CorpusRecord 95034

Planning Board Meeting - 1/7/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / LitchfieldTV
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Hillsborough County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,812 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-12

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay um the first item on tonight's uh agenda is public input on non-agenda items items not on the agenda for this evening is there any public input related to non-agenda items this evening okay seeing none I will close public input on non-agenda items uh we will go to the first order of business this year this evening is the public hearing per New Hampshire RSA 675 col 7 to permit a mixed use Village Development uh alternative in the northern commercial District as a conditional use by amending section 803 conditional uses to include a new subsection e uh the full text is available at the Town Hall selectman's viewing room or on the website Lichfield uh new hampshire. goov planning board portal under the governments tab portal link to the left um is the applicant here this

002evening this is oh is it a public a public he with the applicant well I know Mr Sho was here um certainly this evening um for this and um so this is a public hearing regarding the mix use development um does anybody from the public want to speak so come forward Rick Shino for and child's bankra High the only um thing I have on this is on number five three number five has not less than 100 200 F feet so if that could stay at 100 instead of 200 okay that could be left at 100 and the reason for that we talked about at the last meeting I was okay with it in my mind I was counting the stuff on the other side of the road and I can't do that and it would

003really hurt a smaller development if it was at 200 so 100 is really a better number okay that's it everything else is great great thank you anybody else wish to comment tonight on this um public hearing regarding mixed use Village Development come forward state your name and address uh Jason Brennan 23 aldd Street uh I've been tracking this for a few years now I think it's a a pretty good idea uh for for three reasons it's a good opportunity for the developer in the town to like work together to create something something that's unique within the community um I like the village concept there are you know in town we really don't have a main street I don't see this ever being Tuscan Village Junior but it could be something we do have the bike

004path we do have it's in a a a high visibility part of town uh I think that we have the opportunity here to maybe create something that's unique where people in town can get on the bike path go to some sort of Village type of green area be able to have a sprinkling of Residential Properties around there as well as be able to have some commercial properties a coffee shop and so on so it could create something unique and that's what uh one of the things I like and the last thing is is that you know this is probably one of the most visible pieces of property in town and realistically what would go there now you're not going to put a Walmart there there's not going to be a Walgreens there's not going to

005be any of that someone could come in tomorrow and actually put in storage facilities or a warehouse and the last thing I want to see personally when I drive down 3A and take a left on the Albuquerque is a big Warehouse something is going to be built there someday unless the owner of the property wants to donate to the town which I don't think is is actually going to happen something is going to be built there someday and I think this provides the opportunity for the town and the developer to work together to create something that's mutually benefit official as far as the numbers go the 100 200 the density that's your job but I'm just going to State my opinion on the on the other side okay thank you anybody else want to comment

006regarding the mixed use Village Development yeah Miss gandi I'm sorry for Laur gandia 3 chamberling drive here obviously in lynchfield and I'm just now looking at this this um just a little bit of concern of I just a quick perusal is the fiscally balanced way language um in u e um so a wide variety of housing types in a fiscally balanced way not quite sure how that should be interpreted and again if we have stuff in there we want to make sure we know how we're going to interpret that language and for 10 um shall be submitted for approval by the planning board to ensure that a harmonious development patent and a positive fiscal balance is maintained not quite sure what that means and how the town is going to ensure that that is maintained

007so if we can't ensure that then I would recommend removing that just to avoid confusion yeah in that case the there are generally parts of a development that cost more to the town or would be more valuable in tax dollars and we would want to make sure that the more expensive to the town parts are not built first because like in marac the they had a mix use development and they didn't end up building the commercial part because there was only demand for apartments not commercial in in that part of marac so basically they would have to make sure that at least if the commercial part is the one that's more fiscally um beneficial to the town that would have to be built first or at the same time as the residential um in they

008can do it in phases but if you they would have to have some commercial and some residential and then some more commercial and then some more residential or all the commercial than the residential if that is deemed to be fiscally balanced yes J if I there are no guarantees obviously um but uh the mechanism is on page two subsection 8 uh so a physical impact study would be required as a part of the process so that would be the mechanism for making the determination right and and I understand that but it just said is maintained so just make and I get this the timing phrasing the timing and phasing plan just bringing that to attention for further thought if the board thinks that it's necessary to um just give that a little bit more thought

009just with the wording that's it okay thank you thank you anybody else okay Jay do you have any thing that you'd like to add regarding the uh um not uh not really I I think we know we've we've talked about this several times we just did get some input this evening uh one on subsection 5 um you changing it uh from 200 to 100 square F feet and obviously some concern uh related to uh using the word maintaining maybe it could be providing um so you know I think otherwise it' be up to the will of the board I do think that uh even changing the uh 200 to 100 is a substantive change so um you know if it's the will of the board uh to make that change uh it would need to

010go to a second public which timing wise was not was than 100 the I yeah I I realized there was an error last time and um keeping the language 100 and changing the 200 but the intent was 200 that's why I think it's a substantive change and not a grammatical error I mean granted it's not a huge change but sufficiently substantive that I think we should hold um plan hold a second public he which I believe we still have the time to do in time for the next meeting does the board have any question so I was looking through this I was um wondering why we don't allow any um hotels or bed and breakfasts in the northern commercial District I don't have an answer for that because I I would I did some very

011quick research and it is a it is one method of Economic Development because of course it attracts people to come to us and they would likely use the neighboring businesses um like obviously they a higher density option but we can probably have regulations that bit the feel of the neighborhood obviously there would it would they would not be able to build the same size hotel or Bed and Breakfast as you can in Manchester but we're close to the our regional airport so I'm curious what other people would think about some um permit having some level of it allowed any thoughts Sho I know you had your handle just a question to that you're limited to a six unit building right I think that so how would that fall in how would a hotel fall into

012that I think that was removed I I believe that that was just residential but I do think we removed that limit but if well but what would you yeah we remove that limit okay okay so it wouldn't matter okay do you think what do you think the town would think of it because that's what matters um I believe an Airbnb would fit easily a hotel like kind of I don't know if you would have a large enough hotel to to even bring in value cuz then you got to rely on like a septic system or in Airbnb you could rent out a room or two that's not that much of a demand on the system but a hotel I would think you'd need a fairly large Hotel just to profit off it potentially yeah I

013read that hotels are not the most profitable business um without like tax breaks and stuff um but I guess in this situation the the main value would be to the neighboring businesses which may may make the hotel itself not financially viable yeah and then with the as you said the airport very close by would be a could add that as a draw cuz yeah the probably the more fitting alternative to a hotel for Lichfield would be a bed and breakfast which isn't an airbn isn't NE Airbnb has bed and breakfast in its name but it's I'd say that's different um though you a bed and breakfast can use a service like that for it I think a lot of the uses are going to be dictated by the fact that you don't have septic and

014you don't have you know well you've got water but you don't have septic there and that's that's going to dictate the size of the building I mean if I'm a going out of my way to yeah to put in all that if it's not going to right and if it's a resid if you're dealing with residential I mean I would think you know know the businesses would have to cater to that res the community itself know just don't see how a hotel fits into that I think the hotel would also fall into the 10,000 square ft or less just to align with you know what we have here convenience stores Health and Beauty yeah like obviously I don't know what's size would be commercially viable right and the question is should we allow it and

015then the developers choose if it's commercially viable or not or just not permitted at all well you could sort of split the difference in the sense that you could say bed and breakfast but not you know yeah not implying hotels or motels you know yeah yeah a motel would not fit the a bed breakfast I you could put that in as a conditional use I think that that would probably be acceptable St and that would be how would we categorize that in terms of the village because I think it would make more sense in the village because a bed and breakfast would create would have visitors who would want to use the nearby businesses potentially um I I think got to be a little realistic too I mean this is the town of Lichfield it's

