001[Music] [Applause] [Music] well good morning again indeed so uh welcome to the PO County school board's work session uh we will now call the work session for January 14th 2025 to order uh just like to thank everyone for being here uh thanks to our staff who are available and accessible to us uh and uh basically to address any problems that we would uh you know need to address or any concerns that we have so definitely uh humbled to serve alongside you in the most highly educated and dedicated Workforce in the United States uh I would like to start by reading our who are we statement and it states this we are the P County leadership governance team uh if we were to pick one phrase to describe us it would be student centered uh because
002when we come together to work we lean on our diverse backgrounds and our experiences to ensure that our decisions are focused on providing a high quality education for all students uh the four most important things to our governance team are one operating with Integrity two respecting our students our staff our families and each other number three establishing a culture where stakeholders feel valued um support it and have opportunities for personal and professional growth and then number four supporting an approach of continuous Improvement to ensure student outcomes and then collectively we need to work on behalf of the children we ser serve and we're going to find these Avenues of agreement so that we can govern in an effective Manner and there's no acceptable alternative to that we will always collaborate in a respectful manner in
003order to enhance the opportunities for each student uh and staff member we will not disparage others our students will Thrive because when we remain committed to that to supporting the whole child we hope to engage and Empower our students and then stakeholders to the create this community of lifelong Learners and at this time board members actually I'd like to um close our session out so we can address this first item on the agenda which is our Mr chair no sir we're going to we're going to amend today's calendar I I believe I provided that update to the board um in my previous correspondence that due to my required travel to be present at the State Board of Education meeting I'll need to leave this morning uh Mr pittz will then sit in for the remainder
004of today's session but I am altering um the my workshop agenda today sir okay thanks superintendent so Clos session will be moved to a later point in today's meeting all right and I'll just hand it off to you for uh you to take us through the rest of the meeting today thank you sir so the first item that I'm going to bring before the board is an update on PO SI High School um and so we do have our councel external counsel um Brian Williams we also have Mr pittz and others with us today um as the board knows we were originally received a P3 submission um when we retained Council using the funds provided by that that organization Mr Williams um came to our attention he formerly was with Miami Dade County Public Schools
005he was the author of their P3 proposal um policies and procedures he is now an independent attorney who represents multiple school districts in P3 proposals and their review the timeline development and other things I I won't continue to sing his Praises I'll allow him time to do that for himself um he is with us today um as the board recalls we ended up with uh two submissions that moved forward um one party uh subsequently withdrew and so there's only one um proposal before the board and before I make my recommendation I'd like to go ahead and introduce Mr Pitts and then subsequently Mr Williams um to again outline the process the timeline and the procedures that were followed Mr pittz good morning and I'm basically going to just introduce Mr Williams Mr Hyde did a
006great job of introducing Mr Williams um and he's been guying us through this process um since it was a new process for us uh that we you know navigating through this um and he's done a great job and Mr Williams will you come up um he's going to walk us through the process that we followed um and and we'll go from there and good morning everyone uh board members chair superintendent uh it's a pleasure to be here today again my name is Brian Williams and I am with the law firm of Cole Scott and C say uh as the superintendent mentioned I have a lot of experience representing school districts uh in addition to Miami dat County Public Schools I also served as a chief legal counsel to uh Lee County schools and was also
007an associate general counsel to CER County Schools um I also do represent multiple school districts in this capacity and when I was at Miami Dade I was actually their construction and business operations attorney um in addition to running their Economic Development Department for three and years uh but outside of that uh again I think the intent is to just kind of give an overview and an update on this process and and to ensure the board and the community that the district did follow the statutory provisions and again that makes it relatively easy um with respect to this process because it is very statute driven um the language in the statute um provides the process by which the district is to follow upon receipt of a unsolicited proposal and I am here to assure you that
008that process was followed um and that begins with as you know the district received an unsolicited proposal from an external vendor uh which is essentially a process that um allows for a vendor to prospectively look at a District's needs in a particular area and uh when identifying a particular project in this case this this school um can propose a a unsolicited proposal uh meaning not something the board solicited but something that they are bringing to your attention as a a potential need and then once received the district has the duty to per the statute review that uh proposal to ensure that it meets specific guidelines and then um there is the option of advertising and promoting that um that solicitation to allow other vendors to compete on it uh that is exactly what happened here
009um the district decided to use the ITN process which is an invitation to negotiate um that is a process that is actually being frequently used by districts because it gives a lot of latitude um in terms of the negotiation aspect of a large project uh which in this case given the size of the uh school project itself uh again is probably the uh safest way to ensure that you're getting um exactly what you want and and again the uh difference in this process being that typically you have uh the district for a construction project put together a request for uh qualifications a request for proposals uh where you delineate the criteria that you're establishing for that project well in this case having a proposal being brought to you um it took that kind of control
010out of out of that aspect uh which again when received and the district put out their ITN that is the process where the district was allowed to establish a process to ensure not only that you are properly evaluating the qualifications of the vendor that has submitted the proposal but ensuring a Avenue for negotiating the best price as well ensuring that the uh project itself meets the requirements and the standards of P County Schools obviously um the state has state requirements for educational facilities when constructing a school but each district has its own unique um standards for how they want their schools built including um the uh the certain specifications that are built into those schools and that could be Security Services or security uh I uh IT services that are built into that school function
011well once received the district put out that ITN uh I believe two proposals were submitted in response to that ITN and again those proposals are required to be evaluated on a certain basis of criteria that process was built into your ITN uh which is the evaluation process it has gone through that evaluation process uh it was it's now considered in the negotiations phase which again is a criteria in your ITN and I was looking at it before I got up here and it allows for at this point in the process an opportunity for the district to negotiate with all vendors um relative to their proposals and including uh requesting a best and final offer and again that's to get you to the best price for this particular project as the superintendent mentioned you've had now
012had one vendor withdraw from that process essentially leaving you with one proposal uh Val one valid proposal um active and you're now at that phase of the process but in terms of your process the statute was followed your ITN was followed and your ITN traces the process um that was followed in this solicitation process so I think that's where we're at today um but if there are any specific questions about the process or the statute um I'm here and and more than willing to answer those for the board not seeing any questions uh board members at this time it is going to be my recommendation that we move forward with the proposal from Fortress um you each received a packet today there have been questions by board members asking you know subsequently who is working
013for Fortress you've been provided a resume for each of those respective parties you will find great comfort I believe in recognizing many of those names who have had projects successfully completed here in P County um R of construction being one and others so I again based off the merits of the submission based off the price based off the fact that it met all of our metrics and our requirements it is my pleasure to make a recommendation to move forward with the proposal submitted by Fortress the board will not be voting on this today um board members please note that this will be included in the subsequent Workshop as well to allow you additional time to have discussion or ask questions but it will also be on that board meeting for that next meeting in January
014so it we'll it's essentially it's not coming back to back because I'm giving you over two weeks time in which to submit questions to my office to get you to get addressed and or and I would appreciate questions being submitted before the board meeting so we can make sure we do our diligence provides you with a timely response publicly if that's where you'd like your questions to be addressed um but again and then moving from there the board has two options the board can either accept my recommendation of The Proposal submission or the board can reject that and direct us to go back and read vertise um to see and follow more of a traditional process versus the P3 process so that just want to make sure the board is aware um but it is
015based off the recommendation the quality of their submission their price point and board members keep in mind that there were several things that were different and I'm saying some of this because we have a new board member I want to make sure that Mr Keys and others have the full background um we did put very specific requirements on and conditions on this project that included being within a a certain radius of the initial projected site it also included that the developer would have to bring or the whoever is awarded the contract would have to bring land to the table this was an effort under the P3 for us to basically get out of the real estate business business because as Miss Miss Miller and I have discussed before I think I've had this discussion with
016several of you sometimes when parties become aware that the school district is looking for land the price point changes I won't say if it goes up I won't say that it goes down but sometimes the price point automatically changes because we are the ones in the market we're not Realtors we're Educators and so this was an opportunity um for us to push this issue of land attainment away and so there were certain conditions that were made as far as the distance from a main roadway main tie-ins those types of things those were conditions that we put out in the ITN um there are two steps that are used to evaluate a proposal just again to give complete transparency the first is an initial rubric scoring sheet there's a committee of school district members um who
017are Representatives on that Mr sharpless and others have asked questions about those about the questions and the scoring sheets unfortunately because of the con of Silence we were precluded from sharing that to share that related to Fortress at this time um because as of today Mr Murphy if correct me if I'm wrong the cone of silence is effectively listed because I have now made an official recommendation before the board that is correct okay so we'll be able to address any additional questions or or concerns that you have so if there are additional documents that you'd like to see pertaining to Fortress and their submission happy to share those with you um the others I can share as well but I'll I'll funnel that through our attorney and others just to make sure I'm I'm staying
018above board in all of our actions but again you have one proposal before you at this time it'll come back into in January 28th I believe is our next workshop and board meeting but please don't be surprised to see it on both the workshop and the board agenda so it's not coming back toback but it is giving you affording you an opportunity to have time to review everything and ask additional questions that you may have please keep in mind any questions you submit to my office I will respond to the entire board so they have the benefit of both the question and the response but it will not have a particular board member's name saying Mr or Miss is so and so requested this you'll simply say board members these are the questions that I
019have received okay Miss Wyatt are we going to receive the proposal before the work the agenda usually comes out or is that something that we should just be no we will forward the proposal to you today with the recom staff recommendation to my office thank you ma'am Mr sharpless um so instead of emailing it I'll just put it in public record now the two things that I would like to see and I'm sure they're going to be on the proposal is just location and then also how this is competitively priced um you how how we're getting say price and location is really important to me when building a school so you in The Proposal you Reed the final price for the project um I can speak to the fact that um in this instance it
020did come in significantly cheaper than what we built our most recent high school at okay um you know there's there's speculation about Davenport High School cost due to um changes and other things uh you know it it got close to about $200 million this is well below that and includes the land okay um so when I first came in Mr Wilson and others had expressed a great deal of concern that the initial proposed budget for Davenport High School ended up changing significantly over time versus what the board initially approved and then the final price due to change orders and other factors so we took the opportunity to address a lot of that because at this point it's a baffo the best and final offer and we learned this from our first P3 proposal as well
021that essentially once they're locked in unless we indicate a significant change that requires re-engineering and structural changes to the to the plan any additional costs if they have to bring an additional labor to meet the deadline for the school to open are not District responsibility that is solely on the behalf of the developer and Builders um so this is in that regard it's a process and we will be bringing that process into our traditional design and build scheme as well because once once we receive that again unless we direct a change because something doesn't look right our group does a great job of reviewing the specifications and room dimensions and all programmatic needs as well um so in this case this school when we put out the ITN and we and we communicated with with
022the parties that showed demonstrated an interest we told them exactly what career tech ed and what programs would be at that site so when they submitted the design it should be as close to being the final design need specific for that program as possible so that there wouldn't have to be this back and forth because anybody can come in with a cheap design and then subsequently blame us for change orders absolutely not we told them the number of rooms we gave them a project model sample all those things so we eliminated all of that on the Forefront so I'm very pleased with that part of the process thank you sir yes sir Dr Allen I just want to make sure it's on record I know I had submitted a couple questions to you and if
023you want to maybe address those um and you know I think it's important to bring that forward so if you want to address those sure so Dr Allen has submitted some questions to me specifically pertaining to Shankle Schulz the architect because you'll note that in the Fortress proposal Shankle Schulz is the architect of record um the specific concern was and again Mr Keys um I believe Mr sharpless and Mr Niti were both on the board at the time at before the P3 was submitted to us we don't advertise for P3 let me make sure everybody understands that that is simply a proposal that can land in your lap at any given time uh Mr Williams and Mr Pitts and others can attest to that we had already began the process of reviewing the possibility of
