001ring linger present thank you commissioner Rooks commissioner Rooks present commissioner Slater Harington and she'll likely be joining us uh this evening so I ask that our board executive please mark them present as they come in this evening is there a motion to reopen the meeting Ames messenger so moved thank you commissioner am messenger is there a second you thank you commissioner all in favor um commissioner am messenger am messenger yes coy yes commissioner espo yes Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes thank you welcome commissioner reading linger yes commissioner Rooks yes and I'm in favor um any opposed the motion passes like to welcome once again everybody and we're going to turn to commissioner Rooks for Our Moment of Silence this evening thank you I would like to take a moment to recognize the passing of City
002Schools employee this individual was committ our students through his work the greater City Schools Community will fondly remember this employee tonight we send our deepest condolences to the employees family and friends it is with deep regret we inform you of the passing of Reginal s how reg how started his career with City schools on November 28th 1984 where he served the staff and students for 40 years most recently at Sinclair Lane Elementary School as a special education par educate excuse me par educated Mr how unfortunately departed on December 10th 2024 and will be missed by his friends family and City Schools thank you that concludes a moment of silence thank you commissioner Rooks uh is there a motion to approve the prior Open Session summaries Ames messenger so moved thank you commissioner am messenger is
003there a second I'll take commissioner kenat Bay um all in favor uh commissioner am messenger am messenger yes commissioner koi yeso yes commissioner kinata Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes commissioner reading linger yes commissioner Rooks yes yes as commissioner SL Harrington join us just yet NOP um and I am also in favor um any opposition this motion passes is there a motion to approve the closed session summaries so move desposito thank you commissioner Esposito is there a second am messenger second thank you commissioner am messenger all in favor uh commission messenger yes commissioner koi yes commissioner Esposito oh sorry yes thank you commissioner K Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R allinger yes commissioner Rooks yes and I am in favor any opposed that motion passes thank you just a moment [Music] so good
004evening everybody um and Welcome to our January 14th meeting um there's a lot of procedural things I just want to read to make sure we're very clear on what is going to transpire tonight this is a little bit different of a board meeting than our traditional meeting um that we have I am going to start um I'm going to pause on some of these different items that are in here for now and then kind of run through just kind of what is going to transpire um much more directly tonight so um we are so for over a decade City schools has used a collection of academic and professional recommendations from our staff students families and communities to review discuss plan Implement physical and programmatic developments within the school district this process is known as the
005annual review of schools during a series of board meetings and public feedback sessions to comart hearings the board collabor with the public to find ways that best Foster student learning and professional growth we will discuss difficult topics such as creating new traditional schools relocating schools changes to grade configurations renewing contracts or charters for schools run by external operators amending the 21st century buildings program and even closing schools with each conversation we try to keep you well informed and create a space for you to comment on any portion of the proceedings to keep you up to date here's just a recap of what's happened during the annual review of schools process so number one the annual review of school recommendations for the 2425 school year presented to the school board during the November 12th public board
006meeting the recommendations for the district included a closing combining Edwood Elementary with Gwen Falls Elementary School with a smaller number of students being rezoned to wizard Hills Elementary School B add the Joseph C Brisco building to the Surplus list in Surplus in summer 2020 26 excuse me uh when the renovated Fredick Douglas Brisco campuses complete C remove the Southeast Middle building from the Surplus list and replace it with the Joseph C Brisco building D change the Surplus date for the third Good Marshall building from Summer 2027 to Summer 2026 e CH SCH operative renewal updates for 18 charter schools and second the board hosted an opportunity for the public to comment on these recommendations in two on Thursday December 12th and thday January 9th the board accepted written comments or data via email until Friday
007December 10th I'm sorry Friday January 10th I also want to note that for operative renewal portion of tonight to vote the board has the ability to accept reject or modify the CEO's recommendation before voting for each this means that within reason and as long as these actions see administrative regulations and applicable state law the board can use the full range of options available to them this evening including renewing a school for eight years five years or three years and can add conditions to any of these terms or can vote to non-renew an operator a school or non-renew the operator and keep the school open as a Traditional School tonight's vote on the annual review of schools is a pival moment and will shape the district's work moving forward the board does not take any of
008the suggestions recommended lightly we truly appreciate the feedback we received from our students staff families and Community thank you going to move to our pep agenda this evening um for our quasi judicial matters do we have pep this evening I welcome up um our uh chief of human capital Emily Nelson thank you commissioner s good evening Commissioners on this evening's pep agenda from the office of the chief academic officer we have an appointment recommended that Brad Petri currently educational associate 10 month be appointed director preschool special education effective January 25th 2025 recommended that Joy Guthrie currently School Success Lea on literacy be appointed coordinator literacy Improvement effective January 25th 2025 from the office of the chief of schools an appointment recommended that kaisha Jordan currently educational associate at parkheights Academy be appointed assistant principal at
009parkheights Academy effective January 25th 2025 recommended that irn otera Santos currently educational associate 10mon at hird elementary middle be appointed assistant principal at hird elementary middle effective January 25th 2025 recommended that T Thomas currently educational specialist to school counseling be appointed assistant principal at Carver Vocational Technical High School effective January 23th 2025 recommended that Sarah Dexter Thorton currently assistant principal at viviant T Thomas Medical Arts be appointed managing assistant principal at viviant Thomas Medical Arts effective January 25th 2025 through June 30th 2025 a reassignment recommended that Dana quenu currently principal at Green Street Academy be appointed interim assistant principal at Paul Lawrence Dunbar effective January 25th 2025 to June 30th 2025 and from the office of the chief of finance an appointment Shan McCullum currently or excuse me formerly Chief Financial Officer Cecil County government
010be appointed director of accounting effective January 25th 2025 congratulations to everyone on tonight's pep agenda thank you so much to nson um normally that is remarks but we' switched around some of the agenda to accommodate this evening so I am going to turn it over to Dr cist for CEO comment thank you thank you very much chair and uh this evening's um CEO comments uh given the uh large amount of time we know that we dedicate to annual review each year will be particularly short um and you all may say after this that it should be this way every week and I'm okay with that um but I do want to um not miss this opport opportunity uh to pass out an important shout out to Chief Lynette Washington executive director Scott Washington and the
011entire facilities team for their hard work throughout winter break to make sure that our schools were ready for students even before it snowed the facilities team worked every day during break to check temperatures and maintain more than 160 school buildings throughout a period of intense cold following the snow early last week the team worked efficiently to prepare our school campuses to receive students allowing City Schools to reopen earlier than many districts in our area I want to give my sincere thanks to every member of this team for a job well done we appreciate you and chair that concludes my remarks for this evening yeah I know see don't get used to it don't just kidding zero motion to approve the Quasi judicial matters so move kinat Bay thank you commissioner kinat is there a second
012second espo thank you commissioner espo all in favor commissioner a messenger AES messenger yes yes thank youo yes Kat Bay yes Mohamed yes commissioner reader yes Harington yes and I am also in favor this motion passes I will now review the cons board colleagues please let me know if you would like an item REM moved and please State your question for staff please note that all the comar and contract items will be voted on individually 11.01 School Works LLC 15.0 CS transformational School agreement 15.2 Associated taic Charities Head Start btim City lease agreement item 16.01 Express Scripts prescription drug Benefit Management Services contract increase and extension at a is it item 5.01 BTU Sor go ahead Dr okay uh do we have Melissa McDonald okay this is actually a video so Melissa McDonald from she's
013a member of the Baltimore teachers union and this will be a video for public comment um T we don't have any sound e why don't we go ahead and skip this and move to General Public comment yeah um I do have um one person who's commenting live let me let me one moment we're having um technical difficulty okay thanks Patricia we're going to go ahead and do our live public comment if you guys want to work on that while we have that um we'll have Rhonda Retta come up City Springs Elementary Middle School um agenda topic Charter renewal for City Springs and you will have three minutes whenever you're ready good evening Commissioners good evening Dr Santa lisis as you just heard I'm Ronda Retta the very proud principal of City Springs Elementary Middle School
014and I come before you today on behalf of our entire city Springs Community to make a final heartfelt plea for your consideration to grant us more than a three-year renewal this request comes in light of the significant challenges we've faced during this renewal period largely due to the relocation of our families by the housing authority of Baltimore city as part of the Perkins homes Redevelopment a few weeks ago I shared with you in detail the reasons behind our request today I would like to provide you with some updated current data and uh that I hope will further inform your decision as you consider our appeal since the start of the 2024 school year our enrollment has increased by 80 students in November 111 students had perfect attendance and in December the number Rose to 149
015in addition the percentage of students who were chronically absent is trending to decrease significantly our chronic absent ISM rate for school year 2324 was at an all-time high of 68.9% today the percent of students who are trending towards being chronically absent is at 46.6% a noteworthy Improvement this data clearly indicates that the relocation of our families had a direct and negative impact on our chronic ABS absenteeism rate and by extension our climate rating for Renewal however as more families return to our community we are already seeing promising progress in our attendance adding to our historically renowned positive and supportive School climate with this in mind I respectfully urge you to consider how the ongoing housing Redevelopment has uniquely affected our school and Community I ask that you do not let this challenge negatively impact our
016renewal process instead I ask for the opportunity to focus our time energy and resources on supporting the families who are returning and welcoming our new families to City Springs by granting us more than a three-year renewal at this time along with the Baltimore curriculum project our school staff partners Scholars and families look forward to continuing our work together with City Springs Elementary Middle School as a pillar of our community thank you thank you well we'll go we will go back to Melissa McDonald member of Baltimore teachers union for the video and swiftly switch to midterms and third good evening board Commissioners and Dr Santa lisis my name is Melissa McDonald and I serve on teacher chapter of the btu executive board and I'm an Ela teacher at connections today I'm going to address three topics
017one planning time two the human capital recruitment practices and three the CEO search this this is an intense time of year for educators we reflect on our first semester outcomes and swiftly switch to midterms and third quarter tasks we need a reduction in redundant tasks that consume our instructional planning time BTU members need our academic planning time protected and not filled with mandated redundant tasks redundant tasks include writing and sending attendance letters completing failure charts inputting data into data link attending repetitive PDS and other Data Tracking efforts we need more time for instructional planning so we can reflect on learn learner outcomes and adjust instructional feedback Cycles instead of redundant tasks from North Avenue this month schools begin sharing recruitment Flyers within BTU ranks advertising vacancies hoping to lure candidates to a new school home
018for next year we school-based staff increasingly struggle due to Staffing shortages and this affects our students learning and safety despite these critical shortages year after year new hires both internal but especially external candidates struggle with the same predictable challenges during the job Prof offer process communication from human capital hiring team is extremely delayed resulting in losing valuable candidates to other Maryland districts or schools confusion and misinformation regarding salary offers and confusion and misinformation from the office of certification to the hiring team regarding who is eligible for a conditional certification the btu suggests the following three solutions to these perennial issues one provide every external candidate a copy of the new higher salary placement chart from the btu contract salary offer should not be a secret process a transparent salary offer process would reduce the need
019for salary adjustments after incorrect placement on the salary pathway incorrect salary offers offers without explanation drives external candidates away to other districts two the hiring team needs to review comar regulations on certification why are certain candidates rejected when state law says they're eligible for a conditional license has the hiring team updated their guidance to align with the new msde certification regulations and three prioritize timely communication to internal candidates and new hires why do external candidates wait months to hear back from human capital communication and job offers delay results in we the Educators experiencing partially staffed schools in August or new hires walking into schools without any training stop the practice of new hires walking into classrooms with zero training or onboarding with planning time and hiring practices in mind we hope the CEO search will
020Center a candidate who prioritizes increasing planning time for educators and decreasing the endless stream of initiatives and redundant tasks that take take away from teaching and learning we appreciate the board taking steps to conduct a national public transparent search for the next CEO there are examples around the country that can support this board and District staff in the search process the first step is engaging a full range of stakeholders to develop a profile of the ideal CEO candidate a second strategy is to create a workg group to support the board that includes labor Community families and students this work group can be seated in Coalition with the school board third look at other districts St Paul Minnesota or Philadelphia Pennsylvania public schools provided public facing dashboards used to update the community during their CEO search
021on the CEO search dashboard the BTU wants publicly available timelines consistent and meaningful updates survey outcomes and Leadership profiles large lists of candidates and lists of top finalists the btu wants Community engagement opportunities wild widely advertised as well as surveys and their responses published on the dashboard candidate interviews should be publicly streamed with the opportunity for public comment the btu wants the final three interviews held publicly and live streamed and the final vote by the board for the CEO public and live streamed everything that can be legally done in the public domain should be done in the public domain this is something that has been done in other districts and can be done here uh to ensure that our city gets the best outcome from the CEO search process thank you and have a good
022evening thank you we have one more public comment from David demz Falmer City College notification this will also be a video hello everybody my name is David Demis and I a secondary social studies teacher in Baltimore City Public Schools I'm providing public comment on the issue of certification but before I do please note that my case is not unique in November of 2022 I was hired on a conditional certificate while I was still completing my master's degree in certification requirements naturally I was elated when I completed both in May of 20123 while finishing up my first year of teaching I submitted all of my credentials via the SE and Employee Self-Service my graduate transcript with a Maryland approved program stamp edtpa score report practice content exam and so on and carefully follow the instructions of
023bcpss certification off officers to receive my then Prof Prof kit one as quickly and smoothly as possible it is now January of 2025 about 1 month ago on December 11th 2024 I finally received my initial professional license one over a year and a half after I had obtained the requirements for it the ipl1 label is the only part of my license that is correct this document still says my highest degree is a bachelor's and does not live list my secondary 7 through 12 social studies certification I'd like to focus though on its issue date May 30th 20124 which occurred by the way 121 days after I applied for the then spc1 and 195 days before the certificate itself was issued and sent to me as a PDF the issue date of our teaching licenses is
024important in line with District goals I am pursuing national board certification to even begin the national board process a teacher must have a professional certificate or license in Maryland in IPL one or higher and to achieve certification a teacher must have taught full-time for 3 years while possessing the professional certificate or license throughout because the issue date of my ipl1 was delayed by over a year an entire year of committed teaching is essentially erased from my NBC employment eligibility potentially delaying certific a and career earnings too the inefficiency from the office of certification deinen diviz newer teachers and Veteran teachers to achieve nbct status I share this timeline knowing that I speak for many Educators across our district with similar stories whose accomplishments and worth are devalued when they are not reflected on paper certification
