CorpusRecord 97363

Regular School Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Central Consolidated School District
Date
2025-01-22
Location
San Juan County, NM
Material
Transcript
Extent
25,869 words · about 144 min
Collected
2026-06-15

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] in for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] for [Music] I [Music] I for [Music] present unites pleas secretary e [Applause] [Music] are [Music] under [Music] grammarly now uses AI to help you write not just revise type a prompt and generate a persuasive mistake-free draft in seconds agenda are there any other [Music] modifications a [Music] problem or or can we just keep it on and she shows up she shows up she's she called she said she's not going to be all right not available are there any other modifications Corrections make a motion to accept the agenda as amended do I have a second I vote board member Montoya yes board member so yes secretary Wells yes vice president aspas yes and I vote Yes five to approve the modified agenda F we move to

002Board of Education elections of officers any motions I make a motion that I make a motion that we reelect uh Sayes that hasy as president of the board I second any other nominations okay close we still have to vote okay it's been motion it's been second okay vote um board member Montoya yes four member so yes secretary Wells yes president aspas yes and I vote Yes I uh vote um I motion um Mr Wells for vice president do I have a second make a Amendment here most if possible you consider just keeping the board the same position is the same would you accept that yeah I'm I'm going to second the motion to have Mr Wells be vice president I made the motion consideration for then the consideration for Amendment and I second consideration so

003how does that work I made my motion secretary it's up to you if you accept that that change I mean you did make the motion so we're trying to keep the order of okay that's fine well that's where I I that's fine I'll retract okay yes it's open for nominations and I motion for secretary Wells for vice president and it was second by and I second a motion by board member so any other nominations is is that no I I'll retract it oh I was wondering if that's sry the same that's right then we vote yep okay board member are there any more nominations no orless you have one no okay okay close for vice president um we'll start with board member Montoya yes board member so yes um board member Mr Wells yes board

004member um Miss aspis yes and and I vote Yes open nominations for secretary I nominate um board member so I nominate Gary matya I respectfully C do you accept I'll second the nomination commissioner S I accept Okay um are there any other nominations vote um close nominations we will vote U board member Montoya yes board member so yes board member Wells yes board member aspis no and I vote yes thank you all right we move on to or do we have to do okay all right we move on to number two student staff and Community recognition letter A the milin educator award recognition to rinda uh [Applause] Billy don't be s I'm not shy if you guys know me um so good evening president hasy members of the board superintendent Carlson it is my privilege

005and my honor to announce to you our 2425 milin educator of the year for New Mexico Miss rinda Billy [Applause] and I do have information for the board on the milkin that I'd like to share with each of you so um I know when I first received this award I was very nervous um I didn't really get to thank the people who in I guess would help me get this award um I don't think uh this would have been possible without my co-workers my students my fellow teachers and my family um believe it or not my very first year I was put on a professional growth plan and I knew from there I was like I need to change what I'm doing in the classroom so I researched I worked with my colleagues who taught

006me their strategies like what was effective what wasn't effective I talked with my students asking them what don't you understand you guys need to tell me so I can figure out how to help you and um throughout the years I've seen so much change in myself I recently went back to school to get my Master's Degree because I knew that I wanted to make a bigger change within my school and I think that I have um this just shows that all my hard work and effort was finally recognized and I'm so honored that I was um a recipient for this award so just thank you to Mr bushy my principal who has been my principal for the past 10 years my mom who's always shown her support um and I wish some of my colleagues

007were here but unfortunately they're not but just to them as well thank [Applause] you comment yes go ahead uh I must say I when we showed up had no idea what other than the award but it just blew me away the fact that her response to that the total surprise and quite frankly my humble opinion you know there it shows the passion desire and commitment that you have for your students and that you've been able to pass that on to for the past 10 years and as I told you um when I got just a minute with you that to try to extend that courtesy that you have with that passion desire and commitment to the rest of your colleagues because one of the things that you just said that you asked your students I

008know a couple of other teachers that do the same thing because I've heard it being said that you teach the way they learn they teach down to them teach the way they learn you meet them where they are uh and to me that's just so powerful to be able to do that and then utilizing the instruction like you like you you didn't say it but it seems that that's how you apply your education to the students so for that I am truly truly thankful and grateful and congratulations any other comments I I extend that that gratitude to you also and to know that where you be you started and and to to see all the progress and to where you're at and our kids benefit from it so I really wholeheartedly thank you for doing

009that for our students and for our community thank [Applause] you bil um I don't know if you want to come up and um is there any more anything else the district could do to um you know to to model what you've been doing or um I'm sure Mr deswood has some ideas or I don't know but um you know it's it's always good that our our people get rewards you know especially at that level and um and you know the um what what we're facing with funding you know I know it's not easy to be a teacher and a lot of it comes out of pocket and so I I think um you know you really um you really outdid yourself you know and and um and and not that I wish that you know

010teachers seek other sources of funding but you know with the impacts that the district has has gone through in the past year years and you know we we you know it certainly helps and um and I I just want to say thank you and and if if there's some things that others can model and um other teachers you know um you know please let us know thank you Hi can congratulated you was there and took the opportunity to congratulate you then but uh uh to have the caliber in our district uh that you represent we uh we feel very grateful and uh um recognize your efforts and your diligence and and the fact that you receive this award is uh we'll steal a little of that and and spread it throughout the district thank you

011very much and congratulations thank you okay can I and add one more yes you did say something Miss Billy um the other day when you received award and the one strategy that you had stated I'm a very very firm believer and I wish we would do even more of it which is looping it is a very very powerful tool when used and just as an aside I had a conversation with a former super tenant we were having that conversation about looping and he says well I disagree I said why because what if you have a bad teacher and I looked at him and I pointed at him and I said it's your job to make sure we don't have any bad teachers and again that's a testament to you to accept that responsibility to be

012able to do that and then learn from it grow from it and because I've seen people do it for three years in a row and it is a very very powerful tool and strategy for our kids because to me there's there's really no negative to it you get to learn the kids you learn the parents they learn you they respond you better from year to year and the amount of growth that you can get out of them is huge so to that looking at the superintendent we've had this conversation before as a consideration thank you thank you any other comments all right president hasy members of board superintendent Carlson um real quick Renda Billy will also be recognized at the state capital next Monday uh she will be on the house floor with all the

013representatives there earning recognition down on the floor with uh with all the legislation going on this week and the following so um and then in April I'm not too sure we clear on the on the date no no date yet but she will be traveling to Los Angeles to receive the award with the other national uh milk and educator award recipients so that's all we wanted great glad we got you first Y and and just don't leave so what are we doing to um um promote her um advertise her because I mean right now I think that's what the district needs is is um how to keep our students how to attract more students and um so I'm just wondering how you know I hope that's in the plan superintendent so thank you on the

014website so for that's that's a very good statement that you made there because again um to show the rest of not just the count state that we have one of the top teachers in the country in our district our school district and and again an attestment to the power of the individual with that passion desire and commitment to be able to spread that to our kids so you're absolutely right in this ospice in the respects to say that and absolutely support the fact that if whatever we can do as a board or as a school district to certainly help her and and the district itself to democracy action all right we will move on to if there aren't any other comments we'll move down to um letter B national board certified teachers by Mr Noble

015thank you president hasy members of the board superintendent Carlson and guests who are are here today um it is with great pride and joy to recognize four outstanding Educators who have recently achieved one of the highest honors in the field of Education I am pleased to announce the following Educators from our district who have recently became national board certified teachers if you could please stand when I say your name uh Miss Ramona lero is actually online virtually she is from uh Kirtland Central High School if we can give her a round of applause Mr Carl Shuan from Kurland Central High School Miss Alicia wheeler from Kirtland middle school and Miss Isabelle Ardon from Nukem Elementary [Applause] scho these teachers have worked diligently to meet the Relentless standards of the national board for professional teaching standard

016standards there are over 125,000 national board certified teachers in the United States making it approximately 3% to 4% of us teachers who have become nationally board certified earning national board certification is like earning a master's degree and just take a little bit step further to get that national board certification they show how students learn how they create supportive classroom environments and how they contribute to the profession at the school level we explained to students um that they're like Elite teachers in their school buildings they're like the LeBron James of teaching in their buildings Michael Jordan excuse [Laughter] me excellent correction shame shame on you again these are students we're talking to sir EXC these teachers in the eyes of the N of the nation are the MVPs of education so when you next time see

017a national board certified teacher in your school building that's when you shout MVP MVP achieving national board certification is no easy feat and is a testament to our educational educator skills passion and unwavering commitment to providing the highest quality education to their students so please join me again in congratulating Ramona Lucero Carl Shuan Alicia wheeler and Isabelle Ardon for this remarkable [Applause] achievement great common yes go ahead to the four of you congratulations um again that's one of those things where you didn't have to you want to self-improvement not just for you but for the students that come in front of you so to that I applaud you and commend you for your efforts and your success so congratulations who are the four are there are there some here there are some here we have

018three we have Carl again sh on in the back Miss Isabelle arado they're all on this side um please stand and remain standing get pictures I can get some pictures yes of course could they please stand and remain so we can get to know and there they are again thank you so much for for what you do and um hopefully the board learns through your examples I'm sure it's not streamlined or um given low priority so thank you uh the fourth person is the fourth person here or not online thank you [Applause] [Music] online well Tanya is passing gifts uh to our national board certified teachers uh again SF has come out to celebrate with everyone so they prepare desserts and snacks again to celebrate so feel free to take as many as you want

019back home okay you definitely earned it with all the late night work you probably did and the rigorous assessments so um but again and Kevin uh fukes is our food service manager so feel free he's planning meals and and getting meals to your students in your school buildings well so feel free to meet him and talk to them and he's got great ideas and a lot of things going on in food service so um again congratulations [Applause] okay is there anything else Jared no thank you madam president okay number three comments from the audience a are there any comments from the audience yes would you sorry um I am so happy that Mr bushy is here because my comment has to do with him so I worked for him last year um as a reading

020interventionist and that position um I knew because of funding was not going to be renewed um and that was the only reason that I looked for another job um I just found it very interesting that I was able to finish my national boards and Renda also works for him so um I just felt very supported when I worked for you and um I think your staff feels the same way so I just wanted to make sure that you knew that you are very um we just feel very supported in this community by you so thank you very much that's great any other comments appreciate appreciate all all of you all the support I I you know this is why we're here it's for you working with our kids so a lot of appreciation to all

021of you you guys make everything happen so thank you um number four board and superintendent reports a board member reports are there any reports yes I have a go ahead so the um during the or just before the winter break we had um the naval shoe game and um it it went really well and it was explained and and I I never thought that I would see teenagers actually enjoying you know the the the whole um the shoe game when it doesn't involve your phone or your um TV or things like that you know you you kind of Wonder but and and it was attended by uh Alfreda and uh Donovan Russell and the Ico and oh my gosh I wish I had gone there earlier you know because they had a they had barbecue

022and all that and but um I I just really appreciate their efforts in that and putting something like that and um and and I missed out on the um the winter drum I don't know if I seen that right drums winter and um I missed out on that and um I wish I had attended but um you know I just just um um events like that being put on by Ico it's really um I was I was really surprised on the response I got you know through social media um I had posted it and and um you know just really surprise and and I'm glad that um we're doing so with with our students and and um because you know I I think that really um um that's the real teaching of um our culture

023and our traditions and so I I just really want to say thank you arreda and um Donovan you know that um you guys take the time to put those things on and and as I mentioned before you know I I seen um those particular students out in Palm Springs and um in here uh Donovan was trailing after them with the backpack and and then he puts it down and I was just watching from afar and and here he's taking out all these snacks just like a mom you know like a a parent and and giving it to the students and I just thought that was neat I wish I had taken a picture but um yeah they're they're well taken care of and and and um and this day and age is it's so great

024you know to see them take that for Alfreda and Donovan you know that there used to be that Latin phrase called parentis Loco or whatever and um and Mr Manning he will always tell me oh that's not not no more we don't go by that no more but you know I I see it displayed and and um with the awards with everything that the events going on I just think that's great thank you any other reports and I like to second that I was at the winter drums and that was a really amazing event I wish I had scheduled out my whole evening for that it would have it would have been something that I I wish I could have stayed for the whole duration but it was really it was a really nice event

025um bringing the whole Community together and there was dancing and it was just really um a real nice event with um vendors not vendors um the the nck college n all the different Community uh resources were there so it was wonderful so I like Miss aspis I commend you commend Ico for doing all that stuff it's it's it shows in our community the out the the people showing up coming to our events it really shows so thank you uh yeah the only comment that I got so far is I I actually listen listen in to the LFC or the LC meeting today so one of the budget proposals as before the the state is that they're looking at raising teacher educator pay level one up to 55,000 65 for level two and 75 for level

026uh level three so that that's all I got to report at the moment but those looks looks like some pretty good numbers yeah okay thank you any other reports no okay uh superintendent thank you board president ask youly just a a few things um these are all kind of one-offs I'll do them pretty quickly some Good and Bad and the Ugly first I'd like to again congratulate those national board certified teachers that really is a special achievement and and I wish we had more and throughout the district we have 11 teachers who are national board certified teachers um and we have something like 600 teachers somebody can correct me if I'm wrong that's a small fraction and the reason is such a small fraction is very difficult to achieve it's not something you just do

027overnight it was said that it's something kind of akin to like a master's degree the good news is the public education department does pay for that and so those of you who are thinking about it those of you who are listening in and and other teachers uh administrators you want to talk to your teachers let them know that I mean it's something you can get every year you're teaching um and it's close to $10,000 right now so it's it's a it's a pretty good little chunk however you do need to I think it's after every four years is it or five years you need to go back in and do a bunch of things to make sure you keep with it and so it's not easy um but it's it's worth it if you can

028do it so congratulations and also congratulations to miss Billy I was there uh for the presentation what a an awesome time that was for those folks who could could see that and and great job Mr bushy um I don't want to give you too many accolades because you're already kind of beaming back [Laughter] there yeah anyway no it really was a great event and and I know that the board members Mr Montoya Mr Wells were there really appreciated it and and it pretty sure it was a surprise and and that was kind of the neatest part of it because uh if you've seen pictures if you haven't seen pictures we'll make sure that they are posted in videos U Miss Miss Billy she beans when she smiles and she has such a beautiful smile and

029and to see that in the in the papers and everything it was just it's awesome we need to do more teacher recognition in this district and and somebody write that down because I want to be held to that we need more teacher recognition so just a couple couple items again like I said they're kind of good bad and and hopefully not ugly but perhaps um the first one the good one is we have completed mostly the move back to Shiprock administrative offices and most people know that but in the audience not everybody does we had a flood in September is late o late August beginning September um and and so most of the folks in central office here were displaced for several months and they did a great job um you know people talk about

030they need this Workstation or that workstation we had a flood within the next couple days operations were normal in completely different places matter of fact probably the next day um but it is good to have an office where you can go back to so we are now mostly back in our offices there's a couple more things that are outstanding uh for instance the track behind Sao they still are going to do some work on that um and a couple other Loose Ends they need to fix up but for the most part finally that that drama is over um speaking of drama we also o had something happen oh gosh several weeks ago um and I've been asked to kind of talk about it just a real little bit um we we use power school we

031utilize power school for a lot of our student data and and staff and parent data U there was a data breach that they experienced that affected schools throughout the country um and so we put some things out about that and so folks know that um some of that that data was accessed and and I don't know exactly what I'm supposed to say about it but um it wasn't so much um a ransomware attack but there there were some there's there's some payments involved in order to stop what was happening um if we get more information about specific folks who are impacted we'll make sure you're aware of that and we'll send that out further um we apologize for that happening um we wish that kind of stuff didn't happen in our world today but it

