it to be cut guess what it could even more we may not even have that $200,000 to return to the taxpayers well that's what I'm saying like do we need to have conversations about like is that an appropriate budget number well I think you you aim for that and if you dip into it you dip into it I mean if we need
086to to to use that $200,000 that we've kind of said we change it to 100,000 well I think we could still say you know we we reserve 200,000 but if if time if we need to to tap into it we spend it we're approved to spend every penny of our budget no we are and that's what I'm saying from a budget perspective with an impact to the tax if we have 200,000 great right but from a budget perspective that impacts the tax rate do we put 100,000 as a plan you know what I mean is that enough of a wouldn't that just offset the Tak it down it it takes it down a little bit right I mean you know but you know what I'm saying takes it up a little we're going to bring
087it down wrong direction yeah so I mean I I would leave it at 200 I think you could you can make an argument that you could go as I'm not advocating for against this that you could go as high as 400,000 based on your history of what you would go there right but that's based on on historical last few years and what you've returned but I think the practice you want to get into is budgeting for 200,000 um because this is only going to get tighter right this whole harmless Grant you know it's it's every two years it dips so we're going to have another hard conversation two years from now when that's another div and revenue probably about $380,000 and what you want to do with that right off the jump right before we
088talk about anything else um and people just have to understand that you know it's not necessarily it's it's I guess I say not necessarily bad it's just the reality of it you know now who knows you know State funding could change you know there's lawsuits out there like about Educational Funding that you know if if the um cost of an as an example A lot of people probably aware of the the uh cost of adequate education lawsuit that goes from about $4,000 to about $7,000 in terms of that now granted we raise money through property taxes that's how we do it so it's coming from one bucket or the other it's coming out of our property taxes but that's going to change the revenue formulas potentially of what we're getting from the state well we
089would have to raise less locally in terms of those taxes right now the state's going to have to raise more taxes for property to offset that that c h hypothetically you know that's one way for them to do that um so it's a wash in the big scheme of things but you know that for what we're looking at from state aid could change radically in the next year or too depending on how how things shake out in I think the only other thing that we have to really just be cognizant of with anything with special ed is that we may be dipping into that trust fund and it may not get replenished and I don't know if you guys saw in the news but down in Mass marac Valley School District a short newshire yeah
090I didn't see so marac Valley um Regional School District it's up a little north of conquered Oh I thought that was mass unfortunately you know overspent by about $2.1 Million last year you know that they didn't have um so uh they're they're in a challenging situation um those costs were associated with I I believe it was a failing roof at one of the elementary schools um but a huge increase increase to their special ed right they had I think about 1.2 million of uh special ed costs that they did not predict and they exhausted their um you know Reserve funds um to cover those and are still about a million dollars short so they're working through the state on a plan with that there's good people up there like I used to work up there
091I know some of those people up there they work hard they do the right things um I don't think there's anything evil behind any of it but it is an unfortunate situation that unfortunately I think um districts are facing the special ed cost is is really hard to predict right now and a lot can change on a dime if you're a smaller School District you know um that's you know our worst case scenario is happening apparently north of us not south of us but yeah I mean we we'll talk you know we reasons talk about the warrant articles here you know um I don't if we want to shift that over to the actual War articles or settle on article one and and then go through additional let's just take them one by one I
092I can reading the board it sounds like everyone's in agreement with the bottom three I I can agree with the bottom three which would be a reduction of 141,142 you could do is just let it play out right like and and you would get we're talking like way down the road here right if we have positions we can't fill you know next year for the next school year at the end of that school year in theory that money should be there to return to the taxpayers right like in theory that should be there right so you would eventually in theory see the savings if we had professional staff positions that we couldn't fill for some reason right like that should play out but that's thing that you don't that you don't spend that money elsewhere
093in any other needs and depending on what those professional staff positions are you have to go out and contract for them anyways right like we have that vacant special ed case manager right now that's Services we have to provide so we're going out and Contracting we have long-term sub and doing a little extra Contracting for some of the things related to that to take to take care of it right so are those I'm I'm looking I mean I'm looking up the what we have open right now what what full-time professional staff positions we have open and it's I mean it's special services yeah and that's it yeah and that's what we got so I think the other piece we have to keep in mind though and again you know normally I am I'm in your
094camp on this I think we definitely risk having the default budget our budget our operating budget failing if we don't reduce that dollar number and as much as I don't like it well the Delta stays the same the fall comes down as well if you were to make all these Cuts right here by this amount even if we reduce it we still risk having the default no it doesn't I thought it brings it down it brings it down but you're also going to bring down the fall at the same time the Delta between the two stay the same understood but we risk not having the programs and what we're asking for because someone sees $245 and says that's it's 10 cents so now it's 10 cents I have a question about than 10 cents and
095that's too high a number a question about the reduction of professional staff if all we have open is special ed right and that's driven by you know you legally right we we have legal obligations to meet that do we have enough people that are dual certified because you're you're essentially saying that you can shift people around so do we have enough people that are dual certified that that is actually feasible on paper yes okay now reality is slightly different right um because people may not want to do that you know what I mean there's different things that come into play with with all that but on paper yes do we have people who are certified special ed who are not currently case managers yes we do I'm going to try I'm going to make a
096motion to reduce the operating budget is the operating budget or defa proposed operation operating budget and then it would have an effect on the default budget calculation I'll make a motion to reduce the proposed operating budget um under the superintendent's recommendation by 24,27 I'll second by myself second by Mr Sher additional discussion no I don't like it but it is what it is all right call the vote all those in favor please signify by saying I I opposed I abstained carries 410 now before we leave that discussion there this so we would change the amount on article one there to uh this 27,100 and then adding food service and uh and uh the the grant stuff there as we look at projecting out um the tax rate there is there anything else you want to
097do here to our projections I'd like to just ask a question yeah um and it's mainly because I like I don't get it um row 49 the general fund Revenue in credits right I like I get the land and all that like what else is in this to go from a milon 7 to 320k yep great question so if we go back up to right here I'm going to highlight these three can you say the line Brian so I can yeah it's I can't see that my GL 38 39 and 40 we're going to talk about real quick thank you so this um is part of the difference if you go to line 49 which is where um I think I think that question was you asked Andrew if you look at it's 1.7 from
098from FY uh 25 and next year is 324 so we're we're looking at a difference of about 1.4 a big chunk of that is this set of three lines right here the fund balance to reduce taxes fund balance used for Warrant articles and reduction of taxes with the elementary land the elementary land is the most straightforward of the three right you don't have the land to return it's $500,000 the fund balance offic of taxes we talked about a bunch here you return 640 311 next year the projection is 200,000 we if we were to return the same amount of money next year 640 that would raise that that that number in in line 49 up to 343 to whatever the differen is of of those two numbers there right so there's that part of it
099the hardest thing is with the warrant articles with this line 39 that we have to use when saying the tax rate down the road right now right now none of our warrant articles have passed obviously because they haven't been voted on right there's um for for and these would be ones that come out end of the year bounce so we do have a couple warrant articles related to Personnel related to um putting stuff away in a reserve fund that are not dependent on using end of the year balances right then we have a number of Warrant articles that are dependent on end of the year balance so whichever one of those pass those the amount that pass let's say for argument sake it's $400,000 right that $400,000 goes into our FY 26 budget like it's
100added into it and it's carried over because we're going to bring the money in at the end of the year to offset it so that's why when we put it as a zero tax impact there's zero tax impact the runny has already been raised it's been raised in this year right and we're taking the opportunity to transfer that money from fy2 to FY um 26 in that situation and we're transferring exactly the amount that is in those warant articles that pass so it comes into us as Revenue in this new year so is this like the 500,000 no that's raising and appropriating right yeah so that does that answer some of it so we haven't gotten that money yet so that number can change after the election right so if everything passes I think it's
101what's in there potentially be as much as um I we have written down some $500,000 whatever all those warrant articles pass as as kind of standard you would bring all that money in as Revenue into the next year's budget right to that would significantly help that would significantly help but all those waren go have pass but it's kind of a wash because you're also increasing your budget by that amount of money right right because that's what we're operating so I think the the major thing that sticks out for fy2 was the fund balance to reduce taxes which were what I'm understanding from the superintendent if you're using that large of a number you're not try you're not really honing in your budget as well as you probably should be and I think that the this
102new Administration is saying we're trying to work really hard to get the budget more predictable and to not have huge overages so that makes total sense to me and we going from 640,000 to 200,000 and you learn right like this is all like you learned from your previous year so you had a lot of money left over I was not here I was sitting in the meetings at the end of the year when you guys were going over it right and some of that is vacant positions that you didn't fill right like there's a probably a good chance that our our our fund balance is going to be higher than $200,000 based on our current vacant positions that we have right but we want to make sure we budget what we should budget for so
103you had a lot of vacant positions last year including pair professionals obviously so what happened in this year's budget we made a proposal to reduce by 10 pair of professionals right so like some of that money associated with that fund balance return taxes last year is gone because we've made gone ahead and made the reduction that resulted in all that money to begin with the other line that was very significant for you guys last year is is the special ed specifically out of District tuition and we've gone over that a lot and it's on our agenda tonight to kind of go out how we're projecting out we are projecting out right now to be in line with what is budgeted for that line right now right like we we're go a little bit either way
104it's still about halfway through the year there's a lot of time yet but we ran the numbers at for for the end of the actual year you know 2024 we were about 40% done with the school year and we had spent about 40% of that line so we were going along with what we were expecting to kind of pay out in that line that last year my understanding you know Sarah puler who's our director here obviously she's new the position but has worked with these numbers the whole time the understanding is that you is that um some students you anticipated be out of District um were no longer physically part of the district anymore so while they were budgeted for they weren't part of the district anymore the money's already budgeted for there you are
105so that's kind of the difference at that we have the opposite effect this year we've had students move in you know which is why this budget amount is going to actually work out right because if we didn't have students move in we would be over in that line as well you know um as we were projecting up and stuff like that I know it's a lot you know we've already talked about doing this much earlier next year like this discussion around this and I think this is a learning curve of a lot of new people um and uh so we're not doing this in in January having this discussion right here but unfortunately it's discussion we have to have right right now in January so again again if you wanted to to change your your
106fund balance R taxes a little bit you could I'm not saying do or don't it's the will of the board on that or we can leave it as it is and update that article one um with the with with the new numbers that we have so is the tax rate right now sitting at 210 or 190 190 with the reduction we just with the reduction we that I'm seeing Julie updating the warrant article and I'm just like I'm seeing the numbers change and I see it at 210 that's why I'm confused oh oh I just the default yeah I need to fix that so the operating budget is at 1990 right right and the default budget is at we'll have to recalculate the default I can do a rough estimate real quick here if you
107give me one no no no that's all right I'm just I'm I'm trying to make sure cuz I saw them changing like wait a minute I thought we were just at 190 yeah we're trying to do some of this in real time so people can can see it want to pass this down that way yeah it's got two okay anything else on article one because I'm going to call the vote on article one can I just can we see what 300,000 would do if we did the fund balance I know you said up to 400,000 but I'm just curious what 300,000 would look like not that I think we're don't know what we're going to return I have no idea yeah I guess the other question right and and that's a good point because I'm
108thinking of that too right is going is going from 600,000 last year to 200,000 is that too much of a swing in one year yeah it's a big swing it is a big swing but we knew that was going to happen because I mean there there's nothing we can do about it we can't I don't know how far do we need to cut our budget that we you know we prepared we proposed with what we need to run schools next year because you know is are you saying that's cutting our budget well I I think you're really more just hedging you're hedging open positions that's really all you're doing here but we only have one and that's ins special no that's for the professional staff right we don't we have other unfilled positions right but
