001we have nothing here okay good all right are we ready to go yeah this okay this we don't need nope this is later just waiting for Hank to all right if everybody please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for it stands one nation God indivisible with liberty justice for all please be seated good evening everybody and welcome to our regular Board of Education meeting for the month of December 2024 it's great to see a a good turnout in a room full of people um I know many of you are here to hear an update on regionalization we have moved that up in the agenda we will be uh discussing regionalization after we get through the student presentations like we did
002the last meeting to that end we're going to move into recommended actions which is the approval of minutes recommended motion be it resolved that the Board of Education make any necessary Corrections and move the approval of the minutes of the regular meeting dated November 2st 2024 the executive session dated November 26 2024 the work session dated December 12th 2024 the executive session dated December 13 2024 and executive session dated December 14 2024 do I have a motion motion second Diva discussion all in favor unanimous so carried okay with that we're going to move into our standing reports and the first will be the report from middle school student council Kaye way good good evening and welcome good evening my name is Kaye way and my name is Sarah we are eighth grade students at Jericho
003Middle School it is a pleasure to be here this evening The Sound of Music and the spirit of giving have consumed the halls of the Jericho Middle School this holiday season the seal monthly theme is respect and responsibility respect involves being dependable and responsible as well as being there for others through all the times in their lives it involves fulfilling tasks with reliability dependability and commitment many of our students were involved in the Beautiful music that has been filling our ears and feeding our souls our jazz band performed on Monday December 9th in the auditorium the Middle School winter band concert was held on Tuesday December 17th where family and friends were entertained by our very talented middle school students the Middle School Musical Beauty and the Beast was on Thursday December 5th and Friday
004December 6th congratulations to all the students who have participated Jericho history day will take place on Tuesday January 8 28th during the school day all the seventh and eighth graders participating will showcase their rights and responsibilities history projects good luck Jericho the Jericho Middle School store will be open tomorrow during the Lunch Period shop for spirit wear what a great holiday gift please take a look at the January calendar we have quite a few parent information nights for incoming 6th 7th 8th and incoming nth graders so mark your calendars now our our winter 2 Sports will begin on Tuesday January 21st our last day is tomorrow Friday December 20th we hope you have a h happy and healthy holiday we will see you 2025 thank you at this time we'd like to move to the
005high school student council report Max sharf and Rachel [Applause] Lee yeah I'm not Max please introduce yourself thank you hi I'm rier ready welcome good evening members of the board and Jericho Community we're excited to share the highlights of recent events and achievements in our school Community showcasing the incredible highlights of December unfortunately my co-president and Max couldn't join us today as Caitlyn's dribbling away right now in the home game here at the Sam Springer gym let's go girls basketball speaking speaking of basketball the girls basketball team were the champions of the 10th Annual Jericho Classic on December 4th this was their first title since 2017 huge congratulations to the team from November 12th to December 6th the student council collected toys for Bill Pharaoh's annual toy annual toy drive arranged by the student council
006and National Honor Society a record number of toys were collected this year from all schools in the district and from Jericho's administrators toys games and other desired items were able to support over 650 families this holiday season on December 7th the high school hosted its annual talent and F fion show which featured student performances and student models the event brought together students teachers and families for an unforgettable night filled with Applause and laughter although we had many talleon students Mr grishman Mr Mev and Dr Finley definitely stole the show with their vibrant outfits and elegant walks on December 9th our music department turned up the holiday spirit with their Jazzy winter night and Winter band concerts and this week we're in the middle of our high school holiday spirit week so far we've had holiday
007Pajama Day Tundra Tuesday white lie Wednesday character day and tomorrow we're looking forward to holiday sweater day it's been incredible to see the Jericho Community come together and so show so much spirit and holiday cheer Jericho fpla hosted a shark tank entrepreneurship pitch competition including special guest sh guest shark Dr sunri and Mr Manuel congrats to freshman Selena woo for winning first place on Wednesday the music debt with the cast classes s carols this morning and sold hot ch cholate and thank you to the Jericho student ambassadors club and NHS for their candy gram sales this weekend Jericho's annual wrestling tournament the dick dra cup is happening this Saturday in the Fieldhouse good luck to the wrestling team that's all for this month have a great break and a wonderful [Music] holiday thank you this
008time we'd like to move to the report of the PTA Council alien gingle [Music] good evening Mr grishman Board of Ed members Central Administration faculty staff and community members I am aen gingold and I am the President of the Jericho joint PTA Council and is my pleasure to be here tonight the Jericho joint PTA Council has had a busy month at our meeting this past Monday we hosted Dr hartnet Dr D marinas and Miss cunas from the JTA we had great conversations regarding regionalization and cell phone usage in school while every everyone's opinion might not be aligned we were able to have civil and respectful discourse this is something we hope the community to do can do as well after last month's Board of Education meeting we were disappointed in our community and the tone
009that resulted we need to remember that our Administration teachers board members and PTA work very hard to do what is in the best interest of all of our students the strength of our school district has always been our civility let's always remember to actively and respectfully listen to one another our nutrition committee had a great meeting with daa michelini from Aramark this month as well daa spoke to us about the new breakfast program that high school students are taking advantage of since many of our students are coming in early for driver's ed extra help and clubs we now offer breakfast consisting of bagels waffles oats reduced sugar cereals and breakfast sandwiches in addition parents should be aware of the amazing lto or limited time offerings on our menus if you haven't checked them out they're
010posted on the district website all of our units were busy this month with holiday boutiques Book Fairs pie sales and submitting entries for PTA Reflections canti has been busy preparing for its Winter Dance in February Ratner Seaman ran an amazing Community Drive this month to help Island Harvest for Thanksgiving and donated over 700 pounds of food Jackson Elementary showed the movie Moana and their family movie night at their family movie night and sold out over 240 seats what a nice give back to their family the middle school is getting ready to set to run its first winter Boutique and is selling many spiritwear items the high school is busy planning for their senior party and fundraising events and the high school and middle school had a great treat for all teacher staff and administration this
011morning as a sign of their appreciation for all that they do our PTA Facebook page has been permanently shut down anyone wishing to follow their school social media page or Council should check Instagram for information or the school district website every unit including SEPTA has Instagram Pages where events and information can be posted and found two important events to add to your calendars is the college majors night which will be a zoom on Tuesday January 7th at 7 pm and our course information night on Thursday January 9th at 7M both events are going to be so informative and helpful to your students so make sure to attend I would like to wish everyone a happy and healthy holiday season thank you and good night thank you alen at this time we're going to move into
012the uh update on regionalization there's going to be some additional information we're going to be adding to the agenda so at some point uh we will be making a motion to to move that into this uh topic as you recall on our last regular Board of Education meeting on November 21st just before Thanksgiving we took a position uh where we indicated that we were going to aggressively pursue legal action if the state failed to withdraw essentially uh this plan of regionalization at their at the board of regions December 9th and December 10th meeting unfortunately their verbal assurances fell short of what the Jericho Board of Education was looking for uh and we promptly began um moving toward uh retaining legal repres presentation and looking into pursuing the most vigorous Avenues possible to that end um
013at this time uh we will be discussing this evening and you should all have a draft copy of Mr grishman's letter addressed to the New York State uh Office of Education policy of the New York State education department uh if you'd like we can have Mr grishman read it um but like I said this has been posted to our website it is dated tomorrow because that is the uh the date that this must be submitted uh or rather we have to approve it first but we were going to be submitting this tomorrow to to ensure that we're within the uh the timeline stipulated by the state is currently on our website correct it is in our website and again paper copies are available if you didn't receive one uh please feel free to get one
014from the back of the room so to that end uh just to give you an update on where we stand with respect to regionalizations Jericho Board of Education again this evening will vote uh and I anticipate that we'll be opting out of that process furthermore uh we intend to pursue or we will be voting uh to pursue uh aggressive legal action against the New York State education department for failure to essentially meet our demands that this this plan be withdrawn uh the board of education has been diligent in researching this speaking both with in-house counsel as well as special counsel uh we held a meeting with special counsel earlier in the week where we got the specifics regarding the article 78 proceeding which at this time based upon the legal advice that we've been giving
015is the most appropriate and most uh vigorous and aggressive position that we can take so with that um that's where we stand with respect to the regionalization conversation so at this time the board this evening uh will make a motion to retain special legal council to pursue article 78 action against New York State education department I'm sorry sir no we're talking about it but yeah no I'm just kind of laying it out as a summary and then we'll have to get into the business where the board actually has to do this so again this is you know the discussion that's been G ongoing we formally have to adopt this but I just you know in the interest of full transparency I want to let you know what the the process has been there's a second
016facet to this and this is something that you know we've kind of touched upon but have not really discussed in any detail and it's not part of the same rule but it's in many ways um uh assister Rule and that is expanding the responsibilities and authority of the Bose's superintendent and again uh based on conversation it is my personal opinion that the bosei superintendent should have no Authority that suedes the Jericho superintendent and certainly No Authority that supersedes local control and the Jericho Board of Education so again there is a comment period This is a rule that is supposed to go into effect later uh the board of education has been discussing that and we will vote tonight uh to determine how to proceed any questions specifically on that so at at at this time
017the the Coalition is working with the the same attorney that we're working with so we're doing everything that the the the Coalition is doing but we we'll talk more about that in a bit okay does anybody want to add anything to the background so let's just get into yeah absolutely I just wanted to kind of give you a background on on what's been going on and what we've been doing um that being said so at this time um we're going to need to make a motion to move number four in new business which is the resolution authorizing the commencement of a cplr article 78 proceeding regarding regionalization okay I think he just wants to move you want I was going to bring together I just want to move that to to the reports in discussion
018okay and then right and then the other thing and Mr good I just want to make sure we can do this we can also uh bring the proposed resolution for the Bose uh superintendent our opposition to that is that correct yes you you would just have to move to put the resolution on the agenda because that part's not there and then you'll move it all into one resolution okay and you'll approve all three the same time is everybody okay with that all right so we're just going to need a motion to move a proposed resol res olution I'll let Sam read it I will make the motion to move the new resolution which unfortunately I distributed all my copies here the new resolution be it resolved the Board of Education of the Jericho school district
019will vigorously pursue all legal remedies to the fullest extent of the law should the New York State education department fail to withdraw or substantially change their proposed regulation expanding the responsibilities and authority of Board of Cooperative Education Services bosies superintendence over component districts as reflected in the addition of subpart 124-128 nycrr so I make a motion that we add that resolution to the agenda I'll second yeah any discussion on that could someone just email me the uh resolution absolutely thank you thank you and we're also going to add um move up number four well we said that already we're going to move up number four and we're going to be sending a letter tomorrow to the state the the letter um is very similar to the letter that we sent last month about regionalization I
020will read it quickly if you need it it will get posted on our website in a day or two to the hours that be we are writing to express our concerns regarding the recently announced addition of subpart 24-1 to title 8 nycrr expansion of board of Cooperative Educational Services osies superintendent responsibilities and authority over component school districts and its potential impact on our students Educators and community at large first and foremost we believe that any significant changes Andor initiatives that affect our district should only be implemented with the explicit approval of our local Board of education our board has a deep understanding of the unique needs priorities and challenges of our students and community and it is essential that we maintain local control over decisions that directly impact our educational system we respectfully insist and
021I apologize I'm reading the wrong letter um I was just anyone gonna point that out no I'm sorry we were dealing with two drafts this is the correct draft I apologize it says it's stronger the Jericho Board of Education after extensive disc us involving its members Administration and Community unanimously passed the following resolution at our board meeting on December 19th 2024 now clearly that unanimously is dependent upon how the vote goes resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the Jericho school district will vigorously pursue all legal me remedies to the fullest extent of the law should the New York State education department fail to withdraw a substantially changed their proposed regulation expanding the responsibilities and authority of board of Cooperative educational Services superintendence over component districts as reflected in the addition of
022subpart 124-128 nycrr this resolution underscores the seriousness of our position we believe that any significant change Andor initiative that reflects our dist that affects our district should only be implemented with the explicit approval of our local school board the concerns raised by our community reflect a profound and Collective commitment to maintaining the integrity and autonomy of our educational standards in governance we urge the New York State educational education department to carefully reconsider the proposed expansion of bosei superintendent Authority included in the proposed 124 D1 to title 8 NC nycrr we believe the complete withdrawal a substantial overhaul of the language and intent of the rule is necessary to address the significant concerns raised by stakeholders Statewide thank you for attention to thank you for your attention to this critical matter we look forward to your
023response thank you Sam so if this sounds familiar it it should because this is a almost identical letter that we sent to the state with respect to regionalization and essentially what it allows us to do is essentially positions Us number one to express our our vigorous opposition to this rule as well as positions us to take legal action if need be so I know there's a lot of moving Parts here so just to summarize uh the first part of this that we're going to be addressing is um for having a vote to to formally opt out and have Mr grishman send this letter to the state which is the the uh intention uh secondly um we're going to be making a motion to retain legal council to pursue the article 78 uh legal action against
024New York State education department for their implementation with with the with other schools correct it's part of a class so it's not just Jer we joined the attorney group or we joined the attorneys that the the Coalition has has joined so we're part of that that that same group with respect to uh retaining the attorney and third is um taking the initial step to express our opposition to this rule regarding uh expansion of Bose's superintendent Authority so with that I'm gonna I'm sorry yeah we we can talk about that that's f um okay so we'll move on to the uh the actual verbiage back to regionalization I know this again is is a little uh complicated whereas on September 9th 2024 the New York State Board of regions approved by emergency adoption the addition of
025part 124 and subpart 1243 D2 to sub chapter e of the regulations of the commissioner of Education relating to regionalization plans regionalization regulations and whereas at its December 9th 2024 meeting the New York State Board of regions approved the regionalization regulations for final adoption as amended the amended regionalization regulations and whereas the amended regionalization regulations added a section 124 Hy and two uh point8 titled non-participation which provides a mechanism for a school district to elect not to participate in the development of a regionalization plan by notifying the New York State education Department's Office of Education policy of such election in writing by no later than January 15 2025 and every 10 years thereafter and whereas at the December 9th Board of region meeting the New York State education department Representatives further asserted verbally that notif
026we're gonna we're gonna we're gonna take it out yeah we're gonna take it out because okay fine asserted that not I'll just read that again whereas at the December 9th Board of educations meeting the New York State education department representative further asserted that notification elect not to participate under the amended regionalization regulations constitutes an opt out of the entirety of the regionalization process including the development and implementation of a regionalization plan and whereas the Jericho Union Free School District strongly opposes any initiative that jeopardizes local control of our schools or distributes taxpayer dollars and resources to other jurisdictions and whereas the preservation protection and maintenance of complete and total local control of all School District Operations is Paramount importance to the board of education and administration and in the best interest of the Jericho School