032did and and it does affect people um and and the third thing I do want to talk about I appreciate Mr so bringing up the legislature today was the first day they began at noon um and and I want to say something about our legislators and and what goes on in Santa Fe when when you're there and we're talking about education you have a couple different committees that advise our legislators one is the the legislative finance committee the LFC one's the LEC legis legislative education study committee those are comprised of of folks on the that are blue and red some of on the left and on the right in our state you can barely tell the difference when they're talking about education because right now our state has money flowing in from oil and gas

033and those the legislators are actually utilizing that money for good purposes especially for Education um and so is the governor so what I'd like to do just real quick is is highlight some of the things um that are happening real just real quick um for those of you listen to my weekly addresses I did mention some real specific things but this is just kind of in general um from the governor's office this is from this is executive recommendation um $14 million for training Elementary Educators in the science of reading I know not everybody knows what that means I know one of our board members knows exactly what that means and may not be for the specific use of that money the way it is um but but the idea behind it he would be definitely

034for it can I correct sir what's that can I correct you yes go ahead it's not that I'm against them using that money it's the program that they're utilizing to Institute that yes with that money that's that's kind of what I meant to say I I I understand I I mean to be negative about it you're it's nice to have someone informed and we have five folks who do their best to stay informed so that's great um but there's a few more $5 million to expand structured literacy professional development into secondary schools $30 million to support a second year of summer reading Intervention Program that summer reading intervention program uh there's some data that's come out I don't have it here in front of me that has shown that instead of having a reading loss

035those kids who were in that summer Intervention Program actually made some gains so that it's awesome that we're actually having kids in those programs in the summer um $1 million from the grro fund for targeted attendance Improvement interventions any of you who know administrators out here administrators can all tell you attendance has been a huge huge issue in our district in our State and in our nation um especially since Co and and there's a lot of reasons for it I don't need to get into that because that's not what this is about but we we haven't been getting the funding for doing anything about attendance and so this is a stab hopefully at saying here we're going to actually put our money where our mouth is and do something to help you with attendance and

036and I don't know what that's going to look like but that's that's what they're asking for uh 15 million for out of school learning summer enrichment and tutoring again the tutoring programs we have in in this district and in the State uh they're they're helping students and we need to continue those especially because um they're they're much more teachers can work maybe not oneon-one but in small groups in those tutting programs so they're very effective and also $10 million for for dual credit one last thing you know I'm kind of going over what I usually do um but I want to say something about since we have the school board right here these folks all belong to the New Mexico school boards Association ation and the school boards Association also has a platform um the

037mission of the New Mexico school boards Association as an advocate for public education is to provide leadership and services that enable local Boards of Education to govern effectively there's three guiding principles and so these folks are always going to be asking for these things when they see legislation the first one is local control they we don't want to be mandated how many days how many hours how many exactly all those kinds of things this is your curriculum exactly um that should be something that there's a certain amount of local control for and that's what these school board members are asking for um adequate funding right now we're getting adequate funding for schools but is a targeted in the right places one of the things I'm not going to read it but one of the things

038they mention is the Martinez yai or we usually say yai Martinez up here um court order um funds were supposed to be appropriate specifically for that and and we're hoping to hold them to that a little bit more this year and the last one is unfunded mandates they don't want to see unfunded mandates which tend to happen say you have to have this kind of program but we're not going to give any dollars for it and so those are those are the three guiding principles behind the nmsba and so I look forward to seeing the rest of the legislative session I hope you all want to pay attention if you have anything that you want us to go to them about or or you want to talk to your school board about up um they

039will be going to Santa Fe in February in just a few weeks um and so talk to them and and talk to me about things because sometimes we may not see everything that needs to happen so thank you okay um may I ask a question yes ma'am on your on your cyber issue um can you explain the extent I believe um Social Security numbers I'm going to phone a friend because I'm going to phone a friend if if you don't mind I have Mr venturina who's been working closely um and we have a team I know Mr red bden was here earlier I don't know if he's still here but um he also has a little bit more information than I know but go ahead and ask those questions Mr venturin would you mind standing

040up and go to the podium that way I won't misspeak the Social Security the addresses of parents and students um so luckily in our um I think it was two years that we've been not collecting Social Security uh we've been using uh what we call the State student ID which is a similar n digigit that our state um plays our students um so that's a good thing thing um but however in the past we already collected some of those and um there are there are individuals I I don't I I just want to know that how are they um dealing with you know right um taking that information and um um is if anything I think there was a mber 28th email and then later on there was another recent email and so I'm wondering

041um because that's pretty severe I mean if if they're taking or if um Social Security numbers are involved so I'm I'm just wondering since then have they um had any um like issues that came up and yeah from the parent and from the students and and then you know we're talking about cyber hacking and Cyber attack but um we're not really telling the full story to to parents and and I think it's it's it's necessary that we let them know that it involves Social Security numbers and addresses of of the children yes um as I said and Mr Carson also explained um some of the details that are um sent out or given to us um we we have no um basically more information rather than having you know some of the social securities or

042addresses has been um accessed by those people and um the only thing that we can you know um recommend the public is to be um Vigilant if there are say for example something is unusual with with with their Banks or in things like that um our state ped it it Department as well as Power School um it folks has been have been communicating and actually there is a process if um they're giving free services like um uh Social Security cyber um like support in case there are um um Social Securities has been compromised but um so far and Jared ketes um because he gets all the calls from our parents and Community um luckily um I and I don't want to make an assumption but um so far New Mexico has been the least severed

043um affected by by this cyber security um we have a like a community in power school that had been talking and most of the um more s here is in the midwest Ohio um Indiana New Jersey um those states have been have been affected um more than than we are here in New Mexico okay and and that's another thing to add is that it's National correct so do we know if that those um social security number things like that were shared were leaked yeah um so the the the last information that we had from power school is that um according to the communication is that they whoever that person or those group um basically deleted all the things that they have acquired from power school and and that's the reason why um I think they

044have mitigated the severity and the seress of what happened in December up to the second week of of January so again the the most important thing is to be really looking out what is the the activity in in Social Security if if um if something is not usual and I went through my email and um and I noticed an invoice of 600 and something dollars that I shared with Sharon and I don't know if our email has been hacked too um apparently I don't know um we're going to have to find out through Finance if if if that money was taken or you know that balance um I called a 800 number on that invoice and didn't lead to anywhere so you did receive something like unusual and so um um it didn't it didn't

045name me specifically it just the um email address and so I shared it with Sharon okay and one thing is don't put any information if you receive those are the fishing emails um our our Google supervisor administrator has been very active proactive in catching those fishing emails by far all right welcome go ahead you said that uh the e or the social security numbers that the district had collected before have been deleted and replaced by by another number so that if somebody hacks it again they're not going to get access to Social Security number yes sir um yeah so the the state the state the nine digigit state ID is our reference number for all our our students um since 20 I think 2022 but those before that and if they have access it um

046there are potentials that they have they can be used um in other ways but again based on what we got from Power School um whoever did it had deleted all the information that have acquired from power school so going forward we're covered then yes sir thank you thank any other questions comments thank you thank you thank you Mr okay all right number five aess mid report and introduced a new account manager by Mr f cheral good evening good evening president husy vice president as and board members I'm not vice president oh I'm sorry byee we're just members okay board members I'm sorry so I like to say hello everybody I'm Rose Co James but just Rose for short I know my name's really long but in the presentation as well just Rose this why but

047um like to introduce myself um R again R py but Rose I'll be your news accounts manager for this district and um to the left of me I have my regional manager Lorie Shannon and then to the right of me I have my other boss here J Cheryl and I'm not sure if you guys are familiar what we do with with ESS I've been getting a lot of questions about what we do and of course um we provide substitutes for the districts for custodial F service teachers cl8 do that for you guys and I thank you I want to say I wouldn't be here without you guys without ESS here and again I would like to introduce myself in Navajo of course I'm from a community and I have to do that and I'm from

048Burnham if you guys didn't know that so um it's just right off the by new so I'm I grew up in central Consolidated School District so it's awesome to be back I I really did really want to come back to the school district that's part of me class of 2015 I know I'm young I know I'm it's really different to be in this district and to be in this position and I I've met superintendent um Carlson first while I was here so I had my little little desk right there my little laptop everything but now and then now I'm back at the office so if anything if you guys have any questions please reach out and um we also prepared a few items to give an update on the program so I think we went

049through this slide if we can get to the next slide so really excited well wanted one thing that we really wanted to highlight here is um the the district had a lot of had some extra positions last year and so we we actually have less positions this year than last year because there was some pullback with asra funding Etc so one thing we wanted to highlight this we able to increase the fill rate but we U but the district as a whole did a great job at managing those absences and having fewer absences over over prior year which actually has led to a cost savings for Central Consolidated we built over $400,000 less um this part of the half year than prior year this of fewer absen and this just shows you like on a

050real high level the absences that we're filling for you for the last 12 months um and you can see that've been trending down with the changes that we've had with those so just some quick highlights we've hired 888 um individuals since July 1st to work in our sub pool we currently have over 200 substitutes in our substitute pool in addition to Rose we've also added an additional position in gal mckenley that is also helping she's still being onboarding I think she's on day six day seven so she's still getting um onboarded and she'll be helping support Rose to um you know building out our team to have a little bit more support in this area of of New Mexico um on in the last six months the our the substitutes required 85% have been Native

051American and one thing that was really important is our we've really worked with Tanya's office and Linda on our compliance training with our substitutes to assure that our substitutes have all that same training that the District employees do to really have good training and good thing better things happen when you have training than when you don't have training so we really um want to highlight that work that we've been doing the HR we've had 183 long-term positions that we've filled in this last six months and um 24 of our substitutes and this is kind of an honor that we have the district liked so much that they took them away from us and now we have to go back and recruit but the good news is that they are good quality individuals that the district

052wants to hire and fill those vacant positions so good thing for you that's what we're handing off to the but now we have to get back to work and and find some more of those individual 25 now 25 25 I about that um T that actually took one of our subs so they're employ permanent employ with them but so they on and one of our substitutes was was one employee of the month of November Quin quelin mandito is a precipitant of a $100 GrubHub card for November for employee of the month so as ESS we do all our substitute especially for my district so they our last raffle was a TV so all our subs are all automatic with that one so um quinland was for November December was another District so we kind of

053missed out on my B I'm still and um we've shared some of this in in the board before but you know we do we love payroll so much we do it 52 times a year on every Friday um that's important for our employees and some part of some you know benefit that they like we offer Health Vision Dental life insurance of 401k with the company match um we do incentives we have a referral program so our audience members are listening here if you know someone that be great in the schools you're welcome to go to refer.com and re and refer someone we'll pay you a $100 for successful referral one thing that I'm excited to report on the last year we've been really working on giving opportunities to our substitutes for education and so two

054things we've added is one is a stem certificate and so we worked with the it's a recognized um certificate I think it was like $600 we worked with them to lower the price then yes this is paying half so for about $150 a substitute can get a send certification um with us with with our program that we've set up and then more recently we have um we partnered with gr Canyon University to provide discounted opportunities for bachelor's degrees master's degrees for all of our substitutes and corporate employees and so we're really excited to be able to provide that for for our individuals we have a discounted program on our ESS Marketplace um and you know I think we mentioned before we have all of our substitutes can receive New Mexico paid sick leave as substitutes

055and we started this a couple years ago but we're planning we don't have a date yet but we're planning our appreciation event for our substitutes and so when we get that date we'll let the board know that you're welcome to attend weite the substitutes out foration do you want to talk you're doing the recruiting I'm not so you want to talk about the recruiting on this one so our recruiting from what I've been told was that we've gone to the schools we've gone Flyers to backpack Flyers to the students we try to recruit parents and also social media and as well as I try to um I'm really involved with the um First Responders so I've been reaching out the local Navin Nation fire department they've been telling me all the jobs and even if

056um they want to recruit for me um I'm really big on the community as well like um CH I go to chapter houses of course I grew up there working so now with M being back in the office I'm trying to get all the referrals out so I really urge to the audience even online parents um please if you guys want food the kids need to eat if you guys want to apply to Food Service we need that and well as substituting and I really want to stress that you come as far as as they are not you come and not out I want to urge parents and community members to please apply because that's where we're going to need more of that because they're way out there and I'll try to right now I'm

057kind of getting all myself being back in office now because we've had recent um accounts managers that weren't really kind of reaching out so that's my job now is to reach more out and because I smile no matter where you see me I'm smiling W even if you're walking by me I'm just going to be like this and yeah so I'm going to work on that that's one of my one of my top priorities here is from bring more recruiting you'll see more in my face I go do school visits this morning I went to nsh newom um elementary middle and high school as well as I went to school there so I got to meet a lot of my old teachers again I've hired a lot of my old teachers they're currently and I

058do have one teacher that's there for a long term so I like to see we're doing good so want to thank you for your partnership and the honor it is to work with you and provide a substitute teacher when the licensed teacher is not able to be in that classroom and we're here if you have any questions are there any questions comments I have a question well I I don't know specifically but um I continue to hear issues the ESS and um and one of the big ones is the pay and apparently you um have another party that that I don't know if you guys pay into it and they pay the employees directly or you I don't know some type of chain we have a partner so since we do um we specialize on

059the on on substitutes right so we do partner with a a company called paychecks that helps us with to process the the payroll every week as we mentioned right so two weeks in re but we make payroll every single Friday and you know with that I know in the past when ESS was new I I know that they they had a a payroll problem you know and um and you know with the holidays especially you know certain people were expecting their check and and yet there was nothing so and and it and it seems like we um all that got ironed out but now it's I guess with your payche or the other our partner yeah our partners with us and so um um and then on top of that um how much to me

060it's concerning that we we continue to use ESS um somewhere we need to have um and I hope they're not in core classes and and um do we have the means um um I know our funding our budget's not very stable but do we have the means to um I guess I look at it and compare it to my work site you know you have people that are specialized welders electricians you know and and then they bring in um contractors so you know that that's the way I look at things and um and it's for less money and um you know those contractors the company doesn't need to pay for you know say or our cover RS or you know overtime or things like that and I equate that to to what's happening here and

061with the district so um are we trying to move away from or are we just really um involving them more and more if that's a question for me I would say it's been stable um with the amount we've used them used them for all of our sub needs and that continues to be the process currently so the district has used us less this year than last year so uh at the tune of $400,000 L this year and to me I feel like some the reason why is I don't know what reason you gave but I think more it's uh because our our students our our student count has gone down well I think I think um I think it's based on a floater program that was that changed so there was a a district decision

062on a floater program that we were um Staffing that that Chang this school year so um yeah and and if we continue to utilize you know your services then you know that's one thing that's that really um that's the main thing I hear is is the pay yeah and and um please if you if you have a I know as a board member I'm sure you have community members to reach out to you if you have someone please have we have our contact information please have them contact us because we we want to make um it's very important for all of us that are up here that we pay our individuals the amount money that they're due when they're due right and if we um have a mistake we want to correct that immediately um

063to um to make them hold right so that's really important for us always right thank you comment yes go ahead superintendent how many years have we used I'm going to have to defer to somebody else um I mean I was a principal when they started I believe Mr so might have been on the board when they first began uh I I don't recall perhaps you know I do I'll stop talking we we started services in April of 2019 okay that's what I thought so my question would be do we have a cost benefit analysis of their services versus what we were doing and how we were doing it prior to that so when they were first hired that was done correct it was with Kyle last and that's something that could be done again I

