CorpusRecord 96574

Secaucus Board of Education Board Meeting Janurary 16th 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / SBOE Stream
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Hudson County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,217 words · about 46 min
Collected
2026-06-13

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e Lance if you can read the open public meeting act statement in accordance with the provisions of the open public meetings act the board secretar has forwarded notice of this meeting for advertising by having the date time and place thereof posted in the SE cus town hall on the bullon board education administration building as well as notice being provided to the Bergen Record journal and District website thank you flag salute roll call Mr bartletta present Mr banino present Mr deetta present Mr Barry present Mr debre present Miss Geller present Miss Howard absent Mr Lewis present Mr Lions present executive session I'd like to make a motion to approve the regular meeting minutes of November 21st second discussion call the role Mr bartletta yes Mr Bolino yes M deetta yes Mr Barry yes Mr

002debre yes Miss Geller stain Mr Lewis yes Mr Lions abstain student representative report hi uh sorry but um to start off I'd like to congratulate our Esports team who won second place of the Atlantic region for the EGF gaming League uh next up on January 8th uh NGIT held a Science Olympiad where 20 sophomores juniors and seniors from our school um competed with other top performing students all over the state and we performed uh very well there also the same day we had an alumni day/ Harvard representative um sort of day so the seniors we had the privilege of meeting a lot of um seock High School alumni who go to schools like Princeton and Purdue and there they really um just told us about how they got acclimated to that college life and they

003gave us some very very good advice and it was really nice seeing some old friends over there I said hi and it it was really cool um and also the Juniors they talked to a um Harvard representative uh the Harvard representative gave them some guidance on the application process which they will be starting in a few months as uh the second markting period comes to a close we're going to have midterms next week um from Tuesday to Friday and finally on January 30th the National Honor societies will have their induction ceremony um these inductees have worked very hard to receive their honor and it would be a great night to appreciate their efforts thank you thank you Paul correspondence no correspondence at this time I'd like to turn it over to Mr Fogerty who will

004be doing our ethics review training this evening am I up here yes so good evening um as uh Mrs deetta said this is the annual ethics training that uh board members are required to participate in I'm going to be speaking to you tonight about what your role and function is as uh board members and what the role and function of the board is and the interplay between individual board members and the Board of Education and uh I want to begin by saying that the Acting Superintendent said something to me uh earlier tonight which probably uh uh o is is overarching with regard to uh the code of ethics for school board members as well as all your policies and that is that uh really it's about treating each other with respect and civility uh understanding

005what our respective roles are and respecting uh each other's roles as we go about the governance of the C caucus Board of Education so I certainly won't take credit for that I'll give him credit for saying that to me I'll be it in a different context so I want to begin by by talking about um what the board of education is what our Authority is how it's derived um we are a statutory creature um we have the authority under title 18a uh which is the uh the statute of the legislation uh that establishes what our powers and Duties are uh we uh enforce the rules of the State Board of Education we make amending repeal rules for government and management of our schools and we perform all those things that are necessary in order to

006provide a thorough and efficient education for our students uh and provide them with the equipment and maintenance of buildings that are necessary uh to carry out those functions so the state board's rules require that the board do a number of critical things we approve the curriculum that meets the New Jersey student learning standards uh we adopt a budget that provides for a thorough and efficient education we hire the necessary certified Personnel to educate the district students and we develop policy IES for the management of the school district importantly none of this happens without the recommendation of our superintendent of schools no action can be taken by the board with regard to any of these critical areas without the recommendation of the superintendent of schools the only exception to this is with regard to the renewal

007or non-renewal of our certificated staff members on May 15th of every year the superintendent makes a decision as to whether non-tenured employees will be renewed for a subsequent school year if he makes a decision that they will not be renewed they have the ability to come before the board to challenge that decision and to persuade you that the superintendent's decision is incorrect that is the one and only time that the board can Trump the recommendation of the superintendent and arguably could hire an individual that was not recommended by the superintendent for re-employment however that does not allow the board under any circumstances uh to to do a Leap Frog over the superintendent uh decide to come forward with a recommendation to the board that has not gone through the vetting and recommendation process required by

008the superintendent boards can only take official action at a public meeting the board functions only when it is in session and a quorum a quorum of the board is a majority of our board requires five board members to be present and that is required in order for us to convene a meeting our meetings are govern by the open public meetings act uh civil rights statute uh implemented by the legislature jurisdiction for violations Falls not to the commissioner of Education interestingly enough but actually falls to our County prosecutor so that should uh hopefully impress upon you just how important it is that we comply comply with the open public meetings act committee meetings less than a quorum are not official action so our committee meetings are not advertised there's no obligation to comply with the open

009public meetings act um those committee meetings uh do not operate with a quorum of the board uh so they uh provide an exception uh to the meetings law you want to be careful with emails and text messages and why because even though those text messages and emails are being sent by you singularly not part of a quorum if in fact you are sending emails or text messages to one another in real time and there are five or more of you who are corresponding with one another arguably that would be a violation of the open public meetings act you would be conducting board business uh uh outside of a of of a public meeting uh and if it is in real time uh that would fall within the provisions of the open public meetings act the

