CorpusRecord 95253

SAU 84 School Board Meeting 12-10-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SAU 84 Meetings
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Grafton County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,585 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-12

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001are very well it is uh 5:3 we will call this meeting of school board to order we begin with the pledge allegiance United States ofice right thank you for being here our only order of business is to turn over to the superintendent team and see where that conversation takes us okay thank thank you uh as well coming out a very pleasant winter evening I think um so we're GNA try to move through have five few slides here they are they are in responses to questions from either the budget committee or the board some cases both but uh there's a few but I'll try to move through those fairly quickly and certainly want to be playing discuss in time this time to get into more of the budget itself and warrant articles uh so going to

002talk a little bit what we were asked to do uh the board uh asked the administrative team to to bring a level funded general fund budget to the to the board if possible uh which we did and then the budget committee back in July the the ask was that we keep a total increase by the the town and the the school if we could keep it within 3 to 5% uh that would be that was kind of a goal and we weren't able to commit to that at the time but I think we we certainly hope that we' be able to do that and work to do that as it death settles as of today with teachers contract factored in which is uh which is you know $262,000 uh that does bring us to a

003slight increase of 2.3% below what the uh budget committee originally had hoped um agenda we talk a little bit about The Residency program and then requested information we'll get into the general fund the featur contract Warren AR so I want we we we've done quite a bit with this the board is is very very involved with the with the residency very up to speed uh our staff is but the budget committee we want to make sure you knew a little bit about it we have we have some individuals here tonight that participating in their residency in different form either as residents or as cooperating teachers uh including a one of the residents that we hired uh so we'll have a little time for you to engage with them I just want to hit a few

004of the high points here this is a cohort number three uh the first cohort was larger had six than the last couple years we've had four residencies for Resident teachers thing I think is really important is is to point out that the the resident teachers come in fully certified teachers they're not they're not coming in you know this isn't like student teaching you know they're coming in as fully certified teachers some of them have had teaching experience already but what they are seeking is uh a master's degree and through this program they do get the certification so that they are able to teach special education this uh this program was was conceived as a uh a way to do several things one of one one of the big things was to build capacity in the

005North Country uh especially Littleton but other North Country schools and other places for that matter in special education staff we're lucky to partner with a with a foundation cmf Crosset Mountain Foundation uh which will be footing the bill and next year and the year after for half of the expenses uh incurred in the program uh including they they've agreed to pay for the tuition or excuse not tuition but the housing cost of the residents so no housing costs are charged off the district funds and that's how it has been frankly the last three years the last three years has been Esser next year will be Pro um you kind of look at look at there so many different dimensions financially makes a lot of sense uh the cost the cost per resident if you figure

006the cost with the four what we have to pay to maintain the program is about $26,000 for about what it cost us to have four certified teachers um we have scaled back a little bit with par Educators in the past few years because we had the residents uh so we need to enhance that Staffing back if we were to not have the resident program uh as far as the cost of pairs I want to be careful here both of those last two columns health insurance can is variable but we did to to give the you know we don't we we never know what the health insurance is going to run we know one thing it'll be a minimum of 2,000 because that's what the buy out would cost that's for per step one salary 24938

007that's the beginning salary or wages of a pair of educator that part we do know so we kind of try to get a get a sense of what what it could cost it could cost up of this amount that's assuming we hire a very beginning PA and they take the highest level of insurance coverage on the other hand hiring a teacher uh you see the number there is is pretty high all not quite as high is having the four resident teachers but it's close so you know I say how how you is it a you know is it a good is it a good deal to get four teachers for barely over the price of one I think we know the answer to that benefits cmf match they certified teachers of that said you know

008I think one of the more I think we you one thing is most interesting I remember when the the individuals uh presented at the board here some time ago well we learned from each other our our residents bring in new ideas okay they're taking some of the most recent they're looking at some of the most recent research in the field of educ ation specifically special education so they they contribute it it it learns both ways and I've heard that from we've heard that from our teachers our cooperating teachers whom they work with over and over yeah they they're their benefit I learn from them and I think that's that's good so they bring that to the to the mix includ plus the fact that they're providing students Services one-on-one Services via the from the skill

009level of of a fully certified teacher comments from the participants we have a we have a few uh I'll have people introduce themselves start back here so the budget committee that are here specifically tonight to speak to The Residency program and what you do go ahead want to stand up yeah please there we go so Cheryl Lewis a veter teacher at L life been here few years I'm Ka I'm co- teing with ch Le I'm Laur pero I'm coing in fourth grade i'mna Allen I was in the cohart last year in fourth grade and now I am the uh special education teacher here in the middle school so I'll come back to me I'm going to tell you guys some of the benefits of the program I have been involved since day one Caitlyn is

010my fourth of four my third I've got four kids but she's my third my third resident sorry about that uh and it's been a great benefit to have another pair of hands in the classroom uh who is learning all the special education side of things uh bring some of the newest things that we were just listening to the newest things to the table it's another person for the students to connect with clearly she's younger than I am she's a little more hip with some of the terminology that they hear than I am uh it's the program has changed a little bit as we've gone through from the first year that it started we were kind of learning as we went the first year and now we've got it down to a science you have many

011of the teachers who have done this have stayed with the program hosting multiple residents as they've come through We Have Had Each resident comes with their own set of skills that are unique to them that my last year's Resident was very interested in the lower grades so she was she's very focused on a lot of the younger grade skills Caitlyn was more focused on some of the health and science issue things and so she's brought in that health and science and helping out with the science curriculum she came in with not a lot of background in the reading and the math aspect of teaching but has risen to the occasion she has looked at things on her own she has taken things over we literally do coach teach together I can start a sentence and

012have to step to the side and she completes the sentence the kids don't see us any differently in the room at all and to students in some of the other classrooms as well yeah I think that's a huge part that maybe not everyone realizes you know I'm in the class with Cheryl with that those specific students but I'm touching all of the students within second grade and working with them um and you know we're here for special education but we're reaching out to again all of the students and I think what we bring to the table also you know we have pull out services for students with those needs and those are important to reach and get them to the goals so that they can be successful within the classroom but having my position where

013I'm learning about special education but also in the general education class for most of the day I can also Implement what they're learning in that resource room in the classroom so that they can reach their the goals that everyone is you know trying to be uh successful in um it's been paramont about how you know clear it's been fitting our students but also selfishly I'm clearly this is an amazing opportunity for myself I get this whole year working with amazing people um and I'm learning so many things and it's just so grateful to be part of it and I think it's a beautiful thing to be able to offer that to another um set of students who benefit not only myself but the whole Community to Echo that sentiment um Lauren again um I think

014that like talking in our classes with our other um our Educators um in the making and special education that are in our classes um at P state I'm like well did you learn that and they're like no I'm like oh well we did in our Friday morning meeting so that's why like I'm like mixing up because there's so much benefit for us to be in the school seeing the things happening in the Friday morning meetings that we have with um Jenny Burke and um our mentors Kelly and Christine Forest um like to have that experience that that Hands-On putting it right into application is just so beneficial not only for us but we're seeing the benefit in our students we're seeing the data progression we're seeing the positive impact that we're having in the classroom

015not just on those lower level Learners that are you know special education learners but also the higher level Learners that are usually pretty hard to reach in that General classroom because there's only one teacher so now with the two teachers right you have the ability to expand your level of differentiation um not only to the lower level Learners and and the the you know there really is no normal student anymore no general student um but to to reach all Learners where they're at and not have them meet us where we're at with the curriculum so it's definitely a really amazing experience part of coming out of the experience all of those things and just I I'm absolutely like flabbergasted the amount of like Hands-On like real learning that I did during that time like I

