CorpusRecord 95397

School Budget Hearing/Bond Hearing January 14th 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Londonderry School District
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Rockingham County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,340 words · about 102 min
Collected
2026-06-12

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e to be held on Tuesday January 14 2025 in the C at lenary high school 295 Mammoth Road lenary New Hampshire at 700 p.m. the meeting will all will be broadcast on District YouTube channel as well as cable access Channel 8 could we please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance please to FL the United States of America to One Nation God indivisible thank you we'll get into the consent agenda 3.1 upcoming meetings uh January 28 2025 will be a regular school board meeting right here in the cafe at 700 p.m. on February 7th 2025 will be the deliberative session and a small uh short school board meeting right after right here in the cafe at 700 p.m. on February 18th 2025 will be a regular school board meeting right here in the cafe

002at 700 p.m. uh could I look for a motion to approve the consent agenda please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Amanda all those in favor I I 5 Z thank you all right jumping into announcements presentations filing period for candidates Wednesday January 22nd 2025 through Friday January 31st 20 2 there is one Schoolboard member three-year term one moderator three-year term one Treasurer three-year term and one school district clerk for a three-year term to file please contact Carrie Stanley school district clerk at 9369 or at K Stanley at lenon dar.org carrye will be at the district office on Friday January 31st 2025 from 3: to 5:00 p.m. for the purpose of the final filing all right with that we're moving on uh we're going to uh start and open our public hearing for

003full day kindergarten uh for the district office Bond I will look for a motion to uh open this public hearing please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim I ask for a roll call vote from my left to right please hi Kevin GRE hi Tim Porter hi Bob Slater hi Sarah Laughin hi Amanda butcher thank you and the floor is open great um so what we've prepared if Jason Goes to the next slide um you know what the school board's deciding tonight is is this waren article moving to the deliberative session um so um and and in casting their votes their support for or against it so J goes to the next slide um it is it is article number two the F day kindergart and district office Farm we go to the

004next slide um next one um there is the the verbiage in total Bob's going to read it in a second then I have about you know 10 to 12 slides that'll kind of push out all the facts that are out there there there will be more coming we intend to do our best to share as many facts as possible over the next 8 weeks um so the community feels like they're informed heading into The Ballot Box we'll turn over to to read the article what I'll do this evening folks is I'll read each article in full that is uh on the agenda tonight and will be uh brought forward to the deliberative after deliberation tonight so I will read each one in as we go through this evening article two special article full day kindergarten

005and district office project shall the londondary school district vote to raise and appropriate the sum of 9,50 th000 for the design construction Furnishing and equipping of modular classroom additions and Renovations at South north and Matthew thoron elementary schools to create additional classroom space to accommodate a districtwide full day kindergarten program and for improvements to the renovations of Moose Hill School to serve as District central administrative office and to authorize the is issuance of 9,50 ,000 of bonds or notes under and in compliance with the municipal Finance act RSA 33 colon1 ET period seq period colon as amended colon to authorize the school board to apply for obtain accept and expend federal state or other Aid um if any which may be available for said project and to comply with all laws applicable to said project

006to authorize the school board to issue negotiate sell and deliver said bonds and notes to determine the rate of interest thereon and the maturity and other terms thereof to raise and appropriate the additional sum of 226,000 for the first Year's payment thereon and to authorize the school board to take any other action necessary or pass any other vote relative there to 35th ballot vote required fiscal year 2025 to 2026 estimated cost 226 250 estimated tax 4 cents 2026 to 2027 estimated cost $97,400 estimated cost $886,000 [Music] but not enough um we need to come up with a basically a less expensive solution which I'll go over in a little bit we compromised uh there was feedback that the current district office lease needs to be solved as well to gain that community support for f

007day kindergarten so it's kind of two needs coming together uh we also planned around a smaller incoming kindergarten enrollment which we've seen for the last two years and we're assuming that's that's a it's at least a three-year pattern um and we research multiple solutions to land on the current plan going to the voters in March so if we go to the next slide here's a very quick rundown of uh many months of hard work you know uh there's lots of information from the summer we're going to post on a website next week so people can access this all um one option was just to return uh the same project from last year uh back to the voters uh again this March uh ultimately that wasn't decided to happen um we also looked at a scale

008back Moose Hill so kind of taking that project uh building it around smaller enrollment that we're seeing now and and you know and some compromises and uh that was studied for many months over the summer But ultimately wasn't chosen uh another option was to kind of look at expanding F day kindergarten at Moose Hill now and and then whatever space we might have in in the other uh three currently grade one through five schools with smaller enrollment ultimately that also was not chosen uh we also looked at moving the preschool district office to existing commercial property space and then use Moose Hill uh for for a full day addition uh that was a very complicated project that we looked at for a really long time this summer But ultimately passed on as well uh we

009looked at moving the preschool to the high school and use moale for full day kindergarten with that smaller addition very similar to four uh but just another way of doing that and there's lots of reasons why um we were not comfortable moving the preschool to the high school uh we also looked at moving the fifth grade to the middle school and then placing full day kindergarten to the three elementary schools um there are lots of reasons why uh we kind of pass on that one as well um and then we also looked at um building a lot of modular classrooms at the Moose Hill Campus uh to accommodate full day kindergarten um and we passing that one too largely because of the larger price we go to the next slide um here's what we came

010up with um so leap our three and four yearolds will stay at Moose Hill so they'll kind of be in that Central wing and out to to the to the temporary classroom area that's in Moose Hill the other Wing will be turned into office space um you know kind of a generally a light touch but also you know one that'll be transformed so that um you know what is now classrooms will become Office Space um and you know somewhere by the fall of 2026 uh we would move the district office in there um first we have to kind of move kindergarten out um and then full day kindergarten by August of 2026 happens in Matthew thoron North school and South School um we'll be adding eight total modular classrooms uh they're going to be really

011great classrooms we try to give you a sense of what you're looking at in that picture is actually a modular classroom uh there's a brick facade we want these to to blend in very well to Matthew Jord very well to South School very well to North School um because they're going to be there for at least 15 years um and they're really good classrooms um we've been working with emman and Marines and you know they'll be customized some of them some of them will be a little B more standard but there'll be you know really great instructional spaces for our kids um and they're going to blend in that environment so if we go to the next slide um this is where they're going to go um there'll be four off of Matthew Thorton um

012with bathrooms in them and that so that includes site work an attached hallway there's an attached hallway way to every single one of these so the kids are never leaving the building uh to go to these spaces um and you know we put four 12200 foot classrooms there that can accommodate full day kindergarten um if you go to South School and North school it's a little bit different um we have 900 foot classrooms coming off the third grade wing of North school because we actually have bathrooms in our first grade Wing at North school so that's where the full day kindergarten uh would occur so it'll be more for the second and third graders those those two additional classrooms uh South School is kind of a mix where we will have these two large 1200

013ft classrooms with bathrooms if we needed them for for kindergarten in that area if we if we shifted things around but the current planning at least for 26 is to probably put them in the first grade in a similar spot they're near bathrooms kind of in South School um but you know the these additions will allow for full day kindergarten which we're really excited about so Mo to the next slide um big reductions from last year um you know so the total cost is $9 million still a lot of money uh that we're asking of the of the voters but it's for these excellent modular classrooms the site work and the attached hallways um and then also uh turning the district office into um office base uh sorry turning M into office space um about

014an 80% reduction if you put both those projects together that would be building the district office uh back across the street where it used to be for a long time so really really reduce costs um and and I know there are always going to be questions on enrollment and how that's going to work um so basically right now from from what we're building um you know we're rejecting about 1574 kids K to 5 next year probably 1547 while the following year um somewhere between 77 to 81 total you know K to 5 classrooms um what we're projecting right now is the these these shifting of eight modular classrooms we can handle at least 17 120 kids um and and I'll raise that number in a couple slides too so we have the room to accommodate

015full day kindergarten um we have the room in our Master schedules to kind of make this all work uh we just need to get the modular classroom there so we go to the next slide um this is just a quick view of some of the enrollment um what I was trying to show is where North school and South School were three four and five years ago um basically by by bringing full day kindergarten to those buildings we're refilling them where they used to be um back in 21 North school is at 493 we project two years from now to' be at 473 um with full day kindergarten South School is at 466 uh and they're back to 466 again we've had these two small classes in kindergarten and first grade that'll start to move through

016the system kind of creating some of the space and room Matthew Thorton's a little bit different if you go to the next slide their enrollment H has dropped just not as much is North and South School um last year we have about 540 kids in Matthew Thorton um you know a couple years ago we're we were in the low 500s so this would probably put Matthew Thorton around 600 um but that's why we're adding four classrooms there that's why we're kind kind of keep an eye on Space um and then the bottom chart kind of shows you you know where we were for for a while we were we were around 1,700 kids K to 5 um these two smaller classes definitely changeed that Dynamic by about 150 kids uh which is a lot you

017know um and if we ever had to if we ever ever had to worry about space um we would we would take a take some of our programs and make them more mobile you know so with this build with these modular classrooms we could probably handle anywhere from 1840 to 1900 K to 5 students which we haven't seen in a really long time so I think there is room I think this plan should work uh for the next 15 years um but if we suddenly get a big jump in enrollment hopefully we have many years to react to it we would need to see about 350 kids to 400 kids in a new class to really start to stress us out year after year after year so go to the next slide um besides the

018capital cost coming down the operating budget came down a lot too last year we were projecting about $1.2 million uh based in additional staff and that was additional staff at Moose Hill um we're projecting much lower costs some of it is the uh lower enrollment but some of it is uh the staff we had to bring to Moose Hill uh more nursing more counseling more monitors more janitors more art teachers or music teachers teach and gym teachers uh potentially more special education teachers they exist in these three buildings so we already have them we don't need to invest the same level of resources uh in them so I mean what we're conservatively projecting is probably two two years from now we would need at least um two probably maybe at most um to professional staff

019that would cost us about $180,000 so that's about 85% less than what we were projecting last year so again some of it's enrollment some of it's the plan is different than we're capitalizing on staff we already have we go to the next slide um trying to give a bigger picture uh of um of savings um globally so there are a lot of savings and increased uh state revenue we get in this project uh so we'd save about $280,000 in midday bus runs we tve about save about $260,000 with district office lease in the first year of full day kindergarten we get an extra, per kid um your state aid always runs a year and behind so it would take a couple years but you know we would project about additional $2,200 per student um for

020state aid once once that kicks in uh there obviously are increased costs you know that those two additional staff and the bond the capital costs be about 226,000 in the first year and then an average cost for the next 14 about 760 the other thing I want to point out before I go to the next chart was um there are there are are other capital costs that are coming off the books in these years too uh in this year's budget we already know we saved about 460,000 the districtwide bond retiring next year we have about 300,000 in the north school bond retiring and then by fiscal year uh 2030 we're going to save another half a million dollars from the south school bond retiring and the LED light so a lot of costs are coming

021down um there was a lot of you know uh last last week we were asking for kind of a broader analysis and and and bring it out am and I worked hard you go to the next slide um this is a good exercise for us you know so we saw right away that you know you got a couple years where you have initial upfront costs you know for the first 2 to three years we'll have to spend an additional half a million dollars to kind to get this project started but once those Savings kick in once those additional revenues kick in somewhere between that third and fourth year we're actually going to start saving money um you know so we built a model it's just a model it's just an estimate uh over the next