109this would be in regards this numbers based upon professional staff the the 6 72 right so 300,000 makes no I understand but if we were to increase the the 200,000 to 300,000 we would be just hedging our bets that there might be another position unfilled down this year I Heidi I I don't hate that because I think that we may still be in that scenario where well do we have projections at this point for end of year we're chipping way at it right like we're the guy out of the district you know that's the big one that we're working on you said 400,000 you wouldn't recommend it but that would be as high as you would go I mean 300,000 I don't think you would recommend it either I would assume you want to keep
110it at the 200,000 but my thought would be is if we're committed to returning anything left over from special ed which it doesn't sound like there's going to be anything from Special Ed and we're committed to returning it it's as Matt said comes down to the unfilled positions and how that does for the year compared to you know slight over budget here slight under budget there and tweaks I mean is it is 300,000 a realistic number I think it can be yes yeah so does the 300 come out first before we do the other no it doesn't because it comes out War anything War so we'll talk about that next right like or I can jump to to a slide that kind of shows this so this would be in your agenda uh the next
111bullet under that projections related to one articles um it's a little bit bigger and this is how these different articles get paid out based upon your kind of starting end of the year balance so we Ed kind of three doll amounts here a million dollar that's if we spent about 96.15% of the budget $800,000 92.9 two% of the budget and then um if we have about $600,000 left in the year balance how everything kind of plays out so there's three columns here this is on the the current language of the warrant articles as we have written and gone over so why this is important cuz you would you would um pay out these warrant articles or fund these excuse me not payout fund these warrant articles in the order that they assuming they all pass
112you would fund them out in the order that they're written here in their full amounts because last board me you know we met and we discussed like what is it look like if we just paid out some of these warrant articles and to do that mechanism you have to put these this percentage cap language into your warrant articles so there's an example we had 50% cap 25% cap for the specialty capital improvment building maintenances we can manipulate this stuff same thing you can ask questions we can change things around so let's say a million dollars that's that's uh um roughly kind of what you started with last year for an argument sake it's you funded those uh warrant articles that that you had which came up to about 428,000 438,000 and then you had that
113left over 640 um to give back to the taxpayers right ignoring land this ignores land from that standpoint this is done after you have um with your end of the year stuff so if you have that kind of million starting point and we use our current language you would fund the benefits article fully right so your million goes down to 97,000 then the 100 for the solar then the 200 for the special Hood then the uh 125 for Capital Improvements and the 135 for the building maintenance you would fully fund all of those warant articles and have about $437 um at that point to do with whatever you're going to do with it right as a board you can decide to send all that back to the taxpayers you can send you can decide to
114send a certain amount of it back to the taxpayers and you can do projects right last year you know you took your end of the year fund balance you did some small projects right I think there were some renovations to the bathrooms at the Middle School uh reing GMS or something there was these small kind of things that you had to that you wanted to get done with that kind of end of the year balance so if you said you're giving 200 back you would have about 237,000 to do in these kind of end of the year projects and whatever whatever it is that you wanted to do now for for that large of a quantity amount of money a million dollars that you're kind of starting point doesn't really matter what you do with
115the warrant articles you can use the current language you can put a 50% cap and you can put a 25% cap on it's a large enough amount of money you're not going to run into the Caps you're going to fully benef you're going to fully um fund each of those warrant articles depending as it is where the cap kind of goes into place and I'll go to the most kind of dramatic is kind of at the bottom so you can actually see it in action so say we had a an end of the year fund balance of about $600,000 that means we spent about 97.6 n% of the budget that we had uh that's not bad if we spent about 98% of our budget we've done a decent job of what we're doing here um
116and again this is based upon all these warrant articles kind of passing right if we use our current language you would have to fund these fully as you kind of went through them right you would have enough money to fund all of them but you're not going to have much left over to do anything else with so you would fund all five of these these warrant articles and what would you have left here is this about 37,74617 th000 back to the tax pay that's less Le than we would have budgeted for it predicted that we would return to the taxpayers right so where that $200,000 number is on that tax rate we're only hitting that 37 so the tax rate is going to be higher than what we predicted right but we would have we
117you would see the numbers carry over because all the warrant articles approved as part of that if you put a 50% cap language on you would fully fund um the first four warrant articles fully right and this is a 50% cap for 9 10 11 and we could do that for for8 as well or or not for nine whatever the case may be but just for argument sake you would fully fund the benefits the solar and then the the other three there except the last one you would run into an issue because after you funded warrant article 10 the amount of money that would be left is 17 to um ,000 about right there and that that twice of what your warle doesn't exceed that right so you can only spend up to 50% of
118that so You' be capped at that 50% of accessing that kind of left over money to to fund that warrant ankle and now you're down to about $86,000 in that last one and that's the building repairs mean that's the building repairs one that still allows that other money that you didn't use to to go back so while you funded 86,000 and you still have then remaining in the end of the year trust uh end of the year balance $86,000 again you can elect to do what you want with that and your projects return it um to offset taxes so on and so forth if you put 25% caps and this would be the idea that you're going to put a little in a lot of places right you fully fund benefits fully fund solar fund
119about 124,000 of that special ed 200,000 so you're putting some money back in there that's if you put a 25% cap there you could not put a cap in there you could put 50% cap in that one you could do all sorts of different things you put about 124,000 there that the leftover money there you hit that wall at 25% it' be 93 for for the next warant arle you hit that wall at 69% the advantage of this is you're ensuring that that kind of bottom amount you're going to hit after you funded all your warrant articles is larger right so you you would have some additional money to to get back to taxpayers offset you have a little money to do some very very very small projects and you would hit that kind of
120Target of a $200,000 return to taxpayers there so those are all different things you can do with those War articles to kind of Ensure uh not ensure but you know take some guesses on where you can end up from the end of the year standpoint for the um 25% just so I understand how the math is done so you know benefits it's solar fully funded y sped we get down to we would have been 200,000 what would the number what would the uh fund balance need to be in order to hit the full 200,000 um CU you know how before you said it would would have you'd have to have twice the amount to so one point is it 75% like it depends on what that percent is what a cap is so like what
121you're running into is when you get to that sped one on the 25% uh I'm really trying to do the math of my head is you're at that point have $497,000 right that's where that is because youve SP you put that 100 into the solar right there if you have 25% cap you can only spend up to 25% of that so you would need that dollar amount right there to be at $ 800,000 at that point if you wanted to get the full if you use that 25% threshold and you want to get that fully done at 200,000 right so the way it works is it trickles down and tries to fund 25% of each of the following hit that wall and then it moves on to the next right now if you that's if
122you did 25 for all those you could fully fund all of special ed and then just hit a 25% wall on those other two you could do 50 for special that 25 for that 25 for that I mean that that if you get too fancy you might confuse people like this is confusing enough right like and if you have this is 50 this is 25 this is 33% all this type of stuff like you just got to really do a good job of explaining what what all that means to everybody and and you'd have to change the order of the warrants correct cool correct yeah what you're what you want to do well depending on what yes and no depending on exactly what you kind of shake out there and stuff like that now you
123we we haven't gotten into too much bounce around a little bit but we can talk about what warrant you want to prioritize here this is how we left it last meeting right we may have different opinions now like the marac valley thing you brought it up I was going to bring it up in this context like that make me Shades me to want to make special ed a little bit maybe make that you know above solar you know like maybe not you know I think that's something to kind think about like how you want to do that maybe you don't cap the special it because you don't want to worry about you know exhausting that stuff like that try to maximize what you want that you know so what's the tax rate impact on the
124$500,000 rais on the 500,000 for building maintenance that's 41 cents 40 40 cents yeah so that's another question yeah 40 cents we'll get to that like is that the right amount do we want to consider lowering that but let's get let's get to that when we get to that article okay so we can revisit 789 10 11 but just when we talked about that end of year balance I wanted to start to show you this and then we can kind of come come back to um it when we get to those specific warant articles but we we come back to this $200 $300,000 number that's that's what we're we're looking at right there right um so if you increase it to 300 do I think we can get there I think we can get there
125right but like that does that's not a guarantee we're going to get there it depends on how everything plays out you know that's the reality it brings it down to a tax rate of 1.82 you know which is better than 2.45 you know but there's no guarantee that's what it's going to be I think we have to play consider 200,000 yeah Special no return tax I agree y I just don't think we have enough legal room any any other questions on Revenue operating budget so the the way article one reads right now are there any other adjustments to the wording tax rates um for article one not for article one okay so the way article one reads right now uh for public awareness shall the Lichfield School District vote to raise and appropriate as an
126operating budget not including Appropriations by special warrant articles and other Appropriations voted separately the amount set forth on the budget posted with the warrant or is amended by the vote at the first session for the purposes set forth herein totaling 28,45 6,5 should this article be defeated the default budget shall be 28 milli M1 54,9 37 which is the same amount as last year with certain adjustments required by previous action of lchi school district or by law or the school board May hold one special meeting in accordance with RSA 4013 act um and I guess it's 10 and 16 to take up the issue of a revised operating budget majority vote required the estimated tax impact of the operating budget is currently a190 the estimated tax impact of the default budget is sitting at a165
127is it still is it is a $190 accurate now or did it go back up to no because oh we were we done the other reductions yeah uh is that um default budget number did you just recalculate that yes okay yep so those are the right those are the correct numbers so I will make a motion to recommend article one as read second motion by myself second by Mr Shoemaker any additional discussion on article one all those in favor please say I I I opposed abstained carries 5 Z okay article two article two hasn't changed all right um so this one was voted by the budget committee uh because it is the contract hasn't changed it was voted um not to recommend by a Tai vote 441 the reasons given um the reasons given were
128predominantly around um because the the uh the contract went to the voters last year and again this year and there was a lot of um discussion around the sizable increases for the support staff uh notably over the past few years being far excessive was the word I would use according to the budget committee did have they looked at what they were making before no that's I just would like to point out the fact that uh you know we made those changes because we were severely severely underst staffed to the point that we had people walking in trying to quit uh and the result of this change has been that we stopped the hemorrhaging and we actually were able to hire some people if you have not had the opp I'm sure you haven't because you
129were busy but if you had not had the opportunity to watch the budget committee meeting I I did make that argument as well as a superintendent awesome thank you for making that argument yeah it's really disappointing yeah um so article two reads shall the litfield school district vote to approve the cost items included in the collective bargain agreement reached between the Lichfield school district and the Lichfield support staff Association which calls for the following or increases in salaries and benefits at the current Staffing level over those paid in the prior fiscal year years 25 through 26 has an estimated increase of 26530 year 26 and 27 has an estimated increase of 21,100 year 2728 has an estimated increase of $225,900 and to further a raise inappropriate the sum of$ 26530 for fiscal year 26 such
130some representing additional costs attributable to the increas in in salaries and benefits required by the new agreement over those that will be paid at current Staffing levels majority vote required this has an estimated tax impact of 17 cents and again not recommended by the budget committee at a 441 vote well I'll make an emphatic uh motion to recommend article two as read I emphatically seconding I'm beating you you're just louder than me no I am we this this is ridiculous motion by Shoemaker second by Ames additional discussion this is ridiculous good discussion I I you know I obviously believe in this agreement right like I I think you know negotiations were good they were Fair um obviously personally very supportive of this I think we have a wonderful support staff right you know um and
131obviously we'll be would advocate for our staff to do this I think people would expect that right like um we we think it's it's fair and I I do think you know the the raises or the amount of money in there is is in line with what a lot of other school districts are doing you can see the benefits we are again continue to slowly chip away and hire people um from where we were at the beginning of the school year um we'll talk about a transfer later that represents the positive steps and in that kind of kind of stuff and everything like that so um we just got to make sure we we explain to people properly what what this means so I hate that they are punishing or that four members of the