024a new high school we engaged and and put out through our traditional process a request for proposal or an ITN to architectural firms that we would be looking for a prototype High School many of you realize that several of our schools typically look alike because once we buy those plans we can then replicate them over a period said period of time and we reduce our overall costs as a result of that so we asked for a prototype High School to be designed we then contracted selected and contracted with shangle Schulz that contract would cost about $5 million to the district that happened at the Forefront at the beginning of all of this P3 then came in and overlapped with this process so Dr Allen's question was you know is there a conflict of interest in
025discussing it with staff in discussing it with our Council it was determined that there is no conflict of interest and here's why first and foremost the initial contract that was executed with shangle Schulz for5 plus million dollar to design a prototype high school has never been executed we've not been build no plans have been submitted no work has been performed and I think that was done potentially essentially may have been done intentionally by the architectural firm knowing that they didn't want to have any semblance of a conflict that was not directed by us it's simply the reality that they did no work for us on that contract to this um Dr Allen also requested did any particular party during the submission process have an unfair Advantage because if shangle Schulz was the company that designed
026one of our previous high schools in this case Davenport High School did they have a unique Advantage having designed the Proto high school knowing that that's what we asked people to replicate and the answer based off my response is no because all of the parties who were moving forward in this process had full and complete copies of rooms room numbers square footage design specifications and so everyone had a Level Playing Field as far as their submission so there was no surprises there um and we that was part of why we had the baffo process was to make sure we compared square footage we compared to make sure programmatically they met our needs so all of that was included um and so those things were not conditions that would cause what's considered a conflict of interest
027in this case um very clearly and then I can't recall the third question I addressed for you Dr Allen yeah I mean that was the main one I wanted to know first of all did we pay anything on that initial contract right now you know the question is you know uh what happens to that contract that was already signed by the district um and you know does it because it was communicated to me from our internal audit that it converts to A continuing contract I don't know what what that means I just wanted to know what happens with that initial signed contract that there are two options that contract can either we can either notify the architects of our intent to to essentially not execute that contract there are typically terms and conditions in the
028contract that's stipulate the way both parties can walk away from the contract I'd have to review that with Council um additionally we still require a high school prototype uh moving forward otherwise we're going to pay higher architectural fees each time we design a high school moving forward and so what I'd prefer to do the best way I think to address this question is to bring that to the next workshop and outline for the board what the options would be and what our recommendations going to be because I don't want to make a recommendation outside of Staff again we will still have a need to address high schools and and I can share we have great high school campuses but some of our high school campuses now are getting a bit old and are either going
029to require significant refurbishment or arguably replacement um and so we want to be respectful of that so prototype high school we do save costs um significant costs over time so I'd like to make sure that staff are involved so I can either commit to bringing it to this next Workshop or the immediately Workshop immediately following that but I'll notify the board in my weekly update as to where we stand with that but I think those are your two options we can either cancel that contract because of this certain situation but again we still require a prototype high school and it's probably best to get your feedback on what the board would like to see us do to move forward so all right thank you superintendent M Miller thank you I just want to um thank
030you for the presentation today and just to clarify publicly only because the Optics of issues that pole counties had in the past and the facts if you use Google um has always been that facilities is where um we've had issues we've had legal issues we've had people arrested for um the practices here um which was a long time ago and none of those people are still here and we've made great improvements but for the Optics of the community that still think um and as and I'll I'll correct the superintendent I'm a broker realtor there's none of us here that are just kidding um when I did come on the board and see what was happening with what we were paying um just from good information we were getting or not getting um the fact that
031we were only getting one appraisal at a time for land um there were some things that we could have saved money this might not always be it might go back to where we have to look at at look at land separately um but we've got to find somewhere to pick up those dollars my question to you just for transparency is you came here to to to explain this to us and you reviewed our process which I appreciate looking at the processes that will en will encourage the community to have faith that what we are doing is the best um for the district and spending the dollars and their tax dollars um wisely but you have I just would want you to confirm if you have any affiliation with anyone involved in bidding for our schools
032or um construction projects Andor other facilities projects just so people understand that we are trying U what we're trying to do is show transparency in this process oh no absolutely and no I do not and actually um as I mentioned earlier I I kind of in the business business of rep representing school districts at this point and coming in and using kind of my knowledge in these particular areas to assist districts and that's exactly what I'm doing but as far as the vendors are concerned I have no affiliation with the vendors um that bid on these projects that would be a conflict for me so and the itm process is that something that other districts use yes and so the itm process and I think one one of the places that got picked up uh
033there's another District that uh is also going through the P3 process as we speak and I know that staff when looking out and I do it as well we're we're always monitoring what other agencies are doing across the state relative to this process um what I believe that another District used the ITN process that's something that I think that District in particular utilizes on a more frequent basis but as I mentioned there has been a shift um in a lot of these to that ITN process again because of the ability to negotiate throughout the process usually with the request for proposal or request for qu qualifications it's very delineated on the scoring process here you have built in if you look at the the details of your ITN it allows you negotiation um at the
034second phase of the evaluation process where you have the opportunity to go back and forth with the vendor to really hone in and specify what the needs of the district are what the requirements of the district are relative to the project and I think that process again allows more flexibility albe it a new process for this particular District it does allow a little bit more flexibility in negotiating this type of of project and it is a a process that a lot of districts are kind of Shifting over to um as we speak um you have your more traditional ITB RFP RFQ but ITN is is showing up and I can say in Lee County which is where I live um that is a process that they're shifting to as well thank you and I I
035should also clarify the ITN process um was also used because you had an unsolicited proposal that you received and so we then put out that rather than just a raw RPA you know RPF request for proposal um those types of things which we would do if we had no parties already having had a submission so the I 10 was done because we already had a submission and we wanted a true Apples to Apples comparison so we fully delineated the qualifications and Criterion in that regard Mr Keys I just wanted to say first of all thank you to superintendent Hyde for giving us some information on the process of the P3 and and also for uh chairman Dr Allen for questions and Mrs Miller for her comments because coming into this new it it does um
036shed some light on the the situation and going in and I will I will say that it gives me a level of comfort having actually I think and I'm not going to speak for all the board members but I've actually been through that process of the rubric and the scoring um as a community member and then sitting on the board as a certified general contractor at some of the transparency we'll see in in reviewing those plans and projects I think is um just speaks to the public and showing that we're doing our due diligence so I appreciate everyone involved um and Mr Williams for coming to show us that and and um I'm excited about this because this project is long overdue um those of you familiar with the growth in that area of the
037county I think we're probably a year behind scheduling this so um I appreciate everyone's input in it Dr Allen thank you superintendent and you know Mr Williams thanks again for being here uh with us as well I appreciate your time earlier um you know and I think I'll just reiterate a couple questions I had for you at that time was uh you know we did get the letter right um from the uh with draw from the other organization so I just want to make sure you said there were no critical concerns that you had right that's correct and and actually just from Logistics um standpoint once a firm withdraws from the process there's you know if you look at ability to contest things they lack standing to to raise issues down the line so now
038that vendor has voluntarily removed themselves so now you're essentially left with the the remaining vendor but I think as uh superintendent Hyde pointed out you have the ability to look at the score Ing and the best and final offer that were submitted prior to the withdrawal so you have all the criteria as uh board member Keys mentioned to be able to transparently evaluate the qualifications that me met the criteria that was established by the district also consistent with the statute okay very good I appreciate that superintendent yes sir Miss Fields so the process was very tedious and long and I think that it would have been been good if Mr Williams could have come up front and maybe that wasn't possible because of all the litigations and stuff I'm not really sure but I appreciate
039you being here today and in reference to what Miss Miller said we did have a serious situation back in the early 2000s early 2000s long long long time ago and our facilities Department have really done a great job um trying to make sure that we do things ight and uh it's as a board we are supposed to to be objective until the very end and then look at the information whatever is best for the district and then move from there and I think that's where we're headed now and sometimes it can be a little bit cloudy uh because of pressures that we sometimes get outside of of the boardroom but at the end of the day we have to look at the information and be objective and do what is best again for our students
040and for our school district and and to that point um Madam board member uh I think as far as the tedious nature of this process I will say it was tedious um and but it was followed in accordance with what the staff put together in terms of the process often times with this type of project and I and I work on several of these uh there are things that occur in the process that make it a more tedious process and a lot of times that requires staff to do some extra due diligence in reviewing the information that has been provided and following up on that and and so to that EXT I I can assure you that uh staff understood the the importance and significance of this project and did just that and and that
041sometimes causes um delay Al albeit not intentional but to really make sure that the process is being followed accurately and that the information that is being provided um is accurate as well yes sir thank you you're welcome so and I'd like to go ahead before we wrap up because I don't see any further questions I'd like to thank Mr Williams and Mr Pitts and team because much to Mrs Field's point you know there are times where the timelines and the decisions can seem frustrating and there were times where I'm saying why can't we just do this and it sounds great but I have to rely on staff not to be a bunch of bobbleheads saying yeah Mr superintendent we'll make it happen because simply because you want it to happen to to miss Field's point
042and Miss Miller's earlier Point things have changed and I give a lot of credit to the team for being willing to stand their ground and say no this is the process we have to follow and here's the why but I would like to recognize and again thank Mr Williams publicly because what what you don't know are the number of hours he forfeited on Saturdays Sundays holidays to take teams calls with myself Mr pittz and others to work through all the questions because the P3 process is very new um we're one of a handful of districts that have actually gone through this process and so there's a lot to learn our process will continue to improve we'll have Lessons Learned as you know board members we've had a request to meet um to discuss the the
043process with other parties happy to do so now that Tona Silence has been lifted um and so if we can learn from that fantastic um but I do want to say thank you to Mr Williams um he's been a great partner in this and uh I teased him I said I did tell him we had a vacancy if he was interested um but he's he's done a great job for us and and I look forward to if we have any subsequent P3 proposals or even if we go the route of furthering our itns I I think he's a great partner with us to continue to keep in in in in a relationship with pop County Public Schools so thank you sir thank you Mr pittz and thank you to the entire facilities and maintenance staff
044um for all that they did throughout this process as well thank you and thank you board member of the board there are no further questions thank you board members I'm going to try and get two topics in before I have to trans uh to leave um the next topic I'm going to bring before you is the Crystal Lake Elementary School turnaround option plan you've already seen this but I felt it's important to give you an update simply because I will be traveling to represent the board it's unfortunate you have to travel to Destin for a three minute discussion with the state board but I'm pleased with where we're at we have submitted our presentation uh to the to the floor Department of Education prior to to the meeting because they have to prepare they also
045want to verify data so throughout our presentation they double check our numbers they double check for pm1 pm2 those kinds of things um so what we are submitting to the State Board is what you will recall that your initial approval was that if Crystal Lake Elementary School did not exit da status this year did not see their grade improved to a c or better that the school would be closed for a period of one year and then reconstituted and reopened as a STEM Magnet School um since that time we have learned that that school essentially we are appealing to the State Board of Education that is still the plan should should my presentation get denied by the state board however I am requesting of the state board for a minimum of a one-year extension based
046off that school's positive trajectory and the district's history of exiting da schools we have an impeccable track record uh of doing so we we made great strides at that school I'm pleased I've been sharing with you the progress monitoring data it does wrap up unfortunately you'll have it in time for the next board meeting actually at the next Workshop you will received the comprehensive summary since now graduation data has been released we'll now be able to provide you with a comprehens Ive summary of all of our goals and as to whether or not we've attained all those goals for growth in specific areas so I'm excited to be bringing that to you but I just wanted to to go ahead and summarize for you that I will be asking the State Board of Education for
