CorpusRecord 9602

School Board Work Session | January 28, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Polk County Public Schools
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Polk County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,632 words · about 98 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001for [Music] good afternoon to everyone out there so good to see you how's your uh Tuesday going thus far so excited to spend some time with everyone today at the the table here so welcome to P County school board's work session we will now Now call this work session for January 28th 2025 to order I would like to thank everyone that's here with us today um especially our staff um who I can see would be lined up in the back there indeed good to see you glad you're here uh to address any questions we have along the way uh again we're humbled to serve alongside you and the most highly educated Workforce and dedicated Workforce in the nation so I'd like to start by reading our who are we statement and this is how it

002goes we uh collectively as a board are the PO County leadership and governance team if we were to pick one phrase to Define us it would be student centered uh because when we come together to work we lean on our diverse backgrounds and our experiences to ensure that our decisions are focused on providing a highquality uh education for all students the four most important things to our governance team are one operating with Integrity two respecting our students staff families and each other three establishing this culture where stakeholders they feel valued supported and have opportunities for personal and professional growth and then lastly supporting this approach of continuous Improvement to ensure student outcomes and then collectively uh we we need to work on behalf of the children that we serve and we're going to find these

003Avenues of agreement so that we we can govern the The District in this effective manner uh there is no acceptable alternative to that so we will always collaborate in a respectful manner in order to enhance opportunities for each student and staff members we will not disparage each other um our students will Thrive because when we remain committed to supporting the whole child um and then we hope to engage and Empower our students and stakeholders to create this community of lifelong Learners and at this time I would like to turn it over over to superintendent Hyde to lead us in our work session today good morning Mr chair members of the board community staff thank you for being here this morning or this afternoon with us during our Workshop the first item before us is the

004Baldwin group uh Mr Shane Wingo will make his way to the presentation to the podium uh Mr Wingo is here um as another kind of conversation to have as it relates to employee insurance and benefits uh wanted to make sure that the board continues to hear different strategy different options as we continue to look and explore what's the best possible way for us to support our employees but also do so in a fiscally responsible Manner and there are different strategies different programs that are out there um the Baldwin group was instrumental in assisting the Rosen Foundation um with the program that they've launched in Orange County that now subsequently has been adopted in Oola County just to give you some background so Mr Wingo absolutely thank you so much um back and forth with the

005arrows right all right we got it uh Shane Wingo I'm partner right here in Lakeland with the baldr group you might be more familiar with lanir Upshaw going back to 1941 that was our firm uh came on to work with Scott Franklin who promptly left uh to uh to join Congress for us uh but we've uh We've grown uh We've partnered with Baldwin strategically to bring in some tools and some solutions we we just simply didn't have before so I've got about 15 minutes today so I'm not going to spend a lot of time about me or our firm I want to jump into some thoughts that I have that can be beneficial As you move forward maybe with another RFP or making some decisions so we're going to talk about a few things today

006first and foremost I think it's important to talk about uh direct contract pricing what direct contract pricing is and uh as superintendent Hyde mentioned it's happening all over orange and Oola County School boards are utilizing it but large employers are as well and it's where you circumvent the insurance carrier and negotiate a contract directly with a hospital or a number of Hospital hospitals uh Rosen has been doing this uh M Mr Rosen was a Visionary 20 years ago when everyone else was beginning to talk hmos he was talking direct contract pricing so uh about two years ago I started uh discussions and meeting with Pam Lively who is head of corporate relations for Orlando Health and how does this model work what's happening in Greater Orlando that can be brought to other areas that aren't

007being serviced the same way so how does direct contract pricing work simplified very simplified overview for 15 15 minutes and how does p County's uh current P County Public Schools model currently compare first first off you have your own clinics that was number one for for uh Rosen is what do we set up in a way where we can absolutely control cost because we pay our physician we pay our groups we know our overhead and from there uh we we don't have any other cost every employee that goes there is an absolute savings so that's first and foremost one of the things we're going to talk about is how to effectively and efficiently grow what you currently have in Lake Han City uh direct Hospital contract with a tiered approach so this is what the

008Rosen group is doing um and again stop me anytime I'll go through this pretty quick because there's a lot to talk about but any questions you stop me I can stay longer than 15 minutes if you choose um Orlando Health and we'll go through this in a moment orando Health has a very deeply discounted charge sheet and we're going to go through an example here in a moment and what that means is compared to Advent and other UF other hospitals in area they start at a lower price point so when direct Contracting is being negotiated and discussed first things first let's go to the group that already has the best pricing and let's negotiate from there right so uh so that's what they've done Orlando Health is the tier one option the reason they're the

009tier one option is co-pays are lower the uh max out of pocket is lower deductibles are lower it's incentivizing proactively pushing employees towards the best cost cost factor in their area as organization how do we incentivize employees to go there keep money in their pocket the the best way I say it to my groups whether it's a 50 life group or a 5,000 life group if you can incentivize your employees to make the right decisions by letting them know it's going to keep money in their pocket the claims are going to be lower under the hood and you as an organization will spend less on every claim as well so tier two is is in network slightly higher cost think physician groups uh UF is in that uh tier 2 model tier Three is out

010of network so as you go from tier one two to three everything increases your deductible gets higher or your max out pocket gets higher your co-pays get higher so it's proactive steerage of consumerism you know we'll we'll spend hours on Google finding where we're going to go eat Friday night or what's the best TV to buy but when we need to go get an MRI we spend zero time you know researching on where to go our doctor said go here so I'm GNA go there um so what you'll notice is if you look at what uh Rosen and and this model has carried on with Oola School Board as well um they made some tough decisions advents out of network their their charge sheet is significantly higher than Orlando Health and the other groups they've

011got a blanket in Orlando and Oola County that's a lot of Physicians a lot of doctors that they're telling their employees you cannot use them so they made the tough decisions to manage costs correctly so having a tiered model of directing employees is crucial and making those tough decisions um the other thing is the the the example we have at hand so there's something called a Cost Plus model you may be familiar with a term called uh reference-based pricing it's the same exact thing reference-based pricing was the term five years ago got a pretty bad wrap because it was very new and people didn't know how to maneuver it um and so this is a a rebranding if you will of that that model um so first and foremost the charge amount so what is

012the charge amount charge is a overinflated list price so when you apply a sales percentage to it it's palatable but this is a price that if you go and you are a self-pay uh individual with no insurance you're paying a fraction of this no one ever pays the charge amount but the negotiation of carriers are based on this charge amount so when we get to the next slide we're going to talk about a lot of things that were done very well as of January 1 for p County public schools with the changes you made this absolutely is one of them I think great lak's benefit maybe was involved in the negotiation uh of this along um uh W with with the process you can see moving and I've just chosen these because I like the

013the uh ascending order of the prices I just got a little snapshot here but Etna absolutely is going to charge less for every surgery and procedure compared to Florida Blue so right off the bat the move away from Florida blue and two Etna was a positive move for 2025 and and and basically the way you look at it there's four big in the market now because human has exited they're just doing personal lines and Medicare so if you're looking at Sigma and Etna you're on the low end of negotiated contracts if you're looking at United and uh blue you're on the high end of negotiated contracts for Florida it changes geographically As you move through and go beyond but if you look at Medicare an absolute fraction going back here the one thing to say

014here that's staggering the fact that the same procedure or surgery can be done and it's that much of a cost difference if you're on versus blue Signa versus United care healthc care is staggering so that's why the insurance carriers need to be removed to truly take care or grab a hold of these costs but we look at Medicare an absolute fraction of what we're looking at with any negotiated contract self-pay is the same thing I don't want to have too many things on here but if someone didn't have insurance they would fall somewhere in between Etna and Medicare so what does this model look like if you negotiate a direct contract with whomever Orlando Health Lakeland Regional Watson Clinic whoever it happens to be if you negotiate that contract you're saying I'm going to pay

015you Medicare I'm going to add a percentage on top of that and I'm going to pay you within 30 to 45 days instead of maybe six months from now when the hospital receives it because everyone says why would a hospital agree to Cost Plus 70% if it's three to $6,000 on that first highlighted item less because they need cash flow hospitals need cash flow because insurance carriers drag drag them out I used to be on the other end of that with x-ray sales and the hospitals would drag us out whenever we put equipment in there so cost plus 70 with a 45-day payment schedule is very attractive to hospitals so there's different ways to accomplish this it does not have to be a direct contract on the front end it can be pre-negotiated with a

016third party and that can be for every procedure and surgery that's that's happening so there are Partners we have that do that or you simply go and create it ahead of time so all of that middleman work isn't having to be done and there's not another piece in the wheel that's having to be paid for so what do we see here etus contract is is as you can see just a flat discount off the charge sheet blue and United can get different where every procedure or surgery or action has a different percentage discount but by moving to a Cost Plus model and 70% is what has been landed on with a lot of larger groups whether it be Rosen oal Schoolboard whomever usually somewhere between 65 and 80% of Medicare is is what you would

017see uh on an individual uh spot bys spot negotiation but every surgery procedure everything that's done is 26% under a 26% less under a Cost Plus model versus a carry negotiated contract so this is the importance of As you move forward entertaining and bringing people in that can talk about either direct contract pricing or Cost Plus negotiation proactively not retroactively after the bills have hit because then all of your employees are going to be drugg in to that to that process so that is a very quick overview meant to start a timer I'm not sure we're at with time but very quick overview before I move on to some other thoughts are there any questions about this concept and and why it's important to include and consider Miss Wyatt or is that a hold over

018from last from last meeting that's my fault I apologize Miss Miller thank you for presenting today I just have a couple of questions um because we're trying to compare um Apples to Apples in this and this isn't um this is very this isn't this is not the same as what we were presented it's a different model so can you tell me if Baldwin or your group has any Financial or contractual agreements with providers with insurance companies yeah I mean other than the commission that's renumerated I mean that's just standard you know if we you want to explain the Comm commission that's renumerated to people okay sure sure so uh if we place with Etna or Florida blue or whomever there's a percentage of Premium on a monthly basis that's paid back to the broker a

019as a fee or a commission so I'm really concerned um when with what oel is doing the fact that for financial reasons they had to cut um Advent out because Advent is is one of the leading um hospitals for some of the cancer research and that's going to make people unable to make the choice for themselves but make let someone else make their choice and I'm all about our employees able being able to choose where they where they go for care um what is the relationship with your company in Rosen care we simply have shared ideas we don't I mean we can place Rosen care Rosen care has turned into their own product at this point they're no longer just for Rosen employees and that's a national thing okay so we can place that um

020we choose not to at this time because there is a high cost Factor when they Farm out what they have created and done and it kind of it puts you right back in the ballpark of what you're dealing with with a carrier so it doesn't make sense for us to not build on on our own and to use what they're putting out as a product so for someone who doesn't live in Insurance World um are you similar to a car insurance broker that Brokers policies to multiple groups or are you specifically brokering for a single agency or I I want to hang on Mr Mingo I just want to clarify and make sure on the record we're not here to evaluate you as a potential partner right now the goal of bringing in multiple companies

