001to the flag the United States of America and to the for it stands godice member mandalen I'll make agend approval of the December 17th regular board meeting minut motion I do you want to vot on the yeah there was a there was a motion oh yes on the U approval of the agenda agenda thank you okay I'm take a vote Kathy Glenda yeah Peter and myself okay approve agenda V thank you every time all right thank you Dr Kam then we'll move to um e approval of the December 17th regular board meeting minut and I make that motion voice Cathy Peter well that only needs two of us so um we have to hold that till next meeting but you have a quum so you have a quum there's two extension and there's two V
002if there is half of the Corum I have two different knowledge on that one that if there is a motion and there is a 50/50 the motion St but I don't know what your okay you know what your goal is I think is Penny there no penny is not here oh so we have to uh wait till the next meeting okay you don't have a majority got so I think was for me no yeah two there next month so we'll go next month okay so we will table the approval of the December 17th um Regular board meeting minutes to next month's regular meeting um we'll go on to reports Madam president members of the board and uh colleagues community members good evening uh you have my report and I stand for questions and I just
003would like to uh first of all uh welcome the the board for a new year it's 2025 uh we did start strong we have about 25 26 of our instructional staff present during our uh January 6 training and we really covered a lot during the training so I appreciate the staff members uh commitment and dedication to attend those um we were able to um complete our indicator 133 submission and um the first semester recognition activities have been done by the three schools and we have some of our High School uh took took the asbab test so that is one of our high State Testing um I'm very happy to report that we have our uh water operator that started this year and and that means that we will be able to comply with EPA compliance
004and he has been on top I just uh I haven't reviewed the report but I have just gotten the initial report I'll share it with the board um and to address the previous concern and the district also entered into a contract regarding pest control services and we are address we will be doing deep cleaning and maintenance services is specifically on the elementary and the gyms so that will that will cover uh uh mice droppings infestation as well as B so it will be a yearl service they will do a deep clean and then they will do maintenance so I will update the board on um the service that has been rendered and what progress we're making with that um we have completed our 8th day Medicaid report we get reimbursement uh for Medicaid and that
005Medicaid funding um helps us pay for our nursing services and um um Miss Randy was able to submit our 80-day validation and we have been validated with our elll data so that's a big task because uh I know that from the last three years we were really trying to uh comply with the elll requirements uh our elementary middle school and high school have really done their best in the beginning of the year to start identifying kids and the process is still ongoing one thing that we are still uh trying to work on is to create give El services to the elementary so our El Services right now is limited to the middle school and high school with our um diesel Endor staff and we are hoping that we we should be able to if we
006need to provide compensatory Services we will definitely for the El kids uh we have some hiring uh we now have a hired preka and at the same time we are able to entice uh substitutes so we were able to clear background for three substitutes so that really alleviate our our uh operation need um there was some report and I don't know if you have heard about it uh districts that had been using Power School um it was in the news uh I believe there was some District in California or somewhere else that there was a data breach with the Power School uh uh student information system I cleared it with our partner from c as far as our district is concerned our main assist is the skywire we use po power school for our special
007education and that module of the power school with our district information was not uh was not part of the attack so I'm I'm happy to report that we were able to safeguard the students information there um we made some wins first uh first basketball of our girls have been doing well uh our Athletics director will inform us later but our boys basketball has won their first uh District game and um I will discuss later on um during another time uh the information that I've gathered uh from our training uh in uh the primary training legislative primary training in the capital and that uh we are looking at uh starting to we I'll present a draft District communication plan and then by February I will be able to present a district communication plan so that we
008can um ask I can ask the board for approval and that will really jum start our strategic plan uh information dissemination in different Medias including improving our uh website uh design and website information so an nice time for questions yes I was looking um on your report you said that you hired a prey teacher and then on this is Miss Ben's report said that a teacher a prey teacher was needed is that it's it's actually it's actually an EA so we've hired a pretty EA okay I I believe her sorry I believe her said that they hadn't hired an EA so I'm assuming that she maybe put the report before it did say that like wait we need two of them we are we we do have a good number of our prek we are
009already maxed and as of last week if no changes our PRK is already full for next year so we are um going to apply um for another fiveyear Grant of our prek and we are uh I have been meeting with Mrs Ben and the team so that uh during the application we should apply for uh at least two classes and getting funding I mean I have just uh just this morning I had a conversation with another parents who wanted to enroll her students so I'm not going to close so we're just going I mean it creates a pipeline for our students so the more students you can get the more that can help us any further questions [Music] Dr miss Ben Mrs Ben has to take care of uh family uh needed a family needed
010uh activity is's actually taking care of her husband and but you have her report she wanted to um share some information that award assembly uh was done upon the return upon the return for the new year reports report cards were mailed out and plans are being finalized for the schoolwide school choring beginning the first week of February and that we are applying for the renewal of a prek grant and that she will share data during next month uh school work any questions about I take questions [Applause] let's see good evening everybody members any questions regarding the report I [Music] submitted I didn't have one question on the um Ultimate Warrior I I know we've talked about it but um I did attend the assemblies and I didn't see anything about the Ultimate Warrior so how
