001e e e uh commiss Co commissioner Esposito commissioner esposo present thank you commissioner K Bay commissioner K Bay pres thank you commissioner H Mohammad commissioner reading linger present commissioner Rooks commissioner Slater Harrington present and I'm also present is there a motion to reopen the meeting so moved Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito is there a second second can you have B thank you commissioner Kenyata Bay all in favor Vice chair Parker yes commissioner messenger yes commissioner esposo yes commissioner kinata Bay yes commissioner bre linger yes commissioner Slater Harrington yes and I'm also in favor any opposed that motion passes like to take a moment to recognize um our student colleagues from Patterson High School uh during the JROTC presentation this evening e e this e feel J me and a round of applause for our is
002there a motion to approve the prior Open Session summaries so moved Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito is there a second second Ames messenger thank you all in favor Vice chair Parker yes commissioner Ames messenger yes commissioner espito yes commissioner kinata Bay yes thank you commissioner R linger yes commissioner Slater Harrington yes and I am in favor this motion passes is there a motion to approve the Clos session summaries so moved kinat Bay thank you commissioner kyat Bay is your second second Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito all in favor Vice chair Parker yes commissioner am Messer yes commissioner espito yes commissioner kyata Bay yes M reading linger yes Comm sling hton yes and I'm in favor this motion passes we have a little bit different script this evening things are moving around on our agenda so
003I'd like to take the opportunity to welcome everybody to our January 20th meeting and thank you for being here um we'd like to take an opportunity on our Superstar U scholar Superstars back um it's an our opportunity as a board in the special segment to recognize uh two students and staff who have Board of handpick for their achievements and academics extracurricular activities or their impact for the school Community tonight we'll highlight January scholar Superstars our first winner is Karen Tucker could Karan join us tonight all right so Kieran is a fifth grader at Liberty Elementary School in West Baltimore um a couple of remarks here I was impressed when I was reading this so Karen is a trer um Paving his way to Greatness with integrity and bravery with the support of his family teachers
004and Friends Karen has grown the confidence to be the first male cheer leader on the Liberty Cheer Team and the first male model for the school fashion outside of cheerleading Kieran also participates in dance volleyball and flag football so in the classroom Kieran shows remarkable growth stepping up to assist fellow classmates inspiring them to do their best to learn more about Kieran and personal uh personal congratulating him on his accomplishments the Communications office visited Kieran at Liberty Elementary School to capture this amazing video bring it up in just a moment Tu I am in the fifth grade and I am a scholar [Music] Superstar I Love Cheerleading because it just is one thing that makes me have more [Music] energy I didn't really expect none of my friends to actually be on there with me
005but a lot of my friends were there so I felt comfortable we had to do this super hard dance and it was really hard but to be honest out of everybody else who can not get it it was me I took some groups and I helped them each individual so I got a merit for that which is good being the first boy on the chair car I would inspire all boys if you want to do chair just do it it's not really just a girl thing it's also a boy thing and as you get in that comfort zone then you'll see it it really like has made me step into my comfort zone when I'm at school cuz sometimes I get bullied but that doesn't get in my way for the whole day I just
006think about something else and I walk away and I talk to my friends and I just have a regular day my plan for when I get in Middle School is is to make it kind of the best because after Middle School is kind of high school time goes fast so I want it to be the best math is my favorite subject math and art and the reason I like math is because I just love solving problems and then art I'm I'm an artist I just love art I love to draw I love to do anything that has to do with art I want to be a vet event so I can work with animals I would say keep trying as long as you really like focus in school you don't really have no problems uh
007our pleasure to welcome Kieran his family up to the podium for a few words um we're we're [Laughter] just yes yeah if you push the green button um we'll happily remarks for you guys I'll just push it one time yep um I'm his mom and I'm very proud kran started out under great level in first grade and with the help of the staff at Liberty and the I team they were amazing by third grade and he had to me a Peters who's one of our administrators now he became on great level since then he's been above great of to know his story I'm very proud of him and letting him be who he wants to be that was hard I'm old school but I from the my mentor I've allowed him to be free and
008take the freedom of doing what he likes to do and so I was very honored when he was nominated and he won the award so again thank you all thank you thank youon do you want to share a few remarks uh yeah um I would just say that it wasn't it's not really hard school is basically all about life and as you get into life you need to learn different things to able to able to like take care of life so it's easy we're very proud we're very proud before you go did you want to offer a few remarks to he had such a great structure and great backbones but he works hard in everything he does he tries his best he does not give up and when I had him in my third grade
009math class even in those struggles he never let it get him down so to see him make it to this part with confidence and strength and everything oh his mom who does amazing job we'd like to welcome Karan and's family up and you as well to take a photo and present this award on behalf of the board um so the certificate is proudly awarded to Quran and recognition of your outstanding academic and extracurricular achievements and we're very proud of these achievements this for he congratulations to not only kurran but to the entire Liberty Elementary School Community we know that it takes entire Community to really educate all of our Scholars and so we're very proud of the work um that Coran's done as well as the school Community yes so our second winner is jakai
010Ben benkin is jakai here all [Music] right jaai is a 12th grader at City neighbors High School in East Baltimore jakai is an accomplished and creative student who advocates for people who Encounter social injustices and inequalities he is the co-founder of the city neighbor High School Green te a program he started with last year's January scholar Superstar is it Sarai Jennings s thank you he is also a officer for the best buddies City neighbor High School chapter a club designed to support Student Connection outside of his humanitarian efforts jakai is the president of the school choir of a first chair musician in the still band I love that vice president of the student government Association and a member on the school's chess and track team I love that to learn more about jakai and personally
011congratulate him on his accomplishments the Communications office visited jakai at City neighbors High School to capture this amazing video hello my name is jakai bkin and I'm a senior at City neighbors charter school and I'm a scholar Superstar The Still pan band is a music group that we have at the school it started back in 2021 the steel pan if you don't know what it is it's pretty much these round tub type of shap and it's made of metal and you have these Mallet which have rubber ends on it you play different notes on it it's like a huge Ensemble of people I feel like the steel pants specifically just makes music much more fun especially cuz like you really got to like really be in the music and like embody it so I feel