025should be a smooth and timely process not a pressing distraction from deliv delivering quality education to our youth going forward I implore the board to direct the office of human capital to implement a more accurate thorough and efficient process for reviewing issuing and updating certificates and licenses thank you for your time and consideration great thank you so much believe that concludes all of our public comment for this evening based on public comments are there any items um any board members would like to pull from the consent agenda this evening is there a motion to approve the consent agenda not related to com and contract renewal so move to Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito is there a second second kinat Bay thank you commissioner kinat Bay all in favor commissioner a messenger yes commissioner Ki yes
026commissioner Esposito yes commissioner kinata Bay yes commissioner Mohammad um commissioner Parker sorry it's absent commissioner re wallinger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slayer Harrington yes and I am in favor any oppose this motion passes I will now turn it over and invite our staff actually I'm invite our staff from the office of new initiatives to support the second part of our consent agenda this evening related to our comar we're waiting for staff to trickle in um up front um on an annual basis the board as I mentioned earlier makes amendments to the 21st century buildings plan the board will now consider recommendations related to changes to exhibit six of the 21st century buildings plan actually we'll give our colleagues from the office of initiatives an opportunity to introduce themselves this evening um good evening um
027CH Sally and board Commissioners I'm Angela avz I'm the senior executive director of The Office of new initiatives for City schools good evening Tiffany Young specialist office of new initiatives good evening everybody I'm Lindsay Anderson I'm a manager in the office of new initiatives welcome welcome stand by e I can hear myself in here can you hear me oh good why don't we go ahead and make sure everybody's muted thank you all right there's a lot of logistics [Music] all right um before I start I just want to um thank all the people that are involved in this process this is a huge process um that includes um a lot of stakeholders um from our central office staff teams um they involve members from almost every Department as well as our new and Charter operator
028L schools ADV board which is a volunteer board who reviewed um substantial applications and um spent a substantial amount of time with the heavy lift of this year's process um I want to thank our school operators um we work in a district where um I'm happy to say that I think all of our operators are sincere in trying to dite by kids it's hard work uh it's complicated work um and people are putting the best uh foot forward um which is not always true nationally um when we look at what happens especially in the operator World um I also want to thank our families I know the board has been listening to all of the testimony um whether you sent in letters you participated in work sessions you participated in comar hearings um and really
029um uh are Ted with some very challenging decisions um in a district where it's not easy um and so I just wanted to sort of start um with that um this um set of recommendations touches probably on all of our board priorities but in particular priorities 3 through 7 so everything from uh making sure our student staff um and um families have access to high quality modernized facilities to engaging stakeholders including our students uh and these important processes um to providing um Equitable access um to District resources um ensuring that we have a high quality educational experience for students and increasing the number of schools that meet that and making sure we're continuously working towards Equity um one of the things that underg guards um our belief is that all students in City Schools deserve
030a high quality education in healthy facilities that support teaching and learning um this school system has been engaged over the last decade plus and major change work um resulting in Monumental um uh improvements um to schools within our district not seen in many other places across the country and as part of that deal has had to close and combin schools for a number of years um and one of the things that uh this school system has prioritized and our boards have prioritized is that school communities where we've had to close schools first as part of this plan were the first to get those historic investments from 21st century um and so um um when we're looking at where school's closed we should also be paying attention to what schools open even though it doesn't there's
031loss and it's these are hard hard decisions um but we're all trying to do the best to live up to that ideal that um I started at the beginning uh and made a real sincere commitment to focusing on our communities that are disinvested in as first and when you know 21st century and build to learn doesn't get us to all of our schools and so we've been using all sorts of different resources um as we have continued to have to clu and combined schools due to enrollment changes um in order to ensure that students are really getting everything that they deserve to push and prioritize those schools for any additional resources we get whether it's through the uh leadership of our Dr Washington who and her team who was a knowledge at the beginning and
032really being strategic in how we use our Capital funds uh do the leadership of virt for staff and how we use partner funds to push into schools um and because of all of that um we're getting many more students into facilities that have seen Investments but the need is still there and um the way we're inequitably funded is still there and we are continuing to Advocate and will continue to Advocate until we meet that goal I'm going to turn over to Lindsay just to give an update on what's quickly on What's um um happened to schools that have gone through um combining of other school communities good evening um the first school that we're going to provide an update on is the historic Samuel cge Taylor Samuel clerge Taylor received uh students from Utah marshburn
033when that school closed in 2023 it was one of three receiver schools from Utah marshburn so as a result um the year after they combined with students from Utah marshburn their enrollment went up 21% um after the merge with Utah marburn they were able to add a full-time dance teacher and a full-time art teacher um because they're named after a black composer and musician it's a vision of principal Adams to really build up a robust arts program um they are they continue to steadily do that um expanding their Arts offerings to include choir production media and Visual Arts students also have access to Afterschool programming through the Y of central Maryland in school tutoring and a variety of clubs um the year after Samuel CID Taylor um absorbed students from Utah marshburn we renamed their
034community center after Teresa marshburn who was a parent and an advocate and a crossing guard in the community as a way to maintain the legacy of um her Legacy and the legacy of the school um as Angela shared we really um leverage all of all of the internal and partnership Investments we can when we make these closures and combining um Samuel cge Taylor is an example of that facilities improvements that we've made include um in Spring 2024 uh the school received a School makeover through the heart of America and the Ravens that provided a renovation to the Teresa marshburn Community Center renovations to two staff lounges and VIP lounges for students new painting and classrooms throughout the building repairs and upgrades to the playground um landscaping and um refreshes to The Outdoor Classroom space Renovations
035in new furniture in the school's Courtyard and repainting in the gym um in Spring 2024 the school was awarded a Maggie Macintosh Arts Center Grant to renovate their Auditorium and Auditorium foyer that amazing beautiful space just opened in December um and you can see a lot of us were there for their um premiere of The Nutcracker the next school we wanted to share about is Augusta fell Savage Institute for visual arts Augusta Fells combined with um high school students from blueford Drew Jamison which closed last year so this is their first year as a combined School Augusta FS received 62% of the Rising through 12th graders from blueford Drew Json um as a result of um their increased School population they've been able to increase their AP course offerings as well as offerings in the
036Arts they've added photography and digital media to bridge the art and stem focus of both schools they also added a full-time librarian to support literacy across the school um this year uh redesigning mines um and the movement team have um supported building a combined School culture at Augusta Fells redesigning mind was a partner that was brought over from blueford J emson um and they focus on providing male mentoring to students so now they're working with all male students at Augusta FS this spring we're going to be going through a renaming process um to determine how the combined school can honor the legacy of blue for Drew Json and Augusta Fels and their Joint School culture um as uh all both schools are named after notable African-Americans um facilities improvements that we've made so far include
037Renovations last summer um they received a new health Suite upgrades to several classrooms including new flooring lighting painting and Storage security enhancements and an upgrade to the PA system um last fall the school was named as a a recipient of the Maggie Macintosh Art Center grant program and they will receive renovations to their Art Gallery spaces that feature student work so now we're going to um head into um the voting portion of tonight um there's a lot of legal requirements that we have to make sure that we're on the record for um and so for members of the public you're going to have he us read from my script the script allows the board to modify accept approve reject do different things within it the purpose of it is to make sure we don't make
038a technical error um and all the required things are on the record uh so may sound a little stilted but that but but that is why um so we heard tonight for um the votes uh and so we're going to start with um recommendations that are related to traditional schools in that process we're looking at academic performance and access to programs um climate indicators and availability supports access quality and distribution of um programming ensuring um all populations of students are equitably served uh across Geographic areas as well as across student populations School enrollment and school size building utilization and condition um actions necess for the 21st century um school buildings plan um and um later we'll get to operate a ren or of 18 schools up for review uh we're going to start um Lindsay's
039going to walk us through amendments to zibit six um so as Angela shared as a part of the 21st century school buildings plan the district was required to Surplus 26 buildings back to the city of Baltimore exhibit six is um the list of the buildings we are able to make changes to exhibit six um as construction needs change and our needs as a district change as long as 26 buildings remain on the list um to date 23 of the 26 buildings have already been surplused so the first change to exhibit six um is a recommendation to change the Surplus date of the th Good Marshall building from 2027 to 2026 the thir Good Marshall building um currently houses Furley Elementary School and Vanguard Collegiate Middle School they are in the thir Good Marshall building while
040their permanent school buildings are under construction um in 2023 the board voted to push the Surplus date of the thir Good Marshall building to uh 2027 as we thought it might needed to be needed to be used for um swing space for City College since then the swing plan and construction schedules have changed and city will be swinging under the campus of the University of Baltimore furly is expected to move into its renovated building in summer 2025 and Vanguard will move in summer 2026 and at that point we will not need to use the building for educational purposes um therefore we are recommending to change the Surplus date to 2026 therefore it is the recommendation of the CEO that exhibit six of the 21st century school buildings plan be amended to change the date of
041the thir Good Marshall building from 2027 to the Surplus date of the thir Marshall building from 2027 to 2026 I concur with the recommendations as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff I'll open the floor as well uh for Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation I move that the board accepts the CEO recommendation as stated second thank you so much um Now read a roll call uh commissioner am messenger am messenger yes Coy yes espo yes commissioner kinat Bay yes commissioner Mohammed yes commissioner reading linger yes commissioner Rooks yes M Slater Harrington and I am also in favor that motion passes the next the next recommendation um related to exhibit 6 is um related to the Southeast Middle building and the Joseph Brisco building uh the southeast building has served as a temporary
042swing location for schools receiving Renovations through Capital Improvement program or 21st century um currently Commodore John Rogers is um being housed in the Southeast Middle building while their their permanent building is being renovated as a part of 21st century we know the population is growing in the Southeast area of the city and the building um could house a new school and alleviate overcrowding and other schools in that area um therefore we are we are recommending to remove the southeast building from exhibit 6 and retain it in the city schools portfolio um and use the building to house a new school once it's no longer needed for swing space as a part of the 21st century school buildings program Joseph C Brisco will collocate with Frederick Douglas um in the renovated Douglas building so once that
043building is complete the Brisco building will be no longer needed and therefore we are recommending to add the Joseph SE Brisco building to exhibit with the Surplus date of Summer 2026 or when the renovated Frederick Douglas Brisco campus is complete therefore it is the recommendation of the CEO that exhibit six of the 21st century school buildings plan be amended to remove the southeast building retain the building in the city schools portfolio for use as a new school once it's no longer needed for swing space and in its place add the Joseph C Brisco building to exhibit six with a surplus date of Summer 2026 or when the renovated Fred Douglas Brisco campus is complete I concur with the recommendations as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening and the floor for
044Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation I move that the board accept the CEO's recommendation as stated thank you commissioner Rooks I'll Now read a roll call it has to be oh I'm so sorry second moving part here thank you I'll take uh commissioner kenay on the now we roll call um commissioner am messenger yes commissioner COI yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes commissioner kinata Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes commissioner minger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slayer Harington yes and I'm also in favor that motion passes we'll now move forward into to um for closure excuse me um combining enclosure of a school so this recommendation is for Edwood Elementary School the recommendation is to combine Edwood with gwyns Falls Elementary School with a small of students being to Hills Elementary Middle School by closing Edwood
045Elementary um split the Edgewood zone between the Windor Hills Elementary Middle School Zone and the gns Falls Elementary School Zone Zone and surplus the Edgewood building to the city of Baltimore in summer 2025 after it is no longer needed for educational purposes um Edwood has been the smallest School serving grades prek through fifth grade in city schools for many years and the enrollment continues to decline um due to uh declining population in that part of the city um sustainability for a school of this size has been a concern for many years the school has needed supplemental funds to meet coma requirements for the past several years um when schools are this small and need supplemental funding just to meet basic requirements um School principles have to make tough decisions just to be able to offer
046the basics to their students and are not able to offer everything that they would like to offer to students the rich and robust programming that we know that all students deserve and that students in larger schools have access to um in order to help with utilization EDT has become home to many Citywide Early Learning programs um and and city-wide element El programs if this recommendation is approved City Schools would relocate these programs to other schools um nearby gwin Falls Elementary School and Windsor Hills Elementary Middle Schools both have space for more students and all inzone Edgewood students live within a mile of either school um all three schools have academic strengths um Edgewood gwin Falls and Windsor Hills and it is the goal of this recommendation that by bringing the schools and the staff together
047we we will bring the strongest parts of both all schools um and will'll build on the strengths to benefit all School communities and um you know we hope that we demonstrated a little bit of that by what we're doing uh with schools that have recently combined um despite its small size eduid has had strong academic performance on the most recent um Maryland comprehensive Assessment program the mcap assessment uh for grades three to five in English language arts and it was rated a three star School uh in 2023 and in 2024 um so this is really about the um declining enrollment and not academics um Edgewood gnsf Falls and Windsor Hills have had very similar average student performance levels in English language arts um their average student performance is 2.02 2.09 and 1.98 respectively are all
048within the developing Learners category so both gwin Falls and Windsor Hills are on par with Edgewood um and Ela uh for grades three through five Windsor Hills of the three schools has the strongest math performance on the most recent mcap um where 23.5% of the students are proficient or Advanced which is 8.7 percentage points higher than Edgewood and 14.8 percentage points um higher than gwin Falls and so again just sharing all of this to say that each school has strengths and we hope to bring the strengths of of all the schools together in this um gwin fall just a little bit about the receiving schools um gwin Falls is a community school with with the Y Maryland as its lead agency um the school has been a social emotional learning site since school year 201819
049they offer academically focused after school programs through the YMCA springboard and literacy connections they offer Amplified tutoring in math and literacy tutting in chapter one tutoring Windsor Hills Elementary Middle School is a community school with the city schools as the lead agency they have been an intensive wholeness site since 201920 they offer after school programming through the family league and springboard literacy tutoring through the literacy lab math tutoring through sign and seal clubs with perfectly me superhero club for elementary students I'm sorry elementary students the school also offers athletic programs such as flag football volleyball basketball tennis and palm Squad uh so this slide just shows the Edwood Elementary enrollment over time and this is the map of the a map of the Edgewood students um and you can see here how the Zone would