02215 years but if we assume the these costs escalate uh sorry these savings escalate each year the you know the revenue escalates a little bit each year um the costs escalated each year you know we would project over the life of the bond we would actually save about 2.2 million um once those bond prices really decrease that really compounds upon itself and then we're all when we're all paid with the bond it could potentially be a million dollar savings on the operating budget so um that was a good exercise for us I was glad that this you know this group kind of pushed us to come up with a more longer term analysis but we can kind of see it initial upfront cost but then it turns to to bigger big ger savings and and

023bigger Revenue over time so that was a real eye opening analysis for us and we'll we'll push this out uh with all of our marketing stuff in the in the coming weeks go to the next slide um you know but why we're here too I think why um I feel we've been doing this for years and we have is it's about full dead kindergarten um you know that's that's the big educational gain we get from this um our students who gain 103 extra days um that's a lot of time I saw there's a website created today that was trying to promote that our kindergarteners are doing fine yes they're doing fine in the half day curriculum I think that that what I saw from that website they got it actually wrong our kids are doing

024fine in a half day curriculum uh but if you turn it to first grade which we can put out pretty soon it's the only grade where we're consistently behind the state and National averages we're playing catch-up we're playing a lot of catchup in grades one and two we don't want to do that anymore as a school system we want to take kids that are at a more advanced level in first grade and and and push them and and get them farther up rather than catch them up um I know Bedford is asking for this in their operating budget for next year um I know Timberlin is studying it they're the other uh small dots in the sea of green within the state um and I hope we can lead the way and get there as

025soon as possible 26 27 uh for those families of three-year-olds but also to make sure we can recruit and and and bring more young families into town um so F day kindergarten is obviously the huge academic benefit uh for for this project go to the next slide can I interrupt you really Qui sorry I'm going to interrupt you to quote you because I was thinking about this while you were talking and I was looking for a slide um and I ended up finding it from last January um but in this slide it says that 60% of our students are reaching academic Expectations by the end of kindergarten um and then we're actually playing catchup so in terms of people or kids being um where they need to be that's not accurate and um in a

026local district with similar demographics that did make this change before they made the change onethird of their students weren't reading uh reaching the kindergarten expectations in half day when they shifted to full day they reduced that to one in 10 students so in addition to doing right by kids it's also going to save money in additional programming for the kids that aren't me uh meeting their benchmarks so I just wanted to well said and we'll share all those all over again for a second year in a row um you know so the big points of the project before we turn over to the public we heard you U this is much less expensive I think there's a good compromise in town around a lot of needs coming together all at once um I think we

027built a solid plan for lower enrollment if enrollment changes we can react to it this is a flexible plan um yep there are multiple projects going on but we have a wonderful partnership with emman and Marines to kind of figure this out um I think we've had a great fall and summer with them figuring this out I think the moving parts are fairly understandable um but we'll do our best to um explain it over time um there is not this big net loss of Staff in this process it'll be about redistributing the kindergarten staff into three buildings and and helping them kind of bring their magic to those three schools um we think we have a solid plan that that works with enrollment for the short and long term um these are going to be

028really high quality buildings they're going to be brick it's going to look like they're part of the school um they'll be very safe because they're going to be attached um um we're going to we're going to pump out as much as we can kind of the information we just shared around the costs uh and and that look and in the end again the big academic gain is is full day kindergarten so that's that's it in a nutshell I know we've been talking about this for years so we tried to be short um but I'm sure there'll be questions and things we can respond to sure thank you Dan all right I'm going to uh this is a public hearing uh for our community members so I'm going to open the floor to the public if

029you come up state your name and address please and uh the floor is yours hi thank you very much Christine Perez uh five Wesley drive thank you for this this is an awesome idea thank you I know you worked hard on it it's you listened to what people said last year that they didn't want to spend that kind of money you listen to that they wanted to get the SAU out of the tajma hall you listen to everything people said they didn't want their kids on buses for an hour at a time and I appreciate that um and I think it's absolutely great but now I'd like you to possibly consider um another option for to the consider um it's for the community and for especially for the children since we are here to search

030the children and I'm glad you brought up Bedford because this is bedford's model so Bedford New Hampshire offers all day kindergarten they pay for half day kindergarten and it's my understanding you said you'd be getting more funding from the state for all day kindergarten but um bedford's website even says that and then I didn't check it but um the state only funds half day kindergarten they don't fund all day kindergarten so I don't know and correct me if I'm wrong but I don't know but that's according to their website but what Bedford does is they have what's called K plus and I have copies of information on it so they offer all day kindergarten you can have all day kindergarten you can have half day kindergarten if you want all day kindergarten it is up

031to the parents or Guardians to pay for the second half they presently CH charge um right now they charge $5,250 annually um if a a payment uh schedule can be um established if you qualify for free to free or reduced lunch you may be eligible for a reduced rate this program they did a lot of studies around it and one of the biggest things they came up with when they implemented this was the fact that it was the best for the children if you have a child that is born on September 30th 5 years old they can start kindergarten if you have a child that is born on October 1st they have to wait almost a full year before they can start public kindergarten which makes them almost 6 years old there's a big difference

032between a 5year zero month child and a six year old child and by offering the option of knowing whether and not all children at 5 years old are appropriate to be in all day kindergarten that's proven in every single study you would want to find this gives the parent the option the parent the option who knows that child for those first five to six years the best of anyone the option of doing what is best for their child that's why they do this and I think it is a fabulous model that I would like to see you all consider it's a fabulous model for the children who we are here to serve but it also is a model for the taxpayer but the children first so I'm going to give you some print outs of

033this so M Miss Perez so the Bedford the Bedford school district is choosing to end that program next year well that's not to they have their applications online for next year but they're they're going through the process of ending what you're describing on purpose CU basically the parents told the superintendent they want to have full day kindergarten real full day kindergarten all right well that's fine but that doesn't mean that it there are other school districts that do it too that doesn't mean that we can't implement it in the beginning of us starting all day kindergarten for what's best for the kids and it really should be what's best for the kids and the taxpayer so sure you know we had Readiness back a bit Yeah if you all remember and that's because all children

034were not ready to start the first grade at 6 years old thank you Christine anyone else I have a general question about bonds it seems to be a big thing the bonds coming off this Bond's coming off that Bond's coming off the two bonds that are coming off how much do that equate to our tax rate when we put these out it says it's 28 cents on the tax rate 10 cents on the tax rate how much was that on the tax rate when it came out no ideas we have to estimate yeah we'd have to so if you look at the two it's 4 cents for what we would be putting on um but I'm saying it's so if you look at the estimated costs so we have4 cents for the 226,000 so if

035you essentially double it it would end up being probably estimating around 8 cents would come off the tax rate we're carrying it's about 62,500 per for 1 cent on the tax rate okay so you could take that number and times it to get 1 cent so on 465 um you're looking at about 8 cents roughly okay so effectively 8 cents on our tax rate I'm looking at my bottom line sure my tax bill comes in the mail I can't pay it sure 8 cents on the tax rate right this school district thing is approximately it's 4 4 cents 12 cents and then 12 cents so it's like if you add that together the third year it's what 28 that that's per year Janet that 12 cents is just for that per year not cumulative okay

036yeah we are getting all this increased Revenue so when we get all that increased revenue does that mean our tax rate is going to go down yes by that much correct yeah I mean it's hard it's hard to the next slide next it it's hard to project everything five four six years out but what we can kind of see is those long-term savings and in the additional Revenue you'll eventually see you know much bigger gains by year seven or eight okay I guess what my concern is every time I hear a bond is coming off I never see my tax bill go down this year's different when you look at your tax rate yeah this year is different because we're trying to get this passed no you you you'll see it when we do the

037operating budget the tax rate's going down yeah the operating budget tells a lot more Janet on that case of where the budget is I've looked at the operating budget I know that it's coming down by yeah I don't know it started out like 50 cents and I don't know what it's at now um the operating budget is coming down but we're adding all these bonds that in all these warrant articles that are bringing it right back up so my bottom line my tax bill doesn't go down it it it does in this when you when we go through the whole budget you'll see right you'll see if there is so the cents I think it's $10 like 31 that we're paying for the School portion of our tax rate right now yep is going down

038to $989 next year right with everything if everything passes yeah if everything passes y y if all of the bonds pass the tax rate for next year is less than it was this year by 51 cents is the estimate 51 cents per th000 yep so this is the first time I'm going to see my tax bill go down on the school side scho side scho I understand the I understand yeah we've got two different sides I understand that yep um okay yeah thanks thank you John and I think the difference between what this bond does and some of the other bonds like let's say the water Bond on the town side last year when this Bond passes is it actually brings in additional Revenue because this Bond passes so money from the state education fund

039for full day kindergarten is now going to be added to the school budget which reduces our tax burden is as local our local tax burden as well as the midday bus run expense and the district office lease goes towards the mon yes I understand that so just so you know how it got there I don't even know how I got here but on the town side okay um they said we're going to build x amount of buildings they built all these buildings at North End of town and this that and it's going to increase our Revenue so our taxes are going to go down my taxes didn't go down you built all these buildings you got all this extra revenue from the taxes of all those properties but my tax bill didn't go down yeah

040thank you jenet Tony D franccesco one chesa court so I think there's a differentiator here between the tax rate and the tax bill y the tax bill is a whole different animal than the tax rate and it's all a product of assessment okay so let's be clear that what happens with the tax rate doesn't necessarily mean your tax bill is going to go up or down it's a product of that number times the dollars per thousand of assessment it's also important to understand and I'm saying this to the general public I know you all know this the the the town now is assessing every two years to try and keep Pace with how much how much houses are selling for and so to be clear this shows a tax rate going down on the school

041side but there is not an equal drop in a tax bill a tax bill is something totally different okay so I just I want to get that clear the air because we're going to see it again on some other items as well and what you should hope for is tax stabilization which I think is a more accurate word than up or down to be fair also to you folks and all the work that you have done and it's been substantial um is to say yes the school tax rate is going down down what that means we don't know the state makes you do the verbage and the language that you have that says it's going to be I'll make numbers up 8 cents 10 cents 14 cents but that's off of 2024 assessment the state

042makes you say that it could be it's probably going to be less than that because the assessments are going up and to just put a bow around it all of the commercial development that's that's been happening the tax collections are going to start to increase because of the way the state of New Hampshire charges taxes based on an April 1 completion date and it's a graduated thing and so we're going to start to see those incomes come in they haven't come in yet um you were presented also with with something from Miss Perez and I I I just want to clear the air on one thing not only is Bedford um been advertising for quite some time time now that they're they are stopping that program it's also important to understand and for the general

043public to understand and people with the young children is that every parent currently and in the future has an option to decide to not enter their child into kindergarten in September of whatever year it is depending on the age of the child they always have that option am I correct thank you they've had it as far as I can remember since I I started being a resident here in 1978 there's no indication that's that's ever going to change the parents can decide to not enter their child into kindergarten should they choose that for whatever reason and I'm sure there's some kind of forms that has to be filled out in a meeting with the superintendent or the assistant superintendent or whatever but they already have the right to do that you don't need to legislate

044that thank you thank you good evening Beth Morocco for Wester Drive um before I start thank you a thousand times over to everybody involved in this process it's long it's arduous it's going to make you crazy that you have to rewrite everything a thousand times over but your dedication so appreciated um and you work and you collaborate together even though people have opposing views and different backgrounds it's amazing what happens when people come together for a shared interest so thank you thank you thank you for representing lonary in that way um again as a teacher as a educator I just want to remind people that standards change once upon a time you were a golden if you had a third grade education you had everything you needed to know in the world cuz they were