010board operates as one unit not as individual members we share our opinions we can have a robust discussion at a public board meeting but once the board makes a decision a single course of action by majority vote it is to be respected by the remaining members of the board regardless of whether you may have been dissenting members of the board on that particular action in open meetings to preserve the decorum and ensure that the board expresses a single consistent position the president alone speaks on the board's behalf she may certainly request that other board members continue to that contribute to that discussion uh often that happens in terms of reporting out from uh the work of our committees uh she may also defer to you if you want to contribute to a conversation at a

011public board meeting but it is the board president uh that is delegated with the responsibility under our policies uh to speak on the board's behalf the board and the administration the board's direct responsibilities are to make policies develop plans evaluate outcomes not to manage the day-to-day operations of the school district pretty simple uh we are a policymaking body we should not be involving ourselves in the data Day activities that fall to the superintendent and to the other administrators to whom the superintendent delegates those responsibilities to members are responsible not to administer the schools to see that they are well-run we have a board policy that says and this is really important because this is a provision in the school ethics act it is a provision in our policy that is most often violated by board

012members you see so many you see so many complaints going to the school ethics commission where this happens and that is that no board member by virtue of his or her office can exercise any administrative responsibility with respect to the schools or as an individual command the services of any School employee in simple terms what that means is that a board member cannot call up the superintendent and direct him to do anything cannot call up the business administrator and direct her to do anything cannot call one of our building principles and direct them to do something or to produce something or to prepare a report there's no authority to do any of those things and to do so would clearly transgress both both the statute and the board's policies board members do not have all

013access to the district schools and in many respects our your Authority is no greater than a parent or a Community member you're expected to observe the visitors policy when you come into our schools you sign in and you sign out we all do that we do that for security reasons but we also do that to ensure that we are not using our positions to uh uh for some unwar to take some unwarranted Advantage um and board Pol the board the board's policy explains that board members visiting the schools for any reason must observe direct regulations uh for all School visitors so the board obviously is delegating responsibility uh to uh uh to ad to administer the schools uh to the superintendent of schools he delegates that responsibility to his directors and his supervisors and of

014course our business administrator has the keys to the kingdom with regard to finances she is responsibility for overseeing business maintenance the budget uh fiscal planning and she serves as a general accountant and also as our certified registered purchasing agent so as I started out I want to emphasize that the relationship between the board and the administ ministration is expected to be cooperative not adversarial you should share your concerns with the administration in advance of meetings it assures an effective public response so if you get the agenda if you have questions if there is uh if if the backup material uh isn't sufficient for you to make an informed decision you want to communicate that uh to the administration before the meeting uh ask for that information to be provided to you that makes that that

015accomplishes two things one it makes sure that the administration is able to be responsive to you but more importantly it makes sure that you are able to make an informed decision about whatever that agenda item is that you're expected to vote on at a particular board meeting so you should be mindful of which matters are appropriate for public discussion versus uh versus those that are reserved for private executive consultation um as required by the code of ethics a board member confronted with a community complaint should withhold comment on that and refer it to the superintendent and that would be any Community complaint obviously you want to be gracious about the person who is approaching you you know whether they're approaching you on the soccer field or at the grocery store or on the streets of

016SE caucus and they've got a complaint you have to refer that complaint to the superintendent even at a board meeting such as this if there is a hot button issue in C caucus and they're ready to storm the Basel and the the the C citizenry is coming up to this podium one person after another no matter how compelling that may may be the board does not have the ability to to to take action to resolve that complaint at a public meeting without referring it to the uh to the Acting Superintendent for a resolution it is only if there is not an administrative solution a failure of an administrative solution that the board can take up that action at a public board meeting so the code of ethics requires uh our board members to support District

017staff including the administration support them protect personnel and the proper performance of their duties uh if there are questions about uh a board members uh about if there are questions that board members have uh about the administrative staff they should be rice notice that discussion should take place in executive session uh we should not be criticizing uh our Personnel uh in public in the Public Square on social media uh that would be a violation of the code of ethics a violation of this of this command would occur if there's evidence that a board member took deliberate action which resulted in under opposing compromising or harming School Personnel in the proper performance of their duties um if there's a concern about uh the performance of of an employee in our school district that concern should be

018communicated to the superintendent superintendent alone can rice notice an employee for discussion uh for discussion in an executive session with regard to public meetings it certainly doesn't mean that board members cannot disagree with a recommendation made by the superintendent you have every right and even a responsibility to do that to have a robust discussion but you want to do it here and you want to do it here because if you do it here you are privileged to have that conversation you do that with impunity you don't run the risk that you are going to violate a provision of the school ethics act you also don't run the risk that there may be an issue with regard to the inv to to a violation of someone's privacy rights criticizing the superintendent can lead to a violation

019of the code of ethics where it undermines or compromises the superintendent's ability to do his or her job where would that happen that would happen if you decided that you wanted to speak to your principles and say G you know I'd like to know how Mr Vorhees is doing and if you were to solicit that kind of response from your principles arguably you would be violating this provision of the school ethics act so the powers of the board and the authority of a board member are not coextensive what does that mean in simple terms what it means is that the board acts as a single body or a single unit so no board member by virtue of your office can exercise any administrative responsibility with with regard to the schools or or an individual command

