CorpusRecord 9896

School Board Workshop- 12-17-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / PutnamSchoolsTV
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Putnam County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,707 words · about 38 min
Collected
2026-06-01

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right we'll call the workshop of the uh District School Board to order and uh we'll get started with um Mr bowlan you want to make a presentation yes sir thank you good afternoon everybody good afternoon sir afternoon Susan what's that um agenda E9 so the reason we're having a workshop later today in the uh regularly scheduled board meeting agenda E9 is a change order for um paying for the additional Paving of Brandy Lane just to give you a little bit of background and I'm going to if you want to take a look at the screen I'm actually showing you Brandy Lane here and the School site can you see my cursor kind of moving around mhm this is actually the north south east side of our site this is Davis Lake Road this road

002running right here and then our school picks in right about here and then you have Horsemen Club Horsemen Horsemen's Club Road up here all right so our buses will actually come in off of Davis Lake they'll come on to Brandy l lane and then enter the School site and so going back about 2 and 1/2 years and I think uh this may have been before at least two of our board members um became board members we actually acquired a portion of this road we looked to do a an easement at first and then we decided to go a little bit different route because one owner basically owned um the majority of this road so he we actually bought we we purchased this road for $5,000 June of 2022 and so now we have access to

003this part of the school our intent is to pave this portion of the road so obviously our buses can enter onto Brandy Lane and then ultimately enter the School site and I am getting ahead of myself a little bit I'm going to pause right here for a second and then I'll pick this back up just to recognize some of the people who are here so from the construction site I have Jim hurry um who's here as the uh you're the uh lead project manager correct for the uh Palaca site and you probably just met him because I understand there was a tour um and then we have some residents from the community Renee Laro who actually works here um and then we also have and I'm I don't want to get any names wrong but

004we have um Sarah and man I should have got the right pronunciation before I tried trevarthan welcome and then we have um bilbert Warren yes I also um and after I you know go into exactly what the ask is you'll see that you know there's it crosses over to what we can do and then perhaps what the county could or couldn't do I'm not sure and I I wouldn't dare try and speak for him I did invite um Terry sugs the county commissioner uh to this Workshop today we do have uh I was about to get to him Mr sugs hasn't shown up okay um but we do have um Walton piser he is a county commissioner spoke to him very briefly I'm not going to speak for him either but he did say he's

005here just to observe so he can see what's going on and you know soak it all in so if there's something he'd like to take back to his commission he could do that um so again I I intended to have um someone from the County's Administration presid and they were invited um and they may still show up but at least you do have a county commissioner here um and then we do have some putam County administrators uh district office staff in the back and I know you're you all know them um so back to where I was on Brandy Lane so we bought B the portion that runs all the way up to where the red in and the green picks up if you want to look at it in terms of property Lots if

006you get on Brandy Lane this is the first property this is the second and right between the second and third that property line is right where it cuts off where we own right about to that green line now once upon a time I thought man this was just me thinking wasn't true but I thought we we purchased Brandy Lane all the way to the corner of our property where my cursor is now but that's not correct our property line stops right here and then in the GMP the guaranteed maximum price package that you've already approved what's included in it is Paving up to here not all the way up to here or even here where I you know originally thought it actually stops right here now we do have a service road and let me

007see if the other picture shows it a little bit better get out of that now okay yeah this shows the site a little bit better so this is for fire what do you call this road Jim it's like an emergency access road for it's an emergency access road right for fire department and such and then we have another service road that we're picking up bringing that'll come all the way up to um just the front parking lot here it'll pick up here and that's just for our maintenance people when we want to access the site to do anything so I'm not not 100% sure how much of this road will'll need from here to here um but there's there could be a possibility that we could and then this is playground right here so even

008to come about here to our property line again it's between that second and third house you're pretty much coming across some playground right here so you know as a Schoolboard you have to ask yourself how much of this is necessary to PVE um that we actually that we actually own um the contractors and I think this was part of um you know just overall planning with you know between contractors and and Architects how much road we actually need to successfully enter the project I'm sorry enter the project I'm sorry enter the property to do exactly what we need to do I'm going to go back to this other real quick so again this is what we intend to pave this is what we own so when we first started we had a a neighborhood meeting