045going to hook you up to that farm plow and you were going to pick potatoes but this is not that world anymore and we have a different kind of Education Service and we have different projected outcomes um the world looks different and and all the studies all the longitudinal data says we need to start students younger with all of the pieces that are developmentally appropriate for that age so when they become older and the standards become more complex higher level of thinking these students these Learners have the foundation that they need so they can be Achievers and not catch aupers it is really really detrimental to a learner to be behind as a young kid it throws a cog in the wheel that you cannot remove sometimes and it is a disservice so thank you

046for working so diligently to collaborate and come up with a plan where we can get our kindergarteners full day care kindergarten education um we're taking care of their development needs because it's play based learning this is not fourth grade for kindergarteners and people need to remember that this is a decisively different program and I'm so excited because I have seen the benefits of a full day kindergarden play based program and oh it hurts my body that we don't know that yet like collectively we don't know what that looks like but I do and I'm telling you this is going to be amazing so thank you very much let's get all that information out to the community please folks do your background do your research and get that information out to voters cuz if they don't

047know they might not check the right box and the next day after the vote is a tough tough day to find out you got it wrong so let's do this this is amazing thank you thank you thank you B Christine Perez 5 Wesley drive because this is a public hearing and a I want to make sure sure that we are accurate about what we were saying Bedford is having a hearing tonight on a proposal to go to full day kindergarten funding they have not gotten rid of full day it is a proposal just like you all are proposing full day kindergarten for us so please if we're going to give information out to the public let make sure it's accurate okay I am 100% for full day kindergarten I'm just offering that you consider a

048choice of looking at the funding of it in a little different way for the children and for the taxpayer thank you Christine anyone else Jonathan Esposito 5 shall we drive I just had a couple questions uh one regarding socialization and the other is related to Transportation um so pushing the current advantage of where Moose Hill stands now is that entire space is focused on the kindergarteners and the leap students um and they're kind of secluded in a positive way if we take full day kindergarten kids and push them out to all the elementary schools are they kind of fully integrated and socializing with all the kids up to fifth grade no I mean you know whatever every school kind of does well is that you have your primary grades your grades one and two and

049this would be an extension of that and you have your three four and five sorry third fourth and fifth grade um kind of you know in different SP spots you know for that reason um similar question related to bus transportation so if you eliminate the midday bus run um does that integrate the kindergarteners in on the same buses as the first through fifth graders yep uh like like most school districts in America yes okay just a bit of a concern because at least in my own household I've seen bullying concerns on the school buses um there's varying responses sometimes as to how efficiently those are addressed and uh there's a big gap between a kindergartener and a fifth grader so I I think that is a bit of note of concern to the community um

050the only other question that I had is um regarding the cost Savings of eliminating the midday bus run is there a a figure associated with that either per year or over the life of the contract of what we what the district would actually save for your first point you know I mean when you look at how you can run a bu bus you know kindergarten just to be assigned seats that are very far away from fifth graders you know and that's obviously something we've been talking about with the bus company um yeah what what we came up with it's on a it's on a slide somewhere um it's about $283,000 for the first year we'd implement this uh and then you know based on our contract our our costs always go up so we were

051assuming the savings would go up too U there it is 28 283 right 63 no it's 283 for the buses 23 for district or District police rather thank you very much thank you John everybody Paar 20 woodb Drive I want to thank again as uh as we've heard before I want to thank you guys for the work you put in this is a ton of work and it's appreciated uh it's a great solution I think uh to a a problem that's been with us for a long time uh kindergarten day kindergart to me and no Briner the data is overwhelming we need to do this we should have done this last year two years ago 3 years ago four years ago 5 years ago the time is now we need to get it done you've

052got my full support and I appreciate the work you've done to try to lower cost so that's more palatable to people and that's important in this environment and I I think that's it's great work on your part uh the challenge of course is making sure good information gets out uh I saw the same piece that I think uh Dan brought up uh that was written that was in accurate and it's important that we flush that out immediately and and I know it's hard to jump on everything because there are multiple Town websites out there where the stuff gets thrown people pile on before you know you're responding to everything it's very difficult to do that so I appreciate your good consistent information as you roll it out um one of the questions I had is

053do we know how many uh kindergarten age students are in town you I guess how many are we not getting right now because we don't have full day kindergart we're just H we don't get generally even if maybe they've opted into a different program do we know those answers yeah I think I think one of the puzzles for us is what's really driving our lower enrollment um so for many years in a row you know what we saw there was about 220 to 230 kindergarteners born in town then by the time they were five another 30 to 40 kids moved in so we tended to have 260 270 kids in town but we lost about 30 or 40 more who who wanted F day kindergarten and went somewhere else so by the time we hit

054third grade there was about 300 and we saw that for a while um right now we're seeing numbers below 220 so I don't know if that's a demographic thing uh because I think there's I've been reading a lot around how birth rates have just dropped since 2007 2008 since the Great Recession um and I don't know how much of it is people are just like well you don't have full day kindergarten I'm going to go start somewhere else and maybe I'm happy and I stay there um I think one of the telling signs where I think it's just lower demographics and all is you know again what we would normally see from K to1 in Prior years is 30 to 40 new kids would show up last year only 15 showed up so it might

055just be smaller demographics and it might just be this combination of choice where maybe I started a private school and then I love that private school because they had full day kindergarten and I'm not going to come back you know it's still a puzzle for us and I think if we put F day kindergarten in place we'll have a better answer of what's behind it yeah Dan I don't even know if you'd have this information if you have the town demographical information it would tell you exactly how many kindergarten age kids there are in town or do you have it yeah do you know those numbers I I we can we can track the birth rate but then I don't I don't know the private kids that are not showing up yet now right yeah

056and as you indicated I think that often times I would imagine that someone that doesn't see that full day kindergart is an option and they opt for someplace that does Private School whatever it might be that they might stay there they may be more apt to just stay there and they're not part of the public school curric curriculum sure and that's certainly a concern so I think uh it the benefits of full day kindergarten again are overwhelming including getting hopefully getting more people back into the public education system and again I I think you guys are doing great work here and I appreciate what's being done there will be other opportunities for public comment right am I right about that yeah every article awesome thank you okay thank you anyone else okay seeing none I'll

057close public comment and um I'll close the public hearing and look for a motion to close the public hearing please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Kevin all those in favor I I by zero B I just had a question about something that was said and I was waiting till public comment was over is that okay now yeah we're going to go into deliberation so it's on this article Amanda regarding this correct okay thank you um we'll go right into uh deliberations on the barn article and I'll uh start with the board here and you um I have what I think is a rhetorical question but hypothetically if a student just if someone just didn't register their kid for kindergarten at all um and then they you know are essentially a first grade

058age student that student would go to what grade first grade first grade so essentially if we're not getting those kids in kindergarten they're going to go to the grade of their birth year without any potentially okay that's because that's been my experience but I didn't know if that was a state thing or in theory that can happen in any Community but I think because we have a half day program it makes it worse okay because that's been my experience where I've had kids show up in first grade with nothing it's rare but I just wanted to make sure that I was not speaking at a turn okay thank you good Amanda yep Sor or anything no questions no I think we've covered this yeah Kevin I feel comfortable cover it and um I just kind

059of wanted to address uh what Chris what M Perez gave us um you know we're basically trying to get this Bond pass to have the space I'm sure there'll be a lot of conversation I'd like the board to just talk about this when we're working with the superintendent and staff and we put our full day program together and just make sure we cover all these basis and have have some good dialogue on it moving forward okay everybody fine with that so uh seeing no questions um I'll look for a motion to move the bond article to the deliver session please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Amanda all those in favor I I 5 Z thank you all right are you guys going to vote whether you support yeah I'll do that one

060now and then we'll do them as we go so let's go just back to that quick um who would like to make the motion uh at the deliberative session on article two I can do that Amanda and who would like to Second it I'll second Sarah and this one here I'd like to present if that's okay with everybody okay all right so I'll present um okay and let's you have to let us know whether you support it or not what I was going to do next Y and then I'll look free uh I'm looking uh for a vote of us of the school board uh on a motion to approve uh by the school board a yes or no so I look for a motion to uh if you're a yes or no to the

061affirmative first please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Kevin or actually let me back up on that I'll look for yes votes or no votes on this uh for support all in favor I I I 5 Z thank you a little confused yeah sorry about that and budget committee is going to do at a later date right to get back to us next Tuesday the 21st okay thank you all right moving on moving on to we're going to open the public hearing on the operating budget and all other warrants I'll look for a motion to open the public hearing on the operating budget as well as the warrants please so Move Motion by Sarah second second by Tim I'll ask for a roll call vote to open the public hearing please starting left

062to right hi Kevin gray hi Tim Porter hi Bob Slater hi Sarah Lam hi Amanda butcher thank you very much public hearing is open and we will start with uh article three sure um so uh you know article three is your operating budget I have a very uh quick um presentation to go over the major movements of it uh we spent about five meetings going over all these details so we can definitely dig up the budget book If there if there's burning questions but if you go to the next slide Jason uh to to kind of understand where we're at the operating budget what's being proposed right now is 89 million6 ,600 sorry $875,000 uh it's actually about $33,000 below uh what the voters approved last year I'll call it level funded um you know

063it's pretty close percentage wise and it's also about $123,000 below uh the default budget and I'll kind of explain the major movement um and again I think there were some favorable conditions there were some tough choices um but in the end we're trying to fund our Academic Program our co-curricular program and also make room for these important things like the bond we just talked about and the collective bargaining contracts that are coming up too so go to the next slide um you know here's the tax rate figures something we talking about earlier um the tax rate figures overall down you know as Tony said that's that's a lot driven by valuation um you know so it's down by about 93 cents or about 9% and and it's driven by having fairly similar costs from last

064year um but also that valuation went up as as well and then the default budget's a little bit higher so 2 cents higher in the tax rate uh and then not as not as small of a decrease if you go to the next slide um here's how we got to the major changes um you know so in some in some respects there was favorable conditions so when we hired new staff for this year compared to two years ago they're about $400,000 cheaper you know in terms of their costs um there was a a renovation Bond we no longer need to pay for that we that we're retiring so that save us about another $475,000 and then you know the really big investment we last year in our academic program was for this new literacy program

065that was a one-time cost there are ongoing costs that are now in the elementary school budget but that big one-time cost we we're able to not have to reproduce again so those were costs coming down um but we did see some significant costs in other parts of our budget um our added District placement uh for for students that are required by law uh to be to be to be taught um we in the end were not successful even in some of our excellent self-contained programs that were reviewed by you know a National Organization last year we were still not successful in kind of keeping everyone in the building that does happen that's one of the journeys of being a public school you do your best and and you want to have everyone in the community

066But ultimately we weren't successful and that's a joint agreement between the families and and the school district uh those costs are up by 1.2 million um if you've been watching budgets for for years you'll know that that add placement number can go up and down there could be big swings and this year unfortunately we saw a very big swing um even though we had some savings and some increased costs we did make some very targeted Investments um we put a lot of effort into um the program of studies of the high school and we're working in in a couple different areas um so Rick and his team have really been working on building out our advanced placement classes they've done tremendous work we're able to set aside about $38,000 to to fund numerous classrooms and