047a one-year extension for Crystal Lake based off their positive trajectory um based off you know the scores that we're seeing there the fact it's a community wraparound school and other factors and I think all of those work in our favor um and I've I've gotten great responses from Department staff as to our proposal so I I assure you that I will text Andor call you immediately after my presentation tomorrow if the State Board takes action either way so that you're looped in so just wanted to go ahead and cover that and see if there are any questions or comments about that before I move on to the next item okay seeing none the next item I'd like to bring a veil up to the podium um board members there there's been a lot of work
048and a lot of conversation about employee Healthcare and as a school district we have really two goals number one how do we provide the best possible care options for our employees and their families and number two how equally important how do we do so in a manner that's affordable um Mr Keys is new to the board but Mr Niti and Mr sharpless and and our respective other board members have known for some time that our costs for our healthc care and our insurance plans have continued to grow and because we pay the full cost of that unfortunately it takes money off the table to offer in other areas such as raises and compensation um over the years we've spent since I've been here we've spent close to $21 million to offset the costs of our
049insurance I want to give great I want to recognize Miss fields and Miss Miller for their work on their subsequent committees we've seen a lot of progress to date um recently you recall that we published an ITN um an intent to negotiate looking for a consultant for us because our current consultant is retiring had notified us 90 days of their pending retirement at the time when we posted that ITN there was a there was a a segment in there that actually excluded independent Consultants from being able to apply the phrase essentially I'm paraphrasing and if I get this incorrect I apologize and I'll send out the appropriate phrasing later it essentially said that for you to apply you had to have an an established agreement with the insurance companies and I'm seeing your faces which
050is the same face I made how do you have an independent contractor who that subsequently has some type of relationship with the insurance providers that's not the dog I want in to fight that's not the dog you want to fight you want one that's off the leash ready to go is going to fight for us and do the right thing and by no means am I somebody's going to claim that I'm encouraging dog fighting and that's not what I'm encouraging at all probably not the best analogy I could have used so I apologize to ASPCA I do adopt animals so that being said really worried about that I am actually that being said I think you see the point right we want somebody who's going to truly defend us and so we had an opportunity
051the itm was published we received uh uh three respondents um two we ended up with one that qualified so I am not going to bring you a sole recommendation um so prior to that ITN and US pursuing other options there are companies like Avil that I wanted to bring before you so you could hear from them hear about their consultancy hear what they can do for the district and then I'll have further conversation with you in an open board meeting like this to get your feedback before we go out and pursue options moving forward uh just for full transparency at the next board meeting there will be another company that's coming forward as well just so you can see some comparative options as well this does not mean that I'm supporting a veil I mean
052they're here to to share what they can do I would not have them here if I didn't feel that they basically could satisfy some of our needs and so I'll shut up now and go ahead and turn it over to these gentlemen and welcome them here today thank you gentlemen thank you superintendent Hy thank you board for taking your time to hear from us uh I'm Joe Al Britton I'm the CEO of Avail benefits and this is Darren Bryan Chief Operating Officer um a little bit about our history before we get into this in 2016 out of uh requests from our clients um they wanted an independent truly Independent party representing and sitting on their side of the table uh we're going to explain exactly what that means in here um we started the process
053of building out a very unique skill set that has since been identified by multiple parties as a soul Source solution for what we do um but to to summarize we're going to be able to tell you what who we are and what we do in three slides um and then we're going to open up to questions because people always want to know because this you've never heard anything quite like this I'm betting so we're going to open up to any questions but if you'll please hold your questions until we get through our three short slides I would appreciate that uh oh by the way Miss Le is was not able to make it um she's our senior consultant um she's a tremendous asset to our our company and she's not able to make it she
054wasn't able to make it today so uh first slide independent strategic analytical consultant the most important piece of information on this slide is the bottom portion of the slide um in the State of Florida to become an insurance agent you must satisfy two criteria the first is you must pass the state test to get your A lot of people have heard 215 all that kind of stuff so you have to sit through the class take the test and you pass the state exam to hold the ins insance license but that license is not activated until such time that you are appointed to a carrier when you become appointed to a carrier you're asking the carrier to can I please represent you to the public the carrier then appoints the agent and that license becomes activated
055at that point in time Florida statute sets out that the responsibility of an agent is to solicit negotiate and effectuate cont contracts if you are appointed to a carrier you can only solicit contracts provided by that carrier to the public to you guys that being said um if I was to be an appointed agent and I did something that made the carrier less than happy there would be a potential problem that I could lose my appointment with that carrier I still hold a license from the state of Florida but the license is not activated the process that we went through is called an unaffiliated licensed agent we set out at the State of Florida and we talked with many lawyers and department of insurance and all that kind of good stuff to um go through
056the methodology and the process to hold a license without being appointed to any carriers so we are unaffiliated that means we are unable to place insurance for you that's the catch but we are able to explain everything that's going on to you and truly sit on your side of the table because we don't have to answer to any carriers we don't have to answer to any holding Brokers or aggregators um a lot of insurance agents that you think about are owned by larger broker houses they're subsidiaries of larger broker houses um so it's possible that the larger broker house may hold a license of appointed to a given carrier we cut all ties from all of that we are self-appointed we only answer to us in the State of Florida and whoever our clients are
057that is the simple explanation of why we you know we could not respond to the ITN because your ITN requested that some you be appointed to the carriers well if if you're wanting someone appointed to the carriers they're going to have an affiliation with the carrier so so we we were unable to respond we can't respond to any broker itns because of that but that's also our strength that we don't have an affiliation we know all of them uh we have 25 years of experience in the broker world so we know all these people like I said in the beginning in 2016 the request was made for us to cut ties and become truly independent so we did and our business has flourished ever since um that being said that's what removes the inherent conflict
058of interest that all of you probably walk around in the back of your mind no one was there you couldn't quite put your finger on exactly how or what it meant or what to do about it but you knew it was there so that removes that scenario um the next the next slide I want to talk about is how did we develop a unique set of skills so we have staff that are specialists in Risk Management Insurance they're licensed unaffiliated agents we have armm and cic's and those are all Insurance jargon for people who've taken a lot of other tests to prove that they know what they're talking about we have financial modelers and mathematicians on staff we have experts in negotiations um graduate level experts in negotiations we have graduate level experts in strategy
059we have certified Wellness Personnel we have certified self-insured personnel uh we have people who have high level training in datadriven decision modeling operational op uh optimization behavioral economics change management and general business excellence and practices the behavioral economics scenario is somewhat unique when you think about a wellness program and you think about your incentives and SE charges typically those are arrived at in a non-sophisticated or non-science ific method somebody over here is doing that so that makes sense uh the practical application of that should be driven by behavioral economics you should be doing those things in a way to drive the positive outcome to the district and to the employee so we develop that's I'm just pulling that one out as an example as to why we develop that skill um but those are the
060those are the unique Skillets that we present in addition to that we have former regulators um former doe Personnel former um office of insurance regulation Personnel we have attorneys that specialize in in insurance law and procurement law and we have procurement experts that have done many many many procurements for government entities um that's the unique skill set that we developed in response to what our clients were asking for in 2016 um if you take what we do and and sort of build it into three buckets of expertise you have compliance and best practices analysis some of our clients use us in an attempt to make sure they are in fact compliant with the auditor general um superintendent H I'm sure is familiar with the auditor general they they probably visit him on a regular basis
061a lot of the school districts that we work for um for coffee not because there's a problem no no no no no no bad reasons but some of the school districts throughout the State of Florida have not had such a Jo a joyful experience with the auditor general and they get findings um so what happens is a lot of our clients will hire us to come in and look at their internal procedures and processes and help them evaluate what changes they need to make to become compliant so that's an example of the compliance in best practice the best practice scenario uh we do have tremendous experience and expertise understanding at the health insurance industry as a whole we know the games that are played we know how we know the the uh you know the
062the corn under the coconut game that people like to play we know all of those things so it's easy for us to decipher those things procurement negotiations um a lot of our clients do utilize us for subject matter expertise on procurements it varies from client to client to what degree or what the purpose of the procurement is we gone out and supported other school districts in finding agent of Records we've gone and helped other school districts find uh run processes to find Asos and pbms and a variety of different things once again being unaffiliated we're able to sit on your truly sit on your side of the table and analyze what's coming in and then the last thing is data development what what we determined is every school district is unique every single one especially
063when it comes to your health insurance Dynamic if you think about it just in terms of network access um Baker County Schools does not have access to Lakeland Regional Hospital so when you're when you're thinking of it in terms just of just Network structure and what carriers aligned with who all of those scenarios go into what makes up the unique fingerprint of a given School District so we build proprietary data mines for each and every client we look look at what your employment contracts look like what your negotiating and your bargaining looks like on requirements we look at your board policies we look at utter General findings Geographic constraints demographic constraints fiscal constraints legal constraints if you can think of something we put it in this data mine and then what we're able to do
064is look at each and every one of your strategies and policies and run it run it through our data mind and determine if it's compliant or not um that in a nutshell is if you think about the the practical application of what we do that's what that slide is intended to demonstrate to you this last um we call this the wheel we had to develop a comprehensive understanding of what makes your health insurance actually work giant jigs all puzzle typically what you'll have is somebody will go out and they'll bid the ASO or they'll look for an agent or they'll talk about a wellness campaign or whatever the case may be it all has to fit together and touch every one of these components all nine of these components to work properly every one of
065our clients we utilize this optimization model as the backbone of how we look at what they do and to just give you a a really quick explanation if you look at four five and six on this we refer to that as the change management category that's how you're changing behavior of your employees that's how you're changing for the for the better for them to be healthier and to cost you less money Wellness is when the employee takes action outside of the given Health Care System they're going for a job it's not related to your health care process health literacy simple concept education they need to understand the difference between a deductible and a um co-pay something along those lines they need to understand how the wellness program ties in and then the member engagement piece
066is when that employe does need help how do they take all the health literacy they've had and apply it to the actual engagement or when they interact with the healthc care system itself so all of those pieces fit together and we take this comprehensive View and look in every little crack of what's going on in your health care System to determine what we can do to make directions write the ship save you money get better insurance for the employees um that in a attempted very short time frame it typically takes us several hours to go through all this with people but I you know the best case scenario hopefully I've given you enough to at least uh promote some questions so that is the uh short and simple of who we are and what we
067do so now I would open up for any questions anybody has M Miller Mr Al Britton thank you for coming today and presenting um I know you think I've I'm a jack of M trade so I was raised in the insurance um companies I won't tell you which one in Winter Haven but if you're from Winter Haven you know which one um family or agents I worked for an agent you know I worked for insurance I quickly left the insurance field because of how difficult it can be um just on how it works the process I can tell you I sit on the insurance committee one of the Committees here I asked for the and when it went out I I still haven't received it but um the process is good I know that I
068understand from your explanation today why you weren't able to apply to that um and I appreciate the out the the Avenue that you're coming from only because as an outsider former employee as someone who is an elected official who sits on insurance committees the room was talking and they were talking the business of insurance nothing against any of my staff but the business of insurance is exactly what you what you said it's people that are interconnected selling us their products um giving me data from their products not an overview from best what we would call an education as best practices um and it's kind of how Insurance works it's how it's why you have that multi-layer you know if I have a wellness program that's owned by the insurance carrier and I'm getting so so
069many dollars back in on the usage the data reflects that but it doesn't reflect entirety of what would be available to this and being a self-insured organization as large as we are which largest employer in this County today publ may beat us tomorrow but we're right here we suffer from limited knowledge our limited knowledge of products that would be beneficial to an organization this size even if we started talking outside of the state and so I believe our staff is doing the best they could giving us the best products they were being presented but it is all interconnected and that's where once again like we talked about with facilities you lose Confidence from employees when I'm getting phone calls well in this County we're doing this and in this over here in this organization they're