012like that's what makes me interested in music my mom and my grandmother are like the main ones who like really just keep me grounded if it wasn't for them I wouldn't be doing as as I am doing like when I was younger I didn't really necessarily care about school that much and like I mean I was doing my work but I really wasn't like trying my best when it came to my work and like I I just want to thank her because like she really she really made me the best I am now and like she's the main reason that I'm even being able to go to college for free now because most of the colleges that I've gotten into I've gotten pretty much full ride to and it's mainly just because of her because
013she made sure that I stayed on track same for my grandmother because not neither of them played whatsoever so I I feel like they're the main reason for My Success the most important thing I could possibly say is don't give up on yourself when I wanted to sing like I never actually sung anything that was mainly because of Judge people's judgment and honestly I am not that bad of a singer like I'm not going to say I'm Mariah Carey but I'm not that bad of a singer just trying to ignore other people's opinions is like the best thing you can do jakai it is my honor to invite you your family and our city neighbor staff up to the front and then hold the hi um my name is Jalisa I his mom takes everything
014so UNS serious um you know I love him my je like he said he's always done good in school but since he's been in high school with the help of Miss per he has been great he's just so proud of him speak um hi my name is jakai and I really just want to come up here and say thank you to my mother and my grandmother sitting back there cuz she didn't want to talk but want to say thank you to her and I want I especially want to say thank you to miss zart and miss palor especially Miss peror because she's like my school mother she's I've known Miss ker since my freshman year when I first joined the Ste pan band and I just want to thank her so so much because if
015it wasn't for her I feel like I just wouldn't be where I'm at now and I just want to thank him for all the opportunities that they have given me and yeah that's that's really it so thank you what's next I'm excited for you you're doing so well um well mainly it's just college right now it's between um HUD College Salsbury University oh my gosh and Ohio State University I plan on majoring in either nursing or prental studies and getting a minor in management if I major in nursing so just for right now just to vote for Ohio since I'm from oh Ohio's the heart of it all you know yeah congratulations thank you all right ji so in recognition of your outstanding academic and extracurricular achievements thank you for all your contributions to your
016school community so we invite you up to get your award e what right that's a hard act to follow um and I really appreciate um just the enthusiasm that our young people bring this is probably my favorite part of the entire agenda in terms of us being able to recognize the outstanding accomplishments of our young people to our business um we are looking at is there a motion to approve the pep and quasi judicial matters so move second AER thank you thank you um all in favor Vice chair Parker yes commissioner am messenger yes commissioner espacito yes commissioner kyata Bay yes commissioner reading laer yes commer sler Harrington yes and I'm in favor this MO motion passes uh I'll now review the consent agenda board colleagues please let me know if you have any items
017that you wish removed and please State your question for staff item 6.01 supplemental appropriation HVAC uh replacement at Arundle 6.02 supplemental hbac replacement at Arlington Elementary 6.03 supplemental hbac replacement at Goin 6.04 supplemental appropriation School Improvement at Highland Town Elementary Middle 6.05 supplemental appropriation major projects um ffe which includes armet Gardens Northeast Furley and Marie uh G bearing 6.06 supplemental appropriation the high school plan for construction augmentation 6.07 supplemental appropriation City Springs Elementary Middle project 6.08 operator waivers and cap requests 6 09 fy2 quarter 1 budget amendment 6.10 pair professionals and school related uh Personnel chapter BTU American Federation of teachers local contract item 18.01 Carney Kellen Riser Bennett sheer Legal Services contract Amendment 18.01 IL legal are you pulling 18.01 yes uh State can you state your question for staff I'm sorry there's 15%
018uh increase in um that uh uh particular item and I just uh wanted to know if there was anything special that we needed to know about that increase s member office of legal counsel wants that answer um now or we can do after public comment how about that we'll move to public comment um item 5.01 um remember BTU Diana deso that video or in person if we don't have Diana we'll skip we don't have anybody from BTU this evening oh good evening board members I oh there's Diana s I'll talk to y'all later good evening I am Diana I'm a speech language pathologist and serve on the btu executive board I am speaking to express concerns about issues affecting our related service providers as many of my colleagues have stated in past board comments we
019deserve answers about contractual obligations by the district we are asking why our a payouts for Teacher chapter members have been so chaotic when BTU has asked for clarification on why such decisions were made for the compensation the district has gone dark it's unacceptable that human capital is not responding to questions or answering bbtu emails in addition as per our contract teacher chapter members with a master's degree received $2,500 added to our base salary beginning next school year 2526 the verification of Educators degrees by human capital has been very chaotic the past few weeks hundreds and hundreds of Veteran and newly hired employees received emails detailing that that the district has no record of our master's degree I do not understand how Baltimore City Public Schools does not maintain accurate records of Master master's degrees for
020our teachers but especially for our related service providers who must have a master's degree to practice in their clinical profession this is unacceptable the office of human capital fails to meet basic standards like paying people on time and accurately processing our educator credentials and maintaining accurate records of its employees we hope that the as the board searches for a new CEO they will ensure that we will have a responsive chief of human capital and one that proactively works with its employee represent representatives to solve issues instead of perpetuating harm to workers that make this District what it is there is significant shortage of speech language pathologist in the state of Maryland which has led to overwhelming case loads for the slps that we do have I have close to 50 students on my case load
021and my workload has quickly increased I know my colleagues are reaching up case loads up to 80 students creating a need for extra hands there are literally no extra hands the shortage is causing delays in time sensitive Services assessments coaching paperwork and an overall delay in the entire flow of the EP process it is critical that the district takes steps to attract and retain qualified speech language pathologist and I urge the board to adhere to the btu teacher contract whereas speech language Pathologists have just added language to start a work group to explore strategies for addressing this shortage why hasn't the office of special ed responded to our request to start this work group I am ashamed of how long it takes this District to follow a documented timeline like establishing an SLP work group
022The disorganized system impacts the entire team when one system of the process is broken we are greatly impacted take for example Transportation most of my early learning students ride buses all over the city to attend our city programs our most vulnerable students have been impacted by delays and lack of Support over the years parents ask why do buses refuse to wait to pick up my child in the morning why are they always late I received a text the other day from my special educator this morning one of the buses was 50 minutes late the afternoon bus ride was an hour and a half why we're talking about three-year-olds three-year-old preschoolers on a bus for more than an hour I asked for some compassion for our families as this is their first school experience bus AIDS