016didn't I I I suppose like I never realized how much like you don't really learn like just by going to college you know like all of the EP writing and understanding like all of the you know kind of more paperwork timeline things like all of that stuff was really like 99% of it I learned while in the program and I don't I don't I think coming into like my first year as a case manager as a special ed teacher I would have absolutely blundered if I didn't have all of that experience that I had um and on top of that I I think it's also really special because it brings people from you know all over the place last year we had one a girl from new uh New York yes New York and like

017Maine and like it brings people from all over the place with different life experiences to you know the North Country um the edge of the world and uh so it kind of introduces them to our little community and also you know potentially makes them stay um so uh I think it's really special in that aspect as well McKenna grew up in Lion cter for the record and she's one of our one of our residents that went through the program and teaches at the middle school that something that you guys um I'm not sure how much you know about the program they are also students it's an accelerated year-long program so they're taking classes at night after they come to school with us so when Lauren speaks of their the students in their classes those are

018like day students who pop into the schools two days a week two days a week in their communities and they're at um on campus or near Plymouth where they're doing this other it's a very different type of situation for them and I think they're like they're not getting some of the handson things it's funny we had to we had an assignment where we had to cite our co- teing experiences and ours are 15 pages long and um others have ones that are like three pages long because they have you know two experiences a week of co- teing and we are literally doing it every sing I have a breakdown hour by hour each day for the whole first semester of what coaching look like um and and to see that I showed it to Kristen

019Morland and she was like you guys you guys have to do this for an assignment she's like does Sarah know that you're in there every day of the week and so it just it was a very cool experience to like to be able to show that with our professors and they're like wow this is like a this is a life-changing program like to be able to have this experience not only for our students but for us like you're you're shaping the way that educators are going to to work like coming in as a first year teacher to this program this will forever change the way that I'm going to be a teacher I also want to add the experience of co- teing has helped a lot because now as a special ed teacher now I

020do um push in Services into the classroom instead of pulling the students out of the G General classroom I push in and I provide them services in the classroom so there are times where you know I have to coordinate with the with the general ed teacher like hey what are you doing on this day is this a good time to you know pull the kids you know off to the side and work with them or like maybe I can co- te and a lot of teachers are like yeah if you got something to add you know just jump in or you know sometimes we'll even like kind of co- teach a lesson together um to kind of get that sort of second part of it like the second um special ed side of things to

021kind of get that breakdown that you know sometimes General Ed teachers might not always think about um so I found that that is also very beneficial through that experience of co- teing I don't want anything to get lost in the fact that the first year we had six residents we had six residents because that what the program was designed to have the second year we didn't have six candidates that we were willing to settle for two that we I have nothing to do with the choosing not we the program I don't get to choose I wish I could because you know I would still choose um but we we don't have anything to do with that choosing part of it but it was not because we didn't want six or it didn't work out with

022six or we only had four applicants it because it's because we were choosy as to who we took and we were not going to settle same with this year we had a multitude of applicants who were not offered this space it's we do have the cream of the crop coming through have any questions for us hi Diane is it a two for the Master's component is it um one year one year accelerated master so we started I think we started two days after we graduated this year um because cait and I graduated from the state together in the spring we started we graduated Saturday we started classes on Monday um which is a very uh very quick turnaround um and then we'll actually be done and three of the residents went to Plymouth State and

023our fourth resident did not go to Plymouth state but applied for the graduate program under the Plymouth State umbrella because she had heard of it outside of our area she went to University of New England Inland so how many of you semal from LC I'm I'm from Massachusetts and then I know Elizabeth is from Littleton yes um and Lauren um the other Lauren is from coner yeah so rela and the master program is called um the onee Intensive special education yeah K through 12 different from masters of arts teaching yes but they still have that program they program yes your program is 12 month program the one that they're doing yes it starts soon as you graduate it's 12 months straight straight Y and they actually they will graduate again in May and the way

024the program works is not done in may they don't get to be done till we're done at the end of the school year so they follow our schedule they don't get the long extended vacation at Christmas time they don't get any of the perks that you might get as a college student there you know boots on the ground I will say Just You full disclosure they have a Homework Day built into their schedule on Mondays so that that gives them some extra time to work and they if they uh if we do not have Monday as a school day they are still there all week if we have Friday off then they come on Monday so they're required to be with us four days a week every single week yes so um with um your

025experience and you must talk to your other sister and fellow students is this um is this uh a program that you think is advantageous and should be continued here at wilon and what do we do right here without a doubt in my mind um keeping this program hunting for as like I said like you're you're investing in the future of Education um and in this program I I think I said at the last board meeting but this program when I first heard about it my dad was like it's a scam don't answer the email like it's not real and I was like oh okay like I started looking into it and then I I worked at ad Mission so I kind of heard but this this program is not only invested in us as future

026Educators but every every child that I ever interact with in a school setting will be impacted by little tending like that is something that is so cool like I would have never even I lived in Plymouth for four years I never heard of littl New Hampshire until I found out about this program and then all my friends started applying for the program like this is something that is so wide reaching I don't even think we can grasp the concept of how many lives it'll touch I um I also as well I did um I so I graduated from White Mountains uh Community College I did the I think it's like the two plus one or something like that so I got my bachelors in three years um and I uh left my student teachings kind

027of feeling like oh my good Lord I don't know if I'm ready for this and so um I I heard about this program because I did my student teaching at Lakeway and a fellow Resident was like if you're interested in special ed you should apply for this and I was like that's sounds fake she's like it's not I'm here doing it and so um so then I applied and through my uh you know it's it's I I left I left my bachelor certified teacher but it's also not it's a whole another year of learning and experience and it doesn't feel like you're kind of being launched right into your teaching career it does it feels like you're you have a lot of mentors and a lot of people that guide you so that you have

028like that little bit of extra support before you actually go off into the the big girl world well yeah so I mean looking back at the beginning of the year and and now I see so much growth in myself um and I think that's amazing and like Makenna was saying we are in really great hands um we have our co- teer and our mentor to work with um and we're with their expertise you know we are able to touch upon the hearts of all of the students that we're working with so not only are we learning so much for ourselves but we are just that extra hand those hands in the classroom is benefiting local community and they're extra trained hands it's not like you know some of our pars not to speak badly about

029any of our pars because we've had a lot of them there for a long time but some of our our new Paris come in and they don't have educational background so to have somebody who knows the educational lingo and knows what's going on and sees all the other things if one of our special education mentors were here today they would Echo all of the things that we're saying that I think that another piece that needs to be said is that before they're allowed to leave they will each lead themselves an IEP meeting a special education meeting they will go over the testing they will write the iips which I believe some of you have already started doing right now uh they will we really do treat them as equals with all of us it's not

030treated as if there's somebody else in my room now I have to like babysit them and teach them and this is how we do things it's not like that all at all said she wasn't really ready to get running on her own but a someone else she RVE the students have off RVE the school has benefited they don't just stay in their grade levels they help out in other spaces we have a couple of challenging classrooms that people have gone into I mean they're everywhere and it's awesome did you have something El Dan even when you complete this program it doesn't necessarily mean you're going to go into special education is that correct and that means if there was an opening in the school system that wasn't special you could apply for that and you

031would bring those skills of being able to differentiate the lesson plan far better than if you hadn't had this program like I said like this this background in special education I I never thought I wanted to go into special education I was totally like never not even a thought in my mind I just wanted to be a teacher was like maybe music teacher my dad's a PE teacher so he says he's the smartest man in the building um and my stepmom's a fifth grade teacher and she also had her Masters in special education and the experience that I've seen just watching her be a teacher I watch her as a as a teacher and I just like my job like I'm just like in awe every day um and I'm like I want to be