050be divided between Windsor Hills and gwin Falls if the um recommendation is approved the the heat shows um kind of some where most of the students live in the zone so students would be rezoned to either Windor Hills or gwin Falls depending on where they live in the zone pick up here um uh Edgewood and um shares of right away with the parking lot that's the wber building uh and so this is just showing the part of what we're Surplus is in the dark blue in the bottom right where you see Edgewood that's what we're Surplus we're maintaining obviously our parking lot it goes to wber building P Kip and our entry points into that um so this just to be really clear about what's going back to the city and so with that Cod
051of Maryland regulations orar and City Schools policy FCA closing of schools requires that local Boards of Education ensure at a minimum that consideration is given to the impact of a proposed closure on the following eight factors student enrollment Trends data taken into consideration may include as appropriate student enrollment trends for The Last 5 Years including disaggregated data on student disabilities and English learners for both the school proposed forclosure and the scho schools to which students are proposed to be resed two age of condition of the school building data taken into consideration may include dates of the last major Renovations of both the school proposed forclosure and the school or schools to which students are proposed to be resoled three Transportation data taken into consideration may include transportation and considerations for safe travel of students regarding
052both the school proposed foreclosure and the school or schools to which students are proposed to be resoled for educational programs data taken into consideration may include education programs in both the school proposed foreclosure and the school or schools to which students are being proposed to be resolved including um one specialized programs like advanced placement honors programming special education programs Athletics restorative practice designations before and after care tutoring and mentoring and or Community Partnerships as available two school performance data including State assessments as available three School climate culture data as available and four staff Staffing including teacher retention and certif certification data as available five racial composition of the student body dat data taken into consideration may include information regarding both the school proposed forclosure and the school or schools to which students are proposed to
053be reson six Financial considerations data taken into consideration may include information regarding both the school proposed forclosure and the score schools to which students are proposed to be resed including additional allocations need to stabilize School budgets the ability of the receiving school or schools to provide robust academic programming pending facilities challenges and facility debt at the school proposed forclosure seven student relocation data taken into consideration may include Geographic challenges opportunities distance of students from the school proposed forclosure and the school or schools to which students are proposed to be reson movement of city-wide education programs associated with the school proposed foreclosure and impact on student access to specialized programs programming and a impact on community and Geographic attendance area for the school proposed to be closed and our schools to which students will be relocating
054including opportunities and challenges in the geographic attendance area for the school proposed for closure and the schools or schools to which students will be relocating for tonight's recommendation to combine School communities by Closing one Traditional School the board has receive data including each of the eight comart factors the schools recommended for in in is Edgewood Elementary School with gnall Elementary School and a portion uh to Windor Hills Elementary Middle School based on the consideration of Staff recommendations presented in the annual review of school's recommendations report testimony at the board hearings the contents of the official record the eight comar fa factors um just read it is a recommendation of the CEO that the Edgewood Elementary School program combines with gall Elementary School that Edwood elementary school closes effective summer 2025 that the appr the board
055approved the expansion of the gwin Fall Falls Elementary Zone to include the portion of Edgewood Zone East of Garrison Boulevard and Edgewood Street and the expansion of the Windsor Hills Elementary mle Zone to include the portion of the Edgewood Zone West of Garrison Boulevard and Edgewood Street and that City School Surplus the Edgewood building and parcel excluding the wall Brook parking lot and entryway back to the city of Baltimore in summer 2025 I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening CH yes um if I may I just want to to speak on this as one who actually lives in one of the uh the zones lives I live in Windsor Hills um and had the opportunity to visit all three of the schools that are in
056question and I just want to commend the thoughtfulness the the sincerity of everybody that has been involved at the school level in these considerations uh and just um just add that that it's obviously a change that is being proposed here but the thoughtfulness um is of note and so I wanted to add add my uh my thoughts there and say that you know I took that um that opportunity because of uh you know wanting to see and understand what size of Elementary and elementary middle schools uh is is a healthy size from not only the physical facilities perspective not only the budget perspective but especially the student learning and experience perspective uh so thank you for the hard work that you all put uh into this thoughtful process thank you commissioner um I'd also like
057to comment I think one of the things that was made pretty clear in talking to folks as we were visiting schools is that there's a desire to um really potentially reinvigorate and rethink and reimagine programming in that part of Baltimore um and I want us as a board and as a district to take that seriously um a as well as to note that there are some very special programs at Edgewood and um that we take very seriously the the care and support of those programs um uh in whatever form they take moving forward thank you commissioner rer additional comments I'll now open the excuse me go ahead I moved that based on the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the annual review of schools recommendations report issued on November 12th the testimony
058given at the two public hearings the contents of the official Racket and the eight Co are factors that the board accept the CEO's recommendation as stated thank you commissioner Ken B may here a second Ames messenger second thank you commissioner am messenger I'll Now read a roll call commissioner am Messenger as messenger yes commissioner qu yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner kinat Bay yes commissioner Muhammad no thank you noted commissioner reading linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks no thank you commissioner Rooks uh commissioner Slater Harrington no no and um I am in favor or five in favor six in favor I'm sorry three um opposed and one absent that motion passes okay we're going to head into operator renewal um before we go too far I want to invite Chief Jones um to introduce herself and
059um turn on her camera thank you so much good evening everyone this is Teresa Jones Chief achievement and accountability officer Chief Jones is joining us from a conference she's hardworking lady uh and so we'll be tag teaming uh in person and uh tonight between the three of us um so um we have 18 schools that are up for Renewal um and um our operative renewal process was originally developed in 2012 um working with operators and other partners um to ensure that we had a robust process um that had some level of consistency while also being able to manage changes that uh can occur uh year to year we've G through different state assessments during that time we've experienced Co during that time uh and so we've created a very robust process that um considers both
060qualitative and quantitative um feedback uh and has um flexibility to deal with um those sorts of changes um renol for um all the schools that are up actually started for them last school year so they've been going through this process for a while with um uh coming to the call tonight um the board um for any school can make um uh any of the following recommendations consistent with board policy and uh required law um they they can approve a school for a three-year Ral which is considered a partial Ral a 5-year Ral which is considered a full renal um an 8-year R which is considered an extended your Ral that's for schools who've had two prior four rals consecutively before tonight and more effective or highly effective um those are schools that get recommended um
061for AAL in all of the key areas um or a nonrenal and a non-renal could can be anything from a non-renal and close school at the end of the year or a non-renal and keep the school open um as a traditional school so all of those options for every school are before the um board tonight um the um process is multi-tiered it started with our Charter and operator Le schools Advisory Board whose function is to review the application submitted by our operators and provide advice to the CEO on what the recommendations should be for each School based on the review of those applications um the CEO then considers those and then finalizes recommendations that go to the board and um some of that finalization um continues during the process and consideration of what's happened in
062work sessions and what's happened at Community meetings um and tonight we're before the board whose role it is to make the ultimate decision um that has and the board has to consider all of the things that happened so far so with that we are going to go ahead and get into our first school great thank you so much the first school for consideration this evening is the Baltimore design school this is a school for students in grades 6 through 12 which approximately 502 students enrolled it's actually opened in 2011 and has had a history that involved two prior full-term renewals next slide please this evening's recommendation uh is in 8-year renewal uh this school received effective ratings in all three categories as noted student achievement climate and finance and governance several of the highlights are
063listed here um if you'll indulge me I will read through these um noting that there is additional information available in the renewal report uh they received a highly effective rating in the area of ela 10 uh which indicated that the average average learner is performing at a level three or a proficient learner level of proficiency this indicates that students have demonstrated that required Knowledge and Skills that are expected for the grade level and there are 60.3% of students reaching proficiency which is 33.4 percentage points higher than the median for other schools with similar levels of poverty they were also rated highly effective based on their four-year cohort graduation rate they had a three-year average of 98.7% and for two of those three years their rates were 100% which also included the year 2023 on the
064five essential survey um they were noted as having uh been well organized for Success which yielded a highly effective rating for that particular item they were also noted as effective in their chronic absence data uh where we saw significant decreases since school year 2122 um and that decreases were in grade six through 8 and gray band 9 through 12 uh respectively by 26.8 and 14.4 point when it comes to Fidelity to Charter and application overall they were also rated highly effective uh this particular measure is an indication that the school is delivering effective programming which is aligned to its Mission uh specifically I quote uh Baltimore design school Fosters creativity and develops the academic and critical thinking skills of sixth through 12th grade students and that they focus on architecture fashion design and graphic design
065and interactive media in accordance with policy ibj and administrative Reg regulation ibj and applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Baltimore design school incorporate to operate Baltimore design school be renewed for eight years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2033 I concour with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff I'll now open the floor for Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation for a motion from one of my fellow Commissioners I move that the based upon the consideration of the recommendations and the rationale of the CEO the oper op Ator
066uh renewal report the testimony given at The Operators run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulations ihb j- including sections uh 3 K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial reviews that the board accept the CEO's recommendation as stated thank you commissioner is there a second so moved or second thank you thank you all in favor um commissioner am messenger am messenger yes thank you commissioner COI abstain thank you commissioner Coy commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner Ken Bay yes Mohammad yes thank you commissioner ring linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slater Haron yes thank you and I am in favor that motion passes up
067next we have City neighbors High School number 376 operated by City Neighbors Foundation Inc R configuration 9th through 12th grade current enrollment 417 City neighbors High School opened in 2010 has had two prior full-term renewals and currently is in a 5-year renewal City neighbors high rated effective in student achievement effective in climate effective in finance and governance and the recommendation is an 8-year renewal more context they're infected mcap absolute performance for ELA 10 mcap where the average student is performing at a level two develop veloping learner indicating that students have partial proficiency 33.3% of students reach proficiency for this test which is 6.4 percentage points higher than the median for schools with similar poverty not effective in mcap absolute performance for Algebra 1 where the average learner is performing at a level one beginning learner
068indicating that students need additional academic support to ensure success in the next grade level effective and four-year cohort graduation rate with a three-year average of 87.5% the grad rate has increased over time with the 2023 in 2023 forear cohort graduation rate at 90% they're highly effective in the five essential survey this indicates that the school is well organized for Success they're also effective in each of the four School Effectiveness review measures highly effective instruction talented people vision and engagement and strategic leadership and Professional Management this means effective School practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness in accordance with policy ibj administrative regulation ibj and applicable law and based on consideration of the operative renewal report testimony at the operative ran
069school's work session and public hearings the content of the official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with City neighbors Foundation Inc to operate City neighbors High School be renewed for 8 years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2033 I concur with the recommendation as stated any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening I move please go ahead I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ihj and administrative regulation ihj ra including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public
070charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accept the CEO's recommendation as stated second thank you I'll take a second um commissioner K Bay um all in favor uh Comm am messenger am messenger yes thank you commissioner Quin yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner Kat Bay yes thank you commissioner Med yes thank you commissioner R longer yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington yes thank you and I'm also in favor that motion passes next we have the tonbridge school uh which is operated by AIA Baltimore it is a school that supports students in grades prek through eight and they have 508 students enrolled this school opened in 2010 and has had two fullterm renewals and it's currently in a 5-year renewal term term
071the tonbridge school is being recommended for an 8-year renewal with conditions to participate in a midc contract and administration of the five essential survey or similar tool they received effective ratings in all three categories for student achievement climate and finance and governance they were rated highly effective in their mcap growth for students in for uh excuse me Ela 4 four to five um they were ranked in the 82nd percentile from Middle grades math they were in the 99th percentile and for Middle grades Ela they were in the 96th percentile again growth is a measure that helps us understand to what extent did the school actually improve individual student performance year to year we take a look at their absolute performance in mcap they were also rated highly effective for performance in grade band Ela 6
072to8 this is where average student performance is at a level three level which is the proficient learner level again indicating that the students are demonstrating the required Knowledge and Skills that are expected for their grade level and they had a proficiency rate of 63.5% Which is 5.6% higher 5.6 percentage points higher than the median for schools with similar levels of poverty they're rated highly excuse me they're rated effective in their mcap absolute performance for middle grade math uh students there were performing at a level three which is the proficient learner level when we take a look at their absolute performance in math 3:5 and Ela 3:5 they were rated develop in developing is an indication that the average student is performing at a level two which is an indication that students have partial proficiency they
073were rated either or highly effective in each of the four School effess review measures which include highly effective instruction talented people vision and engagement and strategic leadership and Professional Management this is an indication that the school has effective practices or systems that have been adopted and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness and where highly effective um is an indication that the practices are having a strong or significant or sustainable impact on the schools overall level Effectiveness in accordance to policy ibj and administrative regulation ihb j- and applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renew report testimony at the operator run school work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contractor AIA B Inc to