023have been asking for training on how to deescalate students behaviors adhering to IP safety precautions and strategies CBR training using AAC devices better routes and literally more help and Staffing secondly our parent advocacy groups are lacking parents need more support from our district and outside Community I've attended some cak meetings in the past and feel like they are not targeting what our families need the btu special ed committee has been figuring out ways to support our staff and families but the turnover of Supervisors and lack of response from the office of Special Ed has been frustrating for all the parents and commune members listening please reach out to the btu special ed Department special ed committee as we want to share our concerns and figure out ways to help our parents through this process as
024the speech Lang language pathologist I'm able to witness so much of the chaos around a school or ignore it the teachers shortage is real and those who end up in our specialized classrooms de deserve all of the love from the from the first year International teacher from Kenya to long-term Subs our educators are thrown into the messy world of early learning I know the amount of work for those classrooms is insane and our teachers need more planning time to reflect learner outcomes we need a reduction of redundant tasks that consumes so much of our time those are just some Snippets of my day as a city school speech language Pathologists I hope we can all work together to move towards an effective workload approach if related service providers are expected to add value to the
025students classroom experience our students with disability should receive the support they deserve and ensure that their voices are heard thank you thank you so much I appreciate that now we'll move to associate student Congress of Baltimore City welcome good to see you again good evening everyone oh and you just have to push it one time oh just push it one time okay uh good evening everyone my name is Benjamin galdi and I an eighth grader from Thomas Johnson Elementary Middle School and an at hoc member at acbc the past two weeks have been very eventful for student engagement in City Schools students had an opportunity to weigh in on upcoming board policy revisions and the district's budget priorities in two student forums as a facilitator at both events I hope the board and City Schools
026leadership will take advantage of the valuable student feedback Prov provided at these events two weeks ago asbc co-hosted the youth board Forum at Baltimore design school here students had an opportunity to give feedback on two board policies whose revisions will have considerable impacts on students the two policies are policy jcj which governs cell phones and other electronics and policy jjic which governs academic eligibility for student athletes our student commissioner Dylan Rooks opened the meeting students learned about proposed policy revisions from the offices who are leading the revision process we then broke into breakout rooms with student facilitators who guided the conversation about how students May react to policy changes how effective they think these policy changes will be and what adjustments students think should be made to the revisions staff from City Schools offices leading
027revisions were present to listen and take notes and asbc hopes that they will seriously take the valuable feedback and valuable insights the students raised a majority of students supported the revisions even including strict restrictions on cell phone use however we also rais serious concerns about schoolto school level differences and how that could affect implementation as the people most familiar with how policy actually affects us it's important that City school's leadership listens to us and makes it clear how they've integrated our feedback and concerns into their final revisions thank you to all of the board members and City School staff who attended the board Forum last week we also co-hosted the student budget Forum at Dunbar High School last year asbc requested that students have deeper engagement in the school budget process since then the youth
028Budget workg Group has been meeting with the city schools Finance team monthly to strategize on how to increase student engagement in the budget process the youth budget work group helped to design the for last week we welcome 60 students from all over Baltimore and from a diverse array of schools including Vivien T Thomas Baltimore design School mvo Frederick Douglas and more at the meeting we discussed how the district's budget is developed how the budget process should and can involve students and what areas NE of next year's budget should be prioritized the meeting opened with a presentation co- facilitated by the family engagement group and members of the youth budget work group including Fatima vakas who is the treasur of asbc and is a digital Harbor High School SGA member Zena Shaw who is an ad
029hoc member of acbc and a bolor poly Technic Institute student and Alexis Davis C Academy and sgaa member students broke into groups to discuss what the budget should prioritize next year in the small group that I facilitated students were most concerned about improving attendance in Dropout re-engagement and accelerating student achievement in literacy and math the students believe these are the most fundamental priorities and that due to the likelihood of budget constraints next year these should be prioritized the feedback from all the small groups was captured by staff from the family engagement team and asbc looks forward to follow up from that team and City Schools leadership demonstrating how students feedback was included in the final budget decisions before I close I want to highlight that asbc General Assembly winter will be held on February 11th
030at this meeting students from across Baltimore city will lead will gather for peer-led workshops on leadership and student advoc we're excited to share that this is the first general assembly run by acbc that will offer both English and Spanish we have shared an invitation with the board members and City Schools leadership and we hope to see you at that event thank you for your time and have a great evening thank you and the board just wants to thank asbc for the invitation of the student um uh Youth Forum it was a tremendous opportunity to see you guys look at some of the policies that are coming up so we appreciate that invitation to observe and we look forward to joining you at the general assembly coming up so I now turn over to Dr junkins
031for our general public comment this evening thank you we have one public comment from Kim Knox parent of Baltimore revolutionary Academy for virtual education the topic will be educational interest and this will be a comment that is read good evening bcpss Board of Commissioners in honor of Schoolboard recognition month I dedicated this month of January to learning more about the governance practices of my child school system my deep dive of the board level policy and administrative regulation documents provided me with a deeper appreciation for the board's efforts to cultivate a school system where students and parents are recognized and respected as integral stakeholders and decision makers in the delivery of this public service unfortunately in my family's experience in the school system we have encountered a disconnect in how the vision is implemented at the