070self-insured and they're providing this and so having an organization so once again for transparency you are not connected to anyone selling currently selling us products or trying to sell us an insurance product no ma'am okay you're completely into dependent okay thank you and I think that brings a level of transparency and also a Le level of competitiveness um being in a market that is very competitive being a l we should be the largest not that I need extra special treatment but bringing some bringing this kind of business to the table to an insurance company I feel like we need an outside source to show us where we can go to get the best return on our dollars so thank you for explaining that today I didn't realize about the ITN being limited until you explained
071it and I think it's good for the community and the employees to hear that it's interesting from an outside perspective um the selections that we are making based on um the relationships that people have within the industry and that and it's nothing against it's just how that industry runs um and so I appreciate an outside view thank you for presenting today and to follow up on that most insurance companies perceive Brokers and agents as their distribution channels right and in the correct and on the other side of the Ledger one one problem we ran into with the idea of being an independent consultant like we are is their skill sets are extremely limited also so the second half of what I showed you where we built out those unique skill sets of the the behavioral
072economics and the mathematics all the different pieces of the puzzle outside of just a procurement expertise because there are other a there are other um agencies and companies out there that say we will simply run a procurement for you but the problem is when that is done they hand you the answer to that procurement and walk right out the door so the management and application of what they've just handed you becomes your headache and we don't do that we take the position of we stay with you all the way through the implementation and evaluation at the end of the story we show you an Roi on what you decided and we have not and I I don't think we've had that level um and I can tell you this and my question is to you
073on the other side of this if you are connected if there is an a if if our middle per I call it the middleman or our liaison or our person if they are connected to an outside entity are they being given discounted rates are they being is there any benefit from having that connection other than you're just selling me products of people it's like a it's a medical supply you're selling me the product of the person you represent whether you represent them up front or whether you represent them on the back end are they getting discounts for doing that why is that an advantage to them other than they just have that singular person they can sell products to insurance companies contract with a a pool of independent agents so if you think about say
074a a Florida blue for example there's 5,000 Florida Blue agents in the State of Florida the incentive that a Florida blue agent has is there's such a thing in the insurance industry as a book of business bonus now in chapter 600 which is the insurance regulations that's perfectly legal the bigger your book of business the the the silver Superstar Platinum agent and I'm sure you've had Agents come in and say more than likely if you interviewed the top five broker houses in the State of Florida they're all going to say the same story to you and here's what it's going to sound like we have second to none best relationships with all the carriers we have such a large book of business we can negotiate heavily with these people if there's five of them how
075does that work exactly so then then you get into this scenario of well why would agent a recommend Sigma and Agent B recommend Florida blue if it really comes down to the Actuarial study there's something mathematically off off-kilter there well not I'm not implying that any agents do this please don't misread me but I will tell you that if an agent has a way to develop a revenue stream that's satisfied through chapter 6 00 and perfectly legal as building a larger book of business and they can move $160 million of Revenue being pop County schools into a carrier's book can you imagine what the bonus on the back end looks like 100% thank you for explaining that thank you not once again I'm not happening I'm not accusing anyone of anything we're going to move
076on thank you Mr sharpless uh I want to thank ail for coming today and and for this presentation uh it's been eye opening I think um the key is uh the unaffiliated licensed health insurance agent and so my question really is for the superintendent you said you're going to potentially bring other companies will they will these also be unaffiliated companies yes sir okay perfect so uh thank you for being here and and and presenting what you had but I want to make sure that the future ones will also be unaffiliated because to me that's the key Mr Keys um I'm going to Echo some of that I also want to thank Mr Alberton for coming to today and explain it to us and I think the big part about it was the explanation of the
077affiliation and you guys being unaffiliated um this may come as a shock to some of the other board members but I also at one point held a 215 license so um I couldn't go out and make money until you know I was registered with a company and I was a multi-line agent so I left that industry like M Miller as well um you know for for other reasons but uh I want to thank you for your presentation and to the superintendent for um making that Appo to to say we need to really have the benefit of having someone unaffiliated so we're we're getting the best result and Miss Fields I wanted to know the the cost oh no ma'am we're we're not at that stage yet um but I can be I'd be happy to
078ask them to submit a prospectus and we can go from there but respectfully I'd like to wait till we actually formally advertise I I don't want the perception to be that we're giving it an unfair advantage to any particular group or party well I would ask that if everybody that's coming so yes ma'am Mr Murphy is is a perspective asking him to submit a subsequent perspectus allowable in the absence of an ITN or an RPF right correct so I don't know that gentlemen you're in a position to provide I guess my question might might not be today but I'm just saying typically we know what the cost is going to be ma'am so at some point in time not today I think gentlemen you got your marching orders from Miss Fields if we could receive
079uh a a perspectus just kind of a a draft summary of what your fee structure looks like and potential costs for the district um to be finalized if there's a negotiation or how we should depending on how the board authorizes me to pursue so sir thank you gentlemen and then my other question is what what other school districts are you working with we work in an ongoing basis with Charlotte Schools Hardy schools doto schools hindry schools Leon County Schools we have worked on special projects with a variety of other school districts and we work with some other municipalities cities and counties as well thank you and lastly Mr ni U thank you again for your presentation after what I've heard I'm certainly happy and glad that I picked educational uh route to be a teacher
080and uh but uh you're doing a great job and it sounds u sounds very uh interesting and um looking forward to listening some more thank you very much Happy New Year happy New Year thank you gentleman ER further questions or comments at this time board members I'm going to transition uh to Mr pittz I want to say thank you for your flexibility thank you for your attentiveness we we covered a lot of very significant topics here at the front uh please be kind to Mr pittz for the remainder of the three items um before you we have a community group um that's consistent with our our process of bringing in Partners to share how they contribute to P County Public Schools and our and our staff and our students and then there's one other item
081that's a grant before you and then the last one is a close session item uh pertaining to safety so we'll leave it at that and then I believe there's some training for the board so thank you and um again I will notify you as soon as I get a response from the state board tomorrow thank you all very much thank you thank [Music] you good morning good morning I I know there's no reason that you would not be kind to me correct hold it okay we'll hold that all right all right the the next item on our agenda today is going to be um Aerospace Center for excellence um they're here to present uh their partnership with Poke County um schools and we have Mr Conrad uh the president and CEO of this group and
082Eric Crum vice president well good morning to the board good morning Mr Pitts good morning to staff um first of all just want to say thank you for the opportunity to be with you all this morning appreciate this time I know you guys are all super busy doing other things so I appreciate that um but you know again my name is Jee Conrad I'm the president and CEO for the Aerospace Center for excellence and the sunun Aerospace Expo um and we are here today to talk about our mission the other 51 weeks out of the Year our mission is to engage educate and accelerate the next generation of Aerospace professionals and we do that with tremendous Partnerships like we have here with the district and we also do it through our sixday event which is
083the sun of fun Aerospace Expo which is April 1st through 6 so thank you for that Shamus plug but why I do that is those six days generate 80% of our funding that go into our other 51 weeks out of the year so again want to thank you for the opportunity to be here um and right now I'd like to introduce Mr Eric Crump who's our vice president for the Aerospace Center for excellence and he's going to walk you through the presentation this morning thank you Jean board members good morning um it's a as Jean said it's a pleasure to be able to be here and speak with you guys um it's always great to see you guys out at solo to success uh to honor the students that have soloed each year um and
084so I just saw a few of you a few months ago at that um but I I want to go through as Jean said the other 51 weeks of the year and I want to start with this uh quote from Wilbur Wright which is sort of our guiding principle on the education side of what we do um when asked about their first flight in 1903 and um subsequently how to continue that momentum and how to train further Pilots because they were no pilot training programs Wilber historically said it's possible to fly without Motors but not without knowledge and skill um and that's what we do we we believe that um there is certainly a a methodology for kids to find their way into any career that they choose we think that Aviation is the great
085motivator it's it is a thing that makes kids look up I still look up when I hear airplanes fly over my head I can't help it um and whether our our children end up finding a career in uh Aviation or Aerospace that's really beside the point what we're trying to do is to teach them to love learning and we use airplanes as the carrot to encourage kids to participate to learn and to be motivated uh to grow in their lives we do that through as Jean said our mission to engage educate and accelerate I've broken it down into just a couple of programs into each of these areas um we would need a a whole work session for me to tell you the things that we do the other 51 weeks the year but I
086wanted you to be aware if you're familiar with the flying but you're not aware of beside maybe what goes on at Central Florida Aerospace Academy the other things that happen on our campus um this morning actually they're probably done now uh story time starts for our youngest kids I think our youngest kid so far was 6 days old and I asked his mom why she brought him to Story Time at 6 days old and she said my son sa would never forgive me if we didn't come to story time so I came for him um we have families that come every week we average 8 80 to 85 uh people there every week who come it's early literacy um numbers shapes colors but really just it's airplanes it's in the florid Air Museum uh kids
087stick around and play on our playground they learn more about Aviation this is a free event that's available to anybody in the community to come uh stem Sprouts is our prek enrichment program uh we have an after school program which serves the students at Central Florida airospace Academy specifically they're out of school at 1:30 which is very early for families it's very early for kids um so we give them the opportunity to actually put into practice what they just learned in the classroom so they can literally walk across the street and continue to get their hands dirty um or fly flight Sims or build things um or maintain our uh and restore our Fleet of aircraft so we're excited for that Ace's high achievement is um you guys remember BookIt do they still do book
088it so I was not a big fan of reading as a child but I read my book so I could get my personal pan pizza um this is book it but for airplanes so as you continue to uh participate in school maintain a clean discipline record good attendance uh we reward you with things like a trip to Kennedy Space Center or a flight suit with your name on it or a trip to iFly in Tampa to do indoor skydiving so it's an incentive based program to encourage kids to stay in school and to continue to do good in school and of course we're out in the community all the time doing things like this and working directly with kids on the education side I'm going to talk more about the field trip program in a
089moment so I'll skip that for now but our summer camp program is very robust we have about 300 kids every summer that come through our program uh from future Engineers to Future airframe and power plant mechanics we have a take flight camp that focuses primarily on flight and then our shikin flight Camp which is really designed to en encourage young women to see that Aviation is a career that is open to them as well uh and for the last two years that's the first camp that fills up every year so that's working we are getting that message out we support our education community and teachers and schools um obviously you guys are very familiar with our two Central Florida Aerospace Academy campuses one on our campus in Lakeland and then the the second campus that
090began a few years ago at the Winter Haven airport um we're very excited about the development of that program and the ability to clone programming to clone the success of that program in Lakeland and to bring that opportunity to the east side of the county um very excited to continue conversations with you all and the superintendent about the ongoing nature of our relationship there uh to those that maybe don't know or are not aware um we funded the construction Central florid Aerospace Academy in Lakeland in 2012 uh the school board rents that facility from us and the proceeds from that rent go into the central Florida Aerospace Academy Foundation which enables us to give out two Private Pilot scholarships every month to allow students in pul County to learn to fly at no charge to
091them to dat we've had 184 Pilots certified through that scholarship program who otherwise would not have been able to afford Flight Training so thank you very much for your partnership in that way and we look forward to continuing that in the future we have two High School flying clubs one in Lakeland the Lakeland Arrow club and a second club that began in Winter Haven the aspiring aviators Arrow club that we participate in and we are also the landlord for the Travis Technical College adult airframe of power plant program training adult airframe of power plant mechanics um on our facility which recently uh just added a night shift so we've doubled our throughput of um of Maintenance training on the field we're very pleased about that as well on the accelerate side um the flight scholarship
092is obvious um most people know about that by now um giving out those two scholarships every year every month um we're able to get kids into the air many people may not realize though that that scholarship also funds our continuing education program so every may we hold an an event called celebration of success on our campus we bring in the uh senior class from Central Florida airspace Academy and we fund up to $5,000 a year for uh deserving students to continue their education in trade school Pilot School College University programs to continue the journey and every year we give out about $100,000 every May in continuing education scholarships to that program as well I told you I'd come back to the field trip program um when I first arrived at Ace uh almost 3 years