074operate the TD school be renewed for 8 years with the condition that the school participate in a midpoint review via the five essential survey or a similar tool at year four and for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 303 I concur with the recommendations as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this even thank you I'll now open the floor for commissioner for disc the recommendation I move that the based upon the consideration of the recommendation and Russel the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj a including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that the public
075charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accepts the CEO's recommendation as stated thank you so much commissioner Rooks may I hear a second second Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito all in favor commissioner am messenger yes thank you commissioner Quin yes thank you uh commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R allinger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slayer Harrington thank you and I'm also in favor that motion passes next we have City neighbors Hamilton number 346 operated by City neighbors Foundation Inc grade configuration prek through 8th grade current enrollment 233 City neighbors Hamilton opened in 2009 the school has had both full and partial renewals currently in a three-year renewal which was the max that year
076due to the impact of covid City neighbors Hamilton rated effective Ino student achievement effective in climate effective in finance and governance the recommendation is for a 5-year renewal they rated highly effective in ela 6 to8 mcap growth at the 8 percentile relative to the other city schools in the same grade ban and in MA 6 through 8 88 percentile growth is is the extent to which a school improves individual student performance year toe they rated developing and mcap absolute performance for ELA 3-5 math 3-5 Ela 6-8 and math 6 through 8 indicating students are developing Learners in the subject and have partial proficiency highly effective on the five essential survey indicating the school is well organized for Success also are highly effective in suspensions as well as chronic absence the school's chronic absence and suspensions
077rates have remained low throughout the contract term and are well below the district averages for each grade Bandit serves the school attributes its success to the strength of its model that elevates student engagement relationships and parent School partnership and accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with City neighbors Foundation Inc to operate City neighbors Hamilton be renewed for five years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2030 I concur with the recommendation is stated did do any Commissioners have any questions for staff hearing none I'll open the
078floor for Commissioners for discussion of the recommendation I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given by the operator run school's work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in the policy ibj and the administrative regulations ihb j- including section 3. of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accept the CEO's recommendations as stated thank you so much commissioner is there a second second thank you commissioner R linger all in favor uh commissioner messenger yes commissioner Cory absent commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner breing linger yes thank
079you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner sler Harrington yes thank you and let me Circle back to commissioner Koy yes awesome thank you and I'm also in favor this evening that motion passes the next recommendation is for fir Templeton Preparatory Academy this is a school that serves students in prek through 5ifth grade they have 432 students enrolled and actually were a they were a Traditional School which became a charter school in 2011 and they have had multiple partial renewals that are currently in a three-year renewal term next slide please Fel Templeton Preparatory Academy is being recommended for a fiveyear renewal uh they received effective ratings in all three categories student achievement climate and finance and governance they received an effective rating in their mcap absolute performance for ELA grades 3 to 5 this is where
080students the average student was performing at a level two which is at the developing learner level indicating partial proficiency 20% of students received profic proficiency for this particular assessment uh which is six percentage points higher than the median for other schools with similar poverty levels they were rated developing in their mcap absolute performance for math for grade band to five uh where the average learner is performing at a level two the developing learner level again indicating partial proficiency they were rated developing for their mcap growth measure for ELA 4 to5 they were in the 77th percentile in the district for that particular area and they were developing when it comes to mcap growth for math for four to five in the 57th percentile again growth is an indication of progress uh for students um as
081we compare them to their student Statewide with similar prior test score so Improvement in the individual student performance on the five essential survey the school was rated highly effective uh with based on an indication that the school's ratings indicate that they are well organized for success and chief uh correct they were effective in mcap growth for ELA 4 through five um in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ij- an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator R report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings content of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with FL Templeton Preparatory Academy Inc to operate Ferman L Templeton prep Preparatory Academy be renewed for five years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and
082ends June 2030 I concur with the recommendation as stated thank you D any Commissioners have any questions for staff see um I'll now open the floor to Commissioners for discussion on recommendation I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendation and rational of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the Opera run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy IH hbj and administrative regulation ibj including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that the public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals and that the board accepts the CEO's recommendation as stated thank is there a second a messenger second thank you commissioner AMS messenger all in favor commissioner AMS messenger yes thank
083you commissioner yes commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kenat Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R linger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slater Harrington yes and I'm also in favor that motion passes this evening up next Bard high school early college Baltimore number 362 operator B College grade configuration 9 through 12th grade current enrollment 457 Bard high school early college Baltimore was opened in 20 5 they've had one prior full renewal bar rated effective in student achievement developing and climate effective and finance and governance the recommendation is for a three-year renewal bar rated highly effective in ela 10 where the average student is performing at a level three which is a proficient learner indicating that students demonstrate the required Knowledge and Skills expected for great level 53.1% of students reach proficiency for this
084test which is 26.2% percentage points higher than the median for schools with similar poverty they were effective in a four-year cohort graduation rating with a three-year average of 89.2% Highly Effective in College and Career Readiness College and Career Readiness looks at the extent to which a secondary school is preparing a student for College and Career by looking at a school participation and success in indicators such as the act or the SAT exams CTE dual enrollment APB Bard is at the 100 percentile developing and suspensions while the school is aware of its data and the school has implemented strategies it believes will reduce suspensions these strategies have not yet proven effective finally they're developing in two of the four School Effectiveness review measures highly effective instruction intelligent people a developing rating of the scr means evidence
085indicates that the key action including some indicators is a practice of or system that is emerging at the school but it's not yet implemented at a level that has begun to improve the school's Effectiveness in accordance with Pol policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj D and applicable law and based on consideration of operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Bard College to operate Bard high school early college Baltimore be renewed for three years for a term that commences on july1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff I'll now open the floor for Commissioners for
086discussion of the recommendation I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendation and rational of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the operative renewal run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj R A including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accepts the CEO's recommendation as stated is there a second thank you Commission Harrington all in favor commissioner am messenger yes sorry it's okay commissioner Ki yes thank you commissioner espaco yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner reading linger yes thank you commissioner Brooks yes thank
087you commissioner Slater Harrington and I'm also in favor of that motion passes this evening next we have the recommendation for the city Springs Elementary Middle School this is a school that's operated by the Baltimore curriculum project and serve students in prek through 8th grade it is an enrollment of 480 students it was originally a Traditional School which became a charter school in 1997 it has had a history that includes both full and partial renewals and it is currently in a threee renewal which was the maximum that was available due to covid at the time that they went through the process there is a recommendation this evening for a three-year renewal for City Springs Elementary Middle School based on the following ratings an effective rating in the category of student achievement developing for climate and effective
088rating for finance and governance they received an effective rating on their mcap absolute performance measure for ELA 3 to5 this is where the average student was performing at a level two or the developing learner level of proficiency which is a partial proficiency 27% of students received reached proficiency for this particular test and that was 13 percentage points higher than the medium proficiency rate for other schools with similar levels of poverty they were rated developing and their absolute performance for ELA 6 to8 math 3:5 and math 6 to8 where the average learner is performing at a level two the developing learner level with proficiency rates that are slightly higher than the median for schools with similar poverty in math 3:5 and math 6 to8 they are rated highly effective in their five essential survey results indicating
089that the school is well organized for Success they were also rated effective in Fidelity to Charter and the application overall indicating that the school's mission is clear to most stakeholders and that the school has implemented effective strategies to address challenges that were evident in the school's data City Springs mission is to improve student outcomes raise educational standards and to increase access to Opportunities their key Design Elements include direct instruction restorative practices and core knowledge and the school conducts weekly reviews of cohort and individual student data utilizes staff action teams and quarterly goal setting as a way to address challenges in their data in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ij- and applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renol report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and
090the contents of the official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Baltimore curriculum project Inc to oper City Springs Elementary Middle School be renewed for 3 years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 um and I I need to say one thing that I forgot to say at the beginning um uh uh we can't consider the testimony that was tonight there was not supposed to be any test the record closed on on uh January 10th thank you for that important Amendment for this evening I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening yes uh uh and we speak towards because I think this is very important the impact of Perkins homes closing and do
091are we aware of the impact as parents return to uh the community have our not taken into any consideration of what was uh presented this evening do we have any insight into uh the enrollment increasing based on parents returning after being removed from burgin's homes um so uh enrollment decrease of C Springs before that project was a school of like like seven 800 kids in fact they needed to be in two buildings um the city Springs building and then their early learning grades were in the Lumbard building across the street um because they outgrew that once the Perkins home project started their enrollment I think we is like half what it used to be is it likely that the um cohort retention rating of not effective was impacted by those events um we um actually
092updated their reading on um cohort retention because we think it was impacted so we actually removed that as a consideration spread the points because um there's a onetoone relationship with that uh with the with that change Bas Mater looked up please go ahead commissioner I move based upon the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given at the operators run school work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj a that the board reject the Coo's recommendation and modified to renew the school for a term of 5 years to commence of July 1st 2025 run through June 30th 2030 thank you commissioner based upon that motion that's on the floor is there a second
093second second can I provide additional rationale for um sure let's accept a second the I defer to Comm thank you um I was just given the dis uh sizable displacement of students and surrounding neighborhood as well as the uh long and restorative culture that they have built in the building um to build a healthy and responsive School culture um would be looking to support a five-year renewal thank you any additional comments yes I just wanted to add that um given time that is needed for recovery after something that happened that was not the school's fault um that we need to be um tolerant and also help them build back as the community builds back the school builds back thank you additional comments um clarification yes ma'am so um the motion that is on is for
094five not for the three that's right for five years so just to be really clear the motion on the board is for a fiveyear renewal yeah based upon that um and we have a second on the floor um going through the roll call this evening so commissioner am messenger yes thank you commissioner COI no thank you commissioner Coy No um commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R linger yes thank you commissioner Brooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington yes thank you and I'm in favor that motion passes with eight in favor one no and one absent this evening this is me uh so City neighbors Charter School uh is an elementary middle school um they have roughly 250 students uh they opened in 2005
095at the charter school um they've had a history of both full and partial Ren partial renewals and they're currently in a three-year um renewal um this school is effective in student achievement School climate and financial man and governance uh it is recommended for a three-year renewal um because it's not effective in effective programming for students with disabilities uh and so when there is a not effective in a that haacks a population of students um their recommendation has been to reduce that um in order to address that um in particular when we're looking at um programming for students abilities where we at the extent to which the schools demonstrated a strong trajectory of growth is aware of data and responsibility students with disabilities and have and has effectively and consistently implemented processes interventions and strategies to
096support student outcomes um special education compliance reviews have found significant issues that impact the delivery of services to students um that required uh free and public education or fatee evaluations um um in this school year we are seeing some improvement in practices but that that finding was significant and there was the review of um their entire um uh students with disability population that found challenges um across three years they are highly effective in each of its mcap growth measures Ela 4-5 Ela 6-8 math 4-5 and math 638 where the schools in the 84th 86 86 and 94th percentiles respectively they're effective and incap absolute performance for ELA 3 to5 where the average student performance is a level two indicating partial proficiency um but where the school's uh proficiency of 45.8% is 15.6 percentage points higher
097than the median for schools with similar poverty they are effective in incap absolute performance for math 3 to five um where that 23.9% is 5.7% much higher than the median for schools with similar prty they are developing an effective programming for all student racial ethnic groups which considers um School diverse populations um whether there are achievement gaps that exist between student groups what the school how whether the school providing High qu programming for all students and the processes and practices the school is using to address gaps and ensure high achievement for all students this school had prior conditions related to this area um uh the school's math 3 to5 mcap um uh State growth percentile ranks from then um change from 40 the 44th percentile to the 59th percentile um higher than the median uh
098in ela 3 to5 mcap SGP fell from the 54th percentile to the 40 first percentile which is basically the median in accordance with policy ibj and administrative ibj regulation ibj ra and applicable law and based on consideration of the operator Ren report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the content of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract City neighbors Foundation Inc to operate City neighbors Charter School be renewed for 3 years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff see I'll now open the floor for Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation um there's unless there's discussion I will offer an amendment I
099move that based upon the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operat renewal report the testimony given at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two conse two consecutive partial renewals that the board modified the CEO's recommendation to add the following condition a that the school improves its practice that the school improves its practices when it comes to providing services and programming to students with disabilities that the operator ensures the school improves compliance with relevant requirements and the subsequent reviews of the school special education practices must demonstrate substantial Improvement particularly in