032school level you see I have spent the month of January being ignored Andor gaset by the Baltimore revolutionary Academy School administration and District Personnel even a simple request to learn how to report and submit absence documentation has gone weeks unanswered further School r roles seem to shift and change at the whim of school administration without notice or engagement of stakeholders most recently to better understand how to navigate my child's school I sought access to the school's rules I.E policies and procedures only to learn that none of them have been formally documented to be made available for review and input a practice that not only disenfranchise and disenfranchises my student and family of their rights to participate in school level decision- making as expressed in the the district's 2024-25 students rights and responsibilities handbook and the
033district's family and Community engagement policy but is also of concern given the recent issues these School administrators have faced regarding new accusations of the district grade changing Scandal as Schoolboard recognition month comes to close I hope that the board will actively support School level administrators across the district in taking a moment to review their school level practices for alignment and compliance with the policies and regulations established by the bcpss board and commit to remedying any concerns or violations thank you and that is the end of public comment thank you based on public comment are there any additional items that board members would like to pull from the consent agenda hearing none um I'd like to invite Chief svens up um on the item that was pulled earlier commissioner thanks for the comment um so I
034believe you're asking about the um contract involving Carney Callahan which is one of our outside Council that provides our rray of services um by way I'm Josh sien Chief legal officer I should have said that at the outset um and um they have provided great service to us for a number of years uh around a number of issues including speci ed student services um and other school related matters and um we monitor outside Council closely try to keep those costs within reason um the increase here is merely to make sure that we're well poison the event that we need services on a rapid basis either for a a student related issue like a a student discipline matter or a special UE process case and hopefully we always uh plan for the worst and hope for
035the best hopefully we won't need these services but we have them available when we need them going forward thank you CH I appreciate it there a motion to approve the remaining consent agenda messenger so moved thank you is there a second second Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito all in favor chair par Vice chair Parker yes commissioner a messenger yes commissioner esposo yes commissioner Kata Bay yes commissioner Parker I'm sorry um commissioner Parker twice commissioner R linger yes commissioner sler Harrington yes and I'm in favor this motion passes like to turn over to Dr Sant Lisa now for CEO comments thank you very much chair Sally good evening um everyone I uh oh we do not oh Chief Emily neelon for this evening's pep agenda sorry I've was thrown off a little bit thank you Dr
036santalises good evening board Commissioners on this evening's pep agenda we have from the office of the chief Communications engagement enrollment recommended that am Monique Sims currently Special Assistant Communications and Community engagement be appointed director Community engagement effective February 8th 2025 please stand up so we can recognize you Monique congratulations to everyone on tonight's pep agenda thank you uh Chief vson um February is School Board appreciation month and I am am very pleased to take this opportunity uh to personally thank every member of the Baltimore City Board of school Commissioners um I just want to um thank not only our past our present members but past members just for your Devotion to schools to our families to our young people um I I do know that the hours that folks put in the dedication that you
037do the work with um particularly it would be still uh up and above kind of what normal folks would do even if you were paid the fact that you are not paid shows in my mind your kind of selfless commitment to our young people I want to also note that as a school district um our office of communications has prepared A celebratory video uh for our Board of Commissioners this evening as our way of saying thank you so we are going to turn January marks School Board recognition month a time to celebrate the dedicated leaders who guide and shape the future of Education today we honor the Baltimore City Board of school Commissioners for their tireless commitment to the students families and communities of Baltimore this team of passionate individuals Works diligently to create policies
038oversee budgets and set the the vision for academic excellence in our schools their leadership ensures that every student in every neighborhood has access to the resources and opportunities they need to succeed from fostering Innovative programs to advocating for equity and inclusion the Baltimore City Board of school Commissioners goes above and beyond to empower the next generation of thinkers leaders and change makers to the Commissioners thank you for your unwavering dedication your courage to make bold decisions and your belief in the Limitless potential of our students your contributions truly make a difference together we celebrate the impact you've made and continue to make in shaping a brighter future for Baltimore thank you for leading the [Music] way um so thank you Baltimore C Board of school Commissioners um I would also like to give a huge
039shout out to Roger Schulman president and CEO of the fund for educational Excellence Paul Walman co-founder of the heart of the schools and Kevin ly and the entire team uh just for um the heart of the schools program and the fact that they yet again provided the perfect venue um and celebration for our staff both centrally our school leaders um as we went into our winter break um and it really does mean a lot because every single year the fund puts on um a celebration that where it is so evident their belief in the power of Team City Schools um and they each and every year as you will see here in some of the pictures um they make sure not only that we celebrate but also recognize outstanding School leaders um across the district
040uh folks who know me know I love a good raffle and let me tell you the heart of the schools has one of the best Raffles going uh both for Central leaders District leaders um and they really do go a long way to make sure that we I feel and again line dancing in abundance um that we all feel uh just part of a larger team and in order to be part of a larger team you also have to celebrate together so you can see some of the pictures here um finally every year the heart of the schools honors 10 exceptional principles selected from Community nominations through the heart of the school Awards the nomination process is open now and I want to encourage everyone to vote for their favorite principal at www. heartof thees
041school.org back nominations so everyone make sure you vote and thanks again to our friends at the fund uh finally I am pleased to announce that we have reached a new three-year agreement with the par professionals and school related Personnel psrp chapter of the btu increasing base salaries and adjusting pay scales to add higher maximum levels our psrp employees support teaching learning and District Operations in a real variety of roles from classroom assistants to specialized roles in nearly every district office department they are critical to the success of our students and schools and this agreement reflects our recognition of everything they do every day uh the Board of Commissioners will vote on the agreement at tonight's meeting and back to you uh chair Sally because this concludes my remarks for this evening thank you so much
042um we'd like to take an opportunity to go through our committee reports this evening um our student commissioner is not with us this evening but I'll turn it over to commissioner ESO for our policy committee meeting yep the 17th of December 1st the policy committee met on December 17th to discuss jcj students use of Port portable electronic communication devices uh so we had a framing conversation about the policies and related to student use of devices we had compliance reports for policies on residency non-residency and tuition um we had updates uh for the sexual offender registration kb- to comply with the state law HB 814 juvenile law reform and the uh meeting also introduced a framing discussion around academic eligibility for both in inter inter Scholastic and extrac intra sorry inter Scholastic extra extracurricular activities the