067numerous advanced classes um and we're we're very happy about that and and you know earlier board presentations we talk about the the big changes we've seen in the numbers there too which is wonderful another area we're investing in which I think we're equally excited about is career connected learning uh that that's probably a new term I'll use instead of Career and Technical education so we want to make sure that if there are kids that are heading towards the workforce uh right after high school or or near After High School we're coming up with good plans for them and and good experiences so what we're investing in is in a fire science class in this building to kind of help them on that path that they're interested and a really great partnership right across the way

068with the fire department and we're investing in someone that can keep an eye on Extended Learning opportunities um we're an exciting point where we're going to start building out our ability for our students interact with all those Fortune 500 companies um near the airport local businesses and really getting our kids um Ready For the Working World and and and seeing that experience there's a lot of work we can do there and we're excited about it um we we also made a $23,000 investment to make sure we can have an assistant athletic director at the middle school that was big um you know we're very proud of our Academic Program we're very proud of the connection between co-curricular um just how big our Middle School and High School athletic programs are is gigantic little in the

069space um so to make sure we have proper supervision and a good connection with staff in the building we we needed to add uh this position and we think this is a great investment to kind of strengthen uh that connection to the Middle School um there's also about $199,000 in smaller curriculum things that that uh Jason was working on we can go into um most of them were for districtwide things some of them were for typing and some other some other areas um we're also making targeted Investments about $188,000 in Middle School and High School athletic stiens some for our UniFi programs some for stiens we they were just at a whack with uh the general ecosystem there and we wanted to clean it up um and then another another big investment for us is

070we're bringing a social worker to work work with our 6 to 12 students um you know there are a lot of kids who struggle uh in school and we need to do a better job kind of connecting them to resources within the building and connecting their families to resources in the community um the instability we see in in homes comes into our buildings and I think we need this resource to kind of help families uh adjust to some of their struggles so that their kids are more successful in school most school districts of our size have a social worker um and uh we're we're excited to kind of bring this to our students and our families um beyond all those Investments there were tough choices made too um we did reduce about $410,000 in staff

071um there were two special ed teachers um we reduced in in this budget um and that's districtwide Kim and her team are going to kind of look at the needs over the spring and kind of figure out if we need to shift things around but based on Lower enrollment and based on need we could absorb them um there's no one losing their job in this process uh similarly we also reduced um two staff at the high school um you know from looking at the program of studies uh Rick and Dr sus and I you know made sure that uh the program of studies and all the advanced classes all the career connected learning all the classes are in there can still be offered we can do that um and we're you know we're basically responding

072to lower enrollment but still offering the same program which we're proud of and then I also reduced a staff member of the district office um and that was kind of the the net saving is about $410,000 those are all the major changes you have 300 p of other changes and other things we could always answer questions on when it comes to the details of the budget let's go to the next slide again enrollment drives most a lot of our decision- making we're projecting about 61 less kids from what we have right now most of that is driven by smaller um a smaller smaller group of kids most likely coming in than a group of kids that we are graduating um but you know we look at enrollment closely and we make you know kind of

073our informed decisions and that's that's the bigger picture of enrollment um within the district go to the next slide I think over the last two years we've made a lot of tough decisions um last year we responded to lower enrollment this year responded to lower enrollment you know so if you look at it uh over over two-year period and these are these are not easy decisions uh you know we've reduced 14 staff members for about $1.1 million um those are tough choices but at the same time we're making sure we can offer the same Academic Program offer the same co-curricular program and and make sure our kids still benefit um it's not it's not easy to do it takes lots of hard work to get there um but I think we're doing a good job

074responding to lower enrollment U making sure we're providing the same great product to our families but also respond to the taxpayers too go to the next slide and that's that that's article three in a nutshell um uh I think Bob wanted to read it and then we can go the questions all right article three shall the voters uh general fund operating budget shall the voters of lenary school district vote to raise and appropriate as an operating budget for the fiscal year 2025 2026 not including Appropriations by special warrant articles or separate warrant articles one of the following amounts for the purposes set forth in the budget posted with the the warrant vote for only one a 89,1 16,8 75 uh this is uh Schoolboard budget as amended estimated tax impact $947 or B 9,240 249

075uh default budget estimated tax impact $9 and 49 um just a note here warrant warrant article operating budget does not include Appropriations proposed under any other article in this warrant all right I will open the floor to the public any questions Jonathan Esposito 5 shall we drive can we shift to the slide the multicol slide that says major changes in the operating budget this one or um I just had a couple questions about some of the figures that are up here uh how did we comprise the number the 414k and staff turnover savings is that like Less HR time focused on retention or how was that figure contract no so what happens every year in the bud in the business office is you take all your staff you you load them in you figure out

076what their costs are and we're comparing it to the prior year so you had people that retired that were probably at a high salary rate with new people that came in that might be lower so the net is that number right there yeah thank you uh and I had a question about the 170k uh regarding the onetime literacy program costs I was to understand that we were Fielding a couple of different literacy programs at the elementary school level as like a trial period and then eventually we're going to settle on one so is there an upcoming and you know in the next year or two future investment again into the elementary literacy program so where do we stand on that yep that already happened um you know Nicole and Jason you want to jump in

077there or yeah yeah so yeah we we did pilot two programs uh at the end uh through our district literacy committee we decided on ccla as our program and that'll be our program moving forward so there'll be no changes um in investing in a new program excellent excellent I think I just bear with me a moment um I have a question I don't mean to be contentious in that regard is there a reason that uh for proposed Staffing cuts that we would cut special education staff as opposed to say staff another staff member at the district office um you know I think we're again we're trying to respond to to lower enrollment I mean again we've seen generally lower enrollment we're trying to match it um I I don't have other staff to cut in

078the district office is the lower FTE in special are related to the fact that we're placing more students out of district is that does that drive some of that uh lower need as well no I mean because what you'll see is um higher need students tend to have more Staffing in general um but it's it's more just lower enrollment overall globally thank you thank you John Tony def Francesco one cheser court so um I want to react to two things one um What a Sad State we're in that um the guidance council is now can't handle things because they're so complicated and so out of control that we need to hire a social worker I think we're probably two years too late several years too late in hiring that position um but I think just

079in general it's a sad it's kind of a sad thing uh that we need to do that to to fully service the young people uh um that are in any town and every town everywhere I just I think it's really sad um I would like to react to also to something that happened at a previous meeting and the chairman of uh of the budget committee um was incredulous looking out into the crowd saying we have almost a $90 million budget and no one's here what's going on um I wasn't really offended by that because I was there but nobody was but nobody was there but that's okay but I think that um in the in the analysis one person's analysis that would be me is that the report card that you had last March in

080working together for all these hours a year ago in presenting a fair and Equitable budget the taxpayer responded in a favorable way not only that but they also voted and I've said this if I've said it once I've said it dozens of times it's actually the taxpayer voter that increased the tax rate to what it is today and they did that by voting almost every warrant article in I did say almost and by the way they did it on both tickets both the townside across the street and here what that tells me as the person who decided to do that analysis and you've heard this before is that the people in town are generally satisfied with what you all are doing not only that but they're willing to pay for what your are proposing and

081not only that they're willing to increase the budget to get more services for their children and I said the same thing to the Town Council I've said it several times on both sides it needs to be said as many times as possible you all work very hard all these hours away from your families to present what some people would think is a fair and Equitable budget and not only that but the taxpayers a year ago we'll see what happens this time voted to increase the tax rate to what it currently is so congratulations to that and Mr chair there will be more people here you've seen it you've been around long enough and Mr chair you also have have seen some tumultuous times as well where it wasn't as as favorable and people weren't as

082happy but for the most part there's nobody here because it's fair and Equitable and they're willing to pay for it they like it they enjoy being here they want to be londonairy residents they're happy being London da residents they're proud to be London da residents that's not said enough and if people have complaints they shouldn't come to you and they shouldn't come to the Town Council what they should do is knock on their neighbors doors and say hey how come you increase my tax rate because that's who did it thank you Mr chair thank you Tony anyone else Beth Mar having trouble today Beth Morocco for Westwood Drive um I'll keep it short but we invest in our children because smartly it invests in our future you want the people who are going to put

083your IVs in to be properly educated we need to invest in these Learners um you're you've done an amazing job having such a streamline budget I've worked in other districts and it's like kind of a mess you've done an amazing job coming off of a very tumultuous pandemic amazing work um we just got to get the voters to like collaborate also and talk to each other and run the numbers and just look at the amazing work you've done and that you've projected um will come next through these through these ideas so thank you again thank you I just have a general comment um I was watching the meeting from home when there was one person here I've watched every single meeting from home is there any way we know how many people are watching from

084home I know when they have the other things going on they can tell who how many people are watching from home he knows so there are 63 people watching from home great so we do have some people who are watching um unless they're watching on the cable access Channel true oh access Channel okay my other comment was was um we just had an election okay there were lines for hours and hours wrapping around why don't we have that at our election we have how eight over $89 million get out there and vote I want to see half the lines that I saw at the last election exactly I a quarter of them because I think there's like 3% % of the people in this town that vote on this stuff you don't want your taxes

085to go up vote if I recall in the last election that we had in March of 2024 a little over 4,000 people showed up to vote that was it yep y yep anyone else and that was a big year yeah yeah that was a good turnout that was a good turnout we we were psyched about that Paul scar 21 wood B and drive I just have a couple of questions um on the revenue side of things and maybe I've missed it along the course of these discussions but uh how are we trending from the state uh contribution side of things what are we looking at for for uh the state contribution to public education in London and what do those trend lines look like so if you look in your if you look at the

086budget hearing packet y um you can look on page um seven and it will show you what what we've gotten and what we're budgeting for so this year we've been fortunate um that what we planned for last fall it's been a little bit more but if you hear what's coming out of the state we're estimating it sounds like it could be a little lower next year but um well the reason I bring it up is exactly for that reason um we're looking at real austerity out of the state house coming up um the new governor aot has said that BL has said that um there's going to be less Revenue a lot less Revenue uh coming to local cities and towns uh to the question of why don't you see your tax taxes go down

087why don't you see your property taxes go down specifically it's because we don't have the revenues coming in from other sources so the burden is completely on or mostly on uh local uh residents that own property in town so that's that's the issue you know what I see today and I I don't agree with Christine Perez about pretty much anything but I appreciate that she's here today I see no other state reps I don't see Sher Packard who's our uh speaker of the house I don't see wayne McDonald I don't see Julia so I don't see Tom Dolan I don't see Doug Thomas I don't see any of those people show up at any of these meetings ever do they reach out to anybody here Dan have they spoken to you Bob I have spoken

088to some on have they spoken publicly have they been involved in any of these discussions no we've had conversations about funding through the state with all our state reps but not one of them other than Christine who shows up at these meetings I know she does because I see her and again I don't agree with her about much of anything but she's here and I appreciate that and I appreciate perspective hey Pat do you hear from any of these people at all any of our state reps Sharon Carson who's now going to be the Senate President no uh again we're looking at reduced revenues coming in okay uh just yesterday uh the local Republican party in Londoner made the statement that they're looking to push toward Universal vouchers throughout the state so anybody of any