032that how do I do that and finding this program in special education like it's not it's not just it doesn't just help the students who are in special like I have Learners that it's hard to reach just where they're at like for a certain topic right but I'm using the tools that I learned in the special education classes in the I'm like wow that you know that's primarily a strategy for a student with au but I can use that here I can use that here it's it's everywhere it's so far reaching because we're learning after Co and you know with the with our learner now there is no middle learner like usually like you know you hear the old thing like teach to the middle someone will get it like no like that's not anywhere

033close to what we're looking at right now with our learn with our Learners and our level of Learners and so this is helping us you know reach everyone and we're directly applying like I'm like one that we learned in class last night I think this could work here like and we're bringing it to you know our co-teachers and they're like you know that could work like that's awesome let's try that thank you yeah thank you thank you thank you so much you guys really appreciate you thank you for taking the time to [Applause] listen you know I uh I think one thing about about our district and we probably don't sell it enough within our community but I think I think it's worthy of noting L School District we are we are a leaders we

034are an innovator this is a perfect example of the Innovative programs we have Michelle Cox is sitting here uh director of our above the notch Community School which was you know founded several years ago uh we have state the-art programs for students with disabilities and on and on and on I go on down the list but I think that uh something sometimes we don't we don't always realize what we have in how Innovative we are and how much how much different we are from other other schools not just in the state but the North Country in general um all right requested information um again question asked where we stand with staff over the past five years and so there's a taking directly from our payroll record uh showing how we have a de decreased in

035number sta is that total um total employee everybody y exactly yep custodians Paras administrators teachers exactly uh individuals are not counted in these numbers the the participants of this program are not counted in this so we're saving Paris essentially they well train Paris so to speak but they're not teaching classes completely on their own right now no so they're not exactly PA is again a slight decline you know some of this is due to the the program you know we as in terms of how many students we have for Teacher this is taken from the state I wish they update this data more frequently but this is the latest official data I have from the state school year 2223 so you'll see we're kind of up there in that higher end of things in terms

036of number of students per teacher and then on down to the other other uh left uh fewers fewer students for Teacher Steve got a question yes yeah so it looks like it looks like to me that the bigger the school might be the more opportunity you have to have a High higher number of students in the classroom I think small schools don't scale exactly absolutely although although it's pretty interesting one of the smaller schools here you see on this list is north umberland and uh they have you know more more students teach yeah true yeah so it's kind but in general you have that's a little bit out of line with it's an outlier yeah for sure yeah I think you look there as you look kind of left hand side those are generally smaller

037smaller super the the fact is they're not all K2 they're not and and so that although there's some strangers obviously White Mountain Regional and Elizabeth identical gorum which is very small y oh virtually the same B we're near as big as used be in north right yes exactly you were not familiar with the village concept thank you Steve yeah it took me a while to figure that one out Townships versus Village yeah this is just a funds the return to taxes or taxpayers at the end of the fiscal year for the last few years in total the purpose of the total there was just I don't just to impress us with the fouryear total it's a it's a big it's a big bar there yeah well I think too V and there there are different

038requirements for the school system to return money as opposed to the town if there's unexpended funds at the end of the year they can retain those funds the school on the other hand if there is UN unsta monies um they can retain up to 5% of I think it's whatever was loc locally the taxes you know so1 million 5% of that and anything above that um they have to return to the taxpayer so I think also we get to the budget part and you see those we know what happens on the town side when you buy down the the tax rate they're not necessarily buying down the tax rate they have to return the funds and and that kind of creates a gap so you're going to see that later on in the budget when

039they present that but we we always say we appreciate how you manage your money how you return the money and um but I just want you to kind of keep this in mind as we head to the budget you know this is just kind of a how our budget would look if we with the 3% if it were inflationary addition or whatever we know inflation over those that time span been more than 3% you know there's again there's some factors in here and we have reduced staff a little bit so that that affect some of this as well I think it just kind of put it perspective uh as as does this data can I add something yeah pre previous slide so I went back to the tax rate and I was looking at what

040the town and school taxes were prior to the pilot program and then I took the 2024 numbers because that's post pilot right in the five years the um School increased their or their tax tax rate increased by 21 cents over five years without any without adding any um long-term debt so we're comparing it to the town side pre and post because it's easier to compare apples to apples that way um they their tax rate increased by I think it's a137 I went up about a137 but their long-term debt went up over $2 million in that amount of time so I just want to say kudos to the school board I know that you work really hard to to watch the monies um but declining enrollments and everything else um 21 cents is is not over

041five years that's even taken into account the impact that the pilot had on the fact no pilot I did pre pilot and post okay after it settled back okay after it settled back yeah again this is some data map actually presented this with us the other doing some math because I'm was curious you know again kind of look at dollars if adjusted dollars adjusted for inflation over time and the inflation factor is just the overall inflation yeah I Ed the feds inflation inflation calculator um that's what I was using just to try to Benchmark if you look at what if you look at the first roow you look at $7.5 million in 99 terms weits to in 2004 terms you get that $4 million right and you compare that to the 24 budget of 184

042and you get a $4.2 million real dollar increase which is a $30 increase but then you start to see that story reverse as you get later on in the years the five year increments so it's interesting because I mean if you think about it just in the last 10 years right the 2014 budget at 163 you think of what inflation has done in the last decade you can see that that's actually a pretty significant reduction and inflation inflation adjusted dollars for the buet just in a way kind of a speak was see the the the rate of increase has been I think substantially less than what it could have otherwise I think you're right to point out that the school was trying to do as much if not more in with less I'm going to

043say real dollars yeah the data that would be very hard to capture is the average wage for the people that live in Littleton in 1999 versus 2004 and whatever which I recognize would be practically impossible to get your hands on yeah but unfortunately I'm not sure if People's wages have kept up with that rate of inflation as well yeah of course our drives that our legal obligations for the services we provide has nothing to do with what now you're making a point about the break on the taxpayer which is totally legitimate right and you're right that we don't have that data but at the same time we have to go out to Market to hire people and provide services that were required to do so by law regardless of what the wage rate is doing

044little to so it's this it's this delicate balance right but yeah you make a great point I I don't know where you can begin to find that and I'm sure it's not right I'm sure that people uh uh you know income is not double in the last 10 years whatever the number is if you look back go 2014 but that's that's going to be true everywhere too that's why inflation is awful by the way right no I I get that and I think you did right by pointing out that the reason these conversations be become so difficult is we're essentially asking you to do the same with less yeah for sure and when we say level funded it's not really a level because you're using deflated dollars yep so recognize that but also we can't

045say I I'm going to guess that most people haven't had a substant a sustained 3% raise over the last you know in the same um in the same thing as the other 3% accumulated increases which I don't think anyone on a annual basis would complain about a 3% increase but I think it does show how important it is that we hold the the fin fiscal line as much as possible because those little increases add up greatly I don't know if you I don't know if it's on the agenda I don't know if you were able to see the C and the calonia but that's why we we elected to to defer the Lakeway by right is because looking at looking at the situation the math just doesn't work right we can we can get cute

046about inflation numbers all we want we can justify uh we can use statistics I'm sure to justify anything at the end of the day it's one taxpayer right and the situation is not great for that for us we're all taxpayers yeah and and um I think that that the we've talked to the select board communicated to them at the after the conclusion of our meeting last Monday and Steve and I are in the process of getting together with Troy and carrye to start conversations and broaden it up to both boards about understanding how do we start to get back to a place where we are even though we're two separate boards and two separate governments and two separate mandates two separate budgets and two separate warrants how do we start coordinating more effectively recognizing it