100areas that reflect services to students thank you commissioner re linger based upon the motion that's on the floor this evening is there a second second Muhammad thank you commissioner Muhammad all in favor commissioner Ames messenger yes thank you commissioner Co yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kyat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R allinger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington yes and I'm also in favor that motion passes up next we have El Henderson at John Hopkins partnership school number 368 operated by East Baltimore Community School Inc grade configuration prek through 8th grade current enrollment 637 Henderson Hopkins opened in 2009 the school has had both full and partial renewals currently they're in a three-year renewal Anderson rated developing and student achievement effective
101in climate effective and finance and governance the recommendation is for a three-year renewal they rated howly effective and mcap growth for 6-8 they're in an 89 percentile in the district effective in ela 6-8 65th percentile goow to the extent to which a school improves individual student performance year-to year they're effective and mcap absolute performance for ELA 3-5 and Ela 6-8 where the average student is performing at a level two developing learner indicating that students have partial proficiency for grades 3 through five 19.7 percentage of students reach proficiency for this test which is 5.7 percentage points higher than the medium for schools with similar prty for grade 6 through eight 28.4% of students are proficient which is 8.1 percentage points higher than they me for similar schools they ready developing and mcap absolute performance for math
1023 through five where the average student performance is performing at a level two developing learner indicating that students have partial proficiency but need additional academic support to ensure success in the next grade level they rated not effective in mcap absolute performance from math 6 through 8 where the average learner is performing at a level one beginning learner indicating that students need additional academic support to ensure success in the next grade level finally they are effective in three of the four School Effectiveness review measures talented people vision and engagement and strategic leadership and Professional Management as well as in seven of the the 12 key actions this means effective School practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at a new at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness in
103accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation isbj and applicable law and based on testimony at the operator run school's work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with East Baltimore Community School Inc to operate Elmer erson a Johns Hopkins partnership school be renewed for three years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated thank you do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening please real quick question for you because uh the amount of innovation I expect out of a school with such a strong backing in education have we seen uh a push to improve because um the results are good but they're not U what
104I expect from such an institution yeah um they they definitely have strong reflective practice they a school that um I think I wouldn't say one of the first schools in the district to really Embrace continuous Improvement and so that's reflected like in their application if you visit their school um they are really working hard on uh increasing um literacy within their school so there's been like an intentional focus on that uh on that practice um and and um they really are a school that believes in coaching so making sure that teachers are getting um coach uh that are coached the school leaders getting coached um and making sure that people are getting the tools they need to refine practice uh and so this is um a school operator that's always asking how can we be
105better how can we improve um in fact there questions during this process was oh we were weak in this area what should we do when can we meet to figure out how we do better thank you I'll open the floor for discussion of the recommendation is there a motion I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendation and rationale of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the Operator Operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board the CEO's recommendation as stated thank you commissioner Brooks is
106there a second second esposo thank you commissioner esposo all in favor commissioner am messenger yes thank you commissioner qu yes thank you commissioner espito yes thank you commissioner Kat Bay abstain thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington thank you and I'm in favor that motion pass passes with eight in favor one exstension this evening and one next we go ahead I'm sorry no no problem uh next we have the recommendation for the govin elementary school this is the school that's operated by the Baltimore curriculum project and serves students in prek through fifth grade they have an enrollment of 408 students goin's Elementary was originally a Traditional School which became a charter in 2015 the school has had multiple consecutive full renewals
107and is currently in a 5-year term Goen Elementary School is being recommended for a three-year renewal based on the following ratings in the areas of student achievement and finance and governance they were given an effective rating and then developing in the area of climate some of their highlights include an effective rating in mcap growth from math four to five they were rated in the 76th percentile in the district they were rated developing in the ELA fortifi measure at the 63rd percentile again growth is the extent to which a school improves the individual student performance year-over-year we they were also rated developing when it comes to the mcap absolute performance for ELA 3 to5 and math 3 to5 where the average student is performing at a level two which is the developing learner level indicating that
108they have partial proficiency they were also rated developing in their suspensions um as the school is aware of its data um has had positive behavior interventions in place and has implemented appropriate strategies that the school believes will decrease suspensions these efforts have yet to be proven effective the school has had a focus on relationship building and restorative practices and has implemented a peer mediator program that supports students in fourth and fifth grades to be student leaders again however the school suspensions have actually increased over the last three years and are higher than the district average for students in grades three to five in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ihb j- an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings
109and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract of Baltimore curric project Inc to operate Goen Elementary School be renewed for three years for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur with the recommend ation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff before we proceed based on suspension data has this um operator submitted any plan or there there was a plan there's still not evidence to support that that plan is working yeah I think the here mediation program is fairly new uh and so it's not yet showing in the data it's not yet decreasing the the their suspensions suspensions are is it the feeling based on your experience that conditions would not be warranted in this
110case yeah I think this is an OP I think this is an operator uh and a school that is U well known for like restorative practice I think it just it's going to take time to um figure out what what are the technical things that are not yet resulting in that data and and make those fixes but I don't uh I mean you know you're free to add conditions I don't think it's necessary ce's recommendation was not to to add conditions and I think part of that is because the operator has actually served as a model and a trainer in other school settings with that she say that was fair don't Zone in on that little girl believe me you can take my seat um but I do think because of the operators track record
111particularly in restorative practices and demonstrating plans over the years we did not feel in this particular case with this particular operator that that was necessary that doesn't mean we won't monitor thus the recommendation but that was the rationale thank you thank you any additional comments this evening I'll now open the floor to M Commissioners uh for discussion on the recommendation motion on the floor I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendation and rational of the CEO the Rob the operative renewal report the testimony given at the operative run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj a including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that public charter school is not eligible for
112two consecutive partial renewals that the board accepts the CEO recommendations as stated thank you sir second second Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito all in favor commissioner Ames messenger abstain thank you commissioner poy yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner Kat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner reading linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slayer Harrington thank you and I'm in favor that motion passes baltim minur Public Charter School number 336 operated by Baltimore Minos Inc grade configuration prek through 8th grade enrollment 604 the school opened in 2008 and has had two prior partial renewals but not consecutively UL amount of story rated developing and student achievement effective in climate effective in finance and governance and the recommendation is for a three-year renewal with conditions to maintain
113the current enrollment inclusive of the early learning grades they ready developing English language arts 3-5 math 3-5 and Ela 6-8 where the average student is performing at a level two developing learner indicating that students have partial proficency but need additional academic support to ensure success in the next grade level they're developing an effective programming for all student racial ethnic groups which for schools with diverse populations looks at whether there are achievement gaps that exist between student groups whether the school is providing high quality programming for all students and the processes and practices the school is using to address gaps and ensure high achievement for all students they rated highly effective or effective and three of the four School effectiv review measures talented people strategic leadership and professional management and vision and engagement as well as
114in nine of the 12 key actions this means effective School practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness and where highly effective the practices are high are having a strong significant or sustainable impact on the school's Effectiveness the condition being recommended is that the school not increase in enrollment Beyond current enrollment including in Pre kindergarten in accordance with policy ihb ja and administrative regulation ibj and applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Baltimore Monas Incorporated to operate Baltimore Monas Public Charter School be renewed for 3 years with the condition
115that the school does not continue to expand its enrollment and that that instead maintains current enrollment inclusive of early learning grades and for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 303 2028 I concur with I concur with the recommendation is stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff now open the floor for uh Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation I do want to raise for the board I uh that was someone's button there um I'm curious about this condition and I think as a matter of principle uh for a school that is performing well and um that to my understanding has a robust waiting list and in fact they run a lottery every year uh combined with the fact that I believe the operator stated that they understand that
116it wouldn't be prudent to grow now U I don't want to constrain schools like this in the future and so um I don't uh as a matter of principle I don't think the condition is one uh that would be wise for us to keep on there but I would like to open it up to discussion for other board members with perhaps contrary views so I'll add that the benefit of the uh young people matriculating through their system then we'll be able to see those results in later years in the higher grade so I agree with you and I'm open to changing and making modification uh to this uh open to hear what other Commissioners think before we suggest any amendments the meeting okay um so if there are no additional comments from board uh colleagues
117um I will entertain a motion I move the clar oh sorry por of clarification the limitation on EX continued growth would only be for the terms of the three-year renewal that we would then be able to reconsider after that three years is that correct that's correct I think on this one I would go with the recommendations as written that given just strains around leadership transition communication between Administration massaging how do you implement the monory model which is a challenging one in a public school setting um that I think providing that accountability for the time being would be would be my instinct but so respectfully I think um my stance would be that I think the school knows best when the school is ready to expand it especially given that they've demonstrated uh their that I've
118heard them say that they don't think it would be prudent to grow this year I think a lot can happen in a year and a lot can happen in two years and so I just don't believe we should be putting artificial constraints on schools but I'll offer the amendment and respectfully colleague you can vote it down so let's see where we go discussion yeah yes I just wanted um to offer Captain Obvious here that it also limits parent choice for the three-year period um and so wanting to keep it open for parents to be able charge their existence so that parent can parents can have increased amounts of choice and so it runs counter to that up move uh based on the consideration of the recommendations and ration of the CEO the operator renewal report
119testimony given at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj ra including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board modify the CEO's recommendation to remove the conditions and instead renew the school for a term of three years to commence on July 1 2025 and run through June 30 2028 based on the motion on the floor is there a second second Mohammad thank you commissioner Muhammad all in favor commissioner Ames messenger no thank you commissioner qu obain thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner muhamed yes thank you commissioner R linger
120excuse yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington yes and I and I'm also in favor that motion passes with two seven in favor one absent one exstension and one no next school next recommendation is for the belera Edison school this school is operated by AIA Baltimore and students in grades prek through 8 they have an enrollment of 9910 students the Beller adderson School converted to a charter school in 2016 as the brims Lane Elementary School was one of the lowest performing schools in the district for several years the operator soon after merged the elementary school with its middle school program which was called the AIA Public Charter School this school has had one prior three-year renewal with conditions the recommendation this evening is a three-year renewal with conditions to improve academic
121achievement and outcomes for students raise achievement of lower performing groups strengthening the school's approach to data as noted in the application and the school's School effess review their ratings were developing in the areas of student achievement and climate and effective in the area of finance and governance their highlights include a developing rating in the area of mcap absolute performance for ELA 3:5 math 3:5 and Ela 6 to8 this is indicating that students are developing Learners in the subject and have partial proficiency they were rated not effective in math 6 to8 um with an indication that students are beginning Learners and need substantial academic support to be prepared for the next grade level they were effective in three of the four School effectance review measures specifically talented people vision and engagement and strategic leadership and professional
122management as well as an eight of the 12 key actions this means that um effective School practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness they were R effective in their suspensions the school has decreased suspensions and has been focused on intentional strategies to support both students and staff from school year 2223 to school year 23 24 the school has decreased its suspension rates for Middle grades the school's most recent suspensions rate is 12.7 points lower than the district's average the previous conditions um in their current renewal uh was that the school was to improve in student achievement on their mcap assessments the school did raise their overall mcap proficiency for students in ela 3 to5 from 88.1% um in 2019 at
123which time the map assessment was referred to as Park um to 18.7% um in 2022 similarly in math 3 to 5 the school's proficiency also improved in 2022 from the 5.4% proficiency which was reflected in 2019 on the park assessment to 7.6% however we noted that there have been mixed results since that time period and that the school's most recent results are be are above the median of similar schools in accordance with policy ibj an administrative regulation ibj D an applicable law and based uh and based on the consideration of the operator run a report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with AIA Baltimore Inc to operate the B Addison school be renewed
124for three years with conditions that the operator put a plan in place subject to CEO CEO approval that must be submitted this year that results in improved academic achievement and outcomes for students where student performance must be better than the poverty comparison group and a subsequent renewal raised achievement of lower performing groups um and strengthens the school's approach to data as noted in the application and school effect in this review and for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur I concur with the recommendation as stated let me raise a question that I have for you so based upon the recommendation uh the plan that you guys are looking for from the school can you explain to the board and the public what may happen if you
125don't see the results um that you're looking to see yeah if the school um does not fulfill the obligations of the conditions they could be subject to an earlier uh revocation of the contract or earlier end of the contract thank you that's true for any school with conditions thank you any additional comments or questions this evening based upon that I'll open the floor uh for discussion on the recommendation I move based upon the consideration that the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given by The Operators run school and work sessions and public hearings the contents the official record and the factors listed in policy IH hbj and the administrative regulation ihb j- ra including sections 3K of a policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter
126school is not eligible for two or more consecutive partial renewals that the board accept the CEO recommendation is stated thank you is there a second second Esposito thank you commissioner esposo all in favor commissioner as messenger yes thank you commissioner Koy yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kenat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner reing linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner SL hton yes thank you and I'm also in favor that motion passes connections a community based arts school number 325 operated by Baltimore teacher Network great configuration 6 through 12th grade current enrollment 457 connections open in 2002 the school has had multiple partial renewals and is currently in a three-year conditional renewal connections rated developing and student achievement developing in climate effective in finance
