001e e the floor will be open for public feedback the main purpose of a public hearing is for the V for the board to hear public feedback on the proposed budget and warrant we will attempt to provide clarifications this session is not intended to be a back and forth discussion if you have questions that are not addressed to your satisfaction please contact your board member the board chair or the SAU office as always we hope to maintain respect and decorum the warrant this year's warrant is organized in the F following manner Article One deals with choosing a moderator for the 2026 annual meeting article two is why the polls will be open Thursday March 6th from 11:00 am. to 7 7M for Schoolboard elections article three deals with the operating budget I will provide an
002overview of the proposed budget article four is the mbsa the support staff collectively bargained agreement Jessica wheeler Russell chair chair of the MV SD negotiations committee will speak to the this proposed agreement Article 5 provides for a special meeting should article four be defeated article six Sally hsh Dickinson excuse me will speak to article six which is a request to authorize the board to retain a contingency fund article 7 Dan York will speak to article 7 which is a request to add money to the special education Expendable trust fund article 8 Melissa Muzzy will speak to article 8 which is a request to add money to the maintenance Expendable trust and article nine includes boilerplate language that allows for other business to be addressed at the annual meeting so we'll start with excuse me article
003three which is but I need to read article three that's okay article three states to see if the school district will vote to raise and appropriate the sun sum of 51,6 $5 5,141 excuse me $151 for the support of schools the salaries of school district officials and agents and for the payment of statutory obligations of said District the article does not include Appropriations voted in other warrant article the school board recommends this article in an effort to more succinctly and effectively review the proposed budget we've listened to constituent feedback rather than addressing every single line in the budget tonight we'll be discussing major budget influences and looking at projected expenses and changes from this year's budget by reviewing each function and providing relevant context there will be time for questions at the end of this
004presentation the overall increase to the proposed operating budget is 3,357 43 which represents a six 95% increase comparing some of the main drivers to the overall net increase gives additional perspectives to consider projected special ed education expenses are increasing 1,162 469 if you compare this projected increase to the no overall net increase special special education expenses are 34.6% of the overall net increase the excuse me the increase in our non-sp special education health and dental coverage was 22.2% or 96435 which represents 28.7% of the total increase we are looking to change healthc care providers in the hopes of saving some money and mitigating future large increases like we have seen over the past two years the net increase for previously collected excuse me previously approved collectively bargained agreements is $240,500 which represents 7.2% of the
005total increase the percent increase of the operating budget compared to last year's total approved budget is 6.95% as I said the three areas of increase mentioned previously account for 71% of the over overall increase that's the special ed the health and dental and the collectively bar bargaining agreements the board and administration are consistently evaluating and monitoring longitudinal expenses so I'd like you to please follow along on the overview sheet of the 25 excuse me 2025 26 proposed budget so the following are areas of change function 1100 regular Ed page two believe so we see an overall increase of $563,500 special education also on page two this function has an increase of 5 97,5 we see a significant increase to the tuition lines and the health and dental increases these increases are based on changing student
006needs and are based on what we know about the student population at this time function 1211 extended school year special education also on page two the increase in this function is 149,90 dollars sorry this is due to an increase in salaries transportation and outof District tra to out of District tuition function 1260 our elll program special education also on page two has an increase of $83 due to an increase in benefits function 1290 other special programs on page two the increase is 80,500 $1 is due to the increases to health and dental function 1300 CTE education also on page two the increase of $65,500 co-curricular programs on page three there is an increase excuse me in this function of $287 due to the increase based on past expenditures function 1420 athletic programs on page three
007overall this function is increasing $ 29,6 this increase is due to salary and benefits increase as well as uniform replacement function 2110 school resource officer on page three the increase of $689 is due to an increase in salary and benefits function 2120 School counseling services also on page three there is an increase of $71,400 due to health and dental increases function 2130 Health Services there's a slight increase um in Health Services $2,859 due to an increase in benefits function 2140 special education services psychologist the increase there is $1 17,42 it's due to health and dental increases function 2149 special education services behavioral on page four this function sees an increase of of 8,149 um the increase in this line is also due to the increasing costs of health and dental benefits did I read it
008wrong okay function 2150 special education services speech on page four this function sees an increase of $ 32368 due to health and dental costs function 215 53 special education services hearing and vision also on page four the increase there is 18374 um due to health and dental increases function 2190 student Support Services on page four the increase there is $ 42754 again due to the cost of benefits 2110 and 2111 instructional staff mentoring on page four the increase there is $1,732 due to the cost of benefits function 2212 curriculum development the increase in this function is $ 48,8 49.50 due to the increase in salary and benefits we had been able to use grant money for this over the past few years but those grants are now closed next is 2222 function media library services
009on page five the increase there is $7,988 due to the increase in cost of benefits function 2225 technology services on page five the increase there is $1 140,00 $265 primarily due to increased licensing fees slight bump in the equipment line as well as health and dental benefits function 2310 and 2311 Schoolboard Services page five it the increase there is $1,551 the increase there is the liability insurance premium 2312 moderator and clerk services on page five the increase there is $13 um increase in the salary line um that has not changed in many years function 2317 audit services on page five the increase there is $4,700 um it's due to an increase in the fees that are charged to us function 2321 the sa assessment on page six the increase is $228,100 this is the SAU
010budgeted a portioned out to the two districts within SAU 46 this increas is due to updated pration and preparing for separations the SAU has seen three long-term employees retire in the last few years they have also Ser they excuse me there are also several current employees that would be eligible for separation pay if they decided to retire at any point this budget helps to build the foundation to prepare for that function 2410 Office of the principales the office of the principal function sees an increase of $89,700 operations and manage excuse me operations and maintenance on page six the overall increase there is $758 due to health and dental raises as well as an increase to the supplies and purchase Services line function 2630 Grounds Maintenance the function sees an overall decrease of $144,000 due to
011reduction in the equipment line based on past expenditures the function 2700s all of the transportation services the increase to the transportation functions total $542 756 due to an increase in special education Transportation contracts health and dental cost increases and the vehicle camera line function 2900 is where the previously approved and collectively and collectively bargained Agreements are budgeted the total increase for this function is $240,500 functions 4200 site Improvement and 4600 building Improvement on page seven these functions see an increase of $100,000 and $100,000 respectively these changes are based on longitudinal and expected expenses I'd like to look at the revenues which are on page eight revenues continue to fluctuate year after year this year we see an increase of 500 2,957 in our adequacy funding due to excuse me our adequacy funding due and a
012decrease in Statewide education property tax or swept of $935 196 we anticipate a reduction in the local sources other than taxes of $126,800 and $1 13,950 Less in the unassigned fund balance we estimate the net overall oh sorry oh can we go back I was reading the wrong thing so the unassigned uh fund balance um we are looking at $1,500,000 and other local sources we are looking at a decrease of $28,995 sorry as always District administrators and officials continue to advocate for Revenue when legislation is brought forward at the State House I can attest to that please let your voices be heard by your representatives in conquered as well you can talk to me anytime I now resp resp respectfully open the floor to comments so that the board may hear from the public thank
013you for your time and consideration there we go representative Louise Andreas from Salsbury I'm a representative but I'm here tonight as a disgruntled taxpayer how do you expect us to believe this budget when the SAU and the school board withheld a deficit of $2 million from the taxpayers of the marry ma Valley School District I don't I used to trust all of you I've been coming to this 10 12 14 years and even though we didn't agree I always trusted you that you would do your job and I look at it this way if you can cut a million dollars out of the current budget to make up $1 million of the deficit then the budget is well padded and I am questioning how well bad padded this is as far as the state goes
014I have been told the state is having to cut their budget a minimum of $500 million so I as far as expecting more out of the state I wouldn't even consider it this year and we also have consideration we have the school we have the towns that are going up and we have the county everybody wants an increase I understand it but it's getting to the point I realize there are many people who make big money so if their taxes go up $500 10000 or $1,000 or 2,000 they don't care but then there is the rest of us we're the common everyday taxpayer of the Marry m Valley School District and we cannot sustain what's happening thank you thank you pardon me go ahead nope at Pike from pinook um what is the definition of
015the collective bargaining costs what what's what's all part of that uh so uh each year when we have we pass a collective bargaining like the one that you'll see on this warrant has three years so the year one if let's say that everything passes uh on March 6th year one of the mvs S A which is a total of [Music] $448,500 really appreciate all of your time thank you I'd like to second that I appreciate all of the time that you folks spend here but uh obviously we're all stressed about money right I think we can all agree on that uh and we see these these costs going up I see most of it around Healthcare and understand we can't cut those benefits we also can't cut special ed and we understand that that population
016seems to be increasing the cost of those needs seems to be increasing can you speak to what you folks are doing to prepare for that so that we don't have such an unexpected lump of of cost surprise in in future years specifically about the special ed that seems to be where the the big chunk of this increase came from so I'd love to know how we're we're planning to mitigate that moving forward Julie do you want to grab a mic you state your name in town hi I'm Jen I'm from uh Penacook Jen your last name Chase Chase thank you hi um I'm Julie godette director of student services um so I have a a little list in front of me of what I call Active Solutions um just starting this year this was my
017first year in this position um taking a look at that overage and and you know those um Rising costs for in particular out of District tuition and transportation um so some of the things that we've been actively looking into during this school year um include looking at our existing programs uh we have at each level we have some really specialized um programs so taking Tak a look at the numbers in those programs the possibility of expanding them um which would in turn uh support if we have a student who's placed out of District uh getting ready to return to the public school setting by expanding those programs we could potentially program for them inhouse um sooner um in addition to that um we utilize the Medicaid to schools program so making sure that we're um
018doing our due diligence with that program um regionally we're working with other districts around um some Transportation cohorts uh potentially uh where we could team up with other districts in the same situation um and then uh also the potential is out there um at least for communicating with other districts in our region uh to look at like a um a collaborative program um where potentially we could have some seats to place students uh that would be a cost savings compared to some of the a District programs that we currently utilize thank you so much I appreciate it you're welcome hello Dave hemway Webster uh a couple qu questions and I will focus first on uh buses uh the there's been much in the past to do about having appropriate staff to be able to drive
019the buses to get the right numbers of people uh not being able to get a substitute when a bus driver couldn't make it just can you give a general where are we with all of that at this point sure um we have had a shortage we've added a couple of drivers recently and uh the board just signed a resolution to get some of the 14 passenger buses that is going to significantly um provide us some flexibility so we're we're feeling like we're we're in a much better place having those 214 passenger um uh vans that you don't need a CDL to drive so that kind of opens things up a little bit for us as well as like I like I mentioned that we added a few drivers recently perfect thank you and so my
020question then for busing and the budget that's in front of us is do these amounts appropriately Rel appropriately reflect changes in routes for reasons such as Clos pin Bridge being closed that I know our administration's reached out to a few different uh places within the district about uh does that change things since for example that basically Cuts one of the routes in half in Webster I honestly I don't know really know how to answer that but I do know if we're talking about cutting a route in half um I'm thinking and I'm not the transportation director and uh I don't think Noel is here um but the potential for using the maybe the smaller the smaller buses um and reer that she's very good at um at dealing with that so I'm sure that that's