027Community our students and our schools and whereas after review and consideration of the amended regionalization regulations the Jericho Union Free School District has determined that it will not participate in the development of a regionalization plan or any aspect of a regionalization plan now therefore be it resolved in accordance with the forgoing the Jericho Union Free School District hereby exercises its election not toart participate in the development of a regionalization plan or in any aspect of the regionalization plan unless otherwise subsequently authorized by the Board of Education and be it further resolved that the superintendent of schools shall provide written notification of set election to not participate in a regionalization plan to the New York State Department's Office of Education policy prior to January 15 2025 the second part of this do we want to discuss
028that first or do you want to just whatever you want to just read them all and then we'll we can discuss any part we have to read the article 78 uh proceeding is are you okay with that unless you want to disc okay so I'll continue just in the interest of of of time and then we can just have one larger discussion um resolution authorizing the commencement of a cplr article 78 proceeding regarding regionalization recommended motion whereas the New York State Department of Education has adopted rules and any amendments modifications related or reopt rules Associated therewith and whereas the board of education has determined that litigation against the New York State education department the commissioner of the New York State education department the board of regions the chancellor of the board of regions and or
029any other parties as identified by council is necessary to seek to anull modify Andor amend the rules now therefore be it resolve that the Board of Education hereby authorizes the law firm Rano LLC to commence legal action against the New York State education department the commissioner of the New York State education department the board of regions the chancellor of the board of regions and or any other parties as identified by Council pertaining to the rules titled development and implementation of regionalization in the New York state Register and any amendments modifications related or reopt rules Associated therewith and be it further resolved that the Board of Education hereby approves Rano LLC to spend no more than $10,000 on such legal action in coordination with other school districts and less approved by the Board of Education and
030be it further resolved that the board president is authorized to sign a retainer agreement with the law firm regano LLC which retainer agreement has been reviewed by the Board of Education and authorizes regano LLC to take all steps necessary to effectuate the litigation and lastly is the proposed resolution regarding the bosei superintendent action be it resolved the board of educ of the Jericho school district will vigorously pursue all legal remedies to the fullest extent of the law should the New York State education department fail to withdraw or substantially change their proposed regulation expanding the responsibilities and authority of the board of Cooperative Educational Services bosis superintendence over component districts as reflected in the addition of subpart 124 D1 to title 8 NYC RR all right so at this point we need a a motion I'll
031make a motion Jen second Divia discussion look I I think all these are great motions I think um just to be clear to the question before as you heard in the retention of council it is in conjunction with the other school districts that are are members of that what you'll call the Coalition which is just an ad hoc group part of that so it it's the same it's the same lawsuit that you were that you mentioned earlier ma'am um the only change I would make uh and that's it's more for um operational ability is to take out that third paragraph that talks about fourth paragraph that talks about spending no more than $110,000 I think we should approve retaining them um you know we have a retainer letter we should be able to make whatever
032additions or changes Even in our conversation with the lawyer we talked about there was one little thing we wanted to do that may have cost a few dollars more I don't think we need to come back and pass a resolution each time I don't think we need to call emergency meetings to be able to take action with regards to a litigation that we don't know how quickly we'll be able to do that and so I would propose taking out paragraph four um recognizing that we have a retainer letterer with the Rano firm and we won't adjust that retainer letter until we unless we want to take action unless we want to do something and we shouldn't have to come back to a public board meeting excuse me excuse me you need to wait till you're
033called on to be to speak um I the retainer letter does have the $10,000 limit in it already because when we spoke to Mr orano over the week he said that he doesn't foresee it being even close to that because there's a whole bunch of other um districts sharing the cost and we have a fiduciary duty to the district to spend the money wisely and if we were to give a lawyer unfettered authority to spend money without having to come back to us I don't think that's a fair use or Fair uh um exercise of our fiduciary duty and I think it's important that we stick to I mean have the resolution in there and if needed we could always come back and ex extend the amount if it's needed but I think we we
034have a fiduciary duty to be the Protectors of the district's finances 100% that we have Judiciary Duty which the amount that the lawyer spends is governed by the engagement letter it has nothing to do with this resolution this resolution is giving the board president the opportunity the power the authority to Simply sign whatever engagement letter whatever letter that we want I do not believe it's wise to put this in here thereby handcuffing this board requiring another public meeting public resolution and in which case might even be um indicating to our adversaries what our legal actions will be I don't believe that this in any way helps protect the taxpayers of this District or in any way violates our fiduciary duty to protect the finances by pursuing this transaction as part of the Coalition um one
035of the ideas that many people have put forward that this is by far the most costeffective way to do it and this one paragraph is simply handcuffing our ability as a board and our ability as a school district to as vigorously pursue this as possible in the most Timely manner did you want to speak to you yeah just uh Sam correct me if I'm wrong but didn't um when we spoke with Mr orano didn't he say the vast majority of the districts participating had this um this clause in their uh agreement and that the expected amount would be well under this and even with the addition Provisions you're talking about it would still be under the 10K I I I I don't want to give away what other school districts is public or not public
036I will tell you from my understanding there are school districts that have meaningfully higher caps in their letters there are letter there are schools I believe who have no cap in their letters so it may be true that there I believe it is true that there are some that have this um but as you do say the more the more districts that join the cost per District does go down and in no way am I saying that I expect this to be but as you recall in our conversations with our attorney we talked about something additional that we might want done with regards to this that might have been something that was not actually part of the lawsuit but affiliated with it that wouldn't have been covered by that and that we would have been
037paying out of pocket for and I don't think it's worthwhile for us to come back back and have another discussion another public resolution or calling an emergency meeting we're not talking about a lot of dollars I'm not talking again we have or the lawyers have no ability to charge us anything more than what we agree to by taking this fourth paragraph out it has no impact on our retainer letter all it does is it allows us to sign subsequent letters or subsequent commitments where where the board president agrees to do it at higher amounts so right now I mean just based on the again in the interest of full transparency based on our initial conversation with the attorneys because we are joining a a large group or a class if you want to call it
038again that would drives the cost way down because the total legal bill is split amongst all the the districts who have have signed on with this this group uh the initial conversation with the attorney is that he thought the number would be in in some ways below uh $110,000 to that end um in in in keep keeping with our promise to you if there's things that we can do that are more vigorous or perhaps pursue another Avenue uh that that may uh bring us to to a point where we Prevail that may cost additional dollars I think that's money that the the the board is is committed to spending and I think it's it's money well spent if it gets us what we're looking for um I would be okay with with striking that paragraph
039you yeah I would I think we could remove it I I agree and as I understand that we are we did sign a retainer we did agree what we will sign a retainer I apologize and um the it's clearly laid out how much we're going to be spending but I do think that if tomorrow something was to AR rise and this board would like to you know pay for this lawyer to do write another letter or commend something else for us at least like this we we have the option well we're only signing to a maximum of $10,000 right now anything the ret anything beyond that would require an additional signature and a and a permission to proceed would if we could just discuss this first Jill are you okay with that I'm okay with
040that because even if you take the language out it's we're at the same place we still have to approve again I'm not going to I can't just walk into a room and unilaterally sign a piece of paper saying we're going to spend $100,000 okay so then I'm fine taking the resolution now because we're at the same place still only I think philosophic I think philosophically we're all in the same place I believe our board is is unanimously committed to to fighting this to the end and we will spend you know responsibly what we need to spend to to achieve the outcome that we want okay I think Mr goodat said we could vote this as a as as a group is that correct Mr goodat yeah you would vote on it as amended obviously you
041just amended this resolution so we're gonna vote on the amended resolution that encompasses all of these items correct feedback here including um number four on in new business as amended without Ming that fourth paragraph and the proposed resolution regarding the uh bosei superintendent expansion as well as Mr pran's proposed resolution okay so on those three resolutions with the amendment do we have a motion we have a second with the but we had to strike out the fourth paragraph so that's as as amended as amended all right so Sam second Jen all in favor unanimously carried wonderful thank you and I just want to thank the board of education so uh for working um swiftly and transparently to get this done um in the benefit of Jericho so thank you to all of my um board
042member colleagues uh Mr grishman and um the rest of our Central Administration for helping out thank you wonderful I just I just want to Echo Jen and again underscore the um really the the collaborative effort again the lot of work that's gone into this but more importantly um just validating the fact that we've heard the community we are part of the community just like you um there is nothing more and this is after conversation with with multiple attorneys uh you know investigating on our own at this point we have taken every possible uh Avenue to and the most aggressive Avenue to stop this in its tracks if something else becomes available to us we will look at it but right now um we have just made a motion to join a lawsuit against or we've
043just passed a resolution to to join a lawsuit against New York State education department and hopefully stop this thing cold so the the Coalition was to to Sam's Point earlier and I certainly want to speak for him was a a group of districts that came together to to share information um and at the end of the day try and plot a course that was going to be most appropriate for dealing with this so the Coalition has provided guidance and we've essentially taken their guidance at this point we're doing everything and correct me if I'm wrong that that the the Coalition is suggesting including uh hiring The Firm that the the districts that are you know make up um make up you know not necessarily the Coalition but districts that have joined forces and shared information
044with the Coalition and we we have um and and that's the the Avenue that we've proceeded why are you shaking your head no okay no no no okay let's let's back up okay because there there's some misunderstanding when we talk about the Coalition I forget the formal name but it's the Coalition of independent Schoolboard members it's an ad hoc group that formed itself about three years ago it's a group of school districts where it's the board members it's not even the official School District it's the board members from those districts who get together to talk about issues that are impacting School boards places to exchange ideas places to get advice places to say oh we're doing this in our district what are you guys doing we learn things we get ideas that's what the Coalition
045has been okay it's not a du paying Coalition it is something where it's purely voluntary you go you don't go you do what you want this is completely separate than what it is a dues paying organization which is called the New York State School Board Association okay which also has a subsidiary which is the NASA suffix Schoolboard Association um as an aside not to upset them too much they've been very unsupportive in our efforts you know to understand what's going on with this so the Coalition is a group that's been out there um it's something something that some board members may go to some board members may not one of the issues that they addressed when they noticed it three and a half months ago three months ago was the idea of this res regionalization
046as well as the Bose superintendent Authority regulations that were being put through in terms of regionalization on an emergency basis the Coalition of independent school board members which as I said is a completely voluntary ad hoc group notified many many school districts in Long Island um across New York state or they tried to about the dangers as they perceived with these with these regulations then some people some school districts that actively partic or some school districts where the board members actively participate in Coalition meetings and some school districts where they don't have board members that actively participate they got together and formed an entity to to to retain regano LLC to pursue litigation against the New York State education department so the lawsuit as Dr festo outlined as we just read the resolutions is part
047of that group we will be part of a lawsuit with other school districts whose board members some of some are are the Coalition so the Coalition is not the one who's pursuing this lawsuit it's individual school districts that have gotten together with the help of the coalition to put this together so there's no Coalition that you join and say okay we're part of the Coalition we're we're we're in we're out they hate us they like us you don't get a membership card yeah no membership card no dues it's it's it's a volunteer ad hoc organization where they've put this together where as I said some school districts will say I want to participate some school districts for strange reasons I don't know will say they don't want to participate that's all it is so if
048you're worried about us being um in hand with the Coalition we are on this topic on this specific instance you've heard the five of us vote that we are hand inhand with the Coalition we agree with what they're do the members of the Coalition with what they're doing with regards to regionalization and that's how we're going to pursue it that's why to Mrs citron's Point earlier that's why this is so cost effective to us if we were by ourselves we would never be able to do this in such a cost coste effective manner we are 100% part of what you're referring to is the Coalition and part of the coalition's lawsuit and this is the most aggressive stance that we can take right now and if something else becomes available to us we will communicate
049that and you we will evaluate it at that point wonderful okay thank you this was a a big win for Jericho again I I appreciate well it's a win in the sense that the community came out oh absolutely yeah and everybody was heard and and the board took decisive action so thank you very much all right at this time want there we go can put the signs up too all right um that being said we'll move into Mr grishman's superintendent [Music] report super thank you Chris I also just I I want to add that uh that out of the 56 school districts in Nassau County um as of uh as of this week um the vast majority of school districts have passed resolutions opting out uh to my knowledge there are only three school districts
050in nasso County who have opted in but of the 56 school districts I believe they're pretty close to 50 of the school districts have either passed resolutions in the month of December or plann uh to pass resolutions in early January opting out and again joining uh joining naso County and expressing their serious concerns about the direction that SED uh is currently taking in my heart of hearts I do believe that the impact of Nassau County um and the strong feelings coming from nasso County and the strong statements coming from Nassau County as well as the the article 78 will impact the final decision of the State education department so I think we all have our our fingers crossed that in the month of January we will all uh be able to celebrate uh a positive
051outcome uh as part of my superintendence report uh our student enrollment uh as of December 13 was 3,38 students with no change from our November uh enrollment report rep and I from my memory I think that's the first time I remember uh our enrollment report being flat from one month to another uh couple couple of other comments um through the um the last two months uh our students have been participating in concerts um just incredible incredible music performances um especially our Middle School and High School bands orchestra's chorus um and Incredibly well attended and just congrat ulations to our students uh and our music teachers for incredible work uh over the last two months uh also want to report that our winter sports are well underway um again I thank our our coaches and our
052student athletes um we have probably one of the largest numbers of students participating uh in our winter sports and uh again unfolding well and thank Mr mwit for coordinating that activity uh yesterday um we had what's what we call it what we have called an art alumni day and it's a day where we bring students back I think it was about a dozen students came up on the stage students who've graduated Jericho over the last three four five years and they talked about their experience in their postsecondary um institutions bringing forth uh the Arts and what they're doing with their background in the Arts and they all talked about the uh the experiences they had and the support they had in Jero that has led to whether they're in commercial art graphic arts but in
