CorpusRecord 99506

February 3, 2025 KASD School Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Kutztown Area School District
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Berks County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,899 words · about 67 min
Collected
2026-06-11

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e this let's meing to order would everyone please rise for flag the United States of America for stands one nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all like to thank everyone for coming tonight uh there's a log in the front if you have not yet done so would you please sign in if you have anything in particular that you bring to the board's attention please also write that down if at any time during the meeting you would like to mention something on an agenda item please raise your hand to be recognized after the normal business there's also time for public comment where you can bring up additional issues uh when speaking publicly please speak directly into the microphone uh this meeting is being recorded and also there was an executive session conducted prior to

002the meeting to discuss Personnel matters with that weon angle here Michael Hess here re Hoffman here Cecilia H here Jason cck Jeremiah light here deny vious here Daniel whisper here Lael Zigler here Lucas Hoffman here Joselyn Dall here uh first up on the agenda we have approval of minutes uh approval of minutes for the January 20th 2025 Schoolboard meeting do I have a motion so move test motion a second any question or comments none call please Michael Hess yes Rea Hoffman yes Cecilia H yes Jeremiah light yes Dennis dises yes Daniel whisner yes Laurel Ziggler yes Aon angle yes motion carries uh next on the agenda is item four medications and reports first up is superintendent report what good news for this evening in the superintendent report for February 3rd 2025 um first up on

003academics uh the on what day last week Thursday last week um we had a visitor Beth specker the founding executive director from the renell center for civics and Civic engagement uh visited our seventh grade classes uh we we discussed this opportunity a committee meeting a few months ago Miss specker uh worked with our seventh grade classes to deepen their students knowledge of the judicial system the government branches and trial procedures and this is all in preparation for our entire seventh grade class is going to take a trip down to the federal courthouse in Philadelphia this spring and participa in a mock trial so just a really exciting opportunity um that made available for our students and um you know speaking with Mrs Patton about the experience just said it was a really really engaging opportunity

004for all of our seventh graders and that's just the beginning before they head down to the the courthous the high school boys wrestling team won the bcia AA division 4 Championship um this is the first time that the boys wrestling team has won a division championship since 1984 congratulations to coach and to the boys then made it to the quarterfinals in the bcas and lost to exiter uh 48 to 30 uh but just a great season for our boys you know the wrestling program is strong from starts with the youth kind of working for years and years and years leading up to the high school and two to our Sid there are time team success is elusive but again for the first time since 1984 congratulations to our boys for winning division championship just announced

005today congratulations to re justinen who was named a 2025 pmea all state to the All State Jazz Ensemble and first chair tener saxophone this is a great accomplishment um amongst you know the annual pleora of of honors and awards that are music students earn All State pme All State and especially first chair is right at the top so Reed is a phenomenal musician and student need a credit to him his family he also Mr sherp in our music department for his success congratulations and enjoy the festival on April 11th at Pocono Mountain High School East on Thursday last week the C high cheer team for the first time participated in the State uh tournament they went to states that was held at the Santander Arena and that's 2025 PIAA competitive Spirit state championships they earned

006their trip to the state championships through the performance at Burks counties so congratulations to the girls for this achievement and having the opportunity to experience and boys and boys I'm sorry yes that's right that that's actually a good point because it is um the girls and boys and we participate in the coed it's a separate division it's coed division so thank you for correcting me Mr H and that is our good news for this evening next up we have committee reports quick question on that we don't usually have them first week it's usually only the third yeah week and I didn't prepare because there is no committee to report on right so um that is all for committee report okay thank you okay next up we have student board representative report a think I have

007yeah I mean we've had lots of you know delays and not much has happened the past week I think there's just lots of continued conversation about the graduation requirement change but see that's on the agenda I'm sure that's going to be covered like pretty so wait to get there so your point about delays cancellations and weather I would just like to thank everyone for their patience um you know the morning decisions are we say they're never easy sometimes they're very easy but they're typically not easy and you know some of our side roads are just really really challenging think to the rare three-hour delay that we had um on Friday we're still happy to be able to get students into school but the three-hour delay you know is is a long stretch and what happens

008is you have a two-hour delay and we're we're out driving in and and those of us who are out checking the roads you know find some roads that are just really really challenging um particular on Friday it was Eagle Point Road right where you know where the those of you I mean everybody knows Eagle Point Road I think just where the h coming up 737 the hill that descends down towards gunclub Road everybody was sliding down it they had you know flers closing the road and at the time when buses were to go out it just wasn't quite safe yet so it required another hour delay um the following up you know we celebrated today at the middle school um and typically it would be on the actual holiday but the Seer of seers the

009prognosticator of prognosticators today predicted that we have six Mill weeks in the winter and um I don't know if that makes anybody happy but it makes me a little bit less happy there's you know there's definitely going to be some additional weather for us even looking coming here on Wednesday and Thursday so I just want to thank everybody for their patience I also you know there because we are very unlikely to use the FID day the virtual day or the flexible instructional day anymore it Still Remains one of our options um we will be putting some information out that um you know I did tell our principles to kind of as a little heads up and think about what that would look like for Thursday with this current projection of a significant amount of ice

010that could come on Thursday so um again with all the variables some of the late decisions we always do it in the sake of safety but I appreciate everyone's flexibility understand thank you thank you okay uh next up on the agenda is public comment on agenda items Kelly M Kelly M have to this uh the board requires that public participants be residents or taxpayers of this District or anyone having registered a legitimate interest in a concentrated action of the board participants must be recognized by the presiding officer and must preface their comments by an announcement of their name municipality and group affiliation if applicable each statement made by a participant shall be limited to 3 minutes duration on a single agenda or non-agenda item if a participant wishes to speak on more than one agenda

011item and time remains after other participants have made their statements they may then speak on additional agenda or non-agenda items all statements shall be directed to the presiding officer with the understanding that individual board members are not required to respond to participants comments or questions uh the presiding officer May interrupt or turn the particip statement when the statement is too lengthy personally directed abusive Oben or irrelevant uh request any individual to leave the meeting when that person does not observe reasonable decorum uh and also call a recess or adjourn to another time on the lap of public decorum uh interferes with the orderly conduct of the meeting thank you all right good evening my name is Dr Kelly Mahoney and I am the physics teacher at the high school I'm here to speak on the

012topic of graduation requirements as a teacher I disagree with these changes because I feel that they will be detrimental to our students Futures it has been stated that the removal of required graduation credits will not be lowering the bar I argue that this is not true as many of our neighboring districts are working toward requiring four years of Science and Math and have credit requirements of 21 or more or sorry 24 or more there is only one other District in the county that has credit requirements as low as 21 and that is Wilson by reducing our credit requirements to 20 our students will graduate with fewer credits than 94% of the districts in the county Mr temp chattan has stated that he thinks about 20% of our students will choose to continue taking all four

013content areas as seniors this means that he expects approximately 20 students from our graduating class to be prepared for college because they will have taken as many courses as their peers entering College it has also been stated that the reduction of graduation requirements will allow students more flexibility in their schedules I argue that you do not need to remove credits to allow for flexibility in their schedules students not attending BCC have only four required courses senior year assuming they have passed all their courses in previous years this leaves them with four periods to do as they choose our BCTC students have the opportunity to participate in half day Co-op if they meet all of the BCTC requirements it has also been argued that our current requirements do not allow flexibility in the courses they choose