011um what are are who the Ultimate Warrior how are those people going on so I decided that there are two ultimar field trips first one is going to be after the third quarter 14th of March and requirements for that is from the start the third quarter up until end of the thir quarter requirements that are in the staff handbook is that there is two attendance to twoes 2. average no issu through the office and telling parents of what those two things are the 10 activities are for both trips and so all the students are able to opportunity to earn it yest okay yeah I was a little confused no I had a similar question about what was like attendance like what all of that meant um and more of curiosity what is a student service
012[Music] teacher I do have [Music] here test so first of all if I can put it together the full page this the top just talks about the awards assembly that we had so I didn't have any perfect attendance but what I did was I the state says that the the state says that students should be present 95% of school base so I came up with a 95% tennis award and you see that we have eight sixth graders 10 seventh graders and 14 eth graders that met that requirement so they got certificate and certificate also said what percentage was 95 97% for their attendance that is as through our Sky program um next the honor Ro so he had the the honor which is a 3. 3.49 we had 22 students earn ma eight sixth graders
013eight seventh graders and 68th graders the principal's honor rooll which was the 3.5 to 3.9 point average 28 total five six graders and seven graders and 138th graders and the superintendent on was the 4.0 we had now as far as testing if you flip over to the back side that will tell you this is the print out that the program IA test gives us after the test so you'll notice if you on the first line [Music] says grade six beginning and the second line is grade six middle and so the next four spots is the uh seventh grade and then the eighth grade below those as you move to the right it's made of of three test the reason achievement the language usess achievement and Mathematics and under any one of those three areas that
014student can score in whether we need support near Target or On Target the underneath the end that's the number of students and the underneath the percentage is that the is the percentage of students that made that um that section of within the reports okay so you can look at that as a but um if you flip back to the front page now so I'm was going to go through this quickly but you'll see that the sixth grade there's there's nine boxes the top three sixth grade the middle seventh bot eth and so um for example on the sixth grade I I made a reading eight students were higher than they did before in the first test one student scored the same and seven students scored lower and seventh grade 11 students scored Higher One students
015scor the same 11 students scored lower than me in the first Tas finally the reading is last one the left hand corner uh seven students scor higher zero students score the same and 18 students score lower um the rest of them I'll let you go over yourself but importantly the last box on the bottom this is those three tests I uh on a chart I kept track of of how many students um did better for each test for example in sixth grade 11 students improved in one of the three tests two students improved in two test and three students scored lower than three tests all right no one scored uh above or improved in all three tests but seventh grade eight students approved in one test nine students approved in two tests three students approved
016in all three tests and one student scored lower in all three tests and lastly the e8th grade out 13 students approved at least in one test nine students approved in two test two students approving all three tests and two students SC lower so that's the kind of information that especially I can look at disseminate what areas of the test and what students are to talk to teachers about you know what they need to work on specifically so I just want to share a little you know balloon of what's happened so far this midle year I notic a lot once you take some time and go through yourself you'll see the the chart up here on the back you know as far as being on Target it's not as many it's well we always want to
017see more students be on target you'll see that some students that fell back regressed it's uh I no longer have access to it but when the test is given until the closing window I was able to see how much time each student would work did work on the test and some students you know took you they're giv 45 minutes some students were done in eight minutes some students are done in 15 minutes so there's a level of just being you know on task and take it seriously and you know it's the middle of the year and they kind of know that this one's not really the test so you know cross my fingers that when Real Deal Mak test they're going to take it seriously and U the fact is I just out the was
018five students that made no improvement everybody else improved somewhere within the testing so I think there's there's a good sign there also overall picture but that's all I have to say about that go ahead I was just going to say thank you for the information um you know this is kind of what we do need to see this information and I appreciate that You' taken the time to give it to us thank you the the middle the middle of the Year testing does that mean they came back from break no we took this before we took it before the break okay and when we came back I did what my had oh I'm just thinking about the regression pieces and if that maybe have played a role in it but it sounds like not okay
019that's it thank you very much yeah thank you thank you good evening MERS Dr and facy that's here uh Dr kind spoke a lot about it but we'll go over some things uh last week we did the ASAP test 10th through 12th grade um and so it went really well um we had last week we had our Awards assembly and quite video awards Kathy was there she's back she got to see a lot of kids up there really earn uh the grades in the high school were really really good first semester so very proud of them uh we worked really hard with the teachers and helping our students make sure they get games and they did that um Thursday we're doing the Ultimate Warrior as Mr why you explain the criteria for it and so
020Thursday will be the first trip and then the one at the end of the year they earn uh B attendance academic and of course this the three things that are based on um tomorrow we have a Royal College Fair uh school so I get a couple colleges so they can go and talk to them see if they're interested um and so I think they're getting a good idea of what college is like and I think some of them are really excited and they really want to be there so I I really think it's working exposure is number one key to it uh basketball so first of all I want to thank most of your board members and really all of your board members I've seen at the games and I see a majority of you