016not like we're not like North Conway or you know um up in the north country where you know people get tourists and people are coming in to you know visit and you know having a bed and breakfast is a nice thing and all that stuff I mean the town of Litchfield is it's I mean I'm not saying it's not touristy but it's it's it's a little different you know Vibe I think you know what I'm saying um so we have to be not a destination well I wouldn't say necessarily a destination but I mean it's a nice place to visit but it's I don't think it's something I can't just I can't picture a bed and breakfast I mean I can picture it in North Conway or somewhere where you know people go or tourists

017and visit and you know do all that stuff but I don't know you can come here to golf stay in the night like honestly speaking the only thing that would make a hotel or Bed and Breakfast viable there is probably the during the uh Halloween season with the Spooky World that's probably the only thing that would make that viable tires but even still I mean I think you have to be realistic I mean in terms of our town I mean I think it's you know it's a nice idea but I think I would rather have that you know in a place where you know if you're going to have a tourist destination that's more practicable but Jay there's a list of uses that this points to anyway right well instead of pointing to that list

018we just repeated the things in that list that we wanted here uh so if we wanted to add something different we could because we're not pointing back yeah so step on up state your name yes George lavash 13 Pearson Street Richfield um I'm just looking at some of the the numbers here um you have a minimum uh density of 2.5 units per acre um let's say we had a 20 acre development all right so you would have have to have um 40 50 um units on that 20 acre parcel uh 20% of the area Site Area has to be dedicated to internal space so that's 4 Acres of your 20 acres have to be um open to Green Space if you have 50 um Apartments you now have to have 100 sare ft so that's

019well it's only 5,000 sare ft of um I was thinking it was going to be 50,000 ft so it's 5,000 ft of of um commercial space for one for a second there I thought it was going to be 50,000 so I guess that will work out so I was just wondering out of your 20 acres your two have to be open space you need parking areas and then you're going to require them to have at least 50 apartments or um housing units on there so I I when I first read this I thought it was weird that you had a minimum density for apartments was that a um did you do that on purpose yeah the minimum was added last meting last meeting cuz the hired like part of the purpose of this Village is

020to have um have the residential theoretically support the commercial um and if you have more people living right now next the commercial they would the businesses would be more likely to have users from the adjacent property um or same property if it's on one lot and if the V the density is too low there would not be a lot of people to come over and use the commercial properties okay so that was just my you know I just looking at the numbers was it going to work and you know you are forcing the the 50 thank you anybody else come on yes uh Laur gandia 3 chambering drive and I was just looking at this from a zoning lens so number nine because any of these conditions I believe and I haven't looked at it

021could be uh somebody could come to the planning board for a variance is that correct Jay to the Z board to the own board for a variance yes so if you look at number nine it says the planning board shall determine whether the proposed uses so on and so forth so I'm thinking the wording of that number nine should be changed and I don't know why the planning board shall deter shall shall determine anything about the proposed uses if they're already an allowed use um so I'm thinking that that number nine should be re re Rewritten to um be something like this the building design and Landscape shall be compatible with the character of the area so I think what we had there is a little bit um hard to really get a good handle

022on and I think if somebody wanted to wave the plan board shell determine I don't think that's a provision that we would want to have somebody come to us to say that the plane board can or cannot do something um so that's why again if it and again the proposed uses are allowed so I don't think the planning board should have the ability to determine the compatibility of a proposed use if it's an allowed use we're already saying that it's an allowed use in the zoning so again the building design and Landscaping shall be compatible with the character of the area would be my suggestion thanks thank you anybody else okay all right um so I think if there's nobody else that's going to comment tonight on public input for this um I'm going to

023close public input um on this subject um and I'm going to bring it back to the board um and what is the what does the board want to see happen next so yeah we should probably revise some of the wording um as discussed do you have comments on that yes so I think we just heard the comments on nine um I know I think you probably struck more words that I might but the planning board shall determine whether the building design Landscaping is compatible you said with the Char with the character of the area I think you're dropping mixed commercial residential and historic character um you want me to respond yeah right yes but I also took out the plan aboard shell determine you just put I put the building design and Landscaping shall be

024compatible okay so I I think just from a zoning point of view having the planer board shall determine if somebody wants to come for a waiver for that that's problematic all right so so that was one suggested change we also though had the comment on 10 the concern um I I think in particular it's that the positive fiscal balance is maintained some concern that that might be interpreted that down the road somebody could say gee it's no longer positive so perhaps the that could be worded to in the middle of the section um submit it for approval by the planning board perhaps it could simply strike the rest of that and say instead to encourage harmonious fiscally balanced development pth encourage harmonious pH so we're just encouraging it we're saying that that's the goal but

025we're striking the a positive fiscal balance is maintained if that makes sense yeah it's possible unless like if we want to clarify the what the fiscal balance is maintained during we could say during All Phases of the project building phases of the project yeah I think that the concern though is that down the road it could become a zoning issue um so so 10 years from now could somebody come and say gee you're now in violation because we've run a new fiscal analysis and you're that commercial building is vacant you're no longer yeah that's why I said for all building phases more planned building phases and like I wonder if they could incorporate build phases if planned dur into the fiscal impact study um because theoretically all the data in the fiscal impact study is

026there on this use cost a this and brings this U tax revenu to town and this your fiscal impact study would incorporate All Phases of course yeah so I think yeah I think there all as long as that is provided and we don't see anything wrong with it that I think would satisfy that assuming they build according to their planned phase if they deviate from the the phas plan is there a there it's actionable for the town right well if they if they deviate from the the plan they have to go back and get another fisical impact study don't they well they have to come if you deviate from the plan you have to come back to the board so you're the plan is a you've got a phasing plan that's approved you've got so

027any deviation from the plan has to come back to the board or it's in violation yeah I wonder if we could just clarify eight to specify um for All Phases proposed phases of the project um to basically ensure that the fiscal impact study includes the phases and then for 10 we just require that the commercial and residential are built at the same time we certainly could you think that would solve the concerns I don't think so because I think say the project is all built and it was fully compliant when it was built 5 years down the road 10 years down the road could someone say gee the store is vacant now or the residential units the value has declined because now we're in a recession and condo values are have declin 30% and if

028I were to run a fiscal impact analysis now maybe it's not positive so would they be in violation of the zoning ordinance because that I think that's that's the question it's not the compliance at the time of development it's yeah that's yeah that's why I'm saying for eight the fiscal impact study it just has to be provided to the satisfaction of the board which is a onetime thing at the time of the application and then we can revise 10 to remove the fisical part from that and just require the residential commercial to [Music] together so strike positive fiscal balance from 10 those were those but make up for it by clarifying in eight that they have to include it for All Phase proposed phases we could do that and where in eight would we add

029the Clos about All Phases at the end of the sentence the end I think it's redundant though because effectively the fiscal impact study is going to include All Phases right yeah I mean it's implied right so and if they change phing they need to come back to us anyway but theoretically they could as worded if we ignore 10 and just look at eight if we want to just move all the burden for the fiscal thing 28 then they could just have it so that the last phase of the project is the one that helps the town and say when it's built it does it doesn't work that way because when they when they produce the fiscal impact study at the at the onset right it's going to have all of those components it'll have them

