001Al to the the United States America the stands na indivisible andice good evening everybody all right excellent good evening everybody Welcome to our December work session I hope everybody and their families have a very nice Thanksgiving with that we're going to get ready into it we have two presentations this evening the first is going to be grade 3 to8 testing uh followed by a preliminary budget discussion with that I'll turn it over to Dr Sherman if she wants to make the introductions for the sure um we're very lucky tonight to have our curriculum associate for ELA Dr Dan salsman our curriculum associate for mathematics Helen pin who are going to drill down a little bit of how we uh perform this year on the grades three to eight New York State assessments what do you
002guys have slides that we should sit over there for we'll head to the a thank you very much good and good evening everyone yeah so uh maximum effort is the theme of this presentation uh my name is Daniel solsman I'm the curriculum associate of English language arts K12 here at Jericho my colleague to my left here is Helen creekin she's the curriculum associate of mathematics and really what we want to do is just give some context before we get into the data we were asked to do a presentation in regards to the 338 testing in both English and math and really it's an important data pointing but it's just one data point and I think it's really important to understand that even though uh it is in news day and uh we work very hard
003all year towards that assessment um the learning and the ways in which we try to reach individual students is continuous and ongoing so one big uh uh takeaway from the other piece of data besides student performance is how many students actually participate in this test uh we also um in that Newsday article it showed that we had 88.9% student participation this last year and even in the height of the opt out movement uh we haven't really uh lost that many students to the actual Administration it's wonderful if you don't mind just getting through and then I can answer any questions that's related to that sure is that math or English or both that's combined that's combined yeah um and then just another context Point as you go through we were asked to look at a
00410year trend which you're about to see but I just wanted to give a little his historical context as well so you're going to see data from 2014 to 2024 and just a couple of changes along the way both in ela and math so one big change was in 2016 the standards the content the scoring rubric as well as the actual proficiency the standard for the levels changed okay so what the state does suggest is that you don't compare years after back to you know pre 2016 another change was the test used to be three days and so then in 2018 it changed from a three-day test to a two-day test okay and then we went through another change two years ago where we moved from paper based testing to computer based testing so that what
005year in 20 well we've been doing it for two years strong so it was suggested and then it's now obligatory uh this coming spring so say 23 and 24 were computer Bas computer that's so what you see here is a 10e trend and what we're showing is the comparison 3 through eight uh proficiency levels that includes proficiency and Mastery in grades 3 through eight combined and against the state average okay so you're seeing the Jericho average for the past 10 years and again there's just that black line with 2020 because of the co pandemic so there were no tests in 2020 and then what you see on average and um I'm going to share it with um Helen in a second is that the trend is on average between 30 and 40% above the state
006average aage and that hasn't really changed even when the state Trends down you know we sort of stay with that mode and of course you want to ask you how do we do in neighboring districts on average for the past 10 years we were always in the top one two or three depending on the grade level thank you so as de saying here's here's the data for math over the past 10 years and you can see as Dr Salman was saying if you look at the New York State data um how there's kind of an ebb and flow with that state data we're traveling along that ebb and flow but we're at a higher level right so um we're we're proud of the work that we're doing um there but now the real question becomes
007what do we do with these data right do we just sit and admire it or what are we actually doing and we really use the data to inform our instruction we we talk to our teachers about the data at the district level the teacher level and of course down to the student level so I just want to give you a snapshot of of what that looks like this is actually a slide that we've used in data meetings with with teachers and when we present them with their data and by by the way every teacher 3 through eight has their data each year in in a folder um and when we dive into it we ask these questions right what do you notice what do you wonder is there is there a distractor that you see
008how do we use this information to inform our instruction and what are your next steps in teaching the content and and finally what supports do you need from from us so one of the things that I wanted to show you and this is just a sample um grade five Gap report from 20124 there are two reports that um Dan and I really like a lot the Gap report and the Wasa report Wasa stands for a wrong answer summary analysis I'll show you that in a moment but this is a gap report for the district so you're going to see that this is a double line graph the green line with the green squares that's the district the um the region and the region are aggregate of all of the districts in nasau county that subscribe
009to the data warehouse so there's about 56 or 58 districts and the red would be our school district so this goes question by question along the xais and the Y AIS vertical galaxis is the percentage of students that got a question right so remember before I was talking about the E and flow in the state data you could almost see that here when it comes down to this specific fifth grade test right you see how it's going up and down and we're going up and down too but at a higher level okay so when we present this to teachers there's a third um line in that graph so we'll have teacher data compared with school data compared with District data or teacher data compared with the region data so that they could see that specific
010comparison and then I again this is just a snippet we'll go to the Wasa report that's the wrong answer summary report analysis Wasa wrong answer summary analysis so in the Wasa report we we may find a question that we really want to look at so I'm looking at question 20 here's the standard this first area shows the percentage of the region that got the question correct so remember I said the region is Nassau County the districts that subscribed to the data warehouse so 57.6% of the region got that answer correctly the correct choice is one these are the students who chose Choice One in our school district so 81% or 164 students um and then really no one shows the other choices until you get to the last choice we have 177% who chose Choice
0114 so that's kind of what we notice and then we ask the teachers well what do you wonder and they'll typically say well what's the question so then we go to the question and we dive into this question so this is from a fourth grade test Tiffany has five times as many red apples as she has green apples and if she has 20 red apples how many green apples does she have I'm not gonna but but you do know that the answer is do we know what the answer a is an L right it's a is an L okay so the answer is is the first one and there kids did great on it right we had 81% of the kids get it right but if you remember in the slide before do you see
012right here there's a little bit of a distractor there so we have 177% that are choosing Choice form we want to know why why are they choosing that um so this is actually what we do we go through what the solution is um we would talk about how we would teach this to kids which bar would be bigger the red bar or the green bar and and Y and then we plug plug in the fors where does the question mark live we're looking for the green and interestingly we quickly determine that the distractor is D and we talk about being really careful about asking students to highlight key words can you see why from this question right 5 * 20 it's 100 right so that's why we have to look at these question questions in
013in context and one of the strategies we use is cover up the numbers and just make a bar a bar model so that you get the context of this situation so again this is one question I just want to give you an idea of what we do in these data meetings so that's the type of thing that that we do I do not expect you to be able to see all of this but what I want to show you is what the teachers do with that information so what they do is um they identify areas where they really want to spend time informing their own instruction they look at the standard they talk about the distractor they talk about the implications for teaching they include the assessment question and then they write a parallel question