047was one taxpayer right and and I think there's there's a lot of work to do there that is exactly why I started requesting the coly meetings because um when I was first on the school board in 1997 I hate to say that that's a long time ago um d jent was our town manager and he at that time it was only the town that was meeting before the budget committee and he basically said both entities needed to meet before the budget committee and they needed to meet together and at one point we actually held our deliberative sessions together the same night and um we could hear each other's budgets and that's really important that was reason why um I keep saying we need to come together at the coordin meeting at least we get to

048know each other at least we get it's like going to um rotary club or something you have to make those relationships and um and we have to understand each other's needs in that year and um so we're ful in support of that Vision I would say we take it a couple of steps further I'm sure you agree but it's not even about the needs for that year it's about longer range together right and I think mentioned the quarterly meetings we mention the quarterly me to the select Bo last Monday we think we need to be even more aggressive that right and and and so that's why we're we're chatting and try to figure out what does that potentially look like we all have our own rules that we're governed by have to be careful this

049and that right to know file when over we're trying to sort that through but um it's very much on our minds but the quarterly meetings which have happened on and off to some degree since Town Ro if you would and it it shouldn't be viewed by as it is by some that it's something you got to go get dragged to kicking and screaming to get there it it should actually be an opportunity for both entities to paint a picture yeah you know what are we looking to do to sell each other on it and obviously ultimately end up in coordination that your poliy targeted but uh it needs to be looked at it in a positive fashion not as something geez we got to do this yeah and I agree with that and I obviously

050you know we we misunderstood all but yes we agree I'll move us to the next slide it's all good stuff coming back a little bit to state of student performance and I said last time we give a little more detail data um so what what I'm presenting here is this is the most recent State assessment scores this being in in May of 2024 and again self-explanatory to see the our local scores by grade level versus the state average one thing that one thing is important to remember is this percent proficient it's not like a score it's not like a percentage of correct or anything like that so you know you look at fourth grade 54% you know compared to the state average of 49 that's that's pretty good but i' I've done these presentation before

051and someone will say 54% that's an F that's a that's a you know that's 20 points south of an F what are you talking about that's good and and we and we want obviously we want it' be higher than 54 as well whatever the sayate it doesn't matter we want to get as close to 100 as we can point being this is the percentage of students who met what has been determined as the desirable level of performance but Steve can you translate then obviously not all of them but you know let's say in fourth grade at 49 to 54% what can a kid do or can't do and in 11th grade at 11% what could it I kind of joke here this why you know when you go to McDonald's they have to use the

052adding Cal the cash to figure out the change what do the 11% in particular tell you what what is a kid in 11th grade not able to do on a daily basis because he's only 11 he or she's only 11 11% proficient to to do well on the SAT and this was true before they started using the SAT as a state assessment is is a is a is a is a viable major of the quality of high school learn uh for every student um you know the you need a you need a Algebra 2 you need to be pretty competent up through Algebra 2 you need to had some statistics uh as well uh which is you know as it goes and you'll see that every everybody gets it gets harder I mean look even

053the whole state average is 30% which is not great right 11 is definitely less than great we know that we acknowledge that more on that later what we're doing but you know it just gets more complex and I think that you get into sat is a he very verbal kind of an assessment even in the math a lot of a lot of word problems it's a lot of a lot of interpreting text and so on so uh you know it's it's a very it's a very challenging assessment it's a little more discret I'm not going to say it's easy down in third fourth fifth grade sixth grade it's a little more discreet a little more traditional what we call math although there's even there there's a fair amount of word problems and math reasoning types

054of problems the New Hampshire State assessment scores is that a is that comparable to other states is there any way to compare how we do say to Kentucky or Nevada or whatever they they're comparable in the sense that whatever state determines for their state assessment system be must be must be approved through the Federal Department of Education because this is this is remember this is No Child Left Behind this is one of one of the feature requirements in Noel Left Behind as well as the the program that succeeded no No Child Left Behind which is every student succeeds act um so so the state assessments are similar because they have to meet the certain criteria set by the feds and if they don't then you you know there's states that have said who we're not

055going to do this anymore and the FEDS are act okay no title one money for you no title two money for you no title four money for you I'm not saying that no no I know you're not no no no but the point is but the point is there there is a there is a commonality the other thing I think is important to remember to is that New Hampshire is always in top five sometimes in top three well that's yeah actually what prompted my question yeah yeah so State of Affairs everywhere I think the SAT is if you're not going to college what's your what's your desire to do well on that test I mean I remember being a kid taking mandatory stage assessment test I would do zig zag Right Down the Line because

056I wanted to be done so if I know I'm not going to college but I have to take this test I could not even read it and just fill in circles to get out of the room and get a zero bringing everything down I just think it's a really flawed assessment because it's only applicable who for kids who are actually going to college for people who know they know they're not going to college why why do they care what they get on that test which begs the question if you could actually take the test results and segment them on okay the kids that are going to college what how did they perform as opposed to the others I think that would be much better yeah we're going to do that if you could evaluate that

057be helpful so moving on I know we got a lot of ground to cover uh this is the ELA Ela is a is a combination of reading and writing with the exception being the SAT which is mostly reading oriented uh same same kind of a uh pattern you know although I think we hold up obvious obviously much better in those uh upper K8 grades and certainly in high school um you know at or near the state average so we get even exceeding the state average in a couple of instances 11th grade still again we're just not doing as well on the SAT in general need to be and this one's important because I misspoke last time I want to correct the record I mistakenly said our state Sciences scor for higher than State average that's

058not correct I maybe I had a newbound moment I flashback to a year ago or or a or a Littleton moment a few years ago when we were about the state average in science by the way but I did want to correct that record and that what was this dat uh this is It's 2024 thank you yeah June of 2024 and that science score will be composed of freshman biology sophomore 11th grade it's an integrated y all of them are integrated chemistry y physics physics correct a little bit of everything so I guess to some degree I'm not sure why you could be at 31% in those and only at 11% in the math it's a bit counterintuitive I know that yeah it's a different this is a this is a very different ass though

059yeah but you I mean the tools that you would need love continue framewor yeah I think the point he's making is you can't be that it's counterintuitive that you'd be that bad at math and be more okay in science but I think that that lends Credence to what Travis's point is which those those numbers on math at that grade level are dependent on the SAT and so that might be artificially being deflated by kids who are not right putting putting the the emphasis or value in taking that that SAT test because if it were if it if it if it you would expect a more normalized result between your math and science for is the point I that you're trying to make I think when you compare the against the population of the state though

060you get rid of that VAR because there's no reason to think that our students would be any more out of here than the state aage students could be yeah would where that might drive a little bit different is a population we have a higher population of traditional College B versus not that would be that could drive it a little bit but you're right I mean that's why you have to be careful that's why I always say it need some kind of a standard to compare yourself to the state average with some limitations is is probably as good as anything this is just a longitudinal data you just read just follow you know you figured this out follow the colors that's a that's a pretty much a cohort group of kids could be a few in

061could be a few out you know but you'll see some very interesting numbers here some that are you you'll see the effect of Co smack you right in the face right look at that you go from 1819 third grade went from 79 to 31 and they missed they missed going to a key a key time Co really affected them and others as well affect them all pretty much um this is cohort same same thing except for ELA so what are we doing um I remember sitting at one of these meetings last year and and with a hard conversation and and I and I remember uh yeah there's a lot of conversation I remember Matt saying we hire we'll hire more Math teachers more Al saying we we we trying we're trying they're not flocking to

062Litton uh however we are we are fully staff that helps you know teaching matters quality teaching really really matters uh we have put more resources toward the middle school with using so our title and funds to hire teachers that support math there future Hing a teachers with math in mind I I remember in some of my places where I work uh I would find creative ways to to bring people in that have math and science background for various other positions I just get them in get them in the building grow your own teachers Ed program our teachers Ed program over the years has been instrumental and and I think we need to even focus that more and H in more and hate say I don't want to brainwash any of these kids but say hey