030all have been but approved our goal is to make it so that they don't build certain phases and then stop before a phase that is the one that is profitable to the town um we don't want the burdensome ones to be built first and then the valuable ones that are built later um like we don't want the res if if residential is deemed more burdensome we don't want that built all of it and then the developer to go bankrupt and then no commercial is built or they just determine that oh that's not viable anymore we're just not going to BU build it um so we so are you relying on us to make that decision of what financially viable at which point in time we would want that to all be in the fiscal impact

031study if if possible so I think the goal would be to have the physical impact study demonstrate they would have to specify the phases and then demonstrate that each phase is fiscally beneficial to the town right I I get what you're saying so I think we need to make that explicit so they don't phase it in a way that in the end it's good for the town if everything works but if they stop halfway it's better for the town so it would be a net positive fiscal impact to the town for each phase of the development exactly and then you could strike it from 10 yeah I think that addresses the concern sense could do that okay and then 10 we can strike it all or we can still require commercial and residential portions um

032yeah could still keep the all of that sentence just strike the positive impact because you're still asking that they put in a timing and phasing plan exactly so I think that so you're incorporating all of 10 minus the end okay and all the all of the intent of that part of 10 is now in eight y right and you're just striking those three words positive fiscal balance from 10 is yeah exactly and then do we want to permit not that it will happen but do we want to permit bed and breakfast in in the uh Village I mean I don't see a reason why not considering that they're allowed in the northern commercial Zone um I think the only reason that perhaps they weren't like included on this list is something that was like encouraged

033is cu I guess I could see like a realm where it's not exactly harmonious with like residential but I don't I don't know if we if that's a decision we want to make I I don't know if that was why it was excluded um but I don't see a reason why not yeah the you can interpret it in different ways um but like I think the way to think of it is it'll probably be a small one realistically speaking it will be uh probably utilized most in the Halloween season um and most likely they would if there's a nice restaurant there they'd probably go to it so like it'd be interesting to hear more from residents on that but um think yeah so then you should probably label it bed and breakfast or in yeah

034so how would the in um because the in an in has a full service restaurant that doesn't just cater to its patrons it open to the the yeah good point yeah yeah that would make sense yeah I think so add that as m in the yep use commercial uses and of course they would have to go to the state for the permit to make sure that the U septic works but that will be the responsibility of the applicant in the state anyone is everyone okay with adding that I'm not opposed to again I'm not opposed I mean I guess I'm not opposed to it I would just say thinking realistically I mean we're allowing it I understand what you're saying but I'm just again be realistic never know you never know you're right I I

035mean it's yeah that's true now we got the Holly Jolly Journey during Christmas that's true maybe it'll maybe that'll you can't just say it's Halloween anymore yeah okay flying to Manchester I know right yeah I think that would be didn't know if you were going to bring up the 200 um square feet but that was a that was a very detailed discussion last time and it's it was in the minutes and um yes it was we gave a lot of thought around that and we didn't want it 100 why we did want it 200 we could do 125 um not splitting the difference to 150 just we want it to be viable I guess what does that mean right so 200 versus 100 our discussion as I recall last time was wanting to make sure

036that we had a good balance if I recall the conversation maybe I'm a little fuzzy from before Christmas and everything thing but the whole idea was a nice balance um in the neighborhood so yeah if if we have 35 Acres let's say and we have four units per acre and we require 200 square ft per unit that would be 28,000 Square ft whereas if we require uh 100 it's half that um so 100 uh so 14,000 square ft um so if we picture the size of 14,000 square feet 14,000 square feet is like the size of a CVS I mean just for perspective y yeah a bigger Town CVS cuz we'll allow C there we'll we'll allow a CVS here but it will have to be no more than 10,000 ft um I guess the

037question comes down to as a minimum yeah what's what's really viable it's too viable yeah there one more viable yeah the goal is to promote the commercial development that the town appears to want so well I am not an expert in this so so it was originally one and then we changed it to two last time and what what did you use to DET determine the initial I I I think the 100 was a kind of looking at a couple of things so looking at the types and sizes of uses that back when this was originally put together we thought were viable um for Lichfield uh and also looking at that 10,000 square foot Max that we had put on um you know multiple uses individual buildings so it was just kind of one of

038those looking at the parcels that we have thinking about the size of the kinds of things that um seem to be seem to make sense for Lichfield which do tend to be smaller scale of course you can have a little you know strip mall type thing multiple tenant space so um but what's I guess that's really what it comes down to I I don't I wouldn't say that an economic analysis went into it um it was more thinking about what's realistic yeah so looking at the square footage if we require 200 it would most likely be like two small pharmacies and one small thing versus one Pharmacy in one small thing for a scale doesn't have to be that yeah or you could think Corning Farm is it a 5,000 foot commercial building added to

039Corning Farm or is it a roughly and again kind of what does that look like if you kind of visualize those little groups of tow houses picture one of those becomes a commercial building in terms of scale yeah and that would be for five the yeah I don't yeah I'm slightly conflicted I think you know we could definitely doesn't have to be one or the other it can be some in between also than we can make substantive changes tonight but not after tonight so kind of want to make a decision we think works yep or if you left it more conservative and then if they came to you would would you be able to issue a variance for something more or now planning board couldn't we can't well this this is a minimum so you

040could you can go higher it's it's which you can't go below but the planning board could not so if we say it to 200 and the developers don't think it's viable they would have to go to the zoning board and then a precedent would be set well that's if they ran it they may or may not right realistically speaking like one of those tow houses as commcial would probably be what you can expect to be viable in which field on that plot of land is that what you're saying yeah in that proportion that's overly commercial do you yeah that it's not going to change the character too much yeah at the that's at the 100 200 double that so I guess end of the day you want to make sure that we don't create something

041that isn't going to have any takers yeah yeah I don't know like it'd be interesting to break down the percentage of lvi residents that want commercial because it helps their taxes and the percent of people who want commercial because they can shop there um because I'm sure those that just want it to help their taxes don't want it to grow too much but those that want it for their taxes probably want as much as you can get there and and that I I can answer uh I can say with a survey that was done by the economic development committee at least to me my takeaway was when you when people were asked the kinds of things that they wanted to see in town most of those tended to be things that were places to gather

042or that you know places that people thought were attractive they wanted to go to coffee shops and bakeries and that was the kind of response we got it so and those are not big they don't have to be big right so we can go on the small end of this and still meet that goal anyone else have thoughts yeah I mean I think I don't know I mean I think we just leave it at 100 but that's just my my opinion now that would be changing it back to 100 Chang it back to 100 yeah well technically it says one and then the attention was true yeah um I don't think you're going to do gross harm by putting it to 100 that's my opinion it's still the developer's responsibility to prove that's fiscally beneficial

043yeah nobody wants to move a business then the other that's going to fail so you know yeah so since we have the fiscal impact study I don't think we have to be too strict as long as there it appears to be according to the math fiscally viable uh or beneficial to the town and I'd say let's not be overly restrictive so is anyone opposed to not anyone opposed to reverting back to 100 no versus the alternative of what they can do with it now no okay so anything else and just one comment um the internal Green Space like there's a good chance that that's probably just going to be septic fields um so it's I doubt it will be burdensome at all I'd hope it'd be a little more than that hopefully um yeah like

044if it was a village really dense Village then it would if they if they put him in the front then it would be if it's in the back then it wouldn't be but yeah F candy canes coming up mushrooms yeah very great okay so the changes that we are going to make are revising uh bullets 8 and 10 clarifying the 100 or going back to 100 the the potential in and bed and breakfast use which most likely won't happen but we'll be per subed um is that all the changes yes okay so we probably have to have another have a motion for a public hearing at the next this will be a motion to send it to Second public hearing on the on January 21st as amended okay so I'll make a motion to uh