053in their post-secondary or in their work experience and we probably had uh maybe 200 students U Juniors and seniors in the auditorium listening to to them uh and again gaining um so much information for what's a high school student who loves art what does that look like when they go on to colleges and universities and it just was an incredible experience and again I thank I thank Ruth for putting that together uh and our two art teachers who coordinated the activity um the last issue I have is um I wanted to share with the board uh that on Tuesday uh we gave a climate survey to all students in grades 6 through 12 um that survey um again according to our um our initial U reports on that survey was extremely highly um participated in
054by our students it was and in in every class um the students were informed that the survey is 100% voluntary if you want to participate please do if there are any answers that you want want to leave blank that is more than okay um and again the the um the intention of the survey and again I thank the Dei committee to who spent much of last year um putting this together is to get a sense of our our students and how how they feel are they s do they feel safe do they feel supported um and information that will help us uh plan for for the future it will help us set goals uh in terms of of our middle school and high school programs and even our elementary school programs in supporting our kids
055um you know I thank Dan solsman and and Eric sunberg for spearheading this uh this survey and I look forward to both of them uh making a Public Presentation of the data um sometime in either January or February at a public board meeting uh but again from from first uh first read and and first response from what I've heard uh there will we will be getting a lot of good solid information that will help our school district and help our Board of Education uh as as we move forward and that's all I have obviously I want to move into the Propel report if there are no other questions just a couple very quick questions just because we have a couple of these coming up my understanding is that providing transport for non-public school students on
056days when public schools are closed is not legally required do do we provide transportation to our private school students on days when when our schools are closed I I I I believe we do we yes or no I thought we did I'm asking I I I wasn't again not a leading question I simply was reading an article about it and I don't know what we do Castell yes or no yes we yes we do thank you castelle and again say that probably is a function of the Jericho philosophy of supporting our kids in private and proo 100% um was there any particularly muscle coach who had a muscular coach who had a uh Milestone victory in the past week yes yes there is we uh look forward to a celebration of our coach Brodsky um
057who has uh had a his 300th win as a Star Wrestling coach who's uh been a u a shining star for our wrestling program for many many years um we also uh look forward to a celebration uh and I'm I don't know whether Kevin's aware of this or not and whether I'm leaking out information that I shouldn't be but he's also going to be inducted uh with some recognition very shortly uh relative to his wrestling coaching career I apologize if I ruined Mr Sur I did not see him here so I didn't think we were surprising him today so good all right if anyone's here please don't talk to to Kevin tomorrow um I know I keep harping on it have we solved our electric car charging problem yes I like that I like that
058answer that's the best answer we've gotten on that that's perfect in six months um and I'm good oh and code of conduct Where Do We Stand sorry about that uh the Safety Committee uh did not meet in December uh which was according to calendar uh they're reconvening for the third time in January at that point uh we're going to be looking deeper at drafts of possible uh expanded code of conducts and working together as a committee to uh figure out the direction we want to go in I just want to be clear though that doesn't mean we don't have a code of conduct obviously there is a code of conduct that exists but uh as we've discussed in previous meetings there was certainly uh it exists in multiple policies and uh the committee is looking
059at whether we want to consolidate and make it uh a bit more comprehensive from from a district standpoint thank you okay so what I'd like to do is ask the board for the next two presentations if the board would uh please open open up our uh our screen please so as we're all aware um there over the last probably 10 years there's been a significant issue with the um the amount of electricity um that is fed into Long Island from New York State um as as long island has grown and as the population has grown uh the amount of usage uh the electrical usage throughout the island uh is not being adequately met um and again I would say probably for over the last 10 years uh there have been discussions in terms of how
060how can the New York State Power Authority uh bring more electric to Long Island so there is currently a 10-year plan that is in place um it is sponsored by propel which is a u a joint effort by both the New York State Power Authority and the New York State Transco so what what their plan basically is is to take electricity from upstate uh and bring it into Long Island again um the representatives from popel have spent uh September October November meeting with towns Villages and school districts to share the plan so that communities who are impacted will be fully aware of what what is going to happen so step one which will be taking place uh through uh 2025 and into 2026 uh all of those potential routs will be surveyed uh and that
061survey will actually be some trenching where approximately one foot wide by 1T to 2 feet deep will be trenched tested and then covered up so every every place where you see um a blue blue line over the next 12 probably to 16 or 18 months the soil will be tested to see um and to uh ensure that as they plan to actually run the the fullsize line that it can be accommodated in the roots that they have selected so in terms of the impact over the next year probably the next two years the impact in terms of what we'll see is minimal from that point on they will then begin to actually lay the U the conduit which will be a much more major project in terms of digging and putting that down they're giving
062us the heads up and will continue to give us the heads up in terms of what the potential impact is to our school district what will Castell what are the challenges that Castell is going to have to deal with in terms of road closures during that time period our guess is and and again I think we we will hear um more specific timelines once all the initial trening is done over the next year and a half uh again as they then move forward there will be road closures um and again this project is projected uh at potentially taking up to 10 years to fully complete when it is complete uh the amount of electricity uh coming to Nassau and suffa County uh will meet the current needs and again what we're told the the future
063future needs um Propel will continue to keep our communities updated uh they will continue to meet with again with towns Villages uh and school districts um over the 2025 year um any questions that I can answer or can try to answer Sam I I'm sure that that is a major piece uh Sam no no discussion of EVS in in this discussion this is you know basic um commercial and home need for electricity that currently is is under what we need Chris no to to my knowledge at this point no battery storage facilities but again that could change uh at this point I've not heard anything about compensation all they they've shared with us is you will have prior information in terms of road closures I I think the Major Impact will be that XYZ rout
064107 from here to here will be closed from this date to that date but we'll have again as they're telling us we'll have prior notice that will'll give our again and we'll share that with our community so in terms of commutation uh driving to and from hickville or whatever we'll have prior notification Castell will have prior notification in terms of how uh how it might impact our our buses and bus routs we're told that there will be question is will there be any disruption to our electric service during this time period they're telling us at this point there will be no disruption to either your your houses commercial properties um or you our our homes or our schools I I think this is I believe that this is all additional uh additional K KW coming
065in I'm not sure whether it's going to replace any of the existing wires they haven't told us that or not again it would be a nice offshoot if they would take down the polls I and next time we meet with them we'll ask them that question good thank you all um while we're sitting down here I would like to introduce Brian Cummings uh Brian if you like to take it from here [Applause] good evening everyone and thank you for Board of Education Hank Central Administration for the opportunity for us to talk and brag about our incredible high school and the Visions on moving f moving further what you're seeing on the board now is this year's uh high school administrative team uh earlier this school year I was uh appointed as interim co-principal in the
066high school um I in conjunction with Joe Pano my other our other co-principal rounding out the team we have Dr Mel Michaela Finley our one of our assistant princip principl and adding to the team this year is David MZ our interim assistant principal David Michaela and I will be talking about the high school tonight it is my honor to be co-principal of the Jericho High School it's an incredible place with Rich tradition and we have unmatched success by our students I am proud to call Jericho High School home how is Jericho becomes so incredible I want to talk a little bit tonight about academic Excellence student engagement and comprehensive support uh I feel our academic Excellence stems for our incredible uh curriculums uh that we offer in the high school are different courses in every
067single uh discipline art English math health fette science technology education social studies and business and World Language and family consumer science through each of these disciplines okay it's all right through each of these disciplines we have incredible opportunities for students to pursue their passions to challenge their uh challenge their uh development through AP courses and experience a lot of different opportunities uh with our our diverse elective classes I think we have an incredible depth and breadth of courses in all these disciplines along with what they're learning in the classroom we also students also have an incredible opportunity to experience opportunities outside the classroom through our co-curricular our extracurricular activities our student council Athletics students an opportunity to explore their interests outside the classroom it also gives them a UK opportunity to become leaders within the
068school we also want to ensure that the needs of all of our students are met at all times uh through our uh wellness program our Academy Jericho Academy our PPS our guidance counsel Services I think we we do incredible job of meeting the individual needs on the social emotional level but also on the academic needs of all of our students meeting the students at their abilities and needs all right so how do we go about doing this and where are we going from here uh one of the things I feel very strongly about is collaborative leadership uh I have a unique perspective on this this is my 28th year in Jericho High School and after 15 years of teaching in the math and the science departments teaching APS and many of the AR electives that
069we discussed earlier coached many sports after that I became a curriculum associate for Science and Technology education for 10 years an AP and now as an insum co-principal um I've I try to see the school through the lens of all of our different stakeholders this gives us me an opportunity to really bring everyone in together to make our decision and work through all of our opportunities we also try to foster a strong community of positive culture and supports we do this by modeling what what we expect we want our students to feel supported respected um and we also we and our PPS and their skill to help support our students who need a little bit of help thriving and meeting the goals that we have for them and with regards to supporting student interest here
070at uh Jerica high school we actively work to support a student interest we listen to them and we try to help them find their passions and uh guide their future so they can Thrive and be happier students for tomorrow at the high school we believe it's essential for students to share in a growth mindset it allows our students to maximize their potential while also supporting every student's individual needs relative to their experience at the high school we know that students are going to face challenges adversity uh so we want them to be effective communicators and lean on us throughout that that time along their Journey here to also support them Beyond high school with themes like good communication effective dialogue we want to create well-rounded citizens and we're tasked with creating students who are empowered
071we want our kids to become the total package right we want our kids to be proud of their intellect be confident but at the same time it's just as important for those emotional intelligence skills we want our to be considerate kind confident and thoughtful and what we'll do is we'll always reflect on our actions looking F looking backwards to move forward uh we always want to improve on our actions we're an incredible situation but we always want to improve on that so what's new coming this year some uh committees that will discuss we'll talk a little bit about our new courses that we offered this year and offering for next year and some new clubs that we have added to our student council system um three years ago uh when I when I be when
072I was a new assistant principal uh I took on the task of the challenge of attendance postco we saw students uh missing a little bit more classes a little late to class and through our attendance committee a partnership with teachers uh we looked at our uh procedures and our policies uh not policies our protocols uh to ensure we had as best attendance as possible and that's something I think we make great achievements on uh this year through our Safety Committee you may have seen a little bit more on Communications we're communicating a little more on letting you know about our different safety uh activities drills and such and we're also sharing a little bit more Reflections on how they went um this year uh one of the things I'm I'm very proud of is we've
073created an academic Integrity committee unfortunately uh cheating occurs in schools and in high schools it's not new to Jericho it's not new to kids but uh postco uh the ease with digital a access we really have seen an uptick on uh on on cheating essentially so we've we've partnered with the students the students come to me Express their concerns and we created an academic Integrity committee on the committee on a site based team uh opportunity we have a committee of students teachers parents uh building administrators curriculum Associates and a board of education member and our goal essentially is to create a shared Vision to refine protocols and procedures to support our values of academic integrity uh coming this year we offered two new classes uh one of the classes it was Pursuit of Happiness it's
074a 12th grade English elective um and in this class students explore happiness through lenses of mindfulness practices divers literature film music and expressive writing activities also this year we brought back a class in the social studies Department another 12th grade elective called Product Citizen and in class students explore how decisions are made by leaders impacting money and jobs learn how to manage their own money consider news media identify reliable sources and understand responsibilities from digital lit literacy to good citizenship as I said we're always looking to improve and getting feedback from the students teachers partnering with the curriculum Associates in this coming school year we're offering six new electives uh in the English Department Ela Department Department we're going to be offering a class called dramatic arts in the science department science in action exploring
075today's breakthroughs and challenges in the math department a course entitled mathematics research physical education is offering Fit Body Healthy Mind in the music department Prestige Symphonia in the art Department a class called analog film photography we'll leave this slide here a couple seconds so you can read a little bit about those titles okay let good all right so this year's student council was excited to invite students to propose new club or service functions so students were provided with applications which included criteria on how a club should be created what the values of the high school are and certain requirements and it's also aligned to our student council Constitution so students could complete an application and submit to student council and once applications were received clubs were created by being reviewed by the club committee proposal
076excuse me the club proposal committee which was made up of teachers student council advisers administrators and curriculum Associates and we took a look at the current offerings we have at the high school for leadership opportunities uh and then we considered new new Vantage points for our kids so another way in addition to this process that clubs can be created is through grant opportunities and at the very end of last year we were really excited through a partnership we have with Cornell we were able to start the agriculture Club it's an extension of our agroscience class so what it allows our students to do is to explore science our course is designed around the the science and business of food so it allows students to share who share that interest to join after school uh and
077it allows them to gain an impact provide an impact on local and Global communities and they compete every year in grow and wise competition and they came home their first year winners so we're really proud uh two other clubs that we're really excited for one because it came about from student voice but these other two clubs also give our students another competitive opportunity to meet uh match WIS with students in uh local other schools Nationwide and in some of them uh International so our first one is our physics club and in that club our students our goal is to foster a strong physics Community here through Hands-On problem solving we're really looking forward to seeing how well they do and then next is our investment club and through our investment Club our students get an
078opportunity to analyze um financial markets uh financial plan um and we're really hoping to see how how our students take off in this one uh especially with the competitions that will be coming up for them in the near future so at this point we've tried to give you a little insight on uh a lot of the upcoming things that are happening in the Jericho High School this year and in our future uh essentially we're looking for students to have as many opportunities as possible ensure dialogue with all stakeholders to make best possible decisions create opportunities to inspire students we want to improve all aspects of our school by creating connections for students and ensuring success for all of our students post High School it has been a pleasure to talk about the high school tonight
079and thank you for your time you've heard from us but you didn't get to hear from our student council Representatives so thank you to Rachel and Ramia tonight for presenting for those of you who know Max sharf and Caitlyn Choy they're generally with us at these meetings but they couldn't be here tonight uh Caitlyn was actually at the basketball game tonight so we asked them to sort of join us in this presentation and give us the student perspective on their hopes their vision for the high school as well and here's what they came up with the best way Caitlyn and Max can [Music] what are you doing on my seat what we're taking over this presentation now let's hear some student input on JHS what's your favorite part of jerich SCH the definitely um my