021was to provide information to board members as to the various options that exist because of concerns that they've expressed to me that they haven't always been received that information right so I just want to make sure state that because some of the questions seem to be going down a path that we're evaluating this group potentially and I want to make sure that it's clear that that's not the case yeah no I'm trying there are people employees do not understand this game at all and I can tell you as a board member who worked in Insurance sitting on this committee the fact that we had Blue Cross and Blue Shield for as long as we did when you just explained how high their rates were it's concerning so we're going to have to go back and

022talk about like our processes so I want people to have a very good understanding of the different companies and so they understand what's being brought forward so I appreciate you explaining that yeah um and I appreciate you explaining real quick because you did ask about you know them Advent not being included that's a choice was made by one employer the the choice that would move forward with P County Public Schools is whatever decision you make and that's what I wanted and how you tear that out how do how do you proactively steer and make it as inclusive as possible but create those tiers where if an employee just absolutely has to go here they're bearing more of that cost and you're you're helping get them to the right cost Factor but that's all a choice

023they weren excluded we we might not choose to exclude them it all depends on the employer and I wanted to do you a favor because for employees to listen to hear exclusions then my phone blows up with don't pick someone who's going to exclude a provider right and so I wanted you to be able to explain that so thanks for explaining that that that's just you're brokering um the relationship and the contracts between the groups um and that's what I was trying to get people that's what I was trying to get on air for people to understand um and so that would be made internally but I do appreciate we've looked into this program um and I know other groups that use it so we you know talk to them has been very helpful so

024I appreciate you coming today and I hope that people are listening so they can better understand how we make the decisions for our insurance yeah my pleasure thank you there are no further questions okay uh so let's talk about just a few things after this just a quick review of your benefit guide it's available online I pulled that guide and I wanted to talk about uh just a few quick things first off the changes in between 24 and 25 phenomenal we talked about one right right there you've Incorporated proactive steerage without direct contract by partnering with embold and bold will take take a a scheduled procedure if it's not in the right place they'll reach out to the employee educate them and try to move them maybe from Lakeland Regional for an MRI to riss

025you know it's just a different cost factor and and the doctors read the same images medical tourism whether it's domestically or internationally huge huge because the cause factors in Indiana for a knee surgery might be much different than they are here in pop County and to have that done there tremendous major Wellness initiatives with diabetes management more so sweeping changes is there is there enough that's been done there I think one plan for every employee is something that needs to be discussed uh more readily I'm 50 years old I have ulcerated Colitis and $700 monthly medication I have all these things I might deal with my 25-year-old son that works over at boring is 10 foot tall and bulletproof and isn't going to use his plan all year long you know so having the same

026cost factor for those two employees it's it's got more money coming out of potentially the the school board's budget than necessary to have one plan to meet the needs for different employees um the clinic partnership dock in a box jet Dental some of these supplemental things that can be added on something like jet Dental which is a dental service that would go to the schools it's totally free it doesn't cost you one thing they just get paid by the insurance carrier but then what about the dock and abach options so before looking at expanding clinics on a brick and mortar standpoint which can be literally millions of dollars in a 5 to eight year Roi to get that money back look at some cost-efficient models like creating your own mobile care units very cost effective

027utilizing your people in the clinics to go out on site so create your own docking a box um very interesting right here in our own backyard over in Tampa Urgent Care level kiosk medical grade cameras to do everything except for Stitch and and and bandage but anything else you go to urgent care for 247 kiosk that can be placed anywhere in p County available to uh pop County Schoolboard employees dependants and you can even Outsource that and make it a revenue generator to help pay for itself if someone outside of your group utilizes it at whatever charge you say per pop so they're not having to go there and then what about dead space what do you have on current locations what do you have with other municipality providers uh what can be used to

028partner with other medical facilities where instead of expanding by Brick and Mortar since you're hanne City and Lakeland and nowhere in between currently how can you uh financially expand in a in a fiscally responsible way without new brick-and mortar Solutions and as you look forward to these other discussions um I would suggest be General uh if if if there's another RFP coming out don't don't give the don't give the answers to the quiz ahead of time right talk about that you want to be inventive you want to move forward but let those thought leaders come to the surface let those thought leaders be the one that say this maybe isn't what we end up with but we're going to explore this we're going to explain it we're going to present it we're going to make

029it as clear as possible to not just to you as a board but to the employees uh before anything were to move forward so just some thoughts I had uh on the benefit guide I'm not going to go over uh this last slide but when I hand it out has it all there it's important to look at firms as you're evaluating they're multifaceted we talked about multigenerational have a commu communication specialist that's going to take those concerns and talk to a 25y old and a 55y old in the terms that they need to have it explained to them so they feel comfortable with the benefit plan so again I'm not going to go through all this but I wanted to provide that to you so you could look at just some thoughts As you move

030forward and begin to evaluate again possible uh Partners uh once again any further questions that I can answer or help clarify before I let you move on when you're meeting and get out of your hair Miss Fields I just wanted to know is there any other School District that you're working with other than aola no I work with a lot of charter schools I work with Florida Southern right here locally for their employee benefits I've consulted with some some Charter Schools we as a firm work with a ton outside of the State of Florida but currently inside of the State of Florida no other school districts currently I have worked with the veil um and talked with them uh at length about different opportunities but not currently in Florida thank you thank you there are

031no further questions all right thanks so much everybody appreciate your time next item up for the board is the fiscal year 2023 2024 internal funds audit and I will invite Miss Jenkins and Aline to the podium sorry Mr Nunes good afternoon board members um our um external firm that audits our internal funds is car and Ingram and here is uh today is Miss Jennifer Christensen who's going to present her um audit thank you good afternoon everyone as a line mentioned my name is Jennifer Christensen I'm a partner with car Rigs and Ingram and we audit the internal accounts and so um what the internal funds are I always like to Define them for everyone these are the funds that the schools raise the students raise um the prom sales the football ticket sales the fundraisers

032the field trips and so that's the type of money that's running through the internal funds I'm going to um go through a little bit of an overview of the financial statements for the internal funds and then talk about the audit process and some of the um required Communications and then I'm going to discuss some of the school findings that we had and then some districtwide comments that we had so if you look here at the financial statement ments and um just to kind of at the time that this presentation was submitted it was in draft format but um the final financial statements have been issued and nothing changed from the draft to the final so anything you see here will agree to the final financial statements and so but if you look here you could

033see our um total assets and total liabilities normal for internal funds there aren't going to be a lot of liabilities uh just due to the nature of our year end is June 30th schools have been closed so there's not a lot activity going on in internal funds during that June period so the liabilities are normally accounts payable bills that are owed that's going to be a lower number and you can see it's pretty comparable to the year before and then you can see our total additions which is similar to revenues for the year and deductions would be similar to expenses we're at about 13.9 million of revenues and 13 million of expenses and so it is um comparable to the year before and in fact we are at the level right at that preco level

034in 2019 we were right about um the same amount the 13 to4 million of Revenue so we've kind of had a sharp decrease in activity in 2020 and then it slowly has gotten back to um to that um that stage so one thing I do like to mention with internal funds the purpose of internal funds is to raise and spend the money in the same year the idea is that the students that raise the money the money should be turned around and spend spent on that same group of students and so you can see here we did have um a little bit of excess but we you could see each year there's roughly you know the same amount is going to go out that came in for the year as far as our report we

035um had an unmodified report which means a clean audit opinion and we had two audit adjustments during the year and they were um both adjustments that were provided to us for from the district one um they both have to relate to the Career Center's um accounts receivable one was to record the accounts receivable from the current year and um and the second one was to allow for um AR from prior years that um that were deemed uncollectible and those are from um probably three four years ago um or or older we also had what we call a past adjustment a past adjustment is an adjustment that that is um small in nature so it's immaterial to the financial statements but we have to keep track of them to make sure the accumulative effect of all

036of the past adjustments are immaterial but we only had one and it was actually just the carry forward effect from the prior year of some differences in inventory counts um we do go out to a few schools at the end of the year and we count their inventory and um we had some differences at one of the schools we were at and so that was the um that was from the prior year and then this is just rolling forward the effect of that so that will go away and we won't have that adjustment um in future years as far as sensitive footnotes there really aren't a lot of footnotes that relate to internal funds but one that if um we had a concentration in Investments if we had a large percentage of our investments held

037in one investment we would have to disclose that a government um standards required that that's disclosed in the footnote but there were no such concentrations this year so um so really that would probably the most sensitive footnote but just saying that there were no concentrations so that's a um that's a good thing as far as our audit process there are certain things were required to communicate to those charge of governance which would be the school board and um one would be if we had any disagreements during the audit on accounting principles Accounting Standards how to apply them and we didn't have any such um disagreements we um would have to discuss if we had any difficulties during the audit um if we came across any fraud or illegal acts um that were material to the

038financial statements we would have to communicate that to you and um we would have to communicate if there was any if we were aware that management consulted with other accountants regarding accounting principles and standards and how to apply them and we're not aware of any such consultations that were made so I always like to kind of point out it it it takes a village to get this audit done and so I'd always like to kind of acknowledge the different groups that we work with during the audit because um because it is a lot of um we ask for a lot of information we ask for a lot of support um hundreds and hundreds of samples that we select and so all of these groups um really help to to make sure that the audit um

039runs smoothly and it definitely did this year so I just like to point that out besides auditing the financial statements the other side of the audit for internal funds relates to compliance test in and so we go and and we do compliance testing in some of these or all of these different areas that you see here for 100% of the schools and departments anyone that has an internal fund has activity in internal funds we perform compliance testing and so I just wanted to um bring up some of the different areas that we look at fundraisers um we're going to look at admission events ticket sales and so um so you can see the different the different areas that we um test so here anytime we do this compliance testing if we find one item that

040doesn't adhere with the either the Schoolboard policy the school district's handbook the um the State of Florida has um a red book that has rules for internal funds and anytime we come across something that doesn't adhere to one of those rules we give what we call a school finding a school level finding and so um this graph here is showing the average findings we had per School this year so you can can see uh as I mentioned before activity back in 2020 2021 went down drastically and so the number of the average findings per school would also go down and then it slowly has been creeping up the last couple years which which is expected this year the average was um 1.44 findings per school but um as we move on to the next few

041slides we'll see there was one finding that um we had a lot more instances of this year and if we were to back that finding out our average findings per school would be at 1.13 I think it was so it would actually be right at the level it was at last year so I I just wanted to to make sure that um that was clear so here we're looking at the um the findings per school so you could see we had about um about 72% of schools had either zero findings or one finding and that's pretty comparative to um the year before it was about 74% and um and then I kind of go down to the bottom of the table schools that had five or more findings was 8% which is the same as