093ago we we had field trips from our schools that that would come randomly that knew that the programming was available they would come in the first year we wanted to really standardize some lesson plans look at some tough testing standards some areas where students typically don't do well in math and science and really focus our field trip programming around those things to show kids that that would be a cool thing to learn when they go back to school what we noticed in that program was that we had a lot of participation but we were not reaching the title one schools only about 20% of our field trip attendees were coming from Title One schools we realized that funding was an issue we went to our Municipal Partners in Lakeland in Winter Haven and in Barto
094I just want to publicly thank the airport administrations and the city municipalities for their support of the field trip program um last year and this year they came to the table with with funding so that we were able to make the field trip program free to any fifth grader last year in P County and this year we expanded that to any fifth through e8th grader in pul County um and so that you know um last year we had about 21 uh just just under 2200 students that come came through that program um of those students though almost 90% were from tital one schools so we were able by reducing the funding hurdle by reducing issues for reserving buses and know superintendent height is gone but I wanted to thank him for his support and helping
095us streamline the process of requesting buses guaranteed approval for field trips and also Jeff Hancock who was instrumental in helping us sort of understand how field trips work for the school board we don't we don't do that side of it so it really is a testament to partnership we wouldn't have been able to do it on our own obviously the school board couldn't have done that on its own either we were able to work together though and accomplish something really amazing when you look at this year though we're currently scheduled and this is a little bit old from the time I sent this to Janette we're um a little over 3900 students this year that'll be able to participate in this program and no cost to the student no cost to the schools um for
096attendance or for transportation we're covering those costs through generous support um as Jean mentioned um it's almost time for Sun and Fun so we do hope you'll all come um and everybody else who's watching please do come April 1st to the 6th I it is a really fun party it's loud and it's awesome but it really is for a reason um when we when we have this event that those six days are for the other 51 weeks of the Year thank you for your time and I'm happy to answer any questions genan will as well we we do have questions Mr sharpless I'm gonna direct you no real question more comment um I just first want to say uh thank you for your partnership with po County Public Schools I uh I was able to
097attend that solo to success uh celebration and it was certainly a celebration those students were when they were putting their brick down someone were stomping it in there they're really excited about it um so I want to thank you for that and uh all the partnership you have with us uh you know it's the first time I ever actually went went ac across the street there and went to the the museum I was very very impressive I mean you guys have a great facility there and I would highly encourage people the public to go visit um it's really educational and and all the great programming you have I just want to say thank you thank you M Miller yeah I just want to say um thanks for coming today and sharing I think this helps
098get out the word of what you're doing and what you provide there a couple years ago I went to Sun and Fun on a golf cart with the students and I was excited to see what I was looking at but to hear the students explain um what I was looking at and the opportunities they were given I can tell you that that um that's going to give back for Generations so I appreciate the efforts made there I'd love to come to more events so please make sure we're on that list um and to be able to celebrate the students and I can tell you girls in in um in Flight is something that's very important I've watched two very successful young women go through your program but when I visit your schools we're still lacking
099um we're still lacking that and so I'm hoping we can encourage more girls to get involved in engineering um and flight and all of it so providing the opportunity I think is something that is amazing for p County and I appreciate what you're doing thank you Miss Fields thank you Jan I don't think I've had a chance to congratulate you on becoming the executive director I think it's just awesome the experience that you bring you did an amazing job when you were at the airport and you're bringing that uh now where you are so thank God for you uh it's amazing all of the things that you all are doing that we might not even be knowledgeable of so we appreciate you all coming for your presentation today and I think that one of the
100things that you are do well and I know that we do well is we really uh thank Mr James Ray because had it not been for him we wouldn't have the Aviation Academy uh many many years ago along with uh Gail McKenzie been the superintendent at that time so there's a great history and the partnership is great and I believe there's a young man that used to be a student at the Aviation Academy that now works handing in hand with Miss Crowley I believe um and so that says a lot uh about what we've been able to do as far as partnering and and and students being prepared for the workplace and he's very impressive uh so just thank you all for all that you do and we're happy to be a part of the
101partnership thank you Dr Allen y thank you Mr pres you're welcome great to have youall in the boardroom today um I I was think looking at your artwork um you guys recently hired a Florida Southern uh student um graph designer so uh really appreciate you keeping local talent and I love bantering with him when I see him and he talks uh so highly of you all so appreciate the work keeping local talent but when I look at your social and I just see all those young kids in in your your spaces um and then I'm just like so impressed with uh the accolades of the individuals that you put in front of the students um it's just like pretty incredible so uh thanks for just you know raising up that next Generation uh for us
102so I appreciate the partnership and the information today thank you no further questions Mr Conrad Mr CR thank you for being here today thank you very much y all right board members next we have um Gear Up partnership Grant proposal we have Mr Andy Baldwin our senior director of of federal programs and grants good morning board um the item before you today is information for you in preparation for a subsequent um item on the January 28th meeting where we'll actually ask for your formal approval to apply for this Grant on February 3rd um the gear up Grant we've been working on for some time uh we anticipated that the Grant application would actually be released this spring but the US Department of Education surprised us and actually released it uh late November and then gave
103us a February 3rd um due date so we've been scrambling to get everything together but we have a wide group of uh team members who've been putting this application together um the gearup grant is a competitive Federal grant it is funded by the US Department of Education and it has a total of $35 million uh for the nation we're not asking for the full $35 million we're willing to share with some of the other school districts um this grant program is designed to increase the number of low-income students who are prepared to enter and succeed in post post-secondary education um this grant is kind of unique in that it will follow a cohort of seventh grade students throughout their middle school and into their high school year so it's a six-year Grant um we have
104looked at the the current sixth graders and a set of schools and identified that cohort of seventh graders for next year that we would like to follow through that and help them to uh see some post-secondary success we have listed here the uh middle schools that we are going to Target um it includes seven middle schools and an additional three uh combination schools then the way this grant works is once the students have finished with their middle school the grant follows the the students to the schools that have the highest matriculation rate so um this the students going from Daniel Jenkins we would go to the high school where more than half of the students are going and support them at that uh subsequent high school it's much easier at the combination high schools where
105those students typically follow the feeder pattern and just matriculate directly into their high schools uh the grant funding is set at $800 per student and our current uh numbers show the our cohort for seventh grade of those students next year will be right around 1,910 students so that would give us a total of uh 9,168 th000 over the six-year period for this grant I mentioned earlier that the uh deadline for this grant is February 3rd so we will be bringing an item to you on January 28th to seek your approval to submit this to the United States Department of Education the project period for this grant is uh 91 of 25 so it is anticipated that we would start this grant program if awarded this next school year and then the grant program would go
106through uh 2031 it does have a matching requirement of 50% they call it 50% but it's really a dollar Ford dooll match so our total program costs would be over $18 million but um we are able to apply for a waiver to um reduce our uh match requirement by 70% so our total match requirement if we approve for that waiver would only be about $2.7 million over the life of the grant or around about $450,000 each year we do not expect to have to use local dollars for that but instead be able to use in-kind matches through our partner service and support and uh some of the existing staff that are going to be providing support to this as in kind contributions so we don't anticipate having to come to the board for actual dollars
107just using in kind contributions for our match component I provided a link here um there's quite a bit of information out on the web about this grant so I wanted to make it easy for you guys if you guys wanted to look for for more information and then I'm happy to answer any questions either now or before the January 28th meeting so that you guys can make a good decision seeing no questions thank you Mr Baldwin so before we move on I want to introduce somebody you might have saw her sitting with me uh earlier on the front row it's uh Cindy celo she is our principal of mberry middle and she is shadowing job shadowing me today so I wanted to to let her feel like what the hot seat you know down there
108and that's not because of of board members it's just because of the way the air condition works right there so I just want to introduce her um I was surprised anybody might want to do my job in the future but she's the first person that's ever asked the job shadow me so thank you for being here today the next item on the agenda would be budget and Staffing there is no new information to present I do have information that was presented before uh Christmas break at the last board meeting uh work session in December I can answer question questions if you have any questions um I can pull that presentation up or we can move on if there's no questions I see no questions and we will move on the next um items are informational
109items we have Head Start start uh Services report um and we also have the superintendent evaluation for 2324 there any comments or questions on those I have a question you do well let's address Miss I do see Miss Fields let me there we go thank you this this is to uh Dr Allen are we going to get the uh remainder of the evaluations of the other staff the compilations and all that yes ma'am um I have met with our internal auditor and I will be scheduling an opportunity to meet with u Miss CET as well so once I compile those and complete those I'll send out that information thank you that's it thank you and Mrs White thank you I know in subsequent years we've had a conversation about superintendent Hyde's contract and his um
110current salary level as he has not had any salary increases since he came to us three years ago now is that something that we're looking at at having I know when we brought it up last time he wasn't ready for that until we had data to back it up so yeah I mean I can speak to that I I've definitely asked uh to place that on the agenda uh in a subsequent meeting as well for us to discuss thank you Miss Fields I think that this is just my opinion before we do anything with this superintendent's salary we need to make sure that we've taken care of our other employees as well and I know that that's on the table so I just want to make sure it's aligned together thank you Miss Miller thank
111you Mr Pitts I enjoy you sitting here next to me um chair Allan I I have a question and this might be for later um this this brings up another reason why I think we need to get together before September so um and you might already have this scheduled for later but I would like to discuss going back to dates maybe March or sometime um other than September for us to be able to be in a room and have lots of conversation I think today's process with that hearing brought up another reason why I would like to talk to my colleagues about some of our processes that we follow um so I don't know if you want to address that topic now or later but I would I would like to look at a retreat
112e either adding it to what Mr superintendent Hyde needs or own thank you seeing no further questions we will move on and that ends the superintendent part of the agenda and I will turn the next item over to you Dr Allen which would be item um F1 new business for attorney search great so uh we are now down to F1 and we are so happy to have our guests with us today so um if we can have our consultant Mr Doug Thomas close session after yeah and you are recognized Mr Thomas thank you and I think there's a PowerPoint is that going to be reloaded just to we can work through it but as that's working through the technology I can kind of do some introductory comments as well oh there we go okay it's
113um it's not our go that great thank you appreciate it all right great well thank you for the opportunity to be with you uh this morning as well uh as a little bit of a background as mentioned my name is Doug Thomas I'm an executive vice president with strategic government resources which is the firm that you've all engaged to assist you in your recruitment of your general counsel um for some background information for those who may be watching or in the audience U what we do at the front end of this process is to get an opportunity to meet with all of you which I've done I've held uh uh Zoom uh meetings with each of you to learn a little bit more about what you were looking for and the position and the challenges
114the opportunities that you see that your next general Council will be facing and therefore the district will be facing above and beyond that working with your HR department I had an opportunity to meet with the superintendent and a variety of other staff members including some staff members within the general council's office to make sure we fully understand how your operation works the issues the types of workflow the types of inquiries that you receive and all that led to the document that you had hopefully had a chance to review at this stage the position profile brochure that talks a little bit about how we will Market this position so we'll talk about the district and the the challenges and the opportunities and the position and things of that nature so um beyond that uh when I
115was first engaged I had expressed some concerns about some compensation issues and some potential benefit issues and so I was asked to take a look at that as well so this morning what I'd like to do is just kind of walk you through where we are at this stage get any feedback that you have on the brochure uh and also certainly present some information about what we think um your salary range ought to be uh so we'll capture all that information then I also have a proposed search timeline that we've tried to do uh in concert with your regular board meetings and working with Dr alen recognizing when when members and trying to schedule all of you gets to be a bit of a challenge so with that um if you're ready I'm prepared to
116just work your way through it so super um so for the benefit of the background piece of information um our process really does involve uh first and foremost getting to know your organization getting to know you as the appointing authority uh that involved a pretty extensive background information and discussions with each of you and your staff members as mentioned uh from there after you tell us to hit go and launch this job we'll be promoting the position through all the things that we do uh we have folks that are involved in helping to promote um the through our social media marketing and all the other forms and networks that we use to try to attract quality candidates for this effort and and then as the process goes through I describe that we're at the front
