CorpusRecord 96088

Public Board Meeting 12/10/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City Schools TV
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Essex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,074 words · about 95 min
Collected
2026-06-12

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the call moderator or removed from the call additionally if you are not uh a board member or the CEO and her staff please turn off your video I'll Now read a roll call of the board to identify who is on the call um and present in the room uh please identify yourself first before speaking for the record um I'll go through the roll call for each vote this evening uh Vice chair Parker commissioner am messenger Ames messenger present commissioner Coy commissioner Koy present thank you commissioner Coy excuse me commissioner Esposito commissioner Esposito present thank you commissioner kinat Bay commissioner kinat Bay present thank you commissioner Muhammad will'll note him when he does arrive commissioner reading linger reading laer presid commissioner Rooks commissioner Rooks president commissioner Slater Harrington president thank you and I'm also present is

002there a motion to reopen uh the meeting thank you commissioner ring laer is a second second kinat Bay thank you commissioner kinat Bay all in favor commissioner as I'm sorry commissioner Ki yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner kinat Bay yes commissioner Mohammad um commissioner reading linger yes commissioner slay Harrington and I'm in favor um any oppos this motion passes um in recognition of the jrtc and the student performers we'd like to welcome um our colleagues from Edmonson Westside High School e Miss thank sir oh he bright [Music] the e and we'd like to thank our student performers from hawood elementary um this evening so thank you thank you thank you um now I'd like to turn over to Dr Santa Lisa for a moment of silence this evening thank you chair I would like to take

003the time to recognize the passing of City Schools Employees these individuals were committed to supporting our students through their work the greater City Schools Community will fond ly remember these employees tonight we send our deepest condolences to the employees families and friends it is with deep regret we inform you of the passing of Harry Foster Preston Harry Foster Preston started his career with City schools on June 19th 2010 where he served the staff and students for 14 years most recently at Green Street Academy at as a secondary teacher Mr Preston unfortunately departed on November 17th 2024 and will be missed by his family friends and City Schools it is also with deep regret we inform you of the passing of why why helier cook Ms cook started her career with City schools on October 8th

0042001 where she served the staff students for 23 years most recently at violent Ville Elementary Middle School as a custodial worker M cook unfortunately departed on November 88th 2024 and will be missed by her family friends and city schools and then finally it is with deep regret we inform you of the passing of Dr Gregory thoron Dr thoron served Baltimore city schools as CEO from July 1st 2014 to June 30th 2016 the Philadelphia native arrived in Baltimore after a successful tenure as the superintendent of Milwaukee Public Schools before his role in Wisconsin he served in District level leadership in the Montgomery Maryland Public Schools and near Philadelphia Adelphia during his tenure here Dr Thornton launched the 21st century schools office a dedicated group of City Schools professionals charged with ensuring the success of the largest

005multi-organization school building effort in recent State history he also shephered the school district's initial work in providing free meals to its student a program that continues today and his work supporting the Arts and schools was meaningful and served as the foundation for our current expansion of Arts programming in City Schools upon being hired Dr Thorton said City Schools was a special place for him in a media interview he said he would only leave would only have left the Midwest for Baltimore he will be missed by his family friends and City Schools can we now observe a moment of silence for all of the city [Music] employees thank you back to you chair thank you so much Dr to L this for the moment of silence is there a motion to approve the prior Open Session

006summaries so Mo thank you commissioner ESO is there a second second I'll take commissioner ring linger thank you all in favor uh let's see commissioner Ames messenger has she joined us yes I think she is commissioner qu yes thank you commissioner espito yes commissioner kenat Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes commissioner reading linger yes commissioner sler Harrington um and I am also in favor any opposed that motion passes is there a motion to approve the closed session summaries so move kinat Bay thank you commissioner kinat Bay is there a second second Esposito thank you commissioner Esposito all in favor commissioner koi yes commissioner Esposito yes commissioner kinat Bay yes commissioner Muhammad yes commissioner ring linger yes has he joined us this evening okay commissioner Slayer Harrington thank you any opposed commissioner messenger thank you am messenger

007is good evening everybody and welcome to the December 10th board meeting I am um happy to be here with you this evening um the spirit of progression is all around us here in the city schools as we celebrate the achievements during the holiday season as we prepare for the new year um I want to extend my warmest uh wishes to our students our families uh my fellow Commissioners um and others uh as well as our staff and our partners in the community I am immensely grateful for your Collective efforts this past year um and it's been a journey for growth resilience and shared accomplishments for us all uh the district has undergone several organizational change changes with the appointment of me as the board chair commissioner Parker as the vice chair and most recently the

008board has appointed commissioner reading linger as the chair of the strategic planning committee and commissioner koi head the operations committee chair I know these changes have spark questions about the future of the school board but I want to assure each and every one of you that our mission Remains the Same each commissioner has an unwavering dedication to the betterment of City Schools uh City schools in the progression of our students we are aware of the challenges we face as a district uh as and as the district's governing body and no matter the circumstances we will continue to push forward so that our students receive a high quality educational experience before we move forward this evening we want to take a moment to honor um our outgoing leadership specifically our vice chair I'm sorry our chair

009um Ronald mcfaden who is joined with us here this evening we're very grateful for him uh taking some time to be with us um and recognize that under his Direction and Leadership it's given us a solid foundation to continue to build from um we as part of our Traditions here want to open up an opportunity for our board colleagues to share a few words before we read uh two proclamations that were sent uh from us so I'll turn it over to my board colleagues for anything they would like to lift up yes sir yes um this board and I know from talking with the public when I was campaigning Etc has made great Leaps and Bounds it has become more open has become more directed and it has become more human people do not feel

010isolated from the board anymore yeah there are still barriers and we're going to continue to improve and get better and get stronger and look out for the people of Baltimore city but the point that I bring forward in saying that it was under the leadership of chair r faten that opened this board up that brought it to a new day they brought it to a day where it could even question itself because if you can't question yourself you can never improve yourself and so I um you got it bro thank you so much for everything you brought to this thank you so much commissioner Kat Bay just board colleages can you hear me I'm going to read my statement so that I can be composed um today we're recognizing Ronald MCB for just remarkable service

011and Leadership on this board I want to emphasize the accomplishments under his leadership since his appointment in 2018 chair mcfaden has been a force of change POS of change regarding the adoption of the district's Equity policy being the most huge champion of the Arts and ensuring the success of the transformative 21st century building his vision and advocacy have created a lasting Legacy that will benefit our students and Community for years to come I will say that he was instrumental in training me and onboarding me as the chair of teaching and learning and has always pushed uh for me to show up and be present as a chair he has always held us to the standard of centering our children and their achievement and his leadership missed I want to thank you Ronald for your courage

012your commitment and your Relentless pursuit of better outcomes for our children of I'm saddened to lose your leadership on this board I think for those Commissioners who remained this is not just a moment for recognition but one of Reckoning about embodying the culture that we want to promote it's not enough to honor leaders after their departure we must respect and Empower them while they serve thank you Ronald thank you thank you commissioner Slayer hington any additional board colleagues am messenger we have we may have some sound issues but let's see if we can try to get commissioner A's messenger can you hear me mute I am on mute is not yet um okay commissioner M will may have to come back to you just because of the sound issues this evening but um before we

013move forward I do want to Echo my thank you um to Ronald for his ongoing mentorship from the time I joined the board um through present um I think the opportunity to serve underneath his leadership has helped me to grow um in my influence to understand more about the district to understand more about the call to serve our children um I am forever thankful for that mentorship and that opportunity um to serve on this board um as well as to continue to serve all each and every one of our Scholars here in Baltimore City so I'm very thankful for that that opportunity and the foundation that you've given us as a board to continue to grow so thank you immensely for that sh I'd like to say something um I wanted to join in the

014congratulations for uh years of service I had an opportunity to visit um chair mcfaden at his school to see him in his element and um it was truly truly impressive and I think it is a testament to uh his work ethic that he has been able to chair this board and be an integral member of this community and do all of the work that he's done as an education professional as an assistant principal which is an extremely demanding job uh and you don't have to do anything but go and observe him at the school to see what he means to that Community see how children respond to him see how adults respond to him he is um he's an absolute leader and I appreciate uh his mentorship uh I didn't have much time um under

015his leadership but uh but I learned a tremendous amount from from Ronald mcfaden and I I sincerely um uh will miss him and sincerely applaud his tenure of service and I know he means a lot to this community so congratulations on your tenure and um I'm excited to be able to celebrate your legacy today thank you try one more time for commissioner M Messenger to see if that she's able to unmute not are there any additional board Commissioners like to share anything can you hear me one of the things I really do appreciate is we can hear you onl terms ofur they're integral Partners in this work and um our mayor has provided a certificate of recognition um which reads on behalf of the people of Baltimore I'm pleased to present this certificate to Ronald

016mcfaden in recognition of your dedicated service to Baltimore City uh border of school Commissioners during your tenure chair from 23 to 24 your passion and encouragement for a more holistic approach to education as positively impacted thousands of students in Baltimore City Public Schools on behalf of the people of the city of Baltimore thank you for your dedication and efforts to a better uh city um the second um is one that we provide here at Baltimore City Public Schools um a Proclamation signed by myself and Dr Santa lisis um whereas Ronald mcfaden served as a member of the Baltimore City Board of school Commissioners from 2018 to 2024 as well as serving as the chair of the beo uh CEO and boo of the evaluation uh teaching and learning committees and serving as a member on

017the policy and strategic planning committees whereas R mcfat served as the board Vice chair from 21 to 2023 and subsequently as the board chair from 23 to 24 and whereas Ronald mcfaden served on the executive committee for the Council of great City schools and for the board for Arts every day and whereas Ronald mcfaden has performed outstanding service to the students staff and families of Baltimore City Public Schools and the city of Baltimore now there for as hereby Proclaim our thanks and best wishes through a moment I'd like to invite everybody to join us in a round of applause and thank you for your service and Ronald I'm not sure if you want to uh deliver a couple of remarks this evening if like um is yours good evening everyone thank you all um I

018appreciate the well wishes but most importantly this work has always been about children it's been about the children of the city it's been about school police officers it's been about our teachers it's been about our principles who do exceptional work um and I've always wanted to be a role model for our children particularly our black boys who very important for them to see um folks um work hard and dedicate themselves to better outcomes um and so being the youngest vice chair on the board and the youngest chair um on the board is something that I want our young people to actually um know that they can do the exact same thing um I just encourage you all to stay true to the work for children um as you all know this is a volunteer opportunity

019it is not paid is thankless so I appreciate you you all uh taking this time out tonight I encourage you all to stand for righteousness and to stand for justice and to do what is right because it is right because our children are depending on you um to lead the system it is not about one person so this is nice recognition it is about all of us collectively doing our work to improve outcomes for our for our children and for our city Baltimore City um still the oldest portfolio of schools in the states we experience generational inequities we're still feeling the impact of that Baltimore was the first city um to create an ordinance um you know that city council you know made I believe it was in 1911 that um segregated communities we had