014to as a person who teaches most of the senior science I agree that students senior year should have more options for their courses and I actually do have some options that they could do for science but doing nothing should not be a choice with a new graduation requirements students have the option to do nothing by taking the minimum required classes and spending half their day at home how is doing nothing preparing them for college or career when students come to me as seniors about half of them have no no idea what they want for their future in our classrooms they get to explore new topics that may lead to Career paths they get to talk to teachers who will help guide them and prepare them for college or careers by reducing the graduation credits you

015are taking this away from them Mr temp chaten expects approximately 80 students to choose to leave our building for at least half a day of their senior year that means that 80% of our students may not receive the guidance they need in deciding on their career path this means that 80% of our students may make the wrong decision senior year that will impact them in the future you can't go back to high school after graduating and take classes you now realize you need for your chosen postsecondary program or career their only option will be to try to make up their credits in the summer at a community college or the college they hope to attend so I question how removing these credits will help prepare our students for their future thank you next uh Jeffer

016hi you all know I'm Jeff Hufford president of the Kon Area Teachers Association I'm not going to repeat what Kelly just said she was spot on on everything the Teachers Association feels that the new graduation requirements will limit our students chances rather than increase them and I have another thought if this is such a good idea why isn't every school in the county doing it Wilson does it now they're much larger School much more staff much more students many more businesses in their area we don't have their advantages this is a great idea why aren't other schools doing it thank you that's all we have signed up um I know Robin we move doc Underwood panel Dr Underwood yes hi um Robin Underwood from the Kutztown buau um I just wanted to ask you if

017you have considered uh with these new requirements what is going to do to change uh class Rank and GPA um because I know that when students do take the flexibility that already exists and say study abroad or something like that they're like no longer eligible to be valid dictorian Etc um because it kind of messes with their schedule so if students are taking all kinds of different levels of credits or less um what does that do to class rank um I've seen some schools take class rank away and then the whole Community protests and they bring it back so I'd hate for us to go through all of that um and while I have your attention I'm curious to know why at KD we use a very strange number rather than 4.0 3.0 it's always

018very confusing when you have a senior trying to apply for Grants and scholarships you have to like wait and ask the guidance counselor and that is I don't understand it um I'd like to um and lastly this is well I'll save mine for non- agenda never mind so those are my questions um I'll just the to the weighted number it's the number that is used going to answer the first one is just based off of the it's GP it's a weighted GPA um and where ours is maybe slightly different than some others they I think you'll find a different way GPA number in almost every school to some extent um you know that's one of the challenges I think that um universities have in terms of kind of comparing what apples to oranges in a

019sense you know so I think you'll find a way different way to GPA just across almost any school um as far as uh class rank I mean there's no intention to recommend any change to class rank in terms of limitated sure um yeah there's because different courses come with a weighted rank um for students to be competitive in the class rank conversation they're going to have to take a pretty full load of courses um and also take challenging courses the um the graduation requirements themselves do not change anything about those weights necessarily but if you choose to take you choose to only take 21 credits you're probably not in the running for you know a high class rank because you wouldn't be able to have the weighted uh points that come with taking many of

020the challenging courses weighted so um I don't again it comes out to Choice that's something that you're sort of tipping yourself out of when we recommend the course selection guide um anticipated for the next voting meeting after talking about uh some components of it including leveling um and other parts of the course selection gu at the next curriculum committee meeting there are waiting considerations that must um The Waiting gets approved as a part of that course selection guide so there's waiting things to consider um we will be asking to consider what is currently there is no weight to if you take a dual enrollment course we will be looking at considering whether there should be some weight to a dual enrollment course that you take um you know and we would not be waiting them

021recommending waigh them high of our APS I still believe that rap courses taken on site for 180 days are a much more wigor experience over that length of time you know we do enrollment courses that happen in a more of a short burst but we will be recommending that we add weight to that so um while there's class rank implications um the most direct ones that yes any students that who are choosing just not to take the credits you're probably not going to R really high at the end of the year in class you know class rant so um that's just the reality because you know if you take honest if you take only weighted one point for example if you took only weighted 1.0 credits you're not competing in class rank any anyway the

022way that you do is by taking something that's heavier rated you know for example like R is 1.12 and you get more points for one credit based off your grade you know you do if you just take so um no recommendation to eliminate for sure there are some differences in kind of how you can get there um obviously based off some another appr you you is anybody else have any comments uh next up on the agenda is a new business first up is personnel and that's outlined in the agenda um so second motion second any questions or comment hofman yes Cecilia hul yes Jeremiah light yes deny vious yes Daniel whisner yes Laurel Ziggler yes Aaron angal Michael H yes uh next up is softening Trail extension uh it is the recommendation of the facilities

023committee that the board of school directors approved put buau to extend the SOP Creek Trail onto the school district property for the attached second any questions or comments yeah thank thankfully Mr obviously for continuing partnering with the burrow and looking at raising extending the trail just give it a great opportunity for people to get fit walking up um it extends the trail up behind the uh football field to extend out towards where the softball soccer fields are behind the middle school so just just a general Improvement to the commun that Cecilia H yes Jeremiah light yes Denis udicious yes Daniel whis yes Laurel Ziggler yes Aaron angle yes Michael hes yes Hoffman yes okay motion carries uh next up is 2025 summer school programs it is the recommendation of the administration that the board of

024school directors approve the SU programs for 2025 be attached we have motion second motion and second any questions or comments just comments on what those summer programs are there's no significant changes from recent Summers they include extended school year which is um summer program that we mandated to offer for students with uh special education needs um there is traditional summer school for students need to do credit recovery or list in there for both the um high school and the middle school and in addition is our pause Camp which is a literacy Camp um that actually don't know how many years we've been running here in kown but is an opportunity that over 35 years over 35 years um over 35 years almost as long as it's been since we won the vision for wrestling um

025the uh you know for 35 years where the pause Camp which took a little bit of a different iteration in the last the last few years but is where we offer literacy instruction to students based off a recommendation at the elementary level um so it's a the an attempt and I think a successful attempt to eliminate some of the summer slide for what some and and New Edition transition new addition in the last three years was yeah I'm still thinking about the first 32 the cost on this is to the student right the in the summer programs for middle school and high school yes they have to do it they pay yes yeah just for the just for the like traditional summer school credit it's not for the C any other questions on very none

026Jeremiah light yes Dennis udicious yes Daniel whis yes LL Ziggler yes Michael Hess yes Rea Hoffman yes Cecilia Hol yes Aon e yes motion carries uh next up on the agenda is D conference request it is the recommendation of the administration that the board of school directors approve the following conference requests and these are outlined in the agenda uh looking for a motion second a second any questions or comments I'm just our two conference requests there um you know uh one is it's listed as a conference request because it is a conference but the pmea conference um students attend there and perform as well so that annually we try to point that out while lists as a conference and it is uh we also have students attending so the staff member attends with students um