021at the game so I really appreciate your support because I know the kids do okay and and and so keep doing it the girls are on a good te right now uh Friday we had a I tell you what it was a big crowd and it was a really close game when we one by one the girls and I mean that team was really really good went through the schol and uh and uh doing so tour up on Wednesday but was great because we got to see the Freshman girls play a lot and then was there on Friday uh you know the boys they're they're trying we got some new players and they're trying to learn the system but you know as anything you know as progress built you're GNA you got to get War
022before you get better it's like no pay no game kind of thing so you know that's how programs are and so they've done a great job so uh the med school kids they're really there's a lot of numbers which is really optimistic for our program and we have a lot of big kids uh but they're learning how to play with each other and we haven't won many games in these the girls or the boys but they're they're they starting to get better um so they'll get there [Music] okay uh I don't have my but basically the yeah I one uh oh I did that was it so anyway that's that's it today keep going to the games we had a long stretch we have oo next week before I have another home game so no
023what are you going to do not go to games what do you think about fan appreciation fan appreciation we had officials appreciation last week uh to appreciate the officials so I think we should have huh yeah we had we I made I some accolades and we we played a little snet of how we appreciate our officials and stuff like that g we did we did really good our fish like come a fan appreciation so give me an idea what do you think go for the craziest Manan did that last year so we had the craziest fan not the craziest well not but the most outgoing energetic the girls didan fan all the voted they pck their own [Music] favor year during senior night we did um throw out throw out to the fans um goodies
024and no okay then I think previous years we had the credit donate to CES and then we just that's good idea couple years ago I think they had like each Elementary from the community they had like um E Valley the warrior night and stuff like that something like that I have to talk to experienced people they can tell me Valley that's first time you I'm not GNA say I'm new anymore but I'm still new on from last year so I want to know all those great ideas that work positive for our school of course good any questions thank you guys and see you the next thank you C the budget so um December checklist the expenditures um December checklist consists of Audio Visual services for student dance performance for the white house uh student prum
025meal expenditures supplies and materials for classrooms activities and supplies for Native American Heritage date um Tex supplies ancillary and HB repairs uh Randy submitted three bars for approval F 25147 which is impact 8 25145 impact a SP and both are the first payments received for the fiscal year of 2425 and 24174 this is the final war balance for CTP Randy did not submit any itts for this month um and discussion and review the district continues to work on Grant uh spend down plans with focus on CTE CSI title 4 andk Dr kamada and Randy attended a training at the capital this month regarding upcoming legisl legislative bills which would affect the upcoming budget of all the schools in New Mexico some of the changes are new pay minimums for teachers levels one three which also
026included increase to administrators minimum potential 3% increase for all School staff and this wased to you last month possibility as well as potential changes to the at risk factor and include family income index and the secg calculation this would be increasing the basic program unit for 6 through 12th grade there are there are concerns among districts the state have not funded Transportation appropriately as an example jbps suffered a decrease our budget from 24 2324 due to loss of student um Meers however there was no change to um the route or the miles and Theo has increased therefore forcing the district to supplement with operational dollars this area of concern is pushing districts to actively reach out to our representatives to any questions to the audit report M president I have our um first year Auditors
027um which is L and Farley is on our and he will be presenting on um our audit for fiscal year 2324 [Music] all right good morning uh making sure you can hear me okay and uh I am ready to present if you're ready for me we're ready okay uh we are uh you know this is a public presentation and uh we we have it fairly summarized just down to the essential facts but you know if you have questions I can always elaborate on on them uh for this audit uh it was the uh the last year you had to charter school as a component unit but I'll walk so the team that worked on the audit I was a partner in charge and mclen was the manager and supporting staff or other staff Susan uh
028Nate Kina helped out on the audit and uh then I'll just walk through these these remaining things the results of the audit any findings recommendations and then the some new accounting standard just that every year there's new rules up to be aware of uh the scope of the work was that we gave two opinions one on the financial statements and the other on the major federal program and in addition the state auditor's office requires testing of uh compliance items State statutes under uh state of Mexico and then apart from these opinions and in there's a area called nonattest or non audit work so that is when we put together the financial statements and not disclosures um that's a part of the opinion so we it's separate and we do that which we do for over
02995 96% of our audience and then moving on here here's the uh you know more specific uh things that occur dur in the audit so accounting practices one of the one of our requirements is to uh communicate what for the financial statements all the not disclosures appropriate yes they were everything's been disclosed and there was a new standard called gby 100 which is really a a rule that just talks about when if there's a restatement of equity which is that would be caused by an error or if there's a change in like you have a major fund versus a non- major fund so stuff like that that we deal with it as accountants and Auditors U has been implemented and then moving down to the list here proposed adjustments so we had six journal entries
030that we proposed and uh we use that word proposed because uh heus Valley your the district you basically will will review those make sure you're comfortable with those before you put them into your system and then you see the other adjustment was for the charter school um moving down you see that line called non pass so that's uh these are things that we're providing uh additional help calling it nonest adjustment or government wide so the full grow and there's a lot of adjustments involved there 54 adjustments at the school district and then do charg everything else is straightforward no adjustments that were immaterial so in other words if there was some small adjustment so we don't really have to make it because it doesn't affect uh the presentation to the reader um we can skip