132budget committee are apparently punishing because we put it before the voters last year that was part of the discussion yeah and that was the board decision to try and do the right thing right to stop right beding to keep our that was for and by the way that worked yeah right and it was for a year I mean and so what they we freeze their income and don't for the next years right I mean and that that just you know from my recollection that came about not because we were having trouble hiring we were act being brought information that people were actively trying to resign to go to other districts so it wasn't even yeah was we were already working conflict of interest oh okay as it was there was already um we were already
133working with very low staff I mean to have those people resign at the time would have been yeah I think it's important with number of these positions you know PA of professionals being the obvious their positions we have to have we are bound by IEPs to have these positions right like and when we cannot hire these positions because we have to hire them we then have to contract for them and the Contracting can be three or four times the amount of money it would be to pay your own person so we'll make the case in the voter guide the superintendent and I spent quite a bit of time yesterday gu talking a number of things and um just the voter guide can I just make one more point because I think it really is important
134because I was the one that negotiated that last year um the lssa when we approached them you know they're a union and they did not come to the table and say we need if you're going to do this we need equal across the board they sat down and they talked about where the real problems were and they made agreements based off of where the real problems were because they were trying to be team players so I just would like to also point that out great support staff really so as we go through this right um there's obviously a lot of board members that are passionate behind this one so at deliberative um you know just think about who would want to speak to this article up on stage thank you all right so uh I
135will call the vote so we have a motion by Shoemaker second by Ames third by Harrison please say I I I opposed abstained 5 Z okay article three shall the witfield school district if Article 2 is defeated authorize the school board to call one special meeting at its option to address Article 2 cost items only majority vot required make a motion to recommend article three second motion by Mr Shoemaker second by m AES all those in favor please say I I I I opposed abstained 5 Z Article 4 was not uh voted on by the budget committee this is one that they were going to vote on I had asked for the budget committee to consider not voting to allow for board discussion um this is one that uh I'd like the board to consider
136um removing this year um given the importance and I understand the importance uh in the superintendent's position of this being important to the district given all the conversation this evening on tax impact my view is I understand the importance this is probably not the year to be asking for this position and so my view is it's not the right time and I'd like to see this article so I think uh you know the superintendent pointed out that you know this is something that would help us uh you know Prov provide better security for us and and hedge against risk um I mean I think a lot of these things are hedging against risk and so it's just which risks are worse than others right uh like you know spe to me special ed risk is
137big I mean this is a huge risk but like at the end of the day but having this person is not preventing the risk I agree well yeah right I it's it's it's well I mean it could be mitigating the risk mitigating the risk right the long and short of my point was I agree with you yeah I don't know other thoughts please I don't know I hadn't considered removing this one I I feel like it's very timely that power school was just packed yeah yeah I said I swear I did not plant that help with this but coming off of that and I just when is the right time to ask because I don't think next year will be the right time to ask baby NOP you're right so I think we have to
138ask I I think it's an important position but I think Andrew's point where it's this is going to be a tough all this stuff passes it's going to be tough to get anything but the default and you risk getting no I think will vote no on Warren articles I think they'll give us the budget but they'll vote no on these Warren articles but I think we can make a case that this is critical this is Mission critical position so I'm not in favor of removing it yeah I agree with Tina I think this is if the town doesn't think that we should have it they can vote it down MH I would almost rather that like give the opportunity to have this go forward to show the need so we can come back again to
139show the need so we can come back again to show the need yeah I if we don't ask for it my only hesitation on it is whether the language should say and it was brought up at the budget meeting that I attended um whether there should be some reference to cyber security in the title of the position or in the and we said we would talk about it maybe we do maybe we don't but I don't know that districtwide network administrator is tells the urgency of the decision yeah I don't disagree with that I think the hard thing is this is what the job is called right in the industry this is what it's recognized as it's job could there be parentheticals I mean security I mean we maybe add a little bit about overseeing
140dat data and cyber security you know like include cyber in there somewhere guide sadly but yes if we were how many people read the vo guide versus the article if we were to be fortunate enough for that this was approved by the voters and I think then when we want to post a position we want a person who's a network administrator right so like the title is I completely agree with what you're saying just that yeah and just for for argument sake you know if if this is doesn't go forward doesn't get approved whatever the case may be just want to make it clear we're going to keep coming back with this request it's important right like this isn't just like ah we'll try this if it doesn't work out it doesn't work out and
141I'm not saying that to to to point you in any direction just to be transparent with the fact that this is a need we have and we'll continue to try to address it as time moves forward I mean I guess you guys make a compelling you know point about the fact that the voters can still vote this down and not have the tax impact MH I think you know ultimately um I like we all need to be behind it right because we can't have a you know on this 32 Vote or yeah 3-2 vote wouldn't look good even in future years so I guess the question is do how do you guys feel about letting just leaving it in the hands of the voters like ultimately they do get to choose on that uh I
142I agree with that but I think if you the more you ask for the more likely you are to get nothing like have somebody just go no no from from a voting perspective if it's a 2 three vote right and if it's not recommended that's what matcha said if if you are not going to vote to recommend this war an article then it's going to fail but but Andrew I think is saying then we should pull it before we put it forward with that was my whole point if it's not recommended by the school board then why are why is it in was my whole point was that's why I asked them are they they in this is not one that I would have pulled but I did have one in mind that I would
143reconsider I mean before I call the vot I'm I am not supporting this article this year okay then I I think we should so I make a motion to pull the article motion by Mr plansky I will second I'll call the vote um all those in favor and pulling the article please say I I I oppose no noain that carries 32 will be removed Article Five this one was also voted on by the budget committee recommended 90 um wow this one uh actually was makes mathematical sense well it does but but they we've had a lot of trouble in the past with the logic of having to incl Outsourcing but we're bringing it now shocked that it was a 9 praise a lot of um a lot of thanks by the budget committee on this
144one thinking outside the box um very much uh appreciated the superintendent being creative and uh and and saw the True Value behind this position so Article 5 Shadow Litchfield School District vote to raise and appropriate the sum of $ 48,6 for the purpose of funding the salary and benefit costs for a part-time districtwide athletic trainer position to provide athletic Training Services to student athletes as well as to provide support to the athletic director as needed this position will be included in next year's default budget majority vote required estimated tax impact is 4 cents make a motion to recommend article five second by Mr Shoemaker second by Mr plansky discussion all right I I do want to provide just one clarifying thing just for every everyone's sake obviously we would like this and we want we
145have it here right but then we have to hire for the position right we have both things in the budget like we can't hire for this position then we would return this back and have to use the contract that we have in the budget for them I just want to make that clear so so if we hire for the position does the whatever the contract rate go back into that $200,000 Square essentially yes we have to ensure that it happens you know and not spend that money which if we've fired this position we would have no need to spend that money so okay all right all those in favor of recommending Article Five please say I I opposed stained 5 Z article six what do we get on article six this is the elephant in
146the room for me okay um I think a half a million well I 1,000% agree with the need for this and and the the notion of putting it on this but with a you know when we're negotiating whether or not we're going to change bus routes basically to to offset the the tax impact to ask for something that has a 40 Cent tax impact seems I I can't I can't imagine vot getting voter support for this do you think reducing the number or removing it all together my thought was to remove it but ask for increase the amount that we asked for in UND spent so we have article six in article 11 right so my thought would be to remove this but increase the amount in article 11 I don't know that we're going
147to have enough money to be able to fund that well I would move that one up higher I would not make that you know instead of it being a plan B it would move for me it would move to a higher priority on the list and I get that but I think I think this is going to be a very hard sell so what I was thinking something similar I think is reducing that number from 500 to something else 300 250 whatever yeah but you're talking about taking my 250 and adding it to the bottom and just removing that so does that serve the same purpose well but the article 11's from the bottom line no tax no rais there would be a tax impact on it I feel like we really need to start
148shipping away at this that's my issue is we need to start the precedent people want to hear that we're saving money for the rainy day as opposed to the Panic spending well I mean that 500 was based off of the roof for CHS right I and I know and I completely support it but I think seeing a tax impact of now 190 plus the the you know I'd rather support the support staff contract you know if I'm looking at the ballot it's just hard to ask for another half a million dollars so going back to last point for the last one what's that so going back to your point for the last one people could say no and they could say no to this too well that's what I'm saying they could say no to
149this if they don't want it so I'd rather lower the amount to be honest I'm I'm comfortable with making that move at least you know the the goal was in five years to have enough money to pay for the CHS roof maybe we would have to bond a portion of that but but I agree that we do need to start saving towards absolutely um absolutely I just don't I think it's going to be a hard pill to swallow I I do think on the tax in general not saying anything new you're in a tough spot financially right like and the only way to deal with it is through right you can't escape it anymore right when you factor on GMS whatever the outcome there is millions whatever the outcome is Right CHS is okay right
150now but you don't want it to not be okay and you got to start investing in it that's the time well and we also have the roof at GMS to talk about too I mean there are pressing issues that we know are coming down the pike next year y um I and like I said I th% agree with it I just think that the tax the tax impact on our warrants are too high I don't disagree with that at all you know and I think you know talk about longterm here we're next year is going to be heavy right you're looking at an Lea contract um proposal hopefully that if those negotiations go well hopefully something connected to GMS next year right whatever that that that recommendation is an option is you want to pursue
151um you know we we can't escape lssa if that's a 441 right now and that doesn't pass it guess what we're going back to at the table next year is another contract with lssa so that's another contract potentially on top of that um you know that's just all stuff to kind of factor you we as a district as a town as a community you got to work your way through this it's going to cost some money unfortunately and that's unavoidable at this point I know it's just a matter how you want to do it so was it gradual right I don't know what the right number is but maybe maybe let's just say 300 right and then next year it's 400 right so the tax impact is 300 and then next year it's it feels
152like 100 yeah right yeah did you uh cuz I didn't get to watch the budget commit meeting did you get a feel for their sentiments towards this again I mean I know Mr is in the audience tonight Mr oenus spoke you know a lot about these this article and these articles in the on-site Insight report and the astern report right and the need to have funding right you know but we also talked a lot about tax impact and like we we have to start saving right um you know I just I I I think one thing to consider if I may you have two articles related to this fund M that might be a lot that we checked from the legality stand point of it sure legally you can do it but do you risk
153confusing voters because you get one in the year do you risk I'm going to say no to this because I can say the yes to this one and people might have different to both right or they say no to both or say you know when you have two on there yeah we we were unsure about the legality so we checked and like yep you can do it but probably why people don't is because your the risk that comes with but if we were to remove this one and there wasn't enough money enough money we there would be nothing going in correctly right and we know we know that we're light on that based off of change the order of the Articles down there yeah I think we've got to start putting money away for this
154my view is to drop article 11 and reduce the raise and appropriate article to something less I can agree with that drop article the last one 11 like 135 because we have to start building the tax base up something drop it as in get rid of it totally okay so if that so if if it fails we're rolling the dice like I don't if six fails y if it fails can we I suppose we we don't pose the question we're not going against the voter right if we have fund balance left over can we still move money into that account without it being v no no it's got to be a warrant but I think what what is the balance in that account give a second something it's 360 something look at that not bad
155300 something so uh 367,000 that's not bad it was Zero not long ago yeah yeah I mean if you're looking for numbers I'm just shooting off the hip here you got 367 in there you know if if you knock that down to to 200 for argument sake right here then you and it passes that count has over 500,000 in it which is the goal of this particular War right are you saying also reduce the amount for six yes I'm saying reduce the amount my thought is to reduce the amount of six to 300,000 yeah I think you're starting it that you do have some money in that account already it's not like you're starting at zero right so while you ease the idea behind it is you're easing people into this idea and you know