027and then the second one is for exactly what it says which is an AP similar Institute and this is for a course that is being proposed for AP pre-calculus which be a new AP basically next year um pending approval as part of the course of study any other questions [Music] com judicious yes Daniel Wismer yes Laurel Ziggler yes Michael Hess yes Reba Hoffman yes Cecilia H yes Jeremiah L yes a yes no she Harries uh next up on the agenda is item e uh KD graduation requirements it is the recommendation of the curriculum committee that the board of school directors approved the updates to the cassan area high school graduation requirements beginning with the class of 2026 for the attached any questions or comments oh sorry thank you thank you second thank you Motion in

028a second now any questions to uh jump in so I just had one just because this is more pertinent to the junior class because we just had like the um conversations about like what courses we'll be taking next year and the main one that's come up is I believe how like the senior year like preparedness credit Y and the main question I've just been hearing from um Juniors is what exactly because I know like in conversations we mentioned like PC or like a KU class would count so like is that would like rack dual enrollment credit with those count as well credit so the way so the way it is designed is that you would meet the without taking the class you would meet the requirement if you BCTC did you know did an external

029internship or took a dual enrollment course on campus at our University like went left with it so in that instance taking hours that are offered here through rack would not count but if you took one on campus it rack it would so it's it's kind of that um you know have you left the high school environment to experience something that is post second all right and then my follow question that sorry just lots of conversations was um since it would be an off campus opportunity um pay you and stuff not all students would or their FES not be able to financially course so so you would you would if you would meet the requirement if you experien the off campus but if not you would take a course you're on campus so the only other

030option would be like the senior courts you're on campus yes and then the third thing I just heard a lot of students asking is do we have an idea of like what that curriculum would look like would it be like college appness like life scales like yeah it's more I mean it's more designed to be um in in the realm of I mean when you say college preparedness you mean so I mean answer the question rather than ask you me um you know so the curriculum or the course outline that we have we would still be developing the curriculum is that each participant would be developing their own goals as a part of that program of experiences that they want to prepare for or have throughout their senior year so some of that might be

031preparing college applications or B supp forms like that might be that wouldn't be the total goal of course but it might be one of them it might be communicating with um businesses about job experiences that they want to have you know so um it would be it's goal driven with the teacher as the guide to help you have those experience have some type of experience or at least SE them you know during your senior year it's important then would that course be limited to taking your senior year thinking if like say I've heard this lot for like some students were like I know I want to go to this college and do early admissions with that his almost some of the parts of that course but almost come a little too late if you were

032doing you were enrolled in earli commission that would that would me okay yeah you wouldn't have to have you either to be doing the competency part either prior to your senior or during your senior year all right yeah all right that's the questions I have for students s right one question that came up from a student through the guidance Department specific for that course too was um you know we had a student who was looking at their schedule and was trying to take pretty much every AP that you could and they were believing that um off of the current projection that that would be a barri that this course there would be a barrier to that um you know we identified as we build this we probably need to come up with some flexibility long

033term in how it's offered whether it was an online option or even a summer option potentially for those situations but in the intern from class of 2026 obviously we have to out you know somebody is really trying to push themselves academically even do it here we wouldn't let a require get in the way of that a new requirement you hadn't had the opportunity to plan for two years to get in the way of that so that was specific at least to one unnamed student's question through their school counselor to me was you know we're not gonna I still want to see how that whole schedule shakes out to really understand it but if what was provided to me in the narrative we might wave that in 2026 we want to stop some from there that

034makes sense yeah makes sense I have a quick question to them yep so if the student decides not to do internships or go off campus or anything like that yep well they will be required to take those four four classes still right no not necessarily no if they I mean if they have met the full requirements um you know they would be taking two courses because they would have to select two of the four they wouldn't need to take all four necessarily what happens with the rest of that sign they so they would have be El if any student who is eligible in the eligibility would be you have to establish kind of a GPA criteria and a ten criteria their parents would be able to fill out a late started 30as so now that's

035continued on the getting own transportation as well not to come you know if somebody's going to be here all day they're gonna take some addition okay oh s um so say for example like a student wanted to take like courses at KU or go off campus to Rack if they weren't able to financially afford that would there be any financial aid options or is the senior seminar like their only option that we have we we look to see where we can provide options I don't we're not budgeting for everybody's to take everywhere else we're fortunate to have a grant the last couple years um you know but you know we do have a unel generous Education Foundation that has partially funded you know to support a scholar um program enrollment courses aren going to pay

036for them but they've been able to support um students for like half of the cost of the course you know then we can also seek some addition funding we'll always work with the students and try to find out the district isn't going to be paying for those course so um that's just you know that's I know I wish I could say that we were a little bit further along in this regard but I've had some discussions about trying to make available one free course at KU for every student who wanted to hear at qu and I think there's some optimism that that might in Theiss but anything ask a clarifying question I'm not sure if I miss understanding Jocelyn possibly you um possibly um so when you were asking about early admission what I would

037call that meaning is when you're you're getting accepted early to uh college right yeah so that's that would count that counts yes even though like you're not going until after you graduate in your senior year oh early decision yeah ear like some place they call their early decision Missions at college so the terms were used for just when you apply to a college knowing that that's the one you're going to go but you're not you're not actually alter yeah so I mean that wouldn't count for that requirement if you're not actually doing it until next year have to be something you're generated during your high school years um so thank you to so and the reason you brought that up was because if a student was in that situation where they received their early decision

038than material or goals within that senior credit course so then they would develop their goals around career exploration right I mean or something else potentially but I mean likely it's going to be exporation or post secondary ad combination of those two but they could still even if they've been accepted early admission into college they still explor you know career so but it might not require but they would not be required to go have an internship next you know they canel goals just to exporation still kind of developing that but it's it's just that the idea is that it can be tailed individually to any I even students that aren't doing early admission the acceptance are usually receiving acceptance early part of so so so they still require kind of yeah just being accepted into college

039would not I ask kind of I think it goes in line with some of joselyn's questions so this may or may not be part of the preparedness class what does it currently look like for uh or what would we be moving towards possibly even making sure students are aware of requirements for their individual like if they're they're moving towards just speaking from my perspective with my kid um she's good for what she's planning on doing and state however there are individual schools such as business where they may require more like 3.5 credits for math is the one that is off the top of my head so what does the process look like now or how is that going to be improved so that students have that because right now and I know it's new but

040there's mixed messages coming from yeah I mean that's a school counsel you know that's where school counselors really spend a lot of time with students um in their years leading up to and as they're saying I might want to go into a program like you know X Y or Z they're asking them to go look at those programs and see what their requirements are and and look and I I think one thing we also have to you know keep in mind is that when we're preparing if students are saying I want to go to college but I have no idea for what and um I'm not even sure what Ione to apply we're going to be advised to take all four cores in that senior year because of course that's going to provide you with

041most flexibility um you know so I I I just think a lot of that advice is going to be it I don't want to say it puts because I think there's already a lot on the counseling office and you know understand we our announc here but it's you know it's just that they're going to be advised they are advised currently 10th 11th grade of preparing yourself to be the best potential candidate for what you don't to do and if they don't know you're going to tell them to take all four and I think that's the right advice at that time and you hope that students and families that follow through with that but um it's when you're get into that senior year you're right now your junior year and you're scheduled for senior year and