080favorite part is f with cool beans I love that I can just get snacks whenever I want I like the teachers they're core on their very story that's all uh the academics for sure yeah great teachers great staff already said that um my favorite part of Jericho High School is the volleyball team abundance of business spes it offers especially something like ve where you can actually create your own business and have real world experience my favorite part about Jericho is probably the teachers and like the friendly environment I would say the people my friends because I'm really close with them it's a good one and what is your least favorite part of Jericho High School what do you think we could use a little more Improvement oh nothing it's a perfect District you know uh
081locker rooms could use um Renovations um I think there should be more athlete recognition you know more of the students coming to the games the competitive environment I think if people were a little bit more welcoming to study groups and collaboration that maybe our high school experiences would be a little bit different so maybe if we were to promote a little bit more community and collaboration not a fair of the tea it gets very crowded between periods my least favorite part of the high school is the green Walls probably like the competitiveness everything's very competitive least favorite part is the high expectations if you could change one thing at Jericho High School what would it be um English classes history classes um things like that is there any specifics any sort of classes you have
082in mind um something like mythology Greek Roman mythology definitely more ancient history classes besides like just like world history and um AP push feel like we have nothing that really goes into like hypers specific parts of History that's really important if I could change one thing about Jericho High School um the smell of locker rooms how about that I would give us more time in between classes we need six minut breaks between classes sometimes I want to talk to my friends but I can't so I'm hustling and if you can make the walls any color what would it be white white walls you please elaborate on your struggles with the green Walls um I just feel like if the school was brighter I feel like I'd be more happy to come inside and learn maybe
083closing the bathroom doors the temperature in the school is really and the Wi-Fi really bad paper towels in the bathroom all bathrooms I would start in September extra time outside and extra time with their family and friends over the summer could definitely be beneficial describe JHS in one word what would it be um competitive competitive fun amazing friendly he hectic helpful superb I I want to thank uh Caitlyn and Max uh they are do incredible work um we're always trying to get our student voice and thank you for your time tonight [Applause] that was a great presentation thank you we'll get some air fresheners for the locker rooms and as always uh again great presentation but always the highlight of our presentation is always our students uh our our our students are incredible and their
084uh their comments and their views are uh also uh heartwarming uh and right on thank you uh thank you for the presentation great job thank you right got the screen going up behind us here wonderful um so getting back into uh discussion one of the topics that we we've touched on and certainly wanted to bring up again tonight and we'll come come up again later in the agenda is cell phone use um this is something that I I I think there's been a lot of conversation both at the local level there's been some conversation at the state level my understanding is we're expecting to hear something uh from the governor perhaps uh early um we've also received feedback from from the students uh specifically uh a survey that was administered by by Max sharf where
085there's been kind of you know conflicting opinions on whether cell phones are helpful in school a hindrance in school do they belong in school um I know the board has has discussed it we've we've heard feedback from Administration um but I I I think you know one of the things I'm looking for personally is to to really get input from from all the different groups uh whether it's you know students administrators obviously teachers uh parents family members um so with that I just wanted to open it up for discussion well we could yeah I mean we could well we're gonna have an opportunity I I actually I'd like to say something is it possible for I know that um Mike har you did a survey among the teachers and Max did one with the students
086but can we ask for more um additional surveys that are more granular about you know specifics of what are the you know the times the devices the pros and you know just um something with a lot more detailed feedback and more um a higher participation right me you know give some sort of encouragement to get more of the staff to participate so we could have some meaningful Data before we can come up with what the right policy is I I you know more data is always is good I guess but I think if look at the presentation from the students there's a lot of granularity on there I'm looking at it right now it's like a 10 or 12 Pages two graphs three graphs per page um there's a lot of granularity there and if
087I recall from Dr hartnett's presentation I think he had about 60% participation amongst teachers in the survey World 60% is is a gold standard um if if you get 15 or 20% participation you're you're going to be happy at 60% um I think you're at the gold standard and if you've got 80% agreement amongst those 60% you're not getting better than that and it's a shame that one of our great teachers uh Mrs Miz Mary Dreer is not here she would tell you that 60% participation is is outstanding and I know Dr suberg would probably be shaking his head if he was listening I'm not but I'm I'm talking if we're getting down into the actual specifics of details you know they it would more you know more General and I think if we're going
088to you know I don't I think we're premature we're not up to discussing a policy even though it's later in the um agenda but I think that I'm but I think that if we're going to narrow down to you know times of use and you know details of punishment like I think we need a lot more information um before we're up to getting to that kind of yeah I think also one of the things that would be helpful administrative you know the the administrative work that's going to go into this the enforcement and keeping up with the policy what the teachers how the teachers feel about having to police this it's a whole there's you know a whole lot of open open items that need to be figured out again one of the things that
089I would like to add is that um I have heard and again I'm I don't think we're ever sure uh but I'm I'm told that in the Govern Governor State of the State message uh potentially she will be outlining um her plans and we've heard this I guess for the last six months or year uh that she is going to make a recommendation for legislation um specifically governing the use of cell phones in public schools um there probably is some wisdom for us to continue our conversations uh I think but before we finalize um any any either board policy or um administrative um practice um I I think it makes some sense for us to see what is going to come forth from the state uh and and again you know will it what degree
090of flexibility will there be in what the state is uh is proposing um again over the comments that she's made over the last six months there really has been a whole variety of statements that she's made with some inconsistency in terms of where where that final recommendation will be but I do think it does make sense for us to blend in uh if there is going to be legislation and I believe there is going to be legislation it does make sense for us to blend that legislation into how Jericho um analyzes that um uh and digests it and and then moves forward with some uh some policies and procedures in terms of how we move forward turn it on all right um so just so the rest of you I'm Mike Hartnett I'm the president
091of the local Jericho Teachers Association just a few things um I will uh spend some time over the vacation writing another survey to get more granular data so that it can duvail at the same time whatever material you get from the governor so that we can put that out together should be worth noting that when Mr Perman talked about 80% there was a break in that where 40% looked for some form of partial cell phone ban only inside of classrooms and another 40% wanted a larger level of cell phone ban so there was a lot of nuances in the way people wrote their responses and everything else it's also interesting because we were taking this information with where you had Elementary School which really already has a cell phone band as opposed to the middle
092school and high school so it might be is particularly given what you were writing in your report about cell phones for us to focus much more on the middle school and high school and almost give separate surveys to the Middle School teachers and separate surveys to the high school so we had that information that would be uh more distinguished based on grade level okay just because we're discuss oh sorry go ahead if you had questions for oh my question was also for Dr haret so you can go ahead I if he's gonna stay at the mic oh okay I don't have a question I thought if you have a question for please go ahead oh I did just to um with regards to the survey that you're going to be putting together um piggy backing
093on what Jill said I think the piece that I was missing from what the information that we already had was with regards to enforcement of this policy um if there would were there to be one just from what I've read um and there's not a whole lot there's not a lot of um you know well- conducted studies looking at cell phone use in the states I know a lot of that data comes from internationally but um just from one of the surveys I read um you know how would how does enforcement work best is it um is it a more strict policy that prevents from loss of instructional time with um and how um or are we more lenient more um constructive in our feedback but potentially losing class time in delivering that kind of
094um lesson to these children so I'm I'm very curious to see how you envision um enforcement of such a policy yes and some of that might be how involved the teacher is directly as opposed to the administrators whether there's those shoe sleeves that are up or not whether there's just a general almost uh respectful understanding that you're going to keep your cell phones away without any more than that so I will present questions to The Faculty based on that and present questions like I said that I think I my main plan now would be to separate it out and focus on the high school on one level and the middle school on another because there's also obviously different um responses that middle school students would have to cell phone and their use and we talked
095about the Ancient gener Ancient generation book one of our work sessions when it came to it and which groups also might need to have cell phones later in their lives to be able to transition off to college so these are all things that I think are worth discussing so even separating from yeah well again and that's a good question we were also been talking about devices in general so it's almost like we'd have to separate that out and then you have the issue of watches too which also further complicates the situation so and I think this discussion is is going to be furthered when we discuss the the first reading on the policy well I think it's if we're going to have this conversation I think it's it doesn't make a lot of sense to
096have it absent this policy because the issues that Dr Hartnett has brought up I think I've addressed the issues that Dr balachander brought up have been addressed by um any number of districts where I I've seen the numbers and uh it it does do there's a learning curve as there is with any new policy where teachers will have to unfortunately spend a little bit extra time during the first few weeks or month of this policy but there is data from other school districts out there that shows how that falls off and that after I think it was four weeks or five weeks you know we have Smart students they get it they don't want their phone being confiscated yes it will be somewhat of troubling for um Dr Finley and Mr Cummings and Dr prison
097Zano and Mr mevs and the teachers to catalog the phones that they're confiscating but te but students learn and again we're not creating the wheel here we are simply duplicating what other districts have done and and by the way you know I've heard what you're talking about with the sleeves I don't Envision that in the policy that I wrote it was not that this is trying to teach students a to respect the rules respect their teachers and to respect them elves and learn some self-discipline to the superintendent Point um you know we spent two hours last month and probably 45 minutes this day saying that we don't want to be told by the governor what to do we want to do what's in the best interest of Jericho what's in the best interest of our
098students and what's in the best interest of our teachers so we can introduce a policy we can deal with all the issues that Mrs Citron and Dr balachander raised about how you enforce or how you introduce this policy but let's get ahead of it because you know the government will introduce it and then we'll be scrambling around and and you know what we can spend lots of time trashing the governor but she flops she flips she goes it's going to be a policy it's not going to be a policy we don't know what she's going to do which way she's going to come out when she's going to come out uh she may say there's a three-year implementation I I think that it's important and and if people haven't read the policy um that I've
099proposed I I really would encourage it because and I really propose it to Dr harted I mean do you disagree with the initial premise that the primary mission of the Jericho school district is to provide for the education safety and health of its enrolled St students is is that incorrect yeah but that's a comment H do you believe in motherhood okay but but that's what we're trying to do no no absolutely and and as we heard at our last meeting I forget which meeting it was a work session I apologize um where we had uh Dr Smith and we had Dr Goldstein and and they showed I mean is it is it untrue do do you disagree with the fact that research demonstrates that cell phone use in schools has a significantly negative impact on
100student learning I I think they presented a whole bunch of studies why that's the case so do you think that that information was incorrect and I don't mean to pick on you you're just standing there with the mic I'm I'm happy to ask anyone who wants the mic I mean do Mrs Citron or Dr balach or Dr fresto or Mrs vof do you disagree I mean is that an incorrect statement the research we've seen presented shows that it's a negative on student learning I think we have to start off with the situation on the ground in Jericho I don't think the teachers when you talk to them they speak about yes it would be nice to have cell phones away but they also look at it there there haven't been teachers and believe me when
101there's a problem with teachers they come running and screaming when there's a great concern there wasn't an incredible concern about cell phones in the school compared to other things okay and that in other words that's not it wasn't one of those things where you said we you know like I I spoke given you some anecdotal evidence in my own classroom you ask a kid to put it away most of them always put it away when does he take it out again what when does he or she take it out again sometimes they take it out again and that's when I take it away um but you know sometimes these are these seen in overall scheme of what I'm doing these are padillos these are minor concerns compared to what we're doing in the classroom it
102doesn't mean there shouldn't be a policy on it I just you know as we're going through it I think it's so important to be thoughtful as we go through it and try to figure out a way of you know are we going to suspend a kid for his cell phone Obsession you know where are we going to land on these kind of things I think it's very important for us to to have serious conversations of how we're going to proceed step by step incrementally over something that's a different type of behavior all together than say cheating or something like that I agree with you 100% but the only way you're going to get to what is the enforcement or punishment if there is one going to be is by us agreeing and really I'm still
103struggling to hear from anyone and as to why it wouldn't be why eliminating cell phones from classrooms and again in the policy they written there are schools that don't allow you to take your phone out from the second you walk onto the campus to the second you walk off and that's what's out there there are school districts that go and say okay you get to school put your cell phone into this bag we're going to lock it now granted a 12-year-old as we talked about knows how to unlock that bag but we're going to pay $80 a bag and we're g to make you put it in a lock or we're going to make you put your cell phone in a in a shoe rack on the wall there there's lots of ways to are
104we are we taking the watches away too now absolutely if you look if you look at so now you're going to walk up to a student and ask them what has been traditionally a piece of jewelry and have that taken away I'm just saying we have to think it through I'm not saying it shouldn't be done but step by step all of these increments will be a challenge to figure out and especially so much of this what we're asking about when you're using a Chromebook they can communicate back and forth and do certain things on their Chromebook just by opening a Google doc for example and it doesn't mean that we shouldn't be doing it I'm just saying these are things that we have committees for many many things we if we're going to make
105a policy we really should Hammer that out incrementally step by step where are we going to screw up where are we going to make a mistake pilot it maybe in a couple of classes look at how this is working and be able to work out the Kinks in such a way that might be effective I don't have an easy answer to it we spoke about this long ago at a PTA meeting where it's always a challenge to get this clear um I have some concerns of the document itself there certainly a line in the about teachers not using their cell phones in the class or keeping them away when all we do is need them for dual verification all we do is walk around and use them for all types of information that we collect
106data so that we're not always in front of them and and students can use the Smartboard in those particular circumstances where we take pictures of students so we can post what we're doing online so those kind of things are certain parts of policy that need to be hammered out there's also just logistical things that have to go on for example the middle school day is extended on this list here where it's I thought it ends at 2 it doesn't end at 245 203 I I apologize no I'm just saying that we just all I'm trying to say is we run it through a careful process that's all and and and you you you what you're saying is absolutely correct now let's start off because we often have this problem what is the board of education
107do the Board of Education comes up with policies for the school district it is then up to the administration starting with the superintendent down to every classroom teacher classroom Aid to implement that policy what I am trying to do here by introducing this policy and clearly you've read the document so you know it does deal with non-schooling issued Chromebooks it does deal with watches it does deals with VR glasses or It Whatever new communication device is going to come on the the role of this board is to is to create policy for the district not micromanage not tell you this is what this should be and I believe and and this is why I very carefully laid this out and said our mission is the education health and safety of our children as you said