020two separate school system school system that served colored children and a school system that served White children we have an obligation um at this point even though my role is not with you on the board I am still passionate about bettering the lives of our young people um the roles have changed but we all have work to do everyone in this room we all have work to do to make sure that our young people are well and that they are better so thank you all for your commitment thank you all for your service and continue um to stand for righteousness and Justice um our children are counting on you so thank you all thank you all so before we uh before Ronald leads too he was also um recognized for his participation on the California

021Association of black school Educators so this award arrived here at City Schools and so um want to make sure that uh his leadership is also recognized this evening so commissioner Sally I just want to say that that award um was given um due to the work of uh City schools and particularly the Arts community and so that was provided um at their fall conference so thank you to all of our artists our Arts Educators and our folks who are championing the Arts thank you all joining us this evening um we also have similar um proclamations and recognition from the mayor for our vice outgoing Vice chair uh commissioner Chantel Roberts she's unavailable to join us this evening but we'll make sure that we do send those along to her we're also very thankful for her

022service um to the board to City Schools our Scholars and our families um as well throughout her tenure and her leadership so thank you so much um a couple things I want to turn to additionally this evening in our and board chair comments um regard the ways in which the district can gather input from students families staff and other stakeholders currently the board is working to establish an ad hoc committee designed to support efforts related to the search in the coming months we'll share more information on the process and provide opportunities for the public to get involved um ask Tanisha she has our presentation available to share this evening for the public check check check check check check okay so this um so there's a couple of things that we want to share um on

023this presentation this evening that um we're hopeful that this gives more insight as the process so we go to slide two please this evening our guiding principles for this search as a whole is that we seek to do this um with kind of three main buckets underway so one ensuring that we have clear communication with all of our stakeholders about this process and ensuring that there are regular updates on the intention the process and progress towards the selection of our next city school CEO our second guiding principle stakeholder input uh we are committed to um a full range of the process including um our city schools parents our teachers um our community MERS staff and others that can provide valuable input and third is the benefit of a thoughtful transition and so we're hopeful that

024over the next 18 months that this gives us an opportunity to partner with Dr Santa lisis and her staff to ensure that um as we're thinking about about um the information and knowledge that needs to be transferred to the next CEO of Baltimore City Public Schools that we capture that institutional knowledge as well as um how we can best uh fine-tune and uh deliver on the initiatives that are underway our next slide please our three main um processes that we're going to highlight tonight in the search process is a profile development candidate Recruitment and interview and selection so the first step in the process is engaging with all of our stakeholders to clearly understand um the needs of our district um that us to determine what the profile of the candidate best be selected to

025Lead City schools in the future the second process is on command candidate recruitment So based on the profile uh from the community and the support of a national search firm that we will select the board will uh seek actively seek out candidates to apply for the position and so that actual position description will be posted on our website as well as shared with our entire community and then the interview and selection process um is based upon governance and board policy as well as supported by our national search Forum that will interview and help us select the next chap executive officer to begin in July 2026 the next slide please describes more on what those three phases entail in the profile development on the next slide as that's coming up um will involve the national search

026firm as we discussed um this is where our initial set of commune listing sessions will occur we recognize fully that um we may conduct additional listing sessions to help us make sure that we have all the information that we need to build that profile and then the transition and preparation and planning that we discuss that will occur with Dr Santa lisis and her staff the recruitment process and phase will involve ensuring that we're building awareness um of our search that our position description is fully posted and that we're targeting a range of recruitment efforts to help us select the next CEO the third and final phase of the interview and selection process in which interview um applicants will be interviewed and selected an announcement of a candidate will be made and then we'll support a

027full transition to a new Administration by July of 2026 we and on the last slide here we want to thank uh Dr s Santa lisus all of our staff um as well as our district leaders our community um who will be a really iCal part of this process that will help us to provide information um tonight um we will provide more information on where we can uh select more information or receive information from the public um on our website um and we're asking for active participation from each and every one of our stakeholders in this process and I believe that concludes our um information available to us at this time so we'll we'll be back in January with more information for the public on the search process So speaking of involvement the board will be

028hosting multiple committee engagement efforts for the Public's input the first is the annual comor hearing this Thursday December 12th at 5:30 pm the meeting will be held virtually as an opportunity for parents and staff to share feedback on the proposed annual review of school recommendations so this is one of two sessions that will occur so for more details on the annual review of schools please visit the annual review website on City Schools website the second is an off-site safety and wholeness committee meeting chaired uh by commissioner Muhammad on Wednesday December 18th at Western High School uh we invite the public to come join us um as we work to incorporate cultural restorative and healing centered initiatives for students well-being student performances and free food tasting by the city school's food nutrition office will be provided

029and lastly the board will host its annual student board Forum on January 16th at the Baltimore design school and we encourage all of our students to attend and speak directly with the board about policy reform personal School experience and school safety and more as well food uh will be provided in Spanish language interpretation will be available if needed uh finally as a reminder to recognize important holidays during the winter break tonight uh will be the only public board meeting in December City Schools will be closed December 23rd through the weekend opening on January second so um with that I'm going to transition over to Dr Santa Lisa for CEO I am going to invite Chief Emily NE can you switch to chemistry and then can you go to camera check check check it's muted Event

030Services is muted we can't hear the pet recommended that Anthony Cooper Jenkins currently interim assistant principal at Frederick Douglas hey school will be appointed assistant principal at Frederick Douglas High School effective December 16th 2024 recommended that Latasha Hilton currently educational associate 12-month home in hospital be appointed educational specialist to home and Hospital effective December 16 2024 recommended that Craig Rivers currently interim principal at Carver Vocational Technical High be appointed principal at Carver vocational Tech High recommended that Kristen Taylor currently interim principal at achievement Academy at Harbor City High be appointed principal at achievement Academy effective December 16th 2024 and on CEO notification an appointment from the office of the chief of schools Lisa Robinson formerly police captain Baltimore City Police Department be appointed school police major effective November 18th 2024 congratulations to everyone on tonight's

031pep thank you up there read a brief uh background as has become our tradition um for our two um principal appointees this evening that are here we also have principal rivers and principal Taylor who I know could not be with us this evening uh first toan uh Towanda Coffield previously served served as principal of Federal Hill Preparatory School where she led the school from three to four star State rating before joining Baltimore City she led several schools dedicated to supporting children with special needs principal Coffield holds a master's degree in supervision and administration and a master's in autism and other pervasive developmental disorders from John's Hopkins University she received a Bachelor of Arts and journalism and public relations from Temple University congratulations again principal Coffield and Sheila Adams served as assistant principal at Federal Hill

032Preparatory school during the 2023 24 school year before that she spent 13 years at the tumbridge school including 10 years as principal a lovely footnote principal to all three Santa Lisa's girls thank you um her career also incl includes 19 years in Baltimore city schools as a classroom teacher and literacy coach principal Adams holds a bachelor's degree from Westminster College in New Wilmington Pennsylvania and a master's degree from lyola University congratulations principal Adams and then even though he's not here and I know you all will um tell him Craig Rivers comes from the historic Frederick Douglas High School where he served as principal for the last six years previously he served as principal of merant taller Vocational Technical High School for nine years Mr Rivers began teaching at the former Northern High School after transitioning

033from the United States Army as sergeant he holds a bachelor's degree from Johnson C Smith University and a masters from Lola University and even though it is not included in this blurb I will also say that during his time at Frederick Douglas High School uh we saw a great increase in the school culture indicators based on his leadership during that time please welcome um or congratulate principal Craig rivers and finally chrisen Taylor served as interim principal at achievement Academy she had previously taught Middle School English and English and social studies while serving as a model teacher for eight years she received her bachelor's degree in middle school education from Radford University in 2006 and began her career in City Schools she earn her Masters in school leadership and professional development from talson University in 2010

034congratulations principal Taylor um at this time I am very proud to announce for the 15th year in a row City schools has received an unmodified opinion or clean audit which is the highest level of opinion available of our fiscal year 2024 financial statements I am pleased to welcome Aries Coleman Bill early and Aaron Davis from our external audit team at Clifton Larsson Allen to briefly explain to our public and the board what that means in terms of our Effectiveness in meeting our financial reporting obligations um and are they are you all in person or I think we're on uh we were presenting remotely I hope that's okay very good to see you Aries no nice to see you to always thank you absolutely please I will turn it over to you Ma'am okay great thank

035you I know Bill is here a lot of folks on the line so um bill but I'm okay there he is I think he's there we're here I think Dr s we sent in our PowerPoint uh presentation so if somebody could uh please share that with you all and then ER Eris your camera might be off Eris if you want to be on camera no I'm still I can see everyone I don't know if everyone can see me I can see everyone see you we can see you both okay great thank you all right and the presentation is up thank you we go ahead so thank you so much for allowing us to present to you tonight and also congratulations to the um appointed positions and um you had some other congratulatory moments there so

036just thank you for allowing us to share that with you um at first uh I want to say before we go through the presentation that to thank the uh CFO Mr Dy and then you have his team as well as we work with the grants um Team um as well and um you have your um human capital um Department all of them work with us as this part of this presentation that we're having tonight and I want to reiterate that uh Dr Santa Lisa mentioned that the school board um has unmodified opinion we'll talk about that um and also more importantly that the 9:30 msde regulatory deadline was met um for the uh year ending June 30th 2024 next slide please okay so we went to introductions um and then we do have staff that

037work on the engagement as well um and they're doing a lot of day-to-day work and kind of really doing the um the the reason why we're here is because they work a lot with the school uh system staff and make sure that the information that we're presenting tonight um in our opinion is accurate next St next slide please all right couple things we're gonna um go over tonight we're going to make it quick um but but we have some required Communications we are going to talk about the audit scope and process um the the big highlights the opinions and the communication with governance um and then we will do some um talk about some upcoming um financial statement um pronouncements that will affect how the financial statements look as well as some of the information

038that's presented um in the financial statements themselves and then we do some thought leadership at upcoming uh webinars because those of you especially your school system you have any uh young uh accountants we would definitely allow like them to attend to hear what's going on in the accounting profession next slide please all right so we talked about this a lot so I'll go over this slide real quickly um but we did audit the the school's fiscal year which ended June 30th 2024 um that was presented to uh msde which is Maryland State Department of Education by the regulatory deadline of September 30th 2024 um right now we're in process of reviewing the uh schedule of expenditures of federal awards that are administered by the school system and what that is is we look at all

039the federal um Federal Wars and expenditures that the the school is administering we're required to look at a sample of those um transactions and then we make a same similar to the audit we make a determination of whether or not they were in compliance um with the uh Federal regul regulatory U guidance as well as if there are any msde guid that are related to those Federal programs um we do issue a report on internal controls or financial reporting and compliance and then we uh issue a letter to governance which is going to be some of the key components that we're going to talk about tonight next slide please um so for the single audit these are the programs that will be tested this year um of course you just go through we have the