021something that they will be actively working on I just wanted to make sure that it was reflected in the in the budget and that it could handle that uh so I will move then to my other question which uh is 2225 technology you said this was primar due to license increases so what licenses caused a 50% increase in that budget line item and in considering that that is insane uh what other options were considered to replace those license options so some of that is because we've been able to use Grant funds and essr funds over the past few years as we have more access points and cameras all of those require licenses so uh Beyond like the student information system we have you know the things that are in this room all require licenses for
022those so some of that again was because of the um the eser money that we've been able to sort of pick up some you know let's say some new digital cameras as opposed to the analog cameras that we had before um and I'm I'm again punching a little bit above my weight class I could I'm looking at our Tech folks in the back but but that's the the main idea is that we just have the you know increasing number of of things that require those licenses and we should be steady it's not something that we can say well we just won't get licenses for the cameras or you know something like that so it would be fair to say then that instead of an increase in licensing costs it's that we're now actually being required
023to pay the licenses that we got grants for previously correct okay thank you very much go ahead has wal bosin um I can answer a little bit of your question about the buses in Webster as I am one of the drivers in Webster um all it's going to do is rroo me uh up uh detour road to to Pearson Hill so um just my times will just have to be adjusted a bit for pickup um but it's not going to I've done it in years past when that bridge has been closed um you know so it it we're not going to cut The Roots out there it's just my times are going to have to change so thank you Heather thank you Julie Ned Webster you gave us this handy dandy um sheet here with
024numbers I love numbers so it's right up my alley um I do Wonder though so the salaries for the superintendent assistant superintendent and the business administrator differ from the 123 Financial packet that was po that was for the um SAU meeting on that day so that the current salary numbers show a different number on that packet for the 24 25 adopted versus this sheet here just wondering why there's a discrepancy is that the is that the MV portion um I don't know are you looking at the the marac valley portion or I'm not sure what was in the the 123 packet I know I'm looking at the salary superintendent 2 320 and there's a 111 for the BJ was it the sa board packet yes from 123 it was the sa board packet so correct
025so the um all of those SAU salaries 87% of them are paid from marac Valley and 133% are paid from Andover because it's multi- District so this is the full and this is the mvy piece is that the the difference the MVP is the one with the with the yellow column I'm gonna I'm going to pull up the uh the packet that you're talking about right now Julie and see if I can it's on page four well well it yeah it's on page four according to mine 2526 proposal matches I don't have anything Julie can I get back to you on that when we figure that thank you thank you um Becky Herman Lowden um I had a I had one quick question to start um the SAU the director and administrative assistant is that
026a new position the director of student services say it says um a new position being formed at the SAU it was on their director and administrative assistant $1,220 is that a brand new position I don't know anything about that so what page is that so I found it in this that was on the website and it says on the very first page it says student services addition of SAU level director and administrative assistant what does it say on the front the front of this yes what's the date well that was um December 3rd 2024 December 3D of 2024 so the reason why I'm asking I guess I can get to that and and if it is a new position um confused why we're adding a position at the SAU if that's the case but cutting
027teaching positions where we're not we're not rehiring and teaching positions and um as much as I like Randy and Katherine very much so I don't think like with everything going on that the SIU should be being considered to get raises this year um those those raises were um negotiated so as with any other collectively bargained agreement just like the bargain just like the collectively bargained agreement that we have with teachers with support staff and when was that bargained uh mine was a three-year I'm in the second year of a three-year contract so I guess when I was going through this a lot of the I know it's a lot of work to do the budget and I wasn't sure of the format tonight um but I so if you look at the overall grand total
028of the SAU budget which I got out of this packet which was on your website the total was um the total additional just to the SIU was $257,000 um from last year's budget and my thought was that's a lot of teach teaching positions or a significant amount of teaching positions that could be put into place um and um I have so I did write something up but um can I can I speak to that point though that's what I was trying to figure out the positions were moved from marac Valley to the SAU okay so there was an increase in the SAU budget but a corresponding decrease in the marac valley budget okay because instead of you know so you know if Julie's position we used to have another person that was the director when
029she left we hired that as an sa position so marac Valley actually got the don't tell Andover but MV got the better of the deal okay um because they're now paying 87% of that cost as opposed to fully taking that on and that was the increase was moving positions from Mar ma Valley to an SAU level position so my suggestion I guess would be um I think there's a lot of administrative layers within the district and I think a lot of things need to be looked at because when I went through the budget and I looked it's a lot of the same and not a lot of like thinking outside the box and so my my thought and going through it is to really look at each position and try and figure out like is
030this the best that's getting to the kids like the kids are our main the main reason why we're all here are the students and their success and anything that we could do to help with their success and and you know get rid of those layers even getting rid of some of the layers because then then communication is better and it goes directly to the kids versus versus through all these other positions so I would really um urge you to like relook at the budget and look at the things that could be changed so it directly affects the kids versus going towards extra administrators for example when we were going through and you said the grant ran out on um some of the curriculum um the curriculum positions well maybe those curriculum positions um could be
031done by teachers or leadership people in those positions working directly with Katherine because as an assistant superintendent curriculum is part of that so I think I really truly think we need to look at things more than just continuing with the same and figuring out what the problem is so that we can solve it and have like a sustain sustainable future for all the stakeholders here because I know there are people that are struggling and I do see a lot of things I can think of a dozen things that we could change and I actually Randy I have an email with all of those things in it that I'm going to send to you right um but uh that would be my two cents but I was conf confused about that with the new position at
032the SAU because it should be towards teachers no it was moved this the past year into this one bill Hines bosin thank you I'm I'm wondering my age-old question and over tuition um I don't see the the handout or the citation in any of the handouts here is that going to be in the book this year yes it will be as I said would we do the uh the billing for and over and that's one of the pages in the annual report okay can you tell me how much going to be they're going to pay we're looking I guess there's three years that I'd like to to hear last year this year and what this budget anticipates they're going to be paying next year so next year their their rate according to the um tuition
033agreement I'm going to get close it's around $16,900 right in that neighborhood which represents 90% of the marach Valley High School uh rate as the uh since that is the tuition agreement and I assume again that's the unadjusted number yeah the UN actually they were only off by uh pennies this year for whatever reason I don't think there was a major increase I don't know if you remember the what that number was on the doe2 but it's the crtc adjustment which was a pretty small number it's 23 to I'm I'm I'm it's not it's not tiny Randy it's it's sizable um and this year they're paying I'll have to well I can recite it if you don't want to look it up it's $1 4,540 this year $1 4,540 per student student and last year
034they paid $155,000 per student $540 that's correct um Randy board members there is so much wrong here um I I I the the numbers just make me cry first I'm going to just flat out tell you that it it almost Rises to the point where I feel like there's a fraud going on here with what is what I'm being shown um you've calculated the tax rate here and I'm going to assume that the tax rate estimates that you that you have put forth here are based upon the revenue page correct so the revenue page at the bottom is the 30, 900,000 approximate number and I want to to point out to my peers in this room that at the top of that column is a 1.5 million estimated um fund balance how can you how
035C how can you put that on there do you really believe that we're going to come out with $1.5 million left over at the end of this year we went into the year 25 26 right that's for 25 26 right but so what do you what do you so you're yeah I this so you know that's not I mean I you can't put that in there I don't if and if you're going to come out with 1.5 million we're 1.5 million too much in the budget um you know it's I realize that we've had some Financial challenges I get it I things happen mistakes are made I I I'm really ashamed about the transparency here you heard Mr Collins at the last year I think Jessica has mentioned his name a couple of times this
036year and this this is just borders on fraud um and those are not the numbers that I see when I calculate the numbers and I shared them with you I assume that you reviewed them um there are much bigger numbers in the projected tax rate than what you did than what you have here and I I I'll certainly take another look before for the uh annual meeting thank you hi Ned lazat from Lowden so to me there's a few white elephants in the room and the big picture is that last year you came to us for a $3 million increase in the budget from the previous year there was only approximately 200 people that showed up in the meeting and you lost we lost from holding it back by 80 votes you for it was
037about 200 people that showed up at the at the U the voting last year hook Academy last year they had their budget reduced $3 million and I couldn't understand like and I have a friend of mine that works there as a teacher there and so forth and they've been able to make the budgets cuts and adjustments and stuff like that schools still going along fine they're doing fine we got an increase of 3 milli milon they got a decrease of $3 million and I'm reading in the papers that we've had an overspend of 2 million so that's $5 million increase and then you're coming back to ask us for 3.5 million more that's 8.5 million in a season okay and that's that's insane it doesn't compute the problem is is that you guys we have
038this meeting now right and we have Town meetings coming up in a month and we have infrastructure things that have to be done and voted on and approved and you guys get your slice of the pie and then we have to figure out how to get our crumpets okay at the end and you can't have students transporting to school if we don't have good infrastructure if our roads are not up to C if our fire if our police things like that and I remember talking to Christine Bell back 20 years ago and in 20 plus years you have not reduced or even approximated like working with the towns in order to find some sort of sensibility in finding a budget that we can work with because we're we're at a threshold of things that have
039to be done and then people not affording their taxes we had a big tax increase this year I've heard plenty of people say like wow my bill went up and then we've got more stuff coming up here and at the end result when I hear the terms it's for the children we can't even find a way for the children to afford to live here because they can't afford to live here you know because us adults okay and we were kids at one point in time you know our budgets and stuff like that if we don't if if if our job we lose a job if work goes you know slows down or something like that we we have to come back and make hard decisions not everybody gets health insurance okay and I don't understand
040I mean it's it's like a great great job but at some point the benefits and stuff like that and I know you want quality people but gez aren't you taxpayers too don't you aren't you us I mean how can you sit there and tell us that within one calendar year we're looking at 8 A5 million and that's even before we have our town meetings and our town meetings we have another we have some big stuff that we're dealing with because we've got like fire and safety you know in Lowden we're looking at you know what a 1.5 million because we have to for a ladder truck and that's a big debate all right and then we've got other stuff going on and it's just you know not once in over 20 years has this board
041ever said hey we're going to try to hold the budget we're going to try to keep things down you know we're actually looking for ways to save money you've never done that and it's always gone up I mean over we like five years ago seven years ago we were somewhere below 40 million now we're talking 51 million and then you were you were able to take a million or so out of a fund to figure out this other thing at what point do you actually look at the spending and this you know the special ed and stuff like that and say hey this is out of hand we got to stop this we have to put a stop like Randy you said you put a spending freeze well if a special education stuff like that