156we're educating about why the value of it and why the benefits of it long term are you come down a little bit you have some money already in that account like that might and you think that's a better shot at this passing 50 and it's 20 cents I I I you know what I agree with you because I think we need to get to a place where we're actively budgeting for this and not just saying if there's anything left over we could maybe maintain our buildings so I agree with you so I would be I I'm definitely in favor of reducing this to 250 I'm still on the edge about whether to cut article 11 or not I I understand the confusion of it um are we shooting ourselves in the foot to be able
157to have that if this doesn't pass yeah I I am really nervous that we may walk away with 360 so let's talk about article 6 then by itself yeah okay so I'll make a motion to reduce article 6 to $250,000 I'll second not 00 we're going to stick to 250 because I think it's going to it's going to reduce the tax impact to 20 cents instead of something higher little more palatable I think that'll still give us over 500,000 in that account y right okay go that all right so motion by myself second by Miss Ames all those in favor please say I I I all right so article six will now read shall the litfield school district vote to raise an appropriate the sum of 250,000 to be added to the building maintenance capital
158reserve fund established in 2005 for the purpose it's all changing on me establishment purpose she's not changing the words screw sorry of funding School Capital Improvements Building Maintenance and repairs in the Lichfield School District majority vote required estimated tax impact 20 cents I'll make a motion to recommend article six as red motion by Mr Shoemaker second by Miss Harrison uh all those in favor say I I opposed abstained 5 Z all right thank you for that article 7 this one um was recommended by the budget committee 90 uh this one's pretty straightforward sh the witfield school district vote to raise and appropriate the sum of $2,253 to be added to the employee benefits Reserve fund established in 2022 for the purpose of funding the payment of negotiated employee benefits including but not limited to health
159insurance reimbursements changes in coverage or policies chosen by employees sance benefits and such other benefits as are from time to time negotiated and become contractual obligations of the district with this sum to come from the June 30th fund balance available for transfer on July 1st of this year with no additional amount to be raised from taxation this amount is consistent with the amount raised for severance payments that were not paid out in fiscal year 25 and therefore would be paid out in subsequent years majority vote required I'll make a motion to approve article 7 as written thank you for that Mo second by Mr Shoemaker all those in favor please say I hi I opposed abstained that carries 5 Z just recognizing the time is now 7:30 and we have our student Representatives here you
160guys are you know graciously listening in but uh recognizing it's also a school night it's up to you right so um as riveting as exciting I'm not going to off that to Nick though cuz he's not here he missed out while we're paused for a second there are two signatures on the Manifest I'm going to pass down this way to get up third signature I put I added there's five and I put the on the cover so just so you know exactly what you're signing all right you have a good night I'll spare you all right um article8 did we vote we vote on S we did z i I think we should move article 8 Below special ed so article 8 is the solar capital reserve fund I really think you know special ed
161is I the solar thing needs to be taken care of so Nick um you guys are free to leave a fe like actually we let Danny leave we you have to stay Danny said you'd cover it the rest of the day he's like I'm up appreciate you guys sticking yeah I got got to wake up at like 7:30 tomorrow so oh no you have schools yeah I know that's rare that's rare for for a senior thank you guys you [Music] too I think I like Matt's idea of moving it up moving the special that thing above the right I think because we are anticipating depleting it this year I think it should be a priority also the second someone use the word solar they're going to be sour for the rest of the war article
162so I mean it's the wheel of the board right I you know my thought on this is we've been talking about it on CIP and having sat on the CIP for years myself like it's finally nice to see this article being talked about at the board level and being plan for at the board level with some money hopefully being set aside for this Loom payment in six whatever years is I mean I think the good thing is uh the clock has not started running yet right correct so moving it down one hope we have some January 2026 yeah yeah all right I mean so I'm glad to shift it so do you want a motion on that notion on that so article8 will will become seven no nine nine we'll be after cuz we got
163to remember other stuff anyway so we'll get to the number get to it because took the network off so that changes that's true you're right I'm numbers we got I won't mess with read it as it is now right and you guys can shift it around okay so the current article 8 shall the litfield school district quote to established capital reserve fund under the provisions of RSA 351 to be known as the solar array fund for the purpose of accumulating funds to acquire the solar equipment at Woodville Middle School at the end of the six-year agreement and to raise and appropriate the sum of $100,000 to be placed in this fund with the sum to come from the June 30th fund balance available for transfer on July 1st of this year with no additional amount
164to be raised for Taxation and further to disate the school board as agents to expend this fund the JY vote required estimated tax impact is zero additional discussion motion to approve article eight as written motion by Miss second second by Mr plansky all those in favor please say I I I opposed abstained that carries 5 Z okay current article 9 is the special education capital reserve fund with $200,000 any discussion on this before I read the article okay Shad thefield School District vote to raise in appropriate up to a sum of $200,000 to be added to the special education actually before I start this did we want to add percentages to this well that's something we can discuss right um it's something when I showed you that whole thing with it with 50s 25s and
165stuff if you wanted to discuss this for these warant articles The more I've sat on this I don't think you should do that for the special yeah I think right we want to that you want to fund that fully so I would but I just wanted to bring that in my mind as we get through these later articles yeah and you can discuss it obviously as board you're will but like my recommendation would be to not for this one particularly if you're bringing solar underneath it you know now you're moving that up in in the threshold you want to F from that one okay so start over and and just one more note and why I think it's important to fully fund this all it takes is one movement one moveing and then this go
166shall the litfield school district vot to raise an appropriate up to a sum of $200,000 to be added to the special education capital reserve fund established in 2004 for the purpose of educating disabled students with this sum to come from the June 30th fund balance available for transfer on July 1st of this year with no additional amount to be raised from taxation majority vote required estimated tax impact zero I will make a motion to approve article n as read second motion by myself second by Miss Harrison all those in favor please say I I opposed by Z okay article 10 article 10 is the capital Improvement Expendable trust fund does the board want to consider adding a percentage to this well I mean so if we add a percentage then if we if we don't
167add a percentage and we don't have enough then nothing goes into it or it's just funded up you're might not have anything left but I mean if we're going to talk about getting rid of 11 then what does it matter right it may not matter yeah I think sequencing matters now you know I think absolutely what you would you may want to discuss you know you talk about moving solar down I'm going to talk about this I'm going to ignore 11 for a moment because you're going to have a different debate on on on that article but if you look at the current um 8 n and 10 which is the solar the special lead and then the Capital Improvements the thing you may want to consider is building special lead Capal improvements and then
168solar in that order so the one that is the Le that if you have to not fund one of those fully one it is a solar yeah but I think that might be the way to go is because you have this the six years and that clock still hasn't started it could push into the next fiscal year which means you have seventh year to gain that you know so I agree with that yeah and if if you're going to do that I would leave them as they are okay I agree with that yeah so bump 10 above solar so go specializ solar goes last Capital Improvements solar I like that cuz again I think that the second someone sees the word solar they're going to be not happy I I I I know I I
169agree actually like I think solar will be the thing that turns it and then it's no from there on out you know I could see that definitely being AAR all right article 10 current article 10 shall the litfield school district vote to raise and appropriate up to a sum of 125,000 to be added to the capital Improvement Expendable trust fund established in 2020 for the purpose of the funding study planning and cost of new construction or renovation of existing facilities in the Lichfield School District with this sum to come from the June 30th fund balance available for transfer on July 1st of this year with no additional amount to be raised from taxation this amount is consistent with the capital plan adopted by the town of litfield in September of 2020 majority vote required estimated
170tax impact is zero I will make a motion to approve article 10 second for discussion I have a I just a small very dim light bulb just went off in my head so what if we phrase this as should article is it six fail ask year wa you're talking about for number 11 you're talking about for number 11 oh I'm I was thinking about 11 no never mind I'll hold it light bulb off switch all right um all those in favor of approving article 10 please say I I opposed abstained carries 5 Z back to article 11 on keeping not keeping so Tia with respect to what you're saying I think the more I think about it we we need to shift the way that this particular thing is is viewed in town it can't
171be a if there's money left over it has to be something that we are proactively budgeting to maintain facilities and I think that by removing that yeah we're taking the risk on it but we are just signaling to the taxpayers you're going to see this I think if they see two they're going to be like how what what's it's sending mixed signals like hey well we still could do this by leftover money which we know is not right the r bu I mean I feel that too I would just hate to not be able to put anything away yeah that's the risk that's the risk I don't like it yeah that makes me nervous yeah but could we do it as should that other article fail we'll do but again my problem with that is
172that we're then signaling that either of these are acceptable ways of of budgeting for that and it's truly not an acceptable way to budget for I agree it's a risk reward thing is it worth taking because we've got a lot of work we have to do I think you know again just my opinion if if with the article it was six but with the ring the one that's a stain alone that just comes from raising taxes right taxation you want establish that's the way moving forward and my opinion this is the way to do it because you don't want to try to establish that next year so now you're not looking at trying to establish that until two years from now at the earliest March 27 so you got to take that bite at the
173Apple now it is a risk it could we could end up with nothing right but that's on us you know thus the district to explain to people why this is important right and to do that public messaging it it could fail right and that wor not necessarily worse off we have some money in that account but we're not making the progress that we're hoping to do and what the result of that could be is just a larger Bond down the down the road when we have to do that work right which we know costs actually more money in the long run so you want to try to prevent that unless you absolutely have to so I think it's on us to do a good job of selling it It's Tricky I I'll make yeah I'll
174make I'm going to make a motion to remove article 11 I'm going to Second it motion by myself second by Sho maker discussion no I mean I I think it's a risk but I also think the risk of confusion mhm almost makes negates that risk their risks either way y um and so I agree with the sentiment that we need to start planning for this and we need the town to get on board hopefully with planning for this and the only way to prepare people to do that is to only have one option on there I know we went around in circles on this one I'm very appreciative to the SIU the superintendent for entertaining my crazy idea of putting this article out there right and asking for this kind of and can it can
175it exist on this twice yeah I think it was worth the discussion Y and that would make solar loss so nobody's cranky after they're cranky leaving but not and it gets our articles I think down to nine yeah which is I think also helpful that is helpful so okay um all those in favor of removing article 11 say hi hi post all right that um that's item one on my on my S two hours later warrants which is important to get through all right uh remote learning days I unplugged uh that's the same proposal you saw last meeting with some very small um adjustments to language in the support staff area based upon recommendations from the lssa but it does not change the context of of uh the procedures and what we're trying to accomplish
176there um this is mainly to make sure that we're all doing following the same general guidelines and procedures at all three of the schools when it comes to remote learning days um nothing like this was on the book for the district so we thought it'd be wise to do something District wise obviously schools will be slightly different based upon the age of their kids I think Elementary would still like to minimum do a morning meeting with their kids to kick off a remote day or obviously high schoolers if you get them out of bed by 10:00 in a remote learning day you're probably you're winning you know so um so this just kind of accounts for some of those differences between age ranges but does put set procedures in place for them I think a
177lot of it makes sense has this gone has this been reviewed by the admins and the Lea yes and the SSA Lea everybody so um it's very similar to a lot language other districts use if you go look at bows it's going to be the same very similar look at Timber LS it's very similar you're looking for a motion I'm looking for approval yes sir I'll make a motion to approve the remote learning days procedures second moot by m second by m additional discussion all right Mr piny stepped out all those in favor please say I Iain that's a 4 Z thank you the next one is informational um Mr cutter you asked for this I think at at a meeting or through email to the board or I don't remember the where the specific
178request was whether it was in the meeting or or as we were prepping the agenda but to look at our out of District uh tuition projections I'm not going to project it on the screen just because some of the information there but um it is our production our our expenses through um the end of of the calendar years through 2031 we've have obviously a few bills that have come in since then but for just clean clean the cleanliness of it we just took it to the end of 2024 um do my thing here real quick and uh you can kind of see uh where the different expenses are how we encumbered things at different different different standpoints if you look at copy at the copy of sheet one which is the second page you can