020or as an individual command the services of any school district employee but the board could actually do that so if in fact you wanted to raise an issue that you were concerned about you would do it here if there was something that you wanted the uh the Acting Superintendent to prepare for you or the business administrator to prepare for you you would you would do it here you would see if there's a majority of the board that agrees that they want the administration to devote the time and resources to that particular effort whether that particular effort would actually benefit the board as a whole and the and and and the school district as a whole and then the board would make a decision about that so again it would be the board that would have

021to exercise its Authority based on your request that it consider doing so confidentiality one of the most important things that I speak that I want to speak to you about tonight and impress upon you is the need for confidentiality with regard to what to with regard to discussion that may take place in executive session in our executive sessions you are going to be hearing about things not only in terms of litigation and negotiations but you're going to be hearing about things that are highly sensitive you're going to be hearing about our our employees you're going to be hearing about our students you're going to be hearing about things uh that uh uh clearly uh are are uh are are are private and sensitive and the need for confidentiality with regard to those uh with regard

022to those discussions um uh cannot be emphasized enough a violation of that is not only a violation of the school ethics act it runs the risk that you could Prejudice the board uh student matters are governed by the family education rights Privacy Act furpa that federal law protects uh students it protects their records it protects any personally identifiable information Personnel matters are governed by the open public meetings act in terms of Rights noticing employees in order to protect their privacy rights and of course negotiations uh the need for confidentiality uh uh has to be emphasized as well because disclosing that information could also Prejudice the board um I also want to say that with regard to confidentiality when it comes to students when it comes to Personnel you want to be particularly mindful of this

023because if there is a violation of that you run the risk as an individual board member that you may not be indemnified for those acts uh uh by the board and under our uh uh under our general liability and Arizon omissions policies because you would have been acting inconsistent with your elected responsibilities as a board member so again what happens in executive session should not be repeated to any third party should not be discussed with anyone other than the board your your your colleagues on the board uh your Administration if it's appropriate and of course with myself code of ethics so code of ethics for school board members limits the role of board members it sets clear standards for the Board of Education to follow and there are two important aspects of uh of the

024of of the code of ethics One deals with prohibited acts the other essentially deals with your conduct and uh your relationship with the administration there's uh an important distinction here because if in fact there's been a claim that you have violated the uh the school ethics act that you have tried to use your position to gain an unwarranted Advantage for yourself or friends or relatives if you have done something in order to gain a financial benefit um that is prosecuted by the Attorney General's office uh they are the attorneys for the uh School ethics commission that is their attorney they would prosecute that complaint whereas if someone makes a complaint because you have violated the school ethics act with regard to your conduct or your behavior toward the administration or with regard to any of

025the uh uh with regard to any of the responsibilities that you have as an individual board member somebody makes that complaint that individual is responsibility is responsible for prosecuting that complaint not the Attorney General's office keep in mind that as long as uh uh as as long as your conduct regardless of whether or not uh whether whe whether or not is a subject of a complaint if your conduct happens here if your uh if your conduct happens as a as at a public board meeting if you're acting within uh the course and scope of your official duties as a board member you're going to be indemnified and held harmless if such a complaint is filed it's covered uh by title 18a in terms of your official duties and of course we uh as a board

026you as a board purchase insurance in order to uh which which also covers uh acts and omissions where you may be accused of a violation of the school ethics act um but private action on the other hand is not covered so if you're out there doing something on your own not part of a uh uh it doesn't doesn't occur at a public board meeting uh you take some action on social media you get involved in some activity uh that could compromise the board uh uh what would be an example of that you know let's say that you decide to become part of an advocacy group you're soliciting parents in C caucus uh as part of your representation that clearly would be in conflict with your duties as a board member uh that uh would be

027private action outside the performance your duties arguably would not be indemnified by the board or by its insurance policies also keep in mind anybody can file a complaint uh so except for the board of education so if you're alleged to have done something wrong that complaint could be filed by a teacher an employee it could be filed by uh the sea or it could be filed by a private citizen but we as a board cannot file a complaint against one of our own members we are not permitted to do that and if that were to happen you would have to take a step back and you'd have to file that complaint as a private citizen cus Board of Education cannot take action against one of its own board members um so this is the code

028of ethics I'm not going to go through all of this because I've really highlighted those areas that I think are the most critical but this is the code of ethics uh that sets forth very specifically each of your responsibilities and your decision making um and again I've highlighted uh uh those that I think are the most important for you uh already so the limitations imposed by the code of ethics are clearly seen in your limited involvement in Personnel decisions uh your role in hiring is to vote to appoint the best qualified Personnel available uh available after cons consideration of the superintendent's recommendation uh you uh cannot withhold your approval for arbitrary or capricious reasons but you certainly can withhold your approval because you don't agree as long as the reasons that you don't agree are

029legitimate reasons and that can be for any number of reasons when recommendations come to you you know recommendation comes to you keep in mind that if it's a Personnel recommendation if there's an action uh pending before the board you know you have the ability to look at the qualifications of that individual you have the ability to go into the uh go into the superintendent's office during regular business hours to review a personnel file if someone's being recommended for a promotion or someone is being recommended for uh disciplinary ction you have the ability to do that but you don't have the ability to withhold your approval for arbitrary or capricious reasons uh you do have the ability to say the superintendent you know we don't agree with your choice we don't agree with your recommendation we