031it but we would have to inform uh governance and managers but there were none no disagreement with management uh no discussion of any accounting before we started the AIT and those difficulties performance the audit so all pretty clean there and then moving on to the results and and findings um the opinions so the two opinions the financial statement opinion is unmodify so that means clean opinion uh or another way of saying the numbers that you see in the report are maturely correct and then the federal WS is unmodified that's clean opinion so we're saying that the school district is in compliance with with the uh expenditure of the federal dollars the major uh Federal program was the impact aid program and let's see are you as an a are you qualified to lower as a
032that's uh no and uh one of the reasons why because you had a material weakness finding last year and uh then after two years of no no material weakness findings and your eyes are done on time you would be considered a a lowrisk a below that hopefully you can see these or you can stop me for questions we have a summary of the findings so starting with last year's findings there were the one two three four five six seven findings last year and out of those seven findings uh six were resolved including that material weakness finding which was described as the maintenance of capital assets and then you had one finding that was repeated from last year the school athletic X act uh there's that state state compliance rule uh to report on on that
033on that Equity act and then the new finding you had a finding when we test the payroll uh the I were uh there was there were some that were not uh completed out completely written out or missing so that was the one new finding then uh this is a explanation so we had you'll notice we had all these type of finding and there's all kinds of letters there a b and H's so this page gives a a description or explanation what what type of finding are we talking about uh the new findings were all state compliance or audit role find then moving on uh really just talking about new standards coming out next year and there's one going to be uh it's going to affect competent asss like vacation approvals and so that will need
034be implemented next year we're ready to help you with that and and there's also uh some disclosure requirements this these are G we called certain risk disclosure so it'll talk about the concentration of finding sources and other things like that two years away there's there's two more uh gas fees out coming out the financial reporting model so the way the audits are presented there's going to be some changes and uh gxy 104 there is uh just some guidance Capital assets uh these are just uh more rules and these are well actually these are just some background on this this is the background on the rules I just described just move past those and then these are the projects so they're always working on new standards these are not finalized or they're not deping when they're
035going to come out but they're working on it so there's a you can see there's four projects as they call them uh that they're working on in 2025 and then two more in 2026 and three more in 2027 and other that that that you know keep it fairly summarized I'm happy to expand on anything You' like but that's that's the results of the other uh no thank you all right thank you thank you and I just would like to add that um if we continue with the district's processes and policy on how we do our activities um we should be out of those repeated things most of the repeated and the new is because of the San Diego revers so otherwise just the district we don't have any finding so but that means that we
036have to educate all our staff members that there is a reason why some certain procedures policies are incre because we want to be more and thank you m Ry for making should be on top of this happy with our new Auditors really great to work with and um was really excited about not having any findings this year for the district which is great so just everybody as a collective did really well and making sure that we did everything that we needed to to stay on top of these so I was really happy about it fre um all the ladies and office really helped out a lot and making it um possible I guess to get to this point so really happy about it you thank you Randy thank you a lot really appreciate it yeah
037my head okay um any public comments no public comment I do Madam president I do have a public comment for in behalf of the Hemes Valley Public Schools I'll take I would like to take this opportunity to extend uh the appreciation to our school board to all of you to all the five of you and uh we prepared a certificate of appreciation uh this month January is uh the uh School Board appreciation month and we would like to uh extend to you a certificate of appreciation this certificate is proudly awarded to you and there's a little bit of a uh an inspiring words if your actions Inspire others to dream more learn more do more and be become more you are a leader and thank you board members for for the term that you have
038spent with the district and uh for and in behalf of the hems Valley Public Schools the communities the students and the staff we thank you for your [Music] service and Mr Peter we have your certificate here um okay new business um celebrating students so I um had Dr kamada and Janice add these new business items because they are reflective of the things that I learned at the Mexico um board School Board Association conference and so I was hoping instead of just lecturing you all on when I learned to actually have a discussion around it or to get some feedback um and so I just have a couple of notes for each of these items and the first one a is celebrating students and one suggestion was some of these are very very simple and quick
039so bear with me but was to Simply have a shared Google doc for all teachers to just quickly brag about their students and I thought what a wonderful way for like an easy like Plug and Play for our school newsletters for our app in celebrating students I know that we talked I think Mr Davis talked a lot about like why are we not highlighting the students that are doing really well um and that just being another way to connect with the community and celebrate our students above and beyond sports or things like that um just like hey this person did good on XY andz today and that's wonderful so just an idea um any thoughts or want to add I just said um I think great um you know we've talked about it often how