043recap for the January 2025 meeting we discussed kib B- the sexual off sexual offender registry oh wait no this is not right sorry um so we our next meeting is going to be in February um my bad sorry I have some typos um February 18th from 4: to 5: and if anyone wants to sign up for public comment they can do so from 9:00 am on Thursday until 5:00 pm on the Monday before the meeting and I also want to emphasize that folks can provide feedback uh for any policy through our feed policy feedback form that's located on the website thank you so much commissioner espo commissioner Slayer Harrington for teacher and learning good evening everyone our teaching and learning committee I think met in the beginning of this very long month um it seems
044like last month already um but our meeting focused on uh we had a compliance presentation um from uh gifted learning and then we had a a pretty um robust discussion around summer learning and the impacts the considerable impacts um from a decrease in funding um the district was able to uh make great strides um across each of the board's goal areas and um particularly around graduation um um through much credit given to what we were able to to do over the summer and so um we heard a presentation around um what the staff is considering as we go in um this planning for this um summer um how we will address priorities particularly around Early Learning um and how we maintain progress and uh we're looking forward to seeing how the staff is also going
045to leverage Our Community Partners and um helping um uh close the gap or EX stand in the gap for those areas where we may see deficits due to the decline in funding so thank you awesome thank you and we'll catch up in two weeks on operations and safety and wholeness as well i' like to turn over to staff for a presentation on policy ADH community school strategy good evening Commissioners Dr santis lisis I am Tina H Hub chief of communications engagement and enrollment we are here today to present a quick policy of dat policy ADH Community Schools if you may remember just recently we actually updated and did a very Ro robust engagement process around our community schools policy and then the legislature changed some very interesting smaller things in the in the legislation that
046changed how our policy needed to reflect that actual legislation so our team has done some great work we've met with policy and other committees and they're here to present the final CH recommended changes to policy ADH today and with me I have ragle a director of community engagement for a couple more days um yes as I should have led with that but as we cheered on Mo'Nique for uh her new role she is replacing the lovely and fantastic amazing Chris who we going to miss I wasn't fired at was retirement he's retiring oh my God all right George we just want to be on the record all right George all right George um and the Fantastic Holly Gonzalez and Sheila Drummond who are both managers of the Community Schools strategy they are going to share
047the updates today and Chris and I are here to support and answer any questions all right thank you Chief I covered um so we wanted to begin just by going over a little bit of the purpose of policy ADH which is to establish the framework and responsibility so we have a successful Community spense strategy here in balore city um and as a reminder from this policy the purpose of commu schools is to ensure that all of our students are learning and succeeding with a focus on the key areas mentioned on this slide just as a reminder Baltimore City Public Schools has 154 Community Schools this year um and our model includes both the district hiring Community School coordinators in partnership with the principal as well as having community- based organizations hire that community school coordinator
048position and support them again in partnership with principles um we actually have 98 eight of our community school coordinators hired by community-based organizations and here kind of right at the beginning I wanted to say that policy ADH whoops does apply to both to all Community Schools regardless of whether it is a district hired community school coordinator um or a community-based organization hired community school coordinator oh and also as we talk through this policy or the proposed policy revisions we have several pictures from our community schools in action that we hope you guys enjoy um we talk through the specifics so um the rationale for policy updates as Chief hike hubard mentioned the policy was updated in 2023 with robust feedback and very broad feedback from the community so I would like to say thank you
049to Sheila Drummond cam our manager of community schools and to Sima sha Nelson who at the time was a community school specialist and now a special assistant to the CEO for leading that work you guys did like 20 plus presentations talked to more than hundreds of people um so it was very very comprehensive um and because that was just done the modifications we are proposing are somewhat minor or more limited in comparison they're really being driven by two house bills that happened last legislative um session which updated some of the definitions for community schools and wraparound services so we're going to walk through um those differences now and so first just here real quick again kind of our goals in updating the policy really is to revise it so that it mirrors State language and
050the blueprint for Maryland's future um and we're just going to go right through them so here you can see all the proposed updates are in red and what you can see here with the original definition really is they have added that emphasis on shared accountability and collaborative leadership as well as capacity building an authentic family and Community engagement so of course we would like to also include that in our policy these are changes we very much are in agreement with next there are some slight revisions to the wraparound Services language and so this is really about adding some examples or some additional you know information here to just clarify what these wraparound services are in a little more detail just so you know the blueprint includes 13 wraparound services in Community Schools one of their
051roles is to connect students to these Services um again kind of to support Student Success so the the revisions here really are kind of like you know adding hearing to vision and dental services or giving examples of what an student enrichment experience could look like all right so we also have some new language from housebuilt uh 428 and this included identifying what additional um Services commun schools should offer or could offer rather um to remove out of school learning barriers for students we were pleased to see this language all of these services are services that our community schools are offering and they are resources that Community School coordinators are connecting our families and students too so it is good that they are now kind of included in state legislation we do want to highlight that
052this also created the rental assistance program for Community School families so this program had $10 million associated with it and it is being developed by the Maryland Department of Housing and Community Development and it is administrated or administered by uh hcd Housing and Community Development it is not administered by the schools the coordinators or msde once it is finalized um the state will share um directions with all leas on how to refer families to this program and we are happy to kind of share that information broadly with our community school coordinators um I do want to note one thing that though this is a new resource currently Community School coordinators are referring people to things like our cap our community action partnership centers for rental assistance and other resources that are available in our community