063we we need High School teachers too we need Middle School teachers too we need we need elementary teachers with the math background as well we need to kind of work on that as well speaking of growing your own my granddaughter say she wants to be a ma teacher I like the approach I I think you know you're not going to solve it all over now there big big picture things that we can do you know and and we and we're working on it yes please please so we did change the schedule for freshman so freshman who recommendations should make great teachers ass ready for one taking one allod so have all year not minutes so hopefully by the end the fresman year second year is looking at a 50 minute period or what we're doing

064now is students first semester taking geometry and high percentage of students Tak the second semester we are taking math all year long we've gone from around 40% student volume participating to to over close to 75% why the you want to increase that in sof I think we're going to add a class again the is driving just have conscious of the students are not going too kind of we have yeah yes I know they looking at me on that one since you brought it up is there any possibility that there's a graders that are allow the scheduling of Middle School lend itself to any eighth graders being able to take so so let me go one more out since can't itself but um is trigonometry anywhere in this trigonometry is did analysis of courses typically finding

065that aren as strong develop separate kids want to go to pre all right thanks you still have that track and you look at the SAT results stud in that track well I know I said a lot last year I think you I think everybody seems to calling chy into a different for emphasizing some professional development teachers we do have a our teachers in grades 5 through 12 who teach math are part of a Statewide math cohort with a consultant I've worked with for several years now who been very successful uh helping teachers with new strategies and skills and approaches to engage students in learning and math mathematics and understanding deeply how mathematics Works Judy mayard is a is a consultant that Joanne brought in last year uh as we started down this road of looking

066at you know looking at things on a very micro level but macro as well looking at bigger pictures uh she's provided a lot of support already primarily lway I will be doing more support uh going forward with the high school she's also working with our administrative team a little bit on some of our work to improve supervision evaluation support of teachers you know it's it's kind of it's a very holistic approach here there's a lot of different layers at a lot of different levels but you know we recognize the need to support teachers with PD we recognize the need to do a better job in supervising evaluating and supporting teachers and then the prum alignment uh like ways done a lot of work identifying the key skills concepts of math uh updating some of those

067and aligning that well to the assessment uh 712 we're working with nhli hamper learning uh initiative and with a consultant uh who's been in here several times throughout the year working with the staff in all curricular areas including math but getting better better focus on essential skills these are some very these are great questions John uh I wish I had great answers but I think they wonderful question uh is there any movement anticipate for the state own increasing school funding and you know I don't I'm not a I'm not a funding expert or Economist or whatever uh I think one thing one thing I think in talk to legislature when I talk to them and it's like and they're right you know we have we have to look for sources of fun of funds right

068and and for the state funding formula ever changed dramatically that probably goes down that dreaded Road don't I don't don't say I support this by the way but that goes down that dreaded Road you know what they are sales tax and income taxes I'm not advocating that I think there's a reason for that that that's that people move to New Hampshire that's one of them they don't have to do that but you you know there's no free lunch is the old saying goes and that shifts more of the burden on local taxes and so on um there is a lawsuit in progress one of several over the years that the legislature will be grappling with um so you know and I think you know I think that it's there's the reality of that and I

069think there's a lot of I've talked to many legislators that are very on both sides by the way that are supportive of school supporting of funding but it's a it's hard coming up with the dollar is there any movement from the legislature considering anything you know again I I think we're kind of we're getting a little more into the session now we'll find out more where some of the priorities are um so we we'll see but uh you know funding's always going to be a part of it I think I I would say this I think given some of the things that was in the legislature last year and some of the kind of the trends and all I think we'll see more and more expectations it's not a bad thing by the way more

070and more expectations that school do a better job of engaging parents working with parents individualizing you know communicating General communicating uh so I I do think that's something definitely we'll see more of uh combining assets and offering High School level yeah I think we're we have to continue to look how do we best spend dollars that's why we we've done some reconfigurations it's painful we start to say we're not going to have this program anymore that way it means we're not going to have this teacher anymore that's those are not pleasant conversations to have with people we had to do that but we we believe that the program that we offer you know we need to have a optimal number students in and those programs that need to be continually growing and changing I'm talking

071about tech especially to meet the needs to these are documents just leak the documents so you have those in hand hard copies um so I'm GNA stop there we do have a post an hour tonight to talk about the hard numbers Patty certainly seems like a good point to apologize I have to leave so some of these attachments um were probably generated from conversations with the budget committee so after meeting with Diane and talking about a few things we just generated these worksheets to just answer some of those questions I wasn't going to go over them just start does it make sense to talk about the teachers contract first one on our side we not talked about that yet does that make sense yeah absolutely yeah y so just just a little bit and then

072and then uh from my perspective well I'm going to stop actually Travis Matt anything you want to say on that before we get into some other numbers or whatever yeah I mean so general landscape right level funding budget last this this article right and we're in a position where um over the last Ste un executive for seven years or so the salary schedule has been frozen right and so um if you look at the comps with other districts little to me would could be in a position where uh it needed to be competitive with other districts and we had fallen uh well behind we had a good series of good negotiations with uh the MTA and they we made the right decisions for the right reasons but there there comes a time where you have

073to have a salary schedule that keeps Pace right and so the negotiation negotiation team from the the district side our Focus U was on making sure we emerg from those discussions with um a a CBA that was obviously Fair we have a a priority to be a great place to work but was compet comptitive right put us in a competitive position because as you know steeve was just talking about this a little bit ago it's becoming increasingly challenging for us to hire uh to to identify and to retain uh the right level of skilled professionals to provide the services that we provide to students can I interrupt and ask you what you consider to be competitive would it be the top of the pack the middle of the pack it's very good point to say

074competitive folks what do you mean by that say here yeah so if you here I mean I don't think we have a number right we're not trying to be first we're certainly not wanting to be last so I think it's we not put a number on Travis Ry or Steve or Patty as to what being competitive looks like we certainly weren't with the salary schedule as it currently existed so our our priority was to make sure uh that we we saw significant material increases um on the salary schedule across all steps so that we could be competitive uh with new entrance to the teachers market right new graduates who came out with credentials were looking for jobs but also could be competitive for people who had their masters people who had years of experience we

075wanted to see increases sort of across the salary schedule and that's ultimately what um you see in the negotiated agreement with both sides have t agre to for yes so um had a little history with negotiations we us still look at all the four Childs in the state so um one of the contracts we were in the top of the fourth cour trial and then we negotiated a contract we are now in the uh lower part of the first court trial can you give us any comparisons that way which court trial you were were in and hope to be with the passing of this I don't have those numbers other than what's on the screen and I will give you an additional data point which is Patty tells us seven eight seven North Country districts

076are in negotiations this cycle so some of that data in terms of where we met out is not yet available to the goal post is about to move yeah yes so these this is based on right now all of our salary schedules in comparison before we move the go book before okay but so what do that tell said that we're we're fourth out of 14 that the first line seventh me that's from the top right just want to be the talking about pouse at least of this segment we're we're middle of a pack to a little bit higher currently or will be as a result of this negotiation currently we have no idea what everybody's bringing to their tax no no but I mean this is dependent on us passing this contract this is before

077the cont this where we stand now with with the today or this year keep in mind too one more data point sorry when when we two cycles ago when we renegotiated with the support staff so not this most recent contract that was passed in last Mar but the one that preceded that we were expecting significant wage increases to be necessary across the board this was during Co when when you were seeing inflationary press on wages and you were seeing you know McDonald's and Walmart and whoever advertise at the front of their properties with hourly rates that were well beyond where the our St right and so we knew we were going to have to be in position where we were going to have to make substantial increases to remain competitive we did that with the