064if that's something the board would would request Madam president I certainly would like a cost benefit announce done as to the uh considerations of savings and the investment thank you if you could add that to your list absolutely thank you any other comments okay and also is your dad Harry James he's my grandpa oh wow yeah I work with him he's a welder he's the reason why I'm here he taught me a lot so in that sense he's like shake hands with everybody don't be shy talk he and you catch I don't talk that of him because learn the English language so as that sense I that's what I'm here for and these guys were wanted somebody from this area because from what I've been told it's not nobody from the district or and even

065when he hired me I asked him questions I was like is this going on what are you going to do about this and I was literally in then interviewed for two three hours asking questions like okay this is an issue that I see when I was a student this is what I saw and and I didn't graduate from newcom or to Central School District I went away because there was no teachers they're my senior class so I went to Bloomville I graduated from Bloomville and that's the reason why I came back is because I saw a job opening as a Cil manager and I read all the descriptions and everything and I said yeah I can do this and my grandpa too because he's a welder um he was a boss he's this the main

066man manager guy so that sense he raised me he's like you got to think ahead this is what you got to think so when I asked got in his position and now that I've been here for two months no one not three months I've done a lot more than what um previous accounts managers have I've gone out to the community and now that I'm in office I'm telling s come here come there and as for the older Generations I get with paychecks all the generations are not technologically savvy which that is a problem but I tell them come to me if you cannot explain it to me in English come to me and explain to me now I understand I'll get you and I'll meet you there I'll meet you halfway and you know I

067I I voice this I advocate I'm I'm part of um the people that you know contact me and I um I I wish everything was going smoothly you know um but in the end the priority is the students and and then I I really appreciate you have firstand knowledge as being a student not too long ago and so I appreciate that um but as you know you know these um teachers and these um Educators um just like Miss Billy that was here and and some of the ones that were recognized you know they it it it's it's it's how their whole attitude is and that's the only way that our students are going to succeed and so if we have Subs that are coming in um you know um first of all they shouldn't come

068in with the attitude but you know how I mean let's be re realistic if your pay if things are not being um handled then they are going to come in like that yeah that's one of my concerns um like I know that many here so I understand their attitude and that was one of my concerns I was like okay this is what I need to do and have I been firm with a lot of my subs and I have reled all those those subs that were having giving problems to my teachers I said you guys this is not going to work even in my new hired account this is not going to work if you do not put the kids first respect the kids respect their teachers teachers are here to teach them you're going

069to give them respect they're going to give you respect treat people how you want to be treated and that's what I really emphasize in my interviews and to my Subs I'll tell them good morning how are you con actually sh him and even in person to everybody in the HR office I'm like good morning hello and I that's just how I am and of course I do understand the commun we're we're going to have attitude but I I really I really love my teachers growing up I love my teachers love my teachers and now I say that for my students I'm like okay respect them this Subs be there for your teachers you are there to help do not give attitudes if you're going to give attitude no this is not it this is not

070the price for this is the reason why we here this is the reason why I'm here is to make sure things go good for this school district and that's why I want to say thank you for the board members yeah I want to be here in this position with USS and as in the council man manager in this position thank you thank you can't just real quick what what in terms of numbers um how many ESS employees do you have right now working in central um actually 252 okay 252 all right thank you thank you thank you um letter c d SSA assessment information by Miss Lewis and staff good evening can everybody hear me yes okay I'm sorry I'm not there mece myself [Music] came CPS Late July started the principal and um just

071kind of backgr on me is that I am having an educational Feld for 35 years and going on to 18 years being an administrator um roles as a assistant professor as well two colleges and college and also University so and then my expertise is in fire safety um meaning I served as a volunteer fire Personnel for many years so that's who I am uh so I'm going to go ahead and present on the Desa uh Desa is the the acronym for Deo um I'm sorry uh assessment for students for um sou which is our social emotional learning program how thisa came to be is last year school year 23 24 uh the Eva B sple um leadership team uh came together of course with the staff I'm assuming uh they went through and looked at

072some areas of Improvement that Eva B Stokley needed one area of course others are academic but this was one area is having to do with uh student incidents we in in the data when I was looking at the data sets for Eva stokeley for student incidents um they had a baseline data of 40 45% student incidents and that's almost half the students having uh incidents rates meaning at of school suspension major or minor so when and I'm assuming this is what happened and because I do question the leadership team uh beginning of this year looking at that data from last year um 23 24 they implemented a program called Second Step which I'm familiar with I did use it at the former school I was at with my counselor um it is a really good

073program just so you know that I do have um knowledge of the second step with that second step program um the implementation began last year into this year so when I came on board um I'm new to public school so never been with a public school so everything is new to me I'm learning as I go along but one really neat thing um every school here has is a 90day plan so in that 90day plan which was developed for this year 24 2425 that one of the focused areas is in uh cell social social emotional learning and that curriculum is second step so having said that there are indicator dates that the team came up with so the beginning of this year this will be year two of the second step program uh being used

074in EA be stokeley coming into this year in their um 90day plan it did state that it does state that by September 2024 beginning of year Desa Second Step assessment is going to be completed so when I got here I went on a huge learning curve um I'm thankful to all the staff that are here they've been very helpful principles um Mr deswood thank you so much but having said that with that um I asked if the Desa was already uh ordered for the uh second step program which is the cell program when we look back at the time we had Mr Smith who was our financial secretary he indicated that he wasn't sure so just then change over happened Mr Smith left us to go to District so he's at district and of course

075he did come back to sist again we got a new Financial secretary and somehow the deatha was not ordered but it is in the 90day plan I want to reemphasize the 90day plan because that's the plan we go by uh what we're going to do by the end of the year or what our goals are smart goals so with that we ordered it finally um when our new Financial secretary came on board um it came in so for our beginning of the year that's assessment that didn't occur so we had to push our uh Desa assessment to middle of the year so now we are at middle of the Year we're trying to get all the data um together to make sure that we have uh it for the DAT for the Desa assessment so

076this assessment is going to give us an idea of um what the students needs are we all know that we we came off of the pandemic uh within the pandemic there are studies that show that um um students and not just students but um employees and parents people at at home they did go through traumatic experiences through the pandemic with the lockdowns you can't do this you can't do that and so there was a need everywhere Nationwide for some kind of social emotional learning curriculum and so that's what happened and so when we looked at the data set for this one um like I said for 5% student incident rate is very high um so coming to this year now we looked at the data again for middle of the year for our student incidents

077we are at 5% so the goal for December was to reduce decrease um the student incident rates by 10% from the Baseline data of 45% from last year so we surpassed that right now where we're sitting at 5% which is good um but we want to learn more about what impacted that we don't really have an assessment or something to tell us a data to tell us okay because of the Second Step implementation is that what lowered our student incident rate so Desa is going to give us an idea or give us some data sets to take a look at to see is this what did really did impact our students so having said that um there were some changes um that the staff wanted to make um you all know we have the Dual

078language program and with that program uh there's some uh requirements mandates so because of that some of the time limitations we have it turned into a class an actual class so miss penino our counselor is the one that's teaching the self in her classroom during counseling sessions so that's what's happening now at our school and so now we have good data meaning the incident rates have gone down drastically but now we need to take a look at the actual um the Desa oh thank you um so this is what it looks like right now we are in the um we haven't started the screening yet because we still need to train our um the individuals the teachers are going to be doing the assessment it's 60 second it takes 60 seconds a child to to

07960 seconds to a minute to two minutes I mean and so we're still going through some of the trainings we want to be able to take a look at the data sets to see if this is what um what data sets we're going to be taking a look at um so with this okay there it is um when we look at the deatha competencies there are certain areas that they look at um and when they did a study on this the the reduction in referrals for students came down to 39% reduction in school suspensions came down to the 39% and this is um their study on Nationwide of the use of the second step and then the Desa as the assessment tool and then 7 79% out of school suspension so um like I said

080earlier looking at the data with the staff the um student incidents have drastically come down and this is K through 5th 3K to uh fifth grade so I don't know if there's any questions regarding the Desa I'm not sure if I have any leadership team members I did um ask them to join I don't know if there's any [Music] online U bet the only question I have is do do you have an example of what this assessment looks like because right now I'm I'm trying to look online like what this looks like and how you actually assess students if that's what they if that's what the uh the intention is so um there is a an example and I can um share that with you so there's an examp example of one so there are

081questions like um and so these are social emotional skills for students and one of the some of the questions are like offer help to somebody NE so the answers would be never rarely occasionally frequently and very frequently and so teachers would be the ones to assess uh the students are they do they never do that or do they rarely do that so student they work with the students to see how they answer um and then I can email this to you and this is directly um in correlation to the second step program uh for the Desa assessment um so it like there's like about 26 questions for one and it is K through five for this one and I can send it to miss Ray and she can um maybe send it to you all

082uh the other part of the social emotional learning um is to help you know our children because of this non contact for so long um it seems like we're having I I know because um the other school I was at we had a lot of student um discipline issues um a lot of it having to to do with not being able to work in a group or sometimes being able to um you know share share their uh whatever tools they're going to use for learning it could be crayons it could be um a puzzle so those types of things we're having a lot of um disruption uh issues so for this one the students actually do get raided and the I think think I sent that one to you all there is an example of

083how so it will go when we after we do do the rating uh the Desa will break it down for us and it will tell us which areas our students need um skills in so if it's something having to do with sharing um then that's a skill that we need to teach them the other thing is e all the way down to um empathy you know do our students have empathy to help one another uh those are actual skills that we teach students because of the uh break and not being among uh each others the students so it's almost like relearning skills that they um maybe forgot when they were at just at home and now that we're all back in school fully and we're relearning some of these skills even though it's been a

084couple years now um so some of the competencies um are along the lines of the growth mindset goal setting do they know how to do uh goal setting uh we do set up goal goals for the students the teachers do that with the students uh which I'm really impressed by all the teachers do that the other one would be emotion management um we do have those students that are not able to self-regulate and so we have to actually teach them those skills uh so we're have we're going through some of those right now uh empathy and kindness and then problem solving so when you really think about these skill sets this not only um applies to as as them to as students but also as a child to their parent as a sibling to their

085siblings and then as they grow they're going to become teenagers they're going to go into the workplace and they're going to have to use these skills in the workplace so nowadays if you look at um companies organizations a lot of it is teamwork do our students and children know how to work in a team uh there's always that give and take you know my opinion matters your opinion matters but we have to meet in the middle and come to consensus with certain things uh you can't always have everything your way but that also is a skills to accept Okay I can accept this and I will use this whatever we're discussing or whatever goal we we're trying to get to we'll change it because it's going to work better if we do it this way

086so it's a lot of um skill teaching and it's really based on that second step uh curriculum that was implemented last year so I'm really really excited about the Second Step that that I know uh the Desa is kind of new to me the assessment piece but the second uh step program I have used at the other schools other questions for members any questions I have a question go ahead is um I don't know where to start Miss Lewis um you have different categories here um suspensions and and um it seems like um well at first I I thought of it as another um oh what was that toodles thing oh packs packs um that's what I was kind of thinking it was packs and um but it it sounds more more um if you

087had two minutes to explain your program can you explain it to me Miss Lewis 30 seconds yeah 30 seconds the second step or the the Desa Desa Desa okay so the Desa program that one is the assessment piece to the Second Step so you know how you have math um you have um Ure math you teach and then you assess it by giving a test to see how you what your students did this is the same thing second step is the curriculum the Desa is the assessment piece and so it gives us an idea gives us a picture of what our students need uh whether it's um sharing you know that's one of the skills um how to work in a group that's one of the skills how to have empathy do they have empathy

088and how do we do we need to teach the students those skills so it's it's you know it's two different pieces that go together um and earlier I was saying that I did use Second Step at the other school I was at it's a really good program curriculum the only piece I had never seen was the Desa part because we had to started implementation to at the other school but I seen second step it does work um and like I said earlier in the uh data um we are down to 5% student incident rate right now from 45% last year you know I'm not familiar with all the teachers in the district um are you CCSD teacher Miss Lewis yes you are I'm I'm sorry principal I'm principal for Eva B stokeley okay and um

089so how did I I I guess my my thinking with um all the mandates and what comes down the pipeline and then you have um the the upper chain of the organization um and then we have a principle in that chain that that's um wanting this curriculum or this um assessment um is and then then we hear later um well I'm I'm going to put it blank uh I'm just going to put it out there okay we are in January so um this is way after half of the School term and so how was this supposed to benefit other than um distracting um I don't want to use distracting uh teachers and you know for everybody to to to to um learn this um what you're putting out there and the students to to learn

090and um to me I feel like that's going to take time and then it's um it just throws things off um to me that's my opinion um had it been earlier in the semester or earlier in the in the school year I think maybe then it would have been good and um I may not be saying it well but you know those are my thoughts any other comments um yes I do I have some questions sure go ahead um kind of um going off of what Miss aspas is saying my my question superintendent is in in light of the the comment that was just made did the district do any research and I know she she was talking about second step and and this being a um this collects the data and evaluates is it

091directly in conjunction with or is this something separate from Second Step I'm going to go ahead and I I'll start the answer then I'll go ahead and allow the principal to finish up to my knowledge it sounds like it compliments and and just sort of evaluates the program that's already in place more of that more of an evaluation tool so it's part of Second Step it's the assessment for second step is that absolutely correct I don't know that it's a mandated as the second part of it but that's what it's being used for that's how it's being used yeah and and Miss Lewis jump in well before you go any further um how come you don't know superintendent uh this is something that was decided on by a staff and we do have we give

092them a certain amount of autonomy in terms of um the assessments and this was something that was supposed to according to Miss Lewis have like you mentioned the second semester you know why is this begin now it was supposed to begun in Fall to measure that particular program and how and its success and it's part of their 90day plan and so something that we approve of so so my question would be if I heard this correctly Miss Lis um this was already in the 90day plan nothing that was a construct of the 90day plan that the school put together this school year is that correct am I am I saying that correct yes you're correct um can I add that to that sure please with the um with this cell program it it's not the

093first year they're using the cell the Second Step um last year they started the second step 23 24 and so this is the second year of implementation so just kind of highlight to all of the board members and uh superintendent and U Mr deswood that the data does show there's a huge decrease in student incidents so this program um actually is um impacting the student incident portion so we were last year 23 24 they we were at 45% student incident rate that's how many of our that's almost half the student population that had some type of student incident or discipline um in their in their f file so when we look at the data this year uh as of December we're at 5% so the program itself and the implementation how that happened last year

094I don't know because um we don't really have any data on that other than the implementation so we said we really want to look at data set for this because we want to know if this is really impactful just like the way the data shows then it's something we need to continue and research shows that it does take three to five years to really so show a longitudinal um data announces to see if it's working or not so um it was already in the 90day plan it was started last year and I didn't want to change anything I did put it out there for the staff what do you all think um and uh this is what we went with so so again my question is really what you're what you're responding to is the

095second step and not actually the the uh de because you haven't even implemented the Desa correct we're going to implement it now but month you have not no we have not okay so at this point um you're responding again basically to Second Step and the data that you're pulling from second step and the reduction in in Behavior which quite frankly I appreciate that and my concern is in regards to Desa so in respects to the utilization of a program even an assessment program I asked the superintendent in respects to that uh knowing that when you start digging deep did the district data Department I know there's supposed to be a research Branch did they look into Desa and investigate it and read about it the POS and pros and cons of that because yes go