053but we are excited to have this additional resource coming right next sorry if I okay um so House Bill 200 also added some specific language around the evaluation of Community Schools um and we want that reflected in our policy so this is the proposed language there um we are already working to ensure that all of our reports and materials are tracking information from Community Schools in such a way that we will be able to meet this deadline and um provide this information is required by the state so we would like policy ADH to reflect that um also as the state is going to make a lot of the implementation documents of Community Schools public we would like to do so as well so this will include copies of the needs assessment action plan and annual
054evaluation after they are reviewed and approved by Ms okay so we are very interested in the board's perspectives on our community school steering committee um so Sheila really kind of took this opportunity for us since we were revising the policy to think through with in partnership with our steering committee members how we might want to change up the U makeup of this committee and we really wanted to increase Community presence in it and so that happened in a few different ways um one was increasing the number of Community School coordinators from two to three another was a Community member at large and then also um in order to and this also shows it I think you can see a little bit better um to match kind of the btu representative to add a representative from
055pizaza in order to keep it at an odd number one of the things that did happen is for Community School students like taking them to two to match families and Lead agencies was um another revision we are proposing so just as a quick kind of aside some of the stakeholders who will be impacted by these policy revisions it really is community school team at City Schools our 13 Community School lead agencies and 154 Community School coordinators and the community school steering committee we are absolutely working to make um all of the work or administrative tasks associated with this as minimal as possible for these groups and so that is definitely a part of our planning all right so we have here's our Outreach piece we have presented and or at least share kind of the
056proposed revisions um widely and with a lot of our different stakeholders so here in the fall it was really focused on Community School stakeholder Outreach I would say so we did share the proposed revisions both like in a newsletter with an online form we offered to do virtual meetings with Community School coordinators and what you'll see is there were either kind of no attendees and we didn't receive any feedback from those opportunities uh we did present to the Baltimore climate collaborative they had no concerns with proposed revisions we presented to our steering committee who also had no uh concerns with divisions how's it going and okay for Community supervisors he did a presentation them could we check to make sure everyone is muted please thank you um all right so for Community School supervisors we
057did do a presentation to them 12 of our 13 lead agencies were represented at that meeting they had no concerns they had one clarifying question um about whether or not things like um service learning activities could qualify for enrichment and we said yes the examples are examples they are not the limit of um those they're not the limit of enrichment activities we also presented to the equity ad advisory committee I'm actually going to talk about them on the next slide so these are the official groups that we shared the information with via email it was also posted on our website for public comment um the equity advisory committee had no concerns and their questions were more kind of like how are Community School lead agencies chosen does do the same things apply to community-based and
058uh District hired coordinators which is why we changed the beginning of this presentation a little bit um for Charter Le operate or Charter and operator Le School Board no questions really they we we presented to them they had just some general comments uh for pcab parent and Community Advisory Board we did not receive any feedback uh nor from the associated student Congress of Baltimore City though it was shared with them uh the special education citizens advisory committee secac uh noted that transparency is needed at every level um as the new policy is rolled out and they were requested we share recommendations on how to incorporate the new policy into their work and we will absolutely if approved share information with them and be in communication about how CCA can support um the new ADH revisions
059uh in implementation for Charter School operators we did receive feedback so one of the things that they recommended was that for some of our key steering committee groups teachers students families um and school leaders that a charter represent res ative um be a part of those groups so City Schools did add language based on this comment to our administrative regulations as you can see here stating that we will make targeted efforts to recruit and encourage individuals who are members of Charter operad Le schools to be on our steering committee they also shared some concerns about the administrative burden for schools um as well is wanting to make sure that coordinators or schools were not responsible for implementing the rental assistance program which we clar we will clarify um no feedback was received from the labor
060unions and we did receive a question from a family member via the form which uh focused on Community Schools and the concentration of poverty grants Less on the policy piece so we are working with different departments in order to get a response for that family went through that a little fast questions anyone I just add very quickly that Dr s lisis and I were fortunate enough to present at msde recently on the community schools work to date um it was really well received we left them in tears um with our video of the United Way um but I just also want to say I have the most amazing Community Schools team sitting here next to me and I'm just so proud of the work that they are doing and the way we are implementing this
061strategy to Fidelity and making sure we're staying updated on the policy work so thank you all right so I actually want to take a minute before I turn over to my board colleagues to also commend staff I had an opportunity to join you guys at msde for that presentation and just the tremendous work in terms of the state having a lot of Buy in in terms of what we're doing and having that as a model to share throughout the state for others to learn from so kudos to not only everybody here but to um our entire school school Community who's implementing that work so thank you thank you m Slater Harington I just want to um no questions um but I will take a point of privilege in that I've had the great honor to
062be able to witness the evolution of this work and the evolution of Community Schools uh in Baltimore and what they are saying but not saying won't brag on themselves is Baltimore City's community schools have served as the blueprint across the state and the nation and really warrants all of the honor and recognition that you all get um to be on the Forefront and have the rest of the state coming behind and having our City's um Community Schools really inform what it's going to look like and being the Pioneer to say and the you know just the image for which everybody else is formed um is just a testament to the wonderful work that you all have done and you're right you have the best team and you are a great leader I want to take
063a point another point of privilege and you know it's no um coincidence that this um last presentation is on Community Schools and we have had the pleasure of having one of the best principls in community school history lead this work and Chris Baga George Clooney and I'm just so glad to have had um the benefit both as um a colleague but also a board member to witness is um not just your work at Ben Franklin but um to really Forge your head and Leadership here at the district um you're leaving us in very capable hands I love her um but um I would be remiss if I just didn't take this point of privilege to recognize everything that you've done um and the path that you have laid um and thank you for gracing us