014a parallel question doesn't mean we're going to use the same exact question with different numbers but it has to be a question that is speaking to that specific standard because it always goes back to the standards yes you getor a year later right we usually get them in what September October yeah the fall the next fall we have these data meetings in October for the current their current class but the class A Grade ahead got it wrong so are they somehow the teacher of their next year class going to help them correct with you don't have specific students who gets it right or wrong but those kids got it wrong nowe right so we during those data meetings we're sharing all of the data and we're discussing the trends with with everyone so we'll say
015okay in fourth grade this is what we're seeing we're have we have the fourth grade teachers there so they all have access to it but the teachers of that current grade tweak their instruction to hopefully be able to address those areas in in the current school year does that make sense they're mixed grade level meetings the fifth grade teachers are getting it also yes they're all last year did it wrong yes they're all together they're in the same in the same data me so similarly uh in ela the same meeting we just look at it a little bit different but this is again you're looking at a Wasa report and so what I took was and so this is looking actually at 2023 but I chose a third grade test on purpose for a couple
016of reasons one being that that's our first grade level where our children actually takes those test and developmentally it is a challenge right so this is the first time that they sit in that setting it's the first time that they have to uh take the skills that we're teaching them K through three and then apply them to this kind of uh testing format uh both in multiple choice and constructive response so I'm going to show you a multiple choice question reason being this was the only question that we actually performed less than the region by 5% okay so we had the region was 73% We performed at 67% and I said what's up with that and so we look at this question and we see that the right answer is response one but clearly response
017three and four were distractors okay so we want to dig into that and here's the question and this is why I say it's challenge because there are so many skills embedded into a type of question and more so what's attached to this is a passage called fund everybody knows what a thunderstorm is Right thunderstorm thunderstorm exactly so that our 8-year-olds have to read a passage the title was thunderstorm and it's actually in this question okay so it's also it also includes two words that we don't expect the children to know and that's why they're defined and it asks the children to go into that back after they read it and actually use two different sections of that text to synthesize in order to answer this question okay I didn't even mention what the question's asking
018but I just gave you the layers that go into the skill okay so you can look at this we already know the answer is number one but when the question says uh you know what do they show about the babysitter I think the babysitter probably knows bil very well and the babysitter might have many hobbies based on all the things that she's saying in there but the best answer was the babysitter has a good idea okay that's what the state is telling us this is a crazy question third grade far third we and yet our teachers are doing an amazing job to prepare our students in every grade level and that's the point of this okay so you see the question um and then so so what do we do we know that kids are
019struggling we have this data meeting but then we want to look also how do we train teachers to maybe teach differently or as alen said change maybe how we taught it in previous years and so I wanted to show you this is an anchor chart actually out of a third grade classroom from this year this is how we teach f and I also just wanted to make a nod to the staff development that our teachers are part of um I know I spoke about some of the professional development in previous meetings and so this is um and actually we have this staff development going on with high school teachers today and so this is in regards to learning targets and success criteria for students this is how students would reference when they're learning about how
020to study or how to analyze uh both literature and especially all of these uh levels to author's craft okay yeah question well it's a testing company get to write these questions if you say so we would you have to ask next ter and if students and if students perform again part of my with respect to this if students large groups of students perform poorly on a particular item is that item then discarded or I can't speak to what that company would do but and also the questions that we are able to actually study are only the released questions okay so the state decides which questions are released that we can actually see so we know which questions our students might get right or wrong but we only have access to certain questions so the unreleased
021or more can we never saw are they more experimental or are they just they could be field tested some of them could be field test we don't know okay unless you're standing over a child while they're taking it that would be the only way you would see what's on their screen so when you get this Wasa report does it actually give you the standard of the question or it only gives you the data it'll give you the standard not the question well the Wasa report that you saw before just to just to point out you so if it's highlighted and blue they release that question so when we get the Wasa in the Gap it's in regards to so you will be able to click that link and actually see the stem of the question
022yeah well I'm trying yes so that is the question okay okay but in every instance you'd be able to see that correct okay yeah it's same with the constructive response as well and with the constructive response the other helpful thing is that we get anchors so in the P we scored our Constructor response now it's computer based testing all of the Constructor response is scored by the company um just to go back a second um so of course after we do that kind of teacher training then of we may have students that still need more academic intervention and that's where you get into tier one in the classroom tier two may be outside the classroom and then tier three might be a specialized program research based um but this multi-tiered system of support obviously speaks
023to differentiation and our focus on individual student progress so sure um when when we meet with the teachers to go over the data reports the first thing that they always want to do and I've been doing this for a long time i' we've been doing these data meetings for so long they always want to go to like what was the hardest question where did where was the drop and we have to remind them that we also have to celebrate our sucess right um the way we teach math the way we teach Ela it's about critical thinking we're not all about strictly a test prep institution right we're about teaching for understanding and the scores will follow the scores do follow that um so we're proud of the work that we do we're proud of the
024work that the teachers do and the support of the community and the resources that we have because we are able to provide tiered differentiated support for teachers for students and um you know these results don't happen by by accident so we are proud of that so now is the time for questions and that well that that's us but you can ask us questions right now St do you I understand what you do by the questions do you track students from year to year because and and are the same students in that non three or four 10% or 15% every year or do people score a four one year score a two the next year go back to a four or is it pretty consistently the same cohort of students who are not meeting the the
025state standard so so for those of you who are at home or didn't hear the the question is are we looking at the specific students who AR meeting the standards and kind of tracking them to see how they're doing if if they're improving and and do you providing them extra Services right so we do provide them extra services so for example students who are performing typically at a level one or level two it might not be exactly at those levels we have cut scores within those levels but you know students who are pro pro uh performing below proficiency we offer them some kind of support so that will either be in the form of academic intervention services that Ela and man Support classes it could be um they're getting support through guided study or resource