009um with the residents all were invited from the entire neighborhood whether they lived in one of these homes or over here but by and large the residents from the homes on this side of Brandy Lane showed up and it was basically a meeting meet and greet a Q&A it was just us meeting with the uh resident saying what can we do to help with noise mitigation um you know this is coming in your neighborhood what can we do to actually make this better this site has been selected this will be an intrusion into your your neighborhood what can we do to it all feasible um we talked about some things such as you know noise mitigation um you know they had uh the residents had very reasonable and lots of simple requests such as um

010you know can you keep your Gates closed more for our pets you know we don't want them in um when when it it doesn't NE necessarily need to be open um on this side of the property and that was easy enough to do um on our property we had some grownup weeds and and I think that was back on this side there was a request to cut some of this stuff down and we did that just because it was unsightly um there was a request for some type of privacy fence back here which I think is a good idea because our children will be on the background on the playground back here so um we'll probably not probably we'll have something that conceals the site and our chain link fence on the back end here

011um but wanted to ask was if you're going to pave a portion of this road can you pave all the way down to the end and so I said we can certainly look into it I'm not going to tell you note to anything without investigating I said we'll look into it and we'll um you know we'll we'll exhaust all the the the leads we can I didn't think there was a really a a legal way but you know we have Schoolboard attorneys and and um and I don't go just by what I think is possible or isn't possible I like to dig into it and see so after I came back and I did some of that um as a school administrator or District administrator I found out that you know if you spend money

012on Prop that's not associated with the school board it's probably going to show up as an audit finding and and it's possible that the district would have to pay it back um so it kind of started there with me and and I kind of immediately went to if we do this we'll probably have to break a rule or two and um which it would need to go before the board I'm not going to be we you know we're charged with being good custodians of the uh taxpayers and and uh just State and federally appropriated funds um this is all state but at any rate it's above my pay grade it needed to come to the board to be worksho um so reached out to the County's Administration for them to show up I explained to

013them what the ask was to see if there was anything they could do to maybe pull it in um on their side and again I invited the Administration and and they said that uh commissioner pelir would possibly be here Terry Suggs indicated he might be here so um I'm not going to speak for them any more than just that um they are aware that this does exist um but that's essentially the crooks of it I've invited um the residents from the neighborhood to come out they have some concerns I don't want to speak for them I'd like for them to speak directly to you so you can hear their concerns um but the only other thing is just the cost um can I ask Jim a question first or do we have something else you

014want to do before I was just going to give you the cost of it all right go ahead and give the cost yes sir so the cost to have the the road paved beyond what we've already included in our um GMP is an additional $799,990 and then you you receive that week ago but in the last couple days I believe it was Thursday or Friday Renee Laro reached out to me and of course you know Rene works for us but she lives in this neighborhood and is directly impacted by our project um she said what about the price of of just pillings put down and or millings I'm sorry and um that was the one that I just had I think it's one on one of the slides that has two pictures let's try this

015one there it is no that's the original one I just lost the other one did you okay it's 62,000 right it's $2,113 and you should have a hard copy of it okay before we um is there any questions from Mr bowling before I move to the uh project manager up here just disapp my question would be to the project manager okay come on up Jim and I'd need him to show exhibit a up here because I want to ask him a question about the road that goes in for fire access yeah that's probably what he wants right now don't worry about that other one right now exhibit a is what I'm looking there you go no it was there you go if we're going to Jim my question is if we come in off of

016Brandy Lane and we're going to have a fire Access Road that's going to come in there and cross the back of the across the school ground there why wouldn't you just go up to the corner and come right straight down the property line what is there a reason for that well I I think probably because you don't own that road and to access the property is probably you're access accessing it from the Schoolboard property you know coming in off the bus Loop right there okay CU I thought Thomas said we owned it it only goes where I'll show you it doesn't go all the way down to that corner it yeah but my question is if we on it to there why why wouldn't you take the just go up with the with a fire