040are we going to get this out and um you know this is something that I think is doable yeah so definitely to look at sure and I mean I'm not I'm not lying to how busy uh teachers are but um it was suggested as maybe an easier way and of like we do I have to write this to or email that I have to SS send versus it just being a quick and easy yes I mean speaking for the leadership this is a very very important aspect of our strategic plan sure because we really want to highlight the only reason we are achieving our strategic plan if we are celebrating yeah you know a positive reinforcement um one and I like the idea um the last two years since I was here um we probably
041have to U bring it back again we have a monthly um appreciation of students uh listen attendance leadership um students Pride so middle school high school we have the pride and any students have exhibited those Pride characteristic and um it can be uh through a referal from a teacher or a referral from another student but uh more than that we wanted to Market it so that's one of our uh communication plan how to Market ours our district and our product is our students so that's what we wanted to Market to show to the to the community and to anybody else is looking what is the achievement what are the achievements of our students so I I I am going to ask the school board for support and I'm going to meet with the leadership team
042to come up with a plan that is not just a one thing one time off but a uh with commitment and continuing program and definitely the student body you know the student body should be included in how they want to appreciate each other right so I think that's a that's a very very good uh activity for move on to the superation CLE um so I know that Miss Kath you're repeat yourself again again to me about when we do all of that but this was more so just a Pally informal feedback session um to one make sure that we're on track with our strategic plan and two to give more feedback um instead of just the formal feedback that we've been doing um so that maybe you know we can see more un tangible things
043happening or marking things off on our strategic plan now that we have it um I don't know any feedback on that is helpful I was just again another suggestion around how do we I think it is definitely something that we need to do um we have talked about trying to um you know be on the right cycle as we were moving through and um we just haven't got there so I and I'll I'll tie this into D when we get there but um yeah again something just more so for accountability and Mak same page throughout the whole year verus having gaps in communication that and on a personal note Mr Madame President and board members at this this is a welcome uh this is a welcome challenge because uh like I said I always tell
044my folks if we are if everything is already so so then there's nothing there's no point of doing things so we always wanted to um in as much as uh in as in as much as one of the reason that I chose to be in education is because it's not boring so every every day is a new it's a new things and even though you're teaching the same subject it's still not boring so um this is not just an accountability but this is really to establish that continuing dialogue because we if we need to change course we don't have to wait for the end of the year I would be able to present with the leadership and I think we say for example in our in our um isic plan if we already achieved it
045we don't have to wait five years to change the goal but if uh during you know in the in the quarter of of the year if we're seeing that there is some difficulty on in addressing the goal and I will come to the board to say I would like us to consider our numbers maybe we could not be 80% you know or then you know I think it keeps it keeps the dialogue between um the school and the board and it keeps everybody updated so I welcome that yeah I like um keeping the Strategic plan live document as supposed to be um would you would you be thinking more and I guess this is along the lines of more discussion but is it like workshops like you guys would schedule like workshops or just throughout
046each maybe you know select a board U meeting that happen within the quarter and then that you guys discuss it what were your your thoughts regarding um I don't know I guess that's up for discussion what that might look like um I and I can I can offer a review of what other formats are being used by other districts okay and then I'll be able to present and then uh next next uh next board meeting we can choose which form want to do yeah the reason I just say the workshop is because I mean post that and that's when all of you guys get to together and have those discussions where it's not just you know an email and then individual you know what just an idea of being able to get everybody you know
047IDE you know whatever it is that you guys want to discuss so that was my first thought is probably a workshop but again I don't know I don't know how you guys were thinking good point really good and um if I'm not mistaken I'm still supposed to invite the board for U um a nice today Workshop so that would be a good Avenue so that we can has out and then what you yeah yeah um thank you for um okay uh C the use of AI so there was a lot of discussion around the use of AI and plagurism and what kind of um guidelines we have for that not just in our policy and procedure but in student handbooks and what they're expected to do and not do and how teachers what trackers they're
048using to catch um AI written essays and things like that and I'm not sure if I'm and please correct me if I'm wrong but when we approved the student handbook I'm not sure there was something specific about Ai and I know that that's like maybe newer and things like that but it was crazy some of the things that they were presenting just to tap and just like shaking said yes um like he told AI please write a essay about X Y and Z and make sure you use an eighth grade reading level with some grammar mistakes and make it a b grade and it pops out this very exact thing so I mean being able to catch something like that that's a little bit more more difficult that looks like okay the student wrote it
049versus a student who handed it an F paper last semester and is all of a sudden making A's right and so um just looking at what kind of training teachers may need to like be more strategic about that um to catch things again having an accessible tracker for them to kind of plug in an essay and see um I think Google had a a plagerism tracker um so and just some thoughts around how do we edit the academic uh dishonesty handbook and policies and how we going to go about that um even down to like disciplinary actions for it um definitely something new so need to into yeah our policies as well I did address this with our instructional staff when we came back to our uh PD on December 6 because it's an inevitable
050reality and not just the students staff members or anybody have access to AI phone yeah um one thing experience wise we did have um I know for a fact has report to me that um at least one of the teacher runs the submission in a an AI tracker wonderful and uh she was really able to say okay okay this was really no you know none even if for example they did use an AI they've learned a skill on how to paraphrase it yeah so I I always say it I said copying is it uh wrong or bad and I said well it is bad if you're using it to you know to to uh get get on top of somebody else to ruin an opportunity of somebody but if you're asked you have to copy