026room but we do offer them support in terms of GC students go from a two to a four usually not in in one year um so we tend to see students we see we do see growth but we usually don't see it in one school year no I wouldn't expect it in one year but what I'm saying is you you have a percentage of your students who in third grade the first year you give the test score one or a two below the three that's required for proficiency if I understand right are those going to be the same sort of group of kids who when they get to fifth grade sixth grade seventh grade who are also going to be making up the district's one or two not necessarily no not of course not necessarily
027but is is that really it or are we able to take those kids who score one or twos in their third or fourth grade and get them to proficiency yet it's other students who either new to the district or students who were doing much better in third or fourth grade who fall off I'm trying to say is is there a move is there is there a fluidity in students there is we have Underachievers we work with them we give them all the support we can but they just will remain Underachievers I know it's a hard way I'm understand yeah I don't I don't understand the descriptor underachiever we're talking about human beings not not needing proficiencies under under achieving not my opion however you want def so I'm not def but um I I do
028think that every child has the potential to meet Mastery that's our goal so we teach towards Mastery every student has that potential and that's what we strive for and that's what our teachers are striving for I do want to just make a shout out at this time because we are on um all of the teachers the custodians um the cafeteria workers Learning Center instructors it takes a village to administer this test in a secure and safe environment uh our students have I think a wonderful experience while taking the test um and in that I think gives them that opportunity to perform to their best ability I love the Middle School model they do their personal best so yeah we're tracking these kids every year I'm pleasantly surprised by their growth if it's not in one
029year the beautiful thing and I know you do get the regions data that we have 99% passing in English regions So eventually they get there and that's been for years say we we've had 99 98 99% Proficiency in English regions for years no and that separate question from looking to not not Jericho data I'm I'm talking about across many many school districts when you look at State testing scores you know when you look at um Elementary School the percentages could be 40 or 45% I'm not talking about Jericho I'm talking about other districts you get to middle school and somehow they're at 50 or 55 they get the high school they somehow jump up to 75 or 85 it could be developmental what it could be developmental as the third grade question I showed you
030well no no it certainly could be just what it's basically every District that I've looked at you see this huge jump from middle school to high school and so I don't and and that's why I think this is much more I mean I can show you D it's sort of weird where it makes me think as people have argued you dumb down not us this has nothing to do with Jericho dumbing down standards once you get to high school and say we want everybody talk about J we have but but then that's what not what you're doing though so I still everything what you're talking about I understand everybody can get to Mastery which is a four proficiency is a three we have students who score ones or twos so I understand everybody we have
031has the potential to get to a four our objective is to get them to a four what I'm trying to understand is is it if there is if do the do most of the kids who score one or two in third or fourth grade are those the same kids who are scoring ones or twos in seventh and eighth grade or most of those kids are we able to get them to proficiency I don't know why that's why I don't have to answer because I just don't have to answer that question I I've seen great growth from I'm not gonna speak about I you see great growth I'm sure wait hold on as I said when I posted these questions I understand that our scores are meaningfully higher than Nassau County meaningfully higher than the state
032and I'm sure if this was a national test it would be meaningfully meaningfully higher than the country what I'm trying to understand I understand we have 90% participation rate so we're going to have you know some kids just have a bad day I fully get it some kids go for the whatever you call the teaser answers why are we not like what's the reason why we're not at 95 98% the way we are with the regions so you're saying when we get to Regions we have these kids at 99% pass why are we not at 99% passade in the third grade and the fourth grade and the eth grade different human beings just take longer to get there I guess I I I can't speak for why in one particular grade level or why um
033one particular child differents you may have different the regions we not seen kids taking regions I mean English what until 8th nth grade the regions is only in 11th grade it's a summative exam and that is the culmination for English so that's why I'm just using that as make comparisons corre iy olds necessar yeah I'm still trying to find your question I want to give you an answer I just don't understand it I mean Sam there's a piece that had kids develop and grow maturationally educationally at different rates of speed so there's there's a two-year difference in third grade there's a two-year difference in in in fifth grade and basically I think what the data is showing is that we are we are we are supporting our kids who get ones in twos we're we're
034zeroing in on on their growth and providing them with the supports they need in third grade fourth grade fifth grade sixth grade seventh grade eighth grade and again cumulatively over that span of time based upon the instructional support knowing the strengths and weaknesses of each individual kid by the time our kids graduate 11th grade English as an example by the time they graduate we really have have brought them all up to a a level that we're comfortable with but that's for you could see that Dr Sol if if you look at your third graders and you say in our third graders we had x% of our students who scored threes or fours when those students were in fourth grade x% of them scored threes or fours when they got to seventh grade eighth grade the
035x per of scored three do you see that type of increase when you follow a class from third it changes every year I can't follow a class the core changes sometimes the the test is different um you know but of course the test is different to say that so let me answer this way if a kid is still struggling we're going to keep trying to help and and again that's not the question the question is do the number of do the percentage of students scoring threes or fours in third grade does that number increase by the by the time that same class gets to eth grade I understand there are not our dat shows us so no so no not increase no okay so so so it does so we provide all these services but
036it's really not until high school when you're talking about the 11th grade no that's just the only test I have to show you that men proficiency there is no other regions until 11th grade so after 8th grade there's no other standardized test that I can show you besides end ofba and that's this is another point this is like I started the presentation this is one a point and if you remember my um uh presentation two years ago on fale students we see growth in lots of different measures whether it's a standardized Technology Program pilot for example uh whether it's NWA which shows individual student growth bookended in September and June that way we see growth within the same year regardless of when we get the state data and so I'm saying so in this data
037understand this is one set very specific understood we do not see grow grow in the class of 2030 took this took this test in third grade the class of 2030 took a similar test in fourth grade in fifth grade if I follow the class of 2030 from third grade through 8th grade you're saying that I will not see an increase in the percentage of Mastery or profession I said the opposite you you would see an increase in performance POS I apologize the way you worded that question you were saying does the group of ones and TW yeah you said the group of ones and two the non-proficient does that increase that's why I thought you said and I said no okay the per is not okay so okay so from third through 8th grade you