117end or we will be at the front end of kind of a funnel-shaped process at the very top of that funnel we're going to have a candidates that come in that we're going to know basically what they've told us that about themselves and so as we Whittle that down to the to the applicants and then work with you to go through semi-finalist and selecting semi-finalist they'll be responding with additional information that will start to unpack kind of their style and their background so that will help you kind of narrow that that group of semi-finalists then down to a smaller group of finalists at that point we start investing even more work and energy and resource in terms of additional uh media searches and criminal history credit and reference checks and you know getting to know
118them at a much uh much more granular level um and then I'll walk you through some other options as we go through what your on-site interview process starts to look like as well but the goal here is to hopefully make this process as seamless as possible uh I know that your previous General uh Council have been with you for a long time so you have not probably been through this process any of you I suspect they were I think your incumbent was here before all of you were here probably at this stage of the game so uh our goal is to help you uh walk through this process because it's something we do regularly and certainly work with boards and elected officials such as yourselves on a regular basis so the brochure that hopefully you've
119had a chance to uh to review by now uh talks a little bit about the marketing of this position so we certainly talk about the organization about your size your structure and the program that you offer we certainly talk about the governance and how this position and and how you are are structured as an organization uh then we start to drill down into the department we talk about the position and how it's structured um I have tried to identify we'll talk about that here shortly about some of the issues that I heard common themes it's like a word cloud to me the more often I heard these things the more likely it's something that your folks are going to be dealing with and so uh hopefully we've been able to characterize those appropriately uh and
120then in a similar vein after talking to all of you and your sta um there are themes that come forward with the ideal candidate characteristics that uh hopefully reflect collectively what you what you're looking for in this position um and then we talk a little bit about the education and the re experience that you're looking for compensation and benefits and how to apply and all the other resources with the links to the material the goal here is this document that we will use to market the position really becomes the lens in which your prospective candidates will evaluate whether they think they're a good fit or not for this opportunity so if we get this right it helps our whole process go forward and making sure that we're we're attracting the type of quality candidates with
121the right background and skill sets and hard and soft skills and things of that nature to go forward so um the items that we identified that I heard discussions take place with you and your staff really centered around four different things now these are things above and beyond the general day-to-day operations that the general council is involved with um I know you're in the midst of some public private conversations about school facilities and there was a lot of discussion and angst and uncertainty of what that looked like we don't know if your candidate's going to have that background or not but we felt that it was important to say this is an issue that on day one they're likely to be dealing with in some way shape or form um as you know you have
122I believe 36 charter schools that you've authorized here that's more than some and less than others but it's a pretty extensive component and those come up for reviews and Analysis and and renewals as well as any potential new items and all of you and your staff talked about the role of the general counsil being involved and of helping you and and crafting that process and making sure that process runs smoothly um a significant piece of what I learned about this position as I spoke with uh your representatives and yourselves is that a good portion of this job is involved in mediation and arbitration and facilitation certainly spoken with John Murphy and his colleague uh to as they've stepped into this role to get their perspective as well about what happens and your staff has said
123a good portion of this person's time is involved in doing that type of work so we just want to make sure that that was characterized in the material so that we have an a understanding from your perspective candidates of of what they would like what a typical day might be involved with and then the other piece um even though you're a very large District I think as I recall you're the seventh largest district school district in the state public school system you're a relatively small office um I've I've got some comparables that your staff and and what we have done with sgr and comparable positions have put put together um but um you really have one attorney and two administrative support Personnel there's another attorney that works with the school superintendent that uh is kind
124of a tag team approach but that's a different position overall um and so that was something I thought was important to identify as well that this is not one where you got an army of four five or six other uh attorneys that are representing you now with that there's a lot of work and work working with outside counsel for all sorts of different specialized litigations and program so we thought it was important to say that although you don't have the the the general Council doesn't have a a quadr of attorneys working directly for them they have a quadr of external councel working for them and they have to manage that process and that's a pretty a pretty extensive slate of activities as well so um before I go into the next step maybe I would
125stop there and just get any reaction if there were any if hopefully we've characterized what what you all were looking for in this position but this is your opportunity to let me know if we need to make any tweaks or adjustments in the brochure and then we can talk a little bit about compensation and search timelines and things sorry no Mr pits it was done very late that's okay hi thank you for joining us today and and listening to all of our input um under the day-to-day staff is that where you're going to include a lot of the um a lot of the focus on advising the board on current an upcoming um legislation and or policies that we have to discuss while in a meeting I know that a lot of what we had
126to we had to ask our former attorney very kind man who was here for a very long time um we had to ask him almost it's almost an Associated as meeting facilitator but I don't I don't know how to describe it you and I had a great conversation about it would that be considered under the basic things or would that be considered because as you put charter school here but there's also voucher we have a lot of things happening here I don't know that Charter review is any more of an opportunity or a challenge um because we have a whole Charter office that does that so I'm not sure how we rank these um I mean they're all important very important things I think the public private Partnerships is something that we are coming up
127on that's relatively new that we would need somebody to understand the law and how those things work when I saw trear schools I was just a little bit surprised I would that include all contract negotiations so those are my two because I know that West did a lot of our contract reviews and I mean going even down to purchasing contracts and how we work through um those departments is that something that will be included in this and that probably why we should get together and talk as a board or is this or is that something that will that is not going to be considered in this role and given to somebody else um so um couple things there so so I'll kind of take those as I as in reaction so the reason I put
128Charter Schools is virtually everyone talked about them okay no one really mentioned vouchers I understand that's another program but so as I said in a word cloud concept if seven of you all identifi Charter Schools it's likely I'm going to put that there because it's top of mine for you so I put it there we can we can expand that section I mean this is the opportunity where if I have to make some tweaks in the document we can do that if you want me to add vouchers uh or any other programs we could certainly add that to the charter school section and just modify that a little bit that's not much of a of a tweak to to uh won't take you know very very quickly for us to make that adjustment if that's
129something you'd like me to do well and another board could have um input on this and maybe there's another title for that because similar to we just found out and you might not want to call the voucher program there it's there's other names for it but alternative to what traditionally what we decide here um we've had conversation based on how that's funded there's been some things that have happened in our practices currently um that need that may we need to talk to counsel about about you know how the law works with that and how we can go about facilitating that in a better way so I don't I don't know if and it's my colleagues can chime in if they think Charter Schools needs to be its own or if it needs to be like
130an alternative to our typical traditional funding lawmaking policymaking schools I will I will comment for just a second because I have the opportunity th major topics um and and that's what you focused on correct is is what what we were telling you that we dealt on a day-to-day basis uh with with our former attorney corly yeah I'm G to move on Miss Fields has a question I was basically gonna gonna say what you just said U Mr Pitts I know from previous experience West was very heavily involved with anything related to Charter Schools going to the uh state level when appeals and everything happen as well so I think whever we get needs to be very well-rounded related to Charter Schools the laws and statutes and all of that and as I said if if
131the board desires I can broaden that section in charter schools and talk about vouchers I can work with staff to get your appropriate wording um to make sure it it encompasses more than that and you know add a sentence or so if necessary if if that's desired I mean I would defer to staff I can tell you for one just for an example we've recently found that we have have over 700 students who are getting a different line they're going through the alternative funding through our voucher programs um they're also taking classes with us that we haven't been compensated for and so that's a legal aspect of how we approach that and how we make sure we're being compensated it's it's such a relatively new subject that it doesn't I'm not I don't know that
132it needs to be um it's however I think deferring to staff how they see that but I know Mr pitch you've also been involved in that I just want to make sure the person that's coming understands that the legal requirement for all this new legislation including um the choice is the choice options are no longer just Charter and it affects us legally and financially thank you okay thank um I I I'll just I I think it's appropriate given the the fact that it's you've got that many students and it's an issue let me let me work with your staff we'll get that adjusted and we'll factored into the equation we'll take a I don't think we need a paragraph but we can probably at least highlight it under that section and we'll figure out the
133appropriate way to title it um your other question um Miss Miller was also about um the kind of the the governance and the interaction with the board I've tried to identify that especially in the ideal candidate attributes that that's kind of an ongoing process I will tell you from my experience both as a city manager but also um in working with City and County attorneys and and John would certainly I'm sure address this as well that it's kind of it comes with a territory that that's an ongoing process that when you're on the Das you're likely to get called upon I know there was a desire many of you spoke about the desire for your attorney to be engaged in a regular ongoing basis when you get stuck or when the board seems to be
134you know challenged about what that looks like so I've tried to characterize that that that's the type of skill set that someone that's that's willing to be not overshadow you but help you as you go through your governance processes so uh hopefully we've captured that but if there's uh I'll take one more look at that if we need to tweak something I W allowed to to make emphasize that as well thank you okay any other questions on kind of the the generic part of it and then we can talk a little bit about compensation I see no other questions you can thank you Mr I had oh I'm I'm Sorry Miss Miss Fields I uh app about uh the vouchers and anything else uh char all that however when you do that make sure that
135we don't lose a charter school piece no I I will add two I want not subtract okay but I think that we definitely need to uh honor her request surely my my my thoughts are I may not just title that section Charter Schools I you know I'll work with the staff to get the appropriate lingo there and then we'll probably add a sentence about charter schools and as well as vouchers but let me let me you're in an area I don't know much about so I want to make sure I talk to your staff to get that but we can we can incorporate that yep okay right thank you else all right well one of the piece that um I was asked to review both by your staff as well as by a number of
136you and I know when you were debating about filling this position as you know you you started a recruitment in this effort you didn't really get very qualified pool of candidates most of them were pretty raw and and unskilled some of them freshed out of Law School uh part of that is is how you Market the position but also part of that is your overall compensation range and I I I raised when I first spoke with your staff about that um I've do enough city and county attorney searches which are not identical but comparable many of the skill sets would be very similar and so uh your staff had originally prepared some information uh that came through looking at a number of I'll say from your approaches comparable school districts in terms of size and
137scale and scope and whether they were internal or external U general counsel type services uh I will tell you that I've gone back through that information we've updated that some of that information is still pretty data as you see in this this slide some of it goes back to 2019 some of them are 2023 some of them are 2024 so uh it's the best information we could get in working with your staff through the database you've got but what you what you have presently and I've highlighted the P County Public School general Council position uh as you can see you're about 850,000 a population with about 97,000 students and you can compare that to some other groups and your your at least initially your salary range was 129 260 to 172 502 and that obviously
138is a most current salary I've tried to look at some of the comparables both from in this slide then another slide looking at cities and counties as well based on your size and the comparable number of students that you have to give you a sense of it as you can see I've I've looked at Bard County Lee County and pelis County as as kind of comparables if you will um and this is more of an art than a science anybody that does uh this will tell you that you got to massage this a little bit uh those comparables all reflect salaries back in 2023 so I'm assuming they've been adjusted at least once if not twice since that point so please take that into mind and then and just as a sidebar note um because
139obviously a space that I work in pretty regularly is in city and county and general uh City County attorney positions General Council type positions so some of these represent some communities I have personally done recruitments for recently in some cases just recently uh some of these I have relationships because I've done other recruitments for those organizations since they were able to get me some comperable information as well and so I put the pole County salary there but now I realize it's not identical but you're also looking for in some of your desired skill sets board certified in state local government operations those would be very comparable skills that the certifications these organizations would be looking at um I will tell you that there was also a desire to find folks that might have certific education