179kind of see it broken up by the different providers that we have there and you can see kind of um if you look at that third provider for example you can see there's a monthly expense and we're working our way um kind of down there to to kind of take care of those expenses uh one of these particular um vendors the second one on this particular list if if you're on that second sheet um we anticipated that uh a certain amount of money that we would budget for that line You'll see a change order there for about $95,000 that's because we don't think we're going to spend that money for that provider now so in one hand saving $95,000 because of change of services for the students involved here that's a good thing if you
180look at that top provider on this list that's the student that came in at the beginning of the year that mov additional student that's an additional student that wasn't budgeted for so if you look at the amount of money for that student and what we're saving from that second provider we're saving a little bit more from that second provider but it's essentially almost a wash between those two particular things the amount for the year the amount for the year so we're done okay yeah and we got the first pill last week the end of last week which Alliance about a third of that which is about a third of the the way through the school year that was accounting for and stuff like that so we're in good shape from there so you can kind
181of go through and see the different things there's a little more detail on the first sheet on what some of the specific um expenses are and when we encumber different things if if you're interested in those type of things but uh long story short we are projecting out to spend approximately what we had predicted for for our out of District tuition now again this can change suddenly if we had an additional student move in who required out of District tuition we would 100% need to access um The Reserve fund we have for special ed you know um and uh if something changes in these students um services that could be something that that we would um need to need to look at that that thing but as of this moment today January 15th we're okay
182that particular line so this is more informational there's questions regarding I want to kind of show the board the kind of process I apologize we're not projecting this for the larger audience but we want to keep some of this information that's help thank you very much um the last thing is uh the board approves uh job descriptions um so Lori Martin who's our executive assistant for special services um here at the sa is retiring at the end of January we're going to miss Lori a lot spent some more time with her family um this is a good good thing ultimately um uhor you know yeah I think it's good she she she's um she's excited for for new adventures and stuff like that she thinks we're in a good place in terms of organization that
183transition over um you know the Miss Pooler into that position and everything um so she put in for a retirement at the turn of of the the turn of the month this earlier and um so we we've posted a position but we' tweak the job description a little um so we need the board's approval um for this updated job description the changes are are really basic it's no longer an SAU department head it's a director so we just reflected that as who the person is working with um you'll see see three of the responsibilities crossed out we no longer do Medicare for the district so that's not part of the job responsibilities anymore um School counseling handles the 504 stuff so that's not this person's managing that account anymore for that someone else is doing
184that and then no longer doing the Master teaching for the PA of professional training so cross that out as well so there you go so it's nothing changing too much other than just being a little more accurate on uh specifically what the person is doing so I'm asking for your approval of the updated uh job description here and happy answering questions you have I'll make a motion to approve the job description for the executive assistant to special services as revised second motion by Miss haris additional discussion all right I all those in favor of approving the job prescription please say I Hi hios 5 and uh we' We've posted for this position and good news is is we have uh I think it was 15 applicants when we last elected wow so we have a
185lot of interest uh in the position a lot of qualified people some people who are doing the job in another District um I don't know any of them so they but they seem really really great what's up when when does that start that was we posted a uh I guess is it is it the end of the school year or is it before no it's the end of the month so we'll do we'll start doing interviews uh tomorrow tomorrow tomorrow we'll start doing interviews tomorrow great so I think we're bring in eight of those 16 or 15 to um interview and like I said some strong candidates in there so we're very happy with the pool good it's good to hear um I think that's it for me I'll turn things over to J give
186the superintendent a break well deserved all right um so I did update the financials um I don't know if anyone has any questions about that um open the right sheet here um as far as transfers go um we have two transfers um that we wanted to discuss U for approval one is that we need to hire a par professional for a particular student and it is a vacant position so we are um we're asking to contract with sun belt Staffing who we've contracted with for other positions um and that we are requesting the transfer of the $ 31,2 18125 from salaries and benefit benefits to be transferred to contracted services for this purpose is this an addition to what we've already correct this is a a different student that is requiring um a one to
187one not that I have a problem with I'm just questioning like how's that come how's that going to impact the the the salary and benefits line so we're taking the money from that line to contract the services right so we'll reduce it a little bit and um we're halfway through the year so you know while that position while the contract is going to cost more money than having our own person on staff would because we've had those savings all right already then you know particular cost will be closer to being more neutral but obviously that POS position remained vacant the whole year and we didn't have that need that money would be part of the end of the year balance haven't we already um because we've already done transfers to this agency haven't we already
188utilized what would what we would have otherwise spent for that vacant position so if I'm understanding your question correctly we're trying to transfer over as we have to transfer over so we did V we did transfer money over from from PA professionals over contracted services to cover the the money related to that contract we did from earlier in the year right this is a new contract for an additional par professional out of sunbell because we had a change in services for a student that's going to require one to one pair of professional um so we need to contract for an additional pair of professional from from this agency we've had success with them and in the past so want to continue with that so in terms of is there this is more we're anticipating that
189we're going to use up all the money we originally intended because we transferred the amount over to cover the the first hiring right we're going to bring out the money over to cover the second right now by utilizing some of the money from a bacon position I think I answered your question but but I didn't yeah makes sense I think so I think my concerns going to be if we still need these Services next year we no longer have power Professionals in our budget well we still have some we still have a lot in our budget we still have a lot that are not a lot lot not as much but we still have some that are vacant right now correct yeah so I mean this you know to do a plug this would be
190why it's helpful to pass the lssa contract so we can increase those rates and maybe make the jobs more appealing to to people to come come on board and take so okay uh I'll make a motion to approve the transfer of $ 31,2 18125 as requested I'll second motion by myself second by Miss Ames all those in favor please say I I I I opposed abstained that carries 5 Z thank you um we have another uh transfer that we're requesting with regard to salaries and benefits um we have filled um several custodial positions which we're very happy about um we have been contracting with Citywide um custodial services for all three of our schools this year um so we were able to when we started to see that we were hiring more people we renegotiated
191the contract so that we could end Services um particularly at GMS at the end of this fiscal year so um at calendar year I apologize so as of December 31st um we're no longer Contracting them for GMS so we are asking to um take the remaining 23735 that was allocated for GMS from contracted Services back into the GMS custodial line for second Absolutely I'll make a motion to that back one those that good one I talked about earlier a good transfer showing that we're hiring making progress in this it's saving us money we can pull that money back over um into the Staffing on yes so I will make that motion to approve that transfer back uh from contracted services to uh the custodial salary sign second that motion by myself second by misss additional
192discussion all those in favor please say I oppos stain concrete evidence that the requests to voters last year to approve the lssa contract or negotiated oneyear agreement um is working um another item um I just wanted to let you know about is um the freezer the walk-in freezer that we have over at Griffin um hasn't been working properly so um just prior to Thanksgiving Brak thank goodness it was Prior um we had noticed um that the temperature was really coming down in there so um we were able actually all of the SAU members got in our cars immediately drove over to GMS piled everything into our cars and brought everything over to the Campbell freezer um so since then you know and I I had spoken with our um food service director Lauren um to
193say you know what can we do like is this something that's happened before and she said yes unfortunately it's an older freezer so we talked about a contingency plan of like maybe we just keep what we absolutely need short term in the gmss freezer you know until we can kind of Remedy the situation so that's what we did um and so there was a leak um and they they fixed the leak but that was all um so now we actually just prior to Christmas um break we had a um another situation with it going down and unfortunately it was discovered on a Monday so it had been all the all in over the weekend luckily we didn't have a lot of product that was in there A lot of it was commodity items thank goodness
194um so it did make the loss a lot less significant it was actually a loss more calculated was $52.56 worth of product that we had to get rid of um so what we've done is um we did ask the the company to not just fix like not just like plug the leak and kind of move on they have to replace a coil so we're just going to go ahead and do that um we're waiting on the uh quote for that but we are going to go ahead and do that because we don't want to keep you know risking that this could happen again and lose potentially more product is this unit at end of life where we you to consider replacing it um yes it is an older unit um I I can definitely look
195into more of the details of how old it is and what it would cost to replace um the entire unit but I can certainly get that information yeah me if that's something that is a continuous problem and we need to start thinking about just the maintenance of it right I it's kind of one of these things that we need suppose is going to do the trick I mean that's great to make think great right but if it's something more than that then we need to sure that absolutely um and the other uh I wanted to address the power school breach um the superintendent did send out um as everyone knows a um notification to families that there was a breach uh security breach in the power school system power school does um they're basically an
196umbrella company so like there's a lot of different pieces underneath that um they they house e finance for instance which is what we use for our accounting program thank goodness this breach had nothing to do with e finance so there was nothing compromised with regard to that was the student information system the the CIS um data that was specifically targeted um in this breach um and so we did have um student and um teacher data that had been extracted during um this um Power School feels very confident that they were able to to get all of that information back that there that that information has not been compromised however of course it's you know still a scary experience for folks um so we did um at the advice of um primax our insurance carrier we
197did file a claim um for this um with the loss of data um so their cyber security insurance company is someone that we're dealing with now Beasly um and they're we just had a call with them yesterday to just kind of go over you know that obviously this is is a huge breach that's affected lots of school districts not just us um we are very lucky in that we do not have any Social Security numbers nor have we ever um housed that information in our student information system um so we're in much better shape with that I mean there there was other information but luckily that you know not that really um not as frightening as it would be if it were social security numbers um we I have another call on Friday with McDonald
198Hopkins which is um the Insurance uh the Privacy Council representative that we've been advised to speak with um so if there's any more information we'll certainly pass that along how's that impacting dayto day it doesn't yeah you know in the short answer it doesn't right like it's name and addresses were the things that that were taken uh for the most part they negotiated whatever and supposedly like Julie said it wasn't compromise or anything like that um you know our Tech team did a great job of digging into it I mean some of their practices like not storing so soci Security numbers in that system uh this is why so like some of the steps they preventative steps that they do and procedures they have in place helped us a lot in this matter um we'll
199probably do a revamp you know talking to Chris the director um and probably just out of an abundance of caution do a reset of passwords and stuff down the road and stuff like that once we're ready to do that and like it's the right time um but from a dayto day it hasn't necessarily disrupted anything that we're doing so just to clarify did you file claim with primx or did you just notify primx of the situation I the claim so what's the claim for if there was no well the information was taken so they do have a cyber security Division and anytime that there was data that had been removed they they advise us to go ahead and file the claim and power school has certain notifications that they have to follow if this stuff
200occurs you know like this breach occurred on uh do my head December 18 yeah but they were not they found out about it December 28th and then they have 10 days to notify if you're affected about it which they did not do for any school I'm just trying to understand like what it means to file a claim for something like that because when you file a claim usually you're filing a claim to get compensated for but they may have to offer free credit monitoring they're offering credit monitoring ID protection FR protection all that have we gotten any information from power school about them covering that or yes no I had I got an A bunch of us got an email from them we're digging through that if you go to their website I'm going to
201send it out part of my message it's like FAQ but there's it's there's not a lot there yet I'm assuming it will get added to as kind of time goes on as they get answers about because obviously a lot of people have reached out and be like how how do we do how do we get the credit monitoring Tak care of right and it's like yep we're waiting to hear how they promis they're going to do it we're waiting to hear about the specifics as well we talking hundreds of millions of users that and they've also committed to um notifying all of you yeah they they have to and but they have a pretty long window before they have to it's not like they've got to do it in 30 days it's something silly like