042why are they being tuition out you know moved out someplace else and not handled here I mean there's a there's a lot of stuff that's really wrong and it feels insincere and that's that's not even the right word it feels wrong and the thing is is that most of the people here and I'm surprised that I'm surp this place should be packed no joke it should be packed I was looking for fur hats pitch you know when talk where are they you know but I mean at some point you know the rest of the world is dealing with some budget cuts and stuff like that and having to make hard decisions and is this all we can do as far as getting people to show up because we still have Town Meeting thank you thank
043you we have people waiting thanks thanks for your time thank you so the increase is just over 3.3 million there is no $8 million over the course of this year my name is Kim Fortune I'm from Webster New Hampshire um um it's so nice to see a state representative Louise Andress here recognizing that she has such an impact at our state level in regards to Educational Funding we should all be thanking her and giving her a round of applause for attending tonight all of us all of us she's our voice my question is how much of this district is coded in regards to population of students if you're I'll wait are you asking for the number of identified special education students I am so we are at approximately 29% of our overall population um and
044the total number just need a moment here uh the total number um is 651 students 651 students yes am I correct when I say the majority of the services provided to those individual students is supplied or supplemented by federal funding uh the majority of it is not no um we have we receive our idea Grant which is the individual with dis individuals with disabilities Education Act which is the grant that that we received to help fund um special education and uh this year we received $662,000 61 uh for our school age population which would address kindergarten through age 22 um about two years ago the law changed and we now educate students um who do not receive a high school diploma who are on a um what's called an attendance track um and we educate
045them now uh by law until they turn 22 uh versus what used to be 21 um and we also receive approximately $26,000 uh through that grant for preschool population um which we have two preschool programs in our district one in bosin and one in Penacook thank you very much um now just to clarify what is the source of that funding what is the source of the I DEA it's a Federal grant it's an entitlement Grant Federal grant yes thank you um what is the federal support of those programs uh so again we receive that Grant um and then federally yes and then we also receive um what is called special education Aid which is um we receive once we spend a certain amount of money on a student um typically it would be a student
046who is placed in an outof District program um which here uh at marac Valley it's approximately 1% of our population um is placed in an out of District program uh because we don't have programming to meet their needs um so what happens is once we spend approximately three and a half times the cost per pupil um for one student uh we are we can uh sub for essentially reimbursement for those Services um and the rate at which we get uh reimbursed has decreased significantly um so for example we used to receive um I feel at one point it was 80 something percent um and uh in October of this year we we received a letter um stating that the 80% was going to be cut to um 66 38% of the 80% that we had
047expected or anticipated so in saying that 1% of the 29% is out of district am I I just need to be clear on this understand it it's confusing no that's okay um so 1% of our overall population is placed in an out of District placement out of that 29% that is in fact Cod Ed within the district and they are part of that 29% yes thank you and that would essentially be 651 students am I correct is the total identified so there could in fact be some fluctuation am I correct or no it it literally changes every day um we have students every day yes we have students who are uh currently being evaluated and if there's a meeting tomorrow uh to make a decision about their eligibility for special education then that number would
048increase tomorrow so eligibility could fluctuate between September and June am I correct uh yes so in in special education students can be referred by at any time um summer it it doesn't matter and we have to act on that um we have federally mandated timelines um and so yes we we test um if we if we suspect a disability and we decide that we're going to test that student um within 60 days we have to meet to determine whether or not they're eligible so at every again any given moment we have many students going through that process who by the end of that 60 days could potentially be one of the identified students thank you um taking that further uh how will the current pause at the federal level which is not at this time
049decided impact this budget in regards to the factual figures to the actual budget being presented to the taxpayers at this time maybe the superintendent can chime in on this I didn't understand that question can you repeat that because I didn't absolutely no problem at all that question how will the current pause how will the current what pause pause okay I seem to have heard that a lot lately it that was rescinded there is no pause uh uh thank goodness we have someone who we should be proud of the New Hampshire education system Carolyn levit right Atkinson girl of New Hampshire press secretary okay came came from my most recent interpretation from her most recent update has said although we need to hear that there has in fact been a Judicial proposal and yes there was
050a pause brought from and to Monday as a deadline in regards to om at the federal level which I'm hearing a lot of the funding in regards to at least 29% of this budget is brought forth from federal funding has been paused momentarily but not all so in saying that I would like to reiterate the question I asked and I will go forth it says how will the current pause at the federal level which is not at this time decided currently recognizing that the federal level constitutionally supersedes the judicial impact this budget in regards to factual figures to the actual budget being presented to the taxpayers at this time so the pause that you're referring to has in fact been rescinded the factual only for om the factual budget I you had your opportunity the
051factual budget is what we are presenting to you at this time so there will be nothing changed the the the factual fig the factual pause you're referring to has been rescinded thank you for your question there are people waiting I understand I just want to make sure that all of us as taxpayers are being presented with factual figures to in fact be voted on otherwise there is a conflict and unfortunately as presented by a gentleman over here this could potentially be fraud and Mel and void thank you let let me assure you there is no fraud here thank you oh absolutely that's why I brought this whole annual meeting back a good period of time and we had to vote in July because we did not have factual figures presented to the taxpayers thank you
052go ahead thank you oh can you hold on one second thanks I appreciate you waiting U Bill are you still here I think he left um I messed up and I so I want to address bill you know when Bill was um making his statement I looked back I was projecting a fund balance at the end of 2526 so I changed it I will correct those numbers and I'm doing it right now as as we speak I do apologize and I thank you for you know kicking my brain into gear um what bill is talking about is when I put the $1.5 million at the top that was coming off off of the um the net a size value that we'd have to raise and appropriate for taxes and in my mind I was thinking
0532526 but we need to look at the end of 2425 because that would be the unencumbered fund balance that we' be going towards and we'll be lucky if we have any I'm going to keep a zero in there for the sake of coming up with those tax rates um I will correct that in the annual report as well as putting this up on the on the website thank you for that CLA I did Apologize he's okay yeah I said it's my fault I I I I thank you for that I just I just went through the timeline with my peers to make sure that because that was something that I had was writing some clarifying notes on yeah and just to be clear the line where there's the 1.5 that'll come into play in November
054and the reason that I'm so concerned about that and so that the people in the here could understand is we're in the year on the left-and column right now we're going to get to that end of that year and I I I hope everybody here knows the situation we've started the year a million dollars in the whole we took a million dollars out of our Expendable trust to cover some of the overe expenditures last year and I use that word carefully because when I look at the financial statements which I have done and taken a lot of care to review on my own we didn't really overexp last year's appropriation we tiptoed right up to it but we didn't overexp it the problem that I see here in the numbers are twofold one the revenues
055didn't come in and I have a whole host of questions that I could ask you about that I don't think there's enough time here tonight um but the revenues did not come in to the tune of two million bucks furthermore and there are some adjustments that the auditor put in here and in the fund balance section they're other they're listed under other and they're on both sides of the Ledger the expense side and the revenue side and they're big numbers they're $845,000 and they're $445,000 numbers they don't balance out so that made it worse even so there's thank you thank you Bill so there's a lot there um so can I um just one last little quick I'll be I'll be short I understand um the auditor's report will there be an Auditor's report in
056the book we uh just finished the 23 audit the 24 audit um may not be done in time for the annual report okay thank you for waiting thank you you're welcome um my name is Alexis janat I'm from Webster New Hampshire um I don't really have a question I just have a comment and feedback I'm a parent of a child with special education services my child struggles with intractable epilepsy and I just want to say that this special ed department has been amazing to my family and I cannot thank you enough for the support that you have provided to my family and things are tough trust me I got laid off last week and we have to make a lot of tough decisions but I'm very concerned about cutting special ed and I hear you
057about paying taxes love but I just want to say special ed from this team has been amazing thank you thank you very much I appreciate that um ma'am well I think he was waiting longer he was okay I I'll go along with that thank you ma'am Mike mord and my uh representative of Lowden I have a question and maybe a couple quick comments my question is uh if the Warren artic fail uh in March uh what's the default position what what do you do if if this doesn't pass which you're asking for so uh there is no default budget so the budget if the let's say that the school board presents this warrant as is and decide to move that forward um if the if article three is not passed they would have to if
058there was some U something from the floor kind of it was referenced about Pembrook who cut $3 million from their budget and then after that cut uh 27 teachers um from that that 3 million um that would then be voted on so at the annual meeting the way that the annual meetings go we stay and vote until something something is passed so if it's the proposed number then that goes through and if it's not it's some sort of adjusted number which would happen at the annual meeting correct if the warrant fail okay and the the comments uh quickly uh I know Louise representative andas I've seen her standing outside in a snowstorm trying to get elected to this board and uh I'll be very candidate representative Andress Louise is is not the part of the
059education establishment she represents a lot of folks but those folks aren't here tonight A lot of them some are some aren't so again as someone else said thank you for standing up up and and showing up uh yes um and I have looked at all these numbers tonight and thank you for going through those and I have questions on so many line items but this is there's not time it's too late to really drill down and work on those like Louise um you know I have an interest in education I've taught in public schools parochial schools they've taught in military schools Community College University I was elected to a school board I was appointed to a school board I've served two terms in the House Education committee so when there was an opening a few
060years ago on this board uh someone said W don't you uh for year to fill out of your position I said all right I'll uh show an interest in that but like Louise I don't fit in the club uh so I I think there's maybe one board member who said uh uh who voted for me whatever so I I tried and Louis has tried other folks have tried so uh what I'm saying to you is uh thank you for your work and what I need to say to other people are uh we need to give some other folks like Louise a chance is there a single fiscal conservative on this board I don't know I'm not thinking there might be is there a single Republican up there amongst the 17 of you uh I don't
061know I'm I'm I'm thinking that you're not representing the people in this SAU uh Lise gets elected in November when people show up and I understand about the yet establishment because I I've been part of it so I want to say thank you for your work but I'm also saying to other people uh thank you you we need some other uh some other voices and some other people thank you thank you very much so Mr mafa I just want to clarify you do understand the board members are elected I used to teach Civics man I understand I I understand that okay yes I I agree too yes I understand board members are elected the the scenario I described the the board had a vacancy they asked for people to volunteer to uh fill out part
062of a one-year term which I did I I wasn't given a chance to do that I would like to have had the chance as Louise would to go through the these line items and uh and challenge them the the governor of New Hampshire makes $144,000 last year and nothing and and good on you I know it was negotiated uh but to to make 172,000 to run an SAU uh that's just one of countless line items that I wish some of us could could drill down on and talk about we we're running out of time here which is why I asked what happens if if this doesn't pass uh in March thank you thank you thank you from Salsbury and one of the things that I would like to point out which I think Mr Moffett
063knows and also Lise Andrew is the state of New Hampshire is last as far as what they contribute to offset our taxes so where the fight should begin is down in conquered not here we certainly can look at line items what it's down and conquered where the biggest part of this happens and they also have a voucher scheme which is all Al taking our hard-earned money and pulling kids out of public school school which is increasing the cost to educate our students public education is a right you have to accept everybody and when you take a voucher and they can go to private schools that do not have to accept special needs people so just saying look where the money really should be coming from the state of New Hampshire thank you hi hi Jen