078support staff three years ago right we didn't do that with the LTA and so this can be seen as a continuation of that movement didn't happen in 21 22 23 and we're bringing it to the town now in in 25 the reason why I was working up um where do we stand in state is because it's hard to get people to come up here so not only are competing with your country but you're also semi competing with the whole state so that was I was asking question see if we can get more numbers in advance of the deliberative have so you you had said that in your estimate we're not competitive now yeah we and if if we weren't if we didn't make significant changes we're running the risk of falling behind because if you

079look at I forget the exact numbers right but if you look at like the situation say you're you're looking to be you have an option to be a math teacher at profile or at apartment right if the difference for a step one is eight grand I mean and you're not from around here right and you're just GNA move up here and does make difference right like so like like and you're not going to be like oh well this about little like no you're not even it's not even going to be a consideration for me because it's such a substantial swing right and that's what we kind of have to face and we we recognize the reality of the tax bases are different right the tax bases are different but at the end of the day

080competing for the same resources and and job applicant is going to be like well it's not like well you know I feel for Litton because their tax Bas isn't Sugar Hill right it doesn't matter right so that's that's something that we have to worry about but again I mean I I apologize to repeat what I just said sure but you're saying we're not competitive and yet on your little chart there you're showing that we're we're four out of 14 that sounds pretty competitive to me so I guess even though you say we don't want to be the top that really is what you mean when you say somebody's higher than we are so I don't know there seems to be a little mismatch in the in what's that saying and what we're saying and as

081I say I apologize for the same question but and maybe we should have stretch this out Beyond just current because some of these folks do have multi-year contracts and we know what their base is going up the next few years um so I mean we should have stretched it out saying B on what we know now this is where we're going to go the next two years um if our schedule doesn't change like it has not in the past seven years well let's get to the schedule and I'm still not following what would it take for you to call us competitive oh yeah I said we I I I accept that this is not a satisfying answer we don't have a rubric right we don't say competitive means we have to be number three or

082above or we have to be five or L right so I I appreciate that it would be more satisfying if I had that black and white rule I don't but 8,000 differential you need six and not at eight or four or two it's been at least five years there's been any increase to their base pay on step one at least fighter since any increase with all the inflationary pressures what I think we did the teachers was fair but also still very responsible for the tax pay don't forget out of the 14 schools that are here seven of them are in negotiation so we we're fourth right now but after the seven negotiate we could be forunate right but when you're negotiating this with your current staff yeah virtually none of whom are at step one

083correct okay you're negotiating this contract with them but really negotiating it for the candidates that you're going to be entertaining well it's about it's about it's about attaining and retaining right so it's both well yeah but yeah as I mentioned if we're going to pull up the salary schedule we we worked with the LTA negotiations team intentionally and made sure that there were Equitable increases across all the steps so that we weren't waiting it so that we were throwing all the dollars behind steps you know 13 through 17 we wanted to see increases level across the board from steps 1 through 17 so that it put us in a position to be as competitive as we could be across the board right but your opening comments I'm not saying wrongly so are targeted to the

084disparity and the need to enhance step one no In fairness to me I think I said I think I said higher hand yeah but you gave that $8,000 was wasn't that step one that was step one though yes that was step one yeah so I mean if you don't address that you don't have to worry about where they're going to be later yeah but nothing stopping it's not like they can't leave when they get up and they're like oh well I could go make now I'm at step five here little I could go make $110,000 more just in Lisbon or pile or White Mountain Regal no no and I'm not saying that I just saying sense that I would need that we we were having a hard time getting a new person's attention to start

085with problem bring it and P we have more on I can I can speak to the numbers a little bit sorry I got to move the doc like a we at 41220 now we're at 41220 for a B1 that's starting in the Bach's track so in year one we're looking to add $1,925 so it'll be 43145 in year two we're looking to add another 1925 so we'll be 4,070 year three would be $1,930 so it be 47,000 taking very careful here is that somewhere in the packet that you passed up I have you have yeah um you know I I will say this going back a little bit to the competitive and where we are again this is doe there's always there's always a challenging a little bit to to give average teacher salaries because

086different different districts put their money in different places sometime in different districts have some districts have teachers that are long tenured some have fewer te fewer teachers stay a long time so their average teacher salary is is depressed a little bit or it could be the other way um I know the most recent State data were about in the middle in terms of teacher salaries I can tell you a few years ago and it did the cost of Education study group we were in the top quarter uh teacher salaries so I guess I think part of what we were looking at is yeah we we we we're okay you know we were okay within the North Country we're still definitely competitive we're not the top but we're definitely competitive but we need to stay that

087way and I think that comes when it comes to salary when it comes to benefits we are in a in a competitive market Statewide I don't I don't know where if if this passes where it'll put us I can't I can't predict what's going to happen all around the state uh but and I I apologize I thought we' email that piece out to you as well the the actual agreement but we'll get the salary scheduled for you I think one thing also we just made certain decisions um we felt were served our the purposes best for instance staff increments 7eventh and eth we're probably going to we may fall down we may be more toward 14 than we are now and I don't think that's a bad thing this is why we chose to put

088the money distribute the money equally through the salary schedule so everyone gets the same uh increase every year no matter if they're sitting at step two or it's out the near the bo some some set salary schedules for the yearly step but differential we don't or stays the same somebody some it's okay every every district has their own goals some districts put significant differentials to move across you that makes some sense because it does encourage people to get advanced studies and so on I think and I want speak out a turn from the negotiators from the board but I think and the board as a whole felt like we wanted to be equ so you know we wanted we wanted people to to you know to benefit as equally as we could throughout the new

089salary schedule well it's important to attract new teachers it's important to retain your own teachers it's important to get qualified and experience teachers and so you know you have to look at all areas that you're contract so on the insurance any changes on the insurance benefits I'm just leing here on this yeah yeah go ahead I would like to make a comment on that um and obviously this is not the time to address it because we're well down the road but I was quite appall at the um cost of uh family health insurance policy and I would urge you to look at Alternatives where uh you know maybe it's a high deductible plan and you pay the deductible or something there's there's got to be a way to make it more affordable foring employees in

090the school district I mean it's just has been mention $35,000 is just horrifyingly ludicrous when I saw that figure it just about knock me off my chair Mar but that's been mentioned many times in the past there's been great reluctance to to look outside the um happy to volunteer to work with someone from the administration or the board if you wanted to look into that I don't sell insurance but I have U worked for a small business which was able to uh you know offer the employees a a health insurance plan that was affordable for everybody even on a very small scale I think one of the areas and you can speak to it um there there's salary and then there's benefits right and and the salaries you're trying to address competitive but on health

091insurance benefits where do we stand in comparison to the other districts yeah they're T most of them are 15 or 20% um so I mean we're in the same ballark as everyone else and we don't have the most expensive health insurance as some surrounding districts you say 15 or 20 you say that's the portion of the 15 20% assume you will from the same set of plant that are offered from the state yes health insurance vendor I forget what the group is called several there's several of them yeah there's several different groups you can buy from thank you but you're not necessarily limited to those or by the negotiated agreement something similar yeah so I would just urge you to make it more affordable for everybody I mean even 10 15% of $35,000 a year

092is a lot of money oh AB no absolutely absolutely is but Mary the headwind that we're we're moving into or have been for the last 10 or 20 years is that there was virtually no desire in part the town or the school to look think look or think outside the blocks well okay I just want to clarify that we do have um High deductible plans we have $8,000 um deductible and a $44,000 deductible we brought in a few years ago an Insurance Consultant willing to donate their time and and evaluate both the town and the school plans couldn't get the time or the numbers from Nei the town or the school to do it well obviously I'm late to the party singing the same old tune but I'm going to sing it no and I