096ahead Mr Des good evening board members Mr Carlson colleagues principal Lewis staff anybody listening out there so this program was definitely uh came about because of the data right using data driven decisions last year the leader leip team and the principal decided that this program could help them identify uh and track their their incidents and how to decrease those incidents so this program like uh principal Lewis stated it was in their 90-day plan however on January 13th uh Mr venterina sent me and my department a uh email inquiring about if the program had been vetted yet which we just failed to follow the process for vetting the programs so a couple days yet later it was asked to be put on the board agenda so our department had not um reviewed the program yet however

097the previous day I had met with u Dr Mike at tup middle school and she was sharing very similar data with me that they were tracking in their school but they were using capturing kids hearts and she shared 21 points of data where students had improved as as far as student wellbeing uh self- advocacy how they feel in the classroom so then one of my questions to the to my team was are we collecting data like this already with capturing kids hearts or with packs and board member aspis is correct Pax does collect data like spleen counts but we do have some schools that don't like or some staff that don't like to do spleen counts uh so this is in response to a program where where kids can assess it assess where they are

098as far as um you know how they feel within the school um and like I said we just ski the process and to vet the program in a couple more days uh we would have approved the the program and of course like uh like like we've noticed you we dropped the ball and I'll I'll accept that responsibility from my department and we should have uh made sure that uh what was implemented in the 90-day plan was being carried out okay so having said that I appreciate the fact that you did that and you take that responsibility now I did my own little Deep dive in in this and one of the bigger concerns for me is that the information the data one who is it going to uh don't answer questions please I'm just I

099want to State some some things that I found and that it comes to a larger question because uh you're talking about aperture the company that actually implements and collects that data on a national schedu uh scale because they do their own um analysis uh of that data so as we spoke about not just Thursday but in Prior uh Schoolboard meetings about research being done and that's what they're doing is collecting research and utilizing that data to come up and help solve those issues and concerns has this organization gone just as we said in the last meeting to the naval Nation human research and review board to be able to utilize our students on the Navajo Nation and that information that they're collecting just had a conversation that began in this board meeting about data breach

100and again when you look deeper into their even their own website and about uh opt outs the ca Children online privacy protection acts parents have a right to revoke are we speaking directly to the parents is it in Navajo is in taglog is in Spanish uh are we bringing them aside and say you do not have to participate your child does not have to participate do they know and understand that their children under the ages of 13 protected by this law the co PPA law legally are not bound to give them any kind of information and if they do they're supposed to get rid of it immediately so it's those kinds of things is it culturally relevant are they taking those things into consideration when they look at these assessments and collecting that data that's

101that's kind of where I'm coming from in respect to that about the program who decided what kind of research was done the sign off by admin um once the assessment is completed where does the data go and then CU there's 40 questions on that on that assessment and some of the reviews that I read Because in New York that um it was 830 schools they went to to implement it and the Department of Education caught hell from parents because they thought it was an overreach and even some of the questions then the questions were from the parents are are the Educators asking these questions qualified even to ask the questions to make those kind of assumptions are those questions biased are their own opinions when they're being answered to are they putting their own bias

102into these into the response so to me because it wasn't Ved certainly not deep enough and again considering what we are and considering the nav Nations human um research and review board uh there's way too many questions out that I have and again um the opt out uh the lack of detail explanations um what about our our sped students on that the IEPs um are the parents going to have access to that data um again are the teachers really qualified so there's a lot I got page and a half I spent a lot of time looking that up and it's not because I'm not for but to missas this point we have packs and you alluded to that you you alluded to capturing Hearts um and I've talked about this before when we talking about

103issues and concerns and services that we have even just within the school district in it of itself you go on Community Schools they provide extra resources for support like family counseling access to Medical Services and getting food all of which directly impact a child's mental health we have social workers we have Master Level social workers we have counselors in the schools we have PS we have MH hmh we have Caring Hearts we have mtss all these things are built in to attend to some level of uh seal for our students PBIS the same thing positive behavior intervention supports um you know all of those things were stort of Justice down in those classrooms when you're when you're dealing with some of these issues like bullying and then one of the ones that the teachers were

104complaining about in New York was time consumption and they make it sound really nice and pretty 60 seconds you're done anybody that was trying to implement it in York will tell you it doesn't takes a lot more time than that um so to me there's a a lot more questions that have not been answered and it has not been vetted and and again with the positive Second Step that Miss Lewis was talking about the data they collected just from that program alone tells you there's been a reduction and again from what you were hearing from the principal at uh TBA and again those basic uh pragmatic collection of data that they have within that school is a much much quicker response and again the fear that I have is that data going to a third

105party in the naval Nation or the district didn't sign off in the allowance of these students data to be collected and gone somewhere else who knows where again got help us and or help them if they have a data breach so but anyways I know that was a bucket full and a half now but Madam president I have another go ahead um so with all that said um you know I I um I think a year ago two years ago I sat in on a um meeting and held here um um I think it was a j thing and um the one of the schools that came was one of the tribal bie schools and and I remember that superintendent getting up and saying that um when he became superintendent he really uh put his

106foot down on programs and making sure there there was no redundancy and um and with all that he I mean he really went in and and asked he he found that what was what was happening is um people would go off to conferences and they go to these Expos or these um sessions and then they um presented a whole new um something like this and then they come back and they bring it back and then it just sits there and and then for years and years he found all these these um material that um they were no longer using no longer um textbooks things you know related to those and um but he really cleaned cleaned up and and started asking the questions and then made it known a superintendent that he wanted no redundancy

107and and um and I believe in the um I I guess how they Mark or in the grading of his um school he he came he came out on top and and I think um and it takes somebody really bold in the spine you know to to say those things and and stick to it um you know for me um there's a lot that I still don't understand and and um but you know just seeing some of the titles here um I I I see I hear of and can't say which particular one but um I think these are have already been covered and um but um thank you for being honest and and um and I don't know where we go for go from here because I agree with um board member uh Montoya

108on on the fact that it has not been heard in front of Naval nation and um and I don't um as I said the last meeting you know if they give the yay or nay and um so I I I I don't know what what happens from here from this point on but um I feel like it's it's I don't know Madam president if I may go ahead go ahead uh in light of what Miss ASA said and again that Miss Lewis has stated that they've collected that data from that first year of implement a the first step and and they've seen a reduction in of itself and if it's just being the the Second Step being implemented there at EV and that's the only place that they're utilizing it well then let them collect

109that data and utilize that data and make those changes and adjustments uh I'm I'm of the opinion that we don't need to get a third- party assessment that has not had been that has not been vetted as Miss aspas said um Pro the Navajo nation's review processes to be able to do that with our students particularly on the reservation now I do know that in New York when they implemented that program they spent $18 million for three years I don't think we're paying that but you're talking about 800 plus schools so it it lessened the overall cost per School however and again I don't know what the cost was regarding what uh is occurring specifically for just Eva B but I I think we need to take a very serious look at this because again

110to what Miss Asus says to me I see this as a redundancy and a couple years ago we discussed that and it was said to the board that uh we're trying not to add more onto the plat of the teachers well guess what this does uh even though they're going to say well it's only twice a year extra work is extra work when we're trying to focus specifically on improving grades um and we already have processes in place to collect that data for seal again you have counselors in the buildings you have the teachers you have the social workers you have the cat team as well which I forgot to mention that another layer of uh redundancy uh to me is not helpful especially with these teachers and to these kids the students that we

111have in these buildings and I know it's just at that one however again um I think we need to reconsider my humble opinion thank you thank you I I'm some of the the concerns that I had were vocalized too in terms of all the programs that we have going concurrently in the district if we invest in one program I think it we should standardize it across the school district based on what the outcome the the supposed outcomes are supposed to be I think we're there's so many different ones could we get a listing of all the different programs that we have in our school district so we can actually look at that because even just from Mr desit speaking he mentioned this the Cyber is it cyber capturing capturing children's Hearts packs and the this

112stessa and then the others that Mr Montoya had mentioned so I would like to get a whole listing of all the different all the things that we have going in our school district I I think it's and and that was a concern that had been brought up before was people attending conferences and bringing those things back so that was really um and then to know that it has been vetted I those are just like some big concerns you have any yeah for me um how do I come go back I think for myself I'm I'm going to I'm generally supportive of of this type of program because the way I see it and the question questions that are being asked is about it goes back to some of the questions you really can't look at

113when it comes to student assessments and data and that's looking the other big picture about school culture School climate whether students feel safe whether they feel welcome all these are very valid data points in term in terms of trying to find out about what's going on evb still Beyond just the assessment and this is attempting to dig deeper with this type of assessment so I I really don't think there's much harm in trying to implement this program and as far as like trying to involve other people in decision making all that's already covered I think under our current policies I mean I I really don't think there's a need to I mean this is not a research project or study but this really is a tool inhouse that we're using at this particular school for

114this purposes is that correct that is correct so that like I said the leadership team came up with this program to help support their progress with social emotion learning to help students uh decrease their incidents so if the outcome is what you're trying to get at I'm just a little bit perplexed why why there's a lot of confusion so maybe I think if that was explained from the get-go but why this is here why this particular survey or this tool is been used that would probably clarify the confusion but for me I I do understand why this is needed so maybe uh I'm not sure if there's like a competing um study or or program that's in other schools but this sounds like this is what that this particular School chose to use for their

115purposes is that correct that is correct in fact that's what Mr alluded to like some of these decisions uh we do leave up to the principal and the team to come up with because if we were to get a program for everybody to do then we get pushed back from them but like I said with their 90day plan this was what the team thought would be best for their school Community okay thank you U may I so um with that said uh Mr desck the how many principles do we have 15 so if we have 15 great ideas we're going to have 15 different things yes and no uh like I said before we do have a process which was not in place two or three years ago which was why we had 60 or

11670 different programs so a couple years ago OB Mr venterina the dart department and our department came up with the process that schools are supposed to follow so we can vet the programs like I said in my questioning of the principal and their team was and my team was is this something we already do like I said I had heard the day before Dr Mike sharing her data that was the questions were very similar to the questions that are in this survey or this uh tool that's why I was saying and then that's part of the vetting process so that we don't have competing programs in fact Mr Carlson just sent us a hit high impact tutoring program I checked with my team to see if we already do this we already do with high

117dosis tutoring so we said we need to hold back on this because we don't want teachers doing multiple things so for the last couple of years we've really been trying to streamline the number of programs in fact we've lost programs because we don't have a lot of usage so we' really tried to cut down the number of programs that our schools are purchasing and I can guarantee you our schools are not going to professional development and saying hey this new thing we need to do it because we've really been focusing on supporting teachers supporting principales so that and you know like like we said good practices that are going on the school that's what we need to duplicate in our classrooms that are not as strong the um again I I I think the only

118thing I've heard was that you know it was um voted on by the staff U Miss Miss Lewis and and it's great that you know everybody has a say and um and not just something um you know we're going to do this and that's that but um um steal steal the Precedence and um what stops this and and then um I think we we're just really going to have to get a hold on these things because um um it's no different than things shoot we we just have like you know Santa Fe just started today and what next month what are we going to be deal dealing with and that's not even just Santa Fe but what what about nationally what are we going to be dealing with and so um you know I again

119I I hate to to to um be wasteful because there's already been time and commitment by Miss Lewis and and I you know don't want to um that's that's why I keep saying I don't know I don't know at this point because um you know somebody that goes up and and and goes puts in the work the time the effort um I I certainly don't want to squash that but um those you know those uh uh rules I guess or policies or whatever you know they're there for a reason thank you did you have anything else to include Miss Miss Lewis uh yes just one other just one other I guess piece of um uh think something to think about when we're looking at data sets one of the things that we always look at

120is our academic assessments so I me and my team were constantly uh talking about okay what are we doing what are our strength what is it we need to work on Need for improvement so when we were looking at the data sets for um our Ela which is part of our 90-day plan and also the um math which is also part of the um 90day plan one of the things that we found out um which also goes along the lines of um our Statewide testing Which is my Mesa and I Mesa I'm still getting used to that acronym so we found out that beginning of the year so think about this in Long along the lines that we were all children we all students at one time so if you're being bullied or harass you

121know pretend you're the student that impacts your learning or your want to learn right so when we look at data we also look at the academic data sets so beginning of the year to the middle of the year we increased our On Target students for reading from 15% to 28% which gave us an increase of 13% that is more than what our smart goal was set for we originally said by December this this December 2024 that our grade level 35 are going to get a 5% increase we surpassed that EB s third to fifth grade so that kind of gives you an idea that you know the cell part is also a huge um component of learning you know we need to make our students feel good and to motivate them and that's how they

122become motivated Learners they have that growth mindset and so you know just kind of food for thought for you all uh that the our scores are looking good you know even in the uh the math we had a 10% gain increase and our goal was 5% to December so just imagine we continue with this cell program and what kind of results we're going to get with academic side so I just wanted to kind of include that and kind of have you think about you know this we're talking about the whole tile not just the cell part but also the academic so that's kind of something I just wanted to end with thank you so much thank you comment go ahead Miss l or question I'm sorry um but again what you're talking about that you've

123captured is that second step but and you have not used Desa for the for the um assessment part of it to actually evaluate what you've collected what you've collected and what you expressed to us was just specifically for the Second Step implementation correct yes okay so really this Dessa at this point in time is irrelevant to what you've already done and that's why I say to me when you're utilizing that information that you've captured and I think I'm not going to put words in Moses's mouth I think the consideration is that locally where you're at that's where that information is being utilized and can make you can make those adjustments based off the data that you're collecting so my question is what's the point of the third party coming in and collecting and that data

124being utilized for their purpose rather than yours specifically because you've already put the data out there you have that you just presented that to us and again liken that to what Mr Des was saying about TBA and their principle and the data they've collected and utilized that's all done in house so just a question can I answer that question sure Madam chair go ahead yes okay thank you um thank you for that U Mr Montoya so this this second step program is um the assessment piece is the Desa part it's not another person that's going to come into our school and do the do the assessment it's us that are going to do and we're going to use it to see where our needs are for our students so if they don't feel safe then

125what are we going to do about that if they don't you know feel scared what are we going to do about that and so it's going to give us a better picture of which what each student needs so when we get the report the the results of the assessment piece then we look at that data set to see where our students need um Improvement or need help with those skill sets so that's what Desa is it's not you know somebody else coming in it's us we're going to be the one that's going to be implementing it just like we're doing it with the Second Step all I understand that and I respect that but again it's still a third party that's looking at that data and you just stated it that's what they're doing that

126information is going to them they're looking at it they're assessing it they're going to quantify what they've collected and report back to you and then again my question was initially at the beginning was so what do you do with it who provides the services if you have those extreme cases then who Sur as a child see so it's it's more than just asking questions getting an answer and saying okay well ABC and D go ahead Mr Des I just really quickly so the the question set is what they're getting access to for example like I was saying the 21 questions that Dr Mike was reading to me those questions were the questions that capturing kids hearts provides us to use so we can see where we can provide support for our students or teachers very

127similar Desa gives the assessment how was what are I hear 40 questions that the the kids and the staff take it gives them probably on a fiveo l scale maybe they have a a three on you know students don't feel safe with their teacher so then that data the principal can talk with the staff and say kids take or staff take a look at this when our students were assessed or given this assessment quiz 4 point or 3.2 3 point on of everybody that's that took this assessment they scored a 3.2 out of five what are we going to do to support this kid in raising that score for them feeling safe to share something with their with an adult not only that but what happens is some of those questions are tailored to say