030want you to go back to the well you just don't have the ability as I said to essentially Leap Frog over him and and and decide that you're going to re recommend somebody else for that position the school ethics commission has said that the best practice is that we limit our our involvement to hiring the superintendent uh uh that uh after considering the superintendent's recommendations that we don't get involved in the interview process you know you do obviously get involved in the interview process for the hiring of a superintendent your school business administrator maybe your assistant business administrator maybe even a principal but beyond that the school ethics commission has said that you should not be involved in that interview process um and if you are involved in in the in the interview process U

031beneath those beneath beneath the superintendent and the business administrator in terms of the hiring you need to have the superintendent's concurrence and your involvement is as a spectator so you're not allowed to be interactive as part of that hiring process but you're enti but you are entitled to watch that hiring process unfold You're simply not you're not permitted to ask questions or even to pass questions to the superintendent or to the hiring committee so violations under the code of ethics there are certain actions that have been identified in our our Administrative Code that are considered to be violations of the code of ethics so giving a direct order to school Personnel or becoming directly involved in the activities or functions that are the responsibility of school Personnel so kind of breaking that down to something

032that has real meaning for us let's say that you walk out of uh uh you walk out of this pack center tonight and you walk into uh the reception area outside and you see garbage and debris uh uh all over the floor and you're upset about what you see and there's a custodian within eyesight you don't have the ability to direct that custodian to clean that floor you need to refer that complaint to the superintendent you go into one of the schools and you see somebody acting out inappropriately you don't have the ability to address it you have to direct that to you have to direct that to the building principal uh or uh to or or or to the superintendent let's say that there's some board action involving uh uh employment of an IND

033idual and you're in one of the schools for a proper purpose you don't have the ability to stop by at the principal's office or the ability to stop by with the supervisor and say gee I see that Stephen foger's name is on the agenda for an appointment you know what are his qualifications why are you recommending him clearly that would be a violation of this provision of the school ethics act you can't take deliberate action which results in as I said undermining compromising or harming School personnel and again you cannot act on any complaint without referring it to the superintendent so in addition to adjudicating complaints that come before the school ethics commission they also issue advis advisory opinions so for example if there is something that you want to do or if you're a

034member of an organization or if you are employed in a private capacity and you are concerned about whether or not any of your activities might conflict with your responsibilities as a board member or a committee that you want to serve on or some action that you may want to take you can request an advisory opinion from the school ethics commission and they're good about this you know if you submit the request by the 10th day of the month you're generally going to get an advisory opinion by the following by the following month and it is advisory only I mean if a complaint is filed and it's adjudicated I think it can take some comfort in knowing some security in knowing that that is going to be the outcome but again it is advisory and from

035time to time we have done this on behalf of board members generally speaking if you think you have a conflict then you would go to the board president the board president would solicit an opinion from me if I was clear and unequivocal in terms of my opinion you can rely upon it if I was uncertain if I said I couldn't find any case law to really resolve the issue I would suggest to the board president that I request an advisory opinion on your behalf so that we keep you obviously in a safe harbor with regard to your conduct so you can see these are advisory opinions and very quickly board member uh can a board member participate in negotiation if he or she has an aunt employed in the district but is not a member

036of the local union this board member wanted to know whether or not he or she uh could participate in negotiations and the commission issued an advisory opinion and said no you can't do that you know basically um uh board members cannot participate in any aspect of negotiations including voting on the collective negotiations agreement involving uh uh uh inv following it uh the uh attainment of a memorandum of agreement if they have a relative employed in the same school district so basically you see the school ethics commission reaffirming what they have said many times so here's a board member who's an Adjunct professor and as an Adjunct professor the board member says are there any restrictions on how I conduct myself on the board of education and the the the school ethics commission says yeah there

037are you have to recuse yourself from any discussions or decisions which could relate to or otherwise involve any District Personnel not only who were your students but any District Personnel who were part of that program in that college so let's say that you know you're an junk professor and it it is part it is part of of a a doctoral co-op in a in in one of the the colleges or universities uh any employ any employee matter involving those Personnel that came before the board you would have to recuse yourself another advisory opinion in terms of interviewing Personnel again as I've already emphasized uh uh for you that uh you cannot conduct the interviews you can only be Spectators superintendent has got to agree that you should participate in that and you know what it's

038just not advisable the one thing that I'm absolutely certain about after hanging out with you for a number of years is that none of you want to Simply Be spectators at an interview so my suggestion is that you restrain from doing this entirely restraining yourself from doing it means that you're not going to get yourself into any difficulty you can see this advisory opinion there are a number of board members who were concerned about the staff turnover in the school district they were concerned about the fact that they were having a retention problem with their teachers and so they wanted to conduct exit interviews with the teachers that were leaving the district to find out what the problem was so laudatory purpose well-meaning School ethics commission said not your job that is the responsibility of

039the superintendent not you he or she should conduct the exit interviews and report back to you as to what the problem is and once you know what the problem is then you have the ability to fix it you simply don't have the ability to investigate it to determine what caused it so you can see that this is actually an adjudicated case and this goes to the issue of what you need to do if you are going to make representations about school about school business and what you need to do in terms of self-identification so you can see that this board member in Lacy Township she got herself into trouble she violated the school ethics act when she endorsed new members uh uh to the board in her official capacity as a board member basically said