038follow the same class of 2030 blah blah blah blah blah you will see increased performance so so the when you showed us our overall scores and I didn't write down that specific number how many scored three because you did a schoolwide number you didn't do it by rate I don't think no because I was just comparing it to what news they put out no no I understand so when I look at that number for the third grade we would expect our average to be I'm sorry we would expect the third grade percentage to be lower we expect the eighth grade percentage to be higher no it do why not you just said they increase from third to eighth grade before that is the trend of most of our students I can't guarantee you that the
039eighth grade cohort is going to school because each year they change the test each year I years the kid the example you give the kids in in let's say sixth grade took a paper based test and now they're taking a computer based test in eth grade and you're asking me to compare those values curve though doesn't no there's no curve I don't know I don't even know how the state sets their scale scores and that changes every year so a 420 and one year is not a 420 in another year that's why we always give maximum effort what is back because we keep back effort all the time I thought that's what I said okay so okay so you're saying regardless of how the test changes or the challenges that our kids face there's no
040way to compare correct it's just it's just difficult you're asking you you want the the same sort of criteria no I want say I just want I I just I just want something that points to the fact that yes we are doing a good job that the culminating summative test that the state wants us to do for our kids we have 99% passing in English language arts year over year I can't give you any other and as you've heard me say here before I don't hold the Regents as the best judge of Jericho because if we are if we are the state test is supposed to be the preparation for their regions what I'm talking about is we talk about the 99% region I'd hold us to a higher standard to say that oh you
041know our region scores are higher than they should be higher than the other places so what I'm trying to understand with that I'm not saying higher than anybody I'm just saying that they're all that Mo almost all of our students are proficient I mean I'm saying yes they're proficient I would expect our students to be proficient because they're getting the best education I'm still trying to understand the value added so you're saying that this exam isn't really a great we can't use this because of the changing in tests from year to year because of the various ways it's graded the various ways it's given over the last decade that we can empirically show that we've been value added to these students that's what I'm trying to understand I I want to numerically empirically show that
042we are that our education is value added to these students and so the only thing based on this test well based on this data yeah based on test lot of other data points that show you that we get lots of value out work okay what what's the data point so well I just I just mentioned I just mentioned the region as the summit of uation requirement from New York State um person no I every I agree with everything that Dan was saying um I what what I'd like to add to this is the way that we look at these data we look at it aggregate we disaggregate and then we get down to the individual student right and that's really where we're focusing our efforts on the individual students as opposed to and I understand
043what you're saying as opposed to taking a group of students who got a level one and two and seeing taking that whole group and tracking them year over year we're looking at individual students we have people in the cohort coming and going the tests are different the tests are increasing in difficulty as the as they should right as the kids are aging up so the mechanisms that we're using to track student growth individually are nwaa I EXL Delta math um inclass exit tickets par deck Desmos with data coming in from from that and that's really where our efforts go to individual students and how to move them from one level to another level and it's not just level getting level one to a level two and a level two to a level three right we're
044also looking to get move kids from a level three to a level four but that's where our focuses on does that make sense that's really what what we're looking at that's where our efforts are and I understand that completely so do we have data from any of those acronyms you just threw at us showing how those individual students progress and saying okay here are again in year three third grade we had 15 students who were whatever the measure is for being the lowest proficiency of whatever is in that gr to show how whatever we're doing got them into a higher level forget about this test in anything like where where is some piece of data that you point to and say what we're doing is being successful because I have the utmost confidence that we
045are being successful I just would like to have a number to point to say here this is is how you know we're successful it's not a gut feel it's not a of course we're being good what numbers do you look at at the end of the year so I can't say that we we took these 15 students but we are looking at students individually so I would be able to say um and the buildings would be able to say at their at risk meetings and at their IST instructional study team meetings that's where we look at data where we're spending time talking about individual ual students and the the growth and all of the measures that I talked about that's embedded into all of those meetings so we're go we're really going one student at
046a time and we you know we do see progress and sometimes um it's not as steep of a slope as we would like sometimes it's a little bit flatter but we do see progress that's where the tiered interventions come in right so that's where we start with tier one tier two tier three we collect data for a bunch of weeks we try something else until they're successful until there's some growth so it's hard for us to say um you know we took this whole group and how did this whole group move because every student's different so we're truly going student by student so that's why it's hard I'm not avoiding the question but it's hard for me to give an answer to aggregate I don't think you're avoiding I don't know if we're talking past
047each other or some of this information isn't as simple as I'd like hear my head and and that's how how it comes across but I'm still struggling to understand how someone walks in knows nothing about Jericho okay show me how I have a third grader show me the progress that he or she is going to make over the next five years what can you show me to show me how students are going to be whether he was a one when he gets there or three when it gets there show me that you that that your students are making progress how how do you know that it's ex I'm going if you don't mind it's just that that for instance if a third grader scores a two we will go in and look at that two
048deeply and if it's a low two and then the following year in fourth grade that student scored a high two we know just based on this one particular data point that that child has made progress even though it's still a two in our results so we act Helen is spot on we actually literally go student by student we really do right you but okay and so if have the student by student data you're saying at no point do we ever aggregate it and say that um we from third grade to fourth grade were able to increase I'm not talking about twos or threes or 2. a low two to we don't have any aggregate information that we can point to and say here this is what our fourth grade teachers were able to accomplish by
049taking a student students who are this level in third grade and now they here in fourth grade we do not have anything like that not as a group we literally do individual students so so what happens is at the elementary level um you know teachers will bring at an IST meeting instructional support team meeting teachers will bring up a student if they have a concern and those teachers also they have to bring data to those meetings to support so it's more authentic classroom data I'm concerned this child is struggling what are we going to do about it and we sit as a team or building sits as a team and they develop strategies and that those strategies are monitored every six weeks with data but it truly is an individual student by student piece question
050yeah I have a question just asking for the I mean the the focusing point for the education here is like you were talking about the individual students right if some student have some need to be improved you're focusing on that area but there are two ends right some students they might have their strength on something do you also to devel those group of your student that them go first enrichment is absolutely buil it's built two ends right the talk remediation versus enrichment en we don't want to we go beyond the four yes one trying to say there are two two groups of the people right our goal is not averaging them right focus on the yeah yeah correct you help the top are you only focusing on those or you helping both of them those