108that's like motherhood that's fine but that's my starting premise my starting premise is let's maximize that I've sat through lots of presentations I've listened and read to lots of webcasts podcasts articles scientific research that I only understood every three words and Layman's articles explaining why cell phones are bad in an educational setting and again not talking about elementary schools but everybody wants to focus on the high school during a class when when a teacher is in front of that classroom in my view based on the research based on what we are trying to accomplish in Jericho there is zero reason for that student to be on their cell phone and quite frankly I understand what you're saying with the various things and one of your oh I think it is your wife has has a
109comment but um this no you're not okay are you talking about that the students won't see the feedback or the teachers won't be able to enter it walk I I'm just still trying to understand you're saying the student knows it because they see you enter it or because it pops up on their Chromebook but but they looking at that on their phone or they're looking at on their iPad or excuse me and by the way they would see that because I'm not looking to take away devices that are School issued devices from children okay and and that is obviously something that we can work through S I understand what you're saying but that's oh sorry go ahead Dr no if I may I mean my my personal opinion is that cell phones do not belong
110in students hands in the classroom unless a teacher made a specific exception if there was some sort of learning exercise that required it that being said we're Jericho we have device Chromebooks iPads so on and so forth the first thing I I I will say and and and I think everybody knows you know I'm 150% behind behind teachers I I would only support something that excludes teachers I I think teachers need to be able to have a device in their hands for for a lot of reasons and if it's your personal device it's your personal device I think teachers are smart enough to know when it's appropriate to use a phone for personal reasons and and and when it's not what what I will say is I I I you know I know we have
111two-way radios and we have intercoms and but you know a a responsible adult in a room with a Communications device I think is always a smart thing so again I would support exclusion of of devices for teachers and if those devices are being used to award points or some sort of of um prize if I may for for a student participating in a behavior plan if we're talking about you know an elementary or middle school or even a high school student I mean that in my mind would be fine what what personally for me what I'm what I'd like to see is is students interact more with each other interact you know more appropriately in the classroom because I do think cell phones present a distraction and I'll be the first to tell you my
112my own kids have you know in some ways you know participated in this by using a phone in a classroom being told to put it away you know putting it away for a moment only to pull it out again and then have it confiscated by a teacher I I I think we really need to get more feedback from from teachers from the students themselves Sam I think this policy is is a is a good start I think we're going to find ourselves coming to to kind of some Blended approach to this I just don't know exactly what it's going to look like just two one last thing and I just first of all I didn't think it was a bad document I thought it reflected a lot of what we discussed in those work sessions
113so please understand that the one humble suggestion I would make is um these people are gonna be left holding the bag so more than anything else when you're going through and making this policy I think it's so important for you to consult the administrators of what I understand you're making policy but as you're making policy it's very important to start imagining what it's going to look like so if you can consult them about what it's going to look like like as you're drafting that policy I think that would be helpful of course here here's the thing at some point as you can do in anything where you have it you can discuss it until everybody forgets about it and this document I appreciate the comments on the docum I I appreciate the comments about um
114Dojo I I I I get it um I understand what you're saying it's you know what I don't know the answer on that I don't know if the answer is you walk around with gold stars and you put gold stars back on the walls like teachers did 30 years ago I I I am not saying that I'm saying that what I did here is I tried to take all the input that we got from teachers you know I've spoken to administrators about this as I've said I've spoken to other school districts looked at the research I haven't heard anyone really say that banning cell phones for students I'm not going to get into the teacher part right now the faculty part right now Banning students from using or having cell phones out during class time
115is a negative I I I I mean I'm waiting to hear someone put forward a reason why that's a bad idea forget about the implementation forget about that everybody believes that for the education the research shows it's bad for their social emotional health it's bad for the word that I never heard up until a couple years ago because when I was a kid it wasn't a problem mindfulness they're bad for mindfulness so the idea that students should have cell phones during class I I I think this should be a policy that we should be able to say this is what we want to do yes as Dr Hartnett says we'll have to tweak it and yes it will take effort by the administration and by the JTA members to enforce it but I'm still struggling
116to hear someone tell me this is not the goal that we should be setting for our school district at this time waiting for the governor why are we waiting for the governor to tell us what to do we don't want her to tell us what we want her to do we want to do what's right for us and this gentleman's I guess been waiting by the mic so I don't think anyone is saying that we shouldn't have a policy it just that we this is way too premature we haven't gotten enough information and I don't think it the evidence is 100% conclusive based on what we said at at the work session I think it was there were mixed things mixed um responses and I'm not even saying in any stretch that we should keep
117cell phones I just think there's a lot more information that we need before we put pen to paper on a policy um evidence by the issues that were just raised by the teachers so I know that parents have seen the policy and there's a lot of parents that disagree with it and the administrators haven't weighed in and you seem to Sam have a lot of information that you said you've spoken to other schools but the rest of the board we didn't do our independent research if you have some information maybe you could share it with the board so we could all be privy to that information and then after we've all received information then it might be time to put pen to paper but you know we Jericho we need to be intentional and thoughtful
118and by rushing to put something on paper just to have something to be first is not not smart it's not fair to any any of the stakeholders here to just rush into this without doing enough research and hearing enough people's views and how how things are supposed to happen in each classrooms there's a lot of different things that we just had one example of how it won't work in a classroom and we need to have more information and I'm not saying that I want cell phones in schools I just want more information before we have a pol start going on details of a policy I don't think we're even close to being there and Dy would like to speak before anyone else jumps it um you know Sam I don't disagree with you I actually
119have very strong feelings on this subject but I think it's um irresponsible to to implement a or try to implement a policy without doing as much um evidence-based you know kind of plan making um so I do agree that it I feel like it's a little bit premature is you know they tried to do this and I didn't do I wasn't able to get this policy from other school districts other than the biggest one that was most n newsworthy earlier this year which was the doe when they tried to roll this out and then it was walked back I just I I just think that we really need to do our homework and hear from more stakeholders um particularly our teachers who will be Implement and our administrators who will be implementing this before we
120go forward I I can I you guys on okay I just wanted to jump in and say I think whenever and however we do this I think it's going to be somewhat of a painful process and there's going to be definitely a lot of people unhappy I think there's definitely more good than bad um but as far as Jill and Divia what do you guys are saying do you guys have specific data points or questions while I guess while we're discussing this that we can ask them you know ask the teachers and administration to do their research on Are there specific points so that when we we come back in January we can be more prepared to have this conversation I think if we're going to talk about you know people's opposition F first off
121you know I'd like to get comments from parents because again you know they're here many parents have have a strong opinion on this I've heard people who said you know Chris you know do what you can do to get cell phones out of the classroom and I've had some parents say I feel very strongly that I you know need to stay in contact with my kid over the course of the day my personal opinion is you know you're you're trusting the schools and the teachers and the administrators with your you know your most you know valued you know individual in life your children um I would hope that you feel safe sending them to school uh and that you didn't feel the need to you know communicate all day long whether it's voice or text
122um I think we also need to know exactly what the the teachers are using devices for not the teachers's personal use of the device but in this case it was helpful to know that you know teachers are using their personal cell phones um to provide rewards to you know children who may be on a behavior plan or or some part of the the the class activity um if there's specific examples of of why a student might need a cell phone in a classroom because again I think you know any policy is going to probably have specific exemptions I mean I don't want to hamstring a teacher in being able to say all right fine you know we want to use some app that may not be available on a Chromebook and if you have a
123device you know whether we're using you know if it if it works on an iPad but there are some apps that are only available on on a um an iPhone on an iPhone and the the or on a Google or an Android device that's what I was looking for an Android device or an iPhone again I I do have an opinion that that I don't think phones belong in the classroom but I don't want to handicap teachers from being able to to use them if need be that being said there may be students who don't have a phone and being asked to take out a phone in a classroom may you know make them feel you know like they they you know don't have the device may make them feel like you know they're at
124a disadvantage and we don't want to do that either so I I think there's lots of arguments I do think we're going to need to come up with a policy on this I agree that you know I'm not necessarily concerned with what the governor thinks on this uh because again haven't always been impressed with with her decisions but on that and staying out of politics I I think we need to come up with something but I think we do need a bit more information so if we could get more information specifically from the teachers on what your true opinion is on cell phones in the classroom how you're using them if in fact you do want them and you permit them or if there's reasons why you think they should absolutely you know be removed
125from the classroom and only be provided you know in a limited set of circumstances with respect to the parents I would urge you to reach out to us and and and give us your opinions you know why you think your child should have unfettered access to a device during the day I think it's going to be difficult to operationalize with respect to asking kids to take off their watches unless we're going to you know ask them to put the device on airplane mode or whatever but again you know then we're being tasked with asking kids to give up their phone take off their Apple watch so on and so forth fitbits or whatever they're using and and I think we all have the luxury of parents Cur L that are they have kids inside the
126schools I think we all have the luxury of communicating with them but I think that we're going to be doing a great service to the students ultimately by taking those cell phones away Chris I agree with you I think cell phone use has be is gotten out of hand and I just think it'll be a really great thing for for the teachers for the students for the parents it just it will be less technology used throughout the day it'll be it'll give them Focus to the Ed the wonderful education that Jericho provides and and we we're talking about this policy today because we spent the whole work session looking for the feedback right I I wasn't personally here Sam did update me for that work session so I do know what the feedback was but
127I thought we were pretty ready for this policy today I'm not sure why we're not ready though I'm not looking to rush anything if people are feeling uncomfortable but I thought that we're fully ready to have this conversation today considering we had a whole work session we had time for parents to give feedback I think that people heard which way we might be headed as far as possibly a PO uh passing a policy down the line to ban cell phones to some extent so I'm not sure I think there's been a POS city of feedback though I I agree with you I mean we did have a work session I've only heard from a from a handful of folks uh I can't speak for others with respect to to what their opinions are on this
128I mean ban is a big word it's you know we don't like to but it's no no I I hear you we're not saying the child cannot walk into the school without with a cell phone we're saying put the cell phones away during classes you know we're not saying they're not allowed to walk into the buildings would suff absolutely so it's not a ban I apologize if if this the word is to no I'm not trying I'm just I'm just saying you know I don't know if we want to NE if Jericho necessarily wants to be associated with a with a quote unquote ban um I do think cell phon are you know need to be severely restricted I I I see it in my own kids they're they're just you know not present when
129their faces are buried in a screen I see it when they're with their friends you know when we were kids you know we were interacting with each other talking playing riding bicycles whatever these kids you put them in a room they don't want to go outside and they sit there communicating through snapchat not even looking at each other and I also think it's it's disrespectful to teachers you know to have a kid who's you know fortunate enough to be in Jericho schools sitting in a classroom you know being provided with this you know incredible education and for them to dilute it by burying their face in a phone so that's where I am on this so so what are we really asking for uh okay we're we're ask I mean I would just like to
130give some kind of specific feedback to the administration to the teachers whether it's um um Dr Harnett is going to do some put together another survey what is there anything that we can you know do to help out you know what is needed to go move forward policy I think Chris brought up a good point earlier that there are some teachers that have their students use their phones for certain instructional uh activities in the classroom and I think maybe we need to get our hands around that a little more what are they what are they being used for specifically and why is that important well the enforcement part is going to have to come from the the administration to the teachers to the curriculum associ to the building principles that's not really something I think
131the board should be discussing as far as what the disciplinary or punishment or anything I agree we don't play a role in that but I think that it's important to hear that piece from teachers and administrators alike before we move forward with a policy look look the in in districts that have put this in it's you get a warning you don't listen to the warning you get your phone confiscated and this is one example you get your phone confiscated that day you get it back at the end of the day maybe you have to go to detention I don't even know if we run detention anymore okay M doc Mr Cummings is Shing and said you go to detention so now you've just wasted 40 minutes of your day because you spend 30 seconds or
132a minute or 10 minutes um texting watching movies doing whatever it is you do next thing is there's calls homes to there's call home to parents and again more detention and it sort of escalates from there and remember we have really intelligent students and I will forward the data to you from one school district that showed how enforcement time and enforcement phones getting confiscated decreased over time and it was quick and the second part is I understand what people are saying I appreciate Mrs V's comments where it's like collect data well well let's give people some guidance as to what data it is you want to see because from my stand point it's very clear we're here to educate our kids all the research all the data says cell phone use in school is bad
133for these kids learning and not only that it's bad for their social and mental well-being so again this is 100% consistent with it the second part we can pass a policy it doesn't need to go into effect January 1st we could say this policy goes into effect August 2 7th or whatever our calendar starts next year but we then spend the next few months working towards that maybe we take Dr Hart Net's advice and we run this in a few classes as a test and we have some teachers and I know there are teachers um who who don't want cell phones in their classrooms and we say please would you be our test subjects let them run it for a month let them see how the confiscation policy goes let them see how the repercussions
134policy goes that's the only way you get this done everybody wants to test this let's go ahead and test it what I'm saying is this is the direction we need to move in and I haven't heard anyone say except from Mr Citron that sort of that this isn't the direction to move in more information what in like let's give people guidance as to what information because I I think I I've as you said I've spoken to other districts about this and I've seen their data but so what information can we provide this board or can others provide this board that can move us to this where we start doing this because look if the superintendent's right which you know who knows the and and and the governor comes out and says something we're going to
135be in a position having to enforce this anyway so let's get a head start we are Jericho Mr sitron let's be ahead of the curve not behind the curve let me uh if I can add two cents I do agree that cell phones are an issue and the amount of time our kids spend on cell phones is an issue however I I do not believe that if you walk through the Jericho middle school or High School the issue is in the classroom teachers are teaching teachers will tell kids to put their cell phones away and they put them away or teachers will have a shoe bag in their classroom and the kids will put their cell phones in the shoe bag I don't believe that cell phone use in the classroom is an issue our