064Mercer Lowden I was in the same position as Mike excuse me several years ago where I tried to get on the board by a vacancy position and I did not have any educational experience but somebody who worked for the Nea conflict of interests it's I'm gonna hold it um anyways they got in over me but anyways um Randy since you brought up your contract what does it say about doing your job as previously mentioned there was a 2 million overrun with no transparency so please help me un oops sorry sorry I had to rewrite some of this because everyone told stole my questions so please help help me understand how you think it's okay that if you don't do your job you deserve an 11% raise and that the budget at the seu increases by
06518% um after grossly mismanaging last year's financing and unscrupulously hiding this information from the taxpayers want came to light according to the newspaper article with lots of facts um the actual amount was 2 million versus 1 million not only that I don't see a lot of raises for the actual Educators that actually do the work for the children it's shocking and I'm actually truly disappointed in all of you but more so those that I personally know so yes this you're in your second year your contract has been decided what does it say about your job so first of all let me address a couple of the things I'm not sure where you're getting the 11% from because this year to next year is a 4% increase but um one moment she said that's the descri
066she asked about we have one person at a time because I did the math in what I found from the budget online which was the December 3rd I think I have too many papers to Thum when I looked at the amount that did the math it was was 11% so it must be a different number somewhere else okay um we were transparent from the beginning as far as the overage we used the trust fund in September when um it was brought up in November on November 4th that there was an additional million the board was informed and then we needed to figure out what that meant and what that meant moving forward so how that impacts future years do we need to have a special meeting what are the options which is why if you
067read the financial challenges statement um it outlined that that whole thing um we I'm not a marac valley employee I'm an SAU 46 employee um we had a meeting at the beginning of December again where that was all uh laid out to them if they wanted to act at that time then they would have done so um so but you know the the whole thing about lack of transparency and 11% increase and 133% increase and and all of that um these were outlined all the way along we had a public hearing to take money out of the the two Expendable trust funds to cover the million dollars at the beginning slightly over a million um and and went on from there so I don't have my calculator but it says um you're currently at 155
068to be raised to 172 that's a difference of 17% 165 oh so there's a typo in here then okay so that's why my math doesn't work my three years my first year was 155 then 165 then 172 okay for the for the three years so there would be a total of almost 11% from year 1 to year three okay um so then the next thing it's my understanding that if the budget does not pass um that it reverts back to the previous year's budget that's do you have an RSA that tells me what what the no that would be in SP2 districts there's what's called a default budget but for for us as I said to um Mr Moffett it would have to be something that we we would stay till whenever until um until
069the the body voted to accept a number so if money was going to be added to the budget or money was going to be taken from the budget um it would be a a vote of the folks in the room and that's just a simple majority it does not be a certain percentage Yeah still in the room okay thank you welcome thank you again from Webster um this may be more appropriate for a little bit further down the warrant articles but it brings up the point uh and the couple points that were made about the fund balance in Prior years I have suggested that when you're filling things for example the maintenance trust fund that that come not from the unassigned or unbal the fund balance but that that be normal and appropriated and especially
070in this case where you've drawn that down to basically zero and you've just stated you expect that to basically be zero I don't see how you can possibly say that you're going to take those out of the fund balance and in your financial uh statement when you had the $2 million that you were explaining uh you stated that part of this is also that you haven't had a large enough fund balance to be able to maintain and work around some of the issues now I'm the chair of the select board in Webster and I want to briefly explain uh One impact that this has had in the past year for different reasons but in the past year we had a vast increase in the amount that we were paying to mvsd that was beyond what
071we would normally have expected for an increase we didn't have enough in our fund balance to be able to go through that we almost ended up having to take out Tans or tax anticipation notes in order to be able to pay that bill fortunately we didn't and we changed our policy to increase the amount of fund balance that we now carry in the town of Webster unfortunately that means we weren't able to give it back to our town residents in tax payments immediately but that does put us in a better financial position going forward as you stated that you want to try to grow this how are you expecting to do that since a you can't just add to it and B I see that you're still trying to take out of it to not
072account for the amount that you're putting into funds and feel free to address that as a as a whole now as a partial topic related to budget and or further in the warrant articles I just want to make sure it's an appropriate item to be discussed yeah it definitely hits on three of the upcoming so I don't know if you want me to answer it now before folks have done however you find it the uh most advantageous and most transparent to put it into context when we get there or now it's up to you so the make sure uh the maintenance Expendable trust has $76,900 all the fund balance and this was something that Katherine and I um put out to the board about financial well-being in the district um a a while back and
073that is you know the recommended amounts of fund balance you know we're our Target number is 10% there's also an upcoming warn article that is a contingency a retained Surplus um and that affords the board the ability to for the un unanticipated thing not things that are on the CIP or anything like that but unanticipated things that's that's your emergency fund that's what that would also go back to the fund balance if not spent right at the end of the year that's going to have to go back and you can't have more than the 5% of the of the district's net assessment so that's what what that one is as far as the other money if there's not money there then the money doesn't go into the uh Expendable trust so the special Leed Expendable
074trust as you see this warrant there's a you know a recommendation for 150,000 um at the board meeting last night I suggested that the board may want to consider uh moving that to 300 because of some large capital projects namely the the high school roof um coming up in the future and kind of that new approach to looking at the me and CIP um as far as you know whether they get funded if the money is not there they don't get funded you know if we had one from last year there that wouldn't be funded if we didn't have the money going in sorry Ju Just to be clear I'm I'm not talking about uh that there needs to be funding for the maintenance trust fund which there absolutely does and there should be and
075that's definitely appropriate uh I'm talking about taking that from unassigned fund balance so you can say that you're not including it in the tax rate not including it in taxation not including it in appropriation when you're saying that you still need to grow the unassigned fund balance that isn't large enough in the first place that's why U I think in that document it points out that the board would consider that at the end of of the year not that that was an automatic so considering the the scope of the of the CIP and what that might look like thank you uh my name is Tara gun I'm from Webster I just have a couple of quick questions I'll try not to drag it on um one question I have I see this this sheet with
076the budget increases and um the salaries look like they only go up I don't know um well it's less than 200,000 but then the benefits go up almost a million so where does that come from so the salary line doesn't have um the money that's in the 2900 function added in because that's already part of the budget so the benefits you know in total if we look at special ed and non-sp specialed benefits it's about $1.5 million do which is why we've shopped and we're hoping to be able to change providers and that we can save some of that money moving forward and then another question regarding the same thing I've noticed in in several of the categories like student Support Services there's only a $10,000 difference between salaries and benefits why is that I
077mean the benefits and the salaries are just about even why is that that's double paying well I can tell you that a family um Kathleen if I'm if I'm way off on these numbers you can correct me but like a family health plan um that is a a split cost based depending on the The Bargain agreement is like $37,000 or in that neighborhood so which is a pretty big number so do the um because I mean where I work I get benefits but I also pay a lot for the benefits so is it a is there a copay yes there is a there is a split depending on uh which bargaining unit yes J okay and another question and I'm gonna ask this lovely lady right here who's the bus driver um I drop off
078a couple of my grandkids I've never had a child in in the school district at all um just CU I never have any kids but my um my grandkids um by a second marriage um I drive them to school now when we get there there are a couple of full-size buses there and you know Webster School and I know you're drive a webst for bus and there's about 20 25 cars that people drop off their kids at school and you get these school buses that you can tell me how many people are on the school bus I don't 10 12 how how many really because I'm sitting there and nobody gets off the buses so we've got two sometimes three full-size buses and then there's a a bus from the boys and girls club or
079YMCA or whatever it is and then there's a small van so but I don't see a lot of kids getting out of and how come so many people are driving their kids to school and then picking them up in the afternoons because their those families are paying for the school buses too and while I'm on this on the on the buses um if we have contracted services do do we own any school buses yeah yes okay so what are the contracted services that's in the 2700s Julie do you want to address because contracted services are $842,000 um so that would be the special education transportation that I referenced earlier um and and just maybe to give a little perspective um of that 1% of the population that I referenced earlier um that would be placed
080in an outof District placement um that Transportation cost um our highest for for one student is approximately $85,000 for the year um so what happens is we always try to use our our in-house Transportation Company um but of course due to shortages with drivers and buses um we can't always make that happen um we access approximately I'd say 11 or 12 uh placements in our our state um and so what we have to do is then call uh around to our you know Transportation companies that we utilize and first of all see who has availability and then we get estimates as far as you know how much the run will cost us and um unfortunately those runs can be very expensive um as I said you know one of one student um can be $85,000
081in a year just to transport them to their program and so where just you know no names because it doesn't matter of course but that 85,000 where does that the the student go that that is that much money well so as I said we we have you know upwards I would say at least 12 programs I I didn't um think to really count but I would say between 12 and 15 different private placements that we access and they can span um anywhere you know Lancaster has an Easter Seals program that we don't tend to use um too frequently but in years past we've use them and then there are a good chunk of placements on the Sea Coast he is that a stay over no or the poor kids have to drive almost three hours
082to Lancaster and get there no and it and you know we try to maintain a reasonable bus ride in some cases it does go over an hour um but they um you know the these are day placements these are not residential no residences um yeah I so those contracted services for 800,000 that's for special ed special services yes special education Transportation now the the the tools vehicles and cameras it um line that's up 146,000 um how much of that is vehicles I mean are we re replacing Vehicles very often and do we have any of the smaller buses we do that was uh two of them were just just approved last night that's I referenced the 214 passenger so we do a a lease purchase um and that in part of that increase is because
083we've kept that line where it's been and it's not quite enough to give us the the two buses um so typically it goes that we have we're on a replacement cycle so we might be in uh similar to how I was explaining the CBA there might be in year one of uh a lease on two lease purchase agreement on one and then year two on another year three on another so we're we're replacing buses as we go okay I I will ask you a question um why do we need how many students fit on a bus my bus can hold 77 okay so why do we need two or three buses in our town if we don't have that many kidsy the on the for over hour and if I were the only okay that's
084the one that says school bus on top okay right now how about the little white one the little white bus okay before before school and after school so those are the kids that don't sometimes they ride our parents are home but right YCA YCA and so this is the the conquered YMCA yeah that's crazy no erant pay for it let me see if there was anything else I wanted to ask well I I guess that's all again I I appreciate all your time too I will I will ask something it's probably not the right place but I I have a friend who was an employee driving a truck and a school bus hit this truck and the the school board was heard heard it was a fender bender well the school bus was total and
085the mail truck was almost total and the person driving the mail truck got seriously seriously injured and is still out of will never be able to work again at the age of what the person in charge of the buses I know that person person is not here anymore but shouldn't the people that are in charge of the buses now this was it and it has no nothing to do with this board or the school district but a school bus hitting a mail truck should have made some news it wasn't in the papers it was nowhere and this board Roger sandborn told the board that it happened because this guy happened to be a very dear friend of his when he worked with us why why could something like that happen that the school board was