040I'm a member of the Lacy toship Board of Education and I want you to vote for Gerald Li lions and Kelly deetta she did not say that she was not speaking on behalf of the board and she left the impression with the public that the Board of Education had endorsed those candidates she was censured as a result of that by the school ethics commission you can see in the next case uh coming out of Manchester Township the board member violated the school ethics act when he was a volunteer football coach uh after he was appointed to fill a board vacancy and so why is that you cannot be a volunteer football coach when you are a board member because doing so means that you are being involved in the day-to-day operations of the school you

041are supervising student athletes you are potentially supervising uh uh uh other individuals perhaps even staff members and basically uh basically they spared the rod here because he didn't know that he couldn't do this and it was only for a two-month period so they found a violation but they did not impose a penalty in this case uh Woodbine Board of Education the board member violated the school ethics act when she picked up a letter from the home of a friend School employee regarding the employees disciplinary discussion so she had this friend uh she said and and she said to the board member G uh you know I'm going to issue a rebuttal to a disciplinary uh uh disciplinary action that was taken against me would you mind giving that letter to the business administrator and ask

042the business administrator to make copies for the board members but whatever you do don't tell the superintendent so you can see that this checks off all the boxes you know this is a board member who has taken action that undermines the superintendent perhaps even vilifies the superintendent also has taken action which could Prejudice the board uh so uh here year as a result of the violation the board member was suspended from the board of education for 60 days and by the way these are all 2024 decisions it was a hot year for the school ethics Commission in the next case manua Township Board of Education the board member was in violation of the act when he called the complainant supervisor represented himself as a member of the board and complained about the actions that the

043individual took at their board meeting so imagine that uh I am a uh teacher um or an administrator in Union City and I live here in C caucus and I come out here at every board meeting and I'm railing against the board and your policies and you decide to call the superintendent of my school district as a member of the board and say you know what you really need to put a gag order out on that individual because uh he has treated us disrespectfully and with a lack of Civility uh that was found to be a violation uh that board member was censured as a result that board member took private action the potential of which could have compromised the board and why because that individual could have sued the board of education for a

044violation potentially of their first amendment rights that action taken by a board me by the board member was found to potentially have a chilling effect on the individual's ability to come out and express an opinion at a public board meeting so in the next case uh this board member used her position to further her Personal Agenda regarding her child's disciplinary record so as board members when you have children in the district you need to be particularly careful that about this I mean while you're always board members you're also always you're also always parents you have the right to advocate for your children unquestionably um and while you're advocating for your children you need to make sure that you're doing that as a parent and that you are not representing in any way that you are

045a board member even leaving the impression that uh that kind of uh uh that that kind of coercion uh is any part of that communication in the next case East Orange Board of Ed East Orange Board of Education um uh this was a board member uh who voted against a board policy uh uh with regard to the naming of schools uh this is a policy that we have here in the district uh it's one that we have looked at uh on various occasions but in this policy uh the board uh wanted to impose a restriction so that uh only individuals who are deceased uh could uh could could have their names proposed uh for naming on a school building uh this board member voted against it and instead voted to rename the school building in

046honor of the lieutenant governor for whom she served as Chief of Staff ultimately that was found to be a violation she was censured for her actions using her position uh uh for special interest or political or or partisan political purposes uh and uh also for personal gain or for the gain of friends so you can see that three or four of those boxes are checked off in terms of the school ethics act so as I started generally use good judgment you want to be really careful about social media I say time and again to board members don't use social media time and again I am completely ignored when I give that admonition so I will tell you that since I am ignored what I do want want to tell you is you need to be

047careful about it you need to make sure that you're not posting anything that violates any District policy you want to make sure that nothing in those postings are defamatory nothing in those posting is confidential that it's that it's not something that you've learned about as a board member that the general public doesn't know about you want to make sure that you're not using your title or position to solicit uh uh uh uh for for anything even if it serves a laudatory purpose you want to refrain from having communication through social networks with other board members because that too could be a violation of the open public meetings act you don't want to respond to any postings regarding Board of Education or School District business and I would go so far to say as you don't

048even want to respond to something on social media that might be critical of the board critical of a teacher critical of the superintendent by using an emoji or a thumbs up because all of that can be interpreted as a communication by a board member uh with regard to a complaint that should be referred to the superintendent and upon which you should not act act so don't post any information on on a social network uh that would be a violation of the school ethics act and if you are going to post anything on social media if you're going to write a letter to the editor if you're going to uh uh if if you if you are are going to uh hold Court uh in C caucus and express your opinions about anything uh if you're

049going to do a podcast you want to make sure that you make it clear that you are speaking as a private citizen that you are not speaking in Your Capacity as a board member and you can see the disclaimer right there in quotations and what I want to emphasize is that the school ethics commission has said that this is unconditional and unequivocal you can't go halfway you must go all the way and use that statement so if you have a website if you're on social media you want to make sure that you are indeed uh posting that statement and if you had a campaign website it is no longer prudent for you to use that website on social media you should discontinue the use of that website so there's something relatively new instead of extensions

050we now talk about recusals you know we always talked about uh when you vote you vote to uh you you vote to approve uh you vote to deny or you could abstain but if you have a conflict you should recuse yourself recusing yourself means that you are taking uh that you have a conflict and that you are not participating in the discussion or in the vote because of that conflict it is a recusal it as if you are not even here now I have given you here for anybody that is employed in another school district I have given you a chart so that you can readily determine whether or not you have a conflict and the to which that conflict may involve your ability to to participate in negotiations or to participate in any issues