040oper funds or the um Corona State and state and local fiscal recovery funds they're called AR they're called slurf different names but basically that is part of the American Rescue plan that is flown uh that was basically flow flowed through to the school systems and then we have your special uh special education which is also known the federal level idea cluster um title two um we have the student support and academic enrichment program and then we have the Esser educational education stabilization funds Again part of the um American Rescue plan and funds that were flow to the schools lower schools as well as some of the colleges um the single audit is not due to msde until 12:31 we're currently working with uh your grants team as well as the finance team to get that

041issue to msde on time next slide please all right so the audit process um when we talk about uh the the opinion that was issued it was mentioned that we gave an unmodified opinion which is the highest level of assurance that the Auditors are allowed to um offer on the financial statements so what does that mean so the audit process in the opinions it's a risk-based approach um we do not look at 100% of the transactions as part of that risk-based approach we do a couple of things to determine where if the financial statements we're going to have a material error we where that be and that's where we focus the most of our time um and then we do some other uh procedures maybe over some lesser risk riskier areas so we look at

042internal controls um we talked to uh several persons in management we talked to the internal auditor we talked to Dr sandal Lisas and other um persons throughout the school system to get an idea of processes and more so the consistency of how those processes are being performed um Revenue recognition you always you're always hearing that someone's overstated how much money is coming into um a a business so we Revenue recognition just across the board it's not just for the school system but just in general for the industry Revenue recognition is always an area of risk and we um look at that area pretty pretty pretty heavily um and make sure that the monies that are being recognized actually were earned and are recorded in the right period and then the last part is significant estimates

043um we talk about estimates there are some numbers in your financial statements that are really not $1 or2 they're based on other underlining assumptions um factors and from those assumptions and factors you get an estimate uh and so because of the uncertainty um or some of the high level risk around some of those assumptions they are looked at as a higher risk and we want to get understanding of those assumptions and determine if they were reasonable for the outcome um that was relied on for the financial statements next slide okay so I kind of talked about couple of these items um so the uh unmodified opinion we talked about that Federal awards are in process um the financial statements that we that are being presented did not have any material weakness we had one item

044that's noted over the cash reconciliation process um that process has is being worked on and I know that the school system has a new um an updated Financial system which is definitely helping um the finance team with uh resolution to the cash reconciliation um concern and then the federal Awards um are also in process next slide management letter recommendations so these are just best practices um these are items that as we go through the audit um we're are not allowed to be a part of management but we do kind of put that what you say a bug kind of Management's ear to say hey maybe you want to look at this uh these items here over the Long Haul um but they're not a finding we don't have any U they don't have any impact

045on the financial statements is just back best practices and that's under the information technology observations so we do do a it review over the financial system and they just noted that have five operating systems that have reached the end of the life and a recommendation was for the uh the it um Department if they want to upgrade those those systems next slide all right so this is some required Communications um it was written in the letter to governance um but we also are required to make these communications part of the presentation so uh the audit was performed in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards um we mentioned we gave we get reasonable Assurance not absolute we do not look at every item in the financial statements we do assess whether or not um the significant

046estimates are made by management are reasonable and then we evaluate the overall presentation of the financial system we did Issue an unmodified opinion the school has significant accounting policies which are in note one of the financial statements and that gives you a overview of how the financial statements are structured and what policies um are used to create that structure next page um we talked about the estimates so some of the estimates that are in the financial statements that are being presented is the incurred but not reported and that's the claims um these are health insurance claims that may have happened before 6:30 2024 um but they but but a claim was not submitted to the health um the health care provider so as an estimate as to how many those claims may be part of

047a liability before year end of course depreciation um on your fixed assets um fair value of uh of Investments the pension and the the liability again based on Actuarial valuations we did not have any corrected um misstatements we did not report any uncorrected misstatements um we did know as part of uh again the process of the new accounting system and reconciling um that the financial office is is kind of working with just some um reconciling between the general ledger and subsidiary ledger and that's really is kind of standard when you implement a new system you really are kind of going from one way of accounting um and slightly different so sometimes you have to take a moment and just get both of those accounting systems to to agree so that's a normal um a normal

048occurrence um we didn't have any disagreement with management management was very Cooperative um management did not consult any others in regards to the auditing standards that we use there were no um major issues discussed with management prior to us issuing opinion um next slide okay um just a couple things I'm going to go through these quickly that's going to impact the financial statements um one of the things that you heard maybe a little different than what we presented we talked about estimates we talked about it um and they're part of new standards that were implemented for the year um under audit and what they did is kind of what they just kind of help us um or make us evaluate internal controls over estimates your it systems that your financial statements are built as well

049as any other U factors besides the actual financial data that may affect the financial statements next uh slide please so I'm going to go through these very high levels so the person going clicking just we're going to we're going to keep moving um but just some gby standards that going to come down the road um next year we going to have compensating absence that is going to change and um the way the compensating absence liability is reported next one um so this one is really going to be a footnote if it relates to the schools it's just some additional disclosures and the footnotes to the financial statements next um so this is the big one and I'm sure Chris is probably shaking his head eventually the um financial reporting model that you guys see now

050is going to change um and when that comes down everyone probably will be ready to retire but until then um we just letting you know we have another year before that takes effect next please and then um uh we're going to be looking at how the classifications of um non-financial assets again it's more of a play on the words um and how they're presented in the financial statements next um so just some insights we have uh again any of the young people thinking about the profession of accounting or Auditors or tax um we also have other um lines of careers in our our industry please you know we have this uh this I don't know what they call it but you can scan it there it'll take you to our website where you can get

051some educational information um as well as you have Bill and my contact please feel free to ask um ask us any questions bill before WRA up do you have anything no I think the last few slides Eris we just included um we don't have to go through them um they're just there for information purposes um not related to schools um but um overall uh that's least another good audit for the school system followed on timely with MSD is the highlights that I would take away uh for you and the Commissioners great we thank you Bill you Aries just for the um the the wonderful partnership over years um and being able to uh work together on this kind of extensive audit I also just want to congratulate um Chief dor um I see is Maryann

052here too just the full team because I know that this is a full court press um to get to the audit um every year and we just value your partnership so thank you again um to our partners at Clifton Larson Allen as well as our own Finance team thank you thank you have a good one happy holidays to everyone too thank you as well um I would now talk us oh sorry go ahead commissioner Coy my apologies I'm just barreling through my AP if I can just underscore one piece right as a member of the operations committee the internal audit committee as one who in my own organization has has navigated audits uh turning around an audit from June 30th to September 30th uh you know how many years was it 13 14 years Clean

05315 15 let's be correct on the number 15 years uh for this size of organization uh you know just tremendous uh cannot be underscored enough the uh how impressive that is uh how hard that is uh and you know Chief dhy and team as you as you rightly point out you know and the work that they do uh and under your leadership just um just want to pause for a half moment and say that that is uh that is no small feat uh in something that um that we celebrate here in City Schools uh as as a point of Excellence thank you commissioner PA I appreciate that thank you very good and I you can see uh both Chief dor and Maran are just uh sitting there beaming um I I think they're probably most

054happy that it's over um but almost they got a single audit that's right they have a single audit you're absolutely right right but thank you again for that commissioner um next I would like to call school police Corporal a Kenya FAL forward to be honored for outstanding service and she looks absolutely shocked on November 11th a Dunbar High School student was wounded in an altercation after leaving school Corporal Fel displayed extraordinary courage and skill by quickly performing life-saving techniques alongside Baltimore City police officers ultimately saving The Young Person's life her Swift action and professionalism exemplify the dedication compassion and selflessness that Baltimore City police officers demonstrate every day I want to congratulate you and I also want to note for the larger Baltimore City School community that this is not the first time that you

055have demonstrated this level of bravery courage and true focus on the well-being of our young people thank you for all that you do and we now have I just want to say she just she's one of my stars so you know it's important to me to recommend this recognize the stars when they shine um and people always say give people the flowers by here so thank you here's your flower we're going to have many more flowers because as we move forward we're going to recognize Our Stars as they rise thank you thank you thank you both it's always best when it's a full surprise um I am also very pleased to report that City Schools continued to show progress on the recently released Maryland school report card for that school year 2023 to 2024 uh

056we're thrilled that we continue to exceed the pace of growth um across the state in its entirety 26 Baltimore city schools improved their rating over the previous year including yorkwood Elementary and furly Elementary both of whom improved from one to three stars in one year the only schools to do so in the entire State and once again Baltimore poly Technic Institute earn the highest rating of five stars now we still have work ahead but this is just another indication of continued sustained progress across the district um Chief Jones will be with us in January to give us a more detailed information um and walk us through but I'd like the public and the board to know that the full presentation is posted on the website if you would like the details one of the things

057that stood out to me and it really is kudos to the entire city schools team is that it is across the city it's not in one section of the city that schools are improving when you look at the map of Baltimore city where the resources historically have and have not been what you see is that there are improved school ratings in every section of the city so shout out to the entire city schools team uh both at the school level Central level and I want to thank Chief Jones and her team for just the highlevel analysis I continue to hear from school leaders that they appreciate the assistance in actually knowing what the formula is knowing how they can improve and we are seeing the results this year so thank you again um I was

058also recently updated um on our cell phone free school pilot program now just as a reminder these are 25 five pilot schools that have committed to being phonefree schools implementing policies that ensure cell phones are off away and secure from Bell to Bell and I am pleased to share uh that early data is very promising these schools as well as other schools who have implemented a similar approach have seen dramatic changes in classroom and school culture in Improvement in student behavior and an increase in student academic engagement I want to commend these School leaders for taking the critical step of removing the distractions of cell phones and other personal electronic devices from their schools recommitting to the Integrity of a learning environment that supports student academic and social emotional success and I also just want

059to say we are learning a great great deal from the Pilot School leaders and their stakeholders um I look forward to Bringing more detailed information and data um to the board as it considers um an updated districtwide board policy that really reflects the best practices learned on the ground in our schools and in addition to our 25 um School leaders who really step forward in this I also want to thank Jos sien and the legal team I want to thank um Stacy place toose um and the schools office as well as sea Shan Nelson uh my Special Assistant who have really just dug in and we are doing it thoughtfully it's not just about decreeing something from on high it is about making sure that we are learning um from the ground uh what is

060actually working and we're seeing the benefit uh so I look forward to uh bringing to the board uh suggest uh based on the work of real school leaders and their teams um later on this school year now one of the other things that we love doing even when sometimes it cannot turn out the way uh that we all wanted to do is celebrating our district student athletes and this fall we have a lot to celebrate um the city championship in Cross Country saw Polly taking um honors for the boys team and Western for girls um in the city Championship girls volleyball uh ply uh took home honors top honors in both JV and varsity um in boy soccer uh Patterson High School is both City and Regional Champion shout out to Patterson High School um