202six months or nine months typically yeah heard anything else in this one that's it else uh solar update I had um I know it's later on the agenda but I always have it on my um on my report I saw your coming up D yeah D yes so so we're going to be meeting um with K next Tuesday um at 9:30 a.m. over at LMS okay able to join behind the school mhm sure on the roof on the roof my schedule has changed for Tuesday so I think I can probably that all right fun K just had to [Laughter] reschedule um all right the time is now 8:02 uh and what I'd like to do is open it up for our second Community input this evening um so I will do that so this is
203the second of two Community inputs where it's open to anyone in the public who to share anything to the board thank you for hanging in with us this evening Mr a as riveting as our warrant article discussion was tonight I was going to wait to hear I was hoping to wait uh to hear some of the other reports particularly what was coming back from the fic because um wanted to be sure that all that we talked about which was a lot in the last couple of meetings was reflected well if you would like to stay for that because I wasn't at that meeting I was virtually attending so you can probably help me because in the inter I've had a baby and I'm very jumbled right now I can imagine um yeah I be be
204more than pleased um in fact you might have seen we put put together meeting minutes of that so I don't know if you had a chance to look at it that um just a comment I I I said this before and I appreciate the the need for trying to start a capital reserve fund and I know you reduced it but I I still think it's unwise to try to put it together this year uh and the reason being in my Mo mind is as you know onsite inside comes back and has told us we are looking at $28 million of just maintenance over the next 20 years and if you look at it it breaks down pretty much 15 million every 10 years um and so where we've not solved GMS yet it's going to
205require a bond and I think to my mind I would have actually kept the same thing that you were doing mov we not assigned over uh into the reserve and but waited on this starting this capital reserve until we have an answer on the whole package because you know solving GMS will include in my mind looking at all three buildings we're talking about that in the context of looking at all three buildings for the we'll call it the educational opportunities or options but also you need to look at it from the capital side you know what is the the changes that might be needed to facilitate it the final decision as well as the maintenance and it's going to require a bond there's no way we can you know pay ourselves through this so in
206my mind going to the voters now without a solution or even a um in fact the the thing that you just did is you actually took out the logic of why it was in here the logic of $500,000 was to have money to pay for the the roof so now you only got half the money in the projected time frame so you're not even meeting that so my opinion for what it's worth would be to take that out of there leave the you I know I know you've already done it but leave the capital in there but be prepared to come with the whole solution and that's what you charg the fic with at least as far as recommendation goes so that you then can start pricing that out to have something next year and
207that's going to be multi- years my point being there's no way that you're not going to have to have rebond and I think the whole solution needs to be part of what you present as a bond so I'll stop there and then can I just talk about the solar panel question again um and I I I had to smile when you uh talked about uh being able to attend the meeting with K coming up so I know your uh the frustration level of the board on this this issue is High um but as I said at the budget committee meeting on the solar panel uh bio I really would like to see full analysis of why this is the right thing to do for instance um we haven't even got the batteries installed yet but
208remember once you buy this system all the maintenance comes to you and things fail and one of the most difficult things in today's world is get anybody to maintain a solar system it is impossible to get anybody to maintain these in fact if you look at the schedule of product for the solar array it is it has about 25 different man I say 25 I'm going to say maybe 8 to 10 different manufacturers of pieces of of equipment there's in this and there's all kinds of functions that have I gave the example my friend of mine put in a household one for this was $50,000 just a couple years ago this system was supposed to be able to monitor all the individual panels so when one failed youd know where it was well that system
209is failed he still is producing power and being able to sell it back but he that element he can't find anybody to even talk to him to come out and straighten that out my point being is I would I really want to see a full analysis of is this a good thing to do or not I know that the payments go up after year six once it starts but they only go up less than $80,000 over that number of years and we're already paying $100,000 the other side of it is do we are we convinced that this will actually be cost neutral over a year will it reduce our electric bill to zero will it or not if it doesn't that that $600,000 applied over over the payments the way we are now looks pretty
210good that becomes it the economic solution the other side of it is quite truthfully I believe you know National Grid is the way they're going indicates to me anyway that they're on the verge of potential insolvency they can't get this thing done and usually that means you haven't got the money to do it this battery install is a pantload of money and if we take that on then we're responsible for that battery life is only about 15 years my guess is that's somewhere between 5 00 a million dollar to replace so you need to add you need to put together a the logic of why you're doing this and remember it's not a requirement to pay this out it's an option we're not required it it's not a balloon payment in the sense that we
211had to it is a opportunity and the last thing on this is if you read the contract right now we're estimating I think $660,000 for the biot something like that that's based upon today's estimated of fair market value who sets the fair market value is the seller and they do that 120 days before so we get there we don't know what that number is I understand if you think that's a number and you want to do this yes you divide out and maybe start it but the point being I don't think we've analyzed if this is the right thing to do going forward sufficiently thank you yeah and just on the Sol contract um I your comment at the budget committee meeting was about I did share the the table the 25 year fixed contract
212I share that with the budget committee I'm going to afford it to you as well just for your reference is that out of the contract yes it is yeah I've got the contract and that's why I say right now or $100,000 90 some 97 and it goes up in year 25 just for up to 194,000 194 okay but it's it's it uh less than double in 25 years the point being is if you look at all the other costs that are potentially on our nickel and including replacing the solar panels um because they have a service life as well and when when the system goes down as a for instance remember we have to pay our full electricity bill as well as get it up and running so there's all those those costs that I
213would I'm not saying it's the wrong thing to do all I'm suggesting is I it has not been fully vetted as to the full consideration of this is is it the right thing to do yet that's all I'm asking to I don't think you raise the money we're committed to buying it out because we we don't know how it's going to work because we could return we could return that money if it we we and I don't I don't disagree with that but before you put something for the voters I you know it's like why are you doing this I want to you know we're doing this but okay why and they ask the same questions I do my recommendation would you pull it this year take some of this off because you haven't you
214know the six years hasn't started yet so take this off the off the warn article and get ready to do it next year and have your ducks in a row as to why thank you very much all right all right with that uh we'll close Community input and move uh back into the agenda for curriculum instruction of assessment over to Dr Taylor all right okay so um last time we met um I talked about the um curriculum review committee meeting and going through um several new course proposals that were put forward um mostly at um CHS there were a couple Ela classes for um LMS and then we we talked about coming to this board meeting for approval of the courses um the art program Sue was here this um earlier tonight talking about ceramic
215like the two new art teachers Amanda and Sue are amazing and they are really trying to revamp the program and really make it um a awesome experience for students so with that they were looking at the courses that are currently offered and the uh lack of um like prerequisite knowledge and the need for that so they really put a lot of thought into the courses that they brought forward to us um this year and the um committee has is putting putting forward um all five of their courses except for two would be offered um for next year um one of them being an AP course and we need one of the teachers to go through AP course training um and then sculpture to lar sculpture is on hold and up for discussion again for next
216year so those are the art classes um and then there were two courses for ELA proposed for the high school um one of them Essentials of English would be a recommendation course students would be recommended to go into that course based on um certain criteria um and it would just be the same kind it would be a freshman course most likely um and offer the same skills just at a slower kind of pace um so we thought that that was a good proposal they're just going to rework the description a little bit um based on committee feedback and then um Holocaust literature was proposed there was a lot of discussion on this cuz there are um a lot of changes in the 306 rules for Holocaust Education and all of that so um we thought
217that this would be a really a good way to address those types of things as well so those were the two um courses at the high school then um LMS proposed A literacy strategies course um again kind of going with the essentials of English for the high school this one would be recommend only based on a certain set of criteria and taught by the speech and language pathologist uh it was interesting because when we were reading this I had actually just gotten off a state call with a speech path from a different District that is doing this same kind of course um so it was just kind of timely how it corelated but it would take um it would be UA time so um the Comm thought that this would be a good course to
218put forward at LMS to help catch up the kids that really need it um and then in PE and health at CHS there were five courses put together um they're really working to kind of Garner more interest and um offer more options and variety for students of a variety of profiles instead of just the sports Athletics types like so um they're really putting Shannon really put a lot of work into looking at what kinds of options that they could use um we are proposing a title change for the first aid CPR course because it's definitely more robust than just teaching a CPR class um so but those courses were proposing to go forward um the two Spanish courses that were put forward there was a lot of conversation around those and the needs and ultimately
219the committee felt that having two tracks for Spanish was not the right or Spanish for I should say was not um the right um path at this time not saying that we don't revisit it at a different time in a different year but for right now we um have decided not to put those forward um and then social studies put forward three course three new courses they did a survey with the students to see what the interests are and then of course there's been a lot of changes in the 306 rules for social studies so um um the team has really been doing a lot to adhere to those new requirements but also just stay with what students are asking for and give them more authentic um opportunities to choose from then the last one
220on the list is a yearbook course that was proposed we still had quite a bit of questions and we still need more information um prior to the committee recommending that going forward so um that will be on hold but Val and Jake will be here at next board meeting presenting the changes to the program of studies because what will happen is once we receive board approval they'll look at it and changes will happen to the Department's offerings in each of these areas so they won't offer they won't have like PE won't have five courses that are new plus all the ones that they have currently um there's going to be some rotation out so they'll come in and present what's being rotated out to accommodate what's being rotated in so we are seeking approval for
221to put forth the courses that the committee is recommending to go forward um tonight if you have any questions there's been a tremendous amount of work put into all of this and I'm super appreciative um from yourself from all of the um the staff that's yeah the hours the staff the reviewers everyone that put the time in to to bring this to tonight so thank you very much the committee is great good job I'll go ahead and make a motion to approve the following courses I was going to do we want to do it individually I was going to name them all I I don't think we need to do it individually do you or well I I don't know does any board members have any issues with any of the courses preventing them from
222voting no they were obviously very thoroughly vetted by the committee and I reviewed the materials and the only when I had Andrew was the yearbook that was going to be but it's not going to get forward here today they're still waiting for more information so I guess a question before the motion then right is how are we going to be monitoring enrollment in these courses to make sure that right they're adequately being participated question well that's done by the school counseling office but I think just because we're approving the course doesn't necessarily mean it's going to be offered every year they for a rotation of they add in one of the three social studies for next year someone have a course and have four students right and yeah no they in that case that course
223wouldn't be offered they would be notified that they'd have to pick something else they have to pick something else and like we had a conversation about like U going back to the Holocaust course um there might be a need to offer more um courses in social studies based on that so then that might decline the interest in another um English course so that would be a conversation like for next year the Year following like maybe we don't need the English Holocaust course because we need this one you know what I mean so those continency conversations would happen and we would make sure that the course had enough students to run it okay and also some of these courses have I mean very minor some minor supplies cost items Associated does that just come out of
224the supplies lines the department supply lines yeah each department has one y so we would approve let's say we approved them all but then Jake and that group would say these are the ones we're going to put in for next year and we would yeah we're approving it so that they can be a course that is offered by whatever school it is it goes in the catalog basically for the high school I mean there's an LMS course in there too yeah and like I said Jake and Val will once we get approval to move these forward they'll come next week and say this is what we're going to rotate into the programma studies and these are things that we're going to rotate out that's not a guarantee the course will run right right yeah just