128oh look our kids do feel safe coming to school so this program that they're that they want to use is giving the the set of questions that they can ask their kids otherwise it would be what is it called whenever we borrow something that that we don't have access or we didn't pay for right so that's what this program is about thank you thank you for the information I have another comment um or question um say we is is it possible that we could have a difference um of what pet assesses and and then this and then um are you able to give this uh Desa assessment to to pet and say no so one of the the Clearing Houses that our federal programs kind of follows is like the what what's work Clearing House

129which if you talk with our CSI principles in order for federal funds to buy these programs it does have to clear the what's work Clearing House Stacy danne do you remember the other programs and remember the other sites Desa is actually in the site as had approved because what that these sites do is they say that whenever they there's the studies out there they say whenever um schools use this particular program it leads to improve student outcomes whether it's cell teacher support teacher safety within the school so it did clear the what's wor Clearing House there's some other databases out there that the PED or the federal government uh tells school to use in fact that's a criteria that we're we're looking at because our six CSI schools uh this past year had to anything

130that they wanted to purchase had to be in those um Clearing Houses as far as uh there was efficacy in the study I hope that answered the question no it you did but we need to move on on the agenda but if you could um superintendent if we could get more information about Desa email to us cuz we didn't receive anything there was nothing in the board packet and then all the the questions and regards to um the programs that we have in the in the school district and then it would be really good if we could include the efficacy um the rating on those programs absolutely thank you so next on the agenda is D graduation information by High School principles superintendent you keep us inform on that yes please okay uh Ship Rock

131High [Laughter] School you you are moving around Sharon me it look like you are yeah I'm ready and I am I am ready good evening board president hasy vice president Wells [Music] secretary so and members aspas and Montoya and Mr Carlson who's over there um so we have a little bit of updated numbers from Shiprock High School since December so we currently have 17 seniors four Juniors moved up in December to senior status out of those 117 115 are on track to graduate if all classes are passed two of them are going to need to take some more classes either summer or in the fall um three seniors graduated in December and so there's 118 students possible to walk in May right now um one senior will complete their associates degree by May and we

132do know at this point that this semester we have 54 seniors who passed 59 dual credit courses first semester so we're still staying fairly well on top of our dual credit um students getting dual credits and moving on into college um our interventions haven't changed a lot we do graduation grade checks they're performed every two weeks throughout the school year by our CCR and our senior counselor they met today to go through every single senior's transcript to make sure they've got every single class they double check that at least three or four times a year to make sure we don't get to April and go H that student still needs help so you know they do that they meet frequently we do send letters and rooc calls to parents on attendance and grades we try

133to do that bi-weekly I've actually started a new thing that's probably going to to frustrate some parents but I've been running a what we would call an L3 for first hour because first hour we tend to have kids who are 10 to 20 minutes late so I run that report after first hour and I send a robo call out to those parents hey your student was more than 10 minutes late today this is you know a loss of at least 20% of their first hour instruction just to try to get them coming in and that list is getting shorter so maybe the rooc calls are working plus I've been meeting with the students face to face um we have a student intervention team that meets weekly and they determine what students and families need to

134be contacted whether or not it's with an attendance contract students are failing classes if they're at risk of not graduating we try to bring those in and talk to those parents and those students um the students meet with their counselor myself the my APS and the college in PR Readiness coordinator when they're at risk due to grades or attendance if we see them start to fall off we're trying to jump on that right away to get them in um the only only time that doesn't work is when it's a huge attendance problem and the kids's just not there to get a hold of when nobody's picking up a phone but generally we can get them in there and talk to them an intervention period has been built into the daily schedule for credit recovery courses

135to make up any fail C credits or complete additional College coursework that's at the end of the day we actually use that if students start to fail a class and say they're a basketball player and they're Athletics we'll pull them out of that basketball class and make them go to intervention until they get caught up so that they've got time to do that and then right now we're using it for credit recovery if anybody failed courses first semester they can make that credit up right now this quarter during seventh period and those are taught by a teacher they are not online classes um after school tutoring is available four nights a week part of that's high dosage tutoring part of it's regular tutoring and we do have some kids who do some credit recovery with

136a teacher in the evening and lunch tutoring is offered by many teachers every day so that's how we're supporting our kids trying to keep them on track so that's where we are at any questions no I think I think um your Robo calls for the 10 10 minutes Beyond 10 minutes is great thank you anything that works yeah I hope so okay thank you thank you next let's see on there Kirtland Central High School good evening board members superintendent Carlson colleagues Community curland Central High School we currently have 168 seniors out of that 1684 met graduation requirements um this past December and they're moving forward for they're still taking dual credit classes and will graduate in 25 nine we had nine Juniors that moved to senior status one student is going to be graduating with

137their associates degree from sanon college and two students will be graduating early so their age three um they'll be graduating in May so we currently have 172 students that are slated to walk in me as far as interventions what we're doing to assist the students um definitely After School Credit Recovery high dosage tutoring um we are really encouraging the after school program and the high dosage tutoring because we found it to be more effective than the online bln courses so we do have less than 10 students in our bln and the majority are making up credits in the after school program um our sped support has been phenomenal as far as with inclusion classes and our case managers following up we do have have advisory that meet with our students they do a wellness check

138but they also do grade checks at least once a month for them um we definitely re um have been really utilizing our social workers at the school if we do meet with students that are failing we try to set them up with supports so that they can get back on track um in addition to our restorative Solutions the students get one onone support uh we're also utilizing our attendance incentives and award ceremonies we should have one coming up here in February that um awards are outstanding I believe we have seven perfect attendance students that will be recognizing as well as um students on our AB armal um so we do have our ignite program that assigns mentors so that they do peer tutoring a lot of our seniors take advantage of that um in addition

139to the shs we do the rooc calls to the parents regarding attendance one initiative that we uh are really pushed the first two weeks was we tried to get the students that were consistently either late or absent um and so far those students have been attending um we've set up meetings with parents for those students that may be at risk of falling behind during the semester sending out sen senior letters and then our CCR support do you have any questions am I able to question go ahead um with the um with respect to the family was that student a senior the the student was a junior student okay what I I got an email saying two students but one was just from Kirtland um both students were from the Kirtland area one student was from

140Kirtland Central High School and the other student was from Kur prep oh no but he was part of our community MH well my condolences I'm sure as a principal you you you carry that loss too so um yeah that that was my thoughts as if he was a senior and um but it looks to me like you have um some really good interventions and and just the one thing that I I want to say also to Gallagher is that um um I know I keep asking questions but um it's just for for for me to Advocate and because this happened to myself personally and that was the um the credit recovery and to make sure that our counselors when they um talk with the student or the parent that they know exactly how um you

141know rigorous if if it's rigorous you know and because we when when that happened um I was told that oh you'll be done in a week and not even and those were college courses compared to high school so um I I think we really need to and and those students too that are high risk and are lacking credits you know anything can just you know or forget it I don't want to do it you know and so I think the more they know and the more they're supported um you can get them graduated I agree thank you Fork thank you I you're doing a great job so yeah thank you for that excited to see the the promoted the Juniors going to senior status that's that's huge the best thing to see on a student

142face when they get reclassified because they'll bring your transcript yeah so I mean all of these are celebrations so thank you for for the information any other questions or comments no thank you thank you career prep I'm going in the order that it's listed so just FYI it's ladies first it's not just picking the names good evening uh president hasy esteemed board members Mr Carlson and colleagues and guests um C prep we're uh doing good moving along we've we started the year with 45 students who were within eight credits and normally that would be six credits you know in a standard school but where we're at a in the semester based we can get eight credits a year so that was kind of our bottom line uh like we said before two met graduation retirements

143in October we had projected eight at semester but actually got 10 so we've already graduated 12 out this year 33 students are now on track to graduate in May who need 4.5 credits or less and I have been through every transcript and I have looked at every class and I have met with the counselor and I have met with each student to make sure that they understand what they need to graduate there's a couple of them were're still work a couple who who need extra to graduate in May or maybe even in June if they have to make up a class through through the summer school but I think we're going to get those two through also um sadly the student that we had was a was a senior and uh that was that was

144really tough we we took that loss pretty tough but anyhow we're going to focus on the students we have and uh I met personally with all students in the school once it was released and gave them all the same message that you know we want you here we want you safe please please take care I did reach out to the family also and we have great support from the district too so right now we're looking at uh 47 students who graduate uh in May um that sounds good good we're we're staying there we've had right out 50 to 57 last year was our highest we've ever had so we're graduating a lot of kids once again a lot of them are still the h56 SS but but I think we're doing good things for those

145kids to go out into the community also we did have 10 kids already that have have gone to Junior to senior this year so that's helping push that we are getting a few more h4s and we actually have two h3s this year that are going to be graduating a lot of times we'll get a a student that transfers in and they'll bring a sibling with them and that sibling really benefits from it because they're younger and they'll actually graduate early while the other one gets back on track a couple years ago we graduated three family members at the same time one was an H5 one was an H4 and one was an H3 so that was pretty that was pretty cool so our graduation is on May 21st at 7 7 PM uh Performing Art

146Center all potential graduates we continue to monitor them like I said I've been through everyone and I know Miss Brown has been through it we've sat down with all the kids we want to make sure that we we get the kids what they need in a timely fashion uh once again we document that I've got a I've got a spreadsheet that I I use daily pretty much and go through it's all colorcoded with all my seniors that I can go through and make sure that they're staying where they need to be uh students are referred to social work for additional support if needed and Ico for additional help with food and clothing uh we completed four night school sessions during the during the the fall semester and awarded 40 just over 40 credits or we'll

147continue to do those coming up our first one will be next starting next Monday on the 27th we do have a few other opport options for students who need credits that that we try to make sure that everybody gets to where they need to be as as soon as we can and we may have a few more because we were still enrolling students today so so we've although we graduated 10 out we've probably picked up another so may I yes go ahead so I'm I'm going to read here I guess my one of my constituents is is is out there but don't apologize for asking relevant questions you are speaking on our behalf so but anyhow I um on that um your your number I'm I'm just curious with all that this district has been

148through and with covid is is that 45 lower or higher than the past past couple years yeah it's down just a little bit but part of it is is we're trying to we're trying to ratchet down our kids to where we're getting them a little sooner because CER preps really taking it on the graduation rate because we don't have as much many h4s as they would like us to have uh we've been serving the the more Adult Community uh right now the state does not have a method to evaluate Us in that fashion so I've been working with the other principles and we've been trying to identify students more at the sophomore level and getting them over sooner but just like today I had one that we'd got back on track and she actually could

149have graduated early but she chose to go back to kland so and we're we're good with that too because we will get some credit for that also but it is a few less than we've had but you know it kind of es and flows with us it kind of depends on the student clientele from the different schools right now I've got more from Nukem than I've had in the last four years oh wow wow okay yeah just real quick so based on what you've um provided so far uh did you have like a projected graduation rate because I know when I we're going back through the the csis that your your career purpose flag is M for graduation RIS so do you have like an estimate about if that number is going to increase for

150compared from last year to this year it's probably either going to be about the same because we had our best graduating class at h4s last year we've had in years so we're going to be up in the 40s mid-40s or something this year if you look at my sheet here um I've got right now I'm only looking at 35% of my graduates being h4s um 37% are going to be h5s which are fifth year seniors 23% are going to be H sixes and then 4% are sevens and eights but that that number has changed significantly uh four years ago the biggest group I had was was six sevens and eights they they made about 60% % of the population but that's also what pushed our graduation rate down because unfortunately the state doesn't give us

151much credit for those okay but yeah we're working at it on on that food and clothing thing that um you know your your your Ico is helping with um do you guys I mean shoot I've seen your art artwork in the students artwork that's amazing um how come we can't gener revenue from that that's something we can look into I have done that in in other schools and stuff that we've been able to do things like that but as far as what I was talking about there is the mckin vento because we do have some homeless kids and people who are underserved so they they they have services that they can provide for them but yeah that's a good idea I like it and you know um with the presentation we got at the last

152um conference there was a uh a speaker there um um the main speaker and he he talked about how um students how he helped them um set up a business you know and and I think something like that for these these students if we're able to do that instead of you know generating money for the school maybe for themselves you know if we can get that started yeah I've got a couple teachers right now who uh Dr Chi is one he really really talks with the kids about you know what's what's a business look like what could you do and and they're doing those things frequently and then I have another one Mr Striker who's uh he's he's all he's kind of jumped in this year and done student council and they've been energizing and

153stuff and they've been coming up with some ideas for some fundraisers to promote some stuff in school so it's it's it's been good this year and you know it's if anybody that knows me very well out here they know that I'm always going to say school is culture first because you're not going to learn unless you're comfortable so culture first good thank you thank you for your presentation and everything you do for our students apprciate it Nukem High School yeah good evening members of the board and then superintendent Carlson and then um everyone in attendance this evening this is my first year at Nik High School um during the December presentation I had my assistant principal Miss man she was the one that presented um um so our numbers have changed um we had 53

154seniors that we were looking at back in December but after the reclassification our number went up to 56 um so we have 55 so far on track to graduate if all classes are are passed but within that 55 um seven are short um credits meaning that that's what we have aimed for to really um work some of these classes into their schedule so seven of them pretty much have really maxed out um like a full schedule so some of them have no electives they're just doing like all foure classes 15 students are enrolled in our credit recovery program which is with that bln online um I'm going to add that despite that we don't have any credit recovery teachers we are working with our students like with during our um we call it Sky hot

155wind time which is like an intervention period um that we provide for for our students so our seniors get the max time 30 minutes every day we also try to catch them during lunch and then if we know the students um really need to do like some extra catch up you know for their credit recovery we'll recommend them for also after school um four of our students have been reclassified because they were juniors in the previous semester so they should pretty much be on track to graduate in May because now their uh senior status and their credits are up um today we do have one possible summer graduate um and depending on also how she how she does um most likely um we're we're looking at for sure that that's going to happen um we

156do have one senior who transferred out I believe she went to Kirtland Central High and she was really close to um finishing up her credits she only had two and a half credits to go um so in total we're looking at 57 students on track to walk in me some of the interventions were we're doing and despite that we don't have a guidance counselor a lot of what we do goes back in the hands of we rely on our College current Readiness coordinator as well as just collaboration between the admin team members which is myself and our assistant um principal uh we also involve our registar because she oversees a lot of the attendance and then just really following up with um attendance and like taries so one of the things we um do also

157is um we have progress reports that are sent for um our seniors and we do it on a weekly and we do a weekly grade check during like I said the um Sky hot wind time that's our advisement class that we have um we had two classes of seniors where it has been work working very well because if we need to just do even like a onetoone um meeting with them if we have to do like a whole group or class announcement on certain things that we're concerned about regarding graduation their credit you know it's it's very flexible for us to give us that leverage we also send letters home regarding any attendance and grades um that would be of concern um senior parent meetings we've been updating our parents as far as like what

158their child's um graduation status and their credit status is because I know um like I said they they're they're aware that we don't have a guidance counselor so parents are always asking like is my child on on track you know what do I need to do to support them um and this is when we make other additional um announcements that our parents need to know regarding their senior graduate um so like I said um we don't have a counselor but one of the things that we had our college career raist coordinator do is do audits so these are the credit audits um they weren't completely done in the past so it has been a priority for us think including the next step plans because this gives our students an idea you know where they're at

159with their credits and even considering what they want to do um after graduation and I believe it's part of the um what ped you know would like to have our our students do um the next to complete the next step plans um we also have a class of 2025 progress tracking and this is um similar to I would say what Dan has shared we have a list of all of our students um where their credit status is what classes they're lacking uh and um how far long they are uh and then we do like um especially with the credit recovery we make sure that they're on track so that they start clearing some of these classes that are listed for them that they need to finish um so that really has come in handy as