051involving the superintendent or any supervisor of a relative of yours who's employed in caucus so you can quickly go through that in terms of your own status in terms of the status of your spouse or your partner your dependent child your non-dependent child or relative and you can see uh what those restrictions and or limitations are and are not so I know for example that we have a board member now uh who is a a member of a similar Union is not a member of the sea but is a member of a similar Union so Works in another school district we have several board members that work in other school districts and so can they participate in negotiations no they cannot so they cannot be involved in the development of proposals or strategy or any

052of those issues can they vote to ratify the contract the answer is yes and can they participate in the superintendent issues the answer is also yes what's the aster for well the aster is that the answer may not be yes if you are a union leader in another school district if you are the grievance chairperson in another school district then uh you may be further restricted in terms of what you can do indemnification I want to emphasize this uh indemnification uh is available to all of you provided that what you do you do in the course and scope of your elected public duties uh this is a case uh in which a board member uh was uh uh uh in which a board member filed a lawsuit uh against the board of education on which

053she was uh serving uh ultimately the board said that uh you cannot sue us and also serve as a member of the board uh they uh therefore um filed a petition to have her removed from the board uh ultimately she was not successful she wanted to recover her attorney's fees and that was denied and in this last case this is a a board member that was advocating for her child uh with special needs a child with educational disabilities uh she was advocating for her child and ultimately uh filed what's called a 10day letter which is something that gets filed by a parent when they intend to unilaterally Place her child in a private school and then ask the board to pay for it she filed her 10-day notice but she didn't ask the board to

054pay for it kinan Board of Education said that the filing of that 10-day notice meant that she could no longer serve on the board she challenged that she ultimately was successful and the Appel division said that because she had not actually asked the board to pay for that placement she had not crossed the line with regard to a conflict that would have disenfranchised her from the board so she was successful what that also meant is she would recover her attorney's fees board email confidentiality this was a board member in East Orange came out of an executive session decided to send an email to his friends about what was discussed in executive session he got uh he got in a whole lot of trouble for that because he was disclosing confidential information clearly a violation of

055the school ethics act but there was something else in here that was important and so I I I pointed up I pointed out to you and that is that what the school ethics he defended this on the basis that he couldn't that he should not be found to have violated the school ethics act because if someone had made an OP request for that email that they could have obtained it uh under the open public records act open public records act as you know says that government records uh are subject to access by access by the public depending upon their content everything that we uh receive or send in this school district uh in or out of the district to one another is a government record a government record is any document that's made in the

056ordinary course of business here in seus the question is if somebody wants access to those public record those government records what is the content of it the content determines whether or not they receive it and whether they receive it in a redacted form and what the school ethics commission said is that this email would never have seen the light of day because it was advisory consultative and deliberative it was predecisional it was something that the board was considering but not something that the board had decided so that email would not have been subject to access under the uh uh open public records act you're done with me any questions thank you thank you Mr fogy thank you also I just want to add um we attached to the agenda this evening a guide to the

057Board of Education meetings in New Jersey and some frequently asked questions I just wanted to go over a couple of them ones that seem to continue to come to our attention um and seem to be concerns of the community regarding our role as board members so one of the questions what is the role of the school board and the superintendent the school board is charged with representing the concerns of its Community monitoring the educational needs of its students and creating policies to ensure that its district is well-run it does not operate the district's day-to-day business that is the job of the superintendent the district salary chief executive officer the school board must vote on and pass items regarding policies goals objectives and Personnel it holds the superintendent responsible for implementing and achieving those objectives another

058commonly asked question if I have a problem is the school board the appropriate body to address it the school board should be the quote court of last resort work up the chain of command for instance if you have an issue concerning a district employee first address it with that person directly if the matter is not resolved then take it to their immediate supervisor and follow up the chain of command if you are not satisfied another boards may choose to respond to public comments by seeking additional information or delegating authority to the superintendent or designate to investigate an issue while public education can be an emotional issue the school board should strive to maintain a certain level of decorum at its meeting many meetings are recorded streamlined streamed online or televised and students often attend or

059participate in meetings as such all should maintain a tone of respect and civility courteous behavior is extremely important during challenging times my school board seems to rapidly work through its agenda without much debate why is that school boards sometimes have a workshop or Caucus meeting where they discuss issues in great detail but do not vote on those items boards may use a committee structure where select members totaling less than a quarum of the board often working with the superintendent or key administrators study a specific issue and make recommendations to the full board for a vote by the time the full board meets for the regular agenda or business session where it votes on issues issues agenda items usually have been vetted or studied so those are just some commonly asked questions that you know I

060think it's important for the public to understand what our role is this is attached um there are many more topics that that are discussed so I suggest you take a look at them the it's attached to the agenda for um it's online right Grace is it online as well not yet we will put it not yet not yet we will put it online after tomorrow after tonight's meeting okay and there are copies too for anyone that's here there are copies when you come in if you want to grab one on the way out okay the correspondence uh Acting Superintendent report I um waited a little while to discuss something that that we all experienced over the last couple of weeks here so yesterday my day started out I had a chance to speak with Felicia