140when I went to the Florida bar search just last week to kind of get a snapshot there were like 20 people that were certified in the entire state so it's a relatively small pool I don't know that we're going to necessarily get that right off the bat but there certainly are more State local County Board Ser certified uh candidates and so I wanted to give you this type of salary information as well because I think you're likely to see some candidates come from that those pools that are going to have that background uh there's also certification at the Florida bar in administration and some other sources that we've we've flagged so uh we'll certainly go out and Market that but my sense is when it was all said and done uh as I marked in
141the brochure my sense is your target salary range is probably in that 190 to 220 range and um because you've already been in the marketplace with a lower salary range I didn't want to just put in the brochure salary dependent upon qualifications and experience because people that have seen that before are going to say oh well you know I know what that salary was and I wasn't interested in that before for whatever reason so I think we should be identifying a range that's my best guess but I recognize that has internal issues and Equity but I know in talking with the HR uh folks as well there was a a desire that we probably need to have that conversation with you as a board so I'll stop again there and address and we can go
142back and forth the documents as necessary Dr Allen thank you Mr pittz just a general question I know you talk about the Art and Science of this uh just because I do know about the Lee County one which was a recent uh hire how many of these um would have been just the salary that you get from you know like our public information uh but or some that have actually gone through an attorney search where then they re-evaluate it and adjust it uh and is Caroline yeah all right so car the the background of this material largely came from your staff I formatted it a little bit differently to make it for ease of presentation materials but my understanding is that there was a public records request out to a variety's districts they all directed
143you back to this website and so the website is what the website is Dr Allen it does not give you any of that material it really says here it was and when it was it doesn't tell me how long they've been there sometimes if they if um if there's multiple years of a given person I know they've maybe been there three four five years but once again I you know not being the source uh devel I'm I'm accessing a database that's that the school district had available to it so I can't answer fully those questions indeed thank you that's all I need okay no no further question you good with a 190 220 then I'm hearing kind of a consensus without any opposition to that as a as a desired salary range that's what I
144that's what I put in the brochure I just want to make sure you're comfortable with that before we go live Mrs Fields is it typical that the general counsel is the second highest paid uh person in the school district uh I don't know that now I will tell you that my experience typically for cities counties and other organizations that have boards typically your superintendent your manager your administrator would be typically your highest and your the next other person that would report to the board is typically your City attorney or County attorney and they are normally the second highest yes that would be a fair statement at least in my experience across not just here in Florida but across the country and organizations well just from looking at this um SC uh scale here the salary
145scale um if you look at Panela County that's close to us as far as the population um their school board attorney is almost at 223 well they are and that was in 2023 ex yeah so that's that's a little dated right and so I think that in order for us to attract the the the right uh candidates we're going to have to go a little bit higher than we probably feel comfortable doing I I'm certainly comfortable putting a a higher if you want to go to 2 no no no I'm not saying I'm saying higher than 172 oh oh I'm sorry oh yeah I no I I would agree with you I mean youve you've been to the marketplace you've seen what you what you've attracted in that regard now obviously our our out will
146be a much more targeted approach than maybe what you've done in the past but yeah I I would find it very hard that you're going to find someone with the skill sets and experience and background you're looking for at that level if I just give you that example i' I've done I'm about to do a launch for the the City attorney in Northport uh but I've done four of their assistant City attorneys if you look at theirs and they have at least five plus years of experience their um some of their positions are are above where your your starting salary is here and and that's a much you know know that's a community of 89,000 and there's four attorneys plus the City attorney and that staff so um yeah I think you're you're starting your
147your 172 is not going to be an attractive salary for most qualified candidates agreed okay Miss Miller I just I agree with you I also look at the counties and the cost of living in different counties and um even locally we have to be mindful of what we're selling we're selling different year you're not you are working 12 months but through the summer you are not it doesn't look like the 10 months look much different than than what you would do at a firm also um the time frame a lot of attorney a lot of attorneys and some that I spoke to about this position said you're going to sell quality of life you're going to sell someone who's either leaving or has young kids um there is there are people that are interested it
148is a narrow field but you're not going to be able to sell the salary U range you're going to have to sell what you're offering to that person um and I think that's both considering the salary and the benefits of working for a school district and what you're doing um and I know it's a high stress environment but you know working in a firm is much different and so I appreciate that you've taken on the initi the initiative to talk about salary I think it that was the biggest thing that stood out but I also want to say we sent this out once I can confidently say that it wasn't done thoroughly or to the channels that that I'd hoped it had been done to so I'm just hoping using a concentrated effort that you're
149going to give us Us in itself will bring um people in to interview I can I can I appreciate that in the effort and having done a lot of of city and county attorney searches I can tell you that although we do advertising we're going to recommend some advertising as you seen in the presentation because you got to capture that but most of we're doing a lot more who else has been in searches I'm going to you know these districts I just mentioned they're going to get information I'm going to find out who those folks are and make sure they're aware of it and so that's there in today's market place that's how you have to recruit for positions of this type of stature absolutely okay one other piece just on this and it's on
150this slide as well um for consideration I don't need direction on it today we can see that as we go deeper into the process but I just want you to be aware uh it's my understanding this position has not although you are kind of an F FRS State Retirement System I do not I never got full clarification but it's my understanding the position was not considered in Senior Management uh I will tell you that many of the lead positions we see for City and County attorneys that's something that comes forward so that's a little different multiplier a little different benefit um and the other piece I want to let you know is that often times we would see vehicle allowances and relocation assistance depending upon where the person's coming from so I just wanted to
151to highlight that we don't need to finalize that today as you get to the point where we're getting closer with a candle that you like those are likely to be items of points of consideration so I just want you to get caught off guard with that later as well um so this is uh I mentioned about advertising most of these are uh relatively either free or relatively low cost these are where we would recommend we'll be placing ads we'll work with your staff to make sure you're good with these but if you're good we'll hit go when we launch the job and then above and beyond that we do all the other things that sgr does with our social media and our marketing our job alerts and all the other things that are happening but
152I just wanted to be aware this is kind of the the the market that when we're advertising especially here in Florida what we're looking for what we'll what we'll try to to Target for as well um and then I just I know some of you came on board I think after we were selected so I don't know if everybody kind of understood what this process is so I want to spend just a few minutes just to explain where we are and the steps that will take place and then we can we can close on what the uh the proposed search timeline looks like uh the first part has been completed the organizational inquiry analysis I've met with all of you we've developed the brochure we're here today to approve that with those adjustments we'll make
153those adjustments and we should be able to hit go this week anticipating for projection purposes before the end of the week um we'll do this for about a 30-day window and we'll be out of your hair during that window but I will keep in touch with your HR department to give you updates about halfway into that how the pool is developing demographics you know what we're doing to market the position so you're aware of that I'm also available you've all got my contact information if you got a question feel free to give me a shout as we go forward um as we finish and the position closes um I'll be back preparing a review of that um we'll end up I worked with John I know there's been a recent attorney general's opinion about presidential
154searches that aren't exactly like this but I've looked through that and we've talked through the way to make sure that we don't run any challenges what'll happen is we'll end up um doing a a presentation with you uh to present the quality of the candidate pools you'll we can send you their cover letters and resumes you've got all that ahead of time we'll work through that and out of that group you'll select a smaller number of folks that you want to learn more about um from that Point those folks will do questionnaires and some video interview uh recorded um responses we'll start some media searches I'm doing some of that at the front end but we'll start with a Lexus Nexus type Media review uh and then we'll package all that material up send that
155back to you give you all chance to review that there are video interviews you can review on any online uh information at your own hour and Leisure but we want you to have that work all done and then I'll come back work with you and out of that group I joke it's kind of like being on Survivor who's on the island who's off the island and go through it but normally what will happen is there'll be two or three everybody loves two or three nobody really loves and a bunch that are in the middle and we'll just kind of facilitate that conversation and the goal here is to try to get somewhere between three or five folks that you'd like to bring in for interviews um from there uh we'll talk to you every time
156I'm meeting with you I'll tell you about what's coming next but we'll talk about we normally ask our our finalist to prepare a document called a firste game plan it's a written exercise about if they're appointed how will they approach the position what will they do in their first 30 60 90 180 days and kind of the balance of the year it gets them focused about getting their head and their heart and the Soul about the position you may have some exercises or assessments or PowerPoints that you would like them to do we'll work with you about what that looks and feels like um and then we'll also complete the second part of it now we're down to that bottom of the funnel we're going to do criminal history credit background academic all the all
157the material reference checks all that sort of stuff will be undertaken on those folks that you know everything about those folks that you want to do and then the on-site interview process uh will involve a variety of actions we'll we'll walk through those here shortly um but we'll help you facilitate that we'll have proposed questions and what the schedule looks like many times we're going to involve uh if your senior staff I suspect you're going to want your superintendent some of your your leadership that I met with at the front end to also meet with these candidates to get a chance to to kick the tiwer so to speak um we suggest one-on-one meetings with all of you and then certainly culminating in a public meeting uh as as required under the Florida Statutes and
158at the end of the day uh we would work with you uh to help facilitate a negotiation of whatever that employment agreement whatever that document looks and feels like and working through terms and conditions I always stress the fact that we're engaged by you so you are our client we're here to help facilitate whoever you ultimately select um and I'm in a position to help you facilitate that conversation if a candidate is asking for something that's unrealistic I can be that buffer if the board is saying something thing that I also wouldn't normally see in a in a traditional position like this I'll be candid and um to say I think that's not necessarily what you would expect to see uh for a position of this nature but our goal here is to bring the
159parties together but I always work for you I'm not working for the candidate but the goal is to facilitate a process to get you together and then it's a matter of finalizing that it comes back to you as a board just like any other formal action would be and you'd be you'd be authorizing that and then it's a matter of who you hire when their start date would be and how quickly they're coming on board um so with that as a background um the next steps would take place we'll we'll finalize the brochure we'll launch I would anticipate launching this week um then um these are the things that will take place uh in in upcoming meetings the the next time I'll physically be before you will be after the position is closed and you'll
160have some background material to review the candidates and I'll kind of unpack that through a series of presentations of of you know here's the candidates here's the background here's what we know about them here's all the things that you want to do and from there facilitate a selection of semi-finalist um from there as I say we'll start some additional work um we'll be back again to review your finalist work um they will be selected typically three to five folks as I say we do first year game plans we do the background the efforts there's some personality assessments dis assessments if they want to do those we can we can facilitate that and then the on-site interview process is typically a two-day process uh we will'll talk about this greater but but right now I'm proposing
161a two-day which is normally uh can accomplish what we're trying to uh to to learn about these candidates normally on the day one you would have staff members taking your candidates out and kind of showing them facilities and a tour to get kind of the landscape of what what P County and your District's all about uh we typically encourage um since the general Council be interfacing with a lot of your senior staff we typically encourage an opportunity for them to sit down and what I call an engagement session it's going to feel like an interview but it's also going to feel a little bit like a staff meeting and we'll help facilitate those conversations I'll sit with those those meetings as well I'll be watching how they relate to the candet how the candet is
162relating to the staff uh we'll capture their thoughts and opinions and insights we not asking them to rank them that's ultimately your responsibility but any feedback or Impressions normally on day one um for any of my public bodies in Florida because of the the sunshine act most of the time we have kind of a round robin dating process where you all get 30 or 40 minutes or 45 minutes with each candidate and you get a chance to kind of do that in a one one and we facilitate that on that first day um and then on the second day is where probably in this room uh each of the candidates would normally be involved in a formal public interview process with you collectively as a board uh and we'll help prepare you for that process