045send the um proposed zoning amendments uh for the second public hearing on January 21st 2025 all right I have a motion by Jared do I have a second second second by any uh further discussion all right all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I those opposed abstained motion passes two 70 okay very good we will have another public hearing okay all right moving on uh next item on the agenda this evening is the subdivision application for one lot into two at 288 Charles bankra Highway tax map 12 Lot 29 creating two residential lots with one access from Route 3A the applicant is David hywell is that how you spell it uh owners wi Winford van Mur and Kimberly Queen and are the applicants here this evening anybody representing the applicant

046yeah so if you guys want to come to the table um introduce yourselves to the board how you guys doing good Dave LOL my name is Joel Conley I'm with the debay group I'm the surveer record on this um so this is a um I believe is a subdivision application um and board should have received copies of that uh so this is the other one um so typically what we do when we do an a site plan application so you uh submitted your your plan review and certain documents required um so Joan I'm going to ask have all fees been paid and all AB Butters not ified for this application subis paid and the buts notified December 26 okay um Jay have you had an opportunity to take a look at this plan and it

047looks through to your satisfaction it's complete and required um so first we have to accept the application for its completeness um and seeing that all fees have been paid all the butters have been notified and um that we have all of the paperwork necessary to complete complete for the application I'll entertain a motion to accept the application for completeness for this project so moved I have a motion do I have a second again second any uh further discussion all right this is for voting on the acceptance of the application for its completeness all those in favor um please signify by saying I I was opposed abstained all right motion passes 700 okay so now that we've accepted the application for its completeness um I allow the applicant to um explain what it is that they

048are proposing uh for this subdivision I'll let yeah I'll let Joel go with that all right so um this is uh paral land that um was um somewhat recently approved to have a a Winer interview inard on it um so they've halfway constructed that they the buildings shells there and everything else um but they stopped construction on that and um my client's purchasing the land and his intent is to convert the um building into a residential dwelling um that was going to be a winery um and so do so we need to subdivide the lot into two uh to separate that from the existing house so we don't have two residences on one lot um so it's in we're going to basically the water service is already um across the street and everything you know

049um so we still need to do the you know septic and all that other stuff associated with the house but that's um separate um we've done all our test bits and everything um it currently has a driveway permit um for a residence in a winery so we'll have to update that when it gets converted to a residence to have two resids um they're going to share the existing same driveway um so we're not not changing anything so we don't see any issue with that um it's actually I mean a lesser impact on the you know as far as the driveway um a single residence versus a winery um the uh the existing houses and barns are kind of in you know um the buffers to that Wetland over there but um there's no other new

050construction that's going to be impacting any of those type areas um the you know lots both meet all the Min requirements Frontage area um all the different variations of areas um shape Factor we're all met so um it's pretty that it's pretty straightforward there's nothing you know too crazy that we're doing here it's you know so not there's no necessarily new construction that you know just going to finish off the construction of that house and converting it to a um residential dwelling so and I'll ask you is there any Regional impact to this project probably not right I don't think so the application says there is none no that's cor so but for the record I'll just there don't Regal impact so um anything else think is there anything else you want to add to

051that no uh just looking to live here and uh not change anything you know just uh it's my understanding um and I'm naive to this but you can't have two two dwellings on one piece of property so thus the subdivision but um that stretch of road uh seems like it's sacred land I'd like to keep it that way just occupy it by living in there um and uh not make any impacts or changes other than converting it to a living space that's it okay very good uh Jay did you have anything you'd like to add uh just a couple things of course as they noted update the driveway permit just two other things um for for the uh plan well one for the plan uh you should just add the impact fee calculations yeah yeah

052yeah sent them those over so I've added those to the plan um and uh then other than that uh there is a you know joint access agreement in utility eement uh so we should just uh have those approved by Town Council okay all right good does the board have any questions um for the applicant I have a question yeah um actually all of you is it is there precedent in town for shared driveways oh yeah okay yeah there are subdivisions that have shared driveways never been a good idea but it does exist okay no worries yeah I know um you originally went to the zoning board to try to get reduced Frontage to have three lots right correct and did you determine that it would not be viable to put in a little tiny Road

053to increase your Frontage and have three lots yeah I mean we kind of looked at it I mean it I mean you still get three lots you put a road in I mean it's going to be kind of a big expense to put a road in um when you're basically just adding one lot you already have the two there um so basically you're just getting one one additional lot for an expense of of Road um and just way the shape of it you kind of have to come back pretty far to get a road get all your shape factors get um building envelope was kind of really one of the challenging ones when I kept looking at different shapes in here um mostly because of that wetland in the front corner um kind of really

054just messed with the whole the whole thing as far as shape factors um you know all the setbacks plus you get the front 50 foot setback so then you really start getting into a lot of challenges you'd have to pretty much take out that house that's there on the front to do it okay great anything else on the board all right at this time I will open it up to public uh input is there any members of the public that would wish to comment on this uh site plan application this evening okay all right seeing known I will close public input and come back to the board um would the board to do it's pretty straightforward subdivision application um so we can certainly conditionally approve it uh with those provisors that um the um easements

055and documents will be reviewed by Town Council and um that uh the impact fee calculations be added to the plan um as proposed so it's um so the conditions would be the impact fees shown on the plan approval of the accessing utilities eement by Town Council and uh the the town standard conditions of approval anything else I think that's it okay any more discussion before I make a motion go ahead so I'll make a motion to approve the proposed uh subdivision for existing Lot 12 map 12 Lot 29 into two residential lots with the uh conditions um being uh impact fees shown approval of accessing utility disas Me by Town Council and the town standard conditions of approval okay I have a motion by Jared do I have a second I second the motion okay

056any further discussion all right we'll take a vote all those in favor of the application um for the 288 Charles bankr Highway subdivision please signify for the conditional approval signify by saying I I I those opposed anybody abstained all right motion passes 70 thank you gentlemen thank you got that street number yes yeah the street number did that yeah it's already on the plan two and theith number will carry over to the other lot so get three digits yep so yeah dash one [Music] perfect yeah you can grab it oh oh you need the cor all right the next item on the agenda this evening subdivision application you're good with three lots into I'm sorry application of three lots into to three lots at 157 158 and 164 Charles bankra highway map 6 Lots 3235

05736 ownership applicants D Roa Family Trust and Cecil and claudet de roer applicant Lichfield Conservation Commission the intent of the application is to subdivide map 6 lot 32 and adjust the lot line between map 6 lot 35 and 36 resulting in two building Lots one on the east side and one on the west side of Route 3A and the two conservation Lots um if the uh after mentioned subdivision applications are accepted notice is hereby extended application approval consideration and or continuation to a date certain as required and I assume the applicant is here this evening I see uh folks from the Conservation Commission and dubet group welcome why don't you guys introduce yourselves to the board and your address uh I'm Jason Brennan Conservation Commission Vice Chair George lash Conservation Commission alternate member welcome Joel

058Conley debate group welcome gentlemen so uh the board does have an application uh before them this evening um we're going to do the same thing as we did with the previous application tonight we're going to do a um see if we can accept the application for its completeness before we proceed um I will ask Joan have all abuts been notified and all fees paid yes abutters were notified again December 26th and fees have been waved as it is a town agency okay um I see the application we have um Jay have you had an opportunity to review this application this evening for this evening and um do you do we have all of the required documents we need okay thank you all right and um seeing that we have all um butter has been notified