017access road and go in there unless there's a reason for that be crossing the playground wouldn't you I think they're trying to preserve that play area right there cuz that's that's the only piece of property left there that's hasn't been Disturbed you know for kids to play on right there I got you I got you but also on that North property line there's uh um there's some monitoring Wells probably some whales I forgot about the haze that that are still there that uh St John's Water Management District comes out and monitors monitors so they come out every couple months and take water samples right there so when Walton was in school out there I tried to teach him how to read those gauges but he never could learn it very good yeah so that area

018is fenced off right there um at that northeast corner that was my question yeah so you would have to you'd have to come across the play area but other purpose of that road there's there's fire hydrants on that so it was was part of the uh fire department access to the hydrants well that makes on the north side of that property too we're that far along but I was just curious so I think it you know it it provides the access for fire department and preserves the play area there so gotcha all right uh any questions for project manager I have one oh yes ma'am go ahead um I just want to be clear the the extension that we're talking about for these funds is from the end of where we've already budgeted for what

019you see all the way the whole thing that's in the yellow yeah the area that's highlighted in yellow it's a purple I guess purple or blue depends how you look at it that that was The Proposal was based on that extension right there and there's and everything up to that point would be in the GMP already as far as the widening road to the to the south of that and Paving that that's already included in the GMP has there has there been any um discussion of just taking it to that next Road at that corner of the school property um the corner or where we we'd have to how far up it Amendment and add money to it I went out last week and looked at that and now now I remember the monit correctly

020coming up to here is the property we own if you're talking about all the way up here we don't own this of thead right we property what we paid for already okay okay and so we're looking at let me pull up that other slide we own the property all the way to the corner though no I mean yes property not the road correct come here I think maybe what you're asking about right I'm just wondering and and maybe that'll be initially I thought we were all of this yeah and that would cost us money to do I mean as far as access to the school what what the school needs is is basically what we're Paving now you know to allow buses to get into to the Bus Loop I'm with you you know um

021anything beyond that wouldn't be accessed by buses or the school district for any reason yeah I remember the monitoring Wheels now after riding down and looking at it last week so yeah they they've come in and parked up by our trailer and walk back there or sometimes they'll drive in the back to get to those mon Wells so they they will still need access to that that northeast corner over there all right board any other questions for Mr bowling or the or Jim the project manager okay I'm did you have a question yes Mr chair go ahead I you you you made a statement about uh doing something that legally we cannot purchase would you restate that for me let the yeah we' got a you have a board attorney to talk about talk okay

022all right yeah I wanted I'm good to let the board know that um Mr bowling and myself and Mr Holmes met last week um to discuss this um and I'm going to call on him but before I do that I'm going to go a little bit out of order I'd like Mr pelir to come up and just talk about the the msbu and what the county potentially could do from that standpoint um in the fact that it's you know um what the potential for the county doing helping um I'm actually working on another msbu it's quite a bit larger than this one um is are y'all familiar with the msbu explain it to them um Municipal servicing benefits unit I think is that right Mr hes said it right um what it is is if

023um the group of people that live on that road wanted to enter into this they would um um agree to to give the county the land and enough land to to give us a way to handle the water handle the paving and then they would um break up the payment of that over 15 years I think they might even go 20 um so that it doesn't hit you at one time because it is enhancing the value of your property should you decide to sell and move on um there's a couple ways of and Mr Holmes you straighten me out if I get this messed up that you can do it uh one if everybody agrees to it on the road great grand and wonderful or you can um If U over half of the people

024on the road agree to it they can do it am I saying that right Mr Holmes they can they can they can I really don't know I really haven't I think it is dealt with mspu oh okay well I'm I'm winging this one without legal counsel um that they can do it and force it upon you to do it if the majority wants to they can I think Lake Estates out in West putam have done that over the years in different areas they you have to have 50% Plus for one yeah this actual this this situation I'm working on on another one they have 17 residents so if nine people on that road want to do it it's going to get done and some people on that road are just this one I'm talking about