042La as the year before so it has been um pretty consistent and then you can kind of see the Le hand side I just like to show um the information in different graphical U methods just to to kind of see the pie chart you could see how many um schools had no findings or one finding that it is a a significant um percentage of the total schools here um I just like to list the most common findings that we had and so I mentioned before we had one finding that increased significantly and that's going to be the first one the deficit account balances so what that means is that in one school they could have an account the fifth grade account that had a negative balance at the end of the year um doesn't mean

043in total the school isn't negative but it's just within their funds they have um they had one negative account or you know possibly more than one so we had 68 instances where there were there were negative deficit balances um at different schools and so um that's something we're going to talk about in a in a second when we get to the districtwide um recommendations that we have and so you can look down and see um fundraisers a lot of times we see findings that relate to forms not being completed properly um there there is a lot of turnover in the financial secretary position and when it comes to something like fundraiser forms not only is it the financial secretary that needs to be aware of the rules but they have to make sure it's the

044teachers that are having the fundraisers and the the club sponsors and the coaches that they're also um completing the forms correctly and turning them in so um so it's common that we see this finding throughout our school districts because it is um it is going to be a little more of a challenge because there are so many people involved um in order to to have that I did want to point out one other the third one down dispersements not approved it says zero in the prior year and that's a little misleading I wanted to to bring it up to your attention that was something we tested a little different this year so where we didn't in the prior year so I don't want it to look like it probably should be an NA in the

045prior year um but it it we did have some instances and some of that is um because of the documentation that we have we're not able to tell if a dispersement was approved so we're basically looking to see when the school buys something did the principal approve it ahead of time and in some cases in the system the dates that are that are captured are um not the order date but more the um quote date but we're unable to tell um sometimes which one it is so there are even some of these cases where they may have gotten the approval ahead of time but we're we're not able to tell because of um because of the the dates that are in the system so um so but I still felt like because it was on

046there 27 times that I needed to include it on this slide this is just again a graphical representation to look at I'm not going to go through each of these but it's more for you to look at um the orange bars would be this year and the deficit account balances kind of went off because there were 68 of them but um so it's not that one's not to scale or else if I made it to scale everything else would have been very small for you to look at but but um the rest it's just for you to kind of look down and see we did have a couple findings where there were more this year but you can also see the findings where it went down this year compared to last year so I always

047like to um show this so that you can easily see that even though there's some findings we had increases there's also findings where we had decreases and I feel like that that's important to bring up um to you so now kind of moving to the districtwide recommendations we did not have any material weaknesses in internal control so nothing to report there we did have what what we called a deficiency um and that's the deficit balances because there were there were 68 of them this year and the large increase we did give a comment to the district that we feel like there should be um some kind of process in place to um to make sure the schools are monitoring these accounts and in fact um we we had recommended they monitor it back in October

048the district had already started a process where they're informing the schools on I believe it's monthly basis on a monthly basis of um whether they have any of these deficit balances because a lot of times when we um give these reports these findings to the schools we then have an exit conference with the principal and the financial secretary and at that time they give us responses to these findings and those responses are supposed to include like H how did this happen and then what are you going to do to prevent it from happening in the future and a lot of times when we talk to the schools they'll say well um we just didn't realize it was um negative at the end of the year or we're going to have a fundraiser but the fundraiser

049is going to be in the following year to to try to get that deficit back to Z to zero so with this new um process of letting the schools know ahead of time or each month that they have deficit balances it gives them the opportunity to let the coaches the sponsors the teachers know that they're negative and they need to do some fundraising now in order to um to get those balances back to zero by the end of the year so um so a process has been put in place um since we since we did the audit and then um the other item we had was an improvement point which is so it's not considered an internal control deficiency it's just something we saw when we were testing it General controls that um that a

050disaster recovery um test should be performed annually and um our understanding is that there is a system that's in the middle of being implemented that's going to um allow for those tests to be done again on an annual basis there were a few years where they weren't done um but now there's a new system so that should um should be done in the next year I would expect when we come out next year that we would see that that testing done any questions that you have for me or about the audit or Miss Miller hi thank you once again um no this is always very good information for us and I know you're going to get into how we go back for uh the recommendations but I know and this might be for the superintendent

051because you had just explained um and we hear this from schools sometimes especially for the accounts that are internal where the secretaries or the coaches or the people that are moving money um for the small activities do we have superintendent Hy do we have um a video or something they can go back and and watch for if they have questions on how this is done because a lot of this is just human error of receipts and things I just want to make sure they have a good resource to go to Mr Nunes oh you have the answer thank you Mr Nunes so we are currently working on a schooly course okay that we hope to launch by next month um training in the past usually consisted of just a once a year annual training where

052because of turnover we had um new secretaries coming in that were being missed but we uh plan to have that course out so that it can be taken on demand and then stay there as a resource for those how to do those processes yeah thanks so much I think we've talked about this in the past on how important that would be um because our secretaries you know usually are very they stress about this part of it because they want to make sure it comes in as a clean report so I think that will help them have a resource to go back in view if they have questions thank you Mr Keys more of just a comment uh want to think say thank you to Mrs Christian for for coming and presenting to us today and

053having served on the audit and finance committee for almost six years and chairs for a couple years I'm all too familiar with the findings and what they what they provide to us but I would say I want to Echo in that and for my colleagues here is that the turnover is probably the main issue and um thank you for Mr Nunes for explaining the new training coming forth because I think that should be something that would be provided as part of an onboarding for that specific um job um I had a family member specifically who was the financial secretary at a school of ours so this is this is something that's desperately needed and I think that probably the majority of the finance are are going to be directly related to turnover and understanding the

054process so appreciate you guys for presenting today Miss Fields thank you U just wanted to reiterate about the training I know that that's something that we discuss annually and so I just want to make sure that we're ensuring that when new people come on board that they are getting what they need so that they do understand the process and the procedures yes and currently what we have also been offering is um with um coordinating with the principles we have had new secretaries that have come online or just those that feel they need more in-depth training and they do come here to the district and they'll spend a half day with our department they'll then be able to cycle through each of the different areas so they'll sit with the specialist that handles uh the PE

055cards um they'll sit with the specialist that handles uh collections of money and that way they get a more Hands-On training as well but we hope with the schooly course that that'll be available on demand then they won't have to physically um come as of to do that thank you Miss W thank you um we've talked a lot about the training for for our financial secretaries over the past several years in that turnover so I'm thrilled to see it's an on demand course now one of the things you mentioned earlier was some of our teachers that are sponsors for clubs and things like that is there training done by the financial secretary is there going to be a schoolo of G course for that level of is there any anything on the horizon you can

056tease for us today we don't uh typically the the teachers that are over the clubs would be routed through their Finance secretary at the school for that information but that is something that we can put together awesome yeah I as one board member I think it would be very helpful just to have a streamlined course for that um because I think we all as we get into our jobs start doing things our way which is similar to what the the the schooo course I'm sure says but um just to make sure that that we have it easy and that could be something to take off of some of those financial secretaries as well so just something to think about for the future as I know there's there's a lot of turnover in those those Club

057leaders as well yes thank you no further questions or comments thank you board members the next item is an information update for for for the board and and arguably for our community um even though we've already messaged this um through social media on our website and through direct correspondence with all of our existing volunteers um I have also been in the process these last few days of Hosting teams meetings for our principles assistant principles and others including our charter schools to provide an update I should begin by thanking uh quite quite frankly I should begin by thanking representative Kennedy uh representative Kennedy reached out to me based off some of what we had discussed here at the school board about all of our volunteers requiring a level two based off our interpretation of the statute

058which I I continue to feel as accurate um represented Kennedy behind the scenes worked very quickly with the Department depart and more importantly with the legislative staff to see where they aired in the bill development um and so there was some acknowledgement that while well- intended it fell short and created some issues for many of us so we got um some updates from legislative staff I want to say thank you to them as well um who worked to assist with us assist us with revising our policies and procedures board members you received an update from me I I'll just Briefly summarize them here um as to what we will do moving forward with volunteers there are actually three classifications for individuals coming onto our campus first is a visitor visitor just simply goes through the

059Raptor system scan their driver's license um once you've been in the system at a school you're in there for the entirety of the year until the data rolls over the next year um or you may have to scan again in the subsequent year just to make sure that we're getting accurate information as to who you are and if you have any criminal background history um visitors are there parent teacher meetings they're there for performances they're there for other activities that do not require them to supervise students in any regard okay they're there with their child they're there as a family um and their short-lived visits level one volunteers will continue the fee for a level one volunteer based off the board's previous and current decision to continue to supplement the cost of level one volunteers

060will remain at $25 the biggest distinction between that and a level two just to make it absolutely clear the distinction between what defines a someone to be classified and and interviewed or or excuse me reviewed and approved as a level one volunteer or level two volunteer is whether or not they will ever be alone with a student that's it it's the most it's the easiest thing to to to basically reflect on so if you have someone that's coming into your campus and they work with one of our many agencies that we partner with every meeting we start with at least two partners um that share how they're partnering and working with po County Public Schools and our students so let's say that they come to to school and they say well I'm going to read

061with a student and typically they would take that student out the hallway they must have a level two background check because they are no longer in the direct line of sight of a p County Public School employee however as I shared with principes and administrators these last few days the easiest solution to that is have the volunteer go to the back of the classroom and read with the student or find another site on your campus Media Center where mentoring and those types of things can take place because they're in the direct line of site of a p County Public School employee um and so it does matter what they're doing and with whom there are some complications that people need to understand including some of our parents um so for example chaperoning field trips if

062a school goes to an end of the year shop field trip and Mr Hyde's class has four parent volunteers and we divide my class up into groups of five or six and the parents we say okay we'll meet at 11:00 for lunch right here and then be back at the same spot to load on the buses at 4:00 those parents must have a level two background check because they are not going to continuously be under the line of sight of myself or any other Public School employee so there are some distinctions schools have also been told you have flexibility with some of your internal funds you have Sac PTSA ptso you have booster clubs you have other mechanisms where you can choose to offset some of the cost for those level two background checks and

063given the specificity in which those level twos are required we're not talking about having to do the entirety of your parent population um it is $97 we've been saying hundred because it's $67 for Field Print to do the state and federal background check and then the state mandates an additional $30 Fe fee that will cover five years of data security in the new um Clearing House thank you that is that is not yet active we keep getting told it'll activate to activate right now March is the deadline we are not waiting for them we're encouraging schools to go ahead and get out ahead of this we already do level two background checks for non-employees for athletics so we have a mechanism in HR to track and monitor those individuals Miss Miss Crowley is working with

064HR to make sure we have the similar process in place for any remaining level two background checks that have to be documented so that when we get to end of the year activities spring break for high schools is a big trip period of time where many of our schools will travel all over the US to various competitions and or celebrations um many of our teams will go someplace um warmer right kind of I joke um but they'll go someplace for swim competitions or Swim training or wrestling or those types of things well you're going to have chaperons and you're going to have overnight chaperons which means they must have a level two background check there are exemptions as we've discussed previously law enforcement those in medical industry all po County Public Schools who have already