059all fees paid and the um required documents I would entertain a motion to accept for completeness so moved I have a motion by Travis do I have a second second second by Russ any further discussion all right all those in favor of the motion for the application for acceptance for completeness please signify um or I should say the motion to accept the application for completeness we signify by saying I I I those opposed anybody abstained motion passes 70 and I am also going to ask I assume there is no Regional impact regarding this project so I'm just going to put that on for the record so all right gentlemen um I'll let you guys um make the presentation so all right that'll hold on I might my okay M you never know all right thank

060you very much for having us we're here tonight to present uh subdivision at the Der roer property and this is a project that the Conservation Commission has been working on for uh two plus years I've got I put a quick presentation together just that might answer a lot of your questions for the folks on the planning board I actually just emailed it out like a couple of minutes ago you guys can't I got it thank you quite see it so I kind of sent it out for you um little bit of background about the D roer property it is a beautiful historic Farmland we are looking to acquire 60 of the 65 acres at the D roer property uh about 2 three years ago the do roer family approached the Conservation Commission about uh potentially

061uh selling the property to us because they want to keep it as uh open space and perpetuity uh you know the big thing with these folks that d roers I've learned over the past couple years in talking with them is they have extreme pride in their property it almost kind of makes me like a little bit emotional when you talk to these folks the history of the property their father purchased it in the 40s it was it was primarily farmland for you know 100 200 years prior to that all of the stories that they have all revolve around the farm and um they really want to keep it as Farmland moving forward so it's pretty kind of cool um the con when they came to us we have like a little bit of a checklist

062at the Conservation Commission to see if the uh property actually meets our requirements and there's key things like is it on 3A is it on the river um is it next to other conservation land those are the kind of boxes that we like to check and it pretty much checks all of those boxes um regarding the specifics related to the property it is located in can that historic farming Corridor in town it's Zone residential there's 600 ft of meramac river Frontage there it connects to existing conservation property and it's currently farmed by a combination of mcquesten farm and uh Alver Farm as well as you can imagine in litfield property is expensive and so the Conservation Commission could not afford this property so once we learned that the do roers uh wanted to sell the

063property to us we went out and we researched grants um we researched and put in for two grants uh what they call the New Hampshire lchip Grant and actually the source water protection Grant from uh New Hampshire D that property is within a window within a radius of penchuk water intake so it kind of put us into that that pile of money these grants were uh very highly competitive and we secured both of them to the tune of $585,000 and uh you can see the picture up there we went and met with the governor this Diane Joan Joan and myself last year and then we actually had the New Hampshire director of Agriculture uh heavily involved with this as well to the point where they actually he actually went to the D roer's house and

064sat at the kitchen table and kind of talked them through the process which was was kind of neat okay little bit about the timeline of events here 2022 they contacted us and had interest in selling the property in early 2023 we got an appraisal on the property we also in early 2023 identified the grants that were available and then in mid 2023 we met with the board of Selectmen and we received approval to go after this project and to uh apply for the grants uh the board of Selectmen supported at 500 the Conservation Commission supported at 700 and the D roers were in support of it as well and Steve Ganon was was actually part of that process he was there at the time uh in late 2023 we received both grants to the tune

065of the 585,000 and then 20124 last year we got the purchase and sales agreement nailed down we had two public hearings on this process as well the board of Selectmen uh voted 500 to accept the grants we signed the purchase and sales agreement the grants were signed all that paperwork stuff was signed as well and now we're at the process where we're doing the subdivision and then moving forward trying to get to closing all right so now to the kind of the fun stuff where it is what it what it looks like and so on you take a look at the map up there it's in the kind of the center part of town a little bit about a mile south of the of the center of town and it uh skirts both sides of

066Route 3A uh diving a little bit deeper into the property it consists of three individual Lots tax Lots uh lot one lot two lot three on the west side of 3A it's to the tune of about 26 Acres on the east side of 3A it's a little bit over 40 acres um if you kind of look over to the right side of the map there it backs up the Conservation Commission to the East and it backs up to the marac river uh to the West uh giving you a little bit of of a little bit of photo montage here uh as you can see in the photos little quick Google Street View uh as you're going down 3A the property is on both sides of the road on the right side of the road is

067the house the east side on the West Side excuse me the west side on the east side of the road left side is a storage building that they have we would be looking to acquire where you see on the A on the right side of the map and then B which is the 40 acres uh way off on the side so that's that's what it looks like um I'm now going to take you through like a little picture toward me walk kind of walking down the river and coming back so if you take a look we're at the front of the house right now on 3A if I pivot to the right and start walking down where that a was on the on the previous map you can see that there's like a little road

068going down to the river as you go down there there's uh Farm fields on each side and then when you get down to the river it opens up into this beautiful I me look look at the thing opens up into a flat beautiful farm field that's right on the edge of the river and then if you go to the trees and look around you get the the the river right there now if I pivot and I turn around and I do a 18 and look back that's me looking back toward the house and you can see the smattering of farm Fields back there and that walks back up toward the house and then the the next slide is jumping across the road and that's a drone shot of the uh farmfield across the road which

069was the previous the Blueberry Patch that was there and then the forest behind and that's where the back 40 is that's where the the 40 acres is way back there um and in that 40 acres is a bunch of on for the most part pretty wet back there um a lot of growth probably a lot of ticks and mosquitoes all right so kind of getting down toward the end here some maps and and highlights of the property when you look at this it's a little bit of an abstract view but just to kind of get you positioned there's the house on the leftand side of the road there's the storage barn on the rightand side of the road I'm focusing on the 26 Acres on the west on the left hand side of the road

070Road and uh what you notice here are the individual Farm fields that are in there notice that there's a nice road that actually goes down loops around the back of the farm field actually comes back up in between these Farm fields and Loops back up up around there and um that's the the property in general so it's got really really good access if I lay on top of that the existing property lines that's what it looks like right now up there in yellow and then um if I hit the button here and go down to where we would have the proposed property lines that's what you see there in white so what we would cut out on the west side of 3A is 2.6 acres for their property and then we retain the rest of

071of that acreage behind the scenes and you can see the uh the road going down there looping and coming back up uh quick look from the road when you're at the road we would end owning this piece over here and so that's the that dirt road that I showed you that's the dirt road going down and that's how tractors will get down there and stuff like that okay jumping across to the uh east side of the road that's the 40 acres that's the the big piece of property U that's what it looks like right now as I mentioned a big chunk of this stuff is is wet up there and U you can see the old Blueberry Patch field right here um if you look closely on the left hand side of the screen if

072I hit the button you can see that white Arrow uh that is where the subdivision would end up being and that would cut out uh two acres on that side so 2.6 Acres on one side of the road 2 Acres on the other side of the road uh zooming in a little bit closer this is what the the 2 acre parcel would look like we're split in the driveway essentially uh or the entrance there essentially down the middle so we've got enough space for us to get have a road to get into the back part of the lot and they have enough space there to be able to do multiple different things on that lot we we spent a lot of time trying to figure out the configuration of what it would look like um

073and then I think these are the last uh two slides here this kind of boils down uh the actual subdivision itself so going on the west side of 3A it's 2.6 Acres pretty pretty straightforward everything um you know is inclusive here and we own they own they retain the 2.6 acres and then we retain or we obtain the Farmland around that jumping over to the other side of the road they have a pretty sizable storage building there and um we wanted to make sure that we kept in mind that that might be able to be used for something cool at some point in time honestly I would love to put rury there or something and have a big deck Overlook in the and have a few beers and stuff like that so we made sure