025they don't have Frontage property they just have a legal access off of that road down a lane you might say to where they live in the rear but um they would be taxed with that cuz there have been benefiting from it um it's really depends a lot upon what you know the residents of your road want to do or see accomplish there um some people love payments some people don't you know it just depends on neighbors you can have neighbors that Feud I don't know about your situation this one I'm dealing with is um I've got a couple feers that for whatever reason are uh bickering back and forth and I don't know if if we're going to get off the ground or not but um we're going to try to move forward and and

026so commissioner uh would there be any potential to add that portion to the um betterplace plan projects or or I I can't honestly say that without you know Consulting legal and um this one that I'm talking about is a substantially larger one not not a great deal longer but there's just a lot more folks on it that that it might benefit more than just the what is there four or five we said Mr yeah okay thank you um I'm sorry did the board have any questions for commissioner P here okay good I'm good um I'll open it to public comment um please come up state your name and your address for the record and um generally we limit it to three minutes but I'm going to be lenient today since we got a whole hour

027for this so whoever wants to speak first Renee lamro 118 Brandy Lane I'm at the almost at the end of this road um and I like to refer to myself in this situation as the person caught in the middle because I have worked in the school district for 35 years and I have lived on this road for 31 of them um having been an administrator in this District I have worked many a day of a bus Loot and I know of every parent that will try to escape a parent drop off and pickup line by coming in the back way the only way they have if they get past the Bus Loop and go oh good gosh can't get in here is turning around on the unpaved part which is ours um in this view

028right here I'm just going to say this and I'll make this larger I'm so sorry this is my driveway that we recently paid $5,000 to have it milled because of water runoff from a neighboring property um my car literally got stuck the water off came from something that occurred with the the school build I'm just going to say it like that and I'll go into detail just a little bit longer um my my point is we know parents aren't going to stop at that gate when they try to sneak in the back door they're they're just not people who come to view the school now come down our road because you can see it better from the back view than you can in the front I mean me myself you can ask Dr Cy every

029um leadership meeting we have I almost am in tears talking about how phenomenal this thing is for our children you know and for it to be in my front yard is amazing to me my whole Road might not think it's amazing but as a lifelong educator it is amazing to me to watch this but it's also been a pain in the rear I'm not going to lie about that Thomas and Dr ceny and the contractors were wonderful when we had problems with noise back in what was it June it was in a locken graduation day actually because Dr Cy was out there in a three-piece suit in the sun um with how they could help us out with that I mean literally Windows rattled at 5: in the morning and um they helped a ton

030so I'm very appreciative My worry is that the end of our road is already terrible and it's getting worse so I'll back up and say I do understand um you give and you get I understand how all that works our neighbor that lives in front of us gave up part of his land for the Construction office I understand you you can rent that and I wouldn't want to give up my land for the for anything you know well the his driveway got milled it's beautiful it's gorgeous there's a pad in the back for a pole barn you see it right there to the right this directly faces my property water runs off off it like nobody's business and I believe the Milling was done in tradeoff for us using that absolutely and I get that

031100% right I am not complaining that they got something out of that cuz I I would too to be honest but also off to the left the grass is growing over it now there's a very large section you can see the lighter color of clay that was deposited and spread out on that same land where they dug up the driveway and now I'm talking the house looks like South Fork I grew up with these people I love these people they're like my brother and sister I mean one of them I started kindergarten with I've taught with every day of my teaching career um water doesn't soak in there it runs off it runs off into my yard it runs off into Sarah's yard it runs off into delbert's yard and Clay had X yard also

032but clay couldn't be here today so my issue is that our end of the road is going to continue to wash out just because of the way this was done and it was basically the payment for using the property we literally buy the humongous contractor bags of rocks from Lowe's all the time Delbert can tell you they're out there helping us filling the holes from the water run off and I only know that it's got to get worse because as cars come and turn around as this continues to run off I don't see it getting better um we've offered negotiations I guess you know we went from Paving the whole thing and it looks like the initial quote was for two lanes all the way down we don't we don't require two lanes all the