127and governance the recommendation is for a three-year renewal with conditions to improve academic achievement and outcomes for students with a particular focus on math raise achievement of lower performing groups maintain trajectory of improvement in graduation rate improve the College and Career Readiness participation and achievement as defined in the renewal rubric the read Effective and mcap absolute performance for ELA 10 mcap where the average student is performing at a level two developing learner they ready developing mcap absolute performance for ELA 6 through 8 for the average learner again is performing at a level two developing learner they rated not effective and mcap absolute performance for math 6 through 8th and Algebra 1 where the average learner is performing at a level one beginning learner they ready effective and three of the four School Effectiveness review measures
128people en Vision engagement and strategic leadership and Professional Management as well as in eight of the 12 key actions this means effective School practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness previous conditions the conditions require that the school improve in student achievement on the mcap assessments and its four-year cohort graduation rate the school did raise overall mcap proficient proficiency for students in ela 6-8 from 6.5% in 2019 on Park to 11.2% on mcap in 2022 increasing in each year for ELA 10 they increased proficiency from 5.4% in 2019 on Park to 11.7% on mcap in 2022 increasing in each year in math the school had not made significant Improvement the four-year cohort graduation rate did increase from 60% in 2019 to
12971.7% in 2023 for three of the four years the foror cohort graduation rate has been above 70% except in 2022 where it fell to 52.6% and the and the 2023 rebound is a 19.1 point Improvement in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ihb j- an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renew report testimony at the operator run school's work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Baltimore teacher Network Inc to operate connections a community based based art school be renewed for 3 years with conditions that the operator put in place a plan subject to CE CEO approval this year that results in improved academic achievement and outcomes for students with a particular focus on math um
130and where student performance must be better than the poverty comparison group in a subsequent renewal raise achievement of the lower performing groups maintain a trajectory of improvement and graduation rate and improve the school's college career ready participation and achievement as defined in the renewal robc and for a term that commences on July 1 2025 it ends on June 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening I'll now open the floor for Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation motion I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendation and rationale of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the operative run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation
131ibj including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that the public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accepts the C CEO's recommendation as stated thank you second second kyat Bay thank you commissioner kyat Bay all in favor commissioner am messenger yes thank you uh commissioner qu yes thank you commissioner ESO yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner reading linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington thank you and I'm also in favor that motion passes we going to do this one next school after this school we are going to take a brief recess okay no problem for the next recommendation we're going to take a look at Frederick elementary school this
132school is operated by the Baltimore curriculum project and ser students in grades prek through five they have an enrollment of 323 students this is a school that was converted to Charter status in 2017 and was merged with the Samuel FB Morris Elementary School uh which was a merger that was pre-planned as a part of the 21st century schools buildings plan both schools were the lowest performing schools in the district the school is currently in a three-year renewal which was the maximum that was available due to the impact of covid and this year is its second renewal process Frederick elementary is being recommended for a three-year renewal with conditions the conditions are to improve academic achievement and outcomes for students to raise achievement of the lower performing groups and to strengthen the school's approach to data
133as noted in their application and the school effectus review their ratings for this process include a developing rating in the student achievement area and the effective ratings in the areas of climate and finance and governance their highlights include the following developing rating and their mcap absolute performance measure for ELA 3 to5 where the average learner is performing at a level two which is the developing learner level indicative of partial proficiency they were not effective in mcap absolute performance from math 3 to 5 where the average learner is performing at a level one which is the beginning learner level indicating that students will need additional academic support to be successful in the next grade they were also not effective in ela 4 to five for mcap growth they were in the 26th percentile in the district
134and for ELA 4 to five they were in the fifth percentile again growth is the measure that indic it indicates the extent to which a school has improved individual student performance year-to year they were effective in three of the four School affections review measures specifically talented people vision and engagement and strategic leadership and professional management and they were also effective in eight of the 12 key actions this means that effective School practices or systems have been adopted and are being implemented at a level that is improving the school's Effectiveness they were rated effective in the effective programming for students with disabilities measure uh which looks at the extent to which the school has a demonstrated uh has demonstrated a strong trajectory of growth and is aware of its data and its responsibilities to students with
135disabilities and that they have effectively and consistently implemented the processes interventions and strategies to support student outcomes over the course of the contract this school had few free and in public education or fake findings in their compliance review and the school leverages additional resources to ensure that they maintain a higher level of Staffing than is required to serve students with disabilities they were highly effective in suspensions as the school has de increased there's suspensions over time and the suspension rates are below the district averages across student populations the school employs a range of strategies to communicate with students about Behavior guiding them to make Positive Choices and to resolve conflicts their goal is to foster a positive and supportive environment where students can learn and grow while addressing and correcting behaviors that otherwise may be
136disruptive or harmful in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj that ra an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run school's work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Baltimore curriculum pro project Inc to operate Frederick elementary school be renewed for three years with conditions that the operator put a plan in place subject to CE CEO approval that must be submitted this year that results in improved academic achievement and outcomes for students where performance must be better than the poverty comparison group in the subsequent renewal raised achievement of the lower performing groups strengthening the school's approach to data as noted in the application and school Effectiveness review for a term
137that commences on july1 2025 it ends on June 30 2028 I concur with their recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have any questions for staff this evening yes I I just have a real quick question it seems uh you know that they're doing a good a good job but the thing is it seems uh kind fragmented did you notice that in your observation of this school I mean this school this why understand that history is important they took on two of our lowest performing schools um and so that it t turn around takes time um and so we see areas like of improvement but there's still areas of work to do it's also um in located in one of our um highest poverty parts of the city and that's important I think throughout the community
138has heard us reference if they perform the schools of schools are performing better than their poverty group that's important because there's a relationship between the relative wealth of um student populations and performance and state assessments so in this process we seek to compare you to similar schools to see what it is that your school is doing to control for poverties so we're not measuring how poor um uh the students or families are but the actual work of the schools but you know it's work that takes time um and you know they're still early kind of in this contract I thought that was something that you needed to bring to Clarity yeah thank you any additional comments I will now open the floor for Commissioners for discussion on the recommendation entertain a motion am I moving
139for a recess or we going to vote school before we yes we will be doing recess as soon as we are done with the school I can do it go for it all you sir I move that based on the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ihj and administrative regulation i ihb j r a including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board decide that a public charter school is not eligible for twoe two consecutive partial renewals that the board accept the CEO's recommendations as stated thank you is there a second second k out Bay thank you commissioner k out Bay
140all in favor Vice chair Parker yes thank you commissioner and welcome commissioner Ames messenger yes thank you commissioner Co yes thank you commissioner Esposito yes thank you commissioner kinat Bay yes thank you commissioner Muhammad yes thank you commissioner R linger yes thank you commissioner Rooks yes thank you commissioner Slater Harrington thank you and I'm also in favor this motion passes we are going to adjourn for a 10-minute recess um we will pick back up at 7:55 10 minutes now from whatever your watch says 805 on my watch see you in 10 minutes e e I need spagetti e e e all right everyone we're getting ready to call back to all thank you all turn I'm sorry to make sure that everyone heard me I'm going to turn it over to Miss Alvarez okay we're
141gonna continue all right School of Bost number 32 operator experiential Environmental Education Inc gr configuration K through fifth grade current enrollment 162 the green school tomorrow open in 2006 the school has had multiple partial and full renewals and is currently in a three-year renewal the Green School rated effective in student achievement effective in climate developing inclus additional financial review and financing governance the recommendation is for a three-year renewable conditions to improve Financial capacity through expansion or otherwise identify a sustainable recurring funding source that results in the ability of the organization and the school to fulfill all of its fiscal responsibilities with sufficient Reserve to meet unexpected emergencies or shortfalls qualify as meets expectations and review of the organization's Audits and reviews of subsequent audits fulfill all Kar and state requirements for Staffing and identify and
142secure a new facility or develop a comprehensive space plan to address operational needs that is approved by the CEO Green School rate effective in mcap absolute performance for ELA 3-5 for the average student performing at a level three proficient learner developing an mcap absolute performance for math 3-5 with the average student is performing at level two developing learner effective in the essential the five essential survey indicating the school is organized for Success schools organized for Success are 10 times more likely than less organized schools to improve student outcomes across indicators developing and effective programming for all student racial ethnic groups which is for schools with divver diverse populations and it looks at whether there are achievement gaps that exist between student groups whether the school is providing high quality programming for all students and the
143processes and practices the school is using to address gaps and ensure high achievement for all students the school rate does not meet expectations in audit content and internal controls where the review found the school has had significant financial challenges that impact the future sustainability of the school including operating losses in fiscal year 21 and fiscal year 22 where the expenses out outpace the revenue while fiscal year 23 looked more positive this was due to nonrecurring revenue sources a review of the operator's finances show cash balances decreasing while expenses are expected to increase in ACC here we go in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation IH pj- an applicable law and based on consideration of the operator Reno report testimony at the operative run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the
144official record it is a recommendation of the CEO that the contract with experimential Environmental Education Inc to operate the Green School of Baltimore be renewed for three years with conditions that the operator put an initial plan in place subject to CE to CEO approval that must be submitted this year and updated annually or is requested by the CEO to improve Financial capacity through expansion or otherwise identify a sustainable recurring funding source that results in the ability of the organization and school to fulfill all of its fiscal responsibilities with sufficient Reserve to meet unexpected emergencies or shortfalls qualify as meet expectations and review of the organization's Audits and and reviews of subsequent audits fulfill all comar and state requirements for Staffing and identify and secure a new facility or develop a comprehensive space plan to address
145operational needs for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated do we have any Commissioners have any questions for the staff thank you for um all of the updates and the information You' provided I'm curious though um when you talk about um revenues to support um the increasing cost are the increasing costs um related what are the increasing costs that you're identifying um and What suggests that those revenues would be sufficient and my second question you want me wait or ask both um in your experience uh you've stated an expectation that the um schol um needs to um find a building raise funds um and come up with a solid growth plan and your experience is three years sufficient time to do
146that or would five years allow more time to be able to find adequate space and meet requirements that's that's a great question um so the uh the you know the conditions there are some ores in there so it's not like a fixed thing it does take time to expand if that is what the school's going to do so it they need to I either expand or identify a recurring funding source um to ensure that they're sustainable um the costs that are rising are salary costs the majority of a school's expenses or any organization expenses but a school's expenses is staff so you know last year the Union contract resulted in increases this year they in increases um there's additional things that schools have to pay for that they did not have to pay for before
147like uh cost for overnight fueld F trips or like there's just a lot of additional costs um to schools and this is a small very small schools under 200 kids and so just like earlier tonight with the traditional schools and um with Edgewood and as we've been doing for the last 12 years we've been combining we've been merging and closing schools that are under siiz and so this is a school that has 168 students it's significantly below we've been saying if you're under 300 it's going to become challenging to be able to meet costs um this school is starting to experience that and so the reserves they have one of the things that we did with this school because there was concerns that came up in the finances and I think uh Maran Cox our
148Deputy CFO is also online I'm going to invite her um to uhh to come on in a second to to also add to this um and I lost my train of thought in saying that um but uh it's not a sustainable size and so there has to be the thing that has saved them for being in a worse situation was Esser which is gone um and they got some of the p uh PPP um loans like Co the co relief basically is the only thing that um has really helped them have money otherwise they would have been more upside down does not meet expectations is the lowest rating you can get in this measure uh but this is a school that is a strong it has strong academics it's strong climate and so these conditions
149are designed to to really help the school so we would meet with them um we would um you know support them and part of what they're going to you know put forward is a plan to you know to figure that out I know some schools some of their fundraising is starting to return now that we're of covid so directly after covid a lot of schools experien some some uh challenges with fundraising uh and so you have an operator here that um wants to be around has been around um and so I think these are the appropriate conditions I think if you um um from a CEO administrative perspective the fiscal situation is is challenging that you wouldn't want to leave it um uh without a you sooner um maryan I don't know if there's more
150that you want to add okay okay yep come on up um it's on that okay greetings everyone uh I just wanted to add a few additional comments about the Green School what we found when we reviewed them in detail was that uh they had been recording their costs as they were allowed to they you know there's nothing inappropriate about it but they had an opportunity to take care of the covid funds so they charged some cost their operating cost to the co funds uh Co fund ended on 9:30 2024 they are also charging some positions to the TSI Grant the TSI Grant will end at the end of 2026 and there is also a question about the concentration poverty grant that they are receiving funds now whereas in Prior years they would not have met
151the criteria and so City Schools does not consider that a reliable s of funding because it it relates to the interpretation of what a high poverty school is is that correct Angel yeah Green School is not a they a low poverty School in our district based upon what you just shared on those funding revenue streams they this is my interpretation help me understand if I'm making sense of this appropriately so the funding streams may not be as stable for the school is what you like been C okay in addition to that it's my understanding that there were some uh onetime exceptions made for meeting coma requirements for FY 2024 is is that the year 2023 or 24 it was a one-time exception and that will not continue so when you take away the financial impact