065had employees who've already had a level two background check so if you're a parent and you work for pole County Public Schools you do not have to pay to get a level two background check but they'll have to inform us so that we can make sure the system reflects that they are already approved so there's some procedural steps that we're still ironing out but I wanted to go ahead and give the board some assurances and reassurances that this issue has largely been addressed what I will bring to you at the first meeting in February I'm working with Federal programs I intentionally delayed this conversation today given some of the things that took place last night with the decision to freeze some federal funds we do not know at this time if those if that freeze

066order has any impact on federal funds that support Public Schools we're waiting for clarification actually I was drafting a memo to the board a few moments ago to make sure I gave you the most recent updated information so we can use some of those title dollars to offset the costs for level two background checks however at this time I'm not willing to to bring that or ask you to commit those funds until we realize what potential implications of freeze on federal dollar may have on our overall budget and our and our our work moving forward so I'll open up to any questions that you may have at this time Mr sharess um I just want to make sure that I heard you clearly um so the level two background checks right um obviously with that

067they're no longer it's because it's because they're they're not direct supervision right are we so we are not waiting until March 1st to get those level twos done is we have a mechanism in the district so that's the one thing I'm hearing from some Community groups is we want to go ahead and get these level twos done so who would they contact to get that started Janette Crowley okay he was our volunteer coordinator um it's one of many titles that she carries um and she came and we spoke the other day because I had announced on one of the teams meetings that they should go ahead and start the process and she said well we don't have the Clearing House I could care less about the Clearing House at this point quite frankly I need

068to get people level to background checked because you all aren't going to care about the clearing house either if we get to the end of the year and you're hearing from parents and community members saying these trips are all being canceled because now we don't have enough chapons and that's ridiculous and we already have a mechanism internally where Dan Talbot's group has been working with non-employed coaches to get that background check so they can work with our students so we already have a system it's just we have to tweak it to make sure it's flagging at the right way for janette's ability to track and monitor the beauty of the clearing house and I'm not diminishing it I just wish it was already open like they promised the beauty of the Clearing House is it'll

069it'll maintain that data for 5 years and once you're in it if you move from pole County to Hillsboro County or any place else that level two background check travels with you so you won't have to do it again so there is some justification there and it will allow us to go ahead and clear many individuals who are in law enforcement EMTs fire rescue because they receive the similar background check in many instances thank you sir you're very welcome sir Dr Allen thank you superintendent uh I mean I think most of my questions were answered um you know definitely around the shapping you know we are approving some field trips tonight and you know I've got parent concerns that you know maybe they've um already paid for their trip and they're concerned that you know

070would they get reimbursed if they can't get their you know level two uh done in a timely fashion and so forth so I don't know you know what what that looks like as far as in the pipeline of getting the level two as far as from a timeliness standpoint relax of a better phrase I'd say get her done I don't I I really don't have a timeline for what it's going to take because and we spoke about this when we first brought concerns about getting everybody level two background checked to begin with imagine that many volunteers hitting the system simultaneously and I don't know what potential ramifications that may have which is why we're encouraging people to start the process now and that way it's they're less likely to be in inundated with applications to

071to review and to process and to load um so that process um please contact Miss Crowley she'll be able to assist and give them additional guidance get her done just get her done thank you Miss Wyatt that's as country as I'm going to get so you've been here too long apparently this is not how you came to us um does the level to transfer into the clearing house so if I go and get my background check today it will be recognized in the clearing house and just be like the 5 years would start yes ma'am as soon as it's approved or the last thing I think we need to settle and I I'll wait for Miss Crowley Mr Warren and Mr Davis to bring me a final recommendation procedurally how it's going to take place

072so we can communicate that effectively the the last remaining question I have and I'll just go ahead and state to here is in my opinion we should only charge the 67 and then charge the 30 to then roll them into the clearing house but the 30 may be depending on what happens again with federal funds if the board approves some of that funding to be set aside to offset the cost of volunte as you've done for level ones then maybe we're assuming that $30 cost on our end and we don't have to impact the volunteer again so I think there's some still some things to work out but yes ma'am it will migrate over to the clearing house we will ensure that that takes place okay and then my I sorry I have three questions

073my second question is for the cost of it is that something that needs to come before the board because I know usually our user fees we have to approve for anything that's an interesting question I may have to speak to Mr Murphy offline about that I I and if so is approve you would definitely approve the additional dollars to you be used to offset I don't know if that would fall under fees that the board would have to approve because it's condition of state state statute okay there's just several things that are a requirement of State Statute that we still have to approve even though it doesn't really I'll get back to the board I'll I'll send out a response thank you um I just want if that is something that we need to approve

074we may need to have a special board meeting to do that sooner than ma'am February 28th um then my third question is for so one of the questions I got early this morning was if like concession stands for example if there is a parent that is volunteering that is also an employee for us so I have a high schooler that's in band I'm a volunteer for the band but I work at the elementary school would they count as an employee in in line of sight so does like if they are the level two background check because they're our employee you don't have to answer this today you can do some research if they are our employee that has a level two background check does there have to be does everybody else there have to be

075level two background checked I'm going to give you an answer and then hope that I'm wrong I'll do some research my my initial instinct is to say no because they're not serving their official capacity as an employee and and here's why I would never want to subject an employee who's doing something on behalf of their child in another organization to be subject to potential liability in any in any manner um so that's that's a little complicated answer but let me do a little bit of research and I'll speak with Mr Murphy and others and make sure that we give you the right response I just think because we have so many parents that have students in the system that's probably something we need to have clearly outlined as to the question would be within the

076concession stand is the club sponsor there which then would cover everyone else but they the benefit for that employee was they would not have to have the level two cuz they've already been through that thank you yes ma'am no further questions on that thank you the next one uh board members at the last board meeting or Workshop excuse me I provided you information about the PO Sienna Area High School options at that time I made an initial recommendation the board will revisit that this evening um since that time I've received a few questions pertaining specifically to that project some as as recently as today I did provide the board with an email summary response to as many questions as I've received since the last board meeting on various topics um and so I wanted to

077again provide you and I I think I clarified at the last meeting that I would add it to the workshop today to see if there's any additional questions you'd like to address before this comes before you this evening not to mean that you can't have further discussion tonight but it's easier for us to have and for me and staff to address any further questions you may have um on the project and or on my recommendation before we do that just a reminder this is a recommendation from my office based on information we've we've received and the process that we followed the board has two options they can either accept the recommendation later this evening or they can reject the recommendation and ask us to go back out for a traditional process rather than a P3

078proposal um so that's just background information for the board and for anyone else who's interested so I'll open it up to see if there's any questions comments or concerns um Dr Allen all right I guess I'll be the first one or maybe the only one just to get some thoughts out there um you know this been a long journey an extremely long journey for us uh and I'm I'm going to just say I'm with you uh on this item superintendent and the work that's been done um however I'm I'm not 100% I I still have some hesitancy and I just want to get those out and that's the goal of my thoughts here at this point uh so for for me you know the redeeming factor for me right now is that ra construction is

079a part of the process um I've Got Confidence in their brand there's a sense of credibility there so that uh is probably the one redeeming Factor on this but other variables around this I just need to lay them out there and I think you've addressed a lot of my concerns thus far I appreciate Miss Matthews working with me on this as well and some of the questions that I and concerns that I've had so um I just want to get in on the record right why you know why did we not terminate the previous contract with shingle Schultz uh to provide architectural renderings for the point Siana High School I mean that was my first question I think you've addressed it um that Services agreement it was basically awarded um May 9th of 2023 that

080was previous to to us issuing the ITN and in my mind it created like this conflict of interest although it's not there um but in my mind it's there because you know obviously our lack of communication through this process has definitely been limited um so I can create narratives that may not be accurate um so I just want to put it out there but I can I find it interesting that you know the best and final offer between the two entities um at that point was approximately the value of the contract which was sitting at about 5.8 million now it's a false narrative in my mind because I think Miss Matthews uh you know dug into this to make sure that we did did not pay anything out on that previous contract so it's a

081moot point um so I I appreciate that uh if there was a payment under that contract that to me would have been a big concern so and apparently we did not so I would have and I still would feel more confident that we had terminated that previous contract with shingle Schultz before moving forward and then secondly um you know I call into the question or call into a question the validity of my vote and I was going back just even a few minutes ago to that August 24th uh meeting of 2021 and I wanted to know okay what did I cast my vote on right so I cast my vote on you know the acquisition of that property is what I cast my vote on so I mean I was a fairly new board member

082I know you know superintendent you were maybe here a month at that point but we as a body we voted to purchase the same two Parcels um that are now existing in the Fortress proposal the vote was 5 to2 um what really bugs me more so about it yes okay we vote it we didn't purchase apparently but we voted the purchase of property at 49,000 per acre with the wetlands being purchased for 10,000 acre now the two board members that voted against it at that time because they thought the property was too wet um so my wishes are that we would have been at least informed that we turn terminated that and did not purchase that land that was never communicated to us if that did you know occur I would like to know when

083we did that um because obviously we did have to communicate we had a timeliness on the escrow I think um Boswell Dunlap was handling that at that point as well so now um You know here we are and that property is being spent at 160,000 per acre with no Wetland discount that's uh that's a problem to me especially when we're here uh to bring the sense of accountability um to our financial conditions so now the other thing I was asking is does fortress have ownership of that property and I don't think um I've gotten a clear answer on that one yet um so I mean I think continuity is something that we've continued to talk about as as a board here as it relates to succession I do know that there was a transition that

084took place with um our assistant superintendent at that time uh but we have to be more aggressive and when these transitions happen that there's a sense of continuity in our decision-making um so and then lastly I do think that the 17-month solicitation process it is unusual um I mean do I still have questions about the terms for this pro project yes so I mean hesitantly I may be supporting this tonight um I'm still pondering and but I just definitely wanted to get out there um but I will not be supporting the extension of the portable lease on the contract at Han City High School when that comes back to us so my hopes are that the timeline um for the construction process would move forward so that's all I have and I I mean know

085I know it's long I've just been distilling on a lot of these thoughts uh for quite some time now but I just want to get those out there on the record thank you superintendent you're welcome I I'll provide a couple points of clarification um you mentioned shingle Schulz in their contract why wasn't terminated I did address that publicly at the last meeting and class and clarified that because shingle Schulz was contracted to provide us a prototype for a high school and there are there are multiple examples in P County where a prototype High School model has been used because you save costs over time replicating that design um since they did not do any work again no conflict of interest they never build this for any that they've not turned in a prototype we still

086require a prototype moving forward so as I shared at the last meeting happy to spend some time with Mr Murphy review the terms and conditions of that contract to determine whether or not at this point we want to sever that contract and move forward in a different capacity um as it relates to the property I tried to get you a response a timely response today so they're under contract for that property um previously and and you mentioned the 17-month delay so I have to bring this up some of the delays were brought about because of a lack of transparency um and I'll leave it at that that we felt in order for us to truly do our due diligence as information was being presented to us about certain things that could impact our ultimate decision