042you have a really good idea and then you can make decision inform decision based off of what the called University looking at have expectation of program um not like so I I just think there's definitely a lot um there's going to be a lot of advice that's I still advise you to take four core subjects or you know it's where the requirements land I mean what you see typically is if there's a requirement for four most frequently see that in language ARS that's why we have that as that literacy race requirement if you see it in another area it's Ty going to be in science or it's rarely going to be social stud so we're going to advise that for credit so those are conversational that would it be okay yeah they're conversational because everybody

043has different goals and that's and the idea is just to be as flexible as possible for families and students to make decisions based off what their current goals are or you know they want to keep it you want to keep it as wide open as possible we can take all four I mean it's just that's what the advice is to choose one do that what if I just take the language arts and the math you're probably pretty good there too as far as the requirements apply to most of R and our kids who are in these highest competitive applications well they're they're loading up on the aps you know both Junior and Senior year they're going to be taking two to three APS in senior year in that whole conversation about four or two was

044almost just just to thing you back off that too because I just have some general comments as well um I I mean I I definitely appreciate the the viewpoints here um I'm going to be voting in favor of because I just think that there are there are way more Pros um than cons and some things that have come up with conversations and um public comment um around the preparedness for College um I think there's there's some subjectiveness to what that definition is because I definitely am a big fan of the experience that is more geared towards that postsecondary and so I I personally value that I value that with you know even in the experience with my kids so um that's where I kind of view as far as that College college preparation because you're

045talking about a huge financial commitment and to have that experience um in many cases can have a profound impact in in moving a student in a direction which saves them having to take courses that they're paying for later on um and also I'm I'm just um really going to be in favor of the choice that's provided there where while I understand the the the view of this choice in reduction being the equivalent of lowering the bar I just I don't share that opinion in that um there's not a removal of anything so I think it's more of an expansion and then with the conversation that was had there I feel like it could even have a byproduct of of really having students have these really thought driven meaningful conversations that are really going to point

046them in the the right direction out of this is not even necessarily intent of all of this so I can say that I did a lot of research on this because I've been on the fence about this and uh in in my research I found you know the one thing that kept coming back was well what do universities require for admitted to their universities and when you start going through this I have a bunch here I could reference most of them yeah it is four credits of English la but when you start looking at it you have like a University of Maryland they have four years English two years foreign language three years of history or social science three years of Science in at least two different areas with two lab experiences they require four

047years of math and which includes algebra one two geometry trig calculus pre-calculus and statistics uh you go to Penn State um it's four credits English three credits of social sciences art and Humanities science is three credits math is three credits and algebra geometry but again certain colleges within the university require half a credit in trigonometry or calculus uh World Language is two credits there uh look at Alabama University four credits in english four credits in Social Sciences math three credits Natural Sciences three credits with two loud components foreign languages one credit other courses five credits uh look at University of Arizona english four credits math four credits lab based science three credits foreign language two credits social sciences two credits and one must be in American history uh one year of Fine Art or a

048year of BCTC or similar classes like that um kown university four credits in language arts math three credits science three credits social studies three credits all these universities that I've mentioned and many more that I've looked up are 20 or less credits I mean goodstein University is 13 credits required just to get in so to hear that by changing to 21 credits that to me holds nothing because right here is the proof that what a lot of these big- time universities require um and as stated you know if if our kids took what is currently required they're not getting the pre-calculus or the calculus courses unless they take an AP class but by changing it to the 21 credits and we do get the at the Bri help then it opens the door for other

049you know colleges within universities so I would just recommend that um the parents the students and the guidance counselors all get together and talk about where your student and this is a conversation that should be happening as early as I feel in 10th Grade because I know a lot of 11th graders that already know what they're going for and where where they would like to go to so you know the the talk should start occurring earlier but I still think that even if we prove this now there's still time for these kids to get the necessary requirements you the data available that I requested in the last meeting requested Keystone exams and bats I requested information on the detailed responses and surveys of our teachers I requested the survey results of our community members I

050requested additional data on our students feedback i' I'd say it's all the student feedback that we had had and the community members we don't to share whatever S I had two formal responses into the form and I received two emails not three emails but one te the response that I have here in the form um was one person saying they did not think it was a good idea um saying for those that are college man they should take of these full credits of English M and science um so let me just clarify you're saying that that when you sent out a survey to the public which was sent out extremely late that we received two responses I received two responses um and then I received three separate emails in response rather than to the Fone

051one was a spe very specific uh question from one teacher and the other two one was a father of a recent um graduate who was very much in support of the recommendations and the other one was from a parent of a c seventh grader and we had a conversation where his question or sentiment was buiness producing is it lowering the bar that type of conversation so yeah that's what I when I sent that out I received CL from two teachers and from three parents but it was also available for a week or so it January January I think I'd Clos after I did do think I Clos it after a week it was available for a week and um what about the data from the conversations with the teachers and have we conducted an anonymous

052survey with our teachers no unless there's a vote of five members of the board be conducting an teachers you know teachers union has responded in public multiple I I do think that there's a deep distrust between our teachers feeling comfortable to speak out I I have heard directly from teachers that they feel that there has been retaliation when they have spoken out and that there's real concern that that's not a viable option to them so I know I appreciate Mr huffard standing up um again I appreciate some of our teachers standing up but you know this unfortunately is a climate in which I think we've really silenced our teachers to not feel comfortable uh coming forth and and speaking um you know I I continue to have strong concerns on what is with without question

053cannot be argued 21 credits is less than 24 it is a lowering of the bar um you know I I appreciate some of your comments Mr like as far as College preparedness I have a daughter who's a junior you know yes we're looking at University of Maryland which is ranked 43rd in the nation yes we're looking at Penn State which is ranked 60th in the nation there is I guarantee no chance that a student would get into either of those competitive schools with only 21 credits um you know my daughter has taken APS upon APS and we are still looking at the likelihood that she could get into a competitive School situation I just don't think it is reasonable for children of all different family backgrounds socioeconomic backgrounds um you know parents who may have

054gone to college or may not have gone to college I cannot expect reasonably expect that all of our community members are thinking about the academic implications of the courses that they are selecting in nth grade 10th grade 11th grade and and even when they get to that point of of looking at what their child is signing up for in their senior year um you know I asked for data and information on what the exception policy is right now how many of the students were we allowing to take alternative approaches again there's there's no indication to me that we have not been able to find appropriate ways to really support children who are looking for alternative Pathways right we have we have BCTC they have supervised uh supervised internship opportunities you know we have the uh

055rack um dual enrollment we have courses with KU there there are so many different op opportunities and again I I have requested that we really explore what the options are that we can give our guidance counselors and our school administrators within the high school a better opportunity to really Flex a little bit within the 24 requirements um you know I'm very concerned about students being signed out of of school with their parents permission and going and learing the streets doing who knows what right I mean you know to your question kids could do ever whatever they want you know I I just simply do not understand why we are trying to force kids to grow up quicker than they need to this is the one time in which kids are allowed to be kids let's