033way down I actually think it would be a great idea to move to one lane to show some kind of visual discrimination between the school property and you know it gets a little bit smaller cuz you're coming to a dead end and you're going to turn around in my driveway that's the only way out um and then I said well maybe millings is cheaper I don't know so if millings is cheaper we could go that way I just would love to have something to where we don't continuously have to fix our our end that's just my point Mr Lambo let me let me a couple things because I in my other capacity I do land use planning Consulting and very familiar with msbu and and Mr Hayes should have got a permit from the Water

034Management District because they consider millings impervious area and that you must have a require you know you're required to get a permit if you impact more than a certain number of square feet or or Acres with with respect to that so you know he could solve that by you know digging a a drainage Pond there and and sloping that but you know that that's one option which I would you know pursue the second thing is is that um you can also put up a sign at the beginning of that road saying Private Drive no no trespassing and hopefully that would stop people from going down that road um and then secondly um I do think that you have the option now you'd have to go to the commission and and probably that's you know would

035be my recommendation your next stop get on their agenda and E either decide that you're going to do an msbu either Paving or millings or or um if you're not going to do that you know ask them how long it would take to get that portion of the road put on their better place plan fund project schedule okay okay we can do that and the last thing I'm going to say is this this won't be the feuding neighborhood this is not going to be the feuding neighborhood these five houses we are this is one big happy family the the unpaved part I'm leave it at that the unpaved there that's right at the curve and where would the dog pins be the dog pins are by that trailer over there you'll see them in one

036photo here there they are okay and the intent of the pad is a pole bar I noticed a new pad yeah don't know it okay very nice I mean he he got a he he he needs a permit for that BM no well for a burm or or for that I mean the simplest thing for him to do and I don't think he's property zoned agriculture because he'd have to have that to be able to have an exemption non-residential farm buildings are exempt except for impervious areas that would cause that so yeah okay he needs to be a good neighbor and step up okay uh well he's the reason we found out how we got it to start with I mean it's not he he came and told us I mean everybody who knows he

037knows just as honest as they come understand appreciate your comments and you're coming today who else like to speak please give your name and your address for the record let's see there you are my name is Delbert Warner 120 Brandy Lane that's my house right there at the end of this road and uh I've only lived there a couple years but I've noticed a significant amount of water as Renee mentioned uh since the cool the school construction and has started and they and the they've actually raised that land 2 to 3 feet which uh is going to keep water off of the school property and I think there's still some water that is coming back and meeting up with that water on that pad we're required every drop of rain that falls on that property

038has to stay on the property under our Water Management District permit and it will will all Jim correct me if I'm wrong go into the existing U ponds that are on S side or the the swells I I hope that it does because there's a I don't know if there's an intent back where the wells that you mentioned are the sample Wells it slopes down and and all the the stuff that's been raised is clay and I think some of that water also Ms meets Jr's yard and it then it runs right down through my front gate and this winter when we had the The Continuous rain for several days uh I had at least two Ines of water and it was flowing through the back of my yard but the the main part is

039the road that it's causing uh the added water that then when you drive through it it uh is causing the erosion and the the goes or whatever you want to call that's that's part kind of a big word for that um and I see that from coming here that there's mention of it's unlikely that the school district can help us but it surprises me that we are on a private road and we've maintained this road uh until now and that the now with the school they're only Paving up to the gate for the school buses and the school bus is going to this is U no it'll be paid further down yeah so where that road comes in for fire access yeah no the Fire EX say you turn into comes in the same spot

040that's my question that's my question down further that it's just a little bit past the entrance buses I mean not much maybe 20 to the cor yeah well again and all that P permitted through the county through the public works department and they have the same requirement nothing that we can't impact any offsite as far as storm water it's all going to be drained and as you know uh when we had almost the 30 Ines of rain within 30 days um there there's I mean that's you know a one in, year storm event essentially now they went in and cleaned out dishes and cleaned out the ditch 219 which was the access so um you know a normal rain two to three four inches there won't be any problem but but again we won't be