086told it was a fender bender and the school bus was total this is on way from Len to to Penacook beautiful sunny day dry land dry grounds it's do we have a new person in charge of school buses that that's this isn't going to be hidden again I can't speak to that this is this is really about the 25 and that's why I said I'm probably out of line right here but it was you are the school board right they are yeah so I was wondering because how could the school board not have known about an accident like this between a mail truck and a school bus I mean I went to State Police I went to local police I went to do and they had no records so this is something to think about
087thank you excuse me that's okay I oh no she's next bosin um I'm a trainer over transportation we have uh 58 pages of uh safy 1300 rules that we have to follow um Heather okay this really doesn't have anything to do with this well I'm just thank you for thank you for trying thank you for trying thanksa I just wanted to inform the school board while I'm here that this this person I appreciate that devastating yes thank you it's your turn go ahead hi Stacy Jarvis from bosan I just have a couple of I think quick easy questions um on the budget item 1290 is other special programs could you just share maybe what falls under that category I'm just not familiar is that Julie 1290 is that Julie Julie you no oh sorry it's
088page three hold on one second oh page reading tutors Julie reading tutors and out of District Tut um yes so uh my apologies so um that line references um positions like reading tutors which aren't necessarily special education um but we do have um several reading tutors throughout the district okay thank you and then one last question is for item 2110 school resource officers do you know how many that covers and is it just um I believe I've only seen them at the middle school and high school that's correct we do have two but we're currently um we only have one we haven't been able to hire for the other uh the other position so it's left in the budget for two positions and if it's not filled then we don't spend that that money all
089right thank you Amy corus Lowden um can we confirm that there are three full-time teacher positions leaving Lowden for next year yes we will be reducing um the Lees classroom teaching staff by three classroom teachers can you talk about the other other elementary schools too and what if if and what they're losing as well sure actually Lowden is and I'm not I mean certainly as the year unfolds there could be potential um changes that happen with population but Lowden has seen a a dis a significant decrease in their population um and it is appropriate for us to be reducing those uh features from that building and that will create Equity among other buildings in fact ladden and bosin essentially have the exact same population bosin has approximately two teachers per grade level with one exception
090has three teachers per grade level with I believe one exception as well so the other elementary schools are not losing positions right now we do not have uh position reductions planned for the other elementary schools this school year okay and do you know offand what the class sizes will be changing to and what they are now the ones in lowed in that are combining I if you give me a minute I can pull those up yes and while you're pulling that up how come the budget for Lowden Elementary specifically shows doesn't show a decrease of three positions it's only $1,700 and three positions is should be a heck of a lot more than that you want to speak to leaving cut position so as we've uh talked about you've heard fund balance come up a
091fair number of times and the district's been running at about a 1% fund balance which is not fiscally responsible so one of the things that we've done is we're looking for strategic ways to cut without necessarily cutting those positions from the budget until such time that we can get closer to a recommended fund balance of closer to 10% and by cutting those positions that you don't you won't see a corresponding decrease in the budget we're hoping to get to that point that through our strategic budgeting and cutting down of positions that we can build that fund balance up so that we're a little more fiscally responsible than how we've been running for the last um large chunk of years with about a 1% uh fund balance for an average that makes it very confusing to
092look at this and understand those changes just moving forward maybe that would be helpful to not have it in this format maybe show the actual decrease and then explain that it's coming from a fund balance but it's very deceptive it looks like lowden's going to be sitting at the same amount when in theory they're definitely not going to be running at the same budget thank you I have do you have the answer or can I ask a second question I do I have the class sizes if you would like y So currently we have three teachers for 35 students in our kindergarten class that will be reduced to two um in second grade there are 38 students with three teachers in third grade there are 41 students with three teachers and so those will all
093be reduced to two classrooms okay thank you um do we well you know but can you tell us if we are still paying a an agency an outside Agency for pair positions um yes we are um we still have I do have a number here um we started the year um with far more but we are down to um 12 of our positions being contracted out um we have approximately 137 par professional positions in the district and now we're down to 12 of them being contracted out do you know the hourly rate for the contracted uh it varies um but I could probably dig that information up I just wanted to compare it to the employee paa rate do you know that off the top of your head um I I can get that as
094well Amy I'm guessing your concern is the fact that those agency Paras are making more than our Paras that are working for us a lot more yeah and and to be honest that's a concern that we share as well the reality of the situation is though that we're we're advertising and we are trying to hire for those positions and we're mandated to provide those supports and we don't have people to fill them when we are able to hire for those positions and we have an agency parah supporting a student we are able to notify the agency that we no longer need those services and we're able to replace place them and we've had some pretty good luck reducing our numbers in the agency of Paris since the start of the year I just would like
095to hear the difference because I think it I think a lot of the pairs making I believe $16 an hour are not going to be happy to hear that you're paying the agency $50 an hour some of that is admin and of course it doesn't all go to them but maybe if their pay was higher you could get some better payers and more pairs yeah and and certainly you'll see in a later warrant article where we're bringing forward uh a new contract for our peras we have tried to be pretty aggressive in in paying them much closer to what they they certainly deserve um the concern you're raising is one that we certainly share as well okay because I'd be happy to pay more on the budget if it was going towards paers and teachers
096but when Randy says oh if the budget doesn't pass we'll have to cut teachers that feels threatening that feels like that's what you're going to cut why didn't you say would' have to cut administrators would' have to cut paper costs would have to dig and look for cuts you didn't you said we'd have to cut teachers so 82% of the budget somewhere around there goes towards staff so we can't cut enough pencils and paper to make up we could try we could look we could dig that's what we want to see you guys doing is trying to not cut teachers but you say you're going to cut if we don't pass the budget which means you better pass the budget or we're cutting teachers and I didn't say we're cutting teachers what I said said
097was when Pembrook cut 3 million from their budget that represented 27 teachers and then shortly after that more left we have some of them in this room we were able to hire some folks that happen to be in that situation that's what they did I didn't say we were going to cut teachers right you didn't I misspoke you didn't but that's what it sounded like it sounded like teachers will get cut if you come up with that Agency number can you just let us know please please yes thank you thank you yes I forgot what I was going to say okay come on Ray uh you can do it I I she she took care of uh 2700 transportation services and a lot of the things that I was going to say about that I
098didn't say but she didn't mention the fact of the uh the the uh salaries $600 increase the benefits so how come that's what I wanted to say why which one are you so are you are which ones Ray what can you 27 2700 transportation services 2700 thank you7 one that just the function totals this is the yeah when you were reading that okay sorry hold please I'm going to sit down a minute otherwise you'll forget what you asked right have a copy of that 6 142,000 so the increase in the the salary lines don't show up in that spot because of what's in the 2900 function so what happens the 2900 function is kind of like a a holding place for salaries so there would be the whichever year of the contract it happens to
099be um and then that gets distributed to that so the the increase in the salaries come from that 2900 and they get moved over to those other salary lines so they're not there until um things are approved and then they're they're moving forward so that's why the benefits we know so we were able to take the 22.2% and put that through all of the benefit lines but the salaries depends on who's who falls in that line and then the money is moved from the 2900 function and put into that uh into those salaries so it's not that the salaries are just going up 600 and the benefits are going up 142,000 okay I guess yes and um okay hold on one second Ray because Julie would like to also I know she's gonna respond to
100Amy's oh so Amy sorry Julie's gonna respond to uh yes so um we were able to um I I don't really have an average but um approximately $50 an hour um is what we would pay uh an agency uh that we're charged that hourly rate which does include uh the benefits that the agency offers um and then through uh the district an equivalent position would be approximately uh I'd say between 21 and $23 an hour uh but that of course does not include the benefits that's just the hourly wage you're welcome Dave hemway from Webster one more time uh as was just previously discussed uh you mentioned that there were uh teacher positions being removed but were left in the budget in order to be able to enhance the fund balance as you're trying to
101do roughly how many positions or how much of this uh proposed budget is for that purpose and how much do you plan on adding to the fund balance by the end of this budgeted season so since this is for 2526 right so next year's budget there's we're looking at probably six positions that we're not going to to fill that you know people that have you know retired or you know moved so that's the number that we have based on the openings and being able to um look at strategically you know as Katherine kind of went through some of those numbers for class sizes we wouldn't be doing um our jobs if we had you know you know 33 kids and you know in three teachers necessarily so that's but we're looking right around half a
102dozen um positions and is that the only place that you are leaving stuff in the budget that you're not planning to fill or not planning to use yeah the six is districtwide the only other thing that we may have I'm not talking about just positions but I'm talking about stuff that's left there or slightly high to allow for increase in the uh unassigned fund balance when you were done the the 2526 right so what we're what we're hoping I mean is that we are able to switch Healthcare and then save you know some money and maybe sort of split the difference depending on you know where we're getting you know closer to uh a fund balance to have some Financial stability for for the district um so we do have some things like that but
103there's nothing really that we've said hey here's a place that we can add but again as we change if we're able to save you know 4 or 500,000 maybe we can trim a little off of the budget for 26 27 and then still have some uh there as you know to to feed into what would hopefully get to the point of being a 10% fund balance which that's going to take a number of years this is not something that's going to happen we're not going to go from 1% right to 10% % um in a year or two so it's it's definitely going to be a process but I think being you know strategic about how we're doing things and being mindful of of taxpayer money because having those emergency funds the contingency fund and
104well-funded Expendable trust and the fund balance is really how we're going to have you know healthy finances moving forward I completely agree with and commend that purpose I'm still uh looking for uh uh when you're going through this uh I guess what is the range that you are planning or expecting that you can probably add to the fund balance coming out of this budget that's that's about it thank you yeah hi Jennifer Chase from pen again uh from where I'm sitting it seems to me like you folks are doing the best that you can with the funds you have and I think that we' focused a lot on what can we get rid of out of the budget it's clear that we'd have to get rid of people or benefits which doesn't serve us or
105programming right like are we going to disservice our children to save some dollars I think that what we're not looking at is where are additional Revenue sources possibly coming from so I know that the lawsuit with the state has been hung up in the I think the Supreme Court for a while do we have an idea on where that is in the process or if there are other funding avenues that may be changing to help alleviate some of the concerns with the shortfall okay I can at least talk to there are two lawsuits currently now this is nothing to do with our budget directly I'm just gonna educate a little bit on that there is the conval case which I believe just went through the Supreme Court here and that will be decided the Rand
106case was heard um at the Rockingham courts as like a county level um in I want to say September and so we're still waiting on that decision as well obviously pending any decision um at that point it would really go to the legislators um there actually was a bill that was introduced that I testified um on I want to say a couple weeks ago um at the state level that would actually increase funding but again that goes back to kind of what Tracy was saying is um if the interest is to bring New Hampshire up to what um you know maybe other states do Statewide to support their education system um you you know advocating with your uh state level legislators would be a good step to take but that's the only piece I could