051this we have to know we have to teach our kids how to properly copy it sure but that is a very very good uh discussion topic and we do have to adapt I agree we do have to adapt um ped is uh going to have a Statewide um they are inviting a Statewide um discussion on AI and because it's it's not it's hug but of course as a local board we do have to also to consider our own policy and um but at the same time just on a teaching aspect uh without a policy um my first uh Instinct was to have a conversation with our staff that we have to learn what the students are learning what they're using we cannot um if they're using AI we have to know how AI works so
052that we can have an informed uh knowledge on what are we going to look for yeah you know how are they asking questions and then what part of AI what kind of AI generators they have and the more the staff are familiarized the more that we are equipped on creating a policy handle and say for example and and I when just a simple writing of less of that now if the goal of the lesson is for a child to write uh to write uh a simple sentence of a subject and a verb now okay uh are we are we testing the are we grading the handwriting are we are we grading the subject and the verb are we grading the punctuation so the goal it become a teachable moment to say the teacher okay yes
053you can grade on the subject where you can know I said you know you did not capitalize but I'm I going to am I going to reduce the score for the child because the child did not capitalize but my goal is to teach writing a subject and a ver and the same thing with AI um uh when Twitter was first used my experience with that was uh u in the special education resource I have um Twitter was allowed but because it's a form of communication now my goal is for the student to communicate but is if the goal is to concentrate and follow the that tweeting in my class is a no yeah so it's of course definitely it's a balancing act but I think being ahead of the game is going to be very
054important because uh in as much as technology is getting sharper our students is getting sharper too and uh we have that the staff members has to learn with the time and um I did discuss it during our PD uh we want our students to learn that means the staff members we should also open we should also be open to learn new things and you know just to insulate us because um if if we if the adults don't know how these things work then it's easy for the students to to get by you know oh oh they're using this generator I'm going to use a different they using this Checker I'm going to use a different generator you know so but I do understand and I agree uh we do have to have an AI policy
055and um both for the Integrity because the grade must be must have integrity if we give a 90 we are saying that our graduate got a 90 and they better be ready when they go to college because it's it it will not look good when him as Valley Public School graduate you you gave a child uh a valedictorian and you said that they have a 4.0 but they could not even write this kind of paragraph so that is what we are trying to address with our strategic plan and our portrait of the grad so it's a job for the adults in the district to make sure that the Integrity of the grades the Integrity of the certificate the Integrity of the de that we give means something so and I agree and we will with
056your permission M president um this policy is going to be um a CommunityWide efforted of students and will attend during during the remas I I understand that there's an AI agenda School train and I understand there AI most of the PV right now all has AI I attended gifted training they talk about AI so we do have to we do have to address a thank you any other thoughts or questions on that we forward okay the next One D policy and procedure updates discussion and action so I'm just going to read what my proposal was um I think I sent s you guys this in an email so um I propose that we choose a section of our policy and procedure manual during each regular meeting the aim is to discuss assess and Implement changes
057as the board finds necessary during the presentation at the um conference it was really looked down upon that we just take this manual and plug it into our website and call it good without truly reviewing it and then it kind of comes and slaps us in the face when we don't really know what's in our policy and teure manual and somebody comes and says well I follow the policy and so just like the things we've talked about before the evaluation cycle having that in sstone and plugging that into our policy having um the AI and plugging that into our policy um and I think that if we take small sections of it every regular meeting it's very doable to read through it and decide what we're going to change the wording the dates whatever um
058so that it doesn't feel so huge that's a big book to go through um but I truly think that if we were to just section it off little by little we could get it done I'm not sure if that's been done before with the board or anything like that maybe I'm like repeating things that have already been done in the past do you guys tell me um we didn't go through complete U but our superintendent one of previous superintendent did go through it and and um so there was a lot of changes that were made but I know that there's changes that need to be made so I think you know somehow I kind of wondered you know well when do we get to the policies and so yeah I think you know it has
059to be done at some point and I don't know again is it a workshop session that we do and you know take that section and look at it because it is very time consuming so you know maybe that's throughout our workshop and then we go through it um you know as we need to not as we need to but um not every week but oh yeah yeah yeah for sure not every week yeah um I met like every regular meeting um yeah my experience I I had experience three different uh uh three different uh experiences with Al I had an experience wherein we just everybody has a copy of the policy and then we present approval because it was already uh reviewed by legal counsel and things like that I also did have an experience
060especially in a big District that every month we take like H section by section you know and we present because it's an actual reading yes and then we read and then we say I strike this out we add these words and so and then there's like first reading second reading and then adoption and then I've also did I also had experience wherein it's a work session so there's a regular school board but the regular our regular school board is very very good TimeWise but then uh I saw a calendar of school Bo board meeting where in every month there's like a regular school board on a work session school board work session school board work session soorry during work session it does um they talk about the policy they to dissect those are three different