089income level is going to get a voucher that's a lot of money that'll be going to private schools that won't be coming to the public education areas that's us that affects us that's going to affect your property taxes okay these buildings still need to be maintained we still need to pay our teachers we need to pay our uh our taxes we need to pay our insurance we need to pay for heat all of these things cost money and with less Revenue you have less ability to do that and you ought to be asking every one of your state legisl they ought to be here they ought to be here and ask them if they're supporting that legislation moving forward to to Universal vouchers throughout and all the other mandates that they're now going to be

090presenting that are mostly kind of culture Warrior type mandates that need to be paid for need to be litigated discussed you have more meetings they're going to add to your burden here as as Educators they should be asked those questions maybe Christine can Enlighten us a little bit tonight but the rest of them ought to be here and it's shameful that they're not quite frankly because this is a reality that's upon us right now and there's no more money coming and that burden is going to fall on all of us and the people that should take the blame are the people at the state house right now that aren't here uh call to that point before you sit down I just want to let you know the board and the superintendent are actively meeting with

091State reps um to discuss concerns about the future uh we're trying to do the right things in our buildings for our students for our taxpayers uh as it shows this year in our budgeting and um what we put forward for the bond um I've addressed all our state reps uh I have um met with Frank edbl today to discuss that we've got a meeting with Sharon Carson next week week um with the governor um so we are throwing out ideas we're showing them our model what we do you know diligently working hard to show a good business model uh and that our education is on the ride rise through the classrooms we have a tremendous amount of work still to do but it does take a certain amount of funding to make sure that happens

092um we are cognizant of the taxpayers we listen to them as it showed from last year to this year but our business model we're sharing that with every representative we've already met with Chris papis laid it out for him we got a meeting with Jee Shaheen different board members and that so we are expressing what we've done what we our plans are to show them how diligently public education is for our students and that we can't do it all through our just our local taxpayers so we we are trying to share our plan that maybe it'll be a good thing for the state level what we've done here in londondary and that so we do have those concerns they are very open for us meeting uh with them and have been working with us to

093get meetings as as promto as we can because we know they're in the middle of the budget and we're sharing some some ideas business-wise and educationally wise that we're trying to change here um and I don't know of many other uh school districts that are doing taking that effort but this board and the superintendent are are trying to do what we can for our local taxpayers so appreciate it and Bob I appreciate that I know you do that I know you've been very active in that regard for for a number of years now I appreciate it Y and and you mentioned the federal level Federal level is going to uh kind of rain down a lot of austerity as well uh uh they they don't have a lot of support there's not a lot of

094support in the federal level with the incoming Administration we're certainly in the current uh uh state level for public education generally it's just going to get harder yeah and we just have to be prepared for that yep as a group because uh and we need to hold the people that need to be held resp responsible for that uh hold them responsible for that because we haven't done that quite frankly haven't done that we've we've reelected these people and reelected them and reelected them we're looking at State revenues on the uh I think just on the business profit tax down $83 million from what they thought it was going to be uh just in the last 6 months $83 million it's going down we've got they just eliminated another tax it's gone uh that's the the

095dividends tax they look that as an income tax they want to get rid of it that's now gone these are all these Revenue sources that are just going away yeah and you don't get those back once they're gone no and we to that point that's what concerns this school board and the superintendent and I can tell you the representative has been very open to what we're saying we're hoping it keeps moving it at the federal level I know things are going to change I hope it resonates I don't think it will I hope it does Bob and I hope you we're not going away we're going to keep driving and we're going to keep coming up with ideas and we're going to keep driving public education where it's where it can be affordable for our

096taxpayers in that so I'm supportive of the uh the budget as well and I appreciate the work there so thank you so much thank you two seconds as a State Rep I have worked with Bob to get information to him I went to a special conference and specifically went to about education funding and shared that with the board and shared the information of who to contact at the board to get information as far as the uh efas I Am pro efas I believe that not all not one fits all for children I am not pro making it Universal for everyone at this point because it's just not the time to do that um and I hear my constituent saying it is not the time financially to do that so that out of even though I

097am for them I'm not for changing the level of funding at this point um as far as public education I don't think you have any of your state reps including me that are not pro public education or I wouldn't be funneling things to the school board um and if things are misinterpreted I'm going to go over a warrant article that I'm putting in tonight it is not against public education it is not against funding it is a tool if you need it in the future but we can go to that later sure thank you Christine anyone else Jonathan esposito5 sh we drive I just had a couple questions regarding the social worker staff member um are they going to be an organic staff member of the lary school district or is that someone contracted out

098from somewhere like amus health or one of those Services may be an employee of the school district um if they are a social worker ranging from 6 to 12 is there a projection as to how much time they may spend at the middle school versus the high school um you know that that's a good question and we haven't figured out the exact details yet and the only other question that I had any of those Services billable to Insurance are like funded by Medicaid to schools or anything like that uh to bring the social worker into the district potentially but that's a that's a better question for but I don't even know if she knows the answer I mean maybe sorry you say yes or no you know it would only be reimbursable through the Medicaid

099to school act if the social worker was doing any work that was prescribed um in IEP 504 right now we are not um thinking reimbursement for that do not have that in a prescribed written plan so they're just part of the like General support package like the other counselors and so on correct the state is reauthorizing and redoing how they are billing Medicaid to schools through the act and we're waiting to see how that is done and working with um the other school districts and when we get that information there may be more channels for more reimbursement but right now we don't have all that information thank you all thank you John I apologize another question will parental permission to meet with the social worker have to be given no they would be a staff

100member just like our counselors are you might want to consider right now there is a concern Maine is having a horrible problem we have four clinics in schools now in New Hampshire there is a big concern about clinics coming into the school districts and children being seen without parental permission if they give a blanket my kid has you know can be seen for medical unfortunately we we have clinics in the state and huge in other states and they are in Maine with huge lawsuits where children are being treated with birth control with lots of stuff that parents are not aware of you need to permission to give an Aspirin to a child I really think social work is considered could be considered a mental health medical um whatever however you want to say it treatment

101so I really think I understand bringing a social worker into the commun into the school system but I can tell you quite honestly if I was a parent I would not want my child to be meeting with a social worker without my knowledge and my permission so again you know we have a a staff that's very collaborative with our parents we we I'm sorry I can't hear you we have a staff that's very collaborative with our parents that when when students uh have bigger needs we're always collaborating with those parents so what you're describing is not what we're proposing okay but collaborating and permission for treatment are two we permission huh we agree on permission are you saying you agree that the parent should have permission for the child to be seen by a social

102worker we work together well with families getting their permission to work with their kids that's not answering my question I'm saying written permission for your child to see the social worker or can a child be just sent to the social worker by a staff member there's a big difference again you're you're describing something that we're not proposing so who will Who will have the child go to the social worker who's I who has the child refers the child to the social worker there there could be a whole number of reasons that they get there no no and I didn't ask for reason I said who our staff I really feel that parental notification should be a requirement and parental permission should be a requirement there's a big difference between a teacher teaching and a social

103worker treating thank you I'll just also say on a social worker standpoint um there's a various roles that they do within the school whether it be truancy attendance uh chins petitions just food kids close um just general like that whether it be a parent recommendation to the social worker or a staff member a staff member may see a kid um not eating not having money so just being that lay on for parents who don't know how to reach out to or who um is something we definitely need in this district and something we've been lack lacking as a social worker in general yeah I would say I would um join in Christine's concerns outside of what you're describing Sarah those are obviously services that I would welcome them just having at the ready uh if

104it does rise to Something in the neighborhood of therapy oneon-one for a kid the parents should ABS in my opinion parents should absolutely be signing off on that before it ever occurs but that's not a social workers's role so this is why I'm saying delineating these like duties is important to layout absolutely yeah sorry Beth Morocco for West Drive I just wanted to clarify do parents need to get permission for their child to see the school nurse probably not is it fair to say that they can have contact with the cafeteria staff well this gets to what I was just saying butting the a social worker right has a defined role they're not a school psychologist you know in the sense of diagnosing students they are performing a service that is outlined um it's they

105have clear duties and it may simply be that they're passing students in the hallway and they note an interaction and they help students work through it it's I think we sometimes overd dramatize um and we pathologize um but as a teacher your duty or anybody that works with students your duty is to help them get through their school day successfully and I think we want to be open to the fact that there are a lot of roles that make that happen and so sometimes our cafeteria workers are preparing extra bags of food to go home with students that have food insecurities and we applaud that we shouldn't look with trepidation and conspiracy um around a staff person who was hired to help a student navigate anxiety because I have anxiety I'm I'm a human and

106that's a a human emotion um it is a core human emotion and students exhibit that in different ways and so one student might look very angry and maybe they are just anxious and if a if a Personnel person helps them to say oh gosh do you need 5 minutes over here doing this activity maybe you can help you know direct the first graders through the hallway like maybe just giving them a role to kind of stop and deescalate um would help them so that they don't have a bigger problem um a social worker helps kind of navigate those pieces so we're acting proactively instead of reactively and that is why the district is introducing this role into our district we must start taking a proactive step um we've got to stop with a conspiracy nonsense

107it's just it's it's not it's it's not reality and we really have to focus on the reality of what our students are dealing with um because we need to help them get through this stage so they can move on to the learning thanks thank you ni com social workers help individuals families and communities improve their quality of life through counseling number one advocacy and connecting them with resources they address various issues such as poverty discrimination Mental Health and Family conflicts they are a treating person parent should have permission yes you can go to the school nurse but you can go to if something's wrong the school nurse has to call your family if you want an aspirin you need permission if they're giving you a pill they need the they need the doctor's order so

108social workers are not just somebody to deal with anxiety and anxiety acute anxiety is a medical and mental health diagnosis consider it before it's a problem thank you good evening Brian mcau Buckthorn Street uh I wasn't going to come but then I decided as I was watching at home I should come and voice my opinion here even though I'm at the ninth hour I probably too late for some of this but on the one of the slides I think and I talked to Kim on this so um on one of the slides I think you're proposing a reduction in uh special education by two FTE and I think there's also hidden in the other slides that it's a reduction of another one at the high school to help out with the Outsourcing Above So at

109the if I understand it properly there'll be a threers reduction at the high school for special ed support so I'm very concerned like I have a child that's currently under an IEP that we currently don't have assigned IEP to cover that support so I'm just kind of concerned that and we're working through Kim so I'm not coming here to complain about that we're still working through it we're going through our normal process what I wanted but looking forward I'm concerned by dropping that heads that that support won't be there for either my son or some other people coming through even with an enrollment going down so yes so no it's a good question here's a slide here um the best way to explain it is the the reductions in special education are actually K to

11012 so it's not just the high school okay um so that's the two there but I think so at the high school what's the FTE at the high it says district office two FTE in special aded okay so that's the overall yeah and then two at the high school and that's and that's that's that's for speci regular education general education yeah so at the high school though I think in the detailed presentation I think it's one at the high school plus the person helping out plus a second one going outsourced or helping with the people right yeah so we to go back to you know the Personnel almost like last month but but basically I mean Kim probably wants to correct me if I get it wrong but I we'll see um so uh we

111we are shifting a position to be able to make the social worker yep and then there is someone who is going to be taking on our Charter School placements at the high school two reductions so so shifting shifting around shifting shifting of Deeds y but the but my son for an example now has two less people that are able to help him with those because you're shifting those resources to that other and then you're going to have another reduction of which will be three right no just the two okay just the two yep and but but again kind of looking at the overall ratios looking at the level of needs um we have the room to kind of do that and also you know shift things around generally and the way I explained to staff