056keep them in a a safe environment in which we can help support them we can help them learn we can educate them we can guide them we can make sure that that they're getting as much of that preparation as they possibly can for their after after graduation environment I I just cons continue to be concerned that we have not really thoughtfully considered all of the implications um we have not sought sufficient feedback from the community um and and again the the there just simply is not the data here to support this so I I am baffled on why we as a as a community and we as a school who have striven for educational Excellence for years and years would choose to to lower the bar so it's disappointing to me um you know and

057and again I'm also I I do request that in the future I'll be happy to put my requests in writing but I'm also concerned that there's there's a dismissiveness of what I am asking to see so that I can make an informed decision as a board member and I'd like to make sure that there's a response to the requests that come from all of us here at the table before we move forward with the vote so thank you I will not be voting in support of us this evening I don't think we're lowering a bar students still have the option to take the 24 credits if they want to they can take whatever credits they want to when we if we change this to 21 credits as far as the feedback anybody can email us

058call us talk to us outside of the school I've had numerous conversations in favor of changing these requirements I have only gotten one email and it's from a student that doesn't agree with changing that's it nothing for many teachers except for who's been here at these meetings the last few weeks parents that I've all talked to are all in favor of uh even a lot of the the current Juniors and uh even the seniors are in favor of it that I've talked to so I mean to say we're lowering the bar that's a disservice to the school district we not lowering the bar we're actually raising the bar because now we're giving the students a lot more opportunity to seek other avenues of getting different credits for different programs that they want to seek out

059or internships that if they take the 24 credits they can't do the internships so we're actually raising the bar in my opinion if we change it we're telling students too that like you have you you can do what you want to do you can be as successful as you want to be like I love the idea of choice as a parent I'm I'm talking as a parent here not as a board member I love the idea of having one choice for my child my kid could not do ban because he had to take math so he had to choose one or the other if he did band he would have had to take math outside of school on his own time last year he had to take an LA course on his own time because

060it did not fit his schedule in in his in his day because of being a BCTC so as a parent I love this choice that being able to say listen this is you know if you want to do this and this then we're going to figure out how to fit it in and it gives it gives us more flexibility from CH do we keep any um B or data on where our students currently go after there's a list you know that we have at the time of graduation I don't know that we can actually see how accurate is six months later you know it's about their intents I don't I don't know of any schools that have been highly successful longitudinally being able track where students don't you know so um we don't really you

061know it's just really difficult once many of them once they leave I I was pictured you know last year graduation board outside of the main office there and have a list of what students were doing it's really just a snapshot time of intentions you know and after that you don't know enough so I don't I don't we don't have thetion yeah um so I of course I've heard from people at the meetings who are concerned about this this change but I've also heard from family who are in favor of the change um I think also we've heard for a long time about lack of flexibility in the schedules within the school for students you know regarding what they want to take versus what they have to take um and I know from my own experience

062helping families try to take advantage of some of these alternative experiences although we allow for it it is often very difficult even if you're well connected or um determined um or have resources um so I like the idea of It kind of becoming more the norm to be able to have the other experiences and I feel like I have confidence in our school counselors to work with students and families to you know help them make the right choices I don't think I mean it's going to be different for every kid and every family just like it is now but um um I think there's been overall so much focus on you know just multiple Pathways to success and everything like that and I would I would like to support that um I would also like

063to see some information about what kind of schedules people are taking how many students are doing internships um you know if this passive um dual enrollment Etc how many students are taking only two courses and um or will we have information if they've decided to work for instance or will that the um what we would have is the silver I Tey be a digital form that every any parent would complete for the we started early Le so we would have that you know we would have aent say that they were choos to build so we'll I would definitely like to see a safeguard of I guess Aaron you had talked about the other schools do like the GPA and and that kind of thing so that yeah if you don't meet those requirements you're not

064going to just go be taken out even even if it's with yeah and I mean I I think it was Wilson's that I looked at that there are parameters I think those stringent parameters around whatever is going to be GP or whatever also could Elevate students to be motivated to do better because they want that free time and yeah I get it still feels to be an incomplete proposal right so again I I agree with these sen sentiments let's let's put more safeguards in to make sure that students have the me so the so I'm sorry just to you know we would have you know the graduation requirements approved in the course selection gu go a section on you know criteria forar be a section that be that course selection guide um so the families

065know that but how I I mean isn't it course selection time now I I know my daughter just signed up for her courses you know for next year L literally this week is she's not in this District my other daughter is in this District I mean but I guess I don't understand if we're just making this decision tonight how are our teachers and our our staff supposed to be prepared with the full course selection guide with the details with the answers to these questions and I mean again why why what is the urgency what what are we why are we rushing to try to get this over why don't we we've had these graduation requirements in place for you know how many years 20 20 years this exact version was there are very slight differences

066in the 2018 so again this feels like something that we could thoughtfully consider to get ready for for for a vote this fall so that our teachers and and our guidance counselors can have time and and Readiness to be prepared for next year um again I'd like to see how many students today requested to do something alternative and weren't able to figure it out with our guidance help I I hear of this need for flexibility and yet we've seen no data at all about how many kids were not actually able to achieve that flexibility so it it just again there's elements of the discussion that I can appreciate and I can support but it also it it just feels rushed and and not fully out so I I uh and you know clearly we're all

067hearing from different constituent pockets and different groups of folks so you know the folks that are reaching out to me are you know I've heard one person in support and I've heard a whole long list of folks reach out to me who have concerns I just want to like maybe bring out one thing that kind of dawned on these we were talking about this so we're talking about reducing the credits which occurs in the senior year Texas right um all of the students that are going to college are are applying in the first semester of their senior year and so they're being accepted into colleges based on their first three years as a student more or less I think I think the schools do look at their current transcript even though it's not completed just

068to see what their I think do look at that um but yeah I mean based off on their grades in their GPA that was all that is all in their first so I mean I just I I just agree with the people who have talked about flexibility I I don't think it's just a flexibility issue it's also a choice issue for parents and students um I think in general people are kind of tired of the heavy hand of government and a public school is a government school and want the opportunity to make choices that are the best choices for them and I do agree though that we should have safeguards in place to make sure that we just don't have some troublemakers out on the loose just because they got they got system I just

069want to say that I did reach out I know I had spoken to board members about uh I spoke with Dr tricket Who is the Wilson school district superintendent a couple weeks ago um and I was just you know curious what his take was on you know how the community received it how the teachers and the students um and it's been very favorable there um they adopted the program in 2021 um and he did stress to remember that this the number of credits the 21 credits is aligned with uh pde the Pennsylvania Department of Education um and he said the teachers there did have similar concerns as we're experiencing here um but they've actually turned it into a positive and a lot of the teachers uh and students have worked together the teachers have marketed

070themselves to the students and they've come up with like fun and interesting uh5 credit like electives and stuff like that um so they're having fun with that and again the kids are taking more classes um those who do want to continue taking classes others are being afforded the ability to to take internships um and uh let's see he said that the Wilson school district students have excelled in both College and Career Readiness um since adopting the open campus um see many more students many students take more credits uh the counselors are integral in the whole process um and again and he puts they they put certain guard rails in place they put a minimum of 3.2 GPA and they also look at uh any suspensions like if students been suspended or has had you know