225because program studies and your catalog um you don't run all those courses because of signups interest whatever schedu Staffing these are the options that are available we see what the interest is and then we run the courses based on okay now that was helpful thank you yeah no problem okay all right you're good I'm going to make a motion to approve the following courses that have already been vetted by our lovely um curriculum committee so it is intro to drawing intro to 2D design 3d design AP drawing portfolio but it will not be run in the next it will not be offered next year um Essentials of English Holocaust literature LMS liter literacy strategies first aid SL CPR standards which will may be renamed at some point sports and entertainment standards Sports officiating standards World
226Sports standards yoga and mindfulness standards are different that's different oh I'm sorry I'm reading the whole thing sorry thank you yoga and mindfulness Spanish nope not Spanish uh social studies criminology social studies contemporary issues social studies the fabric of folklore myths from every corner and that's my list that yes that's it it's a bit of a delay there all right motion by same second by myself additional discussion on this one all right all those in favor please say I opposed abstained 5 Z great thank the committee thank you yes we have a meeting coming up next week so that'll be exciting um and thank you all for that um that's exciting to bring all those forward they were Great Courses to look through and um I'm excited to see what students take take up um
227okay so just moving on really quickly to a um quick recap as Brian prefaced earlier in the meeting we did have two um PD days on January 2 and third and um they were I actually got a survey cuz I wanted to get feedback from teachers but they were very well received um January 2nd teachers um um had some time to come in and prepare um for some vertical work that was done midm morning um I they did a showcase and share um where they showcased something that they do in their classrooms instructionally and they were then they went to the high school and shared instructional strategies and people thought that that was very um eye openening some of them I sat in an English discussion and the high school was like I never knew
228what it was like to have to teach somebody how to read you know so um it was they had great discussions and the unified Arts um because they don't have um vertical alignment meeting scheduled with me yet I gave them a different protocol to follow where um they did some kind of looking at their alignments and that kind of thing to do so um that was really well received as well um I had I have qu a ranking question to like did it not meet your expectations at all or did it exceed it and 96% of the responses were that it met or exceeded their expectations for that day which was really great to hear um and then um Friday we did a wellness stay for educators and um Val Lauren Taran Staples and myself
229um work to put together some breakout sessions for teachers and just really focus on you need to fill your cup in order to be your best for your students and a lot of times as teachers there's a lot of burnout because it's you just keep going and you forget to take care of yourself so um we really wanted to drill that point home and I actually had them at the end of the day write themselves a letter that gave goals in how they're going to keep their um focus on themselves in filling up their cup and they sealed the letter and I have them all and I'm going to give them back for them to open at the end of the year to see how they did towards their goals so that'll be a cool
230reflection activity for the rest of the year and my curriculum um newsletters are going to have some Focus here and there on educator wellness and just keep that reminder you need to keep taking care of yourself so you don't burn out um and that day again got really good reviews I did a f a one to five star rating and um 96% gave it a four or five star so so four and a half star review on that day H postcards oh yes the postcards were an awesome Edition that Brian brought um from B and it was so powerful to see I have a photo um of the cafeteria with all the postcards just lined up um and they were postcards for every single student in the district that the teachers came and they picked
231a postcard for students that they had some kind of connection with they wrote a note to that student um just a positive note sharing a connection of some kind with them and then those postcards were mailed out so every student in the district received a postcard from a teacher which was it was I wasn't aware that that was happening and we got one and I was like my this is the nicest thing ever yeah me too and my daughter was thrilled yeah yeah yeah it was really cool and the just the feedback like I'm not going to read all the but the teachers there were so many comments of you know best day I've ever had you know there were just so many great positive things and at first I people I think were a
232little bit reticent like I have so much stuff to do what we cannot do you know I have to work but then they kind of got into it and they were like wow okay I do need this you know now I'm rejuvenated and revived for the rest of for to start the year you know so um and I got some great suggestions cuz I asked for suggestions I don't just want people tell me all the good things that you love you know I asked for feedback and suggestions and there were some great suggestion questions on some tweaks and things to do if we were to do something like that again which I always appreciate so um all in all it was great and um I'm happy with the way that I went and yeah it
233was fun and we have a vertical alignment for ELA tomorrow all right and I saw that Mr cutter attended yeah professional development absolutely and the photo booth was a big success yes yes yes yeah thanks for it yes thank you to again to Ray Peoples for um that it was s it was like the cherry on top of everything because people had so much fun with it and he stayed there for the day and were with helping people and printing things out U printing the photos that says the Lichfield school district and the date so um it was very very well received and we really appreciate his generosity in his time and um reduction of mass reduction of the cost of everything so that was great you Mr peoples he was a great guy all
234right any questions for Dr Taylor this evening appreciate the update thank you we'll see you next week yes all right uh moving into public minutes from December 18th everyone have an opportunity to re re review the minutes excuse me yeah there's just one thing I want to clarify um in the facility section like the very beginning of it um they noted that I noted that new rules for uh state aid require districts to receive the funds in the same year they're allocated I just want to clarify it may have been a little confusing uh basically you have to you can only if you are allocated funds you can only accept that amount of funds you can't you don't get like another bite at the Apple if it wasn't the total needed so you don't have
235to receive them in the year you have the 32 months to get a uh warrant approved I just want to clarify that okay so do we need to make that update to the minutes I mean I know myself I'm on record saying it so I I don't really care if we update them but I just wanted to okay any other comments on the minutes from December 18th all right I'll make a motion to approve the minutes from December 18th second second by Miss Ames additional discussion all those in favor please say I I I opposed obained I'm going to abstain just for the sure those carry 41 all right moving into new business this evening um uh I did add uh this morning and thank you to Renee and the superintendent for adding this um
236a town warrant article discussion I wanted to talk to the board about um the the police station um similar to what the board of Selectmen did last year and had a discussion on the school right I wanted to make sure that you know we're also having discussion um before um the budget committee votes on articles like the police station and I want to make sure I represent the school board's position properly through my vote representing the school tomorrow when this is up for that vote um and so tomorrow is at the after the budget hearing I will be asked to vote on the police station and so I know my personal thoughts but what I don't know are your thoughts so um at the board of selectman meeting this uh this past Monday I know
237you're go you probably haven't watch didn't watch that one either um and that's that's okay uh the board of Selectmen uh did increase actually Mr ob's recommendation the contingency fund for the proposal for the police station from 10% to 20% just 20 yeah just 20 which increased um which increased the overall project from 5.9 is million to 6.5 million so the article for the police station will be $6.5 million um and that's what the article is going to be so there's going to be a public bond hearing on the 21st um for for the police station and again I'd just like to open it up for your thoughts on I should be working this um I understand and I'm very sympathetic to the need and you know this has been on the CIP for for
238years and in the past that the town has graciously said you know GMS is our Town's top priority we need to do something about that first before we do with police station and you know I think there's only so long you can wait before you have to do something so I completely understand why why it's being proposed post and why it's being you know why why it's on the ballot this year I one I haven't seen a lot of information other than the the recorded tours and that offers to tour the station about the process and getting to this point um what other options have they explored is a new build really the best option for the town at this point there is um just in there on on the bfield M h.gov website underneath
239the police department there was a website that I think Mr Bernell put off or somebody put off right for the new police department so if you're looking for information there sure I'm happy to yeah and I'll go take a look I just you know I know the process that we have gone through in you know deciding what path forward and we're still in that process and I just I'm I guess I'll look there and see if there's more information about the process that they went through to to propose this particular project to the town yeah I'm asham to say that I am a little naive to what they've gone through but I think it's just worth noting that the police are really important Partners For Us in abolutely education um and you know with the
240new Chief they've really been very present for us and and involved and so you know I want to extend our support to them as well I think the other thing that was really um notable is the fact that we were I mean arguably at dangerously low Staffing levels for our police department and the chief has done an excellent job of recruiting and you know ultimately we need to retain so you know if they're saying that's something that they really need that I I would give some serious thought to that the only pause I have I I think the merits are absolutely there for why this is a need the pause I have and I I hate to hate that it's being compared but the likelihood of a police station passing and then a a solution
241for GMS passing back to back year to year is very unlikely and so I I don't think taxpayers can afford it um if if already people are hurting as much as they are those are two incredibly large capital projects that we are asking the town to pay for and again I fully see the need it's been needed for a while or I thought it was going to be addressed when the fire station was built when it was a safety complex um so the need is there um but the need at GMS is there there and if it's if it's the police project or GMS as a district I I would vote for the GMS project and and again I know it's not on the ballot against each other but I I feel like as a
242school district we have to look at that elephant in the room and say that if we throw our support behind the police station that could impact the approval process of our school that being said again fully supportive of our Police Department abolutely um I'm not sure how personally I will be voting for it if that even matters but in my role here today as an elected School Board member I can't advocate for the police station over GMS and that feels like how it's being set up and while I don't like it that's the reality so that's I I think I'm with huy to a certain degree I'm not sure how I'm going to vote on it either I think the they did do a lot of research on it it was in it's probably a
243year old okay or more yeah but when the fire station was built that site work was done with the full intention of adding the police station to it that's why that whole area is flattened out so that was the long range plan I think the B was going to be a lot longer than it has been since that station was built yeah um but it is pretty tight in there yeah yeah and and are there other things that you know in are there other things that can be done you know to kind of lengthen that time you know yeah I I think they you know looked at in addition one of the things they did to save costs when they built it was not put a basement in there and if it had a basement
244I think they would be able to resolve some of their evidence storage and ammunition storage and stuff like that but it's just on a laab yeah so yeah I mean I agree with you it seems I mean you know I think that um as a school board and as a school district we need to be prioritizing um the district first and you know uh my vote and going into tomorrow and preparing for the vote um I was thinking that I would not be supportive of the police station and I just wanted to make sure that that aligned to what the board's position is at this time I mean it's reluctant I again because I fully see the need and the merits behind the project but I I just if that gets approved I I don't
245think there'll be a solution for GMS for a very very long time well thank you for entertaining discussion good um with that said and just in terms of another update on the town side the town is about 44,000 underneath the tax cap um there are a few other items that are just remaining um from a budget committee standpoint but other than that uh the budget hearing is tomorrow night 7:00 CHS Auditorium um any questions no I guess my only question is is the board planning to should we plan to attend tomorrow I mean is that are we voting afterwards or we I mean do we could we potential have to vote afterwards CH nothing can really change during the hearing I mean the budget the budget committee will be voting on their recommendations their recommendations
246sure but the Articles themselves won't change I think we went last year though didn't we we did till last year I think we sat in the auditorium I have asked the superintendent um to post a meeting just in the event that we did meet so we're covered okay right because that's been an issue for us the past it has and I we also did that posting last week when we thought we were meeting last week and then the budget committee meeting was going to be after our meeting and that then just because of Life they flipped right so um so yeah that was part of the calculus posting that meeting so y I guess I'm just looking for direction on should I plan to be there I think it's up to you okay you there
247I was planning to go I'll be there you you have to be there all right um moving into policy updates so we have no first reads at this time and we have uh a number of second reads same yeah no updates beyond the second reads we have not met yet this year I think we meet next Tuesday is recall so um we're probably going to have a bit of a delay just with the focus being on budgetary stuff holiday break um all of those things but we'll get back on track um but I haven't received any questions or did not read any feedback from the public regarding any of these policies I'm certainly happy to field any questions to the best I can um but otherwise I I'm ready to go ahead and approve these
248as a second and final read I am as well I will make a motion to approve for second read final approval policy B DH policy ebca policy J JF yeah um policy [Applause] JJ I'll second thank you yeah motion by myself second by same additional discussion all right all in favor of approving those four policies please say I I oppos abstained those four car 5 Z all right moving into Old business I will invite Mr oenus up to the table because we have facilities up next the pressure's on for me to get this right because he keeping tabs I we get the minutes yeah did most of the talking I did I actually did do the most talking at that at that meeting yeah so so lar thank you for the invite my pleasure thank