112when I got the staff meetings is you know we'll kind of use the spring to figure out where we might move people around okay did I I think I got it correct okay I just want to make sure mainly I know I'm not going to solve the issue because I don't think I'm at the 9th hour you're not going to add these heads back into the budget at this point right and even if I did ask you to do it at deliberative it's a bottom line budget you're still going to do what you're going to do right so I understand that piece M um but my concern just voicing the concern is publicly is that currently this level of support's not there today and I think in the future it's probably not going to be

113there because if you can't support it today you're not going to support it tomorrow because I don't think the decline in Special Ed I don't know the facts are probably not significant enough of two FTE and you said you're working with with I'm working with Kim on this so as I sit at home I'm like you got if you see something say something right and that's all I'm doing the deliberative meeting is for the people yeah so things can be done so I would suggest meeting with Kim in the next two to three weeks make sure you're comfortable and if you need to do something sir it's your right yeah so make sure you're comfortable but at the end of the day it's a bottom line budget so even if I voice something as one

114n equals one and get the people on the delivera to go with me Dan can at the end of the day we learned this 10 years ago or whatever that's a bottom line budget so he can do whatever he wants sure I mean but I think if there's a movement at deliberative to put one more FTE we would do our best to honor it that's right that's what I'm getting at so I would have sit down with Kim and make sure and and see what they're moving for personnel and just feel comfortable with that um and then make your decision for the deliver okay can I can I make a comment sure I think Brian what you're saying is you know it's you're working out your own child situation but in terms of the great

115or good what's available and something that I just want to mention and I I'm going to save my social worker suggestion and comment and collaboration issue for the appropriate time but I think when we look at supporting kids where I in my own professional career I'm finding that there are cognitive supports in terms of special needs and they're also more and more kids who aren't learning or aren't succeeding because there are barers in their way um whe whether they're you know um behavioral barriers or all of these things so I think what we're looking at doing by adding that person is um there are different types of support needed for different kids and some kids aren't identified and some kids you know don't access the curriculum because of their behavior and then need an IEP

116right but maybe cognitively they wouldn't have needed the IEP if they had the appropriate supports in place and I think we're also targeting that with the multi-tiered systems support so you know kids who have behavioral needs and challenges they're not needing to get identified with an IEP because they we have these supports in place and access to different types of people whether they're behavioral specialists or you know this you know RTI model for behavior um we're able to now kind of realize we need these supports in different areas to prevent kids from needing a tier three level of support which an IEP was offer so what I have kind of heard in in terms of meetings with that tier one support the behavioral support for all and then things like social workers is maybe the

117support um will still be there but it will be streamlined in different Avenues to best support the needs of the student population is that yeah okay no and to kind of layer that on happy to work with you and Kim too all those decisions in that far right hand column are really tough decisions but but but if if if I were to know that our services would be degraded I would say that you know um we are confident based on the staff we have now the needs we have now we could absorb them but there could be a time whether it's decreased state aid or whatever if we are further reducing and we can't produce the academic program we have right now we will let people know with those reductions or if there's a reduction

118in services to some capacity what we're saying is we can still provide the same thing I I understand your concern it's a real concern we have it too yeah but we've gone through the exercise to kind of make sure we can provide the same level of services the same level of needs and kind of do what what Amanda was describing to okay yeah and like everything else it's perception versus reality so I understand there's a perception but reality what I'm seeing is not what you're perceiving right so um and then the only other thing and I kind of was talking with came on this on a separate subject but around Extended Learning opportunities I see you're which is great you're offering one for at the fire department for I'm going to call it the well

119it's probably open to anybody but it's for the regular population we might want to look at is there opportunities for the special ad side is there learning opportunities for those kids that when they do age out that they can get into the normal working life so Kim Kim and her team have done a ton of stuff uh for kids up to age 22 recently too um but the elos in general are describing what you're saying they could be as wide ranging for anything so we're going to get there we want keep working on that yeah for sure good thank you thank you anyone else on the budget seeing none I will bring it back to the board and look for a motion um to move the general fund operating budget for 2025 2026 to the

120deliberative meeting please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim all in all those in favor i i i i z and while we're here um who would like to make the motion at the meeting motion who's that ke and second I second Tim Dan will present and then I will look for a vote by the school board all those in favor of supporting this moot uh this budget I hi I I 5 Z okay article four lenary Education Association Lea bargaining agreement shall the voters of lenary school district vote to approve the cost items included in the collective bargaining agreement reached between the lenary school district and the lenary Education Association Lea and further to raise and appropriate the sum of 1,9 2,879 for the 2025 2026 fiscal year such sum representing the

121additional cost items attrib to the increase in salaries and benefits over those paid at current Staffing levels in the prior fiscal year the agreement calls for the following increases in salaries and benefits at current Staffing levels over those paid in the prior fiscal year fiscal year 2026 estimated cost 1,920 1879 estimated tax impact 27 cents FY 20 26 27 estimated cost 1,682 340 estimated tax impact 24 C FY 2027 2028 1, 133 uh with a tax impact of 23 c y if you go to the next slide Jason um just a couple big bullet points and we're happy to answer any questions but um I'm I'm really thankful for how the school board approached uh the collective bargaining agreements with both our teachers and Allied Health um we we have great staff and and they

122made an investment in them um so this collective bargaining agreement uh keeps the healthcare plans they currently have for the next three years uh it maintains the investment and the salaries for our veteran staff and kind of acknowledge their leadership in our in our buildings right now and how they're they're the cultural and tone centers of the building um one of the biggest things we're trying to solve is we knew regionally our starting pay was below um nearly all of our competitors and we were starting to lose uh lose out and we don't want to do that we want to be a district that that brings in new staff so we we raised the the starting pay so that we jumped over a lot of school districts and we're now uh very competitive and I

123think that's going to help us as staff turn over uh for future years um and then we updated a lot of language around personal leaves U the evaluation model we've just gone through um increases SI day bonuses and a few other items here and there um but most things collect the baring contract is about salaries and benefits and you know that's that's the summary of and you'll see the same approach for the Allied Health which are an entirely separate group um which we'll get to next but that's the big picture I don't know if you wanted to l or anything else on it yeah I would just hit on what you we knew we were at a disadvantage on the uh starting pay as a teacher um several community members were concerned with that too

124um being able to pay our teachers so we were able to um bring that point to a competitive market where we compete with the surrounding towns and schools of our size um to your point we did lose some good candidates due to um pay uh over the last school year and I think this puts us in a good spot and it works with our veteran um teachers to uh make sure they're compensated but we're able to uh work the top end as well so uh I overall it was a a long um negotiation with a lot of detail but I think we got to a good point uh for for future teachers coming to lonary so that's how I'll end and I will open it up to the floor if anyone would like to speak

125to this seeing none I will bring it back to the board and I will let's do each one as we go so we can uh just keep keep that in um I will look for a motion to move article four lonary Education Association bargaining agreement to the deliberative session please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Amanda all those in favor i i i 5 Z and who would like to make the motion at the deliberative please I can do that Amanda second I'll second Sarah Kevin would you like to present you want to present it okay great and uh for a vote of the board uh all those in favor of supporting Article signify by saying yes I I yes I yes five is thumbs up thank you moving on to Article Five

126gotcha London der Association of Allied health professionals bargaining agreement shall the voters of lary school district vote to approve the cost items included in the collective bargaining agreement reach between the lary school district and the lenary association of Allied health professionals and further to raise and appropriate the Su sum of 189,190 6 fiscal year such sum representing the additional cost items atable to the increase in salaries and benefits over those paid at current sapping levels in the prior fiscal year the agreement calls for the following incre increases in salaries and benefits uh at current Staffing levels over those paid in Prior years fiscal year FY 2025 26 estimated cost 189,000 estimated tax impact 3 cents FY 2627 estimated cost 178,179 with an estimated tax impact of 3 cents FY 2728 estimated cost 18,9 60 with

127an estimated tax of three cents and I think you hit on this the the wording I don't know if you want to add anything to yeah no I mean again different different different collective bargaining group uh but kind of the same the same goals um you know invest in our veteran staff invest in the younger staff so when there's turnover and a few minor language changes but the exact same thing just a different group okay y anyone else good all right I'll open this up to the floor seeing no action bring it back and I will look for a motion to move Article Five lary Association of Allied health professionals bargaining agreement to the deliberative please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim all those in favor I I I 5 Z and

128who would like to make the motion at the meeting Sarah and who would like to second I can Tim and [Music] present want me to do this one Kev we both there I can take it both or we can do you want to do both I can take both okay you got it all right moving on article six authorization for a special meeting on on cost items shall the londondary school district if article four and or five is defeated authorize the governing body to call one special meeting at its option to address article four and or five cost items only estimated tax zero we just do this one every year just in case the collective bar agreements don't go through this is our backup plan to find a new agreement okay thank you m Mr

129chair you voted to move Article 5 to the deliberative do are you voting uh in favor or against Article 5 we did you did I'm sorry yep my bad quiet uh yes we did anyone from the public seeing none everybody's good yes I I think I'm not I'm with you Patrick I think you voted to Lisa in the notes did you hear both you dider to support so I'm not firing all right so yeah you got me going now Pat sorry sorry all right I'll ask let's go uh jump back to Five I'll look for a motion uh uh who approve uh would like to support um Article Five I'll say yes hi thank you yes thank you we good now Pat thank you okay um we're on six nobody from the public um who

130would like to make this motion right Tim second I can do that one Amanda and who would like to present I can read it too okay and I'll look for uh who uh a vote of in support of this article six please i i i i z article 7 School launch programs and federal funds projects shall the voters of the lary school district vote to accept and receive federal grants and other such funds to support the school program and federal projects further to raise and appropriate such funds in a special Revenue fund as follows school lunch program 1,716 th000 and federal projects 1, 579,000 for a total appropriation of 3,295 th000 such funds to be self-supporting through local state or federal revenue sources estimated tax zero Dan anything to add to this yeah no I

131mean so basically what this um what this allows us to do is accept those funds if if this to ever not go through it it always goes through we would have to come up with a difference and that that would be very bad got yeah thank you any questions from the public everybody good all right um who would like to make the motion on article please I can do it s second I'll take the second and who would like to present I can present this one okayand and all those in favor of supporting article 7 i i i i zero thank you article 8 special article buildings and grounds capital reserve fund shall the voters of lary school district vote to raise and appropriate the sum of 520,000 to be placed in the districtwide buildings

132and grounds capital reserve fund established in March 2021 School District meeting for the purpose of the maintenance construction Renovations improvements and related Professional Services to all buildings grounds fields substructures and infrastructure to the overall property of Londoner School District the fund shall provide the funding source for all equipment structures Professional Services machinery and materials necessary to sustain efficiency safety of the district's buildings grounds and infrastructure and subsurface that meet the needs of the school district yep so if you look at the at the bottom of page 19 which is in our packet um there's the list of the proposed projects um there's roof there's fire pan fire panel upgrades there's epoxy on bathroom floors some door frames some other uh smaller hvc stuff but you know these are the kind of deferred maintenance uh spread

133across the the schools that are our highest needs we want to get fixed next year thank you I'll open it up to the floor anyone from the public seeing none bring it back to the board and who would like to make the motion for article 8 I can do that who would like to second Amanda and present I can present it Tim will do that okay all right I get a motion on article 8 to uh special article buildings and grounds capital reserve fund to move to the deliberative session please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Kevin all those in favor I I I 5 Z I think Le Lisa and I didn't hear the motion to move it to um article 6 and 7 to move it to deliberative we heard the