071certain disciplinary actions they're not eligible and again as you said attendance records um and also what I thought was interesting was parental approval is necessary even if the student is 18 or over um so I thought that was comforting um um and also he himself has three students uh who are in or have gone through the district so he also has that tested interest so I I had a very positive conversation I'm in favor of the revised so I and I love hearing that Wilson has had success with this program um Wilson is a school district with 6,000 500 students and 11 1,150 staff members um they have a high school they have two middle schools and they have five elementary schools um again I I just don't think that we're looking at Apples to

072Apples here um I have reviewed course cataloges that are offered by school districts of this size right they're going to be offering a a breath and a flavor of courses that is extensive and Broad um and and again I I think the challenges that we're hearing about a lack of flexibility are coming by nature of the small size of our district right we we don't have the teaching staff and we don't have the capacity within our school to be offering you know five different daytime options for when you take AP Cel or five different options on when you're enrolling in AP Psychology right so so I guess it again I respectfully you know I do not consider Wilson an appropriate um reference point for us to be evaluating here that they have 2,000 students in

073their High School alone so again of course they can provide a ton more comp um flexibility of course they can offer you know creative of fun classes I I just don't see how how with our current Staffing levels and with our our school siid that that they're a relevant refence if I could just make um just one or two observations um and then a request as well um I guess my request is first it will Prim Mir Cecilia's request is just on data points I know we're not going to have a lot if this passes um I would like to see um I would like to get a breakdown of like the number of credits that students are taking um if the students are have met the 21 credit goal like what are they doing

074if they're not taking additional courses here as much as we can find out about if they're working or internship or cour work at the college something to that effect I just would like to know if this passes how successful it is I think you'd have to gauge that off what is it providing in addition to what we have currently um I think just a very obvious observation like off the top of my head is that I don't think we can say that we're raising the bar if we're dropping the credit requirement um you can't say that the requirement for graduating is less but we're making it harder or raising the bar I just don't think those two things go together together um but what I think you can say is that by lowering the graduation

075requirement and allowing students to have the flexibility to change the courses that they can choose um gives them more opportunity to kind of follow a path that is uh something that is more interesting today the problem with choice is always going to be that people have the choice do nothing um and we can all say that choice is is the best thing to offer people and that may or may not be true It ultimately is going to be what do the people decide to do with that choice which is why I'd like us to to track what our choices are ultimately going to be um over the next few years what this will kind of force families to do is be more engaged I believe um whereas before we might have been able to sit

076back and kind of let the requirements set the standard for our students I think now we're gonna have to be more engaged what our students are actually signing up to take um and again will that ultimately be good or bad I don't know I think the numbers are going to have to play out to see if if forcing that engage or we can't really Force the engagement but that level of Engagement if it will ultimately be a good thing or not um being such a small school I can see why if we're tied into required credits there are certain things that our students just won't be able to do because we can't offer certain course work multiple times if we allow that flexibility where they might not have to take one course at this time

077they they might be able to do those other things that they otherwise might not have been able to to do so um ultimately I I will be in favor of this um on the surface I think it will give more choices to the and more power to the students that want to kind of make those individual choices um but ultimately this decision is more of a we are going to have to wait and see if it was the right decision by looking at it a couple years down the road I think to pigy back off that I I don't know that it's as black and white as if it's the right decision or not I think it's being able to make those adjustments to um see what we can do to make it right choice

078but I think you know as long as we can like follow the data and keep track of what what is happening um and adjust that needed yeah we AB absolutely will be able to fall back what students do um you know to a reasonable extent with that time said some of it's dependent upon what families tend to put in you know what they're going to put in day learn for they release or they start but yet you know if they qualify for that then you know that that's 're just to kind of trust the information they have to as far as what courses they take or how many take three of One content area before another we're going to have all that dat if this does pass this evening I would like to see a

079very detailed survey of our senior year students and their parents to understand exactly what what this Baseline is that we're working off of today so that we really understand how many students were not able to make a choice right this year how many were forced into and would have had chosen to take a different path had they had a different graduation requirement available I guess I'd also I don't think that I don't I don't really think there's a I don't think that's a survey that elicits any kind of credible responses saying well if you have opportunity to do this what would you have done I don't know I don't know that the suror parents doing that's like something that is necessary because we're talking about flexibility right and again I don't know how else we're

080going to to want ify and and get a baseline of of are we really making things more flexible for students right again I know we will be but how many were not served this year um and and what do we consider the success criteria right what are what are we hoping to impact here we hoping to you know make sure that we uh don't lose any students who are dropping out their senior year are we hoping to you know look at improving like I just don't know what those success criteria are that we're targeting and saying yeah that this is how we'll know it's a success a year or two or three down the line so I would ask that again in in a public setting in in a board meeting you come back and

081you present what that Baseline data is that we're looking at and what the success criteria are that we're going to circle back at you know next year and the year after and the year after to be assessing whether or not this decision you know was was a healthy one I mean I do think like the what intervie does going forward is kind of I see that as a measure of success I don't think there is a I don't think there's like a statistically relevant Baseline okay let's think about it let's I yeah I think I could probably talk to that a little bit since I'm a senior I actually think that this could help with flexibility a bit because personally I think I only know like maybe two students that do go out of their

082way to go to like or seniors that like go out of their way to go to KU and such I think I only know two students that do that because I don't think it's really been afforded to us on that kind of scale that this is hoping to do I think this kind of sets a president that we can now do internships and go out of our way to take courses at other schools um because I think it is offered now to an extent but I just don't think people talk about it much and I think that's kind of an issue because like I didn't really hear anything about it and you kind of have to know somebody or know guidance and talk to them about it oneon-one so I think this does offer more

083flexibility in that sense but I I do see what I I agree I mean we've heard the concerns about the lack of awareness or the lack of education for parents on how to really take advantage of the current offering and the current flexibility within the 24 credit so um you know is there an opportunity given the importance of this that we could offer it up to the community if anybody would like to speak down I would just want to throw out one of the things um so this is another one of those things where I think it just highlights kind of a philosophical difference so I I think it's always important to have data and have a baseline but um from what I'm hearing it sounds like you just don't value that choice and from

084where I'm coming from the choice is one of the biggest things having a we be able to choose what is best for them um is a big thing and so there are certain parts where if you don't V philosophically you think that there is a you know what is best for everybody you're you're not going to be able to get to that point to Value what that provides so data is not going to be um it can't be a complete picture of this because a lot of this is afforded in that choice that's not to say it can't be without data for sure um but I just I'm you know it's everybody one everybody's got their vote and everybody's got their opinion I appreciate that um but I I appreciate the information that was shared

085too nobody has to place a vote on a board's opinion that's fine um but I just wanted to make that clear we must have data though on how many students are currently this year participating in internships for taking sure that would be good to see would be a great Baseline to that please I just wonder why there can't be like both things like I do hear some concern from many different group members about the like what about the kids who just don't take extra forces and go do whatever for the second half of the day like I don't understand why it can't be like kid has a plan then there's all these things they can do and if a kid doesn't have a plan then need take four courses you know like I don't understand