107talk to is the Rand as lawsuits thank you David uh I just I have an answer to your question um if we were to leave we're if we leave the six positions that we're cutting in the budget at approximately $80,000 a teacher we're looking at just under half a million dollars that we would have towards the fund balance Mark Griffin Lowden um this the fund balance that you guys are talking about where's that in here um coming into this year we have a negative fund balance so when I was saying 1% it's not in here it's not on any of the books that you show no the fund balance is just what's left over at the end of the year as you're going into the the following year okay um and so when I say
1081% that's just how much uh Mar Valley has typically had at the end of the year and it's recommended that that's really between eight and 17% uh to be so it's nothing it's nothing that we keep in like a fund that guys can use no we can't we can't just take it and and put it aside although the uh one of the um articles that's coming up about the contingency fund that would allow the the district to to take f up to 5% of the district assessment and hold that for unexpected expenses which is one of the things that we feel is um you know a smart thing to do to be financially um you know Smart in moving forward so that is why that warrant article's on the on the warrant okay and um
109finally with Lowden going down in population that's in student population right um okay so not to be inflammatory but I don't think the uh education Freedom accounts are a scam or a scheme that you called them earlier it appears that people are actually using them like myself and sending my kid to a charter school because I'm sick of this thank you hi hi Jen Mercer again from Lowden um a couple things so we we talked briefly about being able to cut costs and like pencils aren't going to cut it so um what are these two site improvements uh 4200 and 4600 there site Improvement and building improvements for an increase of $100,000 each is that something that we can hold off and wait I mean we just got a new track we just got a
110new scoreboard are these things that times like this like that's pretty S I know Fred you've got a lot of stuff going on but can can that wait I don't know John it might be able to wait can we look harder at some a couple things like that I mean I know it's a so you've got 275 already in the building and then 156 in the site so we asking for additional 100 on each is can we can we sharpen our pencil on that maybe so if I can you know step in part of that increase was the new look at use of the me and the CIP that I the maintenance Expendable trust um and the capital Improvement plan which Fred has now done a yeah sort of a 10-year uh plan outlined and
111the increase in those lines was with this change in how we look at the maintenance Expendable trust for some of those bigger projects so I think I mentioned before about the the roof to 1.8 million we don't want to add that to the budget absolutely so that that 100,000 on each of those lines would allow uh Fred the ability to do a little bit more with from the capital Improvement port for big projects yeah yeah for some of those smaller ones to save the maintenance Expendable trust for those really big ticket so correct me if I'm wrong because it's been a few years but I seem to remember when we started that and Fred's been working on this Capital Improvement plan for a long time and doing a good job of it but they seem
112to remember that's why that f was set up and I even heard somebody last night at the meeting say why aren't we already doing this or aren't we already doing this like that's what that kind of program should have been I'm trust fund should have been for are the big projects and the other stuff gets taken care of in the budget that aside back to my original question um is that something I mean it's you don't have to answer it now it's just something if we're looking to kind of again sharpen our pencils is that something that we can do hold off for you some things you can hold off on some things you can't I get it um have you looked at the CIP I haven't recently know where is it is on the
113website yep okay I'll take a look I extended it the town of Bas asked me to move it to out to 10 years um it's very fluid going out 10 years uh and you have when did you start that because I remember I seem to remember it at one of the meetings 10 years ago maybe um I we started the 10y year one in the last year but did Capital Improvement plan in general you started working on was it a 5e 10 12 years ago yeah there's a lot of stuff in the CIP millions and millions and millions of dollars thank you we're sharpening as much as we can appreciate that get this back come on you can do it got it thank thank you thank you let's um move on to okay okay um
114Becky Herman Lowden can I just make a suggestion so um I know when Amy was up here talking about the Lowden Elementary School positions and you said there was extra money in that line item can we take all the extra money out of all the line items and make a line item that says extra money or fund or something so it's more clear so people actually know what they're voting for no that is my that is my suggestion thank you thank you and we're going to move on to article four now which is the mvsa collectively bargained agreement Jessica wheeler Russell who is chair of the negotiations committee will speak to this amend agreement good evening uh let's see erle reads to see if the school district will approve the cost items included in the
115collective bargaining agreement reached between the maram Valley School Board and the mar Valley support staff Association which calls for the following estimated increases in salaries and benefits for 242 uh 25 26 excuse me 448,000 $448,000 year $277,450 for the 27 28y year $2,318 um so the uh the mayor MC Valley School Board and the mar MC Valley support staff Association or the mvsa have collaborated to bring forward a collectively bargained agreement or CBA to Envy voters thank you very much for all let me speak to you folks tonight um about an issue that affects every student parent and staff member in our district our support staff these individuals are the backbones of our schools ensuring that students are safe supported and ready to learn each day support staff include our pair of professionals custodians administrative
116assistants bus drivers Food Service workers and others who contribute to the seamless functioning of our schools the roles are vital yet often undervalued support staff are often the first and the last phases students see each day bus drivers greet students in the morning custodians ensure safe clean uh and learning environments and pair professionals provide one-on-one academic and emotional support to students who need it the most like many districts across New Hampshire we Face challenges in retaining and recruiting support staff competitive pay is necessary to attract and keep skilled individuals who are committed to the success of our students without adequate compensation we risk losing these essential workers to other Industries or neighboring districts that offer better wages so like an overview of this contract they're adding an additional paid holiday uh for Columbus Day or
117indigenous people's day uh Health buyback increase from $1,500 to $3,000 a realignment of years of service and adjustment to longevity payments minor wording changes around personal days accumulated sick time and course reimbursement and the year one uh we'll see an average increase of 8.63% in wages um I've as uh I've already read all those numbers so but I can repeat that uh if folks would like me to but in conclusion increasing pay of our support staff isn't just about numbers in a budget it's about valuing the people who make our schools successful it's about showing respect for their hard work attracting retaining talent and ensuring that every student in our district has the support they need to thrive to go a little bit off script I think we've heard tonight what our support staff mean
118to some of our parents especially those um whose students face different challenges and um all of of our staff that you know our bus drivers our food service workers some of which who greet my children as they walk by our house during the summer while we're playing outside these are our neighbors and our friends and um I believe this is uh this contract will show that we value their work every day thank you very much I now open the floor to feedback on article four thank you okay then next up would be article six Sally H Dickinson will speak to article six which is a request to authorize the board to retain a contingency fund oh Sally you're down there I was looking for you over there way over here article Six States to see
119if the school district will vote to authorize indefinitely until ended to retain year-end unassigned General funds in an amount not to exceed in any fiscal year 5% of the current fiscal years net assessment in accordance with RSA 198 colon 4-b Roman numeral 2 a majority vote is required and the school board recommends this article New Hampshire RSA 198 Callin 4-b Roman numeral 2 commonly referred to as the retained Surplus provision provide school districts including multi- toown school districts with the ability to retain a portion of their unexpended Appropriations that is surplus funds at the end of a fiscal year here's how that benefits a multi- toown school district such as ours first there is financial stability through Reserve fund creation this is the provision that allows the district to retain up to 5% of its
120net assessment that is local taxes raised for the school budget as a reserve fund there is also Financial stability through emergency use this Reserve can be used for emergencies unanticipated expenses or Revenue shortfalls without requiring immediate taxpayer impact through special meetings or emergency Appropriations another benefit is tax rate stabilization we can avoid large tax swings by maintaining a surplus the district can reduce tax rate volatility for town within the district helping to smooth out tax burdens from year to from year to year and we can plan for the future the Surplus can offset potential increases in taxes particularly useful in years with higher budgetary needs or reduced state or federal funding third a retained Surplus allows for long-term planning and Investments we can plan for capital projects retained funds can be allocated for Capital Improvement
121projects projects such as building repairs technology upgrades or equipment purchases reducing the need to raise additional funds from taxpayers we can invest in educational programs the fund provides a financial cushion to support Innovative educational programs or Pilot initiatives without risking immediate budget shortfalls finally a retained Surplus allows for voter control there's accountability voters maintain oversight since the decision to use retain funds typically requires approval from the school board which is accountable to the public and there's transparency retained surpluses and their uses are publicly documented ensuring transparency in financial management RSA 198 col 4-b Roman numeral 2 empowers multi- toown school districts to manage their finances responsibly reduce the taxpayer burden and address challenges proactively all while maintaining accountability to the community I now open the floor to feedback on article six thank you okay I'm
122sorry I thought she was coming to the microphone um can you put a number on this as far as what 5% well yeah so so is it the 30 million so 5% of the 30 million so million and a half bucks one and a half million up to that amount but that would be after um so if we fast forward a couple years when we actually have you know things to work with um if there was money going into the me and the special at Expendable trust those would be filled first and they'd look at that and then the board would decide up to 5% if they wanted to hold that as the um retained Surplus so does it yes it has to be well the next year you can't hold more than 5% of
123whatever the net assessment is so that it's basically a 5% emergency fund or up to that amount got it so it can it can never be never be more than 5% it's not something that builds and that you you know it's not like a little you know account that that will keep on building and and it is the school board so it would be similar to a met where correct you have to hold a public hearing and SP the money yep that is what the law states I I understand I think what what I'm you're asking for but I got to be really really really honest you haven't earned my trust at the current I'm not going to say that someday in the future you you will but right now you don't have my trust
124so um I do not support this article thank you okay Dan York will speak to article s uh Kim Fortune well Webster just for clarification recognizing that that gentleman I apologize I don't know his name that just commented um for clarification could RSA 198 colon hyphen small B uh comma 2 be read to the public here please so that we're clear on what exactly that is on article six thank you 198 4-b contingency fund a school district annually by an article separate from the budget and all other articles in the warrant or the governing body of a city upon recommendation of the school board when the operation of the schools is by a department of the city May establish a contingency fund to meet the cost of unanticipated expenses that arise during the year a
125detailed report of all expenditures from the contingency fund shall be made annually by the school board and published with their report not withstanding any other provision of law a school district by a vote of the legislative body May authorize indefinitely until specific Precision uh the school district to retain any unused portion of the year-end unassigned General funds from the preceding fiscal year in subsequent fiscal years provided that the total amount of the year-end unassigned General funds does not exceed in any fiscal year 5% of the current fiscal Year's net assessment under RSA 1985 prior to expending retained General funds the school board shall hold a prior public hearing on the action to be taken with such funds notice of the time place and subject of such hearing shall be published in a newspaper of General
126circulation in the relevant municipality at least 7 days before the meeting is held an annual accounting and report of the activities of a retained General funds shall be presented to the school board of the district and published in the annual report the legislative body uh the part three is just uh having to do with the city of Manchester and not the other municipalities no no no I think it's imperative that that all get read recognizing that um we all not want to know what a legis body the versus a governing body is thank you upon recommendation of the school committee May authorize indefinitely until specific recision the school district to retain year-end unassigned General funds Dan York will oops sorry Dan York will speak to article seven which is a request to add money to