160a review for us on a weekly basis during our admin our admin team meeting um students needing Credit Recovery have been enrolled and utilize their lunch period we have the library open to them so they bring their lunch um and then they they work on their credit recovery we also have the after school tutoring program available to them um one of the things that we get from the bln um is like a weekly progress report which is also very helpful because it'll show us like um the students progress where they're at if they worked on any assignments how many assignments they have left uh and then some students are really good about even asking I I pass um my preest do I need to still finish like the rest of the assignment so um they

161follow up with us in regards to when we get the progress uh reports and we share with them um so that's like a weekly pass that we do and then of course we have college applications that we are doing as part of The Next Step plans and I know as of beginning of January we had seven um acceptance letters for our seniors so that's something that we have added to I'm going to say like one of the ways to encourage our seniors that you know maybe that's an option you know After High School rather than not having a plan so um that's part of The Next Step plans um and like I said I just want to reiterate that despite that we don't have a guidance counselor we're doing our best you know and we

162have to actually you know have a team team onsite to really get a lot of this uh in place so any questions any questions or comments I have a question go ahead so um I I know some years back um before Miss curly and um and she was wonderful I don't know where she's at but anyhow before then um I it was said that we had some students that that could have gone on to like Stanford and and we missed those opportunities because we didn't have a counselor and um and and I and I like the fact that you know you're you're you you you're trying to cover all that you know a counselor tries to um help our students with and um and then um you know with um career raess also um you

163know I I wonder you know how much of those students um you know that they don't want college you know they want to go into the workforce or some apprenticeship or you know things like that um and then too with it coming down uh with a few months till May till graduation I'm wondering are we able to set up um a bus with Wi-Fi out there would that be helpful you mean like for credit recovery you know that something yeah for the students um I don't know if if um you know that was something that was done during Co and I wonder if if that's possible for our seniors you know because you know like in ship brought they have um Taco Bell Burger King they can go to for Wi-Fi um Kirtland you know

164same but um new come yep I know what you mean so I'm wondering if if if that's a suggestion on you know to see if we can do something like that um Park a bus out there or may I I have a comment would they be able to ride the activity bus too for after school they do oh okay yeah they D they do and in fact um since you mentioned Wi-Fi I know like for students who are in sports we emphasize to them that you know they need to do their their homework and the coaches do a good job even sharing with us that you know there's Wi-Fi at the hotel there is Wi-Fi on the bus um when they go on these um trips so it's there but I think um I know

165what um concern you know we have a making sure that there's that Wi-Fi internet access to our students um and and we have shared and we we have asked them like how can we make um maybe our support to them you know better as far as that goes and some parents you know have really been I'm going to say um um striving to even get get that Wi-Fi in your household but it's not it's not 100% so we we have an idea how many students who the students are that strugg with you know trying to um do their credit recovery but that's why we we have to we've been really monitoring uh our students um during our advisement to make sure that they are working and then during lunch we bring them back in um

166and maybe it would have been you know a little bit um different too if we did have like her credit recovery teacher but we don't have one um in the past they did but this year we don't um so I'm going to say right now with what we're working with it's it's working you know okay but not to you know that full 100% of what you know I wish y that you know that was there for for all of our seniors or even the rest of our students um but we work with what we can at the school site you know what we can provide they are aware that um when there's no school we still have that in the library open as well go ahead yeah that was my comment is keeping that Library

167open with extended hours so those students can go in there and utilize that I know there's different municipalities whether it's in New Mexico across the country that open up their libraries for the students after hours or through the weekend so they can utilize it certainly be an option for us without was considered and then earlier you asked about Mrs Curley gyla Curley um she is our U college career Readiness coordinator and she she has we're blessed to have her you know at her school site because she's actually even like I'm going to say right now we're in the Hat of a guidance counselor and um just really working with every single one of our students we're going um backwards doing our credit audits with even our J sophomores um that way we have all in

168that already place ready to go for like right now I know um summer school we have to plan ahead for our Juniors to even make sure that if they need credit recovery we need to catch them um right away and then even considering what classes they're going to need for you know fall but a lot of it also depends on just how well they do the semester I have another comment go ahead so I I don't um you know I I'm grateful for all you're doing but you know to hear Miss Curly's there okay you know but um yeah anything that we can do to help provide Wi-Fi you know to those to the students because um um inflation and you know and and the the DAT that comes from there is um um you

169know if you're going to pick between a car payment and a Wi-Fi payment which one are you going to do so you know I I think um we really need to think out of the box and and try to help I do like Mr montoya's idea of maybe extended hours that Library that's something thing that we didn't think of but we'll definitely I'll bring it back to my admin team and then we'll we'll go from there to see what we can do to consider even that some of what we've been doing um we have been um doing like student surveys just to see what um their thoughts are their feedback to to support them you know the best that we can um I know seniors has been priority to really get them back on track

170it has been a lot of um I'm going to just say like work that we had to go through since um August and I I really appreciate you stepping up I mean there's some things you know but um I really appreciate that thank you is there has there been any thought on sharing guidance counselors also I know Miss curly is amazing I'm sure it's a lot on everybody's shoulders is there okay okay we like what I can say is I have a good team we we already strategized a lot of things back in July um and then we've been really just putting our heads together of you know what we need to get done I have a team that even reflect it back like what didn't work what needs to happen what they would like

171to see happen you know it's just that's that's what we've been doing um even with you know the discussion of the social emotional learning we we established even a protocol of doing referral you know uh you would think a guidance counselor is uh one of the team members or who should be notified first but because we don't have one we've been utilizing like other um team members in our collaboration teams to be able to take care of some of these referrals and then get you know jump on it and you know start seeking or even checking in on the students so I don't know if I'm I I would say we really need a guidance counselor but it would help because um our students do miss you know looking up to a guidance counselor they

172do question but I think they really um have been looking up to Mrs Cur lately question go ahead superintendent do we have anybody in the um admin office that would be able to go down there to assist them especially when you're looking at where we are that um moving forward towards the end of the year that they may be able to assist with Miss Curley and the princip for those Services we can send people down for tasks but we don't have anybody specifically to my knowledge the counseling license yeah I understand that that you know you have to have a specific credentials but certainly something to help lighten that we can offer support yeah absolutely right well thank you thank you for your the information and everything that you're doing um next item where am

173I e District assessment data for quarterly assessment in summer school by Mr desw good evening again board members so go and do the uh presentation for assessment data I know last month uh we gave the presentation as well for like 3rd through 8th grade um beginning of year to middle of year so we go and go to the next slide uh so there's our MSA Elementary again it's his boy Timo reading data and it's broken down by school so red is middle of the year and then blue is beginning of year so majority of those uh bars have increased except for um EV stally EV went from 22 to 20 so that's the only decrease okay so that's and then of course we can see a districtwide and then in comparison to the state okay

174so so with evb is there an explanation why there was regression so this is let me see which which one is the your the schools the red so blue the blue the blue is the very what kids tested at the beginning of the year and then the red is what they tested um in December and then closed up in well closed up in December well actually closed up in January correct for yeah so those are some of the things that the school and the leadership team will look at to see where why there was a decrease in and and this looks like it's it's um all grades combined so then there was a like I said there was a decrease and that's that's what the leadership team uh we'll get together and do as look

175at the data to see why there was a decrease so that's reading we're going to to the next one uh this is um Lang anguage usage again it was there was an increase at every school location and then distri wi from 11 to 16 and then 2 and of course whenever you look it to the compared to the state over on the right okay so that's language uh going to go to the next one and again this is third through eth grade this is mathematics um so Mesa didn't improve and then as titties did at zero all the other schools across the district did improve so we went from 6 to 10 so if you look at that six like for looking at the district whenever whenever 90day plans are written let's say this the

176kids score is 6% at the beginning of the year so the public education department in fact we write this in our the district education plan we look at our data and then we write goals the public education department says a stretch goal is about 10 to 12% so if you figure um if it's 10% 5% growth so we went from 6 to 10 so we're about 2% below our midyear um where we want to be so very similar if you look at some of those schools some of them have doubled already like if they went to nine like if you look at um EBS the if their their goal is 6% they want to be at 16 by the end of the year so then they're a little bit above uh halfway so then the

177conversation and the leadership with the teachers would be okay what do we need to do to stay on course to meet our we're at 14 now let's continue can we hit 19% and then you continue to push um if you're at zero and zero or if you're at Mesa and have 2% uh proficient the conversation okay what do we what are we not doing and what do we need to be doing more than I'm going to be honest more than likely it's probably not following um high quality instruction material and probably not following pacing guides so a lot of times whenever you look at um data like that um we're just not doing um not following those guides we're not providing um what you the the the the state pacing guides and what they say

178to teach because those pacing guides they're called Power standards those power standards are not being taught yeah but I mean to me that that data alone tells me that there's something going on at that school that things are not happening absolutely and that's that's concerning um there there is some and also with Nash as well that's correct so nashy part of uh we had no principal in the building until end of November December so we actually had we were a bit under staff we had a A Lead Teacher serving as a principal um and and then of course the newom administrator would go down and help once per day so some of the instructional time was being um taken and for administrative Duty so um that's definitely um Dr bitsui down and is definitely having

179some some tough conversations with her staff as far as math I know a couple years ago we were in the same um predicament about a year ago no two years ago um and then of course you know just supporting them and making sure that they're following the pacing guyses and following high quality instruction materials um their scores would up so that's definitely um on on our team's radar that uh the support needs to be provided to schol I have a suggestion yes ma'am since we have 3D printers at Bon Wilson I think we need to do that to baded take him over to Mesa and nitty oh for math yes but seriously um that is I mean I for the longest time I think Mesa has always had issues and I I I wonder why

180why why every year and then when did you collect this data so this is this this school year uh beginning of the year August I think the window closed in September so this is really a reflection of last year no no this is current this is our this is our data right now okay so you you had this information before December um well we it was finalized uh the first week in January maybe when it was closed the assessment window yeah January 10th was whenever the window closed that the head closed it okay so okay we can go to the next um so this is I station I station reading this is for Kinder through second grade so if you look at that if you look at kinder 8% to 10% so you're looking at

181Green I wish I could go up there but so for then we also look at the Reds so Kinder started at 31 they dropped to 28 so what we're looking at is we're wanting to have more greens or or move kids up so then those Reds are decreasing so we went from 31 to 28 but since the state looks at the greens uh we did would go from 8 to 10 so yeah absolutely so first grade as you can tell went from they stayed at 10 to 10 that and then go to level four it went from 15 to 19 so we we improved so did our it looks like cyan went from 18 to 9 and then our Reds those are our low kids went from 38 to 27 so we had a 10%

18211% decrease in level one students so that's those perfect that's what we want now this like I like I said in my presentation last month the whole model that the PED uses is based on growth like you know you start the year low and then you're moving your kids um to the right or moving them up so you look at second grade it what goes from 40 in red to 37 so then 3% of our kids um are off of red yes so so green notice it went from 7 to 15 so that's what we're wanting so if you look at those indicators that's why our schools are moving off the CSI status and I mean as you can tell like we're we're starting to get recognized for teacher of the year last year we

183had a principal of the year because of the good work that we're doing now we know there's pockets of good teaching that's what we're trying to do is like we're trying to put systems in place so that like we have some non-negotiables right things that we see in strong classrooms of course we get push back right but we work with them and I know in particular um the Mesa princip is is really working with some of the staff that need a lot of support um she has a lot of first year teachers so there's definitely a lot of support um that is being provided uh to to the school at Mesa okay we go to before go any further is there a separation or do they just count as whole but um considering sped so

184what can happen is we can break it down by school right and then I don't know if we can identify it by sped or we can can but we can the the principal and and Amy can break it down we actually have support that we provide for principles to have these conversations with teachers and how to look at data and have these data conversation and saying what are we doing what are we not doing and what are we going to do different and and then I don't think we've ever asked this question how many percentage if there's a cat or by in each CL uh it's whereas I guess for example like say maybe you have half the students that are in a class size of 25 maybe half of them about 12 are are

185all sped um is do they have like a cap on that on on because to me it seems like your again that teacher student ratio is off so so they try to I guess spread out the case load and not have one teacher have all the students with IEPs or have all the students who identified L as English language learners but the thing is there's some schools that there're just one teacher per grade level so any kid with an IEP might have that teacher but I I don't recall when we did FTE one teacher having more than other if we do we definitely make adjustments to uh case loads um but of course um if when we do FTE in the fall and the spring um like for example prek I think they get it's

18610 10 to1 student ratio and it increases as they go up and I think for middle and high school uh a middle school teacher can have as as high as 150 students for English and math and one60 as much as many as 160 for other subjects for middle and high school but it it we're far below that ratio I think our highest is Kirtland High which has about 109 to 110 to uh one student and then our lowest I think was uh career prep that had like one to like 70 or 80 of course because well actually probably 1 to 45 because uh they're on the Block schedule so and and and then the the last talk that we had on this was um in in um behind closed doors um I I I guess

187I got a better understanding of it and and what concerns me is some of these we we don't have time you know it's it's a Time Factor that's in there that um where um a student goes to different levels with with IEPs or um so I I didn't know that before but you know those are concerning and and with this you know I'm wondering how are we um accommodating so accommodations are definitely written and that would be both the teacher and student that is correct so the accommodations in fact that's one of the district in principl um professional development plans every one of the principles has a sped component for as far as making sure that um IEPs are being implemented in the classrooms and then also making sure that they are there attending the

188IEP so a lot more attention has been paid on like I said uh each principal has three goals um one two self-identified and one a districtwide goal that we had put into place uh for all our principles um and if you want like we can do a presentation on what those um um professional development plans look like of course I can hide the names but I mean it's very it's very driven it's driven by scores um as far as how they rate themselves and then of course how i rate them as principles and then um but and but not of that but how they support the teachers as well have a comment so to kind of work off of uh Miss asus's comments the question I always have is you have a class with 16

189kids what would you call that class that had half of those kids with IEPs and what would you call that teacher because I'd call a special education Cass with a special education teacher but it's a conventional teacher so again and and to her point of the question that she was asking and how is that aggregate directly impact the education of not just those kids with the IEPs but all the other kids general education kids and the stress that it puts upon that educator in that classroom working with those students and that high number of students with IEPs how does a district how does the principal how does a assistant superintendent superintendent address that issue in it of itself because you know that I may if I'm not mistaken That's A time test correct no it's

190not no it's not okay all right I got the wrong Ice Station is the one that's timed if I'm not one of them is timed say it again that is St yeah oh okay so but the main point being is to what Miss aspas was asking about that effect in that classroom with the high number of U students with IEPs and again the load that it puts on that educator in that class classroom without there any direct supports because again you have those different levels of those IPS and directly impacting that education and the time spent with those kids with the IEPs whether it's a Justice or an injustice to those students or even the general education students how does a district address that well it would definitely be addressed within our multi-layered support system

191and and actually it's just it's going to depend on the students level correct because the students may be a uh may need minimal support level one and maybe eight of them might have a level one so it it just depends on the the calculation and that's definitely something Joel could talk more about but but the thing is though is if if the principal and the counselor were to look at that in like you know hey we noticed that you have a large number of students who have IEPs what can we do to spread that case load out between you and another teacher but it just depends if it's if there's only one teacher in that grade level but that's where we look at during FTE that if any adjustments need to be made um I'm