087or the board's ultimate decision and my ultimate recommendation to the board for procurement we had to do our due diligence which meant that we had to get some assurances from everyone involved that there were no legal potential restrictions John I'm relying Mr Murphy I'm relying on you to interject if I cross any lines here okay um so that led to a delay and I so I think that's the important part here which is each time this being brand new there was no intentionality behind delays but there was a lot of uncertainty there were times where we had to go back to Tallahassee and ask questions there were times where we had to go to council and ask questions there were times where we ultimately brought in external Council based off their experience and expertise in

088this area and we've learned a lot of lessons um if we never do another P3 again I understand that if we do a thousand of them I understand understand that too there are some benefits on both sides but they do have a contract I do not believe they they have purchased the land so I believe that ultimately they're going to wait to see what the board decides to do um before they do that I don't know that for certain they very well could have possession of that property and it's entirety I I don't know I'm speculating but all I could find out this morning was that yes they were indeed under contract for that property um and I I will continue to do the research as to why we did not execute the board's decision

089to purchase that property my recollection at the time was the amount of wetland and if I recall correctly I believe I even said out loud at the meeting that while the property in and of itself wasn't ideal because of some of the marsh land that we were paying for You're Building you're paying for acreage you can't use I believe I'm on the record then of saying but this creates an opportunity for us to partner with a university to create an Environmental Studies program or Academy on that campus partnering with UF or partnering with another one that that specialized in those so there are some opportunities there um at the time so again I wish I could give you a straight answer but a a combination of factors staff turnover those things I've gone back myself

090when you brought this to my attention tried to watch the board meetings looked at meeting minutes I'm searching through emails I'm probably to have to submit an email request myself um to see if any other correspondence took place during um Mr fix's predecessor's transition as to why we didn't execute that contract at the time so I apolog I don't have that information for you now but you are correct I think I was on the job probably four weeks maybe five I give you five thank you super yes sir Miss Miller thank you and um we've had a lot of conversation about this piece um and I think this goes back to the processes that we follow or the or how they've changed when when we have staff that change so you know I really um

091urge the board to find a date where we can have a retreat and discuss expectations of what the process should look like so if we have questions we can decide to work with the superintendent so he knows ahead of time um what we expect as a board we are in desperate need of a high school we were in desperate need of a high school in 2021 and that's only gotten worse um but I do think we need to talk about what that process looks like across the board and we might all have different expectations or it might be the same um I was interested in the piece of not owning the property only because in real estate that could change quickly what would happen if we go under contract and something you know um something

092happens with the ownership so we've talked about that we've talked about the wetlands and I can tell you um there and I told this to him which he didn't know because he hasn't been here long enough but we had Wetlands at Auburn Dale High School that were used as a learning space um it was abandoned years ago so if we plan to do that I want to make sure there's a long-term plan for that um because I thought it was very valuable the auale community thought it was very valuable um so that's something needs to be talked about while we this High School moves forward but right now I'm talking to schools in that area and the people that want to come into that area I need my high school up and and functioning soon

093so again I I hope we can find a date as a board so we can talk about the process of how some of these things work and um let our expectations be known on how it should roll out but I will be supporting this this evening thank you you're welcome um Mr Murphy it may be uh I may need to clarify too that the recommendation uh some of the concerns like including the property and some other factors um what the board would approve tonight with a vote is essentially authorizing us to move forward with negotiations and the rest of our due diligence so if we find at any time that that property is not conducive to the design of what we require then that changes some things as well so um and Mr Murphy am

094I'm not saying it correctly please no no you are um want need to push a button okay thank you board chair um I uh I was going to say uh in in conjunction with what you've just mentioned that the action tonight is simply to allow us to move forward with then Contracting with this entity and it could be either an interim agreement or a comprehensive agreement but we need to then negotiate all the all the aspects of whatever contractual relationship we ultimately get into so it's going to take more time you know it's not going to happen immediately part of that evaluation will be looking at the normal dueil things that we look at when we acquire real estate looking at you know um the kind of statuto requirements that we have when we acquire

095land um looking at the construction timelines um what method of delivery is this going to be constructed is it a semar is it a you know there there are a number of different things that will have to go into go into play to negotiate to bring something back to the board that's my understanding um I I don't know if the attorney representing fortresses in the audience or not today but I would expect that that would be fortress's expectation as well okay Mr sharpless so throughout this whole process I I mentioned two of my big concerns were price and location right I'm saying that numerous times um and I mean looking at the hydrological study on this and going through all my notes my my concern for the piece of property is that it's wet and

096as someone who's driven I've out to the FFA Training Center many times uh down fir Tower Road that's a concern of mine um as long as we can ecologically make it work um that would be my biggest my the biggest hurdle for me um and so I don't know if we can have a discussion on that right now or if the Fortress is able to talk about that do you have a would you be able to respond to that as far as the property are we able to build on that property without concern for the Wetland Marshland portion of it yeah I certainly [Laughter] did uh thank you uh Mr superintendent yes in uh in looking at what Fortress has given us in terms of a layout of the of the Prototype it appears that

097it can fit on there skirting the wetlands the other thing that they're able to do if I if I remember correctly is in working with the the property owner they're able to um work in there's a larger there's a larger track all together and they're able to work with a property owner to shift and everything around so that the school is fitting on more of the Upland areas versus the Wetland area so they're able to work around that from what we've seen in their preliminary design so far now of course as we as they give us more detail design we'll be able to look a little bit further and I was just asking Mr pittz and he was talking about how we'll have some time to to be able to work with them and and

098work out those issues and so will we need to mitigate at all well let's see in the in the P3 assuming that this is the land that actually ch right and the so this is kind of different for us because my answer if we were going through our typical um process that we go through I would say oh we we'll have to go through that but remember this is kind of in the P3 we're we're buying this whole enchilada so the the the group that we're working with is supposed to work all that out uh as as part of this process as part of our buying it they're supposed to guarantee us all that so it's not on us it's on them really it is on them that that is correct and that's one of

099the beauties of the P3 is it is putting a lot on them and taking a a lot off of us but there'll need to be a contract that reflects that shift of you know there will need to be an agreement in place between the school board of Pop County Florida and the entity that is going to be responsible to deliver this public asset so that's going to have to be a comprehensive agreement whatever you want to call it I would understand that that isn't that the expectation of Staff as well that there will be some form of comprehensive agreement that ultimately is the conclusion of this P3 process that delineates the rights duties responsibilities and obligations of the parties as it relates to this project yes but my I guess my what my point was

100instead of us having a uh construction management firm over here instead of us having an architectural firm over here instead of us having a civil engineer we're dealing with here we're going through a P3 process and so we have to work out this this comprehensive agreement that you're talking about where all of those details are all encapsulated in there and that's where in doing that any of the for lack of better words negotiation that you're doing has all got to be encapsulated in that agreement correct and so that's a very new thing for us we've not ever done one of those that I'm aware of that's my question was about the the wetlands area and how we were going to be able to build on that or if Fortress was going to be able to

101build on that so Mr Keys I think for me um coming on this the backside but following it as closely as I could um before is my my first one would be I'm pleased to see that this is an all-encompassing and we have a contractual price not to exceed any cost um myself being in that industry I know that cost overruns happen so I'm happy about that the second thing I'm concerned about though is we had mentioned and I'm pretty sure I understand um on the architecture side of it the design the need for a designed for something that we can replicate I'm concerned if that's design for this one is going to carry over into other schools so are we paying for a contract price that's included in that and then now we can't

102use that again and now we have to go back out again and pay another consulting fee to get a um a reusable design no you currently have an architect under contract to design a prototypical high school for us could we reach some agreement that you like this design and that becomes your prototype I'm sure but then that would require an amendment because there's work that's already been done I mean there's I would encourage us not to go that route um my only concern was paying for it twice that's correct so if we have a prototype that we are looking to get and but that prototype ends up being what we're building then in my mind we shouldn't pay for that prototype twice you know typically and and that's just what I'm making sure of because

103I understand that that we we didn't go through with that that prototype design but now that design cost is included in this project so I want to be able to utilize that if possible but if I recall correctly even outside of of a prototypical like entering contract like we have to design a specific prototype if I recall correctly Mr Fix I don't know if P the Peggy is not here but school districts can always purchase plans as well so rather than moving forward with a whole new design scheme again if the board were to say we like this design we'd like to see it replicated make it easier we would ask for a purchase price for those plans and and move forward that way that's one option there are lots of options available we will

104I will assure you we are not paying twice okay for the same for the same work Miss Fields so this is a whole new process for us oh yes ma'am and because of that I think that it has really become a little bit challenging making sure that we all on the same page and understanding the process and making sure that everything has has been vetted my understanding and superintendent high you can correct me if I'm I'm wrong one of the reasons why you slowed down the process was to make sure that every I was doted and every te was cross if my memory serves me correctly um I um I agree with Dr Allen I think the U the comfort and Grace for me is that I know R of construction and I know that

105they do good work and I know that they're honest people I've looked at all of the information I looked at the uh evaluation of the committee and it to me is pretty clear uh the best bang for the buck with the quality work is what is being recommended by superintendent H and his team so um I think it's been a very long and tedious process and I really think that we need to move forward uh and make a decision tonight uh and then do what we think is going to be best for our students and for our families and I will be supporting the recommendation from superintendent height and his team Mr Niti I concur with everybody up here what's been said um Council uh you said we needed a comprehensive uh agreement so by

106voting yes tonight and we keep the ball rolling is that the second step to come up with a comprehensive agreement or do we need to do that first no you you would approve the superintendent's recommendation which is what's being presented tonight right and then that would the superintendent and and and our team would work to get an agreement together a comprehensive agreement that would then be presented back to the board for approval okay and then if we find there's a bump in the road then we it's conceivable okay okay thank you you're welcome sir seeing no further questions we'll move on to the next topic board members um this is going to be a little bit of a redo on information you've received previously but the there are two missing pieces um that I could

107not provide you at the time and that was graduation rate which just recently got released um that was all forwarded to you um and then second to that is dropout rate which just populated last night or today so I still have to update that slide for you um but the academic summary these were the goals um that we established um three years ago we have one more year because part of the problem when we first established our strategic plan as you recall was delays in State Testing because we were exiting covid and then there were changes to the Statewide assessment and we the board much to your credit quite frankly um requested that let's wait till we have Baseline data and then we set our goals we met after the B line year we established

108our goals and then we started working through them um I very very happy to show you the areas highlighted in green are the areas where we exceeded or met our established goal for that specific area what you'll notice here differently is that we've broken out each one of the core areas in particular by demographic subgroup right because you've heard me say before and I'll continue to say it the district doesn't benefit from having a grade of an A or a B if a large percentage of a certain demographic subgroup is not making adequate performance or or making adequate Improvement year-over-year right we cannot create a gap between our students simply because of their color disability or their English language proficiency what I'm proud about here is that nine out of 10 cells improved from the