074that this uh met we we bumped it up to 2 Acres because there's more flexibility and what you can do with that that property in the future so we made sure that they had ample land to uh work with in the future and then we both have access to that property through a different uh two different uh driveway cuts and then this last slide right here kind of gives the details um on the subdivision and uh provides all of the the measurements and and so on so that is a quick story of the the roer farm subdivision okay well thank you very much do you two gentlemen want to add anything to that or um is that the that pretty much covers it that covers it okay and both I me both thoughts are you

075know meeting all the requirements once again shape factors and um setbacks and whatnot okay right um Jay any any issues any questions that you have or I I know it's pretty straightforward just pointing out that the conservation Parcels are non-buildable Parcels uh the buildable Parcels uh you know the two that are proposed you know do meet all of our requirements so it's really pretty straightforward okay does the board have any questions for the app anything anybody wants to ask on a question thank you for all the work the Conservation Commission has done thank you to the D roer family for this this is a big positive for the town thank you everyone thank you um if board doesn't have any questions at this time I'm going to open it up to public comment do any

076members of the public wish to comment on the application subdivision have anything they want to say Jacob mquest 3:30 Charles bankr uh I was not really part of this project in anyway so thank you to the Conservation Commission for doing that um this is some of the I didn't see the slide in there but this property is I know what you're talking about yeah some of the greatest Farmland in the state Maybe in the country um we've been using it for as much of my life as I can remember and you know the the hope is to keep being able to do that so the fact that the roers are able to to come to the town we were able to secure a grant that uh was pretty pretty difficult to get and it's going

077to have no you know impact to the the town anyway I just I'm excited for it to happen um I hope to keep be able to use that my kids hopefully will be able to use that and you know once you take if if we don't do something like that uh the fear of you know taking it not not allowing it to go through conservation which I don't know if that's actually a problem or not but you know if you were to do anything other than this once you put a house on a piece of property this beautiful you're never going to be able to recover any kind of funds uh in a financial way through agriculture it won't it won't happen um so I support it and I like it U thanks to the

078Conservation Commission for doing it and the D roer family for actually thinking to go to the town to to do it in the first place so I support it thank you thank you anybody else have anything that yes please come forward greetings um Ray Peoples 205 Charles bftt highway I just like to say that um A very wise man at a meeting I was at one time or another said everybody should live 10 minutes to 10 acres of open space so they can go there and decompress um this is a beautiful piece of property I certainly applaud the ders for giving it us the opportunity first before they they put this out to somebody that might develop it um as you guys probably all know all the land use studies uh the impact of not

079building on land is relatively inexpensive right the long-term cost of maintaining it that is nothing in comparison to just throwing a couple of residential homes on it the costs you know spiral out of control with what uh Town services and schools and like uh need to need to be supported so I would encourage you to approve this um it's a beautiful piece of land some great farmland and these guys work very very hard doing this I think it's going to be a tremendous asset for the town going forward thank you thank you have one comment yeah J mban Conservation Commission as um Mr mquest mentioned it brought to my memory that when we did a study way back some of this farmland and specifically this is 100% what they call Soil potential index so it's

080like he says probably the best land in Connecticut River Valley or the maram river valley thank you uh anybody else wish to comment on the public okay going once going twice three times all right well um I will before I close public input I do have something that I do want to read into the record and I did get a letter um so we received a letter uh it's dated January 6 20 25 it's to the Lichfield planning board and it's uh regarding the D roer land subdivision chair Coto and honorable planning board members I am so excited for you to review the subdivision of the historic D roer Farmland this has been a project that has been years in the making it was nearly three years ago that Joan McKibbon and I were contacted

081by the Der roers about the desire to preserve their land as Agriculture and perpetuity we first brought in the pasca quag Land Conservancy to meet with them and to discuss the possibilities of putting the land into a Land Conservancy only to hear that the D roers would like the land to be owned and managed by the Lichfield Conservation Commission that rested uh the conservation um I'm sorry that rested the conversation as the town could not afford the property without additional funding several months later Mr D roer contct Ed us again and said that he had spoken to Mr Shawn Jasper the commissioner of New Hampshire Agriculture and that there were grants available to protect such an important piece of agricultural land from there we identified Grant programs applied and were awarded 585,000 in Grants we

082worked closely with the board of Selectmen along the way and received their full approval to proceed with the project after a long process we can finally see the finisher Line This purchase means a tremendous amount to the D roers and the town D roers get to preserve their legacy and land that they are very proud of the Town obtains a stunning piece of property that helps retain the character of the town and keeps the D roer Legacy of farming into the future thank you to the planning board for your assistance in reviewing this project we are looking forward to bringing this project to Parish thank you Diane plansky Lichfield Conservation Commission so okay and I guess if there's no other public input um at this time I'm going to close public input on this and

083I'm going to bring it back to the board and if there's any further questions from the board or what would you like to do um I think it's pretty straightforward I think this is a this has been a Monumental um project and um I think you know Mr Brennan deserves much of the credit Diane Miss plansky and and many other Conservation Commission members deserve much of the credit to putting this together I think it's a great great thing for the town of litfield and um that's just my personal opinion and um I think you guys did an outstanding job and uh putting it together and um the work that you had put into it it wasn't easy it wasn't an easy process I know and but it was it's achievable if you believe in something

084I guess you can it can happen so it's very good I concur with your statement knowing that this has been in the works for over three years and the amount of work and effort that Jason has put into it especially chasing the grants is applaudable definitely thank you for Jason and the Conservation Commission um so if is there any other questions from the board before do we want to vote on this um what do you want to do make a motion say I'll make a motion that we approve the subdivision an application of three lots into three lots at 157 158 and 164 Charles bankrupt highway map six Lots 32 35 and 36 okay I have a motion do I have a second second I have a second by Russ any further discussion should we

085explicitly mention the standard conditions of approval in the motion sure we can do that next one and what would those be we can just say lichfield's standard they're pretty much I mean yeah they're listed if you look at the bottom of the um the work the plan review it's plan copies with professional seals and signatures original myar all fees paid uh if applicable Bas curve Cuts subdivision okay okay anything else okay I'm going to to take a vote all those in favor of approval of the De roer Land subdivision please signify by saying I I I those opposed abstained motion passes 700k you thank you gentlemen thank you [Music] guys thank you it was great thank you thank you all right the next item on the agenda we have a work session this evening um

086couple of things in the work section we have a building code warrant article that was good proposal by the planning board a butter notification definition to align with the state definition for butter um I have a historic district ordinance which was discussed on uh October 29 2024 and December 17 2024 and the storm water management and erosion control appendix D so I guess uh Jay if you wantan to where do you want to begin we can begin at the beginning I guess start with the bu building code building code go from there Kim was going to be here for this but um I think she had to go to another meeting okay you know about this I really have um very little background on this um but these from what I understand these are updates

087that do need to happen yes um I can't speak to any of the specific requirements because building code is kind of not so much my world um but it would have to be um go on the warrant and if we do want to move forward with it um we would have to send it to public hearing on the 21st so I do apologize that I can't speak to the specifics of it but I do recognize that these are amendments that do need to happen Okay so if the board wants to move forward with it with probably not that great comfort level uh um the action would be to send it to a public hearing on the 21st yeah so this includes a building code board of appeals which shall consist three or five members who

088shall be appointed in a manner prescribed by the local legislative body provided however that electing Zoning Board of adjustment may act as the building code of appeals pursuant so basically in reality this would probably mean that the zba can appeal um building code problem that the zba would be the building board of appeals until such time as a building board of appeals a separate one was created which that would that's not going to be anytime soon for litfield I don't think that's right that's yeah yeah yeah this is um it is a work session so we were pretty informal if you want to come up SC you I think I can give a little bit of background to what may be happening um there was some uh concerns about when building permits were issued and