061Maloney who's been here for 42 years as a teacher this morning morning I I had a chance to talk to Jim baraba popular for Zed teacher and coach for many years worked here around 40 years and then I thought about how long I've been here um kindergarten 1970 I'm 59 college for 4 years away one year after that had nothing to do with C caucus schools two years coached somewhere else 52 years I had something to do with sea caus that's a long time you know but we lost a teacher Lisa Smith Bonin um not too long ago so we talk about time tonight you put a lot of time into this and and the people that work here put a lot of time into this and it's precious time and I ask that you

062make it efficient time thorough and efficient are the two words that have never changed in public education never changed let's make sure we always make sure we take care of ourselves with our time because it goes fast later on my good friend over there is going to give he's going to read out some awards a lot of kids put a lot of time into what they do and he's going to do a great job thank you Charlie business administrator board secretary report yes tonight I have two things the first I good evening I would like to request approval to amend the schedule board meeting dates for February for the year 2025 I'd like to change the February 20th board meeting as the school district will be closed to February 13 and I would like to

063change the March 20th board meeting to March 18th as we have to submit our budget to the county on March 19th so I ask approval for this discussion uh February February 13th Grace did you say or February 20th to February 13th 13th is the new date you're welcome and then March 20th to March 18th okay thank you no discussion call the role Mr bartletta yes Mr banino yes Miss deetta yes Mr de Barry yes Mr debre yes Miss Geller yes Mr Lewis yes M Mr lions yes thank you um you're welcome now I'd like to take a moment to recognize our board as this is School Board recognition month whereas school boards create a vision for what students should know and be able to do whereas School boards establish clear standards for student performance whereas

064School boards ensure that student assessments are tied to establish standards whereas school boards are accountable to the community for operating schools that support student achievement whereas school boards align School District resources to ensure that students meet standards whereas School boards create a climate that supports the philosophy that all children can learn at high levels whereas School boards build collaborative relationships based on trust teamwork work and shared accountability and whereas school boards are committed to continuous Education and Training on issues related to student achievement now therefore Acting Superintendent Mr Vorhees and myself hereby declare our appreciation to the members of the SE caucus school board and proclaim the month of January to be Schoolboard recognition month we urge all citizens to join us in recognizing the dedication and hard work of local school board members in

065preparing today's students for tomorrow's world thank you [Applause] all thank you thank you Grace thank you Charlie thank you Grace and Charlie thanks for the pens public forum agenda items nothing okay thank you Pat governance committee Personnel this month we are approving and welcoming an elementary teacher substitute teachers for DM bus driver pum nurse and pum clerk I would like to make a motion to accept the recommendation of the Acting Superintendent to approve and adopt resolutions R 1.01 through r 1.09 and motion M 1.01 second discussion call the rooll Mr bartletta yes Mr banino yes Miss deetta yes Mr de Barry yes Mr de ombre yes Miss skeller yes Mr Lewis yes Mr Lions yes under policy Strauss Esme is a company we use to help update our policies and assure we are in compliance

066there are new numerous policies tonight that we will be updating to make sure we comply with regulations I would like to make a motion to postpone P 5111 policy P 5701 and policy p 9163 and I'd also like to make a motion to accept the recommendation of the Acting Superintendent to approve and adopt resolutions R 2.01 second discussion thank you uh and thank you for the very productive meeting we had the other day in governance I went through the manual the policy manual and I presented my questions uh to the board some of them include uh issues with Essa the every student succeeds act funding and if I can ask our ba um some questions related to that under under Essa funding are we still receiving funds and under what titles are we still getting

067the funds yes we currently are receiving funds we receive under Title One title two three and four okay and there's very specific guidelines to when those funds need to be spent and I assume all that is being worked out so we're not going to lose any of those funding that is correct our order does display that we have metal requirements very good one other question uh we have the parent and family engagement it says the district will comply with the requirements as outlined in policy 24154 title one districtwide parent and family engagement in policy can you is this still something that's active or we're still working on that as a part of our program yes we are current with that our director of um curriculum and education Miss lot will handle those meetings and she

068does um prepare the agenda and it is taking place thank you very much that answer my questions thank you any other discussion call the rooll Mr bartletta yes Mr Bolino yes Miss deetta yes Mr Barry yes Mr debre yes Miss Geller yes Mr Lewis yes Mr lies yes education committee curriculum hi good evening all uh we had the education committee had its first meeting of the year I would like to thank you everybody who participated also I would like to motion to accept the recommendations of the Acting Superintendent to approve and adopt uh resolution R 3.01 and R 3.02 this has to do with field trips we have two high school trips coming up and one uh field trip for Clarington and also approval of the curriculum for English 11 British literature second discussion call

069the rooll Mr bartletta yes Mr banino yes Miss deetta yes yes Mr Barry yes Mr dbre yes Miss Geller yes Mr Lewis yes Mr Lions yes operations committee Finance so this month we had our committee meeting we were updated on projects that were ongoing in the district we had uh door Replacements at Huber Street were all completed prometheum boards were installed at Huber Street uh rexus system for computer storage was installed lighting project is still ongoing um we're in the process of changing out the old lights and adding LED lights which is going to uh be about 90% more efficient um at claran school uh promethium boards were installed lighting projects are go ongoing over there at milridge I'm sorry at Middle School and High School uh the gym floor and that's about it so