051AB absolutely so every every student should have the opportunity to grow and to be challenged right so that means and I think this is to your to your point students who are performing at a very high level yes they need to also be challenged cor so the growth we're not focusing all of our energy solely on moving students from a level two to a level three we need to make sure that even our students who are at a level four which is at a Mastery level we don't want them sitting around admiring their own work we well they can admire their work but we want to give them appropriate challenges so we we're doing as much enrichment as we are um pre- teaching and reteaching and Remediation also yeah thank you that was question our
052classrooms are very differentiated teachers were trained a lot on how to work with children at all yep within one class on their own strength and their own correct C thank [Applause] you we're going to move into the uh preliminary budget discussion Mr Emanuel is going to be leading that so as we uh as we come back up together I just I want to point out and again I've done this numerous times before one of the strengths of our school district is that we have the ability to focus on the every individual child whether the child is here here here or here that that we are able to deliver that because of the work of the curriculum Associates so tonight you heard from two curriculum Associates who spend their entire day analyzing data and providing professional
053development for teachers to support every kid who's here here here and here the work that the curriculum Associates do the end result is when our kids graduate our kids are almost 100% of them at Mastery and again large part of that is from excellent classroom teaching and from the work of the administrators and the support of the parents but again I don't think people fully understand the role of the curriculum associates they spend their day working with analyzing kid by Kid by Kid working with teachers to to how can I best support this seven-year-old kid or 10-year-old kid or 12-y old kid uh and it's something that that again I think we we need to to recognize and say thank you to the role again the role of everyone in the organization but the leadership
054within the curriculum Associates two of whom you heard an excellent presentation tonight and I thank I thank all the curriculum Associates and and the teachers as well good evening everyone um just want to start the budget um discussion a little early this year um we received a little information earlier than we normally do so it worked out well with the timing as far as process We Begin the budget process basically as soon as school starts for the next school year so in September we're sending out information to the principals to curriculum Associates um to provide us information in November uh regarding Staffing enrollments um supplies equipment Etc and we had our first round of staff meetings uh in the last couple of weeks the first round is obviously just based on current enrollment where we
055are roll those grades forward and see what sections we may or may not have for the following year so we completed that process and that's an ongoing process process especially at the high school level where students will be choosing their courses as we get into uh the winter months as far as information um one of the big pieces is the tax cap so that's one of the areas that we received some earlier early information which was good for us um two big pieces of that is the CPI which will be over 2% so the calculation is 2% or the C whichever is lower so that part of the calculation will be 2% and then there's the tax-based growth factor which we receive from the office of real property taxes and for Jericho that's 66% additional
056on top of the 2% so as of now we're looking tax capit will probably be in the high twos to around three at this point um health insurance uh good news for next year we were very surprised pleasantly surprised the health insurance rates are increasing minimally um in most areas and flat in a couple of other areas which is really good excited about that that's one of the biggest pieces of the budget any any decreases re like so minimally uh but there were a couple of like individual uh health insurance that did actually go down a little bit very little um extremely unusual yes especially last year year where we saw 15 to 20% hug yeah um teachers retirement system basically flat maybe negligibly a little bit lower as far as far as the employer
057contribution rate which gets multiplied by the payroll so we'll see a slight increase overall in that employees retirement system went up pretty significantly probably 10 to 15% in that area um transportation we discussed this last year uh will be going out for an RFP this year uh which will definitely increase our uh first student uh prices for next year I don't want to go into too much detail until the RFP goes out but um as I mentioned in the last couple of years we're anticipating um increases in that area uh payroll typical um probably overall payroll is probably going to go up about 3% with the new um hires that we had this year um and that's basically where we are is that because is that because of um increases or just additional teachers combination
058okay overall payroll um again that's probably half of our budget uh payroll health insurance is another big part do you know what the heral increase was the year before remember approxim probably about the same was it about the same yeah so over year over year are we going up about 3% of P for the most part sometimes um in the last contract it was probably a little bit uh lower um we did have enrollment increases over the last few years so Staffing General increase uh both at the teacher level as well as the teacher Aid level uh we saw uh this year definitely in the a categories for IEPs 101 AE probably increase um at a decent clip this year as far as the number of people um and then the other piece that we'll
059start talking about in January is capital we're still reviewing that um and we'll have more information in January the architect will be joining us to go over the uh building condition survey that they did um over the last few months and um that's basically where we are at this point is there anything on the horizon as far as large projects besides Building Maintenance obviously aging of buildings anything thatfor the next two to three or four years that we might want to add on like for example we did at turfield a couple years you know ago that might like addition type of yeah like a big Capital project like aight room uh that's up to the board that will remain on the list like it has but um there are definitely more items maintenance wise as
060far as the new building condition survey it's the first one that we've done in probably eight or nine years so they'll definitely you mentioned that a couple months ago yeah it used to be every five years it was mandated for every District at the same time what the state did because they didn't want to get 700 districts in this at the same time every five years they started spreading it out so in doing that we were this year as far as doing the building addition seron so we're do we did and we we're going to be presenting those results at the January meeting do you have that information already or are you just working through it working through it so you'll definitely see more items on the capital plan spreadsheet per building than we did
061last year which I mentioned that after the building condition survey there will definitely be more items on the list yeah for the building condition survey it's definitely more needs than want so the build is also a year older so it's you know since well since we did the last building could condition survey sever right but I mean just year to year we're obviously looking at building condition but you do the survey but you know you have that just year over year you're going to have deterioration of of of certain maintenance items 100% yeah you had mentioned that you um you guys have spoken to different departments different staff as far as needs yes right um anything uh coming out of the technology department that they foresee would cost you know more than the usual as
062far as investing in new whether it's new cyber security new platforms of any kind the as far as cyber security I I think we're at a level where budget Wise It's not going to impact okay I think um we are definitely beginning the recycling program for Chromebooks uh districtwide uh we did a major purchase um during Co and we're at that point where those that were purchased then need to start getting replaced at a at a higher level than we have in the last few years okay so there's there has been no big asks from the technology department as of yet there's there's constant asks but nothing other than the Chromebooks that I mentioned that would impact the budget in a significant way and so and my last question then I'll let Sam ask whatever