061and in girls soccer Polly was the city Champion we were also very um many of us were inspired for our inaugural girls FL flag football um season this year and our city Champion was dunar we're looking forward to competing um at the state level and then um for football for uh division 1A and 2A uh Dunbar High School um again took Regional and City Champions and then for division 3A 4A mvo was the regional Champion um both teams uh did not win this year but they lost in Incredibly Close games in this year's state championships they are still Champions um to all of us and they did incredibly well so I just want to shout out um not only our football teams but all of our fall championship teams um in sports and our student

062athletes we continue to see um that our student athletes um continue to have some of the highest GPA in the district they graduate at higher rates and they go on to leadership positions so yes it is about winning but it is not just about winning on the field um or on the court it is about winning in life so I just want to shout out all of our student athletes um from this fall season can we give them all a round of applause and then finally I want to remind everyone that the annual school choice Fair will be held this Saturday at the Baltimore Convention Center from 10:00 a.m. to 300 p.m. make sure you participate in this important process in the next big step um in your students education and on your way out

063this evening and for those of you who may be uh visiting uh North Avenue I do want to draw your attention uh to the new presentation of Student Art in the hallway um it really is is uh just I would say kind of Museum Gallery level um presentation it looks wonderful and you will see there um this year's three winners of the CEO holiday card um art contest we had three winners uh prek third grade and one secondary uh winner for Middle School this year and I just want to give a shout out of congratulations to them um because our young people um are getting more and more opportunities and our Arts students really showed out this year their designs will go all over not just the city and the state um but all over

064the country uh bringing holiday greetings um on behalf of city schools and this concludes my remarks for this evening chair thank you so much um the artwork is beautiful and it's it's a welcome addition as we walk down the hallways here at City School's headquarters so thank you for making that available um I'll now review the consent agenda board colleagues please let me know if you have any items that you'd like to be removed and please please State your question for staff uh beginning with item 9.01 the 2025 legislative platform I am going to pull that for presentation this evening uh 9.02 BTU um aft local 340 AFL CAO contract um item 9.03 the Fraternal Order of Police contract 9.04 supplemental appropriation thirdparty billing 12.01 Studies Weekly 12.02 supplement uh contract increase 14.01 computers hardware

065and related Services Contract Services 15.01 wood floor refinishing replacement repairs and relining services 15.02% 15.03 chill M Corporation elevator replacement at Wolf Street Academy 15.04 chilar Corporation Dallas F Nichols 15.05 motor coach bus transportation services 15.06 moving and Hauling Services 15.07 e ponus Construction and 15.08 which also belongs to EP corus Construction 15.09% CNN Associates 15.10 Cole Roofing 15.11 educational Logistics and 16.01 National Vision administrators vision benefits yes ma'am uh children's Guild Association 12.02 it's a social study supplemental instructural materials contracts why don't we for the moment why don't we pull that for clarification um before we vote on that decision thank you got it thank you great thank you so much I appreciate that before we move forward let me see we are going to move into public comment um we'll start with 7.01

066for our recognized groups the Baltimore teachers union Mr Nathan Ferell hello good evening Board of Commissioners and Dr Santa lisus uh Nathan frell here I'm a Spanish teacher on assignment at the the btu um I do look forward to the day that all of our meetings are going to be fully interpreted in Spanish for our familias Latinas that are here with us tonight um I also want to thank the board for listening to our members on the issue of locking doors um committing to classrooms with doors that lock is the right decision uh investing in evidence-based safety measures is the right decision additionally we're grateful to the board for listening to our members and agreeing to engage in a thoughtful review of our Employee Retirement savings plan so all City Schools Employees including folks in

067this room will benefit greatly from this uh a recent B article titled Maryland teachers may be losing thousands from their retirement savings without knowing it highlighted The Plight Educators across Maryland pH to save for retirement and it also reflected City Schools commitment to ensure that employees have access to lower fees non-commissioned agents and better investment options for all city employees and we thank the Board of Commissioners for that BTU members ratified uh sections 5.1 and 5.2 of the 2326 uh teacher chapter contract and we encourage you the Commissioners to ratify the agreement today currently the btu is at an impass with the board over rpsp chapter contract negotiations we're at an impass because the board's negotiations team refuses to compensate our members adequately um there are over 200 PA of professional and school related Personnel

068job titles and the psrp contract covers our school secretaries for example who are the face the voice and the front line of every school Community uh it covers the payroll specialist working with an Antiquated and error prone as was evidenced in the audit system how old and how at the end of life these systems are and our payroll Specialists work diligently to ensure that our colleagues are paid correctly using these these Antiquated systems it covers the registrars and the office assistants who maintain records to ensure that our per pupil funding is accurate so the wonderful School leaders who are promoted tonight can staff our buildings it covers Community School coordinators and student wholeness Specialists who deescalate a community crisis in one moment and then literally start the laundry machine and restock the food pantry shelves

069in the next the contract that right imp Passover covers our PA Educators who change the diapers and wipe away the cold weather sniffles all while providing academic and behavioral support and it covers our bus AIDS who are lovingly transporting our most vulnerable Learners to and from school every day these are the workers who are negatively impacted by the board's unwillingness to compensate them fairly for the work they do and that is why the btu has entered impass because we know the following that our members are deserving a better compensation that honors their years of service in this district and they're deserving of compensation commensurate with Baltimore County for example our working conditions are far more challenging than every other Maryland school district and our psrp members are well behind Baltimore County in terms of career

070earnings Baltimore County has significantly better and higher longevity rates that kick in earlier and that's a better reward for working longer in the system and the district can greatly improve and restructure the compensation for our psrp chapter members um you know the school board has agreed to significant raises restructuring for our school police uh who were honored tonight 32% increases for school police our school administrators and congrats and everybody who got pep tonight they are earning bonuses of $4,000 on top of 4% salary scale increases and today the board will hopefully approve a much needed restructuring for the teacher chapter compensation the btu entered impass mediation with a more modest proposal than everything I just listed uh and the district failed to present even a meaningful response to that and that's why we're at impass

071right now even today the current contract for our psrp members does not have increases based on education credentials which the B2 seeks to remedy and to be clear that is literally how you create a par to teer pipeline incentivize education I sat and I listened to a par educator yesterday I was at her school and we she's been loving and serving our students for 20 years and the entirety of her 20-year career she has maintained a 7-Day a week work schedule working a second full-time job at Walmart on the weekends she works uh 20 hours sometimes she starts 5:00 a.m. to 3 p p.m. usually works to double ship both days and she has a message to the board please let me allow to deliver it she says we are the mothers when they mothers

072are not there these kids come to a sick on a daily basis they face neglect and it is us the psrp member that meets that child with love and she wants the board to understand the liability that they face uh as as as Educators in our schools every day you know some parents think that our psrp members are are magicians that they can wave a wand and fix everything they're incredible people but the psrp members feel like the district thinks that they're also magic that they can work tirelessly and just not get paid for it we can't keep on picking out of the emotional and physical bank accounts of our psrp members and not put something back into them so we urge the board to make a meaningful effort at impass negotiations with the btu

073thank you thank you Mr come back so let's move on to officer republ thank you chair right to those coming to provide public comment the board recognizes the importance of receiving public comment on matters of educational interest each speaker shall be granted 3 minutes official time will be kept at the end of 3 minutes please conclude your remarks um no speaker may use the opportunity to Air employee grievances or make complaints on behalf of specific students speakers must stay on the agenda topic for which they signed up to speak it may not verbally or personally attack a school system employee or board member um should speakers stray from this guidance they'll receive a warning and um ask to redirect their comments thank you again for your interest in participation in City Schools education we'll now

074move to our first public comment from Julia D buso agenda topic is FY 26 budget recommendations this will be commenting live in person you will have three minutes hi good evening my name is Julia deuso I am the director of Arts everyday a nonprofit profit that works in partnership with the office of Fine Arts and organizes Community Support of the Fine Arts strategic plan each year members of the Baltimore Arts education initiative advisory committee develop recommendations for the upcoming fiscal year Based on data and experience but first before we get to that we have some really good news to share uh we continue to see a steady increase in the number of certified and conditionally certified Arts teachers districtwide and Based on data collected in 2022-23 compared to 2425 we see a 7% increase in

075the number of schools serving prek to 5 offering both visual art and music we see an 11% increase in the number of schools serving grades 6 through eight offering two or more disciplines and we see a 10% increase in the number of schools serving 9 through 12 offering depth of study which means three or more courses within a discipline we want to thank Dr sisis the office of teaching and learning and of course the mighty office of Fine Arts for their dedication and collaboration our letter which will distribute through uh Dr Judkins and we have some paper copies does outline several recommendations for your consideration um so I will use my time to focus on our most urgent concern which is administrative support and accountability at the school level for our Fine Arts teachers lack

076of school administrative support scheduling an access to materials of instruction continues to pose a serious risk to teacher retention especially for newly hired teachers we have heard from several new teachers who are trying to teach District curriculum with no access to supplies many Arts teachers are not given a budget for materials which makes planning instruction very challenging teachers are afraid to question or raise concern out of fear for retaliation of their administrator meanwhile schedules vary greatly and do not allow for scaffolded sequential instruction imagine being a teacher who does not have an appropriate Supply bank or list of materials or a schedule that is conducive to student learning it is easy to understand why you might think to look for another District where these BAS Givens exist Effective Teacher Recruitment and Retention are crucial to

077the long-term sustainability of the Fine Arts strategic plan and we recommend developing centralized guidelines oversight and accountability for scheduling program budgets And Timely provision of instructional materials that exists Beyond just the budgeting process that occurs the year before but really happens in real time throughout the year and then dedicating funding for the early PLC conclude thank you you our next public comment is from Zoe Phillips agenda topic is students creative expression and access to the Arts commenting live in person oh you'll have three minutes hello Dr sant's Board of school Commissioners and other Le ERS my name is Zoe Phillips I am a senior at Baltimore design school today I am here as a member of Baltimore youth Arts advocacy Council also known as Bak we believe that all students deserve the right to a

078first class education that includes the Arts before attending classes at Baltimore design school in which I went to City Springs Elementary midle I didn't have enough time in art class to do anything because the classes were so short I would draw or make CL crafts in another class and the teachers will always get upset they would say that I wasn't doing anything but making a mess and art isn't as important as my coursework I would be so upset that no one cared about art like I did and I didn't see it as making a mess I saw it as doing something that helped me calm down when I was stressed and it was a way to express how I was feeling at that moment and I really love drawing after a while after all the

079times I had had my art materials taken away from me during my classes and as many times the teacher would tell me that my coursework was the only important thing I started to lose motivation in art I didn't have anywhere to practice my art especially not at home because I didn't have many art materials my mind began to block out all of my creativity because I couldn't let it out when I wanted to and I became pretty drained I wrote this prom to talk about the creativity that I have sorry I wrote this poem to celebrate the spark of my creativity that makes me who I am today I look back down at my canvas which was before fit with great imagination but now back to White I started to believe that the others were