086where there's a mismatch there it seems like both things are possible I agree that very much Echoes my view right I mean again because they if they don't know what they're doing if they don't have a plan they still walk out the door with like you said all their options up the most options open to them and they think for a kid without a plan and and also it's important to remember like okay lots of parents are really engaged and supportive of their kids and their choices there's different families and there's families where parents aren't as supportive and parents aren't as engaged and those kids there's got to be something to catch you know I I think that's what this is doing though that's what this is exactly is doing if you have a plan

087you have the flexibility to tailor your credits to your plan right but if you don't have a plan you're going to be in school to take those four unless your parents say sign and be out at 21 but that's what they're say that's where the Safeguard comes into place you have to have that GPA you have to have shown that you are going to that's where that Safeguard comes in if you're showing that you're not on that track and that you have not been consistent with coming to school then no you're not it's good but then in your senior year if you just have a massive case of senioritis and you're like I don't want to take masks you just walk out without no again that's where that Safeguard is we don't know what the

088Safeguard is because that the saf guard is part of sa guards have been so well defined for like if we're saying there's going to be a percentage of kids who are whose parents agree and they agree they're just going to walk out of the school halfway through the day not have an internship not have a job not have a p course not have a rack course they're just gonna play video games for the other half of the day I mean I guess if their parents are like yeah that's great do video games with the other happy day I guess we have to I I don't know that doesn't my requirement for voting for this is that we have a safeguard in place before we in that so yeah again I mean these are we think

089of like the way we need to like approve things we don't um I wouldn't Envision we would we would approve graduation requirements also then the regulations for what you know procedure for somebody to sign out there's a commitment and there has been to putting together you know what that is um I think person has in place is very reasonable right and you know putting that in the course selection guide before it's approved you know which does get approved by the board what gives the board the opportunity to feel good about what's there um you know there absolutely is an opportunity if there's a number of students I'm not going to try to put percentages that I get myself in trouble when I do that I don't think they're very I don't think it's very um

090scientific in that way to say a student who would meet that criteria because they've performed well through their junior year they have good attendance they have good behavior their parents say yes you can do early leave and not go to work you know there there's going to be some students where that's the case again at the end of the day I come back to that that's like a that's a family's decision you know to make that and some families will say well they've earned that doing X Y and Z all these years and you know performing and doing well and some are going to say Well they're going to they're going to use that time and go get a job and they're going to help P you know and that's just where ultimately as long

091as students have a um successful track record you know they are going to need a guardian's approval to not be in school in school they're going to take you know they're going to take a load that's more than what the minimum is you know so that's just that's just the reality again it's just it comes down to flexibility to a family's decision to be able to make choices about their child and their education and you know yeah I mean as a school board it just it's also about premise like what's our premise here is our premise to graduate kids who are then having the most options moving forward and if so then it seems like unless the kid has a specific plan for like what that extra time is going to be used for then

092the default should be this thing just I mean as a parent I I hear that there was a survey but I didn't I don't remember ever seeing an email or anything like that I didn't feel like I had an opportunity to respond to that or I definitely would have two days after you were here last okay yeah it was just you know we're now using Parent Link communication system assuming you have all your information I get all the emails I right I mean if you get the two-hour delay messages that I send every couple days now so are we saying the Safeguard just going to be part of the AR process well I use the term AR right AR is the AR that would govern pieces of this will be the core selection yes sometimes

093we and we use the term AR it's administrative regulation so board policies often have ad administrative regulation sometimes there Standalone ones that go right through policy most often they are just the other documents that drive our datto business on procedures um the course selection guide in this would be ar that governs these pieces with that proposal so if that were the case what what we're talking about here would be that parents would have to be able students who are not participating parent parents would have to sign off for this unconditionally even if they're over 18 so is that correct in that scenario then what would happen is let's say the parent would sign off I'm seeing that scenario playing out is then the school would Trump the parental choice is that how that would play

094out in that situation in your mind I don't know I just I don't I guess I question whatever I don't know as a parent of a team teenager I want that teenager to be walking out of his high school education with the most options going forward right so if he doesn't come to me like Mom this is what I'm going to do and this is how I'm going to do it and being self-motivated I mean me personally I'm not going to sign off on anything and I'm going to want him to go through you know physics and I don't know what the senior year math is but I'm going to want him to have those core bits of information walking out into the world because to me that's a high school right is that you're

095you're you're walking out with a standard piece of information as a member of our society right and I don't know it just makes no it just makes no sense to me if a kid doesn't have a plan the kid isn't self-motivated enough to say here's my plan these are the this is why I need this extra flexibility because I'm going to do this yeah then why I mean I guess yeah sure a parent could sign off on a whole lot of different things I just worry about that kid yeah no I understand I I think I understand it's just but that's kind of the crutch of the issue then because it would be then it would be what the school decides versus what the parent in this position then the parent I guess I question

096if I I question the exactly I question the premise of that like why does it have to be the school is trumping the parent why doesn't it just be like this is what a college or a high school education is unless a kid has a specific plan and then we have all these other flexible options and the kid can go down all these different paths and have different graduation requirements based on that plan like why why isn't like this is just default and then if your kid is like cool I'm going to get this internship then you go down those paths you know which kind of seems like kind of what we have in place but it could be made more flexible that gracefully summarizes what I would like to see right let's encourage more

097opportunity within our structure but still know that the kids leaving the suay school at least have this could I just get your name please Jessie yeah and what like are you Bown or that y oh I'm lard so yeah okay much much thank you I think lot I might have already said this but I think I'll just say it again um I I'm in support of what I think this can do and the success and flexibility I think ultimately will be a good thing for the students um with the caveat that we need to have safeguards in place to say for you to have the option to opt out there has to we have to have guidelines in there that that say to do that you have to have a certain GPA certain you know

098amount of less than a certain amount of absences or an excuse ABS what they are and I think I do just want to kind of reiterate that we are just talking about senior year it's not like we're going to have sophomores that are adopting out of school like this is all kind of leading up to that last year before you graduate kind of become like a citizen of of the United States and we're trying to weigh the pros and cons of giving you enough choice but also giving you enough structure and and boundary to try to help you make the best choice that you can ultimately to put the best product in our case that's going to be putting students out into the real world trying to produce the best product that that we can

099any more questions comment um the stage cards seem to be a big part of it um and just listening it sounds like some very different there was talk of 80% of students maybe qualifying for this there was positive response to a 3.2 GPA that will see us and those Define very different thresholds for those those safeguards and so could you share where you guys are thinking those what what that 80% is not what I'm just the 80% you're referencing the other side of the 20 like saying that I mean that was just a that was me just making a comment that there's exra percentage of students were going to take four core courses in their senior year um you know so that that had nothing to do about a prediction of who would be eligible

100to start um I mean I think I don't guides these conversations I think looking at something in very close in the range shared from districts that I mean that's that's where we are planning to put it I think is that the exact measure I don't know you know talk about that a littleit for that course guys but something in that range is what everybody seems to kind of really makes a lot of sense right is that having a it's demonstrated academic success it's demonstrated um attendance success attending as a student and demonstrating behavioral success now the thing that want we want to play out a little bit is just um do any of those numbers you know do they disproportionately try to limit certain populations of students and I think that's something want to think