136teachers do a good job of of of providing a sound instructional environment and they supervise their classrooms they make decisions in terms of whether they tell a kid to put their cell phone in a shoe bag or to put their cell phones away or to keep them out because they're going to use them instructionally I trust in in our teaching our our professional teaching staff in terms of what takes place in their classroom I don't think we need from my perspective and for what I see I don't think we need to place rules and regulations in classrooms I think that the issues around kids overusing cell phones takes place in unsupervised time that problem takes place again in unsupervised time that kids overusing cell phones is frankly at the dinner table is in their beds
137at night um there my my concern concerned about overuse of cell phones and overuse of social media does not take place during the nine period day that our kids are in school might it take place in the hallways or cafeteria um before before first period or after last period it very well may be but again I don't see a major critical issue in Jericho and I think Mike may have underlined in terms of what is the what's the size of this problem and this issue that we need to solve is it in the classroom I don't believe that it is but again I I also seek input from more input uh from our teachers and from our students and from our administrators um we you know let's you know let's let's build a policy um
138with with with more input more Jericho input not not input from another school district but from input from our teaching staff I respect their opinion and their recommendations I appreciate app the input that we will get from our administrators and I appreciate the input that we'll get from our students I think we have to do a better job of collecting data collecting input and and whether that's formalized or informal I really believe that that is the appropriate Next Step all right okay hi Fran o Conor um so I'm not speaking about the teachers about this issue at all I have never felt anything about the teachers um using their phones inappropriately I'm just speaking as a parent who has very strong feelings about children not having cell phones uh so right before covid hit I
139was looking into a program called weight until 8th and it's basically educating parents to come together and join together and stand together and not get your child a smartphone until at least 8th grade so it was more about having the parents there to rely on each other because it's almost like peer pressure all my friends have a phone I want a phone and the parents feel feel PE peer pressure and that's why a lot of them give them their phone so early my daughter who is now 19 did not get a cell phone until 9th grade did not get social media until she was 16 and she is doing great in college right now and it never affected her my current seventh grade daughter does not have a cell phone and does it limit her
140sometimes unfortunately it does just this morning her first period class she walked into and her class was not in there it was a different class um they had a move because her another class had to use their classroom for some reason everybody got the notification on their phone through Google Classroom she is not opening her Chromebook at 7 o'clock in the morning because we know the start time is so early she's not opening up her Chromebook to look and see if there's any notifications so yes she didn't see that did she Panic a little bit yes but I raised her to be independent and to advocate for herself so she went into the classroom and said to that teacher my class is not here where is my class and they told her and she went
141to the classroom so yes it does limit her sometimes however I feel it's more important that she learn responsibility and that she doesn't have to rely on a cell phone that she should be communicating with her peers she should be talking at lunchtime she has lunch with friends who don't take out their cell phone and look at their cell phone the whole time so it's the friends that she chooses to be with so I do agree that cell phone should not be in the classroom should not be in school in my opinion but I understand I understand everyone's feelings on that um and I do know that with technology I rely on my cell phone I know a lot of kids do I think it's about educating the parents like you said when are they
142using it at home in bed at the dinner table you go to dinner do you ever go to dinner and see how many kids are sitting there like this and the parents too and no one's even talking at the dinner table that's like part of this whole issue so I believe it's educating the parents it's having the parents come together and be there for each other and letting each other know that yes I don't have my children have a cell phone it's okay they're doing great you can do that too and it's also educating the children to be um respected like Mr proman said if a teacher says put cell phone away that cell phone should be away and should not be coming out again that's all there is to it so it's really about
143educating everybody involved in my opinion and that's just my opinion thank you Fran Mr Briny did you want to say something uh is it on or no I I think it maybe actually okay so couple question okay need to be close sounds like it is on yeah yeah is it on okay um sorry Dr heart okay apologies um where are these surveys shared do parents have access to these the results that you're referring the results from that survey I don't believe were posted online I Dr Hartnett delivered them at our work session he summarized them we have not seen the raw data for it I don't even know if there was a formal printed report prepared or he was just reading from his his notes you did is there any way that you'd be able
144to provide that to the district would you be comfortable providing that to the district so we could put it on the website I I wasn't there are others who are there others who want more data yes okay of course were thank you were parents surveyed no we did not survey so we we asked for for feedback Visa V you know communicating with the with the um Board of Education email we asked for feedback at the work session um well I'm just here sorry to interrupt um but you you said board faculty and students but it seems like there's one more missing from that equation I I I had actually previously said we we had requested in an email you're saying right in no I I I I had asked at at at the work session
145if for individuals to email us that that if they had you know opinions on this that being said you know since we are talking about collecting additional information I do think there should be a parental survey thank you um the comment that was made respectfully about the faculty being left holding the bag currently the parents are left holding the bag with the situation um in my own personal experience Direct directly to Mr grishman in the past um three weeks after q1 for my junior and she's probably going to kill me if she watches this her grades weren't so great so reached out to the wonderful um counselor that she has reached out they set up meetings got uh parent teacher conferences set up worked on it one of the teachers said her cell phone usage
146I said 'great take it away she goes you're okay with that I said 'absolutely take it away guess what her grades are up now so and and I'm telling you from a parent probably the most notorious parent in this in this community I have every parental control you can imagine on my child's phone I have every limitation available on my child's phone my child's phone gets bricked at a certain time at night so she can't sit on the bed and and be on there she gets an hour to two hours of Snapchat she doesn't have Tik Tok she doesn't have Instagram and it's still a problem for her and I'm controlling every aspect of it probably to an extent that has fragmented our relationship parent child relationship it's insane how much of a fight it
147is but it's also insane to see from one quarter to another how much of a difference it is just her putting it in the pocket I'm not saying she's not bringing it to school she's still using it in the hallway it's just in her pocket and now all of a sudden in an AP class she's excelling when earlier in the year The Counselor thought she should drop the class the the only only Factor there is that right so I just want to share every single teacher I've talked to and I have four kids okay from elementary to Middle to high school I haven't heard one teacher advocate for the cell phone being out and used in a in the classroom I have yet to so different experience than you've had um yes there's problems at
148home with cell phone usage but I think the the actual in school usage is a problem I don't believe there's any policy but we've we've created the school has policies around what you can browse what you can search the vpns the all these different tools and mechanisms to prevent kids from going to certain things on their phones using their phones in a certain way but we have yet to make a policy that fundamentally attacks the core root of the problem which is the device itself so that's that and then my last comment apologies Mr to miss Citron if you could just clarify because you're saying and I believe um somebody said up there there there hasn't been studies in the US and their foreign studies I believe there are I think Pew had a 2024
149study and I just want to clarify if you're asking to see other stuff are you conducting a study or are you requesting like some funded study to be like what is the what are the parameters for what you're looking for to determine that a policy is valid enough to your standard and what is that standard and how do we meet it that's it thank you no than no I mean the data that I was asking for is what our our district wants Sam was just referring to so many other um policies and other districts and other research he read so I just wanted him to share whatever he read with the rest of the board I wasn't asking for any I am asking for more information from our students our staff our parents our teachers
150I want our administrators I want Jericho data I think at this point I'm sorry and um and I'm not I'm not saying that I want cell phones in school I did I just was um touched by a little bit and I think it was what Max had said in the um at the work session and he said that the students are going to go out into the real world and go go to college next year and have unfettered access to their phones so that just struck me that it is something we should take into account that they are going to have to have the responsibility of having phones so if we and I'm I don't know what my feeling is I just was struck by the statement that he made that we should take that
151into consideration that you know these students have to learn how to be responsible when they move on to the Next Level I'm not saying what the answer to that is or if that's you know overrides the whole policy of not having a cell phone but I think that is something that we should take into account and it's not like Sam said 100% all bad there are uses for some apps and some some um programs in the classroom that they do use the phones for so I just don't think I don't agree to make a blanket statement that it's all bad and I you know I think it's great that your your daughter is doing better without the cell phone and I think think that probably is very valid and it's probably valid for probably most
152people but I'm just not acceptable accepting a blanket statement that it's all bad and I'm not saying that we should allow cell phones in school I just want more information so can I answer that it doesn't have to be all bad like there there there's very few things in life that are black and white where you could say it's all bad you're saying it's all bad no I didn't I said the preponderance of the research says that cell phones in School are are are negative or a hindrance on the educational process okay I didn't say it's it's negative on 100% of the educational process as I said I'm sure there are redeeming values to it but the vast majority preponderance whatever word you want to use shows that these are negative to the educational process
153that that's it so I I I don't need 100% I need 55 80 but I have 80 but go ahead and and one thing we're trying to address edge cases as they're referred to like I fully understand the teachers using Class Dojo completely get it but my my eight-year-old doesn't have a cell phone so she's not going to see it unless she's on the Chromebook so there there're edge cases that you're trying to address for and in any scenario there's an edge case because I could say the same thing well if a teacher requires a cell phone what if a parent hasn't given their child a cell phone yet um I'm not sure who just said that but that's a valid point right so if so now all of a sudden that kid can't participate
154in educational instruction because a teacher has changed the way they're administering their teaching to cell phones only makes zero sense again Edge case my last Point coming from I guess a business standpoint I doubt any of you up there would go to a restaurant or any other place of business and pay for a service and allow that person serving you to be on their personal cell phone our kids this is their job they're showing up to go to school to be educated in one of the top school districts in the country it's their job to put their phones away and be educated by this standard that you guys have set so just as we expected in our daily lives which is if I'm paying for something you shouldn't be distracted with your personal my kids
155shouldn't either in in the institution they're coming to to get learning I I I just I'm sorry go no I just wanted to respond to what was mentioned earlier and you know from the research I did I was simply making the point that I haven't seen any peer-reviewed studies um in the States but it's there's there's multiple I can I can list them out to you that's fine PE Pew did a 2024 when you're saying peer reviewed this it's not a medical study you're saying like it's not corre nor should it be right you it's unethical to do like a randomized control I get that I'm just saying even um I'm and I please please understand I'm not waiting for any large study like that I just think because I do feel very strongly about
156this I just would like more information from within about how to best execute this but can we at least tonight if you're going to say look we're not going to agree with the policy lay out what your standard is to be met for a policy to be created because moving the goal post doesn't work for us that's all I'm saying is if you're going to have it one way or another make a decision tonight the policy doesn't work great then we expect Dr hartnet to do the following and deliver the following based on these parameters and if the parameters are met we as a board will indicate that we will move forward with the policy as Mr prman or whoever wrote it I think that I think that's what I'm hearing is that we would
157just like to hear more from our teachers what is more well I so I've mentioned now a couple of times I'd like to see with regards to enforcement I don't know if there are other things that people what they're using for what's the question on enforcement like what what is it that we need to know that they do they not want to be troubled with enforcement I I mean who else who who wants something added to their job I mean the answer is going to be no and and you sayone said we let's PLL students what are students going to say we saw that we want to have our cell phones I'm not yes or no whether they they agree with enforcement more just how do they foresee going forward like I said before from
158again whatever I've read um that was significant concerns a concern among teacher unions was just how to enforce without detracting from instructional time and so I just would like more information about about that before putting that upon them and I think in terms of like we just saw one example about the dojo like there might be I mean we we're not in the classroom every day we're not in the classroom any days really so I would leave it up to the teachers to say what are the specific issues that come up that need to be addressed so I mean we can't come up with the parameters because we're not there in in the in the trenches on a day-to-day basis the teachers are the ones that are going to know the issues so I don't
159think it's right for us I mean I think that just that that shows the fallacy of the policy without taking into account these all of these issues that the teachers know about and we don't first of all the the dojo issue is is is one issue and that deals with the wait that deals with it's just one example so there could be many many more examples like that that we don't know about and you don't you don't know about that because you're not in the classroom a couple things as well as we have Smart students we have very smart teachers can teachers figure out the way to work it around absolutely they can like I said I was in school I had a whole long list of gold stars hanging on the door not only
160did I know I was amazing everybody in the class knew I was amazing you know what that's what it is there's ways to deal with this what you do is you find out where you want to get to and then you can figure out the path on how to get there all I was doing with this policy was saying this is where we want to get to okay and you know we have actually a fair number of parents here today I know a lot of them came for other issues but we've only had two parents speak and and not surprisingly well one case surprising I feel like they agree with us pursuing a policy like this so if there are parents here who who have an issue who have specific um concerns or wants to
161see specific data it would be really helpful to hear from those parents just what just one moment before you you speak I I I feel like this conversation would have been better had in the work session we just didn't get this sort of feedback um because no I'm no understand but I mean again I'm not against the policy at some point um we've heard that you know the teachers you'll potentially have more information for us Mr berini you know asked about you know feedback from parents perhaps we we just didn't give enough thought or allow enough time or provide the proper vehicle to collect that information so I think it's it's pretty clear where you know many of us stand on this um hi I'm Alison I'm um a few things um first Sam you
162just what bothers me one thing that you said is that we keep looking to other schools and seeing what they've done already and that's never been our view in the past we do what Jericho wants to do we don't care what the other school districts do we do what's best for our students here that's just first thing to say um the second thing I did go to the work session and I remember there were a few things from Dr hartnett's uh survey that we were questioning the participation how many they were and part of the other thing was the um grades the teachers represented because there is a huge difference between the K to five students where their cell phones are in their backpacks all day long and then comparing it to a 12th grader
163who's off to college and should have some Freedom or responsibility I 100% agree that the teachers should control whether they should students use cell phones in the classroom I don't think it's a big issue to be honest I think that the our kids are respectful to our teachers and the teachers handle it if there's a problem with one kid they handle it that's just my opinion um the thing that just not coming up tonight that you did also mention in your policy is cell phone use in the hallways that you Banning um having a phone call um a center for a guest parent call Center for parents to use um and also devices which that concerns me a little bit too because our kids again I'm speaking more to high School some prefer to use
164an iPad especially in math some prefer to use um their laptop our kids have different freedoms and they're comfortable organizing themselves certain ways um especially kids maybe with 504 IEPs they rely on certain apps and certain things that maybe they can't always get on their Chromebook and they use in their iPad so I think that should be a part of the survey look I I appreciate all those comments I I think one when I said look at other districts I was simply talking about implementation that when Mrs Citron talked about how do we do this I said we are not creating the wheel here there are other districts we can look at and pick and choose how they do it for implementation in no way am I saying do it the way this District does