080right but the others are not right my art should not be avoided and ignored my art is my mind my mind should be explored my mind should not be hidden and drift into boredom my art is my light my endorsement my right my canvas is my blanket that Wars me through the night I Will Stand Tall with my canvas by my side my brush as my guide one day my art my mind will be heard loud as a powerful Roar and my Arts my voice will no longer be ignored thank you for listening thank thank you our next public comment is from Andy sorry if I mispronounced agenda topic is electric school buses commenting live in person you'll have three minutes good evening my name is Andy dieus I a seventh grader a seventh grade

081student at hamon Hill Academy I'm here today with my little brother Manny who suffers suffers from asthma and autism along with other students who also fa faces challenges with asthma we're drawn by our parents and most students who are all and most importantly Chief by Maryland an organization that helped our families understand environment environmental justice and the harmful effects of diesel bus Emissions on our health for children like my brother who already struggle with breathing due to asthma exposure to toxic diesal fumes makes life even harder did you know that Baltimore city has some of the highest asthma Rate rates in the country according to Maryland Department of Health approximately 20% of children in Baltimore City have asthma a rate significantly higher than the national average these high rates are no coincidence they're linked to

082poor air quality and pollutants like diesel emissions which directly harm our lungs and worsen asthma symptoms every day students like us ride diesel school buses that pump out dangerous balloons creating a mobile source of air pollution that that we cannot Escape research shows that children riding diesel buses are exposed to higher levels of prate I don't know how to pronounce it sorry matter which can trigger asthma attacks reducing lung function and increase of resp increase the risk of respiratory illnesses that's why we're here tonight to urge you to take full advantage of all available funding to accelerate the trans transition from diesel school buses to clean zero emission electric school buses these buses not only protect students Health but also reduce the city's overall air pollution shisa Maryland has collected a sign on letter endorsed

083by over 20 nonprofit Community organizations that that support the electrification of school buses even more importantly over 40 parents and students like my brother and I have joined this call for Action urging you to prioritize our health and safety the decisions you make today will shape the future for thousands of students in Baltimore City please take our recommendation serious seriously and seize this opportunity to secure funding for electric school buses together we can make a healthier cleaner and more Equitable future for all children of B thank you for your time your leadership and your commitment to our health I just want to say something as well we have the signal letter for each of you guys um to read it and go over all the community uh organization that s on to this letter that

084really into uh prioritizing and moving forward with electric school buses thank you uh next public comments from Jordan Fowler agenda topic is par Educators wages uh this will be an email that I'll read dear CEO and Schoolboard members my name is Jordan and I'm a par educator and member of the paraprofessional and school related Personnel chapter psrp it often feels like PSPs are looked down upon by many employees in the Baltimore city schools because they are seen as uneducated I can attest that PSPs are educated staff members of Baltimore city schools I for one am a par educator with a bachelor's degree I'm often asked why I don't consider being a teacher because of my degree and I find that offensive the reason is because I believe that being a par educator is a valuable

085career being a par educator allows me to have my own relationship with my students as a par educator I'm often the one who the students go to first because they spend the most time with me throughout the day for example I rotate from small group to small group I attend lunch with the students I and I go to Resource with them to name a few having a bachelor's degree helps me to be more effective with my job one example that comes to mind is with Ela classes I am able to provide a deeper understanding because I am able to break down the story in a more meaningful way due to my degree in English with a concentration in literature and culture parent Educators should receive a differential from the district for their educational backgrounds because

086it will encourage more prayer Educators to have a degree and it allows the students to work with an alternative effective educator if a member of the psrp chapter sees a pay difference based on college credits or degrees more of them will see the job as an important valued career in addition they will work hard to make sure they meet the needs of the students in our district I am asking for PSPs to get a raise for for a differential education based on college credits and additional college degrees thank you for listening and considering my recommendation and our last public comment is from Melvin Henson agenda topic support for school leadership commenting live in person and you'll have three minutes uh good even and thank you for this opportunity and uh unfortunately uh commissioner B left

087cuz he uh made a statement in reference to uh it's more open than it used to be and I've been coming here for 30 years so I'm trying to find out where it's more open that but basically I'm here I'm here tonight because you know for the 30 years and so I've been coming here one of the things that I've always fought for was a elected school board and one of the reasons is because we always feel that when you have elected School Board then you have people that's a little bit more independent and they wouldn't just go along with the grain they would go along Against the Grain if it's what they believed in so I'm here to support commissioner Heron you know from being a champion in terms of standing up and if

088it's something that she don't think is right she's not just going along just to go along she's strong enough to have opposition because she believes in the best interest of the community and of the children and I think that all of us should strive to be like that because we always say it's about the children but if we just go alone just go alone because we don't want to be different then we're really not fighting for the interest of the children right so I just want to say thank you you know and I'm begging you to stay because we need people like you and we need Champions you know the people need somebody that's going to give them some hope some motivation and I'm simply saying you doing that for not just the children but

089for us the grown people that see what you're doing seeing you leading that that that championship fight and not bending down so thank you right and I'm encouraging other members to be like that uh Miss espano we we was out there uh you know campaing together because we believe that people need to be independent on the board they shouldn't just sit here and go alone because they're here right so I'm saying thank you and we we need Champions I mean look I'm 72 years old and you know the school system is worse today than when I went to school children is learning less today than when I went to school I mean the young lady sit up here and she talked about the Arts right and how they don't even have the opportunity for her

090to practice what she Lov right so I'm saying we need Champions on all levels right so I know you can ready tell me my time is up so me and Dr bundley is here together because I'm gonna let him conclude with the comments but I'm begging y'all and I'm begging you to stay because you been there is hope for a whole lot of us and I'm just here representing myself I'm representing a lots of people that's not here tonight because this woman is a champion for us and I want everybody to know that you are our champion so please stay here thank you that's time it's quick and clean thank you stay here and we got your back I'm not here representing the mayor tonight I'm ready here representing the community right okay that's the

091end of public comment thank you before we move I just want to make sure have com so we're move forward for our committee reports um unforunately commissioner is not here this evening so look forward to our operations Comm chair uh thank thank you I'm happy to report uh that on November 19th the operations committee met and we discussed a number of items including some student enrollment projections um as well as uh some of the implementation of policy related to compensation and the changes that are that have occurred there uh and that are working to implement uh in uh still there we also had a discussion about life insure updates and some of the hard work that the district has been doing in the office of human capital to to listen and respond uh to some

092of the uh the shortfalls and the need to improve the systems um in teacher lure process and certification there's some changes that are occurring around the process by which uh items are submitted to msde uh for to to ex expedite the process there uh as well as other efforts to better serve our our teachers uh in that process uh additionally there was a presentation relating to Medicaid fund uh process and one of the the items that I particularly took note of is the ability the the increase ability and the the degree to which uh the district has um been able to uh have um Medicaid billing for mental health services inside School as well and just how important that that is uh for our young people uh that they are receiving those those various supports

093uh that the the schools really are the heartbeat of our communities um so thank you to those that attended and and presented and would encourage anyone that is interested in any of those topics to go and watch the the posted uh recording of that committee meeting thank you so much commission Cory the policy committee met on November 19th at 4 to 5:30 and we looked at ADH which is community school strategy we also reviewed an administrative regulation for kd- ra uh and we saw where we reviewed compliance reports for ihama which is heroin and addiction education and jfd withdrawals and re-entries our next policy committee meeting is December 17th which will be virtual and we will be looking at jcj student use work electronic devices and receive administrative regulations on IG or ig- RB School

094uh library media media program and compliance reports for jfa residency and non-residency tuition jfbc informal kingship care and we welcome anybody that wants to provide public comment to do so by sending uh a notification at 9:00 a.m. on Thursday up until the Monday before the meeting want to raise two dates for uh the community there on the December the 18th at Western High School we will be holding a public safety and wholeness meeting we want to encourage everyone to come out but particularly we want to encourage our students to come out as this work is about you and this is an opportunity for your voice to be heard this committee meeting will have a special presentation from our fellow commissioner Brooks so we encourage all of our uh School community members and students to come

095out our second date is a save the date of January the 13th on January the 13 we will be holding a community listening session where we will be looking at And discussing the board goal of Holiness the work that's being done around it and how we measure this will be held in the community and we will have further details at the safety and wholeness meeting which means you got to come out to learn about so look forward to seeing you at Western on the 18th at thank you so much for teaching and learning committee met on December 3rd we had updates on um our math and literacy goals um um for our math uh we received updates and a presentation on the focus ear Improvement areas of high quality instruction materials you got to talk

096about the pilot U that taking place now and the efforts to increase uh teacher coach and Leadership capacity to uh Implement uh that de with Fidelity and talked about the expansion or scaling of use of that curriculum uh for literacy uh one of the highlights was hearing from the Baltimore design school the principal and literacy coach St here about the wonderful work and the support that they are doing to meet Learners where they are and help them achieve um their goals and their U targeted how they target uh growth um they talked about how they are differentiating uh for Learners and um supporting teachers and U helping students at every level in their L literacy Journey our next meeting for teing learning is January 7th where when we will discuss exended thank you so much

097appreciate it um based on public comments there any Des more members pull from the consent agenda let's move to .1 our platform for a presentation from okay it's not allowing me to go to slideshow but it's up there good evening chairman Sally um board Commissioners Dr Santa lisis and members of the public D stet the executive director of Baltimore City Board of school Commissioners direct uh legislative team I say team because I also work with Melissa broom from the CEO's office and I'm here to provide information about the 2025 legislative platform it's my recommendations and suggestions for adoption tonight I'm having technical problems here we go so I wanted to first start off with the board's role um I because we have several new Commissioners I wanted to give you the uh education article and

098the code that allows the board to set the legislative policy management and operations of the school system so the policy portion of the board is one of the most important roles that the school board has um in in its um its work so to develop the 2025 legislative platform I listed all the different groups that I spoke with during the course of my work I meet with individual board members um I have discussions with the co staff mainly through Melissa broom and sometimes with Chiefs when when necessary especially with the chief legal officer Josh Sion um I meet with various elected officials throughout the year it's just not a one-time moment um May which is the Maryland Association Boards of Education they have a legislative committee but also May has a subgroup of my colleagues

099called Green Street we meet we we meet weekly throughout the year to discuss issues that Bubble Up um legislatively um the Public School Superintendent Association the executive director is part of the Green Street Coalition so we meet on a regular basis I had individual meetings this fall with uh PTA pcab cak asbc and also the Maryland State Board of Education or I should say the Maryland State Department of education's legislative person also attends the Green Street meetings and legis legislative committee so with all that I help to uh form my opinions and recommendations for the board to consider I'm also providing you with sort of like some key dates this legislative session so session begins January 8th which is just in a short of a month um typically there are over 2,000 pieces of legislation