127the special education Expendable trust article 7 reads to see if the school district will vote in to raise an appropriate the sum of $300,000 to be added to the special education Expendable trust fund pre previously established for the purpose of supporting student services with said funds to come from unassigned fund balance available for transfer on July 1st 2025 no additional amount to be raised from taxation the school board recommends this article the marac Valley School District is requesting voters to approve adding $300,000 to the special education Expendable trust fund this fund serves as emergency Reserve to ensure the district can responsibly address unforeseen and Rising costs associated with special education services the special education expense often fluctuate due to unpredictable needs such as new student enrollments required requiring specialized services or changes in current student
128support plans these costs are critical for providing Equitable education opportunities but can create significant financial strain if unplanned by contributing to the trust the District aims to be financially respons fiscally responsible by preparing for unexpected expenses without disrup disrupting other educational programs maintain compliance with state and federal mandates for special education uh minimize the need for midyear budget adjustments or emergency measures your support will help ensure that all students receive the necessary resources for a successful education while keeping the district financially stable stable money can only be added to the special education Expendable trust fund through voter approval at annual meeting and money can be withdrawn from this fund only after a public hearing at the public hearing the board will provide information as to why money from the fund is being withdrawn the board
129will listen to feedback from the attendees and then at the board meeting or at a board meeting the board will vote to take action I open the floor to feedback on article 7 thank you Melissa that's okay I don't know who made the motion to speak to it sure Melissa did you want to speak to that I'm not sure who made the motion from the board to add 300,000 um when that was because you can see why why that's a little concerning if we don't actually know why 300,000 is the number we had um I know that we had taken 500,000 exactly so so why 300 because um I think that the reasoning was there was not there it's only up to $300,000 so um it's not necessarily that there will be $300,000 left um
130you've heard us talk about the fact that we don't have um much of a fund balance this past year we didn't have any so um the fact that it could be up to $300,000 but it doesn't have to be $300,000 okay but we're we're voting on 300,000 no you're voting on up to 300,000 okay so it could have been any number I mean ideally because the special ed trust fund is wiped out now we still have you know some in the maintenance Expendable trust which is definitely going to be needed for the roof on this building um you know it it could have been a million but the odds of us having a million dollars that that would have so I think 300,000 was a um sort of a low estimate to get things started
131and get that uh fed back in okay David oh Dave hemway Webster again um this and maintenance as you've mentioned are are from that unassigned fund you've mentioned multiple times that that is coming in at zero so is there any point to these articles or are are you actually expecting that you will generate this amount uh by the time that we hit July which is the date that's listed here it seems like this is a we should do this but we're not going to have funds to do it anyway this is for the 2526 yes and this is stating the funds available by July 1 of 2025 oh that should say 2026 say 2026 okay thank you okay okay excuse me enough you want to move on to so Melissa muzy will speak to article
132eight which is a request to add money to the maintenance Expendable trust okay I think this yes I wasn't sure it was on before that's why I didn't speak to the special item out uh so article8 is our Expendable trust fund and the article reads to see if the dis the school district will vote to raise and appropriate the sum appropriate the sum of $150,000 to be added to the maintenance Expendable trust fund previously established for the purposes of maintaining school buildings and grounds with said funds to come from unassigned fund balance available for transfer on July 1 2026 no additional amount to be raised from taxation the school board recommends this article I did take the liberty of changing the date that was stated on the paper from 2025 because obviously that was an
133error yes sure we can actually can uh so article 8 is um for our Expendable trust fund and in 1993 mvsd voters approved the establishment of funding of a maintenance Expendable trust fund or me the express purpose of this fund is repairing and maintaining the district's school buildings and grounds the district has worked hard to craft a proactive Capital Improvement plan plan CIP this CIP is a available I'm sorry the CIP is a valuable communication and planning tool and helps the district protect the investment represented by our buildings and grounds an insured value of over $90 million feedback from the community indicates that rather than bringing larger Capital expenses and projects to the voters through separate articles on the warrant the district should save in anticipation of these future expenses with that in mind we
134are asking to reserve $50,000 from the endof year un aund fund balance to be placed in the district's maintenance Expendable trust fund the money will be utilized to support the MV SD's Capital Improvement plan as we prepare to addressed infrastructure and building needs throughout the district as with the other art uh trust fund money can only be added to the maintenance Expendable trust fund through voter approval at an annual meeting the money can be withdrawn from this fund only after a public hearing at the public hearing the board will approve information as to provide information as to why money from the fund is being withdrawn for example to replace a roof at one of the schools the board will listen to feedback from the attendees and then at a board meeting the board will vote
135to take action I now open the floor to feedback on article 8 thank you Bill Hines bosquin again I I don't think we can appropriate 26 funds here I think this the timeline here is not correct we would be voting for a surplus that might happen this year so I believe that what David Hemingway had told you that if there's no money these aren't going to get funded so it's almost a moot um but I I I will say that I do support these kinds of Articles and I especially support Fred and in his efforts that to put together a CIP to plan ahead it's hard to argue with somebody who puts a plan together you know failure to plan is a plan to fail um and he's planning and furthermore he has the met
136there that he's managed to get you guys to fund to do stuff and um I think when everybody comes here in these buildings we can see the kind of job that he has done over the years and we will miss him when he is retired so that's my two cents but I don't think you I think you need to check with your lawyer I don't think we can do 26 funds thank you Bill so in closing I want to thank all of you for your support and interest your feedback has great impact on the budget and warrant that is brought to the annual meeting the SD board will be reconvening their recessed February board meeting in a few moments please feel free to remain with us for that meeting uh the Ann just a reminder
137that the annual meeting is on Thursday March 6th at 6:30 right or seven sorry 7 o'clock in the mvhs gym so Thursday March 6 700 p.m. in the mvhs gym don't forget March 6 though you can vote all day from 11: till seven here at the high school thank you I never got an answer to my question from article three the discrepancy from the TW 126 board packet versus this oh thank sorry sorry Julie thank you um can you um the amount of the the amount of the superintendent um it's all three that are listed on here they're all off uh the why the um amount of the um SAU uh salaries the SAU salaries and the SAU board packet why they differ from the SAU board packet thank you Julie and Randy will get
138back to you and I'm sorry about that was the hand answer oh right so we'll take it just a couple of minutes to uh get the board to um do whatever they need to do and uh we'll be back for the board meeting e e e hi there we'd like to get started please thanks okay Sam I'll remember if I don't remember will you like reach out to me and say hey Tracy the CES tennial or whatever it is CES whatever yeah exactly way too many for me thank you thank you very much for the rest of other people say I think that that would have been how I would address that person that kept El I guess I can go well this is just a yeah I'll pass some of those down I know
139I'll take what did you think you would have I don't know it was a date so I I'd like to think I would I would like to reconvene the this Schoolboard meeting um from last night to right now please um if I could have a roll call please Tracy bricky here Jones Blanchard here Val H Dickson here Eric Hansen here Julia Jones here Melissa Muzzy here Jessica wheeler Russell here Laura Vincent here Daniel York here paa here Gary tman here Tracy do you think maybe we could so um certainly bring your microphone and some of you can sit here in the front we did that last year so that um we have more of a we so we can actually see each other when we're chatting okay so I guess nobody wants to move I'm
140going sounds fine that's just fine I'm gve so is moving okay thank you so next on the agenda is the discussion of the public hearing anybody want to start with that um I mean I I suppose I've had some thoughts um so I would like to address a couple of things that I heard as a theme tonight um but I will start with the budget and the requests for bending over and cutting where we can and cutting cutting and cutting I do not serve on the finance committee but I went to I think almost every single meeting and in that time um I also went through the budget on my own and I tried to find a way to save bucks anywhere that would not be detrimental to our kids okay as we all know
141special education is mandated we cannot touch that um uh collectively bargain agreements mandated can't touch that as well as um what was um health and benefits I mean pending maybe a change in provider we can't touch that either so what does that leave right um you know given some of the financial challenges that Randy was talking about that making the move to have an Underside fund balance so that we are in a better place fiscally is The Right Move we risk so much by not being able to handle unexpected costs you know what happens if a roof caves in in the Met is not fully funded right I could not think of anything other than some really like I'm not saying I want to do this I'm saying this is something that could be do
142we cap the number of students we sent over to conquer's um Tech program I don't want to do that those programs are very valuable for career Readiness and that's our goal is you know to make sure our students are prepared right so I just want to be clear that I personally think this budget is basically where it has to be without starting to um really affect our kids period um I like to say I I know that Penbrook and I you know I I don't like using other school districts in examples but it was H as an example but I think it's more of a warning because if a budget is cut so drastically that you have staff that have to be left kids classes are you know are an upheaval that the you know
143Administration doesn't have a lot of time to plan for that as well as then staff are just leaving like this is not you know the kids are doing fine perhaps on paper but it looks a little uncomfortable in speaking with parents in that District they are terrified um so I again I think it's it's not an example it is a warning and I really really hope that folks understand what would have to be done if this budget is not um you know or if it's drastically cut the last thing I really would like to talk to is this idea of fraud there is not any fraud that was happening at the time that was with my mistake I don't think he meant anything beyond oh I think I I know but I'm I'm talking about
144the $2 million right I'm gonna go back to this this $2 million statement that was made that had to go through legal and I would hope that folks who do you know are in governmental bodies understand that when legal is involved it takes time that we also had to go up to the SAU so instead of you know when we were looking when the administration was looking into the full extent of everything rather than coming half coocked with something that we made sure it wound its way through correctly so that everything was presented correctly because otherwise half you know like not quite understanding things can cause even more confusion and and issues so I don't think there was fraud around this shortfall or the timeline of the discussion I think that it just took a
145little bit of time to make sure that we had all of the information correct and we have the added um part of the SAU board as a whole which only meets twice a year so it just took a little bit of time to get there but we were all very clear that this had to be talked about that we had to put information out there and we did that and so that's basically all I will kind of say about the public hearing anybody else have anything they'd like to say about the public hearing yeah I'd like to say something I think the public had some really valid points uh I think that I heard repeatedly the word trust uh I think that I also heard some really good um ideas about not a reduction in
146force but a redesign and structure that I think that you know we talk about special it's never going to go down it's like a bad it's like a good Bruce Springsteen song right two steps forward one steps back it doesn't happen so if this continues at the rate and the percentages that it is going to look like it may continue what is the solution to the problem it's not asking for more money it's redesigning the programs that we have within our schools and redistributing the services that we provide through Cross trining or whatever you can come up with creatively it's thinking outside the box so I think that you know another good point was made by a gentleman in Lowden Town budgets now are going to public hearings they have to plan for their infrastructures
147to get the buses to the kids he made a valid point so I think that as we move forward thinking that this 6.92% increas is you know okey doie that we've got to rethink about how we do things across the board I don't believe that anybody on the board believes that 6.92% is oky doy I also believe that um Julie has worked her darnest this year and will continue to work in the coming years to redesign how we um have special ed Happening Here in the district um I believe that we inherited some unfortunate specialed practices and they are being remedied due to Julie um really working hard at that um so I I would like to speak to um also the whole idea of Fraud and I believe that there were people in this