165it do it the way that District does it when I said look at other districts I was also saying look at how cell phone use or enforcement and the it takes for faculty or administrators to deal with that it declines substantially over time over a short period of time that's what I'm talking about when I say look at other districts as I mentioned earlier participation in a survey and Dr hard correct me if I'm wrong I believe you said your participation was close to 60% um Dr sunberg 60% would you say that's a good number an okay number or an outstanding number for a survey thank you so I I appre appreciate the comment that there was only but me when we had a survey over what we wanted I understand I think that's what
166Dr haret is going to work towards but to say that there wasn't strong participation um I I I think that's uh a little bit misrepresenting and I understand the grades represented I I don't think that um the point about the free freedom and the expression I I fully get it the fact of the matter is we're trying to do what's best for the entire student body here and at the end of the day all of not Jericho specific research because I don't think Jericho specific research is any different we have really smart kids but I don't believe that they're outliers that it's suddenly going to be that they're the only School in the world or one of 10 schools in the world that benefit from having cell phones in front of them as this parent
167pointed out um there's just no reason during class you talked about hallways I I wasn't quite sure what you meant by hallways no no but I'm saying you're saying yes they shouldn't be allowed in hallways as you heard in the presentation earlier kids are already stretched trying to get one from one class to another if they're now in their hallways using their cell phones one they're either late to class or two if you go back to the research that was talked about at the work session once they're on their cell phone it takes an average of 22 minutes for them to refocus back at the task at hand so if they have a six minute passing period they're on their cell phone for four of those minutes they've now lost half of their period because
168they have not been able to focus because they're thinking about the text or the video or the message they just saw or the message that they just sent um in terms of call centers the call center was set up to deal with what I thought was the um concern that parents would have that they could not get in touch with their student or their student could not get in touch with them so what I'm saying is as part of this policy the board would expect the administrations of each building to put in a way that messages could be very expeditiously delivered to their children should they be important if it's oh I'm picking you up at 4 o'clock instead of 3:30 and it's only 10 o'clock in the morning the kid will get the message
169by four o'clock if it's 2:30 and it's like I have to pick you up because XYZ happened that message will get there in 2 minutes 90 seconds going the other way the call center was set up so that if your child needs to reach you they can go there and we will guarantee that they will have a phone to reach you if they don't know your phone number because it's only in their phone there will be an administrator there to say here your mom's number is this your dad's number is this that's not working use this alternate number that's all I was saying with the call center that was set up not as some type of punishment that was set up to facilitate this process and make sure that parents who felt the need or
170had the need forget feel the need had the need to communicate with their child or vice versa could in terms of devices I fully understand that different kids like different devices as and I think Mr Cummings left as you would hear but as you might be able to hear from your daughter devices are part of some of the Integrity committee's work as to what goes on there whether it's cell phones whether it's non-issues Chromebooks so from that standpoint this is also trying to address some of the issues that have been raised there and in terms of the concern about you know what we couldn't adopt it I would love to see this policy get adopted January 1st we couldn't because part of this policy as you know deals with school issued devices and would we
171be in a position by the 2nd of January to have school issued Chromebooks to all these kids of course not as I said this was an this was a policy that I put together having taken in a lot of the other effects there are parents who said we heard it from Mrs OK Conor she doesn't want it in the lunchroom with the library this policy has it so she may say okay this goes 75% of the way there but you're missing it even worse the superintendent thinks this policy is completely backwards he wants no cell phones in the cafeteria no cell phones in the library library because those are unsupervised times Mrs gingle that's not exactly what I said Sam what did you say you said that it's unsupervised time that creat I said I
172have I said I have concerns about cell phone use during unsupervised time you have no concern about it in the classroom based upon Sam based upon feedback that I've received teachers that I've spoken to listening to Dr hartnett's comment um I don't have a high level of concern about cell phone use in classrooms I have a as I said I have a serious concern about cell use on the part of kids and very frankly I think 50% of that 75% of that is at the dinner table and in their bedroom absolutely and and two things more cuz I remember one of the points Mrs Edelman made but before I get to that your point I think part of our school is teaching kids life as someone said and you know what if they can go
173six and a half hours during the school day without their phone they may realize wait you know what I can go 30 minutes at dinner or if they're going to a fancy N five star restaurant two hours without their phone and they'll survive you know what their friends won't think they died because they didn't respond to their message in 30 seconds this is part of the educational process Sam to Mrs Ed to Mrs edelman's last point and then I'm going to put the microphone down before Mrs sitron yells at me again um she said that you know what you know the teachers you know you know do this and Dr Hart net and we talked about this the work session not every teacher is as bold as Dr Hartnett who's an amazing teacher and willing
174to be the bad guy there are some teachers who are hesitant to say to the student do this there are teachers who are hesitant to say you know what I you watching your phone again because there are kids who are watching movies in class I I I'm not trying to tell you something if you don't know that as a parent know it there are kids that do that I'm not telling it's your kid I'm not telling it's my kid there are kids doing that there are kids I assure you tomorrow the last day before vacation I'd be shocked if any kid is not pulling out their cell phone to do anything other than whatever the school work is so I I I I still struggle with the idea of why we're not trying to do
175this look I'm very happy that I put for this because this got to a conversation as Dr freso said that you wish we would have had at the work session we didn't here we have a policy and I still am waiting for someone to tell me where it's wrong I've heard we want more information I haven't heard what we want I I think it's it's like I said I I do think there's going to be a blended approach to this I I think we're going to end up dealing with this in in one way or another that being said I would like more feedback from the teachers I would like more feedback from the parents I propose just one moment if you don't mind I would propose that we get a a surveys out and
176into the community uh for for for the parents and I would ask Dr Hartnett to you know repo um the the faculty and hopefully we'll have some additional information to continue this conversation at our next board meeting I just what's the date of our next board meeting or a separate work session where we just talk about cell phon already no one came here we have people but let's again we've been discussing this for an hour I don't think we're going to you know drive this home tonight and that's fine I mean the conversation is more important at this point let's get a survey out Sam do you want to help craft a survey for the parents everybody hates my idea Mrs citon and Dr balach no Mrs Citron and Dr B we did not say
177we hate your idea we're just not I'm saying to do we want more inform okay I have all the information that I personally need so if there's more information Mrs citran and Dr balachander would be more suited to constructing that simply because I don't know what information people are looking for I I I believe that I'd be happy to help work on a survey I I believe that we can ask Dr hartnet to reconstruct and and and deal with teacher feedback and again to the recommendation um differentiating teacher feedback between Middle School High School uh and Elementary School I think we can look at uh one of our research uh social science research possibly to put together a survey that we can put out to our parents and to our students um and we'll have
178conversations tomorrow in terms of how we can move forward in getting solid feedback from can I ask one last question excuse me oh sorry from our parent from our parent Community from our student community and from our professional Community being teachers and administrators Dr hard how many members of how many um Elementary School teachers are there in the JTA and how many Middle School teachers 90 and high school20 240 3:30 okay thank you so I'd like to we will get these surveys done we'll get them out uh we'll get this on the agenda for the next Board of Education meeting I look forward to continuing this conversation um moving along Sam wait can we use chat gbt to create the survey or is that against policy all right so we can work samor in the
179interest of time are you okay with moving past number eight for now just so we can get to uh some of the businesses 10 is number eight the electronic devices of course number eight is the Schoolboard election procedures I mean that's G to be another I mean yeah as long as we get it on the on the doc for January so we can deal with this before we get to may I just want to have I'm sorry January agend no and I know that I just want to make sure we're actually going to discuss it in January AB sure to be on the agenda AB no I I I think for for January just in the interest of of you know getting the rest of the board business done I know people are you know
180kind of anxious to get on with the holiday too no because we're also going to be talking about electronic devices again which is an hour it is but we already had a spirited conversation number seven and8 cell phone use and Schoolboard election procedures chance I want to say something sure just one moment if you don't mind um and School Board election procedures will appear on the the January agenda in terms of the yeah the policy I think you need to Table Right the first we may need what we we may need more time then the January board meeting I would ask that we we give the staff an opportunity to put together their their process and then we'll come back with a recommendation whether all right so I'd like to make a motion that we're
181gonna table the discussion of the use of electric well we're not there yet Joe why don't well why don't we just get that over with but our meeting is not for another month we can't do a survey in a month no I'm saying to table the policy that's part of the agenda we're gonna get to that we are no but we're just talking about like the superintendent said that we're going to push it off to February you know this is the problem this is why I wanted the Poli I didn't say we'll push it off to February what I'm suggesting is giving Administration an opportunity to meet with staff and see what a realistic opportunity a Time frame is for the teachers for us to get a a survey out and back from our parents
182and our students and us to come back to the board we will do it as expeditiously as we can and get it on either a separate agenda or the January agenda as quickly as we can oh okay so we'll be on the latest of the January agenda that's fine I mean I have no issue with that we will discuss this again be on the January agenda great we'll be we'll be able to to provide some update I know you know we can work to certainly get a parent survey out Dr Hartnett will you know do his best to to work with with his team to uh get some information and again if it's you know delayed for a period of time for you know short period of time hopefully uh at least we'll have some
183update but we'll get the parent survey out and we'll communicate hopefully get some it'll probably be a link off the website but we'll we'll have to look into that and and we'll let we'll let the parent Community know again you know some some people have a feeling that that's speed is more important than accuracy um and and receiving as much data as we possibly can I strongly recommend that we move ahead as quickly as we can but I want to make sure that we give an opportunity to all parents to have enough time to receive a questionnaire and get their feedback I want to make sure we do the same thing with our students and I want to make sure we do the same thing with our teachers and administrators I just want I would
184rather excuse me I would rather make sure we do it right than do it quickly and if we're doing that can you please make sure the survey deals with all the Imp all the parts of this policy specifically non-school issued devices so I don't want to come back and say okay we're getting rid of cell phones and then someone says well everybody who has an iPad or an iMac is able to um use their thing but I'm not all aable to use that because I have my Chromebook so it it's got to be a comprehensive approach because I think everybody agrees if we get I shouldn't say that I think I heard a consensus that if we get rid of the cell phones if we limit usage of cell phones we have to limit usage
185of non-school issued devices Sam if there some as we're putting together a a survey if there's specific components that you want to ensure that are part of that please send us an email and we will uh take into account your recommendations thank you please yes I have been attending the meeting many a little closer to the microphone I'm sorry yeah I have been attending the meeting for many times and then you guys did talk about the issues about the using the cellone but I want to say this is obviously it's better idea to let the kids bring the cell phone in the in the uh classroom the reason why is like have you guys heard about the Roblox the Roblox Roo yeah the Roblox game all right this game to all too all too well
186I know Roblox well Roblox game was released on 2006 and due to the covid-19 there's so many user they play this games and they push the Roblox uh game on the marketplace so the roblo is on the market they have a you know it's on Roo is one of the biggest currencies out there right now well however yeah there are so many users and then um so the kids can easily install the app through the phone so I'm pretty sure 99.9% of the students they can access the phone and then play the Lobos game during the school during the lunchtime so it's going to be out of control so I'm here I'm just want to address this issue here because you guys talk about oh what's the bad things about the remove the phone uh
187okay some people were saying okay we shouldn't remove the phone but I'm I'm just saying here the lobal game is going to affect the kids's study and then uh for this point I'm with Sam we just need to remove the phone from the kids's hand when they in the classroom they need to focus on on the academic that's it yes yep that's it that's all we need all right thank you thank [Applause] you I I think the one thing I would definitely vote for right now is to to ban Roblox but that's uh I don't I don't even want to tell you how much money I've spent on Roo um it's it's that game is addictive it's also you know a it's a vehicle that that kids can communicate inappropriately with each other so I
188I'm I'm totally with you on roblocks and listen again not to to be labor this because I really do want to move on I I think we're all acutely aware of the of the I don't want to go so far as to say dangers but the the negative implications of of cell phones in a classroom and in fact if if students are distracting themselves with them we need to you know figure out a way to kind of Center them and and remove them from the devices and have them pay attention to the teachers because that's why they're sitting there all right thank you moving on uh opportunity did we actually did we actually table Sam no we're gonna we're gonna get to that okay uh opportunity for the public to be heard please note if
189you'd like to make a comment or ask a question please tell us your name and affiliation if you are representing A specific group if you would like your statement to be included in our board minutes you must hand in a written copy of your remarks to the district clerk Victor Manuel immediately before speaking as always public discussion on matters relating to staff and students at which their reputation privacy or right to-do process or those of others could in some way be violated is prohibited with that Dr [Music] hartnet okay yeah a good idea so uh dear members of the board of education on the more challenging standardized exams like APS SATs and for that matter Gres and lsats test creators incorporate distractors in multiple choice questions distractors are attractive appealing answers that happen to be
190incorrect I believe at last month's Board of Education meeting I witnessed a crowd full of people embracing the distractor at first glance it might be easy to select regionalization as this ominous threat that will swoop down and Destroy Jericho schools as we know it perhaps a careful reading of behavior behaviors of the New York State education department was required the state department is Fain for vague bumbling statements that could easily cause alarm if you haven't gone through 40 Years of watching what were initially considered controversial proposals transform into something either benign or ineffectual the messages from the state education department last month and on December 9th were affirmations of the story of regionalization running the same course of so many considerations and initiatives that preceded it however the bigger concern was the reaction to regionalization
191at last month's Board of Education meeting the tone of the crowd was disturbing I understand that there can be anger over the Potential Threat to the J Jericho School District but that concern should not lead to a mobike atmosphere while there were thoughtful comments they were often drowned out by yelling and by attempts to shut down those with differing opin iions I have much more fear about that sensibility and angry willingness to clutch on to distractors than regionalization I've seen my home District Locust Valley toss away good money that could have been used to help its students instead fritted away on grandstanding lawsuits that the boards of Locust Valley and mipe would led the charge on regionalization fight should give us pause a few years ago those Two school boards combined to to become embroiled
192in an anti-mass mandate lawsuit that could serve no purpose other than feeling good about acting on impulse a lawsuit that squandered educational funds I invite you to get away from the distractors take a look at the scores at Locust Valley in mipa compare them to Jericho decide if those are the districts you want to follow I happen to live in Locust Valley as I said I've witnessed the deterioration of that District through the board's creation of an unstable educationally compromised environment one that has led to departures of key staff I speak from my own personal experience and fears I witness superb dedicated teachers there and a few more a few of the more experienced administrators who decided to hang on in Locust Valley nobly pushing to maintain the high standards that once were the norm