041discharging any water offsite of our property okay my I would hope that at a minimum that the the County's School Board would pave to the end of their property because if there's going to be an MSB that uh that if we all incur that that the school as part of what they're doing would go up up to the end of the the property well we we'd have to do a budget amendment and that would you know and take money out of our um our bond fund to do that and you know we're trying to keep our cost down because we have a lot of construction projects that that we've got to complete before the end of the the bond cycle um you know I really think this is something that you know that the county

042should be jumping at to wal not getting nothing get but they should be since we are Paving a portion of it and that they can solve you know some problems that either through Milling or Paving that they could complete and understand that the msbu is that each property owner based on their uh you know Frontage on the road there's a calculation done and the bond or the yeah the bond is done over a 10year period and divided by the homeowners so the 80,000 divided by 10 divided by four or five I don't know how many ever homeowners that would be participating so so uh you guys are neighbors too so you're on the same road we but but we're not we're we're Paving our portion so you're not you're you it's he already showed there

043was a green section is that I can't remember the color was that you're not Paving you'd have to go all the way evidently we on the road right up to where the the fence line by the mm-m well where the where the whales are the whales are on Schoolboard property is that correct I can wait until you fin I'm done but if yeah if you could point out the part that that I don't think well I'm not as this is easy for me to say but I'm I'm not as concerned about an audit finding and people Raising Cane because I've you that's what they pay Auditors for you're going to come in you're going to every year you have audit findings if you don't have audit findings they're going to quit using those Auditors and

044find different Auditors that'll have audit findings Jonathan I'm just being I've done it a long time but uh I I I'm more inclined to to want to right here well you need to hear the attorney I want to hear the yeah I want to hear the attorney before I go to spouting off so just just to just to tease out what you're saying so we're Paving the right here and he's saying what about this other portion in green right here just this right here that the school district does own will you at least pay up to here is what he's asking now what's been what Phil was saying was um the board chair was saying that we've already agreed to pay for this and this is what's necessary to enter the school for the buses

045um do we actually want to Fork up the money to do the rest of this that's that's you know where the rub is we we could we could participate legally in an MS Buu I think um i' I'd have to you know we'd have to get our legal counsel to to discuss that but because we do have you know part a portion of that road um I think that it could be potentially could be a possibility well even if even if you just put millings down it to the top and on on our portion of our property that's a consideration and but I know we've got people that are losing their minds over everything we do when it comes to build in any school in putham County they can't see past the nose on the

046end of the face about what the future is it's impacting the residents for the to benefit our children and that's easy for me to say again but I'm not the attorney that's going to have to advise so I understand everything you're talking about that's sight's always you know even where those Wells are I think Mr Hayes used to have Jr Daddy had cows that would be in a pond right there around those Wells and and uh drank right there on the ground but anyway it's it's a wet area always has been but you never know when we might need to go in and cut across the playground and have a substantial base to support whatever vehicle goes in there I'm just saying expect the unexpected but I'm not you know everybody else needs to hear

047this but I'm whatever we do there'll be somebody pulling public records and going absolutely insane over whatever we do if it's not if it if it benefits neighbors and benefits the kids in a way I mean there's a couple of people that just are nuts over this and that doesn't stop us from making our decisions but we need to comply and follow the attorney's legal advice okay we can let's do our discussion at the end can I can I just clarify real quick you have another comment you want to make I just want to clarify real quick because I just learned this within the past few days too I didn't even understand the family that lived where Elbert lives now at the end of this road years ago he bought the easement rights in front

048of these two houses when he passed away his family sold the easement rights which the school board now owns but Mr hadic who's the third house on the road was deeded the easement rights which is green so technically clay hadock owns the easement rights here even though the school board owns the land property is my understanding which is why they only Paving the easement part that the school board owns versus the whole property I just wanted to clarify that thank you that's good clarification all right um what I'm going to do unless there's any of the other homeowners that want to speak um I'm going to ask our board attorney to um give us his legal opinion on this so there are a number of issues that are have been brought to to bear um