070I'd like to make a motion to accept the recommendation of the business administrative board secretary to approve and adopt resolution R 4.01 through r08 as described below second discussion call the rooll Mr bartletta yes Mr banino yes m deetta yes Mr Barry yes Mr dbre yes Miss skeller uh abstain from R 4.02 and R 4.03 and yes for the rest Mr Lewis yes Mr Lions yes and everything ex standing on 4.02 and 4.03 safety security buildings and grounds there was nothing nothing okay thank you the ad hoc committees um we had no meetings this month but meetings will be on the calendar for February as far as legislation um those meetings are several times a year I believe Grace you said in the spring is that correct yes okay so the legislation committee will meet

071in the spring um and no other meetings negotiations um there's nothing we just recently negotiated the supervisor's contract and the next negotiation will be the principles and when is that coming up in 2025 this year okay this year okay directors as well public forum General oh I'm sorry oh I didn't even see Athletics on here oh okay I'm sorry yep Paul yes so we had um a lot of students to see uh postseason honors for The Fall season uh to start off we could go with football AJ concepion First Team all division offense in concepion again all state group one second team Brandon Vega First Team all division defense Dan Casas second Team all division offense Marcus goldsack second Team all division offense Noah Santos second Team all division offense Josh masro Petro second Team

072all division Defense Joseph Pinto second Team all division defense Aiden uh Marano honorable mention all division dalan span palano honorable mention all division moving on to boy soccer Danny grov First Team all division forward Yousef abata First Team all division midfielder Jacob YY First Team all division Defender Lucas Rodriguez second Team all division midfielder Noah tuna second Team all division Defender and Paul Young honorable mention all division soccer girls um Jasmine Bradley First Team all division midfielder Gabriela trillo First Team all division Defender Eva Lucy second Team all division forward Julia poo second Team all division forward Kate apter second Team all division Defender Caitlyn Tusa honorable mention all division moving on to girls tennis Anika Anala first first team doubles all division Katerina sakado first team doubles all division DIA second team singles all

073division jellen beaston honorable mention all division tenzen chosen honorable mention all division moving on to our volleyball team uh the girls volleyball team who won ngjc national division uh they're a CO co- championship team uh Hudson County championship team and a section two group one championship team Sophia Guzman First Team all division Sophia Guzman third Team all state and Sophia Guzman First Team all state group one uh Olivia jasek First Team all division Olivia jck First Team all state group one AVN Torres First Team all division AVN Torres second Team all state group one Sarah Alo second Team all division Sarah Alo third Team all state group one Isabella Pablo second Team all division Angelina Fitzgerald honorable mention all Division and for the cross country boys Dominic Vargas First Team all division Yan Sherpa second

074Team all division Maxwell Donaldson George second Team all division caros aad second Team all division Andre delos Santos honorable mention all Division and finally cross country girls Anan bpai First Team all division Arya shra First Team all division Juliana Tango second Team all division elain Jen honorable mention all Division and Isabelle um honorable mention all division thank you thank you Paul now moving on to public forum nothing okay thank you uh board member comments I'd like to say a quick congratulations to all the athletes I mean it was a those are some especially our own Paul who made the list so thank you through the chair uh first of all I want to thank my fellow trustees and president for allowing me to sit up here because I'm getting new hearing aids and hopefully it'll

075be better I'll be able to hear everything all the important things everyone to say I asked the uh president the ba and the acting superintendant to provide a copy of the long range facilities plan and its volume is 10 pages it was last done in May of 20120 it's due every 5 years and our president said that she will be working on developing a committee to review this so we can have an update at one in time we have about 3 months left before this one is due uh when I met with the RBA about this there's several issues in here that they projected a lot of money was involved in that and none of those things came through they were expecting this huge growth in our population and needs for additional buildings or classrooms

076and stuff so it's very interesting to see what transpired and what has not and the monies that were tied into this that we did not need to spend so I'm looking forward to seeing what we do with our new longrange facility plan I thank you all for bringing this to to our attention thank you Jerry I just wanted to just if you can speak on Grace what is the protocol for developing the long-term facilities plan is that a committee that is established by the board or is that something that gets worked on internally how do how does that work excuse me it's normally it's developed in conjunction with the buildings and ground supervisor and our architect of record okay so we have to go out for an architect of record so that will be the

077first step in us doing it the next thing is we did receive notification from the state of New Jersey yesterday that they are revamping the entire long range facility platform so it's a major undertaking and more word more news would be coming out about it exactly when they have not given us specific deadline you know timelines so as of right right now even though it expires in May of 25 there is a possibility as which has been in the past there will probably be an extension on it okay because they're working on that but we are in the process this is basically the architect B&G myself that developed the plan along with the superintendent okay and then it's presented to the board that's correct to the committee to operations and finance committee for review and

078then it is brought to the entire board okay all right thank you for that explanation Grace and just in my comments I would like to say on behalf of the board congratulations to all of our athletes especially as Lance said our very own poll down there at the end huge accomplishments by the district athletically and also um would like to congratulate uh Susan red vanley on her retirement um on behalf of the board we wish you well on a personal note she taught all three of my children so she will be missed by the dietta family and we wish her well thank you anybody else uh I also want to congratulate the athletes and thank the coaches for putting all their time in to make our athletes who they are yes absolutely motion to adjourn

079motion second second third all in favor I I for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.