089people disagreed with the decision of the building inspector where do they go for Relief do they go to the board of Selectmen or do they go to the zoning board so that issue came in front of me in my capacity as chair of the zoning board and I said no it does not come to me because the only way it would come to me is by State Statute it says if it's listed in the zoning code that the zoning code acts as the building code of appeals then it can come to me but it's not listed in our zoning so it can't come to me so it needs to go to the board of Selectmen and so I I think you got that's kind of the background as I understand of what's happening so until

090such time the zoning ordinance is changed or amended to appoint the Zoning Board of adjustment as the building court of appeals we have declined to act in that capacity so I think this may be what is happening with this to try to figure out if somebody wants to appeal the billin inspector's decision where do they go and how is that set up so I think there's some options you can create your building code of appeal which I think is what may be trying to be happening here yes um which is on two um so she has you know that you know can be three or five members appoint it or as Jay was saying you know um the zoning board can act as the building court of appeals only if it's provided for in the

091town zoning ordinance which it's not so right now I think it's my my understanding is it goes to the board of Selectmen until such time that the town either um changes the town zoning to appoint the zoning border adjustment or they create their own building code of appeals this document doesn't state that it is ordinance it's that it's correct but it is it would have to be adopted as an ordinance that's why we're workshopping it tonight right and I so it's 673 colon 1 Roman 5 it says if no provision is made to establish a separate building code of appeals the ordinance shall designate the Zoning Board of adjustment to act as the bill and code of appeals okay okay we don't have that designation in our town zoning to give the Zoning Board of

092adjustment jurisdiction to act in that capacity yes okay right now again I think it goes to the it should go to the my position is it should go to the board of selectman I agree with that thank you uh anybody else have anything they want to comment about this um so this needs to go to a hearing 21st yes so I think we'd have to move it to public hearing um so does anyone want to entertain a motion to do though what we're looking at here forgive me Mr what we're looking at here though is a conceptual this isn't written up as if it were the problem is we don't have a building code right now so we have to adopt this they looked and searched we don't have one so we need to adopt

093this to get this to just so for clarification the public hearing is to to adopt that code is that no no no public hearing and then it has to go to warant okay so is would the so would this be permission to by the residents to create that um the ordinance this if I'll leave the state building code but don't we have a building code I don't think so well I'm looking at one find like is this the case of does are you saying lvi has one or are you saying that l I've got one in my book that's all I know is it does it look like lichfield's never find where it was adopted it says the town of Lichfield building code so if they I guess Joan is saying there's no record of

094it being adopted but it's definitely in this book so the problem is wasn't adopted you say so so it sounds like the problem was they were created but not adopted yeah that's a recipe for confusion it says it was adopted September 29th 1984 there we have a date then it says it was recodified in ' 86 and then it was amended March 1988 March 1990 in March 1996 again that's just looking at what it says okay well at least we have dat so we have code so I think we would it would be beneficial to have some comments from those who were involved in this at least we could set this to hearing and then hopefully Kim will have a de maybe Miss Kleiner can come in and and if she can't come in some

095at least some comments from her digitally would be helpful to clarify this confusion yeah I think there's a lot yeah I'm sure a lot not sure what we're supposed to do so what what we're being asked to do frankly yeah what public hearing to hearing and then if is you can always not you know hopefully should get more information right but we could yeah we could we could certainly put it to here okay that'll be the first and only time yeah that he was aole have that right because you that's pretty much okay yeah yeah this would have been helpful if we saw this before I even still I I still don't know what's being asked of us to move forward forward to public hearing yeah this is not the usual format yeah and there's

096lots of subtext in here that is talking to us as a board for instance in number one in parentheses this is automatically the case anyway but you should include it just to be clear so you know I don't see any line cross outs I don't see you know what I'm saying I yeah yeah yeah not really sure what's intended for us as the audience or what's intended for the code AS in the Warren article yeah this seems like a set of instructions for what needs to happen did legal take a look at this legal I think legal did take a look at it I I believe Mr Shino I'm sorry really have to rush into this I mean the system's been working well I think one one date to go one more hearing date to

097get on the warrant but I ain't going to make you're going to have to make change no one knows what in this is what we're going to put onto the warrant going to be the right thing to put on the warrant if we rush through till she has on the if we can go to the selectman go to the selectman for now yeah I think um unfortunately uh Kleiner is not here this evening I think it might have been a little bit more informative if she was here um but it sounds like we already have a building code that's been established although Jon is saying it wasn't adopted but I that's what they I think we're going by the state building AR we we don't have any trouble I mean it's pretty Clarity just it's

098just always been in my book here J has to Pro see you Jason been building in town for 40 years and I haven't had trouble yet with anything like that so this I just hate to rush into it without without review exactly I mean I don't know maybe someone else has reviewed it but at least let us have some in input and right now we have none yeah according to this it's already um the RSA length is already um sets the building code probably from the state right um so it would just explicitly mention that um but yeah this is definitely not the format that we are used to it does look like the thrust is to create the building board of appeals right yeah but here's the draft building code on the back pages

099so I guess I mean says required steps planning board must hold a public hearing so I assume that's what they're what they were looking for us to do so why don't we put this as a an item to work on throughout the 2025 yeah I I would I would agree I think there's this was just presented to us at The Stroke of Midnight yeah sort of so it's worth investigating further let's do our D job with it I think I think to do it in such a compact timeline as we have in front of us now right I don't think we can do it justice not responsible okay all right so that's that one um so I guess we'll put this one we'll table it um do we want to move on to something else

100notification want do storm water storm water Y what about butter is it should easy that's going to be butter is next order so I'm no longer on um the big screen but if folks have would do you need that back it's connected where let me try again yeah that's what worked last time I just tried it again no so I think we I I'll keep talking while we're looking because this is a pretty straightforward one I think as we've talked a couple of times before stayed updated their definition of a butter um so we need to ad update our definitions to be consistent we've gone through a couple iterations one was to just simply Define the butter as defined under the RSA as amended uh that would initially we had all the language then we

101went to that and then we went back to all of the language because of the concern expressed that it's helpful for people to be able to see what's required on the ordinance so basically this is simply taking I can read it but it's really convoluted um it's it's changing the lichfield's defin of a butter to parallel the state definition of the ab butter and then in addition we simply add um as amended uh afterwards so it will Encompass future amendments and that's it okay I see Miss gandia has her hand up Laura gandia three chambering Drive um thank you for the uh change to the abot definition but I also don't know if it's too late to request this but Section 1 190 of the zoning code um talks about any person agreed from the

102decision of a code enforcement officer May appeal to the Zoning Board of adjustment um State Statute has changed that um and it now says that appeals to the board of adjustment may be taken by the applicant and the butter as defined by RSA 672 col 3 and so on and so forth so our zoning code section 19 is not compliant with HB 1359 that went into effect in September it's not too late we could send that to public hearing if this is our last chance tonight yeah this is it kidding can I get the reference again y so so for the Lichfield zoning it's Section 1 190 appeals and the bill that was passed last legislative session is HB 1359 and that uh limits who can make appeals to the zoning board before you just

103had to be an agreed person right and they now narrowed that so can't be just the name of X door you have to have now be either the applicant in a butter and then any the officer Department board a bureau of the municipality that's a that is correct I forgot about that one y so if we could have that updated I think that would be helpful for folks okay so yeah the board can vote to send that to public hearing on the 21st okay thank you anybody else all right um so I guess with that in mind we can probably vote to move it to the 21st for public um yeah vote on the on both of them on both yeah together or separate it's a you could do it either way but I'd say