134Motions you made on who was going to present it and what your support was did you did you get it Lisa because I didn't hear it either I did not whether we support it or not uh no you got whether you support it and who was doing the plan you didn't make the motion to move it to deliberative session for six and seven okay let me finish this and uh then we'll go back to that thank you okay um all those in favor of article 8 please say I I I 5 z um article 7 school lunch program and federal funds project do I have a motion to move it to the deliber of session please so mve motion by Sarah second second by Amanda all those in favor I I I 5 Z and

135six article six authorization for special meeting on cost items do I have a motion to move article 6 to the deliberative please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim all those in favor I I I 5 Z don't know where my head is lot going on article nine special article District technology Network infrastructure capital reserve fund shall the voters of lary school district vote to raise an appro create the sum of 125,000 to be placed in the school district technology Network infrastructure capital reserve fund established in March 2019 School District meeting to provide funds for equipment and services for the school district Network infrastructure such as but not limited to routers wiring switches access points wireless network improvements or any other equipment software or service that is necessary for the maintenance Improvement performance

136or management of the district's Network estimated tax impact 2 cents yeah so from our it Department uh the major Investments they're looking for for next year is to renew the security software renew the maintenance of our virtual server Hardware uh replace some outdated fiber Network um server hardware and maintenance and then our firewall Hardware maintenance those are kind of the main areas they're investing in any anyone from the public seeing none I'll bring it back and I'll look for a motion to move article 9 District technology Network infrastructure capital reserve fund to the deliberative please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Kevin all those in favor I I 5 z um who would uh like to motion this article can do that Amanda who would like to second a second Sarah and present

137I can present it Kevin okay and I look for a uh vote on to move uh to support article 9 please all by saying I I I I five Z only took me to article nine to get it right right article 10 special article equipment capital reserve fund shall the voters of lenary school district vote to raise an appropriate up to the sum of $95,000 to be placed in the school district equipment equipment capital reserve fund established in 2013 for the purpose of funding the acquisition of minor ongoing equipment and tools such as but not limited to classroom Furniture technology Furniture building and maintenance equipment and tools used in the school district with this sum to come from the June 30th 2025 fund balance available for transfer on July 1 2025 and no amount to

138be raised by additional taxation estimated tax zero so if you look at page 22 22 of the packet you can see the list of the the small Furniture items that are kind of spread throughout the district and the needs uh of the schools in that area thank you Dan and back to the public any questions seeing none I'll bring it back to the board I look for a motion to move article 10 equipment capital reserve fund to the delivera of please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim all those in favor I I 5 Z who would like to make a motion to bring this to the floor please thank your motion Kevin I can second Tim will second and who would like to present want me to do this one I haven't

139done one in a while yeah sure all right all right and I look for a vote uh to support article 10 by saying I please I I I article 11 special article vehicle and Machinery capital reserve fund shall the voters of the lary school district vote to raise and appropriate up to the sum of $50,000 to be placed in the vehicle and Machinery capital reserve fund established in March 2020 for the purpose of funding the acquisition of vehicles and Machinery with with this sum to come from the June 30th 2025 fund balance available for transfer on July 1 2025 and no amount to be raised by additional taxation estimated tax zero yeah yep so so if we go back to last week the line painter has been moved into the uh buildings and grounds budget

140but we just absorb it we didn't we didn't change the overall spending amount for the whole budget if you've noticed we just kind of absorbed that lowered some costs in some areas so we'll be leasing that uh as the school board requested what we have left is this is not a normal um special article we see year after year it's only when there's large equipment so we need a mower for the buildings and grounds department and the music department asked for a box truck to kind of basically help our world class band uh get to their events some of it's for winter percussions some of it's for their their their larger trips um but we also will be using this uh districtwide in other areas and uh we feel it's a good investment to support

141them but also the other District needs thank you Dan and I'll go to the public Christine Perez F wedley Drive I just have a quick question a lot of this is being funded with the fund balance I just do you have an estimate of how much you're going to have at the end of the year that in total it it's still estimates right now we'll have a quarter two report on the 28th of January we feel we'll have that right now based on where projections are um but we want to get through the winter okay and but you will also have plenty left over to keep your bond rate because I know that's always been an issue that that's our hope thank thank you anyone else seeing none I'll bring it back to the board

142and I'll look for a motion to move article 11 vehicle and machiney Machinery capital reserve fund to the delivera of please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Amanda all those in favor I I I 5 z uh who would like to make the motion on article 11 I can do that Tim who would like to second I'll second Kevin and present I can do that you want to okay sorry and I would look for a vote um from the school board on article 11 uh in the affirmative of this please I I I I 5 Z okay care that part now we have one you have yeah do thing thing yeah project ISS um we did receive a citizens petition Warr an article today um it's pending voter signature verification which will happen

143tomorrow with the um uh for the um supervisors of the checklist they'll do that tomorrow evening we anticipate um that that should go through once it goes through and it's verified um this is what we received today we the UND we the undersigned registered voters of the town of blary request the school board to insert the following article on the warrant for the March 11th 2020 2025 town meeting of lonary New Hampshire shall the town vote to adopt a tax cap for the lenary school district in accordance with RSA 32 5-c as amended effective October 1st 2025 and amend the school district Charter as appropriate RSA 325-c states that in a town that has adopted this paragraph a tax cap limiting the base amount to be raised by property taxes to last year's base may

144be adjusted to account for inflation and change in attendance for school districts according to the following formula this year's base equals parentheses last year's base times parentheses 1 plus CPI times this year's attendance divided by last year's attendance okay is the presenter here to talk on this come on up we really haven't had a time to review this I spent some time know you I spent some time with Amity this afternoon up at the office but the the board has I warned you this was coming um this is a may not a shell and this was a um a law that was uh went through the house and the Senate and was signed that was put into place on October 1st and what it does is it gives you a tool if you so choose

145to use it it is a may not a shell now you all do a great great great job and I'd like to think that we always had the people up there that were going to do a great great great job and I hope that we do but this is a tool in case you run into something so that you can use this to cap and keep things in line again the law feel I brought the law but it's the one I marked up I apologize um um multiple districts are doing this but the problem that they're having is that they're putting an amount you know like um I think it was kir saer one put in an amount of $27,000 this does not need an amount it needs to go by a formula it's very

146basic it's very easy to follow um the um the law shows the definition of what they mean by base amount attendance and all that stuff as I say this needs to pass I Believe by 60% yeah um so as I say it's just an option for the future if you should so need it any questions go ahead so you're saying if if it does pass gets a 60% you're saying it's still a may but not a shall it will always be a May the law specifically states that they may adopt this you may utilize this let me find the exact words because it's in here uh if a town haser tax um in accordance with this amendment may be adjusted may be adjusted is right in the law to account for inflation may be adjusted

147does not have to be there's a big difference between May and shall at the state level trust me but to to your point you start the paragraph Christine to adopt a tax cap for londondary school what is that tax cap it's in accordance with the law so we so if we do approve this we would have to follow this you may follow it because the law says you don't have to do it it says you may do it if you adopt it you have it in your drawer y if you need need it mhm okay but you do not have to use it and take it out of the draw because the law specifically says that you in a town that has adopted this paragraph a tax cap limiting the base amount to be raised

148by blah blah blah blah may be adjusted may be adjusted doesn't have to be adjusted you don't have to cap anything because you're not adjusting anything like I said I I get what you're saying I understand that I understand the wording but the way I've looked at it is you would have this if you had a tax cap to use no this is the cap that you can use okay I guess we'll have to get clarification and read the law the law is it's very specific it's very um um well it's legal e but it's it's I understand it yeah well think it'll be better cuz the attorney will have a few weeks now to look at it and he'll that's why you get them in early yeah I just want to make sure we

149understand where you're from Absolut he can hear what you're saying and then maybe he can chime in on that at and feel free to have him call me but this is just something that went into effect as a people are always complaining right and yes y all did a great job this year and you have in the past but in the past past we always haven't done a great job so it's so this is where I'm a little confused because you referenced and thank you because you complimented us on the work that we've done um but what if a future iteration of board are all spend thrifts right they still won't have to take that out of no they don't have to it's not a shell it never went in as it never went in

150unfortunately in my consideration it should have gone in as a shell so if you adopted it you shall do it right but I think what they were trying to do I'm not I was not on the education committee which was split this year into two because it was so such a crazy committee I think the attempt was because there was so much that this percentage of your tax bill everywhere comes out we have towns that have their P per pupil cost 31 $40,000 a kid okay so I think it was put in as a May for maybe towns that would really want to do it but not a shall for towns that really didn't have to do it but we never know where we're going to be we don't know where we're going to be

1515 years from now I mean we're building hundreds of apartment buildings in town hundreds it's just a tool and it's a new tool and since it was passed by the state I thought if I brought it to the town they would have the option of voting for it and if they choose not to vote it for it well then don't complain about what the board is doing I you know what I'm saying you had a chance so yeah all right um so the first thing is is when you use the word may you said May adjust for inflation is may only apply to adjusting it based on inflation no that's why it says no it's in a town may be adjusted may be adjusted to account for inflation and change in blah blah blah blah

152blah it goes on you may do that okay you may adjust your budget based on um last year's T last year's budget and then it tells you what's included in last year's budget in the full law May um last year's base may be adjusted to account for inflation and change in attendance for school districts according to the following formula this year's base blah blah blah blah blah okay so but there's so there's only two things in inflation and the number of students you know that that simple equation right there yes that's it well no it's last year's base you have to take last year yes I get that adjusted for inflation or CPI and this year's attendance okay so what if the state cuts onethird of our funding what do we do does that equation

153still work according to the state it does yeah wow according to the state as far as cutting as far as cutting the state has to cut their budget all of the money from Co is gone it's all gone and we meaning all of us lived high in the hog for with all that money and trust me one of the main things that we are forced with doing we just had to fill out surveys about what if something is in the budget would you not pass it what if we put this in the budget would what what would we put in the budget that you wouldn't vote for it there is a huge huge huge active group Finance committees and the entire legislation and the Senate are working to cut the budget not looking to cut

154it cut it from education education is so up in the air right now because of lawsuits going on but that's not where they're looking to cut it they're looking to cut what we always call the pork that's in the in these budgets they're looking to cut that it has to be cut it has to be cut some people are saying a billion some people are saying 500 million the speakers said 500 million some of the other groups are saying we need to cut it by a billion we are all looking everybody is looking where to cut money and but it's not looking to cut it from schools and that's one of the reasons why I feel that now is not the time to increase our efas um percentage wise personally I feel that I don't

155think my constituents want it even though I am a big fan of efas um so this is just a tool that you can use okay so thank you it's taking your budget has nothing to do with what the state is when you do your budget and what cost that you need your budget isn't it isn't based on what you're getting from the state it's what you need isn't it correct me if I'm wrong don't you put out what you need from to the public Yeah in our that's what you put out what you need and then where the money's coming from is a whole separate ball game if you're getting some from the state some from this some from that so this doesn't affect the state this affects what you all or we all are

156spending on the budget now this can be done for the town as well it's not just for the um municipalities but the reason why I did it for the school is because you don't need it right now and I didn't want it to look like a slap at perhaps the town who people are concerned about the budget more but moreas this is something you can have in your pocket and people wouldn't be voting on it because oh look at the horrible job you did so we're going to put this in they maybe would think about it more do does the town of lonary the dtic need this and not just have it be a kneejerk response does that make sense and you plan on attending the deliberative I hope to give of course and that