100introduced each year and of those 2,000 about 400 relate to education in some manner um also the Governor will be introducing or has to introduce the budget bill the operating budget bill by January 15th and that's a very key date not that's a key date in every year but it's also extremely important this year um in light of the fiscal issues that I will address later on at the state foresees um the final date to introduce any bills that are guaranteed a hearing um for the Senate is February 3rd and for the house is February 7th and that's important because as I move through my legislative platform there may be items that the board would like to have on legis ation drawn and or amendments um crossover which is when each of the bills switch

101houses so the house bills go to the Senate the Senate bills go to the house and that is a key date because then you know or you have a better idea of what bills may actually have a a a chance of Passage because a bill has to pass both houses in order to become a law and then and you know in in Maryland the governor does not have to sign a bill he just has to it just has to pass both houses um and session ends on April 7th as better known as s die so here's just the overview of some of the big key topics that I foresee this session um clearly the budget the operating and capital budgets blueprint because of the fiscal issues I will be talking about a later we have

102to be very um conscientious of what happens with any changes to the blueprint adequacy of funding which is also tied to blueprint um our CIP funding request which is our Capital Improvement program request of $1 169 million this year um age our aging infrastructure so capital is always very important to the school board and the poverty count while we are um trying to ensure that poverty is truly counted um we have something and I'll get into a little later about the neighborhood indicators of poverty which we are hoping can be considered um it will be a tough year this year but um we will still move on as we always have to ensure that our kids get everything that they need mental health for student staffs and security um and safety and that's going to

103be I think rolled up into some of the juvenile issues we'll see and what we call the reportable offenses that occur um in in statute so first we'll start with the state operating budget as I said earlier right now there is a billion dollar or foresee a billion budget Gap in the state um and it intends to grow or they expect it to grow to six billion if there is nothing nothing done with any Revenue enhancement packages or any other measures um last year we went into a session with the mere 761 million deficit and they were able to figure that out a billion dollars now back to back it's a little bit more difficult so that's why throw in there about the blueprint concerns um we have funding for blueprint um right now in

104the state coffers to last through to 2027 after that we never did have anything specifically set aside to go beyond that so now with the state's budget woes um the concern is and I'm hearing that there are uh discussions about how to slow down the growth of the blueprint um if we recall when we had Thornton there was discussion of slowing the growth and slowing the growth really just sort of stopped the growth and so that's what we really need to be concerned about this session and even speaking with other advocacy groups and when I listen to some of their um online virtual meetings everybody is concerned about the blueprint and what will happen um of course we're always concerned about again unfunded mandates so this is could potentially be a year where we always

105see unfunded mandates but since there's so few State dollars to go around they may end up pushing more onto the school boards and the school systems um another issue is the concentration of poverty grants right now we have in law through F uh through 2025 that our concentration of poverty grants can be used to help with some of those Fine Arts things Fine Arts programming that um our students spoke about earlier um this is set the sunset like I said in fy2 which is this next budget year we definitely want to continue that and so we're hoping to get an amendment um on the budget Bill uh to include to um in to not to remove the sunset um the Maggie Macintosh School Arts fund this was supposed to be and is a non-aps fund

106and I put this here where it's supposed to be non-aps but this is the kind of fund that could just sort of disappear out of the budget because it's just something very simple and so I think we just have to be um very careful about ensuring that that does not happen um the CIP again uh ensuring that at a minimum the state gives $450 million that it has promised to give for this for um School construction we generally get about 25 to $28 million of that on a typical um school year um the healthy school facilities fund this is a fund that um is $90 million and it set to sunset in fiscal year 2026 and last year we went in to try and uh remove that Sunset but instead and I'm going to move

107ahead um we um they didn't remove the sunset but they decided to reestablish the school facility assessment work group they're supposed to meet be starting in June of 201 25 and they're to look at all the school buildings across the state and assess their conditions and coupled with that they're supposed to set aside $70 million um to help with in the it's called the Nancy cop facility fund to um set aside money to help bring some of those school buildings that they are that are the worst in the state once they prioritize them from the facility assessment group um to help them with um some construction or renov but the problem with that is right now we get 45 million of that $90 million in the healthy school facility fund there's no guarantee in this

108$70 million um Nancy cop facility fund that we would get $45 million so we really do want to remove the sunset we also want to work with the facility assessment group when they convene in June and I'm sure I will be down in Anapolis Andor looking at it virtually and talking to our elected leaders on that facility assessment workg group but we really want to keep that off $90 million in the statute right now until they come to a conclusion of how to prioritize and understand exactly what that priority will look like um we also want to reclaim the Aging schools program which was um wrapped into this to the uh built to learn they said when the built to learn was passed that the Aging schools program which is a very small program of

109$6 million that we that most school districts use to to facilitate it at the renovation of things like small libraries and small items that they would um that they would wrap that into the bill to learn but and built to learn would be wrapped that they would wrap the CIP aging schools program into the built to learn program but there's no evidence that that has actually happened so again I think we want to resurrect that aging schools program I mentioned early about earlier about counting poverty so for those that don't recall I believe it was maybe 2013 or so we began we became a community eligibility provision uh district and that's a federal law that allows all our students to eat if the district um through direct SE um has been uh has about 40%

110of its students eligible for free and reduced price meal you automatically are eligible to have all your students eat but the problem with that as it moved as we discovered is that um the way that the the state counts poverty is by using the free and reduced price meal forms and so when we had the passage of the blueprint in order to according to them to get an true accurate portrayal of what the poverty count is they wanted to return to us collecting forms now we haven't collected forms in years also there's no incentive for our parents to actually fill out forms so we through research and working with some Advocates discovered that there is something called the neighborhood indicators of poverty and that uses more socioeconomic issues housing issues not just direct C it

111also looks at education it looks at um the concentration of poverty that the person lives in not just income like a free and reduced price meal form does and so even the State Department of Education they were tasked with looking at uh a way to count poverty they also endorsed the neighborhood indicators of poverty a few years ago but unfortunately uh the state did not um did not want to uh use the neighborhood indicators of poverty because it would have cost the state about an additional $300 million and if you recall the state a few years ago yes last year had a 761 million gap we have a billion dollar Gap this year um we still need to push to find a way to count poverty the um last year we were successful in having

112the enough act include language in there that requires the governor's office of children to look at the neighborhood indicators of poverty and figure out the best way to count poverty and they're supped to have a um a uh um um recommendation by October of 2025 I believe that's the thing I think it's October I'm have to get back to the date I believe it's October um yeah October 1st 2025 of the best way and recommendations to count poverty and so while it's not really a legislative action but it's something that we really need to keep an eye on that um there's the governor's office was just newly um uh newly put together over the last last year and so now we have to make sure that this is something that actually is beneficial for all

113and including especially for our kids some other things that we need to look through um or look forward to this session is finding innovative ways to recruit and retain staff um also our school safety which I we talked about the reportable offenses I think there's definitely going to be legislation that we need to work with and help put guid around um if you recall there are certain offenses that when a juvenile is arrested that they have to notify the superintendent that they're coming back coming to their school district so it's like it's a murder or arson it's some major offenses um what happened this past year was that a student and I won't say which jurisdiction but a student was in a jurisdiction and then transferred to another and that new jurisdiction did know that

114the student had these charges and so they found that was a loophole so the state department of education went to the ALR Committee of the general assembly which is the administrative executive um and legislative Review Committee I might have missed a letter there um to seek U additional regulations to tighten that up but the ALR committee said no we know we're going to look at that during session so that alone we know that there's going to be something coming out to deal with the reportable offenses and how we ensure that that Gap is no longer there um again trauma informed care is always something that we need it's not just about restorative practices which is what I think a lot of our our some of our elected officials believe is the only thing but um

115there should be other things but trauma informed care is something that will be very important this session um mental and behavioral health issues will pop up um and some other key issues to watch preas students and private providers the um the blueprint requires that by 2028 2029 school year that 50% of our pre students should be in private provider settings or public settings now Baltimore city has been giving has been doing pre- for many many years and so the concern we have is that if there's a requirement for this 50% that we may end up moving kids from our public setting to a private setting just to get them at the 50% which makes no sense last year we thought we had an amendment in the in the in the law to change that but

116it fell off so we're going to go back again this year and and try and get that done um prek students tier 2 funding um prek students are um are divided up into different tiers based on poverty and they receive state funding and or the school system receives State funding for for Te for teaching them and tier two funding was supposed to tier two students were supposed to come into the school system this past School year but in order to save about $7 million the general assembly last year delayed the um the tier 2 um entrance of pre students in exchange for for the per pupil to increase to $19,750 by the 2027 2028 school year and so I think we just want to make sure that that doesn't disappear in the budget this year

117um environmental factors impacting education we heard a student talking about the diesel fuel and also but just the general air quality I believe we'll see some legislation um introduced like that chronic absenteeism that's going to be a big issue um there's been bills in previously about average daily attendance funding for average daily attendance which is you know something that this board has always been against and I think we should definitely still be against that um but I think there's going to be some legislation that will um ask for some guidelines and some recommendations some reporting on what to do about chronic absenteeism cell phones that's that's a big issue as well I think we're going to I'm sure we're going to see something about cell phones but what we need to do as a district

118is to ensure that they can put guidelines of cell phones but to ensure that there's local control on the specific policies that each district is required to uh implement the charter school facilities funding that has been introduced for the last couple of years that is a bill where um um Charter Schools would receive direct payment of $2,000 per pupil to allow them to deal with any renovation and construction of their privately owned uh school buildings um we have opposed that in the previous years I suggest we continue to oppose it it was about nearly $50 million the charter schools would receive and if you recall as I just mentioned our CIP we only get about 20 28 and a good day um million from the state and so they would have gotten $50 million to

119allow them to deal with their privately owned buildings but people don't understand that the IAC in 2023 that's the public school construction program they have passed regulations to allow charter schools to access um State funds for some of these for renovation and construction of their facilities in fact in 2024 one charter school got $560,000 and uh 2025 they have there's a pre-authorization for another Charter School to receive a little over a million so this is um something that I think we should continue to oppose not that we don't believe in charter schools but when we deal with that sort of money and we and they know when the charter school law was passed that that was part of the deal that they would they would take care of their buildings um and also artificial intelligence

120um again that's going to be something introduced that would deal with how school systems use artificial intelligence for tutoring and for teaching and what sort of allowance do students have to use artificial intelligence when they um do homework and do research and so those are some of the big issues I had this all written down but I went it off the top of my head so I hope I didn't miss anything um so then I just hope that the uh school board will adopt you have the longer version which has specific supports and oppositions with you um you've had it I gave it to you I think in October and then again um you had it in your packet the public has it as well and it has all the the the very detailed information

121thanks I want to uh start off by say thank you um this is extremely important work I think that in the uh past couple months my time on the legislative committee May has really uh opened up my eyes to the significance of our role in this work he knew it was important but really the crust of the funding that we receive as a district comes from the state and the things that are important to us during this process this is how we protected so so I want to encourage us to spend time with this uh this these legislative uh efforts that have been uh for Force because there are efforts to take our funds away we often talk about our poverty dollars which uh those are very it's it's very obvious that those dollars are