104separate yeah okay so for the better definition we're not making any changes to it right no ST we do we need to put that to a second hearing or are we done with that um well we didn't you could vote to move it to the warrant so yeah you could CU we're not you're right we're not changing language so you could to put that to the warrant if you wish yeah it's pretty straightforward um I think the the only concern with this proposal was that it's going to go out of date eventually but it legally is going to be okay because it has as amended um so if when who will be crafting when do we determine the wording of the warrant article for this after the um second public hearing we'll know which items

105are going to go and then we'll put together we'll put it in warrant form okay so I guess I'll make a motion to put the proposed zoning uh Amendment for the definition of a better for Warrant okay I have a motion on table do I have a second second all right second any further discussion on the motion all all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I I those opposed abstained motion passes 70 okay that's one so um I'll make a motion to put to hold a public hearing on the uh January 21st 2025 um meeting April 21st Jan you're right January 21st I I got April sorry for uh the proposed changes to section 1 appeals motion have second I'll second that second by Travis any further discussion all right

106take a vote all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I I those opposed abstained motion passes 70 0 okay and I think we have some people here probably interested in the historic district ordinance okay um I believe I do see some people in the gallery um did you folks want to come up to the table um and I sent a letter to Joan okay to our okay consideration the election of 2025 so we were surprised to hear it as we were leaving and that's why we stayed we could still work on it's just we're going to work on it individually and we'll come back when we have it the way that the the way we the way that legal and you people want it to we're not going to work

107on it tonight okay well thank you very much and thank you for coming all right so I guess with that I can go to storm wi I guess you can go to storm water all right so for if if people have it in front of them obviously we SP a lot of time on this and um at our last meeting um [Music] we received several comments good night and I I think there was a general consensus um that it made sense to address those comments so rather than go through everything what I thought I would do is just go through the comments uh that we received and the changes that were made in response to those well at least I'll go to the changes so the first one was on page six and um under

108design standards 3.41 subsection a um there was concern uh at the use of the term plan uh all measures in the plan um shall meet the best management practices so it suggested that that uh the word plan be changed to design so that was done moving on further down that page under uh section 3.5.1 uh kind of again a terminology concern for clarity uh here we use the term plan and the suggestion was that should be changed to application and so again that was done and that's because For What It's Worth it's this is something that affects the application as a whole not just the plan itself moving down to the section below that uh 3.5.2 where we talked about construction drawings uh a suggestion was that that be changed to storm water management plans

109rather than construction drawings that's clearer so that change was also suggested moving on to page seven uh going down to close to the middle of the page uh you see subsection B uh where it starts with other um previously plan requirements again and the word plan was changed to application uh to be clearer moving right below that section 3.5.3 um and again again trying to make things clearer report section what is that report report section accompanying the storm water management permit application is inserted um and then the next change does not come in I believe until page 16 I think if I'm correct yes so that'll take you the next change will take you all the way to page 16 where we have a few so there were a couple of concerns that were uh

110raised related to section 313.2 so one was just you know provid a little bit more flexibility and also there was some concern for well C should be a requirement um and so kind of been looking at the way this was structured I thought had to be because if you see the intro it says the applicant should consider if it says consider you can't make it a requirement so at any rate I just changed the wording a little so the first change you'll see is at the beginning the paragraph is the um the applicant should in instead of consider include colon um and again the use in a I I think that still works B subb still works so C is where um we had some concern so c will now say instead of submitt of

111um inspection and maintenance logs to the planning board on a yearly basis it will say the application again has to include a schedule uh for submitt of inspection and maintenance logs to the planning board on a yearly basis or periodic basis as appropriate so that gives us flexibility to say based on this application maybe it's every two years or whatever um then moving on down that page section 3.13.1 um again kind of which operation maintenance procedures so uh a couple of changes to this one so it would Now read a description of the operation and maintenance procedures approved by the planning board shall be recorded at the register of deeds uh so that's the final plan that that gets approved moving on down to the very bottom of the page under subsection B uh just

112to clarify the erosion and sediment control inspections that we're looking for in this section are during construction so just the words inserted during construction the applicant shall conduct and document in inspections Etc Jay I'm looking at a different terminology the one I see it says during development y i I'm sorry during development is what I put we could put during construction yeah I just want to make sure we're all you're right I I misspoke during development okay turning the page same section uh along similar lines here we just added on a monthly or periodic basis as may be appropriate so kind of that's the theme we've been running kind of throughout providing that additional flexibility and I believe that's it those are the changes they weren't particularly extensive so the one like little thing that

113seems oddly word to me is uh the on page 16 uh section 313.2 uh it was When developing these procedures the applicant should um and now you cut out the first two words but you still have these procedures comma the appli I'm sorry where are you the end of the first part of 313.2 on page 16 at the very end you cut out When developing and that doesn't seem sound right I think it should be when you just cut out yeah with maybe within these procedures not these procedures the application should include yeah it it should probably within these procedures yeah and I would say that that's a nonsubstance change no you're right you're kind of lose track sometimes when you're making changes to changes yeah you know what you wanted to say right but

114other than that typo um is it ready for us to adopt uh we'd have to move it to public hearing so last time we just felt there were enough changes that we wanted to see them so it'd be public hearing so I guess um but you could do on the 21st you don't have to do on the 21st yeah is there any downside to doing on the 2 no this is just one where we don't have um a schedule that we're looking at but yeah we can do it on 20 Jon are you aware of any additional um applications that will make that will make us want to defer this only the um gas station update and a minor subdivision on Rocky Hill Road that's all I have for 21st okay so should anyone oppose

115to a public hearing on that date let's do it not do a lot of work on that we should yeah at that point it should be a does anyone have any problem with it no no we adopt it um so I'll make a motion to put the proposed um uh storm water management regulations for public hearing on January 21st 2025 all I have a motion do I have a second second all right any further discussion all right take a vote all those in favor of the motion please signify by saying I I I those opposed obain motion passes 70 okay very good all right okay that's it and that's it I think that's everything yep have a good night see have a good night have a good night y all right moving on to committee

116reports any reports from any committees Jeremy's not here did you want to talk about Economic Development J or yeah we don't yet have one on the next meeting scheduled although I think it's tentatively going to be the January meeting and um so I think the focus there is going to be a discussion on alternative zoning strategies one of which is mixed use okay developments that was one of the things that's been discussed very um the Conservation Commission did meet uh last week the 2nd of January um obviously tonight we heard about the diversal property and the subdivision so um I have not heard from the lower marac local River advisory committee I don't there hasn't been any meetings so Capital Improvement committee did meet last night um set the schedule for 2025 which is good

117so so the next meeting will be in April uh and that's everything I have for that um approval of the December 17 20 2024 minutes any no opportunity to take a look at those have any questions concerns amendments looks good to me yeah make a motion to approve the minutes of uh December 17th 2024 I have a motion by Russ to approve the minutes do I have a second second second yes uh any further discussion all right all those in favor of the motion for approval of the December 17 2024 minutes please signify by saying I I those opposed abstained motion passes 70 okay [Applause] see uh any other business even John do you have anything no I do not okay I do not okay okay um uh anybody have anything okay uh all right

118so um when is our next meeting 21st 21st of January 2025 so couple things on that agenda yes yes there is so we will continue several public hearings several public hearings in all right since there's nothing else uh that concludes our business for this evening um does anyone want to entertain motion to adjourn make a motion to adjourn a meeting motion to adjourn second any discussion no all those in verely signify by saying I I those opposed abstain motion passes 700 thank you very much ladies and gentlemen uh Happy New Year and um we will see you on the 21st of January good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.