193I invite you to look at school data and rankings about how close to Jericho and quality Locust Valley was in 2012 and where the district is today compared to Jericho what happened to that school district the board of education clutched on to distractors I urge the Jericho Board of Education to not follow a similar path the seductive narrative is to say the reason the State education department put out their clarification is because it buckled under the intense pressure you have put on them that's a narrative that makes those involved feel Vindicated still I invite you to study history to study the clunky way that the State education department has introduced initiatives and what signs exist when an initiative actually does have steam or does not and what did we lose in the process of this
194somewhat uncivilized Board of Education regionalization meeting that meeting transformed the school into a place it should never be schools particularly elementary schools are sacred places to us who work in them there are sanctuaries welcoming places that Foster calm reason discourse to us such an environment is the ideal path to attain High higher order thinking such an environment provides stability to build from simple comp Concepts to complex ones it is an environment that makes us less prone to jump to the distractors distractors are often designed to appeal to emotions and baseer instincts the better we embrace the San city of the school the less likely we are to succumb to th such distractors when it came to the the question of whether the administration and the Board of Education was against regionalization at Jericho I witnessed
195a crowd that would not take yes for an answer make that six emphatic yeses from the school superintendent and from the five Board of Education members I cannot imagine potential superintendent candidates were impressed by such a display I urge the members of the community to embrace the inclusive and thoughtful approach that has led Jericho's to Jericho's success for many years at last week's work session a question was asked by a board member about what evidence exists of how our approaches towards three to eight testing in math and English lead to Greater achievement the questioner did not consider success on regent exams as a strong indicator since he viewed them as a bare minimum for the district while I would not underestimate the value of the region exam of the region exams because they measure and
196confirm broad foundational skills I will say that a clear sign of higher level achievement is Jericho's position on the AP honor role that is where our 3da a testing approach leads us on that honor rooll we are not at the bronze silver or gold level but at Platinum the highest level but what I believe is much more important is along with the plat Plum ranking is are receiving the AP access award a rare achievement even rare at the Platinum level this access award honors schools that demonstrate a clear and effective commitment to Equitable access to advanced classes that means jerich that means at Jericho we push to find a way towards achievement for all students by the time I arrived in 1993 here the district had already had open enrollment policy for all AP classes
197this extraordinary overarching philosophy in Jericho schools informs everything teachers and administrators do here we the student we meet the students where they are and seek to raise their ceilings we are deeply committed to your children creating an environment where they can grow not only academically but also socially and emotionally that success only comes in an environment of kindness and conf comedy and yes one of the essential lessons of the Jericho classroom is how to address those distractors in order to achieve success in my own life I have chosen distractors instead of searching for the better answer indeed on every Journey getting past the distractors is a process so let me return to where I started considering regionalization as a distractor from the business of spending our time and resources on our constant Quest to improve
198Jericho schools I ask the Board of Education members to think quietly and thoughtfully before they pour money into legal action funds that could be used for programs that could continue to build on Jericho's rich and enriching Legacy programs as simple and valuable as say Elementary School clubs indeed keep your eyes out for the distractors as we all know the result of picking the distractor is clear and simple your score goes down thank you for your time thank you Dr har anybody else like to speak hello everyone um I think it is actually hello yeah hello everyone um I am disappointed that we're not going name if you don't mind I'm sorry uh Hassan fani I am a uh Jericho High School alumni than thank you for joining us this evening yes uh hello everyone um
199I am disappointed that we are not going to be talking about this topic tonight however I wanted to talk uh tonight in regards to School Board elections uh procedures um one of the things that I thought from last year's election um that I think we should uh we need to implement this is where High School seniors who are 18 can have an opportunity to meet the candidates at the tent uh outside the Sam Springer gym I think this is very important especially you know for students who are not aware of uh the election that is you know going on uh it's a great uh opportunity especially since uh especially since Stu uh teachers encourage students during their class periods to go to the Sam Springer gym to go uh to vote and I think you
200know this is important uh I would like to see this implemented uh or try to see if we can implement this for this year's uh for next year's election thank you so much thank you anybody else like to speak sir hi my name is Brian sorry again I will go back to the regiz plan currently as I know there are 20 school district has on the article 78 with the Coalition um I my question is are all those school districts sign the same rtina agreement with the same law fir so the the answer to that question I mean I haven't seen the retainer that they signed I've only seen the retainer that that we've signed but we've been given indications by the attorney that they've all signed uh similar retainer agreements and we are in
201fact sharing those costs so whatever the the cost of the the litigation is will be equally born uh amongst those districts so I may say we could put our Jericho School District on the list of the cison right now it become 21 school district of the list that's participating in that lawsuit yes there is no list of school districts for the Coalition there's a list of school districts that are participating in the litigation and they there may be additional and that list May grow and if that in fact happens the cost born to the Jericho school district will subsequently decrease okay good so thank you very much yes would anybody else like to speak I just wanted to um respond to Hassan um just so you know we do have a meet the candidate night
202every year in um I think it's usually two weeks before the election maybe three weeks before the election so everyone's welcome to come to that our students are studying in May for AP exams or Regents exam so to let them out of their cages for five minutes probably wouldn't hurt anybody we'll discuss it next month when we do the election I'm not commenting on whether I'm just telling him there's an O there is an opportunity to be continued we we we'll get there all right with let's move into oh did you want to speak I'm sorry please yeah hi everyone um my name is Joyce I'm parents um I just want to respond to the comments that Dr heret just made about uh regionalization would just a distraction if it just a distraction then why
203would you know it has potential to take away our resources so I don't think that is simply as a distraction it's a major issue right now right so like the reason we go into litigation just because we want to protect our resources so so then um we can achieve um academically right we we we're competitive um we know for um our academic achievement um so we really want to put this regionalization to rest so then we can focus on what we always Focus which is academic achievement um also for the device restriction um I really want to see this policy to be um put in place I know there's some concerns um and some questions and somebody want to do more researches but like I I want to see more specific research that you're looking
204for right and then maybe we can make a timeline like I know like the policies there like people want to put some kind of restriction but sounds like we're not just not sure how we can reinforce in the classroom in in school um we can fine-tune that but I think some kind of policy need to be adopted um in order to restrict non-school device usage because I do see that impact my children um academically um yeah that's all my input thank you all right anybody else can I just make a general comment sure sorry it's not going to be like a long thing Dr hartnet respectfully said uh that regionalization is a distractor and I appreciate she just said that um like to introduce him to a distractor that we just fought tooth and nail
205not to put a policy in place so all right I don't want to get into a this is you're minimizing distractor and yeah everybody is entitled to their opinion I I which I commend the parents that came out at the last board meeting and spoke up it's the parents rights to and however they choose to do it is their right so I know PTA also said something and I think it's absurd that you guys have an issue with how parents approach what they say it's our right just as it's your right to get up there and you know but it's not your business to tell us how to say okay just no not to you it's not your job to tell me guys guys so we're not going to get right everybody's right it look
206and the board has talked about this and I think we say this one of the issues we had last month was we were in the canag auditorium where people were just too close and too on top of each other too hot too crowded and that was it look ever since Sam stopped talking everybody's been a lot more cordial to everybody so let's just we'll keep going in that direction last month was just a blip and we're going to keep going and we can argue about who's distracting whom but everybody here is making good points and and delivering them properly thank you okay well we we moved past that that being said let's move into uh the The Unfinished Business adoption of board policy number 7130 admission of Resident students residency reverified motion be it resolved
207that the Board of Education adopts the following policy policy number 7130 admission of Resident students residency favor discussion on this I'm sorry did you have any discussion the um the we added third grade oh we were adding one right we were adding one um yeah I just yeah no it was the addition is there yeah the addition is there okay I I wasn't sure I don't I'm not sure who put this policy and this is not the policy that was on for first read the first the policy that was on for first read had that third grade line in there oh no it was supposed to be added it's the wrong version that was uploaded I don't know what version this is well that's why I'm just no but it it was after the last
208meeting and we did agree that we're putting the third grade in well that was the correct version so that's fine it will it'll it'll Rectify in there the most the most recent version of 7130 oh 7130 yeah okay that's why that's not the correct give me give me five seconds Mr Perman I'm looking at the agenda from the last meeting so I can tell you yeah we we were adding the uh the additional grade right right yes and that was in the last policy I believed right so we just want to make sure that's the that's the version of the policy we're adopting correct yeah is that correct Steve I wasn't I was adding third okay just got to be added third grade so we're adopting this policy with the third grade edit yep we
209have to edit you have to add third grade do we pass it or you will be if you it was it was approved after the first cor it okay so all so this is all in favor with the addition of third grade yes all in favor Jill unanimously carried thank you adoption of board policy 71 31.1 attendance zones recommended motion be it resolved that the Board of Education adopts the following policy policy 71311 attendance zones do I have a motion on this Jen second Sam discussion point of this point of as I'm looking at this policy on the first line on the first page you can remove the phrase it said the first sentence is the Board of Education effective September 1996 we can remove the phrase effective September 1996 at this point if the
210board's okay with that are we good with that all in favor with that change Jill div you Diva unanimous Thank you new business acceptance of donation recommended motion be it resolved that the Board of Education accept a donation of $1,257 from the Jackson PTA who respectfully requests had funds be used for the Bose arts and education program at Jackson Journeys into American Indian territories on December 2nd 2024 so very generous and kind donations we have a motion on the donation second Sam any discussion on this other than a thank you all right all in favor of acceptance unanimously accepted thank you that's very generous donation and uh we know it'll be put to good use acceptance of assembly Grant in Aid letter whereas on December 4th 2024 a grant in Aid of $100,000 has been
211a portioned to the district from the state treasury in support of the general expenditures of the district and now therefore be it resolved excuse that upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools in pursuant to its authority pursuant to education law 1718 subsection two the Board of Education hereby accepts the aforementioned Grant in aid from the state treasury to be used to support the general expenditures of the district we have a motion Jen second Divia discussion with a thank you with a thank you of course um yes all in favor unanimously carried acceptance of first reading board policy use of electronic devices during school hours first reading recommended motion be it resolved that the Board of Education accepts the first reading of the following policy use of electronic devices during school hours I believe we
212said we were going to table this I will second that motion any discussion all right we're good all in favor of tbling this motion all right table un ly thank you all right and moving on to the approval of schedules business Affairs schedules A1 14870 through u373 do I have a motion motion second Divia discussion Mr Emanuel you'll be able to get me that financial information at some point right on those specific questions I don't know if you want to go through them now or it's up to you whatever you prefer I mean if we could just bang through them this way all po the first item um $812 what was the event for was staff recognition Okay evening um hmb Consultants is 6,000 per year 600 per month is the payment schedule 600 per
213month 12 months or 600 per month 10 mons 6,000 total um the program in South Wales what you saw there was the total District expense it was about 2,000 Al together okay uh the I'm going to skip number four for a moment renew Contracting uh more than half of that was for the generator replacement and the balance was for outstanding payments from the summer work bathrooms districtwide so half and half half half remediation half new construction okay um the number six a an explanation for the 10% drop in lunch sales actually lunch sales increased year-over a year uh monthly sales will fluctuate because depending on the school camp calendar October this year could have 20 days last year may have been 22 days so there will be fluctuations in the month to month but the
214overall sales year-to date are higher than I mean um are higher than last year not in the page I'm looking at wait I'm looking at sale of lunches I there's some ancillary income so if you look at year-to dat total income I know I'm not looking at total income I'm looking at sales of lunches because total income in well if you look at reimbursement earned lunch to third column that should be included in sale of lunches also so you have 18,000 more in that versus 9,000 Less in the other one so overall it's an increase wait say that one more time sorry guys we're talking about lunch how much we're making or losing on lunch go ahead you were saying the if you look at the third item under there which is reimburse lunch yep
215reimburse lunch that increased by 18,000 the sale of lunches above that decre increased by about 9,000 but overall it was an increase I'm looking at October's report that was in the package I have sale of lunches the first line going down by 12,000 you said year over year you didn't say for October but for October like I said before there could be based on the calendar uh actually if you look before last year there was 21 days this year there was 20 days and the yeah okay I mean it is what so we don't think there's any issue with sales at this point I I do not no okay that's so that was the that was the gist of the question inventory uh the inventory item one why is inventory school always zero because it's
216not our inventory anymore because we have eror markets their inventory the other two items I will need to follow up on okay um our lab why is our labor up 60% for the month um there are two so there's 26 payroll checks in a c in a fiscal year July uh to uh June and in that there are two months where there are three paychecks instead of two to add up to the 26 total perfect okay so depending on the Year this year um there were three payrolls in October last year there were three payrolls in September understood all right all right um why did the full Fringe of benefits year-to date hit the p&l in the month it is done quarterly the timing was last year was probably September this year was October thank
217you uh what are type A lunches those are just student lunches what is adult money that is Staff thank you and I think that was it that was sure so since we've had this is our second full year with arar is that correct this will be our second full year second full year so should um I guess normalizes in the right word but should it um we be seeing similar Trends now that we've had them for a year or almost two years yeah at the end of this this year will be we'll start to see a trend um last year with the full year of error mark was the first year we did not need to transfer monies from the general fund in order to subsidize the cafeteria fund I expect that to be the
218same this year Mr Emanuel two last things when you said you were going to come back to number four I'm sorry Mr siton were you done I apologize um when you said you coming back to number four you're coming back to number four after the meeting not tonight is that not tonight yeah okay and then under inventory your Roman numerals two and three I will need to follow up on okay and okay perfect and then just the last thing um if I'm reading this properly at the bottom of the page where it says total where it says participation yes and for 2024 average per day pupils for this year was 1,030 for last year was 1,088 for the high school middle school right now is there something there that would not say that we're down
219four plus percent lunch sales or is or is that again a number that's just it fluctu because that that's a per day number isn't it that's an average so that's not a monthly effect that's not dependent on the number of days served um but it's one month so and we're only this is only looking at October at this point which is the second month of school um I will be watching that number as the year progresses perfect thank you very much all right on the schedules all in favor Divia did I get you oh unanimously carried all right uh before we bring it to a close just on behalf of the entire Board of Education I want to wish everybody and their families happy Holidays happy and healthy New Year I thank you for your
220participation and attendance at these meetings and with that I would request a motion to adjourn second all in favor all right so carried happy holidays everybody thank you very [Applause] much thank you