122at constant Threat by the advocacy of other districts that we have a role and responsibility to protect those dollars but there are other dollars that those other elas are after as well so I just want to highlight the importance of this I want to thank you for uh your leadership in this work and uh I look forward to supporting you in it both on the legislative committee and this year in Anapolis thank you commission commissioner voler thanks I just had a couple questions um first of all thank you for the presentation and for your work on our uh legislative agenda one is just a quick clarifying question so I heard a couple numbers tossed around for CIP just going back to the state capital budget know you said we get about we got about 28

123million last year what's the to I heard two different figures for the total what's typically the total the request was 169 million this year and generally we get around $28 million from the state and do we think what is your anticipation around it'll probably be about about the same I don't think it'll be any higher no um and then I just want to make sure I'm understanding our position on reportable offenses so is the position that we support uh reportable offenses for certain offenses uh what can you clarify what exactly we are the reportable offenses I'm sorry I didn't want to cut you off the reportable offenses are already in the law they are already stipulated I think what I what I was trying to say is that that will be an issue this session

124without seeing the actual legislation it's hard to say what we what it will be but I believe that there has to be um a effort to ensure that local school districts aren't put aren't used as a liability and point the finger at the school district is saying you didn't do this because we have to be notified and so there should be maybe it's Department of juile Services maybe it's um I don't know some other entity they should notify school districts it shouldn't be just Baltimore or in our case Baltimore City shouldn't be the ones on on the ones told that you didn't do it I see uh but the legislative effort is likely going to be focused on fixing the loophole that uh yes that okay yes thank M SL sure thank you chair um

125thank you one for but I wanted I've been doing it a long time I to take a moment Rec talked about and I just wanted um while we don't know what is coming um there have been some forecast and I just want to take a point of privilege to uh to request that in the coming days that we talk about and maybe dis this around what could be happening Fally with regard to legislation um incl Department ofeducation um or dismantling it is not but I think that there is a lot of conjecture that is happening in public sphere and I think it's important that we as District um be able to um bring our state holders along us on this journey because while you're talking about State session um there certainly is federal implications our

126work moving forward we should just bring them along our state and and for the dismantling of the Department of Education I mean I was young but I do remember um and that Ronald Reagan attempted wanted to do that as well and um that didn't happen he I I think we could think we could see a scaling back of the Department of Ed but I don't think there's going to be a complete removal of the Department of Education or Title One [Music] mhm right and The Angst yeah yes you any addition comments this evening hearing none um is there a motion to adopt the legislative platform for 2025 so move thank you moham second secondo thank all in favor commissioner a messenger yes hey commiss yeso yes K along with us commissioner Mohammad yes yes commission

127rer yes commissioner SL Harington and I am in favor any opposed oh is commissioner r with us I see um any of those this motion passes um before we vote on the remainder of the Senate agenda this evening I just want to go back to clarify the record I may need some friends here to help make sure we've got this correct so 12.01 is supposed to be um social studies uh Studies Weekly um I'm excuse me I'm sorry 12.01 should be the children's Guild contract and 12.02 should be Studies Weekly social studies say correct great thank you so much I just want to make sure the record was complete Inc correct is there a motion to approve their aband concept J messenger I'll take am Messenger as a second all in favor commission messenger yes

128Coy yes commissioner espo yes commissioner mohammd yes commissioner R ler yes commissioner sler Harrington and I'm in favor there any opposed that motion passes uh before we move on back to item 9.04 the third party billing um item the board would like to express its support and excitement for the third party billing supplemental appropriation request that was shared during November's operation committee meeting and ultimately approved tonight through um our consent agenda this approval speaks directly to the need for our investment of most vulnerable students those with disabilities and those needing mental health supports this release of the third party billing funds will enable the district to provide all schools with a direct application of funding to support and deep in special education support and services secondarily this expands our mental health supports to students by

129nearly doubling our investment in expanded School Behavioral Health Services we as a board want to thank third party billing and finance team as well as the academic and special education staff of work on this proposal look forward to hearing about the impact of these Investments and future board meetings thank you again for the thoughtful work on behalf of our students and our schools we are going to move forward to item 10.01 for presentation um information discussion on the administrative modernization project Nelson Tommy J good evening Commissioners good evening Chief Tommy Jones and I are looking forward to presenting you with our annual full board update on the administrative modernization project which is a multi-year program um that's a partnership across Information Technology finance and human capital and sorry I thought the slides were going to

130be shared do you need one of us to SL share the slides we can certainly do that but I thought they were going to be shared Emily I can Cube them up for you great thank you e next slide as always when we do our projects we always look at how they uh connect to the boards these priorties and the amp project makes two primarily and that is priority three uh high quality modeling systems and making sure we have equal access excellent as we know since the very beginning the goals have have been to replace a 24 year- old system um that has been a challenge as it always is uh and we also want to make sure that we are moving towards a single source of the truth amp is not the only thing

131that we're doing for that but it is a major step forward in the finance and human Capital Area exell SL just a quick recap uh amp is made up of multiple phases phase one phase two phase three which actually is made sub phases phase one was Finance we went live uh in January I'm sorry July of 5th of last year uh and the finance team has been the yans and taking us live and getting through the audit and so forth that we end the year reporting and we very successful at doing that the second one was the budget budget is actually been reevaluated as we were set to launch it we realized there were some additional things we wanted to do and then uh phase three is really three parts and the three parts is

132the human capital work uh with the U payroll involved it is the uh performance management system as well as the learning management Performance Management actually did launch and chief Noone talk about it in a second and learning management is about uh is being prepared to be launched next slide so as Chief Jen shared we launched our performance management system which we call charm this fall since our last full board update about AMP and so I wanted to provide you with a few highlights we had over 93% of our staff complete the training to use charm at the beginning of the year and we also had a record high 79% complete their individual development plan in charm this year we know that the individual development plan lays an important foundation for success in the evaluation and

133employee development over the course of the year so we were glad to see that the new platform was enabling a higher percentage of our staff to participate in that we also have had some strong feedback from staff about this new platform with over 73% of respondents agreeing that charm is a better platform for evaluations which included 83% of our school leaders who responded this is uh a key reason why we selected this platform since our teachers and our principles have been having to use two platforms for their evaluation and their student learning objective historically and now it's in one uh we also received some uh positive feedback about the customer service the team provided and the training and resources that were available to staff in using the new evaluation platform we're looking forward to seeing

134these successes continues as we roll out additional platforms um in the coming months as I said earlier amp has many timelines uh there's the financial there's the uh human capital and the one thing that we wanted to highlight here tonight was that we had initially planned to roll out the uh payroll system um for January of 2025 uh but that has changed and we now moving that to 20 to to 2024 sorry to 2025 January 2025 um so it'll be later in the year next slide well we wanted to just briefly update everyone is why do we need more time prior to go live uh two major factors the first one was we as we were about to roll out and testing and testing and testing uh we discovered that there was a major technical

135issue with one of our Platforms in the integration with the with each other um after a lot of testing we realized we could not uh be confident that we would create and generate paychecks accurately um that was an untable situation that was not acceptable to us U so we made the very tough decision after all the hard work to drive towards January 2025 that we were going to delay it and make some corrections to the technology as well as a number of other areas next slide so now that we've made the decision to postpone the go live of human Capital Management payroll and ukg the electronic timekeeping solution we're actively replanning for when we can bring that live and since we are considering a later date we're having to work around the workloads of the

136team that does the setup and testing for this system which will be running the budget process when we get back from winter break and then involved in hiring and processing over a thousand new staff members for the start of the upcoming school year so we're working through that to make sure we can fix the integration do all the retesting prepare staff and uh because this is a payroll system it does need to start on the beginning of a quarter for reporting purposes so we're looking at either a July 1st October 1st or January 1st start date instead of the January 1st 2025 and we'll be sharing a replanned timeline with the board and the community in January next slide so we always look to how we can learn from what has happened and to share

137our Lessons Learned in our board presentations so in the last year we've learned of course the importance of testing it was through testing extensively that we knew that we weren't ready to go with the payroll and timekeeping we did learn uh in the last several months about the importance of moving quickly when there is a problem discovered and uh to try new Solutions and test them out rather than to keep testing a solution that doesn't seem to be working we also learned that we have some work to do to improve our end user support we use our heat ticketing system and we learned that we need to be able to respond to concerns submitted via heat faster and present stakeholders with resolution uh so that's something we're working on addressing as we do our replanning

138and finally we do have uh what we call change Champions on every school on every team who support this change management through additional messaging uh and communication support to their school colleagues and their team members and we need to do even more to involve them and help them bring their team members along in this change process next slide so our next steps we're working right now with the team to replan our timeline and our budget which we'll be sharing in January and then we're doing more testing more development of the system as well as training resources and materials and making sure that we're communicating to stakeholders throughout the district about what the plans are and how they'll be experiencing their work day-to-day at City Schools it's beneficial for us that problem early on problem f

139want think that one of the lessons that um I would suggest that take from this outside enti City Schools I think that our kids deserve the best of so we identify partner question would be around cost now talking about pushing this back and there are some potential costs that may come along with this I want to make sure that we have the ability not to wait on this uh vendor suggesting of cost but us kind of pushing to find out what we're going to be liable for if anything and really having a push making sure that they're liable for extra time that we're going to have to spend in starting to do our beta testing all over um making sure that that doesn't fall on the back Mark so it's that something we can before

140and if so uh where when can the board hear back from you regarding uh any cost if if any that's already in progress and we'll be sharing with the board an update in January yeah and I do want to just one additional Point quick Point uh we uh when we realize that the vendor was not performing um they were a system generator so a one step down from the actual owner we went to the primary um organization and they I have to give them credit they responded quickly with a team to come in and help us evaluate what was going wrong what we need to fix they've been um meeting with us almost every day for the last couple weeks once we made the decision and so we're trying to do exactly that we're trying

141to figure out what it takes what where the responsibility lies and what are we going to do differently um it's not a year ER of work it's spreading uh the work out over till we hit the right date to make it successful so we are working very diligently on that very day and we will give you an update uh you know in the first quarter of this year or in January any additional comments questions yeah I just want to say thank you for the the transparency and the conversation around lessons and and learning you know it certainly is something that uh you know so many teachers rely on and and school-based staff and wanting to know that uh that you all are are working to get it right uh really matters so thank you for

142for that uh that vulnerability and that conversation here tonight thank you thank you thank you so much we appreciate time this evening and presentation we're gonna move forward um to the office of new initiatives for our next two items so operator waiver and cap request and um going into our next item which is annual review for new song good evening I'm Angela Alvarez I'm theor director of The Office New initiatives for Baltimore city schools good evening my name is specialist office of new initiatives you're going to do it okay right so tonight we're um um presenting operator Weaver um and cap requests um uh on a biannual basis uh School operators can make um requests to make changes to their contract um so with that I'm going to turn over to Tiffany he's going to