101about before the board kind of votes on it um you know but um I think we have a pretty good idea what the range I I think it's fair to say I have a good idea what the range is of what the board's looking for for those types of something in the range of shared F if that's if that's good enough for the board before it be it would have to be voted on anyway but I just think without saying that's definitively end I think something in that moment maybe we could see with that like how many students would qualify based on those requirements yeah yeah and that's kind of I mean that's my idea is we run like I would like to run that and say it seems like it's disproportionately hitting a group

102of kids that you know I don't want to call out BCTC for some reason but say what if it seems like a large proportion don't qualify think about why that might you know or any I just I think that's fair when the meantime to kind of take a look at that that's I agree that's a great suggestion why don't we delay the vote until we actually have an idea again I I don't understand what the rush is well I mean I I do think this is the absolute last time happen class I do think I don't see why it needs to happen for class the other thing I'd like to call out the email that you sent out the verbiage in your email was I would be happy to discuss you you shared the r

103graduation requirements recommendation um as a link and then your verbiage was I would be happy to discuss concerns with any Community member if you have any clarifying questions please use this form with a link or email me at your email address that that is is from my you know perspective that is not encouraging and soliciting feedback and saying hey I have a whole host of questions of which I'd like to get your feedback in in detail that's really and again I have folks reaching out to me saying well his email was really really asking reach out to me if if you have any questions on it so again that the in the future I would just ask that we'd be more explicit if we're doing a survey that we branded as a survey and that

104we actually ask parents that you know and tell them that we're still trying to formulate a perspective and a Viewpoint and get their input not just be available to ask questions good I don't I don't brand it as a survey i Brand as as a feedback opportunity I mean just because surveys surveys um you know tend either have a some kind of a binary choice or a m scale some it's an it's an opinion right typically we do those surveys I intended for it to be an opportunity people to give me their thoughts and feedback and I you know again small number did that's what they share but um i u i I think there's a time and a place not that the survey would be making the choice right we're all here to to

105make that decision but I do think getting again a sentiment from the community would have been helpful in this case any other questions I I would like to say that um many of the students on in my specific region of the district they don't have not not so many of them are in more upper class or even higher middle class families and I feel like if they and their parents are given the opportunity to opt out of classes in their senior year they will so that they can make extra money for their family but at the same time these are like pretty much a lot of many of them are like right in they're in their academic classes and taking more they're having like more average grades and that's fine but if they're meeting the

106requirements that were setting a lot of these students specifically I'm afraid would just opt out a bit and want to support their family which is a great cause but in the future that might make it so that then it makes it harder for them to be accepted into colleges um with higher things such as um off the top of my head I believe that Penn state is above a 3.4 GPA from the last time I checked that's only for main campus for main campus for main campus which is a very high most kids wind up going to satellite campuses before they even go to main campus you have to have a specific I've known several K several kids who wanted to go to main campus but had to go to a satellite campus first and

107then be able to go to main campus so yeah it's actually a 3.5 GPA to get into main campus and you also have to meet other requirements as well too just get in the main campus I'd love to hear what else you had I would like to say that if it were the case that we were to take away some of these uh requirements for students it might make it so that then students in these um po families are not um are just not going to have as much success later in life and not have as many opportunities if they have let's say directly on a 3.2 GPA or somewhat lower it it may lower their chances for their opportunities for going to select colleges that they might be looking forward to and in my

108opinion that could be a big U issue especially with the fact that then that will make it so that they probably will be making less income than they would be without a college degree overall it their options thank you can I have your name too please Elijah s s i c h e r thank I GRE thank you any other questions or comments [Music] fo call on graduation requirements Daniel Wismer yes Laurel Ziggler no Michael Hess yes Reba Hoffman yes Cecilia Holt yes Jeremiah L yes deny dishes yes sorry Aaron yes that motion cares next up on the agenda is item thanks a lot introduction of new business by board members does anyone have anything here to leg word um I did have a recommendation that I'd like the board to consider um I Heard

109recently of some other school districts that actually at their graduation recognize um a valedictorian from BCTC so the toob student in BCTC and I thought that that would be um a nice suppl to our graduation uh ceremony [Music] gonna say would it follow the same like would it be a GPA based one or like total encompassing or would it just be from BCT work I guess just details I think it's a great idea but I'd ask Mr chanon to I find out more someone else do school in particular um he none next up on the agenda is uh public comment on non-agenda meetings anyone sign up our mind there is Dr Underwood hi um given Trump's recent actions to roll back sensitive locations um has led to fears among teachers and families about the protection

110of undocumented immigrant students so I'm just wondering if Mr chatan you're going to put out a statement about your position and how you would handle the situation if ice were coming and asking to enter our schools um I have no intention to put out a statement necessarily because I believe that our you know as a district um our responsibility to protect the privacy and individual interest of a student remains you know the same no matter what the situation you know at the end of the day if a student hears in one of our schools and someone is you know attempt is attempting to pick them up who is not documented parent or guardian or emergency contact Etc we require legal documentation that gives them the authority to remove a student from school building so I

111mean that just Remains the Same for anyone there's a Corder document um you know we we have to honor it I mean that for us typically those examples are you know custody type agreements and scenarios where we previously may not have had any of information and that type of thing happens so um that is that's simply what the school stance is on anyone outside of the known and documented um individuals who are except coming to pick up a student from school I do think get this as an example where I again have heard of other schools in the area actually sending out proactive emails really clarifying the school position you know we obviously don't know who may or may not be documented or have documented you know or undocumented cases within their family and I

112think it could really do a lot to put the community at ease um I also it's my understanding that there is a specific type of judicial War it that is required it's again it's not just kind of anything so I'd like your assurance that if that situation Came Upon Us that it would be that highest possible standard of of expecting um um what is required by law um not just you know Open Door a lower no agreed it's the it's only the you know high standard of I mean to me I just we are in any of these instances we are possession possessions that or but if someone's child right and to release possession to anyone we would need the high standard documentation you know so I think again please reconsider sending something to our

113community that in this time of uncertainty you know I think that the effects are of of having a again an an unexpected situation at our school would be extremely traumatizing for all of the students not not just that one you student impacted um and again I'd really like to put our broader community and anyone who we may or may not might be concerned about this uh at at to ensure that we will follow the law I have an opinion on that one too I think it's it would be probably a dangerous standard to set to feel the need to for the school district to put out a position on every announcement or order that comes into play so I think that would be heading down a a road that would probably not the best practice

114well this is simply reasserting that we will follow the law for this very visible and you know obvious again I'm not arguing with you I'm just stating my opinion that's okay okay any other uh comment on non-agenda items hearing none moving on to item eight informational items that are outlined in your agenda uh item nine is upcoming public meetings and inform dates February 10th is policy and curricul curriculum committee meeting as well as facilities and extracurricular committee meeting those are at 6m and 7M in the high school and by Zoom respectively uh February 18th is a Tuesday that's a school board meeting at 7:30 p.m. in the high school and by Zoom uh February 24th is budget and finance committee meeting and that is at 7M and that's in middle school that I would be

115second Hoffman

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.