063um as far as needs or wants should we should the board mention that like soon or like deadline to mention that it would be uh preferably sooner rather than later this way I could so can we uh and I don't know how this works but I foresee um setting aside a small dollar amount this is proba very small in comparison to other things for outside Council to be able to retain outside councel is that something I once again very small in comparison to anything come that's budgeted already the board would like to have have have someone on outside counsel as retainer that budget line is Oh flexibility always okay I thought that that's not while we have a retainer while we have a retainer every year we also budget for un unforeseen legal legal issues
064so there is there is money in that code got it above and beyond what we would need for your recommendation thank you are we talking about now sure before we go on with on the budget is tight it's not you sound like my husband it's not it's don't ask yeah it's um there's not a lot of room for wants but go ahead okay so we had discussed um several I don't even know how many years ago that we would like to add a PPS person um each year social worker psychologist so we were we had been doing that for the past several years except we didn't have at what level Elementary Middle High School we no just generally we said we were going to add a you know Social Work guidance you know we were
065going to add to that each year and we had done that every year except we didn't do that this year so I would like to I think Jill I think to your question I I think we had talked about we we added a an elementary position that's now serving serving all three buildings and we had talked about the the uh the aspirational goal or the goal of uh increasing that level to two or three over over a number of years I think you know at this point um we have we have that position in the working budget uh but again we we want to get Victor's draft budget uh into January and see what that bottom line Looks like in relation to the uh the tax cap uh so as we and we're also looking
066at at potentially as we're reviewing staffing needs we're looking at some significant increases in general Staffing so in that in that discussion between now and early January we again we all want to see that position in we'll have to do an analysis of that as we get to the bottom line of the Staffing budget okay I just wanted to reiterate that that is on our want list and like I said if you didn't hear me the weit something that you know I guess that would be a capital thing rather theat reformer that that'll be on the spreadsheet but it will not be highlighted but if that if we're talking about a capital that would be a separate Capital project probably [Music] not one of one of the conversations Joe that that we had um with
067with our architect and frankly it's a number that that surprised me um John and I guess it's been verified by U some other school school districts that are currently going out for work new construction is now running for our estimate purpose $1,000 a square foot which is absolutely I mean insane uh in terms of as as you look at uh any any new construction in any school district and again Victor was not that long ago where we looking at know $500 $600 a square foot um and it just the prices since Co um again and $1,000 a square foot is an absolutely ridiculous number should have done a bond and built everything six years ago um I don't know we made that recommendation but uh along those lines not to to to just add on
068to Mrs citron's point I I think also is the most popular class here I think Coro might be the most popular class I know the initial plans we had for the wait room included some new dance studio which I'm sure Mrs Corbett Mrs leonetti would fully appreciate as with the hundreds of students who currently participate in in in that program um for the technology that Mrs vof asked about is it possible perhaps for the technology department to put together almost like a road map for technology purchases the way Mr Han and and you put together a road map for Capital expenditures just because like you mean as far as like what um what we're doing this year what we're doing next year like like a three or four year road map to say this is
069what we want these are the you know if there's yeah devices or infrastructure things like that I didn't remember see I mean well if it's if it wasn't in the technology when we get to technology I think that's the third presentation um I'll ask Patrick what that in again I think when when Patrick is presented he has presented um this year I'm planning on buying 600 grown and you know 100 iPads and I think typically he has laid out for us and you know that that is this year's plan and we'll make sure that he talks about next year the year after well no he certainly said what he's done doing for this year but it's like also you know what we're doing for the next three years so it's not just okay this is
070what it is next year we're going to do it um with the technology plan only because it's come up recently again I know that there's 1,800 factors that go into it and hopefully when we get rid of cell phones they will become much easier here but some focus on our Wi-Fi and you know systems here where whether it's students or parents who are in the building I I still hear about it but um I don't I don't see it as much as they do wireless access points I think are included in our eate so I think there's an upgrade in that area in your what Your eate it's it's Federal funding oh just I'm sorry back to dance studio and and the weit room are we is there anything else guys oh I mean the
071SE Auditorium is always going to be in there as a as a line item joke but yeah it's always good for Chu 10 10 mil I think the weight plus wait for that's four for the double story dance studio weit room or is that just the one story weight room that's the wait that's the weit room if you build a s that's if I build it if I P for it I'll take it under advisement along with Jennifer's husband he I go on well if we can do with two story and we could do the Pearlman weight room on the first store first story and the Barton off on the second story so when when it comes to the Thousand I'm just curious with the per square foot is that when you're dealing with demolishing
072something I mean demolition is usually very cheap that's just new construction that's new construction is $1,000 a square foot so when so the you have to you have to demolish it to kind of it no se it would be new construction it would be an I think that I think we had looked at you know building it next to the uh next to the gy but it would be that would be new construction the perin weit room would be new construction you can see perin spends very little time in the weight room so he really doesn't get that excited about it um you may not this is sort of weird one as I was saying before I've been going through a lot of just state why statistics when I look at us news and World
073Report and they talk about Jericho they say that we have revenue of $40,000 per student and we have a spend of $355,000 per student where's the other $4,500 I'm not sure exactly what Sam no I'll send you I'll it's from their website like I said I was going through I was just sort of looking to see how various districts reported to sort of Benchmark it and every district has that every district has you know several th000 whether it's $2 to $5,000 more Revenue per student than spend per student and I SP per student will likely not include the propositions that we do every year so the propositions that we do every year that is spending out of the capital reserves that would not be included in some the spending data that is out there and
074that makes a pretty significant difference also if you look at at different sources and very frankly I I don't understand it but you look at us news report and say 40 um and you look at at other um other reports I've seen A variation that's been from high high 30s to mid mid-40s um in in in their depiction of our expend expenditure per student and I don't know whether they have again different different variables of what they include and what they don't include but again i' I've over the years I've always seen five six s $8,000 variation in terms of what they tag us as spending per kid what they include what they don't include my experience has been the same when I looked at it even what a district says not just ours what