157way we'll have our attorney here he can clarify any questions anybody has and as I say if you speak to him please tell him feel free to call me I have my phone off when I'm at the state house I'll be there up a lot but I I if he leaves me a message I'll return it okay okay I I have a couple of questions about this when you're talking CPI which CPI are you talking about wait a minute it's in here um the increase for inflation or CPI Consumer Price Index in the formula above shall be an in uh an annual inflation index published by the US District uh Bure us Bureau of Labor Statistics as of January 1st or the annual Municipal cost index uh published by the American city and county as

158of January 1st right but there's local CPI their CPI not adjusted for inflation there CPI with Energy prices included this is Formula above shall be annual inflation as published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics they published multiple versions of the CPI so that's I was an economics major that's why I'm asking I can find that out for you yeah we'll have the attorney here too so yeah I can find that out for you I was a nurse maybe that's why I'm the social worker thing more than the CPI but any other questions yes uh could that law could we get it to the school board but it can all you have to do is go online and put it up I as I I can give you the one I marked up I'd be

159happy and I I'll get it to the rest of the bu committee at least read because I'm looking at that one too and it says under adoption RSA 325-c the following shall apply and then when I'm looking at this again it says uh in a town or District that has adopt this section the estimated amount of local taxes to be raised for the fiscal year shown in the budget certified by the governing body uh or the budget committee and posted with a warrant for the annual meeting pursuant to RSA 325 shall not exceed so may wait wait when was that ad uh that says at the very bottom uh [Music] 20203 okay thank you thank you for that correction all right no you got to get back to the microphone so you can people can

160hear you um so what you Christine what you hand to me was uh 32 colon 5-b and that's referencing 325-c no I'm looking at that right there and then what's up there no right here upon adoption under 32-5 C the following okay then what's the difference between that Dash B on the that was what this is under so says the question should be provisions of RSA 32b so we definitely need the lawyer to weigh in it looks like it also requires a 3- fth majority I'm looking at the updated text yep okay cool we're going to have the attorney here too so there's nothing we can do with it tonight it's going to go to the deliberative so um yeah so we'll uh have have an attorney here but thank you for presenting this there's

161not much we can comment on I I understand and that's why I brought it tonight so I see the questions and all that that everybody has absolutely absolutely thank you that's great um I as one probably would not vote on this it's not monetary and we don't have enough information on it um at this point unless somebody wants to vote not to support for a tax cap or a tool but that's up to you guys everyone there's no way I'm doing this on the FL yeah so we'll just leave it status quo and still want a motion to move it to deliberative it goes here anyway so we automatically they got good so all set everybody oh come on up come on Paul scar 20 Woodbine Drive um this this article is confusing as all

162get out um it's evident by everyone on the panel I don't understand it the petitioner doesn't understand it it ought to be probably taken off if Christine would do that I doubt she will because it needs a ton of clarification understand exactly what it is it is monetary by the way Bob you know so it's not as if so I don't even know if this would be um advisory right so uh that needs to be clarified as well uh if it is advisory I guess you move forward with it as as it's written I just don't know but again this is another attempt by um legislators to try to tie the hands of a school department uh and a a budget committee and a school board by imposing certain uh rules around funding that you

163don't really need I don't know what prompted this I don't know who prompted Christine to present this where it was formed I have my ideas about that but again it's very it's really ill-conceived uh ill-developed uh petition and I hope that she'll reconsider uh even putting it Forward uh because no one's going to understand it I think the only thing people will see is tax cap and that's what they'll glom on to and that'll be the end of that and a lot of people like the idea of tax caps even though they're really understand the meaning in the context presented thank you Tony thank you Mr chair Tony def Fran um so this is poorly conceived poorly written and generally a bad idea for years for decades the state has passed unfunded mandates and pass

164those costs onto local towns like ours increase ing tax rates this is yet another attempt to undermine public schools and budgets in general I would urge you all to vote this in the negative 05 both from a school board and from a budget committee the language is hard to understand the language is confusing and it's been yet to be tested in New Hampshire if an RSA hasn't been tested in a court of law you don't know if you have something that's legal or not regardless of who wrote the legislation I can't stress enough how this is a bad idea I watch Judge Judy every day I can't understand this language something's wrong thank you thank you anyone else I just clarify tax cap has been around since 20 2011 that language has not I know

165I'm I I know but I'm just saying the idea of a tax cap has been around since 2011 the language that is here I specifically put in the language that was right from the legal document the law specifically put that in feeling that that was clear because it's stating exactly so I understand that rsas can be difficult to understand at times I don't know how much clearer this could be so thank Beth Morocco for Westwood Drive um I feel like we've seen this play before um right at the last hour we see these final articles um being forwarded by Miss Perez um there's always a lot of verbage um there's a lot of head scratching from all of the people trying to to understand what is being presented here um I didn't see I'm pretty

166involved in town and I didn't see any conversation around with this I didn't um see Miss Perez you know getting feedback from community members um asking is this something that they want um but again these these last Stitch warrant articles reappear every year in a different form and um last time it was trying to split administrators from Educators when really we are a collaborative group we cannot have one without the other um and so now this is just a different um a different animal it's like wearing a different costume but it's it's the same thing um hiding underneath and I just I feel like we are better than this and I feel like there's just too much seriousness and too much weight in this budget um to throw in these last Stitch GES um I

167just feel like um we should all be voting no there's just no there's nothing that we can look at this and say oh I understand um no one is understanding here so I think that's a clear zero a clear no from everybody um would really benefit the voters who are also not going to understand what this is thank you thank you anyone else Jonathan esp5 shall we drive I just wanted to offer some clarification that this is not unheard of by any means uh Manchester is our immediate neighbor they have a tax cap that limits the school district's proposed budget to the average inflation rate of the previous 3 years Franklin New Hampshire a little further out they have a municipal tax cap that limits annual increases in the budget to the National cost of

168living index uh the Newfound school district uh they set precedent with their tax cap in the increase in the amount to be raised by property taxes to 2% um so communities around New Hampshire have successfully implemented this uh the particular legal ease here may be a bit confusing on the floor as you said Bob the attorney may be able to offer some clarification but this isn't far out of left field uh communities have successfully implemented tax caps both on the municipal and the school district side and as somebody who signed this petition I think we would be well served to do this here thank you thank you anyone else hi Bri M buckthorne Street um is there a way with this article so I agree with what some people are saying I don't know if

169this is a good or a bad article to be honest so when I read it like I see tax cap so obviously that puts off one thought is there a way to put an example at the bottom like what that would look like like I could go home I have to think okay what's last year's base I have no clue where would I find that number to be able to do the calculation myself going on what we were saying here the CPI index so I can do the calculation I just don't know where to find that information and say okay what does this mean so I don't know if as part of the warrant article can you add an example to it or is that not so people can actually understand what this means so

170okay this is all lawyer speak I'm going to say because they're lawyers at the state house right that rol this but it doesn't mean anything to the late person right mean I just don't know if there's a way to do that in these I I think for the deliberative session um once we have our lawyer review it and we all understand it better we could in theory apply what this would mean for the the current budget as we're looking to the future you know we'll never know what's going to happen two or three years from now but we can at least come up with a theoretical example I I don't know if that helps or hurts it in terms of language but we could at least explain a deliberate Obsession and I intend to put

171articles in the times also explaining this to people so that they know but if you all could figure it out for me based on that formula with last year's budget what it would look like that'd be a great help CU I was going to try to figure it out but again I was a nurse so I have a question though because doesn't that mean then like let's say hypothetically um a bond is passed that has an in like an an an an increase to the tax rate over 20 years of like let's say 10 cents for each th000 if we're putting a cap on that and now that bond is included in the regular operating budget doesn't that really restrict regular operating costs because the town's people voted in a bond later down the road

172yeah so so in theory again we we'll we'll try and come up with an example but you know let's say we tease out this um this formula and we realize we could only raise taxes by 600,000 but but let's say our taxes the are actually going up by 2 million we would then need to offset $1.4 million in spending in the operating budget correct you know so we'd have to come up with other savings yeah right right yeah um it says in here what the um what the different things mean as far as um uh what's included as far as the base in this um it's population it's the local taxes raised the prior year right the base y so but I get your point um that's that's why what jumps out at me like

173I said is to adopt the tax cap that we have no idea how it operates so the wording here even though it says shall leaves no it says may or may that's very important but it says it's an adop that's why I figure part C needs to be adopted a tax and this is a tool to work with a tax cap so I I need clarification but we are we are in no position to support any type of tax cap with this type of information is what I'm getting at okay you know what I'm saying at this point maybe at the deliberative would be different but we need clarification not getting this so as far as supporting the word here I truly could not support it not having the information or time to deliberate or

174see a formula that would work um that the schools School District can operate year after year um because to the point of but you don't have to use it every year that I don't know no you do not have to use that's for a lawyer I'm not right I'm not going to get into that tonight cuz we just got it today so right and I would be happy to have the lawyers at the state house also bring clarification if ation on this too so um I'd be happy we have research lawyers and lawyers that do that we don't have staff but they do do that so sure thank you if I may Mr chair I think one more point of clarification that we need from the lawyers uh is that it seems like the changes

175that the state made to this law according to this take effect October 1st 2025 if this passes in March it takes effect July 1st with the new fiscal year and it would still be under the 2024 version of that law which says shall and not May so that's a 4month gap when I'm not sure which what's in place you follow me yeah so I would love to hear what the lawyers have to say on that sure and that's a typo but you because this went into effect October 1st 2024 yeah okay you're looking at the it went into effect October 1st 2024 that is a typo just for clarification was that what you submitted though yes it is is that what everybody signed the petition towards yes so it's an invalid POS it's invalid right

176so it should be removed I remove it based on my typo okay well that was a fun half hour other questions not okay everybody good yeah appreciate it thank you Patrick if this St I just need some clarification on whether we are voting on it the night of deliberative to show whether we support it or not uh CU obviously we wouldn't be voting on it next week before we get the lawyers weigh in try that again so the budget committee votes you know in favor or against the all of the Articles uh that that concern finan right and we're doing that next Tuesday obviously we're not going to vote on this next Tuesday till we wait for the lawyers to weigh in so I want to make sure that mechanism works for us to vote

177on this at deliv I did she just say she was removing it well yes but I'm just saying just in case it's it's on record it's it's not going to be submitted then so it's it's off this year okay okay I just going to say the same thing I think she just removed the article okay so it's gone that's how I took it it's out okay thank you appreciate it thank you good cool you guys all good yes yeah all right you guys good good all right um I'd like to have a motion to please close public the public hearing please so moved motion by Sarah second second by Tim all those in favor I I 5 Z and we do have a segment here I know there's a few people here just for regular

178public comment if they had anything else regarding School District that we may need to uh hear from I'll open the floor for public comment on regular school and Community things seeing none I'll bring it back and I'll close public comment before I go into uh uh that I we've got a one thing to discuss with the superintendent and non-public so at this point I will look for a motion to go into non-public under RSA 91a col three section 2C please so motion by Sarah second second by Kevin I'll ask for a roll call vote please starting left to right hi Kevin gray hi Tim Porter hi Bob Slater hi Sarah hi Amanda butcher thank you everyone appreciate it thank you thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.