093not and appreciate you saying it but but it is it's just amazing how much both systems are stuck in the mud and Bally refus business as usual and God it's horrible it's going up another 20% this year gas gas but that's where we are so John has to leave at 6:30 so if we could go through the tables but now that we have P when's the last time we did a r valve on the health insurance year I went out to B last year no we will we can do it again but I think you tend to go out to just the same people you've gone out to before he J is ridiculous all over us that's but there there are some innovative ways and if you want to bring the cost down for our

094employers or our employees it's going to raise the cost to the taxpayer to do that we're going to pay more well that's I don't think this is a town or Schoolboard thing I think this is an insurance thing being ridiculous all across the country there virtually no private business in Littleton that hasn't found an inov Innovative way to approach it and most of it has involved the Assumption of some amount of Self Insurance not to a risky level but to a manageable level so well put well now that we have the schedules yeah um you can see so py um the first year um base is moving to 43145 that correctly correct and that's that's 1,925 higher than the previous yes so it's 41220 it's currently so the staff would if they were on step

095one they're going to move to step two so they're going to receive the base increase of the 1900 and the step increase 1 correct correct yes and for the first year that is a what kind of impact is that the 2 that's the 262 and the average increase is 4.4% I just can you decipher the column headers for us please I'm sorry I see ba 30 B4 so that's a a bachelor's plus 30 credits a bachelor's plus 45 credits or a master's degree then a master's with 15 credits and a master's with 30 credits thank you so one of the things that Steve and I when we were on the cost of Education committee together and and state as well um we had the Bachelor and the bachelor's plus 30 but there was not a

096bachelor's plus 45 there was just a master's so in in the other districts it encouraged the people to move to the Masters um and not just accumulate credits and so just I'm just saying that food for thought for maybe next time so because they can just rack up the the credits without going on to get the the Masters and with an emphasis on having dual certification right to make them more verselis especially for a small school district trying to to be the Devil's Advocate there do you find that people um you know rack up their post bachelor's credits but don't continue to move on toward and eventually get the Masters or are they just in the process generally would you know the answer to that yeah I don't I do we don't have people that

097just racking up credits they're in a program to get way to their Master we have one of the lower in the area we have one of the lower numbers of Staff having a masters and many other communities around us so that's the reason why I was saying that I don't have a problem rewarding people as they make progress so think there's some they have to have the master in order to teach you know a good teacher there's another reason whether they got a PhD or a bachelor I I like a good teacher I I do too but I think there wasas there was a limitation on what what what they can teach without Masters they can't teach AP courses that's it that was it correct that was it thank you John but now the school

098has all these um agreement with running start and whatnot all right so I apologize I've got to run I really don't want to but I do apologize um I do see there was a really sincere attempt to keep the cost within our guidelines that we asked for in the first place so thank you than so if I was a ba at step 10 step 10 means I've I've been a teacher for 10 years correct so am I getting an increase of 1925 plus 13,000 because of the 1300 150 but I'm saying I'm it's 1350 because of Step period whether it's 10 steps 12 steps 15 it's 1350 it is okay and we didn't make any changes to steps in this contract only it's been 1350 for a long time y any other questions on any

099other things that you want to tell us about the contract there wasn't a lot of changes a lot of it was wording wording that had been in there for probably DEC dates um we just needed to bring them up to date date changes um yeah emailing instead of posting on a bulletin board you know like notifications you know just trying to update those type of things I mean we negotiated a lot of things um but the committee decided that all their efforts and funds would go into the salary there 262 the first year3 the second 21 the third and your um support staff contract is what is the next negotiation we're in year one right now oh you are y we're in year one right now and this is for like three years we didn't

100want them to renew at the same time like they were so just curious we have offet this pad when you said put all their uh funds into the salary schedule as opposed to what else might they put their fun um they might have wanted to increase let's say sick day buyou or retirement benefits you know other issues you know different things just want all great Med [Music] impct so you have good teachers and not so good teachers and they all have to get paid the same correct absolutely well that's unfortunate but that's the way it is I get that evaluations are important and and that that was addressed to the description of what your assignment was the beginning of like September 1st or something [Music] the administration will provide preliminary notice to teachers of their

101expected schedules is that just a schedule just a schedu that's just their schu I have a question you said you just made a statement that the evaluations are important what is the evaluation what does an evaluation do well it depends on how many years they've worked here um I'm sure be other administrators that actually evaluate teachers can explain that well basically the long and short of it is the the teachers are on a contract right and the superintendent has to bring them forward for a nomination so if there's a evaluative process and somebody is not really they need to be the call nomination that's the process but within once they're nominated and they're under the CBA they make the same amount based on what their credentials re is that for step increases no no you

102know it's all so you work in here or you're not yes okay yeah yeah that's what I that's what I meant when he made the comment about good teachers and Bad Teachers that's why I said that's why evaluations are important because if they're done you know if they're done and reflect a poor instructor then the superintendent bring for so just in the in the context of the conversation that we've been having having hard time finding teachers that can do a job so you have a p teacher or you have no teacher you're kind of in a tough spot Onre probably probably unless the administrator wants to work in the classroom in in their office yeah okay so I think any other questions on the negotiated agreement and it sounds like we want move to uh

103the the full budget thank you I want to say that it looks like you did a great job it's a large bump 4.6% on the bottom end but if someone in the middle or you know on the upper end it's right fairly standard like if you're not getting a 3% you know and it does drop year two and three it does drop down so that's year one's the highest you talking about the contract this yeah yeah yeah the average just the average you know that's the average of the whole group and then does decrease this this is a three-year contract right in 2020 it ends in 2028 so the total tax burden at the end of that will be 1.5 million right4 that sounds about accurate we worked on that so you expect the bad

104the budget to raise the 2020 by at least that the contract is that TI oh the total total because that 26 accumulates right so it's around 1.2 1.3 1.5 okay okay so um I handed it out we didn't put it on here because it's so small and then we have to have like 15 slides so just gave you the traditional handout you're going to see several of them the very first one is with no articles it's just the operating budget and how you how we came to the um level level funded budget compared to the total Appropriations last year um the second one I'm just going to give you an overview right now and then we can talk about line by line is just adding the teachers contract so on page five you can see

105that the teachers contract is 624 so um that would be the increase to the budget there or overall appropriation let me rephrase that and then on page eight um we're going to talk about having additional articles like we have in the past for depositing into our capital reserve funds I did put on page nine the current balances of them what we're talking about is the district equipment capital reserve which currently has 67,000 and the district facilities it currently has 65,000 so we do know that we will be purch purchasing a piece of equipment so that 67 won't be 67 in June so that's why we want to um put 50,000 of fund balance if we have it into that and we wanted to bump up the facilities we've been doing 50,000 the last couple years

106I've been here we want to bump that up to1 ,000 so that we would have over 100,000 for June in case there's an emergency or or something like that we certainly have been using the facilities um capital reserve fund and we want to make sure because we're not directly collecting those expenses from the taxpayers the board has been approving the withdrawals to use it as that's why we've um created them and keep putting money into them for those type of projects like the gym ceiling this past year so um that shows you the total increase now mind you the capital reserve deposits don't have a direct tax impact I say that in a way that when I write the article the article will say no tax impact because it's going to come from revenue of

107the fund balance at the end of the year but it is um appropriate 3% increase the bottom line but also on the other hand my revenue on the other side increases 150,000 so there's no implication in the actual estimated tax rate I know we went down through this really quick it has not changed since we met at the last meeting I do want to note again um that the proposed operating budget is $40,000 below the default budget I just submitted my default budget to Dr today um so and typically you don't see that you don't down three teachers though right you remember from the last the last meeting that we had what down three teachers right yes this proposed budget um that we're proposing is down um an administrator and two teachers and two teachers