152of the uh of the exception and add the fact that the covid grants are ending the TSI Grant will end and the um the concentration of poverty is not considered reliable Grant then that's why she was referring to a stable replacement source of funding just to allow them to maintain comar requirements Okay so based upon that and the condition that's warranted associated with that um I guess my question is the type of review that the district would undertake to ensure that they're building a sustainable budget over the course of that entire three years yes yes we intend to do a more uh intense detailed review on a continuing basis um what Guidance Do you have for uh the amount of Reserve that an organization that has about this about this size school so an organization
153with this level of operating budget what kind of a reserve should they been actually when we do the evaluation for audit it it there's many different criteria most of them are all about cash applications of cash um what does it do to your net assets do you have positive net assets you know what do your Auditors think we can tell by looking at your audited financial statements if the Auditors have a going concern or a liquidity question so we're looking at all that we do not tell them you must have this what we do know is that we have certain criteria that we like to see which is how many days um um of your operating expenses do you have well we're all keeping in in mind the fact that the charter schools don't pay
154for their um uh their Staffing for the the people who are employees of city schools which is the teachers and a lot of their their Central staff so that's not a cash outflow for them they generally when we look at the cash on hand those are the costs that they pay out of their um their quarterly uh cash outs so because over 34 of their costs are not reflected in their out uh you know their needs um it it makes it more of a a subjective uh decision because I I know what their cash balance is and and it that's not enough to cause the concern what our concern was the fact that we know the grant the grants were either have ended or are ending or are unreliable and uh what are you going
155to do when all those costs come back they it's it's it's going to be very difficult to maintain uh an an excess of Revenue over expenditures which is one of the criteria we look for yeah and they were upside down I mean the other thing I will say about their cash on hand is they're using it it's it's going down so we've collected their bank statements from we started the review for each month it's going down they're using that and so there's not an identified source to replace it if we did not do the exceptions they cash at amount this year would have been very minimal and that that could gives us concern because they have operational costs like their building their utilities that kind of stuff my understanding is that they've reported a an
156increasing a more positive cash position than in recent years that has been steadily increasing it's not it's it's it's their cash position is decreasing it it certainly has decreased remember how we we typically look at these things at year end and what we had done when in areas where we need to take a quick a closer look we look at the last fiscal year for which they have uh information available in this case would be 6:30 2024 and then we went month by month after that and what we saw was that um the cash was going down from from that point from 6:30 2024 according to the bank statements for the months that they gave us which I think the last month we looked at was October so on a month-by-month basis that's that's what
157we ended up doing when we start looking at the details and that's kind of scrutiny we would be applying for the future I was the information I was was on a year year Bas that now 21 and 22 they had more expenses than they had Revenue they look like they look better in 23 because of all of those forgiveness right so I'm accounting for it's an accounting thing I'm accounting for things in a different place but my true position which is why we wanted to look at well what do you actually have now yeah is it's going down they're having to use that to cover expenses confidence do you believe that they'd be able to come up with sustainable Europe that's our hope I I mean I think we have a good operator here uh
158like I said who is committed to being around their board um wants to make these commitments it's a risk and be honest and very clear and public proposing that we continue them as a risk we think it's worth the risk because of what they're doing for student how long they've been around and what we know about the team that's running the school but that's why the CEO's recommendation is for a three-year period so that we can kind of check on that um and uh it's going to require more checking given the level of concern I'll just give a comment that where there is we we have a some belief there that we have a good operator and they are performing and when you have that that's a combination of success so I uh appreciate the
159risk and I'm open to a high level of commitment any other comment or question with that uh I move that based upon the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report testimony given at the operator run of schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ihj and administrative regulation ihb J including 3K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a Public Charter School is not eligible for two consecutive partial renew renewals that the board reject the CEO's recommendation and modify it to renew the school for a term of five years to commence on July the 1st 2025 and run through June 30th 2030 does anyone second sorry second can B all right um so we'll do the
160roll call on that chair quick clarification sure so the modif the recommended modification but not to change any of the um conditions this is correct that's what I that's that's what I was going to ask before you make sure okay and maybe one just sort of reflection of noting that it is I've not seen and perhaps you could correct me if if I'm wrong but I I don't believe I've seen a fiveyear renewal with conditions uh previously sorry eighty year with conditions we have an eight-year with conditions this year just for record but Angel if you wanted to add to it the midterm yeah we have schools with longer terms in the past like eight years they've had like a midpoint review but not with like a list of condition so maybe like this feels
161different than yeah like notably different yes and I will just know you know again for the board if I can I don't know where we are in the process that this is point of information only that if we do prior to five years if the board votes for the five years and prior to five years there is um an operating deficit which we have had before by the way and the school cannot maintain its finances we will have to come back to the board if that school can can not sustain and in the past that has actually led to closure at that time because of financial so I just want to put that out that even though there is a fiveyear if a school cannot afford to run the fivey year will be immaterial to
162them being able to actually operate so I just want to make sure that the board understand stuff all right thank you chair Sally no no commissioner Ames messenger oh I'm sorry second yes Kat yes I will restate my vote is no all right yes commissioner Ames messenger no commissioner Coy No Commission Esposito abstain commissioner Kang commissioner Mohammed yes commissioner R linger yes commissioner Brooks Brooks I'm sorry yes commissioner Slater Harington okay and then it's myself I vote no so that is four yes five Nos and one extension is that cover so that so it do not face be we need to entertain a second entertain a second motion uh I would like to move that based on the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator will will report the testimony given
163at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors list in the policy ihj and administrative regulation ibj including the sections 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board accept the CEO's recommendations as stated anyone second second k b thank you I'll be R call ask for discussion okay so we'll go into a roll call chair Sally yes chair I'm sorry commissioner am messenger yes commissioner Koy yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner katab yes commissioner Mohammed yes commissioner R linger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slater Harington and myself votes yes the motion passes uh the next school is new song Academy operated by the New Song Community Learning
164Center Inc uh they're Elementary School no they're Elementary Middle School that's incorrect um their enrollment is 322 um students um they uh originally were a new school initiative school this is their first renewal as a charter school um this school is um rated developing in student achievement School climate and in financial management governance inclusive of an additional financial review the recommendation is three years um with conditions um the Schools rated highly effective in each of its mcap growth measures um for um Ela um and Math middle at the middle school level where the schools in the 95th and 81st percentiles respectively um they're effective and incap absolute performance for ELA for Middle grades for the average student performance in level two indicating partial proficiency but where the percent of students that reach proficiency is 25.5
165percentage points higher than the median for schools with similar poverty uh in math in middle school math their performan is developing um and where um their growth is um 7.9 percentage points higher than the median for schools with similar prty they're developing an mcap absolute performance um they're effective in the school Effectiveness uh review measures um for vision and engagement and strategic leadership which means the school's practices or systems have been adopted at the school and are being implemented at level that is improving School Effectiveness there does not meet expectations in the audit content internal controls where the review found the school has had significant financial challenges that impact the future sustainability of the school including several years where expenditures exceeded Revenue in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ihb j-r and applicable law
166and based on the consideration of the operator renov report testimony at the operator run schools work session and public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the recommendation of the CEO that the contract with new song Learning Community Inc to operate new song Academy be renewed for three years with conditions that the operator put an initial plan in place subject to CEO approval that must be submitted this year and updated annually or as requested by the CEO to improve the financial capacity through expansion or otherwise identify sustainable recurrent in funding source that results in the ability of the organization and school to fulfill all of its fiscal responsibilities with sufficient Reserve to meet unexpected emergencies or shortfalls qualify as meet expectations in review of the organization's Audits and reviews of subsequent audits
167fulfill all comar state requirements for Staffing excuse me and identify and secure a new facility or develop a comprehensive space plan to address oper needs for a term that commences on July 1 2025 and ends on June 30 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have questions for the staff all right I'll open the floor to the Commissioners for discussion of the recommendation um I would like to put out on the floor that I think that um after visiting new I think they have a a a particularly strong culture they mean a lot to the community that they're in and I think they are worthy of renewal I would like to see a more targeted approach to uh teacher development and capacity building um and so pending further discussion I'd like
168to uh add an amendment to add a condition to the renewal anyone else any discussion similarly I support that um that recommendation in terms of ensuring that the school continues to make progress in those areas that were identified by my colleague on the board um one other thing I'd like to say for the record is I think um there are some physical constraints to the growth of the school and um given that uh um the finances are a concern I think we need to as a board as a community think about ways in which we can support um the uh the other Avenues to uh Financial sustainability for this school so just something for us to consider but with that um I moved that based on the consideration they have most on floor already no
169I thought it was no we're in discussion I'm I'll leave it open does someone else have a item for discussion oh I just wanted to add that um um the school is being asked to um expand to grow um yet the facility that is available to them is not being provided so I think that also in my mind needs to be considered in um that request in that um stipulation I do think that um the condition as as written provides for that provides for the or clause in my mind provides for some flexibility and how they uh how they Achieve Financial sustainability okay commissioner laer before you do your imve there's just an error on that page so can you read it from um page 42 yeah and then you can go back for the
170other parts the just the introduction just the introduction I move the base on the consideration of the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report the testimony given to the operator run schools work session in public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy IH ibj and administrative regulation ibj including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that a public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board modify the CEO's recommendation to add the following condition with to the conditions already shared on behalf of the CEO to develop a comprehensive plan by May 1 2025 to improve the capacity and effectiveness of teachers and academic leaders that include specific and detailed approaches to professional development and coaching for
171our roll call we need a yeah M amended motion thank you commissioner as messenger um so we'll go into our roll call chair Sally yes commissioner Ames messenger yes commissioner Coy yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner katab yes commissioner Muhammed yes commissioner R reading linger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner slat Harren yes and my vote is yes as well that motion passes creative City Public Charter School uh is operated by creative City Public Charter School Foundation they're an elementary school they serve around 210 students um they first opened in 2013 they've had U multiple partial renewals and is currently in a three-year with conditions um the school is rated developing and student achievement um School climate and Fin and governance the recommendation for this school has been updated and revised by the CEO to be a
172three-year renewal with conditions um the school is rated not effective in ela um 4 five and incap growth where at the 47th percentile and in math where they're at the 26th percentile they're developing an mcap absolute performance for elementary and math um for English language arts and U math for elementary students indicating students had partial proficiency they were rated developing in the five Essentials indicating the school is moderately organized for Success a school that is modernly organized for um on the five Essentials means that the school is performing at an average level in terms of overall organizational structure and systems falling within the middle range oh no my computer's about to die can you somebody can can you start sharing and kick me out of sharing okay with the middle range compared to other schools
173indicating that while there are functional systems in place there's room for improvement in key areas they were not effective in programming for students with disabilities um uh which looks at the extent to which um schools are um uh aware of and have a trajectory of growth for um students with with disabilities that they're aware of their responsibilities um for students with disabilities and that they have effectively and consistently implemented processes uh interventions and strategies to support um student outcomes the special education compliance review found that found issues that impacted the delivery of services were good um to students for um for almost every Fold review which require um free and public um education or feap evaluations um in the previous conditions the school was required to improve student achievement on the mcap um and provide
174evidence of improved dat processes align to best practice the school did raise mcap Proficiency in ela 3 to 5 from 10.1% in 2019 on Park to 20% on mcap in 2022 similarly in math the school's proficiency improved from 2020 um from um 6.9% in 2019 um to 8.4 4% on the mcap however the results have been mixed since then um in accordance with policy ibj and administrative regulation ihb j- and applicable law and based on the consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run schools work session in public hearings and the contents of the official record it is the revised recommendation of the CEO that the contract with created City Public Charter School Foundation Inc to operate creative city public charter school be renewed for 3 years with conditions that the operator
175put a plan in place subject to CEO approval that must be submitted this year that results in um improved academic achievement and outcomes for students where student performance must be better than the poverty comparison group in the subsequent renewal raiseed achievement of the lower performing groups strengthening the school's approach to data and instruction as noted in the application and the school Effectiveness review and for a term that commences on July 1 2020 five it ends on June 30 uh 2028 I concur with the recommendation as stated do any Commissioners have questions for staff also I have comment uh when we see a a school community that reflects what's going on in the community and this renewal period gave us the opportunity to see that where these gaps are in the school that you guys have
176a plan to be able to address them and have the partners to address them in the high level commitment of your partners along with hearing from your school Community has been very helpful uh during this process so I I just want to say thank you for the work that you have done during this renewal process because it has been helpful to understand that you have a pathway to success and then you have the partners to support you in that so I I want to say thank you for your work and I personally look forward to the future success of creative City yes sir first of all um You probably heard me say this before that uh as a community grows or becomes more involved that schools grow um I've watched this development and a lot
177of the community has poured into uh creative City they have done uh Yan's work um we should not be afraid that the community now is doing what we've been asking for a very long time to be dedicated to the Improvement and the growth of an institution um and I think that I'm looking forward once again to seeing this growth this continued growth this has been a stressed area where creative cities exist and all of a sudden now it's beginning to Rally I'm I'm I'm really a big suppor of watching that rally continue um I think that you have a good plan in place and the more brains you bring to the table the more Minds you bring to the table the more Community you bring to the table you will become a stellar institution I