109Baseline year with the one exception in 23 24 for reading being our students with exceptionalities and so obviously we need to spend more time there I'm very proud of the fact that our data this year is tracking ahead of where we were last year in in multiple areas I've been providing that data to you you'll get another update as to our progress monitoring Period 2 assessments um now that those have been completed but there are some areas in here that I think you would agree show very significant improvements from a prior year board members at the end of this year will receive additional data set our summer strategic planning meeting um I know Mr sharpless Dr Allen I I think every one of you has actually said this did we set our goals adequately are

110they rigorous enough are they challenging enough or are we soft balling it to make sure and we didn't know at the time because we have Baseline data so now you have one year so at the end of this year when we're talking about this strategic plan potentially sunsetting and moving in a New Direction you'll have two years of consistent data so when we establish that next series of goals and expectations you'll have a data set that says maybe it should be 3% per year rather than 2% maybe it should be 4% per year rather than 2% um but you'll have that information for you okay moving forward um for our students this was our reading data excuse me why is this not oh yours is moving line is not moving because I'm looking at the

111wrong thing so in our mathematics area again we saw improvements um in 1 2 3 four five six seven of our 10 cells um we saw some minor improvements with our Asian students we saw the only uh area I believe we saw a decline in was with our native uh Hawaiian Pacific Islander students please keep in mind that is an incredibly small subset of students within our within our population um so the numer and denominator are very very small so we get a see there on math in science 10 out of 10 that's 100% that's pretty darn good Miss Miller should be thrilled we're making gains here miss Miller in science in science also in social sciences sorry um so in social sciences we did make gains um we made it in nine of the

11210 cells I apologize we're missing a highlight there on the 2324 data where we improved from the 2223 Baseline Year from 59 or arguably 6 % to 66% Proficiency in social sciences in the next area for acceleration um one data set the College of career acceleration data will not be available till March I apologize um that's not my delay uh that's typically when the state releases that but I am proud to show that Middle School acceleration improved three percentage points from the prior year going from 67 to 70% again our overall goal is to make sure we match or exceed the state average in each one of these respected areas respective areas advanced placement AP passing rate we saw a 5% jump from the prior year at 48.9% um keep that keep this in mind

113um because what you see in the next group again I I'm a huge believer in looking at our demographic subgroups and it's very apparent that we did not do as well with many of our demographic subgroups as we would like to have seen however the number of participants went up in many cells from the prior year um not not just in AP but in Cambridge and also in other areas and so we're starting to see some students fluctuating between programs IB Cambridge Ace and AP um what you will have board members after the meeting today I have it I just didn't send it to you ahead of time you'll have the Excel spreadsheet that you previously requested that breaks out each one of these by their respective school um because especially when we get to

114um to one of our data sets tenor Rock's inclusion this year in that data set significantly impacted the overall average so again you'll be able to drill down and look at individual school performance in each one of those respective areas okay our IB passing rate we did see overall Improvement that very top row is an overall District average we improved from 74.2% to 83.3% with approximately 200 additional students participating in IB but again demographic subgroups we're not seeing um significant Improvement in their participation rates now when you look at the passing rates we met or exceeded all of our goals so for the students that participated that's fantastic but participation rates are also a concern are we seeing the number of kids getting access to these programs um increasing year-over-year are we preparing students for

115academically rigorous coursework Dr Mr sharpless you're giving me that inquisitive look um I see I have speakers let me pause here and Miss Miller and I'll come back to you Mr sharpless yeah thank you I just want to know when we meet to go over this data is there a strategic plan or a plan when we because students with disabilities dropping significantly even from the base year is concerning and I know we've changed support materials especially in Reading science is sometimes reading so it's it's interesting to see science go up um with and reading not but when you present to us are we going to have an action plan for those any of these you know that have seen significant decrease decreases so for the this year you will in subsequent Years it'll the action

116plan will be directly related to the goals that the board establishes since we're still in the me in the middle towards the tail end of the existing strategic plan yes ma'am you my recommendations will be the changes that we've implemented to help address that deficiency but thank you for pointing out science is not the only reading test science social studies math are all comprehension tests first and so that's important to note that that how do you see a decline in ela but you don't see a subsequent decline in math science and social studies or commensurate decline in those same areas so it is interesting and we'll make sure we dive into the data set because Beyond this we start looking at grade level performance um because some grade levels will perform better than others um

117and it's just the way the the cut scores and other things play out at certain grade levels third to fourth grade being a good example and the last thing with students with disabilities it's such a spectrum that the support materials that match that might look different and some you know and how that they test out looks different so it is very difficult to capture these other um subcategories are a little bit in my opinion um not as complicated so I'll be interested in seeing what our action plan is because it is a complicated um set to try to to try to hone in on what exactly is the need thank you you're welcome industry certifications very proud that continue to show a significant increase in the number of Industry certifications that are being awarded even

118though the the overall percentage declined we increased the number by close to 3,000 additional students from the prior year that is truly commendable um when you look at that so you're going to have a little bit of flux there in the numerator and denominator obviously we want to see a higher passing rate but I am pleased to see participation rates increasing significantly and remember those are two grading areas for our high schools and our middle schools at acceleration points and so it's important for us to give students those opportunities to be successful there again when you look down participation rates don't necessarily show a huge change in their percentages based off demographic subgroup information but our passing rates did improve um even in the cells that are that are not highlighted for example the passing

119rates for males did improve by almost a full percentage point but again the goal was two so it doesn't get highlighted but we did see improvement from year over-ear dual enrollment we saw a jump from 74.2% with just over almost 1100 students to 80 3.5% at almost well 1,65 I won round that up to 13 that's that's cheating but we did see Improvement in overall participation we also saw a pretty a fairly significant Improvement in in passing rates so that's what I mean I think we're seeing students fluctuate between programs I know many of you who have Cambridge schools will see that and hence the reason several of you have asked me for the Cambridge data to be drilled down by based off of your individual schools Cambridge is probably the one area where we're

120not seeing academic Improvement I am concerned about our Cambridge ice programs Ace programs excuse me but I I definitely want to make sure that we drill down school specific this is the area where I was explaining that one of our schools new to the program seeing expansion in their participation we did see a pretty significant impact in the overall average so again that's why you'll have the breakout data today I actually have it I can send it to you during the break between the workshop and our board meeting great news graduation rate nine out of excuse me 10 out of 10 I missed the Highlight there um look no I didn't U we had nine out of 10 of our subgroups including the overall average improved um for the by the overall goal um you

121will note that in every one of those um with the exception of students with disabilities even though we saw Improvement there um we saw five percentage Point Improvement there um there are some areas for example Asian students where we did not see that significant Improvement but look at their overall graduation rate as it sits it's very difficult to move graduation rate once you get above 92 93% um but I am very proud to see so many of our students I'm very proud of our our our young ladies um when you look at gender performance 91 almost a 92% graduation rate amongst our young ladies that is absolutely fabulous um multiracial students jumped from 84 to 89 um about 5.5% jump um so we did see great improvements white students 85.6 to 92.4 Hispanic students 80%

122to 89% a 9 percentage Point jump in their graduation rate our African-American black students jumped um 5% 5.3% or a 5% total When you subtract the average from the prior year and then we saw a good improvement in our students um with exceptionalities our our low E low economics socio economic students saw an improvement so very proud again students with disabilities has been a conversation um quite honestly Miss Miller and I have had rather frequently um we look at not only our own data but we look at State calculated data because the state will calculate five-year graduation rates and those types of things for students who are allowed to persist in our our education system and it's important it's a it's a good point that she raises and others rais to and this is the

123reason why we drill down into demographic data you know you can hide student populations within an average and that's not our interest we want to make sure that we're drawing attention to the areas where we're deficient and we can seek to address those next one uh dropout rate that's the one it just populated so I will update the slide and get it to the board um staff Recruitment and Retention so we saw a decline in new teacher retention rate we went from 77% to 69 but we did see an overall 2% improvement from the prior year for Teacher veteran teacher retention rate and I think we've shared this number before roughly 51 to 53% of our current teaching Force have less than three years of experience three or four years of experience I'll I'll get

124Mr Warren to confirm that during the break um but it's a rather large segment of our population and I know if I recall correctly um several of you at our Retreat made it very clear that you wanted to see these numbers move I was proud to see the veteran numbers improve by two percentage points I was very disappointed to see the decline in new teacher um but in talking to our principles and others um it is a pattern that we see where people come in it's not what they really thought it was going to be and they transition um but we we are working hard with our team Mr row and others work very very hard to recruit retain Mentor support our teachers they host multiple fairs throughout the year um to make sure that

125they feel that level of support and our our principles are doing a great job mentoring and coaching as well so I'll pause there I see Miss Miller I just I just had this is interesting data and I think once again proves that culture and retention is it goes hand inand when you build culture if the new money to teachers brought them in you know and they didn't stay for whatever reason we don't you know it could be it could differ a lot of ways I think we definitely need to go back to building those cultures in culture in school where people feel validated and they want to show up every day and it's secondary to that um the pay because if our veteran teachers felt that compression and stayed I can bet you we talked

126to some of them and it's about what they felt with the leader they had in their school or at the district level so I think that's something um that we could talk about and even when we have that retreat with you you know what we're doing to not only um bring them in but to keep them and I do think Mr R is doing a phenomenal job I found that a lot of people don't know about her Department yet and so um highlighting what they're doing and showing the success I think is going to be something that'll help us retain even more thank you you Mr sharpless a couple things first um when I'm reading this on the staff Recruitment and Retention it says all teacher rate which means that would include the new teachers

127as well or no am I reading that wrong no that's the veteran teacher rate just veteran okay yes all right um and so that actually is interesting to me that the uh veteran teachers are increasing the retention rate especially because the narrative out there is that our teachers are leaving in droves but it seems like it's the new teachers that are not the veteran teachers um so that's interesting to me um but my other question is uh on the industry certifications so uh I agree increasing by almost 3,000 IND certifications is a big deal um something that should be celebrated um the decrease of percentage uh or the percentage of passing rate that means to me that we're obviously testing a lot more students and so are we um do we have any controls in

128place to where we know we're testing a student that's ready for these industry certifications um you know are we testing maybe too many students that that that passing rate has declined yeah so I think you're seeing a combination of things um some of those you know and you can really go down the rabbit hole when you start digging into Data Dr alen and I have these conversations from time to time right so we saw a 3,000 in increase in overall industry certifications but some of that could be attributable to a student taking six instead of just taking two um I would I would largely attribute the success rate or the passing rate change to the fact that we have a lot of new programs and a lot of staff that we're ensuring alignment with um