108people are right right so yeah and that's why um when I gave that explanation of salaries and benefits and stuff when we met last that's why you know the numbers aren't a significant increase because we did reduce Staffing which in return reduces taxes and health insurance and everything that goes along with it so I know that you're very um f go on on estimating your revenues not expenses conserv very conservative realistic yeah so so I'm looking at the federal funds and um for tit one title two and all of those and um compare them I know um Esser is gone Esser is gone so that was 2023 is that eser 24 this year will reflect Esser 25 okay next year does not reflect okay so you have 200 and 200 so that that's what you're

109estimating to get for those the 650,000 oh I'm looking right here federal funds this is oh you look at the individuals okay yeah so these are just based on estimates of what we anticipate um actually we talked we just talked about this Steve and I did 650 um is a figure that this district has used for many many years um if I increase the federal funds are in and and out if I appropriate 650 I have to show 650 as the revenue I could increase that to a million dollar and increase the revenue to a million dollars the bottom line is it does doesn't impact anything it's just a placeholder for funds that may be coming in and then you can spend what and I can we can spend whatever the board accepts um so

110it's truly just a placeholder it certainly won't be 2.6 million um that was a big year for eer funding this past year we um it will be pretty big a million and something this year for federal funds and we only appropriated so you don't typically touch that because the appropriation bottom line is going to increase by that amount and you're not required to you just you have to have a placeholder sort of what our revolving funds on town it's just report on both sides of the balance sheet as a placeholder so yeah I talked about that um but there really isn't a mean to do it to to increase it well the only thing is is that you have programs that are associated with those numbers and and um you know transar on what you

111have as programs where funding is coming from John dues and fees went up 18,5 588 21% I read the explanation of increased cost and doing fees and conferences for CTE it Department NH nhba school students yeah um so are we doing different conferences and is the IT department right we never budgeted I mean I can tell you it's not 18,000 for Dale's Department absolutely not but we never budgeted for them to go to conferences go to trainings and we did add that in um the school board association dues which we have to pay has increased significantly and um I'm trying to remember the CTE what was the significant increases on yours I highlighted the three departments the three departments that increase significantly um which is yours it Association a little a lot bud any other

112questions I got have question for you and I I realize it's it's a small number but what what is the bank fee the bank fees okay so we have a we do have a commercial account it's not free P you know personal accounts can be ours is not we also this year it increased this year because we added security to our processes that happen at Union Bay so that Fe to have this increased security Cy yeah we had a check that was compromised so um now before the bank clears them we actually physically look at them front in back um and it the system Compares it to what we sent out to what then is bringing back in so we physically look at them so that service cost us and I again it's not a

113lot of money but it high 140% raises right for the additional few dollars a month but um certainly is something that is um well worth the minimal minimal increase and then furniture and equipment and software well the software we knew was going to increase because some of it was in and we Dale and I the schedule where every five years some some software renewals are three years some are one some are five so we have this rotation and we tried to spread them all out so that deal would have huge like increases so that'd be somewhat steady over a fiveyear period there were some that were still in effort that obviously had to budget in the general fund this coming year so I thought we were very careful not to spend Sr funds on continuing

114costs this was I think probably a couple of those we weren't sure if we were going to keep maybe we may not but at this point they are budgeted for I think there was quite a bit care taken I think you're right pointing that out on the Personnel side and this is where school got got a lot of trouble you know and again you wanted to our Personnel because the learning Gap and everything they acknowledge that at the same time it did create a bit of a budget put the F away any other questions so um going to the warrant do vote on any of these tonight or do you want to over we're gonna have well if you guys want to do what you did in the past let my board My Board needs

115to needs to decide themselves at the next board meeting what articles they want to have on there am I correct that you guys want to vote at your next board meeting what articles they're definitely going to have we vote before you so what I was after we get done Monday's meeting and I know exactly what I need to submit um to Dr I was going to email it to you so that the next time you guys meet at whatever meeting you have next you could vote but not too likely things going change and that's pretty moderate so yeah yeah I mean I I can't imagine anything would be changing budgetary wise I just haven't truly gotten confirmation from them on um trust fund and a board member had brought up increasing the moderator I don't

116know if the mo did the moderator's term get increased at the Town level um I don't think so I didn't see it I don't remember seeing okay so that was one that was brought up last year but it was kind of late and um we had already created the warrant so we said this year we would bring It Forward is there a background for changing from one to three just yeah I mean it was a request it was other terms of three years essentially right right and you know it I'm not saying that the person we have now wouldn't run but it's just redundant right you get the same person you have them for a decade or five decades right and it's just a one-year term you know I'd love to see everybody have somewhat

117of a term and staggered but I don't believe by law the treasurer or the clerk could be more than one year I did a quick research on it but I'm town the moderator until until they quit it's one year year right now it's one year right now it's been requested that they change it to three yeah I was say it was requested to both of us because there's so many War articles on the town side geted yeah I know it was requested of the town and of the schol increase the moderator to three and I so if it passes this year then next year on that warrant it will save three years instead of one but ste's question on the big ticket items right the the negotiated agreement that's not going to change between now

118and our next meeting because it is what it is right um on not bringing forward Lakeway we're not going to change our minds again between that in Monday so that's staying off the ballot and then on the budget itself as we've been reviewing and presenting with you I think the only open item that we have to make a decision on by Monday the 16th is whether or not we're going to continue to include the the the $50,000 for or $100,000 excuse me for The Residency program the presentation on tonight so there's a chance that that $100,000 comes out of the budget but that's the only barring any late minute surprise we don't tend to surprise each other I think that's the only thing that that could potentially shift between now and when we officially vote

119on it you the opportunity we had a good discussion it makes sense to wait till till after you guys definitely but thank you I appreciate it we did it I'm like I'm counting down on my budget committee meetings this year one more to go pretty efficient thank you sorry the um we hav A J yet so what is the I would what are we getting for the extra $50,000 actually $60,000 if you include the it so the contracted Services um explanation is because there was a $10,000 increase on purchase services and that was for IT services and then another $50,000 for software as where we just found out right so what are we talking about there and I guess I'm pushing back a little bit like are we getting the value for that 60 Grand

120what is the what what what's the change here Dale do you want to speak to that the $10,000 in purchase Services is a new teacher evaluation tool that Dr nyas has met with the administrative so that's the the $110,000 increase on that side and software every single piece of it was originally in ESS it had to come out it's decided to keep it so in order to keep it we had to increase up $50,000 we we put almost $300,000 in software in ESS the last three years so at some point we we have to decide we're continue on that path with those I can't speak to whether or not it's efficient because it's all curriculum off most is so a good share of it is if we were W the clock back five years before

121eser even existed we've since used 300,000 of those thater money for software and now we looking at $50,000 of ongoing costs or going back to the level of software integration that we had before yeah we we have eliminated software that that we determined was not being used enough and didn't have value to it um but yeah mean most every addition that's in there is a curriculum based software it was so curriculum based software means communication with the parents like ccul basware math or science curriculum [Music] Ela gotta and the other thing we did is that we we bought three to five new licenses that software so that no group sections come due and it's not all due in one year don't get that Flex the 50 is so that it stays consistent and that's how

122it into it shouldn't it shouldn't go up I mean it shouldn't flate that we anticipated last year to add 25 and we decided not to and just for the sake of adding it to the budget so it had less of an impact this year did not yeah okay thank you [Applause] the the town moderator last year the town moderator last year was voted for two years all right so if there are no additional questions thank you obviously of course as always but we'll look formally for a motion to adjourn yes second any discussion all those in favor I the same motion cares we did 65 to 28

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.