192not too sure maybe the other teacher might have um a higher case load as far as a level two or level three so that they probably equal um the level one eight students that are level one maybe they she has the other teacher has two or three students that are uh two or level three am I correct Joel yeah some of our students are on a different levels and from the different levels that they belong to if they're on a level one uh more of them are uh exposed within the Regular Ad setting so you will find more of them like five or six in the regular Ed classroom but for sure those who are in level three or level four on those uh having those uh intensive needs like uh toiling skills Behavior needs

193and academic skills those are the ones who are uh more within the uh s classroom life skills or those that are provided more of special ed classroom so definitely in the different schools in Nukem area Shick area and kland area there would be different uh distributions of numbers of students in the Regular Ad setting because for some uh with a number of teachers on each grade level number of enroles and uh different levels of the students needs it kind of affects how these students are distributed in the uh and the different grade levels so some teachers will definitely have more students with special needs and if in cases like this uh the state also have a level of control or layers of control where in the district will be required to submit a waiver that

194what is the district doing to kind of alleviate the situation so uh coming in new with these things that's that are happening uh in our district and I'm finding out that these things are really in there and as a challenge that we are also trying to kind of mitigate and support within the school level and then with the teachers so we're having this real things thank you well I I come from a place that um you know those kind of things when when doing presentations that me those kind of things need to be covered instead of drawing it out and um um that way we know that you know they are being um considered right so rest assured that that we are taking kids taking care and making sure that the kids needs are being

195met um I know we probably won't be able to disaggregate the data by school because right that the the numbers might be lower uh to see that that specific students growth because I know like whenever the state releases test scores um anything less than 5% they mask it correct because you can identify which kids so I don't know if if that was what you're asking as far as seeing that student grow but but whenever um principles are having conversations with their teachers they're they're they they know um they have items that they look at to know what skills they need to work on with kids and and to be honest with you like if you had a bunch of kids in the red I would be like oh my gosh the only way for us

196to go is up because you provide support you provide care you take you do sell you provide you you teach to the standards or you teach the standards using the high quality instruction materials your kids will grow right you I mean we have we we have schools that are that are proving uh that happens I mean you're in the last three years when when I've done this presentation our data is is growing each year so again it's just making sure we're providing support for principles and providing support for teachers because the teachers are the ones that are working with the kids we can go and go to the next one so this is Ice Station math um again um we went from 8 to 12 for green but also look at the red went from

197is it 43 to 19 that's that's the data we want to see because look at how low Kinder math is so when you look at first grade we went from 8 to 26 and then first grade 41 to 18 for red so like when you look at D you look at the red first because that's the indicator for this ped is proficiency right or lot on level five but then the second indicator you go to the kids that are in red and did we move kids did we move kids up on this particular scale so when we go to second grade we went from no kids to more than likely Amy that's probably like one or two% correct but it's not showing for second grade yeah right so we move we had no um second

198graders in level five but then more than likely 1% five okay 5 perc so if you figure 5% of of all of our second graders in the district um I'd say probably four 3 or 400 second graders 5% of that is about what 15 kids but we went from no kids proficient or level five and we went from seven to eight that are the the lighter green and then when you look at the second grade in red 45 at the beginning to second grade 33% so perfect that's the data we want to see do we want more we do want more right we we that's part of the thing is we want to continue to move and I think one thing that's important is 3% growth this year for first grader plus 3% next year

199plus 3% 3% that that's starts to increase all right we go and go to the next slide so this these are the PSA the PSAT scores um if you take a look at that the district we had a 751 uh global test takers all around the world the score was a 950 uh the state was 832 the US was a 949 so um definitely some numbers that we need to work on however whenever we compare this to how we did the previous year we saw growth there as well okay and I know Leandro and his Department keep a long the longitudinal data for that um if you go over to the right um for career prep there at a 675 um it's broken down by uh by um by by High School in fact one

200of the things that we've really been challenging our our school in this area is why you know Mr Carlson brought it up to you and we've had some pretty tough conversation with Miss with Mr Westbrook why are we at 7:53 when Ship Rock high is or when newom is at 760 and ship Rock's at 764 right so those are conversations that we're having for them to in turn have that conversation with their staff what is it we're doing what is it we're not doing and what do we need like do we have an do we have a plan in place to support our kids um so definitely asking those questions around the data so wasn't there one of them that's no longer Act was it well students can still take the acts but uh this

201particular one is for the pat which is grade 10 and then of course the SAT is in the uh in April but we don't have that data yet but if you look at our SAT data over the last four years um we've seen growth um from year to year again like I said if you look at the PED model the P model is as long our schools are improving our kids are improving it's not like like Skyrocket improve but like we're we're we're steadily uh improving and we're steadily moving our kids uh to to proficiency um go and go to the next slide uh summer school data we currently do not conduct a pre and a post assessment in fact Amy um and my staff and Leandro and I think Mr B were having conversations

202what can we do to do pre poost test assessments um the past couple of years a lot of summer school has been focused on is enrichment trying to get keep kids um coming to school during the summer so a lot of the fun activities and based on the funding that we had in previous years it was all about enrichment um now the pet is starting to move like high dosage tutoring and with the high dosage tutoring it's like a one to four ratio and then that's why we're trying to come up with assessment to see if our kids backslide or kids stay the same or see if they decrease over the summer so that's definitely something we're looking at we're talking about it we'll talk about it academic planning and then I stand for questions

203more questions any questions or comments yes um wasn't that the summer school that you were working on today yeah okay so so with that um is math going to be a big part I mean since yes math is a big area in fact one of the big things that we did districtwide was actually Mr Carls and I looked at the data and we saw that the teachers who had had like significant growth in math they had math instruction in the morning so one of the things we did was we moved math instruction across the district to be the in taught in the morning and across all all elementary schools and then in the next couple of days uh teachers are getting uh math instruction elementaries tomorrow uh tomorrow morning in the afternoon and then the

204following day will be middle and high school but really we we've been really trying to it seems like even like the public education department is really focus on like structured literacy letters training and a lot of reading right so a lot of times math is just kind of like on the back burner that's why one of the decisions that we made was to move math instruction in the morning because math was always taught at the end of the day and if everything else gets covered and there's a time crunch math just gets pushed aside so that's why we say we need to teach math in the morning so but we definitely are taking steps uh to improving math instruction thank you yeah comment exactly have a comment go ahead and if I'm not mistaken that's

205really the focus of that uh high doses tutoring is the reading and the math components correct that is correct yes which um in my opinion I've said this quite a few times about devising those sumar school programs to focus on those specific areas that the Educators that they're coming let's say they're in fourth grade and then they go into summer School allowing those teachers to utilize differentiate instruction to really focus on those two areas and those weaknesses of those students and then testing where they were when they first come out of school and then out of the summer school to have a gauge to when they go into fifth grade and that teacher knows specifically where they work where they're at and then what they can focus on when they get to fifth grade or

206third grade or whatever grade it is yes sir that is that is that is ideal I mean like right now they use previous year scores and then of course the beginning of year to kind of group kids for interventions um many of our schools do like walk through interventions um where they identify kids uh but basically in groups like remember how that first through second based on those colors then they're putting them in intervention groups thank you good thank you okay um we will move on to F attendance rates by schools and grade levels by Mr deswood I just want to thank uh data LeAndre and his team they got all the numbers for us to use and CR they crunched all the numbers and then like I said we share this data every month

207with the principles and you know we ask them what's going on what do we need to do differently and you know like you know this is part of the accountability that we're talking about and asking these tough questions about what's our plan what's our plan to address not only student achievement but what's our plan to address attendance um so we can go and go to that uh first slide versus overall attendance comparison and I usually have um I usually send it to Mr B but I think uh coach at city is the one that gets all these reports ready correct Co Terry Terry City Tammy I knew was close in the neighborhood somewhere um but I do provide these uh reports to the principls like I said every month so that they can share with

208their leadership teams one of the other thing other things that um we do is we share like discipline data um with uh with principles as well and I think if you if you saw ebs's report that's where last year we sent those reports to the schools to to help them make decisions so if you look at our our attendance data districtwide for the first semester we are at 8 89.7 so a little bit below um 90% um so and then you it's broken down by of course our Lois's career Prep High School at 73% and then it's broken down by each school so it seems like in like there's a definitely a trend there right our elementary schools the parents are really getting those kids to school and making sure they're getting there but when

209you start getting to Middle School there's a little less accountability I guess or um you know well actually some of the conversations that I that I've heard with uh some of our our schools down south and there's definitely a trend like over over here in Kirtland attendance rates are higher and then they start going lower as you go to Shiprock and then low towards Nukem and one one of the conversations actually that I had with uh newom High principles was one of the trends that they found were that parents like we have a whole system set up it's it's called CCSD attendance procedures there's um there's layer one supports layer two layer three layer four supports so our schools have to write these uh attendance Improvement plans each year and these interventions are built into

210them and and when it came to a level two a level three intervention with their families um the principls were saying that the families were communicating that their kids their older kids were actually they were saying that they would leave their kids at home they'd leave for work at 6 to go to gallore to Farmington to go to work and you know of course they accept the responsibility okay we'll do our part to try try to get the kids there but then those kids the older kids would end up having to be there with the with the families when the F when when the parents went to work and then in the afternoon it happened again right the kids are are are at home waiting for parents to come back from work so then Mom

211and Dad get home or or Grandma Grandpa Auntie Uncle get home about uh 536 so then again the older siblings are left with the responsibility of of of um making sure that the younger siblings are there but that's those are some definitely some some concerns that came out whenever we whenever I was having conversations with the principles um about attendance data so definitely trying to find Provide support for those families um I think that's where Ico really comes in tries to support uh you know our families as far as their their wellbeing um again we can go and go to the next slide but that's the graph by by all schools so if we look at one of the things we look at how is how is the district How are schools doing in comparison

212and then we also break it down by by level like Elementary how are you doing how are we doing like in comparison because I know people are really competitive and they want to know let see how did Judy Nelson do how did EBS right well this is probably this is how this is why we send it so this is what I'm saying remember I said we're at 91% for a district just for elementary so then we're at this your school fall in comparison to the district so that's where um you you the schools and principles and the data teams or the attendance teams are looking at how if their if their supports are working I know one of the principles talked about um um attendance incentives right so th those are some of the ways

213that they're using the data the track to provide Provide support for improving attendance okay we going to go to the next one um mayor yes go ahead um superintendent is this what um presentation is it U the result of of my request I believe so because this is not what I wanted what did you want I wanted the the principl here you know because as you bring up attendance and you know the the things associated and some of these um um barriers or whatever that's happening I want to hear from them how are they helping we're going to we're going to do that as well okay your suggestion was I don't know if it's it's it's really really not what I wanted um I don't know if we want to continue um we can move

214on I don't know the bo unless there's questions on what he's already done it's fine I mean the data is pretty self-explanatory like Mr so likes to say that it's right there so but yeah I I mean are are you here like to really beat them over the head or is it I mean what's requesting that is beating them over the head no because I think we've already gotten the answers from our our assistant superintendent about what they're trying to do at the schools to improve outcomes I mean no um I want to hear well superintendent I want to hear um again how they're helping Families how are helping students each school middle school elementary school yeah we'll do that February March April we'll do and how are we um attracting you know students um

215that that was my original request we can do that um and then if we um because we were so focused on graduation rates and which is good you know um as I told you we we um have high school come forward and for the years that I've known we've never had any kind of U from the principles of the elementary order um um middle school and I do resent your comment and um I don't think I've ever beaten anybody over the head thank you go ahead do you want me to share what we uh information that we Shar to the uh legislative Finance or the LEC when we met with them in Farmington regarding attendance I can kind of give a a brief overvie brief overview sure one of the things that we recommended was

216like I said here in kland there's a lot more supports as far as cfd when we get to L level layer three and layer four support when we when we talk with families and say well you know we're going to need to work with cfd our families come to the table because they don't want cfd invading in their personal like family business so the fames start come to school however as we move this West and then down South we do not get any support um from nav nation cfd in fact principes say that they they do referrals to cfd and why are you calling us right so I mean that's that's some things that we had communicated um another another thing that that we communicated to the legislative education study committee was the was tougher

217of attendance compulsory attendance laws right um 108 8 to 10 years ago it was that the laws were a lot stricter a lot stricter for example uh there were there was talks and and I actually only heard of one family that got a $200 fine for not having their kid come to school so one of the things we said was to Advocate to to um improve the compulsory attendance law from the um you know in The Roundhouse so those were a couple of items that we had sent with the OBC okay thank you if there isn't any other questions comments we will move on to this uh G letter G presentation on sped Educators license and uh certificates certifications by Joel Basit may I make a comment go ahead I do agree with Miss aspas

218in respects to hearing what the principles from each of those schools are doing to attract the students in those schools so thank you you may begin good evening to The Honorable uh board officials superintendent uh community members and colleague good evening oh may I thank you my apologies for not being able to prepare a graph representation of this one and I hope I'll be able to uh give a good information for this presentation I'm T to provide some information on the license uh status for our district on our license special ed teachers um just just to cut to cut to it yes ma'am and um um what I'm what I'm hearing is that um we have some teachers that um are are titled their positions titled a different um say for example um e teacher

219and yet they're teaching sped so that's why I really want to see are we doing things right and are we because you know sped and IEP you know those students deserve a quality educator specialized instruction within the classroom man yes okay um board members uh this information this is uh sensitive information after we review this topic if we could please give it to um back to Mr M Mr bisit so that um so I I just want to make sure that's not [Music] happening uh I'm not aware of any concerns happening uh within the school building wherein a special ed teacher is being assigned I mean a PE teacher is being assigned as a specializ that's just a so yeah uh sorry it's just okay there's so should I just uh give a yes yes

220so currently our school district uh CCSD has uh uh for the schools there's 46 uh in total who are licensed special ed teachers who are covering our um who are covering resource classrooms for specializ teachers self-contained classroom like those in the life skills and autism classroom so there's 46 in total they are licensed uh per state and they and are allowed to provide specialized instruction in that classroom some of these uh teachers are going through uh the our the district's initiative of growing your own through uh alternative uh a lure and some of our teachers are fully licensed based on my review of the names of the teachers that I've seen in the list that I just shared there's [Music] around uh 27 with three years uh of more than three years of experience and

221around 20 that are from uh fresh to going to three years so uh with that number 27 more of teachers will are uh staying uh within those critical Tri years is a good sign uh however though we have some challenges with regards to the uh looking for special teachers this uh there are some programs that the state also is helping us with by providing stiens or pay differentials in recruiting and retaining teachers uh just to wrap up uh we have 46 teachers in total there's one uh program that currently the district is doing uh which is the project search this is a work skill program that uh we allow graduated students going to learn and experience work skills within the operational department and that one is not licensed as a teacher but when I conferred

222that with un mcdd who is helping us and uh with running that program it's fine for now to go ahead with that since we didn't have anybody uh over the summer and then the beginning of the school year and it was planned out already for the span of two years to get the parents and the students uh experience the work and skill learning in our district so that's the only one that we it's not a specializ license thank you very much give these back to you please thank you take them and burn them sh thank you appreciate it okay letter HG report from school year 2019 to present by Miss Alison hi good evening board members superintendent Carlson members of the um audience uh a request was made for a um SE history report so

223that's the first item that I have on the SE um I did uh just this uh short summary of the information by F by school years starting with 2019 2020 school year scg amount that we received the unit value at that time and then the count that was used to um provide the scg amount and uh for 2019 2020 35,6 126,000 for SG 2020 2021 39,9 120 2122 54,3 44,000 um 2223 61 m 352,000 23 24 61 M3 79,000 and for the current year 2425 6,910 May yes so so on that 20124 is is is that the old SG formula yes that's the one before it was changed for the 24 25 year okay um in your assumption how does it look for upcoming with the new formula with the new formula um and do