129and that they're teaching to the standards that are expected for the students to pass those industry certifications um so I think there's several things we're working towards I I would I would be more reluctant to say we're testing too many kids I I want to see as many kids take participate in this as possible um every student could benefit from one area of our industry certification or another as you well know um and so I think it's just making sure we find the right teacher the right place the right course at the right time and we'll continue to see that number improve not only in participation rate but passing rates as well and then I would also say making sure a student ready for that exam absolutely that's just it making sure that what's being

130taught aligns to what the expect expected outcome is thank you thank you sir Miss Wyatt thank you across the board thank you I know last time we talked about this we had a conversation about is it the participation rate versus the passing rate so thank you for elaborating on that in every category cuz obviously for participation rate the way that it was being reported somebody has to lose for somebody else to win when you're looking at at the percentages um so I I appreciate the change in in reporting them for the teacher retention rate could we get those hard numbers too as well as percentage I just would be interested to see is it going down because it's it's we're closing the that the numbers are small how large those numbers are I guess for

131those cohorts is it that we had positions yes so for you know is it we retained 77% of a th000 employees last year but this year we retained 69% of 1,200 employees um just to see where the where the numbers are for those retention take us a few days but yes ma'am I that's totally fine just thank you yes ma'am and Miss Fields thank you uh we have this comment I have this comment every year I am still struggling with the academic performance and um the certification interest for people that look like me uh we are still struggling we are the lowest group uh and when you look at the um the AP and some of the other areas we have very little participation and so um my question is similar to Miss Miller when

132we have our Retreat um can we have some things in black and white that we're doing specifically to Target and to find ways to bring bring bring these kids up yes ma'am absolutely thank you you're very welcome seeing no further question oh let me rephrase um if you take out participation rates for Ace IB and you look just at passing rates and you count the total number of cells we're well above 70% of meeting all of our goals um so you'll have those hard numbers the time we Retreat I've heard from four of you about the retreat dates I sent out so I'll be following up with the rest of the individuals who haven't responded to see what may work for you um you know I I talked about this with Mr Murphy you're not

133going to necessarily be voting on anything well it'll be a good discussion robust discussion many of you have asked for me to present information specific to what's the district going to do differently um to help Target these so if if Mr Murphy's in agreement you know I'll reiterate I don't believe that for the retreat you necessarily have to have a quorum I have to have a quorum if you all are going to vote and provide me direction but if I'm providing you information and a summary and you're giving me some feedback that doesn't mean we won't subsequently bring something that the board may want to make a decision about and you can always make that motion but I can work through that with the chair and Mr Murphy but Mr Murphy I believe I'm accurate

134in how I shared that want to make suree correct okay and board members do you need a break or you want me to go through the last item go through the last item we're going through the last item okay Captain Shay next item before the board is a statutory obligated uh presentation by our safe schools leader um Captain Ryan Shay Captain Shay it's all yours sir uh good afternoon board members Mr Hy Murphy um I will keep this brief because I know we've been going for a little while but I will need you to pause when I'm done giving out this not so good report um for a special presentation so um you received a copy of the information that we got from the state this is all the information we get from the state

135um so it basically tells you the number of schools that Doe inspected during the second quarter which is 18 which totals out to 11.32% um of our school district um the obvious number there that is caused for concern even for our folks is no schools passed a compliance inspection now I need to reassure you that does not mean our schools aren't safe our schools are safe this is strictly as it relates to compliance with all the new doe regulations that have come forward most of them through the house bill 1473 so some of the areas that were having challenges with so far are whether or not there's paperwork and it's incomplete so I'll give you an example we have to complete after action reports following every drill well if it doesn't list every staff member

136that participated in the drill and it only lists the one person that filled out the paperwork that's not in compliance if they don't fill out the paperwork where it says areas of concern or areas of success in what we plan on doing to make the next drill better and they just put na or there nothing to report that is not a complete report per doe so we're working through those items um there is also we're making changes of course throughout the district on a regular basis we're moving mental health people around we're moving even members of my safe schools team around to different schools and if they don't bring their certificates their physical copies of certificates and put it in the black folder for that new school it's inevitably that time when doe is going

137to show up and we miss that opportunity and just because it's not in the folder at that very moment we are not in compliance it doesn't I have it with me no they check the folder it means we're not in compliance so little things that we are working through to make sure that those things do not slip through the crack um there's also as as it relates specifically to House Bill 1473 the safest area markings are a concern these are the if you go into a school the are green stickers that we utilize for safest areas so um there hasn't been any guidance from doe with their expectations or training on where they expect these markings to be but inevitably we're being marked deficient in this particular area but they haven't given us any training

138so I am meeting with doe tomorrow in Land of Lakes um for our regional meeting so I will be there um and I'm going to ask how are we able to mark people deficient if you haven't provided the necessary training in order for us to be successful so I'll have that information and I'll bring it back to you because we intend to be successful we intend to be compliant with the Florida state mandates that are there and that's the expectation of all of you that is the expectation of the sheriff of this County that is certainly my expectation as your director of safe schools so um I welcome any feedback that you may have for me for this meeting tomorrow or about this report M Mr Keys my only concern would be in my understanding

139this that this could be the smallest little infraction that would create that they didn't they weren't compliant what I'm understanding okay okay yes sir and I I appreciate Captain Shay you know prefacing um you know the report the way he did because I I think what most people would would assume is when you see Zero schools and 100% compliance they assume that means Gates were left unlocked doors were left unlocked you know people are coming and going we're not checking IDs none of that's true um but these are procedural things that due to so many changes occurring we're still working through and much to Captain Shay's credit he's absolutely right and this is why you know I sit on the superintendent association's Council for this very topic because we bring that big District perspective and

140we don't communicate anything to the legislature as far as concerns or with um Department of Education without consulting with our Sheriff's Office to make sure that they're in agreement that we if we have a concern that they share that concern um and so there are some things but we have had a couple instances where they've done some site visits you see the they've done some revisits um so if a school is found out of compliance they will do a revisit within a specified period of time um and if we find that they have repeated a violation then we are addressing that in accordance with your policy the board adopted ay in accordance with statutory requirements that we have a dis Progressive discipline plan in place for people who refuse or fail to adhere to Safe

141schools policies and procedures um and so we are following that U and I appreciate the captain's participation and support for us um because a couple of those he and I had phone calls about when when it because I get I get a notification and I immediately look at the report and then I'm calling him saying what do you mean they did this twice and he's said and I'm dealing with it on the administrator side holding the administrators accountable um because they're supposed to be walking their campuses and ensuring these things are being addressed he's got a guardian or SRO who's walking to campus doing the same thing so we're making sure that if they spot something don't wait for somebody else just do it just fix it um and that way we don't have any

142we don't have the opportunity for for any serious issues to take place so I appreciate his the thoroughness in which he he does his job and the seriousness in which we take this um I want to thank the Regionals and others because there isn't a site visit that we do that we're not talking or looking at safety and saying hey what about that hey what about this so that's important and several of you I want to thank Mr Keys and Mr sharpless they were able to join us um we did some ballistics testing thank you to the Sheriff's Office for Lending us not only your officers who by the way are highly skilled I was impressed um to test out the window film um and it was quite impressive so I'll be I'll be bringing

143a separate recommendation to the board you've already approved the window film as an add-on um but I'll be bringing to the board our our architectural Department engineering department is already looking at um changing our standard for front entry Windows um to include the laminated film versus just the film that's adhered to the frame and the glass so that will be coming before you in the near future so I see no further questions or comments sir I'm bringing in your surprise stand by my surprise well for everybody oh thank you so I'll tell last time they surprised me it was a dancing I need to get ready to I'm happy I'm happy to share with you that our newest Firearms detection K9 certified today um Mr Hyde is not going to be happy with the name

144selection um but the dog came to us over a year and a half old and already had this name and it you'll understand why it's pretty cool the it worked out the dog's name is Russell the can9 Handler's name is Scott Russell so I introduce you to Russell squared so this is Russell don't trigger on don't trigger on anybody Russell people can see him hey buddy oh yeah well don't don't tear up the carpet please um so just to give youall a little bit of information um obviously he's our newest Firearms detection canine he's roughly 19 or 20 months old now 20 months old now um he was donated to us so it came at no cost to you all or the sheriff's office which is a lovely um part of all of this um

145but he is full of energy um but most importantly he's certified to be in our schools now um Scott and Russell it seems weird to say that um Deputy Russell and Russell the K9 um just went through 200 hours of training before certification this morning so the timing of this worked out really great for you all to have the opportunity to meet him um Deputy Scott Russell has 28 years of law enforcement experience um and he's been with the safe schools team for the last two years has a passion for this work he also had eight years on our SWAT team so Russell is in the right hands so I wanted you all to meet Russell and yall can come down pet Russell this is your time with your dog so there you go that

146concludes the superintendent portion of today's Workshop you're welcome to go down there and pet the dog if you want can I pet that dog yeah he can be here as long as I need him we have a five minute break to go I think they need a little bit more time than that um for recording so we'll go ahead and go offline in 2 minutes at 2:20 um board members can go ahead and recess as they see fit and we'll come back at 230 please I'm coming to pet the puppy [Music] [Applause] [Music] good afternoon I would like to call this work session on this fine uh January day back to order so superintendent if you can lead us through the remainder of our work session today um once you're finished chewing yes sir sorry

147took the opportunity to eat a Mento have fresh breath um so uh Mr chair members of the board MERS of commun Staff um that concludes the superintendent portion of the report today you'll note there's nothing under budget and Staffing information items are our typical information items information items that we provide for you um and so please let me know if you have any further questions or concerns if not I will turn this over to the board chair all right great thank you superintendent Hyde thought that was a great work session as well by the way uh so next uh up is our board meeting agenda for tonight so board members if you want to take a moment just to flip over to tonight's agenda and we'll go through that together all right so here we

148go we're going to be looking at sections a through F if you have any questions a through F and then we'll move down to sections G through J and moving down to sections K and or K through M rather so miss white you are recognized thank you I just want to give a huge shout out to facilities on K5 um for the parent pickup drive at Chain of Lakes Elementary School the number of calls it's not even in my area but the number of calls I get about pickup the pickup line at Chain of Lakes Elementary School um is insane because it backs up literally the entire side of the Town um so thank you for working on that and smoothing that out because I know that's been a big under tanking so I'm excited

149to support it tonight that's awesome thank you Miss why now we're at section n through P section n through P actually just one item there uh so then moving to sections Q through R any comments questions sections Q through R again I mean there's been a lot of questions flying around thank you superintendent for being responsive and providing a lot of data and response to some of those questions in that section in particular all right and now we're down to section s which is our action agenda tonight any comments in this particular area Miss Wyatt you are recognized thank you I had asked for what's now S7 and S8 both to be pulled from the agenda or pulled from the consent agenda and put on action I will not be supporting these tonight um as