075other districts say they spend and then what gets reported here I'm just try to figure what that Delta is but Sam I me you've been on the board for four years you've been in the district a long time you know that Delta is used to put into Capital reserves and capital projects year after year after year no no 100% I understand that but it's like every District like I can show you Jer rosn scas Great Neck Garden City East Williston all of them have this three or $4,000 difference some of them spend a lot more on capital projects that they do some of them spend a lot less but it just seems like in the current numbers there everybody's got a three to four and half thousand Delta there which leads me to believe it's
076not just oneoff projects because everybody's not building at the same amount of time if you like I said I was trying to figure it out I'll call us new world figure out I don't know what it is I but again I'll go back to you know what we do with our Surplus every single year 100% it's putting it into Capital reserves and we put forth propositions every year a lot of districts you mentioned earlier Bond everything and they don't have a lot of capital reserves and that's why I don't think Capital reserves is what compensates for that that's what I'm saying because every District even those with like sasin who just put out hundreds of millions of bonds they still have a a Delta there of $5,000 wait wait till you see but Sam wait
077till you see what that Delta is 3 years from now that Delta will be based upon 17 I both W be here so it's okay but both of us you just mentioned about 4,000 per student we have 3,000 kids that's a surplus of $12 million we do not have a surplus of $12 million no Mr man I never thought it was a surplus I didn't know what they were saying this was is this what they're saying Administration is is this what they're saying it's like I don't know what we could spend $12 million on I I did that math that's assuming this data is even accurate are we providing this data or are they getting this provide obviously we provide all of our financial data to the State education department which that information is obviously
078foilable by any online it's online right um and there are times where they include the proposition to Capital work which to me doesn't really make sense because that's not comparing Apples to Apples of what your general um expenses are for the year that's an add-on that we do because we have the money saved already and and again it's it depends on how they use the data I look I think their data is right I just don't know what their data is like there's lots of ways of presenting numbers and this I was just trying to if Mr R would ever looked at it well they do this across lots of different right absolutely measur I mean hospitals schools again colleges like you said you did the math we don't have a colge no and that's
079why I didn't think it was Surplus I thought they were breaking it apart and I thought maybe in your spare time you looked at it one year and you said oh that's what it it is but that's fine um you said it before between fixed cost for salaries insurance I'm salaries health insurance retirement benefits and all that we think that this coming year is still going to be around that 75% 72 to 75% of the budget uh probably and finally Bose's Aid readers but what is our percentage each year what was our percentage for this most recent year that you have no risk for what was our B's a reimbursement changes every year and the bottom line Aid is probably about 52% um there's gross amounts which are higher but then there are certain expenses
080that are pulled out of that um and we get eight the net Aid is about 52% so 52% of the stuff we buy through bosies we get about 52% back from the state yeah so just and just want overall BOS AG if we're buying something what do we get on our on our laptop on our Chromebooks buy that's probably the higher amount there's not much deducted from that so we get most of that back from the state you're saying only 60 got it okay um thank you oh and uh I know it was a surprise to me we've got more be property beautification projects that we have thrown in like we had all that planting by the front that was a surprise when we came back we just add those in every year what do
081you mean which we planted the whole a bunch of trees by the guest parking lot by the ad by the by the administration bilding outside where the buses are all that stuff it was just like it was beautiful but it was just surprised we do things like that on an annual basis that's not a capital project that's something we just do through the uh budget okay wonderful anybody else right thank you for the excellent um so that concludes the the two scheduled uh presentations for this evening thank you to everybody for presenting I know we have a few people here tonight uh not to preempt the the work session but I know uh the community is is deeply interested in what's going on with regionalization we firmly intend to to give a very detailed update
082uh next week at our board meeting but in the interest of just following up from the previous board meeting before Thanksgiving the state did meet on December 9th the the board regions December 9th and December 10th as we anticipated they verbally walk back back some of the things they said they were going to do unfortunately the written rule uh doesn't reflect that uh so in keeping to our word uh the Board of Education of Jericho in no way supports this regionalization plan uh we are the process right now of uh beginning to look at uh other avenues with respect to uh legal representation to see how we want to proceed but we did indicate that if if this was not done to our satisfaction and and walk back in a sign significant way that we
083be pursuing uh legal remedies and again we are beginning to look at that right now hopefully we'll have more of an update next week but uh we will pursue this aggressively do you want to join the we're looking at that I I don't so I'm not saying no and and again that's something Bo would ultimately have to agree upon we want to do what's best for Jericho and may very well be the the the course of action that we take but you know individually or perhaps with other districts that are not involved article 78 is is what the the Coalition is pursuing and again I commend them for their efforts I just want to make is the most vigorous and my understanding at this point is we do have standing at this point to pursue
084legal action previously we w't sure um and we will to that um be looking at at different options but I I uh considerably more information next to report but this board is in the process now of doing due diligence to identify how we want to pursue the the legal action and again for for clar again for clarification is everyone at this table and everybody within on the same page we are in 100% agreement of how going to move forward to protect the district the board of regions took the word compelled out of the how they did not make it as black and white as we wanted to see it so as long not done that there is unanimity within our school district that we need to pursue our options right now the board is going
085to look at what our options are with through what agencies and hopefully we will have more information by again a week away difficult time of the year but hopefully we'll have more information to share with you next Thursday we did not we did not inform the state that we are opting out of the of the regionalization offici officially yes correct okay so on we could not take that action tonight on our board agenda it's already on our board agenda there is a resol solution from the Board of Education saying superintendent please inform the State education department we will not participate that is on our agenda for next Thursday with full agreement from our Board of Education what's the that bu for about well well it's it's in January we're well before the deadline we're we're
086in line with with pursuing legal action if we have to if we want to join the Coalition we have PL more appropriate for Jericho we're going to going to you know take that option we're going to look at the costs involved in doing all of this it's our responsibility you know to make sure that we're responsible with the with the taxpayers money but I I I can assure you that we will not participate in regionalization and to to to the the truth of what we said at the last meeting we are pursuing legal action we will be speaking with with law firms we will getting be getting legal opinions and we will do what is best for Jericho but but make no mistake we will not comply with this January 15th is the deadline to
087opt out of regionalization so we we have plenty of time for that as as I think the superintendent or Dr just said today was a work session so you know technically we could do whatever we wanted but you know bad form to take a vote since we have a meeting next Thursday as the superintendent said agenda for next week's meeting comes out tomorrow afternoon evening so if you go online see that proposal on that proposition on on our agenda for next week in terms of litigation it's a little fuzzier but we have we believe until at least January if you're had a sue would what matter so additionally I I asked the board I said I am not going to send the 54 page document that they've requested I'm not going to finish filling it