061experience I have I don't I don't know any other experiences and um in each of those experiences it work uh you know uh I was a part of the policy when it comes to with at least two uh exercise wherein uh it was reviewed by the council uh copy for the board and then present for approval and then I also have personal experience wherein because I'm special education so I have to present the special education part of the policy and right there and there it's a long like about because it has to be read it has to be read and uh page one strike out uh uh strike out line number 10 and then you know add this and then draft it again and then first uh second reading we the draft and then present
062it to the third reading for adoption so those were my experiences and of course I understand and I really appreciate that that that the school board is acknowledging the primary function of a school board which is policy review and adoption so knowing that you are invested in actually reviewing the policy gives me you know gives me some uh Comfort because we refer I whatever administrative decision we make we refer to the to the policy and if the policy is not working on our favor it's a we fail you know so we definitely would like to address that and I am open to have a discussion on the best way the most practical way uh at the same time without encumbering in your time and but as far as the district leadership is concerned we're here
063to work for you so we did have a prev superintendent because for years and years and years the district kind of went with um contracted Services um did all of our board policies and it was multiple districts that um paid this this one individual and he just kind of created all the policies for all the districts however when we had the superintendent come in she noticed that a lot of the policies intertwined with process and so it was really tying our hands when there were certain that came up like administrative and so what we did was I believe this 2122 and I could be wrong so we ended that contract of services we hired oural Council and they did all of our policy to be just strictly policy and take out all of the process
064and let us just put all of the process into our student and employee um but I know I get where you're going with this and that you do have to look at the policies and kind of make sure that like you said we don't have an a policy right so looking to see strict policy and then putting the process into our handbooks as to you know do this and this or you know what not um so I would just ask and again this is just my input that we continue to keep policy separate from our processes and that go into our handbooks but if we do continue as a board and Dr want to um proceed with policies updates and things like that that we just have legal to make sure that the language because
065once we get into litigation every word yeah and so that would just be my only um recommendation on that but we do have to look at the poliy for example super evaluation you know that's been kind of talked about for a couple of years now so yeah just looking at those different things I think that's a great idea but that would just be my my only ask is if this is something that we the district and the board proceeds with that we just kind of remain keeping them separate and then just have legal counsel yeah when start asking about the changes and things like that and um and then we can we can do a tri right and say for example for this year we can divide our policy sections I believe we have like
066five sections in there five well one of the policies that we're probably gonna have to look at again is AR so it kind of swwa last Administration and in this incoming Administration we don't really know what's going to happen so that's one thing that's definitely going to be on the table and then so we would have legal um definitely give us input what needs to be like very specific language and the title process so um I think you asked about policy and like when we update stuff I feel like that question came up at some time and I was like that's I don't really know like how often we have to like change it and look at it because I only know for certain areas that I look at like title n and those sorts
067of things like I wait for legal to tell me this what we need to do yeah but um yeah I think that's yes but I I I agree and um since I've been here I know there's a policy and I use it but we do need to review it and so we can do a trial to say for this year we'll divide I believe there's like six or seven sections in the policy we divided into four and then every quarter I mean most probably there's there's some section that you probably don't want to change yeah or you know and some you know and then we will see how fast or how um how slow it can be and then next year we can adap to say for starting 20 uh starting January 26 this is
068going to be the process of review so we can do a TR it and you know we could do one section every month or we can divide the whole policy into four and we can do part review and and then you know of course but I'll I'll of course um we'll consult with our legals on how to how to go about with the policy review I mean I'm only talking with my experience when we have to do first reading second reading and third reading approval so I have to rush up and um um also you know on that um I don't I think we do need to have a discussion as to whether we're going to do it in the workshop or in meeting because when we do do the readings I think we have
069to do the readings and that is very very time consuming and as we went through those alone just the readings um those were our late nights you know 10 11 o' going through some of the readings and stuff so I you know I would like to see what legal says or you know we have to discussion as to when we're going to you know look at them and take that time because it is a lot time yeah and we can be strategic to say we can you know we can during one of our Workshop we can identify out of seven sections which what what is the thing like AI then say okay what part of section will it will it affect it's going to impact instructional section it's going to Impact Staff Personnel section and
070then it's going to impact discipline section so we can review those sections to say where can we end where you know where we can put and then we'll ask our legal for a suggestion and then I'll present it to you and then you know I mean trial and err but I agree we do need to review so we do need to review an update it's just a question of how we can act Peter did you have something to add I know that a I always mentioned that that's our our primary focus our job is to procedures so mentioned that and me so I think and then by I know it's to me but you know there something in there that to be Chang there was another strategy and I never had that experience the board