148audience this evening who boarded on liel I am disgusted that you would that there were people out there that would think that your elected officials would actually try and pull one over on you because that is not at all what happened we had so many discussions on what we needed to fund this this coming year and um I I am just beside myself that people would talk about all the work that's gone into this and um say that we are trying to pull one over on you because that is not even close to True anybody else have anything they'd like to say Laura okay is this working yep sure is I this was a long hearing but I think it was good we explain stuff some stuff I mean this is a complicated situation this
149is probably the most complicated situation the district's been in since I've been on the board and we explained it and we explained it but some you have to keep explaining it and I think people began to understand the situation more so it wasn't just out there and I think people were receptive to hearing our s of story it was a long he hearing but I think it turned out well thank you anybody else would like to talk about the public hearing anybody else on the board I guess I just want to toss one last thing out sure um one thing that I was heartened by was the support for increasing salaries for teachers and support staff so I want to keep that alive and well and um when it's time to negotiate cbas and we
150bring it back to the district after those have been negotiated um I'd like us to you know kind of revisit this particular conversation and see what we can do for those who give their time their energy everything to the district and the kids thank you anyone else yes you don't have to touch it it's on is it now oh yep okay oh I I didn't know I was confused I'm not good with microphones um I just I think the public hearing is an opportunity for us to also get a picture of where the confusion lies with our constituents clearly we're throwing out a lot of numbers there's a lot of information out there there's an impact to their pocket and they are feeling the strain just like the rest of us you know somebody pointed
151out that we're taxpayers too yes I am um and I do take this job very seriously in terms of like trying to support a budget that supports kids as an educator I have a strong belief that that's important but I think we have to take this as an opportunity to say okay where are the confusions and how can we make them clearer because there is a lot of numbers here and I got confused we obviously got confused even on the dates at one point so I know I messed that up so I feel like this is an opportunity for us to yes we might get frustrated at some of the things that are said especially if we don't take the time to recognize that some of it's coming from fear and confusion so um you
152just got to make notes of those areas that we really need to like drill down into and give them more information thank you Melissa I anybody else I just I think to one more thing to kind of to that um I agree like um having this is is a good way to understand where folks are maybe not quite understanding things and it's confusing and like like Melissa I even right up until 550 I was going over all of my notes going what okay like making sure I had things down and I do this like you know I spent eight hours this weekend doing this you know what I mean but I think one of the more uh things I would like to keep doing is these graphs that are on the website right now are
153really really useful to really display and show exactly what these things look like where our budgets are going and in the increases it's very help it's a helpful useful tool that I've been I've seen being shared so it's not just even in this room it's being um you know distributed across our district so folks can have a good understanding of what these you know the increase in budgets and stuff is like that so I'd like to see that again next year too thank you is there a way for us to project that information because I mean I think everybody's looking at pieces of paper and there was like lots of pieces of paper being discussed and we had to keep like asking what specifically they were looking at is there a way for us as
154we go forward to display that information like we have that board in the library obviously is there something here that like a mobile board that we can use at the meetings for the for the size crowds that we get at the annual meeting there's really nothing um but it is on the website a lot of those same Graphics are up there um and we're we're going to be adding more I'm going to do the corrected um you know tax rates and we'll throw some more things up there maybe maybe do one of them as a as a slideshow to you know move some of those uh static things but I think you know if folks are are interested and I think we saw some increased interest here this year um hopefully they'll go on the
155website and and take a look at those prior to the meeting we may have them in the hall when people are waiting to come in on some smartboards and have them kind of going through a a little slideshow just to kind of give them um yeah I like that idea it would be great to make note of that because I do think the more visuals that we can share really does help give P people a better picture of things um like I said it's a lot of numbers it's a big budget um but it has a huge impact on our kids so okay thank you so next on the agenda is um action on the proposed budget warrant the whole warrant sorry it says budget here should say on the warrant it should say on
156the warrant I'm sorry it should be action on proposed 2526 warrant um and I can entertain a motion to um amend anything um I will make a motion that we pass articles one two three four five six seven as written oh and excuse me nine as well as written and that we modify article eight to instead of reading $150,000 but read $300,000 and if I get a second to that motion I would be happy to explain my reason up to up to $300,000 so that motion is um made by Jess seconded by Laura um do you want to speak to that yeah so now with the understanding of um the what we are um what the district is looking at for uh addressing the roof in at High School um I think it would be
157prudent for us to put in you know as long as the funds are there put in a little bit more so that when we get to that point we have a better um more of a of a fund balance in that in that Expendable trust the maintenance Expendable trust to uh kind of get ahead of being able to do the roof sooner so that it doesn't cost us money more in the long run so that's my reason why uh try and think about increasing that ask to up to 300,000 any questions for Jess yeah I have a concern about passing all the warrant articles as a slate um is article two article three excuse me is article three in in uh included in that slate yes we doing so I I have an issue with
158putting a motion forward to putting those to vote I will accept a friendly amendment to remove article 3 and we can discuss it afterwards if that's what you would like to do I would like that to remove article three and then you could pass the others I Will Wait Laura are you okay with that um yes but I'm concerned about articles seven and articles seven and eight in the date I 25 is the correct right date yes we're yeah yeah I was confused in that in that final moment but yeah there probably won't be any money you're right Lauren but we have to leave correct yeah correct yeah correct okay yeah so yeah thank you for making sure that was clarified because that was one of the areas that I messed up on too because
159we talked about it being 26 so verbally I said 26 what did we just say like after all these numbers go flying around sometimes so um just to reiterate um my motion is now to move articles one L one two four five 6 7 and nine as is article 8 adjusted to read three up to $300,000 and we will discuss article three after any other discussion on that all those in favor of Jessica's motion say I I I any opposed say nay any abstentions perfect okay then I would entertain a motion on article three move uh second so the motion the article for motion the motion for article three is to see if the school district will vote to raise and appropriate the sun sum of 51 m655 one51 for the support of schools the
160salary of school district officials and agents and for the payment of statutory obligations of said District the article does not include Appropriations voted on in the other Warren articles so this is just on the budget 51 m655 one51 and it's been moved by laa laaa Laura and seconded by Jess I would just like to request a roll call vote on that if I may well I we're going to discuss first but we can have a roll call vote sure motion is to approve it the motion is to approve it yep no discussion okay there hang there has been a request for a roll call vote um does Julia want to talk no I don't think so okay sorry sorry like you were so Kristen Tracy bricky yes Sally H Dickson yes Eric Hansen Julia Jones
161gu no we're voting on The are you voting yes or no on the article three to put it on the warrant no Julia says no Melissa Muzzy yes Jessica wheeler Russell yes Laura Vincent Yes Daniel York yes Paula I'm G to abstain Paul's going to obstain thank you and Peggy Jones Blan no thank you yes yeah yeah yeah he did so Kristen can you read back the um the vote please sure Tracy bricky yes oh no I didn't mean that just read back the totals I'm sorry I didn't I wasn't very clear two knows and one extension correct and how many yeses is that eight yeses so eight yes two NOS one exstension uh that uh motion passes next is public comment Laura if you come down here okay forget it thank you he'll give
162you a microphone okay thank you I don't like standing up here like this and saying what I'm going to say but I am very surprised that the school board or somebody didn't apologize to the people here tonight for the deficit last year now I am a former bookkeeper I've been a bookkeeper all my life I'm not an accountant and I don't claim to be but that deficit should never have happened number one number two I feel none of you really understand what's going on people aren CLA in fraud but we want accountability honesty and transparency and we don't have it and I'm going to I I'll explain why when the business administrator resigned she did it on December 3rd there's nothing in the minutes to indicate that and to my knowledge there's no minutes anywhere
163to indicate she resigned it will be done in February so I started asking for some information on the maintenance because that was over so I got the invoices and this is what is wrong and this is what you don't understand that track which took place the bills were paid in July and August of 24 came to over $500,000 thank you there was no and I'm not taking excuses from anybody there was no RFP and there it was no contract so if that one case right there there was no RFP and no contract how much of that goes on in our school district we need more openness and more honesty and as far as the deficit we had to drag it out of the SAU and they posted what they posted other than that I don't
164think anybody would have told us and the the board Knew by then and the board may have discussed it in nonpublic but they never put anything you know you got to be more open with us if you want us to be agreeable you got to be more open and honest and uh after 10 12 years I find it just doesn't happen and somehow things have got to change it's not all about the money I wouldn't be standing here if I thought 100% of our kids were getting the education they deserved I'd go home and just pay my tax bill but we know from all the test results every child doesn't know how to read every child doesn't know basic math and somehow the basics have got to come back into our kids' lives and as
165far as Sports Go I love sports but we are spending so much money in our school district on Sports maybe it's time the parents start paying more instead of the taxpayer we I mean with the nciaa and all that you have requirements for this and requirements for that it costs a lot of money and I don't I think we are taken away from the basic education of our kids and putting it in other places I think if we really looked we could cut the budget thank you thank you Louise Lee Lee is gonna say we has something to say not entirely sure that this is an appropriate interaction Le Lisa Laughlin from Lowden thank you you're welcome I'm curious as to the board members who voted no on the budget to move the budget forward
166and chose to abstain is there an opportunity for them to discuss their why I mean my understanding of that vote and this could be wrong my understanding of that vote is merely to put it forward to the public so is this ceremonial I mean why why say no Paula so so they don't have to say anything don't forget this is public comment I understand and there is no back and forth so thank you Lee I feel like that it would be an opportunity for you to explain to people and I apologize because I had a work event tonight that kept me from here until 7 o'clock so apparently I missed some fireworks but I feel like give Miss some fun yeah yeah it always is such a good time yep um but I feel like
167that would be worth explaining publicly to people for us to understand why it's not a unanimous front I mean if you had all this time to work on it why not say yes so thanks Lee anybody else would like to make a comment Heather it's okay uh Heather LEL bosin um Randy I was pretty sure when we met that we voted for a five-year contract and it's only a threeyear in here no there were there were two options for a threee and a six-year okay and the um they paired it down to the to go with the threeyear oh okay all right I don't think we ever actually got the result of that vote thank you thank you heather Bill Hines bosin um I I I want to respond to you know the comments about
168fraud and it was a thought about word it wasn't a word that I wanted to use sorry that I offended you and I will take it back knowing that Randy had admitted that there was a mistake there to see a million and a half bucks that was expected to be there knowing what I know we start with a million short we go through this year I see overages in a in the millions uh it it was it looked a lot like a fraud to me just for the purpose of lowering what the expect expected tax rate was going to be to the people so I'm I'll take that back that word back knowing that there was a mistake I'll leave it there thank you for your comment anyone else hi there Teresa finore from Webster
169and I just want to point out um I'm sorry I did not hear the um the fraud comments and such and um it hurts me a lot to hear how you take that personally but I like to point one thing out fraud doesn't typically happen on this level typically I should say you know typic Al it does not happen on this level but if you truly want to make sure there's no fraud nothing hidden um look at the individual levels look at the um the programs make sure there are contracts in place make sure there's checks and balances in every area and um that's the best way to fight fraud and again please don't take that personally thank you anyone else okay so we're closing public comment anyone anyone I move that we adjourn youve
170already very much