064with your presence before you go to continue your acting career thank you George thank you boy colleagues yes sure um again thank you all for your great work um I also want to take the time to thank you Mr bagia um for your work and your contribution to Baltimore city but your work and your contribution to me um so many people do not know that Mr bagia was my teacher and and it is uh a great full circle moment um to be here and just a part of your legacy and what you have put into students for the many years that you have served so thank you rest and enjoy commission am messenger I say there's nothing that you can add to those two things but I think we can't say enough about Community Schools
065as a strategy and I think just for what that means for students and for families to be able to belong and be seen in schools and how it changes the posture of what we do as Educators like that's the magic sauce that we've that kind of makes it all come together so thank you for your work that is hard um I think also just for the service to teachers that gets missed a lot um I think back to being a first year educator and the countless dams that you're trying to shove fingers into and wishing desperately at the time that I had had a community school build and a coordinator in my building to be able to build those relationships to set that stage to change the culture so that you as a teacher then
066can come in on the academic part and partner with families based on the work that's already been done not just by that person but by a whole department that is building a strategy to be thoughtful in the most strategic ways and so I hope that our state learns from your lessons are learned that we are compensated for that knowledge and expertise um and just well done for you all as a team thank you additional I just want to say very uh public goodbye um to Chris Paglia and uh to have a school leader bring the knowledge of families um from the ground up to the work across the district um I remember when Chief High cup said she had found um the right person and you were the right person and you've carried the work
067um in ways that don't frankly always translate at scale um just because you can do it at one building does not mean you can do it across a district and you came at just the right time and you found your sweet spot and my only requirement um and kind of last directive to you is I better still get pictures of that beautiful grandbaby when you're thanks for all all your work and service C gonna bring her to visit because love poppy will be watching her she's gonna bring her down for lunch oh I love it I love it I'm gonna put my final bow on it and thank Chris paga for uh my very first year on the board an opportunity to do graduation for Ben Franklin and um the reason why I really wanted
068to do that school like I I hopped at that at the opportunity to like see in action all the good things I've read and so under your leadership and seeing you bring that level of enthusiasm and passion to this work here inside Central District has been amazing so congratulations on a career well done so everybody join me a round of applause for Chris bad here and I'm excited to see this work continue to unfold with Community Schools going forward so I think we're all set for the evening but we've got lots more work to do as a district so thank you guys thank you you thank you so and we'll while they're transitioning away we're going to set up our next presentation which is an important one uh 9.02 which is our fy2 24 closeout
069this looks ahead at our fiscal responsibilities as a board um which is really important for our community to know where we stand and where we're moving forward as we put a B on fy2 24 so Chief dor good evening everyone good that all the time good evening everyone my name is maryan Cox I'm the Deputy Chief Financial Officer this young man here is Chris D this CFO and uh uh we're here to present the fincial summary uh to the board um so Finance presents on on behalf of the entire finance office we all have a part in this um I wanted to uh talk to you a little bit about our financial reporting cycle the generally the end of January is the end of our reporting cycle as you all know we we have a
070fiscal year for our operations which end 6:30 each year per comar we are required to re to submit our audited financial statements to msde no later than 9:30 each year what we typically do then is have our external Auditors at this time Clifton Larson Allen they Comm in and they submit a report to the board on the results of the audit and uh they talk a little bit about the single audit too they typically come in October or November um then uh we also have the single audit which is the audit of federal funds which is which must be submitted no later than 1231 each year so um that that uh audit report is also completed and submitted to msde um I wanted to remind you that when we submit our reports to msde typically
071we uh Finance submits them to the CEO and then the CEO submits them to the board so there are also other governance documents that that come along that are just for Board review so okay I'm sorry was there a question just ask any folks who are online to make sure that your phone lines are muted this evening thank you I'm sorry oh okay um you know also uh with our single audit due 12:30 one we also do a reporting on the federal funds to a central Clearing House as we're required to do and that we also do some other reporting at the end of January which is on like uh uh maintenance of effort and excess cost so as part of this uh close out for our financial reporting we wanted to come back and
072touch basis with the board to give a little more detail on the financial information that you've already received so uh typically the board receives the audit of basic financial statements uh anywhere from the beginning of October to the middle of October so um in terms of financial reporting we must follow comar and comar says we report according to category so all of our financial information in our financial statements relates to category not object we are required to comply and Report with the uh items in the msde uh Financial man uh manual so that's what we do so we're I'm going to just give you a little bit of detail that is not um uh demonstrated separately in our audit so if we could go to the revenue first yes thank you Jonathan uh what I
073wanted to point out to you you can see here that there's two columns the final budget and that's after all the board approved uh budget amendments and then our actual and and some variances um what I wanted to talk to you a little bit about why where the variances come from we have variances in our state revenue because when we set our budget we use the best information we have at the time which is the January uh State a calculations that's the best we have when we start our budget process and we don't update it as we go through but the state also continues to do updates and the final revenue is not uh released until uh June so you can see that we have some variances on that so uh we also do trups
074for uh which will come into play in the variances and the trops can be plus or minus from the uh prior year we acrew any Revenue to which we're entitled but we have not yet received uh we uh acre that based on the best information we have at the time so you can see that we have some variances there as well um our funding formulas which is what the budget is based on and the Appropriations we get from the state is uh based more on funding formulas based on enroll funded enrollment and relative wealth of the city of Baltimore compared to the rest of the state so other than that we get the same funding everybody else does you know the same rules apply to us as do every other Lea in the state um