071and the board divided themselves into different committees and then you know each of the board choose a policy section and that they meet with the leadership team separately and then the board comes up and then because the board you can already identify which I mean you can agree this is what collectively this is what we want to change and then in each section and then you come back during we come back during work session and then we go just different formats but I think but I think everybody we do have to change remembering I just ition discussion as to what's gonna work best us definitely moving forward what we need to do but what's our best yeah I mean definitely time froming that I view it as like our security blanket my security blanket has
072a bunch of hold in I don't some can't anymore right so um even if we even take smaller pieces if it feels like it's too overwhelming for a human human being to go through a whole section like maybe we break up the sections themselves into more manageable pieces because I know all of us are busy and so not to you know consume all of your time outside of our meetings but um why not make it smaller why not make it work for us there's no time I would imagine there is no time restraint on we're putting this on ourselves no one else is putting it on us so so um and this is just my uh thought Madame President uh when we do that um that invitation for a workshop with the board would you
073prefer me to invite uh legal council to give us uh legal guidance on how we can do policy you know what's reading one you know what's required just a training sure okay 30 minutes an hour 30 minutes one hour give us just legal you know legal parameters again so everybody understands you know what the process is in the policies and working okay um so it is an action item so I guess a motion to um I'm not sure um at least start the process for updating our policy and procedure manual does that feel okay and then maybe starting that process with the workshop with the training yeah so I'll make that motion okay do I have a second or do you want to stay stay um no I think I think we're okay yes I
074have a question is there anything in the policy currently that says that we have to update the Poli year I'm there's no statement in there now I don't have my book that I have no idea just my question if there's anything already saying that we have to do updates every year because I know that Law changes every year and we have to go by what the state does to especially now there's a lot of changes in education that we have to kind of go with and also what we want support as far as proces what's work for us what's work us for our kids in the district but then there's also state that we have to abide by as well too right that's a good point Peter I I don't know the answer to your
075question but if there isn't one we could add it and if I me mam president in our board policy there is board policy series 100 uh section uh section 110 yeah section 110 and it's it's titled policies of Board of Education and there's a there's a summary there's a introduction and then development of policies policy development adoption and review consideration and Adoption of policies and ongoing review of District policies ongo so it it does have those and basically the superintendent will recommend in the ongoing review and if I may read uh the superintendent will recommend to the Board of Education which policy should be reviewed Revis on a rotational basis the superintendent shall develop recommendation for changes and the board May accept or reject for modify the superintendent's recommendation in conformance with state and federal
076law the board may direct the superintendent to seek external advice from legal counsel and or policy consultant as it sees F in aing section paragraph clause or provision of this policy manual for any reason shall be held invalid and Parable the invalidity or enforceability of such section paragraph shall not affect any of the remaining provision so it's pretty broad basically so yeah I think in PR years that's what we have done and CH and it does have the provision of first reading second reading so it does have that first reading that's remember we've done in the [Music] past previous superintendent and so I mean I'm just reading a policy right now in the policy as it is written and you can revise this it says it shall be the duty of the superintendent to recommend
077needed policy and manual change so and of course it goes back to the primary function of the board yes is policy you know so yeah I mean that's how it's right so but yeah but would like to to revisit that because it has to be right up to the whole board yeah so I guess for the for tonight though the motion is to start the process of a policy procedure update with a with scheduling a training for legal councel yes well a training for us with legal with legal counsel yeah and then we can just you what it does see the board may direct the superintendent to seek external advice from legal councel uh as it says fit so the motion could be a directive to the superintendent so the motion is everything in there
078already uh Kathy made a motion I need a second oh there a second no I need a second oh there's no second second I'm sorry Peter can you repeat that I mean if there's no there's no there's a motion there's no then I'm I'm asking for a second oh oh okay so there's four board members yes there's four board members oh okay president um so Peter I could um restate my motion um that we um ask the superintendent to um get guidance um from legal action do I have a second so we're going train yeah me [Music] so do you second that yes so okay can I do I have a second I believe correct me if I'm wrong Mr M president can I can I clarify um uh you are okay with the you
079are seconding the motion to direct the superintendent to start the process up to to seek legal council on how to uh proceed with policy review and amendments yeah thank you Peter okay um um V Kathy Peter and myself all right uh we're going to move on to consent agenda I will make a motion that we approve the consent agenda Voice v Kathy Peter and myself and now Advanced planning um upcoming board meetings is February 18th um I'm to dates March 18th the 15th of April a 20 of May and the 17th of June um board trainings the board Institute is February 13th through the 15th in Santa Fe and the annual nfba conference is in April um the 4th through the 6th in Georgia and do we need to go into the executive session uh
080Madame President just for the advanced tring um just for each of the board to identify a date on the later part of February or beginning in the last two weeks of February or the first two weeks of March for our 90day Workshop whatever is and we don't have we have to decide now no because we still a February okay okay so yeah so need dates yes and it's you know I I believe a one day is enough uh for our uh Workshop unless okay uh do we need to go into session yes I like to sh and uh with Advan planning this we don't have to vote that right I'll make ites I make a motion we go into executive session okay L Peter into executive session at