178support your continuation and I'm just going to go back because I just want to highlight something to you that is I I haven't seen many schools have the ability to have both size of our city as a partner this is a a school that's been able to bring copin and Morgan and uh for me that's say something so appreciate it uh I also wanted to uh just address the members of the board at creative City for the effort that You' have shown over the last couple of um months just in showing up and walking in the perspective that you shared on your work there um in that Spirit really realizing the the lift that you also have ahead of you and making sure that you are equipped to be successful in that and that we
179are not back here again in three years um and so looking to make sure when you talk about these ample partners that you are well supported um specifically when it comes to finances and thinking about what your vision looks like when you talk about Arts integration in this community and the vision that you have for what that mean and meeting the needs of diverse Learners and Learners with uh special education needs and just making sure that we were able to do that in a meaningful way and that you have the financial resources and board resources to support that effort yes um I'd like to Second those uh comments and and will say that I was also greeted by members of the board um for my visit all of whom I believe were parents of the
180school which I think sh demonstrates a real um investment in the school um and uh that there are certainly a lot of components of strong culture and buying from the greater Park Heights Community um I would uh like to add a similar Amendment to the one that I previously added um which is I do believe the school would benefit from a comprehensive and specific plan um to improve teacher Effectiveness and capacity uh and so I don't know if other colleagues will be offering any amendments but I just request that if you are that you add that amendment to your proposal all right any other com any other questions before um we go into discussion okay so I'll open the floor for two Commissioners for a discussion I move that based upon the consideration of the
181recommendation and ration motion to add to it as to read I think okay right do you have them yes the amendment language for both of them uh so let's so I'm looking at B and then also the language that Stefon so just for my board colleagu so we can add any um additional ones that we want um we can have multiple ones that may be helpful um for us to consider all at the same time or can them we should go through um yeah let's do one um larger one so if we do one motion that contains um all the ones that you want um even if you want to read them say it's one and then here's the second one here's the third one um that will inform what the vote will be on
182that first one though I move that based upon the consideration the recommendation and rationale of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the operator run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative and administrative regulation ibj a including section three. K of the policy providing that those that the board may decide that the public charter school is not eligible for two consecutive partial renewals that the board modifies the CEO recommendation in the following manner to require the operator P procures the financial expertise necessary to ensure strong financial management inclusive of fundraising through training selection to the board and or selection of a contractor subject to the CEO renewal review sorry and or develop a comprehensive plan by May 1
183202 five to improve the capacity and effectiveness of teachers and academic leaders that include specific and detailed approaches to professional development and coaching one quick clarification that was a both of those it was not a and or between those two um items correct correct second K B all right thank you uh chair Sally yes commissioner am messenger yes commissioner Coy yes commission commissioner Esposito yes commissioner King adab yes commissioner Mohammed yes commissioner R linger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner SLA Harington yes and myself I vote Yes motion passes I'm thinking like okay so next is Southwest Baltimore Charter School um is operated by Southwest Baltimore Charter School Inc it's an elementary middle school enrollment around 365 students it first opened as tter School in 2005 the schools had a mixed history of renewal is currently
184in a three-year um renewal term the school is rated not effective in student achievement developing in climate and effective in finance and governance um the CEO's recommendation has been revised um to non renew the operator but to keep the school open and change management to a traditional school starting in 2526 school year the schools read not effective and incap growth for math where they're in a 26 percenti um for um elementary math um for elementary English language arts where they're in the 27th percentile and for Middle grades English language arts where they're in the 23rd percentile they're not effective in the five essential survey the school is not yet organized for Success the school is weak in four of the five Essentials effective leaders collaborative teachers supportive environment and involved families research shows that a
185score a low score and even just one of the five Essentials reduces the likelihood of improvement to less than 10% they're not effective in chronic absence uh the school is not aware of its data for example the school claimed that its chronic absence rates are below the district averages when they are above the district averages by 5.3 percentage points for students in elementary grads and 4.1 percentage points higher um for students in Middle grades in accordance with ibj and administrative regulation ij- an applicable law and based on the consideration of the operator renewal report testimony at the operator run school's work session and public hearings and the content of the official record is the revised recommendation of the CEO that the contract with Southwest Baltimore Charter School Inc to operate Southwest bore chter school be
186non-renewed and that the school transitions to become a traditional school starting in the 25 26 school year I can I concur with the the recommendation as stated do any commissioner have questions for staff yes um but this the uh school is rated not effective in three out of four uh mcap measures how how did they do in the fourth one um and can you uh um the gradations between not effective and developing I know there's a lot of different things that go into the rubric but can you sort of voice over uh the difference between not effective and developing for specifically for academics for academics um if a school um is below the median um for their comparison PTY group and absolute performance that's not effective um if they are um in the lower half
187of percentile rankings for growth that would be considered um a not effective um uh um if the schools um um for um the five Essentials you know they were kind of weak so that's also considered in the academic SE section because it's predictive of improvement um so those are like those are the um uh heart data measures that are part of the academic section academic section also considers the Fidelity Charter where their school is um delivering on their Charter and whether they have um how they manage handling concerns in their data uh or the responsive data are they actually um working towards providing high quality uh programming for students this is the only school we cons we've considered today with the not effective rating in academics yeah this is the only school that uh in
188this renewal process has a not effective in the academic section of renewal and um the last question is about governance if you could shed some light on the findings on the governance section for this operator yeah just to go back to your question about the other rating in the academic section so Tiffany just verified for us they were developing in the other academic rating for um uh repeat the last question sorry a governance standpoint what were some of the findings can you sh some light on the operator and it uh uh governance capacity yeah an operator capacity was was there rating all right long night lots of stuff in my head go to the go to the to the go to the um the reading sheet where you were before thank you I need an
189extra project this down with me um in in operator capacity they were found to be developing so operator capacity is where we're looking at the extent to which the schools operated effectively has consistently mat all state federal reporting requirements critical District requirements um whether we've issued notices of concern um or uh repan to the school than no further questions one question and that's um simply when if we're looking at transition to a Traditional School what type of impact or resources are going to change for that Community that's directly affected by that school that's a good question it's hard to it's hard to say now like not having built the budget this you know this process is ahead of the budget season so if the board approves that you know part of that finalization of the
190budget um would include um uh you know input from Community some of that has started but that continues once the budgets go live in February AR so that engagement would continue um the we've what we one of the things we've heard from the community and engagement in the community is this import around maintaining um uh expeditionary or Project based learning uh as a value within the school community and so that's something we would seek to maintain we have another Traditional School um Fort worington that has um that model um um that's part within it um the staff uh the majority of Staff within um tur schools are District staff um so we would be able to maintain um the current Staffing um but as a traditional school they would get District supports um that they
191don't have now so they would sit with a within a cln so there would be um support uh academic support they would have access to additional PD that's run by the district um they would be um School leadership would be part of a network of schools and looking at their data under the supervision of an IED uh and really implementing our traditional schools imple continuous Improvement so they would benefit from from those pieces um but there could be differences and so that's what the budget process would help us kind of uh figure out um uh in terms of you know what that means um for their school and there's there's differences in cost because this um for example trer schools are responsible for the cost of their facilities right uh and so that's something they
192have to uh pay you know rent for because it's our facilities a traditional school that's considered in a different place so um so there there will be some differences that pluses and ins and outs so we would have to figure that out um in the budget process Ju Just One More um before we entertain a motion I just U Miss Al can you remind the bo of the revised recommendation of the CEO just want to be super super clear y it's to non-renew the operator but to keep the school open um and change the management type to that be it will become a traditional school starting in 25 26 school year thank you I appreciate that any other question comment or comment okay so I will um open up the floor to the Commissioners for
193any discussion of the recommendation board colleagu so there's a couple of options that we can pursue with this particular school so one um is accepting the recommendation as proposed by the CEO um for their non-renewal second is to modify that third um is to um to reject and modify I'm sorry that third is to um modify and renew um the operator's contract um for a term of three years um or another option could be placed on the table um by our board here this evening for consideration I guess I'll I have a comment um would like to just commend the really thoughtful advocacy of a wide cross-section of students families and parents um I've had the privilege to speak to a number of community members I used to live in the community working at a
194neighborhood school and just the the significance of of loss and the complication of it to school closure is um just of that that is a challenging consideration I do also just really want to lift up the consistency with the things that you acknowledge around your school community that make it um that make it unique and when you're talking about Expeditionary Learning Andor Project based learning when you're looking about creativity about creating a space for all students kind of for regardless of where they are coming and a sense of belonging and identity in that and really just that there didn't matter how many people you talked to it was like hearing the same narrative over and over again and I think just calling um moving forward through a lot of this process that that those and
195and I think the last things of that is just the identity of Southwest Baltimore public charter as a hub in that community and its connection to the park um and I think in all of those things looking how those core elements of the identity and the history of the school can be preserved and carried forward um as a source of stability and identity for the students that attend there and the families that are associated with that school community so just I wanted to commend the consistency and voice that that was present in those statements um and that um I I guess an encouragement to continue to advocate for those things that you know to be part of yourself in this next St and in the process of transforming in this next iteration of the school
196Community there in Southwest I'll also just lift up the you know the option in front of us that's being presented as the CEO's recommendation that provides um a degree of stability and predictability for the school to continue and and to serve in the community there's obviously questions of the work ahead if this were to be uh approved to to support academic achievement uh and that is no small undertaking um but the sincere advocacy and the uh the things that we heard from the school community that desire to have the the school remain in the community uh I just want to commend that uh and the the sincerity uh of this of of that advocacy uh was not lost on me and and I imagine my other Commissioners as well and and the School District staff
197can I I I just want to go back to your question about the academic performance Allison was helpful in giving the reading support um so the school was not if in terms of the assessment measures that was your question they were not effective in five of eight measures they were developing in two and they were effective in one math um uh 6 HTP so I just wanted to answer that fully on the record just to I guess just to raise this I think this it's an important point to make that a school could uh outperform other schools on star ratings for instance and yet still get a not effective on this rubric because of the ways in which schools are compared to other peer schools and the way in which SGP and growth is taken
198into account is that yeah so the the state star reading system it's a completely different way of looking at the data um and so within our review process we are comparing schools um with similar schools in terms of how we look at it um and so it's the the reading system is not looking at the same thing so for example in the state reading schools get credit for things like um the having a a a variety of courses offered to students for example right so we're not looking at exactly the same things in this process as is looked at in the report C process the challenging part will we do we need to place a mo motion on the floor for consideration by the entire board I move that based upon the consideration of the
199recommendation and ration of the CEO the operative renewal report the testimony given at the operative run schools work session and public hearings the contents of the official record and the factors listed in policy ibj and administrative regulation ibj are a including section 3. K of the policy providing that the board may decide that the public charter school is not eligible for to consecutive partial renewals that the board accepts the CEO recommendations as stated any one second second Kat Bay okay roll call chair Sally yes commissioner Ames messenger yes commissioner Coy yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner katab yes commissioner Muhammad yes commissioner R linger yes commissioner Rooks yes commissioner Slater Haron yes and I vote Yes the motion carries I will now turn the meeting back to chair Sally before we conclude tonight I just want
200to thank um our colleagues in the office of new initiatives for their work in preparing the board um as well as the work in terms of working with the entire Baltimore City School Community um I'd like to thank my board colleagues for the amount of work and effort that um has gone into the evening in terms of being able to review the recommendations to vote um as well as to make the really hard decisions that are really important to move our our system forward um I also want to thank our entire Baltimore City Community for your thoughtful input throughout the process um and advocacy that we received uh this evening and throughout the season before we conclude as well this evening uh we have a couple of um reminders that we want to send out
201uh there are housekeeping things that typically we would do at the top of the call um we want to a um start with our student board Forum um actually like to turn over to commissioner Rooks just to lift up what our student board Forum will will be this month thank you chair um the student board form will be held at the bottomore design school January 16th from 5: to 6:30 I encourage all students to uh to attend this uh event I will be hosting it alongside my Commissioners as well um please come out enjoy there will be a lot of fun you get to talk with the Commissioners such as myself and that'll be our time to hear you and have a conversation on what your Academic School Achievements would like to be thanks so
202much ch um you know in particular uh the board will be addressing on the stud Bo Forum policies jjic and jcj so um if you have not done so already we ask that students register for the event we'd love to have you come out that evening um let's so later next uh later this month the distri will be launching a new YouTube channel called City Schools live dedicated to sharing live and recorded District events such as board meetings Town Halls ribbon cuttings external training celebrations and more the YouTube I'm sorry the original YouTube channel City Schools TV will continue to show storytelling pieces emphasize student content daily work of the district uh the district will inform every one of the launch date for the second YouTube channel soon and tonight's board meeting recording will be
203found on the original City Schools uh TV channel um we are going to foro committee um reports this evening we'll be back on the 28th to provide those a notice of our upcoming meetings um is our operations committee heading up on Tuesday January 21st uh policy committee meeting same day in the afternoon at 4M safety and wholeness will convene on Thursday January 23rd um and our regular board meeting exec session will be held on the 28th and um exec and Then followed by our school board meeting is there a motion to adress move no move thank you I'll take commiss SL Harrington and the second from commissioner kinata Bay um all those in favor say I I thank you we are adjourned we'll see you back in a few weeks two yeah you're good here