088out and I am not going to send it to the state and I said with your permission informally it will be with their permission next Thursday we will will not we have not submitted it we will not submit it the board officially will give me permission to not submit it next Thursday so we're we're we're we're we're on the right Road and we will have an update next Thursday night with respect to our legal position and and what we think will be best to pursue but again we we will share that fully with you and you know I anticipate we'll have good information yeah thank you and comment is that for next would you like to share draft of the reply that email I mean the response to all us next Thursday to share your
089response to who to the state to the state I mean the draft you would like to take a look at before you click the B is is the letter going to be you're talking about saying that we're opting at of regionalization not the lawsuit you're talking about opting out of regionalization on the agenda it's it's a copy of that a dra that is on the agenda you'll a to read the language theend the agenda will we're in the process now putting the final touches on the agenda once the agenda is approved the agenda will be posted and then we will we will read that letter yeah in public put that you you will see it can go online tomorrow night you can see it in print tomorrow night website you will send the parents Square
090no no actually if you if you go on the Jericho schools website and you click on district and you click on board of educ can able to agenda for the meeting which is next Thursday December 19th and you will be able to see the agenda and you will be able to see the the verbiage of that letter again we're going to discuss this at length next Thursday night and in great detail we will read that letter in that meeting because the board is going to have to approve that letter being sent but again I don't like to speak for people but this is going to opt out we're not completing that survey Mr Gman is not doing and we are going to pursue legal action so I can tell you in no uncertain terms that's
091the plan yeah you'll see that letter before posted and into a chat room or into an email and you know you you'll all be able to see it well before next Thursday's thank you thank you people like to take a look at it you click the it's going to be it's not going anywhere until next week after the board meeting again we have I haven't seen it it's a very simple letter saying we're not doing this thank you very much thanks and good luck we're not we're not participating yes we have a final decision on on the legal by next First's meeting I I don't want to promise you that we're going to have a final decision because I like I said we're we're in the process now of of seeking additional legal advice because
092again article 78 proceeding and we talked about this on November on November 21st when we last met that may be the best route and if that's what the attorneys tell us is is the strongest and most appropriate route then we need to decide do we want to be part of article 78 with the Coalition or pursue something independently as Jericho schools which obviously you know carries uh you know significance with that so Wonder we may not have enough time to finish the resarch to make a decision why or if we need to so I actually you know we had spoken as a board if we need to call a special meeting to to conduct our business and app point law firm and pursue legal action we will before January before January so we will not
093let those deadlines get in the way of us doing what we need to do if we have to call a special meeting just like the state said this is an emergency this is an emergency for Jericho we will call a special meeting we will all get together and we will pass whatever motion we need to pass to to get the work done so am I understand that correctly saying that taking the legal action is for sure right and then how to with that under this at this point at this point you know based upon the letter that we sent to the state or and the resolution that that that we passed at the last meeting we said if the if what comes out of December 9th December 10th Board of regions meeting was not satisfactory
094to the Jericho Board of Education we were going to pursue vigorous legal action we are at that point okay we we have we have decided to take the legal action at this based on what we know at this point yes we've decided that's the taking legal action is the only alternative available to us as Dr foresto said is there's not just one course of legal action there are several courses and we just need to now take a little bit more time to determine which is the optimal course of legal action to take the strategies as the strategy exactly the strategy laion exactly the the the the the intent the intent is to do that unless yes the intent is to do that wholeheartedly the only issue is what is the best strategy and as Dr
095foreso said there are a couple of options one there's legal action by our by ourselves there's legal action with some school districts there's legal action as part of you know for the people who don't know the Coalition of independent school districts which is which is a day facto is there of an ad hoc group really who's formalized and they have their own they have litigation that we could join if we wanted to um on the off chances there some other legal principle we should be pursuing article 78 those are all things that we just need to solidify in our heads and with legal counsel to figure that out but yes the intent and the expectation is the state has left us no other choice at this point but to pursue legal action and those phone
096calls are taking place tomorrow uh we've had this conversation we we will be we've spoken with our our own in-house attorneys and we're also speaking with with other firms so that process will begin tomorrow morning okay yeah thank you thank you for clarifying that Our intention our purpose our goal is to taking the legal action since right now we don't see a proper that's happening Amendment yes 100% else those those phone calls will be made tomorrow morning we yeah thank you very much for the effort be highly a great appreciate wonderful does anybody else have any other questions on this I I I don't want to you know take too much time on this tonight because people didn't have the opportunity to be here that perhaps wanted to be here and here but what what
097I can say is that we will have you know considerable more information and we will you look forward to discussion curious that how many firm we have been contacting with like so far so far so we've spoken with our with our own firm we've done a little bit of informal research just to kind of position ourselves appropriately but you know tonight the board made the decision to formally pursue the the no no we didn't take any votes we we we are we want to toward formally pursuing legal action I don't want to misspeak so we will be speaking to law firms so then we could you know get information from them and ultimately make a decision as to you know how we want to proceed with that but we we do want to go legal
098again to retain a law firm to actually pursue to to file a lawsuit would require a vote of the entire board yeah thank you we like those kind of this kind of the open uh discussion and uh transparent discussion we would like to participate this of the meeting in the future and and we we welcome we welcome the input and to be perfectly honest with you I mean you know this this topic of regionalization has has brought the community together in ways that I can't say that I've seen in in in the recent past and again it's great that people came together that had a strong opinion on something personally I I'd like to see more Community input on all topics that affect our kids and the one presentation right I like it those data
099analysis great great but different people have different opinion like I ask questions I do have something like uh to ask I do have some concerns I mean and this is this is this is participate and this is the Forum to ask those questions yeah so I I I I I thank everybody for coming together next Thursday should be a great meeting I hope to have some more information for you that being said I I appreciate everybody coming outside and have a great evening hold on before before you go where is next week's meeting is next week's meeting back here back here it's back okay so we won't have space issues next week is 7:30 act unless lots and lots of people show up in which case we'll move to the we'll move to the auditor
100we're GNA we're going to have the you'll be able to see it on the website in the agenda legal uh legal AC