224you mean by do we do I think it's going to be higher or lower okay um my opinion is going to be that it might be a little bit higher not a whole lot um between 23 and 24 it's about $400,000 difference so if it's going to be an increase it would be probably just a little wow not not so much as a million I don't think at my opinion I don't think it'll be close to a million if it's an increase small percentage because the three items that that I saw in the session was student count teachers um and then the third being do demographics of the community and I and I say um because our student count were now down to what 4, 4 something 480 and um and then teachers are tied

225directly to that um so I'm sure it's less and then What's happen with the closures I I find it I find it interesting that we're going to come out maybe yeah I wouldn't imagine it'd be a whole lot I think it'd be less than less than the 500 more I would I would think that it' be more around maybe 300,000 is what my assumption would be taking um into consideration some of the we're talking about scg for next year right 25 26 legislation so um what I've because let me stop um don't me to but um javana from Galla the financial director there she in her in her presentation she talked about how um that it should be concerning and then I I felt like well this is something we're going to have to keep

226um a top of because you know she comes kind of from the same yeah and you know with Galla and so she's concerned and and nothing's really happened Dave had growth you know with a solar farm project and but we're not supposed to be complete on this one here in top 2028 and so we still La um so um yeah I find it interesting I'm from my from looking at the information it um I think that we would be considering it to be I'm optimistic I'm I'm assuming that's what I'm saying um hoping that we would have an increase in the unit value based on the information so um the that's what I would um hope that would be happening unless they added a multiplier or something okay thank you okay um the next report

227is the utility comparison report um one year ago in 2023 or a little over a year ago total dollar amount spent is $ 51,67002 total spent 433,92 and um with the current year everything is being paid out of the 15,000 um impact date account I have a comment it's kind of in general of of the of the entire report had a conversation with one of the constituents who um was asking about legislative session and the funding and how and why we were even involved with the politics in Santa Fe and some of the conversations we've had with state legislators and the governor's office and why why would you even talk to her about it so I had to explain and how the impacts of the taxation the closure of a power plant which this individual

228had no clue or knowledge of how it directly impacted our students and then the individual made a comment that was making my argument and I told the individual that we Mak my argument for you why we do what we do and my point of saying that is to the audience and anybody listening is the fact that what we do as a board and how we excuse me involve ourselves into the politics matters to the education of these kids and the dollars that we have to fight for one mention was made about Gallop in their position and just as farmington's two hours and the loss of uh tax revenu so that's why it matters thank you I have a question so um on that on that um what did you have yeah so on the impact

229a you know I I just happened to run across um one of the the council delegates and that being um Amber Cate and you know I find it um surprising you know she she she talks they they know um just a limit of about impact a and I think it's crucial that uh superintendent that they um our our our area Council delegates as well as our Representatives that they understand how impact a works and then also the fact that um uh board member Montoya found where we're still not equitable um that there still need some work done on that so um if we can you know if we could do something like that you know so that we um they know when they go when they have access to you know the legislator or other

230places that you know they they can or they they know for sure where we stand and have we had any um as far as a financial director we did I lose oh we go there it go thanks J we have hired a finance director we have and he's is did he start today he will start next Monday he's not well he he's officially agreed to terms can use his name and all that or no maybe not his name is uh Dominic satena perhaps he yes he's he's from the area and some of you may know him you know what I'm talking about Mr grego that's the same one I'm thinking of okay thank you all right not that there's any inside it's just the the name that's all okay all right thank you thank you

231for that now there was some in meeting we're supposed to catch on uh J letter j u procurement over 60,000 and 25 3500 to 10,000 by Alison again okay uh we had one purchase order for over 60,000 and this was to Sentry Link total dollar amount 75,000 for communication services have a question go ahead um I heard I don't know if you know about this but um Frontier changing over from landlines to their landline to um I don't know if it was fiber optic or it was supposed to be a changeover the delivery of their services does that does that sound help from mrina yeah there you go yeah okay yeah I don't know if it directly impacted the district any other questions or comments okay thank you um the next item is K counts

232pay dispersement okay uh our dispersements for the month of December we had a total of 2.5 million out of the operational account year to date 16 . 3 million activities is 3,282 year-to date is 151,000 outstanding check listing for the month of December for operation was 2.6 million year to date is 3.5 million activities outstanding check listing is 3,282 year-to date is $3,020 expenditures for the month of December number for operational funds General funds is 7.2 million a year to date 40.2 million expenditures for 15100 impact Aid is 1.5 million year to date 13.7 million fund 15200 expenses for December was $138 year to date was $170,600 180 Grant funds total spent 1.4 million year to date 9.2 of this amount fun 24174 call Perkins 6,659 year to date 29,9 24176 spent in December year

233to date 4 point or 400 4,7 115 jom $ 23,9 year to date 49,682 1883 year to date 202,000 impact Aid indied 474 th000 year to date is 2.7 Capital out capital outlay and debt Services total spent in December was 52,900 Million year-to date 0 spent out of fund 31500 year to date 4683 Revenue received for General funds 6, 36,000 year to date 47 .3 million impact Aid received 0 in December year to date 12.3 million adalum received 13,944 year to date 1871 grant funding received 29,36 for the month of December year to date 15.2 million no uh Revenue received for um Carl Perkins jom impact dat sped or impact 8 indied Capital outlay Revenue received 247,000 and 0 receed for fund 31500 and then um the bar adjustments we had four for the month

234of December the first one is fund 27901 Indian Ed a decrease of 59,000 and this was to adjust for the final um 24 25 school year and then we have have fund 26 or yeah 26143 save the children um $0 transfer to the 3300 function impact age 15100 0 transfer to cover school year expenses and then fund 24174 Carl Perkins increase of 4,283 and this is for the um 24 25 final award question so U from that Carl Perkins one um I mean that as far as I know that's been more for um Bon yes so why are we taking or are we taking M on that last line the 4,000 we're increasing okay okay all right thank you thank you I do have a comment Mr Vice President may I all right thank you

235um the information that's being presented in those dollar totals uh as we get closer to the possible closure of APs that are even much much more every single year so people need to understand exactly why and what and how we get this funding notice used for um because we are looking at an impending shutdown at a APS but certainly loss of any revenue from them that's it thank you thank you any other question thank you we on M discussion of dates and Topics by Jermaine Chappelle Jermaine are you out there yes sir good can you hear me yes we can hear you uh so this pertains to the topics that you all wanted to discuss for the board retreat and I believe um we've had a couple discussions on those um I can give you

236a summary of the ones that you all have discussed but this is more just for discussion of the board on what you want to cover at the board retreat so the list um that we've talked about before is continue the reorganization discussion uh budget strategic plan superintendent evaluation legislative matters update on legal actions and um a workshop on effective boards that came out of the last conference so those are the things that I had in my notes I turn it over um to you all for uh continued discussion are we miss Chappelle are we um looking for a date now you have any dates to have our board retreat I yes ma'am I believe that's at at your all's discretion and I will do whatever I need to do to make sure I'm there for

237whatever you will decide okay are there any dates in particular that you can't we would I think we're already too late into January so February and legislative the the first week is um the SE yeah the that's when we have our nsba um there's the third and the last week in February is there any particular day that everybody is available does a Friday work or Saturday preferable I'm open 21st 22nd February probably 22nd I'm open 22nds a Saturday does the 22nd work for everybody okay it works for me what is it no it don't work for me what about the 21st no how do those dates look for you Mr Montoya either open what date does it have to be on a Saturday no it can be on a Friday can be on the 21st

238which is a Friday or we can do the 28th which is the following week then we're going into March what does the 28th look for you that still doesn't work for me um but what days of the week were best for you miss aspis with the um is it a one day deal we'll start with one day I think it's going to be more than that we're not going to be able to pack it all we're not going to be able to pack in everything that's a lot our board Meers are longer than what what is the board retrieve the board retreat will be covering the continued discussion on the reorganization the budget strategic planning completing the uh superintendent evaluation legislative matters um update on legal action and workshop on effective boards I think um

239maybe the I don't know I can do both 28th and the first okay let's let's start with the 28th Miss Chappelle yes ma'am how does uh February 28th sound can you schedule that okay perfect and it'll be here at the boardroom correct does everybody agree to that sure here okay and then we can start at 09 I had to make sure I knew what that me Z 900 hours 00 hours 900 hours Scouts is that uh cover letter M Miss Chapelle yes ma'am okay and topics I I think we need to just um just the legislative and and then what comes down from National maybe we have a better idea what what we're dealing with wouldn't that be kind of formula the Strategic it would be I think it all is all together the Strategic

240plan includes all of those those areas quite honestly my humble opinion that would be the focus that's the title for the to include the national strategic the Strategic plan encompasses everything that's priority for the school district okay so um any other questions comments okay letter N support resolution of Department of Transportation chaining assign AG in front of schools in Highway 64 by Miss Chappelle Sharon did you get it and not I can read it from here or I can share my screen please share your screen missel okay do that oh there we go need to beer can you all see that singing and reading different thing small it's there you go a little bit bigger little more now little more little more okay right there okay I'll start reading Central Consolidated School Board of Education

241resolution support to increase school safety on Highway 64 ship New Mexico date January AR 21st 2025 uh subject support to increase school safety on Highway 64 Shi Rock New Mexico whereas the central Consolidated School District is committed to providing for the safety and well-being of CCSD students staff and families L they are driving to and from CCSD educational facilities uh Highway 64 is adjacent to Shiprock High School sh Performing Arts he would be Stokely Elementary and career prep whereas concerns have been reported that semi- trucks and other vehicles travel at high rates of speed on Highway 64 and threaten the safety of CCSD students staff and families when they are driving or walking to and from CCS the educational facilities located near Highway 64 whereas the manual on uniform traffic control devices provides information on

242how schoolst signs should be posted whereas the school board requests that lighted school zone signs be posted one hour prior to through one hour after the starting Bell and dismissal Bell schedules or Ship Rock High School Eva be stly Elementary and career prep EG 7:30 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. and 2:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m. whereas the school board requests that radar speed signs showing the speeds of vehicles on Highway 64 also be posted whereas the school board further requests that a double fine Zone be implemented on Highway 64 now therefore be it resolved that the of Education of the central Consolidated School District request that consistent with the mutcd applicable federal tribal state and local governmental entities work with CCSD to implement the following safety mechanism on Highway 64 in shrock New Mexico a one

243posted lighted post lighted school zone signs one hour prior to through 1 hour after the starting Bell and dismissal Bell schedules for shrock high school Eva stly Elementary and career prep EG 7:30 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. and 2:30 p.m. to 4:30 p.m. post radar speed sign showing the speeds of vehicles on Highway 64 and Implement a double time zone adopted um the other draft I have actually has this date sorry I'll put that back in um today's date by Central Consolidated School District Board of Education I stand for questions any questions or comments from the board okay thank you Miss Chapelle just real quick who who's this resolution going to uh this resolution was brought to us by board member Montoya after he observed some concerns on that Highway which you presented last Thursday and

244so ultimately this will go to New Mexico Department of Transportation but also um Navajo Nation so it's going to go to all of the entities that have something to do with the three requests um for number secretary so okay okay thank you thank you moving on to number six review consent items see below and items pulled from consent agena for discussion and or approval a possible item remov from consent agenda I um to remove letter D unique trip requests the Shiprock High School robotics club that would be the only item that would that I would I see item D no um Delta what was it that it was not it's an extended trip and not unique it was pulled from the reports Thursday and it was just it had automatically been added to the this

245the consent agend so now so already you been taken care of yes okay all right with that said I will make a motion to approve all the items listed for on the consent agenda with the exception of D second uh what about the one with the um Deborah yai it's not on the consent agenda it was just a report so motion by secretary so seconded by vice president Wells roll call vote board member Montoya yes board member aspis yes secretary so yes vice president Wells yes and I vote Yes and then number eight request action items Ann or reports for next meeting a possible items for next meeting uh the only comment I have regarding that is the fact that I was going to ask for discussion on the Strategic plan but since we're going

246to do that for the um Retreat I will acqu yes and take it down any other items yes I um I I want to discuss the light BR me I don't know what that's supposed to illuminate out there but it's not good so I I would like that brought back up again are you saying he doesn't light up your life or somebody's life anyway what's wrong with the light and where the light that bus stop light insufficient okay yes very very I don't know the picture that was provided to me it looked like it was bright but it was it's not it's not and and then it being in the middle almost well shouldn't exaggerate that's not in the middle of the field but it's way and I don't see how that's supposed to help

247well no no no no we're not discussing this she's just going to have it put on the agenda the next okay thank you are there any other items hand it to Alex uh yeah I guess going back to one of the prior discussion items that we had before on the attend rates and that that came up which is actually really good report um so rather than have this report kind of go all over the place I I suggest that we have structure and guidance that way there's more focus and we're not I mean where where where the where the M committing can go off the deep and is when there's no no guidance or structure so I suggest that the principles what with whatever report indicate one what is working two what are the existing

248challenges and their data uh three what is not working and four what has been done to improve outcomes at the schools that have been brought up that way I think if the principls or the persons at the school have more information that there's more structure rather than have it Go all over the place more Focus yes any other items okay I I would like to have a report on the Outreach by um human resources to the schools on our employ empy resources how that looks and um how the information is being disseminated I I do have one more yes go ahead slit my brain uh update on Community Schools where are we with that um are we expanding I know the state was looking at uh increasing or at least getting to the point where

249they were funding what they said they would initially uh so that may hopefully help us expand that can I make an invitation for Thursday could I make an invitation for Thursday is it a possible oh you already did no I understand that but I want that for the board so they can hear that so the community can hear that cool and just a couple things the reason I say that there is a field trip and I'll just reiterate in case you haven't seen emails um to bloom field to see Community Schools in action but also Thursday the blessing that we were going to do last week that was cancelled is going to be this Thursday 8 o' that um 8:00 a.m. yes in u the board roomans shro this Thursday this Thursday correct and then

250the field trip so if you want to come out to you can do both okay all right if okay and then next uh are there any other items last last call nope okay number nine plus Deltas uh board member Montoya uh Lively discussion thank you okay thank you uh board member asked this indeed there was Lively discussions and um and U I don't like being bullied and I don't respond to it very well um but if we want to go down that road I'm a veteran I I've been down that road and I will speak on behalf of my Advocates and my constituents and so I think um when I asked you know you're was wanting to rush and when he got up there and started his presentation I thought I was doing the ones

251that want to be out of here right away a favor by stopping him and letting him know this is not what I wanted and I I I don't know superintendent you're you were the one that was to relay the requests so um instead of wasting time or if you guys want to continue and hear the rest of it but that was the only reason why I disrupt him is that it wasn't what I wanted and nobody else seemed to be engaged um but I guess that looked like I was beating them over the head so it's a delta or member or secretary so sure I thought there's a good discussion on on a lot of topics our our data has also shown a sign significant Improvement across our district in terms of uh test scores

252and outcomes and hopefully that that translates onto the assessment that happens at the end of the year otherwise that's it thank you vice president Wells I thought we covered a lot of pertinent information U I think discussion and and understanding is important and relevant I thought we had a good yeah thank you um I always uh for me I think there was a lot of good good information that was shared areas that we can improve and areas that we are improving so it's always good information to hear and I appreciate all the people that were here earlier and all the people that are still here so I much appreciation to all of you so thank you be safe on the road home and I motion toour board member Montoya yes board M aspis yes uh

253SEC secretary so yes vice president Wells yes and I vote yes thank you [Music] I [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.