150we've had pretty robust conversation since as early as September um about how we have ruled out our changes in healthcare plan for the the period that really started January 1st but um was advertised to our employees in October and the lack of transparency and advertising it to our employees um I will not be supporting either of these items thank you Miss Wyatt Miss Miller you recognized I just want to back up a little bit I um fortunately I guess finally have filled my three um committee members for the half cent sales tax committee and so I'll be quick with that I'll read their um bios and comments is that what you want me to do after we make the motion and just give a little bit okay thank you yeah thank you Miss Miller uh

151great recommendations as well I did fill some conversations on that I was just wondering um I know Miss vette's not over there but it'd be nice um for all of us just to see again that updated list of our half cent sales tax oversight uh committee appointments just so we're aware when their terms expire I know Mr Noti was asking a question about that as well just so we can be in the loop with that I may um you brought that up and this has been a topic that I I was actually remiss in addressing with you last time in February um I will be bringing back to the workshop um the charge sheets for each committee um part of what the board had had asked me about before was was in each one of

152the existing committees what's the duration for someone to sit on that what's the process for replacing them what's their goals or their objectives so if you recall um and several of you are new to the board and would not have received this all I'll forward those again we redid All the charge sheets um but I think it's worth some conversation because they're not consistent as far as duration of appointment so I think there's an opportunity for you all to make sure that before we publish those again and then make all that information available again on our website that we I give you the opportunity to give us feedback on those charge sheets and then each one of those respective committees would then meet members would agree to the charge sheet and then we can publish

153all of that but I can definitely get you the list of the uh happening sales tax committee members yep and and just as these questions were coming up along the way here this week um you know I was directing you know individuals to our website as it relates to the half cent sales tax oversight committee and just looking at that would be nice if our agenda uh and meeting minutes were actually updated consistently on our website uh cuz I know you know we're we're meeting um aggressively and around the half cent sales tax oversight but just looking at the website itself uh that data is not being populated um out there for general public to see so it would be nice to get that updated sir as well all right any other questions on our

154action agenda items this evening and then from there there we have a superintendence report or actually rather we have the public hearing uh that we'll work through tonight in regards some policies that's already been before us multiple times and then from there we'll go to the superintendent's report you have a report tonight yes sir all right very good and then from there attorney report wow I'm gonna miss out on that man I'm gonna miss that all right thank you Mr Murphy and then we do have uh an Auditor's report so miss Matthews will bring a recommendation to us so thank you and then we have board member reports and that's about it uh public comment and then adjournment any questions at all all right very good I'm excited about our guests tonight I'm sure everybody

155read the bio uh Isabelle I believe is her name um from tenaro high school and is in the 3de program part of Junior Achievement so pretty excited about our guest tonight to lead us all right any other thoughts on the agenda all right so now we'll pop back over into our work session and finish our work session off uh I would like to just briefly start uh [Music] on uh letter G within the work session as it relates to board member comments I wanted to give an update with our general Council search um there were a couple questions that came through in regards to that uh those April dates April 15th and 16th I did reach out to Doug Thomas Mr Thomas and ask uh some followup questions in regards to what's expected as far

156as time on those days so he reported back and is asking for a half day and we'll get this calendar update um calendar invite update it right now you just blocked off those two days but on the 15th we're looking at for those one-on-one meetings with the finalist it's going to be either the a or p.m. but he's looking for a half day so uh typically we would come in at 9:00 a.m. you know so on some of our work sessions so I just wanted to hear from board members if you're content and and and that works for you on the 15 15th if we came in at 9:00 a.m. we did a half day that would put us at 1:00 um if you want to flip it and do the PM you could uh

157if that would be the will of the board and then second on the 16th he's definitely uh expecting a full day um that's going to be full board public interviews and deliberations so you know we don't know how many finalists are going to end up here U which could you know change that required time commitment um but for planning purposes you know I think that's um sort of the the vision there from Mr Thomas all right so if you're okay with it uh we'll have the calendars updated to be from 9:00 a.m. to 1 p on April 15th and then the full day on the 16th with a 9:00 a.m. start 9 a.m. to what time time um I'm assuming a full day he means from 9: till 5: all right board members very good

158um and you know just going back to our conversation around the academic targets and our successes uh we want to keep celebrating that and sense and think through that board retreat you've got those dates and superintendent Hyde you can you know pipe back in because you did give us a quite a bit of you know detailed information around the board retreat but um those dates are out there what I'd like to hear from you is if there and I'm going to list the dates are there any of these because we're looking at four um Retreat dates based on um the information that was provided to you so one being a full day uh and then the other three I mean they would all be full days but you would have the necessity you your a

159availability would be only half um of those other days so here's the dates what I'm I'd like to just hear from you if there's any date in particular that you're opposing that just doesn't fit your schedule so February 14th that is Valentine's Day I don't know about y'all but I do have um planned events already that February 6 was the first date yeah I did feel like that that was a pretty quick date um so I wanted to give us a little bit more time but if y'all want to not available on February 6th okay um the 14th if I get um any nose on February 14th no okay so I've got two NOS all right how about February 18th Dr Al if we could go a little slower so I can capture the nose

160cuz I'm keeping a spreadsheet here oh that would be because again we we don't require a quorum for some of these so I want to make sure um so February 14th was a no from Miss fields and a no from who who Mr Shar Mr sharplus thank you sir I have your dates says yes is captured I already have mine so are are your blank dates NOS okay that helps me all right very good uh so February 18th any knows on that day okay and the 24th March 3D okay I'm not going to say already submitted mine too yep so all right very good uh March 11th that's the one I submitted I had I had two no dates for you correct all right and then April 7th was okay so if you haven't sent

161your uh response as the superintendent this is now your opportunity here verbally so April 7th okay April 10th the 11th April 11th and then we have April 21st okay all right so uh April 11th and then we have a April 21st April 25th and then lastly I can't do that's opening night of Annie oh boy be but I have to be there during the day to support okay thank you Mr keys so April 30th is that last date days and basically we just need four that we're targeting but we need four full days four full days yes all right good deal um I do see some comments here miss Miller you were recognized oh I had I had something for a little bit later on committee reports but I also just with these um and

162I know we sent that to Mr Hyde there's a we today discovered there's a lot of things to discuss um in a retreat also we've um shared there's a lot of organizational things that maybe we could talk about so once we have the dates we'll we then um will an email go out on what's planned for those days or how is that going to work yes superintendent you did send out that list of all the various topics that you would like to um Target within your time but if you want to maybe speak to the retreat and the vision for that based off conversations with board members um I'll be adding to that list so you'll get a survey my my commitment to you last time was that we would survey you to see which

163and based off how you rank prioritize those topics it's not necessarily you're choosing one excluding some you're going to prioritize what you feel is most important and then I'll take consensus as to what you all are prioritizing and then schedule those develop some draft agendas give them to the chair and then run them by all the rest of the board members to make sure you're comfortable with those dates and times and if there's something you're really passionate about but somehow I've inadvertently scheduled it on a day now thankfully based off what I'm looking at here we do not have a single instance where we would not have a quorum um at at one of the retreat dates so but if it was something you were truly passionate about I'm more than happy to make adjustments

164to the agenda so that you can be there um to voice any concerns or add commentary but again please recall because there will be at least in many instances at least two of you that can't attend some of these dates if they're selected I will promise it will come back as a workshop item for further discussion I I that way at least you can hear a summary from what took place during the retreat and then add or contribute your thoughts or concerns at the same time in fairness all right anything else Miss Miller oh no all right Miss Fields you recognized okay In fairness I know that everybody has a busy schedule uh but I've been uh around the block for a minute now and I have never known us to have a retreat where

165everyone was not present so this would be something new and something different just want to make sure that that's understood I know we're busy and God knows I know that uh it's a heavy lift um but I just want to make sure that I say that on record thank you Miss Fields Miss Wyatt you're recognized I would agree with that Miss Fields I can't remember the last time actually the the one time it would have happened I think we ended up canceling the retreat because it's it is information that's important for all of us to get um superintendent Hyde for those topics if we have a topic that was not in your list that you sent out originally do you want us to email that to you to make sure it's on the survey make

166sure I don't miss anything that based off my conversations with you please do thank you all right thank you Miss Wyatt any other board member comments at this point uh now I'd like to transition to committee reports if anybody wants to report out on your committee work Miss Miller you're recognized thanks um this isn't specifically on a committee but it's something that I got to go experience that I wanted to share with the board and I only can do that in a public setting um and we all have different professional development um opportunities and one that I've been working with is leadership Florida and I visited a school yesterday that is a charter it's UCP it used to be it used to be United Cerebral paly and it now is stands for something else it

167just left my mind but was excited there are talks to come to pulk so I wanted to go see what they were about and it is the first school that I've seen as a K8 that is fully inclusive of children of every ability it was impressive um they're opening in Oola County I'll be attending that groundbreaking just to see what that facility looks like but I sat down and gave her all the hard questions about budgeting how do we meet the needs how do the academic needs met for students that vary and such because if you've lived in this world for a long time you've seen many of um our schools including magnets and other specialty schools wanting to do and just not knowing the how I don't I don't I've never thought that people

168left LED with malicious intent not to include but the how has never been shown to them so to be able to see a school that is very successful with their Partnerships with the University of Central Florida and um and how they meet the needs of a a range of students I've never seen together before I think is very hopeful it's where we've always wanted to go and it was a great experience to um to learn from I had one other and it's currently leaving me and so this is what happens when you get close to 50 um but if I have that I will share it out it was um an exciting time to meet people from different parts of the state oh I it just came back see how quick that does um we

169were talking about graduation rates and I met with um some leaders in Lake County in that school district that do something I thought was super Innovative and I shared it with the superintendent and I think it would be great and possibly it would be part of our discussion when we talk about that they actually their graduation rate has gone up over 95% for Lake County and a lot of that was yella high school that was struggling so much they offered a late afternoon almost early evening session for students who needed to to get those credits to graduate and it we talked about the cost and how they um and how they administered that and that was one area that they really focused on providing an additional opportunity for students that were struggling and instead of

170them giving up or letting go or going somewhere else it was that one more chance to be able to graduate and they saw a huge increase in their graduation so I think there's a lot of opportunities maybe doing things that we haven't always done that would help meet the needs of students who um you know with those last year they're either working or they have other obligations and they've really um not been able to see the potential of graduation so I thought that was interesting and Lake county is Sim a little bit similar to us just because they're rural um they're not the size of us um but I learned that from being a part of that group so I thought I would share thank you thank you Miss Miller all right so with uh

171no further business to come before us all right Mr Keys I just wanted to share that I did uh attend my first session of the PK Education Foundation last week um was absolutely fabulous saw a lot of familiar faces there um known Mrs Porter for oh gosh long time now um but was welcome with open arms and was able to to inject some some knowledge there and um just excited to play that role and and to be a part of that group awesome thank you Mr Keys all right at this point this meeting is now adjourned we will be uh back at 4:00 U for our discipline hearing

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.