249you for being here largely the conversation was around uh getting gaining a better understanding of the high school's current capacities And discussing more about seventh and eth potentially going up there but I'll let the superintendent talk more about what he shared yeah I mean I'll try to summarize as much possible regard seeing all of it um you know we looked at uh the idea was what happens if seventh and eighth grade came up to the high school and from like a raw space standpoint yes it's doable if you take the number of classrooms that are in the building um you factor in like what their what their uses are currently right you know like uh an English classroom could be used for an English class social class Spanish class so on and so forth where
250you know an art classroom is really going to be kind of exclusive to Art smaller classrooms might be reserved for special education services so on and so forth if you looked at just just raw space like yes it's doable you can bring up two grades that' be about you know we for numberers sake we said about 90 students per grade that'd be 500 40 students in that building that building has had that capacity in it before it is doable once you kind of get over that that kind of Hump right and you talk about what is now the educational components of this type of move and like what does that do and we talked about the different things that you would have to consider for example just the schedule right like if you look at
251the high school and I I I was honest about this facilities committee former High School principal I'm a little biased towards the high school way of doing things right so you would have to kind of run the whole building most likely on some sort of block schedule like the high school does right now an AB block right that's different than what the seventh and eighth graders do right now they they do more of a seven period skinny schedule with like about 52 uh long minute long periods where the block schedule at the high school is closer to 90 minutes right so that's a change in the instruction that's a change in in approach a change in assessment that you're going to do for the kids my my point was not to say recommend or not
252recommend you just need to be aware of what you're doing you're changing the educational programming for your kids um if you make this decision and there are certainly school districts that are are set up where they have a 7 through through 12 kind of building or or mindset there and there are plenty of districts that don't right that don't have seventh and eighth grade at that kind of high school level um so you talk about the terms of scheduling credit classes versus non-credit classes you got to run them all at the same time staffing issues such as certifications right you know the run the gamut of certifications those are all things you got to kind of figure out um little decisions on who you would have in particular courses like right now for for um
253say like algebra one there are kids in the Middle School who are taking algebra one for credit for high school credit right those are typically eighth grader maybe you have a couple seventh graders in there but they middle school students all in there together right if you're going to run a four credit classes at the they're obviously running alra one at the high school right now if all these people are in the same building together are you going to have just algebra one classes period are you still going to differentiate between these are for seventh and eighth grade students versus these are for 9 through 12 students again you can go a number of different Avenues about that but you got to start making decisions on doing that the social components of putting students 7th
254through 12th in a high school obviously you have seventh graders who are as young as 13 14 years old when the school year starts and you have um High School seniors who are adults they're 18 years old right and you're going to have that in the same same building um you have the social aspects of that and then sharing common spaces they' be sharing restrooms sharing other of those areas locker rooms I made the joke that kids seem to to change anymore in locker room so maybe it's an irrelevant conversation but certainly when I was in high school we were using locker room showering and doing all those things in there I know it's a different time and age but you're going to have all these interactions you're going to have seventh and eighth graders
255exposed to adult to kids who can drive who can self transport which is been big thing right you know um you know right now we have freshman who theoretically could hop in a car with with an with an older student they're a little bit mature on that but now you're you're opening the Avenue for seventh and eighth graders saying it's impossible these are just things you need to kind of consider and know what you're you're getting into um lunch things you want to make decisions around that you have kids intermingle you can have great exclusive lunches you're going to increase the number of lunches you're going to have to at least have four I think with that cafeteria depending on how your schedule breaks you might need five you might not if you're going to
256mix them all together so on and so forth so in uh 2008 my son graduated 2008 was a big there was a big was 580 kids or whatever it was and I asked him how many lunches you have he's I don't remember yeah yeah I went outside and smoke during [Laughter] lunch nobody's watching I'm he's not our viewership is at an all-time high remember and I also asked him about the other second principal yeah and he didn't think they had another a second principal so sort of questions for you yeah you can go back and look he said there was somebody else who was sort of in charge but it was not a principal it was some other role yeah so that's one things like Staffing you have to kind of talk about there's little
257things that you might save money on Staffing you might have to spend more money on Staffing or it might be neutral right that was one of the examples I used right if you're looking at 540 kids for argument sake Bo high school which I just left had about 600 kids right we have two assistant principal like positions one was your classic assistant principal and one was an AC academic Dean but you had two people kind of under your principle because of the vast number with and all the issues not issues but everything that has to be solved right there right now what we're structured is just the principle and the AP right so there be a consideration would you need to add that you know every school district's different in that context and but that's
258a consideration you have to do you would have to think about um you know little I use this as a i as I hope was a simple example like right now the nurse's office at the high school is just the nurse and she can she can handle all the foot traffic that comes in and out of it um if you you're adding two more grades into there particularly younger students who will more frequently access the the nurses we have data that shows the the younger the kid the more frequently they visit the nurse um that's unique not unique to this District that's unique to schools in general would you need some sort of assistant in the office to just help with the foot traffic part-time full-time do you have to change someone's like do you
259shift someone part of the day over there those are just considerations that you have to kind of weigh and like when you talk about the Staffing you can't split Staffing right it's you can't necessarily take half of the people at the middle school and then move those people up to the high school to fill those spots like on paper sure right like you're moving half the kids out of that building take half the adts with them right but for example a subject like the the um the tech class down down uh in the middle school that's access by all four grades so only half of his case load is seventh and eighth graders you can't split him in a half so maybe there's something you do you know some schools have teachers float between buildings
260there's pros and cons all that um maybe there's capacity at the high school with some those teachers to do that already maybe there's not these are all just considerations you kind of have to kind of start slowly chipping away at and kind of figuring out if you want to do that but fundamentally it's going to change your educational programming for your kids again I'm not saying it's going to be better or worse but it's going to change there's no way around that right you're going to have the S through 12 kids in in that High School bill for argument sake we'll call it junior high high school right there right the the Middle School the building in the middle right would likely in this kind of math be a three through six school at that
261point you have to make some decisions on how you're going to educate those kids you know the the reflexive answer is it becomes more of an elementary model again where those fifth and sixth graders are going to come back to a classroom based schedule because you certainly going to keep those third and fourth graders in that classroom based schedule right that doesn't mean it will be exactly the same in third grade and fourth grade right now the middle school is not the same Fifth and eighth are different there's differences between that and everything like that look at the elementary school kindergarten different fourth grade there there's certainly differences but it's going to be more of a shift into that educa in that Elementary mindset if the grades in there are 3 through six again I'm
262not saying there's pros and cons about that but there are pros and cons you just have to work through that it's a change on what that building is it's clearly a classic middle school right now 5 through 8 it would not be that classic middle school if it was 3 through six right I don't think that building has capacity to add to it right like I I don't think the result is this is you're down to two buildings with the buildings that you have you still have we looked at trying to put an addition on there would be yeah and even if it was possible that time has probably passed with with the renovations that you did to that building so you would still have that kind of third building you know in this scenario
263here you're talking probably prek through 2 I think to do the 7 through 12 at at Campbell you would have to move the sa out and naturally end up where that prek through 2 building is right like the 30s building is the natural answer to that if you were to move the SAU out that's what PL of districts do they go to their their oldest Schoolhouse and convert it into an SAU um so like you would you would look at those type of things you got to look at that prek through 2 that's a very different feeling school than like a prek through 4 school again not good or bad there there are towns that have those those type of schools it's just different it's a different environment the Staffing is also not clean right
264like it's just not going to be clean breaks that you might save some need for Staffing in certain places you may not in others right if you made that determination they use that assistant principle like position like whether it ends up being a classic assistant principal or something else if you determine that was necessary in the 7 through 12 building you can't just pull a person from one of the other buildings that Middle School of the group would still have four grades and have need the second administrator there that administrator at the elementary level Mora right now kind of doubles as someone who helps out a lot with special ed that's pretty classic in the elementary kind of mindset because there's so much of that starting at that age group right everyone's kind of entering
265the system so you're not necessar neily going to pull that position and move them up to the high school so you it's not as clean as just like take X people and put them here and it works is it possible sure like you have the raw space to do it right but then you have to consider as a community these are all the educational and other components that kind of bounce off of it and stuff like that so the reason why this conversation is happening is because uh you know ultimately we as a committee felt like we needed to talk about at least the top three responses that we got the surveys the surveys are are only one component of the analysis the next component of the analysis is going to be the grid that
266we're creating that will basically look at uh each of the options and talk about how they satis how they how well they satisfy different needs that we have whether they're educational needs or you know just physical building needs um and that is going to largely be developed keeping the timeline in mind they the committee is well aware of that um you know we have the upcoming outsite Insight conversation and I think once that happens that will'll be finalized and we'll be able to um get a better idea of how those things match up uh Brian one thing we had asked about and you uh talked about is whether you can move just eighth grade up there versus seven and eight yeah I I would as I said to me I would strongly oppose that I
267think you can run into a number of issues when you just moved to one grade and a not saying athlet is the end all be all but it's the cleanest example of moving just one grade up right like what do you do with those eighth graders for athletics right they can't play on the high school teams yet I mean you could technically start them but it clock it starts out you only get four seasons right what I'd like to propose this is all very important conversations I believe at our next week's meeting January 22nd right we have the representative from onsite Insight scheduled to present to us I'd like to Mr please come and join us than I think most of our commit everyone's intending to right please come let's have let's have a longer
268keeper conversation with onsite Insight let's have a a longer it's :00 right let's have a longer conversation on facilities I think with tonight's meeting um you know being kind of heavier on agenda stuff I think next week's meeting is probably going to be a little bit lighter on agenda stuff Mak him wrong that's a request I mean hopefully from a from a budget it's going to be it we got the program of studies I don't know how in depth or not in depth you you all get on get in on that you know um and that onsite Insight presentation I think you know that's that's the presentation next right yeah Mr C I did send you the meeting minutes and it has all the stuff he presented so that should be helpful for you to
269I did read through it thank you thank you well point being right hopefully next week we can have a deeper conversation when it's not 9:00 at night on all facilities and right really us some thought about everything that can just present Y sound good that's great perfect why don't we do that okay um school board comments none none none okay um manifest do we have three signatures on the Manifest this evening yeah they come back yes I have okay and there's a manifest overview added so just a quick summary of manifest from December 18th we have manifest payroll from December 18th of $383,500 uh there was a man a manifest of a one check payroll of $12.52 again this is all from December 18th accounts payable manifest of 37,38 128 um there was a manifest
270for Lea and lssa dues 14,1 13810 uh 403b deductions and nhr deduction s manifest $233,200 70 as well as a credit card manifest of $ 41,47 47 all right anything else from a manifest perspective Su ises that summary work y works for y quick and easy absolutely all right with that uh that will conclude our public session this evening the board does have a couple of matters to discuss in nonpublic session this evening under RSA 91 A3 C specifically uh and with that I'll entertain a motion to go in and on public by Mr Shoemaker second by Miss Ames all those in favor please say I I I opposed abstained that carries 5 Z again our next meeting is uh well technically tomorrow because we have a posted meeting at the budget hearing but also
271next week January 22nd thanks all have a great evening