163with questions and issues and just facilitate that all the way through your selection process so those are kind of what that looks like um we'll we'll flush those out every time I'm with you to get a little more detail but I wanted to give you a sense of of uh the process that we normally use that gets us to a successful conclusion and then um based upon trying to working with your staff and working with uh Dr Allen and what meeting dates you've got I've tried to land as many of the dates as I could for my selection of triage for selection of semi-finalist and then also selection of finalist on dates that you already are meeting in the challenge of trying to get seven of you um on new new meeting dates so um
164doing that kind of pushes a little bit longer I wouldn't normally need as much time between the selection of semi-finalist and the selection of finalists but in talking with Dr Allen the week before that would work I think you've got a um you've got legislative days up in Tallahassee and and also several of you I think are going to be involved in a Schoolboard Retreat or Schoolboard uh conference of some sort so I just left it on the March 25th to to so we didn't have to worry about changing that date but we we could have made that a little earlier but I don't know that that's going to work on your schedule um and then you'll see kind of it becomes self-executing once we're through this process so that gets us to interviews and
165I've given a couple options of a two-day process I would not need all of you for both full days but I would need you at least for the one-on-one section on the first day and we'll facilitate once we know how many candidates we've got on what that would look like but so that could get you to Mid April 15th and the 16th or potentially the 22nd or 23rd so um I wanted to get those dates out there and if those work or if I've got to work with IET and uh you collectively will we'll figure out what other dates come into play but that's kind of the way the process would work Mr Thomas you need direction though on the salary piece or I mean the direction is we're going to because what you've post
166what you've listed here that's our salary that's our current salary range for this position and just to give the board a little bit of extra information um we have the the superintendent which obviously is the highest paid employee and that's under contract um but the next few positions that you'll see in our administrative salary guide um is Deputy superintendent with and also chief of staff is on that next salary grade and then our attorney is on the very next and that's the salary grade that you list there that doesn't mean that's the order of how employees are paid because it depends on their experience and other factors when we we hire um but that's why we post that range there um is based on that administrative guide that that we have on how we place
167and that's how currently the attorney position is placed so to your question then I what I'm recommending is that salary range ought to be somewhere in the 190 to 220 range which is I what I proposed in the brochure if that takes official action of the board I'll defer to you to whatever that would be but we yes we would need that because we'd be ready to hit go on this with these Minor Adjustments that we've talked about with Miss Miss Miller's comments I think that would be consensus because that's kind of what I was I was reading it that way John yeah um Mrs Wyatt yes I looking at the the calendar portion of it um I really appreciate you using dates that were already available um because I I know how difficult it
168is to get seven people's calendars to align the just wanted to put it on the board's radar that 15th and 16th may be more um appropriate the 22nd we have a board meeting but we also have inside pcps before that um so I just wanted to make sure their whole whole calendar is based on being able to meet with the school board that date so if if we're not we just need to let them know sooner rather than later um my other question on the um calendar that you provided us it looks like the resume materials and PowerPoint will not be given to the recruiter until the day before our school board meeting in February all inside baseball don't worry about that I I'll make sure I have it uh yeah you'll need it for
169your board you'll need it for your presentation though as correct but we'll need more than 12 hours to look at that right so could we get it by Friday the Friday before which then at least gives us the weekend to review any of that sure let me let me kind of thank you for raising that I I had thought about that and I was thinking about from my standpoint not not on getting it to you ahead of time so um what we end up doing that that presentation um will be here's how we Market the position here's what your demographics look like and the the pool and then I'll walk you through those candidates that have meet or exceed the minimum requirements for the position and I'll kind of unpack their experience and background and
170positions they've had any education or certification they've got so that will be the way to help kind of you collectively talk about these candidates and then we can start to identify typically it's you know one I'm interested to might be interested in three I'm not interested and we'll we'll do the math and low scores typically will get you to your get you to your your semifinalist um but what I'm going to do in advance is once the position closes I'm going to send to you through your your uh secretary your administrative support uh staff um the alphabetized list of everyone who's applied cover letters and resumes so you're going to have all that well in advance of the PowerPoint the PowerPoint will just be kind of summarizing it so um I've got to work with
171your staff about how quickly I can get that PowerPoint pulled together after the position closes but I appreciate you raising that question I didn't think about the advanced time you might need it to be ready for this meeting we'll we'll make that work Dr Allen yeah thank you Mr pittz and in that um we would need to vote on those semifinalist uh candidates for that night in that meeting yes so what'll take place I said normally the way I've done that Dr Allen is um I'll just have a spreadsheet with all the qualified candidates names that I'll use as a laptop St and and as I say when you start reviewing the material I'm going to ask you to review their their cover letters and resumes ahead of time we used to be able to
172do this differently but given the given the change in the the AG's opinion on a on a presidential search we're going to have to do this a little bit more old school so you're going to have the benefit of that review um I'm going to highlight their skill sets and then at the after I unpack those candidates for you as a group I'm going to say okay um are there any questions about any candidates we've gone through and address whatever they be because I often will be talking to some of these folks before that meeting and I can add some insights that might not be available in the resumes or whatever um and then from there I'm going to say okay let's just work our way down through the list and I'll say candidate one
173candidate two candidate three and I'll ask you to say it's a one it's a two or a three um one is definitely two maybe a three and no and we that'll that'll that'll quickly give us an idea of where you are as a group so yes you will take official action in selecting your semi-finalist and then again when we select your finalist it'll be a similar type process at that stage perfect uh so I appreciate um everybody looking at this timeline I I would love to hear some feedback I think as Miss Wyatt mentioned we have the N uh CPS that morning of the 22nd so when if you notice the interview start date he's um mentioning those two different options so he did mention I was just wondering with those one-onone interviews if you
174didn't want to carve out two extra days right and you're everybody's schedule the 15th and the 16th um and you would then only be carving out the 23rd from your schedule because we already have um you know obviously a full day inside pcps work session and board meeting on the 22nd um you're looking at about three hours three and a half hours is what I was sort of collectively hearing from you as far as how much time we need it a lot it for those uh one-on-one interviews yes um between 30 depending on how many candidates we have if we got three we can spend a little if we got five we'll probably spend a little less time with them um and um yeah so we have to juggle that plus have bathroom breaks and
175all that sort of stuff but yeah so assume assume half a day just to be on the safe side yeah so maybe some feedback board members because you could do like a 7 a.m. start I think the inside pcps starts at 11: so you know so I guess you know what my question is to you are you willing to carve out those two extra days on the 15th and the 16th um beyond our already busy day on the 22nd with the first day meeting maybe half a day is it the 22nd or is March is the 25th I'm confusing yeah yeah I'm speaking of the the interview start date if you notice on the very bottom there he's got the two options noted so it's either uh we need to carve out the 15th and
176the 16th or you know on the 22nd we already have a work session and a board meeting that night but you do have the inside pcps that starts at 11: that day on the 22nd so technically you would just be carving out the 23rd as an extra day beyond your normal day that you're already um you know you're obligated to on the 22nd and we work with you to determine if the morning's available or the we'll figure out for the one-on-one sessions what fits in your schedule I would also not to over complicate things but I I I believe I picked that because I knew you had a meeting on 22nd if those present a challenge the Thursday the 24th and the Friday the 25th are also available on my schedule but I I don't
177want to create conflict if those if we don't need to go there but I want to throw those out out there if need be I'm good if you want to hear from other board members thank you Mr pits Mr sharpless um I'm good with with either option I would prefer option one um which is the 15th and 16th because we don't have that work work session and board meeting I think it would just give us more flexibility through the day sure Mrs Wyatt thank you question just on after the it stops with the interviews and at some point I'm hoping we're going to hire someone um if we do the interviews on the 15th and 16th would the thought be that it's on our agenda for the 22nd to appoint that individual typically um I've
178not looked at your whatever agreement when Wes was here you know that agreement is probably way dated at this stage but we would work with your staff to kind of make sure that kind of the basic terms and conditions of a traditional contemporary agreement would be in effect then it's a matter of just kind of filling in the blanks and adjusting based on the negotiations with who you select so normally a week to 10 days after a candidate is officially selected as the lead candidate it is normally my experience before you get that button down and then you can have it ready for your action so your next board meeting is when again after that the 22nd well if we do it on the 15th and 16th it's the 22nd if we do it on
179the 22nd 23rd it's not till the question's going to be is um I don't know what your lead time is for needing that for your agenda packet that would be the only question I would have because you've got to have You' got to have s days you need seven days but we could we could upload the item though we could add it as an item and not upload the attachment until I mean I would think that there's reason that it's necessary to do it before the next you got a placeholder to do it and then you could plug it in but I that's only point is sometimes you know you're working through the logistics we just don't know we don't know who that person is yet if all those things work out um but I
180think that that a 7 to 10 10day window is a typical negotiation window in my experience okay and that's correct our items are due uh seven days before but um we can put a placeholder and then attach the item and then my last question is probably more for John does that to be able to approve a contract on the 22nd would that mean the 16th at the end of our interviews that we would need to have an actual board meeting to vote on and I was a good question any of these it items that Mr Thomas has talked about that would connote or require board action official action would likely need to be noticed as such a board meeting as as board meetings as opposed to work sessions like like what you did today you
181took action at the 9:00 meeting um so a component of that work session could then go into a meeting if you needed to take action and well I think all of these are have board meetings attached to them already for the because they're both end of the month but the the 16th is something that we're adding on so that's if if those are the dates we select so that's why I was just asking if that would need to have a board meeting yes attached to make action and noticed appropriately thank you typically what you do is you open the meeting and then your agenda is the very speaker or your and then you close you're done with the last interview and then you reconvene the meeting for discussion deliberations but to to your question yes
182each time I'm going to be with you in the future there'll be official board action required which would require appropriate notice so but we need to do that during the work session we can't put it on the agenda for the night of so if it's on our work session that morning I mean I suppose you could have consensus and talk about it and then vote on it that evening okay I don't know how long Mr Thomas is going to if he needs to be present normally I would be here to help you facilitate that conversation and when I walk out the door I know who your semi-finalist are um because I'm going to then be notifying them and getting them prepared for the next step but if that's a two-step process I just have to
183work that out with John to figure a scale of B I understand what you're saying yeah I just I'm always hesitant to schedule a board meeting in the middle of a work session because those time certains right understood Mr Keys I was just going to um be on the same page as Mr sharpless on the 15th and 16th of April um because the following of those other dates suggested um after the 22nd and the 23rd in the month I would not be available so um in consensus with the 15th and 16th all right thank you Miss Fields 15 and 16 15th and 16th great that it's extremely help thank you for for locking down I know it's I know it's important to you but it's also helpful with my candidates because as they apply I
184can tell them here's when action steps are going to be there if they got a cruise or a wedding or you know something like that it's easier to make give them as much advanced notice and when we think these dates for on-site interview should they be selected will occur so thank you that's all I have unless there's any other questions um I'm going to then I'm just for clarity Clarity I'm going to take into account the comments that we addressed I'll work with your staff here in the next day or so to incorporate the issues about vouchers and all that but if you're good with that I'm not going to come back to you with a second I'll just hit go with the brochure as with those adjustments if you're comfortable with that okay Thomas
185thank you for being here today my pleasure thank you so much look forward to working with you and as always you've got my contact information if there's any questions along the way we're here to help you through this process give me a shout and shoot me an email or text whatever works for you great thanks again look forward to it thank you board members that is the last item on our agenda today um we do have a closed session that we'll follow up uh as soon as we close this work session um thank you for the opportunity to sit with you today and for being so kind we will move on and call this business uh meeting closed thank you uh Mr pittz uh I would like to maybe just see if anybody had any
186other board member comment I'm sorry I'm sorry that I didn't it that's all right thank you Mr Pitts we unclose it right so good uh that you're here yeah um I just basically any board member comments before we do adjourn all right very good all right Miss Miller you recognized I apologize for my absence was it disc I know we discussed the date for the dates we're doing the attorney search have you have we discussed um a me setting a meeting date before September for a retreat a meeting the board people all at the same table Yeah and and again this was something superintendent and I were working on to try to bring some of those dates back to you but you could see obviously we're already carving out a lot of time as well
187so we will bring some dates back to can we get them before the next meeting he thought I had them and I don't have them so obviously he's provided them can you forward them before the next meeting misset does have a list of those dates okay thank you Miss W that was my same question sorry all right I see no other questions yep sounds good I say we adjourn the meeting all right at this point this meeting is now adjourned