075I um I want to talk about the city of uh Baltimore again uh we have the same type of variances where uh the the the uh base budget we get is based on the required local contribution that would come from the first state Aid Cal and of course those numbers Chang through the end so we have some variance from there too uh wanted to talk about federal revenue uh federal revenue uh comes from a lot of different sources we get various roty reimbursements we get er we get FMA Ira subsidy and last year we started getting the emergency connectivity fund which is based on a general fund grant that uh City Schools was awarded uh based on uh technology needs so our oit department uh processed the uh the request and we had received some
076money last year from for the Emergency connectivity fund of course investment earnings uh we see it's very unpredict ictable the number varies from one year to the next I mean it wasn't but uh 3 years ago May before where we had 27,000 in uh investment income and you can see where it is now so it's it's dependent largely on the T Bill rate t- Bill rate hadit an alltime high during FY 2024 and it's still relative ly high but it has come down there have been a few Cuts so we don't expect that to repeat at that level uh other revenue is another U thing that that is not really detailed in our audited financial statements this is where we put everything else so other Revenue will include intestate revenue and that's where if a
077Baltimore City resident dies without a will any money in their estate flows to City Schools it's that way all over the state you know it's based on the geographic boundary so uh that we report in other income we report non-resident tuition we have miscellaneous rent which is that one is basically the permits and such and that was over a million dollars we have reimbursement agreements which was over 3 million we have home and Hospital reimbursements restitution of over a million and we also have MS MSA uh reimbursements to the um general fund in 4 and a half million so really the other revenue is everything that's not included anywhere else and of course uh being a a governmental agency we have to respond to the gby requirements and the fiduciary activities there that's noted is
078actually the income for our school activity funds and the cable fund as we're required to break it out and the same thing for the leases we now detail leases uh revenue and expense and record them according to the requirements in that gasby statement okay so you can see when all is uh said and done we had a a a yeah this we had a budget of 1.4 billion and we had uh an actual revenue of 1.48 billion so that access will flow to uh fund balance okay uh next slide are we on the categories um I'm just going to speak a little bit on this one um remember we are required to report my category so that's that's what happens here and um I could tell you if you like you know all the little
079things that go in each one but some of it is just common sense um uh again it's our reporting is laid out in the MSD Finance manual so we must comply with that uh there were two items here I wanted to point out to you is a capital outlay you can see the budget is 22 uh five million that is where we record the contrib butions to MSA for the 21st century fund so of that 22.5 million 20 million of it relates to the contribution that City Schools makes for the 21st century 10 million of that is for is on behalf of city schools and 10 million of that is on behalf of the city of Baltimore um I also wanted to point out that uh we have Debt Service we record our own Debt
080Service uh City Schools is the only Lea in the state who has the right to issue revenue bonds of their own so that was that right was given to City Schools back with the city state partnership um uh law in uh 1997 okay the next page is um by object this is the one that that most of us most of our conversations uh talk about uh our expenditures by object you know they're they're very self-revealing here I do want to say that as a rule Thum City School says we spend about three4 of our expenditures in Personnel related so that will be on the first two lines of salary uh salary and wages and fringe benefits so we had budgeted 997 million which was 70.3% of the total budgeted expenditures and our actual was 983
081million so um you know a total 70.7% of the uh total expenditures um so we're we're very close in the ballpark and you can see that when all a said and done City Schools uh spent most of the money that we have were pledged it uh for incumbrances which carry over to the next year um oh one other thing that I wanted to point out here on the indirect cost recovery you can see a credit of $9.8 million that won't happen again the U the 9.8 million is the indirect cost that we are allowed to recover by federal law on fed on federal grants mostly we get a little bit on State uh to recover our administrative costs uh remember we had the Esser grants all the covid grants flow through our books so that's
082why this number is so high and it will not repeat at that level okay uh the next one is a summary page uh we just wanted to talk a little bit uh about how items get into aign fund balance um uh as part of board policy D fund balance the CEO is the board designate to and she has the authority to place items in general fund assigned funds balance that's where all these items went however when we want to expend the money we come to the board for approval so the CEO places it in in there and it's reported our financials and but we come to the board to spend it um the only other item I wanted to say here you can see what happens to the difference between Vue and expenditures it it
083goes largely to our assigned fund Bal what do we do with our assigned fund balance where these type of projects the B all of it goes capital projects to pay for the maintenance and and operating needs that we we have in in capital projects just as a a point of this 92996 that uh would have been the slice of fway 2024 amount added to fund balance we have the um the board approving actually a total of seven supplementals tonight five of which are on this list and those five were over $71 million so that's where the money goes it it it comes in we co-mingle fund we've got investment income in there I mean there's a lot of things that go into that but when all said and done um the CEO discusses with cabinet
084and and tries to determine what projects should be funded if we can and so we follow the CEO's Le on that are there any questions thank you so much for the comprehensive update it's really important for our fiscal and fiduciary oversight responsibilities as a board turn over to my board colleagues for any questions that they may have on tonight's presentation okay thank you thank you Edie before you leave right quick just to make sure I think that's it we appreciate this work I think it's very important for us to keep this in mind and sight as we enter the budget cycle this year um we'll come back with more robust questions that we take from here into their forward thank you thank you all right so our notice of upcoming meetings um we'll are leading
085off with teaching and learning on February 4th will be virtual we'll be back here on February 11th for our public board meeting um safety and wholeness um specifically want to lift up safety and wholeness we are having a listening tour commissioner Muhammad is not here to join us this evening to talk about it in more detail but he'll be back on the 11th to talk about um what to expect on the 12th we do invite our entire public to join us at colington Square Rec Center um this will be held at uh Dr jins do you know the time for this 5:30 to 7M at colington square there's more information available on the board uh sorry on the board's website operations committee meeting will be on February 18th poliy committee at the same time I'm
086sorry the same afternoon and safety and wholeness virtual session will be February 20th before we adjourn this evening I do want to take an opportunity to thank our entire board for their service once again very appreciative of the work and the dedication and tireless hours that our entire board puts in to ensuring that each and every one of our Scholars here in Baltimore City have an excellent education is there a motion to adjourn thank you commissioner slay heritton is there a second second Esposito all in favor by saying I I thank you we are adjourned for the evening