143walk us through um the requests so uh we'll start with our board priority connections which would be priority five and priority six and just to give an overview of what waiver request process looks like um waiver requests cover waivers of District policy major changes to academic or other school programming changes to enrollment in capacity opportunities for request happen in two windows which would be fall and spring requests can also be made as a part of the renewal application request that AR made as a part of the renewal application are considered separately from the application itself and are voted on after the renewal vote the considerations um in this process are rationale for how change meet meets a school need evidence of demand stakeholder engagement quality of school programming and the capacity to implement it which

144can include anything from Staffing facility Etc our waiver timeline starts when school submits a request that begins on no November 1st request vetted um by our office and key offices happen between November and January 2025 request presented to the board for information is happening right now we're in tonight on the timeline and then next in January the Char and operator Le School Advisory Board considers the request and provides advice to the CEO and then in January on January 28th the CEO's recommendation is going to be presented to the board of of school Commissioners for a vote so we'll start with our Geographic attendance area wer request that we've received um it comes from Green Street Academy school number 377 um they are requesting a geographic attendance waiver they are operated by Green Street Academy Inc

145they're in a current contract term from 2024 to 2029 the grade configuration is 6th through 12th grade green stre Academy is requesting a geographic attendance waiver citing the potential to address lower than expected enrollment and chronic attendance challenges among Scholars living outside of the geographical attendance area green Academy also indicates that the waiver could support stronger Partnerships with feeder schools through joint programming the school states that if granted the waiver would allow for priority placement of Scholars within the geographic attendance area which they believe could enhance engagement with families in their by communities and just one more thing before we move off of um Green Street just so we're super clear for members of the public this would be establishing uh a geographic area where um people who live in that area we get preference

146in the lottery and be more likely to get seats so that's what the request is to be able to establish a geography around the surrounding School Community to give preference for seats into the school um to those communities just to be super clear and so we'll move into enrollment waiv requests that we've received first we have Bard High School school number 362 they have submitted a request to modify their admissions process operated by bar College contract current term is 2020 to 2025 with a grade configuration of 9th through 12th grade Bard has submitted a request to modify their admissions process to include a review of applicants attendance records Bard states that this change would help support students academically and would position students for a success in high school and college level coursework this school is

147in the renewal process currently and is recommended for a three-year contract renewal pending board approval next up we have the tund tumbridge school school number 373 they are requesting an enrollment cap increase from 455 students to 478 students they operated by AIA Baltimore Inc in a current contract term from 2020 to 2025 with the great configuration of prek through 8th grade time Bridge request an enrollment cap increased from 455 students which is excludes their prek of 20 to 478 tumri asserts that this increase would provide more seats to the community and offer greater Financial flexibility to address the school's needs their plan includes adding more seats in the middle school and increasing enrollment in Elementary grades this school is currently in the renewal process and is recommended for an eight-year with conditions contract renewal pending

148board approval just to kind of show of what this might look like uh the last few years of the current the contract proposed um that they're up for Renewal right now is shown on the screen and it's going to look the same throughout the the contract if approved with the approved cap of 455 students the requested change cap change of 478 with the difference being 23 and that's it for our waivers there are any questions comments okay let me defer to my colleagues for any questions they may have this evening thank you uh thank you for this um questions on a question on Green Street and then also a question on Bard um what is the anticipated um impact on the socioeconomic makeup of the school if the waiver is granted what do do you

149have sort of a an analysis of the area and how it would impact not yet so that's part of the vetting process we're kind of still beginning so um when we come back at the end of January it'll be with a full recommendation that reviews all those kinds of considerations thanks I'm getting ahead of it um uh the second question is about bard and I guess I'm I'm curious how common this is I'm a little skeptical of um these types of uh requirements I think kids in middle school don't get themselves to school so I think holding a kid accountable holding a student accountable for attendance um to me is uh a questionable practice I'm curious how pervasive this is and what the rationale for the request is yeah so one board is a high

150school they're you know they're early High SCH but they would be correct but they would be looking at attend they would be looking at the attendance of middle from kids were Middle School I'm with you now sorry long day I'm with you now um uh it's not common it's not something that um we do currently in our district there was a time when we did look at attendance we've moved away from that practice for um for a lot of the uh reasons that you site um so but schools can requests can make requests okay um so thank you additional questions that we may have one I had was about when we're looking at the capacity of our operators who are involved um how heavily does that weigh when we're looking at um the track record

151of our operators in this process to be able to absorb higher Caps or any other waiver um in this process yeah so School quality is one of those things that we're looking at uh and and that whole capacity goes into like could they handle more students what's the climate like like what are these other indicators as well as what's their Staffing plan they have a realistic plan to be able to to sort of address that so all of that kind of factors in into the evaluation great thanks heing no additional questions why a quick question yes go ahead I'm so sorry um so and these are relatively small numbers when we're talking about the scale of the school district but looking at how this impacts like the larger strategic plan in that these students even

152if there only 30 of them are coming from other places um how does this play out in terms of the longterm strategy for maintaining that we have a district portfolio with schools performing at their Peak size does that make sense like is this are there certain schools that we're anticipating these students to be coming from will that ultimately negative impact other schools in the portfolio yeah that I mean right again we haven't done the that analysis yet but that's part of what we look at like what's the what's the impact on that and so part of what you'll hear when we have an actual recommendation or the why we support or do not um and and those considerations so we'll go through all the things that Tiffany shared in terms of the factors will actually

153go through each one with uh uh considerations so you'll hear you so you'll see a detailed accounting of that in our thank you very much that makes sense great I think we're ready to move forward to the next presentation all right um so next we want to officially um share a recommendation for new song Academy so on November um 10th when we um first shared the renal recommendations we had a pending recommendation for the school we wanted to understand better their finan situation uh and so tonight we're going to share uh an update on the recommendation and again I'm going to turn it over to Tiffany he's going to walk us through okay and so this one is connected to uh board priority four and six just an overview of the operative renewal process again

154for those of us joining us tonight it was developed in 2012 by stakeholder working group which included School operators um supporting Public School of Choice Maryland Charter Schools Network and and City Springs City School staff renal is a process to review performance of operator Le schools including Charter contract and transformation schools key features include consistent set of metrics from year-to year annual debriefing process with key stakeholders narrowly focused changes to address challenges that may have Arisen 18 schools have Cur are currently going through the renewal process in 2024 2025 renewal OCC occurs in the pulet year of a school's operating agreement and the following recommendation ations can be made to the board on terms of its next agreement partial renewal which is 3 years for renewal of 5 years extended renewal eight years for schools

155with a history of multiple successful prior renewals and also non-renewal and possible School closure the operator renewal process here's an overview of it we first start with the review of the conducted uh that's conducted by the charter and operator Le Advisory Board which includes members that represent the community organizations nonprofits School operators District Representatives a second level of review happens with our CEO an administrative review that considers The Advisory board's recommendations the qualitative and quantitative review and a thorough um administrative review then from that a final recommendation is made to the board finally the ultimate decision on all operator renewals rests with the board which considers the recommendations and rationale of the CEO the operator renewal report testimony given at public board meetings and work sessions the contents of the offal record and factors that

156are listed in policy ihj and administrative regulation ibj R for charter schools and for non-charter schools policy FCA and administrative regulation FCA our operative renewal timeline is just an overview of what has occurred thus far um tonight we are giving you an updated recommendation for new song So NewSong Academy school number 322 the Opera operational history is as shown they operated by newstone Community Learning Center Inc the gr configuration is prek through 8 the enrollment right now is 322 and for new song Academy they originally a new school's initiative school that became a charter school in 2020 the school has had multiple partial and full renewals and is currently in its final in its initial five-year term as a charter school so for new song they received a developing and student achievement a developing in

157climate and the updated uh rating of developing which includes an additional financial review for finance and governance the recommendation is a three-year renewal with conditions to expand school size and to improve Financial capacity some highlights of their renewal is that they have the recommendation that we're presenting now they have a highly effective in each of its impact growth measures in ela 638 and mass 6 through 8 where the school grew in its 95th and 81st percentiles they're effective in mcap absolute performance for ELA 6-8 developing in mcap absolute performance for ELA 3-5 not effective in mcap absolute performance for math 3 through five and effective and school effective Effectiveness review measures currently they do not meet expectations in audit and audit content and internal controls where the review found that the school has had significant

158financial challenges which will impact the future sustainability of the school including several years where expenditures exceeded Revenue that's why the recommendation includes the conditions that the school needs to expand the school size and to improve Financial capacity yeah if I can just add a little bit of context um so this is the first time new song is being reviewed as a charter school uh and so um the financial responsibilities of charter schools are different than when it was a new school initiative school um it's also a school that's been working on expanding it's a it's a very small um size School uh and that's been delayed it's been trying to move into um um The Gilmore building um in coner with the city and that's they've experienced some delays so these these things are contributing

159to some of the things we're seeing in the finances uh and so it's not an issue where we're concerned about um um management this is more so has is a function of uh not being able to grow and being small um squeezing on the budget with um The increased um you know cost that schools have to bear um um and so you know they're at a size you know we've been recommending and closing schools that are like under 300 kids and so they're in that under size and they're experiencing that challenge at being so tight uh and so part of the conditions is that they need to actually expand uh and we would do uh additional Financial reviews and so um I just wanted to be clear about um what there is but you know

160there's there's been challenges in in the budget in this interim in this uh first revie as a charter and any questions or comments questions on Newan Academy go ahead go um thank you again um so the I understand the the uh condition around increasing is really around their financial sustainability and their ability to do more you know more things um programmatically um but you also sort of made it sound like am am I UND correct in understanding that in order to grow they would have to successfully move into this new building are they Limited in their current building uh in terms of their ability to grow yeah so part of what we will talk with them about is other ways to expand um so that's going to be sort of our continued sort of conversation

161um with them um uh the um delay getting the building is uh has to do with um um uh when buildings are left open sometimes people take things out of the building and so someone before they had full control of the building has impacted like the pipes so this adds to additional costs so I think we have to be um creative with them but um um I think we have like a a a path forward a clear path forward uh and so we'll keep you updated uh very frequently on on these these are not like the other kinds of um both for them and green School these are not like the other kinds of conditions where you need some time right to see so you'll get much more frequent updates if you approve um uh

162this contract and with the conditions that we're recommending sounds good I I cognizant of trying not to set people up to fail if that is this is this a feasible thing for them to achieve in we would not recommend um continuing we didn't think we had a feable path forward thank you additional a new song right thank you so much I and I we really appreciate everything um especially recognizing this is a heavy LIF this time of year we appreciate just the thorough updates the organization of the process ensuring that we're well informed as board Commissioners um and are able to make um our decisions on the process so thank you thank you e e e Mr Slater Harrington and I'm also in favor thank you so much that motion passes we hope that you

163all have a good evening uh we look forward to seeing you guys back soon here

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.