049let me mention the easement first without looking at a title search I couldn't tell you whether or not there is an easement across the property that the school district owns might be but as anybody who's um ever done much with land understands the devil's always in the details so there are easements that are assignable there are easements that are not assignable um there are easements that run with the land and and then they may or may not have survived so I don't know about any easement that that might be owned by anybody but to my knowledge the school boards never had uh never voiced any intent to stop anybody from utilizing that roadway in question from what I understand and I got it from my property umer um realtor earlier today um was that every

050res and then that was part of the deal every resident had EAS very well like I said without looking at title title work I I would not offer an opinion um what is clear is that uh it is inappropriate and maybe was rising to a level Beyond an audit note for a public entity to pave private property so um to the extent that we don't own weed to the extent the district does not own the roadway as long as its ownership remains intact it would be more than inappropriate for you to pave property that you don't own and there's an attorney general's opinion that specifically states that just because you paved it doesn't make it a public road so if it's owned right now by someone else other than you someone other than the school

051district and you paved it that wouldn't make it a public road it wouldn't make it your road it would still be private property but with an improvement that had come at taxpayer expense that's not that would not be something I could advise you to do obviously I'm just the attorney I don't vote but in my opinion it would be inappropriate for you to PVE property that you don't own now with regard to taking it a step further because someone's always going to ask well what if what if you somehow acquired the ownership over that property or some form of RightWay uh then could you pave it the criteria then then comes into play and it's pretty clear is that you have to be able to articulate a public purpose for the road that you're Paving

052and um you know normally public purpose extends to more than just a couple of folks in order for you to determine a public purpose but my understanding that road does dead end so it's there's not a loop you can't access the school from a different way and come in from the the far end of the road I don't know if that is it says it's oriented in a in appropriate fashion so you can't come in from the East as I understand it you can't come in from the north you you have to come in off of uh Davis Lake Road and and travel northward to get to our school site as I understand understand it so you know the the the public purpose in my opinion would be you'd be stretching it to try to

053find a public purpose there I understand it would benefit three or four homeowners but normally that's not a large enough segment of the public to constitute a public purpose so all I would tell you is that uh and then and then as a practical matter any of you that have ever done this very much and Mr pelis here would understand you know it's not always as simple as just Paving a a travel way because as the uh citizens spoke about unintended consequences now I've got now you've got more impervious surface if that is a low area then that impervious surface is going to create runoff where does the runoff go are you going to have swells alongside the new roadway that you're Paving or that somebody's Paving and where does that where does that water

054where does it go um so that's a bit of a practical side of the equation that maybe uh you can think about but is beyond my real uh opinion my opinion is if you don't own it you shouldn't pave it if it doesn't serve a public purpose you shouldn't pave it now that's my opinion and as I said I don't think so and and those are both um constitutional and statutory Provisions correct there are constitutional provisions and then and then attorney general opinions uh interpreting thank you okay what I'm going to do is um now I we say determining a public purpose is you know that may be the only gray area I'm not the one that can say whether four is going to constitute a public purpose or not normally the case law suggests

055that you need something that doesn't confer a special privilege on a small group in order for it to be taken out of the context of a purpose a private purpose in other words it has to be it has to serve a larger uh popul than just a couple otherwise it's not considered to be a quote pure public purpose it's actually serving some private interest even though there may be more than one person but that's a gray area that would be what a judge would have to decide if it were to get into that context and this is the kind of thing and the reason I say it's a kind of thing because the research I did all came in the form of um looking at opinions in taxpayer lawsuits against districts whether it be a

056county most of them are County because school boards don't normally pave a lot of roads I mean just to be honest about it that's not normally the business of a school board normally a municipality or a county or some other government entity is in the paving business the state school boards aren't normally but those all came in the form of taxpayer suits uh class action suits or suits because theoretically every member of the public who pays taxes would be funding the the roadway and then they have standing to file suit challenging it so okay I'm going to bring it back to the board and we're going to start with um M Wagner on comments or questions I just want to just for discussion's sake so we own more of the is it true Mr bowling

057we own more of the roadway than we're Paving that's correct and that's what I was clarifying with um Laro a minute ago these lines were actually uh drawn by um Jim earlier today and we pulled out property description to see exactly what we owned and where we start where our property begins right here at the end of the green and comes all the way back and then I said draw us another line based on how far up the road we're actually Paving to meet our needs to enter the property and it stops on the red so in the event and this might be for Mr Holmes but in the event that we decided to pave only only the part portion of the road that we do own uh beyond what we've planned to do the

058section in green right so if we ended up doing the section in green we would be okay as far as um public purpose and all that we wouldn't have to worry about it because we own it correct well I I think the burden would be much less on you to prove public purpose but the first criteria would be you do on it so that that criteria would be satisfied and then as far as the public purpose um you know it would be hard for anyone in my opinion to argue that you might not at some point in you might not at some point utilize that northernmost location of the paving to access your property for something you know whether it be maintenance or otherwise so yeah I mean if you're asking me do I think

059that would be a lot easier to defend the answer is yes if you paved you're still Paving adjacent to your property you're still Paving adjacent to the school site it is possible that even though right now you're planting a playground there and you might not want to cross it it is possible that at some point it would be beneficial or advisable for you to access your school site from that Northern end of that of that property the road that you own the Northern end of the road that you own so if you did decide to do that I'm saying that I I think it would be pretty defensible and I realize it I mean that wouldn't I'm just looking for potential other options but that doing that alone is not going to help everybody down

060at the end of the the roadway anyway um that's that's thank you and that was pretty much going to be mine if we were to just just pave ours how would that impact them you would get runoff am I correct we oh so even okay so for us Paving ours it would be a benefit somewhat put in swells and everything to to offset our drainage and then so it would exceed the oh yeah exed significantly the 62,000 okay Mr buckles well my my point a while ago was What Mr Holmes said because I've been involved in this stuff over the years time and time again if we determine that that our property has a purpose to do that we can do it now they can you can have Joe Blow come in here and pull

061a audit request and try to make front page news and go crazy for a month or two because we paved a portion of the road that borders our property that we own but it it would have to be something that the board would have to agree to now I don't I don't know that you wouldn't have to go out across that field there and get a kid that's been injured at an accident with an ambulance I don't I don't I don't know and I'm I I I would like to see how the msbu thing plays out with the county before we make a final decision or I mean we're we're going to have to move on and keep going but at some point you know we have the right if we own the property to

062join our property and to have a a structured nice Transportation Route along the edge of that property now you wouldn't be able to go up and turn down because of the Water Management Wells cuz I already looked at that but you never know what's going to happen you don't but uh I U I mean we've already substantially improve the neighborhood with the road that that'll be going to Davis Lake Road oh yeah tremendously tremendously and a big problem at the intersection Davis Rene and and folks I'd like to see what the county does because they've worked with us over the years we've School boards have traditionally given millions of dollars in real estate to the county for different things maybe the county wants to try to figure out a way to work with an msbu

063and and help you and we're going to continue whether this works out or not to work with the county because none of us is as strong as all of us together so I'm glad Walton came I really appreciate that but I I just I'd like to see how the msbu works out Phil all right thank you um Miss Pickins um my only question or or opinion is that Paving from where we intend to pave to the finished part of our property at this point I don't see it serving us or or any purpose in doing that except to maybe encourage someone to continue to drive down that road I feel like we should put signage up at Davis Lake Road that says school buses only um you know that's that's kind of how I feel

064um and there should be you know a private property after that but and I also feel that if that part of the road that we own you're having to put Rock in that's shouldn't be that I mean I feel like we should maintain our part of the private road okay you know very good all right we are about to run out of time so here's what we'll do um homeown homeowners um I do think that in my experience dealing with msbu is that there is a potential that we if y'all decide to enter into an MSP with the county that we could be included in that and pave that portion that we're not currently Paving um as Mr Buckle says for you know future reference um but that is a cost that we have we

065don't have budgeted so but at any rate um I'm open to continuing the dialogue and let's see what how the county can help us and and if your other property owners are that aren't here today are willing to um you know try to determine whether an msbu would be be a good thing for y'all and then we'll we'll continue and we'll keep an open mind okay any other questions from the board all right stand adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.